Seoul National University - Eric Y....
Transcript of Seoul National University - Eric Y....
Improving Type Ia supernova cosmologyEric Y. Hsiao Florida State University
on behalf of the Carnegie Supernova Project and collaborationsM. M. Phillips, C. Contreras, N. Morrell, C. R. Burns, M. Stritzinger,G. H. Marion, D. J. Sand, P. Hoeflich, T. Diamond et al.
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
10�2 10�1 100
z
�0.4�0.2
0.00.20.4
µ�µ⇤
CD
M
34
36
38
40
42
44
46
µ=
m? B�M
(G)+↵
X 1��C
Low-z
SDSS
SNLS
HST
2
Betoule et al. (2014)Perlmutter 2003
Type Ia supernova cosmology Calibration of supernova luminosity is achieved through empirical relations.
Credit: Mark Phillips
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] FSU, October 20153
■ Type Ia supernova cosmology is currently systematic limited.■ On their origins, “they are explosions of C/O white dwarfs in binary systems”
is about the only thing we can agree on.
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
How to improve improve Type Ia supernova cosmology?
Go to the near infrared!
Outline1. Why near infrared?2. Probing the physics.
4
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Why near infrared? Theory and observation agree they are better standard candles in the NIR.
5
0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0∆m15(B)
−20
−19
−18
−17Mmax
−20
−19
−18
−17Mmax
−20
−19
−18
−17Mmax
−20
−19
−18
−17Mmax
IKC
J
H
K
B
V−20
−19
−18
−17
Mmax
−20
−19
−18
−17Mmax
0.01 < z < 0.1 (Ho = 74) Cepheid, SBF, PNLF
Kasen (2006)
Phillips (2005)
Theory Observation
NIR
opticalNIRoptical
B-band light curve decline rate
Dev
iatio
n of
pea
k m
agni
tude
from
mea
n
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6
−20
−19.5
−19
−18.5
−18
−17.5
−17
−16.5
−16∆ m15(B)
Peak
Mag
nitu
de
0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6∆ m15(B)
MBB0−µ
MHH0−µ
Why near infrared? Observations in the NIR suffer little dust extinction.
6
Mandel et al. (2011)
optical NIR
B-band light curve decline rate
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Why near infrared? There is mounting evidence for its utility in the NIR.
■ Krisciunas et al. 2004Dispersion in near infrared < 0.2 mag.
■ Wood-Vasey et al. 2008Dispersion of 0.16 mag in H.
■ Folatelli et al. 2010Dispersion of 0.18 mag in J.
■ Mandel et al. 2011Near infrared provide independent information.
■ Kattner et al. 2012Slight near-infrared decline rate relation detected.
■ Barone-Nugent et al. 201212 supernovae in the Hubble flow show dispersion < 0.010 in H.
■ Weyant et al. 2014Can achieve low dispersion with 1-3 light-curve points.
■ Friedman et al. 2015Near-infrared light curves of 92 nearby supernovae.
7
1985ApJ...296..379E
Elias et al. (1985)
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Why near infrared? CSP II aims to produce the definitive low-redshift reference with emphasis in NIR.
Carnegie Supernova Project II (CSP II) PI: Mark Phillips
■ Well-understood and stable photometric system.
■ Allocated in 2011-2015:800 nights on 1-m Swope for optical light curves 300 nights on 2.5-m du Pont for NIR light curves 70 nights on 6.5-m Magellan for NIR spectroscopy
■ Observations completed in 2011-2015:NIR light curves of 123 Type Ia supernovae in the Hubble flow. 624 NIR spectra of 151 Type Ia supernovae.
8
Credit: Yuri Beletsky
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Why near infrared? NIR is also the ideal region to probe the physics of supernovae.
Improve Type Ia supernovae cosmology through 2 routes:
■ Avoid things we do not understand.
■ Probe the physics.
We do not know the nature of the explosion and the companion star.
9
Credit: ESO
NIR
optic
al
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Why near infrared? NIR provides independent information unavailable in the optical.
10
Hsiao et al. in prep
0
1
2
3
log 1
0(F λ
) +
cons
tant Type Ia
SN 2012fr+14d
super−ChandrasekharASASSN−15hy
+10d
Type IaxSN 2013gr
+15d
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5rest wavelength (µm)
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
0
1
2
3
log 1
0(F
λ ) +
con
stan
t
Type IaSN 1994D
+14d
super−ChandrasekharSN 2009dc
+12d
Type IaxSN 2005hk
+15d
0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2rest wavelength (µm)
0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2
optical NIR
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Probing the physics NIR spectra contain many physical diagnostics.
■ Unburned material Pre-maximum C I 1.0693
■ Boundary between C/O burningPre-maximum Mg II 1.0927
■ Mass and distribution of radioactive nickelPost-maximum H-band break
■ Stable nickel Transitional phase [Ni II]
■ Companion signaturePost-maximum hydrogen P-beta
■ Progenitor central density and magnetic field,explosion (a)symmetryNebular phase [Fe II] 1.6440
11
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Probing the physics Carbon represents pristine material from the progenitor white dwarf.
■ Detection of carbon indicates incomplete burning and provides constraints for explosion models.
■ Optical surveys detected C II 6580in 20-30% of supernovae.Thomas et al. (2011) Folatelli et al. (2012)Silverman et al. (2012)
12
Thomas et al. (2011)
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Probing the physics Carbon appears to be ubiquitous, contrary to findings in the optical.
■ Near-infrared C I 1.0693 is always stronger and lasts longer than its optical counterpart.
13
Hsiao et al. (2013, 2015)
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
log 1
0(Fλ)
+ co
nsta
nt
0.60 0.65
−20−10 0
optical C II λ0.6580
SN 1999by
−4.0
SYNAPPSC II
1.00 1.05
−20−10 0
NIR C I λ1.0693
−3.3
−0.4
SYNAPPSC I
0.60 0.65
−20−10 0
iPTF13ebh
−11.9−11.1
−6.7
−3.8
−0.5
1.00 1.05
−20−10 0
−12.8
−10.7
−6.8
−3.7
−1.0
0.60 0.65
−20−10 0
SN 2011fe
−12.7
−6.6
+0.4
1.00 1.05
−20−10 0velocity (103 km/s)
rest wavelength (µm)
−12.6
−6.7
+0.3
0.60 0.65
−20−10 0
SN 2014J
−9.1
−6.2
−3.6
−0.6
1.00 1.05
−20−10 0
−9.9
−6.3
−2.9
−0.4
0.60 0.65
−20−10 0
ASAS14lp
−1.0
1.00 1.05
−20−10 0
−9.9
−3.9
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
Probing the physics So far, no stripped hydrogen from companion has been detected.
■ Hydrogen stripped off the companion star is embedded at low velocity.
■ NIR P-beta is stronger and appear above photosphere earlierthan optical H-alpha (Maeda et al. 2014).
14
Sand, Hsiao et al. (2016)
Eric Y. Hsiao [email protected] EAMA Seoul, September, 2016
How to improve improve Type Ia supernova cosmology?
Go to the near infrared!
15
Conclusion