Scientific Ways of Knowing Raphael’s School of Athens Image from Wikimedia CommonsWikimedia...
-
Upload
reynold-bond -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
1
Transcript of Scientific Ways of Knowing Raphael’s School of Athens Image from Wikimedia CommonsWikimedia...
Scientific Ways of Knowing
Raphael’s School of Athens Image from Wikimedia Commons
The scientific method
• State the problem
• Gather information about the problem
• Form a hypothesis
• Perform an experiment to test the hypothesis
• Record and analyze your data
• State a conclusion
Don’t scientists just always use the scientific method?
NO!
The problem is that it is pretty clear that there is not a single method that scientists use.
State the problemGather information about the problemForm a hypothesisPerform an experiment to test the hypothesisRecord and analyze your dataState a conclusionCommunicate your conclusions
Scientific Ways of KnowingInduction (or inductive logic) – Proceeding from
examples to general rules or principles
Induction leads to empirical approaches of understanding
Deduction (or deductive logic) – Using rules to understand examples
Deduction leads to theoretical approaches to understanding
Premise 1: Every horse is a mammal.
Premise 2: Every mammal has a heart.
Conclusion: Every horse has a heart.
Deductive Logic
Premise: Every horse that has ever been observed has a heart.
Conclusion: Every horse has a heart.
Inductive logic
Deduction
Given Model/Concept Expected Data
Induction
Inferred Model/Concept <- Actual Data
Deduction & Induction
Scientific Ways of Knowing
Raphael’s School of Athens Image from Wikimedia Commons
Scientific Ways of Knowing
Science’s intellectual underpinnings are philosophy.
Plato – Pointing upward, indicating that knowledge comes from pure thought, emphasizing theoretical models and a deductive approach.
Aristotle – Pointing down, indicating that knowledge comes from the world, emphasizing empirical data and an inductive approach
Image source: Wikipedia.
Francis Bacon (1561-1626)
In the 1500s, he introduced inductive logic in its modern form.
I started college at 12.
Widely attributed as the founder of British empiricism and the originator of the essay.
Image source: Wikimedia Commons.
Bacon did not do science himself. Rather, he put forward the idea of induction in his philosophical workNovum Organum.
He suggests that the success of science “all depends on keeping the eye steadily fixed on the facts of nature and so receiving their images simply as they are.”
Image source: Wikimedia Commons.
Scientific Ways of KnowingInduction -> Approach is observing (Empiricists)
1. Natural Observation – observation of natural system without manipulation
2. Experimentation – observation of natural system with manipulation
Deduction -> Approach is modeling (Theoreticians)1. Theoretical modeling –quantitative models designed to
make predictions of geometry or behavior of natural systems
Empirical Approach
Empirical approaches require that data is collected from the natural world.
Consequently, scientists are very careful about observations (something that everyone will agree on) versus inferences/interpretation (something based both on observations and an individual’s perspective).
Image removed due to copyright: Gary Larson “The Far Side” cartoon: Cavemen inside animal trap: “Shhhh, Zog!... Here come one now!! (copyright 1982) by FarWorks Inc.
Make five observations about this cartoon.
Image removed due to copyright: Gary Larson “The Far Side” cartoon: Cavemen inside animal trap: “Shhhh, Zog!... Here come one now!! (copyright 1982) by FarWorks Inc.
Make five inferences based on your observations of this cartoon.
Image removed due to copyright: Gary Larson “The Far Side” cartoon: Cavemen inside animal trap: “Shhhh, Zog!... Here come one now!! (copyright 1982) by FarWorks Inc.
Observation – Provide five observations
Inferences/Interpretations – Provide five inferences that correspond to the observations
How do we know the Earth is round?
Scientific Ways of KnowingInduction -> Approach is observing (Empiricists)
1. Natural Observation – observation of natural system without manipulation
2. Experimentation – observation of natural system wit manipulation
Deduction -> Approach is modeling (Theoreticians)1. Theoretical modeling –quantitative models designed to
make predictions of geometry or behavior of natural systems
You can see a lot just by observing.
Yogi BerraImage source: Wikipedia.
Of all discoveries and opinions, none may have exerted a greater effect on the human spirit than
the doctrine of Copernicus. The world had scarcely become known as round and complete in itself when it was asked to waive the tremendous privilege of being the center of the universe. Never, perhaps, was a greater demand made on mankind - for by this admission so many things vanished in mist and smoke! What became of our Eden, our world of innocence, piety and poetry; the testimony of the senses; the conviction of a
poetic - religious faith? No wonder his contemporaries did not wish to let all this go and offered every possible resistance to a
doctrine which in its converts authorized and demanded a freedom of view and greatness of
thought so far unknown, indeed not even dreamed of.
-J.W. Goethe
Ptolmey (85--165 C.E.), aka Claudius PtolemaeusLived and worked in Alexandria, Egypt
Ptolmey used natural observation to propose Geocentrism: The Earth is at the center of the
solar system, and the planets and the sun rotate around the Earth
For the record, Aristotle proposed this earlier.
Ima
ge
sou
rce
: Wik
ime
dia
Co
mm
on
s.
Image source: Wikipedia.
Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1543 CE)De revolutionibus orbium coelestium libri vi “Six Books Concerning the Revolutions of the Heavenly Orbs” (1543 CE)
Copernicus used natural observation to propose Heliocentrism: The sun is at the center of the solar system, and the planets and the Earth
rotate around the Sun
Imag
e so
urce
: W
ikip
edia
.
Geocentrism and Heliocentrism are both theories
Scientific theory – Systematic sets of concepts that provide explanations for observing patterns in nature. Theories provide frameworks for relating data & guiding future research. Theories change as new data become available.
Scientific hypotheses – a tentative explanation that accounts for a set of facts and can be tested by further investigation.
The colloquial use of “theory” is very different from a “scientific theory”: A everyday “theory” is a scientific hypothesis.
Geocentrism! Heliocentrism!
An anachronistic rock-em-sockem matchup.Who was right? Let’s look at the evidence!
What are the relevant observations that can be used as evidence for geocentrism
or heliocentrism?
1) The sun rises and sets every day
(each 24 hours)
2) The moon goes from fully illuminated to dark to fully illuminated every ~29 days.
Image removed due to copyright: 29 phases of the moon. Available through USNO.
3) Sun, Moon, and planets all move in a single plane in space,
called “the ecliptic”
Image source: NASA Clementine Project.
4) The Sun does not always cover the same stars in the sky. In fact,
we can divide the sky into 12 more-or-less equal parts that lie along the ecliptic. These are the
signs of the zodiacs.
It takes the sun ~365 days to make it through all the signs of the
zodiac.
Zodiac from500s (Israel)
360° panorama of the Zodiac
Image source: Wikipedia, courtesy of NASA.
Image source: Wikipedia; image credit 2005 Digital Sky LLC
5) Some planets (Mars, Jupiter, Saturn) all appear to have
retrograde motion. That means, they move general forward (east to west), but occasionally move
backward (west to east) for short periods of time.
One picture, per night, of Mars. The movement is judged by the background stars.
One last relevant observation
Image source: NASA, courtesy of Tunc Tezel.
Ptolemy’s solution: The epicycles
Planets are not attached directly to the concentric spheres themselves. Rather, planets are attached to smaller spheres (epicycles) which themselves are attached to the big, crystalline concentric spheres (deferents).
Copernicus’ solution
It is an optical illusion for planets that are further from the sun than we are.
Actually, retrograde motion is a necessary consequence of the orbits, a type of optical illusion, if you will.
http://www.astro.uiuc.edu/projects/data/Retrograde/
Ima
ge
mo
difi
ed f
rom
: W
ikip
ed
ia.
Image source: NASA, courtesy of Tunc Tezel.
Two Scientific TheoriesBoth the theories of Ptolemy and
Copernicus actually fit the available evidence- what are you going to do?
Hey, who cares who is right, at leastwe are incolor!
Image source: Wikipedia. Image source: Wikipedia.
What makes a good scientific theory?
A good scientific theory:
1) Has logical consistency - parts of it don’t contradict other parts
2) Agrees with the data3) Suggests verifiable causes that explain and predict 4) Advanced comparisons (simplicity, tradeoff of
generality and specificity, distinction between non-fatal difficulties and fatal difficulties)
Occam's RazorNamed after the English philosopher, William of
Occam (1300s).
Two or more models accurately explain the observations? No Problem!!!
Best model is the simplest one fewest assumptions/modification needed to fit the observations.
1285-1349(died in the BlackDeath)
a.k.a the Principle of ParsimonyI’m the original
KISS guy - “Keep it simple, stupid”
Image source: University of St Andrews, Scotland.
Ptolemy vs. CopernicusSo, what theory is most acceptable?
Occam says Copernicus
Won’t really know until Galileo
We have a winner!
Image source: University of St Andrews, Scotland.
Galileo Galilei (1564 – 1642)
I’m not feeling verycomfortable in thishighly starched shirt.
The resolution was provided by Galileo, using new technology.
Image from Wikimedia Commons
Ye olde telescope(refractor, for youastronomical weanies)
Image source: Wikipedia, courtesy of Michael Dunn.
Image source: Stephanie Smith, Space Telescope Science Institute.
The Ptolemaic system and the Copernican system madedifferent predictions abound the shadows on Venus.
Geocentrism Heliocentrism
Back to HeliocentrismNew technology (telescope) allowed Galileo to make
observations that are consistent with Heliocentrism and not with an Geocentrism.
Result is the Heliocentrism is adopted by scientific community.
Vindicated!(but happilyvery dead)
Image source: Wikipedia.
The list of the whole narrative:
1) Aristotle proposes theory (Geocentrism)
2) Ptolemy finds data (retrograde motion) that doesn't fit with theory
3) Ptolemy has two choices. a: propose new theory or b: modify old theory to fit new data (which he decides to do)
4) Copernicus comes up with new theory (Heliocentrism) using exactly the same data as Ptolemy.
5) Using Occam’s razor (the best solution is the simplest), Copernicus’ model is superior. The idea is resisted because of social concerns, pre-conceived assumptions, and lack of understanding of physics. Yet, the model is used because of its predictive power, but not adopted as reality.
6) New technology (telescope) allows Galileo to make observation (phases of Venus, Moons of Jupiter) that are consistent with Heliocentrism and not with an Earth-centered Universe.
7) Heliocentrism is adopted by scientists.
The scientific method
• State the problem
• Gather information about the problem
• Form a hypothesis
• Perform an experiment to test the hypothesis
• Record and analyze your data
• State a conclusion
Scientific lawsOR
Scientific hypotheses, theories
Scientific law – generalizations of observational data that describe patterns or relationships. Law change as new data become available.
Scientific hypotheses – a tentative explanation that accounts for a set of facts and can be tested by further investigation.
Scientific theory – Systematic sets of concepts that provide explanations for observing patterns in nature. Theories provide frameworks for relating data & guiding future research. Theories change as new data become available.
Did Copernicus know how big a deal this was?
Yes.
Knew about planetary motion by 1508. He did not, however, publish his book “De revolutionibus” until 1543, the year he died (and thus avoided problems).
My mommaraised nofool.
Image source: Wikipedia.
Galileo Galilei (1564 – 1642)
I’m not feeling even lesscomfortable in thishighly starched shirt.
Others were less lucky (and more outspoken) than Copernicus.
Image from Wikimedia Commons
Galileo was subject to the Inquisition, because heliocentrism was a heresy.
He was put under house arrest until his death in 1642.
But, and this is big but, it is there that he did arguable most important work and developed a whole other “way of knowing” : Experimentation
More next time!
Forget experimentation,I’ll sell my telescope oneBay and make a quick buck.
Image source: Wikipedia.