Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the...

54
United States Copyright Office Library of Congress · 101 Independence Avenue SE · Washington, DC 20559-6000 · www.copyright.gov Anne Marie Bowler, Esq. Gabay-Rafiy & Bowler 291 Broadway Suite 1901 New York, NY 10007 August 3, 2017 Re: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register "Solcin & Atelier 2015 Collection"; Correspondence ID: 1-1HR3ZRY; SR# 1-3114944301, 1-3134585300 Dear Ms. Bowler: The Review Board of the United States Copyright Office ("Board") has considered Monique Pean Fine Jewelry LLC's ("Monique Pean") second request for reconsideration of the Registration Program' s refusal to register jewelry design claims in two collections titled "Solcin Collection" and "Atelier 2015 Collection" (together, the "Collections"). After reviewing the applications, deposit copies, and relevant correspondence, along with the arguments in the second request for reconsideration, the Board affirms the Registration Program's denial of registration. I. DESCRIPTION OF THE WORKS The Solcin Collection contains sixty-six pieces of jewelry, including bracelets, necklaces, earrings, and rings, made up of various materials ranging from plain metals to combinations of precious gems. The Atelier 2015 Collection contains 106 pieces of jewelry, including bracelets, necklaces, earrings, and rings, all in an art deco style but similarly made up of various materials ranging from plain metals to combinations of precious gems. The Collections are depicted in Appendix A. II. ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD Monique Pean filed an application to register jewelry design claims in the Solcin Collection on February 16, 2016, and an application to register jewelry design claims in the Atelier 2015 Collection on February 20, 2016. In a March 28, 2016 letter, a Copyright Office registration specialist refused to register the claims, finding that "these particular works"- namely, all of the jewelry pieces in both collections-"lack the authorship necessary to support copyright claims" because "[c]opyright does not protect familiar symbols or designs [or] basic geometric shapes." Letter from Adrienne Brown, Registration Specialist, to Anne Marie Bowler (March 28, 2016).

Transcript of Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the...

Page 1: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

United States Copyright Office Library of Congress · 101 Independence Avenue SE · Washington, DC 20559-6000 · www.copyright.gov

Anne Marie Bowler, Esq. Gabay-Rafiy & Bowler 291 Broadway Suite 1901 New York, NY 10007

August 3, 2017

Re: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register "Solcin & Atelier 2015 Collection"; Correspondence ID: 1-1HR3ZRY; SR# 1-3114944301, 1-3134585300

Dear Ms. Bowler:

The Review Board of the United States Copyright Office ("Board") has considered Monique Pean Fine Jewelry LLC' s ("Monique Pean") second request for reconsideration of the Registration Program' s refusal to register jewelry design claims in two collections titled "Solcin Collection" and "Atelier 2015 Collection" (together, the "Collections"). After reviewing the applications, deposit copies, and relevant correspondence, along with the arguments in the second request for reconsideration, the Board affirms the Registration Program' s denial of registration.

I. DESCRIPTION OF THE WORKS

The Solcin Collection contains sixty-six pieces of jewelry, including bracelets, necklaces, earrings, and rings, made up of various materials ranging from plain metals to combinations of precious gems. The Atelier 2015 Collection contains 106 pieces of jewelry, including bracelets, necklaces, earrings, and rings, all in an art deco style but similarly made up of various materials ranging from plain metals to combinations of precious gems. The Collections are depicted in Appendix A.

II. ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD

Monique Pean filed an application to register jewelry design claims in the Solcin Collection on February 16, 2016, and an application to register jewelry design claims in the Atelier 2015 Collection on February 20, 2016. In a March 28, 2016 letter, a Copyright Office registration specialist refused to register the claims, finding that "these particular works"­namely, all of the jewelry pieces in both collections-"lack the authorship necessary to support copyright claims" because " [ c ]opyright does not protect familiar symbols or designs [or] basic geometric shapes." Letter from Adrienne Brown, Registration Specialist, to Anne Marie Bowler (March 28, 2016).

Page 2: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

Anne Marie Bowler, Esq. Gabay-Rafiy & Bowler

August 3, 2017

In a letter dated June 21 , 2016, Monique Pean filed a single request for reconsideration asking the Office to reconsider its initial refusals to register both of the Collections. Letter from Anne Marie Bowler to U.S. Copyright Office (June 21 , 2016) ("First Request"). In its letter, it argued that "the level of creativity required under the law is low, with the vast majority of works making the grade quite easily;" as such, given the creative designs of the jewelry pieces in the Collections, they "contain creative authorship." Id. at 1, 4.

After reviewing the Collections in light of the points raised in the First Request, the Office re-evaluated the claims and again concluded that the Collections "do not contain a sufficient amount of original and creative authorship to support a copyright registration," and also that "neither collection meets the requirements for registration as an unpublished collection" or "a unit of publication." Letter from Stephanie Mason, Attorney-Advisor, to Anne Marie Bowler (Nov. 22, 2016). As to originality, the Office stated that "common and familiar shapes, or minor variations thereof," and "geometrically shaped semi-precious stones and other natural material features of each design" are not copyrightable. Id. at 2. The Office thus concluded that "the elements [ of the jewelry designs] are not combined in any way that differentiates them from their basic shape and design components," and are "arranged in garden-variety configuarations," and so "they cannot rise to the level of creativity necessary for copyright registration." Id. at 3. As to the collections failing to meet the requirements for registration, the Office noted that the collections were published, and so could not be registered as unpublished collections. Further, in order to be eligible for registration as a unit of publication, "the separate elements must be physically bundled together for distribution to the public as a single, integrated unit." Id. The Office thus explained that, " [w]ith regards to jewelry, a box containing a necklace and matching earrings that is sold as a set to the public would be considered a unit of publication," whereas "[a] catalog of [a] number of separate jewelry pieces that can be purchased individually would not." Id. at 3-4. Since "the pieces of the [Collections] have not been physically bundled together and sold as a unit," they could not be registered as units of publication. Id. at 4.

In a letter dated February 21, 2017, Monique Pean requested that, pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 202.5( c ), the Office reconsider for a second time its refusals to register the Collections. Letter from Anne Marie Bowler to U.S. Copyright Office (Feb. 21 , 2017) ("Second Request"). In that letter, Monique Pean claimed that the Collections "contain sufficient creative authorship" and "satisfy the requirements for registration as a unit of publication." Id. at 1. As to the creativity of the Collections, Monique Pean stated that its designer "creatively selected, coordinated and arranged jewelry pieces to create the unique collections," having spent "months formulating and perfecting the unique designs she creates and curates as part of her collections, generally inspired from her travels." Id. at 1- 2. It argued that the Solcin Collection "contains uniquely sculpted and designed ... cuff bracelets showcasing an unusual format with a diamond suspended between the yellow gold design," among other pieces, and the Atelier 2015 Collection "was inspired by geometry and architecture." Id. at 2.

Further, Monique Pean argued that the Collections should be registered as collections of published works and that the Office' s position "is directly contradictory to the holding in Yurman

-2-

Page 3: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

Anne Marie Bowler, Esq. Gabay-Rafiy & Bowler

August 3, 2017

Studio, Inc. v. Castaneda, 591 F. Supp. 2d 471 (S.D.N.Y. 2008)," which it argued held "that jewelry collections are eligible to be registered in a single work registration" and "can be deemed a single unit of publication." Second Request at 3 (quoting Yurman Studio , 591 F. Supp. 2d at 492). Monique Pean asserted that the Compendium (Third) of U.S. Copyright Office Practices ("Compendium") does not "have the force and effect of law and [is] not binding upon the Register of Copyrights or U.S. Copyright Office staff," and may only be used "to persuade in the event there is no controlling judicial authority." Id. at 3 (internal quotations omitted). Since the Collections "were each compiled by Ms. Pean using jewelry designs she created specifically for each collection and to be released for sale at the same time," Monique Pean argued that the Collections were registrable. Id.

III. DISCUSSION

A. The Legal Framework-Unit of Publication

A unit of publication is "a package of separately fixed elements and works that are physically bundled together for distribution to the public as a single, integrated unit, and all of the works are first published in that integrated unit." COMPENDIUM (THIRD)§ 1107.1. The Compendium gives examples of the types of works that may qualify as units of publication: "a bound volume and dust jacket; a compact disc with liner notes and cover art; a multimedia kit containing a book, a compact disc, and a set of stickers; a board game; or the like." Id. The Compendium further clarifies that "the unit must contain an actual copy or phonorecord of the self-contained works"; "a box of jewelry containing an actual necklace and an actual set of earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while "a catalog that merely contains photographs of necklaces and earrings that are offered for sale" would not. Id. The works must also "be distributed to the public as an integral part of the unit." Id. In other words, " [a] unit that merely offers works to the public without distributing actual copies or phonorecords does not satisfy this requirement." Id.

The decisions relied upon by Monique Pean are based on prior Office practice, and do not reflect the Office' s current (and operative in 2015) practices related to the "unit of publication" registration option. The unit of publication option is not mandated by statute and instead was developed by the Office to make registration more efficient pursuant to the Office' s power to "establish regulations not inconsistent with law for the administration of the functions and duties made the responsibility of the Register under" the Copyright Act. 17 U.S.C. § 702. Publication of the Compendium, which sets forth Office interpretations of copyright law and provides standards for examining and registering works, is similarly an exercise of that authority. See 37 C.F.R. § 202.1; see also Varsity Brands, Inc. v. Star Athletica, LLC, 799 F.3d 468, 480 (6th Cir. 2015), aff'd, 13 7 S. Ct. 1002 (2017) (internal citation omitted) (recognizing the Compendium as an "internal manual that instructs [Office] employees who are tasked with reviewing and registering copyrights how to apply the relevant provisions of the Copyright Act uniformly"). The unit of publication construct is precisely the type of practice the Office is permitted to

-3-

Page 4: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

Anne Marie Bowler, Esq. Gabay-Rafiy & Bowler

August 3, 2017

establish and revise as needed to improve the registration process based on Office assessments of the needs of creators, while balancing those needs with the resources of the Office.

Courts regularly look to the Office's practices when assessing whether multiple works are registrable under a single application under the unit of publication option. Though the Office has revised the standards for the unit of publication option over time, courts continue to reference the Compendium when discussing these issues. See, e.g., Olander Enterprises, Inc. v. Spencer Gifts, LLC, 812 F. Supp. 2d 1070, 1075- 76 (C.D. Cal. 2011) (referencing the Compendium, noting that "the Ninth Circuit has held that courts should generally defer to the Register's interpretation of copyright statutes and regulations"); Yurman Studio, Inc. v. Castaneda, 591 F. Supp. 2d 471,494 (S.D.N.Y. 2008) (referencing Compendium when determining sufficiency ofregistration); Kay Berry, Inc. v. Taylor Gifts, Inc., 421 F.3d 199,206 n.2 (3d Cir. 2005) (noting government's interpretation that only those individual works first published in the single work will be covered by the single work registration but remanding to district court to determine in the first instance whether that interpretation presents a barrier to plaintiffs copyright registration).

B. Analysis of the Work

After carefully examining the Collections and applying the legal standards discussed above, the Board finds that the Collections may include some pieces that may possess the requisite copyrightable authorship, but the Collections themselves are not registrable as units of publication.

Though the Collections might include at least some jewelry items that may be protected by copyright law, 1 the Board finds that the Collections simply are not registrable as units of publication. Monique Pean correctly identifies case law that was previously relevant to the definition of a unit of publication. See Second Request at 3. But in the time since these cases were decided, the Office's practices developed and the Compendium was updated to reflect a current definition of unit of publication-one the Collections do not meet. Indeed, courts have recognized that the definition has changed. See, e.g., Schenck v. Orosz, 105 F. Supp. 3d 812, 820 (M.D. Tenn. 2015) ("Effective December 22, 2014, the Copyright Office issued a superseding 'Third Compendium of U.S. Copyright Office Practices, [which] contains a 'unit of publication' rule that the plaintiffs' earlier copyright registrations may not have met.").

The Compendium's example in § 1107.1 is directly applicable to the Collections. It states that "a catalog that merely contains photographs of necklaces and earrings that are offered for sale" would not be registrable as a unit of publication.2 To be registrable as a unit of

1 The Board does not here opine on whether any individual pieces in the collection are sufficiently creative to warrant copyright protection. This matter involves a claim to register under the unit of publication option, and the Board thus limits its analysis to the specific procedural issue here. 2 To be clear, such a catalog may itse lf be registrable as a literary work or two-dimensional artwork. But the registration of such a catalog would not result in registrations for all of the pieces of jewelry depicted therein.

-4-

Page 5: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

Anne Marie Bowler, Esq. Gabay-Rafiy & Bowler

August 3, 2017

publication, all of the sixty-six pieces in the Solcin Collection would have to be distributed to the public together as a bundle or set, and all of the 106 pieces in the Atelier 2015 Collection would have to be distributed to the public together as a bundle or set. Thus, even though pictures of the jewelry pieces were published together in a catalog, because the pieces themselves are distributed separately to the public, the Collections may not be considered a unit of publication, and cannot be registered as such.

Monique Pean may refile individual applications for those pieces in the Collections it deems sufficiently creative to merit copyright protection, and the Office will determine the copyrightability of each piece at that time.

IV. CONCLUSION

For the reasons stated herein, the Review Board of the United States Copyright Office affirms the refusal to register the copyright claims in the Collections. Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 202.5(g), this decision constitutes final agency action in this matter.

BY: ~=A--Copyright Office Review Board

-5-

Page 6: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

IV. CONCLUSION

For the reasons stated herein, the Review Board of the United States Copyright Office affirms the refusal to register the copyright claims in the Collections. Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 202.S(g), this decision constitutes final agency action in this matter.

BY: Catherine Rowland Copyright Office Review Board

Page 7: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

Appe~dixA .

Page 8: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MON IQUEPEAN

SOLCIN COLLECTION

Page 9: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

•.,

r,

BBWD646W

THOMSONITE , CREAM F OSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY,

FOSSILIZED D INOSAUR B ONE, C ITRINE ANO WH ITE

DIAMOND BRACELET, I BK RECYCL E D WHITE GOLD, I .59

TC W **ONE -OF -A - KIND

BBWD647Y

C REA M FOSS I LIZED WALRUS IVORY ANO WHITE D IAMOND

H I NGED BANGLE , 18 K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD , 0 .29

TCW

S O LC IN C OLLECTION

BBWD648Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALR U S IVORY AND WHITE SQUARE

CUT DIAMOND H INGED BANGLE, 18K RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD , 0 .20 TCW

BC524Y

A RCH CUFF, I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

Page 10: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

-~·o . . '

'«:

BCD569W

THOMSONITE, FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE , TREMOLITE

AND WHITE DIAMOND ARCH BRACELET , 18K RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 1.38 TCW **ON E · OF· A · KIND

BCD570Y

WH ITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE ARCH CUFF, I BK RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD, 0 .20 TCW

SOLCIN COLLECTION

BCD57 IY

WH !TE DIAMOND ARCH CUFF, I BK RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, 0 .45 TCW

BCD572W

A ZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND HINGED BANGLE, 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.29 TCW

Page 11: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

BCD57 3 W

B LACK G UATEMALAN JADE AND WHITE DIAMOND HINGED

BANGLE , I SK RECYCLED W H ITE GOLD, 0 . 29 TC W

EBW543Y

CREAM FOSS I LIZED WALRUS IVORY ARCH STUD

EARRINGS, I SK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

SOLCIN COLLECTION

EBW544Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY, WHITE SAPPHIRE

AND BLUE TOURMALINE EARR I NGS, I SK RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD

EBW545Y

CREAM FOSS I LIZED WALRUS IVORY ARC H H OOP

EARRINGS, ROUND, I S K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

Page 12: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

' EBWD60 I Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY, GREY FOSSILIZED

DINOSAUR BONE AND WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE

EARRINGS, 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD ,

0.38 TCW

l-EBWD602Y

C REAM FOSSILIZED WA L RUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

NAVETTE STUD EARRINGS, 18K RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD , 0 . 17 T CW

SOLCIN COLLECTION

E BWD603Y

GREY SUNBURST FOSSILIZED WALRUS I VORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND OVAL EARRINGS, 18K RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, 0 .6 I TC W

E BWD604Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY ANO WHITE D IAMOND

BAGUETTE EARRINGS , I SK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD,

0 .0 8 T C W

Page 13: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

EBWD605Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

OVAL EARRINGS, I SK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0 .66

TCW

EC538Y

WHITE SAPPHIRE ARCH HOOP EARRINGS, I SK RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD

SOLCIN COLLECTION

r. '

EC539R

ARCH HOOP EARRINGS , ROUND, I SK RECYCLED ROSE

GOLD

EC540Y

ARCH HOOP EARRINGS , OVAL, I SK RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD

Page 14: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUE PEAN

ECD700W

AZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND OVAL EARRINGS , 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .66 TCW

.,

G

ECD701W

GILALITE, VIVID BROWN FOSS I LIZED DINOSAUR BONE

AND WHITE D IAMOND EARRINGS, 18K RECYCLED WHITE

GOLD, 0 .26 TC W **ONE ·OF· A · KIND

SOLC I N COLLECTION

E CD702W

AZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND NAVETTE STUD

EARRINGS, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 . 17 TCW

E CD703 W

BLACK FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE AND WHITE

DIAMOND EARRINGS, I SK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.48

TC W

Page 15: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

f .

' ECD704W

B LACK GUATEMALAN JADE AND WHITE DIAMOND OVAL

EARRINGS, I S K RECYCLED WHITE GQLD, 0 .66 TCW

E PD50 I W

SUSTAINABLE GREY TAHITIAN PEARL AND WHITE

DIAMOND BAGUETTE EARRINGS, FRONT AND BACK, I SK

RECYCLED WHITE GOL D , 0.39 TC W

SOLCI N COLLECTION

NBW5 IOY

GREY SUNBURST FOSS I LIZED WALRUS IVORY ARCH

NECKLACE , 37 . 5 ', 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

NBW5 I IY

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY ARCH NECKLACE,

17 ", 18 K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

Page 16: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

NBW5 I 2 Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY RECTANGULAR

NECKLACE, 27 ' , I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

NBW5 I 3Y

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY ARCH

NECKLACE , 17 ' , IBK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

SOLC I N COLLECTION

NBWD72 8Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS I VORY ANO W H ITE D I AMOND

NECKLACE, 17', I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0.42

TCW

NBWD72 9 Y

DENORITIC AGATE, CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY

AND WHITE DIAMOND NECKLACE, 24", I S K RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD , 0 . 5 I TC W

Page 17: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

NBWD730W

SEPTARIAN , CITRINE, RUTILE , BROWN FOSSILIZED

DINOSAUR BONE, OENDRITIC AGATE , THOMSONITE ,

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY ANO WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE , 18', 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 6 .04 TCW

* *ONE -OF -A - Kl ND

NBWD73 I Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, 20' , 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0.46

TCW

SOLCIN COLLECTION

NBWD732Y

GREY SUNBURST FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY ANO WHITE

DIAMOND ARCH NECKLACE, 37 .5", 18K RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD, 0 .99 TCW

i

NBWD733Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, EAST -WEST, 17", I BK RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, 0 . 18 TCW

Page 18: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

NCD726Y

ROSE GARNET, STRIPED AGATE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE , 17', 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 2.55

TCW **ONE -OF -A - KIND

NCD727W

QUARTZ AM PH I BOLE ANO WHITE DIAMOND NECKLACE,

17' , I SK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, I .86 TCW **ONE -OF ·

A - KIND

SOLCIN COLLECTION

I

NCD728W

SEPTARIAN AND WHITE DIAMOND NECKLACE, 16.5" , I SK

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.31 TCW

NCD729W

STRIPED AGATE , RUTILE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, 24 ' , I SK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1.65 TCW

**ONE -OF - A - KIND

Page 19: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

NCD7 3 0W

GREY FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE , AZURITE , S TRIPED

AGATE AND WHITE DIAMOND NECKL ACE, 24 ' , 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 2 .08 TC W

NCD7 3 1W

GREY FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE, CREAM FOSSILIZED

WALRUS IVORY , BLACK GUATEMALAN JADE, AG ATE ,

WHITE SAPPHIRE AND WHITE D I AMOND NECKLACE, 24",

18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.96 TC W

SOLCIN COLLECTION

NCD732Y

WHITE D IAMOND BAGUETTE ARCH NECKLACE, 17 ', 18K

RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0 . 10 T C W

.t

NCD7 3 3W

l /

A ZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND NECKLACE, EAST· WEST,

17 ' , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 . 18 T C W

Page 20: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

NCD734X

GREY FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE AND BLACK DIAMOND

NECKLACE, NORTH - SOUTH, 17 ", I SK RECYCLED

OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD, 0.18 TCW

NCD735W

R UTILE, WHITE SAPPHIRE ANO WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, 17' , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .56 TCW

SOLCIN COLLECTION

N CD736W

AZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND NECKLACE , 17 ', 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .42 TCW

RBWD585 Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

NAVETTE ARCH RING , 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD,

0.58 TCW

Page 21: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

RBWD586W

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND BLACK DIAMOND

OVAL RING , 0 . 1 9 TC W

RC528Y

L UCIN RING , 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD

S O LCIN COLLECTION

J

RCD719W

SIBERIAN AZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE

NAVETTE RING , I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 . 12 T C W

RCD75 IW

A ZURITE AND WHITE DIAMOND OVAL R I NG , 18K

RECYCLED W H ITE GOLD , 0 . 1 9 TC W

Page 22: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUE PEAN

RCD752W

Q UARTZ AMPHIBOLE AND WHITE D IAMOND ARCH CAGE

RING, I S K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1 . 17 T C W **ONE ·

OF -A - KIND

RCD753Y

STRIPED AGATE AND W H ITE D IAMOND OVAL RI NG, 18K

RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD , 0 .43 TCW

S O LCIN COLLECTION

RCD754Y

TREMOLITE AND WHITE DIAMOND OCTAGONAL ARCH

RING , I SK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0 .42 T C W **ONE ·

OF ·A · KIND

i

"'• .. .., -~ .r ii ,. . -' '

_).J

RCD755W

SEPTARIAN AND WH IT E D IAMON D OVAL RING , LARGE,

I SK RECYCLED W HI TE GOLD , 0 . 3 1 TCW

Page 23: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUE PEAN

RCD7 56W

SMOKEY TOPAZ ANO WHITE DIAMOND ARCH RING, 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .84 TCW

RCD757Y

W HITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE L UCIN RING , 18K RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD , 0 .04 TCW

SOLCIN COLLEC

RCD758Y

STRAW TOPAZ AND WH ITE DIAMOND ARCH RING , 18K

RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0 .34 T C W

RCD759W

GREY FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE , WHITE DIAMOND

BAGU E TTE AN D BLACK D IAMON D NAVETTE ARCH RING,

18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .58 TC W

Page 24: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

RCD760W

GREY FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE AND BLACK DIAMOND

OVAL RING , 0 . 1 9 T C W

RCD76 IY

W H ITE DIAMOND ARCH RING , 18K RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, 0 .20 TC W

SOLC I N COLLECTION

RCD7 6 3W

RUTILE AND WHITE DIAMOND ARCH CAGE RING, 18K

RECYCLED WH !TE GOLD, I . 17 TCW

RCD766W

B LACK GUATEMALAN JADE AND WHITE DIAMOND ARCH

RING, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD , 0.34 T CW

Page 25: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

RPD5 I IW

SUSTAINABLE GREY TAHITIAN PEARL AND WHITE

DIAMOND RING, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.48 TCW

RPD5 I 2Y

SUSTAINABLE BLUE TAHITIAN PEARL AND WHITE

DIAMOND RING , 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0.48

TCW

SOLCIN COLLECTION

Page 26: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

M 0 N Q u E p E A N

ATELIER COLLECTION

Page 27: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIE R 20 15 COLLECTION

·~ -=l =a· if_ ;.~1.,;r ~ ... L J~~~ J ~···!\ ·~.

ATBACD548W

WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE AND ROSE CUT DIAMOND

BRACELET, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, I 1 .8 1 TCW

,'' ...

' I

ATBACD5 49W

~- '

GREY ROUND ROSE CUT DIAMOND AND WHITE DIAMOND

BRACELET, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 26 .79 TCW

ATBAC D 550W

I. I O CARAT WHITE HEXAGONAL DIAMOND AND WH ITE

DIAMOND PAVE LINK BRACELET, I SK RECYCLED WHITE

GOLD, I . 69 TC W

A T BACD5 5 I W

i

:~

W HITE DIAMOND TRAPEZOID BRACELET, 18K RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 3.48 T CW

Page 28: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

.-

ATBACD552W

SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND BRACELET, I BK

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1 .66 TCW

ATBACD555W

WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

HINGED OVAL BANGLE, 18 K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

1 .28 TCW

ATELIER 20 I 5 COLLECTION

ATBACD558Y

WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE AND ROSE CUT DIAMOND

BRACELET, I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 8 . 27 TCW

.,

/ I

ATBADS524R

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

BRACELET, I BK RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, 12.49 TCW

Page 29: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

ATBAD S W 523W

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE , OLIVE GREY FOSSILIZED

WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND BRACELET, 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 12 . 67 T C W

....

ATBADSW524Y

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE, GREY SUNBURST

FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

BRACELET. 18K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 6 .87 TC W

A T BADW51 0 W

GREY SAPPHIRE SLICE , VIVID BLUE AND CREAM

FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND

BRACELET, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD , 2 .87 T CW

Page 30: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

'

ATEACD616W

WHITE DIAMOND TRAPEZOID AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

EARRINGS , POST BACK, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

0 .46 TCW

ATEACD617X

BLACK ROUND ROSE CUT DIAMOND AND WHITE DIAMOND

EARRINGS , WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE POST TOP, I BK

RECYCLED OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD, 2 .63 TCW

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTI ON

D

.i ,J ,,

ATEACD618W

CHAMPAGNE ROUND ROSE CUT DIAMOND AND WHITE

DIAMOND EARRINGS, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 2 . 14

TCW

Q .

ATEACD619W

WHITE AND CHAMPAGNE ROSE CUT DIAMOND STUD

EARRINGS, I BK RECYCLED WHITE G O LD , 0 .60 TCW

Page 31: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

)

I

' J ~·. -.;_

ATEACD620W

WHITE ROSE CUT DIAMOND HOOP EARR I NGS , I BK

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 6.00 TCW

', ...

ATEACD62 I W

BLUE -GREEN TOURMALINE, GREY OIAMOND AND WHITE

DIAMOND 2 -TI ER EARRINGS , POST TOP , I BK RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 3 .90 TCW

ATELIER 20 I 5 COLLECTION

~r·

ATEACD622W

WHITE ROSE CUT DIAMOND STUO EARRINGS, 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .60 TCW

., q

'3

ATEACD623W

GREEN SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

OVAL EARRINGS, POST TOP , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

0 .87 TCW

Page 32: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

AT EACD62 3 Y

GREEN SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

OVAL EARRINGS , POST TOP, 18K RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, 0 .87 TCW

-,

ATEACD6 2 5 W

GREY ROUND ROSE CUT DIAMOND AND WHITE DIAMOND

STUD EARRINGS, I B K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1.94

TC W

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

A TEACD626X

NATURAL FANCY COLORED DIAMOND STUD EARRINGS,

18K RECYCLED OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD, I .54 TC W

' ~ .... . ~

ATEACD627W

OPAQUE GREY DIAMOND, GREY SAPPHIRE SLICE AND

WHITE DIAMOND 2 -T I ER EARRINGS, POST TOP , 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 2 .30 TC W

Page 33: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

,,

AT EACD628R

PEACH SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

EARRINGS , CROSSOVER HOO P TOP , I BK RECYCLED R O SE

GOLD, 2 .30 TC W

>,

·3

,'J .. .

ATEACD629W

GREY SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE D IAMOND 2 ·TIER

EARRINGS, I B K RECYCLE D WHITE GOLD . 0 . 17 TCW

A TELIER 2015 COLLECTION

A TEACD629Y

GREY SAPPHIRE SLIC E AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 ·TIER

EARRINGS, I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 0 . 17 TC W

,._, ... I 0 ,1

ffi t4 ) f l •:

Ct

J

ATEACD6 3 1R

CHAMPAGNE ROUND ROSE CUT DIAM O ND AND W H ITE

D IAMOND EARRINGS, I BK RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, 2 .38

T C W

Page 34: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

AT E ACD632W

7 .38 CARAT OPAQUE GREY ROUND WATERFALL CUT

DIAMOND AND WHITE D IAMOND EARRINGS, POST BACK,

I B K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 8 . IO TCW

ATEACD6 34W

I .8 5 CARAT O PAQUE GREY ROUND WATERFALL CUT AND

WHITE DIAMOND EARRINGS, POST B ACK, I BK RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 2 .03 TC W

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

.. .

'I

AT E ACD637W

W HITE SAPPHIRE AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER

EARRINGS , POST TOP, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0. 19

TC W

ATEACD6 40W

6 .00 CARAT OPAQUE GREY WATERFALL CUT DIAMOND

AND WHITE DIAMOND EARRINGS, POST BACK, I BK

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 6 .64 TC W

Page 35: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 C O LLECTION

A TEACD6 4 IR

CHAMPAGNE ROUND ROSE CUT DIAMOND AND W HITE

DIAMOND STUD EARR I NGS, 18K RECYC LED ROSE GOLD,

1 .94 TC W

ATEACD643 R

BROWN SAPP HI RE SLICE AND W H ITE DIAMOND 2 -T I ER

EARRIN G S , I BK RECYCLED ROSE GO LD, 0 . 17 TCW

A TEACD6 4 6 W

OPAQUE GREY DIAMOND AND WHI T E DIAMOND

EARRINGS , WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE POST TOP , 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 5 . 13 TC W

ATEACD647R

OPAQUE PEACH DIAMOND AND WHITE DIAMOND

EARRINGS . WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE POST TOP , I S K

RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, 3 .09 TC W

Page 36: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

A TEAD561 9 W

H EXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND STUD

EARRINGS, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD , 4.29 TC W

AT E AD5620W

KITE -SHAPED DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -

TI ER EARRINGS. POST TO P, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

6.37 TC W

ATELIER 20 I 5 COLLECTION

()

r

A T EAD562 IW

LIGHT YEL L OW KITE D IAMOND , K ITE -SHAPED DIAMOND

SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND 3 -TIER EARRINGS, POST

TOP , I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 6 . 14 T C W

ATEAD56 2 2R

KITE -SHAPED DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DI A MOND 2 -

TIER EARRINGS, POST TOP, I B K RECYCLED ROSE GOLD,

7 .6 1 TC W

Page 37: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

,,

ATEADS623W

KITE -SHAPED DIAMOND SLICE , BLUE- BLACK

TOURMALINE AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER EARRINGS,

POST TOP , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 3 .36 TCW

ATEADS624R

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

EARRINGS, I BK RECYC L ED ROSE GOLD, 3.38 TCW

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

ATEADS625R

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND STUD

EARRINGS , LARGE, I BK RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, 3 .77

TCW

ATEADS626R

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND STUD

EARRINGS, SMALL, I BK RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, I .49

TCW

Page 38: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

AT E ADS626W

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WH ITE DIAMOND STUD

EARRINGS, SMALL, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1 .49

TCW

ATEADS627Y

CONFLICT AND DEVASTATION FREE KITE · SHAPED

DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE D IAMOND 2 -TIER EARR INGS,

POST TOP , I B K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 7 .33 TC W

~

., . .. ..

. ~ 1. )("'"

A TEADS6 2 8Y

CONFLICT AND DEVASTATION FREE HEXAGONAL

DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND EARRINGS, SMALL,

I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 2 . I I TCW

ATEAWD5 3 IR

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND OVAL EARRINGS, POST TOP, I BK RECYCLED

ROSE GOLD, 0.87 TC W

Page 39: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

AT EAWD53 IW

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND OVAL EARRINGS , POST TOP , 18K RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 0 .87 TCW

A T E AWD53 IY

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE

D IAMOND OVAL EARRINGS, POST TOP, 18K RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD, 0 .87 TC W

ATELIE R 2015 COLLECTION

AT EAW D532W

GREY SAPPHIRE SLICE , GREY FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY

AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER EARRINGS, SMALL, POST

TOP , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.45 TCW

AT E AWD533W

GREY SAPPHIRE SLICE, VIV I D BLUE FOSSILIZED WALRUS

IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER EARRINGS, LARGE,

POST TOP, 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, I .34 TC W

Page 40: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

ATEAWD533 Y

GREY SAPPH I RE SLICE , V IVID BLUE FOSSILIZED WALRUS

IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER EARRINGS, LARGE,

POST TOP , I S K RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, I .34 TC W

ATEAWD535R

P EACH SAPPHIRE SLICE , LIGHT SUNBURST FOSSIL IZED

WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER EARRINGS ,

LARGE , POST TOP , I B K RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, I .34

TC W

ATECPD505X

CHAMPAGNE ROSE CUT DIAMOND, SUSTAINABLE CREAM

TAHITIAN PEARL AND WHITE DIAMOND 2 -TIER

EARRINGS, POST TOP, 18K RECYCLED OX IDIZED WHITE

GOLD , 2 .45 TC W

Page 41: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

ATNACD54 9 R

CHAMPAGNE MIXED SHAPE ROSE CUT DIAMOND

NECKLACE, 30. 5 ', I S K RECYCLED ROSE GOLD,

4 I .80 TC W

I

' ' ' '

·" · ... .,,.

_., ,. ,,,

ATNCD720W

I ;

;

;

I

" /

; I J

f

(

; , ;

I

WHITE MARQUIS ROSE CUT DIAMOND NECKLACE , I 6 ',

I S K RECYCLED WH ITE GOLD, 6 .48 TC W

ATNCD721W

WHITE MARQUIS ROSE CUT DIAMOND NECKLACE , 18 ',

18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 7 .02 TC W

l#

- .• 11

ATWCD565W

B LACK OVAL DIAMOND BEAD WRAP NECKLACE WITH TWO

WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE LINKS, 34', I S K RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD , 56 .20 T CW

Page 42: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 C O LLECTION

.... ,·

ATWCD566W

GREY OVAL D IAMOND BEAD WRAP NEC KLACE W ITH TWO

WHITE DIAM O ND BAGUETTE LINKS, 34 ', 18K RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 56 .20 TCW

' i ;

• i . ( ! ; • • I J

I l ;

' , ' I ~

~ I J

\ f

' I ! \ • f l ' i I \

, '

., • ' • '· • • .... "

I

' ·" I \ ---- ......... -. - I

' ' \ ~ .... • ' ' /

,. r · .... " .,. .. ,. -,.

ATWCD567W

WHITE MARQUIS ROSE CUT D IAMOND WRAP NECKLACE ,

37 . 5 ' , (SK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, (3 .50 TCW

. ; I \ ·, ' I I

• • ' I t ~. I \

i I

' I

I

'

' ·.

... . .... _ ..... -

.............. ,. -,,

; I

;

,,, /

r

ATWCD568W

• t ~ ; ... , ,'

' j ; I i t t

/

·' '

; I

WHITE MARQUIS ROSE CUT DIAMOND WRAP NECKLACE ,

48', (SK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 17 .28 TCW

' •• ' \. , \ . ' • \

\ \ ' • ~ . • • i

••

I! , II • • I ~

I • '111

(I •

' . .. ....

ATWCD569X

• , ' i

BLACK OVAL DIAMOND BEAD WRAP NECKLACE WITH TWO

WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE LINKS , 31 ', I SK RECYCLED

O XIDIZED WH ITE GOLD, 5 1.60 TCW

Page 43: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

\

\

ATNACD532R

S UNSTONE A ND WHITE D IAMOND NECKLACE WITH

CHAMPAGNE DIAMON D B RIOLETTE CHA I N, 18 ', 18 K

RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, 2 .05 TCW

ATNACD535W

W HITE, CHAMPAGNE AND B LACK ROSE C U T DIAMON D

O PEN COLLAR NECKLACE , 16 ' WITH 4 . 5 ' DROP, 18K

RECYC L ED WH ITE GOLD, 34 .7 6 T CW

ATELIER 20 15 COLLECTION

l ·' I

r ,J

ATNACD536W

B LACK PEAR SHAPED DIAMOND, CHAMPAGNE ROUND

ROSE CUT DIAMON D AND WH IT E DIAMON D N ECKLACE

WITH CHAMPAGNE DIAMOND BRIO L ETTE CHAIN , 18 . 5 ',

18K RECYCLED WHITE G O LD , 17 .05 TC W

• I

ATNACD53 7W

, ,

BLACK FOSS IL IZED DINOSAU R B ONE AND WHI T E

DIAMOND NECKLACE W ITH BLACK OVAL DIAMOND BEAD

CHAIN , 24', 18K RECYCLED WH ITE GOLD, 39 .52 TC W

Page 44: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

A T NAD5543Y

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE D IAMOND

NECKLACE , MEDIUM, 17.5 ' , 18K RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, I .64 TC W

j I

l J 8

j

ATNAD55 34W

I #

/ I

j I

./

YELLOW HE XAGONAL D IAMOND SLICE AND WHITE

DIAMOND NECKL ACE , 16 .75', 18K RECYCLED WHITE

GOLD, 3 .50 TC W

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

j

I i

\ j

ATNAD5534Y

YELLOW HEXAG ONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND W HITE

DIAMOND NECKLACE, 16.75', 18K RECYCLED Y ELLOW

GOLD, 3.50 TC W

ATNAD55 3 5R

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND W HITE D IAMOND

NECKLACE, LARGE, 16 .75 ' , 18K RECYCLED ROSE GOLD,

1.34 TC W

Page 45: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

':.

ATNAD5535W

.'i' >' ,> .,

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WH ITE D IAMOND

NECKLACE, LARGE , 16 .75', I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

1 .34 TCW

\ \ \

\ \ \

\ 'I. \ \ ' l

l

I C .t

I ! l I l I I

I' ;

f /

i

ATNADS536W

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, SMALL, 17' , I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

0 .93 TCW

ATNAD5536Y

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE , SMALL, 17', IBK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD,

0 .9:3 TCW

\ t

i f l /

! \ \ \ I

!

' I \ /

~ i \ i \ ,ff! .l

ATNADS537W

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, GEOMETRIC SETTING , SMALL, 17' , I BK

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, I .02 TCW

Page 46: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

L

MON

' ,, r I

p

\ ;' ·'

,, ,,

I ;·

' .,

ATNAD5537Y

HEXAGONAL DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE, GEOMETRIC SETTING, SMALL, 17", I SK

RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, I .02 TCW

\ l '

ATNAD5540X

KITE · SHAPED D IAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE WITH WHITE DIAMOND BRIOLETTE CHAIN ,

18" , 18K RECYCLED OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD, 3.87 TCW

,,, IQ U EPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECT ION

I

I

I

ATNAD554 I W

HEXAGONAL D IAMOND SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND

NECKLACE , 17 ' , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 2.28 TCW

ATNAD5542X

KITE -SHAPED DIAMOND SLICE AND WHITE D IAMOND

NECKLACE WITH A WHITE DIAMOND BRIOLETTE, 18' ,

18K RECYCLED OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD. 2.67 TCW

Page 47: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

l

,,, MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 20 I 5 COLLECTION

"

ATNADW52 IY

LIGHT SUNBURST FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND

WHITE DIAMOND GEOMETRIC OVAL NECKLACE ON

CHAMPAGNE ROUND DIAMOND BEAD CHAIN , 25 ' , I BK

RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 7 .66 TCW

.... - ,.

ATNADW5 1 IW

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY, GREY AND

BLUE SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND OVAL LINK

NECKLACE , 16 .5 ', I BK RECYCLED WH /TE GOLD, 2 .69

TCW

\ \

C

I

I

i J

A T NADW5 12 W

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY, BLACK

GUATEMALAN JADE AND WH ITE D IAMOND NECKLACE

WITH WHITE DIAMOND BRIOLETTE CHAIN, 17 ', 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1.84 TCW

l

A T NADW5 13 W

!, >

!

I

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND NECKLACE WITH GREY ROUND D IAMOND BEAD

CHAIN, 24', I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 17 .55 TC W

Page 48: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

ATNA D W514W

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY, BLACK

GUAT EMALAN JADE AND WHITE DIAMOND NEC KLAC E

WITH A WHITE DIAMOND BRIOLETTE , 17', 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0 .64 TCW

ATNADW518W

VIVID BLUE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND NECKLACE WITH BLACK OVAL DIAMOND BEAD

CHAIN, 19 .7 5 ' , 18K RECYCLED WHITE GO L D, 32.60

TC W

A TNADW5 I 9 Y

CREAM FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY NECKLACE WITH

WHITE DIAMOND PAVE ON A CHAMPAGNE ROUND

DIAMOND BEAD CHAIN , 18.2 5 ', I SK RECYCLED YELLOW

GOLD, 7 .55 TC W

_. I

ATNADW520Y

FLAWLESS BLACK SUN B URST FOSSILIZ E D WALRUS

IVO RY , BLACK GUATEMALAN JADE AND WHITE D IAMOND

NEC KLACE, 17 ', 18 K REC YC LED YEL L OW GOLD , .84

TC W

Page 49: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

A T NACD539W

WHITE DIAMOND SUSPENSION NECKLACE , 27 .5 ", 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD , 12 .24 TCW

L ATNACD5 48W

W HITE DIAMOND SUSPENSION NECKLACE , 36" , 18K

RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 16 .32 TCW

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

Page 50: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATE LI ER 20 15 COLLECTION

A T RAC D 6 IOX

CHAMPAGNE PEAR -SHAPED ROSE CUT D IAMOND AND

WHITE D IAMOND OPEN RING , EAST -WEST, I BK

RECYCLED OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD, 1 .36 TC W

ATRACD6 I IX

CHAMPAGNE PEAR -SHAPED ROSE CUT DIAMOND AND

WHITE DIAMOND OPEN R I NG, NORTH -SOUTH , 18K

RECYCLED OXIDIZED WHITE GOLD, 0 .79 TC W

ATRACD612W

W HITE D IAMOND PEAR -SHA P ED ROSE CUT DIAMOND

ASYMMETRICAL RING, I B K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 0.44

TC W

ATRACD613W

W HITE ROSE CUT DIAMOND CLUSTER R I NG, NORTH ·

SOUTH, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GO L D , I . 16 TC W

Page 51: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

r

ATRACD614W

12.90 CARAT BLACK OVAL WATERFALL CUT DIAMOND

AND WHITE DIAMOND RING, I BK RECYCLED WHITE

GOLD , I 3 .54 TCW

ATRACD6 I 5W

GREY FOSSILIZED DINOSAUR BONE AND WHITE DIAMOND

PAVE SIGNATURE RING, NORTH -SOUTH , I BK RECYCLED

WHITE GOLD, 1. 6 7 TCW

ATRACD616W

OMBRE MORGANITE AND WH ITE DIAMOND RECTANGULAR

RING, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 2. 18 TCW

ATRACD6 I 7W

WHITE DIAMOND BAGUETTE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

RECTANGULAR RING, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1.5 1

TCW

Page 52: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

, ,.

ATRACD618W

2 .27 CARAT BLACK OCTAGONAL DIAMOND AND WHITE

DIAMOND PAVE RING, I BK RECYCLED WHITE GO L D , 2 .82

TCW

ATRACD635Y

PINK SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

SIGNATURE RING , I BK RECYCLED YELLOW GOLD, 1.22

TCW

ATRACD641W

SERRA WHITE DIAMOND PAVE AND WHITE DIAMOND

BAGUETTE OPEN BAND, I SK RECYCLED WHITE GOLD,

3.95 TCW **PRICE MAY VARY BASED ON SIZE

ATRADS514R

PEACH SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WH ITE DIAMOND PAVE

SIGNATURE RING, I BK RECYCLED ROSE GOLD, 1.22

TCW

Page 53: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

MONIQUEPEAN

ATELIER 2015 COLLECTION

ATRADS5 I 5W

BLUE SAPPHIRE SLICE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE

SIGNATURE RING , I S K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 1 .22

T C W

ATRADW509W

G REY OM BR E FOSS I L IZED W AL R U S IVORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND RING , I S K RECYCLED WHITE GOLD, 2. 8 9 TC W

ATRADW5 I OW

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY AND WHITE

DIAMOND PAVE S I GNATURE R I NG , I S K R E CYCLED WHITE

GOLD, I .22 TC W

ATRADW5 IOY

GREY OMBRE FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY A ND WHITE

DIAMOND PAVE SIGNATURE RING, I SK RECYCLED

YELLOW GOLD, I . 22 TC W

Page 54: Second Request for Reconsideration for Refusal to Register ... · earrings that are sold to the public as a single, integrated unit would be considered a unit of publication" while

,, MONIQUEPEAN

MNRACD605W

2 .38 CARAT B LACK OCTAGONAL DIAMOND, WHITE

DIAMOND BAGUETTE AND WHITE DIAMOND PAVE RING,

18K R ECYC LED WHITE GOLD, 2 .88 TC W

ATRADW51 IW

A TELIE R 20 15 COLLECTION

F LAWLESS BLACK SUN B URST FOSSILIZED WALRUS IVORY

AND WHITE DIAMOND RING, 18K RECYCLED WHITE

GOLD . 2.89 TC W