Self-healing Anticorrosive PU Coatings Embedded with...
Transcript of Self-healing Anticorrosive PU Coatings Embedded with...
Chapter 3 P a g e | 69
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
Chapter-3
Self-healing Anticorrosive PU Coatings Embedded with
Microcapsules Containing Tung Oil
A convenient method for the preparation of robust polyurea microcapsules
containing tung oil as a interior material was developed for self curing anticorrosive
application. Well distinct microcapsules with polyurea as a shell material were
prepared by reacting hexamethylene diisocyanate (HDI) trimer (isocyanurate) with
0.0 G polyamidoamine (PAMAM) via interfacial polymerization technique. Fourier
transform infrared spectroscopic (FTIR) analysis was performed to elucidate the
chemical structure of microcapsule and to confirm successful encapsulation of core
moiety. Surface morphology, particle size and size distribution, thermal and
mechanical properties of prepared PAMAM based polyurea microcapsules were
studied against microcapsules prepared with DETA and TETA. The prepared
microcapsules were embedded with acrylic based PU coatings to ensure self-healing
nature of microcapsules. The immersion study of self-healing polyurethane (PU)
coating loaded with different percentages of microcapsules revealed that the
composite embedded with 5 % PAMAM based polyurea microcapsules shown
satisfactory anticorrosive property under an accelerated corrosion process in 5% NaCl
aqueous solution.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 70
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
1. Introduction
In current years, microcapsules containing healing materials have been drawn
immense interest in self-repairing polymer composites [1-5]. Among the different
approaches developed for self-healing material such as loading of microcapsule,
microvascular network and hollow pipeline embedment (including glass tube and
glass fiber), microcapsule loading become more popular and widely used because of
simple preparation and easy dispersion in polymer matrix [6,7]. Different chemical
methods are reported including in situ polymerization, interfacial polymerization, etc.
to prepare microcapsules having desire properties [8, 9]. Different process parameters
such as agitation rate, weight core-shell ratio, type and concentration of emulsifier,
reaction temperature, etc. have been found to bring the microcapsules with variable
properties [10-12]. In the last few decades, researcher’s working in this field has paid
more attention to improve the performance of microcapsules to make them more
effective tool for self-healing composites. Tong et al. demonstrated melamine
modified PUF microcapsules with long storage time, improved heat resistance and
water resistance properties [13]. Interfacial interaction between microcapsules and
matrix was found to be improved by shell modification of microcapsules through use
of coupling agent or grafting of specific functional groups on the surface of
microcapsules [14, 15]. In our previous study we reported greater thermal stability of
polyurea microcapsules prepared using PAMAM dendrimer with improved interfacial
interaction towards the matrix [16].
The membrane strength of microparticles is also one of the most important
factors that need to be improved for successful accomplishing microcapsule-based
self-healing system. Thus in order to have adequate strength and withstand the
Chapter 3 P a g e | 71
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
breakage of microcapsules, which otherwise happened during the post treatment and
dispersion into polymer matrix, microcapsules must be carefully fabricated [17]. If the
membrane is not adequately sturdy, the external impact would trigger the unwanted
release of healing agent during handling and processing of microcapsules. Therefore,
considering technical and commercial importance, it is of basic requirement to
develop and explore a new shell material having high impact resistance.
Out of the several microencapsulation techniques, the interfacial
polymerization, due to its simplicity and versatility of structural performance, it is one
of the most common processes used to encapsulate wide range of active agents within
different polymeric shells [18]. Dicyclopentadiene [19-21]
and epoxy resin [22-24]
are the most common healing agents which have been used for self-repairing coatings.
However, to polymerize both reactive healants released from ruptured microcapsules
catalyst is required that must be dispersed into the matrix or in some cases needs to be
encapsulated to maintain its activity which would make self-healing mechanism quite
complex. But drying oils such as linseed oil [25] and tung oil [26] act as healing
agents and do not require the catalyst to polymerize. In such cases oxidative
polymerization of drying oils just with air contact heals the crack present in the
matrix. Faster drying rate due to high degree of unsaturation and ability to polymerize
into a tough, waterproof coating could make tung oil, a good candidate for self-
healing mechanism.
Considering afore mentioned points, here attempts were made to fabricate the
polyurea microcapsules containing tung oil as a curing agent by interfacial
polymerization. Multifunctional HDI trimer and 0.0 G PAMAM dendrimer having
several amino groups were reacted to form highly branched crosslinked polyurea shell
Chapter 3 P a g e | 72
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
wall with the hope to obtain microcapsules possessing improved mechanical and
thermal stability. It is noteworthy that heterocyclic isocyanurate ring present in trimer
of diisocyanate enhances thermal stability of polymer [27] and trifunctionality of
trimer can introduce higher cross linking density in polymer structure which is
advantageous for the wall strength of the microcapsules [28]. In first part of the work
optimal emulsifier system was investigated to obtain polyurea microcapsules with
superior morphology. Further, PAMAM based polyurea microcapsules fabricated at
optimized emulsifier system were evaluated in terms of particle size, shell
morphology, thermal and mechanical stability against microcapsules prepared with
different types of amine. PU coatings embedded with PAMAM based polyurea
microcapsules containing tung oil were tested and found with better anticorrosion
performance.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Materials
Aliphatic polyisocyanate based on hexamethylene diisocyanate trimer [HDI
trimer] (Tolonate HDT 90, Perstorp Chemicals, India) was used as oil phase monomer
for shell material. Tung oil (Rarco Research Lab, Mumbai) was used as a core
material. Zero generation PAMAM dendrimer was used as a water phase monomer
for shell material. Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) was procured from Loba Chemicals,
Mumbai, India. Acrylic polyol was synthesized as reported in the literature [29].
Sodium dodecyl benzene sulfonate (SDBS) was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich,
India. Triethylenetetramine (TETA), diethylenetriamine (DETA) and butyl acetate (s.
d. fine - Chem Ltd., Mumbai, India.) were of synthetic grade and used as such for the
reaction. Desmodur W was used as received from a Bayer Material Science.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 73
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
2.2. Experimental Synthesis of Microcapsules
The preparation of polyurea microcapsules containing tung oil was carried out
by interfacial polymerization in two steps viz emulsification and polymerization. In
first step an organic phase containing HDI trimer (2.0 g) and core material (9.0 g)
dissolved in butyl acetate (3.0 g) was mixed with aqueous emulsifier solution. Then
the mixture was emulsified at 3000 rpm with homogenizer (ultra turrax®, Ika T25,
Germany) at temperature from 15 - 20 0 C for 5 min to obtain stable emulsion.
Thereafter the emulsion was transferred to 100 mL three necked round bottom flask
equipped with a mechanical stirrer and thermometer. Polymerization reaction was
started at lower temperature by dropwise addition of a solution containing 1.0 g of
PAMAM in 20 mL of 1 wt % emulsifier solution. The reaction mixture was stirred
continuously at 300 rpm over a 45 min period at ambient temperature around 25 - 30 0
C to complete the formation of the polyurea shell. Formation of microcapsules was
checked by observing reaction mixture time to time under a optical microscope. The
resulting microcapsule suspension was filtered and rinsed first with ethanol solution
(25% v/v in water) and with water for few times to remove the remaining reactants
and then dried under reduced pressure at ambient temperature. Scheme 1 illustrates
possible reaction mechanism of wall formation for polyurea microcapsules.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 74
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
Scheme 1: Reaction scheme for wall formation of polyurea microcapsules
2.3. Optical morphology
The microcapsule formation during the fabrication process was preliminary
observed by a optical microscope (Labomed Sigma, 2124001, Texas) at magnification
10–100X. About 1-2 mL of capsule suspension was took out and spread on a clean
glass slide. Various images were taken by a digital camera (model -Fujifilm Finepix
S3300) during the microcapsule forming process.
2.4. Scanning Electron Microscopy
Surface morphologies of microcapsules were recorded in a field emission
scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) (Model S- 4800, Hitachi High Technologies
Corp). The dried microcapsules were mounted on a double sided adhesive tape,
sputter coated with a thin layer of gold prior to examination and were observed at a
NN
OO
O
O
NNH2
N
NH2
N
H2N
N
H2N
HH
HH
0.0 G PAMAM
N N
N O
O
O
(CH2)6
(CH2)6(H2C)6
HN
HN
O
R
NH2
NH2
NH2
HNHN
O
R
NH2
NH2
NH2
NH
HN
O
R
NH2
H2N
H2N
N N
N O
O
O
(CH2)6
(CH2)6(CH2)6 NCO
NCO
OCN
HDI Isocynurate (trimer)
Polyurea
R
NH2
NH2
H2N
H2N
RT
Chapter 3 P a g e | 75
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
voltage range of 0.5 to 30 kV. Dried microcapsules were ruptured manually with a
razor blade for measurement of shell thickness.
2.5. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy
To identify the constituents of the microcapsules, transmittance analysis of
microcapsules, pure capsule shell and pure capsule core material were performed in a
shimadzu 8400 FTIR spectrophotometer with resolution of 2 cm-1
and 40 scans per
spectrum. Specimens were prepared by homogenizing the samples with a potassium
bromide (KBr). To obtain pure capsule shell for FTIR spectrum, small amount of
microcapsules were crushed in a Morton piston and washed for a few times by
ethanol. After filtration and drying, pure shell was used for analysis.
2.6. Particle size Analysis
The particle size and size distribution of prepared microcapsules were
determined on a Malvern Mastersizer 2000 particle size analyzer (Malvern
Instrument, UK) by a laser diffraction technique.
2.7 Thermogravimetric Analysis
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed to evaluate the thermal
stability of microcapsules on a PerkinElmer TGA 4000, operated in the temperature
range of 30 0 C to 600
0 C at a scanning rate of 10
0 C min
-1 in a flow rate of 20 mL
min-1
N2.
2.8 Viability of Encapsulation and Flexibility of Microcapsules
Elastic strength of newly fabricated cross linked polyurea shell wall and its
feasibility to encapsulate the core material was practically judge through visual
observation under the optical microscope and video recording by the digital camera.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 76
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
About 0.1 g of microcapsule powder was mounted on a clean glass slide immediate
after filtration and drying. Under the optical microscopic observations, one particular
microcapsule from the elected field was dragged by using capillary in order to
demonstrate the elasticity and finally squashed it to verify encapsulation of core
material by observing it’s come out from ruptured microcapsule.
2.9 Preparation and Analysis of PU coatings
PU composite coatings were prepared by dispersing PAMAM based polyurea
microcapsules with different loading from 0 to 5% into the synthesised acrylic polyol
dissolved in xylene. Then Desmodur W was mixed with the above polyol solution
containing microcapsules at ambient temperature. The mixture was then applied by
brush on mild steel panels of 150 mm × 70 mm × 1 mm in dimension with a wet film
thickness of 250- 300 μm and resultant coatings were allowed to cure at room
temperature. Pure PU coating was prepared as a control. Steel panels were polished
by sand paper and degreased by acetone before application of coatings.
The prepared PU coatings embedded with different amount of microcapsules
along with control sample were then tested for anticorrosion property by immersion
study carried out in an aqueous solution of NaCl (5 wt %). For this study artificial
cross scratches were made on the coating with razor blade with the aim to break the
microcapsules in the path and left at room temperature for 3 days to allow to heal the
cracks by tung oil leak out from ruptured microcapsules. After 3 days the specimens
were immersed in 5 wt% NaCl solution for a total exposure time of 120 h to evaluate
the accelerated corrosion process. The corrosion performance of all the panels coated
with neat PU coating and self-healing coatings was examined by a optical
photography.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 77
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Overview of microcapsule formation
In the synthesis of polyurea microcapsules to encapsulate a tung oil as a
healing agent by interfacial polymerization, HDI isocyanurate was dissolved in butyl
acetate along with tung oil to obtain oil phase. In order to get stable dispersion, oil
phase was then emulsified under higher agitation speed in 1 % emulsifier or stabilizer
solution which formed an oil in water emulsion.
Emulsification was carried out at lower temperature (15-20 0 C) so as to
minimize the chances of reaction between triisocyanate and water. Polymeric shell
membrane surrounding the core droplets was formed when reaction between 0.0 G
PAMAM having terminal amine groups in water phase and trifunctional HDI
isocyanurate in oil phase taken place at the interface of oil and water. To avoid the
possibility of gelation due to fast reaction between reactive PAMAM and HDI
isocyanurate, dilute PAMAM solution (in 1 wt % emulsifier solution) was added
slowly at lower temperature (15 -20 0
C) for a period of 15 min. Then temperature was
allowed to rise at room temperature and hold the reaction for a period of 45 min.
The Fig. 1 illustrates schematic diagram for preparation of polyurea
microcapsules by interfacial polymerization method. Stable microparticles were
observed by optical microscope just after 10 min of PAMAM addition. However to
complete the reaction between isocyanate and amine, reaction mixture was stirred
continuously for next 45 min. The used functional monomers, PAMAM dendrimer
and HDI isocyanurate were with multiple functional sites which contribute to form
highly branched cross-linked structure in the interaction region to form the polyurea
membrane with good mechanical strength.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 78
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
HN
HN
O
R
NH2
NH2
NH
HNNH
O R
H2N NH2
NH
HN
HN
O
R
H2N
HN
NH2
R
Polyurea Shell
Water Phase
Oil Phase
O/W emulsion
Amine Phase
PolymerizationEmulsification
3000 rpm, 15-20o C 300 rpm, 20o C - RT
Filtration & drying
Fig. 1: Preparation of polyurea microcapsules by interfacial polymerization method
3.2 Selection of Emulsifier System
The formation of microcapsules involves two steps i.e. emulsification and
actual polymerization. In emulsification step surface active agent and stabilizer play
an important role to form stable oil droplets dispersed in the continuous water phase.
In a typical experiment, emulsification was carried out by using 1 % PVA solution. It
was found that the prepared microcapsules were larger in size with wrinkled shell
wall and they get ruptured over the period of time after exposure to surrounding
environment. It suggested that for the present system, PVA could not be able to
stabilize the droplets formation and tend to coalescence of particles which results into
larger microcapsule formed. Further experiment was carried out with 1 % SDBS
solution, an anionic surfactant adapted for oil in water emulsion system having
Chapter 3 P a g e | 79
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
hydrophilic–lipophilic balance value (HLB) suitably matched with used oil, in order
to produce stable and uniform size microcapsules. It is clearly seen from the Fig. 2
that prepared microcapsules were coagulated with major abnormity and weaker shell
wall which infers that the emulsifier SDBS fails to keep the balance between
interfacial tension and stability of the present colloid system.
Fig. 2: PU microcapsules obtained at different concentration of SDBS/PVA (a) 1/0
(b) 0.5/0.5 (c) 0.4/0.6 (d) 0.2/0.8 (e) 0/1
Chapter 3 P a g e | 80
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
Thus in order to provide suitable formulation that can facilitate desired
interfacial properties both for droplet formation and subsequent stabilization, series of
composite emulsifier (SDBS/PVA- (a) 1/0 (b) 0.5/0.5 (c) 0.4/0.6 (d) 0.2/0.8 (e) 0/1
were used for the present system. It was found that with the composite emulsifier
SDBS/PVA-0.2/0.8, spherical, smooth, compact shell walled microcapsules were
formed. Hence it was concluded that composite emulsifier system is more effective
than individual emulsifier and the ratio of SDBS to PVA of 0.2/0.8 was found the
optimal emulsifying system for present study.
Particle size distribution curve for polyurea microcapsules containing tung oil
prepared at composite emulsifier SDBS/PVA-0.2/0.8 is represented in the Fig. 3.
Fig. 3: Particle size distribution of the polyurea microcapsules containing tung oil
The size of microcapsules was found to be distributed in the range of 58–260 μm. It is
reported in the literature [30] that during the preparation of microcapsules due to the
turbulence fluid flow, higher shear force is produced near the propeller blade which
tend to lower the size of microcapsules while comparatively larger microparticles
Chapter 3 P a g e | 81
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
exist away from the propeller which overall tend to wider size distribution of the
microparticles. The mean diameter of the prepared microcapsules was found 133.6
μm that is quite suitable to utilize it for self-healing application.
3.3. Structural Analysis
The Fig. 4a shows the FTIR spectra of the polyurea microcapsules and
extracted shell. The spectrum of both polyurea microcapsules as well as shell showed
the absorption band at 1685 cm-1
, which was assigned to >C=O stretching frequencies
for amide. Furthermore N–H stretching was evidenced with a broad absorption band
observed in the 3550–3300 cm–1
range. Also absorption band at 1440 cm-1
was
corresponded to the –C–N stretching of amide.
Fig. 4(a): FTIR spectra of (a) extracted polyurea shell and (b) microcapsules
containing core material
Chapter 3 P a g e | 82
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
Fig. 4(b): FTIR spectra of (a) extracted core and (b) pure core material
The spectrum of core material tung oil (Fig. 4b.) revealed strong
absorption band at 1745 and 1162 cm-1
that were assigned to >C=O stretching and –
C–C(=O)–O- stretching vibrations of ester respectively. Moderate to weak absorption
peak for –C=C– stretching vibration was observed at 1640 cm-1
. The frequencies
observed at 2927 cm-1
, 2858 cm-1
were corresponded to C–H stretching and at 1457
cm-1
was corresponded to C–H bending of methylene group.
FTIR spectrum of microcapsule (Fig. 4a) discloses whether the core
material was successfully encapsulated or not within the polyurea shell wall. The
appearance of characteristics signals at 1886 cm-1
for >C=O stretching frequencies of
amide group present in shell and >C=O stretching vibration of ester at 1745 cm-1
confirmed the presence of core in the synthesized polyurea microcapsules. Also
observing nearly identical spectrum for the individual core and extracted core were
confirmed again that by retaining all functional groups, tung oil have been
encapsulated by polyurea microcapsules.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 83
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
3.4. Scanning Electron Microscopy
The Fig. 5 illustrates the surface morphologies of microcapsules synthesised
from the different amine monomers viz. 0.0 G PAMAM, DETA and TETA at
agitation speed of 3000 rpm and optimized emulsifier system. In case of DETA and
TETA, microcapsules observed were spherical in shape having wrinkled wall
structure along with shrinkages. On the other hand spherical microcapsules with
compact, smooth wall structure was obtained in the case of PAMAM. Among the
microcapsules synthesized from DETA and TETA, comparatively less shrinkage was
observed in the case of TETA. The different chemical structures and reactivities of
amines can significantly determine unusual membrane morphologies of resultant
microcapsules. In the PAMAM based microcapsules, it is certain that a rapid reaction
occurred on the emulsion globules between PAMAM with several amino groups from
the water-soluble phase and HDI isocyanurate from the organic phase, producing a
cross linked network structure in wall membrane which tends to healthy, spherical,
elastomeric microcapsules as compared to microcapsules based on DETA and TETA.
Additionally, shell thickness of the microcapsules were 1.84, 1.68 and 1.60 µm, found
higher in the order of PAMAM> TETA >DETA. Thus the things responsible for the
shrinkages of microcapsules such as compression and shear forces, shell determined
elastic forces, etc. [31] are defeated in the case of PAMAM based system which result
into microcapsules with better membrane morphology than in case of DETA and
TETA where thinner shell thickness promoting wrinkled formation.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 84
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
Fig. 5: SEM images of polyurea microcapsules showing (a) capsules prepared from
DETA (b) capsules prepared from TETA (c) capsules prepared from PAMAM (d)
compressed capsule reflecting elastic nature which is squeezed at first after compress
but not ruptured easily (d) core-shell morphology of a capsule and (e) shell thickness
of a capsule
Chapter 3 P a g e | 85
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
3.5. Microcapsule Size and Size Distribution
The Fig. 6 represents the particle-size distribution of the polyurea
microcapsules prepared with different amine monomers. As shown in the figure,
mean diameters and particle-size distributions of the microcapsules are affected by the
different chemical structure and properties of amines used to prepare wall membranes
of microcapsules. The particle size of the samples was found to be decreased in the
order of PAMAM > TETA > DETA. The mean volume diameter of the microcapsules
prepared from PAMAM, TETA and DETA were 133.58, 54.86 and 48.76 μm
respectively.
Fig. 6: Particle size and size distribution of polyurea microcapsules from different
amines (a) DETA (b) TETA (c) PAMAM
The molecular weight and reactivity of the monomers combinely affects the
mean diameters and particle-size distribution of the microcapsules, as reported in the
previous literatures [32, 33]. The sample has many large particles than DETA and
TETA, when PAMAM was used as a monomer, which may be due to the higher
molecular weight and reactivity among the amines used, while due to not significant
Chapter 3 P a g e | 86
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
difference in reactivity and molecular weight, slight variation in the mean diameters
of the particles from DETA and TETA was observed.
3.6. Thermogravimetric Analysis
Thermal degradation profile of the extracted polyurea shell walls of
microcapsules prepared from different amines were investigated using a
thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and result are shown in the Fig. 7.
Fig. 7: TGA thermogram for shell material of microcapsules prepared from (a)
PAMAM (b) TETA and (c) DETA
Initial 2-3 % weight loss was observed in all samples from 100−170 °C which
may be associated with evaporation of solvent entrapped or trace amount of moisture
present in the shell material. The degradation observed between temperature range of
170 - 600 °C attributed to the decomposition of polyurea network and the residual
weight of each sample verified the formation of microcapsules wall membrane with
different heat resistant properties. As compared to DETA and TETA, thermal stability
Chapter 3 P a g e | 87
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
of shell in temperature range of 250- 450 °C was observed higher in case of PAMAM
with 10 % of the original mass remaining at 600 °C while only 8 % and 5 % residual
mass was observed for DETA and TETA respectively. As reported in the literature,
chemical structure of monomer such as presence of number of reactive groups and
linearity play an important role to decide the thermal performance of the material
[32]. Thus in the present work, use of PAMAM with more reactive amine groups
corresponds to higher intensities of cross linked structure in the resultant membrane
that would lead to have higher thermal stability than with other types of amines used.
3.7. Environmental Stability of Microcapsules
In order to observe the elastic strength of the prepared microcapsules, manual
compression test of single microcapsule was performed under optical microscopic
observation and results are represented in the images (Fig. 8) taken from recorded
video. In this test single selected microcapsule was drag up and down under compress
pressure. It can be noticed that the microcapsule from PAMAM exhibited good elastic
strength against applied force while comparatively the capsules from DETA and
TETA were not withstand to applied force and broken easily. Thus it can be conclude
that the strength of polymeric membrane obtained from HDI trimer and PAMAM is
as good as to make microcapsule survive during the polymer processing. Also nature
of compressed capsule reflecting elastic behavior which is squeezed first after
compress but not ruptured easily. Further in addition to the FTIR analysis, the leak out
of encapsulated fluid from single ruptured capsule during this test validated the
entrapped tung oil within the polyurea shell. The core content of the microcapsules
was found to be 68 % determined by Soxhlet extraction method (as described in
previous chapter).
Chapter 3 P a g e | 88
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
Fig. 8: Optical photographs of PAMAM based Polyurea microcapsules at different
stage when mechanically drag
In order to utilize the microcapsules in hot and humid condition, the capsules
were analyzed for hot water resistance by examining the morphology under optical
microscope. The microcapsules were stirred at 300 rpm in hot water for 3 h at 70- 80 0
C temperature and the result are shown in the Fig. 9.
Fig. 9: Optical photographs of PUa microcapsules after hot water stability (a) DETA
(b) TETA and (c) PAMAM (magnification: 10x)
Chapter 3 P a g e | 89
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
It was found that the samples from DETA and TETA shown intense
deformation with 70-80 % microcapsules and ruptured after stirred for 3 h rather in
the case of PAMAM based microcapsules, less amount of deformations were
observed and only 5-10 % microcapsules were found to be failed to withstand
surrounding environment. From these results it can be concluded that the PAMAM
based polyurea microcapsules exhibit better stability to hot water than the
microcapsules prepared from DETA and TETA.
3.8. Immersion Study
The Fig. 10 represents the results obtained from immersion test of the
prepared PU coatings embedded with 1 to 5 % PAMAM based polyurea
microcapsules. The test was performed in a salt solution since a presence of
electrolyte is one of the factors affecting on corrosion rate of metal surface [4]. It can
be seen that least corrosion was taken place with 5% loading of microcapsules after
120 h immersion in NaCl solution. On the other hand in the control sample severe
corrosion was seen in and around the scribed area. This difference in corrosion
performance of coated panels could be the result of self-healing of cracks by releasing
tung oil from ruptured microcapsules present in the path. The process of corrosion
inhibition involve filling of crack by released tung oil which protect the opened
metal surface from surrounding environment through protective film formation by
oxidative polymerization of tung oil. This newly formed material tends to responsible
for sealing of grove and protection of substrate from corrosion by avoiding the
diffusion of salt ions. The healing mechanism encompasses autonomous repairing of
the crack without providing any external assistance such as catalyst, heat, etc. In
contrast, for the sample without microcapsules metal surface was exposed to the
Chapter 3 P a g e | 90
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
environment and resulted in severe corrosion after 120 h of exposer. Hence from this
test it can be revealed that self-healing PU coating composite containg 5 % polyurea
microcapsules exhibit better anticorrosion property for steel panels tested in a salt
solution.
Fig. 10: Corrosion test results for steel panels coated with PU coatings with and
without microcapsules after 120 h
Chapter 3 P a g e | 91
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
4. Conclusions
A method for fabrication of PAMAM based polyurea microencapsule
containing tung oil via interfacial polymerization between HDI trimer and 0.0 G
PAMAM in an oil-in-water emulsion was developed. Well defined and spherical
shape microcapsules were obtained at optimal composite emulsifier system with ratio
of SDBS to PVA- 0.2/0.8. The particle size of the resultant microcapsules was found
in the range of 58-259 μm with the average diameter of 133 μm and shell thickness in
the range of 1–1.9 μm were observed. Successful encapsulation of tung oil within
polyurea shell wall was confirmed by visual observation as well as FTIR analysis.
Difference in chemical structure of amines (DETA, TETA and PAMAM) tends to
form microcapsules with different morphology, particle size, thermal and mechanical
properties. Spherical, elastomeric and healthy microcapsules with better thermal
stability and processing survivability were obtained in the case of PAMAM as
compared to microcapsules with DETA and TETA. It was found that the self-healing
coating with 5 % loading of PAMAM based microcapsules shown significant
corrosion retardancy under an accelerated corrosion test in 5 % NaCl salt solution.
5. References
(1) Samadzadeh M., Hatami Boura S., Peikari M., Kasiriha S.M., Ashrafi A. A.
review on self-healing coatings based on micro/nanocapsules. Prog. Org.
Coat. 2010, 68, 159.
(2) Stankiewicz A., Szczygiel I., Szczygiel B. Self-healing coatings in anti-
corrosion applications. J. Mater. Sci. 2013, 48, 8041.
(3) Huang M., Yang J. Facile microencapsulation of HDI for self-healing
anticorrosion coatings. J. Mater. Chem. 2011, 21, 11123.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 92
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
(4) Chaudhari A., Tatiya P., Hedaoo R., Kulkarni R. Gite V. Polyurethane
prepared from neem oil polyesteramides for self-healing anticorrosive
coatings. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2013, 52, 10189.
(5) Blaiszik B. J., Kramer S. L. B., Olugebefola S., Moore J. S., Sottos N. R.,
White S. R. Self-healing polymers and composites. Annu. Rev. Mater. Res.
2010, 40, 179.
(6) Yuan Y. C., Yin T., Rong M. Z., Zhang, M. Q. Self healing in polymers and
polymer composites. Concepts, realization and outlook: A review. eXPRESS
Polym. Lette. 2008, 2, 238.
(7) Liu X., Zhang H., Wang J., Wang Z., Wang S. Preparation of epoxy
microcapsule based self-healing coatings and their behavior. Surf. Coat.
Technol. 2012, 206, 4976.
(8) Bansode S. S., Banarjee S. K., Gaikwad D. D., Jadhav S. L. Thorat R. M.
Microencapsulation : A Review. Inter. J. Pharm. Scie. Rev. Res. 2010, 1, 38.
(9) Perignon P. C., Ongmayeb G. Interfacial polymerization versus cross-linking
microencapsulation. Bioencapsulation innovations, 2013, P8-P10.
(10) Wang R., Hu H., Liu W., He X., Guo Q. The Effect of synthesis condition on
physical properties of epoxy-containing microcapsules. J. Appl. Polym. Sci.
2012, 124, 1866.
(11) Hedaoo R. K., Tatiya P. D., Mahulikar P. P., Gite V. V. Fabrication of
dendritic 0 G PAMAM-based novel polyurea microcapsules for encapsulation
of herbicide and release rate from polymer shell in different environment. Des.
Monomers Polym. 2014, 17, 111.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 93
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
(12) Li G., Feng Y. Q., Li X. G., Gao P., Wang J., Xie J. Y. Preparation and
characterization of polyurea microcapsules containing colored electrophoretic
responsive fluid. J. Mater. Sci. 2007, 42, 4838.
(13) Tong X. M., Zhang T., Yang M. Z., Zhang Q. Preparation and characterization
of novel melamine modified poly(urea–formaldehyde) self-repairing
microcapsules. Coll. Surf. A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects, 2010, 371, 91.
(14) Li H., Wang R., Hu H., Liu W. Surface modification of self-healing
poly(urea-formaldehyde) microcapsules using silane-coupling agent. Appl.
Surf. Scie. 2008, 255, 1894.
(15) Wang R., Li H., Hu H., He X., Liu W. Preparation and characterization of
self-healing microcapsules with poly (urea-formaldehyde) grafted epoxy
functional group shell, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 2009, 113, 1501.
(16) Tatiya P. D., Hedaoo R. K, Mahulikar P. P., Gite V. V. Novel polyurea
microcapsules using dendritic functional monomer: synthesis,
characterization, and its use in self-healing and anticorrosive polyurethane
coatings. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2013, 52, 1562.
(17) Noh H. H., Lee J. K. Microencapsulation of self-healing agents containing a
fluorescent dye. eXPRESS Polym. Lette. 2013, 7, 88.
(18) Dubey R., Shami T. C., Rao K. U. B. Microencapsulation technology and
applications. Def. Scie. J. 2009, 59, 82.
(19) Wang R., Hu H., He X., Liu W., Li H., Guo Q., Yuan L. Synthesis and
characterization of chitosan/urea-formaldehyde shell microcapsules containing
dicyclopentadiene. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 2011, 121, 2202.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 94
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
(20) Brown E. N., White S. R., Sottos N. R. Microcapsule induced toughening in a
self-healing polymer composite. J. Mater. Sci. 2004, 39, 1703.
(21) Lee J. K., Hong S. J., Liu X. Characterization of dicyclopentadiene and 5-
ethylidene-2-norbornene as self-healing agents for polymer composite and its
microcapsules. Macromol. Res. 2004, 12, 478.
(22) Yuan L., Liang G., Xie J. Q., Li L., Guo J. Preparation and characterization of
poly(urea-formaldehyde) microcapsules filled with epoxy resins. Polymer,
2006, 47, 5338.
(23) Yang Z., Wei Z., Le-ping L., Si-jie W., Wu-jun L. Self-healing coatings
containing microcapsule. Appl. Surf. Sci. 2012, 258, 1915.
(24) Yin T., Rong M. Z., Zhang M. Q., Yang G. C. Self healing epoxy composites-
Preparation and effect of the healant consisting of microencapsulated epoxy
and latent curing agent. Compos. Scie. Techno, 2007, 67, 201
(25) Jadhav R. S, Hundiwale D. G., Mahulikar P. P. Synthesis and characterization
of phenol−formaldehyde microcapsules containing linseed oil and its use in
epoxy for self-healing and anticorrosive coating. J. App. Polym. Sci. 2011,
119, 2911.
(26) Samadzadeh M., Boura S., Peikari M., Ashrafi A., Kasiriha M. Tung oil: An
autonomous repairing agent for self-healing epoxy coatings. Prog. Org. Coat.
2011, 70, 383.
(27) Gite V. V., Mahulikar P. P., Hundiwale D. G., Kapadi U. R. Polyurethane
coatings using trimer of isophorone diisocyanate. J. Scient. Ind. Res. 2004,
63, 348.
Chapter 3 P a g e | 95
Ph. D. Thesis, Mr. P. D. Tatiya School of Chemical Sciences, N. M. U., Jalgaon, 2014
(28) Ghosh S. K. Self-healing Materials Fundamentals, Design Strategies, and
Applications. Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim, 2009.
(29) Gite V. V., Mahulikar P. P., Hundiwale D. G. Preparation and properties of
polyurethane coatings based on acrylic polyols and trimer of isophorone
diisocyanate. Prog. Org. Coat. 2010, 68, 307.
(30) Bagle A. V., Jadhav R. S., Gite V. V., Hundiwale D. G., Mahulikar P. P.
Controlled release study of phenol formaldehyde microcapsules containing
neem oil as an insecticide. Inter. J. Polym. Mater. 2013, 62, 421.
(31) Finken R., Seifert U. Wrinkling of microcapsules in shear flow. J. Phys.
Condens. Matter. 2006, 18, 185.
(32) Hong K., Park S. Preparation of polyurethane microcapsules with different
soft segments and their characteristics. React. Funct. Polym. 1999, 42,193.
(33) Hong K., Park S. Polyurea microcapsules with different structures: preparation
and properties. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 2000, 78, 894.