SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long...

24
Gary Holmes, P.E. Mark Hugaboom, P.E. City of Binghamton McFarland-Johnson, Inc. Engineering Department 49 Court Street, Metrocenter 38 Hawley Street, City Hall Binghamton, NY 13901 Binghamton, New York 13901 Phone: (607) 723-9421 Phone: (607) 772-7007 [email protected] [email protected] Synopsis: The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside Drive over the Chenango River in the City of Binghamton. The bridge, originally constructed in 1923 and rehabilitated in 1972, was determined eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places in January 2000. The design phase of the Memorial Bridge Rehabilitation Project began in 2000; the project was let in December 2002, and is anticipated to be complete in September 2005. The project includes: replacement of spandrel walls and earth fill over the arch; repairs to the concrete arch, piers, and retaining walls; incorporation of a pedestrian underpass through the retaining walls and under the approach roadway, and; approach roadway improvements. This work was performed under staged construction to maintain vehicular traffic (one lane in both directions) and pedestrian traffic at all times. This presentation will: provide a general overview of the project discuss the key issues and unique engineering challenges encountered and overcome during the design and construction phases of the project discuss the importance of municipalities working closely with the NYSDOT, engineering consultants, and regulatory agencies during all phases of a project About the Presenters: Gary Holmes has served as the City Engineer for the City of Binghamton for over eight years. Mr. Holmes is a registered Professional Engineer in New York State with thirty-two years of experience. He worked for private consulting firms for thirteen years in Pennsylvania, Delaware and New York. For eleven years, he was an Engineer with the Broome County Department of Public Works. Mr. Holmes graduated from Broome Community College and attended the University of Delaware. He has been involved in numerous New York State Department of Transportation and Federally-funded projects. SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge over Chenango River

Transcript of SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long...

Page 1: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Gary Holmes, P.E. Mark Hugaboom, P.E. City of Binghamton McFarland-Johnson, Inc. Engineering Department 49 Court Street, Metrocenter 38 Hawley Street, City Hall Binghamton, NY 13901 Binghamton, New York 13901 Phone: (607) 723-9421 Phone: (607) 772-7007 [email protected]

[email protected] Synopsis:

The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside Drive over the Chenango River in the City of Binghamton. The bridge, originally constructed in 1923 and rehabilitated in 1972, was determined eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places in January 2000. The design phase of the Memorial Bridge Rehabilitation Project began in 2000; the project was let in December 2002, and is anticipated to be complete in September 2005. The project includes: replacement of spandrel walls and earth fill over the arch; repairs to the concrete arch, piers, and retaining walls; incorporation of a pedestrian underpass through the retaining walls and under the approach roadway, and; approach roadway improvements. This work was performed under staged construction to maintain vehicular traffic (one lane in both directions) and pedestrian traffic at all times. This presentation will:

• provide a general overview of the project • discuss the key issues and unique engineering challenges encountered and

overcome during the design and construction phases of the project • discuss the importance of municipalities working closely with the NYSDOT,

engineering consultants, and regulatory agencies during all phases of a project About the Presenters:

Gary Holmes has served as the City Engineer for the City of Binghamton for over eight years. Mr. Holmes is a registered Professional Engineer in New York State with thirty-two years of experience. He worked for private consulting firms for thirteen years in Pennsylvania, Delaware and New York. For eleven years, he was an Engineer with the Broome County Department of Public Works. Mr. Holmes graduated from Broome Community College and attended the University of Delaware. He has been involved in numerous New York State Department of Transportation and Federally-funded projects.

SESSION 2.4

Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge over Chenango River

Page 2: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Mark Hugaboom is a Transportation Manager at McFarland-Johnson, Inc., where he has worked for approximately five years on bridge and highway design projects. Mr. Hugaboom is a licensed Professional Engineer in New York, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut. His previous work experience includes seven years at a private consulting engineering firm in Connecticut. Mr. Hugaboom is a graduate of Clarkson University with a B.S. in Civil Engineering and of SUNY Potsdam with a B.A. in Physics.

Page 3: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Memorial Bridge OverChenango River

Statewide Conference on Local Bridges Wednesday, October 26, 2005

McFarland-Johnson, Inc.

Page 4: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Presented By:

Gary Holmes, P.E.City of Binghamton, NY

Mark Hugaboom, P.E.McFarland-Johnson, Inc.

Page 5: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Project Team• NYSDOT Region 9 Local Projects Unit

• Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)

• City of BinghamtonOwner

• McFarland-Johnson, Inc.Design Engineer, Construction Inspection, Construction Support

• Shumaker Consulting Engineering & Land Surveying, P.C.Construction Inspection

• FAHS Construction GroupConstruction Contractor

Page 6: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Communication

• Consultant Relationship

• NYSDOT Local Project Liaison

Page 7: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Regulatory Agencies

• NYSDEC

• SHPO

Page 8: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Project Challenges

• Regulations (DEC, SHPO, NYSDOT)

• Chenango River Waterfront Development

• Scheduling Conflicts

• Claims and Disputes

• Public Concern

Page 9: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

History - Original Construction

Original Construction – 1923 to 1925

Page 10: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

• 5 Span Earth Filled Concrete Arch Bridge• Overall Length = 534’• Out to Out Bridge Width = 59’

History – Original Construction

Bridge Barrier Brick Pavers

Fill

Top of Arch

Spandrel Wall

9.8’ 9.8’18.0’ 18.0’

58.0’

Page 11: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

History – 1972 Bridge Rehabilitation

Page 12: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

History – 1972 Bridge Rehabilitation• Roadway Widening• Sidewalk Replacement• Incorporate Bridge Lighting• Replacement Bridge Rail• Drainage Improvements• Maximum Out to Out Bridge Width = 63.5’

1972 Typical Section

8.0’ 44.0’(4) – 11’ Travel Lanes

8.0’

Fill

Bridge Rail

Spandrel Wall

Page 13: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

2005 Bridge Rehabilitation

Rehabilitated – 2003 to 2005

Page 14: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Preliminary Investigation• Review of Record Plans

• Concrete Testing and Hammer Sounding of Arch, Spandrel Walls, and Retaining Walls

• Underwater Dive Inspection

• Geotechnical Investigation

– Approach Fill

– Earth Fill Over Arch

Page 15: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Project Scope

• Replacement of Earth Fill Over Arch

• Replacement of Spandrel Walls

• Repairs to Concrete Arch, Piers and Retaining Walls

• Roadway Improvements

• Incorporation of Pedestrian Underpass

Page 16: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

• Maximum Out to Out Bridge Width = 64’- (2) 10.0’ Travel Lanes- (2) 13.0’ Shared Lanes- (2) 6.5’ Sidewalks

Bridge Configuration

46.0’6.5’ 6.5’

2005 Typical Section

Lighting PilasterBridge Barrier

FillSpandrel Wall

Page 17: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Engineering Challenges

• Maintenance and Protection of Traffic

• Incorporation of Pedestrian Underpass

• Selection of Bridge Barrier Acceptable to the City and SHPO

Page 18: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Maintenance and Protection of Traffic

REQUIREMENT:• Maintain Two Lanes Of Vehicular Traffic

and Pedestrian Traffic At All Times

SOLUTION:• Replace Earth Fill in Stages

• Seven Stages of Construction

• Use Geosynthetic Reinforced Earth System (GRES) Wall

Page 19: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Maintenance and Protection of Traffic

Temp. Pavement

25.0’Temporary Roadway

8.0’

STAGE 1

20.0’3.0’ Sidewalk Removal

Existing Fill

Temp. Sidewalk

5.0’

Flow

Page 20: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

CONSTRUCTION PHOTOS

Maintenance and Protection of Traffic

Page 21: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Pedestrian Underpass

Plan View

Floodwall

PedestrianUnderpass

Riverside Drive

Existing Retaining Walls

MEMORIAL BRIDGE

Susquehanna River

Riv

erw

alk

Confluence

Park

Chen

ango

Riv

er

Abutment

Page 22: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Pedestrian Underpass

• Provides Pedestrian Access to Confluence Park Without Crossing Riverside Drive

• Required Temporary Soldier Piles and Lagging Walls to Maintain Traffic

• Required Removal of Retaining Walls

Page 23: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Pedestrian Underpass

PLACING UNITS

Page 24: SESSION 2.4 Rehabilitation of Memorial Bridge · The Memorial Bridge is a four-lane, 534 foot long five span earth-filled spandrel wall, concrete arch bridge, which carries Riverside

Pedestrian Underpass

UNDERPASS ENTRANCES