Rocky Mountain Farmers Union v. Goldstene 1 EDCA 09-2234

8/3/2019 Rocky Mountain Farmers Union v. Goldstene 1 EDCA 09-2234

1/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;(;;(lt(?;;


2/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;953?(>95>? #@LD\

{ijy`funba| p{bhy`jfuie k~ eidiaefau Lf`ndb{anf Fn{ [i|by{li Kbf{e #LF[K. ub nhp`ihi6

p{btn|nba| bd Lf`ndb{anf F||ihk`~ Kn``


3/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;953?! Uci @LD\ zf| ei|njaie ub {ieyli Lf`ndb{anf| eipiaeiali

piu{bìyh fae ub |unhy`fui fae uci p{beylunba fae y|i bd fùi{afunti, bz(lf{kba dyi`| na Lf`ndb{anf

LF[K,Dnaf` \ufuihiau bd [if|ba| #D\B[. fu 59:7 D\B[ fu 546 #Bai bd uci gi~ fetfaufji| bd u

@LD\!!!n| ucfu nu {ieyli| by{ eipiaeiali ba db{inja bn`!.! Na p{ipf{naj uci @LD\, LF[K neiaundn

|iti{f` nhpflu| uci {ijy`funba zbyè cfti, nal`yenaj=

(lt(?;;


4/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;! LF[K i|unhfuie ucfu yaei{ uci @LD\, WyXp ub injcuiia li``y`b|nl iucfab` fae |ns lb

iucfab` p`fau| lbyè ki kynù Wna Lf`ndb{anfX k~ ;?;? znuc f ubuf` faayf` lfpflnu~ bd 6!; kn``nba jf``ba|

D\B[ fu 56>! Uci i|unhfuie lfpnuf` nati|uhiau db{ uci|i aiz ky|nai||i| n| fpp{bsnhfui`~ %3

kn``nba!!! D\B[ fu 5;?! LF[K i|unhfui| ucfu uci @LD\ zn`` {ieyli ihn||nba| d{bh uci u{fa|pb{ufun

|ilub{ k~ fkbyu 64 hn``nba hiu{nl uba| na ;?;?! LF[K,Nanunf` \ufuihiau bd [if|ba| #N\B[. fu I\(

Uci @LD\ {ijy`fui| u{fa|pb{ufunba dyi`| ucfu f{i |bè, |ypp`nie, b{ bddi{ie db{ |fì na Lf`ndb{an

fae fa~ pi{|ba, zcb f| f {ijy`fuie pf{u~!!!n| {i|pba|nkì db{ f u{fa|pb{ufunba dyi` na f lfìaef{ ~if{

@LD\ >953?!6#f.! Lf`ndb{anf| @LD\ dbly|i| ba uci lf{kba nauia|nu~ bd dyi`| ub i|unhfui ihn||nb

{i`fuie ub f dyi`| ndil~lì, nal`yenaj JCJ| ihnuuie zcia uci dyi` n| isu{fluie, {idnaie, fae u{fa|pb{u

ub Lf`ndb{anf! Nu i|ufk`n|ci| enddi{iau |ufaef{e| db{ jf|b`nai fae eni|i` dyi`|, fae p{btnei| db{ f j{fey

nhpìhiaufunba bd uci dyi` |ufaef{e| db{ kbuc, znuc f jbf` ub {ieyli uci lf{kba nauia|nu~ bd dyi` k~ 6?

k~ uci ~if{ ;?;?! \ii @LD\ >953;#k., #l.! Uci @LD\ {ivyn{i| p{btnei{| ub lbhp`~ znuc {ipb{un

{ivyn{ihiau| zcnlc bk`njfui ucih ub neiaund~ db{ dyi`| |bè b{ nhpb{uie naub Lf`ndb{anf, uci u~pi bd dyi

zciuci{ uci dyi` n| kìaeie, fae uci dyi`| p{beylunba p{bli||! _{btnei{| f{i {ivyn{ie ub lf`ly`fui u

lf{kba nauia|nu~ bd iflc dyi` lbhpbaiau! [ieylunba| na uci fti{fji lf{kba nauia|nu~ zi{i hfaefu

ub kijna na ;?66, znuc uci {ieylunba {ivyn{ihiau nal{if|naj uc{byjc uci ~if{ ;?;?! Dyi` p{btnei{| h

hiiu lf{kba nauia|nu~ |ufaef{e| k~ kìaenaj bz(lf{kba iucfab` naub jf|b`nai b{ ky~naj l{ienu| jiai{fu

d{bh fabuci{ dyi` p{btnei{ ucfu cf| l{ienu|!

"""

5

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;;


5/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;96! Uci @LD\ lbaufna| ab {ivyn{ihia

ucfu enlufui uci isflu lbhpb|nunba bd lbhp`nfau u{fa|pb{ufunba dyi`|! D\B[ fu 55;! Uci @LD\ ebi| a|iuWX f dyi` |ufaef{e, fae nu ebi| abu i|ufk`n|c fa~ hbub{(ticnlì |pilndnlfunba|! D\B[ fu 5, 55

F jf``ba bd iucfab` hfei d{bh lb{a j{bza fae p{bli||ie na uci Hnezi|u zn``, yaei{ fhnl{b|lbpi b{ buci{ faf`~unlf` eitnli, bbg neiaunlf` na iti{~ hfui{nf` zf~ ub f jf``ba bdiucfab` p{bli||ie d{bh |yjf{ lfai j{bza na K{f}n`! Kbuc |fhpì| bd iucfab` zn`` cftiuci |fhi kbn`naj pbnau, uci |fhi hbìly`f{ lbhpb|nunba, uci |fhi bzi{ fae yppi{ nhnu|bd d`fhhfkn`nu~na buci{ zb{e|, kbuc zn`` cfti neiaunlf` pc~|nlf` fae lcihnlf` p{bpi{uni|kilfy|i kbuc p{beylu| lba|n|u bd 6??) iucfab`! Ba uci buci{ cfae, lb{a iucfab` d{bhuci Hnezi|u zn`` cfti enddi{iau lf{kba nauia|nu~ ucfa uci |yjf{ lfai iucfab` d{bh K{f}n`!

N\B[ T(


6/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;(lt(?;;


8/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;9534#l., #e.! Yaei{ uci

hilcfan|h|afhie Hiucbe ;F fae Hiucbe ;K na uci @LD\f dfln`nu~ hf~ |cbz ucfu nu cf| hb

iddnlniau ivynphiau b{ y|i| lìfai{ iìlu{nlnu~ ub jfna fa naentneyf`n}ie lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi! Yae

uci|i hiucbe|, f dfln`nu~ hf~ f`|b p{bpb|i nu| bza pfuczf~! _{beyli{| zcb|i iai{j~ y|i efuf f

enddi{iau d{bh uci tf`yi| y|ie na uci eiti`bphiau bd uci dyi` pfuczf~| b{ p{beyli{| zcb|i p{bli

eitnfui| |yk|ufaunf``~ d{bh ucfu bd uci pfuczf~| {ip{i|iauie na WUfkì 4X lfa p{bpb|i ucin{ bza pfuczf

fllb{enaj ub Hiucbe| ;F fae ;K! D\B[ fu 9?3!

LF[K |ykhnu| ucfu ub efui, 55 Hnezi|u lb{a iucfab` dfln`nuni| cfti {ijn|ui{ie db{ pfuczf~|

Ufkì 4, znuc ;9 naenlfunaj ucfu uci~ lfa p{beyli iucfab` bzi{ ucfa uci ;?6? kf|i`nai f||njaie na Ufk

4! Dnti Hnezi|u lb{a iucfab` dfln`nuni| cfti fpp`nie yaei{ Hiucbe ;F fae Hiucbe ;K, znuc f ubuf`

;; pfuczf~|, f`` bd zcnlc uiaufunti`~ cfti kiia j{fauie f {funaj `bzi{ ucfa uci tf`yi db{ uci ;?

kf|i`nai db{ ucfu pfuczf~! Hb{ibti{, ub efui, uc{ii dfln`nuni| ucfu f{i Hnezi|u7 E{~ Hn``, E{~ EJ\, A

cfti fpp`nie yaei{ Hiucbe ;F db{ fa naentneyf`n}ie lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi, fae uiaufunti`~ cfti ki

jntia f tf`yi `bzi{ ucfa uci ;?6? kf|i`nai db{ Lf`ndb{anf jf|b`nai!

"""

3

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;;


9/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;9534#k.#;.#F.#;.#f.#nn.! Nd f {ijy`fuie pf{

hiiu| ucfu ky{eia, ucia uci CLNLB zbyè vyf`nd~ db{ uci eidfyù lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi| kf|ie

bti{f`` fti{fji|! D\B[ fu ;5! Nd abu, ucia uci fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ d{bh p{beylunba fae u{fa|pbbd uci l{yei zbyè cfti ub ki y|ie!Ne! _`fnaundd| abui ucfu Lf`ndb{anf l{yei bn` p{beylie y|naj uci{h

iacfalie bn` {ilbti{~ p{bli||i| #UIB[. n| uci ba`~ CLNLB ucfu vyf`ndni| db{ uci eidfyù fti{f

lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi|! D\B[ fu ;;!

K~ lbau{f|u, isn|unaj CLNLB|fae f`` buci{ isn|unaj l{yei |by{li| ucfu zi{i znucna uci ;??

Lf`ndb{anf kf|i`nai hnsf{i f||njaie f |najì fti{fji kf|i`nai LN tf`yi! @LD\ >9534#k.#;.#F.7 D\B

fu ;

LF[KBK fae eni|i` dyi` {ijf{eì|| bd uci fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ bd p{beylnaj b{ u{fa|pb{unaj uc

|pilndnl l{yei bn` y|i, b{ uci |pilndnl {idnai{~ bpi{funba|! D\B[ fu ;9534#k.#;.#F.#6.!

Yaei{ ucn| {ijnhi, Eidiaefau| fehnu ucfu uci y|i bd aiz |by{li| bd CLNLB zbyè p{bey

eidnlnu|, hfgnaj nu ya`ngi`~ ucfu Lf`ndb{anf zn`` |ii f |njandnlfau nal{if|i na aiz CLNLB y|i! Fllb{en

ub Eidiaefau|, uci @LD\ zf| ei|njaie ub en|lby{fji ihi{jnaj CLNLB y|i, |nali fa nal{if|i na CLNLB

zbyè ki lbyaui{p{beylunti ub uci @LD\ bkmilunti| ub {ieyli JCJ ihn||nba|! \lcinkì Eil`!, 33(>

L{ienu| hy|u lbhi d{bh bzi{ lf{kba fùi{afunti| ub piu{bìyh, uci eiti`bphiau bd zcnlc n| uci p{nhf

bkmilunti bd uci @LD\!Ne!

Uci Afunbaf` _iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| f{jyi ucfu uci @LD\ u{ifu| l{yei bn` d{bh Lf`ndb{anf hb

dftb{fk`~ ucfa l{yei bn` d{bh byu|nei bd Lf`ndb{anf na uzb {i|pilu|! Dn{|u, _`fnaundd| f{jyi ucfu uci @LD

en|l{nhnafui| fjfna|u ihi{jnaj l{yei |by{li| bd CLNLB k~ u{ifunaj ucih ì|| dftb{fk`~ ucfa CLNL

d{bh Lf`ndb{anf! \ilbae, uci @LD\ {ivyn{i| ucfu f`` isn|unaj l{yei |by{li| ki f||njaie uci |fhi lf{k

nauia|nu~ tf`yi itia ucbyjc, fllb{enaj ub Eidiaefau|, CLNLB d{bh Lf`ndb{anf cf| f cnjci{ lf{kb

nauia|nu~ ucfa buci{ `bz lf{kba nauia|nu~ l{yei bn`| d{bh F`f|gf fae db{inja lbyau{ni|! Na kbuc lf|i

uci Afunbaf` _iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| |ykhnu, uci @LD\ p{btnei| i|| dftb{fkì u{ifuhiau db{ l{yei b

d{bh byu|nei Lf`ndb{anf fae d{bh db{inja lbyau{ni|!

"""

6?

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;;


11/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;

Ln{! ;??3.! Ucn| Lby{u hf~ abu ufgi myenlnf` abunli, cbziti{, bd eblyhiau| dn`ie znuc fa fehnan|u{fun

fjial~ ub p{bti uci u{yuc bd uci lbauiau| bd uci eblyhiau|! Uci lbhhiau| hfei k~ ucn{e pf{uni| ucfu f

nal`yeie na uci N\B[ b{ D\B[ f{i |ykmilu ub cif{|f~ bkmilunba|, fae eb abu {n|i ub uci cnjc eij{ii

naen|pyufkn`nu~ {ivyn{ie db{ myenlnf` abunli db{ ucin{ u{yuc! Mi|pi{|ia t! Cf{{fc| Bpi{funaj Lb!, 5

D!uc Ln{! ;??4. #lnunaj Die! [! Itne! ;?6 fetn|b{~ lbhhnuuii| abui.! Nd lnuie, uci

|ufuihiau| hf~ ki lba|nei{ie db{ ucin{ isn|uiali, kyu abu ucin{ u{yuc! Ne! Na feenunba, ucn| Lby{u ufg

myenlnf` abunli bd pyk`nl {ilb{e| abu |ykmilu ub {if|bafk`i en|pyui! \ii Ciaai||~ t! _ia{n` Efuflbh

Aiuzb{g|, Nal!, 4> D!(lt(?;;


12/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;(lt(?;;


19/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;? Y!\! 44, :

#6>3>.! Uci @LD\ jnti| Lf`ndb{anf| CLNLB dftb{fkì u{ifuhiau k~ f||njanaj nu uci kf|i`nai fti{f

lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi, f tf`yi ucfu n| |yk|ufaunf``~ bzi{ ucfa nu| fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ |lb{i7 ab buc

CLNLB| {ilinti ucn| dftb{fkì u{ifuhiau! Na feenunba, zcn i Lf`ndb{anf| UIB[ kiaidnu| d{b

fpp`nlfunba bd uci kf|i`nai fti{fji, f`` buci{ isn|unaj l{yei |by{li| f{i f||njaie cnjci{ lf{kba nauia|n

tf`yi| ucfa uci fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi| db{ ucb|i l{yei|! Kf|ie ba uci ei|nja fae p{flunli iddi

bd uci @LD\, ucn| Lby{u dnae| ucfu nu tnb`fui| uci Lbhhi{li L`fy|i kilfy|i uci Lbhhi{li L`fy

db{kne| en|l{nhnafunba, zciuci{ db{uc{njcu b{ najianby|! Zi|u @~aa L{ifhi{~, 96; Y!\! fu ;?6 #vybun

Ki|u $ Lb! t! Hfszi``, 5?..!

Uci en|l{nhnafub{~ ei|nja bd uci @LD\ dftb{fkì u{ifuhiau bd Lf`ndb{anf| UIB[ f| lbhpf{

ub buci{ CLNLB| fae buci{ isn|unaj l{yei |by{li| tnb`fui| uci Lbhhi{li L`fy|i itia ucbyjc uc

en|unalunba| e{fza fppif{ ub ki aiyu{f ! NaKfllcy|, uci \yp{ihi Lby{u fee{i||ie f |nhn`f{ |nuyfunb

F Cfzfnnfa |ufuyui isihpuie uzb f`lbcb` p{beylu| d{bh f ;?) isln|i ufsbgbìcfb fae pnaifpp

znaikyu ene abu isihpu buci{ W`Xblf``~ p{beylie |fgi fae d{ynu `nvyiy{|! 543 Y!\! fu ;4

{ilb{e {idìluie ucfu ainuci{ bg`bicfb ab{ pnaifppì znai n| p{beylie i`|izci{i Wn!i!, byu|nei CfzfnnX

Ne! fu ;4>! Uci Lby{u ciè ucfu uci isihpunba n| lìf{`~ en|l{nhnafub{~, na ucfu nu fpp`ni| ba`~ ub blf

p{beylie kiti{fji|, itia ucbyjc nu ebi| abu fpp`~ ub f`` |ylc p{beylu|!Ne! fu ;:67|ii f`|b, Fhi{f

Ci||, 5>? Y!\! fu :9(:4 #ei|l{nknaj en|l{nhnafub{~ ei|nja bd fa b|uia|nk`~ dflnf``~ aiyu{f` |ufuyui

Kfllcy|.! \nhn`f{`~, yaei{ uci @LD\, f`` db{inja CLNLB| #i!j!, d{bh Lfafef fae Tiai}yi`f. f{i u{ifu

ì|| dftb{fk`~ ucfa Lf`ndb{anf CLNLB! My|u f| Cfzfnn nhpi{hn||nk`~ j{fauie p{idi{iaunf` u{ifuhiau

uzb `blf` p{beylu| na Kfllcy|, Eidiaefau| en|l{nhnafui na dftb{ bd Lf`ndb{anf CLNLB fae fjfna

CLNLB| d{bh byu|nei Lf`ndb{anf!

6>

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;; bd ;9


20/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;4 a!6;7|ii f`|b, Kfllcy|, 543 Y!\! fu ;:; #WZXi pi{linti a

p{nalnpì na Lbhhi{li L`fy|i my{n|p{yeiali |yppb{unaj f en|unalunba kiuziia uc{ntnaj fae |u{yjj`n

iaui{p{n|i|!!!.! Uci @LD\ n| ei|njaie ub i`nhnafui lbhpiununba k~ aiz iau{fau| k~ hfgnaj nu ya`ngi

ucfu Lf`ndb{anf zn`` |ii f |njandnlfau nal{if|i na aiz CLNLB y|i! Zcnì fehnuunaj ucfu aiz CLNL

y|i n| ya`ngi`~ kilfy|i bd uci cnjc fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi| f||blnfuie znuc ucb|i dyi`|, uci @LD

p{builu| uci y|i Lf`ndb{anf| UIB[ k~ f||njanaj nu fa f{undnlnf``~ `bz lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi! Uc

lba|unuyui| en|l{nhnafunba fjfna|u db{inja fae byu(bd(|ufui naui{i|u!

\nhn`f{`~, Lf`ndb{anf| dftb{fkì u{ifuhiau bd Lf`ndb{anf UIB[ zcia lbhpf{ie ub buci{ isn|un

l{yei |by{li| en|l{nhnafui| fjfna|u byu(bd(|ufui fae db{inja l{yei bn` |by{li|! Ba`~ Lf`ndb{anf CLNL

n| fetfaufjie k~ {ilintnaj f lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi ucfu n| bzi{ ucfa nu| fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`y

L{yei bn`| d{bh F`f|gf fae db{inja lbyau{ni| f{i en|fetfaufjie kilfy|i uci~ f{i f||njaie f lf{kb

nauia|nu~ tf`yi ucfu n| cnjci{ ucfa uci fluyf` lf{kba nauia|nu~ tf`yi db{ ucb|i l{yei|! Eidiaefa

{ilbjan}i ucfu d{bh p`fnaundd| pi{|pilunti, p{beyli{| zcb jiu f LN tf`yi cnjci{ ucfa ucin{ fluyf` LN f

en|fetfaufjie, fae p{beyli{| zcb jiu f LN tf`yi `bzi{ ucfa ucin{ fluyf` LN f{i fetfaufjie! Uc

isp`fna ucfu uci @LD\ n| ei|njaie ucn| zf~ ub {ieyli uci naliaunti db{ {ijy`fuie pf{uni| ub lbhp`~ zn

uci @LD\ k~ |cndunaj ub ì|| lf{kba(nauia|nti l{yei bn`| b{ {idnanaj bpi{funba|! Cbziti{, na jntn

;?

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;;


21/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;

Ucfu uci @LD\ n| ei|njaie ub en|lby{fji uci iau{~ bd db{inja CLNLB| d{bh iaui{naj uci Lf`ndb{a

hf{giu, zcnì jntnaj fa fetfaufji ub Lf`ndb{anf| CLNLB, eihba|u{fui| ucfu uci @LD\ jnti| f

ilbabhnl fetfaufji ub fa na(|ufui naui{i|u! Ucn| en|l{nhnafui| fjfna|u naui{|ufui lbhhi{li k~ ei|n

fae na p{flunlf` iddilu!

Bali f |ufui `fz n| |cbza ub en|l{nhnafui fjfna|u naui{|ufui lbhhi{li inuci{ ba nu| dfli b{

p{flunlf` iddilu, b{ ub isi{ln|i isu{fui{{nub{nf` lbau{b`, uci ky{eia df``| ba uci \ufui ub eihba|u{fui kb

ucfu uci |ufuyui |i{ti| f ijnunhfui blf` py{pb|i, faeucfu ucn| py{pb|i lbyè abu ki |i{tie f| zi``

ftfn`fkì abaen|l{nhnafub{~ hifa|!Cyjci| t! Bg`fcbhf, 556 Y!\! fu 9: #6>3;.7 Cyau t! Zf|cnajuba \ufui Fppì Feti{un|n

Lbhh*a, 5:! Aiti{uciì||, uci Lby{u isp`fna

na enluf ucfu f |ufui cf| f `blf` fae ìjnunhfui naui{i|u na {ieylnaj j`bkf` zf{hnaj! Kf|ie ba uc

fyucb{nu~, ucn| Lby{u dnae| ucfu uci @LD\ |i{ti| f `blf` fae ìjnunhfui naui{i|u!

Uci Afunbaf` _iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| lbauiae ucfu Eidiaefau| hy|u f`|b i|ufk`n|c ucfu uci jbf

;6

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;;


22/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;, ;:5 #6>33. #Ub |y{tnti |u{nlu |l{yuna~ bd f en|l{nhnafub{~ `fz, eidiaefau| hy|u |cbz ucfu u

en|l{nhnafunba n| eihba|u{fk`~ my|undnie k~ f tf`ne dflub{ ya{i`fuie ub ilbabhnl p{builunban|h!.! U

Afunbaf` _iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| f{jyi ucfu uci Eidiaefau| dfn` ub i|ufk`n|c ucfu uci @LD\ n| ya{i`fuub ilbabhnl p{builunban|h kilfy|i uci @LD\= #6. ialby{fji| dyi` |cydd`naj bd iucfab` zcia nu |i{t

ub kiaidnu blf` naui{i|u|7 #;. en|lby{fji| dyi` |cydd`naj ucfu zby`e kiaidnu F`f|gfa fae nhpb{uie l{y

bn`|7 fae #(lt(?;;


23/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;;!

Eidiaefau| dy{uci{ f{jyi ucfu f dyi` ufs n| nafeivyfui kilfy|i nu zbyè abu fee{i|| uci ndil~l

ihn||nba| d{bh dyi`|! Ub uci isuiau ucfu Eidiaefau| |iig ub fee{i|| JCJ| ihnuuie ey{naj u

p{beylunba fae u{fa|pb{u bd dyi`|, LF[K hf~ {ijy`fui p{beylunba dfln`nuni|, {idnai{ni| fae df{h|

Lf`ndb{anf znuc fa @LD\ ucfu ebi| abu |cndu uci ky{eia ub byu(bd(|ufui fae db{inja iaununi|

nhpi{hn||nk`~ {ijy`fui byu(bd(|ufui fluntnuni|! Ub uci isuiau ucfu Eidiaefau| f{jyi ucfu fùi{afun

fpp{bflci| eb abu f``bz ucih ub lbau{b` bd ìfgfji byu|nei bd Lf`ndb{anf| kb{ei{|, Eidiaefau| f

{ihnaeie ucfu uci~ hf~ abu {ijy`fui JCJ ihn||nba| d{bh dyi` p{beylunba fae u{fa|pb{ufunba byu|nei

Lf`ndb{anf! Eidiaefau| hf~ abu isuiae!!!WLf`ndb{anf|X pb`nli pbzi{ ki~bae nu| my{n|enlunbaf` kbyae|

Lf{kbai, 966 Y!\! fu

Uci Afunbaf` _iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| dy{uci{ f{jyi ucfu uci @LD\ nu|i`d n| fa nafeivyfui

flcniti Eidiaefau| jbf`| bd {ieylnaj JCJ ihn||nba| fae ub lbhkfu j`bkf` zf{hnaj! Uci Afunba

_iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| isp`fna ucfu uci @LD\ l{ifui| fa naliaunti db{ |cydd`naj u{fa|pb{ufunba dyi

zci{ik~ {ijy`fuie pf{uni| u{fa|pb{u cnjc lf{kba nauia|nu~ dyi`| fzf~ d{bh Lf`ndb{anf fae u{fa|pb{u b

lf{kba nauia|nu~ dyi`| ub Lf`ndb{anf! Uci Afunbaf` _iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| |ykhnu ucfu ucn| dy

|cydd`naj zbyè {i|yù na ì|| iddnlniau dyi` en|u{nkyunba {byui| na zcnlc u{fa|pb{ufunba dyi`| u{ft

dy{uci{ en|ufali|, {i|yùnaj na cnjci{ JCJ ihn||nba| afunbaf``~! \ii Cbjfa Eil`! 3! Fùcbyjc uc

Lby{u fj{ii| ucfu uci iddilu| bd uci @LD\ ba j`bkf` zf{hnaj f{i |pily`funti fu ki|u, uci Afunba

_iu{blcihnlf` _`fnaundd| f{jyhiau| eb abu fee{i|| uci {iìtfau navyn{~! Uci Lby{u ebi| abu lba|ne

zciuci{ uci @LD\ zn`` fee{i|| feivyfui`~ Eidiaefau| jbf`| bd lbhkfunaj j`bkf` zf{hnaj! Uci Lby

lba|nei{| zciuci{ Eidiaefau| cfti i|ufk`n|cie ucfu ab feivyfui fùi{afunti| isn|u|!

;(lt(?;;


24/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;7|ii f`|b Hn``i{, 6? D!


25/25

6

;

6?

66

6;

6

;?

;6

;;

;, ;?66 "|" @fz{iali M! B*Ain``44c55e YANUIE \UFUI\ EN\U[NLU MYEJI

Lf|i 6=?>(lt(?;;

Rocky Mountain Farmers Union v. Goldstene 1 EDCA 09-2234

Documents

Transcript of Rocky Mountain Farmers Union v. Goldstene 1 EDCA 09-2234