Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

24
Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. An Aspect of the Shugen-Dô ("Mountain Asceticism") Sect Ichiro Hori History of Religions, Vol. 1, No. 2. (Winter, 1962), pp. 222-242. Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0018-2710%28196224%291%3A2%3C222%3ASBIJAA%3E2.0.CO%3B2-O History of Religions is currently published by The University of Chicago Press. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/about/terms.html. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/journals/ucpress.html. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. The JSTOR Archive is a trusted digital repository providing for long-term preservation and access to leading academic journals and scholarly literature from around the world. The Archive is supported by libraries, scholarly societies, publishers, and foundations. It is an initiative of JSTOR, a not-for-profit organization with a mission to help the scholarly community take advantage of advances in technology. For more information regarding JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. http://www.jstor.org Fri Jan 18 00:05:29 2008
  • date post

    28-Jul-2015
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    237
  • download

    3

Transcript of Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Page 1: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan An Aspect of the Shugen-Docirc (MountainAsceticism) Sect

Ichiro Hori

History of Religions Vol 1 No 2 (Winter 1962) pp 222-242

Stable URL

httplinksjstororgsicisici=0018-2710281962242913A23C2223ASBIJAA3E20CO3B2-O

History of Religions is currently published by The University of Chicago Press

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTORs Terms and Conditions of Use available athttpwwwjstororgabouttermshtml JSTORs Terms and Conditions of Use provides in part that unless you have obtainedprior permission you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles and you may use content inthe JSTOR archive only for your personal non-commercial use

Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work Publisher contact information may be obtained athttpwwwjstororgjournalsucpresshtml

Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printedpage of such transmission

The JSTOR Archive is a trusted digital repository providing for long-term preservation and access to leading academicjournals and scholarly literature from around the world The Archive is supported by libraries scholarly societies publishersand foundations It is an initiative of JSTOR a not-for-profit organization with a mission to help the scholarly community takeadvantage of advances in technology For more information regarding JSTOR please contact supportjstororg

httpwwwjstororgFri Jan 18 000529 2008

Ichiro Horn S E L F - M U M M I F I E D

B U D D H A S I N J A P A N 1

AN A S P E C T O F T H E

S H U G E N - D O ( M O U N T A I N

A S C E T I C I S M ) S E C T

INTRODUCTION

I should like in this paper to report on the recent discovery of self- mummified Buddhas in the Shugend6 sect of the Shingon school and to discuss in more general terms the characteristics of Japanese Shu- gen-db mysticism together with its theoretical institutional and re- ligious background

1 This paper is based upon field research undertaken by the writer on a rather unusual religious phenomenon in Japan I t is our hope to pursue research on this subject to find relations with other similar phenomena as eg in Tibet Never- theless it seemed appropriate a t this time to present the essence of the writers research as it has developed thus far

Research and the wnting of this paper were facilitated by the Investigating Committee for Mummies in Japan sponsored by the Mainichi Press We wish to thank Professor Joseph M Kitagawa Professor Mircea Eliade and other col- leagues a t the University of Chicago for their encouragement We are grateful to Professor Kitagawa and Mr Charles 5J White for reading the final draft and for making a number of helpful suggestions

We should also like to recommend a recent book Nippon no Miira (Mummies in Japan) written by Professor Kosei Ando of Waseda University head of our investigating committee This book published by the Mainichi Prcss in 1961 will be helpful in understanding more clearly and generally the curious custom of religious mummification in the Far East including Japan China and Tibet

222

Last year self-mummified Buddhas were discovered by chance a t five Shugen-dB temples in Yamagata Prefecture These Buddhas have since become the scene of research by our special investigating com- mittee This was a miraculous discovery for the only other known example of mummification in Japan was that of four members of the Fujiwara family the ruling family of northeast HonshQ in the twelfth century Because of Japans exceedingly humid climate furthermore mummification is an extremely inappropriate way of disposing of the dead Thus although i t was known by many historians of religion and folklorists that legends surrounding the gyhin-zuka mounds in Japan tell that a t such places a certain gydnin had been buried alive i t was not known whether these legends contained a kernel of histori- cal truth The six newly discovered mummified Buddhas however were found in their own special hall a t an altar within a temple and were worshiped by a small group of believers

As a result of the field studies which have been made on these newly found mummies several important and hitherto unknown facts con- cerning the history of the Shugen-dB sect have been made clear Im- portant among these are the characteristics of the gybnin a certain type of ascetic in the Yudono sect (a subdivision of the Shugen-dB) who was quite different from ascetics in the other sects of the Shugen- dB as well as from those in the same sect such as the shugen-sha the head of a seminary on or around the sacred mountain or the sendatsu a guide or conductor The status and functions of each of these types will be explained in detail in the following sections of this paper

I BRIEF HISTORY OF THE S I X MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

Before entering upon a discussion of the specific characteristic of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular those of the Yudono I would like to describe briefly the history of the six newly discovered Buddhas

1 HonmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t HonmyB-ji in Higashi-Iwamo- to of Asahi-mura) Born of the Togashi family a retainer of the feudal lord Sakai a t Tsuruoka Honmygkai became a gyhin in the Yudono sect in order to pray for his lords recovery from a serious illness I-Iav- ing left his wife and children behind he entered the Churen-ji Semi- nary a member of one of the four main groups of seminaries in the Yudono sect and gained a knowledge of some of their primary doc- trines prayers and rules of discipline After this he led a secluded life in a special place named Sennin-zawa (literally Swamp of Wizards) between Churen-ji and the Shrine of Mount Yudono holy of holies for the Yudono sect and there practiced a severely ascetic regimen for several years I t is said that after 1673 he began abstention from

223

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in J a p a n

cereals (mokujiki-gy6) for about eight years sustaining his life by the consumption of only the bark of pine trees His lord Sakai having become his supporter because of the virtue and superhuman powers of Honmy6-kai instituted a drive to raise a temple for him Mean- while Honmy6-kai had determined to become a Buddha in his very own body as his body was (sokushin-jdbutsu) and in 1683 he entered into a stone chamber under the ground and died a peaceful death while chanting a prayer to Amitabha Buddha (Amida-butsu) His corpse was exhumed from the chamber immediately after his death made to assume a sitting posture with crossed legs like a Buddha and dried up with a charcoal fire and incense fumes After that the corpse was buried again in the underground chamber for about three years When it was again recovered the corpse had become completely mummified I t was enshrined by the followers and disciples of Hon- my8-kai as an object of worship in a special hall in HonmyB-ji called soku-butsu-d6 (hall dedicated to the person who became a Buddha in his very own body) HonmyB-kais lifelong desire was to free his people from suffering and illness Even today he is worshiped as a Buddha and supplicated by the peasants near a temple for the relief of eye diseases

2 ChQ-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Kaikd-ji in Sakata City) Born of the Togashi family ChQ-kai was a nephew of HonmyB-kai ShBnin He deeply admired his uncles virtues and superhuman power and he wished to model himself upon his deeds He adopted a severe asceti- cism a t Churen-ji Seminary as well as a t Sennin-zawa on Mount Yu- dono one feature of which was the practice of eating only chestnuts or torreya nuts for a period of a thousand days Through his own efforts he then built a temple named KaikB-ji in Sakata City in which his mummy is now contained Determined to become a mummified Buddha as his uncle had ChQ-kai Shdnin entered into a wooden coffin in 1755 a t the age of fifty-eight and was buried alive The body of ChQ-kai was dug up three years later and following the same meth- od previously outlined was dried through the use of candle fires and incense fumes a t the main temple of Churen-ji His mummy was en- shrined a t the soku-butsu-d8 hall a t KaikB-ji

3 Shinnyo-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Dainichi-bB in ampmi-mura) A member of the Shindo family and a farmer in Higashi-mura near Tsuruoka City formerly the feudal capital of Sakai Fief Shinnyo-kai killed a samurai (warrior) accidentally following a false accusation He escaped to Dainichi-bd Seminary a member of another important seminary group of the Yudono sect on the west side of Mount Yudono The chief abbot of Dainichi-b6 succeeded in sheltering him from the

224

FIG 1-Mummified Buddha of Chfikai Shbnin dressed in the isse-gybnins official costume a t KaikG-ji Temple in Sskata City Yamagata Prefecture

FIG 2-Isse-gydnin performing the agricultural rite called 0-saku-matsuri on February 18 a t KaikB-ji Temple in Sakata City The one a t left with a symbol and wearing a white robe and a special ascetic hood is falling into a trance in order to announce the divination

FIG 3-Isse-gybnin in a uniform for the religious austerities in the cold season with the special symbol named bonden and offertory box

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 2: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Ichiro Horn S E L F - M U M M I F I E D

B U D D H A S I N J A P A N 1

AN A S P E C T O F T H E

S H U G E N - D O ( M O U N T A I N

A S C E T I C I S M ) S E C T

INTRODUCTION

I should like in this paper to report on the recent discovery of self- mummified Buddhas in the Shugend6 sect of the Shingon school and to discuss in more general terms the characteristics of Japanese Shu- gen-db mysticism together with its theoretical institutional and re- ligious background

1 This paper is based upon field research undertaken by the writer on a rather unusual religious phenomenon in Japan I t is our hope to pursue research on this subject to find relations with other similar phenomena as eg in Tibet Never- theless it seemed appropriate a t this time to present the essence of the writers research as it has developed thus far

Research and the wnting of this paper were facilitated by the Investigating Committee for Mummies in Japan sponsored by the Mainichi Press We wish to thank Professor Joseph M Kitagawa Professor Mircea Eliade and other col- leagues a t the University of Chicago for their encouragement We are grateful to Professor Kitagawa and Mr Charles 5J White for reading the final draft and for making a number of helpful suggestions

We should also like to recommend a recent book Nippon no Miira (Mummies in Japan) written by Professor Kosei Ando of Waseda University head of our investigating committee This book published by the Mainichi Prcss in 1961 will be helpful in understanding more clearly and generally the curious custom of religious mummification in the Far East including Japan China and Tibet

222

Last year self-mummified Buddhas were discovered by chance a t five Shugen-dB temples in Yamagata Prefecture These Buddhas have since become the scene of research by our special investigating com- mittee This was a miraculous discovery for the only other known example of mummification in Japan was that of four members of the Fujiwara family the ruling family of northeast HonshQ in the twelfth century Because of Japans exceedingly humid climate furthermore mummification is an extremely inappropriate way of disposing of the dead Thus although i t was known by many historians of religion and folklorists that legends surrounding the gyhin-zuka mounds in Japan tell that a t such places a certain gydnin had been buried alive i t was not known whether these legends contained a kernel of histori- cal truth The six newly discovered mummified Buddhas however were found in their own special hall a t an altar within a temple and were worshiped by a small group of believers

As a result of the field studies which have been made on these newly found mummies several important and hitherto unknown facts con- cerning the history of the Shugen-dB sect have been made clear Im- portant among these are the characteristics of the gybnin a certain type of ascetic in the Yudono sect (a subdivision of the Shugen-dB) who was quite different from ascetics in the other sects of the Shugen- dB as well as from those in the same sect such as the shugen-sha the head of a seminary on or around the sacred mountain or the sendatsu a guide or conductor The status and functions of each of these types will be explained in detail in the following sections of this paper

I BRIEF HISTORY OF THE S I X MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

Before entering upon a discussion of the specific characteristic of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular those of the Yudono I would like to describe briefly the history of the six newly discovered Buddhas

1 HonmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t HonmyB-ji in Higashi-Iwamo- to of Asahi-mura) Born of the Togashi family a retainer of the feudal lord Sakai a t Tsuruoka Honmygkai became a gyhin in the Yudono sect in order to pray for his lords recovery from a serious illness I-Iav- ing left his wife and children behind he entered the Churen-ji Semi- nary a member of one of the four main groups of seminaries in the Yudono sect and gained a knowledge of some of their primary doc- trines prayers and rules of discipline After this he led a secluded life in a special place named Sennin-zawa (literally Swamp of Wizards) between Churen-ji and the Shrine of Mount Yudono holy of holies for the Yudono sect and there practiced a severely ascetic regimen for several years I t is said that after 1673 he began abstention from

223

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in J a p a n

cereals (mokujiki-gy6) for about eight years sustaining his life by the consumption of only the bark of pine trees His lord Sakai having become his supporter because of the virtue and superhuman powers of Honmy6-kai instituted a drive to raise a temple for him Mean- while Honmy6-kai had determined to become a Buddha in his very own body as his body was (sokushin-jdbutsu) and in 1683 he entered into a stone chamber under the ground and died a peaceful death while chanting a prayer to Amitabha Buddha (Amida-butsu) His corpse was exhumed from the chamber immediately after his death made to assume a sitting posture with crossed legs like a Buddha and dried up with a charcoal fire and incense fumes After that the corpse was buried again in the underground chamber for about three years When it was again recovered the corpse had become completely mummified I t was enshrined by the followers and disciples of Hon- my8-kai as an object of worship in a special hall in HonmyB-ji called soku-butsu-d6 (hall dedicated to the person who became a Buddha in his very own body) HonmyB-kais lifelong desire was to free his people from suffering and illness Even today he is worshiped as a Buddha and supplicated by the peasants near a temple for the relief of eye diseases

2 ChQ-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Kaikd-ji in Sakata City) Born of the Togashi family ChQ-kai was a nephew of HonmyB-kai ShBnin He deeply admired his uncles virtues and superhuman power and he wished to model himself upon his deeds He adopted a severe asceti- cism a t Churen-ji Seminary as well as a t Sennin-zawa on Mount Yu- dono one feature of which was the practice of eating only chestnuts or torreya nuts for a period of a thousand days Through his own efforts he then built a temple named KaikB-ji in Sakata City in which his mummy is now contained Determined to become a mummified Buddha as his uncle had ChQ-kai Shdnin entered into a wooden coffin in 1755 a t the age of fifty-eight and was buried alive The body of ChQ-kai was dug up three years later and following the same meth- od previously outlined was dried through the use of candle fires and incense fumes a t the main temple of Churen-ji His mummy was en- shrined a t the soku-butsu-d8 hall a t KaikB-ji

3 Shinnyo-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Dainichi-bB in ampmi-mura) A member of the Shindo family and a farmer in Higashi-mura near Tsuruoka City formerly the feudal capital of Sakai Fief Shinnyo-kai killed a samurai (warrior) accidentally following a false accusation He escaped to Dainichi-bd Seminary a member of another important seminary group of the Yudono sect on the west side of Mount Yudono The chief abbot of Dainichi-b6 succeeded in sheltering him from the

224

FIG 1-Mummified Buddha of Chfikai Shbnin dressed in the isse-gybnins official costume a t KaikG-ji Temple in Sskata City Yamagata Prefecture

FIG 2-Isse-gydnin performing the agricultural rite called 0-saku-matsuri on February 18 a t KaikB-ji Temple in Sakata City The one a t left with a symbol and wearing a white robe and a special ascetic hood is falling into a trance in order to announce the divination

FIG 3-Isse-gybnin in a uniform for the religious austerities in the cold season with the special symbol named bonden and offertory box

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 3: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Last year self-mummified Buddhas were discovered by chance a t five Shugen-dB temples in Yamagata Prefecture These Buddhas have since become the scene of research by our special investigating com- mittee This was a miraculous discovery for the only other known example of mummification in Japan was that of four members of the Fujiwara family the ruling family of northeast HonshQ in the twelfth century Because of Japans exceedingly humid climate furthermore mummification is an extremely inappropriate way of disposing of the dead Thus although i t was known by many historians of religion and folklorists that legends surrounding the gyhin-zuka mounds in Japan tell that a t such places a certain gydnin had been buried alive i t was not known whether these legends contained a kernel of histori- cal truth The six newly discovered mummified Buddhas however were found in their own special hall a t an altar within a temple and were worshiped by a small group of believers

As a result of the field studies which have been made on these newly found mummies several important and hitherto unknown facts con- cerning the history of the Shugen-dB sect have been made clear Im- portant among these are the characteristics of the gybnin a certain type of ascetic in the Yudono sect (a subdivision of the Shugen-dB) who was quite different from ascetics in the other sects of the Shugen- dB as well as from those in the same sect such as the shugen-sha the head of a seminary on or around the sacred mountain or the sendatsu a guide or conductor The status and functions of each of these types will be explained in detail in the following sections of this paper

I BRIEF HISTORY OF THE S I X MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

Before entering upon a discussion of the specific characteristic of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular those of the Yudono I would like to describe briefly the history of the six newly discovered Buddhas

1 HonmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t HonmyB-ji in Higashi-Iwamo- to of Asahi-mura) Born of the Togashi family a retainer of the feudal lord Sakai a t Tsuruoka Honmygkai became a gyhin in the Yudono sect in order to pray for his lords recovery from a serious illness I-Iav- ing left his wife and children behind he entered the Churen-ji Semi- nary a member of one of the four main groups of seminaries in the Yudono sect and gained a knowledge of some of their primary doc- trines prayers and rules of discipline After this he led a secluded life in a special place named Sennin-zawa (literally Swamp of Wizards) between Churen-ji and the Shrine of Mount Yudono holy of holies for the Yudono sect and there practiced a severely ascetic regimen for several years I t is said that after 1673 he began abstention from

223

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in J a p a n

cereals (mokujiki-gy6) for about eight years sustaining his life by the consumption of only the bark of pine trees His lord Sakai having become his supporter because of the virtue and superhuman powers of Honmy6-kai instituted a drive to raise a temple for him Mean- while Honmy6-kai had determined to become a Buddha in his very own body as his body was (sokushin-jdbutsu) and in 1683 he entered into a stone chamber under the ground and died a peaceful death while chanting a prayer to Amitabha Buddha (Amida-butsu) His corpse was exhumed from the chamber immediately after his death made to assume a sitting posture with crossed legs like a Buddha and dried up with a charcoal fire and incense fumes After that the corpse was buried again in the underground chamber for about three years When it was again recovered the corpse had become completely mummified I t was enshrined by the followers and disciples of Hon- my8-kai as an object of worship in a special hall in HonmyB-ji called soku-butsu-d6 (hall dedicated to the person who became a Buddha in his very own body) HonmyB-kais lifelong desire was to free his people from suffering and illness Even today he is worshiped as a Buddha and supplicated by the peasants near a temple for the relief of eye diseases

2 ChQ-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Kaikd-ji in Sakata City) Born of the Togashi family ChQ-kai was a nephew of HonmyB-kai ShBnin He deeply admired his uncles virtues and superhuman power and he wished to model himself upon his deeds He adopted a severe asceti- cism a t Churen-ji Seminary as well as a t Sennin-zawa on Mount Yu- dono one feature of which was the practice of eating only chestnuts or torreya nuts for a period of a thousand days Through his own efforts he then built a temple named KaikB-ji in Sakata City in which his mummy is now contained Determined to become a mummified Buddha as his uncle had ChQ-kai Shdnin entered into a wooden coffin in 1755 a t the age of fifty-eight and was buried alive The body of ChQ-kai was dug up three years later and following the same meth- od previously outlined was dried through the use of candle fires and incense fumes a t the main temple of Churen-ji His mummy was en- shrined a t the soku-butsu-d8 hall a t KaikB-ji

3 Shinnyo-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Dainichi-bB in ampmi-mura) A member of the Shindo family and a farmer in Higashi-mura near Tsuruoka City formerly the feudal capital of Sakai Fief Shinnyo-kai killed a samurai (warrior) accidentally following a false accusation He escaped to Dainichi-bd Seminary a member of another important seminary group of the Yudono sect on the west side of Mount Yudono The chief abbot of Dainichi-b6 succeeded in sheltering him from the

224

FIG 1-Mummified Buddha of Chfikai Shbnin dressed in the isse-gybnins official costume a t KaikG-ji Temple in Sskata City Yamagata Prefecture

FIG 2-Isse-gydnin performing the agricultural rite called 0-saku-matsuri on February 18 a t KaikB-ji Temple in Sakata City The one a t left with a symbol and wearing a white robe and a special ascetic hood is falling into a trance in order to announce the divination

FIG 3-Isse-gybnin in a uniform for the religious austerities in the cold season with the special symbol named bonden and offertory box

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 4: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in J a p a n

cereals (mokujiki-gy6) for about eight years sustaining his life by the consumption of only the bark of pine trees His lord Sakai having become his supporter because of the virtue and superhuman powers of Honmy6-kai instituted a drive to raise a temple for him Mean- while Honmy6-kai had determined to become a Buddha in his very own body as his body was (sokushin-jdbutsu) and in 1683 he entered into a stone chamber under the ground and died a peaceful death while chanting a prayer to Amitabha Buddha (Amida-butsu) His corpse was exhumed from the chamber immediately after his death made to assume a sitting posture with crossed legs like a Buddha and dried up with a charcoal fire and incense fumes After that the corpse was buried again in the underground chamber for about three years When it was again recovered the corpse had become completely mummified I t was enshrined by the followers and disciples of Hon- my8-kai as an object of worship in a special hall in HonmyB-ji called soku-butsu-d6 (hall dedicated to the person who became a Buddha in his very own body) HonmyB-kais lifelong desire was to free his people from suffering and illness Even today he is worshiped as a Buddha and supplicated by the peasants near a temple for the relief of eye diseases

2 ChQ-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Kaikd-ji in Sakata City) Born of the Togashi family ChQ-kai was a nephew of HonmyB-kai ShBnin He deeply admired his uncles virtues and superhuman power and he wished to model himself upon his deeds He adopted a severe asceti- cism a t Churen-ji Seminary as well as a t Sennin-zawa on Mount Yu- dono one feature of which was the practice of eating only chestnuts or torreya nuts for a period of a thousand days Through his own efforts he then built a temple named KaikB-ji in Sakata City in which his mummy is now contained Determined to become a mummified Buddha as his uncle had ChQ-kai Shdnin entered into a wooden coffin in 1755 a t the age of fifty-eight and was buried alive The body of ChQ-kai was dug up three years later and following the same meth- od previously outlined was dried through the use of candle fires and incense fumes a t the main temple of Churen-ji His mummy was en- shrined a t the soku-butsu-d8 hall a t KaikB-ji

3 Shinnyo-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Dainichi-bB in ampmi-mura) A member of the Shindo family and a farmer in Higashi-mura near Tsuruoka City formerly the feudal capital of Sakai Fief Shinnyo-kai killed a samurai (warrior) accidentally following a false accusation He escaped to Dainichi-bd Seminary a member of another important seminary group of the Yudono sect on the west side of Mount Yudono The chief abbot of Dainichi-b6 succeeded in sheltering him from the

224

FIG 1-Mummified Buddha of Chfikai Shbnin dressed in the isse-gybnins official costume a t KaikG-ji Temple in Sskata City Yamagata Prefecture

FIG 2-Isse-gydnin performing the agricultural rite called 0-saku-matsuri on February 18 a t KaikB-ji Temple in Sakata City The one a t left with a symbol and wearing a white robe and a special ascetic hood is falling into a trance in order to announce the divination

FIG 3-Isse-gybnin in a uniform for the religious austerities in the cold season with the special symbol named bonden and offertory box

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 5: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

FIG 1-Mummified Buddha of Chfikai Shbnin dressed in the isse-gybnins official costume a t KaikG-ji Temple in Sskata City Yamagata Prefecture

FIG 2-Isse-gydnin performing the agricultural rite called 0-saku-matsuri on February 18 a t KaikB-ji Temple in Sakata City The one a t left with a symbol and wearing a white robe and a special ascetic hood is falling into a trance in order to announce the divination

FIG 3-Isse-gybnin in a uniform for the religious austerities in the cold season with the special symbol named bonden and offertory box

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 6: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

FIG 2-Isse-gydnin performing the agricultural rite called 0-saku-matsuri on February 18 a t KaikB-ji Temple in Sakata City The one a t left with a symbol and wearing a white robe and a special ascetic hood is falling into a trance in order to announce the divination

FIG 3-Isse-gybnin in a uniform for the religious austerities in the cold season with the special symbol named bonden and offertory box

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 7: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

pursuing officials of the fiefs government for even a t that time some Buddhist temples were protected by the principle of extraterritoriali- ty Both for the salvation of the deceased samurais soul and in order to become a mummified Buddha Shinnyo-kai became an ascetic gydnin of the Yudono sect and practiced a severe discipline Leading a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa he took up the exercise of abstaining from cereals for about three thousand days Finally in 1783 he dug a pit on the hilltop near Dainichi-bB and stepping into a wooden coffin with a breathing hole made of bamboo ordered that he be lowered into it He died a t the age of ninety-six on the fourteenth day of the eighth month chanting the name of Amitabha Buddha and ringing a bell

4 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (enshrined at Churen-ji) Born in 1768 of a farmers family named Sunada in a suburb of lsuruoka City Tetsu- mon-kai ShBnin carried timber and gravel on the riverside One day when the banks of the river were about to break because of the long heavy rains Tetsumon-kai saw that two samurai in charge of the flood control were drunk and he charged them with negligence They struck angrily a t him and Tetsumon-kai killed them with a fire hook He then escaped to Churen-ji where he was sheltered by the chief abbot and became a disciple a t the seminary performing the austeri- ties of the Shugen-dB He also engaged in public works and in medical care with the use of herbs He left his mark not only in northeast Honshd but also in the Kanto area centering around Yedo (Tokyo) Monuments of his virtuous deeds are to be found in many places even in Kiigata and Chiba prefectures I t is said that Tetsumon-kai dedicated his eyes to the deity of Mount Yudono in order to save the people from the sufferings of eye disease Consequently the Tet- sumon-kai Buddha is worshiped and prayed to as a guardian of the eyes In 1829 when he was sixty-one years old Tetsumon-kai entered nirvdna after having performed a fast a t the main hall of Churen-ji according to the precedent of KBbB Daishi (KQkai the founder of the Shingon school in Japan 774-835 AD) Afterward his corpse be- came a mummy that is a Buddha in his very own body and was en- shrined a t a special sanctuary in Churen-ji Temple

5 EnmyB-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t KaikB-ji in Sakata City) Born in a suburb of Tsuruoka City as a farmers son EnmyB-kai was con- verted in his youth to the Haguro sect of Shugen-dB a rival of the Yudono sect centering around the sacred mountains of Gassan Yu- dono and Haguro He became an ascetic within this group but was afterward strongly influenced by Tetsumon-kais virtuous deeds and became his disciple a convert to the Yudono sect As the heir of his master letsumon-kai EnmyB-kai succeeded the chief abbot of KaikB-

225

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 8: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

ji in Sakata He then practiced abstaining from cereals for several years and he entered nirvcina alive in 1822 preceding his master He was fifty-three years old a t the time His corpse became a mummy although the place and manner of his death are not yet clear

6 letsuryu-kai ShBnin (enshrined a t Nangaku-ji in Tsuruoka City) Born in Akita Prefecture Tetsuryu-kai became an ascetic of the Yudono sect following Tetsumon-kai Until 1862 he engaged in abstaining from cereals thereafter he became a chief abbot of Nan- gaku-ji In 1868 (according to another report 1881) he was voluntarily buried alive in the precincts of Nangaku-ji Unfortunately his corpse had not yet mummified naturally when i t was dug up His disciples extracted the viscera from the corpse and carried the corpse to Churen- ji where i t was dried I t has been observed that the body cavity of this mummy has been filled with lime powder up to its neck This is the newest mummified Buddha and is the only instance in which mummification was due to an operation

Two more examples should be added here from the Tokugawa pe- riod One is KBchi HBin who was enshrined a t SaishB-ji in Teradomari- machi and the other is Jun-kai ShBnin who was enshrined a t Gyoku- sen-ji in Tsugawa-mura both in Niigata Prefecture KBchi HBin1s mummy remains in its original resting place and was investigated by our committee members I t is said that he was from Chiba Prefecture was trained in the Shingon school a t Mount KBya and then came back to his native land to reside in a temple Later in his life he made a preaching tour and he settled down finally a t a small hermitage near SaishB-ji where he died in 1363 The details of this biography are now obscure but as far as we know he is the oldest mummified Buddha Jun-kai was also a mountain ascetic belonging to the Yudono sect and he died around 1630 a t Gyokusen-ji

11 COMMON CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MUMMIFIED BUDDHAS

The relationship between the two mummies previously discovered and the six new mummified Buddhas cannot be traced historically How- ever looking over the brief biographies of the eight mummified Bud- dhas we might point out certain common characteristics

1 First of all I would like to suggest that all eight of these mummi- fied persons were during their lifetime very rigorous ascetics of the type peculiar to the Yudono sect and known as isse-gydnin

2 They all practiced abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) The food staple was buckwheat flour while the subsidiary foods were pine bark chestnuts torreya nuts grass roots and so forth Abstention lasted from one thousand to several thousand days and it was under-

226

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 9: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

gone while in seclusion a t Sennin-zawa a spot reserved exclusively for the ascetic practices of the isse-gydnin Nearby was the holy of holies on Mount Yudono the Yudono Shrine and here the isse-gyBnin came to worship three times a day after cold-water ablutions The deity of the Yudono Shrine is believed to have been an incarnation of the Dainichi-nyorai (Mahcivairocanasatathcigata) symbolically repre- sented as a hot spring emerging from a huge round rock

3 All of them resolved to become mummified Buddhas because they believed in the doctrine peculiar to the Shingon school of the sokushin-~Bbutsu (becoming a Buddha in his very own body) The lat- ter is one of the fundamental points of difference between the Shingon and the other Buddhist schools such as the lendai (lien-tai) the JBdo (Pure Land) the Nichiren the Zen (dycina) and others

The pioneer Great Master of the isse-gy6nin ascetics KQkai (KBbB Daishi) was the model of their religious faith and practice especially in the matter of self-mummification for it was believed that he became a Buddha in his very own body in a stone cave on top of Mount KBya and that he is still awaiting there the advent of Maitreya Buddha who is supposed to appear 5670000000 years after the death of Sakya- muni I t was thought that he spent his time in meditation although periodically he would wander all over Japan to save people from suffer- ing and misfortune Once a year the ceremony for changing KBbB Daishis robe took place in accordance with this legend

The beginning of the legend of KQkais deeds is to be found in a book supposedly compiled in about the twelfth century the Konjaku- monogatari (Stories Ancient and Modern) Here we are told that Kangen Sojo (d 925) who had entered his stone cave to worship the still-living Great Master (K6bB Daishi) changed Daishis robe ton- sured his hair and repaired his rosary which had been scattered about The same legend is found in the Heike-monogatari (Historic Romance of the Taira Family) compiled supposedly in about the thirteenth or fourteenth century and in other books From this we may surmise that the legend was generally believed to be factual in substance

The legend which inspired the isse-gydnin to abstain from cereals in order to become a mummified Buddha is that of the KQkais Last Injunction (Yui-gB) in which KQkai looking back upon his past writes that his chief pleasure was in the practice of meditation and that he disliked taking cereals as his food from the twelfth day of the eleventh month of the ninth year of TenchB (832 AD) Though this Last Injunction is of dubious authenticity it seems a t least to testify that abstention from cereals was an important training exercise for Shingon ascetics both during and after the Heian Period

227

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 10: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

4 I believe that the reason why seven of the eight mummified Buddhas (ie with the exception of KBchi HBin) had the suffix kai appended to their Buddhist names is that their Great Master was named in this way KB-kai Yet why was the special Buddhist name with the kai suffix conferred only upon the isse-gybnin group in the Yudono sect In order to understand this we must first clarify the history of the Shugen-dB sect and in particular that of its subdivi- sion the Yudono sect together with the structure of the latter dur- ing the Tokugawa Period

III SHORT OF INHISTORY THE SHUGEN-DC JAPAN

As I have already pointed out in my paper in Numen (Vol V Fasc 2-3 [1958]) the Shugen-dB seems to have originated in an ancient mountain worship and in the belief in magicians and shamans in sacred mountains The sacred mountain was recognized as the resi- dence of a deity or deities and of spirits of the dead who bestowed rain and fertility upon the peasants of the plain at the foot of the mountain

The legendary founder of the Shugen-dB was the famous magician and ascetic saint named En-no-ShBkaku (or E-no-Ozunu) who is supposed to have lived as an updsaka (Jap ubasoku) on Mount Kat- suragi and to have been the chief of a priestly family which from generation to generation served the deity of the mountain Hitokoto- nushi (literally Lord of One Word) This deity was well known as an oracle because his name as was derived from the declaration at his first advent that is the Ruler of the Word This legend should be understood to mean therefore that the En or E family had a special hereditary gift for speaking oracles and that the Shugen-dB in its origin had a close relation with shamanism

During the Heian Period (784-1185) MantrayAna Buddhism was widely favored among the people I t had been introduced by SaichB (DengyB Daishi 767-822) the founder of the Tendai school as well as by KBkai (KBbB Daishi) of the Shingon school The MantrayAna element within the Tendai was called the Tai-mitsu (Tendai Mikkyd) while the Shingon MikkyB was called TB-mitsu (an esoteric doctrine based upon the training program at TB-ji in Kyoto a center of the Shingon school) In addition to Mantrayha Buddhism Chinese Yin- yang magic and divination (Onmyd-db) and Taoistic thought en-joyed a great vogue particularly among the upper classes Thus the heterogeneous formulas of ancient shamanism were revived and be- came strongly influenced by and involved with Mantrayha and Yin-yang theory and practice

228

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 11: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

A most significant phenomenon in this process of syncretization was the belief in the gory6 a belief which rapidly swept over all of Japan and was prevalent especially among the royalty and the upper classes The gory6 (whom I have described in my paper mentioned above) was a malevolent or angry spirit of a dead nobleman who had perished in a political tragedy or intrigue Unusual events such as a violent political change civil war epidemic famine drought earth- quake thunderbolt typhoon or any other extraordinary phenomenon in heaven or earth and events involving pain disease or death-all these were believed to be the revenge and punishment of the gory6 To protect themselves against the goryd people employed the services of Buddhist ascetics Mantrayha magicians and Yin-yang priests paid great respect especially to the ascetics trained in the mountains (yama-no-kenza) The latter by virtue of their religious austerities were believed to possess superhuman magical powers and were called either yama-bushi (an ascetic who lies down in the mountain) or shugen-sha (a person who practices religious austerities and attains superhuman powers through his penances) A significant role in the exorcism of the gory6 was played by the substitute or female shaman known as a milco kaji-dai nori-wara or yori-mashi These female shamans through the use of magical spells and the chanting of a sfitra or dhdrani fell into a trance in which they were possessed by unseen spirits who employed them as a mouthpiece for their grievances and prophecies

As the belief in the gory6 and the demand for the mountain shugen- sha or kenza increased all over Japan there emerged many shugen-sha who took up permanent residence on the local sacred mountain and spent their time building temples seminaries and Shinto shrines dedicated to their own mountain deity as well as priests lodges and habitations for pilgrims The earliest and most famous of such settle- ments were a t Mount Yoshino (Kinpu) Mount Ohmine and Mount Kumano in Middle HonshQ (Kinki area) Mount Hiko in Kyushu Mount Ishizuchi in Shikoku Mount Tai-sen Mount Kojima in West HonshQ Mount Ontake Mount Tateyama Mount Haku-san in Middle HonshQ Mount Haguro Mount Gassan and Mount Yudono in Northeast Honshd The last three mountains are called Dewa-san- zan that is Three Sacred Mountains in Dewa Province (present Yama- gata Prefecture) These were the main centers of Shugen-dB from medieval to modern times

The present form of Shugen-dB is said to have been instituted by ShBbB (832-909) a higher priest of the Shingon school who practiced religious austerities on Mounts Yoshino and Ohmine following the

229

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 12: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummifLed Buddhas in Japan

model of the legendary En-no-ShBkaku He built a Shingon temple named Daigo-ji in Kyoto which became very powerful it lies in a tri- angular position with TB-ji in Kyoto and KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya I t should be observed that the headquarters of the Shugen-dB is SanbB-in Seminary within the precincts of Daigo-ji

As the practice of austerities in the mountains was held in high repute by both priests and laymen pilgrimages to such sacred moun- tains were flourishing The Mitake-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kinpu) and the Kumano-mGde (Pilgrimage to Mount Kumano) began to be very popular among both upper and lower classes These pilgrimages were performed in order to receive divine favors and to attain to spiritual enlightenment and peace The custom gave rise in the first place to the prosperity of the mountains inhabitants and the appearance of professional conductors named sendatsu who guided the pilgrims to their mountain from Kyoto and other places while teach- ing them the rules of religious purification and abstinence in addi- tion there came into being many permanent leader-priests called shugen-sha shzito or oshi who taught prayed for and guided the tem- porary lay-ascetics and pilgrims on the sacred mountain They built their own seminary and lodge around the main temple to shelter their adherents and pilgrims

At the end of the Heian Period Mount Kumano was a t the peak of its prosperity This was due mainly to two retired emperors Shirakawa who made nine pilgrimages to Mount Kumano and Goshirakawa who made thirty-four The popularity of this mountain is indicated by the old and well-known proverb speaking of the pilgrimage of ants to Mount Kumano (Ari-no-Kumano-mGde)

The shugen-sha on hlount Kumano subsequently came under the control of the Tendai and Shingon schools as the result of the efforts of the sendatsu who served on the emperors pilgrimages as conductors and guides The institutionalized Shugen-dB was gradually established around Mounts Kumano and Kinpu (Yoshino) under the doctrinal influence and management of both the Tendai and Shingon schools Roughly speaking the Shugen-dB of Mount Kumano was ruled thereafter by the Tendai school (Honzan-ha) while that of Mount Kinpu and Mount Ohmine was guided by the Shingon school (Than-ha)

Before the Tokugawa Shogunate established its feudal hegemony over Japan the Shugen-dB centers in several local areas (except those a t Mounts Ohmine and Kumano) had escaped direct control by the Kamakura or Ashikaga shogunates and the feudal and manor lords as well as by the Buddhist schools themselves This is not to

230

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 13: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

deny however as I have explained above that they were strongly influenced by Mantraydna Buddhism as found in the Tendai and Shingon esotericism and ritualism and by heterogenous Shintoism and the way of Yin-yang (Onmyd-dd) From these various sources they accepted and combined elements of various doctrines and prac- tices especially Buddhist prayers and magic according to the Man- t r a y h a sdtras and dhdrani Nevertheless they maintained their own uniforms religious teachings and mode of life their succession was hereditary and they did not shave their heads or marry They dis- regarded the disciplinary rules (Vinaya) of the Buddhist priesthood (bhiksu) because they were not bhiksu but only upcisaka Sometimes as substitutes for Shinto priests they celebrated Shinto services for their mountain deities as well as agricultural festivals

The religious policy of the Tokugawa government (Bakufu) de- manded a strong control over religious institutions The Buddhist community was especially the victim of high-handed procedures be- cause the many daimyd (feudal lords) in the age of the Civil War (about the fifteenth to sixteenth centuries) had been harassed by the monk-soldiers (s6-hei) from such powerful Buddhist temples as Enryaku-ji and Onj6-ji of the Tendai school K6fuku-ji and T6dai-ji in Nara Negoro-dera and KongBbu-ji of the Shingon school as well as by the Ikk6-ikki (agrarian disturbances against manor lords which had been instigated in several areas mainly by followers of the Shin sect) Indeed the political economic and military strength held by the powerful temples was the largest hindrance to the establishments of the feudal system

Accordingly Oda Nobunaga (1534-82) and Toyotomi Hideyoshi (1535-98) who preceded the establishment of the Tokugawa feudal system made a mighty attack against Enryaku-ji (in 1571) Negoro- dera (in 1585) and Hongan-ji at Ishiyama (now Osaka City) of the Shin sect (in 1576-80) In the meantime he formed a counterorganiza- tion against it from the ranks of the newly arriving Christian mis- sionaries (Kirishitan) utilizing such men as L Frois (d 1597) G Coelho (d 1590) and A Valignani (d 1605) although the Kirishitan mission was subject to severe pressure in Hideyoshis last years (1596- 98) Tokugawa Iyeyasu (1542-1616) founder of the Tokugawa Sho- gunate and his successors completed the destruction of the power of Buddhist temples and incorporated them into the framework of the Bakufu system An idea of the religious policy of the Bakufu may be gathered from the Jiin-hatto (ordinances for Buddhist temples issued by the Bakufu) along with various other laws and ordinances con- cerning the regulation of Buddhist temples and monks

231

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 14: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummiJied Buddhas i n J a p a n

Among such measures I should like in particular to note the fol- lowing (I) the enforcement of the parishioner system (danka-system) after 1638 for the purpose of a strict prohibition of the Kirishitan mission that is every Japanese person and family regardless of social status and occupation had to register a t a specific Buddhist temple while the temple (danna-dera) had to keep a record of its parishioners (2) the establishment of a system of main and subordinate temples (Hon-matsu system) that is every temple had to become subordinate to a central temple and obey the laws and orders of that temple (3) the fixing of the status of each Buddhist monk and temple as well as the regulation of the religious practices and discipline of each Buddhist school and sect (4) the direction of the temple estate that had been authorized by the Shogunate (go-shuin-chi) or by each daimyd (yoke-chi) in order to guard against the possible enlargement of the economic and military power of Buddhist temples The head- quarters of each Buddhist school and sect was placed under the strict control of the Jisha-bugyd (commissioner of Shinto shrines and Bud- dhist temples) composed of five daimy6 in hereditary vassalage to the Tokugawa after 1635 under which were the Fure-gashira (chief offi- cials for proclamation) the representatives of the leading temples of each sect The latter were obliged to deliver the commands of the Bakuju to the subordinate temples and to report petitions from the temples to the office of the Jisha-bugyd

As a result of these restrictive procedures the Shugen-dB temples and the shugen-sha or yamabushi became subordinate to either the Tendai or the Shingon school Nevertheless the shugen-sha or shQto a t the Dewa-sun-zan retained some measure of independence Here the shugen-sha had occupied only two of the three mountains in the range Mounts Haguro and Yudono while the last and highest of the three Mount Gassan (literally Mount Moon) although employed for wor- ship by both groups had not yet been permanently settled Subse- quently however i t became the center of two Shugen-d6 groups one called the Haguro sect and the other the Yudono sect

The history of the Shugen-d6 a t Dewa-sun-zan prior to the Toku- gawa Period is not yet clear However a t the beginning of the Toku- gawa Period there appeared a politically astute priest named TenyQ who had been appointed a superintendent (bettd) to the Haguro sect in 1630 TenyQ had been deeply attached to the famous Tenkai SBj6 of the Tendai school an aide-de-camp to Tokugawa Iyeyasu com- monly known as the Premier in the Black Robe Accordingly TenyQ soon declared openly to the subordinates of Kanei-ji in Yedo which had been built and occupied by Tenkai that he and his semi-

232

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 15: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

naries a t Mount Haguro had been converted to the Tendai school TenyQs ambition seems to have been to use the political influence of Tenkai to consolidate under his own leadership the doctrines and prac- tices as well as the policy and economy of the seminaries on the Three Sacred Mountains and the whole shugen-sha

Originally there were seven pilgrimage routes to the shrine on the top of Mount Gassan Each of these proceeded from a group of semi- naries and sendatsus dwellings centering around a main temple Two of these settlements acceded to the wish of TenyQ but four of the rest-Dainichi-bB and Churen-ji on the western foot of Mount Gas- san and Dainichi-ji and I-TondB-ji on its eastern foot-set themselves to oppose it for they had long been a t odds with the Haguro sect These four had traditionally been closely united and all shared allegiance to the deity of Mount Yudono an incarnation of Dainichi- nydrai (Mahcivairocanasatathdgata)and a supreme Buddha of the Shin- gon school I t was their desire therefore that the whole shugen-sha and sendatsu be converted to the Shingon school the adversary of the Tendai The chief abbots of these four centers declared that since in ancient times Mount Yudono had been discovered and developed by KQkai (K6bB Daishi) they should be restored to the Shingon school and be subject to the authority of KongBbu-ji on Mount KBya

After three long series (1639-1791) of legal proceedings initiated by TenyQ against the four centers of the Yudono sect in order to convert them to the Tendai school the judgment of the Jisha-bugyd was a t last given in favor of the defendants As a result the Haguro sect and the Yudono sect operated independently of each other in such matters as doctrine policy and economy Quarrels and conflicts con- tinued to break out between the two however and even today there is a discrepancy between them not only in institutional and doctrinal aspects but in emotional ones as well

IV DOCTRINAL AND INSTITUTIONAL PECULIARITIES O F THE YUDO-

NO SECT DURING THE TOKUGAWA PERIOD

According to the theories of the Yudono sect concerning the Honji- suijaku (the reality behind the phenomenal appearance) of the Three Sacred Mountains the deity of Mount Gassan was an incarnation of Amitabha Buddha and the peak of the mountain one of his terrestrial pure lands while the deity of Mount Yudono was an incarnation of MahAvairocana Buddha and ruled over the Garbhakosadhhtu (Taizd- kai) a counterpart to MahAvairocanas rule over the Vajra-dhAtu (Kongd-kai) in the Great Mandala a supreme iconographic symbol of the Shingon school

233

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 16: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummijed Buddhas in J a p a n

Some very complicated and mysterious developments have taken place in the religious thought of the Shingon school one of which seems to have been the evolution of the MahAvairocana who rules over the GarbhakoSadhAtu from a primitive goddess of the Great Mother variety As I have pointed out above a huge rock from which hot mineral waters flow is worshiped a t the Yudono Shrine and it is said that this rock symbolizes a female body At the same time this shrine was believed to be a place for the practice of austerities as well as for becoming a Buddha in ones own body

The shugen-sha of the Yudono sect chose to bypass the deity named Haguro-gongen who was native to Mount Haguro and supposed to give divine favors in this world preferring instead the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha and the promise of Mahhvairocana that each be- liever can become a Buddha in his own body Though the last two ideas might be thought to be inconsistent the ascetics of the Yudono sect practiced their austerities in order to become Buddha or enter nirvcina as in their own bodies while praying Arnitabha Buddha to complete their invocation

I believe that the above historical background may explain in part why the six mummified Buddhas have come only from among the ascetics of the Yudono sect those specifically who are called isse- gy6nin are permitted to bear the kai-sufi on their religious name and practice abstention from cereals (mokujiki-gyG) I must now give a detailed explanation of the structure of the Yudono sect of the ShugendB to clarify the characteristics of self-mummified Buddhas

The ShugendB priests and ascetics consisted in general of three ranks the first was composed of the seis6 shugen (authorized Buddhist monks) who were appointed as chief abbot or priest a t the main temple or in their own seminary (in) and presided over the lower ranks of hereditary sendatsu (or shdto shugen-sha) and their dwell- ings (bG) They formed the very heart of the Shugen-dB for they con- trolled the services for pilgrims and believers the economy and the management in general of the whole institution Unlike the shugen-sha of the Kumano who had scattered and settled down in various places all over Japan systematizing the pilgrims and believers in each area the shugen-sha of the Yudono following the principle of the TGzan-ha line were not permitted to remain permanently in any one locality They traveled here and there from the centers on Mount Ohmine in order to propagate their religious faith as well as to take care of pilgrims regardless of their school and temple affiliation This is a striking point of contrast between the TBzan-ha line and the Honzan- ha (Kumano shugen-sha) based upon the kasumi system in which

234

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 17: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

the priest of a leading temple controlled each local shugen-sha or yamabushi

The Yudono sect however had the third rank called the gydnin these were not shugen-sha or shuto but true ascetic devotees The name gydnin was originally that of one of the three divisions in the monastic system of Mount K8ya the first and top rank was the gakuryo-gata (learned monks side) the second was the gydnin-gata in charge of revenue expenditures and accounts in the Mount KBya headquar- ters while the third was the hijiri-gata those individuals who traveled all over Japan under the name of Kdya-hijiri to propagate Nenbutsu beliefs as well as to gather the ashes of unknown people and carry them back to Mount KBya where memorial services were held for them

While the function of the gydnin of the Yudono sect was unlike that of the gydnin on Mount KBya the name was the same The high- est class of gydnin in the Yudono sect was the isse-gyhin while the lowest was the hztokuchi-gydnin the temporal pilgrims from various places The isse-gydnin were the ascetics who contrary to the example of the sendatsu or shugen-sha followed the Buddhist precepts with all strictness Abandoning wife and children they fled to the mountain and with faith in the deity of Mount Yudono and KBbB-Daishi de- voted their lives to the practice of asceticism and the salvation of the people At first the isse-gy6nin was initiated as a disciple into a semi- nary in one of the four centers of the Yudono Under the guidance of a teacher ranked in the seisd (gakuryo learned priest) he was taught simple doctrines and the recitation of slitras as well as the performance of rituals and the mystery of the sacred fire He was given the isse- kaigo which is the religious name with the kai-suffix peculiar to the isse-gydnin During this period the isse-gydnin lived as a Buddhist priest in the Yudono sect of the Shingon school under the control of KongB-bu-ji on Mount KBya His head was shaved and he wore a black sacerdotal robe

After two or three years training a t the seminary the isse-gydnin grew his hair long adopted a white robe beard and mustache and began a secluded life a t Sennin-zawa (Swamp of Wizards) The most significant characteristic of ascetic training a t Sennin-zawa was the so-called mokujiki-gyd mentioned above which lasted for one to four thousand days and permitted only the consumption of buckwheat flour and some kinds of nuts and grass roots After cold-water ablu- tions the isse-gydnin worshiped three times a day a t the Yudono Shrine unlike members of the other two ranks he was now without a teacher and free to discipline himself

235

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 18: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummiJied Buddhas in Japan

The isse-gydnin a t Sennin-zawa which is three kilometers distance from the Yudono Shrine and lies along the pilgrims road from Daini- chi-bB and Churen-ji to Mount Yudono stood in a close relation to the people of Tamugimata Village on the western foot of Mount Yudono the only community on that road Because the village had originally developed as a transit station for pilgrimage the people there felt an obligation to support the isse-gydnin during his daily life a t Sennin- zawa

Many monuments to the memory of prominent isse-gydnin can be found which were erected from 1700 to 1900 by their disciples and followers in and around Sennin-zawa hermitage and Tamugimata To clarify the characteristics of the isse-gydnin we note the wording on some of them 1 1836 (The Seventh Year of TenpB)

Mokujiki-gy6ja (ascetic who practiced abstention from cereals) Tetsu-un-kai ShBnin

Sefua-nin (caretaker) ShunkB-in (a hereditary shugen-sha of Churen-ji)

2 1856 (The Third Year of Ansei) Shimekake Mokujiki-gyija Zen-kai (Zen-kai an ascetic who practiced

abstention from cereals in Shimekake-mura the home of Churen-ji) 3 1862 (The Second Year of Bunkyu)

Issen-nichi Sanrd (one-thousand-day confinements at the Yudono Shrine)

Tetsuryu-kai (a mummified Buddha) Un-kai (Tetsuryu-kais disciple)

Sewa-nin (caretakers) Tamugimata-mura (names of two persons) Oami-mura (names of three persons) Shimekake-mura (names of three persons) Higashi-araya-mura (name of one person) Iwamoto-mura (name of one person)

4 1900 (The Thirty-third Year of Meiji) Kyu-sen-nichi Yama-gomori Ito Un-kai (Un-kai who had practiced

nine thousand days of confinement a t Mount Yudono)

After training for more than a thousand days a t Sennin-zawa the isse-gydnin left the mountain and traveled from place to place as itinerant missionaries Some of them acquired disciples because of the merits of their magical powers and their social work Occasionally temples called gydnin-dera were built and dedicated to a particular gydnin by his followers while some gydnin succeeded their master as the chief abbot or supervisor of such a temple The gydnin-dera sys- tem played an important role in the missionary work to various local areas of the Yudono sect and helped to provide a substitute for the kasumi system as found in the Kumano Shugen-d6 The isse-gydnin

236

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 19: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

of various gydnin-dera gathered and systematized their followers guiding them to the main seminary (hon-ji) of either Churen-ji Daini- chi-bB EIondB-ji or Dainichi-ji to encourage a pilgrimage to Mount Yudono Furthermore the isse-gydnin supplied the central seminaries and conductors (sendatsu) with a huge sum of money and the pros- perity of Mount Yudono depended upon their activities

The succession of the chief abbot of the gydnin-dera was not heredi- tary as was that of the mountain shugen-sha or sendatsu Another characteristic of the gydnin-dera was that it included only voluntary adherents not true parishioners (danka) Thus it was an exceptional case in the temple system of the Tokugawa Shogunate and resembled rather the system of seisds seminaries (in) We may illustrate this by giving as an example the succession of supervisors a t a typical gy8nin-dera KaikB-ji in Sakata City where two mummified Buddhas are enshrined

KaikB-ji was presumably built by ChQ-kai ShBnin (a mummified Buddha) although its legendary founder was KQkai (KBb8 Daishi) From the Tokugawa Period onward KaikB-ji belonged to Churen-ji on Mount Yudono However it now belongs to both Churen-ji and Chishaku-in in Kyoto headquarters of the New Shingon School (Shingi Shingon-shzi) The supposed lineage of the supervisors of this temple found in the necrology and memorial tablets is as follows

1 Chfi-kai Shonin (d 1755) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 2 Seihan HBin (d 1771) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 3 YQchi Dai-OshB (date of death unknown) May have been a seisd who

had been appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji 4 ChBei Con-Risshi (d 1782) May have been a disciple of Churen-ji 5 KeiryQ HBin (date of death unknown) May have been same as above 6 TenryQ-kai ShBnin (d 1805) Isse-gydnin 7 Enmy6kai ShBnin (d 1822) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 8 Tetsumon-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin A self-mummified Buddha 9 Nan-kai ShBnin (d 1829) Isse-gydnin

10 Sei-kai ShBnin (d about 1843) Isse-gydnin 11 Rin-kai ShBnin (d 1853) Isse-gydnin 12 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1871) Isse-gydnin 13 KyBun-kai ShBnin (d 1892) Isse-gydnin 14 Sei-kai ShBnin (d 1894) Isse-gydnin 15 Yfi-kai ShBnin (d 1897) Isse-gydnin 16 KBun-kai ShBnin (d 1902) Isse-gydnin 17 Reiun-kai ShBnin (d 1916) Isse-gydnin 18 Tokuryb-kai ShBnin (d 1917) Isse-gydnin 19 KB-kai ShBnin (d 1920) Isse-gydnin 20 Zen-kai ShBnin (d 1928) Isse-gydnin 21 KBki HBin (d 1937) Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji

237

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 20: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

22 EihB HBin (d 1952)Appointed by the chief abbot a t Churen-ji born of the shugen-sha family named SeizB-in a t Churen-ji

23 Present abbot Appointed by the chief abbot at Churen-ji studied a t Churen-ji and Chishaku-in

In closing this section I would like to give a r6sum6 of the structure and functions of the Yudono sect of the Shugen-dB According to a manuscript dated 1804 they were as follows

A Western Provinces Governing Temples Churen-ji (in Shimekake-mura)

Dainichi-bB (in 6ami-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple who presides over disciples

(shugen-sha or shdto sendatsu and isse-gyhin) Shugen-sha or Shato Residents at their particular in or 66 in the vicinity

of the superintendent temple succession through heredity ten shugen- sha each and their seminary under Churen-ji and Dainichi-b6 The shugen-sha has the right to conduct all pilgrims to Mount Yudono except those from the Northeast

Annai-sendatsu Beneath the shugen-sha there are fifteen professional con- ductors or guides who have the right to escort only those pilgrims com- ing from the Northeast Succession was by heredity While the shugen- sha was not a peasant directly ruled by a lord although in courtesy he was treated as such and pressed into public service the annai-sendatsu was a peasant directly ruled by the fief (han) both nominally and vir- tually The former is tonsured in principle while the latter is long- haired

Isse-gydnin The scope of the activities of the isse-gydnin extends to Niiga- ta and Yamanashi prefectures in the west centering around the North- east and the KantB areas

B Eastern Provinces Governing Temples HondB-ji (in Hodouchi-mura)

Dainichi-ji (in oizawa-mura) Seisd-bettd Superintendent of each temple presiding over seminaries dis-

ciples sendatsu isse-gydnin and others Seisd-tutchzl There are six seminaries peculiar to the learned monks of

the Shingon school located within the precincts of their governing temple the monks who reside in these seminaries are not permitted to conduct pilgrims and they are exempted from all public services as- signed by the han government

Sendatsu There are seventy conductors or guides in each some of them are peasants under the control of the governing temple others are within the temple estate they have the right to conduct pilgrims from all over Japan though not directly under the control of the han government in courtesy they are treated as peasants and take part in public services some are tonsured but many are long-haired and wear the so-called kake-goromo (informal robe) during the pilgrimage season

Isse gydnin Same as those in the western provinces they scatter and settle down a t gydnin-dera in various places they are controlled by the fure-gashira in their particular area for instance the fure-gashira in

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 21: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Yedo are H8j6-in for the subsect of HondG-ji and Fukumoto-in for the Dainichi-ji

C Regulations concerning the pilgrimage to Mount Yudono 1 The pilgrims who have reported to HondB-ji or Dainichi-ji must go to

any of the six tatcht2 seminaries There they are met by the particular sendatsu in charge of their regions (danna-ha) Having received a fixed fee the sendatsu guides the pilgrims to the governing temple in which they are treated to a meal After this they are conducted by their par- ticular sendatsu back to the tatch22where they remain for the night The next morning they are led to Mount Yudono and Mount Gassan The fee mentioned above belongs to the governing temple a charge for one nights lodging is collected by the tatcht2 seminary while the income of the sendatsu results from the charges made for prayers and exorcisms in the sacred mountains

2 The pilgrims who report to Churen-ji or Dainichi-bB are met by shugen-sha or sht2to The latter receive a fixed fee part of which goes to the governing temple the remaining portion being considered as a charge for conduct into the mountains The pilgrims then have their meal and remain for the night a t the temple preparing themselves for their journey the next morning to Mounts Yudono and Gassan The income collected from the prayers and exorcisms in the mountains is kept by the shugen-sha and annai-sendatsu

V HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE FOR T H E EMERGENCE O F MUMMIFIED

BUDDHAS AND CONCLUSION

Finally I would like to touch briefly upon the subject of abstinence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) the practice of all isse-gydnin a t Sennin- zawa As I have already pointed out the tradition of mokujiki-gyd presumably originated in the Last Injunction of Kbkai in which he relates that for three years before his death he despised the con- sumption of cereals Mokujiki-gyd seems to have been influenced either by Hindu asceticism (Yoga) or by the training of wizards in Taoism Of course though it should not be a Buddhist doctrine prop- er Japanese mountain ascetics usually adopted it in order to master the mysteries of religion as well as to acquire superhuman powers I t should be remembered that Japanese Shugen-dd (mountain asceticism) is a compound of ancient shamanistic magic and Mantrayha Bud- dhism Yin-yang magic and Taoism

We may now note further instances of the practice of mokujiki-gyd in the history of Japanese religion First there is the case reported by the Montoku Jitsuroku (Official Record during the Reign of Emperor Montoku 850-58) in which an upcisaka who came to Kyoto in 854 announced that he abstained from cereals An imperial edict provided him with a lodging in the Imperial Garden named Shinsen-en and he there became the object of worship by the citizens of Kyoto who asked

239

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 22: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummi$ed Buddhas in Japan

him to pray for them and the welfare of their private affairs Many women especially were dazzled by the brilliance of his reputation After about a month however someone claimed that he was eating rice a t midnight and going to the toilet early every morning Others then spied upon his doings and discovered high piles of rice excrement As a result public estimation for him rapidly declined and he was dubbed a bei-fun-hijiri (saint of rice excrements)

Second we find in the Gyokuyb (diary of Kuj6 Kanezane a chief adviser to the emperor 1149-1207) that in the first year of Genryaku (1184) on the third day of the last month a saint named GyBshB-b6 came to Kanezanes house and talked with him for several hours Kanezane wrote This saint has practiced abstinence from cereals a t Mount K6ya and is said to have done so with great efficacy This saint is also mentioned in another diary Tamashibe in the fourth year of ShBgen (1210) on the fifth day of the ninth month GyBshB ShBnin is now eighty-one years old practices abstinence from six kinds of cereal His moral energy seems to be very vigorous Is he a real incarnation of the Buddha in his own body

The Jikkin-shb (legendary literature compiled in the Kamakura Period 1185-1337) mention that a Buddhist priest who lived in the mountain temple named Kong6-ji in Kawachi (Osaka Prefecture) usually took only pine needles as his daily food He had heard that those who do so do not suffer from the lack of cereals and that upon completion of the practice they become wizards and are able to fly freely through the air

Several other examples could be added from the documents of the Middle Ages We may point out however that the GyBsh6 ShBnin cited above transmitted the tradition of mokujiki-gyb on Mount KBya at the end of the Heian and at the beginning of the Kamakura Period As a matter of fact mokujiki-gy8 on Mount KBya is supposed to have been practiced continuously from generation to generation from the medieval to the Tokugawa Period The Kii-no-Kuni Meisho- xuye (A Pictorial Description of Noted Places in Present Wakayama Prefecture) compiled in the Tokugawa Period says that the center of mokujiki-gy6 practices was built by ChBgu ShBnin He had been chief abbot a t ByBd6-ji in Miwa-mura in Nara Prefecture a temple affiliated with the deity of the Miwa Jinja Shrine but when he was converted to the teaching of KQkai he entered Mount KBya residing a t RenjB-in Seminary in Isshinin Valley and then transferred to TBrin-in Seminary near the holy of holies where the corpse of KQkai was enshrined He practiced mokujiki-gyd a t his seminary and he was therefore called mokujiki-Ch6gu He was succeeded as chief abbot by

240

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 23: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Kaiho ShGnin and thereafter mokujiki-gyd practices became a main-

stay of the training program there To understand the great importance of mokujiki-gyd among the

isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect one must also appreciate the role played on Mount K6ya by the politically astute gyhin named Ohgo (1536-1608) He had been a warrior (samurai) who was converted to Shingon Buddhism at the age of thirty-seven He took only fruits and nuts as his daily food a t Mount K6ya and was called mokujiki-Sh6nin He was not a genuine Shingon priest but only a guest-priest on Mount KBya just as were the isse-gydnin on Mount Yudono However an accident made him a mail of distinction When Toyotomi Hideyoshi wished to attack Mount Kdya in 1585 Ohgo mediated between Hide- yoshi and the authorities of Mount K6ya and he secured an agree- ment from Hideyoshi to protect Mount K6ya against the ravages of war As a result Mokujiki-Sh6nin converted Hideyoshi and enjoyed his confidence Hideyoshi intrusted him with the management of Mount KBya and all its seminaries saying to the priests of Mount KGya You must not think of Ohgo as a Mokujiki a t K6ya but as the Mount K6ya of Mokujiki Thus Hideyoshis proclamation bears witness to his reliance on mokujiki-Sh6nin In accordance with the order of Hideyoshi Ohgo later built a Great Buddha a t HBkB-ji

When the conflict a t Sekigahara burst out in 1600 between the Toyotomi and the Tokugawa the decisive moment was reached for the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate and its feudal system Ohgo desired to mediate between the two sides to restore peace but his offer was refused by Tokugawa Iyeyasu for Ohgo had been too intimately associated with Hideyoshi After the battle Ohgo resigned his position as superintendent-general on Mount KBya and he was succeeded by his disciple Seiyo who belonged to the gydnin group As a result the gakuryo (learned priests) group initiated measures against Seiyo and the gyhin group since throughout the long history of Mount K6ya they had been superior to the gydnin element there although they were forced to submit to the leadership of Ohgo in the crucial years around 1585 However the crisis a t Mount KBya had passed Meanwhile the strong Tokugawa Shogunate was established Accordingly the gakuryo brought suit against Seiyos rule over Mount KBya with the intention of recovering their lost rights (When the name of gydnin had first appeared on Mount KBya in 1130 they had been a minority group whose function was to serve a t the holy of holies but in the course of time they had gradually increased and seized the right to perform services a t the guardian deitys shrine as

241

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya

Page 24: Self-Mummified Buddhas in Japan. an Aspect of the Shugen-Do Sect - Hori - History of Religions

Self-mummified Buddhas in Japan

well as the management of the secular affairs of all the seminaries on Mount KBya The gakuryo therefore eyed the gydnin with contempt while the latter prepared all their forces for a struggle with the gakur- yo) The suit initiated in 1602 continued for almost a hundred years and concluded with more than six hundred of the gydnin a t Mount K8ya being sent into exile

Because of the lack of documentary evidence we cannot ascertain where the exiled gydnin may have settled down Nor is it clear pre- cisely what influence the personality and activities of Ohgo and his mokujiki-gyd had upon the isse-gydnin of the Yudono sect However we cannot deny the indirect influence of the Shingon school at Mount Kdya if we remember (1) the sudden rise of the isse-gydnin group a t Mount Yudono after 1700 (2) the custom of assigning the kai-suffix of the priest name only to the isse-gydnin (3) the practice of absti- nence from cereals (mokujiki-gyd) which was peculiar to the isse- gydnin group (4) the strong desire of the isse-gydnin to become a Buddha in his own body (soku-shin-jdbutsu) as the perfection of the self and ( 5 ) that the pattern for the worship of the self-mummified Buddhas was the legend of K6b8 Daishi a t Mount KBya