By Sam Kay and amanda SeitzFor the miami Student

The department of com-parative religion has decided to pull plans to invite a mem-ber of the Westboro Baptist Church (WBC) to Miami University’s campus. The department was in the plan-ning stages of bringing WBC member Shirley Phelps-Rop-er to professor Hillel Gray’s 100-level class on religious extremism, according to Ste-phen Nimis, comparative reli-gion department chair.

The department will instead invite Gray to lecture on his previous WBC research. The department considered having Gray interview Phelps-Roper off-campus for subsequent viewing by his class, but de-cided against this option.

Confusion surrounding the WBC visit swept the Miami community when an article in the Sept. 20 issue of The Mi-ami Student said College of Arts and Science Dean Phyl-lis Callahan had approved the speaker. Miami officials de-nied Callahan had approved the department’s proposal to bring WBC to campus.

Comparative religion pro-fessor Liz Wilson declined to comment on why she told The Miami Student Sept. 19 that the proposal had Callahan’s approval.

“They had a proposal, they left with notes and questions,” Callahan said. “The proposal was not accepted.”

It is unlikely a stamp of ap-proval from the administra-tion was necessary to bring a WBC member to campus for a classroom visit and public playback of an interview.

Faculty members have the right to bring nearly any guest speaker to class under the prin-ciples of academic freedom.

The proposal from the com-parative religion department was not to seek approval, but to give notice and invite input concerning the plans.

“We knew the visit would be controversial and therefore were giving a heads up to the college leadership,” Nimis said via email.

The university would only intervene under extreme circumstances, such as a threat to campus security, ac-cording to Miami President David Hodge.

“We have limited author-ity to step in and tell someone they can’t do something un-less we fear for the safety of others,” Hodge said.

Callahan said academic freedom is “at the heart” of a university campus.

“We do not restrict faculty members’ ability to invite a guest speaker to their class,” Callahan said.

The dean questioned the risk associated with bringing a known hate group to campus.

“Because you can do something, should you do it?” Callahan said. “If I have an approval voice, I will not ap-prove it.”

The WBC expressed dis-may at the comparative reli-gion department’s decision to pull its tentative offer.

“It’s just a sad state of af-fairs, especially in the univer-sity forum, for people to be so scared about what the Bible really says that they would pull an offer,” WBC member Steve Drain said. “That’s not an open exchange of ideas at that university.”

Before the invitation was pulled, The Miami Student asked Phelps-Roper whether the group would stage a Mi-ami picket if uninvited.

“We’re not going to make a special trip there,” Phelps-Roper said. “We’ll be there if this is what [God] is to have us do.”

Hodge said the visit could have provided an interesting learning experience for the Miami community had the proposal moved forward.

“It [would have been] a chance for our students to see these people, to put them under the lens of academic inquiry, by no means giv-ing them a venue to stand up and spew their hatred,” Hodge said.

Gray’s lecture on his WBC research is tentatively sched-uled for Oct. 25.

Before the proposal was abandoned, the Comparative Religion Student Association planned to request Associated Student Government (ASG) funding for the WBC visit. At a funding hearing Thursday evening, it instead requested the funds for Gray’s lecture. ASG has given initial approv-al to the request.

See clarification of Sept. 20 article on page 9.

By ellie GonSoFor the miami Student

Any excitement incom-ing students have at fresh-men orientation comes to a screeching halt the minute their counselor hands them a single white sheet of paper. Graduation requirements: a daunting, undecipher-able, jumbled mess of letters and numbers.

Although the Miami Uni-versity College of Arts and Science degree requirements may appear to be written by a rocket scientist, there may be a disconnect between uni-versity division requirements and the Miami Plan.

Although the purpose of the Miami Plan is to enhance students’ overall liberal edu-cation, there is a question of whether it needs to be reeval-uated holistically. The dis-crepancy is illustrated by one of the most popular courses

on campus, Communications (COM) 135.

On Sept. 10, Richard Campbell, director of the journalism department and interim chair of the commu-nications department, sub-mitted a petition to the Office of Liberal Education request-ing to delist COM 135, a public speaking course, as a humanities credit under the Miami Plan.

Currently, COM 135 is re-quired by 31 different majors to graduate, many outside of the College of Arts and Sci-ence. According to Camp-bell, the course now fills nearly 26 sections a semester and the course is led by most-ly visiting faculty members. However, Campbell feels the discrepancy lies in the fact that students outside of the College of Arts and Science can fulfill their one Miami Plan humanities requirement with COM 135.

Campbell’s issue with COM 135 is that, while it is an important course, it does not embody the core elements of a typical humanities class, such as history, literature or religion. However, he views the COM 135 quandary as a small symptom of a much larger problem.

“I don’t think it’s right that business and engineering students can fulfill their one humanities requirement with COM 135,” Campbell said. “This is an illustration of what I think is a larger prob-lem in terms of rethinking the entire curriculum.”

When the new Global Mi-ami Plan went into effect in the fall of 2010, three credits were extracted from the sec-ond foundation, decreasing student’s overall exposure to the humanities. Accord-ing to John Tassoni, Direc-tor of Liberal Education, the Liberal Education Council

(LEC) sent a survey, asking the humanities departments to audit their classes to en-sure they still contained core humanities elements.

Tassoni said the findings of the survey raised some inter-esting questions about how courses are categorized.

“Because of the tightening of the credits, we wanted to look and see that students are getting the most out of the humanities courses as they can,” he said.

Tassoni said it is important to the LEC that every course

gives as much exposure to the humanities as possible. COM 135 may be one example of a course that does not embody classic humanities elements.

Alternatively, students in the College of Arts and Sci-ence are required to take nine hours of humanities, a foreign language and potential addi-tions of quantitative literacy and writing requirements. While some may gawk at the additional requirements, Campbell sees them as ben-efits to students’ overall liberal education.

“What we’re doing in the college is making require-ments that we want students to know when they leave here. I want our students to be good writers and have an understanding of quantitative literacy,” Campbell said.

But as the College of Arts and Science continues to make changes, some ques-tion whether the Miami Plan is at odds with the division’s goals. According to Camp-bell, some students in the College of Arts and Science graduate well above 128 hours due to the require-ments of both the college and the Miami Plan.

Junior Brooke Sheehan said she has been swamped with the amount of hours she has to take.

“Since I was undecided freshman year, I’ve had to

The Miami StudentFRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011

Oldest university newspaper in the United States, established 1826

miami uniVerSity OXFORD, OHIOVolume 139 NO. 10

In 1973, The Miami Student reported that the Oxford City Council had rejected for the second time a resolution to decriminalize small amounts of marijuana. The initiative petition called for a $5 fine for “casual possession marijuana in quantities of four ounces or less.”

COM 135 exemplifies debate over definition of a humanities course

AR Rahman surprises Oxford Religion department drops WBC proposal

rahman,SEE PAGE 9

miami Plan,SEE PAGE 9

Because you can do something, should you do it?”

PhylliS Callahandean oF the ColleGe oF artS and SCienCe

andreW Bray THE MIAMI STUDENT

AR Rahman signs Miami University junior Charlie Poe’s music score at a recital held for Rah-man Thursday in Hall Auditorium.

today in miami hiStory

I don’t think it’s right that business and engineering students can fulfill their one humanities requirement with COM 135.”

riChard CamPBelldireCtor oF JournaliSm dePartment

By dan hamlinFor the miami Student

AR Rahman might not be as well known in the United States as other mu-sical geniuses such as John Williams, Howard Shore or Hans Zimmer, but world-wide, he is in a class of his own. Rahman made a sur-prise visit to the campus of Miami University Thursday to take some time to listen to performances by the Sym-phony Orchestra, Jazz En-semble, Choarliers and Col-legiate Chorale in preparation for this weekend’s Global Rhythms performances.

Word spread around quickly throughout the music department and campus that Rahman would be visiting for a brief amount of time. His visit only lasted around

five hours, but included multiple performances and many pictures.

How significant is his ap-pearance at Miami? Charlie Poe, the Miami University Symphony Orchestra presi-dent put it simply.

“It’s huge,” Poe said. “Somebody that is recog-nized around the world to come visit Oxford is amazing.”

Junior Andrew Moore, a music performance minor, agreed with Poe.

“I’m really excited,” Moore said. “I don’t think we have ever had a world renowned composer come to Oxford to listen to his own music.”

This is not Rahman’s first visit to Oxford. His ties to Miami are deep, stem-ming from his friendship

with alumnus and Global Rhythms director Srinivas Krishnan. Former Colle-giate Chorale and Men’s Glee Club director Ethan Sperry arranged numerous selections by Rahman for the choral world. Pieces such as “Zikr,” “Jai-Ho” and “Wed-ding Qawwali” have all been sung at concerts at Miami and elsewhere. This past sum-mer, Miami students had the opportunity to visit and per-form in Chennai at Rahman’s KM Conservatory.

Senior Sean O’Neill was one of the students who was able to perform at the conservatory.

“[Rahman] has a really crazy schedule,” O’Neill said. “Trying to meet with

By AdAm GiffiSenior StAff Writer

Concerns about the uncer-tainties surrounding Ohio’s Enterprise University pro-posal were raised Monday in a roundtable discussion with Miami University President David Hodge. The plan will partially privatize public universities in Ohio.

The talk lasted roughly one hour and was held in Roudebush Hall. The meet-ing was organized by Mi-ami’s chapter of the Defend Ohio campaign. Hodge de-scribed the meeting as pro-fessional and useful.

“I thought it was a very constructive conversation. We got to discuss a lot of things that ranged a wide variety of issues,” Hodge said. “The thing that we all agreed on is that there is a large amount of uncertainty about actually what the plan will look like when it gets introduced to legislature.”

It is this ambiguity that Rachel Radina, president of the chapter and a gradu-ate student in educational leadership, said prompted a desire to discuss a wide variety of concerns about the plan. Of these, Radina explained that fears about increased enrollment rates were something that was addressed for a variety of reasons.

“One is because a couple of years ago, Miami came up with a shortage in student housing because there were more students than Miami had room for,” Radina said. “The president doesn’t think that enrollments would dramatically increase even if the enrollment cap was removed because we are not currently near the

enrollment cap anyway.”Radina said another ma-

jor question raised was the concern about the potential for the university to gain power to substantially in-crease tuition. According to Radina, Hodge assured in the discussion that this is not something that stu-dents should be concerned about. Hodge reiterated this statement.

“The plan doesn’t have anything in it about giving us the authority to raise tu-ition. It is probably unlikely that the legislature will ever give up that authority,” Hodge said. “Even if they

did, market forces are at work and it simply wouldn’t be feasible to raise tuition very much.”

Hodge said that for the foreseeable future, the tu-ition increase plan will re-main the same.

“In Miami’s long range five-year plan, we’re esti-mating a 3.25 percent in-crease per year,” Hodge said. “We are not sitting here waiting for an oppor-tunity that allows us to radi-cally raise tuition.”

Additionally, Radina said concerns were presented that the plan would result in departmental cuts. Accord-ing to Hodge, any of the likely departmental cuts that occur in the future will be unrelated to the initiative.

Meanwhile, Hodge

presented the universities’ concerns about the plan.

“I think most of the uni-versities, if not all of them, would say that it’s not at all clear that we’re willing to give up our state resources to gain the proposed advantag-es,” Hodge said. “We’re still arguing that most of these straightforward advantages are ones that are pretty logi-cal and we shouldn’t have to give up money in order to get these logical changes.”

Hodge said the final plan will be revealed and taken before the state legislature in January. When this hap-pens, Hodge plans to pro-

vide the Miami community with opportunities to dis-cuss the proposal.

In the meantime, Hodge does not suggest that Miami dwell heavily on the issue.

“There is no reason at this point for Miami students to be overly concerned about the impact of the ‘Enterprise University’ system. The big-gest impact would be if they cut our budget, and they can cut our budget whether there are ‘Enterprise Universi-ties’ or not,” Hodge said. “I think it’s good to keep track of the conversation, and as a campus, we will get back into it in January or Febru-ary as we understand what exactly is going to be put on the table.”

Nevertheless, student fears do currently exist

beyond those in atten-dance of Monday’s meet-ing. Sophomore Adrian Christ worries that, if the proposal passes, it could change the entire makeup of the university.

“I feel like losing the ‘public’ label could create an entirely elitist culture here,” Christ said. “More people are able to and interested in coming to a ‘public’ univer-sity than a ‘private’ one.”

Hodge said Miami will continue to have discus-sions with the Inter-Univer-sity Council, Board of Re-gents Chancellor Jim Petro and other officials about ways for state universities to gain benefits without losing funding.

The Defend Ohio cam-paign chapter will be pur-suing their opposition to the plan.

“Our next step is to talk to legislators and bring our concerns as well as universi-ties’ concerns to the table in regards to this plan,” Radina said. “We’re hopeful that we can create a strong stu-dent and worker movement across the state of Ohio so that we can keep our public universities public.”

Despite his own worries, Hodge hopes budget cuts are not in the future and stressed a commitment to what he believes is the uni-versity’s bottom line.

“We’re already very poorly supported by the state financially, relative to the national landscape,” Hodge said. “We’re going to continue to fight to keep as much of state funding as possible so that we can keep the cost of going to Miami as low as possible and yet achieve the high outcome measures that we work on.”

editorSLauren Ceronie

Jenni WienercAmpuS@miAmiStudent.net2 CAMPUS

FriDaY, SePTeMBer 23, 2011

‘Forgotten president’ leaves mixed legacy

By mAtt LevySenior StAff Writer

Miami University’s Associated Student Gov-ernment (ASG) plunged into its second meeting of the year with a lengthy agenda and a truncated meeting time.

Laws 100, ASG’s meet-ing space, was reserved for a class exam at 8 p.m., forcing ASG to hasten its meeting. According to Student Senate President Tom Kirkham, this was an event that would only hap-pen one other time.

The meeting began with a funding request from Miami’s club sports, bring-ing attention to the fiscal numbers involved in club sports activities. Student Body Vice President Matt Frazier questioned the large numbers requested by Miami’s equestrian team ($80,717.20), and was told the team has con-siderably larger expenses than most other club sports teams and they often have to pay out of pocket for many expenses.

The meeting continued with the elections of three positions; the President Pro-Tempore, the Parliamentar-ian and the representative to University Senate.

Senator Brandon Patter-son won the President Pro-Tempore position, beating out opponents Tom Ho-hman and Mike Merrill. The President Pro-Tem-

pore is one of the highest leadership positions within ASG. Patterson, a Student Orientation Undergradu-ate Leader (SOUL), a member of ASG’s funding committee, scholar leader and mock trial member,

detailed how his experiences in

ASG and as a SOUL quali-fied him for the position. He prom-

ised to bring in “great speak-

ers” to come to ASG’s weekly meetings.

Conor Nelson, a senator for Heritage Commons and formerly for Peabody Hall, won the position of ASG Parliamentarian. Nelson faced questioning by other members of ASG to see if he was the right candidate for the job and fielded questions regarding the ex-act nature of his duties.

“Parliamentarian is actu-ally a simple job,” Nelson said. “You are the head of an administrative commit-tee that looks at the bills we pass and makes sure they hold against the constitu-tion of ASG.”

Peter Dougherty, sub-bing for an absent senator, grilled Nelson about his exact knowledge of ASG’s bylaws by asking him to state where in the organiza-tion’s informational binder the role of Parliamentarian is defined. Nelson imme-diately responded with the

ohio Governor appoints two alumni to Miami’s Board of Trustees

By LAuren ceroniecAmpuS editor

This article is part of a series The Miami Student is running about the University Archives. All information in the follow-ing article was obtained from the University Archives with the help of University Archi-vist Bob Schmidt.

The names of former Mi-ami University presidents are familiar to students — Robert Bishop, Orange Nash Stod-dard, David Tappan, William Anderson, Phillip Shriver, the list goes on and is featured on quite a few buildings on cam-pus. However, there are a few university presidents whose names never made it onto academic buildings, residence halls or stadiums. One such former president is George Junkin (1841-1844).

Junkin’s tenure as the sec-ond president of Miami lasted

only a few years, but in that time he managed to stir up quite a bit of controversy.

“He’s one of our forgotten presidents but he’s also one of the most colorful presi-dents we’ve had,” said Bob Schmidt, university archivist. “He’s my favorite part of the archives because he’s quite an interesting character and there’s a bit more to him than meets the eye.”

Junkin was indeed colorful. He went as far as to compare himself to a monarch in his in-auguration speech at the uni-versity and stressed discipline over learning.

“It matters little what be the methods of teaching and what the branches taught, if there is not government, nothing can be done efficiently,” Junkin said in his inaugural address.

Miami students living on campus today bemoan the sometimes strict rules of the

residence halls and wish for greater privacy while at col-lege. However, they can be grateful the strict disciplin-ary measures of the Junkin administration are long gone. While Junkin was president, he would have the faculty con-duct daily searches of the stu-dent’s rooms. In his mind, the biggest problem facing Miami was the sex he tried to prevent students from having.

In one of his university reports Junkin said, “the sexual vice is not exterpated [sic] but there has been no gross outbreak.”

Junkin’s university re-ports often contained only information about disciplin-ary action taken on campus with no mention of students’ academic progress.

He was not known to have a warm or fuzzy side while at Miami. Junkin once told a group of students when their

friend died, “your comrade is in hell and you will be there soon unless you change your course.”

Needless to say, Junkin was not popular with many of the students.

“There’s a lot of stuff he did you look at today and go ‘ugh,’ but he did do some good things,” Schmidt said.

“As far as the crackdown on disciplinary problems, he was the first to suggest they ban guns and firearms on campus. In that sense, you have to give him some credit.”

He was also strict in the aca-demic realm, and went so far as to ban students from hold-ing meetings unless they were given permission by the uni-versity and to prohibit students and faculty from discussing controversial subjects such as slavery and religion.

The subject of slavery was one Junkin seemed to struggle

with throughout his life. He didn’t support slavery, but he was against abolitionism as well as secession.

“The problem with Junkin is he was so combative it’s

hard to pigeonhole him into anything,” Schmidt said.

Junkin’s mixed feel-ings about slavery were not helped when one of his daughters married the fa-mous Confederate general Stonewall Jackson.

Although Junkin is mostly remembered for his intense discipline and opposition to students’ academic freedom, he did have some good quali-ties. He was good with money and managed to keep the university out of debt, even though the number of students attending the university de-clined under him. Junkin even made personal sacrifices to keep the university from go-ing into debt, such as getting rid of the university ground-skeeper and taking over the position himself.

Junkin left Miami in 1844 to become president of Lafay-ette College in Easton, Penn.

enterprise university debate continues

By urSuLA cAuffieLStAff Writer

The Miami University Board of Trustees – com-posed of nine voting mem-bers, three national trustees and two non-voting students – presented its two newest members: David Budig and Mark Ridenour Sept. 13. Both men are Miami Univer-sity alumni and are happy to come back and make a dif-ference for the school. They were appointed by Ohio Governor John Kasich for the voluntary position and are excited about being on the board.

Budig is currently the

Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer for Budco Group. The Bud-co group is a large, private equipment rental and leasing company out of Cincinnati. Budig has two sons at Miami right now: Max, a junior and Quinn, a first-year.

Over the years, Budig has kept his ties close with Miami and that is one of the reasons he was chosen for the position.

Budig, a 1984 graduate said, “I was chosen for the Board because of my in-volvement with Miami Uni-versity over the years and my commitment to keeping Miami one of the premier

universities in the country.”According to Budig, he

is filling the position of Kay Geiger, who left the board a week before he was appointed.

“Each Board member’s term is staggered which means there could be a new Board member appointed each year,” Budig said. “This year, Mark Ridenour was se-lected by the Governor for a full term and I was appointed to fulfill the term vacated by Kay Geiger.”

His term is ending in 2013, but the Governor can renew it upon appointment. His main duties will be work-ing with the other board

members on critical issues that arise to keep Miami head-ed in a positive direction.

The other new board member, Mark E. Ridenour, is also a Miami alumnus. Ridenour is the Executive Vice President and Chief Fi-nancial Officer for Heidtman Steel Products, Inc. in To-ledo, Ohio. Heidtman Steel Products sells steel process-ing equipment and machines that make necessary items.

“Typically, members are appointed due to spe-cial skills or relationships with Miami that would in turn enhance the board and Miami as well as exhibit a willingness to serve the

institution,” Ridenour said. “I also have a strong background in public service serving other institutions on boards and committees.”

Being a Miami alumnus and having so much experi-ence, it is easy to see why Ridenour was appointed.

Ridenour’s position on the Board of Trustees will involve similar duties to Bu-dig’s position, but also has some specifications that he knows of. According to Ride-nour, he will be involved in overseeing all financial, ac-counting, IT, legal, credit and HR functions of the board.

Miami junior Ali Sey-frath was impressed with

the qualifications of the new trustees.

“I think that they both sound very intelligent and have been successful in their current ca-reers,” Seyfarth said. “That shows that they are going to be very involved on the board. I also think it’s great that they are Miami alumni. It makes me feel that I can trust them to do what is best for the students, and university as a whole.”

Ridenour is pleased to be returning to mother Miami.

“(I’m) glad to be back to help advance Miami in the future and make it an even better institution of higher learning than it is today,” Ridenour said.

ASG holds elections for three positions

The problem with Junkin is he was so combative it’s hard to pigeonhole him into anything.”

BoB SchmidtuniverSity ArchiviSt

We are not sitting here waiting for an opportunity that allows us to radically raise tuition.”

dAvid hodGemiAmi univerSity preSident

ASG,See PaGe 8

ANDREW BRAY THE MIAMI STUDENT

GETTING THEIR GREEK ONAbove, Greek Week softball with Jordan Lafferty of Chi Psi. Top right, members of Chi Omega participating in the obstacle course. Bottom right, Greek Week basketball.

3 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011www.miamistudent.net

LISA GEHRING THE MIAMI STUDENT

ALLISON BACKOVSKI THE MIAMI STUDENT

9,000...The number of Miami Student

readers who will see

YOUR AD HERE!To advertise inThe Miami Student, please contact

Joe Gioffre at gioffrjv@muohio.edu.

Male reports iPod golf clubs stolen from car

JUSTIN REASHSARAH SIDLOW

COMMUNITY@MIAMISTUDENT.NET4 COMMUNITYFRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011

POLICE BEAT

At around 4 p.m. Mon-day, a Miami University se-nior reported multiple items missing from his vehicle that was parked next to his house sometime overnight. The student found two of his golf clubs missing in the trunk and his iPod missing from the front console, police re-ports said. The glove com-partment was also opened. No damage was found to his vehicle, police reports said.

Uptown unrest highlights police staffing concernsBY SHANNON PESEkSENIOR STAff WRITER

After the unrest that oc-curred uptown during the early morning hours of Sept. 11, the recent de-crease in officers at the Oxford Police Depart-ment (OPD) is a concern among students.

Interim Police Chief Bob Holzworth, who recently replaced Stephan Schwein, said the disturbance up-town was not a riot, instead referring to what occurred as “not unusual.”

“What occurred was not a riot, it was just a couple of groups from outside of the city and it was blown

up into a confrontation,” Holzworth said.

Holzworth has been with OPD for 38 years and re-garded the only unusual part of the uprising as the sudden “pulsing” into the street.

Holzworth was not uptown when this event occurred.

Zoey Hesp, a senior at Miami University, was up-town when the unrest took place and characterized it as more of a “mob” than a riot.

“I would not even call what occurred a riot, it was more of a mob. And, the police response was instan-taneous,” Hesp said.

Sgt. John Varley attrib-uted the unrest to the need for OPD to hire replace-ment officers for those that have retired.

“Shifts are light due to man power, if more offi-cers had been on duty they could have seen it, maybe. But, it happened so fast that it may not have made a dif-ference,” Varley said.

Nevertheless, Varley be-lieves that it would have been better to have more officers available to re-spond to the unrest.

Varley confirmed there were three arrests and three citations for disorderly con-duct issued after the con-frontation was controlled.

The decrease in offi-cers at OPD is due to the recent retirement of five officers, whose positions have not yet been filled, Holzworth said.

“We’re working dili-gently to fill the positions, but we are just a little un-derstaffed. There are only a few positions that we have been unable to fill, but we have the authorization to do so,” Holzworth said.

Holzworth said that within the next few months, the department should be fully staffed.

However, despite the de-creased number of officers, Holzworth believes Oxford is still as safe as ever.

“We still have multiple units that are 24 hour units, there are just less right now. We can still adequately pro-tect the public, but it will be safer when we fill these po-sitions,” Holzworth said.

Varley said the most im-portant way for students and residents to feel safer is to prevent events such as the unrest on Sept. 11.

“People need to be re-sponsible because bad things can happen and people can get hurt,” Varley said.

Hesp, upon hearing that

Female finds drunken man standing in shower

A Miami student re-ported an intoxicated male standing in her shower stall 2 a.m Sunday on Sycamore Street. When she went into the shower, she saw the male standing fully clothed with vomit on his shirt, po-lice reports said. When she asked what he was doing, he said he lived there. She told him he had the wrong house and then he walked out the front door. The in-cident was documented but the student did not want to file a report.

Suspect throws rock through home window

At 2:15 a.m. Wednesday, a rock was thrown through the north patio door of a home located on Bishop Avenue. The subsequent damage was a broken glass door. The victim said they did not see anyone and did not call the police at the time of the incident.

Boy receives citation for not going to school

Around 7:15 a.m Tuesday, a mother called police re-garding her 15-year-old son who refused to go to school. Police arrived and the 15 year-old, who has a history of attendance issues, was on the couch. The juvenile was cited for unruly behavior.

Hamilton debuts paving experiment to save moneyBY SARAH SIDLOW COMMUNITY EDITOR

Drivers travelling on Eaton Road in Hamilton will be, perhaps unknowingly, par-ticipating in a rather unusual experiment conducted by the Butler County Engi-neer’s Office (BCEO). The BCEO has begun laying down six different paving solutions on approximately one half-mile stretch of road, including blacktop and chip seal sections.

The effort is in order to indentify the most cost-effec-tive solution for paving roads in Butler County.

“We’re trying to determine which surface treatment gives us the most bang for our buck,” Chris Petrocy, spokes-person for BCEO, said. “In this economy, governments are just like public businesses. We’re doing everything we can to cut expenses and save tax dollars.”

Much of the fiscal pressure comes from increases in fuel and resurfacing costs.

Choosing the chip seal solution over black-top, for example, saves

about $100,000 per mile. “The task now is to figure out what roads are appropriate to do the more inexpensive treat-ments,” Petrocy said. “Heav-ily travelled areas, particu-larly in West Chester, Liberty Township and Oxford will get more blacktop. Granted [chip seal] is not quite as nice, but as the traffic presses the gravel into the tar, it’s really not a bad treatment at all.”

BCEO plans to finish lay-ing the pavement by the end of September, though the re-cent rain has proven problem-atic, Petrocy said. The testing process will cost $27,000.

Drivers shouldn’t notice any difference in drivability on Eaton Road, Petrocy said. While some sections may be smoother than others initially, once the roads are driven on, everything will smooth out.

BCEO will evaluate the road over the course of the next five years and will ex-amine the paving solutions quarterly, after each season. The BCEO is particularly interested in how each so-lution will stand up to road salt and snow plows, as well as the relative safety of each

surface, Petrocy said.Butler County Engineer

Greg Wilkens commented on the unusual nature of the project.

“[The project] came about because there are so many new products on the market now,” he said.

Wilkens said traffic has been and will continue to be maintained as the paving products are laid out.

Miami junior Evan Burch thinks this experi-mental procedure is an innovative solution.

“I know back home, when the roads get worn down, they pour new blacktop no matter what. I think if they took the time to investigate other solu-tions they could end up saving a lot of money,” Burch said.

BY JUSTIN REASHCOMMUNITY EDITOR

Over the years, Brick Street Bar and Grill has become a beloved enter-tainment venue. From live concerts to themed nights, Brick Street provides the type of entertainment col-lege students crave. Owned by Mark and Will Weis-man, who also own 45 East Bar and Grill and Will’s Pizza, Brick Street’s popu-larity reaches much further than Oxford.

Throughout the past two decades, and with the help of social media, Brick Street has gained a faithful following of professional athletes who, whether in Oxford for the night or a weekend, always seem to end up at the bar they all love.

This high-profile group of followers has only served to further enhance Brick Street’s reputation in the Midwest.

“It’s good publicity when professional athletes or other celebrities choose to come in your establish-ments,” Will Weisman said. “With Twitter and texting,

word gets out pretty quick and students get a kick out of taking pictures and get-ting a chance to meet these guys. Fortunately, the Mi-ami [University] students are respectful and the ath-letes enjoy the interaction.”

A member of almost every major professional league in the United States has stopped by Brick Street at one time or another.

However, it is former Miami student-athletes that return the most to their old bar.

Athletes like Ron Harp-er, Wally Szczerbiak and Jake Bell have all returned more than once to Brick Street (and each have a signed jersey on the wall of the bar). The most fa-mous professional athlete to come out of Miami, Ben Roethlisberger, has visited the bar many times and has remained good friends with the Weismans since his time as a student.

“Of course, there are many former Miami hock-ey players who are now in the NHL that come back and visit us on an annual basis,” Weisman said.

Non-alumni professional

athletes have been to Brick Street as well. Former Ohio State University ath-letes Anthony Gonzalez and Ted Nugent (both cur-rently in the NFL) have stopped in according to Weisman, along with Rob Gronkowski of the New England Patriots and UFC champion Rich Franklin. Brandon Phillips of the Cincinnati Reds has been to Brick Street twice, with his last appearance happen-ing Sept. 16.

“It was really neat when he tweeted to his 150,000 followers that he was head-ing to Brick Street for the night,” Weisman said of Phillips’ appearance.

Asked if Brick Street has ever paid a player to come, Weisman said, “We have never paid a professional athlete as it cheapens the impact. We are proud that [when] these folks choose to come to Brick Street they know they will be treated in a first class way.”

Weisman said his fa-vorite memory with a professional athlete over the years involved Pitts-burgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.

“One night me and Ben were intentionally getting rough with each other be-cause Ben said to me the ‘I want to get officially thrown out by Will Weisman.’ We were both laughing about it but it was dark and

employees and customers could not see that we were joking and thought that a fight was brewing,” Weis-man said. “Once they saw

Local bar feels love from celebrities

JULIA ENGELBRECHT THE MIAMI STUDENT

The jerseys of former Miami athletes Ben Roethlisberger and Wally Szczerbiak hang on the wall of Brick Street

BRICk,SEE PAGE 13

RIOT,SEE PAGE 13

BY LISA REYMANN fOR THE MIAMI STUDENT

The numbers of uptown student apartments have steadily been increasing in the past four years. Since 2007, 327 new beds have

been added to the structural layout of the buildings on and just off High Street, according to Alan Kyger, Oxford economic develop-ment director. Although in-creased housing options and new locations sound ideal

to most upperclassmen, the detail of parking has yet to be fully addressed.

The issue was discussed in August at an uptown land-lords, property owners and property managers meet-ing between the Chamber of Commerce, Oxford Po-lice Department and various business owners.

“This summer, the City Council voted to make all of the Uptown District ‘No Overnight Parking,’” Kyger said. “This was done for two reasons: one, to allow street cleaning and maintenance, and two, to encourage uptown residents to store their cars in long term parking lots.”

Park Place Real Estate houses approximately 100 students uptown and this school year the company opened up additional apart-ments. Luke Williams, a se-nior living in one of the com-plexes, was fortunate enough to find a solution of what he could do with his vehicle.

“Park Place provides two parking spots per four-person

Uptown district sees increase in beds, but not parking spaces

ANDREW BRAY THE MIAMI STUDENT

Packed parking lots are a common sight uptown

We’re trying to determine which surface treatment gives us the most bang for our buck.”

CHRIS PETROCYBCEO spokesperson

PARkING,SEE PAGE 13

Professional athletes routinely visit Brick Street Bar and Grill

London Barcelona Athens Munich Lauterbrunnen

Summer 2012 Multi-Site Business in Europe Program Offered by Professors Tom Porcano and Wayne Staton

Experience Western Europe!

Open to All Majors

Attend Our Family Weekend Presentation Saturday, September 24, 9:00-10:00 a.m. at the Sigma Nu house (300 N. Tallawanda)

Contact: porcantm@muohio.edu or statonw@muohio.edu

5 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011www.miamistudent.net

The proposal by the de-partment of comparative religion to bring a member of the Westboro Baptist Church (WBC) to campus has caused an uproar in the Miami community. Shirley Phelps-Roper was to visit professor Hillel Gray’s 100-level class on religious extremism. The depart-ment has since dropped these plans. In response to this situation, the editorial board of The Miami Student considered two questions: whether Gray should be able to bring Phelps-Roper to campus, and whether Gray and the department would be right to follow through with the plan.

We came to an immedi-ate and clear consensus that Gray and any other profes-sor is within his or her rights to invite whoever they want to their classes unless there is a threat to safety, especially if the event in

question is optional for stu-dents. Academic freedom is the bedrock of intellectual inquiry. It is what enables free thought and scholarly pursuits to take place on this campus. However, aca-demic freedom comes with responsibilities in addition to rights.

This board was nearly evenly split on the ques-tion of whether going ahead with the visit would have been a good idea. In the end, we decided the potential harm from the visit outweighed the educational benefits.

A WBC visit would have offered students, faculty and the community expo-sure to a group of people who view their cause as rational. This would have been a rare opportunity for the students in the religious extremism class to interact with someone whose views are almost universally

rejected by society.But the problem with a

WBC visit goes beyond arguments of First Amend-ment rights. The WBC is known for their overt hate-speech. The group tar-gets large fractions of the American public as a ploy to garner media attention and further its cause.

Generally, this board un-derstands the societal value of minority viewpoints. But some viewpoints are so heinous and potentially harmful they do not de-serve an equal seat at the table. While the group has the constitutional right to speak, why go out of our way to listen? Why give them the satisfaction of knowing they are being heard? WBC should be left to shout their hate into a vacuum, perhaps observed to the extent that we can understand and avoid their twisted views.

EditorsNoëlle BerNard

ThomasiNa JohNsoN Editorial@miamistudEnt.nEt6 OPINION

FridaY, sePTemBer 23, 2011

Oldest university newspaper in the United States, established 1826

The Miami Student

Editorial Board

sam Kay ediTor iN ChieF

BEthany BrunEr News ediTor

noëllE BErnard ediTorial ediTor

thomasina Johnson ediTorial ediTor

Justin rEash CommUNiTY ediTor

laurEn CEroniE CamPUs ediTor

JEnni WiEnEr CamPUs ediTor

miChaEl solomon sPorTs ediTor

amanda sEitz sPeCial rePorTs ediTor

all letters must be signed in order to be printed. Please send letters via e-mail to: editorial@miamistudent.net We reserve the right to edit for length, content and clarity.

the following letters were submitted before the department of Comparative religion announced its decision to withdraw its plans for a WBC visit.

Westboro Baptist Church abuses their right to speak

The freedom of speech is something that I feel we all have access too and should not be hindered in using in any way. In regards to the Westboro Baptist Church (WBC), they have the right to protest in the ways they do and they take full advan-tage of this right. However, it seems that their use of this right verges on the edge of abuse at times. Protest-ing a nine-year-old shoot-ing victim’s funeral and saying that this is “God’s

punishment for America’s lack of morals” seems to be more of a tactic in hate-ful torment than expressing legitimate concerns. The radical views and actions by WBC against homosexuals, various political groups and almost every religious sect have even the KKK calling them a group of “hate mon-gers.” I found it interesting that a Miami University professor would invite such a group to speak in their publicly funded classroom.

If the WBC is invited to speak, then why not invite another group with similar caustic tones, perhaps the neo-Nazis? Calling atten-tion to a group such as this does nothing but provide fuel to their fire and furthers the hateful messages they wish to spread. Messages that do not seem to fall in line with Miami’s call for “love and honor.”

stEPhEn hEndriCKsonhEndrisJ@muohio.Edu

scripture, used by WBC to espouse hate, holds keys to combat hate

Like many in the Miami University community, (I am the parent of a current stu-dent), I initially reacted with dismay to the news that Pro-fessor Hillel Gray had invited a representative of the West-boro Baptist Church (WBC) to participate in his Com-parative Religion class. My reaction was based on equal measures of horror at WBC’s hateful practices and a belief that the First Amendment in no way requires either Miami or Professor Gray to provide WBC with a platform.

After reflection, I have come to believe that Profes-sor Gray’s invitation is exact-ly the action that one would hope for from a professor of Comparative Religion and from a leading institution of higher education. Having

WBC participate in his class will give the Miami com-munity the opportunity to go beyond a mere visceral reac-tion to WBC, and to instead to have them “explain” the scriptures that they use to justify their hateful behavior; and to then be able to criti-cally examine WBC’s scrip-tural interpretation within a religious framework.

I suspect that WBC mis-takenly bases its picketing of soldiers’ funerals on the “curses,” particularly the curse of military defeat that Moses uses to exhort his people in his final address contained in the book of Deuteronomy. If so, WBC ignores Moses’ message that blessings flow from societal justice; including command-ments to contribute to the

widow, the orphan and the immigrant and that curses are the result of an unjust and divisive society. WBC also ignores the fundamental les-son, also contained in Moses’ final speech, that each of us is created in God’s image. When WBC blasphemes the funeral of one of our soldiers, their actions are a direct re-proach to God, our Creator.

I don’t know what Profes-sor Gray’s lesson plan will be. But how else can Miami’s students gain a better under-standing of how scripture can be misused to create hate and how that same scripture can be better used to combat hate?

aBraham KayafK55Ps@aol.Com

lEttErs to thE Editor

A story broke in The Miami Student on Monday, Sept. 19, that had some unfortunate inaccuracies and produced unnecessary anxiety. The Department of Comparative Religion had been discussing the possibility of holding an event in conjunction with a class on religious extremism that was using the Westboro Baptist Church as one of its case studies. We were explor-ing the idea of the instructor of the class holding an inter-view with a member of this group using research meth-ods that we believe are vitally important for understand-ing the human dimension of religious extremism.

It is unfortunate that while we were still in the plan-ning stage, someone leaked a memorandum about the proposed event to The Mi-ami Student. The memo that we put together to seek guid-ance from various stakehold-ers on campus was clear on this point: we were in no way considering inviting the West-boro Baptist Church to come and evangelize.

In light of the many con-cerns that have been ex-pressed, we have decided not to proceed with plans re-garding the Westboro Baptist Church. Although studying religious activists, religious extremists and religious militants is vitally impor-tant, we see the complexi-ties that arise when this sort of research is done under the auspices of Miami University and we appreciate the poten-

tial negative impact on the Miami community.

Our department’s interest in the Westboro Baptist Church arose in the context of a class on religious activists and ex-tremists taught by a member of our department who has done interviews with mem-bers of that group. We have invited him to make a public presentation on his research, tentatively scheduled for Oct. 25, and we hope that many of you who have expressed con-cerns will attend. In this way, we wish to inaugurate discus-sion of the difficult question of studying the offensive, hated, or dangerous.

Something that may be good about the public out-cry — despite the disinfor-mation and sensationalizing that have occurred — is the opportunity to have conver-sations about how to study the incendiary language of activist and extremist reli-gious groups without giving added power to such groups. That is obviously a question on which people will have diverse perspectives.

Some scholars working in the field of comparative reli-gion have chosen to study the hated haters, the most inflam-matory of religious activists, to try to understand the forma-tion and development of such groups. The need is clearly im-portant. But how is this to be done? What methodological protocols should be followed? How might this be translated into pedagogical strategies for the classroom? These

are questions that frame the current controversy over the proposed interview with rep-resentatives of the Westboro Baptist Church.

The importance of scholar-ship on religious extremists and religious militants has been acknowledged by gov-ernment agencies in recent years. After the tragic events at Waco, for example, the FBI began consultations with the American Academy of Reli-gion, the professional associa-tion for scholars in compara-tive religion. It was clear that scholars could provide useful frameworks for understand-ing the Branch Davidians in Waco, Texas.

Unlike the Branch David-ians, the Westboro Baptist Church is not a physically violent group. As horrifying as their rhetoric is, what vio-lence has occurred at West-boro Baptist Church picket-ing events has typically been directed at them. Such violent responses to this group can have the effect of confirm-ing their own confrontational world view.

We thank all of those who have shared their thoughts and opinions with us. We believe this kind of conver-sation is vitally important and hope that you will join us in the conversations that we plan to have this year.

stEPhEn a. nimisProfEssor of ClassiCs, intErim Chair of ComParativE rEligionnimissa@muohio.Edu

a message from the department of Comparative religion

Consider what if would look like if WBC appeared on campus

There is a lot of murmur-ing going on in the student body of Miami University about the possibility of any Westboro Baptist Church (WBC) members coming to one of our campuses. None of it is particularly positive, even from a guy like me who cannot resist playing devil’s advocate to really terrible ideas to try and understand the “why” of it all. The in-vitation has not yet been ap-proved, so let’s not get ahead of ourselves here, but for the sake of argument, let’s look at it as though some-one had the idea of inviting them to our school in the first place, which is actually completely true.

I understand that it is not as many might think it is; it is not a rally, it is merely a small classroom interview. I also do not believe that the idea behind this invita-tion has anything to do with supporting the Westboro Baptist Church and I recog-nize that the school does not condone their message, as per President Hodge’s very clear statement on the mat-ter. So let’s not look at this as condoning the opinions or actions of the Westboro Baptist Church.

But, how can we not look at it like that? Even if the school itself is not inviting the entire compound to come and rally on our streets, what guarantee do we have that such a situation will not oc-cur? How can we know that the group will not want to gather around one of our surrounding cities or towns and set up a demonstration? Wouldn’t we be at least par-tially to blame for that?

The idea of having some-one that wants to incite ha-tred towards a specific group of people as our guest seems in poor taste. There’s really no way around that. It sim-ply is not a good idea. What would make it a good idea? I have my sincerest doubts that any good open dialogue will be had with a repre-sentative of the Westboro Baptist Church, as you can-not speak reasonably with the unreasonable. We know their answers to all of the questions. Anyone who has seen as much WBC cover-age as I have can tell you that all of the answers are, well, it’s because they think God hates the entire world for al-lowing homosexuals to exist and that is why all bad things happen. Except maybe God

doesn’t hate the members of their church. But everyone else is doomed to hell.

There you go, not only did I just save some depart-mental money on flying someone out here, we also dodged that crazy tension bullet that would result from inviting a hate group to our school after there have re-cently been gay-related hate crimes committed on our own campuses.

If you want to educate a class on the hatred of the Westboro Baptist Church, check out YouTube. It’s easy to find some good ex-amples. Louis Theroux had a wonderful documentary in 2007 called The Most Hated Family in America and even followed up on it with America’s Most Hated Family in Crisis in 2011. Plenty of information can be had there.

The invite, as I understand it, is still pending approval. More people need to speak out about how they feel concerning this issue. Who knows, maybe someone will listen.

JosEPh rayrayJP@muohio.Edu

Westboro visit must encourage peaceful, respectful exchange of ideas

The open exchange of information and ideas is paramount to the develop-ment and dissemination of knowledge and ideas. With that in mind, I would like to posit that the Westboro Baptist Church’s visit to Miami University should be cautiously embraced for what it is — an invita-tion by a professor of Re-ligious Extremism to Shir-ley Phelps-Roper to be the subject of an interview for hate groups. This group’s beliefs are rooted in an extremely fundamentalist and literal construction and interpretation of Christian-ity. It’s hard to separate their religious beliefs from bigoted hatred with slo-gans such as “Thank God for 9-11,” “Priests Rape

Boys” and “Thank God for Dead Soldiers.”

With the general consen-sus (even in the Supreme Court) that Westboro’s speech is harmful, even hateful, it is appropriate that a Westboro spokes-woman is being invited to a class entitled “Religious Extremism.” Even more apropos, this spokeswoman is being invited as a mem-ber of a hate group. In light of these circumstanc-es, Shirley Phelps-Roper’s visit is quite suitable — I struggle to think of a more hateful group.

In contrast to Westboro’s antagonistic approach of spreading their judgmen-tal version of religion, Spectrum and many oth-er student organizations

offer peaceful, respectful dialogue between opposing views. In Spectrum, every meeting begins with a Re-spect Agreement, a general code of mutual respect es-tablished for all people. It’s how we run our meetings and it’s how we grow. All people are included in our discussion, and anyone who desires to speak has a chance to have his or her voice heard. Peaceful, re-spectful exchange of infor-mation builds knowledge and enhances education. Visit http://spectrummiami.wordpress.com for more in-formation about Spectrum.

Billy PriCECo-PrEsidEnt, sPECtrumPriCEWC@muohio.Edu

Editorial

academic freedom is a vital right, but comes with responsibilities

The following piece, written by the editorial editors, reflects the majority opinion of the editorial board.

7FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011 OPINIONwww.miamistudent.net

LIBERTY AND JUSTICETY GILLIGAN

Hate group visit must not be allowed in classroom forum

It was announced in Mon-day’s edition of The Miami Student that a request from the Department of Compara-tive Religion to allow Shirley Phelps-Roper, a member of the Westboro Baptist Church, (WBC) to speak at Miami University, is currently under consideration by Miami’s administration. I feel that a majority of the Oxford com-munity, as well as myself, are confused and disgusted by the mere suggestion of the WBC coming anywhere near Oxford’s campus. Al-lowing Ms. Phelps to speak at Miami would be horribly disrespectful and a slap-in-the-face to the majority of Miami’s students.

I understand the argument that all sides of an issue must be explored in order for indi-viduals to come to a conclu-sion about a topic. This is why universities often sponsor controversial politicians or ce-lebrities to speak. However, it is foolish to believe that some-thing about Christianity and religion can be learned from the WBC.

The WBC does not engage in productive, open dialogue; they engage in name-calling and personal attacks, tactics more suitable for a kindergar-ten playground than an aca-demic setting. To think that Ms. Phelps can impart some sort of “knowledge” or “wis-dom” on Miami students is a complete joke. Frankly, if the department of comparative religion or individual profes-sors supporting the visit feel Ms. Phelps would be a good speaker, why not invite the Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan? Or perhaps the leader of the Aryan Nation? Appar-ently, any ideology is worth

sharing with students here at Miami. That was sarcasm, in case it wasn’t clear.

The WBC may be one of the most hated groups of peo-ple in America; I have yet to meet a single individual who remotely agrees with any-thing the WBC preaches. The “church” targets gays and lesbians, African-Americans, Jews, Roman Catholics, most mainline Protestant churches (Lutheran, Methodist, Pres-byterian, Anglican, Baptists), Muslims, Hindus and military service members. It’s a lengthy list and it would appear that everyone except WBC mem-bers are “going to hell.” It’s worthwhile to note that The Anti-Defamation League and the Southern Poverty Law Center monitor the WBC as a hate group. No wonder.

The Westboro Baptist Church thrives on media at-tention it gets for its childish displays. Miami would only appease them by giving them a public forum. Compensation is irrelevant. If the WBC does actually come to campus, stu-dents will be in an uproar and might protest Phelps appear-ance, and Miami would be in the national spotlight as the center of a controversy. This is exactly what the Westboro Baptist Church counts on; getting a large enough nega-tive reaction that the media is brought in to report on the controversy, thus giving them a platform to spread their hate and “ideology.” I refuse to let Miami provide that forum for them.

I am very confused as to why the comparative religion department thinks a conver-sation with the WBC would be informative or prudent. A BBC report in 2007 indicated

that the church only had 71 members and almost all of them are extended relatives of one another. According to several religious associations, the WBC is not affiliated with any Baptist convention or as-sociation. It’s essentially one family living in a compound in Kansas. The WBC doesn’t represent a theological branch of Christianity or even a set of common beliefs within Christianity. Even extreme fundamentalist groups within Christianity are offended by the WBC. They are extremists pure and simple.

The president of the Com-parative Religion Student As-sociation said that allowing the WBC to speak is like allow-ing the Dalai Lama to speak. I find this statement frighten-ingly misinformed. Equating Buddhism to the WBC is like equating al-Qaeda to Catholi-cism; you can’t equate a small extremist group to a world-wide, mainstream religion with millions of followers and a solidified ideology. The Dalai Lama represents hun-dreds of millions of Buddhists worldwide. Shirley Phelps-Roper represents 71 members of her church in Topeka; they are fundamentally different organizations and should not be lumped together.

I hope the College of Arts and Sciences and the admin-istration will carefully review and scrutinize this proposal and recognize the negative impact it will have on the university population. The university should not be sac-rificing a comfortable atmo-sphere for the majority of its students, simply for the (un-likely) potential benefits for a few REL 102 classes. It is not justifiable.

ESSAYJ. DANIEL WATKINSWATKINJD@mUoHIo.EDU

Where’s the open exchange when refusing unpopular visitors?

With the recent announce-ment of only the potential visit from a spokesperson of the Westboro Baptist Church (WBC), I read, as the com-ments on the article did noth-ing to refute the existence of “Godwin’s Law.” This states that the longer an on-line discussion goes on the probability that it will include references to or mentions of Hitler reaches 1. Rest as-sured, the comment section of The Miami Student did not disappoint. It happened. See-ing as this group, the WBC, has made a name for itself on the easily categorized ac-tions of religious craze/hate, one cannot help but wonder what an actual interview with someone like Shirley Phelps-Roper would be like. And if you don’t wonder, I hope that college didn’t rid you all of your academic cu-riosity. In particular, one of these comments mentioned reviving Hitler to give him an interview as an equal option. One even said it would be better to invite “Neo-Nazis” to campus!

Besides all the obvious dif-ferences, like genocide, I think there is a point to be made here. Better for it though, are the tapings of Eichmann’s trial in Jerusalem. Take this in combination with the Han-nah Arendt book Eichmann in Jerusalem: the Banality of Evil and there exists rea-sonable grounds for such an interview. When people dis-cussed the atrocities that took place, they were able to refer directly to what the master-mind explained. Instead of making assumptions about what he might have thought was right or wrong in his actions, people were able to examine first hand. This is a

real opportunity to shed light on existing moral reasoning.

Here we can provide this opportunity for Shirley Phelps-Roper. As an attor-ney, she argued before the Supreme Court and got an 8-1 decision in favor of pro-tecting her group’s actions. There must exist, in some form, intelligence worth exploring here.

If one is to believe the comments left on the article, then I must admit, there is no hope for understanding on either side. But consider this, every person drawing comparisons and separations from WBC seems to miss the entire point. The members of the WBC are exercising constitutionally protected rights, and of course, this doesn’t make such opinions correct. It doesn’t mean they need to do it, but I can count on no hands the number of times I’ve seen this particu-lar woman give an interview with the sole intention being to provide, for academic pur-poses, more insight in their motivations. If you respond, “there are no reasons, they’re just crazy,” yet immediately draw a line between their brand of religion and your own, then you should prob-ably reconsider the premise, because that’s an intensely arbitrary distinction.

Another complaint is the subject of financing. It will cost the university precisely $0.00. If the university pro-vides no compensation to Phelps-Roper but the abil-ity to voice WBC’s position, how does one arrive at the opinion it is disgraceful for her to come anyway? To the credit of an academic insti-tution, where people should never fear expressing an

opinion, it follows logically in no way that such a person should be denied the oppor-tunity to speak. People don’t want her, or members of her group here, because they find it offensive. An entirely emo-tional response, alluding to shame and anger (seriously read those comments on the article), again fails a litmus test that provides censor-ship as a legitimate course of action.

Furthermore, the pres-ence will be so minimal, that there’s not even a ticketed event for students to come and hear her. Controversial figures such as Karl Rove and Christopher Hitchens were at least afforded this.

In the end, it would be much easier to address the scenario in this light. Taken from On Liberty, the work of John Stuart Mill, we can ad-dress the importance of being able to share opinions.

“If all mankind minus one were of one opinion, and only one person were of the contrary opinion, mankind would be no more justified in silencing that one per-son, than he, if he had the power, would be justified in silencing mankind.”

A final criticism amounts to “I don’t want to prevent their opinions from being shared, I only want them not to be shared or defended in relation to my interests or place.” They can say what-ever/wherever they want, as long as it doesn’t affect or isn’t near me. If your posi-tion is not to support the free exchange of ideas, no matter how unpopular, then don’t be surprised when I advocate for you not to appear or speak on campus, because it’s doubtful you’ll agree.

ESSAYANDREW BoWmANBoWmANAJ@mUoHIo.EDU

miami’s smoking ban will continue to be full of hot air unless enforced

“All Miami University Campuses are designated Smoke-Free Environments,” says the Miami University Student Handbook 2011-2012 edition. Didn’t get a chance to read the handbook? The hun-dreds of signs and postings on all of the buildings should be plenty obvious then, since it is state law that they are printed in color.

Yet, every time I walk on campus, I see multiple people smoking. Students are the main offenders, but employees smoke on campus too, though out of view from their bosses.

The usual smoking hang-outs are outside the libraries and in front of the residence halls. Don’t be confused though, it happens through-

out the campus despite the university’s hard stance against tobacco.

There are, of course, with any laws, exceptions and loopholes. The exact rule is no smoking on university property. For instance, Miami does not own the west side of Campus Avenue. Also,

anyone in his or her own per-sonal vehicle can light one up. Both of these defeat the purpose of the ban. The wind can blow smoke from across the street, and if all the win-dows down in the car then it is completely pointless to have the ban.

In addition, the president

can grant zones for overnight guests of the university staying at any hotel or lodging type fa-cilities on campus, such as the Marcum Conference Center.

The arguments in favor of smoking stand on shaky ground. It lowers stress lev-els. Others argue that it is their constitutional right to slowly kill themselves.

Smoking is addictive. Smoking causes cancer. Sec-ond hand smoke causes can-cer and when smoke blows into other people’s vicinity, it stops being one person’s con-stitutional right and becomes the public’s problem. So on and so forth with the hundreds of arguments against it. The ar-gument isn’t whether smoking is good or bad, even though experts, scientists and people

with common sense know it is a waste of time, money and good health.

The problem is why it isn’t being enforced. Miami enforc-es parking laws to the letter, laws that do not hurt anyone. Yet, it won’t enforce a rule that protects its inhabitants from disease.

Granted, it is not entirely up to the role of formal officials on campus. Fellow students need to each other account-able. It is easy.

“Would you please not smoke here? Thank you.”

Polite. Direct. Quick. Still, a few oppose the rule and con-demn you for asking by giv-ing the bird (middle finger) or screaming at you.

For those people resis-tant to common decency, the

university should be stepping in and enforcing their own law. The Miami University Police Department (MUPD) has more important things to do, so it falls on other leader-ship positions on campus.

Around the residence halls, resident assistants (RAs) and the advisers should be enforc-ing the roles. It is disgusting to have someone else’s smoke blow into your room. Of course, some of the RAs and advisers will need to follow the rule first themselves, even if it means Susan Vaughn and the rest of the Office of Ethics and Student Conflict Reso-lution are working 12-hour shifts. To not enforce the ban is not only hypocritical but also makes the university appear weak.

JULIA ENGELBRECHT THE MIAMI STUDENT

On an average day, we interact with many different “groups” of people. You may have a group you study with on Tuesday nights, you may have a group you watch Jer-sey Shore with every Thurs-day or you may have a group that you go out with every weekend. Whatever the goal, most of us have groups of people who help us along in day-to-day life.

Most of us would like to admit that we are independent and self-sufficient. We’re out of our nests and we’re ready

to fly on our own. Help is not for us and we’ve got it all under control. Or so we’d like to believe. However, I believe that groups are a ne-cessity, a part of life we can-not live without. So much so, that we do not even realize the importance of having a group until we don’t have one anymore. These aren’t just friend groups I’m talking about, study groups, lunch groups, clubs and teams. A group is anything that has a goal that cannot be accom-plished by just one person.

Groups are beneficial to us in numbers of ways. Accord-ing to scientificamerican.com, being a part of social networks enhances our resil-ience and helps us cope later on in life with serious trauma or death. If you think about this in terms of your own life, you can see the truth to these findings. If your test went poorly, you have a group of classmates you can complain to and try to make sense of what didn’t make sense to you. Then you can come home to your roommate or

house mate and complain to them. While they may not be able to give you any insight into what you did wrong, they can console you and make you feel better. Those are two different groups right there helping you overcome sorrow in one short day.

But putting complaints aside, groups are also very helpful resources. We can exchange information with one another about where to eat, where to get our hair done or the best place to go on the weekends. They can

help us adjust to a new en-vironment or give us advice on how to survive a cer-tain class. Groups can also help enhance our academic knowledge. Study groups and project groups can help our knowledge base grow as we try to keep up with the smartest kid in the group. They may introduce us to new research methods or quick tips on how to side-step a long night of studying. Groups can help us better ourselves in every sense.

Ultimately, groups are

fundamental parts of life. Ev-eryone needs a group in or-der to survive. We have core groups in our lives, there are groups to monitor and help the education system, the judicial system and even the president. As people, we need each other to bounce exchanges and receive in-formation. It’s hard to admit at times, especially when we think so highly of our abili-ties to manage our own lives independently, but there will be times when we just need a little help from our friends.

ESSAYSARAH TITLETITLESE@mUoHIo.EDU

Group interaction can help us stay happier, healthier, fulfilled

Howe Writing Center helps garner national recognition

JEFFREY SOLOMON THE MIAMI STUDENT

JAI HO!The Miami Univesity Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Ricardo Averbach, performs for Indian composer AR Rahman Thursday.

8 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011 www.miamistudent.net

BY ABBY RuSS FOR THE MIAMI STudENT

Miami University stu-dents are no strangers to the ongoing changes on-line. With the axe of Black-board, Miami will welcome CampusEAI at the end of first semester.

CampusEAI, “EAI” standing for Enterprise Application Integration, is a web platform where students can receive more organized information.

“You will be able to get all of the information in one place so you won’t have to memorize pass-words for different fea-tures,” said Corey Close, marketing and commu-nications coordinator of CampusEAI.

MyMiami will have a new look designed by University Communica-tions using the new Miami branding. It will feature a single sign that will pro-vide access to Niihka, Ban-nerWeb, Gmail, Exchange and some social networking sites like Facebook, Cathy McVey, senior director of Strategic Communications and Planning said.

“The whole idea of the portal is to provide a one stop place where you can get lots of services, so stu-dents can see the dining hall menus, check their bursar bill, see their courses etc.,” McVey said.

CampusEAI will inte-grate these applications across the whole university hopefully after the initial launch of the new platform.

Students are familiar with the changes regard-ing Niihka and McVey is confident that the transition from Blackboard to Cam-pusEAI will be seamless in December.

“We didn’t get a lot of support from Black-board and the faculty was

unhappy,” McVey said. Miami won a grant to

help pay for CampusEAI and the cost has gone down significantly. The univer-sity paid $300,000 a year for Blackboard’s services and with the five-year grant, Miami will only be paying $75,000 per year for CampusEAI.

“There are a lot of ben-efits to the grant, including opportunities to collabo-rate with other schools,” said Jonathan Mullapudy, director of relationship management at CampusE-AI. He went on to say the

Blackboard does not offer as many features such as the Smartphone app and the ability to instant message other students.

Miami has been talk-ing with CampusEAI since the spring in preparation to launch at the end of Decem-ber when the contract with Blackboard is over.

McVey, Close and Mul-lapudy all said there will be no problem with the transi-tion to CampusEAI and that

the new platform will be easier for students to navi-gate than Blackboard.

“These changes are not drastic enough to confuse students,” Vice President of Student Organizations Meghan Wadsworth said.

CampusEAI’s platform will allow Miami to ex-pand its technology base bringing social media and mainstream technology to students.

“I think the new platform is a step in the right direc-tion as we move to update Miami’s most visited web-page,” Wadsworth said.

New social media platform to replace Miami’s most visited website

BY JESSIcA BARgAFOR THE MIAMI STudENT

Miami University will soon be taking part in a new accreditation process called Open Pathways, ad-ministered by the Higher Learning Commission, that will test the university’s ef-fectiveness as an institution of higher learning.

“[The] university has been chosen to pioneer a new process for affirming our accreditation,” said Cecilia Shore, executive

vice president for Aca-demic Affairs. According to Shore, the new process will involve two separate parts that will test the qual-ity of Miami’s programs and provide assurance for re-accreditation.

“[This] demonstrates to our accreditors we are a functional and effective organization for support-ing student learning on … different criteria levels,” Shore said. “[It] demon-strates our effectiveness as an institution.”

These criteria include having a clear mission, having integrity in deal-ings, being honest about in-formation like the financial aid process and understand-ing effectiveness in sup-porting teaching, learning and scholarship, according to Shore.

“[It’s an] effort to define for the public what a col-lege means … our project is to find out what Miami University believes what a degree qualifications profile means,” Shore said. “The

quality assurance process is already being implemented in that we are collecting data about our institution.”

Jennifer Blue, executive vice president for Aca-demic Affairs said, “We al-ways do two things … one is the assurance part, where we make sure we’re doing what we’re supposed to be doing and the second part is improvement.”

The difference between the new system and the old one, she said, is the splitting of the assurance program

into two separate parts. “The improvement part

is a degree qualifications profile … and the Higher Learning profile basically asked us to test a tool for them – and that is a degree qualifications profile. We’re supposed to see if that reso-nates with us,” Blue said.

Shore said that Miami is one of a group of 20 colleg-es, community colleges and universities nationwide that is using the new system of accreditation this year, with different schools being

selected each year. Miami first-year Anna

Tyrlik said she thinks the university is taking a posi-tive step by participating in the new accreditation sys-tem and improving itself for the students.

“It’s important for the university to not make stu-dents a number [by] teach-ing someone to learn not just a set of courses … so students [can] learn what they need to learn so they can be the best they can be,” Tyrlik said.

BY EMILY BALcHFOR THE MIAMI STudENT

US News and World Report recognized Miami University along with 23 other universities for mak-ing writing a priority. Writ-ing is essential and stressed for any major at Miami. All students have the op-tion to visit Howe Writ-ing Center for Excellence that plays a huge role in Miami’s recognition.

The Howe Writing Cen-ter is located in King Li-brary and a smaller center in Peabody Hall. Since its establishment, students of all majors have taken ad-vantage of this resource. In order to use this center, appointments are needed in advance and can be sched-uled online. If both of these locations are full, students can be put on waitlists in case someone cancels their appointment since there are only 222 consulta-tions per week, according to Maurica Allen, adminis-trative assistant of Howe.

“Comparing the first four weeks of this school year to last year, we have performed 18 percent more consultations,” Allen said.

Siobhan Watson, a sec-ond year graduate student and graduate assistant at the center, had more en-thusiastic remarks about this report and Howe. She was thrilled with the report

and thought all the work Miami is putting into writ-ing and the curriculum is paying off.

“We have been com-pletely booked for a couple weeks even with a ton of staff,” Watson said.

Howe is usually more popular around mid-terms and later into the semester, according to Watson.

Howe director, Paul Anderson, is elated to be recognized.

“We are turning stu-dents down, the demand is greater than the capacity,” Anderson said. “Consul-tants are really good and students are hearing from one another the value of coming here.”

The center has been busy due to the fact that profes-sors and the university are putting such an emphasis on writing, which goes along with the honor, ac-cording to Anderson.

Josh Kiger, a fifth year creative writing and history major and student manager of the center was very hap-py with the report and said the honor is deserved.

“When you work for a writing center like we do, you feel unappreciated until we are recognized,” Kiger said.

He said he believes there are many reasons why Howe has been recognized. Miami has put a lot of effort

into their writing program and realizes how important it is, according to Kiger. To improve the quality of the center this year, Howe has added more graduate consultants and personal consultants to work with international students.

“With a writing curricu-lum being so progressive, we had to up our staff a lot,” Kiger said.

Along with adding more staff, the center also has add-ed a program called “quick questions” that allows stu-dents to come in without an appointment just to ask questions on assignments or projects.

Kiger said writing and the Howe Writing center are very beneficial to stu-dents. “Writing goes across all subjects,” Kiger said. “Writing and good com-munication skills are what you need to be successful later in life.”

First year Ab-bey Kunce said Howe has helped her so far and she was not surprised by the report. She has gone twice so far this year and has two more appointments this week.

“They really help ex-plain what is wrong with my paper and they give me the right strategies to fix it,” Kunce said. “I don’t think I would able to get through my first semester without it.”

I think the new platform is a step in the right direction.”

MEgHAN WAdSWORTHVIcE PRESIdENT OF STudENT ORgANIZATIONS

University tests institutional effectiveness in pioneer accreditation process

correct page and paragraph.Senator Tom Hohman ran as a

candidate for both the President Pro-Tempore position and for the representative to University Sen-ate position. When questioned about his knowledge of Univer-sity Senate, Hohman faltered.

“I would think they do some-thing similar to (ASG), only with more power,” Hohman said.

Student body president Nick Huber asked Hohman if he has class during the regularly sched-uled University Senate meeting time, to which Hohman respond-ed “yes,” and that he would not be available. His competitor, first-year senator Cole Tyman, won the position.

The meeting closed with the introduction and passage of a resolution to pledge continued support of the forthcoming Arm-strong Student Center. The bill, co-authored by 11 senators and sponsored by ASG’s executive cabinet, promises to support the university in its ambition to con-struct the Armstrong Student Cen-ter, which has had attention called to it recently for going over its budget drafts.

“I think it’s important we vote on this today to show the admin-istration they still have our sup-port,” Frazier said.

Dougherty agreed and encour-aged senators to not only pass the resolution because they think it is right, but to also not forget their constituents and encourage their support too.

ASgFROM PAGE 2

9 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011www.miamistudent.net

Level2727Student Apartments

Level2727Student Apartments

3770 Southpointe ParkwayOxford, OH 45056

www.LiveAtLevel27.com513.524.3000

Pool & Three Hot TubsPrivate Bathrooms

Individual Storage ClosetsPrivate HD Movie Theater

State of the Art Fitness CenterPrivate Shuttle to Campus & Uptown

Now Leasing for

2012-2013

Have a SmartPhone?Scan this code for more info.

Level 27_8.5x11ad.indd 1 9/8/11 3:46 PM

him is really difficult. His visit here is something special.”

Rahman is perhaps best known in the US for his Academy Award winning soundtrack for the widely popular film Slumdog Million-aire. While his name may have gained significant popularity for

composing songs such as “Jai Ho” and “O… Saya,” he continues to fascinate audiences worldwide.

TIME Magazine has listed Rah-man as one of the world’s most in-fluential people and described him as the “Mozart of Madras.” He is only 45 years old and has produced over 100 film scores, 200 commer-cials in India and two big production musicals. The popular Broadway

musical Bombay Dreams features original music by Rahman.

How can one man produce this much music?

When asked, Rahman said his music evolves primarily from emotion.

“I write it and then listen to it a few days later,” he said. “If I think it is good, I share it with others.”

Rahman said his biggest musical

influences include John Williams, Queen and Bach. What does this composer listen to in his free time?

“Classical music,” he said “Not Lady Gaga.”

In addition to his music, Rahman is a true humanitarian. He is associ-ated with the “Save the Children” charity in India and operates the KM Music Conservatory in Chen-nai, bringing music to many who

otherwise might not ever have the chance to embrace it.

Rahman has one message that he lives by and would like to share with everyone: “Be open, understand dif-ferent things and embrace them.”

To embrace some of Rahman’s music, this weekend’s Global Rhythms concerts in Hall Audito-rium feature multiple pieces of his and a wide variety of global music.

play catch up ever since. I feel like I’m overwhelmed with the amount of hours I have to take every semes-ter to graduate,” Sheehan said.

One of Campbell’s primary concerns is that if the college adds course requirements, something should be taken away so that stu-dents are not overburdened with hours. To accommodate the Global Miami plan, it was a humanities course that had to be sacrificed during this round.

Since the Miami Plan is now over 20 years old, both Campbell and Tassoni think it may be time to look to the Miami Plan to coin-cide with the necessary changes students need.

“We want to see the Miami Plan change to reflect some of the chang-es in the college. We should try to redesign the Miami Plan and get total graduation requirements down to 120 hours,” Campbell said.

Senior Laura Swan is majoring in marketing, which falls within the Farmer School of Business. She thinks the requirements between the different divisions and the Mi-ami Plan make it very complicated for students to have flexibility with their majors.

“Originally, I thought about dou-ble majoring in marketing and Eng-lish,” Swan said. “But with all of the classes I needed to take for the business school, the College of Arts and Science and the Miami Plan, it was just way too complicated.”

Tassoni said he agrees the Miami Plan may need some restructuring.

“I would like to a have a univer-sity wide discussion about what we value and our principles and reeval-uate from there,” Tassoni said.

RAHMAN, FROM PAGE 1

MIAMI PLAN, FROM PAGE 1

The Miami Student reported Sept. 20 that College of Arts and Science Dean Phyllis Cal-lahan approved a proposal from the department of comparative religion to bring the Westboro Baptist Church to campus.Comparative Religion Profes-sor Liz Wilson told The Miami Student’s reporter the dean ap-proved the proposal the morn-ing of Monday, Sept. 19. The Comparative Religion Student Association also confirmed that WBC would come to Miami Oct. 25.

The reporter sent an email Monday evening to Callahan including a statement about her alleged approval of the event and stating the article would run the next day.Callahan’s response email gave no clear indication that she had not approved the event.

Miami University Communica-tions Director Claire Wagner contacted The Miami Student Tuesday afternoon and said the event did not have the dean’s approval. The Miami Student’s website was updated Tuesday afternoon to reflect this.

CLARIFICATION

miamistudent.net

Miami university Study Abroad

Final Information Session: September 24th 9:00 am, 1000 FSB

Applications Due: September 26, 2011. Apply at www.studyabroad.muohio.edu; search by term and program name. Notification of acceptance: September 30, 2011

For more information contact Kim Suellau. Phone: 513-529-1712 Email: suellaki@muohio.edu

Vietnam * Cambodia * Hong Kong

FSB Southeast Asia Winter Program

10 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011 www.miamistudent.net

We believe that our people make our business. We want the brilliant ones. The ones who rock our world every single day.WE ARE LOOKING TO FILL THESE POSITIONS:

» National Account Managers» Interns

Coming to work shouldn’t be a grind, it should be something to look forward to, and Coyote makes that happen. The culture and work environments here are important to us. We recruit the best people around. And when you add our cutting edge technology to the mix, it makes sense that we are the fast growing 3PL in the country.

1–877–6–COYOTE www.coyote.com

study abroad with cieeCIEE is a co-sponsored provider with more than 130 programs in over 41 countries.

Miami University of OhioOffice of International Education216 MacMillian Hall513.529.5628international@muohio.edu

Learn more at the study abroad fair!Wednesday, September 2811:00am–4:00pmShriver Multipurpose Room

www.ciee.org/study

africaasiaaustraliaeuropelatin americamiddle east

11 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011www.miamistudent.net

News 513-529-2257 Editorial 513-529-2259

Advertising 513-529-2210 Fax 513-529-1893

12 FYI FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011

The Miami StudentOldest university paper in the United States, established in 1826

Website: www.miamistudent.net For advertising information: miamistudent@gmail.com

The Miami Student (Tuesday/Friday) is published during the school year by the students of Miami University, Oxford, Ohio.

The content of The Miami Student is the sole responsibility of The Miami Student staff. Opinions expressed in The Miami Student are not necessarily

those of Miami University, its students or staff.

CORRECTIONS POLICYThe Miami Student is committed to providing the Miami University community

with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.

Sam KayEditor in Chief

Joe Gioffre Business Manager

Baylor MyersAsst. Business Manager

Carly Huang Finance Director

Kendall Flynn National Advertising DirectorClassified Advertising Director

Danny NicolopoulosAdvertising Representative

Nick StrzeleckiAdvertising Representative

Pat GodfrayAdvertising Representative

Katherine MeilnerAdvertising Representative

Steve ZinsAdvertising Representative

Sacha DeVroomen BellmanAdviser

WDJ Inc. - Bill Dedden Distributor

Bethany Bruner News Editor

Colleen Yates Managing Editor

Hunter Stenback Online Editor

Lauren Ceronie, Jenni Wiener Campus Editors

Taylor Dolveu Asst. Campus Editor

Justin Reash Community Editor

Sarah Sidlow Asst. Community Editors

Amanda SeitzSpecial Reports Editor

Megan McGill Arts & Entertainment

Thomasina Johnson, Noëlle BernardEditorial Editors

Michael Solomon Sports Editor

Julia EngelbrechtPhoto Editor

Senior Staff Writers

Adam GiffiMatt Levy

Shannon Pesek

Staff Writers

Shay CorcoranJames PrewittSarah Sidlow

Editorial Columnists

Ty Gilligan Karli Kloss

Oriana PawlykJessica Sink

Sports Staff Writers

JM Reiger

Designers

Nicole CrandallErin Killinger

Michelle LudwinAbigail Offenbaker

Photography Staff

Scott AllisonAllison BackovskiThomas Caldwell

Andrew BrayElizabeth Haenng

Bloggers

Brittany DoveMcKenzie GrahamHannah Poturalski

Emily SheriffDavid Small

Garrett SmithJessica Stringfield

Cartoonists

Noah CarlAshley Ceroli

HELP WANTED

Earn $1000-$3200 a month to drive our brand new cars with ads. www. FreeCarJobs.com

For rENT

Red Brick Property Management is now renting for the 2012-2013 school year. For more info. call 524.9340 or visit our website at www.redbrickoxford.com

For rent Now renting for the 2012/13 school year. Visit us at www. MUOH.net or www.Schmatesrentals.com The best homes are the first to rent. Please call 513-505-4918 or 847-274-6600

4 - Free Flat Screen TV’s Like new Four Bedroom homes all kitchen amenities plus washer/dryer. Off street parking for four. www.mustudentrentals.com or call 513-756-0780 for details.

For rENT

Single & Double Occupancy Apart-ments Available now and Second semester Check Us Outwww.foxan-dhounds-apts.com www.oxfordrents.com Call 523-2440 Text 335-704

APArTmENTs

Live Uptown in the Lofts at 1 West High St. Quite simply the most amazing place ever built in Oxford. For details or to arrange a showing, call 513-524-9340 or visit us at www.redbrickoxford.com

Roberts Apartments2012-2013. Great Location! Close to Uptown/Campus. Laundry Facilities. Off-Street Parking. Well-Maintained. Pet Friendly Units! www.roberts-apts.com 513-839-1426

One Remaining Unit available for 12-13 at the Metropolitan Lofts above Quarter Barrel. Oxford’s most spacious, sophisticated and afford-able housing Uptown. Contact Red Brick at 524.9340. www.redbrickox-ford.com

Roommate needed for next semester above Wills Pizza. Great view of uptown, affordable rent and fun housemates. Call Dett at 513.227.0416

HousEs

Immaculate Newly Renovated 8 Person House Available for 12-13. Located between Vine & Withrow. Call 524.9340. www.redbrickoxford.com

Attention Outdoor Enthusiasts: We have the perfect house for you. Enormous home in the woods avail-able for 12-13. Complete with front deck, hot tub, hardwood floors, and 6 parking spots Uptown. Don’t miss out. Contact Red Brick at 524.9340. www.redbrickoxford.com

SATURDAY,

Sept 24TH 10-4

OPEN HOUSE

Fox & Hounds Apartments

And OxfordRents

325 Foxfire Drive, #201

Oxford, OH 45056

513-523-2440 (Located Near McDonald’s)

*Efficiency, 1-2-4 Bedroom Apartments

*2 Semester/12 month/Summer Only Leases

*Near Miami Metro Bus Routes

*Furnished and unfurnished Units

Spring Semester 2012 &

2012/2013 school year

Life is calling.How far will you go?

Information Session: Wednesday, Sept. 28th 6:00 pmPsychology Building, Rm 127

Be part of the next Peace Corps generation.

Apply online by Oct. 1st to receive consideration for future Peace Corps assignments best matching your quali�cations!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

!"#$#%&'%()%*+,-#%.)$%",/&(0%)(%)1$%-,2*1'3%4!5%&'%,%*$)16%'*)(')$%).%7,8&)(,+%9,/&(0%:$#;#(8&)(%<##=>%?#*8#2@#$%ABCDE>%DFAAG%!"#$%&'%($)%'*($)%&+%(,(#$'*%-(.#$,G!

!"#$%!&%'!()*+%!,-!+./.0#1!$.!2#!%!-*./-.0!.3!4%$,./%)!5%6,/7!80#9#/$,./!:##;<!=#*$#>2#0!?@ABC!%/1!#DE,$#1!$.!*%0$,E,*%$#!,/!4%$,./%)!5%6,/7!80#9#/$,./!:##;!./!$+#!F,%>,!G/,9#0-,$H!E%>*'-!=#*$#>2#0!BIACJ!K,$+!9%0,.'-!%K%0#/#--!E%>*%,7/-!%/1!>%;,/7!$+#!*)#17#<!%)./7!K,$+!$+#!L0##;!E.>>'/,$H<!%7%,/-$!+%6,/7M!!

When you’re finished reading

The Miami Student,please recycle!

TMSONLINEwww.miamistudent.net

Summer Workshops, 2012-13UAA Cologne Design at the Ungers, 2012

Cologne, GermanyMay 12 – June 156 creditsContact: Gerardo Brown-Manrique529-7222, brownmg@muohio.edu

Türkiye Workshop, 2012TurkeyJuly 15 – August 166 creditsContact: Gulen Cevik529-7272, cevikg@muohio.edu

Experiencing Arts & Culture: Paris, 2012

Paris, FranceMay 14 – June 149 credits; fulfills a thematic sequenceContact: Peg Faimon529-1407, peg.faimon@muohio.eduNOTE: information meeting on Thursday, Sept. 29,

4:30 pm, Hiestand Hall, Room 218

London Theatre, 2012London, EnglandMay 14 – June 226 creditsContact: Lewis Magruder529-1288, magrudwl@muohio.edu

Design/Build Ghana, 2012Ghana, West AfricaMay 11 or 12 – June 246 creditsContact: J Elliott 529-2484, elliotje@muohio.edu

London, 2013 May – June 20136 creditsContact: J Elliott 529-2484, elliotje@muohio.edu

Passive House: Malta, 2013Germany & MaltaMay – June 20136 creditsContact: Mary Rogero529-7271, rogeromr@muohio.edu

Spring Break, 2012-13Details for Architecture and Interior Design, 2012

Basel, Switzerland, Austria, Germany, FranceMarch 2 –11, 2012 (Spring Break)Contact: Ben Jacks529-4916, jacksbm@muohio.eduNOTE: information meeting on Wed, Sept. 28,

4:00 pm, Alumni Hall, Room 1

Details for Architecture and Interior Design, 2013

Amsterdam, Utrecht, Rotterdam, the NetherlandsMarch 8 –17, 2013 (Spring Break)Contact: Ben Jacks529-4916, jacksbm@muohio.edu

Semester AbroadUniversity of Applied Sciences, 2012

Rosenheim, GermanyFebruary 15 – July 20 (approximate dates)Contact: Diane Fellows529-6447, fellowd@muohio.edu

Korean National University of Arts, 2012 Seoul, South KoreaMarch 1 – June 15 Contact: Howard Blanning529-1270, blanniha@muohio.edu

SACI (Studio Art Centers International, Florence Italy)

Information Q & A Wednesday, September 28, 9:00 – 10:00 am, 109 CPA

International OpportunitiesOFFERINGS FOR MAJORS AND NON-MAJORS

arts.muohio.edu/school-fine-arts/students/international-programs

13 FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2011www.miamistudent.net

Oxford first in county recycling percentagesBy Catherine UBryFor the MiaMi StUdent

Since 2008, the City of Oxford has been ranked No. 1 in Butler County when it comes to curbside recycling throughout the community. Not only has it held this position for the last three years, but it is also projected to rank in the top position yet again in 2011 at the end of the quarter.

Curbside recycling throughout the community entails the total number of curbside recycling efforts taken on by community homeowners and res-idents, including Miami University students living off campus as well.

Anne Fiehrer Flaig, the Solid Waste District Coordinator for the Butler County Recycling and Solid Waste District said Oxford is a very well developed community with environmentally conscious citizens who are well aware of how to best improve the environment.

“Recycling is something that is very actionable and something that everyone can do,” Flaig said. “Ev-ery individual can make a difference by recycling.”

And Miami itself serves as a very positive reflection of recycling ef-forts throughout Oxford.

“Miami processes its own recycla-ble materials,” Flaig said. “Residen-tial recycling is managed by Rumpke, but any campus activity is managed

by Miami University’s Material Re-covery Facility (MRF), which is like its own recycling plant.”

Sophomore Alexa Livadas agrees that Miami students contribute posi-tively to the area’s recycling.

“With Miami making up most of Oxford’s population during the school year, I think it’s easy to see how Miami students’ efforts reflect and contribute to Oxford’s high ranking. I always see recycling bins on the curbs off campus and around uptown,” Livadas said.

Efforts throughout Butler County remain strong and surrounding areas such as Fairfield are all highly ranked when it comes to curbside recycling.

For local residents and students who would like to know how to increase their efforts and ensure that Oxford stays ranked at the top, the city has introduced larger re-cycling bins that will contain even more material than the previous standard-sized bins.

By making these larger bins available to residents, households throughout Oxford will be able to recycle even more materials than before.

By keeping up and promoting these curbside recycling efforts, the residents of Oxford will be able to ensure that they stay ranked at the top and keep the community envi-ronmentally friendly.

BriCK, FROM PAGE 4

us laughing, they knew that it was a joke but for a short period they had no idea what to do.”

Even with all of these high-pro-file athletes in such an intimate place, Weisman said there have never been any security issues due to students being respectful and mindful of the presence of these celebrities.

One of those celebrities visited Brick Street again a few weeks ago. Gordon Hayward of the NBA’s Utah Jazz came to Miami to visit his good friend and high school teammate Julian Mavunga of the RedHawks basketball team. They both attended Brownsburg High School in Brownsburg, Ind. This was not his first time in Oxford, as he visited earlier in 2011.

“During the summer, we work out together a lot, sometimes five days a week,” Mavunga said.

During this trip, Hayward played pick-up basketball at the Student Recreational Center and eventually made his second trip to Brick Street.

“It was fun, a real good time and they were all friend-ly and took care of me well,” Hayward said.

“For the most part, I felt com-fortable. I would be a senior in college this year had I not left for the NBA, and being at Brick Street felt like I was kicking it right back in school,” Hayward said. “I would definitely go back (to Brick Street) after the fun times I’ve had.”

Hayward’s visit is only one of the many made by athletes in the past two decades.

Furthermore, Brick Street’s popularity amongst these athletes adds a unique dimension to the social fabric of Oxford.

“It’s great that athletes come to Brick Street to have a good time, and not for just some publicity stunt,” senior Andy Solada said. “It’s definitely unique to hear that professional athletes have had the same experiences at Brick Street that I’ve had as a student.”

Brick Street attracts some of the most famous ath-letes and musicians to our “small town” community.

“Professional athletes certain-ly increase exposure and bring more credibility to Brick Street,” Weisman said. “Students enjoy looking at the signed jerseys and posters with comments about the ‘great time at Brick Street.’ How-ever, ultimately it is about offer-ing a great experience to custom-ers that builds success.”

OPD is understaffed at the mo-ment, admits to feeling “trepida-tion,” but said she would have never known that they were un-derstaffed by the events that oc-curred Sept. 11.

“The police went directly to the offenders and got the

situation under control. More po-lice force may have made them back off faster, but the response was immediate,” Hesp said.

Holzworth strongly believes there is no serious public safety problem in Oxford, but warns students to simply be cautious and aware.

“I still feel very safe on cam-pus, especially compared to other universities,” Hesp said.

riot, FROM PAGE 4

apartment in a lot about two blocks from my apartment,” Williams said. “It’s not ideal, but it’s still great to have.”

The other two flatmates would have to find other means of parking.

Park Place representative Tom Girardot said, “Everyone else want-ing to keep a car at school must park on the streets or be lucky enough to obtain a permit for the city lot.” Girardot said Park Place would not consider adding additional parking spaces for lessors.

Since the uptown area is shared by both residents and business own-ers, plans to increase parking op-portunities in the central area were

rejected. There are 703 metered parking spaces available uptown, not including the additional 61 re-served in the parking garage or the Holiday Inn according to Oxford Parking System statistics.

However, students may be more inclined to purchase permits to store cars in reserved areas like in the Millett Hall lot or in one of Miami University’s parking garages. Ky-ger said most class locations are not much of a walking distance from uptown and the Miami Metro sys-tem is networked to be easily uti-lized for off campus living.

“If Oxford provided parking for every car uptown, we’d have acres and acres of lots,” Kyger said. “Plus from the perspective of property value, land is much more valuable as a site for residency than parking.”

ParKinG, FROM PAGE 4

By Tom DowneyFor The miami STuDenT

The Miami University women’s volleyball team enters Mid-American Con-ference (MAC) play after three tough losses against St. Louis University, the University of North Caro-lina and the University of Tulsa in the Tar Heel Clas-sic. Their current record stands at 9-5, good for sec-ond in the MAC East right

now. The Red and White road record stands at 2-2 as they prepare for the Kent State University Gold-en Flashes and the Ohio University Bobcats.

The ’Hawks travel to Kent State to open MAC play 7 p.m. Friday. The Golden Flashes record cur-rently stands at 7-8, with two straight losses against Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne and

the University of Dela-ware. Kent State typically has a very good serving team, with one or two go-to players. However, Kent lost several seniors so their team is still a work in prog-ress and it’s not quite clear who those go-to players are quite yet.

Senior Amy Raseman said that Kent State is “very scrappy” and the team has to “never give up and play bet-ter defense” in order to beat

them. Coach Carolyn Con-dit echoed similar thoughts. “Our team defense has to prove itself against both Ohio and Kent,” she said.

In order for the team to win, they’ll need sopho-more defensive specialist Madison Hardy to continue to play like she did in the Tar Heel Classic, where she averaged just over 19 digs per game.

Following their match

against Kent, the Red and White then travel to Athens, Ohio for a match against the Ohio Bobcats at 7 p.m. Sat-urday. The Bobcats’ current record stands 8-6, with wins over the University of Mary-land, Villanova University, Virginia Tech and the Uni-versity of Pittsburgh. Much like Kent, Ohio lost several key seniors, but Raseman says the Bobcats will be a tough team.

“Ohio typically has a strong team and we expect them to be strong as usual,” Raseman said. “In order to beat Ohio, we need to have a strong offense.”

The Bobcats have been one of the better MAC teams over the recent years, demonstrated by the fact they are celebrating their “decade of dominance” this year. In order to win, the RedHawks will need to be on their best game offen-sively and need Raseman to continue her strong play, as she has averaged just over two kills per set this year.

After two road games, the Red and White will re-turn for their MAC home opening weekend. On Sept. 30 the ’Hawks welcome the University at Buffalo and then on Oct. 1 they will host the University of Akron.

Miami looks to start MAC schedule on a high note

eDiTorMiChAel SoloMon

SporTS@miamiSTuDenT.neT14 SPORTSFRiDAY, SePTeMBeR 23, 2011

roSS SimonSimon SayS

The enD oF college FooTBall aS we know iT

A few weeks ago in the “the Good, the Bad and the Ugly,” Michael Solomon wrote that ‘the ugly’ was the formation of the new Super Conferences and how we’re closer to the “Pac-28” then the “Pac-10.” The same rings true today. Only three weeks later, the Big 12 and Big East have both started crumbling into ashes of what their former conferences were. Syracuse University and the Univer-sity of Pittsburgh have left the Big East to join the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC), while the Univer-sity of Texas, Oklahoma University, Oklahoma State University and Texas Tech are all having closed door meetings to decide the future fate of their respec-tive memberships in the Big 12.

The potential destruction of the traditions and history surrounding many of these conferences is about to go straight out the window. The Big 12 is about to be-come a mid-major confer-ence. According to Andy Katz of ESPN, the Big 12 is soon to be the Big 2 with only Missouri and Kan-sas not currently looking at other options. The Big East, once the premier col-lege basketball conference with 11 of its 16 members making the NCAA Tourna-ment just last year, is now the “Not so Big and Not so East” with Texas Chris-tian University (TCU) having joined last year, which is located in Fort Worth, Texas.

What we continually for-get about these conference remodeling is not the fact that in the very near future we’re going to end up with two conferences which will just be called the “Big Pac West” and the “Big Atlantic EC” but why these Univer-

sities are making these ma-jor realignment switches. Every team needs to have the ability to change con-ferences, can you imagine if Tulane University still played in the SEC like they used to? But the fact is these universities are not making the switch for bet-ter and fairer competition or better academics, but rather for lots and lots and lots and lots of money.

With the creation of the individual conference net-works, money became a major tenet of the future of college sports. It started with a commercially viable Big Ten Network and has ended with the $330 million Longhorn Network. This is the penultimate problem with major college sports. What is the essential pur-pose of college sports? It is to provide students the opportunity to compete at a high level event for fun and glory. Today, college sports have turned into the “you’re here to play and win first, school second” rather then “you’re here to learn first and if you win, that’s great too.” Universi-ties are losing touch with the essence of amateur athletics and have become obsessed with the bottom line. How many times have players been paid under the table all across the coun-try while coaches, athletic directors, professors and even presidents and deans look the other way?

These conference re-alignments are by far and large the most hypocritical event in American sporting history. Major colleges and universities can no longer say they are in athletics “for the student,” when they so blatantly are not. The stu-dent athlete is no more, might as well just call them “the money machine.”

“ohio typically has a strong team and we expect them to be strong as usual. in order to beat ohio, we need to have a strong offense.”

amy raSemanSenior ouTSiDe hiTTer

JeSSi Thorne The MiAMi STUDenT

Senior Amy Raseman follows through on a swing on Sept -. 9 against Florida Gulf Coast University. Raseman and the Redhawks start their MAC schedule on the road this weekend.

’Hawks seek win at homeNEXT HOME GAME: 1 p.M. SATurdAy, vS. BOwliNG GrEEN

By Jm riegerSTaFF wriTer

Looking to notch their first win under Head Coach Don Treadwell, the Miami Uni-versity football team (0-2) will host Bowling Green State University (2-1) this Saturday at Yager Stadium.

Following two close loss-es to the University of Min-nesota and to the University of Missouri where the Red-Hawks failed to capitalize on various scoring opportuni-ties and turned the ball over at key moments in the game, the Red and White will try to put together a balanced, dis-ciplined game this week.

“I think we’re moving for-ward with positive strides,” Treadwell said. “I think if we can continue, which we will do, to clean up those things that put you in a negative situation, which we always know are turnovers, we can continue to improve in those areas.”

One of the keys this week on the offensive side of the ball for Miami will be es-tablishing the running game. Redshirt sophomore run-ning back Erik Finklea has performed well thus far, but the running game may prove to be an important factor this week against a Bowl-ing Green team that has al-lowed over 110 yards per game on the ground, while

holding teams to under 200 yards passing through three games.

“It is really important that we protect the football [this week],” Running Backs Coach Mark Spencer said. “We need to establish the run early. It matters what happens between the lines and at the end of the day, we are focused on the game and on executing each play.”

However, look for the RedHawks to utilize their dynamic passing attack early and often. Sophomore wide out Nick Harwell will look to build on a 162 yard, 12 catch performance last week while redshirt senior wide receiver Chris Givens will likely be a big target for Miami, especially in the red zone.

“Big plays on offense are huge,” Treadwell said. “I think Nick came back in and added a little bit of juice to the offense. But it also, when you have more than one re-ceiver, makes the passing game in general better, and I think that’s what he did was just provide us more oppor-tunities for more people to demonstrate their ability.”

Defensively, the Red and White will look to shut down one of the top pass-ing offenses in the country. Bowling Green’s redshirt sophomore quarterback Matt

Schilz is first among all Mid-American Conference quar-terbacks in passing yards, while senior wide receiver Eugene Cooper leads a vet-eran receiving corps that has caught 11 touchdown passes already this year. Shutting down these weapons will be one of the keys this week for the RedHawks defense.

“We need to play hard and play physical all day for all four quarters,” sophomore cornerback Dayonne Nun-ley said. “[Bowling Green] has a great offense and we need to come out ready to go [on Saturday].”

Miami has struggled against the run this season, partially due to the two du-

al-threat quarterbacks they have faced, but has shut down opponent’s passing at-tacks. The RedHawks have allowed just over 150 yards per game through the air this year, and a veteran front seven will likely come to-gether as a unit as the season

progresses to help shut down opponent’s ground attacks.

The Red and White have also struggled on special teams this year, but most of the mistakes are cor-rectable and the team is not concerned, according to Treadwell.

In addition, Miami is very close to selling out Yager Stadium for the first time in eight years. Saturday not only marks the home opener for the RedHawks, but it is also Family Weekend. Campus Activities Council, Red Alert and the Miami Athletic Department will co-sponsor Tailgate Town Sat-urday starting at 10 a.m. in the Millett Hall parking lot.

Fans should wear white and arrive early.

If you cannot make it to the game tomorrow, you can listen to the game on Mi-ami’s IMG Sports Network or on WMSR at www.red-hawkradio.com. Kickoff is set for 1 p.m. ET.

We need to play hard and physical all day for four quarters. Bowling Green has a great offense and we need to come out ready to go.”

Dayonne nunleySophomore DeFenSiVe Back

Blake wilSon The MiAMi STUDenT

Three in a row anD counTingFreshman Emily Hyde watches her shot fly towards goal as the Indiana State University goalkeeper makes a diving attempt. The Redhawks beat the Sycamores in overtime 2-1 on Sunday to increase their win-streak to three.