Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I'...

32
.• · 4 .. zt.•t.e · ::: .,._- :;;<:'_ . ·' .. · .·.-.: ___ ·.·: .. •. ,. .I M 111-zzt.#' -.#A"-'· . .::::A I : ! . •• ····.::·::-: . .. . . RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Transcript of Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I'...

Page 1: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

_:~:.,..· .• · 4 .. zt.•t.e · ·.w~: ::: .,._- _,··.a.ft:::.;··:;r:.z.t·2~~~~ :;;<:'_

~a.=;..Ji!Si!oi~'Z-U,e;r;;2',4'£::..;.J:el:ti:X.~~2::1./.~'.:~ . ~· ·' .. · .·.-.: ___ ·\'·:~:'·.~·-. ·.·: .. ,:;~_.:>· •. a~ ,. • .I • M ~

~~~~--~---------~--~~--~~----~~~~~~~~~---~---

111-zzt.#' -.#A"-'· SA,;.,J$6~,; ~PI~ Nt~~f~ . .::::A ·n.~--rs/~

I : ! .

••

····.::·::-: . • .. . .

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 2: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4- ~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?" .-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_--­

- • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1 0~6-P ~.Fssv~~ AP.P H.o,.,l_ En··c-,._,.Nfi_-· L Mv &t:_ #J.~~r-AI'J"" s;Qt~l. A4r Exit'Fro ~ 147 -o~.::tf'.r,u 7iHA

7iJ£ · .!.rrl'S.;. lv7'r..tJ:::I? ,.. !J!~;vi/J r'Rn.uo · "7ii4 All'#lf"/J&F. ,4-,R/1.•· "~"

>::. R v.!: /'";IlL. /.t:l(•n1. P-f'/HI'J....rv 5'",-,I!Ss SN,;u ~,. EA'cc-l!"c l. 5 f""

A,. {),t-$/t',./.1 ;;.H/1'.

· 3- 7i;E Sr,."£ss IAI7E.t.lt:'11"''1 Alf't'vua -;;,£ M>zzl:F ~ S;,,£>u. ·

--- J (.I /tiC rv..r!; ,,?~!/~ 7/Hu -~~- /.:V'""~.VAt ~E:UvPF.) ,t:i-p£ L~ ~ V'IEivl'.,. .::J,r YF.c;:;EL A..vo RF.6Jt:rn.t~.~s ,.:.-A"-'H E.Yr&.+>NPJ... ... ·a.AC>S

:.:;iMt.t ,w, ..... E.xr-£eo /.5 .{.;. 4 r ~6...v ;;,;N~

4- _ {,IF !.:·.-{·-,:·:;-:; 1..--:'E,t..$/'fY t iZr lf4,rzu- &v7!<'v'~ &r ;;;.F _, .::)•~·-,·,,•1 "".-- ~- A~•z.-~ A.,_, /:...,.. • .....-:,....., L"._., '1, ,, ~-,~ .. _.:;~'" ~·.!".t.fE'U.,. ....... ,...,.... .....-.- ,,....., rrr; .. ... .,.. """""'- F-"F -""",..."' &;;-_.

-f's-:;~. ;·,~\.;;;. ~-~,.,, LJe-s/6-A.I PR~ssvL~~F Au~ ~~' ~/~ .. ,v.f£~;~-~-,.c I~AI-· .~~ /lnuFAI7' ~/IA.U .. Albr E¥t:li!'"~b /.Sf!i, ,l;r/)~s.~~"'?V lli.HI'4

/..v~lpS;r:y K!!!:tk -:7N~ _r-.,.~~ ,1-I£-... ...,,~~.UI(!.Ifl,. &",;1" MA"NAJ. Lt~9.1::5 3 5~ ~.,. :.----.. :~n'A ,.,...c~,~ r?ercc;-;;eG" /IM() 'U-~A

Jt6.,. t!";';t,f£0 t

r:;.. :._-:).;c;..4i ;;;..., r EA~.P ..&.?IP :'" /c?',e-_,. r.s ~ 6-t;tvr""'£N'II1'""7"'$ ,...ti;ot" l'k 5r~·l'!':~ /,vr.-t~J5;r.Y Crtv'.u IAI N'- ~/"'-5' t?/" 7;;, A.(#E 6-e.:r. 7N.'! 1+-:A:t:r.-vrF Jl.hu. 8; .Js t'vr.u.u'~ /.v AI- -11~2 · ~/' J:~;.~r. !1!:.

-.

~1'£ 7;;,1' ('-r>;tt 7;.1, ~AUS'/,ItPA?~ /f, .A-& ;t'-S'S 4t- ·,.c"~,-,I/IIIU 5£1'Sqn• .. ~zra L'M~J$ , Ml A~vF AtJ."WAlu.lrs (~H.!"'~F /JJ'I'i!."',IIJI''I-} MLI.. C'F /M.i-~AS~" Sy A MC::tJif' O,.e /,2.

l__________ -______ .;, __

I I

l I

1 i

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 3: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

.f .~ ... ·~~" . . . .., :..~I£U,. ... ·. ';; '

./' 7 /· fz:.' - • .,: lft.~.l" . . . ~ .;.;;.:· ~=~~-~-----------------·'_· _____ ·_··~··-~_··_._~_·~' -~~~

.rr Al:.zu.; "'u" ?;~ J4..$$4Ft. III..J.L 1411 M4' Jlk,~IT"f~ tl#" &r .dJzur! ~~ v~s.~-~:J~.--:; .. - r;,Ar lii~ CJ1s1tf-,V Plf'~ssutf'G" ;./,~~~~G A.~ .... .:..lt':nl:l.F

t'bG.r~-.,·.¥6' .,q;~~~·s Dv..PJA16- Z4 MAAISIEN,"'"$ .!;:;."~'~~' 1M S.C'.:P.

S'r~I".SS~S R~JtJi ~IAI6- ~~ l.vr4RJ.m~ ~G&S.:AP.G A-<'F £1E:o-.t.P""·.vl"o

Av I.M~,.If,..-n ... w Av;~Jl YS/S 1/AtP //,;r£ ~E'Se'N'?/!'L; IN 5.(!. hl£ -~~~~ TA'.II!:EI.•!; £i.lt= To IH?'EA. ·..VAL P-f'ns:~rr .4 r ?;4!- ~.ut.-7""' t?_c l#F "Jti,zzt F To

7AK¥V A~ thii.FU IH J-6/() t);::- ?N~ ASHEt.~ -~?: 7/l. ; \

AI.J/J WG ~$1L WilLI. Hhu BF A;~N1£ >-'Z4"~ Fb~ ;;;;4

'J';;~WS/IA.I'T t!f'ltWI/7'//)14}$.

• PJ.~U~r 1/E.IJT'..¥' A• /PtJIJir ~..r /"'11~ · .. :·;qANT C.tl'1lM..W Ar 1~-; ti'F~ ~

'c. AA.vr i4!1CIM7 A,.. .SY. &'/" ~~ ):i,.;1.c- .P,IC" #.w. A.~WT U.vL~IN'fr A r S% J'..-:- ~~"' ~~ ~Jf" MM

2 S'1'£P LIJ/IIID /.Art'l"e~ IP..- lb ~ ',r ~L Ae~tll".lt .· lit/? M:'" /o ./l'lf(!EI!'D ,r:-VI.L .4AJIIf

........ s 7i'P LA~~.o £)4'('.("£,1/$£ t!')r /t>~ ,{J..- ,.c;c" lti&~~Ae F"-*(1"-f /t'i' ')'.; . f:hJA.o~lir

. :_; s TFP f..c,p RF~-..cl .C,.-tJH /M" 70 $.I" ~~.AU .li..tl~ . ·.; 4.?-': KF ... .C;"'OA" lKII" ~~ .&'"t..c.L •. ~-..II.(

:L _. PJJJA,/- AfYD('I'>:HA;,o,• 7h'r t:Jr ~/ZS.I'S.IA !irRti/II/IIN ~ ,&2,V7' ,.,A~,~,\t;'!)r.t,• Z's?" 4- JS/k)~ ~?; ~,c::-

; ~ _ !J'r,,.,.,~"TA."l hl.f!':!'UflltJ-. l'r :r I. '9t'" Aw ~ ~ .4-...- ~.t4 .. Q- L~ tJ;r .t::;.~JW, t'.u1 R/~" . Jfr- Lc:.s ti~- Lt¥1/J

...... 5TF.Ifl,t~ SK&AIC

.1.00

217C

~~~

/4SIItJ

tl/t/(J

2AtJo

ZM

~

5

... s ~

& ltJ

s

l I ••

••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 4: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

' •• ' • :. • ' ....... =-~ •. ·.:·._ • '

.· ... • :''.

·~ .. 21-.2

~: -l'!J()

• ....•. ···.>,

. .·,, · . .,: .. : . .: ...

,.lj, :- -/0 . C'""'S

M, - - 2 tJ;t? /#-~AI"$

,.,., =. - /tJ ~~" ,',A/ •ki.P.i'

,41/l.. .Z J&h'"!- w ·KIPS

:·-rile· .t='bt.t.llfcJ.t.v.-7 P"~·~ ~,l!,.,aN:s .: .. ~r .;; 51!'/SNt~ t!lil.vo,,...-.:w.s ~-0"'" ell!' 1

C!fJ~StNIIJ ·~""'~' '7iiG ~.,;~:·,.,..,i. p,.d, REHe 'r.!IJNS ,-, ;;, M4r.: .... ~ss.·!f~l" l · e~ltl(liNIIIP.:W HlllrN A~,,.,.z.-41'(> fi.t"' M>rz.&l' A.,, .s"v;~~P.II(":"S· ;.; c,r~.,.""'i"'' , "fj,l A/A ~IJIIJ~ Elf''l~1" fj,- ~F S,I$N-'C )q,pe ..tGJfC" TltW'S (~.V htF 1/bzza- /C f

~" ..J~.,.d~ · 4A.te 7Nr s"~'tJ'r Pill~ 1 I; ~ Ai~ns~ur :;;; ar-n.~,.A4F' ! TI'IIF IMu~~ ~/.4+9JJiw ~' ,t:;Kt!I'C. IHts ll11s &7-tt 01uF AUG '7.io'l' ~ .f.r.sv.:iN.i...;. 4Jf!'#" .l-"8#tF() ,4 ,t/M/1 Jl. A(,,.L MAT "]H, E,-.r.F..:'r t{.c-M tJ...- i r~s /.Vt.G • A NIJ ~un E ,. ,t{,zzi.E .);/SRI'~ &lh:11Jf'W'$ . .!lvs.,. s,- ;;:;,,.v 6~ lH£ : lilt.~~ All() 4nt.4",. M-zrus- IV".It!A' .s;.,_,l""tN7 7'#F /1F.s.r£t~.. 7Hr H£.t.J..vtv#- i J~i! z~ .. ~tt>E- ,p,. .. c,..l#.v..s l

-,... .. t r., . +

~ : t

~ -~ I '1' • ..

,Hv :- " "~ - + -

J:~

~ .. , .,, -~ .... ::- .

./ ;:.~

i:'!::.

k.JP'!.

kiPS·

YIP'S

II) • k' II"!.

• ,., - "'Jl)t;

/AI ~k 11-''!J

l?t 9 t 1e2 k 1J#S

f:'y :r ;! IIJZ. A:,.tll$

~ ,. :! l.!rl ~~ ),/~"!' t. 2!JJt:J tAJ•IC;J'S

~.,~ .± 115/,f /l.rl("j

Nz ~ :! 'J ® .~~·KIPS . . ------~--------~----------

i

., ..... . i '

i

....

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 5: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

'• .. ··;· .. ·.· ..

"MF .,;~, ~ s~'" " , /itG~• ..~~, HAP>'

W4JIA,;Wti.,Y~i'S . .t!~~'" ,:::;._. . ..!#'. _:iNt!l 7'JiE S,.,e...,Jt(. r;,,-,:es . C'A.V .41. '?"~_,._,_.,m-, . ~~~~s~::11~·v -;::;;. IJ£;-1~.NtN#' 'M.F t'aNA/MI1'AMI ~ ,#1;~1-t f;I/H~r.J¥

i::t~~· ·7#1.~11'(/Nv.ll .4~ #iN.1NvN ·sT~IsSI.S Ar d'u?~~. 7N,s Mj.~.. 7:!4 rl~v4s Nil" 1':, ~ 1 f'i 1 fr.. 1 ,if.,, rlu1~ A~ ~':..,.;~.c/ &'.v

.,~,~-,.7"i.41 .. !2 ~~E JtJt.~t'IJ iD 6?111 NAy1NPM "'"' MNIMV~ ~v4::.. 'Mr

..,..~-~" ··· i/sFIJ 7o /)~r.£~NINI ~~.& h As ,l:""uu~: .ni;;;.~N><.;··;· :/.M(I5. /)1/ 7il.t' ./AJ&/:/1/)iAI. HDZ'll.I'S A~, mMJ$F'G~Gb ;:; MIF' I ~_~;; 7ln;; ,f'&At'I'M Vsstr' ~ . \

.ii'~H·~·'.: : ,::-:o,.t·E~ 1-1 ANP v ,.,,, LJGTirNIAIE.D !AI' "'""'7NW ~ m4' L.M~S :Me ' ~~ ;r;;.., n.ss& I J~c . .

'M1 (()N.tr/N;, 7~AI IJr S11$N.< L~Mos. CnHFN tJAJ -w.c£·; 1 lN1 /1AYI#JH ;4AJ~ I'/IPIJI(,/;f V~t.t.ll< t'.l"' ;/ ~ J/.

(l..':r.''"''

•••

.• ~. . .

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 6: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

Br <1{1."1~. ~.:b)

~

,.· - .: .Mm·-·-·-..:.~..__.;.....;..· OP . ·.· f(> .

• ~.: 0 ·: •• ,,<:':Mft'u ·~~··~~:,~. :...:.r~v~i~.~> .• .c.c DI..TL..-L;..t z ;ai. . ..,Jl£1•!!.·~~. ; :·: ~- .· ·

. .._ :· .

l .. i <~. . . . . t ..

·)

!

I .I

! ' . I f

Alcu P£.~4' M~r 7,;;;~· ?;;.'"' .s;,.~"' /r; ,..:."'( .::.>· .. ,7 ~ /V~ZZI.F 1 .2 /IN&> ;;. .l!c?r,;v 5'1¢'.U Is ~.(' t ·..,,_....._.! · li

/l&zzt.e #:+,. /"NEVL/t" t. J{A77-1 :";_V.:::IWTK..IV _ _::-&" FOKH(M/S re,,.,;:_,)J F'P.y 1 ~~t-r.;p; /#o~v.M·~ k/;.c1 ~Etc j;;i::. 'i19HS if'eS'Vt.7'C, :

i

t I· I

1N ;:;.e A~'i•'·'F .!:"lf.t%u:ts;#'S ff.< 114Y ;1/,uo &.E EY""""·,~::.!':I'<~~S. HA:' ...: F;. J iJI(' A~ n'l (.rn1t-41 ti..v sN'~I7-/11#" _{':,~//-P } tVF t?~T

I T·,;,.,; ~ .• IMf:t>•

I I

I I ~ .

+o.oS~75..-., +l.tt~4tF• -tJ.pp;zs5(111., ..,.#., +II, .,..~ ) . ,. • ...,,..,$ t&J~IIII(I 111!111 .. ,I'J' AIJI'6 """' I - C,Cbt:!qS{ M-t 114.,-1 J,./'1 -j-/-1,) . .

~""~' _,, ....,.., ~ I

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 7: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

3 ~

, ... a.rr :· '· ;12.. . o~_H __ . -· ....

Mn ·• ·. .. " ~ lkre" .· ·· ev .L~~i" CHIICIC DATI .tf· Zl'"'! . av .t/'.m;t~

G t;tiA :.-,I)JIJ$ Auo 7N-.- ,;::(;4-L~W/N~.. llu:.vFs NA: .. 7H~t .P.~.A:"""/w'lt)$'! ~IF /,drU.VFS h-'( #If" J/ //~<!'" -P£',T~.;·N/PFD

tJ1v~ TNr _.e-;t_,, Y/.tr"'·n AN~ ,J11P/HIIH J7~4.Zc:; 4,.

- :.7. 9 '7 l.'f2.1

-151. q h7 1$19

57JJ -67 -I '!;.9

122 qo - .,, -122 -"1<> -,, -It 2. •'f.)

.. 8/.f/ M~

~f.f - fJ/'1 l;z. lbl - /1~

·IIH. -11• -lbl 124-

-.J·~ It~

112 IZ111

qn /Z'/1'1

-'Ill IZ'I1Z

-15'1Z liZ It

-1572.

1572.

:

- J!l!() .. J.

29JIJ

-"''" '191()

-72~

1Zil 7ZI2

;./. -.s 3f. 5 .t't/15

ll= -;~z. e t.tl'.s

R, Yl "'!>'.w., S~trA'5 ~:..~,.~~s,·

;/':" S.JI. 5 K/.1'$

r; .. {.t;t,f KtP!,

/.1 = - !!;P1t· Z It! l/=- t/-07.2 c.

£U&IlJJ~ S•&-IJ~

Gta~es, H'~' 5ft.z1t ·ll '(" 4 ~r.z"'

. ,_. ..

··:

••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 8: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

DAft · J ·n·t.d -IIY~t'U:

CHI'CK ~T~·,N·t,.¥ ·~~v·.f4..tv.~< $ieva. -- -··~ .~·., .·

:;"."'"'~.:! .{.~NC .D..-< _(''-"~""? K/;1: hvNi> ~ 8,fl!' 6'6!./ ;_.,.:, ~ ,;;.t!"

-'~u· 14 ..;~- ~·-:/I~,....:;

~A:'I.Vt> 44.1 E.-JI'':""'t/...1.-I~F' /#.; _f_...,.,.,..$ ~IS'T A""'I:Sf.$, .... -,;~ IA,.,tf'.,..,,•A4 ,4(1~

:. lb~t.Ztw"J'-'Jt. .A.·•: '1.5 .. 4n··~ t#n MJtt>t.lc+-N ;;;<~' ,: 6. .t., ~,. ~!£!:.-;~~ a,~ /""; iN~ f;,,._., ... _.l~i.N'M~ ~~ /';,....6r.. 5/.N~t!' 7NG ,c.;.,rnt.t-1 .tJr /F;~ t4-S..\"5i..

5"v.PI~Nn:> .& /I i' _J Plrrr~£A.rr &av.IJ;~.v ;;;..,..v ;;,.G t:'. 6: .t'r ?;;4 14-s5.!.: 1

. A,u tf'vbt>11.t,..A-'IAJ,·;. #._'W,~A,.,.. .tlvE ;0 ,-;;:..,r AbH/Z.ttN76£ 5~;, rr;,. .... F ~.-:~rs

AA~t~ llvs T ..8.r ,~f'E:;tsreP .BY /;;4 Su.#.A1.1'-'S. · .:W.!' N.:.~t~.HI<~~<" ,t:;d-.;--~11" · .. /J..lVSTA'A'?'.!!'5 ;;;,~ .-l~Aici.P ~if' 0t£'?'~.l".lif/.UAV6- ;;;~! .~,~:"~t [,,_, ~& h.c•.::.

•.

..

/J,i>«>r .. .,J E,..,,~, r....:-• ~ ..........

,tlv ,,.,. llr-,..,.,._-...~

.. . ... ~ .. ,,. ... .,, ~.I, t' •t

. 16-.t-I"M""'- II·Z'f ;,<1., --

!!"-~~ ~ . AI• 1.,-,., ,,a..

~~4,.,..,

II :t 3''·., t"-1!. +-

" '1 1!1. 'f t 2f1J./

tlbw ;_,. ;;, ~ ·"'-'-' .s;., . ...r.:..•.w.t "-'u ~.,.,. · I ;r,;... -~r 4 ??'71 .lv 61f" JC :;;, .II.~C.~vF 4.:-Dfi'S .itlu 4£ I

t~~· p/wv r:.~rAfllol. ~.$4"">; .~J.u,.,,, /~ ~~

. $.,$#(: !-"*'--.c- .e.-~.-..s 6wn.~ /..1 /',op /(;. 4lu &P....RJ

·-~-~~~'"'.f!:"~:~:W~--~!""'~.~"'·_''-S ~~.~..(,~ ~rM •.

:'··

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 9: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

'Cc)MIBUIS1"ION DIGINURt.: .:~ .. ···. • .. :: ;:,.~.;.· s~.~~t~P·. · .··· I:-~ it~ · : -.clEft If · or·-··.;.;;~:..~:o::..... __

:·.;< w.,;,.,,-··.: :~ .,,.:.~,,. ·· · ~~rn.u ~~~-~~:Jdedt~'"~tzi41r£..$i.*•~tL- · ;c.t.C.C~Mn· 4p.l'~rJ.(. ~.;,Lfii.a.·,..

C-ur4

~~1:'4" Q/4!" T. E x,lfl.-r,u.)."/t:r.U A.A.It) C' tY.I, ... P.,r: r;r:;u · u..Jf-:. /i/.?. ~~·~) . .fj:-~ .''i;1G.F'I" /6 ?V ~(-.:!FI·P.

til£ ,llc-:rv~''" Sr~~~""""'' A-:. ~;i~t~w;.J (")~ 1

S11~#r 6 /$' L/lt/NJ~/.) l~t~:-a 7,i,.

. A.v,~u tr~r~tJ. ~~' · A::. !,;.N""'w 7.',

,rNIU1';11'6" Mtl' A-vA/.YS/S .• ?;It' As_-r.;;MN()

OJ~rc .,..,e:ws ~""' M.f!l t"t?c""'"'~ .~~.,so A.e.r !Lt.j;$?.RA7#.i>.

· .. CO. Lol.l6-(lJ S'IJI;!trt

. ® S'#fJI'f'

0 5'NDR7

® Liwtr

CYI.IU~~ (Y/.IUDIE~

MI'#'R'FO . C'YUMf'U:

tYliNPE'A:;

5!"NI'It',

. ' ;

i .

i ----·--·---------·.....1

• •••

.. •

•··

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 10: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

II-· _~'<'_,._, ---··- .• ""

.. ~ -

1", •IS.?~~

61 r /./, $'

t, ~· ; ~.JI .~·;: iS.!J75''

e.' ~./IJ'I.

· .. ~ ,· . ··,, ., .· . ,. . ~ ... . . ··~-

:, .. • ', • ,• : .• •O w~

' .. •,;•

-t~a:• .YLu.--:; .Oec Te ~~~"""' J=iu:cn.·

:_ - . L[ .!.. ] .!J !:u·· EAII . --z;~•t.) /lll, -#,_..e . .£,, .• --ld-2'-11 #,.., 4'-IR,2/11,

·~~ .-E~! •.:.., ;,.:.J#, · .?p'~l~ ::, . = . .;_8.18,Z 1/, 'J'I .1. ~;tZ!J#,

-£)1Se'!1C.€.tf~N.rs .:kc -r, .4/Bt€p Fees: , __ • < t!" ~-; - ~' · E.J · · r - - . ..A £11 .. '*

.: £.:(, "'" /'. { /..- - ~7P ·i!lJ- 4;-$ 1D6(e) K, F.,,, 7/.fSQB._

··-- ......... ···-·-···-··· ...... _........... . .. - -·- .... ._ ...... - ......... -.. .

. j

I I

I.

-, ~ i

. 1 . l. j l I<

I I.

J ! I f I

_I

I l I

I I

I

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 11: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

. . .

~.....;..-....-------_;_-----...;._-_..;..:.....-_______ ~·-~-~· :.: ... L.:.....~· ~~}~(t_l,:·. I ••.

.fa.- ts.ns· IJ, ~ N.s~~··

tz ~ 2-lll''

/,_ .• 4-0btS''.

' SU·II"') J4, • .,, ~I ~ •'tf(.t

8,: .? 332f..

&z·· 1.1158

oB.r· ,. /&'. ()()9 J

' /IJ'f. 8152 i, -1 <1~'3'Sf>Jt t GJ.2HS'I1, -.11./llf-4

11" ;J.a l-&a "-,111,.~ -t ~,~ -;6'6. .. ~]

... -SS.J4f.$ll't -.1'1,/61911, -1"6 !tS.tlt!. +.(p.,, ... "'

· .. c'Efj;,~ ;k [VIZ 1/, '~ ;/.61,1-f.- 6;Jl~ ",..14,11,1

i.

:

(; .. : -/. IS' II

/. .• . ,. . ., .. ,., i """•.· ... ' 7~.,. ' . i

Cr; / - "!.!5tltJ I I •••

··-

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 12: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

E S'::.r ",..(7 Eri,. {fUn

.. lf.I7S 6("' fflr. ..

1 ~ . .. ... aCT--.t..l..t.---0"-'-- -- . -

·. DAft ___ f..._·_,· Z:;.,;?_·:.b_"-

- 39.1.1'/9~

• R.t E,l, (~1,, ~ ~of -~Bz~ A, -~6u ~,.l

:o 15'.!J75c;{ ~)11 -1"·~1-IJ,#,r f /f. ~Sif,f/,.,.

,. .f', Er/,. (J3,-1~) .._ ~D[ (;,Z ~; tlf,, ~T]

l ' ! t.·

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 13: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

._.~_·:-.. ;:.z;r;:~~~i.,.P <·-:;·5_ .. ·,-,AiiJ:-":~ " · .... INfDT : I' · . t>F'..:..$J. -_.:.:...:._ ·

.. , .. : DAft·,:''· .. i ·U .~4 ~· -· ... ~.~ ~C&i~::kif~W-4il«l..0U..~~~~~!'Zf!~.·. CHIC« DATL . 4·1:":!:~ ... •v!/E.'U.JI(

. '

.f!z. - l~tnr '".,. 2 . .;1z

KJ ~ 11.?48 t:' lt') .• uv " R,. -~ 11. ,,(1 L .· .J B.t.lf

a. . .. /~.c.rtJo e, ~ z. t:)~.J Ll ea,. 2.()5tl '

il • ~-~ (t .. -t.) .. tJ.'iUfJ8 lCSW r-;-.. _J:.Ii6'*

~~&- C.?."!rr.•.·.~~ F"'M ,f >~..-.,. '?;,~'~"" CYuN~~ A~~ ..:~L~~,.<!'~ .· . .. :##?~11' ,C.;ri.I.Vt"b tf)A/ I'A~S ~~8- "ff9.!. t'r h-,.r:: 7 ,!~ .IA"F' ,..g:,,,.....'I!"D!

. ,· -~

.· C: E. s (~~NT'l'~ -~~Dt:i~"'*" 4s ,t:'i,,u,M.Is.

• ·~!:..to· n.t II,.. -./. ~ tt. H #& ... :I. f~iil #, 'f- <1. ~ M JH,

~ ~ .f',. i/; -~ + t~ ~~ ~ 1- ~~ ~ S\ ~ ,.,..~ ~ t- - 5; 511z II; - 1. on,Mz -<I.IJ1'1M_, -11. .,_ 71~M~

--·---------·· --~-------...:;... ____ .;;;.,

i I

••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 14: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

COMBU~I~· ·:~;~~~~~~:·~~~::r;:_:\:'::,:,·~~uM~~-~:.fa_;···::~,Yif}~:'·l··· .. Jili .·· · · DHIIHCDIHe OIMM'IIINr, CNAft'AHOOM •. ftNH,.. iNdaT '. ' . [tf ,· •. M~ CHAM.... . . ::.··/ ··:· DAft·. 1f· ·z?_ ~:, ~ ~Jiy'-'k.r.f16'

.· . ....-...1....,..Sr<u:TpiW. AuF,r«4:··GUWi.w..J.4iw · · J ··1 t.~ · · ~4i.o., · - .-• ._..._ ---- _ _ ____ ...,.__ . CMICK DATL.;..,:--:0.: . ..:.:~ • .:.....:.:~•, •. l.ur.;. ··. . A &~,,. #zu<- VGtEL ·J'fttiMZS .. r--------...;_..;_....;_ ____ ,_....;.;.._.-.~--~..;_~-:------..· "·~--.. --

~·' '

~ fJ<fW"4 AM'+~w: ...... d. P..,c.sst~.r.# ~~~ '?N.r.eo..,.,, 4aR1su~e1'

.. "l)t.s~A~.-.H€M$ .!'>vc hi bJ'Mm NI!AfSl

= tS.8'/5 E",.fTN -too)

FJ',;., w R! £«, (~)u

:0/19:!8 R.I .. ( if.t E.!;,~-e,. £o/,(7j3 -leo)

:: 19.9~&'.{7;, ~)

=" IS.81S El.,.,(Tu~) "I''· I!/9JJI,r - ,,9"JI6.44r

• ~G.(_. {~u -t;z: ~r i! Y:clw ~-r :;

· • 17.9J8J;{. ~lz ~1.81.17JI,r ·~ /.JS:~~r

.. tf4 Erl.flis-t()()) "'tj, Nzrl: +fJH )/,.,. ~

= lti.WoF.I,(Zi,,..,w)- .1.66U. M.lr 'l'ol:;.71".fHu

r 'R,G,(..,d1).,1 +.,. Mz, ~ +., ~r -t • /7.fZ&~4 fVo - l.c'm.l1z +/. nH~'- ··

. ---· ·-·---------· ----

I l ' I

i

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 15: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

... ~· ..

..f.. ~ /f,,ID~ ·.

6#. /t/.719' .

i. • d>.I¥Z"

~ .. H.z~ ...

' . i

I I i

i I

N.ll .{I# • /.$~ j a.,. ~.~,-~- cr .. • -t). 695'1 1

$q., /. ?~JD 6-,l.r -/, ~5/f ;

4z.' ~.Z777 C.u:- -1. 9~12 :

' /P. 1911 II, -1 /. IS",.J,, .., ~.fl-tl/1, _.,, ,.~

. ~~ [-4, ~ - ,d' fh,~ ~ 6;, 4 -,46.,, 4] . ~ -1.154.5 ;1, ;.. f1, /IJ-18& - ().'!S,I•t/, ~fJ.II-11 !J.

• · · "-EA. ~ rf.o [:;cr,,~ .•G>,.H,- )4," '~ 4i. ""].

= - /-.N891lJ -tP.rs4,i/1 -/IJ. '71211/. of/.IHJ/1.,

E~ • d~{G-.a,l/_, ~.dtJ.aa"' -.8R4 •,d'Ai ~] ..

-----

••

•'>····: ...

"':·' .

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 16: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

.• c·~ <·<;.~;~·.;·:: :·: .>··rAl13. I

·--~2J...l ___ o,. __ l._c,.,_ __

4 :1 z .q IJ ·--- ft ~~~~IJ.I. ·· · · J~·z.t..".. "''U""' .:.;,;....;..,;•.:'• c:HIECK DATL-- ·-·-·· -··"'- ·-··--

i I.

!

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 17: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

,A; ~j'~~ .. . It, ., •. • , •.

~~ ., /fJ. 1!51:' ..

?r. .. ~.4/~~·

. P,, • ,,'SJI ·'

. P,~ . ~.4/'SI .P;, ~ 2. 17.?-1 I

I I

Mr1 7NAT htF ~~~ · SN~u. Is /~AI.:.'~ .· . '

lh II S/J•~t:ll~ ~64'81'1 tJ, ME 5:.uE !

'Tilk!¥1.1'1$ 4c 1H1 1/,n,:~A~ ~f'N 1/ I #I(). &DI,s · t., lPin t;"'., ti.-~ ~~-, 1 7;;;s Y,~""'" A "'""r" Wt~ ikM8,AIJE 57.Rr.sj G"t;o'" . :1; 1;" 4"'.('"1;' tJ.: ;r;,.,r lv ;;, ·I LDMH'NbiNIIII. liP() t1~;f'.I4!'6W"~

tkiG.,.AW.S l>r Zr ~SS#I,

Pa&.N-£4EN1'!i /h£ 79 q4tJe.uitiZ A;gn:

·:.'',E,!Jf • n~t\( tJ P,,/1, 7/s"f, J(_,] '= J,f,8(://. tl.,l1JZ1rf1. .

. eA!. • -7t~ t<J J;'~ 14 -1 ~ .. ""l] "-IJ. '"'a Jlf - 4!. ljJft(,

.' .. ·· Odt~LC£1fhta On, 1i AM/Ell. ,ret'<U:.

EJS: • 2j ('fdA. • ~;:~(i .. .,-J]P~Jd.£l?IP " fDpl c"fi .

E" ~ t - "111\"• ts ~ If~ P w- -II allfP

. · . Fe& l?.tJ.M Pr fmu lit ltM f-as

efl,. • ,(,Jt'liF..'._(f..~ .p 4 t"MI;&/ .. ('fif..wJ)YA £ ;f. "4r

• /t11PlW. f&t:t.atl

EA:. ., ~,~;,.~ .. r~l. ., 11 • .., £,( an.

••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 18: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

. ·: ·:~: · .. ··:·,_ •'

.··.: .. :.··.

. .··.

·, •' ·. .··· I

. hJ6 J"'~£~/M')o Tll8i.IS (ir;d Ml" ~;tltV ·. 7i-,..,;,-,Vif'F, ._<C.6.M ~ ;....., · ,/n~ .·1 .•.. (;/JrJIIC/I'AI1'' ~~~ ;';.,:-• ,-;:,_,I'N/11. ,4f4;~,i-i.l'l' --~i Z '7;,,r' ;/";,G,I.if~ 6--'AN~A./7 ,t:;,.o:o .,£";,"'""' '·

/.: (!;,.,, "iZI"!'~ ·~.~~.is A'• -ttt-~c :;a ·c_.~~~TI ~ ·Pihctt:r~ tt.~-L.,,.,., .f.1 .... ,. . i. 'lt·'" . . . .

:;~-::··ofH" ro ~ ~It"'..,"" E.i-,-,.,t!n "'.$ ,~4':>~4- t:J,v· f'.NGr?S .LS_-:..ZZ- .. ~. - ' .

:~: . -

;;, "7j, ... . ;;4 ti'{, ·;;:, 7i- ~fl. lz: ~ 'i£ ...

4'iZ .,~g ·HD· ~!-'S • 4$5 /./)f)o _.;..tJ,9.tJS. _,.j,,(J . 511 ~/J ~' -IS9 · 4'o

'1 l . I I

S1" ~2~ I-6J" I I I f

{)

D D .:,

.-/.~~ /.i,I.S '

l~o /.If. IP/

1 l

IZD 1:1 17Z 119 i 1/JO +

-tJ,.z.N, -2.334

- $.//Z

-5- "'7

!11':' 5'11!> S8f 'S72 _,,,,, "'

~ S'fD ·$,$ S'"7o . -/.''' ~.u, ~-7Z~

S'~' Sll -~, 5IJ -/,JJJ. t~~.Hz.

!SZ G-6" ~;7.1i'

--·-

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 19: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

., --- -·····- .. --·-··. ··--------

' -f

~ '

i

1 -------'--J

_·;' .·-

••

••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 20: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

~· 1!3

''13~ -.) :i5t:>

<"'.13'1 - .P ~:=:o

·' <1:-... ;r t)

"' ""'"1 ()

-.'"~./S3 0

. ,).l,.t;.1 - t>./00

-(l,4f)O - C.4aa

-0. 701>

- v '1~~ - ~ 7$~

-0 9.!3 - Z.S(JC

-o.fot~ - z ./)t:J<>

-1.1-.JZ

-!.'IR

-1,~16

-I~SJ

/)

2.ZI9

;.siJ

2ezs

-.?-'531

-Z.b/'1

.J4,..

,!.l1f-

;:.~7

1·318

l..!Z!J

-.?.2tb

-.:.$(}1

-z .... ' '"

-t:J.

:.J"f9

2.'511

1 'ff.(,

u .. ss

- t ·'-"' • 2'. 7J'f

~··

'l I.

-..,',· I . I I .. I .,

#_,..

"""' ~,... i

! 1

I I i

.7~/.r.ll/ }.Sf.911 Ji'O. ,01'

201-ZZB 1~71113 52Z-3S3

2b3.~ 2(:.!.739 !Z~.9eJ'I

ZO'I.tb4 Z64.91!} :·ZS,4SJ'

i l l I

l -Z.0/.21;1 -z!?1.97/ -::l't),!Of

-z~;.zzs -ZhZA/3 ·:·Z2 .%1 I

I -z~.~. 139 -SZ.!. .'?(J'$

i : I> 7, JN 71.067 /!.bZ!:!>

/o7.M!!> /Z$.:ZCO ;ent I.

i I 142..J~o 16'7.119 ;?.2~5

l i 14£;.941'

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 21: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

' . ... • ,,.. ~ ~ •t ' ... .__

AIU-~~-.s~qz-P ......, .. . '21t cw-19.......___ ....

-~~ff:.!.lii.C.._a~!2L~:rd£...;J;~~"=· ;z;, A!.; :::.c;.._,I.A_··· ..;,:~-~...,:z-.:~::;..:.;;...-~-'1_.:=: ·. -;j;

0

/-"btt:· t:hs;o~.lk!I.N,...,.s A.s P~G:s~7.tr.t:J .o..u 7;;, ~ltiiS 6-n"'.V t::J11.1 _f.w6.4!'7"<S ,:'~ ..... ;'S1

i="n~ /);sN-10<:"1~ ~~~ ;J,!':, .... .A/PF~.

:..o.··

••

••••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 22: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

. . ...

/.d. f!r~€., W.lfM 'h;TI~ft~M"N;.'' ;;;, .r.4 E< Zf"'M$!

E!;,7 FJ:J~ EJ;,.,.

155tJ./ .::'.1?7 /15'8,1,

11:.<1-lJ. 4- .J.t12t.. f/.J2,7

lb~i.!' 12~/.$'

1/J>.l) -.!J.F4/ 773. 56.7

J'.?.IP

/9t'.J.9

EJ;,~

J.tl()::)

.}'.JII/5'

2.711

11M.? -l • .f.f'l

E.J;l..,.

1/-16.!) 127P..,.

ll/9,8

12fH.f!,

b8.z. )-1.(7

1.5 I 310.5

.· .. . ! ..

. !

El;:.,. . .;/JJ!1"'

-:.Z.911 11-16.5 ! -/~.5'17]

-2.9/1 /2.?.'-!4 I

-/S-57£ i

-2.110 11-19.,'3 -/~S7S

'-291.7f

2.1-"Z .1797 C:J.z fr!.,970

2.19o $-1.0 /4.t:I.JZ

,t'. () 13!!).3 '-4 . .5'60 -t'. 7ZS' /~bJ.6 - 7. 'Ji:ll

-l;lllf

-2.m

.;> .2..!7

&. 72.5 Nt%.z.. . 6./SZ 'f.D72..

~7U.

' >

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 23: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

'' '

.. ····

I

! i I I

••

•••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 24: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

.,, . ,'· '· . ·· .•.. ' . ' '·' ..

'' ! .. .. I

I I. i ' ; j.

\ .. ;:-.ir

~h,~ r

rJ;,~,. rJ;.:-- E.J;ifr .-E~,. E,r;f,. £::r;._,. £4:,.

12,;t,,"1 -1'!-.5# 1261.7 -3.4-t;.Z 123~./ -3.~{ ;:r4.".7 ~927

l~f'l;.S' -;$.5/17 I!~Zs· -$.41 13~,() -.S.<I-bb 1]!7.f... :J. '!21 /i"f-1.2. -~572 /:Jfi.Z -$.4~ l!-7fi.4- c):fztl

0

J'P.5'.5 ;s.t>fz Jf.S':5 f,J&,2. .3.~ 3/3.~ ~,::. '!t:JI ,

~$1./ :~.1)/(-. )$9.1 3.3.$'9 35(,1 ~n.3 -~·'/()()

,)l!'.b .!. 1!'.1 .2<//.~ !.1$"(, ZJ1~ tJ 0

/682.7 - t'. """

/(, .,.., -0.-HI- ll:>ln4.S p

/71».'1 -t'.~Z. /~fJ,b -d.~.z. /e4/.Z. -~.372

17~·"' ..:.;1>.!1.1 nu..t5 -1.-tft" 1&,7/,j? -/.-lfb~ i

17-1~1 -2.~.-

t../41 /838."1

11'/J,.f ·.1.~~

•··-· -•·•-. ,..,.,;., .... •-"'~"-·•-·v-·-n--·-., ... -----.. --~-----._~--- -..--~-----"

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 25: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

' '•. ~ ". ::·~ .... : ... ·: .. ;,. .... : ' ....

... I

• i l l i· l

••

•••

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 26: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

;-.·.

,~.;,/ ~

/jff. 3

/!I~·· r

/~{,I).'Z

t7'1!.0

;:(,~

.~.~·n:'

~.722.

g, 7tH

J.?W,

5J;, .; E~

IJ Zb. 3 /tJ. 1!i:.

II ¥1.9 //./JS()

12;9.0 //.11-/.

117~ -1/. Jf:,O

IJ'l·Z ·//.229

' . I

Ec/;u 6!-.~, E./;z• l I

1/f:!.l /7. {;~/ · ::_~s .. ~o

IZ.S7.Z -,''( ..... }', i

' 12 96 .. 1' . ur.o

··. j·' .. : . ...

·' i

.E<(J,:.

.?52.!::?

: :;:.,v,~ : :. .r:,.,JJ

nz . .t?f;

17/.rl'4- I

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 27: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

••

·····, .. ·.. . - .. ·.

··.·.

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 28: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

/;:~.9 •/,2.~71. ,,.,.;,'! 21.2!S 'e'.f/.3 -;:; . .f9;J

f..:;.J!J • .f.. -/i!.ff6 !4~.5· t4.b:)K '4-.-~~-:" .:;::t, 7#

I?JI.o ,[.f.;4:? y ~~ ;'<'!? -!-/. 997. /;";' Jt: •• - -f'}".,l(;; , .

.A""N. h .:;'/. 7/Z

/.77./ :7! ..d]h ;

211:.~ 14"/.f/1 lti. 71"3. II:. 7"3.1 - 5.::;15 · z.:::r;.z lf7.t1? -5./21 )

!1/J: J -/ .• ,, l"Jl'i. ~

'lfb'/.b -5.898

... ~ ............. _ ... R·--·•- ... -,,. ____ .. __ .....,_..._,....;..., ______ _

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 29: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

' .. '

,c' .·... :

>.-:>= ·, I r I ' l I ..

...

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 30: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

/4.17S<J

. ·£9.1il9

~ 19.651'?

" .'?

()

. : .·· .. •'' ·.

l -s~.t-14~ ., :ff-1!11 o .o

:·t.JKtf 1 -;9.051f o I I I'

0

I)

: ·112.~$ (;. ; ~4.10!7 i -IS.lfM I J,//U·~ ·!lt~-.zon! U.7o3~ l.~)tl 1 -/.,S!So

I ·I ; -tZ S/73 j -3.St-1+ --32.7U.!J 1 3.5J.4-0

-c-.~112 II -/.&nr., • -5.SZJtJ !1.'-112 I ' e> 0 1 -4. 'Nre. 1 -v. ·fue.

I , ! I 0 1 -tJ. 9'5/JI:. ~- P. I /tiZ.

: .:.:.'1;;0;..

; -J¢ • .,1!)05

' i -C.,\'4-:'0

. ' . . . . . . . . ·-~- ..- __ .,.. ... _ _.;· ...... -, ... '

~ ., .

·' f.'

-t:>./14 2

-r t/.l i-1 !

/!, M,

lb #,

IJ,l )1._

::.

~-------------.RA~ tlr 5"7~~s --------.,.._-------IJIII':'-'~<~------------1•1.~" •<~~JAu r:- r~Difl-.~~~1....---..-~

r~~.J"!; f"-1-.5 f'.-.j,(J' 7'•~#e> ••rQ~;y<.:'!'Af'l! 7'•.;.00#.1} 1'.f.z:'> ;

-..:J/,.2.

_,:,, • '::;; !-.

ll

1?.~

-.I u .o --~-~ t -h.i'sr -f.::..nz.

0 12 .)0~

7.5

"'·?"f7

I? ;:J7

: .. ------------·--------- K~

-.t.f.5. 1 't'

-; ./'J(i

() I

--.!f.. :3

0 0

,:;

-I/. 73 0

0 -73 I

-~.2(:,1'JJ -7.3

-.t.rn

...._ ___ ~.· ... ,...,;, .. ·~----~·~r~------- A .. AIT ,,_AI• _______ ___. ...... tr ...... .:. ..... , 7"·-#<11'? 1"1/:(Jt) 1"•,t1•- .,...,s .,.-,..ao -r ... .z.s -:'"•so ISn~l

-H.:L

b.'-3~ t..~u

() I -<IU.I r- --1/':J. - 14/5'.2.

t; -7.1,1() -£.'f.tl:j -7.()96

-50!. 0 -5~1. 6

-4 .?'!5/ .:.eo

{)

1.".11.3 0

- 1 ·' 717

[ -.. \ - <~-.;01 L

{ ...

·' ,,

·-"· r~ 0

,.,

(,)

fi.ir-

-e.. -.?.01'/

0

., ()

/.tf'b -730~]

-5~.1

-/.4.1."1- -/ .. -.~.n I __ .. ~ ... --

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 31: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

o,

, . . ·.t

"~ . · .. , . . _· .. ·· t .... ,,,. I.

::'>-"~ :: ··: .: .. ~~~.: ~' . . , .:· """' -·: . . i ·,.,,~ :.Pr· --~~l:s$ • I

, ...

. l'/.lf£~T t/IWIA~JM~~~> . •1e -f' t"- . -- --~!? -.,.,.15 ,.,,., ,-:.,, .,..,,. - ;,_ .•• r•.-t.t:M~t~ -r •II r~,f.r

-t/5~.~ - .t/.S,:). b -~u, --1.'!/..tJ. -·~.1.'-9:5 -;.,.49.? -<11~?., f 7. "'I'Z. 7-tiO!" 2~1-/.Z o--. 0 0 0

i

I () 0

.. 0

I 0 (":) 0 t'.) " I

';'. .. c•l 7.!1~~ g,.t/U, -/.9-H ... ;.~.fl -A~~ - l, 9<tl$ l () (.) 0 c) 0 0 " 0 l

l ._9,/,()V;. -12·~1'1 -/2·'-"' -It'.~-' -,2.5{)'/ -;.,, 7 S"o 'f ' I -~1.1 -~~-2 -Z~b 0 0 0 () i -S'.!If -- " . .;:re, -ti.S"'I'/ -/.?.zf/<1 -/.?.2'116 i •• ..

't'.

R;,;,,Ji;F ,p, Swns ::•·

I. r- j

,."''·IJttb I tit r- ..e--; . .

"1'·4;•.11). '!{.~. 1"ri'J'.Y.:; .,.--,,. f" I

- ,1():6,() -~2 -.50'1.(, . ~5()7. b -~~./ I

() -Jf,!'.~

() :> -'·"''' () ;:.6ZO 0 0 0

() (') 0 d' tfJ 0 c.) 0

-I.'U:J 0 -125'" "' It· "U'X. -I. 11 I -1. ftl/ -/.1-12 I It) f) 0 ~ ()

1-::J " 0

-1·5~! f) /I. 'HI " -1'/. 7t-r -Z.S't#i/ -zsenr -r.sttr () 0 () () " a 0

I) J • .t/2/ " -J..1r'6 -q_H'- -..-z Z-''-_ .::/L. ZN

tJ/1". ': w·~.s """'k .s :1li'4PS-.

f"•N~ j ll ,...,_

- ..,.,tl.tr "!"fqf.lt" ,.._,.,.,. •. ~tiO

-~9/.1, -~~S-7 ... ,.$ .• . - .,.~,.tJ, z ... .... -N.,!. ·- 'll.f2 .2 -~7Z.%

0 0 D 'oz. z•"? . :;.u.~ . 2,J'1D ;.~'f#- leJ; 7.'9 (J e) () _,.,.,,.,

-I~U.f -/~.1/.7 .;.~~-5'" -?tJ/1,7 '•

-/.1~1 -I·N't -/,lit/' z. !';1./f(; Z$6 .. U Zl'lo$/'1 ZJf.f~1 1/l .• ff:'):., ·'· " -tf!.i ·.

'- ; .. ~ () 0 -1!5.1.1 -lf/'S,.S -1M-/ --/75.1' ... z~'S" -: .lfjt.)f' -z.;.u -Zf.l.~J -::w.ll#1 •lltf.tt>; .· " ...

() ~ 0 -:.h -f,/ -1 . .:~'. -,t}.f ,·:

·'·· -h"';tt!~ -4-/.1./D ·.··

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011

Page 32: Riverkeeper (RIV) Pre-Filed Evidentiary Hearing Exhibit ... · TN' 5?-"~"5 Ml~AH11'i' _ .4-~I' Rl/#,a't".rN.d"..V?".-%..c"r/P..V b, .W !_-- - • ·~rlll' .~~~~"" ,.~;w·.. ,t:;.-41-1

l ..

PI.Q~t $''rNISS -~-------------------:

..,. ~~"-'"'-.t1f'N,V -------10;,..-tj·------ ,.,,.~.,.· ,_,.-r.wo, -<&'f'#' ........... I 7"'1. ~~,. __ --_ • .: :u •· :--: "t r: f'· .f.~., r~r (')6 ·r. ~,.,_.. ... •I'; I" - l " r . -r . .,. --- ~ , , - ,, -··

-·lc"'.:. 11 /!.J , 2~.7 -· ~C--.2 I Zt.. !:" l --1-.q~./! -t:~>-:. -"-"t?-7 ',

-.:· . .;,;: · ~:.-.~z~: ~-;::7~ ·j . .;.:;:.:. -!2.n;.· -14S~ -/7.M __ .s -IQ-t(,_; \

14/~.i ltl-:-'.'9 /4!1.7 14SI.~ 7(;1.7 -4!5.-f.f... -7?1.9 ""'"'977.1 '

-2!':'.t.Z 7 -;'!"6-lb;::. -23f.~"l1 -2!~·5Z -/1/,.,..,z. ~.J'!?. c::.467 17/.::JS.~ . ,;.-~Q I ./_ , I lft.,_::.>,J 47~5 --;-o.~.i' -J.~ff-Z -'-'5'~.5

::9!". l!""b 2.9 7.$ -97-lv' 1 - 1~-:!~. ~ .

:..9 - _1';.! ;.~.

.;,<,;

71..f"!7

/#.~9~

//),/

4/.40.}

- !!7.1 I -(;,"' 0

-9/JJf _-:P. 79?_

:4f";.'lillf ,!; -:--,.rs-; -----------------

je ---- -r: ~ 'll ' -;: .

- ~'""IN.t.-l'' •./)l'dlo'O~ -"'1-""<t( ~..r ... ~ I · <,:·; .. t·=z 115 -r., J4"'-:'\ v .. ,N-v:; ..,._.,_. ":!"~· A:av.....,

PLIIA; ~ Vlf/.uJ~fii)IP$-

'f"•LS ";"Er U '1r Zft.

-·~!;; 3:1."' ~;.l/1'1 ~r , --!Ot:,.p ·:~ . 17}. 745

-~.~.{

- t·l (_, . b - :· s 7./:• __ ., 79. !i

?'.1'3 7 1.~ 1l.15tl

·94~1 -/~·2.'1 21b.t/

Jh/.1.f') .~'f.!'J'S --~-&.so

-~1-/. S"' -11,1. 3 /!~. 2.

•/15.7!2 - ~:.()35 1,.1.11.0

-133. / -1•'!7.1 -15.!'. f 7.$60

_,_~,.,] --1--.?, .4- ..:.f26.2. - 471:J.4- - 4..31~4

/7.S7~ /9.113 4.Zii' -/.tJ<i£1 !J.O

5S9.'f 1'14 .() ..!~~. 2. 795 . .,_ -/.;.;..-. f -'JS:/12. ·/#.Ill --t~l.'lst, 1r7."~Z tf. P ?3

~1/f.l

IZD.<;;.N -/.J/, .3

ll.z.~•

-IB(,.<;

17!./H -NJI!T. :r ll.W,!"'

-7!/.S -.1,~3 -//P-1

z.2.n.z._ -~'"b- -!!-5"3 '""'-----------....;_--I'I'Air S '?'I~.S ,__ ___________ 9 ----·--------·r """-_,$_ r•d "1'"-l!t.$ ~~..."'t:' __ .,...'liP

(;_tJ

-J(,~ rl!

:1.rr~

-/.;I.)

- 4441. 7 ~<19 7. It -506. 7 --/99. 6 tJ •• /1.tl

-l/.2.9

;~.ff3

-/U.~

--;;, ' -IN. I

- fj,t;tt/1 -.<.i.~o<l

o.o

-Jw.lf

zfl.rtS"' -/,;~5

-J?.Pf$"

·(').0

-11.2.'1

ttt~.,rJ

-MJ -5l.Pf!"

-11.,,1 -1/tl./

-~.s""' -~·~Cf

l ,._ _____ j ------·-----

j./41

-I~S'f-1

;'~6.11

-lfl.$.1

-lf1.11f1

.<.$. _'{',_-t:;t.lll#$

-]!)I. 0 ?7.1

P.O -i.,Ph

~~~.1 I

.;. ; iJ ./itt~ ! . ""'·' l !/1.~/Z.J

B.Z !

7~ .IZf

RIV000053G Submitted: December 27, 2011