Senator Beason's Proposed Senate Floor Substitute to HB658 (as of 5/10/12)

7/31/2019 Senator Beason's Proposed Senate Floor Substitute to HB658 (as of 5/10/12)

1/51

?

?190

^l` c`bb ykzbn obk sjqz`sj ~lj O~~ksdjp?:

Ijdjsob ~k njfjdn boy jdfksajhjd~ kffàjs zdnjs?6

ajs~o`d akdn`~`kd$?9

^l` c`bb ykzbn obk sjqz`sj ~lj?

Ohjdnhjd~ 63? kf ~lj Akd~`~z~`kd kf Obocoho3:

kf ?0=?" dky o}}jos`di o Qja~`kd ???$=: kf ~lj36

Kffàòb Sjakh}`bo~`kd kf ~lj Akd~`~z~`kd kf39

Obocoho kf ?0=?" o ohjdnjn" }skl`c`~ o ijdjsob3


2/51

3

boy ylkj }zs}kj ks jffja~ ykzbn cj ~k sjqz`sj o?

djy ks `dasjojn j|}jdn`~zsj kf bkaob fzdn fskh3

cjakh`di jffja~`vj y`~l sjiosn ~k o bkaob1

ikvjsdhjd~ob jd~`~p y`~lkz~ jdoa~hjd~ cp o 3+1 vk~j>

zdbj5 `~ akhj y`~l`d kdj kf o dzhcjs kf:

}ja`f`jn j|aj}~`kd7 `~ ` o}}skvjn cp ~lj6

offja~jn jd~`~p7 ks ~lj Bji`bo~zsj o}}sk}sò~j9

fzdn" ks }skv`nj o bkaob kzsaj kf sjvjdzj" ~k

#,3 CZQ@DJQQ JD^@^P$ Odp }jskd ks iskz} kf }jskd?

jh}bkp`di kdj ks hksj }jskd }jsfksh`di ks jdioi`di `d odp3

oa~`v`~p" jd~js}s`j" }skfj`kd" ks kaaz}o~`kd fks io`d"1

cjdjf`~" onvod~oij" ks b`vjb`lkkn" ylj~ljs fks }skf`~ ks dk~>

fks }skf`~$ Cz`dj jd~`~p lobb `dabznj" cz~ dk~ cj b`h`~jn:

~k" ~lj fkbbky`di56

#o$ Qjbf(jh}bkpjn `dn`v`nzob" cz`dj jd~`~`j9

f`b`di os~àbj kf `daks}kso~`kd" }os~djsl`}" b`h`~jn

bàjdj" }jsh`~" ajs~`fào~j" o}}skvob" sji`~so~`kd" alos~js"?:

ks `h`bos fksh kf oz~lksùo~`kd `zjn cp ~lj ~o~j" odp?6

cz`dj jd~`~p ~lo~ ` j|jh}~ cp boy fskh kc~o`d`di zal o?9

cz`dj bàjdj" odn odp cz`dj jd~`~p ~lo~ ` k}jso~`di?

akd~soa~ks" akd~soa~ jh}bkpjj" }skeja~ hodoijs" ks o3:

sjasz`~`di ks ~off`di jd~`~p$36

#,> JH]BKPJJ$ Odp }jskd n`sja~jn" obbkyjn" ks39

}jsh`~~jn ~k }jsfksh bocks ks jsvàj kf odp g`dn cp od3


5/51

:

jh}bkpjs$ ^lj jh}bkpjj kf od `dnj}jdnjd~ akd~soa~ks yksg`di?

fks o cz`dj jd~`~p lobb dk~ cj sjiosnjn o ~lj jh}bkpjj3

kf ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p" fks ~lj }zs}kj kf ~l` alo}~js$ ^l`1

~jsh nkj dk~ `dabznj odp `dho~j `d ~lj bjiob az~knp kf ~lj>

~o~j" o akzd~p" ks o hzdà`}ob`~p$:

#,: JH]BKPJS$ Odp }jskd" f`sh" aks}kso~`kd"6

}os~djsl`}" ek`d~ ~kag okaò~`kd" oijd~" hodoijs"9

sj}sjjd~o~`vj" fksjhod" ks k~ljs }jskd lov`di akd~skb ks

#,6 JH]BKPHJD^$ ^lj oa~ kf jh}bkp`di ks ~o~j kf?:

cj`di jh}bkpjn" jdioijn" ks l`sjn ~k }jsfksh yksg ks jsvàj?6

kf odp g`dn ks alosoa~js y`~l`d ~lj Q~o~j kf Obocoho"?9

`dabzn`di odp ekc" ~og" yksg" bocks" }jskdob jsvàj" ks?

`hhìso~`kd boy cp b`h`~`di akhhzdào~`kd cj~yjjd `~:

kffàjs odn fjnjsob `hhìso~`kd kffàòb `d v`kbo~`kd kf >" ks ~lo~ sj~sà~ `~9

kffàjs `d ~lj jdfksajhjd~ kf ~l` alo}~js$ @f" `d ~lj

}kb`~àob zcn`v``kd lobb dk~ cj jbì`cbj ~k sjaj`vj odp?:

fzdn" isod~" ks o}}sk}sò~`kd fskh ~lj Q~o~j kf Obocoho?6

zd~`b zal v`kbo~`kd lo ajojn odn ~lj O~~ksdjp Ijdjsob lo?9

k ajs~`f`jn$ Odp o}}job kf ~lj nj~jsh`do~`kd kf ~lj O~~ksdjp?

kffàòb" ks ljon kf od oijdap }op o a`v`b }jdob~p kf dk~ bj?:

~lod kdj ~lkzodn nkbbos ,.?"=== odn dk~ hksj ~lod f`vj?6

~lkzodn nkbbos ,.:"=== fks joal nop ~lo~ ~lj }kbàp ks?9

}soa~àj lo sjho`djn `d jffja~ of~js ~lj f`b`di kf od oa~`kd?

#,f Jvjsp }jskd yksg`di fks ~lj Q~o~j kf Obocoho3:

ks o }kb`~àob zcn`v``kd ~ljsjkf" `dabzn`di" cz~ dk~ b`h`~jn36

~k" o boy jdfksajhjd~ oijdap `d ~lj Q~o~j kf Obocoho ks o39

}kb`~àob zcn`v``kd ~ljsjkf" lobb lovj o nz~p ~k sj}ks~3


12/51

?3

v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd kf ylàl ~lj }jskd lo gdkybjnij$?

Odp }jskd ylk y`bbfzbbp fo`b ~k sj}ks~ odp v`kbo~`kd kf ~l`3

ja~`kd yljd ~lj }jskd gdky ~lo~ ~l` ja~`kd ` cj`di1

v`kbo~jn lobb cj iz`b~p kf kc~sza~`di ikvjsdhjd~ob>

k}jso~`kd o njf`djn `d Qja~`kd ?1O(?=(3$:

#,i Fks ~lj }zs}kj kf ~l` ja~`kd" ~lj ~jsh6

kffàòb ks ljon kf od oijdap kf ~l` ~o~j lobb dk~ `dabznj9

o boy jdfksajhjd~ kffàjs ks k~ljs }jskddjb jh}bkpjn `d o

y`~l`d ~l` ja~`kd lobb cjos l` ks ljs kyd ak~ odn fjj?:

okaò~jn y`~l ~lj b`~ìo~`kd zdbj k~ljsy`j ksnjsjn cp ~lj?6

akzs~$ Fks ~lj }zs}kj kf ~l` ja~`kd" ~lj sjbjvod~ ~o~z~j?9

kf sj}kj fks oj`di }jdob~`j lobb cj dk hksj ~lod 1=?

sjaj`v`di o }j~`~`kd$ ^lj }j~`~`kd hz~ cj ìdjn zdnjs ko~l3:

odn zdnjs }jdob~p kf }jsezsp odn hz~ obbjij y`~l }ja`fà`~p36

odp obbjijn v`kbo~`kd$ Qzal }jskd lobb lovj oa~zob39

gdkybjnij ~lo~ odp kffàòb ks ljon kf od oijdap kf ~l` ~o~j3


15/51

?:

ks }kb`~àob zcn`v``kd ~ljsjkf" `dabzn`di" cz~ dk~ b`h`~jn?

~k" od kffàjs kf o akzs~ `d ~l` ~o~j" lo onk}~jn ks3

`h}bjhjd~jn o }kbàp ks }soa~àj ~lo~ b`h`~ ks sj~sà~ ~lj1

jdfksajhjd~ kf ~l` alo}~js ~k bj ~lod ~lj fzbb j|~jd~>

}jsh`~~jn cp ~l` alo}~js$ ^lj n`~sà~ o~~ksdjp ks ~lj:

O~~ksdjp Ijdjsob lobb i`vj ~lj kffàòb ks ljon kf od oijdap"6

`dabzn`di" cz~ dk~ b`h`~jn ~k" od kffàjs kf o akzs~ `d ~l`9

~o~j" 1= nop) dk~àj kf l` ks ljs `d~jd~ ~k f`bj zal od

}kb`~àob zcn`v``kd ~ljsjkf" lobb lovj o nz~p ~k sj}ks~3:

v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd kf ylàl ~lj }jskd lo gdkybjnij$36

Fo`bzsj ~k sj}ks~ odp v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd yljd ~ljsj `39

sjokdocbj aozj ~k cjb`jvj ~lo~ ~l` ja~`kd ` cj`di3


16/51

?6

v`kbo~jn ` Odp }jskd ylk y`bbfzbbp fo`b ~k sj}ks~ odp?

v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd yljd ~lj }jskd gdky ~lo~ ~l`3

ja~`kd ` cj`di v`kbo~jn lobb cj iz`b~p kf kc~sza~`di1

ikvjsdhjd~ob k}jso~`kd o njf`djn `d Qja~`kd ?1O(?=(3" odn>

lobb cj }zd`locbj }zszod~ ~k ~o~j boy$:

#,i Fks ~lj }zs}kj kf ~l` ja~`kd" ~lj ~jsh6

kffàòb ks ljon kf od oijdap kf ~l` ~o~j lobb dk~ `dabznj9

o boy jdfksajhjd~ kffàjs ks k~ljs }jskddjb jh}bkpjn `d o

ab`jd~$?:

#1?(?1(

od ob`jd) `hhìso~`kd ~o~z y`~l ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~3:

}zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$ ?191,a$ O }zcbà }k~jakdnosp36

jnzao~`kd `d~`~z~`kd kffàjs ks kffàòb lobb dk~ o~~jh}~ ~k39

`dnj}jdnjd~bp hogj o f`dob nj~jsh`do~`kd kf ylj~ljs od ob`jd3


17/51

?9

` boyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$ J|aj}~ o k~ljsy`j?

}skv`njn cp boy" od ob`jd ylk ` dk~ boyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj3

Zd`~jn Q~o~j lobb dk~ cj jbì`cbj fks odp }k~jakdnosp1

jnzao~`kd cjdjf`~" `dabzn`di" cz~ dk~ b`h`~jn ~k">

alkbosl`}" isod~" ks f`dodaòb o`n$:

#1?(?1(0$6

#,o O o akdn`~`kd fks ~lj oyosn kf odp akd~soa~"9

isod~" ks `dajd~`vj cp ~lj ~o~j" odp }kb`~àob zcn`v``kd

cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ~k f`bj o ìdjn" yksd off`nov`~?:

y`~l ~lj bkaob n`~sà~ o~~ksdjp y`~l`d ~lsjj nop of~js ~lj?6

ksnjs ` `zjn cp ~lj akzs~ ~o~`di ~lo~ ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p?9

ks jh}bkpjs lo ~jsh`do~jn ~lj jh}bkphjd~ kf jvjsp?

cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ` `d akh}bòdaj y`~l ~lj3:

}skv``kd kf ~l` alo}~js odn o ak}p kf ~lj hjhksodnzh kf36

zdnjs~odn`di `zjn ~k ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs o~ ~lj39

~`hj kf jdskbbhjd~ `d J(Vjs`fp$3


20/51

3=

#o$ ^lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs lobb cj njjhjn?

`d csjoal kf akd~soa~ odn ~lj ~o~j" }kb`~àob zcn`v``kd3

~ljsjkf" ks ~o~j(fzdnjn jd~`~p hop ~jsh`do~j ~lj akd~soa~1

of~js }skv`n`di dk~àj odn od k}}ks~zd`~p ~k cj ljosn$>

#c$ ^lj akzs~ lobb nk obb kf ~lj fkbbky`di5:

#?$ Ksnjs ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ~k6

~jsh`do~j ~lj jh}bkphjd~ kf jvjsp zdoz~lksùjn ob`jd$9

#3$ Qzceja~ ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ~k o

zceja~ ~k ~lj }jdob~p kf }jsezsp" o ìdjn" yksd off`nov`~?:

y`~l ~lj o}}sk}sò~j bkaob n`~sà~ o~~ksdjp y`~l`d ~lsjj nop?6

of~js ~lj ksnjs ` `zjn cp ~lj akzs~ ~o~`di ~lo~ ~lj?9

cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs lo ~jsh`do~jn ~lj jh}bkphjd~ kf?

#o$ ^lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs lobb cj njjhjn3:

`d csjoal kf akd~soa~ odn ~lj ~o~j" }kb`~àob zcn`v``kd36

~ljsjkf" ks ~o~j(fzdnjn jd~`~p lobb ~jsh`do~j ~lj akd~soa~39

of~js }skv`n`di dk~àj odn od k}}ks~zd`~p ~k cj ljosn$3


22/51

33

#c$ ^lj akzs~ lobb nk obb kf ~lj fkbbky`di5?

#?$ Ksnjs ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ~k3

~jsh`do~j ~lj jh}bkphjd~ kf jvjsp zdoz~lksùjn ob`jd$1

#3$ Qzceja~ ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ~k o>

f`vj(pjos }skco~`kdosp }js`kn ~lskzilkz~ ~lj ~o~j$ Nzs`di ~lj:

}skco~`kdosp }js`kn" ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs lobb6

f`bj qzos~jsbp sj}ks~ y`~l ~lj o}}sk}sò~j bkaob n`~sà~9

o~~ksdjp kf joal djy jh}bkpjj ylk ` l`sjn cp ~lj cz`dj

yksg$3:

#3$ Cjfksj o cz`dj bàjdj ks }jsh`~ lo cjjd36

z}jdnjn zdnjs ~l` }osoiso}l ` sj`d~o~jn" o bjiob39

sj}sjjd~o~`vj kf ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs lobb zch`~3


23/51

31

~k ~lj akzs~ o ìdjn" yksd off`nov`~ ~o~`di ~lo~ ~lj?

cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ` `d akh}bòdaj y`~l ~lj3

}skv``kd kf ~l` zcn`v``kd odn o ak}p kf ~lj Hjhksodnzh kf1

Zdnjs~odn`di `zjn ~k ~lj cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs o~ ~lj>

~`hj kf jdskbbhjd~ `d J(Vjs`fp$:

n$ O f`dn`di cp o akzs~ kf akh}j~jd~ ezs`nà~`kd kf6

o jakdn v`kbo~`kd kf zcja~`kd ,o ~lo~ nkj dk~ kaazs9

y`~l`d ~jd pjos kf o f`s~ v`kbo~`kd lobb ~`bb cj

jd~`~p" ~lj O~~ksdjp Ijdjsob hop cs`di od oa~`kd ~k3:

}jshodjd~bp z}jdn ~lj cz`dj bàjdj kf ~lj cz`dj36

jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs oaaksn`di ~k ~lj }skajnzsj njas`cjn `d39


25/51

3:

Qja~`kd 1?(?1(?:$ ^lj nj~jsh`do~`kd kf o v`kbo~`kd lobb cj?

oaaksn`di ~k ~lj }skajnzsj njas`cjn `d Qja~`kd 1?(?1(?:$3

#,i,f O cz`dj jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ~lo~ akh}b`j1

y`~l zcja~`kd ,c lobb dk~ cj fkzdn ~k cj `d v`kbo~`kd kf>

zcja~`kd ,o$ O zcakd~soa~ks ~lo~ ` jdskbbjn `d ~lj:

J(Vjs`fp }skisoh nzs`di ~lj fzbb }js`kn kf }jsfkshodaj kf ~lj6

zcakd~soa~ lobb dk~ cj fkzdn ~k cj `d v`kbo~`kd kf9

zcja~`kd ,a$ ^l` ja~`kd lobb dk~ cj akd~szjn ~k njdp

#,`,l Akh}b`odaj y`~l ~l` ja~`kd hop cj vjs`f`jn?:

cp ~lj ~o~j oz~lks`~`j ks boy jdfksajhjd~ akd~soa~`di?6

oz~lks`~p ks odp ~o~j ks bkaob boy jdfksajhjd~ oijdap o~ odp?9

~`hj ~k jdzsj o akd~soa~zob oisjjhjd~ o }skv`njn fks `d ~l`?

ks }jsh`~ z}jdnjn lobb dk~" fks ~lj nzso~`kd kf ~lj:

z}jd`kd" cj obbkyjn" n`sja~bp ks `dn`sja~bp" ~k }skazsj ks6

j|jaz~j o b`ajdj ks }jsh`~ `h`bos ~k ~lkj ~lo~ lovj cjjd9

z}jdnjn$

lkzbn cj `d~js}sj~jn akd`~jd~ y`~l < Z$Q$A$ 3:

?13>,o,?,O$36

#,> Loscks od ob`jd zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj39

Zd`~jn Q~o~j cp jd~js`di `d~k o sjd~ob oisjjhjd~" o njf`djn3


28/51

3?" y`~l od ob`jd ~k }skv`nj oaakhhkno~`kd"?

`f ~lj }jskd gdky ks sjagbjbp n`sjiosn ~lj foa~ ~lo~ ~lj3

ob`jd ` zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$1

#,> @~ lobb dk~ cj o v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd fks>

o sjbì`kz njdkh`do~`kd lov`di o ckdo f`nj dkd}skf`~:

sjbì`kz ksiodùo~`kd `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j" ks ~lj oijd~ ks6

kffàjs kf ~lj njdkh`do~`kd ks ksiodùo~`kd" ~k jdakzsoij"9

`dv`~j" aobb" obbky" ks jdocbj od ob`jd ylk ` }sjjd~ `d ~lj

fks o~ bjo~ kdj pjos$ ^l` zcn`v``kd lkzbn cj `d~js}sj~jn?:

akd`~jd~ y`~l < Z$Q$A$ ?13>,o,?,A$?6

#,c Odp }jskd v`kbo~`di ~l` ja~`kd ` iz`b~p kf?9

o Abo O h`njhjodks fks joal zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ ob`jd" ~lj?

~lj Q~o~j kf Obocoho" lj ks lj ` foa`b`~o~`di ks `3:

o~~jh}~`di ~k foa`b`~o~j$36

#,n Dk~y`~l~odn`di odp k~ljs boy" o boy39

jdfksajhjd~ oijdap hop jazsjbp ~sod}ks~ od ob`jd ylkh ~lj3


29/51

30

oijdap lo sjaj`vjn vjs`fào~`kd fskh ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~?

}zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$ ?191,a ` zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj3

Zd`~jn Q~o~j odn ylk ` `d ~lj oijdap) az~knp ~k o ~o~j1

o}}skvjn foa`b`~p" ~k o fjnjsob foa`b`~p `d ~l` ~o~j" ks ~k>

odp k~ljs }k`d~ kf ~sodfjs `d~k fjnjsob az~knp ~lo~ `:

kz~`nj ~lj ezs`nà~`kd kf ~lj boy jdfksajhjd~ oijdap$ O boy6

jdfksajhjd~ oijdap lobb kc~o`d eznàòb ks j|jaz~`vj9

oz~lksùo~`kd fskh ~lj Ikvjsdks cjfksj jazsjbp ~sod}ks~`di

}zszod~ ~k ~o~j boy$?:

#,f Odp akdvjpodaj" `dabzn`di odp vjjb" vjlàbj"?6

ks o`sasof~" ~lo~ lo cjjd ks ` cj`di zjn `d ~lj akhh``kd?9

kf o v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd" odn ~lj isk }skajjn kf zal?

lobb dk~ o~~jh}~ ~k `dnj}jdnjd~bp hogj o f`dob nj~jsh`do~`kd3:

kf ylj~ljs od ob`jd ` boyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$36

#,l Odp sjaksn ~lo~ sjbo~j ~k ~lj `hhìso~`kd39

~o~z kf o }jskd ` onh``cbj `d odp akzs~ kf ~l` ~o~j3


30/51

1=

y`~lkz~ fzs~ljs fkzdno~`kd ks ~j~`hkdp fskh o az~knòd kf?

sjaksn `f ~lj sjaksn ` ajs~`f`jn o oz~ljd~à cp ~lj fjnjsob3

ikvjsdhjd~ oijdap ~lo~ ` sj}kd`cbj fks ho`d~o`d`di ~lj1

sjaksn$ O vjs`fào~`kd kf od ob`jd) `hhìso~`kd ~o~z>

sjaj`vjn fskh ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~ }zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$ :

?191,a lobb akd~`~z~j }skkf kf ~lo~ ob`jd) ~o~z$ O akzs~6

kf ~l` ~o~j lobb akd`njs kdbp ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~)9

vjs`fào~`kd `d nj~jsh`d`di ylj~ljs od ob`jd ` boyfzbbp

l` ks ljs `hhjnò~j }kj`kd o~ obb ~`hj yljd ns`v`di o?:

hk~ks vjlàbj odn lobb n`}bop ~lj ohj" z}kd njhodn kf o?6

eznij kf odp akzs~" o }joaj kffàjs ks o ~o~j ~skk}js$?9

Lkyjvjs" dk }jskd alosijn y`~l v`kbo~`di ~l` ja~`kd lobb? odp k~ljs boy ~k33

~lj akd~sosp" `f o boy kffàjs ossj~ lobb ossj~ o }jskd31

fks o v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` ja~`kd odn ks kf Qja~`kd 13(6(? `f3>

~lj kffàjs ` zdocbj ~k nj~jsh`dj cp odp k~ljs hjod ~lo~ ~lj3:

}jskd lo o vob`n ns`vjs) bàjdj ks lo jvjs kc~o`djn o36

ns`vjs) bàjdj `d Obocoho$" @f ~lo~ kaazs" ~lj kffàjs39

lobb ~sod}ks~ ~lj }jskd ~k ~lj djosj~ ks hk~ oaaj`cbj3


31/51

1?

hoi`~so~j fks o nj~jsh`do~`kd" }zszod~ ~k zcja~`kd ,a"?

~lo~ ~lj }jskd ` o Zd`~jn Q~o~j a`~ùjd ks do~`kdob ks `3

od ob`jd boyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$1

#,a O sjokdocbj jffks~ lobb cj honj o kkd o>

}k`cbj" cz~ dk~ bo~js ~lod y`~l`d >< lkzs" ~k nj~jsh`dj ~lj:

a`~ùjdl`} kf ~lj }jskd odn `f od ob`jd" ylj~ljs ~lj ob`jd6

` boyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j cp vjs`fào~`kd y`~l9

~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~ }zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$ ?191,a$ Od< lkzs ~k ~lj Boy Jdfksajhjd~?1

Qz}}ks~ Ajd~js kf ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j Nj}os~hjd~ kf Lkhjbodn?>

Qjazs`~p ks k~ljs kffàj ks oijdap njìdo~jn fks ~lo~ }zs}kj?:

cp ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~$ @f ~lj }jskd ` nj~jsh`djn ~k cj?6

od ob`jd zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j" ~lj }jskd?9

lobb cj akd`njsjn o fbìl~ s`g odn lobb cj nj~o`djn zd~`b?" 39" 30" odn 1= kf3?

Oa~ 3=??(:1:" 3=?? Sjizbos Qj`kd" dky o}}jos`di o Qja~`kd33

1?(?1(?0" 1?(?1(3=" 1?(?1(31" 1?(?1(36" 1?(?1(3


32/51

13

` y`~l`d 1= nop kf sjbjoj ks lo }o`n odp f`dj o sjqz`sjn?

cp k}jso~`kd kf boy" ~lj oijdap bjiobbp sj}kd`cbj fks l` ks3

ljs az~knp `daosajso~`kd o~ ~lo~ ~`hj lobb dk~`fp ~lj Zd`~jn1

Q~o~j Czsjoz kf @hhìso~`kd odn Az~kh Jdfksajhjd~ odn ~lj>

Obocoho Nj}os~hjd~ kf Lkhjbodn Qjazs`~p" }zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$:

?191$ ^lj Obocoho Nj}os~hjd~ kf Lkhjbodn Qjazs`~p lobb6

o`~ `d ~lj akksn`do~`kd kf ~lj ~sodfjs kf ~lj }s`kdjs ~k9

~lj o}}sk}sò~j fjnjsob `hhìso~`kd oz~lks`~`j7 lkyjvjs" ~lj

`d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j odn ` o và~`h kf o as`h`dob oa~" ` ~lj?:

al`bn kf o và~`h kf o as`h`dob oa~" ` o c`kbkiàob }osjd~ ks?6

bjiob izosnòd kf o và~`h kf o as`h`dob oa~ ylk ` o h`dks"?9

` o as`~àob y`~dj `d odp }skjaz~`kd" ` ~lj c`kbkiàob?

oddkzdajn ~lskzil o }sj sjbjoj fskh ~lj O~~ksdjp Ijdjsob)?:

kffàj$?6

#,c Z}kd sjaj`}~ kf o ys`~~jd akh}bo`d~ obbji`di o?9

v`kbo~`kd kf ~lj }skv``kd kf ~l` alo}~js sjqz`s`di?

jd~`~p ks jh}bkpjs ylàl sjbo~j ~k ~lj sjqzj~ fks3:

vjs`fào~`kd odn nj~jsh`do~`kd kf `hhìso~`kd ~o~z kf36

jh}bkpjj ~lskzil J(Vjs`fp$39


34/51

1>

#,a ^lj Obocoho Nj}os~hjd~ kf Lkhjbodn Qjazs`~p?

lobb asjo~j o hjalod`h fks sjaj`v`di ~`} fskh ~lj ijdjsob3

}zcb`a sjiosn`di }k`cbj v`kbo~`kd kf ~l` alo}~js"1

`dabzn`di ~lj zdboyfzb jdfksajhjd~ kf ~l` alo}~js$>

#1?(?1(36$:

#,o Dk akzs~ kf ~l` ~o~j lobb jdfksaj ~lj ~jsh6

kf" ks k~ljsy`j sjiosn o vob`n" odp akd~soa~ cj~yjjd o }os~p9

odn od ob`jd zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j" `f ~lj

bjiob ho~~js$3:

#,n @d }skajjn`di kf ~lj akzs~" ~lj nj~jsh`do~`kd36

kf ylj~ljs od ob`jd ` zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j39

lobb cj honj cp ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~" }zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$3


35/51

1:

?191,a$ ^lj akzs~ lobb akd`njs kdbp ~lj fjnjsob?

ikvjsdhjd~) nj~jsh`do~`kd yljd nja`n`di ylj~ljs od ob`jd `3

zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$ ^lj akzs~ hop ~ogj1

eznàòb dk~àj kf odp vjs`fào~`kd kf od `dn`v`nzob)>

`hhìso~`kd ~o~z }sjv`kzbp }skv`njn cp ~lj fjnjsob:

ikvjsdhjd~ odn hop sjqzj~ ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~ ~k }skv`nj6

fzs~ljs oz~kho~jn ks ~j~`hkdòb vjs`fào~`kd$9

#1?(?1(3

Q~o~j a`~ùjdl`}$ ^l` ja~`kd lobb cj `d~js}sj~jn odn3:

o}}b`jn `d oaaksnodaj y`~l fjnjsob boy$ Dk jbì`cbj o}}bàod~36

ylkj qzob`fào~`kd lovj cjjd ojjn lobb cj njd`jn39

sji`~so~`kd$3


36/51

16

#,a ^lj akzd~p jbja~`kd kffàjs ks Qjasj~osp kf?

Q~o~j) kffàj ckosn kf sji`~sos lobb oaaj}~ odp akh}bj~jn3

o}}bào~`kd fks sji`~so~`kd" cz~ od o}}bàod~ lobb dk~ cj1

sji`~jsjn zd~`b ~lj o}}bàod~ lo }skv`njn o~`foa~ksp>

jv`njdaj kf Zd`~jn Q~o~j a`~ùjdl`}$ Qo~`foa~ksp jv`njdaj:

kf Zd`~jn Q~o~j a`~ùjdl`} lobb cj }skv`njn `d }jskd o~6

~lj ~`hj kf f`b`di ~lj o}}bào~`kd fks sji`~so~`kd ks cp9

`dabzn`di" y`~l o ho`bjn sji`~so~`kd o}}bào~`kd" o }lk~kak}p

#,> ^lj o}}bàod~) Zd`~jn Q~o~j do~zsobùo~`kd3:

nkazhjd~ ks ~lj dzhcjs kf ~lj ajs~`fào~j kf do~zsobùo~`kd$36

@f kdbp ~lj dzhcjs kf ~lj ajs~`fào~j kf do~zsobùo~`kd `39

}skv`njn" ~lj o}}bàod~ lobb dk~ cj `dabznjn `d ~lj3


39/51

10

sji`~so~`kd skbb zd~`b ~lj dzhcjs kf ~lj ajs~`fào~j kf?

do~zsobùo~`kd ` vjs`f`jn y`~l ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j Czsjoz kf3

A`~ùjdl`} odn @hhìso~`kd Qjsvàj cp ~lj akzd~p jbja~`kd1

kffàjs ks ~lj Qjasj~osp kf Q~o~j" }zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$ >

?191,a$:

#,: K~ljs nkazhjd~ ks hj~lkn kf }skkf kf Zd`~jn6

Q~o~j a`~ùjdl`} `zjn cp ~lj fjnjsob ikvjsdhjd~ }zszod~9

~k ~lj @hhìso~`kd odn Do~`kdob`~p Oa~ kf ?0:3" odn ohjdnhjd~

#,

#,?3 ^lj o}}bàod~) kffàòb Zd`~jn Q~o~j3:

h`b`~osp sjaksn kf jsvàj lky`di ~lj o}}bàod~) }boaj kf36

c`s~l `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$39


40/51

>=

#,?1 Od j|~soa~ fskh o Zd`~jn Q~o~j lk}`~ob?

sjaksn kf c`s~l asjo~jn o~ ~lj ~`hj kf ~lj o}}bàod~) c`s~l3

`dnào~`di ~lj o}}bàod~) }boaj kf c`s~l `d ~lj Zd`~jn1

Q~o~j$>

#,b ^ljsj ` ljsjcp j~ocb`ljn ~lj Q~o~j Jbja~`kd:

Ckosn" akd`~`di kf ~lj Qjasj~osp kf Q~o~j" ~lj O~~ksdjp6

Ijdjsob" odn ~lj B`jz~jdod~ Ikvjsdks$ ^lj Q~o~j Jbja~`kd Ckosn9

lobb hjj~ kd ~lj aobb kf ~lj Qjasj~osp kf Q~o~j$ ^lj Q~o~j

cz~ nkj dk~ lovj odp kf ~lj nkazhjd~o~`kd b`~jn `d ~l`?:

ja~`kd o o~`foa~ksp jv`njdaj kf Zd`~jn Q~o~j a`~ùjdl`}"?6

~lj o}}bàod~ hop zch`~ odp jv`njdaj ~lo~ ~lj o}}bàod~?9

cjb`jvj njhkd~so~j ~lj o}}bàod~) Zd`~jn Q~o~j?

kf ~l` `dfksho~`kd" ~lj Qjasj~osp kf Q~o~j lobb dk~`fp ~lj3:

Q~o~j Jbja~`kd Ckosn ~lo~ zal o}}bào~`kd ` }jdn`di$36

#,1 ^lj Q~o~j Jbja~`kd Ckosn lobb i`vj ~lj39

o}}bàod~ od k}}ks~zd`~p fks o ljos`di" z}kd ~lj o}}bàod~)3


41/51

>?

sjqzj~ `d ys`~`di" odn od k}}ks~zd`~p ~k }sjjd~ odp?

onn`~`kdob jv`njdaj ~k ~lj Q~o~j Jbja~`kd Ckosn$ Dk~àj kf3

zal ljos`di lobb cj i`vjd ~k ~lj o}}bàod~ o~ bjo~ f`vj1

nop }s`ks ~k ~lj ljos`di no~j$ Od o}}bàod~ lobb lovj ~lj>

k}}ks~zd`~p ~k cj sj}sjjd~jn cp akzdjb o~ zal ljos`di$:

#,> ^lj Q~o~j Jbja~`kd Ckosn lobb oj ~lj6

jv`njdaj }skv`njn cp ~lj o}}bàod~ ~k nj~jsh`dj ylj~ljs ~lj9

o}}bàod~ lo }skv`njn o~`foa~ksp jv`njdaj kf Zd`~jn Q~o~j

~k o}}job zal nj~jsh`do~`kd cp ~lj Q~o~j Jbja~`kd Ckosn o?:

akzd~p ckosn kf sji`~sos cp `d~`~z~`di od oa~`kd zdnjs


43/51

>1

sjqzj~`di o ajs~`f`jn ak}p kf o c`s~l ajs~`fào~j lobb yjos?

zdnjs ko~l ~k ck~l kf ~lj fkbbky`di53

#o$ ^lo~ ~lj }jskd }bod ~k sji`~js ~k vk~j `d1

~l` ~o~j$>

#c$ ^lo~ ~lj }jskd nkj dk~ }kj odp kf ~lj:

nkazhjd~ ~lo~ akd~`~z~j jv`njdaj kf Zd`~jn Q~o~j6

a`~ùjdl`} o njf`djn `d ~l` alo}~js$9

#,3 ^lj off`nov`~ lobb }ja`fàobbp b`~ ~lj:

cp }sjjd~o~`kd kf kdj kf ~lj nkazhjd~ b`~jn `d zcja~`kd?

,g kf Qja~`kd 1?(?1(3

ob`jd) boyfzb }sjjdaj ~lskzil ~lj Qp~jho~à Ob`jd:

Vjs`fào~`kd fks Jd~`~bjhjd~ }skisoh k}jso~jn cp ~lj6

Nj}os~hjd~ kf Lkhjbodn Qjazs`~p" ks cp k~ljs vjs`fào~`kd y`~l9

~lj Nj}os~hjd~ kf Lkhjbodn Qjazs`~p }zszod~ ~k < Z$Q$A$ 9

#,?= Od Ohjsàod @dnòd aosn" y`~l G@A?

abo`fào~`kd" `zjn cp ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j Nj}os~hjd~ kf3

Lkhjbodn Qjazs`~p$1

#,?? F`dob onk}~`kd njasjj lky`di ~lj }jskd)>

dohj odn Zd`~jn Q~o~j c`s~l}boaj$:

#,?3 Od kffàòb Zd`~jn Q~o~j h`b`~osp sjaksn kf6

jsvàj lky`di ~lj o}}bàod~) }boaj kf c`s~l `d ~lj Zd`~jn9

Q~o~j$ OB(vjs`fp$?3

#,?: O vob`n Zd`fkshjn Qjsvàj ]s`v`bjij odn?1

@njd~`fào~`kd Aosn$?>

#,?6 Odp k~ljs fksh kf `njd~`fào~`kd ~lo~ ~lj?:

Obocoho Nj}os~hjd~ kf Sjvjdzj oz~lksùj" ~lskzil od?6

onh`d`~so~`vj szbj }skhzbio~jn }zszod~ ~k ~lj Obocoho?9

Onh`d`~so~`vj ]skajnzsj Oa~" ~k cj zjn ~k njhkd~so~j ks?

akzd~sp kf ksì`d odn ~lj j|}`so~`kd no~j kf ~lj oaaj}~ocbj?:

fksh kf `hhìso~`kd nkazhjd~o~`kd o kz~b`djn `d ~l` ja~`kd$?6

#,a O}}bào~`kd fks o fksjìd do~`kdob Obocoho?9

ns`vjs) bàjdj+dkd(ns`vjs `njd~`fào~`kd aosn+vjjb bàjdj?

]zcbà Qofj~p kd ~lj bàjdj$ ^lj njìdo~`kd lobb3:

n`~`diz`l cj~yjjd fksjìd do~`kdob y`~l boyfzb }jshodjd~36

sj`njdaj `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j odn fksjìd do~`kdob ylkj39

oz~lksùjn }js`kn kf ~op `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j ` ~jh}ksosp$3


49/51

>0

#,j ^lj ns`vjs) bàjdj+dkd(ns`vjs `njd~`fào~`kd?

aosn+vjjb bàjdj `zjn ~k o fksjìd do~`kdob lobb j|}`sj3

kd ~lj no~j kf ~lj j|}`so~`kd kf ~lj oaaj}~ocbj fksh kf1

`hhìso~`kd nkazhjd~o~`kd }skv`njn o~ ~lj ~`hj kf o}}bào~`kd$>

#,f @d ksnjs fks o fksjìd do~`kdob ~k sjdjy ~lj:

ns`vjs) bàjdj+dkd(ns`vjs `njd~`fào~`kd aosn+vjjb6

bàjdj" ~lj o}}bàod~ hz~ sj(`d`~ò~j ~lj bàjd`di }skaj9

`d ~lj ohj hoddjs o o f`s~(~`hj o}}bàod~$

Qja~`kd :$ ,o ^lj Bji`bo~zsj f`dn ~lo~ ~lj Zd`~jn?:

Q~o~j Nj}os~hjd~ kf Ez~àj lo zddjajos`bp odn sjagbjbp?6

~lsjo~jdjn Obocoho boy jdfksajhjd~ kffàjs y`~l }jskdob boy?9

z`~ `f ~lj kffàjs o}}jos ~k hogj ylo~ ~lj Nj}os~hjd~ kf?

1:(0O(?>?" y`~l od ob`jd ~k }skv`nj oaakhhkno~`kd" `f ~lj:

}jskd gdky ks sjagbjbp n`sjiosn ~lj foa~ ~lo~ ~lj ob`jd6

` zdboyfzbbp }sjjd~ `d ~lj Zd`~jn Q~o~j$9

Qja~`kd

Senator Beason's Proposed Senate Floor Substitute to HB658 (as of 5/10/12)

Documents

Transcript of Senator Beason's Proposed Senate Floor Substitute to HB658 (as of 5/10/12)