Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio...

47
Understanding how signaling networks evolve Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology University of Toronto

Transcript of Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio...

Page 1: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding how signaling networks evolve

Sergio PeisajovichDepartment of Cell and Systems Biology

University of Toronto

Page 2: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Signaling networks: connecting cells with the outside world

Image: http://nursingcrib.com

Page 3: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Signaling networks: connecting cells with the outside world

Images: http://www.fi.edu

Page 4: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Signaling networks: connecting cells with the outside world

Image: http://nursingcrib.com

Page 5: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Signaling networks: connecting cells with the outside world

Signal Processing & Integration

Signal A Signal B Signal C

Outputs

Page 6: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Signaling networks are made of multiple proteins and genes

Image: wikipedia

Page 7: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Lab Interests: Signaling Networks

Evolution

Disease Engineering

Page 8: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

How does this complexity evolve?

Page 9: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

How does this complexity evolve?

Page 10: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

input

output

How does this complexity evolve?

Page 11: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Modularity in Transcriptional Circuits Is Believed to Play an Important Role in Evolution

Sean Carroll & colleagues

David Kingsley & colleagues

Page 12: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Modularity in Transcriptional Circuits Is Believed to Play an Important Role in Evolution

Stimulus

Delay

However, evolution mediated by shuffling of genetic elements controlling gene expression is limited to processes that do not need

fast responses

Page 13: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

How do processes that require faster responses evolve?

input

output

Page 14: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

How do processes that require faster responses evolve?

input

output

faster outputs

Page 15: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Proteins are organized in distinct domains with modular functions

Page 16: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Modularity in protein function regulation could play an important role in the evolution of fast cellular processes

Stimulus

Delay

Re-wiring of transcriptional nodes leads to changes in

slow responses

Stimulus

Re-wiring of signaling nodes

leads to changes in fast responses

Page 17: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Modular allosteric regulation controls signaling protein functions

Regulatory domain Modular protein Catalytic domain

Page 18: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

One of our research goals:

Exploring the role of protein domain shuffling in the evolution of signaling networks

Page 19: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

The Yeast Mating Pathway

MAPKKK

MAPKK

MAPK

Page 20: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Synthetic Biology/Laboratory Evolution Approach

Page 21: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Quantitative Analysis of Large Collections of Strains

Page 22: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Quantitative Analysis of Large Collections of Strains

Page 23: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Domain Recombination Leads to Rapid Diversification of Mating Pathway Response Dynamics

Page 24: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Does Domain Recombination Affect Mating Efficiency as Well?

a

a/α

α WTWTor

library

Page 25: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Domain Recombination Leads to Strains that Mate More Efficiently than Wild Type

a

a/α

α WT

WTor

library

Page 26: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Why are there variants that mate better than WT (in the lab)?

Page 27: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Why are there variants that mate better than WT (in the lab)?

Page 28: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 29: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Fluorescence Microscopy Experiments Suggest Possible Mechanisms Leading to Changes in Response Dynamics

Page 30: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 31: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 32: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 33: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 34: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 35: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 36: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 37: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 38: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 39: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Understanding the Mechanisms that Result in Response Changes

Page 40: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Would domain recombination still lead to adaptive evolutionary change when at least one wild type gene is deleted?

Page 41: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Would domain recombination still lead to adaptive evolutionary change when at least one wild type gene is deleted?

Page 42: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

Path

way

Act

ivat

ion

+ pheromone- pheromone

Network re-wiring in the absence of the Ste11 kinase

Page 43: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Network re-wiring in the absence of the Ste5 scaffold

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

4N-5

C

5N-1

1C

20N

-11C

42N

-18C

50N

-7C

50N

-11C

50N

-18C

50N

-20C

50N

-24C W

T

Ste5

KO o

nly

Path

way

act

ivat

ion

(GFP

)

+ pheromone

- pheromone

X

Page 44: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Network re-wiring in the absence of the Ste20 kinasePa

thw

ay a

ctiv

atio

n (G

FP)

+ pheromone

- pheromone

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000 X

Page 45: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

Path

way

act

ivat

ion

(GFP

)

+ pheromone

- pheromone

Network re-wiring in the absence of the Ste7 kinase

X

Page 46: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Conclusions

• Recombination of modular protein domains leads to the rapid diversification of signaling pathways.

• While domain duplication could lead to dominant negative effects, recombination is needed to create novel pathway responses.

• Most significant changes result from recombination events that alter the localization and/or regulation of catalytic domains.

•Mating network is very plastic, tolerating recombination events that involve deletions of WT genes.

Page 47: Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems …colloq/2012_2013/120927_SergioPe... · Sergio Peisajovich Department of Cell and Systems Biology. University of Toronto. ... .

Thanks to:

•At UCSF: Wendell Lim Joan Garbarino Andy Wei

•At U of T:Paloma Mieko Sato Andy Lai Jae JungInna Dimenshtein Purnima KompellaRaphael Brisset Di Roberto Nadine Leone Nick Broad

•Funding:Human Frontiers Science Program NSERCConnaught Fund Boehringer-IngelheimCFI-ORF