Sales Guide DGS-8000 Series Chassis Switch D-Link HQ, Feb 2011 D-Link confidential.
-
Upload
karen-bell -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
2
Transcript of Sales Guide DGS-8000 Series Chassis Switch D-Link HQ, Feb 2011 D-Link confidential.
Sales Guide
DGS-8000 SeriesChassis Switch
D-Link HQ, Feb 2011
D-Link confidential
Contents
Business Challenge
Product Overview• Hardware Overview
• High Performance and Advanced Switching/Routing Technologies
• Technology Briefing
Target Market
Product Application Guide
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Business Challenge
Minimize Network DowntimeBusiness must run continuously
Enhance Network Performance Files’ size is getting larger than before (mail’s
attachment and multi-media transmission) “Gigabit on client” pushes faster switching in
core network
Increase Network SecurityAgainst inside and outside threats
Realize Real-time Applications IP telephony and Video streaming applications
need faster response and guaranteed “QoS” level
Protect Return on Investment10GE requirement for backbone bandwidth
increase rapidly IPv6 application development
Business Challenge
Business Challenge
Premium Offerings of DGS-8000 Modular SwitchMaximized Network Uptime
• Redundant H/W design (switch fabric, power, CPU..)
• Resilient switching & routing technologies (VRRP, MSTP..)Network Performance improvement
• High port density for mission-critical wiring closets, core and distribution network requirements
• Maximum port count (384 GE copper port,192 GE SFP slots, 64 10GE SFP+ slots)Comprehensive Security
• Network access control
• Denial of service prevention
• CPU protection policyApplication Awareness
• VoIP-enabled network by multi-layer QoS classification and prioritization
• Video-enabled network by advance multicast routing and switching mechanisms
• Flexible deployment by PoE modulesReturn on Investment
• Ease of expansion to increase bandwidth and deploy mixed transmission media network
• Upgradeable to enable new applications / services
• Superior performance at affordable price
• Future-proofing IPv6 features
Business Challenge
Value Proposition
“Modular Flexibility” + ”High Density GE/10GE” + “Superior Features”.
Deploy DGS-8000 as – Core Switch of Medium Enterprise Network– Distribution Switch of Mid./Large Enterprise Network
D-Link DGS-8000 series switches deliver resilient, high performance, multilayer Gigabit and 10Gigabit connectivity, fulfilling the needs of enterprise, carrier and data center.
Business Challenge
Product Overview
DGS-8000 Hardware Overview
Scalable H/W Architecture – Flexible modular design
– 6 and 10-slot chassis models
– Switch fabric capacity up to 2.56Tbps (DGS-8010)
High Resilient H/W Design– Dual active load-sharing redundant switch fabrics
– 1+1 power redundancy
– Hot-swappable modular design
Superior Performance– Gigabit and 10-Gigabit Ethernet
– System performance up to 1,905Mpps (DGS-8010)
Power over Ethernet (PoE)– IEEE 802.3af standard PoE (up to 384 ports)
Product Overview
DGS-8006 DGS-8010
DGS-8000 highlights (compared to DES-7200) DGS-8000 Series is a 1GE/10GE non-blocking forwarding chassis-based switch
New appearance design (1)
Decreased chassis height: DGS-8006 from 21.5U to 21U (compared to DES-7206), DGS-
8010 from 14.5U to 11U (compared to DES-7210)
New Enterprise (E) and Carrier (C) series I/O Modules (2)
New CM engine boards
DGS-8000-CM1 on DGS-8006 for 80GE bandwidth for each I/O module
DGS-8000-CM2 on DGS-8010 for 80GE bandwidth for each I/O module
New power supply with power monitoring function
New fan supports speed automatic adjustment function
New temperature display and alarm function
New power management and monitoring functions for I/O modules, and permit the
power on/off control for I/O modules
Up to 160Gbps odd-direction bandwidth per slot (3)
Distributed MPLS/VPLS/IPFIX on Enterprise/Carrier I/O modules (4)
Carrier I/O modules support high capacity ACL/Routing table/MAC table
Product Overview
DGS-8000 System Capacity (compared with DES-7200)
DGS-8006 DGS-8010 DES-7206 DES07210
Total Open Slots 6 10 6 10
Slots for I/O Modules 4 8 4 8
Slots for Control Modules 2 2 2 2
PERFORMANCE
Packet Forwarding Rate 953Mpps 1.905Gpps 142Mpps 286Mpps
Fabric Bandwidth (Single/Dual) CM1:320G/640GbpsCM1:320G/640GbpsCM2: 640G/1.28TbpsCM3:1.28T/2.56Tbps
96G/192Gbps 192Gbps/384Gbps
Passive Backplane Capacity 1.28Tbps 2.56Tbps 0.8Tbps 1.6Tbps
PORT CAPACITY
10 Gigabit Ethernet (XFP/SFP+) 32 64 16 32
Gigabit Ethernet (10/100/100M) 192 384 192 384
Gigabit Ethernet (10/100/1000M) PoE
192 384 192 384
Gigabit Ethernet (SFP) 96 192 96 192
Product Overview
Highly Reliable Hardware Architecture (DGS-8006)
DGS-8006 Rear
ReplaceableFAN Modular
DGS-8006 Front
Dual Switch Fabrics
Hot Swappable I/O Modules (3,4)
Hot Swappable I/O Modules (1,2)
1+1 Redundant Power Supplies
Dimension Height: 486 mmWidth: 436 mmDepth: 500 mm
Product Overview
High Reliable Hardware Architecture (DGS-8010)DGS-8010 Rear
Eight Hot swappable I/O Modules
Replaceable FAN Modular
Dual Switch Fabrics
Dimension Height: 930mmWidth: 437mmDepth: 450mm1+1 Redundant Power Supplies
DGS-8010 Front
Product Overview
Components of DGS-8000 Series
8000-CM1• CPU Module for DGS-8006 & DGS-8010• 320G Switching Capacity
• Load sharing and wire-speed performance• Out-of-band management• 800MHz CPU• 2GB RAM
8000-CM2• CPU Module for DGS-8010• 640G Switching Capacity• Load sharing and wire-speed performance• Out-of-band Management• 800MHz CPU• 2GB RAM
Console port
USB port
10/100M out-of-band MGMT port
Product Overview
Coming soon
8000-CM3• CPU Module for DGS-8006/DGS-8010• 1.28T Switching Capacity• Load sharing and wire-speed performance• Out-of-band Management• 800MHz CPU• 2GB RAM
Planning
Components of DGS-8000 Series (Cont.)
I/O Modules: Enterprise(E) Module
8000-24TC-E12 10/100/1000 and 12 combo(10/100/1000 or GE SFP)
8000-24SC-E12 GE SFP and 12 combo
(10/100/1000 or GE SFP)
8000-48TC-E 44 10/100/1000 and 4 combo
(10/100/1000 or GE SFP)
8000-48PC-E 44 10/100/1000 PoE and 4 combo (10/100/1000 PoE or GE SFP)
8000-4XG-E4-port 10 Gigabit Ethernet (XFP)
8000-24SC2XG-E12 GE SFP and 12 combo (10/100/1000 or GE SFP) and 2 10GE XFP
Product Overview
Coming soon
8000-8XS-E8-port 10 Gigabit Ethernet (SFP+)
Components of DGS-8000 Series (Cont.)
I/O Modules: Carrier(C) Module
8000-48TC-C 44 10/100/1000 and 4 combo
(10/100/1000 or GE SFP)
8000-4XG-C4-port 10 Gigabit Ethernet (XFP)
8000-24SC2XG-C 12 GE SFP and 12 combo (10/100/1000 or GE SFP) and 2 10GE XFP
Product Overview
8000-8XS-C8-port 10 Gigabit Ethernet (SFP+)
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
8000-16XS-D 16-port 10 Gigabit Ethernet (SFP+)
8000-48XS-D48-port 10 Gigabit Ethernet (SFP+)
8000-4QXS-D4-port 40 Gigabit Ethernet (QSFP)
I/O Modules: DataCenter(D) Module
Planning
Planning
Planning
Key features of I/O modules
E Modules C Modules 7200 Modules
(HW: V3)
MAC 32K 512K 32K
IPV4hostLPM
16K12K
16K512K
8K12K
IPV6hotsLPM
8K6K
8K256K
4K6K
IP Multicast / L2 Multicast
4K/1K 4K/1K 2K/1K
ACL (ingress/egress) 2K/4K 2K/256K 1K/4K
WRED Support Support Not support
VRF 2K 2K 64
VLAN translation 16K (8Kin/8Kout) 16K (8Kin/8Kout) 768
MAC 32K 512K 32K
IPV4 hostLPM
16K12K
16K512K
8K12K
IPV6 hostLPM
8K6K
8K256K
4K6K
Product Overview
8000-ASE-IPFIX Advanced Service Engine : IPFIX module*
Planning
Components of DGS-8000 Series (Cont.)
Advanced Service Engines
Product Overview
8000-1400AC
AC Power Supply
1400Watt
8000-2000AC
AC Power Supply
2000Watt
8000-1200DC
DC Power Supply
1200Watt
You may learn how to propose the power supply for projects by using the “Power Configuration Tool” on PMD server
For 1+1 redundancy,
the type of power supply should bethe same.
Components of DGS-8000 Series (Cont.)
Product Overview
8006-FANFAN tray with 6 high-speed fans
Components of DGS-8000 Series (Cont.) FAN Tray
8010-FANFAN tray with 6 high-speed fans
Product Overview
Ventilation/Heat Dissipation Solution of the DGS-8006 & DGS-8010
Blue: Air Flow by FAN moduleGreen: Power Air Flow
Power Supply (1+1)
Integrated Hardware Redundancy
Hot Swappable I/O Modules(slot 1,2)
Slot1
AB
Control Module (1+1)
X
XPower Supply (1+1)Hot Swappable
I/O Modules(slot 3,4)
Replaceable FAN
Power Circuit Redundancy
Hardware Redundancy for most important components
Product Overview
Slot2
Slot4
Slot3
rear
Switching Technology Comparison
• Dumb Line Card without capabilities to determine switching path• All traffics MUST be processed by “Control Card”• Switching performance relies on “Control Card”• Packets always be transmitted back and forth between Control Cards and Line Cards
• Intelligent Line Card with capability to determine switching path• Synchronized switch/route information on Control Card and Line Card • Layer 2/3/4 Local on board switching capability• Fastest forwarding, near zero-wait
Centralized Switching
V.S
Distributed Switching
Legacy Catalyst 6500
HP A7500 with SA mudules
Legacy Catalyst 6500
HP A7500 with SA mudules
Product Overview
Ports
Control Card
Line Card Line Card Line Card Line Card
Drawback of Centralized Switching
All traffics MUST go through control card even traffic in/out on the same line card.
2
Route and VLAN forwarding information is stored in control card. Before sending packets, dumb line card needs to ask control card
1
Ports Ports Ports
Poor performance is resulted from waiting transmit permit while sending packets
3
Product Overview
• Distributed switching architecture– DGS-8000 consists of chassis, Control Modules, and I/O Modules.– Control Module and I/O Modules comprise
– ASIC for switching functions– CPU for management and module control
– Synchronized switch/route information on control modules and I/O modules.
– Switch/route information on I/O modules is periodically updated from the Control Module.
– L2/L3/L4 ACL/QoS intelligent switching on I/O modules– On-board crossbar fabric comes fastest switching performance.
Distributed Switching on DGS-8000
Product Overview
Dual active load-sharing CMDistributed ASIC + Crossbar Design (Ex: DGS-8006 + 2 x 8000-CM1 + 4 E/C modules)
DGS-8000 Switching Architecture
E/C Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
Backplane
E/C Module
Control Module (CM1/CM2)
(Crossbar Chip)
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
E/C Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
E/C Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
Control Module (CM1/CM2)
(Crossbar Chip)Scalable by abundantbandwidth
Non-blocking on-boardcrossbar for local
switching
Intelligent I/O ASIC provides
on-board L2/L3/L4 local switching
40G Channel
40G Channel
Product Overview
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
40G Channel
Distributed ASIC + Crossbar Design (Ex: DGS-8010 + 8000-CM3 x 2 + DataCenter I/O modules x 8)
DGS-8000 Switching Architecture (Highest Performance) *
Backplane
D Module
Control Module (CM3)
(Crossbar Chip)
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
Product Overview
80G Channel x 8
Control Module (CM3)
(Crossbar Chip)
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
D Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
80G 80G
80G Channel x 8
Future-Proofing Switching Technologies on DGS-8000
I/O Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
Backplane
I/O Module
Control Module
(Crossbar Chip)
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
I/O Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
I/O Module
ASIC ASIC
Crossbar
Control Module
(Crossbar Chip)
Ports Ports Ports Ports
Unparalleled performance - on-board local switching Unparalleled performance - inter-module switching Optimized traffic flow
Product Overview
Advance Service Engine for Investment Protection
I/O Module
ASIC ASIC
CROSSBAR
Backplane
I/O Module
Control Module
(CROSSSBAR Chip)
ASIC ASIC
CROSSBAR
I/O Module
ASIC ASIC
CROSSBAR
ASE-IPFIX
NP NP
CROSSBAR
Control Module
(CROSSSBAR Chip)
Service Integration
Flexibility
Integrates advanced service (IPFIX) engine Converging ASIC & NP (Network Processor) technology Expansibility of future needs Investment protection
Product Overview
Data Channel
Management Channel
Control Channel
Control Module
ASE Module
I/O Module
Separated channels and dedicated bandwidth for 3 planes respectively
Data Plane Protection Management Plane Protection Control Plane Protection
Right architecture for highest network stability
Separated channel design for 3 Planes
Product Overview
IPv6 to IPv4 – H/W Wire-speed Processing
IPv4
Network
IPv4 core
Network
IPv6 Network
IPv6 Network
ISATAP Tunnel
Manual Tunnel
IPv6 6to4Dynamic TunnelIPv6
IPv6 Network
IPv4 to IPv6 will experience a fairly long time of co-existence
IPv4/IPv6 Dual Support across Nodes
Accomplish Immigration from IPv4 to IPv6 Tunneling
IPv6IPv4 Data
H/W based IPv6H/W based IPv6
IPv6 NetworkIPv4NAT-PATNAT-PAT
Product Overview
DGS-8000 Hardware Architecture Advantages
Product Overview
Feature Advantage
On-board intelligent local L2/L3/L4
wire-speed switching
• Faster switching performance• Eliminating unnecessary backplane traffic• Packet-In/Packet-Out directly without Fabrics
Distributed crossbar fabric • Right architecture at reasonable cost• Lower latency• High performance
Load sharing Control Module • Both Control Module actively work together and backup each other• Better use of capital investment• Faster network convergence
Various media GE modules • Higher flexibility for network requirement
• Pay only for port type/performance required
Non-blocking forwarding for each I/O
module *
• Ultra high 160Gbps bandwidth between Control Module and each I/O module
slots. All I/O modules can run non-blocking wire speed.
• Up to 16 10GE ports per slot running at non-blocking rate, helping
enterprises migrate to 10G back bone.*
Robust control plane design • Right architecture for highest network stability
Future-proofing backplane architecture • Investment Protection
Comprehensive Enterprise-class FeaturesDGS-8000 series provides comprehensive and enterprise-class features covering Security, QoS, Resiliency to enrich your network.
Product Overview
Network Foundation Multiple-Service Security
IPv6 Routing (H/W based) BGP4+ Policy Based Route VRRP OSPF v2/v3 ECMP, WCMP ERPS & RERP (Ethernet Ring
Protection Switching ; Rapid Ethernet Ring Protection 50~200ms convergence)
Traffic Classification Advanced QoS Bandwidth Control (minimum
granularity 64Kbps) Hardware Multicast Routing (lower
latency) PIM-SM, PIM-DM
Access Control 802.1x Access Control MAC Authentication Bypass L2/3/4 Advanced ACL’s
Robust Infrastructure Anti-DDoS Attack Protocol Verification
Traffic Management CPP (CPU Protection Policy) L3 Protocol Authentication Bandwidth Rate Limiting Port Mirror / Traffic Redirect
Secure Management SNMPv3 Management SSH v2 Secure Shell Client
BW
Data Plane
I/O ModuleInterface
Control Plane
CPU RAM
CPU Protection
I/O ModuleInterface
Attack
Benefits: Stability of CPUBenefits: Stability of CPU
Feature Highlight – CPP
Product Overview
You Need to Know
Functionalities May lack of some xStack feature set (ZD, SIM, WAC, MAC, 802.1X, sFlow ). Similar function but with different term (CPP vs Safeguard), & different behavior Similar term but with different behavior (IMPB) Longer response time for new feature request
User Interface Incomplete MIB support currently (future upgradable) Web UI support in the future Cisco like command, same as DES-7200 , but won’t be 100% the same with DGS-6600
CLI
Product outlook Different outlook with existing/future D-Link business switches
Product Overview
Product Application Guide
Product Application Guide
Campus Network
Rich access option FE,GEUnmgm, Smart, Mgm, xStack switches
Rich aggregation option
DGS-3120, DGS-34/3620
Rich WLAN option
Standalone/ Unified APWireless Switching
Unique Solution on DV6
E2ES, Unified WLAN, NetDefendOptions of core
Low cost: DGS-6600
HA: DGS-8000
DGS-6604 Modular resiliency VRRP, ERPS 428.57 Mpps throughput
DGS-8006 Modular resiliency VRRP, ERPS 477 Mpps throughput
DGS-6604 Modular resiliency VRRP, ERPS 428.57 Mpps throughput
DGS-8006 Modular resiliency VRRP, ERPS 477 Mpps throughput
DGS-8010 Modular resiliency Fiber aggregation Advance IP route 953Mpps throughput
Large LAN(Fortune
500)
Core Aggregation Wiring-closet
DGS-3420, DES-3528/52 L2/3/4 ACL 8 priority queues Advance security
DGS-3620 L3 series 10GE uplinks Fiber/Copper aggregation VRRP resiliency Advance IP route
DGS-6604 Function-completed GbE/PoE/Secu./QoS Investment Protection
Mid/Large LAN
Small/Mid LAN
DGS-3420 Function-completed GbE/PoE/Secu./QoS Investment Protection
DGS-3420 L2+ series 10GE stacking Fiber/Copper aggregation Static routing
DGS-3120, DES-3028/52 L2/3/4 ACLAdvance security
Featu
res
, Fu
nct
ions,
Sca
labili
tyProduct Application Guide
DGS-8000 Advantages HA by dual CPU engines High performance with advanced distributed switching architecture Advanced features ( ERPS, IPv6 Routing, BGP, MPLS )
10GbE Fiber Trunks
Building
Building
Building
DGS-8006
Core Switch
xStack Edge
Switches
DGS-8006
DGS-8006
10GbE Fiber Trunk
InternetInternetxStack
Edge Switches
xStack Edge
Switches
Computing Center
DGS-8010
10GbE Ring
Product Application Guide
Competitive Comparison and Analysis
Art of War Competition with Cisco Catalyst 6500/6500E
Competition with HP Procurve A7500
Competition with HP Procurve E8200zl
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Compete against Cisco Modular Switches- Catalyst 6500 At a Glance
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
• Catalyst has five products, they are:
› 6503
› 6506
› 6509
› 6509-NEB
› 6513Catalyst 6500
C6509
C6509-NEB
C6503
C6513
C6506
Series Chassis
configuration
Switching capacity Performance Deployment
Catalyst 6500
series
6503 3-slot
6506 6-slot
6509 9-slot
6509NEB 9-slot
vertical
6513 13-slot
32G shared bus Supervisor Engine 32:
15Mpps (Centralized)
Wiring Closet
256G switch fabric Supervisor Engine 2: up to
210Mpps (SFM+DFC)
Enterprise distribution,
data centre and WAN edge
720G switch fabric Supervisor Engine 720: up
to 400Mpps (DFC)
Enterprise core and WAN
distribution
DFC-Distributed Forwarding Card (a daughter card on interface modules)SFM-Switch Fabric Module
Catalyst 6500 Line Card / Supervisor Index
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Performance Sup32 Sup2 Sup720
Forwarding Mode Super Engine Super Engine Distribute (1) Super Engine Distribute (2)
Forwarding
Performance
15 Mpps 30 Mpps 210 Mpps 48 Mpps 400 Mpps
Data Path 32G Bus 256G
Fabric
256G
Fabric
720G
Fabric
720G
Fabric
(1) DFC daughter card is needed on each interface module for distributed forwarding with Sup2(2) DFC3 daughter card is needed on each interface module to achieve sustained 400Mpps for
distributed forwarding with Sup720 DGS-8000 is corresponding to C6500 with SUP720 and DFC3
Catalyst 6500 Line Card Performance
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Line Cards TypeEngine Type
Switching Mode
PerformanceNeeded DFC card on the Line Card
Slot limitation
WS-X67xx: X6724 has single 20G channel; others have 2*20G channel
SUP720
Centralized 30Mpps/System -Only 9-13 slots have dual channel on C6513
dCEF72048Mpps/Card26Mpps/X6724
DFC3x
WS-X68xx: 2*8G channel
SUP720 dCEF256 24Mpps/Card DFC3x
WS-X65xx: single 8G channel + 32G BUS
SUP720dCEF256 15Mpps/Card DFC3x No limitation
Centralized 30Mpps/System -
SUP32 Centralized 15Mpps/System Not support No limitation
WS-X64xx/X63xx/X61xx: 32G BUS
SUP720Centralized
15Mpps/SystemNot support No limitation
SUP32 15Mpps/System
Catalyst 6500 1st Generation System (32G Share Bus)
Supervisor Engine
Classic Line Cards
All packets are processed by supervisor. VLAN/Route information is stored here.
No Switching Fabric, No dedicated
bandwidth for line card
Even traffics on the same card, the classis line card still sends packets to Supervisor Engine
PFC MSFC
Bottlenecks. i.e. 48-port GE line, but only total 32G shared bus for data transmission. Before sending packets, line card needs confirmation from Supervisor Engine.
32Gbps Shared
Bus
Interface Line Card
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Interface Line Card
Interface Line Card
Interface Line Card
Fabric Line Card
DistributedFabric Line Card 32 Gbps
SharedBus
32 GbpsShared
Bus
Supervisor Engine 2
Catalyst 6500 2nd Generation System (256G SFM)
15Mpps
PFC MSFC
Classic
Classic
CEF256 (WS-65xx)
dCEF256 (WS-65xx)
dCEF256 (WS-68xx)
8Gbps
8Gbps
256GbpsSwitchFabric Module
256GbpsSwitchFabric Module
Dual 8GbpsDistributedFabric Line Card
30Mpps for centralized switching
Without DFC card, the switching performance of the whole system is only 30Mpps.
Classic cards work on shared bus
Legacy centralized switching
On-board local switching supported by this expensive card.
Under redundancy mode, it needs to consume 4 slots. (dual Sup-2 & SFM)
CEF256(ws-65XX)
There are two types of connectors on the CEF256 module. Cross bar and Shared bus connectors. CEF256 works under shared bus if SFM is not installed in Chassis. Cisco just waste your investment.
Shared Bus Connector
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Interface Line Card
Interface Line Card
Fabric Line Card
DistributedFabric Line Card 32 Gbps
SharedBus
32 GbpsShared
Bus
Supervisor Engine 720
Catalyst 6500 3rd Generation System (Supervisor 720)
15Mpps
PFC MSFC
Classic
Classic
CEF256 (WS-65xx)
dCEF256 (WS-65xx)
dCEF720 (WS-67xx)
8Gbps
8Gbps
IntegratedFabric
720Gbps400Mpps
IntegratedFabric
720Gbps400Mpps
Dual 20GbpsDistributed
CEF Fabric Line Card
30Mpps for centralized switching
Hardware IPv6 30Mpps is the limitation of PFC.
On-board local switching supported by this expensive card.
Classic cards work on shared bus
Without DFC card, the switching performance of the whole system is only 30Mpps.
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Compete against Cisco-DGS-8010 vs. Cisco Catalyst 6509/6513
D-Link DGS-8010 Cisco 6509 / 6513
Open Module Slots 8 8 / 12
Switching Architecture Distributed Switching Distributed (SUP2 + DFC, SUP720 +DFC3)Centralized (SUP32, SUP2/SUP720 without DFC)
Switch Fabric Performance 2.56Tbps 1.4T
Packet Forwarding Rate 1,905Mpps 15M(SUP32)30M (SUP2 with SFM)Up to 210M (SUP2 with SFM & DFC)Up to 450M (SUP 720)
Maximum GE Ports 384 385 / 577
Maximum 10 Gigabit Ports 64 130 / 194
Super VLAN Yes No
Protocol-based VLAN Yes No
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
CISCO-6500: Switching Capacity Calculation - engine
switching channels
full duplex switching bandwidth per channel
Bidirectional
• It is stated that Sup720 has 720G switching bandwidth which is
calculated as the following algorithm:
• 18×20G×2 = 720Gbps
• Due to hardware architecture, one 20G channel is for internal use. Only 17 channels can be used by users.
• Currently, only three interface modules (WS-67xx) can fully make use of dual 20G fabric channel to 720G SFM.
• Abundant Interface modules (WS-65xx and WS68xx) are only one or two 8G channels to 720G SFM, such that utilization of bandwidth is very low.
Catalyst6500 series
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
CISCO-6500: Switching capacity calculation - chassis
C6513 switching capacity: 40G1 * 2 * 5 + 20G2 * 2 * 7 + = 680Gbps2
C6509 switching capacity: 40G1 * 2 * 8 = 640Gbps
C6506 switching capacity: 40G1 * 2 * 5 = 400Gbps
C6504 switching capacity: 40G1 * 2 * 3 = 240Gbps
C6503 switching capacity: 40G1 * 2 * 2 = 160Gbps
Sup720 provides uni-directional 40G (dual 20Gbps) per slot
Competitive info:1.With dual engines, chassis switching capacity needs to minus 80Gbps (the engine occupies one more slot)
2. Switching capacity of engine (720G) Switching capacity of the chassis (listed above)
*Switching capacity of chassis means summation of all slots bandwidth
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Note1: Bandwidth of WS-X67xx (dual channels)Note2: 2-8 slots only have single channel on C6513
Analysis: CISCO-6500 throughput - chassis
With SUP32, the whole chassis only reaches 15Mpps (equals to 20Gbps bi-directional,
10Gbps uni-directional):• Support up to 1G x 10 with line rate
• Support up to only 10G x 1 with line rate
• SUP32 is only suitable for Wiring Closet, or FE to desktop
Claimed SUP720 switching capacity (WS-SUP720 & WS-SUP720-3B): 400Mpps
Real SUP720 switching capacity (if with C6509): :• C6509 with one SUP720 and maximum 8 slots for service, also consider GE x 2 on
engine:
• 48Mpps * 8 + 1.4881Mpps * 2 = 387Mpps
• If dual engines are configured, the chassis throughput is: 342Mpps
• And above calculation is based on line cards with DFC3!
Why does not C6500 propagate throughput to the whole chassis
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
The real throughput is not as claimed 400Mpps
X65xx line card, with DFC3 daughter card, throughput is 15Mpps
(equals to 10Gbps uni-directional)• Support up to 10 GE ports at line rate
• None of X65xx GE line cards is line rate
X67xx line card, with DFC3 daughter card, throughput is 48Mpps
(equals to 35.8Gbps unidirectional)• Support up to 32 GE ports at line rate; 48*GE or 4*10GE line card are not line rate,
• 24*GE line card (X6724) only have 17*GE line rate
• None of X67xx line cards is line rate
X68xx line card, with DFC3 daughter card, throughput is 24Mpps
(equals to 17.9Gbps unidirectional)• Support up to 16 GE ports at line rate
• Only X6816 of X68xx can be line rate, the only line rate card of CISCO GE line cards
Why does not C6500 propagate line rate ability
Analysis: CISCO-6500 throughput – line card
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Competition With Cisco Catalyst 6500
How to compete with Cisco 6500/6500E
Cisco 6500 Backplane design with 32G share bus increases possibility of single point of
failure
Cisco 6500 SUP32 can not work with C6513
Cisco 6500 SUP2 and 256G SFM occupy at least 2 slots in chassis, port density is not
competitive
Customers’ switching bandwidth is smaller than publicized 720G by Sup720
Cisco 6500 can offer up to 400Mpps throughput only in case of Supervisor Engine 720, WS-
67xx interface card, and DFC3 card
Cisco 6500 SUP720 can work with WS-65xx/68xx interface modules, but only one 8G or
dual 8G channels available, utilization of bandwidth is low
If classic 6500 interface module exists in SUP2 or SUP720 chassis, only 15Mpps throughput
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Compete against HP -DGS-8000 vs. HP ProCurve A7500
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Number of slots 4 3 5 8 8 (vertical) 12
Switch Fabric Slots 2 1 2 2 2 2
I/O Module Slots 2 2 3 6 6 8
Feasible Fabric Modules
•A7502 Management Module
•A7503 Fabric Mod with 24 GbE Ports
•All A7500 Fabric Mod 384
•All A7500 Fabric Mod 384
•All A7500 Fabric Mod 384
•All A7500 Fabric Mod 384
•A7510 Fabric Mod 768
Switching capacity (bps)
192G 144G 480G 768G 768G 768G/1152G
Packet forwarding capability (pps)
143M 107M 274M 488M 488M 488M/714M
A7502
A7503
A7506
A7506-V
A7510
A7503-S
Compete against HP -DGS-8000 vs. HP ProCurve A7500
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Fabric Engine
A7502 Managemen
t Module (For A7502
only)
A7503 Fabric Mod with 24
GbE Ports(For A7503-S
only)
A7500 Fabric Mod
384 Lite
A7500 Fabric
Mod 384
A7500 Fabric Mod
384 Advanced
A7500 Fabric Mod 384 w/12 SFP
A7500 Fabric Mod
384 w/2 10GbE XFP
A7510 Fabric Mod
768(For A7510
only)
Switching capacity
(bps)192G 240G 384G 384G 384G 384G 384G 768G
Interface No 24 SFP No No No 12 SFP 2 10GbE XFP No
L3 Forwarding
Yes Yes No * Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
MPLS/MCE No No No NoYes
(12G bi-directional)
No No No
CPU/Control Engine Type
* It relies on I/O modules to forwarding L3 traffic ; one SC module or all EA mudules required.
Compete against HP -DGS-8000 vs. HP ProCurve A7500
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Access Module (SA)
Standard Module (SC)
Advanced Module (EA)
Extended Module (SD)
Enhanced Module(EB)
Distributed forwarding
• Support L2 distributed forwarding
• Support L2 , L3 distributed Forwarding
• Support L2 /L3 /MPLS distributed Forwarding (IPv4 only)
• Support L2 /L3 /MPLS/ VPLS distributed Forwarding
• Support L2 /L3 /MPLS/ VPLS distributed Forwarding
• Support BFD
L2 / L3 table Mac : 8KIPv4: 512
Mac : 32KIPv4: 12K
Mac : 128KIPv4: 128K
NA NA
IPv6 Hardware Forwarding
No support Support No support Support Support
MPLS No support No support Support No support Support
Port Type • 48 PoE
• 48 FX SFP
• 48 FE PoE
• 8 SFP+
• 2 XFP
• 2 XFP + 24 SFP
• 2 XFP + 24 Tx
• 12/24/48 SFP
• 24 SFP with 8 combo Tx
• 48 PoE
• 40 PoE + 8 SFP
• 24 Tx
• 1 XFP
• 12 SFP• 2/4 /8 XFP
• 2 XFP + 24 SFP
• 48 SFP
• 24 SFP with 8 combo Tx
• 48 GE PoE
• 2/4 XFP
• 48 SFP
• 24 SFP with 8 combo Tx
I/O module Type
Compete against HP -DGS-8006/8010 vs. HP ProCurve A7500
D-Link DGS-8006/8010 HP ProCurve A7506 HP ProCurve A7510
Open Module Slots 4/8 6 10
Switching Architecture Distributed Switching Distributed Switching Distributed Switching
Switch Fabric Performance(Dual Engine)
1.28T/2.56Tbps 768Gbps 768Gbps/1152Gbps(Fabric 768/ Fabric 384)
Packet Forwarding Rate 953M/1,905Mpps 488Mpps 492Mpps/720Mpps(Fabric 768/ Fabric 384)
Maximum GE Ports 192/384 288 480
Maximum 10 Gigabit Ports 32/64(non-blocking forwarding)
48 (1.66:1 blocking rate)+ 4 (Engine)
48 (1.66:1 blocking rate)+ 4 (Engine)
Queuing schedule Method SP, DRR, WRR, SP+DDR, SP+WRR
SP, WRR, SP+WRR SP, WRR, SP+WRR
MSRP (Chassis+PWRx2+CPUx2+48G +24G SFP + 10Gx4)
USD 62,323/ USD 63,217 USD 64,882 USD 79,532
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Competition With HP ProCurve A7500
How to compete with HP chassis DGS-8000 can support up to 160G bandwidth per slot, but HP A7500 only supports up to
48G bandwidth per slot and has poor performance in the status below: Without Fabric Mod 768, HP A7510 can’t reach 1,152G bps and will have low
performance .
Ex: With one engine and Fabric Mode 384, A7503E/A7506E can support 24G channel per slot; but A7510E only supports 12G channel per slot)
HP A7503-S uses low cost chassis and supervisor engine (Only 12G channel per slot)
DGS-8000 Line cards support L2/L3/MPLS/VPLS/IPFIX/IPv4/IPv6 and up to 8x 10GE ports per line card*. But for HP A7500 line cards:
SA can’t support L3/MPLS forwarding SC can support L3 distributed forwarding but can’t support MPLS forwarding EA can support L3/MPLS distributed forwarding but can’t support IPv6 hardware
forwarding Only SD/EA/EB can compete with DGS-8000. But SD only has maximum 8-port 10GE
(1:2 blocking rate) and no MPLS support; EA only has 1-port 10GE and does not support IPv6; EB only has 4-port 10GE.
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Competition With HP ProCurve A7500
How to compete with HP chassis DGS-8000 supports BFD for static route/OSPF/VRRP. But for HP A7500, only EB cards
support BFD
HP A7500 Fabric Mod 384 Lite can’t support L3 forwarding. Even using two fabric cards, it cannot run continuous forwarding when one fabric card crashes because the L3 table in line cards must be refreshed.
HP A7500 uses sFlow and Netstream for packet sampling. sFlow and Netstream has poor sampling performance. Netstream is not an international standard. DGS-8000 supports IPFIX which has better performance than sFlow. (When IPFIX is in use, suggest to adopt 8000-ASE-IPFIX)
DGS-8000 uses new DRR (Deficit Round Robin) for scheduling which can handle packets of variable size without knowing their mean size. HP A7500 only supports WRR (Weighted Round Robin) which can not differentiate the video, voice or data packets.
DGS-8000 has more competitive price then HP A7500, especially for A7510 with Fabric Mod 768 engine.
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
FansFabric Modules
I/O Modules
1+1 Switch Fabric• 288 10/100/1000• 12 slots for I/O Modules (half size)• 692 Gbps Backplane
HP ProCurve 8212zl
Compete against HP -Drawback of HP ProCurve E8200zl
Drawback Highlights Although HP provide the low cost for pre-configured bundles. The total cost for HP
8212zl is still a little higher. (see next page) HP ProCurve E8200zl Series switches do not support some features for advanced
application, such as BGP, Policy-based routing, Ring Protection, DHCP Server etc. HP ProCurve E8200zl Series switches does not support dynamic IPv6 routing
protocols.
I/O Modules
ManagementModules
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Compete against HP -DGS-8010 vs. HP ProCurve E8200zl
D-Link DGS-8006/8010 HP ProCurve 8206zl/8212zl
Open Module Slots 4/8 6/12 (Half-size, which equals to 3/6 full-
size)
Switching Architecture Distributed Switching Distributed Switching
Switch Fabric Performance 1.28T/2.56Tbps 496.3G/692Gbps
Packet Forwarding Rate 953M/1,905Mpps 369.6M/428Mpps
Maximum GE Ports 192/384 144/288
Maximum 10 Gigabit Ports 32/64 24/48
BGP Adv. Routing Support Included No
MPLS/VRF Support Yes No
Fast Ring Convergence RERP, ERPS No
IPv6 Routing Support RIPng, OSPF v3, PIM-SM6, PIM-DM6, PIM-SSM6
No
Competitive Comparison & Analysis
Competition With HP ProCurve E8200zl
How to compete with HP ProCurve E8200 chassis
HP 8212zl series only provides 993.6Gbps switching capacity ; DGS-8006 series can
provide up to 1.28T bps .
HP 8200zl series only have 28.8Gbps from modules to backplane. It has high blocking
rate for 4-port 10G modules.
Many advanced features are missing like BGP Policy-based routing, Ring Protection,
DHCP Server etc.
You can easily spec HP chassis out in truly core application because its limited S/W
functions.
E8200zl is positioned in between D-Link DES-7200 & DGS-8000. For feature
competition, use DGS-8000. For price competition, use DES-7200.
Competitive Comparison & Analysis