SEEK INTELLIGENCE 2006 EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION & MOTIVATION · what really makes employees tick. ......
Transcript of SEEK INTELLIGENCE 2006 EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION & MOTIVATION · what really makes employees tick. ......
SEEK INTELLIGENCE 2006EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION
& MOTIVATION
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
SEEK INTELLIGENCE: 2006 SURVEY OF EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION AND MOTIVATION IN NEw ZEALAND Have you ever wondered what New Zealand employees really think of their managers? Ever wondered what makes them leave their current jobs? In a tight employment market where demand for quality candidates outweighs supply, it is more important than ever to understand what really makes employees tick.
The fourth SEEK Intelligence ‘Survey of Employee Satisfaction and Motivation in New Zealand’ has collected responses from over 2960 participants about how they view their work.
This year’s survey included questions relating to work-life balance and the priority work takes in employees lives. Questions relating to loyalty and the key reasons why people would leave their current job have also been included to determine if any patterns are emerging. Employees were also asked to rate their own ability and whether or not they felt they could do a better job of their immediate bosses role.
The survey responses were collected from a broad online audience of employed respondents, of which 72% are looking for a new full-time job.
For the first time in the four consecutive years of the survey it appears that employees are generally happier and more secure in their jobs.
With unemployment at such historically low levels, staff attraction and retention remains an important issue for New Zealand organisations. The 2006 survey suggests that both organisational and management culture matter most to employees. Given that a high proportion of employees leave existing jobs due to poor Management, Managers in New Zealand must “walk the talk” to retain quality employees.
1
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
2006 SURVEY OF EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION AND MOTIVATION IN NEw ZEALANDTAbLE OF CONTENTS
01. ThE TOP 10 INSIGhTS 03
02. EMPLOYMENT IN NEw ZEALAND – SECURITY AND hAPPINESS 04
03. ThE GREAT NEw ZEALAND wORKPLACEThE GREAT NEw ZEALAND wORKPLACE 08
04. SATISFACTION AND MOTIVATION – LOVE & hATE 10
05. EMPLOYEE LOVES/hATES – bY INDUSTRY– bY INDUSTRY bY INDUSTRY 12
06. GREENER GRASS? CANDIDATE jOb hUNTING CONFIDENCE 15
07. MANAGEMENT �UALITIESMANAGEMENT �UALITIES 19
08. whAT ATTRACTS CANDIDATES? 21
09. RESPONDENT PROFILE 23
10. AbOUT ThE SURVEY 25
11. APPENDIX 26
Appendix 1: Chart of job security - by industry 26
Appendix 2: Chart of happiness/unhappiness - by industry 27
Appendix 3: Table of what employees love about their job - by age 27
Appendix 4: Table of what employees hate about their job - by age 28
Appendix 5: Chart of importance of factors when looking for a new job - by age 28
2
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
01. ThE TOP 10 INSIGhTS 1. The“mosthappy”employeesworkin: Insurance & Superannuation 56% HR & Recruitment 55% Construction 50% Advertising/Media/Entertainment 47% Real Estate & Property 47%
2. The“mostunhappy”employeesworkin: Legal 60% Science 49% Primary Industry 46% Consulting & Corporate Strategy 43% Banking and Finance 41%
3. OrganisationalCulture:
52% of employees do not think the company they work for rewards individual achievement.
4. Whatemployees“love”abouttheirjob: People I work with 57% Hours of work 44% Benefits and conditions 37%
5. Whatemployees“hate”abouttheirjob: Quality of management 43% Salary 41% Stress level 37%
6. Managementculture:
Employees across New Zealand score immediate managers poorly on feedback and appreciation and their ability to follow up their words with actions.
7. Themostimportantfactorswhenlookingforajob:
Quality of management 51% Career development 45% Salary 42%
8. Factorsthatmattermostinjobadverts:
Job description & responsibilities 83% Salary package 78% Experience and skill requirement 78% Benefits offered 63%
9. Jobsecurity:
Job security has increased significantly in 2006 in comparison to the previous decline in 2005. 29% of employees describe themselves as more secure in their jobs (up from 18% in 2005).
10. Happinesshassignificantlyincreasedin2006:
In 2006, 38% of employees describe themselves as Happy (up from 21% in 2006).
Lead by example and make employees feel like they are making a difference. Survey Respondent
3
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
02. EMPLOYMENT IN NEw ZEALAND – SECURITY AND hAPPINESSSATISFACTION – jOb SECURITY
Job security has increased significantly in 2006 in comparison to a decline in job security in 2005. Almost 1/3, 29% of employees across New Zealand now describe themselves as more secure in their jobs (up from 18% in 2005). A similar proportion of employees describe themselves as less secure. The main shift has been in those employees who have felt the same level of job security. 45% of employees now describe themselves as having the same level of job security (down from 56% in 2006).
EMPLOYEES ARE ThE MOST SECURE IN 2006
Jobsecuritytoday,comparedto12monthsago
2004 2005 2006
Less secure
About the same
More secure
20%
58%
22%
26%
56%
18%
27%
45%
29%
AUCKLANDERS FEEL ThE MOST SECURE
Jobsecuritybyregion
LessSecure Aboutthesame Moresecure
Auckland
Wellington
North Island – other
Christchurch
South Island – other
27%
26%
25%
25%
32%
42%
47%
47%
49%
41%
31%
27%
28%
25%
27%
National security… the research shows up regional differences in employee feelings of job security. In 2006 employees who work in Auckland feel the most secure in their job, while employees in the South Island feel most insecure in their jobs.
SATISFACTION – hAPPINESS
EMPLOYEES REMARKAbLY hAPPIER IN 2006
A positive comment from an employer is very effective and costs nothing. Survey Respondent
As opposed to 2005 where employees felt more unhappy in comparison to 2004, the opposite appears to be true in 2006. 35% of employees now describe themselves as unhappy (down from 51% in 2005). The research shows that a similar number of employees are neutral (27% compared to 29% last year). The decrease in employees feeling unhappy has resulted in a positive impact on overall happiness. 38% of employees now describe themselves as happy (up from 21% in 2005).
4
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
Happinessinthecurrentjob
2004 2005 2006
Very unhappy
Unhappy
Neutral
Happy
Very Happy
13%
31%
29%
22%
5%
16%
35%
29%
16%
5%
11%
24%
27%
27%
11%
AN ObVIOUS E�UATION
As expected, it is unhappy employees who feel the least job secure and vice versa, for happy employees who feel the most job secure.
Happinessinthecurrentjob-byjobsecurity
Lesssecure Aboutthesame Moresecure
Unhappy
Neutral
Happy
42%
24%
16%
41%
53%
38%
17%
23%
46%
ThE hAPPIEST INDUSTRY? INSURANCE AND SUPERANNUATION ThE hAPPIEST INDUSTRY
Happiness varies according to Industry. In 2006 the happiest employees are those who work in Insurance and Superannuation, while those in the Legal industry are the most unhappy.
Happy–top5 Unhappy–top5
Insurance & Superannuation
HR & Recruitment
Construction
Advert/media/Entertain
Real Estate & Property
56%
55%
50%
47%
47%
Legal
Science
Primary Industry
Consulting & Corporate strategy
Banking & Finance
60%
49%
46%
43%
41%
(For a chart of happiness by industry please refer to Appendix 2)
5
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
TENURE
NEw EMPLOYEES ARE ThE hAPPIEST
Length of tenure does not necessarily equate with happiness. It is employees who have worked for organisations for between 7-10 years who appear to be the most unhappy and those working for between 1 and 6 years the closest second. The happiest employees appear to be those who have worked for organisations for less than a year.
Happinessinthecurrentjob-bylengthofemployment
Less thana year
1 to lessthan
3 years
4 to lessthan
6 years
7 to lessthan
10 years
11 yearsand over
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Happy
DO DOLLARS bUY hAPPINESS?
MONEY ALONE CAN’T bUY hAPPINESS
It appears that employees who earn between $50,000 and $69,999 are the most unhappy. Some 37% of employees who appear in this salary range describe themselves as unhappy.
Unsurprisingly the happiest group appears to be those who earn $150,000 or more. Although at more senior levels of management where greater responsibility comes with a greater salary/package it appears the additional responsibility does not impinge on happiness.
Pay me a competitive wage and offer me better than average benefits. Survey respondent
lessthan$15,000
$15,000-$29,999
$30,000-$49,999
$50,000-$69,999
$70,000-$124,999
$125,000-$149,999
Morethan$150,000
Unhappy
Neutral
Happy
28%
35%
37%
36%
27%
37%
34%
27%
39%
37%
24%
39%
32%
25%
42%
35%
33%
31%
44%
3%
53%
6
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
ChANGES wITh AGE
YOUNG EMPLOYEES ARE ThE hAPPIEST
Happiness tends to outweigh unhappiness up until the age of 40. It appears that young employees between the ages 18-24, are the happiest. Employees aged 55+ appear to be the most unhappy.
Happinessinthecurrentjob-byage
10%
5%
0%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
less than18 years
old
18 - 24 25 - 30 31 - 39 40 - 54 55 +
Unhappy
Happy
Happiness in current job - by age
HappinessinthecurrentjobacrossNewZealand
33% 27% 40%
34% 26% 39%
32% 30% 38%
37% 26% 37%
37% 27% 36%
0 % 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
South Island – other
Wellington
Christchurch
Auckland
North Island –other
Unhappy Neutral Happy
Happiness in the current job across New Zealand
7
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
03. ThE GREAT NEw ZEALAND wORKPLACE wORKPLACEORGANISATIONAL CULTURE
“wORKPLACE CULTURE MATTERS�wORKPLACE CULTURE MATTERS�CULTURE MATTERS�
I crave for an inclusive culture, open, free thinking and innovative. Survey Respondent
Although the 2006 survey shows that companies are seen to score poorly in some key areas of organisational culture, New Zealand organisations promote cultural diversity.
Similar to 2005, companies score lowest on rewarding individual achievement. 52% of employees think that companies do not reward individual achievement (down from 63% in 2005).
Organisations score highest on employing a range of people from different cultural backgrounds. 82% of employees think that New Zealand organisations employ a range of people from different cultural backgrounds (First time question 2006).
52% of employees do not think the company they work for, rewards individual achievement.
Levelofagreementordisagreementwithstatementsaboutorganisationalculture
Stronglydisagree
Somewhatdisagree
Somewhatagree
Stronglyagree
Totalagree
My company embraces change and innovation
13% 24% 45% 18% 63%
My company encourages flexible working arrangements
15% 23% 40% 22% 62%
My company encourages employee development and training
14% 25% 38% 22% 60%
My company strives to provide a good working environment
15% 24% 41% 21% 62%
My company displays values I share
16% 28% 41% 14% 55%
My company rewards individual achievement
24% 28% 35% 13% 48%
My company employs a range of people from different cultural backgrounds*
7% 11% 36% 46% 82%
My company promotes based on merit rather than tenure (length of employment)*
16% 25% 43% 16% 59%
Overall average 15% 24% 40% 22% 62%
*First time Question 2006
8
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
65%oftheemployeeswhostronglydisagreedwitheachoftheorganisationalculturestatementswereunhappyintheircurrentjob.
Unsurprisingly given that employees are significantly happier with their jobs in 2006 in comparison to 2005 with 38% describing themselves as happy; there has been a corresponding increase in happiness for employees that strongly agreed with each organisational culture statements.
Of those employees that strongly agreed with organisational statements 62% describe themselves as happy (up from 50% in 2005) and only 17% describe themselves as unhappy (down from 23% in 2005).
In contrast to this there has been a drop in unhappiness amongst employees who strongly disagreed with the organisational culture statements. 65% of employees who strongly disagreed with organisational statements describe themselves as unhappy (down from 77% in 2005) and 13% were happy (up from 6% in 2005).
Interestingly an overwhelming majority, 78% of employees that strongly agreed with my company displays values I share describe themselves as happy. The correlation is very significant.
Thefollowingtableshowsfindingsforeachoftheorganisationalculturestatementsbyhappinessincurrentjob
Employeesthatstronglyagreewiththestatements
Employeesthatstronglydisagreewiththestatements
Happy in current job
Unhappy in current job
Happy in current job
Unhappy in current job
My company displays values I share
78% 12% 7% 74%
My company strives to provide a good working environment
47% 10% 7% 74%
My company rewards individual achievement
69% 14% 13% 62%
My company encourages employee development and training
66% 16% 12% 67%
My company embraces change and innovation
65% 28% 11% 65%
My company encourages flexible working arrangements
62% 18% 15% 61%
My company employs a range of people from different cultural backgrounds
46% 30% 23% 55%
My company promotes based on merit rather than tenure (length of employment)
65% 21% 14% 62%
Overall average 62% 17% 13% 65%
9
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
04. SATISFACTION AND MOTIVATION – LOVE & hATE whAT EMPLOYEES LOVE AbOUT ThEIR jOb
EMPLOYEES LOVE ThEIR wORK COLLEAGUES, hATE ThEIR MANAGEMENT
Good feedback is necessary in order to assist employees to feel valued and to encourage growth. Survey Respondent
Whatpeopleloveabouttheircurrentjob
0 % 1 0% 20% 3 0% 4 0% 50 % 60 %
People I work with
Hours of work
Variety and content of work
Benefits /conditions
Workplace environment
Job security
Salary
Access to training or skills development
My boss
Career development
Feedback/appreciation
Stress level
Quality of management
For the third consecutive year the top 3 most loved aspects about an employee’s job remain the
same. New Zealand employees love the people they work with most. Over half of employees, 57% love their work colleagues. 44% of employees love hours of work and 37% love both benefits and conditions and variety and content of work.
(For a table on job ‘loves’ by age, refer to Appendix 3)
10
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
whAT EMPLOYEES hATE AbOUT ThEIR jOb
Whatpeoplehateabouttheircurrentjob
Quality of management
Salary
Stress level
Feedback /appreciation
Career development
Workplace environment
My boss
Hours of work
Variety and content of work
Access to training or skill development
Benefits /conditions
Job security
People I work with
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 60%50%
For the fourth consecutive year, the quality of management is again the number one aspect employees throughout New Zealand hate the most. Almost half, 43% of employees hate the quality of overall management (down from 60% in 2005).
Salary has moved from third position in 2005 to second place in 2006.
The table overleaf highlights the differences between industries in terms of what people love and hate.
(For a table on job ‘hates’ by age, please refer to Appendix 4)
11
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
05. EMPLOYEE LOVE/hATES – bY INDUSTRY MOST INDUSTRIES EMPLOYEES LOVE ThE PEOPLE ThEY wORK wITh AND hATE ThE �UALITY OF OVERALL MANAGEMENT
Thetopfactorsthatpeopleloveandhateintheirjobbyindustry
Love Hate
Accounting
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
53%
42%
33%
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
Stress level
43%
43% 36%
Administration
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
54%
51%
37%
Salary
Quality of management
Variety and content of work
40%
37%
35%
Advertising/Media/Entertainment
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Benefits/conditions
54%
51%
37%
Quality of management
Salary
Stress level
43%
41%
35%
Banking&FinancialServices
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
56%
41%
41%
Stress level
Quality of management
Salary
52%
45%
43%
CallCentre/CustomerServices
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
62%
37%
33%
Salary
Quality of management
Hours of work
46%
44%
40%
Community&Sport
Access to training
Hours of work
Variety and content of work
59%
52%
48%
Salary
My boss
Quality of management
56%
36%
36%
Construction
People I work with
Workplace environment
Variety and content of work
48%
48%
45%
Salary
Feedback/appreciation
Quality of overall management
45%
35%
32%
Consulting&Corp.Strategy
Hours of work
People I work with
Variety and content of work
62%
53%
50%
Quality of management
Salary
Career development
42%
42%
39%
12
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
Love Hate
EducationandTraining
People I work with
Hours of work
Variety and content of work
66%
51%
47%
Stress level
Quality of overall management
Salary
45%
44%
33%
Engineering
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
52%
39%
39%
Salary
Career development
Quality of management
42%
40%
38%
Government/Defence
People I work with
Benefits/conditions
Hours of work
59%
46%
43%
Quality of management
Salary
Workplace environment
49%
40%
32%
HealthcareandMedical
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
55%
50%
46%
Salary
Stress level
Quality of management
41%
38%
38%
HRandRecruitment
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
59%
50%
43%
Salary
Stress level
Quality of management
42%
39%
34%
InsuranceandSuperannuation
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
50%
50%
50%
Stress level
Quality of management
Variety and content of work
46%
46%
38%
IT/Technical
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
58%
44%
39%
Quality of management
Career development
Feedback/appreciation
43%
40%
38%
Legal
People I work with
Hours of work
Job Security
55%
55%
35%
Salary
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
58%
48%
45%
Manufacturing/Operations
People I work with
Hours of work
Variety and content of work
53%
50%
35%
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
Career development
48%
46%
45%
13
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
Mining,OilandGas
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
63%
63 %
63%
Feedback/appreciation
Career development
My boss
67%
50%
50%
PrimaryIndustry
People I work with
Salary
Variety and content of work
50%
50%
42%
Stress level
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
61%
48%
43%
RealEstateandProperty
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
67%
60%
60%
Stress level
Feedback/appreciation
Quality of management
69%
54%
46%
Retail/ConsumerProducts
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
65%
41%
36%
Salary
Quality of management
Stress level
56%
40%
39%
Sales/Marketing
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
55%
39%
38%
Quality of management
Stress level
Feedback/appreciation
52%
39%
39%
ScienceandTechnology
People I work with
Variety and content of work
Hours of work
50%
50%
41%
Quality of management
Career development
Feedback/appreciation
55%
48%
48%
Trades/PersonalServices
People I work with
Hours of work
Workplace
53%
52%
33%
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
Stress level
47%
39%
39%
Transport/Logistics
People I work with
Hours of work
Variety and content of work
43%
42%
41%
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
Salary
47%
47%
41%
14
Love Hate
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
06. GREENER GRASS? CANDIDATE jOb hUNTING CONFIDENCELESS EMPLOYEES ThINK IT wILL TAKE ThE SAME TIME TO FIND A jOb, MORE ThINK IT wILL TAKE LESS TIME
In 2006 there has been a shift away from employees thinking it will take the same amount of time to find work. 30% of employees think it will take more time to find a job (up from 27% in 2005) and 32% think it will take less time to find a job (up from 26% in 2005).
Timetakentofindajob
2004 2005 2006
Take more time
About the same
Take less time
26%
47%
27%
27%
47%
26%
30%
38%
32%
hOw FRE�UENTLY EMPLOYEES LOOK ThROUGh jOb VACANCIES
Asignificantproportionofemployees,67%lookthroughjobvacanciesonaregularbasis
Every day At least once a week
Less thanonce a month
Once or twicea month
Every few months
I am notlooking for job
vacancies
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
In 2006, 67% of employees who completed the survey are looking through job vacancies on a daily or weekly basis. 23% are looking less frequently than weekly and only 10% describe themselves as not looking at all.
15
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
I would like a real opportunity to find work - life balance and setting goals that are aligned with my personal interests as well as the companies. Survey Respondent
Loyaltytoyourcurrentemployer
5%
18%
33%
20%
9%
16%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
I am veryhappy with my
current employer and
would not dream of changing
I would bereluctant to
move from my current
employer
I’d happily move
employer forcareer
development
I’d happilymove
employer for a better salary
I’d happilymove
employer atthe drop of a
hat
I’d happilymove
employer to beable to
achieve a better
worklifebalance
Loalty to your current employer
EMPLOYEES wOULD LEAVE ThEIR EMPLOYER FOR CAREER DEVELOPMENT
Given that career development is the second most important factor employees look for in their new job, there is no surprise that it is also the main reason why employees would happily move from their existing employer.
33% of employees would happily move employer for career development, followed by 20% who would move employer for a better salary. 16% of employees would move employer to be able to achieve a better work/life balance.
While 18% of employees would be reluctant to move from my current employer, only 5% of employees describe themselves as happy with my current employer and would not dream of changing.
The message to New Zealand companies is clear, the majority 78% of employees, would move their existing employer to fulfil career/lifestyle aspirations.
16
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
FACTORS IMPORTANT TO jObSEEKERS
�UALITY OF MANAGEMENT CAN NOT bE OVERLOOKED bY EMPLOYERS
Factorsthatareextremelyimportanttojobseekerswhenlookingforajob
Extremelyimportant
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
9
10
11
12
14
13
Quality of management
Career development
Salary
Variety and content of work
People I work with
Workplace environment
Job security
Benefits/conditions
Hours of work
Company direction and goals
Access to training or skills development
Company reputation
Low stress
51%
45%
42%
41%
39%
38%
40%
34%
34%
30%
35%
28%
22%
IMPORTANT FACTORS bY INDUSTRY
�UALITY OF MANAGEMENT, SALARY AND CAREER DEVELOPMENT MATTER MOST
Factorsthatareextremelyimportantwhenlookingforwork–byindustry
Accounting Administration
Quality of management
Salary
Career development
48%
47%
42%
Quality of management
Variety and content of work
Salary
45%
43%
43%
Advertising/Media/Entertainment Banking&FinancialServices
Quality of management
Career development
Workplace environment
46%
43%
41%
Quality of management
Career development
Salary
62%
56%
55%
CallCentre/CustomerServices Community&Sport
Quality of management
Career development
Job security
57%
56%
48%
Quality of management
Variety and content of work
Hours
48%
41%
39%
Construction Consulting&Corp.Strategy
Salary
Job security
Quality of management
56%
56%
53%
Salary
Career development
Quality of management
59%
56%
51%
17
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
Education Engineering
Quality of management
People I work with
Career development
51%
47%
47%
Quality of management
Salary
Career development
55%
45%
41%
Government/Defence HealthcareandMedical
Variety and content of work
Quality of management
Salary
52%
45%
45%
Quality of management
Job security
Benefits/conditions
53%
52%
46%
InsuranceandSuperannuation IT/Technical
Hours of work
Salary
Career development
44%
44%
39%
Quality of management
Career development
Salary
38%
40%
39%
Legal Manufacturing
Quality of management
Variety and content of work
Job security
49%
49%
46%
Quality of management
Job security
Career development
48%
44%
41%
Mining,OilandGas PrimaryIndustry
Quality of management
Job security
Hours of work
50%
50%
50%
People I work with
Quality of management
Job security
52%
50%
50%
RealEstateandProperty Sales/Marketing
Job security
Career development
Quality of management
69%
66%
60%
Quality of management
Career development
Salary
57%
51%
48%
Retail/ConsumerProducts Trades/PersonalServices
Quality of management
Job security
Career development
57%
54%
52%
Job security
Quality of management
Feedback/appreciation
56%
55%
45%
ScienceandTechnology Transport/Logistics
Career development
Access to training and skills development
Salary
59%
42%
40%
Quality of management
Salary
Feedback/appreciation
48%
47%
45%
18
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
07. MANAGEMENT �UALITIES Action should speak louder than words and regular feedback is key to successful management. Survey Respondent
whAT MANAGEMENT �UALITIES ARE MOST RESPECTED bY EMPLOYEES?
IMMEDIATE MANAGERS MUST DELIVER
In 2006, the important aspects of overall management that employees respect the most are openness and honesty and the ability to follow up their words with actions. However when employees were asked how their immediate managers performed on actually delivering these management qualities, a different picture emerged.
Immediate managers score significantly lower on actually delivering the management qualities that employees respect the most. Strong disparities exist. Employees score their immediate managers poorest on their ability to follow up their words with action and their ability to provide regular feedback.
Organisations throughout New Zealand need to look at ways they can bridge the gaps between what management qualities employees aspire to work with and the reality of how immediate managers perform in these key areas.
I think respect can be earned through Management showing leadership, while actively driving the company forward, and providing guidance and support systems that empower and make staff feel that they’re an integral and valuable asset to the company. Survey Respondent
Comparisonbetweenhowemployeesratetheirimmediatemanagerv.managementqualitiesthattheyrespect
Whatqualitiestheyrespect(1-5;least-most)
Immediatemanager(1-5;poor-excellent)
1
2
3
4
5
6
Openness and honesty
Ability to follow up their words with action
Support of their team
Ability to encourage and listen to suggestions
Leadership
Ability to provide regular feedback
4.7
4.6
4.5
4.5
4.3
4.2
3.3
3.0
3.2
3.2
3.2
3.0
19
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
Comparisonbetweenhowemployeesratetheirimmediatemanagerv.managementqualitiesthattheyrespect
Mg.qualitiestheyrespect2005(1-5least–most)
Mg.qualitiestheyrespect2006(1-5least–most)
ImmediateManager2005(1-5least–most)
ImmediateManager2006(1-5least–most)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Openness and honesty
Ability to follow up their words with action
Support of their team
Ability to encourage and listen to suggestions
Leadership
Ability to provide regular feedback
4.9
5.0
4.8
4.8
4.7
4.5
4.7
4.6
4.5
4.5
4.3
4.2
3.2
2.8
3.0
3.1
3.1
2.9
3.3
3.0
3.2
3.2
3.2
3.0
20
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
08. whAT ATTRACTS CANDIDATES? Good job description, oh and the money, that’s what I want. Survey Respondent
whAT CANDIDATES LOOK FOR
For the fourth consecutive year, employees rate the same top 3 components in job adverts as most important. Again job description and responsibilities matters the most with 83% of employees rating this as number one. Salary package and experience and skill requirement are joint second at 78% and benefits offered moves up to third place.
• Job description and responsibilities
• Salary package
• Experience and skill requirements
• Benefits offered
ImportanceofdifferentcomponentsinJobAds
Importance of different components in job ads
0 % 1 0 % 2 0 % 3 0% 4 0 % 5 0 % 60 % 7 0 % 8 0 % 90 % %1 0 0
Not Important Neutral Important
Job description and responsibilities
Salary package
Experience and skill requirements
Benefits offered
Company location
Company reputation
Industries the company operates in
Position title
Reputation of the recruiter advertising the position
3% 14% 83%
4% 18% 78%
3% 19% 78%
8% 29% 63%
8% 19% 63%
14% 30% 56%
18% 31% 51%
25% 30% 45%
37% 29% 34%
21
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
hOw CANDIDATES EXPECT TO FIND OUT AbOUT ThEIR NEXT jOb
INTERNET jOb SITES ARE ThE FAVOURITE METhOD TO FIND A NEw jOb
Howcandidatesexpecttofindoutabouttheirnextjob
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
How candidates expect to find out about their next job
Directapproach to
organisations
Internetjob site
Newspaperad
Recruitmentagency
Word of mouth (friends
or family)
Word of mouth
(businessnetwork)
2005 2006
Internet employment job sites are the main way employees choose to find out about their new job. This year’s survey shows that 86% of employees expect to find out about their next job using employment websites (up from 77% in 2005). 60% choose the newspaper (down from 66% in 2005).
22
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
09. RESPONDENT PROFILE SEEK USERS RESPONDING ARE MAINLY EDUCATED, YOUNGER PROFESSIONALS
EMPLOYMENT STATUS
The respondents to the survey are currently employed. 72% are employed on a permanent full-time basis, while the remainder, 28% are either in casual, part-time, temporary or contract arrangement.
The majority, 58% are in white collar or professional work and are between the ages 25-39. The survey represents employees with a variety of skill levels with a good representation of entry level/graduate positions, trades, unskilled workers and white collar professionals.
Worktype
Work type
Unskilled
Entry level / Graduate
Trades
White collar / professional
Managerial
Senior management
12%
20%
10%
35%
17%
6%
23
Less than 10 employees
Between 11-25
Between 26-50
Between 51-100
Between 101-500
Between 501-1000
1001+
17%
16%
12%
11%
19%
8%
17%
Sizeoforganisation
Less than a year
1 to less than 3 years
3 to less than 6 years
6 years or more
41%
35%
15%
9%
Lengthoftimeworkingforthecurrentemployer
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
‘A DEDICATED wORKFORCE’
Whichofthefollowingbestdescribesyou?
Agegroup
0 %
5 %
1 0 %
1 5 %
2 0 %
2 5 %
3 0 %
le s s than
1 8
1 8 -2 4 2 5 -30 3 1 -39 4 0 -5 4 5 5-6 5 m o re tha n
6 5
24
Which of the following best describes you?
0 % 5 % 1 0 % 1 5 % 2 0 % 2 5 % 3 0 %
At the momentmy lifestyle takes
much more priority
At the momentmy lifestyle takes
slightly more priority
At the momentneither my work or
lifestyle takes priority
At the momentmy work takes
slightly more priority
At the momentmy work takes
much more priority
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
10. AbOUT ThE SURVEYThe findings from the SEEK Intelligence 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction and Motivation In New Zealand, are based on a sample of 2960 completed responses, collected by online survey.
The survey largely represents a New Zealand audience that is online. Invitations to participate in the survey were published online on seek.co.nz, and partner sites. It is interesting to note year on year changes given that the sample is largely made up of SEEK jobseekers. Invitations to participate in the survey were also sent in an email newsletter to jobseekers registered with SEEK and alliance sites.
The sample represents both ‘active’ jobseekers who are actively looking for new employment, as well as ‘passive’ jobseekers, who are fully employed and may be browsing for new opportunities.
PEOPLEPULSE
The employee feedback in this SEEK Intelligence research report was collated by SEEK using PeoplePulse, an online research tool developed in Australia by Quinntessential Marketing Consulting. For further information on the PeoplePulse product or Quinntessential Marketing Consulting, please go to www.quinntessential.com.au/peoplepulse.htm.
AbOUT SEEK
SEEK Limited is the leader in the online employment and training market in Australia and New Zealand. SEEK is a media company that uses the Internet as its distribution channel.
SEEK manages seek.co.nz, New Zealand’s largest employment website and one of the best known Internet brands. At any one time over 15,000 employment vacancies are advertised on SEEK NZ, and more than 280,000 unique visitors are drawn to the website each month.
Online advertising enquiries can be directed to SEEK’s customer service team on 0508 733 569, or by email to [email protected].
25
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
11. APPENDIX 1.Jobsecurity-byindustry
0 % 1 0 % 2 0 % 3 0 % 4 0 % 5 0 % 6 0 % 7 0 % 8 0 % 9 0 % 1 0 0 %
Advert./Media/Entertain
Primary Industry
Trades/Personal services
Community & Sport
Real Estate & Property
Call Centre/Cust. Sevice
Administration
Engineering
Retail/Consumer products
Healthcare & Medical
IT/Technical
Sales/Marketing
Science & Technology
Manufacturing/Operations
Government/Defence
Education & Training
HR & Recruitment
Transport/Logistics
Consulting & Corp. Strategy
Legal
Banking & Fin. Services
Construction
Mining. Oil & Gas
More secureAbout the sameLess Secure
23% 41% 36%
23% 42% 35%
26% 40% 34%
38% 28% 34%
27% 40% 33%
27% 40% 33%
23% 48% 29%
32% 39% 29%
20% 51% 29%
34% 38% 28%
29% 43% 28%
26% 46% 28%
22% 51% 27%
36% 37% 27%
16% 57% 27%
33% 42% 25%
17% 58% 25%
28% 48% 24%
29% 49% 22%
23% 54% 23%
36% 42% 22%
33% 50% 17%
50% 38% 12%
26
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
2.HappinessInthecurrentjob-byIndustry
0 % 1 0 % 2 0 % 3 0 % 4 0 % 5 0 % 6 0 % 7 0 % 8 0 % 9 0 % 1 0 0 %
Insurance
HR & Recruitment
Construction
Advert./Media/Entertain
Real Estate & Property
Education & Training
Government/Defence
IT/Technical
Healthcare & Medical
Administration
Accounting
Banking & Fin. Services
Mining. Oil & Gas
Transport/Logistics
Consulting & Corp.
Engineering
Call Centre/Cust. Sevice
Trades/Personal services
Sales/Marketing
Community & Sport
Retail/Consumer products
Science & Technology
Primary Industry
Legal
More secureAbout the sameLess Secure
22% 22% 56%
25% 21% 55%
36% 14% 50%
28% 25% 47%
27% 27% 47%
25% 30% 45%
35% 20% 45%
36% 22% 42%
31% 27% 41%
33% 27% 40%
37% 23% 40%
41% 20% 39%
38% 25% 38%
35% 30% 35%
43% 22% 35%
33% 32% 35%
13% 52% 35%
33% 33% 34%
38% 28% 34%
34% 31% 34%
37% 30% 33%
49% 25% 27%
46% 27% 27%
60% 17% 23%
3.Whatemployeesloveabouttheirjobs–byage
LOVE 25 25-30 31-39 40-54 55+
People I work with
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
Variety ad content of work
Salary
Job Security
Workplace environment
Access to training or skills development
Career development
Stress Level
Feedback/appreciation
Quality of management
My boss
63%
43%
38%
26%
19%
25%
35%
24%
28%
18%
21%
13%
22%
50%
39%
38%
35%
22%
28%
34%
26%
27%
14%
19%
13%
24%
56%
46%
39%
40%
26%
25%
30%
21%
18%
16%
19%
11%
21%
56%
44%
33%
44%
27%
26%
31%
21%
13%
16%
19%
13%
21%
58%
55%
37%
50%
15%
27%
36%
20%
13%
16%
22%
16%
20%
27
2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited 2006 Survey of Employee Satisfaction & Motivation in New Zealand ©2006 SEEK Limited
4.Whatemployeeshateabouttheirjobs–byage
HATE 25 25-30 31-39 40-54 55+
Quality of management
Salary
Feedback/appreciation
Career development
Stress level
Workplace environment
Variety and content of work
Access to training or skills development
Hours of work
Benefits/conditions
Job security
People I work with
My boss
39%
50%
34%
34%
36%
29%
34%
23%
33%
21%
18%
17%
27%
43%
41%
35%
35%
37%
33%
27%
23%
27%
20%
16%
15%
26%
42%
38%
34%
36%
36%
29%
22%
26%
20%
18%
17%
13%
24%
48%
34%
39%
38%
39%
31%
19%
24%
26%
19%
22%
14%
27%
44%
39%
42%
24%
39%
28%
14%
21%
19%
16%
29%
11%
28%
5.Whatisimportantwhenlookingforanewjob–byage
Access
to tr
aining
Compan
y dire
ctions a
nd goals
Salary
Hours of w
ork
Benefits/co
nditions
Job se
curit
y
Career
Dev
elopm
ent
Low st
ress
People I w
ork w
ith
Quality
of man
agem
ent
Varie
ty an
d conte
nt
Workplac
e environm
ent
Compan
y reputa
tion
0 %
1 0 %
2 0 %
3 0 %
4 0 %
5 0 %
6 0 %
7 0 %
8 0 %
9 0 %
1 0 0 %
^25 25-30 31-39 40-54 55+
28