Service Blueprint of KFC and Shangri-la
-
Upload
guy-kilarney-muchineuta -
Category
Services
-
view
2.767 -
download
308
Transcript of Service Blueprint of KFC and Shangri-la
1
University of Cyprus
SERVICE MANAGEMENT
MBA 545.7
MANAGING SERVICES FINAL PROJECT
Name: Guy Muchineuta
Instructor: Professor Antreas Athanassopoulos, Ph.D.
2
Table of Contents Introduction....................................................................................................................................................3
Background of the study...............................................................................................................................3
Definition of terms ........................................................................................................................................3
KFC Company ..................................... ........................................................................................................4
KFC store layout ..........................................................................................................................................5
Advantages of KFC service layout................................................................................................................6
Blueprint.........................................................................................................................................................7
KFC blueprint................................................................................................................................................8
Strengths of KFC and successful points......................................................................................................11
Weaknesses and fail points..........................................................................................................................12
Gap Model analysis......................................................................................................................................13
Recommendations........................................................................................................................................14
Blueprint of Shangri-la restaurant................................................................................................................16
Recommendations........................................................................................................................................19
Comparison of the blueprints.......................................................................................................................20
Frontline employee Interview......................................................................................................................20
Conclusion...................................................................................................................................................21
References....................................................................................................................................................23
3
1.Introduction
The global fast food restaurant industry has managed to grow over the past five years despite
being weakened by global economy and society's increasing awareness of the health risks
associated with a diet high in fat, salt, and sugar. The industry's attempts to respond to changes
in consumer preferences have supported revenue growth. These companies are finding the best
ways to improve customer retention and increase their efficiency through service strategies.
2.Background of the study
This study sought to determine the service strategies that are adopted by companies in order to
satisfy one common goal of meeting the needs of their customers. In this study the researcher
will compare the service blueprint of two different companies in the same industry and compare
their service strategies. These companies are in the fast food restaurant industry and are the
world's most popular restaurants. The reasons why the researcher chose these two restaurants are
that restaurants have been used by people to eat food and relax and are also a point of meeting by
companies to hold meetings to mention but a few. It can be noted that people flock to restaurants
where they are treated well and provided quality services. In this research we are going to
examine the strengths and weaknesses of each restaurant by comparing and contrast their
activities in relation to bottlenecks and lines of weakness. The first restaurant is KFC and the
other one is Shangri- la restaurant in Harare Zimbabwe.
3.Defination of terms
-Customer actions which includes steps, choices , activities and interactions that customer
performs in the process of purchasing, consuming and evaluating the service,
-Onstage contact employee actions are steps and activities that the contact employees performs
that are visible to customer
Backstage contact employee actions are steps and activities that occur behind the scene to
support onstage activities
-Support processes covers the internal services, steps and interactions that take place to support
the contact employees in delivering the service.
-Line of interaction direct interactions between or within the customer and organisation
4
-Line of visibility is a line which separates all service activities that are visible to the customers
from those that are not visible.
-Line of internal interaction separates contact employees activities from those of other service
support activities and people
4.1 KFC Company
Kentucky Fried Chicken, more commonly known by its initials KFC, is an American fast food
restaurant chain that specializes in fried chicken headquartered in Louisville Kentucky. It is the
world's second largest restaurant chain in sales after McDonalds. The company uses the proper
method for facility location and layout analysis of new or existing outlets. Internal and external
layout of KFC outlet is attractive and charming all over the world with ideal color schemes,
pleasant lighting outlets. In addition to the above the company provides comfortable sitting
arrangement for their customers to relax enjoying their food.
Furthermore it can be stressed that these are customer service and attitude of service personnel,
cleanliness of staff and of the physical environment, price and food quality. From KFC, it can be
concluded that the features of a restaurant establishment are not equally important to guest when
evaluating their restaurant experience but rather the product itself and how it is delivered. The
main thing the company is delivering to its customers is not only the food but fully trained
employees and their proper work division to satisfy the customer needs and wants. It can be seen
that KFC offers a state of the art interior beautifications, speedy and appropriate cooking process,
special club/ block for kids are the vital characteristic of the company layout in terms of the
environment.
One of the most significant aspect to take into account is that KFC as a company operates in a
continuous process in order to deliver fresh foods to customers in a proper manner and they have
dry food supply and frozen food supply. The company managed to establish their own
warehouse for dry food supply like burgers buns and frozen food supply for example chicken
they have their own suppliers and spices for a better and quick way to satisfy their customer
preferences and needs. The process is illustrated in the diagram below how overally the company
operates.
5
Phases in the company operations
As illustrated by the diagram as we are focusing on operations management department in
having a clear view how they operate in order to provide a service through the food they offer, it
can be seen that the HOD supply chain give necessary instruction to manager chain and pass on
the instructions to supply chain executives to ensure adequate flow of information in providing
supplies.
Customer perceptions of service quality have a strong influence on both purchase intentions and
customer satisfaction and this in turn influences profitability and customer loyalty . Perceptions
can be defined as the process by which an individual selects, organizes and interprets stimuli into
a meaningful and coherent picture of the world when guests perceptions of a service exceed
their expectations, they perceive a high service quality and when guests‟ perceptions of a service
fail to meet their expectations, they are dissatisfied. In this case we will design a diagrammatic
presentation of KFC layout to satisfy a service.
4.2 KFC Store layout
Designing a service delivery system is a creative process. It begins with a service concept and
strategy to provide a service with features that differentiate it from the competition. The various
alternatives for achieving these objectives must be identified and analyzed before any decisions
can be made. Designing a service system involves issues such as location, facility design and
layout for effective customer and work flow, procedures and job definitions for service
providers, measures to ensure quality, extent of customer involvement, equipment selection, and
adequate service capacity. The design process is never finished, once the service becomes
operational, modifications in the delivery system are introduced as conditions warranty
Raw
materials
from
suppliers normal storage
cold storage
Preparation and
packaging
Distribution to all the
branches
6
counter
sitting area kids club
Exit
Entry car park
4.3 Advantages of KFC service layout
The major factors considered for service providers, is an impact of location on sales and
customer satisfaction. Customers usually look about how close a service facility is, particularly if
the process requires considerable customer contact. It can be seen that KFC has numerous
advantages in accordance to the their layout to meet their service strategy.
Reduces bottlenecks in moving people and goods
Kitchen Store room (( wifi))
7
It can be seen that from the diagram one of the advantages of KFC service layout is that it
reduces bottlenecks in moving people or materials. This because the food is always prepared and
displayed on the warmer and once the customer places an order he or she does not have to wait
for a long time for the order.
Utilizes available space effectively and efficiently
One of the most advantage of KFC is that it provides free space for customers to seat waiting for
their orders and also relax with their families enjoying food whilst seating in the restaurant.
Facilitates coordination and face to face communication
KFC service layout allow customers to interact with the employees in case they need support or
help, also on the other coordination between employees is good because they work very closely
on the counter and the kitchen.
5.1 Service Blueprint
Christain (1990) defines a service as an activity or series of activities of more or less intangible
nature that normally, but not necessarily, take place in interactions between customer and service
employees and or physical resources or goods and or systems of the service provider, which are
provided as solutions to customer problems. Valarie et al (1996) incited that services are deeds,
processes and performances.
Blueprint is a picture or map that accurately portrays the service so that different people involved
in providing it can understand and deal with it objectively regardless of their individual point of
view. It provides a way to break the service into logical components and to depict the steps or
tasks in the processes, the means by which they are executed and evidence of the service as
consumer experiences it.
Customers are concerned about customer service and attitude of service personnel, cleanliness
of staff and of the physical environment, price and food quality. From the study, it can be
concluded that the features of a restaurant establishment are not equally important to guest when
evaluating their restaurant experience but rather the product itself and how it is delivered. It can
8
is recommended that hotel restaurants in order to improve guests‟ perceptions of service
experience and loyalty, need to motivate and empower customer contact employees so that a
smooth service is delivered to the guests.
5.2 KFC Service Blueprint
F1 wait
line of interaction
line of visibility
F2
F
line of internal interaction
F3
Failed Points
Dining room and service area
((free wifi))
Backstage
employee
contact
clean tables
after
customer
departs
Customer
Actions
Physical
Evidence
wait
at
counte
r for
food
On stage
employee
contact
place
order at
counter
and pay
receiv
e food
Food
Items
Posted menu and counter
review
menu
items
Visit
website to
identify
location
advertising
website,mu
sic,lcd tv,
car park
website
Support
Processes
sit in dining room and eat food
leave refuse and uneaten food on table
departs restaurant
receive order/ collect payment
receives
food from
back area
deliver
food to
custom
er
prepare
food items
heat grills
etc
cook and prepare food place on heating trays
Reusable
items
washed and
stored
website provide information on KFC products, services, ordering etc.
Food items removed from storage
food items
received
from
suppliers
and stored
used food items
are totaled
when low, new
order is written
new
orders
given to
suppliers
9
The blueprint of KFC shows the core concept of service design, a powerful approach that
examines complex interactions between people and their service experiences. It can be seen that
KFC's products and services are delivered through systems of touch points that cross channels
and blend both digital and human interactions. There are two dimensions in the blueprint which
includes the horizontal axis which represents the chronology of actions conducted by the service
customer and the kfc company. The vertical axis distinguishes between different areas of actions
and are separated by different lines.
Customer Actions
The customer journey mapping shows customer interactions with their product or service
overtime. The actor actions and physical evidences are shown by boxes, sequences of boxes
show action flow for each actor. In addition arrows between actors show communication flow
and the horizontal segmentations of actions represent actor categories. The actor categories are
customer , on stage employees, backstage employees, support and management. The four lines
segregate actors based on distance from and interaction with the customer and were in the
original conception of service blueprint.
The KFC blueprint shows that the first service they offer to their customers is their online
website which shows the company address, hours of opening, offers, direction and also the
contacts in need of help. The physical evidence include the physical location, website, car park ,
signage and also internal customers can be seen by the customer but cannot reach or
communicate with them. It can be seen that the customer can only interact with on stage
employee.
Visit
website to
identify
location
review
menu
items
place
order at
counter
and pay
wait
at
counte
r for
food
receiv
e food
sit in dining room and eat food
leave refuse and uneaten food on table
departs restaurant
10
As the customer enters the Kfc restaurant there will be good counter setup with a 5 lcd menu
and a good sheeting arrangement, good system and better light decoration. In this case the
customer picks up the menu to choose the right food he or she wants.
The customer then place an order at the counter and pay and wait for some minutes while the
order is being processed. As soon as the order is ready it will then be delivered to the customer
and receives the food. Once the customer receives the food he or she sit in the dining room or
departs the restaurant with the food. It can be seen that through its provision the company offers
free wifi for its customers to browse when enjoying their food. In addition to the above after the
customer has finished eating the food he or she leave refuse and uneaten food on the table and
departs the restaurant
Onstage Employee Contact
The visible employee is separated from the customer by the line of interaction, those actions of
frontline contact employees that occur as part of face to face encounter are depicted on onstage
contact employee actions. Every time the line of interaction is crossed via a link from the
customer to a contact employee a moment of truth has occurred.
The onstage employee receives payment from the customer punch in the system and perform the
transaction. In addition to the above the employee then receives other payments whilst waiting
for the order of the previous customer to be processed. When the order is finalized from the back
stage then the employee prepares the food in the food tray and put the ketchup in the food and
provide drinks from the refrigerators then deliver it to the customer. The other onstage employee
will then have to wait for the customers to finish eating the food so that he or she can clean the
tables and prepare for other customers who want to use the tables.
Backstage Employee Contact
11
The next significant part of the blueprint is the backstage contact employee actions separated
from the onstage actions by the very important line of visibility, everything that appears above
the line of visibility is seen by the customer , while everything below it is invisible. It can be
seen that below the line of visibility , all of the other contact employees are described , both that
involve non visible interaction s with customers.
Furthermore it can be seen that the backstage employee prepare food items, thaw frozen foods
heat grills from the support processes, cook and prepare food, place on heating trays and send to
the onstage employee when an order has been placed. The backstage then takes the used food
items to the support processes. The backstage employee is responsible of the reusable items such
as plates cups dishes and wash them, store them for use by other customers.
Support Processes
The fourth critical component of blueprint is support processes separated from contact
employees by the internal line of interaction. These are all of the activities carried out by
individuals and units within the company who are not contact employees but that need to happen
in order for the service to be delivered .
The support processes from the blueprint is responsible for the information systems of the
company taking for example its responsible for the creation of the website to for the comapny to
interact with its customers. The website provides information on KFC's products, services,
ordering, details and storefront locations.
In addition to the above the support processes is the one responsible for food items removed
from storage for use. It can be noted that the receiving of food items from the supplies is
conducted by the processes crew and the receive food items supplies and store. When the lead
time reaches then the processes place new order to supplies or to the company warehouse is
discussed in the company service layout of KFC.
5.3 STRENGTH OF KFC AND SUCCESSFUL POINTS
12
In terms of cleanliness of staff and of the physical environment, guests felt employees dressed
professionally and reflected the image of KFC and the restaurant environment was also
generally clean. These minor but contentious issues have a strong effect on the customer future
purchase intentions.
From the blueprint the company offers a quick service that does not require time to order food
and delivered to the customers within a short period of time of less than five minutes and
reducing waiting time for customers which the company can use as a service quality to fight
competition from rival restaurants around KFC
It can be observed that KFC, feedback is taken from the customer in order to know the customer
demands and then improvements are made in products and service. This has an advantage to
customers because they are involved in the service process to satisfy their needs.
KFC focuses on pure and fresh food in order to create a distinct and clear position in the minds
of customers. It has s strong brand name and they are leading the market in fried chicken which
is a strong competitive advantage.
In addition another strength by KFC is that they provide Kids room where kids can play when
the parents are eating or making an order, in this case this can also be attributed by kids meal and
also buckets with different types of meals. This has a strong advantage to the customers because
they feel a sense of belonging to the restaurant and feel appreciated.
As it is not enough KFC offer a home delivery of meals to all its customer and this is a strength
to the company because all its competitors are offering the same service. It can be seen that
customers need a quick delivery after placing the order and KFC is one of the companies that
deliver on time.
5.4 WEAKENESSES AND FAIL POINTS OF KFC BLUEPRINT
Failures in service process may be attributed to either the service provider or the customer. It is
possible that the service provider did not utilize resources in a way that best serves the
13
customers' needs. Alternatively, service provider failures may be caused by mismanagement. For
example, an employee, who chooses to deviate from the script, may fail to serve the customer
correctly. Finally, failures can be caused by customers who do not understand the process and do
not know what they should be doing
F1
Fail points are part of the blueprint that might cause delay or bottlenecks and compromise the
quality of the service expected. It can be observed that from the blueprint that in terms the fail
point F1 in times of heavy volume, the wait at the counter can be excessively long leading to
extreme wait times and unsatisfied customers, This is mainly caused by poor forecasting and
demand which will end up causing bottlenecks as the onstage employee will be one taking orders
and making payments.
F2
The f2 illustrates a failing point where in times of heavy volume it is difficult to keep the volume
of food orders, additionally, it is important that cooks do not prepare too much food anticipation
of demand that might go to waste. This can be a failure to the company because it will bring loss
due to unsold food.
F3
It can be observed that as new orders are placed with suppliers, the system becomes dependent
on the ability of a different firm to fill the order. Issues unrelated to the company may impact the
company and causes delay.
5.6 Gap model analysis of KFC
Gap analysis refers to the process through which a company compares its actual performance to
its expected performance to determine whether it is meeting expectations and using its resources
effectively. It can be observed that from KFC the first gap to be investigated is the expected
service and perceived taking into consideration that there is no welcoming from the onstage
employee and also limited variety of food that the customer need. The attitude and behavior of
employees especially of those customer contact employees offer to the guest an assurance of the
14
quality of service to expect from the restaurant. The manner in which employees welcome the
customers, recommend the dishes and beverages according to the customers' expectations and an
impeccable dress code represent just a few of the criteria a restaurant that aims to offer high
quality products and services to its customers needs to fulfill
Furthermore another gap is the expected service between management perception and customer
expectation. This can be attributed by high prices that a customer might seem expensive and
cannot afford and also some customers might be limited to delivery due to distance from the
company which might compromise the quality of the service.
Some customers perceived that the price was unreasonable in some hotel restaurant, and they
negatively evaluated their experience with the restaurant. As Lim (2010) suggested, the price of a
product was highly related to its perceived value. Lim (2010) referred to perceived price as the
customer's acceptable, reasonable and fair judgment about a service's average price in
comparison to its competitors. However, customer may still not hold strong behavioral intentions
unless they are satisfied with their experience at the restaurant. As Donkoh et al (2012) notes,
customers were likely to come back again and again if prices were perceived to be fair. However,
if guests perceive that the price is unfair they will complain and finally defect to other
restaurants. Customers are therefore not willing to revisit a restaurant when they believe that the
prices on the menu were unreasonably high. Thus, Han & Ryu (2009) suggests that providing
pleasing and innovative atmosphere and high quality of service or food to restaurant customers is
necessary to improve price perception.
5.7 Recommendations
From the gap analysis it can be observed that in order to satisfy a service KFC has to employ a
lot of mechanisms that cater for its customers to add value in their service delivery. One of the
recommendation that the company has to do is to train its employees to welcome customers by
greeting them and ask how they can be helped, by doing so customers feel welcomed and ready
to make a purchase.
15
In addition to the above it is of great importance to say that when customers enter the restaurant
there should be an employee who is within the entrance providing a menu to the customers and
by doing so it helps creating an impression that the company has a lot to offer in terms of variety
of food.
Linked to the above one can note that not all customers can afford expensive meals and it is of
great importance to break these meals in sizes to accommodate low income earners who can
afford it .However less price foods for middle class people will give a competitive advantage to
the company.
There is need for training and motivation of customer contact employees so that they develop a
service culture which would increase customer satisfaction and ultimately customer loyalty.
Customer contact employees need training in such areas as attitude training and up selling as
these help the waiters to develop confidence and believe in the product they are selling and also
make them proud to be working for the KFC restaurant. Motivation therefore would allow
waiters to execute their duties diligently as they know their efforts would be rewarded. Offering
some performance incentives can be used to motivate waiters, for example, an incentive for the
most outstanding waiter would motivate some waiters to perform their duties with all their heart
as they know their performance and contribution to the overall restaurant performance will be
rewarded
16
6.1 Service Blueprint of Shangri-la Restaurant
Restaurant Entry hostess Waiting Table Menu Drinks Food Bill
Parking Way Stand Area Appearance Exit way
Physical Space customers {not good}
Evidence {waiting}
Customer
long wait
contact
person
(onstage)
poor service
Backstage
Support
Processes
Key Bottlenecks
6.2 Description of the blueprint Process of Shangri-la
Service blueprint is more than just a process control tool that serves as a platform for systematic
service innovation and improvement as depicted by the diagram above from Shangri-la
restaurant. The first observation from the blueprint is to see how the customer interacts with the
restaurant as soon as she or he arrives at the restaurant. It can be noted that there is a physical
evidence outside the restaurant which is shown by various tangibles of physical infrastructure
the customer passes through each phase. These include the parking area, porch, garden and
Arrive at
the
restaurant
Go &
sit at
the
table
sit and
wait name put
on waiting
list
Receiv
e
drinks
Get an pay
bill and
leave
restaurant
order
drinks
and
food
Welcome
and greet
customer
Walk
in receive
food
Takes
customer's
name
Deliver
drinks
Take drink
and food
orders
call
customer's
name and
take to their
table
Deliver
food Process
bill
Receive food
order
Waiting
List
Prepare
drinks Cook
food
Computer
registers the
bill
17
hostess desk of billing counter. Tangibles are the appearance of facilities, equipment, personnel,
materials.
As the customer walks in the restaurant a line of interaction is drawn across chart which
separates the customer space or area and the employee on machines with the customer interacts
to stop. As soon as the customer enters the restaurant quickly the onstage employee will
welcome the customer and greet them as a way of improving customer service. The greatest
satisfaction can occur at this stage. From the observations made at the restaurant it can be seen
that the employee speaks to the guest very nice and wearing uniform. A simple name tag is
always on the shirt of the employee which helps to reduce the guest anxiety when interacting
this does not take a lot of time the customer will be directed to the hostess stand and puts the
name on the waiting list.
In addition to the above the customer after goes and wait sitting on the tables. Once seated, the
customer begin to review the menu and waits for the waiter for the placement of the order. The
waiter then takes the order and afterwards confirms to the customers whether all orders were
taken. When the customers confirm the order, the waiter then places the order on the order board,
otherwise ask the customers to repeat the orders. The chef then takes the order and reviews it. If
there are no clarifications to make, the chef proceeds to cooking the food, otherwise call the
attention of the waiter to verify the orders. After cooking the food, the chef prepares the food and
places it on the designated area and rings the bell to call the attention of the waiter.
After cooking the food, the chef prepares the food and places it on the designated area and rings
the bell to call the attention of the waiter. The waiter then picks up the prepared food and serves
it to the customers. The customers then eat the food and subsequently ask for the check. After a
certain period, the waiter arrives with the check. The customer then reviews the check. If there
are no concerns, the customer pays the bill, otherwise verify the check to the waiter. After
paying, the customer finally leaves the restaurant.
18
Looking first at the elements of the process map, the blue boxes in the process map represent the
start and end of the process. The first blue oval that is seen in the process map signals the start of
the process, while the last red oval indicates the end of the process. The blue rectangles on the
other hand, represent operations or work activities. Consequently, there are about 21 blue
rectangles in the process map, which show vital activities or tasks.
6.3 Strength of Shangri-la
It can be observed that the restaurant interact with customers and take their feedback when there
is a need to make suitable modifications on their service blueprint. The restaurant attracts
customers owing to its price and convenience ensuring repeat customers. In spite of having
repeat customers, it faces heavy competition from KFC, Chicken inn to mention but a few.
When it comes to information to its customers it can be noted that there is enough that the
restaurant provides in terms of products, prices and offers. All its customers are aware of its
offers and wide variety of options in the menu, the information is available online as well as in
store
Employees often assist customers to inform of other products available in their menus and the
payment procedure is simple and provides wide options on mode of payments such card, cash
and online payment. The ordering taking mechanism is adequate and the attendants also use
force functionality along with providing information to customers about various options in the
menu. Shangri-la customers have been actively involved because of low prices , standardized
product and partial employee behavior of the process in the system .
The chefs and the cooking equipments are situated in the kitchen where the food is cooked.
Similarly, the receptionist is situated in the arrival area, as she/he is responsible for receiving the
guest. According to Collier and Evans (2007), the fixed position layout is appropriate to service-
providing firms, such as the restaurant. In this regard, the current layout pattern of the restaurant
may be considered appropriate.
6.4 WEAKENESSE AND FAIL POINTS OF SHANGRI- LA BLUEPRINT
19
Moving to the process time, each step in the process consumes a considerable amount of time.
For example, it takes about 10 minutes before the customers are taken to their seats. Upon entry,
the customers are held temporarily to allow the receptionist to get their names, which takes about
five minutes. Afterwards, the customers are again held temporarily while the table is being
prepared, which takes again another five minutes. Looking at the other stages in the process map,
chef's cooking time and the customers' eating time tends to be longest processes. It takes the chef
about twenty minutes to cook and prepare the food. Similarly, it takes the customers about 20
minutes to consume the food.
A closer look at the process would reveal that certain activities and operations in the process map
may be categorized as either value adding or non-value-adding. The value stream includes value-
adding activities that help in the creation of the product or the delivery of the service (Jones
2002).
Collier and Evans (2007) stated that non value adding activities in particular, refers to certain
activities such as transferring materials between two non adjacent workstations and waiting for
service, which generally lengthen the processing time, increase the costs, and in most cases,
increase customer frustration . In the process map for the Shangri-la restaurant, stages in the
process such as the customer waiting to be seated, to place the order, and to get the check are all
non value adding activities, which lengthens the process time and trigger customer frustration.
Consequently, these non-value adding activities constitute about twenty minutes of the process
time. For managers seeking to streamline the process, the purpose is to eliminate non value
adding activities in the process flow.
6.5 Recommendations for Shangri-la
Restaurant managers need to know that charity begins at home, therefore they first need to
create a loyal employee. A loyal employee can then help the restaurant to create loyal customers
and more business can be realized from loyal customers. Restaurant managers also need to
develop trust and confidence with their employees as they the ones who are in constant contact
with the guests. If a manager trusts his subordinates, they in turn deliver can deliver a service
that is next to none as they know that if they do not perform well that trust the manager has with
them will be lost. On the other hand employee empowerment is also crucial in the hotel
20
restaurant. Employee empowerment gives privileges to some service personnel to handle guest
complains and not unnecessarily wait for a superior to come and solve minor service problems.
In order to increase the share prices, attract and retain customers and reduce high employee
turnover, the restaurant should emphasize more on providing excellent customer service,
eliminating long queues, providing healthy menu options , training and revising employees'
wages to mention but a few.
6.6 Comparison of the blueprints
It can be noted that in order to have a clear comparison of the two companies we have to start
from the customer action and all the processes in the blueprint as illustrated by the table below
KFC SHANGRI-LA
Both online and physical ordering There is no online ordering or booking
No welcoming employee There is an employee greeting customers
Payment is done at the counter after
ordering
Payment is done after eating the food
The food is always ready on the oven The chef cook food according to orders
Time to wait for food is lesser Waiting time is high due to food preparation
Offer delivery of orders No delivery of orders
7. Frontline employee Interview of KFC
For the purpose of this study a convenience sample was drawn only from the one frontline
employee who was willing and available to take part in this study. The employee was selected
at KFC restaurant and was targeted for interview. All the restaurants used in this study share the
same characteristics which are; they are all city hotels, they attract the same clientele, that is,
business customers and they all belong to a hotel chain group.
Having conducted the interview with the frontline employee he stated that he is a counter
attendant and both cashier as he receives orders and making payments. The counter attendant is a
21
term used to describe the job of the one who stand behind a counter and takes order. The
working counter attendant is required to stand on his feet for the entire shift and occasionally lift
heavy boxes so being physically able to complete these aspects of the job is necessary.
Furthermore the task entail taking customers' orders, clean, slice and trim foodstuffs, ensure
tables are correctly set, side stations are tidy and work is appropriately completed, resetting
tables with flatware and napkins, handling guest complaints and notify manager on duty
immediately. In addition to the above another significant aspect of the job is to provide and
maintain sanitation of the restaurant including floors, tables, ledges and counters
It can be seen that the job requires demonstrated ability to take and fill orders, first-hand
experience in cleaning and maintaining dining area and also
• Competent at preparing food and specialty beverages
• Effective skills in delivering food orders at counters and tables
• Special talent for maintaining cleanliness, clearing and wiping tables and sweeping floors
• Well-versed in stocking food products
• Adept at using point of sale system, making bills and receiving payment
• Excellent customer service skills
• Good interpersonal skills to deal efficiently with patrons, coworkers and general public
• Professional appearance and manners
• Ready to work in varied shifts, including weekends and holidays
From the interview the employee stated that the company to enhance employee motivation KFC
is using one to one meetings strategy and also they have staff incentive programs. In term of
communication the company sends email together with the memorandum to employees, the crew
incentive program to retain its employees and the company uses bottom-up approach and top to
down in strategic decision making.
In addition to the above KFC provides training to all the staffs and they offer each employee a
form entitled Training Needs Assessment. More so the company provide some basic training to
22
staff and also incentive lectures. The employee furthermore stated that the company provides
comprehensive training in leadership development, coaching skills, culture, interaction
management, fire safety, first aid training, food safety, workplace and health and safety and
information systems which he values most important that is keeping him and enjoying his job.
Having said this the employee stated that lower employees are unhappy as most of the benefits
are only offered for qualified employees, qualified employees are very much satisfied with the
benefits offered by KFC. In addition every employees are very much satisfied with the health
insurance provided as compared to other fast food outlets
8. CONCLUSION
The findings from this study show that guests perceived the quality of service offered by
restaurants is generally high. It can be seen that comparing the service blueprints of KFC and
Shangri- la the differences are that Four themes emerged as the guests‟ criteria for evaluating
restaurant experience, these are, customer service and the attitude of service personnel, food
quality, cleanliness of staff as well as the physical environment and the price of meals. Amongst
these service quality attributes, customer service and the attitude of service personnel emerged as
the most dominant attribute used by guests in evaluating their restaurant experience. It can be
concluded that the features of a restaurant establishment are not equally Research journal's
Journal of Hospitality Tourism Vol. 2 | No. 4 August | 2015 10 important to guest when
evaluating their restaurant experience but rather the product itself and how it is delivered. On the
other hand, guests hold different perceptions towards restaurants depending on the previously
held experiences with the restaurants.
23
References
Aaker, D.A., Kumar, V., & Day, G.S. (2007). Marketing research, 9 th Ed. John Wiley & Sons
New York. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative
Research in Psychology, 3 (2), 77-101. Bruhn, M., & Georgi, D. 2006. Services marketing:
Managing the Service Value Chain. London: Pearson Education Limited. Caruana, A. (2002).
Service loyalty: The effects of service quality and the mediating role of customer satisfaction",
European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 (7/8), 811-828. Dogdubay, M., & Avcikurt, C. (2005).
Customer loyalty in the specialty restaurants: An example from Instanbul.
Collier, D & Evans, J 2007, Operations Management, Goods, Services, Value Chains. Cengage,
NewYork.
Greasly, A 2009, Operations Management 2nd ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Heinrich, B, Henneberger, M, Leist, S & Zellner, G 2009, 'The process map is an instrument to
standardize processes: design and application at a financial service provider', Information
Systems and e-Business Management, vol. 7, no.1, pp. 81-103.
"KFC to open 1st outlet in Tibet". The Tribune. December 10, 2015. Retrieved April 19, 2016.
"KFC Menu, Menu for KFC, Sector 18, Noida". Zomato. Retrieved August 27, 2016.