September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on...

12
September, 2005 What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcas ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcas Thoughts on panels to illustrate Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IH vendor/product milestones with IH

Transcript of September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on...

Page 1: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

September, 2005 What IHE Delivers

IHE CardiologyIHE CardiologyACC 2007 Interoperability ShowcaseACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase

Thoughts on panels to illustrate Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHEvendor/product milestones with IHE

Page 2: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

2

GoalGoal

Goal: (per last IHE Cardiology Planning Committee decision)

Develop a matrix to be displayed and highlighted at the ACC 2007 IHE Interoperability Showcase which will clearly illustrate to clinical users which vendors and which products have adopted and integrated IHE connectivity into their products, including releasing that software to the field.

Page 3: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

3

Typical software lifecycle process incl IHETypical software lifecycle process incl IHE

TimeTime(not to scale)(not to scale)

Product Product conceptionconception

RequirementsRequirementsDefinitionDefinition

Draft IHE Draft IHE IntegrationIntegrationStatementStatement

Software Software DevelopmentDevelopment(many sw builds)(many sw builds)

Internal swInternal swvalidationvalidation

sw buildsw buildMESA MESA testingtesting

ConnectathonConnectathon sw buildsw build sw buildsw buildAlpha releaseAlpha releaseTo clinical siteTo clinical siteWith IHE connectivity?With IHE connectivity?

sw buildsw buildBeta releaseBeta releaseTo clinical siteTo clinical siteWith IHE connectivity?With IHE connectivity?

GeneralGeneralRelease toRelease toClinical sitesClinical sites

Field Field MaintenanceMaintenance

Verify andVerify andPublish IHE Publish IHE IntegrationIntegrationStatementStatement

Page 4: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

4

Note “gold star” was previously awarded hereNote “gold star” was previously awarded here

timetime

Product Product conceptionconception

RequirementsRequirementsDefinitionDefinition

Write and/or Write and/or Publish IHE Publish IHE IntegrationIntegrationStatementStatement

Software Software DevelopmentDevelopment(many sw builds)(many sw builds)

Internal swInternal swvalidationvalidation

sw buildsw buildMESA MESA testingtesting

ConnectathonConnectathon sw buildsw build sw buildsw buildAlpha releaseAlpha releaseTo clinical siteTo clinical siteWith IHE connectivity?With IHE connectivity?

sw buildsw buildBeta releaseBeta releaseTo clinical siteTo clinical siteWith IHE connectivity?With IHE connectivity?

GeneralGeneralRelease toRelease toClinical sitesClinical sites

Field Field MaintenanceMaintenance

Verify andVerify andPublish IHE Publish IHE IntegrationIntegrationStatementStatement

Page 5: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

5

Connectathon gold stars historyConnectathon gold stars history

Gold stars were previously awarded for the Connectathons and there was no incentive and no repercussions for not continuing to develop the IHE software into the General Release of a product.

Users were misled into thinking that a “gold star” meant the IHE connectivity was available in their product.

“Gold stars” and “black dots” have been used in the past and have connotations such that they should not be used again. Need new icons.

PC agreed to award “IHE connects” logo to sum of milestones

Page 6: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

6

Candidates for recognition criteria at ACC 2007Candidates for recognition criteria at ACC 2007

timetime

Product Product conceptionconception

RequirementsRequirementsDefinitionDefinition

Draft IHE Draft IHE IntegrationIntegrationStatementStatement

Software Software DevelopmentDevelopment(many sw builds)(many sw builds)

Internal swInternal swvalidationvalidation

sw buildsw buildMESA MESA testingtesting

ConnectathonConnectathon sw buildsw build sw buildsw buildAlpha releaseAlpha releaseTo clinical siteTo clinical siteWith IHE connectivity?With IHE connectivity?

sw buildsw buildBeta releaseBeta releaseTo clinical siteTo clinical siteWith IHE connectivity?With IHE connectivity?

GeneralGeneralRelease toRelease toClinical sitesClinical sites

Field Field MaintenanceMaintenance

Verify andVerify andPublish IHE Publish IHE IntegrationIntegrationStatementStatement

Page 7: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

7

Examples of MatrixExamples of Matrix

Vendor Product Software release

Echo Workflow Actors:

Acq Image Image

Modality Mgr Display

Company XYZ

My echo cart

V7.41b

Cardiac PACS

My EMR

ABC

Echo Workflow and MeasurementsEcho Workflow and Measurements

Page 8: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

8

Matrix Elements ExamplesMatrix Elements Examples

Integration Statement onlyIntegration Statement only

IHE Integration IHE Integration StatementStatement

Page 9: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

9

Matrix Elements ExamplesMatrix Elements Examples

Connectathon and Integration StmtConnectathon and Integration Stmt

IHE Integration IHE Integration StatementStatement ConnectathonConnectathon

Page 10: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

10

Matrix Elements ExamplesMatrix Elements Examples

All required criteria met = IHE logoAll required criteria met = IHE logo

IHE Integration IHE Integration StatementStatement ConnectathonConnectathon

IHE ConnectivityIHE ConnectivityInstallationInstallation

Release – Release – Which one?!? Any?Which one?!? Any?

Page 11: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

11

Matrix Elements CriteriaMatrix Elements Criteria

Recommended milestones to earn Recommended milestones to earn the IHE connects logo:the IHE connects logo:

• Integration Statement PublishedIntegration Statement Published• Connectathon – (NA, Euro, Japanese)Connectathon – (NA, Euro, Japanese)• IHE connectivity operating in at least one IHE connectivity operating in at least one clinical siteclinical site• Released in at least Alpha software releaseReleased in at least Alpha software release

Page 12: September, 2005What IHE Delivers IHE Cardiology ACC 2007 Interoperability Showcase Thoughts on panels to illustrate vendor/product milestones with IHE.

12

Other issues/notes/rulesOther issues/notes/rules

1.1. Include Connectathon and results from all three Regions (North Include Connectathon and results from all three Regions (North America, Europe, Japan)America, Europe, Japan)

2.2. Include results from all previous ConnectathonsInclude results from all previous Connectathons3.3. Create matrix columns for all existing IHE Cardiology + XDS Create matrix columns for all existing IHE Cardiology + XDS

Profiles (except DRPT??)Profiles (except DRPT??)4.4. Recognized method to publish Integration Statement = Recognized method to publish Integration Statement =

published link on published link on www.ihe.net5.5. Need name of clinical site, contact at site, and list of Need name of clinical site, contact at site, and list of

implemented transactions at that site to attest to clinical implemented transactions at that site to attest to clinical installationinstallation

6.6. Need exact software revision number and some kind of internal Need exact software revision number and some kind of internal document or press release to attest to state (alpha/beta/general document or press release to attest to state (alpha/beta/general release)release)

7.7. Do we note state of release (alpha/beta/general) on matrix?Do we note state of release (alpha/beta/general) on matrix?