SEMP Annual Compliance Report – NEWGEN NEERABUP ... · • An internal compliance audit of the...

SEMP Annual Compliance Report – NEWGEN NEERABUP PARTNERSHIP

2012- 2013

ERM Power Limited

NewGen Neerabup Partnership

330 MW NEERABUP GAS FIRED OPEN CYCLE POWER STATION

2012-2013 STACK EMISSIONS MANAGEMENT PLAN (SEMP) ANNUAL COMPLIANCE REPORT

January 2014

SEMP Annual Compliance Report 2012-2013 NewGen Neerabup Partnership January 2014

of 15

Document version control Revision Date Issued Reviewed by Approved by Date Approved Revision Type

A 27/11/2013 B Lanciano Draft 0 29/11/2013 B Lanciano

B Lanciano P MacMahon

29/11/2013 Reviewed

1 08/01/2014 B Lanciano P MacMahon

08/01/2014 Approved/Issued

Distribution of copies Revision Copy no Quantity Issued to

0 1 1 Bruno Lanciano ERM Power - Neerabup Office

0 2 1 Andrew Sutherland ERM Power Perth Office

0 3 1 Phil MacMahon ERM Power Brisbane Office

0 4 1 DER/DEC PIMB 0 5 1 OEPA

File name: 130108 SEMP Annual Compliance Report 2012-2013 Author: NewGen Neerabup Partnership – Bruno Lanciano PowerStation Manager: Bruno Lanciano Name of document: 2012-2013 Neerabup SEMP Annual Compliance Report Document version: 1


of 15

Contents 1.0 Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................. 5

2.0 Key Recommendations / Future Work ............................................................................................... 5

3.0 SEMP Conditions ................................................................................................................................. 5

3.1 SEMP1 ................................................................................................................................................. 7

3.2 SEMP2 ................................................................................................................................................. 7

3.3 SEMP3 ................................................................................................................................................. 9

3.4 SEMP4 ............................................................................................................................................... 10

3.5 SEMP5 ............................................................................................................................................... 10

4.0 Certification of Results ...................................................................................................................... 11

Appendix 1 – January 2013 Stack Emissions Sampling Reports (unit 11 & unit 12) .................................... 12

Appendix 2 – Incident Reports ..................................................................................................................... 13

Appendix 3 – External Complaints register.................................................................................................. 14

Appendix 4 – Inspection Plan Schedule ....................................................................................................... 15


of 15

1.0 Executive Summary This annual Stack Emissions Management Plan (SEMP) Compliance Report is produced internally by NewGen Neerabup and covers the period from 1st July 2012 to 30th June 2013. The following is a summary of the key points in this report;

• NewGen Neerabup submitted a revision 2 of the SEMP to OEPA for approval in May 2013, OEPA approved the revision to the SEMP on the 15th August 2013. This report evaluates compliance with the requirements of the Stack Emissions Management Plan, June 2013 Rev 2.

• As required by the environmental licence, annual stack emissions testing was conducted by ECS Pty Ltd:

o Unit 11 – 8th January 2013 o Unit 12 – 8th January 2013

The results of these tests were within the defined limits.

• An internal compliance audit of the SEMP was conducted on 31st January 2013 found compliance with the SEMP.

• An external compliance audit for the 2011-2012 period (15Feb11 to 15Feb12) was completed by Strategen Environmental Consultants Pty Ltd on the 30th March 2012 for the banker’s compliance audit. This audit included a review of the SEMP and found compliance with the SEMP.

• Strategen conducted the 2012-2013 FY external audit on the 16th August 2013 and is currently being finalised and will be referenced in the next years SEMP report.

• Complaints procedures and register have been developed, however no complaints have been received to date. NewGen Neerabup also regularly completes (annually) pipeline landowner and other relevant third parties that are located within 500meters of the pipeline easement and power station (eg; all close neighbouring residences and business), no complaints have been received via this consultation process.

2.0 Key Recommendations / Future Work

• Nil action required.

3.0 SEMP Conditions This report evaluates compliance with the requirements of the Stack Emissions Management Plan, June 2013 Rev 2.0 (SEMP) as agreed with by the Office of Environmental Protection Authority (OEPA) and NewGen Neerabup. The key compliance requirements of the SEMP and comments on the status of these requirements are summarised in the table 1 below.


of 15

TABLE 1 – SEMP compliance summary Ref # Action Reporting / Evidence Status

SEMP1 The power station shall be designed and constructed to comply with the emission concentration targets specified in 5.1. The power station will utilise low NOx burners to ensure that emissions of oxides of nitrogen are minimised as far as is practicable.

General Turnkey Specifications for plant providers. Inspection of installed low NOx burners.

Low NOX burners designed and installed and utilised.

SEMP2 The power station shall be maintained and operated in a proper and efficient manner and in accordance with the manufacturer’s operation and maintenance manual to ensure compliance is achieved with the emission concentration targets specified in 5.1.

Maintenance planning schedules. Annual stack test results.

Maintenance planning schedules show compliance with the manufacturer’s requirements. Monitoring results for emissions are below specified concentration targets.

SEMP3 Sampling and analysis of air pollutants as specified in Table 4 shall be undertaken and reported as provided by S4.2 of AS4323.1.

Annual stack test results. Annual reporting to OEPA and DEC.

Emission monitoring is being done in accordance with AS4323.1 table 4.2 , (summarised by SEMP - table 4)

SEMP4 A complaints procedure shall be established to receive complaints from the community associated with air emissions. The power station operator shall investigate all complaints and implement measures to ensure that there is minimal risk of the incident recurring.

External Complaints Procedure [NPS-OPS-EXT-COMP] External Complaints Register [NPS-REG-EXT-COMP] Stakeholder Management Guidelines [NPS-PL-ROW-14 ]

Procedure and register established. No complaints or investigations recorded. No complaints of investigations recorded via the Pipeline easement stakeholder management procedures

SEMP5 Annual internal audits and annual external audits will be conducted as specified in the Operational Environmental Management Plan. These audits will assess compliance with the SEMP.

Internal Compliance audit of SEMP by the Operator ERM Power Limited for period 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2013. (this report), Also Internal Audit of the Operational Environmental Management Plan for the Neerabup Pipeline PL 75 and Also the Stack Emissions Management Plan was completed 31/01/2013 External compliance audit for the 2011-2012 period (15Feb11 to 15Feb12) was completed by Strategen on the 30th March 2012. On the 16th August 2013, Strategen conducted an external audit of the ministerial statement (MS759) and also a bankers audit for the period 15 Feb 2012 to 30th June 2013. Stategen are currently finalising the audit report and it will be referenced in the next years SEMP report.

Internal /External compliance audits for 2012/2013 found compliance with SEMP.


of 15

3.1 SEMP1 Action: The power station shall be designed and constructed to comply with the emission concentration targets specified in S5.1. The power station will utilise low NOx burners to ensure that emissions of oxides of nitrogen are minimised as far as is practicable. Evidence: Emission concentration targets are specified in section 5.1 of the SEMP and as summarised in table 2 below; Table 2 – SEMP atmospheric emission concentration targets

Gas-turbine Air pollutant Operational Condition-1

Emission concentration Target -2, 3

Averaging period

Unit 1 and 2 Oxides of nitrogen All 25 ppmv or 51 mg/Nm

3

1-hour

Unit 1 and 2 Carbon monoxide All 10 ppmv or 12.6 mg/Nm

3

1-hour

Table Note 1Excluding start-up, shutdown, initial commissioning and other times when the units are operating below

60% maximum load. 2Corrected to 15% O2 basis.

3mg/Nm

3, corrected to 101.3 KPa, 273 K.

The design criteria in “General Turnkey Specifications, NEERABUP POWER STATION, March 2007, Commercial-In-Confidence, ERM Power”, which was supplied to prospective plant providers, includes NOx emission target of 25ppmv. Note: the design specifications precede the SEMP by over two years.

• Low NOx burners were installed on the commissioned units in 2009. • Annual stack test results refer SEMP3.

Comments: Remains compliant.

3.2 SEMP2 Action: The power station shall be maintained and operated in a proper and efficient manner and in accordance with the manufacturer’s operation and maintenance manual to ensure compliance is achieved with the emission concentration targets specified. Evidence: Maintenance: Maintenance planning schedules are in accordance with the manufacturer’s requirements (refer to attached Inspection Plan Schedule in Appendix 4).


of 15

The hardware component affecting gas emission i.e. fuel gas burners and combustion chamber hot gas path items are inspected during every minor inspection at 250 stars or 8,000EOH whichever is earlier. Based on current operating regime of Neerabup Power Station the 1st minor inspection for both GT units will be due in May-Oct 2014. However a preliminary inspection near similar to the minor inspection was performed in end of Aug / early September 2011 i.e. before the end of OEM 2-year warranty period. A more extensive inspection involving repair / replacement of some components of fuel gas burners and hot gas path items will be performed during a major inspection which is scheduled at every 1250 starts or 41,000EOH or 12 year time period whichever is earlier. Based on current operating regime of Neerabup Power Station the first major inspection will be due in Oct 2021, i.e. based on 12 year time period from the commissioning dates. A yearly maintenance programme is in place for checking and testing flame monitoring and protection circuitry. Running parameters of fuel gas combustion performance e.g. combustion chamber differential pressure, combustion chamber noise level, combustion flame intensity and gas turbine fuel gas inlet temperature are being regularly monitored online during gas turbine operation. These all provide normal operating parameters and deviation from these normal parameters are alarmed by the Turbine control SCADA system. Operation: The power station has conducted operations in compliance with the SEMP emission targets. Results from sampling and analysis of air pollutants, undertaken by Environmental Consultancy Solutions (ECS), are summarised below in table 3 below. Table 3 – Summary of stack emissions test results

• The full results of the monitoring are included Appendix 1. • Appendix 2 – Nil notifiable incidents detected or reported to Department of Environment

Regulation Comments: Remains compliant.

Machine output Concentration 1 hr avg Criteria Compliance Concentration 1 hr avg Criteria Compliance

MW ppmv @ 15% O2 ppmv @ 15% O2 Yes / No ppmv ppmv @ 15% O2 Yes / No

8th Januaray 2013 11:57 to 12:57 162 4.8 < 25 Yes 1.6 < 10 Yes

Machine output Concentration 1 hr avg Criteria Compliance Concentration 1 hr avg Criteria Compliance

MW ppmv @ 15% O2 ppmv @ 15% O2 Yes / No ppmv ppmv @ 15% O2 Yes / No

8th Januaray 2013 15:14 to 16:14 163 4.2 < 25 Yes 1.4 < 10 Yes

Date of Emissions Testing

Time of Emissions Testing

Date of Emissions Testing

Time of Emissions Testing

Neerabup Unit 11Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) Corrected to 15% OxygenParameter

Parameter Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) Corrected to 15% Oxygen

Carbon Monoxide

Carbon Monoxide

Neerabup Unit 12


of 15

3.3 SEMP3 Action: Sampling and analysis of air pollutants shall be undertaken and reported as specified in section 7 of the SEMP and as summarised in table 4 below; Evidence: Sampling and analysis of air pollutants, as shown in Table 3 below, was undertaken during the period by NATA certified Environmental Consultancy Solutions (ECS) on the following dates:

• Unit 11 – 8th January 2013 (11:57 to 12:57) • Unit 12 – 8th January 2013 (15:14 to 16:14)

TABLE 4 – Emission monitoring parameters, Units 1 and 2 Pollutant/parameter Units of measure

Method Frequency

Oxides of nitrogen ppmvd@15% O2 or mg/Nm3 USEPA Method 7E Annually

Carbon monoxide ppmvd@15% O2 or mg/Nm3 USEPA Method 10 Annually

Stack Gas Velocity m/s USEPA Method 2 or 2C Annually

Stack Gas Temperature ºC USEPA Method 2 or 2C Annually

Stack volumetric flow rate m3/s USEPA Method 2 or 2C Annually

Moisture content % USEPA Method 4

Annually

Dry gas density or molecular weight

Kkg/m3 g/gmol

USEPA Method 3 Annually

Oxygen % USEPA Method 3A Annually

Annual stack testing was conducted on 8th January 2013 on both units. The reported data provided by ECS have been attached to this report in Appendix 1. Comments: Remains Compliant.


of 15

3.4 SEMP4 Action: A complaints procedure shall be established to receive complaints from the community associated with air emissions from the power station. The power station operator shall investigate all complaints and, where the power station is found to be the cause of the incident, the operator shall take actions to ensure that the cause is rectified and implement measures to ensure that there is minimal risk of the incident recurring. Evidence: NewGen Neerabup has a complaints procedure and complaints register to meet the requirements of the SEMP- External Complaints Procedure [NPS-OPS-EXT-COMP]; External Complaints Register [NPS-REG-EXT-COMP]. NewGen Neerabup also performs annual Stakeholder consultations to meet the requirements of the Pipeline Licence (PL75) for the Department of Minerals and Petroleum as per Stakeholder Management Guidelines procedure [NPS-PL-ROW-14]. This procedure regularly (annually) prompts pipeline landowner and other relevant third party consultations that are located within 500 meters of the power station and pipeline easement (eg; all close neighbouring residences and business). During the reporting period no complaints have been received by the above processes as both require the complaints to be entered into the complaints register. Refer to appendix 3 for the complaints register for the reporting period (Nil or blank). Comments: Remains compliant.

3.5 SEMP5 Action: Annual internal audits and annual external audits will be conducted as specified in the Operational Environmental Management Plan. These audits will assess compliance with the SEMP. Evidence: Operational Environmental Management Plan states auditing is to be done in accordance with requirements of MS759 and other approvals. Internal and external audits conducted found compliance with the SEMP; • Internal Audit of the Operational Environmental Management Plan for the Neerabup Pipeline PL 75

and Also the Stack Emissions Management Plan was completed 31/01/2013, (audit report dated 08/03/2013), File reference: 2012-2013 Internal Audit Neerabup Pipeline OEMP & SEMP.pdf


of 15

• Internal Compliance audit of the SEMP by the Operator ERM Power Limited for period 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2013. (this report)

• External compliance audit for the 2011-2012 period (15Feb11 to 15Feb12) was completed by

Strategen Environmental Consultants Pty Ltd on the 30th March 2012 (report date). Filename reference: EPO12017_01_R001_Rev0_30 March 2012.

• The next external audit period currently being reviewed is from 15th Feb 2012 to 30th June 2013, hence dates now be aligned to financial years.

• An annual external compliance audit of the SEMP was conducted on 16th August 2013, for the the

audit period July 1 2012 to 30 June for the Ministerial Statement and 15 Feb 2012 to 30 June 2013 for the Bankers Audit , the external audit was conducted by Strategen Environmental Consultants Pty Ltd. Strategen are currently completing the review and will prepare an external audit report that will subsequently referenced in next year’s SEMP report as the report will be published within the 2013-2014 FY SEMP reporting period.

• Internal / External Audit reports available on request.

Comments: Remains compliant.

4.0 Certification of Results The monitoring results supplied in this report are a correct representation of the plant as required by the SEMP. Signed: Name: Bruno Lanciano Position: Power Station Manager Date: 08/01/2014


of 15

Appendix 1 – January 2013 Stack Emissions Sampling Reports (unit 11 & unit 12)

NEWGEN/ERM POWER

NEERABUP POWER STATION

ANNUAL COMPLIANCE

JANUARY 2013

TEST REPORT NUMBER: RSW12253 REV1

REPORT REVISION HISTORY

REVISION NUMBER DATE ISSUED REVISION DETAILS

1 4th December 2013 Update Section 3.0

REPORT DISTRIBUTION

REVISION NUMBER COPY NUMBER LOCATION

1 1 ECS Stack Pty Ltd: Project File

0 2 NewGen Power: Neerabup Power Station

0 3 NewGen Power: Neerabup Power Station (Electronic Copy)

Environmental Consultancy Services (ECS Stack Pty Ltd) RT‐001: RSW12253REV1

RSW12253 – NewGen/ERM Neerabup Power Station Annual Compliance Report Page 2 of 10

DOCUMENT INFORMATION

REPORT NUMBER RSW12253 REV1

REPORT TITLE: Annual Compliance

DATE OF ISSUE: 23rd January 2013

ATTENTION: Mr Bruno Lanciano

ADDRESS: NewGen/ERM Neerabup Power Station

Trandos Road

Neerabup, Australia

WA 6031

EMISSIONS TESTING INFORMATION

SAMPLING COMMENCED: 8th January 2013

SAMPLING COMPLETED: 14th January 2013

TESTING LABORATORY: ECS Stack Pty Ltd

LABORATORY PREMISES: Unit 2, 27 Clark Court, Bibra Lake, Western Australia, 6163

REPORT AUTHORISATION

REPORT PREPARED BY: REPORT AUTHORISED BY:

Reshme Nair Nicole Bolte

BSc (Biotechnolgy) BSc (Env. Science)

Environmental Scientist Technical Co‐ordinator

NATA Accredited Laboratory Number: 14778 This document is issued in accordance with NATA’s accreditation requirements and is accredited for compliance with ISO/IEC 17025. The results of the tests, calibrations and/or measurements included in this document are traceable to Australian / National standards. This report is a product of ECS Corporate Pty Ltd Certified Quality Management System and must not be reproduced in any form except in full.



TABLE OF CONTENTS

1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY....................................................................................................................................4 2 INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................................................................................5 3 SAMPLING PLANE ...........................................................................................................................................6 3.1 Non Ideal Sampling Plane ..........................................................................................................................6

4 RESULTS ..........................................................................................................................................................7 4.1 Volumetric Flowrates and Gas Velocities...................................................................................................7 4.2 Determination of Combustion Gases Concentration .................................................................................7 4.3 Determination of Gas Moisture Concentration .........................................................................................7

5 DEFINITIONS ...................................................................................................................................................8 5.1 Practical Quantitation Limit (PQL) .............................................................................................................8 5.2 Method Detection Limits (MDL).................................................................................................................8 5.3 Result Codes...............................................................................................................................................8 5.4 Average Calculation Methodology ............................................................................................................8 5.5 Significant Figures......................................................................................................................................9 5.6 Units of Measure .......................................................................................................................................9

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1: Summary of Source Emissions Criteria and Compliance Achievement........................................................ 4 Table 2: Sampling Program ‐ Source and Methods.................................................................................................... 5 Table 3: GT 11 Sampling Plane Characteristics .......................................................................................................... 6 Table 4: GT 12 Sampling Plane Characteristics .......................................................................................................... 6

SUMMARY REPORTS

Summary Report: Combustion Gases ‐ GT Unit 11 ‐ PAG Off Summary Report: Combustion Gases ‐ GT Unit 12 ‐ PAG Off Summary Report: Combustion Gases ‐ GT Unit 12 ‐ PAG On

GRAPHS

Graph 1: GT11 Combustion Gas PAG Off ‐ Concentration vs Time Graph 2: GT12 Combustion Gas PAG Off ‐ Concentration vs Time Graph 2: GT12 Combustion Gas PAG On ‐ Concentration vs Time

RAW DATA

Raw Data: ECS Job Log Raw Data: ECS Laboratory Data Raw Data: ECS Gas Analyser Calibration Data Raw Data: RSW12253 ‐ USEPA Method 4 ‐ GT Unit 11 ‐ PAG Off Raw Data: RSW12253 ‐ Gases ‐ GT Unit 11 ‐ PAG Off Raw Data: RSW12253 ‐ USEPA Method 4 ‐ GT Unit 12 ‐ PAG Off Raw Data: RSW12253 ‐ Gases ‐ GT Unit 12 ‐ PAG Off Raw Data: RSW12253 ‐ USEPA Method 4 ‐ GT Unit 12 ‐ PAG On Raw Data: RSW12253 ‐ Gases ‐ GT Unit 12 ‐ PAG On Note: Raw Data of worksheets are available electronically on CD provided with report. The worksheets provide raw data collected during sampling for the purposes of traceability of results.



1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

At the request of NewGen/ERM Power, the emission source was tested for a variety of parameters. The following data is presented to determine NewGen/ERM Power’s compliance with the site licence conditions as stipulated in Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC) licence document L8356/2009/1. The concentration for each parameter as compared to the site environmental licence criteria is shown in the summary data below. A brief summary of the compliance status of the site release points is presented. Table 1: Summary of Source Emissions Criteria and Compliance Achievement.

Source Identification GT Unit 11 – PAG Off

Parameter Concentration Criteria Compliance

Units ppmvd@ 15%

O2 ppmvd@ 15%

O2 Yes/No

DEC / Internal Criteria

Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) Corrected to 15% Oxygen

4.8 <25 Yes DEC

Source Identification GT Unit 12 – PAG Off

Parameter Concentration Criteria Compliance

Units ppmvd@ 15%

O2 ppmvd@ 15%

O2 Yes/No

DEC / Internal Criteria


12 <25 Yes DEC

Source Identification GT Unit 12 – PAG On


4.2 <25 Yes DEC



2 INTRODUCTION

ECS Stack Pty Ltd was requested to conduct stack monitoring for NewGen/ERM Power at the Neerabup Power Station, in Western Australia. Testing was conducted on the Gas Turbine Units 11 and 12 according to the Annual Compliance Program. The methodology to be employed for the annual compliance testing program is consistent with USEPA CFR 40 Part 60 Methods, and where applicable Australian Standards. The methodology to be employed is consistent with the requirements of the WA Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC). Further to this, ECS Stack provides NATA accredited test results for the sampling carried out under this program, unless where otherwise specified. Limits of detection will be aimed to achieve the best available under normal sampling conditions. The following table outlines the variety of tests to be performed on the emissions sources at the NewGen/ERM Neerabup Power Station. Table 2: Sampling Program ‐ Source and Methods

Gas Turbine 11 and 12

Analyte Method ISO 17025 (NATA) Accreditation

Sampling Plane and Traverse Point Selection AS4323.1‐1995 Yes

Gas Flow Rates USEPA Method 2 Yes

Carbon Dioxide and Oxygen USEPA Method 3a Yes

Moisture USEPA Method 4 Yes

Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) USEPA Method 7e Yes

Carbon Monoxide USEPA Method 10 Yes Note:

1. The first four items are required determinants for the calculation of Emission Rates.

The following report details the sampling results from work performed on the aforementioned emission sources at the Neerabup Power Station on the 8th and 14th of January, 2013. The results presented relate only to the sources tested.



3 SAMPLING PLANE

3.1 Non Ideal Sampling Plane

GT Unit 11: The sampling plane is considered to be Non Ideal for the determinations for flow rate and particulate test parameters as detailed in AS4323.1‐1995 due to the following:

1. The upstream stack diameters to the nearest disturbance being 5.0 stack diameters less than the requirement and the downstream stack diameters to the nearest disturbance being 1.7 stack diameters less than the requirement. Due to the sampling plane not being the required distance(s) from a flow disturbance, the number of traverse points sampled across the sampling plane was increased from 36 to 54.

2. Isokinetic ratio highest to lowest velocity exceeds 1.6:1.

Table 3: GT 11 Sampling Plane Characteristics

Parameter Measurement Units Image

Distance to Far Wall of Stack (Lfw) 6.65 M

Distance to Near Wall of Stack (Lnw) 0.29 M

Diameter of Stack (D) 6.36 M

Area of Stack (As) 31.8 m2

Distance Upstream to Nearest Flow Disturbance (B)

6.50 M

Distance Downstream to Nearest Flow Disturbance (A)

2.20 M

Is this sampling plane Ideal?(1) No ‐

Note: 1. Sampling planes are in non‐ideal locations, additional sampling traverse points were used in accordance with AS4323.1‐1995 to correct and achieve valid sampling results.

GT Unit 12: The sampling plane is considered to be Non Ideal for the determinations for flow rate and particulate test parameters as detailed in AS4323.1‐1995 due to the following:

3. The upstream stack diameters to the nearest disturbance being 5.0 stack diameters less than the requirement and the downstream stack diameters to the nearest disturbance being 1.7 stack diameters less than the requirement. Due to the sampling plane not being the required distance(s) from a flow disturbance, the number of traverse points sampled across the sampling plane was increased from 36 to 54.

4. Isokinetic ratio highest to lowest velocity exceeds 1.6:1.

Table 4: GT 12 Sampling Plane Characteristics

Parameter Measurement Units Image

Distance to Far Wall of Stack (Lfw) 6.65 M

Distance to Near Wall of Stack (Lnw) 0.29 M

Diameter of Stack (D) 6.36 M

Area of Stack (As) 31.8 m2

Distance Upstream to Nearest Flow Disturbance (B)

6.50 M

Distance Downstream to Nearest Flow Disturbance (A)

2.20 M

Is this sampling plane? (1) No ‐

Note: 1. Sampling planes are in non‐ideal locations, additional sampling traverse points were used in accordance with AS4323.1‐1995 to correct and achieve valid sampling results.



4 RESULTS

ECS Stack Pty. Ltd. uses instrumentation that meets the United States (US) Code of Federal Regulations 40 Part 60 & 63 Appendix A & I. Results are representative of process conditions during the sampling periods. Full detailed descriptions can be found in the Summary Reports Section at the end of the document. For further information please refer to Raw Data Appendices. 4.1 Volumetric Flowrates and Gas Velocities

USEPA Method 2 was used for the measurement of gas flow rate. The velocity and gas flow rate was determined using a Pitot tube, manometer and thermocouple. Differential pressures and temperatures were measured from the predetermined traverse points from AS4323.1‐1995 from USEPA Methods 3A and 4 were also required to be used in conjunction with this method. The velocity was then used to calculate average flow rate so that the total emission mass rate on a volume per unit time basis could be determined. For the determination of flowrate from sources noted in Section 4 as being non‐ideal sampling locations, additional sampling traverse points were used in accordance with AS4323.1‐1995. 4.2 Determination of Combustion Gases Concentration

ECS Stack Pty. Ltd. used a Horiba PG250 Portable Gas Analyser (PGA) for the measurement of gaseous parameters from the GT Units 11 and 12 emission sources. USEPA Method 3a was used for the determination of combustion gas concentration. A gas sample was continuously extracted from the effluent stream; a portion of the sample stream was conveyed to an instrumental analyser for the determination of Oxygen and Carbon Dioxide. Additionally, 7e and 10 were used for the determination of Nitrogen Oxides (reported as NO2) and Carbon Monoxide, respectively. Refer to the Summary Report Section Combustion Gases, for detailed sampling and analysis results for the GT Units 11 and 12. 4.3 Determination of Gas Moisture Concentration

USEPA Method 4 was used for the determination of gas moisture concentration. A sample was continuously extracted from the effluent stream using a heated probe and passed through chilled impingers containing water. The water component was removed by condensation and the amount collected was determined volumetrically and used to calculate moisture concentration.



5 DEFINITIONS

5.1 Practical Quantitation Limit (PQL)

Practical Quantitation Limits (PQLs) stated in the following report have been derived from the associated analytical laboratory reports. 5.2 Method Detection Limits (MDL)

Method detection limits (MDLs) stated in the following report are derived using the analytical practical quantitation limits (PQLs) and field test dry gas volumes. This is the minimum detectable limit for each run based solely on the PQL divided by the Dry Standard Cubic Metre (dscm) for each run. This value incorporates analytical instrumental uncertainty only and does not include uncertainties due to manual sampling. 5.3 Result Codes

Result codes are assigned to each result to illustrate the level of detection that each specific analyte has achieved. The two main codes that are assigned are “D” and “nd” which represent the result being equal or above and below the MDL respectively. All subsequent codes (Noted in brackets) indicate where laboratories have found analyte present in one or more of the samples (Test or Blank). All combinations of codes are listed and explained below:

nd Final result is below the MDL, has no detects in any of the Blanks or any of the Test samples.

nd (D) Final result is below the MDL, has no detects in any of the Blanks but at least one detect in one of the Test samples.

nd (B) Final result is below the MDL, has no detects in any of the Test samples but at least one detect in one of the Blank samples.

nd (D,B) Final result is below the MDL, has at least one detect in one of the Blank samples and at least one detect in one of the Test samples.

D Final result is above the MDL, has no detects in any of the Blank samples and at least one detect in one of the Test samples.

D(B) Final result is above the MDL, has at least one detect in one of the Blank samples and at least one detect in one of the Test samples.

5.4 Average Calculation Methodology

The Average Calculation (for a sample within a duplicate, triplicate or quadruplicate test) is calculated depending on one of the following:

If all runs are detected, then the average is calculated based on the results of the detected compound and then divided by the number of runs;

If a run (or more) in a sample set is non‐detected then half of the respective MDL is used in the average calculation

If all runs are non‐detected, then the average is reported as ‘nd’.



5.5 Significant Figures

All data generated from external laboratories is presented to two significant figures as laboratory results are typically supplied in this format. ECS results are consequently bound by this accuracy. All calculations are performed on unrounded data. All physical parameters displayed in the report are unrounded. All particulate date is presented to three significant figures. All combustion gas data is accurate to two significant figures. Oxygen (%vol/vol) and Carbon Dioxide (%vol/vol) is reported to one decimal place accuracy. 5.6 Units of Measure

All data generated from external laboratories is presented to two significant figures as laboratory results are typically supplied in this format. ECS results are consequently bound by this accuracy. The following units of measure are referred to within this report;

dscm Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s ‐ All concentrations and emission rates are based on the gas being dry and at Standard conditions (101.325kPa and 0oC).

g/dscm grams per Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s.

mg/dscm milligrams per Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s.

µg/dscm micrograms per Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s

pg/dscm picograms per Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s

dscm/min Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s per Minute.

dscm/hr Dry Standard Cubic Metre/s per Hour.

wscm/min Wet Standard Cubic Metre/s ‐ All concentrations and emission rates are based on the gas being wet and at Standard conditions (101.325kPa and 0oC).

acm/min Actual Cubic Metres per Minute flow rate at sampling conditions.

m/sec Metres per Second – Velocity of the stack or duct gas at sampling conditions.

% Compositions (%) Percentage constitution of an analyte measured on a volume basis.

ppm Parts per Million – Volume based measurement.

Summary Reports and Graphs

Client:

Job Number:

Sampling Date: dd/mm/yyyy

Sampling Start Time: hh:mm

Sampling Finish Time: hh:mm

Average Stack Temperature: C

Average Stack Gas Velocity: m/sec

Average Stack Moisture Content: %

Dry Standard Flow Rate: dscm/min

Carbon Dioxide 3.8 % 0.1 % D N/A

Oxygen 14.1 % 0.1 % D N/A

Carbon Monoxide 2.0 mg/dscm 1.3 mg/dscm D 3.2 kg/hr

Carbon Monoxide 1.6 ppm 1.0 ppm D 0.90 g/sec

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 3A

12:57

Emission RateCode

Summary Report: Combustion Gases ‐ GT/HRSG Unit 11 PAG Off

NewGen Neerabup

RSW12253

Emission Rate

8/01/2013

Concentration Method Detection Limit

Method Detection Limit Code

Code

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 7E Concentration Emission Rate

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 10 Concentration Method Detection Limit

11:57

8.4

26969

520

46

Nitric Oxide ‐ mg/dscm ‐ mg/dscm ‐ kg/hr

Nitrogen Dioxide ‐ mg/dscm ‐ mg/dscm ‐ kg/hr

Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) 11 mg/dscm 2.1 mg/dscm D 18 kg/hr

Corrected Nitrogen Oxides (as

NO2 @15% O2)4.8 ppm

Nitric Oxide ‐ ppm ‐ ppm ‐ g/sec

Nitrogen Dioxide ‐ ppm ‐ ppm ‐ g/sec

Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) 5.6 ppm 1.0 ppm D 5.1 g/sec

Page 1 of 1GT/HRSG Unit 11 ‐ Summary Report: Combustion Gases

246810121416

2

4

6

8

10

Con

cent

ratio

n (%

)

Con

cent

ratio

n (p

pm)

Combustion Gas Concentration vs Time - GT Unit 11 PAG Off

CO ppm

NOx ppm

CO2 vol%

00

11:5

7:00

12:0

2:00

12:0

7:00

12:1

2:00

12:1

7:00

12:2

2:00

12:2

7:00

12:3

2:00

12:3

7:00

12:4

2:00

12:4

7:00

12:5

2:00

12:5

7:00

C

Time (hh:mm:ss)

O2 vol%

Client:

Job Number:









Oxygen 15.1 % 0.1 % D N/A



Summary Report: Combustion Gases ‐ GT/HRSG Unit 12 PAG Off

NewGen Neerabup

RSW12253

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 7E Concentration

14/01/2013

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 3A

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 10 Concentration

504

36

CodeConcentration Method Detection Limit

Method Detection Limit Emission Rate

Emission RateCodeMethod Detection Limit

Emission Rate

13:55

5.6

22013

Code

14:55





NO2 @15% O2)12 ppm



Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) 11 ppm 1.0 ppm D 8.6 g/sec


468101214161820

4

6

8

10

12

14

Con

cent

ratio

n (%

)

Con

cent

ratio

n (p

pm)

Combustion Gases Concentration vs Time - GT Unit 12 PAG Off

CO ppm

NOx ppm

CO2 vol%

O2 l%

024

0

2

13:5

5:00

14:0

2:12

14:0

9:24

14:1

6:36

14:2

3:48

14:3

1:00

14:3

8:12

14:4

5:24

14:5

2:36

Time (hh:mm:ss)

O2 vol%

Client:

Job Number:









Oxygen 13.9 % 0.1 % D N/A



Emission RateCode

15:14

7.7

24357

16:14

CodeMethod Detection Limit Emission Rate

CodeMethod Detection Limit

525

41

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 10 Concentration Method Detection Limit

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 7E Concentration

Summary Report: Combustion Gases ‐ GT/HRSG Unit 12 PAG On

NewGen Neerabup

RSW12253

Emission Rate

14/01/2013

Analyte ‐ USEPA Method 3A Concentration





NO2 @15% O2)4.2 ppm



Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) 4.9 ppm 1.0 ppm D 4.1 g/sec


4

6

8

10

12

14

16

10

15

20

25

30

Con

cent

ratio

n (%

)

Con

cent

ratio

n (p

pm)

Combustion Gases Concentration vs Time - GT Unit 12 PAG On

CO ppm

NOx ppm

CO2 vol%

O2 vol%

0

2

4

0

5

15:1

4:45

15:1

9:15

15:2

3:45

15:2

8:15

15:3

2:45

15:3

7:15

15:4

1:45

15:4

6:15

15:5

0:45

15:5

5:15

15:5

9:45

16:0

4:15

16:0

8:45

16:1

3:15

C

Time (hh:mm:ss)


Page 13 of 15

Appendix 2 – Incident Reports No incidents were reported to DER during this period.

O:\Operations\Neerabup\10000-Operations & Maintenance\Registers\Incident Register\NPS-OHS-INC-REG NPS Incident Report Register.xlsx\DEC - Environmental Incidents

MEX W

O#

Propsed A

ctions

Com

pleted A

ctions

1 1

1 1

1002 4 4

01/07/2012 to 30/06/2013 Nil incidents recorded

up to 30/06/2011 Nil incidents recorded

01/07/2011 to 30/06/2012 Nil incidents recorded

NPS-ENV-INC-02 30/10/2009 Unit 11 NOx Measurement above target 31/03/2010

NPS-ENV-INC-03 25/02/2011 Unit 12 NOx Measurement above target 29/04/2011

Incident Number Date Description (abbreviated) Actions Closed Date

NPS-ENV-INC-01 30/10/2009 Unit 11 CEMS Availability 31/03/2010

STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE

Incident Report register for DEC Reportable Incident Reports

NPS-OHS-INC-REG

REV NO: 0 REV DATE: 20/07/2009


Page 14 of 15

Appendix 3 – External Complaints register No external complaints have occurred during this reporting period.

O:\Operations\Neerabup\10000-Operations & Maintenance\Registers\External Complaints Register\NPS-REG-EXT-COMP External Complaints Register\Power Station Incidents

Complaint No Date Received Description (abbreviated) Actions Closed Date

No complaints received to date. 23/12/2010


External Complaints Register - Power Station

REV NO: 0 REV DATE:

NPS-REG-EXT-COMP

22/12/2010

Date Notification Completed





MEX WO#

O:\Operations\Neerabup\10000-Operations & Maintenance\Registers\External Complaints Register\NPS-REG-EXT-COMP External Complaints Register\PL75 - Ext Complaints

Complaint No Date Received Description (abbreviated) Actions Closed Date

Date Notification Completed

MEX WO#


External Complaints Register - Pipeline PL75

NPS-REG-EXT-COMP

REV NO: 0 REV DATE: 22/12/2010







Page 15 of 15

Appendix 4 – Inspection Plan Schedule

NEEARBUP Forecasted Inspection Plan 2009 - 2030GT Inspection Interval GT Geno Inspection IntervalEOH Start Years Years

GT11 as of 30/06/2013 8000 250 n/a Min MaxDynamic Hours 370.8 41000 1250 t 12 10000 20000 n/aBaseload OH 759.3 1E+05 3000 n/a 8000 10000 upto 3Peakload OH 1395 16000 20000 upto 6Normal Start 199 40000 60000 t 12Emergency Start 8 Inspection scopeEOH 4595.2 1 Minor - entry to accessible regions for visual inspection on followings:- 1 Initial - maximal as Main inspection, removal of rotor

compressor inlet including air intakeburners and flame cylinder end plate 2 Sh t checks and measures required based on observation

GT12 as of 30/06/2013 ceramic tile lining of flame cylinders, hot gas path of mixing and inner casings during operation and checks; Dynamic Hours 440.5 turbine stage 1 and 4Baseload OH 532.3 exhaust casing and diffuser liner 3 Intermediate - similar to Short Inspection including partial Peakload OH 1257.5 disassembly but without rotor removalNormal Start 188 2 Major - extensive dismantling, detail visual inspection and non-destructive evaluation;Emergency Start 3 refurbishment of coated airfoils in turbine and compressor sections; 4 Main - similar to Intermediate Inspection but with rotor removalEOH 4140.3 scheduled and condition-based repair measures

3 LTE - extensive dismantling, detail visual inspection and non-destructive evaluation;scheduled and condition-based repair measures;implementation of LTE measures

Forecasted EOH (accumulative)

31-A

ug-0

9

30-S

ep-0

9

31-O

ct-0

9

30-N

ov-0

9

31-D

ec-0

9

31-J

an-1

0

28-F

eb-1

0

31-M

ar-1

0

30-A

pr-1

0

31-M

ay-1

0

30-J

un-1

0

31-J

ul-1

0

31-A

ug-1

0

30-S

ep-1

0

31-O

ct-1

0

30-N

ov-1

0

31-D

ec-1

0

31-J

an-1

1

28-F

eb-1

1

31-M

ar-1

1

30-A

pr-1

1

31-M

ay-1

1

30-J

un-1

1

31-J

ul-1

1

31-A

ug-1

1

30-S

ep-1

1

31-O

ct-1

1

30-N

ov-1

1

31-D

ec-1

1

31-J

an-1

2

29-F

eb-1

2

31-M

ar-1

2

30-A

pr-1

2

31-M

ay-1

2

30-J

un-1

2

31-J

ul-1

2

31-A

ug-1

2

30-S

ep-1

2

31-O

ct-1

2

30-N

ov-1

2

31-D

ec-1

2

31-J

an-1

3

28-F

eb-1

3

31-M

ar-1

3

30-A

pr-1

3

31-M

ay-1

3

30-J

un-1

3

31-J

ul-1

3

31-A

ug-1

3

30-S

ep-1

3

31-O

ct-1

3

30-N

ov-1

3

31-D

ec-1

3

31-J

an-1

4

28-F

eb-1

4

31-M

ar-1

4

30-A

pr-1

4

31-M

ay-1

4

30-J

un-1

4

31-J

ul-1

4

31-A

ug-1

4

30-S

ep-1

4

31-O

ct-1

4

30-N

ov-1

4

31-D

ec-1

4

31-J

an-1

5

28-F

eb-1

5

31-M

ar-1

5

30-A

pr-1

5

31-M

ay-1

5

30-J

un-1

5

31-J

ul-1

5

31-A

ug-1

5

30-S

ep-1

5

31-O

ct-1

5

30-N

ov-1

5

31-D

ec-1

5

31-J

an-1

6

29-F

eb-1

6

31-M

ar-1

6

30-A

pr-1

6

31-M

ay-1

6

30-J

un-1

6

31-J

ul-1

6

31-A

ug-1

6

30-S

ep-1

6

31-O

ct-1

6

30-N

ov-1

6

31-D

ec-1

6

31-J

an-1

7

28-F

eb-1

7

31-M

ar-1

7

30-A

pr-1

7

31-M

ay-1

7

30-J

un-1

7

31-J

ul-1

7

31-A

ug-1

7

30-S

ep-1

7

31-O

ct-1

7

30-N

ov-1

7

31-D

ec-1

7

31-J

an-1

8

28-F

eb-1

8

31-M

ar-1

8

30-A

pr-1

8

31-M

ay-1

8

30-J

un-1

8

31-J

ul-1

8

31-A

ug-1

8

30-S

ep-1

8

31-O

ct-1

8

30-N

ov-1

8

31-D

ec-1

8

31-J

an-1

9

28-F

eb-1

9

31-M

ar-1

9

30-A

pr-1

9

31-M

ay-1

9

30-J

un-1

9

31-J

ul-1

9

31-A

ug-1

9

30-S

ep-1

9

31-O

ct-1

9

30-N

ov-1

9

31-D

ec-1

9

31-J

an-2

0

29-F

eb-2

0

31-M

ar-2

0

30-A

pr-2

0

31-M

ay-2

0

30-J

un-2

0

31-J

ul-2

0

31-A

ug-2

0

30-S

ep-2

0

31-O

ct-2

0

30-N

ov-2

0

31-D

ec-2

0

31-J

an-2

1

28-F

eb-2

1

31-M

ar-2

1

30-A

pr-2

1

31-M

ay-2

1

30-J

un-2

1

31-J

ul-2

1

31-A

ug-2

1

30-S

ep-2

1

31-O

ct-2

1

30-N

ov-2

1

31-D

ec-2

1

31-J

an-2

2

28-F

eb-2

2

31-M

ar-2

2

30-A

pr-2

2

31-M

ay-2

2

30-J

un-2

2

31-J

ul-2

2

31-A

ug-2

2

30-S

ep-2

2

31-O

ct-2

2

30-N

ov-2

2

31-D

ec-2

2

31-J

an-2

3

28-F

eb-2

3

31-M

ar-2

3

30-A

pr-2

3

31-M

ay-2

3

30-J

un-2

3

31-J

ul-2

3

31-A

ug-2

3

30-S

ep-2

3

31-O

ct-2

3

30-N

ov-2

3

31-D

ec-2

3

31-J

an-2

4

29-F

eb-2

4

31-M

ar-2

4

30-A

pr-2

4

31-M

ay-2

4

30-J

un-2

4

31-J

ul-2

4

31-A

ug-2

4

30-S

ep-2

4

31-O

ct-2

4

30-N

ov-2

4

31-D

ec-2

4

31-J

an-2

5

28-F

eb-2

5

31-M

ar-2

5

30-A

pr-2

5

31-M

ay-2

5

30-J

un-2

5

31-J

ul-2

5

31-A

ug-2

5

30-S

ep-2

5

31-O

ct-2

5

30-N

ov-2

5

31-D

ec-2

5

31-J

an-2

6

28-F

eb-2

6

31-M

ar-2

6

30-A

pr-2

6

31-M

ay-2

6

30-J

un-2

6

31-J

ul-2

6

31-A

ug-2

6

30-S

ep-2

6

31-O

ct-2

6

30-N

ov-2

6

31-D

ec-2

6

31-J

an-2

7

28-F

eb-2

7

31-M

ar-2

7

30-A

pr-2

7

31-M

ay-2

7

30-J

un-2

7

31-J

ul-2

7

31-A

ug-2

7

30-S

ep-2

7

31-O

ct-2

7

30-N

ov-2

7

31-D

ec-2

7

31-J

an-2

8

29-F

eb-2

8

31-M

ar-2

8

30-A

pr-2

8

31-M

ay-2

8

30-J

un-2

8

31-J

ul-2

8

31-A

ug-2

8

30-S

ep-2

8

5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5Starts no. GT11 3 23 37 37 37 40 41 41 41 41 41 41 41 46 46 48 61 62 73 90 90 90 91 98 98 103 115 135 142 153 165 167 167 167 168 176 177 179 180 180 187 190 196 196 196 196 197 203 209 215 220 226 232 238 244 250 255 261 267 273 279 285 290 296 302 308 314 320 325 331 337 343 349 355 360 366 372 378 384 390 395 401 407 413 419 425 430 436 442 448 454 459 465 471 477 483 489 494 500 506 512 518 524 529 535 541 547 553 559 565 570 576 582 588 594 600 605 611 617 623 629 635 640 646 652 658 664 670 675 681 687 693 699 705 710 716 722 728 734 740 745 751 757 763 769 775 780 786 792 798 804 810 815 821 827 833 839 845 850 856 862 868 874 880 885 891 897 903 909 915 920 926 932 938 944 950 955 961 967 973 979 985 990 996 1002 1008 1014 1020 1025 1031 1037 1043 1049 1055 1060 1066 1072 1078 1084 1090 1095 1101 1107 1113 1119 1125 1130 1136 1142 1148 1154 1160 1165 1171 1177 1183 1189 1195 1200 1206 1212 1218 1224 1230 1235 1241 1247 1253 1259 1265EOH GT11 40 572 975 975 1000 1016 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1086 1086 1115 1397 1422 1764 2255 2255 2255 2168 2373 2373 2346 2752 3286 3431 3698 3956 3998 3998 3998 4008 4101 4112 4136 4148 4148 4332 4419 4555 4555 4555 4555 4569 4747 4926 5104 5282 5461 5639 5817 5996 6174 6352 6531 6709 6887 7066 7244 7422 7601 7779 7957 8136 8314 8492 8671 8849 9027 9206 9384 9562 9741 9919 10097 10276 10454 10632 10811 10989 11167 11346 11524 11702 11881 12059 12237 12416 12594 12772 12951 13129 13307 13486 13664 13842 14021 14199 14377 14556 14734 14912 15091 15269 15447 15626 15804 15982 16161 16339 16517 16696 16874 17052 17231 17409 17587 17766 17944 18122 18301 18479 18657 18836 19014 19192 19371 19549 19727 19906 20084 20262 20441 20619 20797 20976 21154 21332 21511 21689 21867 22046 22224 22402 22581 22759 22937 23116 23294 23472 23651 23829 24007 24186 24364 24542 24721 24899 25077 25256 25434 25612 25791 25969 26147 26326 26504 26682 26861 27039 27217 27396 27574 27752 27931 28109 28287 28466 28644 28822 29001 29179 29357 29536 29714 29892 30071 30249 30427 30606 30784 30962 31141 31319 31497 31676 31854 32032 32211 32389 32567 32746 32924 33102 33281 33459 33637 33816 33994 34172 34351 34529 34707 34886 35064 35242 35421 35599 35777 35956 36134 36312 36491 36669 36847 37026 37204EOH Geno GT11 40 572 975 975 1000 1016 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1086 1086 1115 1397 1422 1764 2255 2255 2255 2168 2373 2373 2346 2752 3286 3431 3698 3956 3998 3998 3998 4008 4101 4112 4136 4148 4148 4332 4419 4555 4555 4555 4555 4569 4749 4930 5110 5290 5471 5651 5831 6012 6192 6372 6553 6733 6913 7094 7274 7454 7635 7815 7995 8176 8356 8536 8717 8897 9077 9258 9438 9618 9799 9979 10159 10340 10520 10700 10881 11061 11241 11422 11602 11782 11963 12143 12323 12504 12684 12864 13045 13225 13405 13586 13766 13946 14127 14307 14487 14668 14848 15028 15209 15389 15569 15750 15930 16110 16291 16471 16651 16832 17012 17192 17373 17553 17733 17914 18094 18274 18455 18635 18815 18996 19176 19356 19537 19717 19897 20078 20258 20438 20619 20799 20979 21160 21340 21520 21701 21881 22061 22242 22422 22602 22783 22963 23143 23324 23504 23684 23865 24045 24225 24406 24586 24766 24947 25127 25307 25488 25668 25848 26029 26209 26389 26570 26750 26930 27111 27291 27471 27652 27832 28012 28193 28373 28553 28734 28914 29094 29275 29455 29635 29816 29996 30176 30357 30537 30717 30898 31078 31258 31439 31619 31799 31980 32160 32340 32521 32701 32881 33062 33242 33422 33603 33783 33963 34144 34324 34504 34685 34865 35045 35226 35406 35586 35767 35947 36127 36308 36488 36668 36849 37029 37209 37390 37570

Starts no. GT12 5 25 33 34 35 37 39 40 40 40 40 40 40 42 44 46 58 66 76 81 82 82 83 93 94 98 121 134 136 144 149 150 150 150 151 163 166 168 168 168 172 179 184 184 184 184 187 193 199 205 210 216 222 228 234 240 245 251 257 263 269 275 280 286 292 298 304 310 315 321 327 333 339 345 350 356 362 368 374 380 385 391 397 403 409 415 420 426 432 438 444 449 455 461 467 473 479 484 490 496 502 508 514 519 525 531 537 543 549 555 560 566 572 578 584 590 595 601 607 613 619 625 630 636 642 648 654 660 665 671 677 683 689 695 700 706 712 718 724 730 735 741 747 753 759 765 770 776 782 788 794 800 805 811 817 823 829 835 840 846 852 858 864 870 875 881 887 893 899 905 910 916 922 928 934 940 945 951 957 963 969 975 980 986 992 998 1004 1010 1015 1021 1027 1033 1039 1045 1050 1056 1062 1068 1074 1080 1085 1091 1097 1103 1109 1115 1120 1126 1132 1138 1144 1150 1155 1161 1167 1173 1179 1185 1190 1196 1202 1208 1214 1220 1225 1231 1237 1243 1249 1255EOH GT12 59 404 539 552 569 601 628 645 645 645 645 645 645 668 690 717 1094 1382 1753 1867 1887 1887 1898 2048 2058 2110 2749 3084 3128 3354 3470 3489 3489 3489 3499 3639 3673 3697 3697 3697 3825 3967 4092 4092 4092 4092 4127 4305 4484 4662 4840 5019 5197 5375 5554 5732 5910 6089 6267 6445 6624 6802 6980 7159 7337 7515 7694 7872 8050 8229 8407 8585 8764 8942 9120 9299 9477 9655 9834 10012 10190 10369 10547 10725 10904 11082 11260 11439 11617 11795 11974 12152 12330 12509 12687 12865 13044 13222 13400 13579 13757 13935 14114 14292 14470 14649 14827 15005 15184 15362 15540 15719 15897 16075 16254 16432 16610 16789 16967 17145 17324 17502 17680 17859 18037 18215 18394 18572 18750 18929 19107 19285 19464 19642 19820 19999 20177 20355 20534 20712 20890 21069 21247 21425 21604 21782 21960 22139 22317 22495 22674 22852 23030 23209 23387 23565 23744 23922 24100 24279 24457 24635 24814 24992 25170 25349 25527 25705 25884 26062 26240 26419 26597 26775 26954 27132 27310 27489 27667 27845 28024 28202 28380 28559 28737 28915 29094 29272 29450 29629 29807 29985 30164 30342 30520 30699 30877 31055 31234 31412 31590 31769 31947 32125 32304 32482 32660 32839 33017 33195 33374 33552 33730 33909 34087 34265 34444 34622 34800 34979 35157 35335 35514 35692 35870 36049 36227 36405 36584 36762EOH Geno GT12 59 404 539 552 569 601 628 645 645 645 645 645 645 668 690 717 1094 1382 1753 1867 1887 1887 1898 2048 2058 2110 2749 3084 3128 3354 3470 3489 3489 3489 3499 3639 3673 3697 3697 3697 3825 3967 4092 4092 4092 4092 4127 4307 4488 4668 4848 5029 5209 5389 5570 5750 5930 6111 6291 6471 6652 6832 7012 7193 7373 7553 7734 7914 8094 8275 8455 8635 8816 8996 9176 9357 9537 9717 9898 10078 10258 10439 10619 10799 10980 11160 11340 11521 11701 11881 12062 12242 12422 12603 12783 12963 13144 13324 13504 13685 13865 14045 14226 14406 14586 14767 14947 15127 15308 15488 15668 15849 16029 16209 16390 16570 16750 16931 17111 17291 17472 17652 17832 18013 18193 18373 18554 18734 18914 19095 19275 19455 19636 19816 19996 20177 20357 20537 20718 20898 21078 21259 21439 21619 21800 21980 22160 22341 22521 22701 22882 23062 23242 23423 23603 23783 23964 24144 24324 24505 24685 24865 25046 25226 25406 25587 25767 25947 26128 26308 26488 26669 26849 27029 27210 27390 27570 27751 27931 28111 28292 28472 28652 28833 29013 29193 29374 29554 29734 29915 30095 30275 30456 30636 30816 30997 31177 31357 31538 31718 31898 32079 32259 32439 32620 32800 32980 33161 33341 33521 33702 33882 34062 34243 34423 34603 34784 34964 35144 35325 35505 35685 35866 36046 36226 36407 36587 36767 36948 37128

####

####

#

30-S

ep-0

9

31-O

ct-0

9

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

0

28-F

eb-1

0

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

0

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

0

31-J

ul-1

0

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

0

31-O

ct-1

0

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

1

28-F

eb-1

1

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

1

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

1

31-J

ul-1

1

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

1

31-O

ct-1

1

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

2

29-F

eb-1

2

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

2

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

2

31-J

ul-1

2

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

2

31-O

ct-1

2

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

3

28-F

eb-1

3

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

3

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

3

31-J

ul-1

3

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

3

31-O

ct-1

3

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

4

28-F

eb-1

4

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

4

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

4

31-J

ul-1

4

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

4

31-O

ct-1

4

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

5

28-F

eb-1

5

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

5

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

5

31-J

ul-1

5

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

5

31-O

ct-1

5

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

6

29-F

eb-1

6

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

6

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

6

31-J

ul-1

6

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

6

31-O

ct-1

6

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

7

28-F

eb-1

7

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

7

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

7

31-J

ul-1

7

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

7

31-O

ct-1

7

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

8

28-F

eb-1

8

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

8

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

8

31-J

ul-1

8

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

8

31-O

ct-1

8

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

9

28-F

eb-1

9

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

9

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

9

31-J

ul-1

9

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

9

31-O

ct-1

9

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

0

29-F

eb-2

0

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

0

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

0

31-J

ul-2

0

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

0

31-O

ct-2

0

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

1

28-F

eb-2

1

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

1

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

1

31-J

ul-2

1

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

1

31-O

ct-2

1

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

2

28-F

eb-2

2

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

2

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

2

31-J

ul-2

2

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

2

31-O

ct-2

2

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

3

28-F

eb-2

3

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

3

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

3

31-J

ul-2

3

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

3

31-O

ct-2

3

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

4

29-F

eb-2

4

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

4

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

4

31-J

ul-2

4

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

4

31-O

ct-2

4

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

5

28-F

eb-2

5

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

5

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

5

31-J

ul-2

5

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

5

31-O

ct-2

5

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

6

28-F

eb-2

6

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

6

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

6

31-J

ul-2

6

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

6

31-O

ct-2

6

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

7

28-F

eb-2

7

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

7

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

7

31-J

ul-2

7

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

7

31-O

ct-2

7

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

8

29-F

eb-2

8

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

8

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

8

31-J

ul-2

8

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

8

7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 78 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8

Starts no. GT11 3 23 37 37 37 40 41 41 41 41 41 41 41 46 46 48 61 62 73 90 90 90 91 98 98 103 115 135 142 153 165 167 167 167 168 176 177 179 180 180 187 190 190 196 196 196 197 197 197 197 197 210 223 236 249 262 262 262 262 262 262 262 262 275 288 301 314 327 327 327 327 327 327 327 327 340 353 366 379 393 393 393 393 393 393 393 393 406 419 432 445 458 458 458 458 458 458 458 458 471 484 497 510 523 523 523 523 523 523 523 523 536 549 562 575 588 588 588 588 588 588 588 588 601 614 627 640 653 653 653 653 653 653 653 653 666 679 692 705 718 718 718 718 718 718 718 718 731 744 758 771 784 784 784 784 784 784 784 784 797 810 823 836 849 849 849 849 849 849 849 849 862 875 888 901 914 914 914 914 914 914 914 914 927 940 953 966 979 979 979 979 979 979 979 979 992 1005 1018 1031 1044 1044 1044 1044 1044 1044 1044 1044 1057 1070 1083 1096 1109 1109 1109 1109 1109 1109 1109 1109 1122 1136 1149 1162 1175 1175 1175 1175 1175 1175 1175EOH GT11 40 572 975 975 1000 1016 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1086 1086 1115 1397 1422 1764 2255 2255 2255 2168 2373 2373 2346 2752 3286 3431 3698 3956 3998 3998 3998 4008 4101 4112 4136 4148 4148 4332 4419 4555 4555 4555 4555 4569 4569 4569 4569 4569 4906 5243 5579 5916 6253 6253 6253 6253 6253 6253 6253 6253 6590 6926 7263 7600 7937 7937 7937 7937 7937 7937 7937 7937 8273 8610 8947 9284 9621 9621 9621 9621 9621 9621 9621 9621 9957 10294 10631 10968 11304 11304 11304 11304 11304 11304 11304 11304 11641 11978 12315 12651 12988 12988 12988 12988 12988 12988 12988 12988 13325 13662 13999 14335 14672 14672 14672 14672 14672 14672 14672 14672 15009 15346 15682 16019 16356 16356 16356 16356 16356 16356 16356 16356 16693 17029 17366 17703 18040 18040 18040 18040 18040 18040 18040 18040 18377 18713 19050 19387 19724 19724 19724 19724 19724 19724 19724 19724 20060 20397 20734 21071 21408 21408 21408 21408 21408 21408 21408 21408 21744 22081 22418 22755 23091 23091 23091 23091 23091 23091 23091 23091 23428 23765 24102 24438 24775 24775 24775 24775 24775 24775 24775 24775 25112 25449 25786 26122 26459 26459 26459 26459 26459 26459 26459 26459 26796 27133 27469 27806 28143 28143 28143 28143 28143 28143 28143 28143 28480 28816 29153 29490 29827 29827 29827 29827 29827 29827 29827Geno GT11 40 572 975 975 1000 1016 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1086 1086 1115 1397 1422 1764 2255 2255 2255 2168 2373 2373 2346 2752 3286 3431 3698 3956 3998 3998 3998 4008 4101 4112 4136 4148 4148 4332 4419 4555 4555 4555 4555 4569 4642 4715 4788 4861 5224 5587 5950 6312 6675 6748 6821 6894 6967 7040 7113 7186 7549 7912 8275 8638 9000 9073 9146 9219 9292 9365 9438 9511 9874 10237 10600 10963 11326 11399 11472 11545 11618 11691 11764 11837 12199 12562 12925 13288 13651 13724 13797 13870 13943 14016 14089 14162 14525 14887 15250 15613 15976 16049 16122 16195 16268 16341 16414 16487 16850 17213 17576 17938 18301 18374 18447 18520 18593 18666 18739 18812 19175 19538 19901 20264 20626 20699 20772 20845 20918 20991 21064 21137 21500 21863 22226 22589 22952 23025 23098 23171 23244 23317 23390 23463 23825 24188 24551 24914 25277 25350 25423 25496 25569 25642 25715 25788 26151 26513 26876 27239 27602 27675 27748 27821 27894 27967 28040 28113 28476 28839 29202 29564 29927 30000 30073 30146 30219 30292 30365 30438 30801 31164 31527 31890 32252 32325 32398 32471 32544 32617 32690 32763 33126 33489 33852 34215 34578 34651 34724 34797 34870 34943 35016 35089 35451 35814 36177 36540 36903 36976 37049 37122 37195 37268 37341 37414 37777 38139 38502 38865 39228 39301 39374 39447 39520 39593 39666


31-A

ug-0

9

30-S

ep-0

9

31-O

ct-0

9

####

####

##

31-D

ec-0

9

31-J

an-1

0

28-F

eb-1

0

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

0

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

0

31-J

ul-1

0

31-A

ug-1

0

30-S

ep-1

0

31-O

ct-1

0

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

0

31-J

an-1

1

28-F

eb-1

1

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

1

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

1

31-J

ul-1

1

31-A

ug-1

1

30-S

ep-1

1

31-O

ct-1

1

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

1

31-J

an-1

2

29-F

eb-1

2

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

2

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

2

31-J

ul-1

2

31-A

ug-1

2

30-S

ep-1

2

31-O

ct-1

2

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

2

31-J

an-1

3

28-F

eb-1

3

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

3

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

3

31-J

ul-1

3

31-A

ug-1

3

30-S

ep-1

3

31-O

ct-1

3

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

3

31-J

an-1

4

28-F

eb-1

4

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

4

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

4

31-J

ul-1

4

31-A

ug-1

4

30-S

ep-1

4

31-O

ct-1

4

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

4

31-J

an-1

5

28-F

eb-1

5

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

5

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

5

31-J

ul-1

5

31-A

ug-1

5

30-S

ep-1

5

31-O

ct-1

5

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

5

31-J

an-1

6

29-F

eb-1

6

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

6

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

6

31-J

ul-1

6

31-A

ug-1

6

30-S

ep-1

6

31-O

ct-1

6

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

6

31-J

an-1

7

28-F

eb-1

7

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

7

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

7

31-J

ul-1

7

31-A

ug-1

7

30-S

ep-1

7

31-O

ct-1

7

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

7

31-J

an-1

8

28-F

eb-1

8

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

8

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

8

31-J

ul-1

8

31-A

ug-1

8

30-S

ep-1

8

31-O

ct-1

8

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

8

31-J

an-1

9

28-F

eb-1

9

####

####

##

30-A

pr-1

9

####

####

##

30-J

un-1

9

31-J

ul-1

9

31-A

ug-1

9

30-S

ep-1

9

31-O

ct-1

9

####

####

##

31-D

ec-1

9

31-J

an-2

0

29-F

eb-2

0

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

0

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

0

31-J

ul-2

0

31-A

ug-2

0

30-S

ep-2

0

31-O

ct-2

0

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

0

31-J

an-2

1

28-F

eb-2

1

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

1

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

1

31-J

ul-2

1

31-A

ug-2

1

30-S

ep-2

1

31-O

ct-2

1

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

1

31-J

an-2

2

28-F

eb-2

2

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

2

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

2

31-J

ul-2

2

31-A

ug-2

2

30-S

ep-2

2

31-O

ct-2

2

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

2

31-J

an-2

3

28-F

eb-2

3

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

3

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

3

31-J

ul-2

3

31-A

ug-2

3

30-S

ep-2

3

31-O

ct-2

3

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

3

31-J

an-2

4

29-F

eb-2

4

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

4

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

4

31-J

ul-2

4

31-A

ug-2

4

30-S

ep-2

4

31-O

ct-2

4

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

4

31-J

an-2

5

28-F

eb-2

5

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

5

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

5

31-J

ul-2

5

31-A

ug-2

5

30-S

ep-2

5

31-O

ct-2

5

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

5

31-J

an-2

6

28-F

eb-2

6

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

6

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

6

31-J

ul-2

6

31-A

ug-2

6

30-S

ep-2

6

31-O

ct-2

6

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

6

31-J

an-2

7

28-F

eb-2

7

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

7

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

7

31-J

ul-2

7

31-A

ug-2

7

30-S

ep-2

7

31-O

ct-2

7

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

7

31-J

an-2

8

29-F

eb-2

8

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

8

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

8

31-J

ul-2

8

31-A

ug-2

8

30-S

ep-2

8

7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 710 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10

9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9Starts no. GT11 3 23 37 37 37 40 41 41 41 41 41 41 41 46 46 48 61 62 73 90 90 90 91 98 98 103 115 135 142 153 165 167 167 167 168 176 177 179 180 180 187 190 203 196 196 196 197 197 197 197 197 197 198 201 204 207 208 208 208 208 208 208 208 208 209 212 215 218 219 219 219 219 219 219 219 219 220 223 226 229 230 230 230 230 230 230 230 230 231 234 237 240 241 241 241 241 241 241 241 241 242 245 248 251 252 252 252 252 252 252 252 252 253 256 259 262 263 263 263 263 263 263 263 263 264 267 270 273 274 274 274 274 274 274 274 274 275 278 281 284 285 285 285 285 285 285 285 285 286 289 292 295 296 296 296 296 296 296 296 296 297 300 303 306 307 307 307 307 307 307 307 307 308 311 314 317 318 318 318 318 318 318 318 318 319 322 325 328 329 329 329 329 329 329 329 329 330 333 336 339 340 340 340 340 340 340 340 340 341 344 347 350 351 351 351 351 351 351 351 351 352 355 358 361 362 362 362 362 362 362EOH GT11 40 572 975 975 1000 1016 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1086 1086 1115 1397 1422 1764 2255 2255 2255 2168 2373 2373 2346 2752 3286 3431 3698 3956 3998 3998 3998 4008 4101 4112 4136 4148 4148 4332 4419 4555 4555 4555 4555 4569 4569 4569 4569 4569 4569 4581 4617 4653 4689 4701 4701 4701 4701 4701 4701 4701 4701 4713 4749 4785 4821 4833 4833 4833 4833 4833 4833 4833 4833 4845 4881 4917 4953 4965 4965 4965 4965 4965 4965 4965 4965 4977 5013 5049 5085 5097 5097 5097 5097 5097 5097 5097 5097 5109 5145 5181 5217 5229 5229 5229 5229 5229 5229 5229 5229 5241 5277 5313 5349 5361 5361 5361 5361 5361 5361 5361 5361 5373 5409 5445 5481 5493 5493 5493 5493 5493 5493 5493 5493 5505 5541 5577 5613 5625 5625 5625 5625 5625 5625 5625 5625 5637 5673 5709 5745 5757 5757 5757 5757 5757 5757 5757 5757 5769 5805 5841 5877 5889 5889 5889 5889 5889 5889 5889 5889 5901 5937 5973 6009 6021 6021 6021 6021 6021 6021 6021 6021 6033 6069 6105 6141 6153 6153 6153 6153 6153 6153 6153 6153 6165 6201 6237 6273 6285 6285 6285 6285 6285 6285 6285 6285 6297 6333 6369 6405 6417 6417 6417 6417 6417 6417 6417 6417 6429 6465 6501 6537 6549 6549 6549 6549 6549 6549Geno GT11 40 572 975 975 1000 1016 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1030 1086 1086 1115 1397 1422 1764 2255 2255 2255 2168 2373 2373 2346 2752 3286 3431 3698 3956 3998 3998 3998 4008 4101 4112 4136 4148 4221 4332 4419 4555 4555 4555 4555 4569 4642 4715 4788 4861 4934 5078 5258 5439 5620 5763 5836 5909 5982 6055 6128 6128 6201 6345 6526 6706 6887 7031 7104 7177 7250 7323 7396 7469 7542 7686 7866 8047 8227 8371 8444 8517 8590 8663 8736 8809 8882 9026 9207 9387 9568 9712 9785 9858 9931 10004 10077 10150 10223 10366 10547 10728 10908 11052 11125 11198 11271 11344 11417 11490 11563 11707 11887 12068 12249 12392 12465 12538 12611 12684 12757 12830 12903 13047 13228 13408 13589 13733 13806 13879 13952 14025 14098 14171 14244 14388 14568 14749 14929 15073 15146 15219 15292 15365 15438 15511 15584 15728 15909 16089 16270 16414 16487 16560 16633 16706 16779 16852 16925 17068 17249 17430 17610 17754 17827 17900 17973 18046 18119 18192 18265 18409 18589 18770 18951 19094 19167 19240 19313 19386 19459 19532 19605 19749 19930 20110 20291 20435 20508 20581 20654 20727 20800 20873 20946 21090 21270 21451 21631 21775 21848 21921 21994 22067 22140 22213 22286 22430 22611 22791 22972 23116 23189 23262 23335 23408 23481 23554 23627 23770 23951 24132 24312 24456 24529 24602 24675 24748 24821


####

####

#

30-S

ep-0

9

31-O

ct-0

9

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

0

28-F

eb-1

0

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

0

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

0

31-J

ul-1

0

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

0

31-O

ct-1

0

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

1

28-F

eb-1

1

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

1

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

1

31-J

ul-1

1

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

1

31-O

ct-1

1

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

2

29-F

eb-1

2

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

2

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

2

31-J

ul-1

2

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

2

31-O

ct-1

2

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

3

28-F

eb-1

3

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

3

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

3

31-J

ul-1

3

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

3

31-O

ct-1

3

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

4

28-F

eb-1

4

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

4

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

4

31-J

ul-1

4

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

4

31-O

ct-1

4

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

5

28-F

eb-1

5

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

5

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

5

31-J

ul-1

5

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

5

31-O

ct-1

5

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

6

29-F

eb-1

6

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

6

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

6

31-J

ul-1

6

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

6

31-O

ct-1

6

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

7

28-F

eb-1

7

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

7

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

7

31-J

ul-1

7

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

7

31-O

ct-1

7

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

8

28-F

eb-1

8

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

8

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

8

31-J

ul-1

8

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

8

31-O

ct-1

8

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-1

9

28-F

eb-1

9

####

####

#

30-A

pr-1

9

####

####

#

30-J

un-1

9

31-J

ul-1

9

####

####

#

30-S

ep-1

9

31-O

ct-1

9

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

0

29-F

eb-2

0

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

0

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

0

31-J

ul-2

0

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

0

31-O

ct-2

0

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

1

28-F

eb-2

1

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

1

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

1

31-J

ul-2

1

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

1

31-O

ct-2

1

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

2

28-F

eb-2

2

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

2

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

2

31-J

ul-2

2

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

2

31-O

ct-2

2

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

3

28-F

eb-2

3

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

3

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

3

31-J

ul-2

3

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

3

31-O

ct-2

3

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

4

29-F

eb-2

4

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

4

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

4

31-J

ul-2

4

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

4

31-O

ct-2

4

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

5

28-F

eb-2

5

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

5

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

5

31-J

ul-2

5

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

5

31-O

ct-2

5

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

6

28-F

eb-2

6

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

6

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

6

31-J

ul-2

6

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

6

31-O

ct-2

6

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

7

28-F

eb-2

7

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

7

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

7

31-J

ul-2

7

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

7

31-O

ct-2

7

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

8

29-F

eb-2

8

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

8

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

8

31-J

ul-2

8

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

8

7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 711 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11



Notes: 1) The forecast results for Neerabup are based on two likely scenarios i.e. a) Operating Regime No.5 (70 starts / yr) yeilding 2140 EOH / yearb) Combination of Operating Regime No. 7 (no starts for 9 months) and No.8 (3 start / week for 3 summer months) yeilding about 26starts & 1000 EOH / yearc) Combination of Operating Regime No. 7 (no starts for 7 months); No.9 (3 start / mth for 3 summer months) and No.10 (1 start / mth for 2 summer shoulder months) yeilding about 11 starts & 132 EOH / yeard) C bi ti f O ti R i N 7 ( t t f 9 th ) d N 11 (5 t t / k f 3 th ) ildi b t 63 t t & 1584 EOH /

2) For all scenarios, most inspection intervals are pre-dominated by time factor rather than EOH factor3) With a lower starting EOH, and to achieve a staggerred outage, inspection intervals for GT12 lags GT11 by a few moths to a year (Major Inspection) 4) EOH criteria for Geno is different from GT .5) Inspections for Geno are scheduled to coincide with those for GT as far as possible to minimise number of outages.

Scenario d)

Operating Regime No.7 - no startsOperating Regime No.11 - 5 starts / week

Main Inspection (4 weeks)

Operating Regime No.7 - no startsOperating Regime No.8 - 3 starts / week

Operating Regime No.5 - 70 starts / year

Operating Regime No.7 - no startsOperating Regime No.10 - 1 start / mthOperating Regime No.9 - 3 starts / mth

Scenario a)

Scenario b)

Scenario c)

EOHDescriptionMinor inspection (3 days)Major inspection (25 days)

Life Extention inspection (35 days)

Description

Initial Inspection (4 weeks)Short Inspection (3 days)

Intermediate Inspection (2 weeks)

GT1

1/12

Com

mer

cial

O

pera

tion

19 O

ct 2

009

GT1

1/12

End

of W

arra

nty

19 O

ct 2

011

GT1

1 1s

t Maj

or O

verh

aul

12 y

ears

tim

e ba

sed

GT1

2 1s

t Maj

or O

verh

aul

12 y

ears

tim

e ba

sed

GT1

1 1s

t Maj

or O

verh

aul

12 y

ears

tim

e ba

sed

GT1

1/12

1st

Min

or

Insp

ectio

n G

T12

End

of W

arra

nty

Insp

ectio

n 29

-31A

ug 2

011

GT1

1 En

d of

War

rant

y In

spec

tion

1-2

Sept

201

1

ERM

GT12 Geno 2nd Intermediate Inspection

ERM

GT12 Geno 2nd Short Inspection

ERM

GT12 Geno Main Inspection - 12 yrs time based

ERM

GT12 Geno Intermediate Inspection

ERM

GT12 Geno Initial Inspection - 6 yrs time based

ERM

GT12 Geno 1st Short Inspection

ERM

GT12 5th Minor Inspection

ERM


ERM

GT12 Major Inspection - 12 yrs time based

ERM

GT12 3rd Minor Inspection

ERM

GT12 2nd Minor Inspection - 250 starts based

ERM

GT12 1st Minor Inspection - Starts based

ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM

GT11 Geno Intermediate Inspection

ERM

GT11 Geno Initial Inspection - 6 yrs time based

ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM

GT11 2nd Minor Inspection - 250 starts based

ERM


ERM


Kho


Kho

GT12 Geno Initial / 1st Intermediate Inspection - 6 yrs time based

ERM

GT12 2nd Minor Inspection

Kho


Kho

GT12 1st Minor Inspection

ERM


kchuan


kchuan

GT11 Geno Initial / 1st Intermediate Inspection - 6 yrs time based

ERM

GT11 2nd Minor Inspection

kchuan


kchuan

GT11 1st Minor Inspection

ERM

GT12 Geno 3rd Short Inspection

Kho


ERM


ERM

GT12 Geno Initial Inspection

ERM


ERM


Kho


ERM


ERM

GT12 2nd Minor Inspection - Starts based

ERM


ERM


kchuan


ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM


kchuan


ERM


ERM

GT11 2nd Minor Inspection - Starrts based

ERM


Kho


Kho

GT12 Geno Main Inspection - 12 years time based

Kho


ERM


ERM


Kho


Kho

GT12 Major Inspection - 12 years time based

Kho


ERM

GT12 2nd Minor Inspection - Starts based

ERM


kchuan


kchuan

GT11 Geno Main Inspection - 12 years time based

kchuan


ERM


ERM


kchuan


kchuan

GT11 Major Inspection - 12 years time based

kchuan


ERM

GT11 2nd Minor Inspection - Starrts based

ERM


31-O

ct-2

8

30-N

ov-2

8

31-D

ec-2

8

31-J

an-2

9

28-F

eb-2

9

31-M

ar-2

9

30-A

pr-2

9

31-M

ay-2

9

30-J

un-2

9

31-J

ul-2

9

31-A

ug-2

9

30-S

ep-2

9

31-O

ct-2

9

30-N

ov-2

9

31-D

ec-2

9

31-J

an-3

0

28-F

eb-3

0

31-M

ar-3

0

5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 51270 1276 1282 1288 1294 1300 1305 1311 1317 1323 1329 1335 1340 1346 1352 1358 1364 137037382 37561 37739 37917 38096 38274 38452 38631 38809 38987 39166 39344 39522 39701 39879 40057 40236 4041437750 37931 38111 38291 38472 38652 38832 39013 39193 39373 39554 39734 39914 40095 40275 40455 40636 40816

1260 1266 1272 1278 1284 1290 1295 1301 1307 1313 1319 1325 1330 1336 1342 1348 1354 136036940 37119 37297 37475 37654 37832 38010 38189 38367 38545 38724 38902 39080 39259 39437 39615 39794 3997237308 37489 37669 37849 38030 38210 38390 38571 38751 38931 39112 39292 39472 39653 39833 40013 40194 40374

31-O

ct-2

8

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

9

28-F

eb-2

9

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

9

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

9

31-J

ul-2

9

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

9

31-O

ct-2

9

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-3

0

28-F

eb-3

0

####

####

#

7 7 7 7 7 7 7 78 8 8 8 8 8 8 9 10 11

1175 1188 1201 1214 1227 1240 1240 1240 1240 1240 1240 1240 1240 1253 1266 1279 1292 130529827 30164 30500 30837 31174 31511 31511 31511 31511 31511 31511 31511 31511 31847 32184 32521 32858 3319439739 40102 40465 40828 41190 41553 41626 41699 41772 41845 41918 41991 42064 42427 42790 43153 43516 43878

1165 1178 1191 1204 1217 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1243 1256 1269 1282 129529563 29900 30237 30573 30910 31247 31247 31247 31247 31247 31247 31247 31247 31584 31920 32257 32594 3293139404 39767 40130 40493 40856 41219 41292 41365 41438 41511 41584 41657 41730 42092 42455 42818 43181 43544

31-O

ct-2

8

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

8

31-J

an-2

9

28-F

eb-2

9

####

####

##

30-A

pr-2

9

####

####

##

30-J

un-2

9

31-J

ul-2

9

31-A

ug-2

9

30-S

ep-2

9

31-O

ct-2

9

####

####

##

31-D

ec-2

9

31-J

an-3

0

28-F

eb-3

0

####

####

##

7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 710 10 10

9 9 9 9 9 9362 362 363 366 369 372 373 373 373 373 373 373 373 373 258 261 264 267

6549 6549 6549 6886 7223 7559 7559 7559 7559 7559 7559 7559 7559 7559 7559 7896 8233 857024894 24967 25040 25403 25766 26129 26202 26275 26348 26421 26494 26567 26640 26713 26786 27148 27511 27874

352 352 353 356 359 362 363 363 363 363 363 363 363 363 258 261 264 2676107 6107 6119 6155 6191 6227 6239 6239 6239 6239 6239 6239 6239 6239 6239 6275 6311 6347

24525 24598 24742 24922 25103 25284 25427 25500 25573 25646 25719 25792 25865 25938 26011 26192 26373 26553

31-O

ct-2

8

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-2

9

28-F

eb-2

9

####

####

#

30-A

pr-2

9

####

####

#

30-J

un-2

9

31-J

ul-2

9

####

####

#

30-S

ep-2

9

31-O

ct-2

9

####

####

#

####

####

#

31-J

an-3

0

28-F

eb-3

0

####

####

#

7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 711 11 11 11 11 11

1262 1283 1305 1327 1327 1327 1327 1327 1327 1327 1327 1327 1327 1348 1370 1392 1392 139244165 44693 45221 45749 46277 46805 46805 46805 46805 46805 46805 46805 46805 47333 47861 48389 48917 4944552513 53046 53580 54113 54646 55179 55252 55325 55398 55471 55544 55617 55690 56223 56756 57290 57823 58356

1165 1186 1208 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1230 1252 1273 1295 1295 129543723 44251 44779 45307 45835 46363 46363 46363 46363 46363 46363 46363 46363 46891 47419 47947 48475 4900352071 52604 53138 53671 54204 54737 54810 54883 54956 55029 55102 55175 55248 55781 56314 56848 57381 57914

ERM

GT12 1st Geno Intermediate Inspection

ERM


ERM

GT11 Geno 1st Intermediate Inspection

ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM


ERM


GT Inspection Plan

Inspection IntervalsMinor Inspection 8,000 EOHMajor Inpection 41,000 EOHLife Time Extention Inspection 123,000 EOH

Operating Regime ( highlighted most likely one)

1.) Cycling Plant (daily start stop through week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10OH/ day 12Day/week 7Monthly EOH 719Yearly EOH 8630

2.) Cycling Plant (daily start stop through business week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10OH/ day 12Day/week 5Monthly EOH 528Yearly EOH 6335

3.) Cycling Plant (no starts, operation minimum load to baseload)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 25Start Penalty factor 10OH/ day 24Day/week 7Monthly EOH 755Yearly EOH 9060

4.) Cycling Plant (weekly start stop, operation through business week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 25Start Penalty factor 10OH/ day 24Day/week 5Monthly EOH 590Yearly EOH 7078

5.) Cycling Plant (starts per year) 70Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10Estimated running hours per start 12OH/ mth 70Starts/mth 5.83Monthly EOH 178Yearly EOH 2140

6.) Cycling Plant (starts per year) 140Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10Estimated running hours per start 12OH/ mth 140Starts/mth 11.67Monthly EOH 307Yearly EOH 3680

7.) Cycling Plant (no starts)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 0Start Penalty factor 10Estimated running hours per start 0OH/ mth 0Starts/mth 0.00Monthly EOH 0Yearly EOH 0

8.) Cycling Plant (3 daily start stop through business week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10OH/ day 12Day/week 3Starts/mth 13.04Monthly EOH 337Yearly EOH 4041

9.) Cycling Plant (3 starts per month)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10OH/ start 12Starts/mth 3Monthly EOH 36Yearly EOH (over 3 summer months) 108

10.) Cycling Plant (1 start per month)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10OH/ start 12Starts/mth 1Monthly EOH 12.00Yearly EOH (over 2 summer shoulder months) 24

11.) Cycling Plant (5 daily start stop through business week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor 10OH/ day 12Day/week 5Starts/mth 21.73Monthly EOH 528Yearly EOH 6335

GT Geno Inspection Plan

Inspection IntervalsInitial Inspection Overhaul between 10000 20000 EOHShort Inspection Overhaul between 8000 12000 EOH upto 3 yearsIntermediate Inspection Overhaul between 16000 24000 EOH upto 6 yearsMain Inspection Overhaul between 40000 60000 EOH upto 12 years

Operating Regime ( highlighted most likely one)

1.) Cycling Plant (daily start stop through week) EOH Tequiv = K1.T1 + K2.T2 + n. T3

Start Penelty factor (T3) 10 Tequiv = Equivalent Operating Hours

OH/ day (T1) 12 K1 0.8 (weighting factor for stress impact during normal operation)TG / day (T2) 12 T1 xx (operating time in hours)

Day/week 7 K2 0.1 (weighing factor for turning gear operation)

Monthly EOH 633 T2 xx (turning gear operating time in hours)Yearly EOH 7592 n xx (number of starts)

T3 10 (weighted time equivalent in hours per start)2.) Cycling Plant (daily start stop through business week)

Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ day (T1) 12TG / week (T2) 108Day/week 5Monthly EOH 473Yearly EOH 5673

3.) Cycling Plant (no starts, operation minimum load to baseload)Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ day (T1) 24TG / week (T2) 0Day/week 7Monthly EOH 584Yearly EOH 7008

4.) Cycling Plant (weekly start stop, operation through business week)Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ day (T1) 24TG /week (T2) 48Day/week 5Monthly EOH 481Yearly EOH 6778

5.) Cycling Plant (starts per year) 70Start Penalty factor (T3) 10Estimated running hours per start 12OH/ mth (T1) 70TG / mth (T2) 660Starts/mth 5.83Monthly EOH 180Yearly EOH 2164

6.) Cycling Plant (starts per year) 140Start Penalty factor (T3) 10Estimated running hours per start 12OH/ mth (T1) 140TG / mth (T2) 590Starts/mth 11.67Monthly EOH 288Yearly EOH 3452

7.) Cycling Plant (no starts) 0Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 0Start Penalty factor (T3) 10Estimated running hours per start 0OH/ mth (T1) 0TG/ mth (T2) 730Starts/mth 0.00Monthly EOH 73Yearly EOH 876

8.) Cycling Plant (3 daily start stop through business week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ day (T1) 12TG/ week (T2) 132Day/week 3Monthly EOH 363Yearly EOH 4354

9.) Cycling Plant (3 starts per month)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ start (T1) 12OH/mth 36TG/ mth (T2) 718Monthly EOH 181Yearly EOH (over 3 summer months) 542

10.) Cycling Plant (1 start per month)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ start (T1) 12OH/mth 12TG/ mth (T2) 742Monthly EOH 144Yearly EOH (over 2 summer shoulder months) 431

11.) Cycling Plant (5 daily start stop through business week)Dynamic op. hours (TRIP/LR/Fast Ramp) monthly 50Start Penalty factor (T3) 10OH/ day (T1) 12TG/ week (T2) 132Day/week 5Monthly EOH 533Yearly EOH 6398

SEMP Annual Compliance Report – NEWGEN NEERABUP ... · • An internal compliance audit of the...

Documents

Transcript of SEMP Annual Compliance Report – NEWGEN NEERABUP ... · • An internal compliance audit of the...