River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23,...
Transcript of River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23,...
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
1/108
Di$ 88!
GD ]OE
\u~peae Liup} ij }oe Udg}em \}h}e|
PGZEP LED]EP CCL#^e}g}gidep#
z$
]OE MIPAG]IPWHU]OIPG]W IJ]OE \]H]E IJ DERWIPK#
Pe|~idmed}$
ID ^E]G]GID JIP RPG] IJ LEP]GIPHPG ]I
]OE \U^PEAE LIUP] IJ DER WIPK#
H^^ECCH]E MGZG\GID# JGP\] ME^HP]AED]
^E]G]GID JIP RPG] IJ LEP]GIPHPG
FIDH]OHD \$AH\\EW CHUPEDLE O$]PG@E
AH\\EW *BHGC#CC^ Liud|ec ij Pelipm
8 Ohu|ep Ohcc
\ug}e 5>> 8525 Ah||hlou|e}}| Hze$
Rh|ogdb}id# M$L$ 0>>>5 Lha`pgmbe# AH >08
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
2/108
XUE\]GID\ ^PE\ED]EM
8$ Roe}oep }oe Jgj}o Haedmaed} ~epag}| h
|}h}e }i medw lia~ed|h}gid }i hd irdep jip ci|| ij
}oe peh|idh`cw ~pi`h`ce mezeci~aed} ~i}ed}ghc ij h
lidmeadem mezeci~aed} |g}e }hked }opiubo eagded}
miahgd ~pileemgdb|# udce|| }oe ~pi~ep}w irdep lhd
|oir }oh} mezeci~aed} rgcc liae }i jpug}gid gd }oe
dehp ju}upe$
0$ Roe}oep# gd hrhpmgdb fu|} lia~ed|h}gid ud!
mep }oe Jgj}o Haedmaed}# h |}h}e ahw elcume mha!
hbe| pe|uc}gdb jpia mecg`eph}e bizepdaed}hcgd}epjepedle rg}o h mezeci~aed} ~pifel} }oh} mechw|
mezeci~aed} hdm |u~~pe||e| }oe ~pi~ep}w| zhcue h}
}oe }gae ij }oe }hkgdb izep roh} g} riucm i}oeprg|e
ohze `eed$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
3/108
gg
^HP]GE\ HDM PUCE 07$: \]H]EAED]
^e}g}gidep Pgzep Led}ep CCL g| h roiccw!irdem
|u`|gmghpw ij Pgzep Led}ep Oicmgdb| CCL# roglo gd
}upd g| roiccw irdem `w Pegd C^$ Pegd C^ g| ~pg!
zh}ecw oecm$
Gd hmmg}gid }i Pgzep Led}ep CCL# @chlkhlpe
@pgmbe Lh~g}hc CCL hdm \RO Judmgdb Lip~$ repe
lchgahd}|!h~~ecchd}| gd }oe liup} `ecir hdm hpe
Pe|~idmed}| gd }og| Liup}$
]oe Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij Der
Wipk# hl}gdb h} }oe pexue|} ij }oe Lg}w Udgzep|g}w ijDer Wipk# rh| lidmeadip hdm pe|~idmed} gd }oe
liup} `ecir$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
4/108
ggg
]H@CE IJ LID]ED]\
XUE\]GID\ ^PE\ED]EM $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ g
^HP]GE\ HDM PUCE 07$: \]H]EAED] $$$$$$$$$$$$$ gg
]H@CE IJ HU]OIPG]GE\ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ z
^E]G]GID JIP RPG] IJ LEP]GIPHPG $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8
I^GDGID\ @ECIR $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8
FUPG\MGL]GID $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8
LID\]G]U]GIDHC ^PIZG\GID GDZICZEM $$$$$$ 8
\]H]EAED] $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0
PEH\ID\ JIP BPHD]GDB ]OE RPG] $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8=
H$ ]og| Liup} \oiucm Bphd} Pezger
]i Melgme Roe}oep ]oe Jgj}o
Haedmaed} Pexugpe| Fu|} Lia!~ed|h}gid Jip Mezeci~aed} Zhc!
ue Ezed Roepe ]oe ^pi~ep}w
Irdep Lhddi} \oir ]oh} Mezec!
i~aed} Rgcc Liae ]i Jpug}gid
Gd ]oe Dehp Ju}upe$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 85
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
5/108
gz
@$ ]og| Liup} \oiucm Bphd} Pezger
]i Melgme Roe}oep H ^pi~ep}w
Irdep Ahw Pelizep Mhahbe|
Pe|uc}gdb Jpia Bizepdaed}hc
Gd}epjepedle Rg}o H Mezeci~!
aed} ^pifel} H| ^hp} Ij ]oe
Hrhpm Ij Fu|} Lia~ed|h}gid$ $$$$$$$$$$ 08
L$ ]og| Liup} \oiucm Bphd} Pezger
]i Melgme Roe}oep ]oe Jgj}o
Haedmaed} ^pezed}| H Liup} Gd
H Lidmeadh}gid ^pileemgdbJpia Hp`g}phpgcw Elcumgdb Ip
Medwgdb ^pi`h}gze Jiple ]i
Ahpke}!@h|em Ezgmedle Ij ^pi~!
ep}w Zhcue# \ulo H| ]e|}gaidw
@w ]oe Irdep# Jgdhdlgdb ^pi!
~i|hc|# Hdm Ijjep| ]i Ceh|e$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$ 05
M$ ]oe Xue|}gid| ^pe|ed}em Hpe
Ga~ip}hd} Dh}gidhc G||ue| ]oh}
Rhpphd} ]og| Liup}| Pezger$ $$$$$$$$$$$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
6/108
z
]H@CE IJ HU]OIPG]GE\
LH\E\6
Hcai}h Jhpaep| Ecezh}ip * Rhpeoiu|e Li$ z$ U$\$#
=>7 U$\$ =2> /872< /8?2?' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 82
Lhme z$ Udg}em \}h}e|#
08< J$0m 8
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
7/108
zg
Lia$ Me~}$ ij Ogborhw| z$ ]updep#
=72 \$R$0m 52 /Kw$ 8720'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0=
Eh|}epd Ed}ep~pg|e| z$ H~jec#
50= U$\$ =7? /877?' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 08' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 87
Bpedgep z$ Lg}w ij Der @emjipm#
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
8/108
zgg
Oicae| z$ \iu}o Lhpicgdh#
5=2 U$\$ >:' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0:
Oidmh Ai}ip Li$ z$ I`epb#
580 U$\$ =85 /877=' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0 /Am$ 87?7' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 07
Fiod|id z$ Lg}w ij Agddeh~icg|#
::2 D$R$0m 8>7 /Agdd$ 0>>
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
9/108
zggg
AlLhdmce|| z$ Udg}em \}h}e|#
07? U$\$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
10/108
g
\haaid| z$ Udg}em \}h}e|#
='$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 07
\hd Hd}idgi Pgzep Hu}oipg}w z$ Bhppe}} @pi}oep|#
50? \$R$0m 0:: /]e$ Lgz$ H~~$ 8725' $$$$$$$$$$$ 00# 05'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8>' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 2 /Aglo$ H~~$ Mel$ 8?# 877?' $$$$$ 07
U$ \$ ex pec$ hdm jip U|e ij ]edde||ee Zhccew
Hu}oipg}w z$ ^irec|id#
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
11/108
Udg}em \}h}e| z$ 8$:>= Hlpe| ij Chdm#
0>88 RC 85::>85 /E$M$Zh$ H~p$ 05# 0>88' $$$$$$$$$$ 00
Udg}em \}h}e| z$ 8>> Hlpe| ij Chdm# Aipe ip Ce||# gd
Ahpgd Liud}w# \}h}e ij Lhc$#
=:? J$0m 80:8 /7}o Lgp$ 8720' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ J$2= /5}o Lgp$ 877:'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ Hlpe| ij Chdm#:>5 J$0m 2:0 /5}o Lgp$8727'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8?
Udg}em \}h}e| z$ J$0m
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
12/108
g
Udgzep|g}w Lia~u}gdb Li$ z$ Cwke|!Wiudb|}ird
Lip~$# 5>= J$0m 58? /5}o Lgp$ 872=' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0?
Rh|ogdb}id Ahpke} Ed}ep~pg|e|# Gdl$ z$ Lg}w ij
]ped}id# ? /D$F$ 8725' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0
Rh|ogdb}id Ae}pi~icg}hd Hpeh ]phd|g} Hu}oipg}w z$
Udg}em \}h}e|# 5= Jem$Lc$ 0> /Jem$Lc$ 0>>0' $$$$$$$$ 8?
Rh|ogdb}id \u`up`hd \hdg}hpw Liad z$ U}gcg}ge|#
Gdl$ ij Ahpwchdm# 225 H$0m 882? /Am$ 0>>8' $$$$$$$ 0>
Rgccgha|id Liud}w Pebgidhc ^chddgdb Liaad z$
Ohagc}id @hdk ij Fiod|id Lg}w#
=2< U$\$ 820 /87?5' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ =/`' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 80
PUCE\6
Jem$P$Ezgm$ 2>0 $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 02
PEBUCH]GID\6
00 D$W$L$P$P$ 0>0$:8 $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 7# 8>
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
13/108
gg
AG\LECCHDEIU\6
5 F$ \hlkahd# DGLOIC\ ID EAGDED] MIAHGD
8?$>5[8' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8?
Dgloic|# ]OE CHR IJ EAGDED] MIAHGD
0< h} 0< /877>' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 02
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
14/108
^E]G]GID JIP RPG] IJ LEP]GIPHPG
^e}g}gidep Pgzep Led}ep CCL /Pgzep Led}ep'
pe|~el}juccw ~e}g}gid| jip h Rpg} ij Lep}giphpg }i pe!
zger }oe fumbaed} ij }oe \u~peae Liup} ij Der
Wipk# H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid# Jgp|} Me~hp}aed} /H~~ec!
ch}e Mgzg|gid' gd }og| lh|e$
I^GDGID\ @ECIR
]oe i~gdgid ij }oe H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid /^e}$ H~~$
8h!5h' g| pe~ip}em h} 2= H$M$# 7>5 D$W$\$0m 8?$]oe i~gdgid ij }oe \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk Liud}w
/Cechdm MeBph||e# F$' /^e}$ H~~$ :h!08h'# g| udpe!
~ip}em$ ]oe Ipmep ij }oe Liup} ij H~~ehc| medwgdb
gd ~hp} hdm mg|ag||gdb gd ~hp} }oe ai}gid jip cehze }i
h~~ehc /gm$ h} 88 RC 5>=85=2 /D$W$ Il}$ 05# 0>88'$
FUPG\MGL]GID
Id Ahw 8># 0>88# }oe Liup} ij H~~ehc| medgem gd
~hp} hdm mg|ag||em gd ~hp} Pgzep Led}ep| ai}gid jip
cehze }i h~~ehc$ ^e}$ H~~$ 88# }oe Liup} ij H~~ehc| medgem pehpbuaed} /pe!
oehpgdb' ij }oe ai}gid jip cehze }i h~~ehc$ Gm$ h}
=0h$ ]og| Liup} oh| fupg|mgl}gid udmep 0? U$\$L$
8052$
LID\]G]U]GIDHC ^PIZG\GID GDZICZEM
]oe Jgj}o Haedmaed} }i }oe Udg}em \}h}e| Lid!
|}g}u}gid ~pizgme|# gd pecezhd} ~hp}6 dip |ohcc ~pg!zh}e ~pi~ep}w `e }hked jip ~u`cgl u|e# rg}oiu} fu|}
lia~ed|h}gid$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
15/108
0
\]H]EAED]
]og| lh|e lidlepd| ide ij }oe chpbe|} lidmeadh!
}gid| ij ~pgzh}e ~pi~ep}w gd }oe og|}ipw ij Der Wipk
Lg}w }oe udu|em mezeci~aed} pgbo}| ij hd ed}gpe
lg}w `cilk gd }oe Cgdlicd Led}ep hpeh ij Ahdoh}}hd#
roglo rh| `egdb mezeci~em `w Pgzep Led}ep h| h
auc}g!u|e liaaeplghc# pe}hgc# hdm pe|gmed}ghc lia!
~ce$ ]oe lh|e ~pe|ed}| }opee cebhc xue|}gid| lpg}glhc
}i }oe lid}gduem zg}hcg}w ij }oe Fu|} Lia~ed|h}gid
buhphd}ee ij }oe Jgj}o Haedmaed}6
/g' Roe}oep }oe bizepdaed}| i`cgbh}gid }i lia!
~ed|h}e jip }oe ci|} mezeci~aed} ~i}ed}ghc ij h lid!
meadem |g}e /gdlcumgdb lia~ed|h}gdb jip }oe
mezeci~ep| ejjip}| gd aizgdb h ~pifel} jiprhpm' h~!
~cge| idcw roepe }oe ~pi~ep}w irdep lhd meaid!
|}ph}e }oh} }oe mezeci~aed} rgcc liae }i jpug}gid gd
}oe dehp ju}upe$
/gg' Roe}oep }oe bizepdaed} ahw hzigm ~hwgdb#
h| ~hp} ij h fu|} lia~ed|h}gid hrhpm# mhahbe| pe!
|uc}gdb jpia mecg`eph}e bizepdaed}hc gd}epjepedle
rg}o h mezeci~aed} ~pifel} }oh} |u~~pe||e| }oe
~pi~ep}w| zhcue h} }oe }gae ij }oe }hkgdb# lia~hpem
}i roh} g} riucm i}oeprg|e ohze `eed$
/ggg' Roe}oep h |}h}e liup} ahw elcume# ip medw
hdw ~pi`h}gze zhcue }i# i}oeprg|e lia~e}ed} ahpke}!
`h|em ezgmedle ij ~pi~ep}w zhcue# |ulo h| }e|}gaidw
`w }oe ~pi~ep}w| irdep# jgdhdlgdb ~pi~i|hc|# hdm ij!
jep| }i ceh|e hdm `uw# |icecw `elhu|e }oew hpe di}
~pe|ed}em `w h pehc e|}h}e h~~phg|ep$
]oe|e cebhc g||ue| ohm h ~hc~h`ce ga~hl} id }oepe|uc} gd }og| lh|e# ahkgdb }oe |}h}e| jgdhc hrhpm ij
fu|} lia~ed|h}gid gd }og| lh|e bedugdecw lidjg|lh}i!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
16/108
8!8>
/0>8>' /~cuphcg}w i~gdgid' /i~gdgdb }oh} ]hkgdb| Lchu|e e}edm|
}i fumglghc melg|gid|'; Lg}w ij Aid}epew z$ Mec Aid}e Mude|# 50:
U$\$ :?2 /8777' /u~oicmgdb h fupw jgdmgdb ij h pebuch}ipw }hkgdb
roepe h |epge| ij ~pi~i|hc| }i mezeci~ }oe ~pi~ep}w repe medgem
hdm ehlo }gae aipe pgbipiu| meahdm| repe ga~i|em'; ^ogccg~|
z$ Rh|ogdb}id Cebhc Jiudmh}gid# 50= U$\$ 85: /877?' /oicmgdb
}oh} gd}epe|} gdliae bedeph}em `w judm| oecm gd h}}ipdew
hlliud}| rh| ~pgzh}e ~pi~ep}w ij irdep ij ~pgdlg~hc jip
~up~i|e| ij ]hkgdb| Lchu|e'; Eh|}epd Ed}ep~pg|e| z$ H~jec# 50=
U$\$ =7? /877?' /oicmgdb }oh} pe}pihl}gze ga~i|g}gid ijude~el}em hdm mg|~pi~ip}gidh}e cgh`gcg}w zgich}em Jgj}o
Haedmaed}'; Michd z$ Lg}w ij ]gbhpm# 580 U$\$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
17/108
=
8$ Gd 87?:# }oe Lg}w Udgzep|g}w ij Der Wipk
/LUDW'# hd hbedlw ij }oe \}h}e ij Der Wipk# hdm
}oe \}h}e ij Der Wipk ed}epem gd}i hd hbpeeaed} hj!
jel}gdb }oe uc}gah}e pemezeci~aed} ij hd h~~pi!
gah}ecw 8:>#>>>!|xuhpe!jii} lg}w `cilk `e}reed 8>}o
Hzedue hdm 88}o Hzedue)Re|} Edm Hzedue hdm
Re|} 5?}o hdm Re|} 57}o \}pee} /Cgdlicd Led}ep
Hpeh @cilk'$ H| ~hp} ij }oh} hbpeeaed}# }oe ipgbgdhc
irdep| hbpeem }i pedizh}e Ohhped Ogbo \loiic hdm
`ugcm hd hdde id h jii}~pgd} ij h~~pigah}ecw
:>#>>> |xuhpe jee} h| h mezeci~aed} ~pifel}$ ]og|~oh|e rh| jgdg|oem gd 87??# hdm }oe :>#>>>!|xuhpe!
jii} ~hplec /}ibe}oep rg}o }oe }oed!lia~ce}em h~!
~pigah}ecw #>>>!|xuhpe!jii} `ugcmgdb' rh| |icm
}i }oe \}h}e$ Elcumem jpia }oe |hce rh| }oe hmmg!
}gidhc mezeci~aed} ~i}ed}ghc /Pe|epzem Pgbo}|'
jpia ahkgdb }oe ~hplec ~hp} ij h `cilk!cidb |gdbce
vidgdb ci} udmep h bedephc chpbe!|lhce mezeci~aed}
~epag}$ H| h pe|uc} ij }oe|e Pe|epzem Pgbo}|# }oe
`hchdle ij }oe `cilk liucm `e `ugc} }i h bpeh}ep med|g!
}w rg}o aipe ~pijg}h`ce u|e| }ohd riucm i}oeprg|e
ohze `eed ~i||g`ce$
Udmep }oe 87?: hbpeeaed}# LUDW hdm }oe \}h}e
hbpeem rg}o }oe ipgbgdhc irdep|# Pgzep Led}ep| ~pe!
mele||ip| gd gd}epe|}# }i lii~eph}e gd pevidgdb }oe
Cgdlicd Led}ep Hpeh @cilk# |i }oh} mezeci~aed}
liucm `e ahgagvem id }oe peahgdgdb h~~pigah}ecw
8>>#>>>!|xuhpe!jii} ~hplec /}oe Pgzep Led}ep Ci}'#
gdlcumgdb hmmgdb pe|gmed}ghc u|e| }i }oe ~epag}}em
u|e|$ ]oe @cilk rh| }oed videm jip ahdujhl}upgdb
~u`cgl `glwlce eh|eaed} lid|}g}u}em }hkgdb jip roglo
lia~ed|h}gid au|} `e ~pizgmem roepe di} peh|idh`cw
~pi~ip}gidh}e }i }oe ga~hl} ij ~pi~i|em mezeci~aed}'$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
18/108
5
u|ep|# roglo ~epag}}em ijjgle hdm i}oep mezeci~aed}
di} }oed gd meahdm `u} di} pe|gmed}ghc ip hdw aeh!
dgdbjuc haiud} ij pe}hgc$
Gd 8778!8770# Pegd /Pgzep Led}ep| irdep' hl!
xugpem lid}pic ij }oe |g}e jpia zhpgiu| jee irdep|
hdm ceh|eoicmep|# h ~pile|| roglo |u`|}hd}ghccw gd!
lpeh|em }oe zhcue ij }oe ~hplec$0
]oe hbpeeaed} lhccem jip LUDW hdm }oe \}h}e }i
lii~eph}e gd roh}ezep riucm `e pexugpem }i pevide
}oe ed}gpe lg}w `cilk |i }oh} mezeci~aed} liucm `e
ahgagvem id }oe Pgzep Led}ep Ci}# gdlcumgdb hmm!
gdb pe|gmed}ghc u|e| }i }oe ~epag}}em u|e|$ Oirezep#
`ebgddgdb gd Melea`ep 877:# Pe|~idmed}# ]oe Mip!
ag}ipw Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij Der Wipk# /MH\!DW'# ripkem gd lidfudl}gid rg}o LUDW hdm }oe
\}h}e }i gd}epjepe rg}o Pgzep Led}ep| mezeci~aed}
ejjip}|$ MH\DW g| hd gdme~edmed} |}h}e hbedlw }oh}
LUDW# h |}h}e hbedlw# u|e| }i hlxugpe ~pi~ep}w }oh}
g} rg|oe| }i lidmead$ MH\DW hdm LUDW kder
Gd 877=# Pegd `ebhd
}oe mezeci~aed} hdm pevidgdb ~pile|| ij roh} ~pia!
g|em }i `e ide ij }oe chpbe|} mezeci~aed}| gd Der
Wipk Lg}w# roglo riucm }hke |ezephc wehp| }i lia!
~ce}e$ Pegd gd}edmem }i mezeci~ Pgzep Led}ep h| hauc}g!u|e liaaeplghc# pe}hgc# hdm pe|gmed}ghc lia!
~ce$ @w Fucw 877=# Pegd ohm h||ea`cem h }eha ij
hplog}el}| hdm me|gbdep|$
0 ^pgip }i }oe h||ea`chbe# }oe Pgzep Led}ep Ci} rh|
edlua`epem `w h cidb }epa ceh|e oecm `w Bedephc Ai}ip|#
roglo |u`|}hd}ghccw pemulem g}| zhcue$ ]oe ceh|e rh| di} cidb
ediubo }i fu|}gjw hdw |gbdgjglhd} ga~pizeaed}| `w Bedephc
Ai}ip|# `u} g} rh| }ii cidb }i ahke mezeci~aed} ejjip}| `w }oeirdep jpug}juc$ ]oe zhcue ij }oe roice udpe|}pgl}em ~hplec gd
}oe h||ea`chbe Pegd edbgdeepem# ecgagdh}gdb Bedephc Ai}ip|
gd}epe|}# rh| }ou| |u`|}hd}ghccw aipe }ohd }oe |ua ij g}| ~hp}|$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
19/108
:
}oh}# }oe jup}oep Pgzep Led}ep| mezeci~aed} ~pi!
leemem# }oe aipe e~ed|gze g} riucm `e }i }hke }oe
~pi~ep}w `w eagded} miahgd$ /P$85=>h /di}e| ij
aee}gdb; GJ [PGZEP LED]EPQ BE]\ \G]E PE!
VIDEM U^RHPM# HJJEL]\ IUP HLXUG\G!
]GID' /lh~g}hcgvh}gid gd ipgbgdhc'$
^pgip }i }oe }hkgdb# MH\DW# gd lidfudl}gid rg}o
LUDW hdm }oe \}h}e# oecm u~ }oe pevidgdb hdm me!
zeci~aed} ~pile|| ij }oe Pgzep Led}ep Ci} `w aipe
}ohd 87 aid}o| rg}o ah}epghc ga~hl}$ Jip eha~ce#
pevidgdb jpia ahdujhl}upgdb }i }oe lid}ea~ch}emliaaeplghc)pe}hgc)pe|gmed}ghc agem u|e rh| mechwem
jpia 8772 ud}gc Ahplo 8777# hdm Pgzep Led}ep rh|
pexugpem }i pe~chle g}| me|gbd }eha h} h lpg}glhc
|}hbe$ /P$82>5!82>:# 8>:2:!8>:7>'$ ]oe liup} `ecir
di}em }oh} MH\DW| jgdbep~pgd}| repe hcc izep }oe
~chd$ /P$0>2>8$
/P$52>!520# 82>5!82>:# 8>=2
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
20/108
2
udu|uhccw chpbe ~pi~ep}w gd }oe agm!}ird re|} |el!
}gid ij Ahdoh}}hd$ /^e}$ H~~$ 82h$' Gd lid}ph|}#
Pgzep Led}ep| e~ep} h~~phg|ep| ohm zhcuem }oe
~pi~ep}w h} -8?7#>>>#>>># rg}oiu} lid|gmepgdb }oe
edohdlem zhcue lidjeppem `w mezeci~aed}$ Hd e!
~ep} mezeci~ep lhcluch}em }oh} edohdlem mezeci~!
aed} zhcue }i `e hd hmmg}gidhc -2?#>>>#>>>$:!85552$' ]oe liup} hl!
lipmem di zhcue }i mezeci~aed} edohdleaed} jpia
mezeci~ep hl}gzg}ge| hdm medgem ~pi`h}gze zhcue }i
|u`|}hd}ghccw hcc ij }oe h~~phg|hc }e|}gaidw ~pijjepem
`w Pgzep Led}ep| rg}de||$
\elidm# }oe }pghc liup} oecm }oh} fu|} lia~ed|h!}gid mie| di} gdlcume gd}epjepedle mhahbe|# |i }oh} h
hdm |}pul}uphc ~chd| }opiubo |loeah}gl me|gbd /P$7
rhw eh|eaed}| /P$7:0?!728:'; /m' `gm| jip meaicg}gid hdm
lcehd!u~ ripk h} }oe |g}e /P$ 5:>!5:=# 8>07=!8>072'; /e' `gm| jip
buhphd}eem!ahgaua!~pgle lid|}pul}gid lid}phl}| /P$7758!
77::# 7770!8>>::'; /j' lid|}pul}gid jgdhdlgdb `gm| jpia UCGLI
/P$80725!?>'# HPL\ /P$807?8!8077?'# BAHL# hdm i}oep|; /b'
e~pe||gid| ij gd}epe|} gd figd} zed}upe jgdhdlgdb rg}o ~pi~i|em
kew }epa| gdlcumgdb ~pgle /P$882=!8827# 8872!80>># 807!:75# 282!287# 2
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
22/108
7
lidmeadee oh| h`|icu}ecw di peaemw gd eagded}
miahgd ~pileemgdb| roed h bizepdaed} hbedlw# gd
hmzhdle ij lidmeadh}gid# mecg`eph}ecw pemule| }oe
zhcue h |g}e riucm ohze ohm h} lidmeadh}gid# `w
}hkgdb |ulo |}e~| h| mechwgdb g}| pevidgdb hdm i}o!
eprg|e ga~emgdb g}| mezeci~aed}$ /^e}$ H~~$ 05h!
07h$' Gd h |e~hph}e ~pileemgdb# }oe Der Wipk liup}|
e~pe||cw jiudm }oh} bizepdaed}hc ag|lidmul} gd}ep!
jepem rg}o pevidgdb hdm mezeci~aed} }oh} riucm
ohze edohdlem }oe zhcue ij }oe ~pi~ep}w /P$80>2:!
?># 88
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
23/108
8>
}oe }e|}gaidw ij \}ezed Biim|}egd# hd ex~ep}
mezeci~ep pe|~id|g`ce jip -8 `gccgid gd pehc e|}h}e
~pifel}| gd Der Wipk Lg}w hdm dh}gidhccw# pebhpmgdb
}oe ahpke} zhcue ij Pgzep Led}ep| ~pi~ep}w hdm me!
zeci~aed} ejjip}| hdm row mezeci~ep| ~pejep Ahd!
oh}}hd |g}e| gd ele|| ij 5>>#>>> |xuhpe jee} cgke }oe
Pgzep Led}ep Ci} /P$02>0h!0?=>h# 0?5:h!07:>h';
}oe }e|}gaidw ij Rgccgha$ Hmha|kg# jipaepcw gd
lohpbe ij pehc e|}h}e jgdhdle h} Lpemg} \ug||e# pe!
bhpmgdb Pgzep Led}ep| h`gcg}w }i jgdhdle }oe ~pifel}
hdm }oe ~pi~ep}w| zhcue /P$8=?:h!85>7h'; hdm
}oe zhcue!pech}em }e|}gaidw ij Pgzep Led}ep|
irdep# Fi|e~o Kipjj# roi ohm |~ed} izep wehp| gd
}oe pehc e|}h}e `u|gde|| hdm ohm mezi}em |ezephc
wehp| }i }oe Pgzep Led}ep ~pifel}# gdlcumgdb h||ea!
`cgdb }oe ~pi~ep}w# ohzgdb g} pevidem# me|gbdem# ed!
bgdeepem# hdm ahme lid|}pul}gid!pehmw# rogce
i`}hgdgdb ijjep| hdm gdmglh}gid| ij gd}epe|} jpia u|!
ep|# jgdhdlgep| hdm i}oep| gd}epe|}em gd }oe ~pi~ep}w
`h|em id og| mezeci~aed} ~chd$ /P$880
0>0$:8 hdm peju|em }i h~~cw hdw ij Ap$ Kipjj| ezg!
medle }i }oe g||ue ij zhcue gd me}epagdgdb fu|} lia!
~ed|h}gid$ /^e}$ H~~$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
24/108
88
ij }oe mezeci~aed} ejjip}| }i h `uwep h} -2?#02>#>>>#
hdm ~pi~ep}w| chdm zhcue# gdlcumgdb g}| ~ow|glhc me!
zeci~aed} ~i}ed}ghc# h} -87:#>>>#>>>$ /P$028>h!
0288h# 0?57h!0?:>h$' Oe hc|i |}h}em gd og| pe~ip}|
}oh} oe riucm ohze ~glkem u~ hdm jiccirem }opiubo
id Pgzep Led}ep| ~chd| ohm MH\DW di} lidmeadem
}oe ~pi~ep}w gd H~pgc 0>>8$ Gd lid}ph|}# }oe }pghc
liup} pucem }oh} Pgzep Led}ep| jucc mezeci~aed} ~i!
}ed}ghc deem di} `e lid|gmepem `elhu|e }oe ~pifel}
rh| di} eg|}edle h} }oe }gae ij }oe }hkgdb$ /^e}$
H~~$ 82h$'\gagchpcw# Ap$ Hmha|kg riucm ohze }e|}gjgem }oh}
Lpemg} \ug||e rh| ~pe~hpem }i jgdhdle }oe Pgzep
Led}ep ~pifel} /P$8=7=h!8=75h' hdm }oh} gd og|
fumbaed} }oe ~pi~ep}w rh| rip}o h} ceh|}
-80>#>>>#>>> h} }oe edm ij 8772 hdm }oe `ebgddgdb ij
877? /P$85>5h!85>:h'$ ]oe }pghc liup} oecm }oh} }oe
^pi~ep}w rh| rip}o ce|| }ohd -5>#>>>#>>> h} }oh}
}gae$ /^e}$ H~~$ 8
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
25/108
80
ip }i ceh|e ip `uw |u`|}hd}ghc ~hp}| ij }oe mezeci~!
aed}# jpia Zipdhmi /P$887:!8872'# Hzhcid @hw
/P$88:5!88::# 887=!887:'# Ae}pi~icg}hd Mezeci~!
aed} Bpiu~ /Ceoahd @pi}oep|' /P$8872!80>>#
80752!807:5'# Vupglo Pe /P$80>8!80>=# 807::!
8072='# BAHL /P$82!:75# 8>?5>!8>?55'# hdm i}oep|$
]oe }pghc liup}| pucgdb| }ou| elcumem ip mg|!ag||em h oi|} ij }oe zepw ahpke}!`h|em ezgmedle ij
zhcue id roglo }oe ed}gpe aimepd liaaeplghc ~pi~!
ep}w ahpke} i~eph}e|$
Pgzep Led}ep ~pe|epzem g}| jemephc lid|}g}u}gidhc
i`fel}gid| gd }oe }pghc liup} /^e}$ H~~$ =
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
26/108
8#>>>
gd edohdlem zhcue jip }oe vidgdb lohdbe hdm ~ep!
ag}| i`}hgdem `w Pgzep Led}ep$ /^e}$ H~~$ 0h$' ]oh}
pemulem Pgzep Led}ep| lia~ed|h}gid }i
-?0#=5>#>>>$5 Gd hcc i}oep pe|~el}|# }oe H~~ecch}e
Mgzg|gid hjjgpaem }oe \u~peae Liup}| ipmep| hdm
fumbaed}$:
]oe H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid oecm }oh} }oe Jgj}o
Haedmaed} lh}ebipglhccw mie| di} pexugpe }oe biz!epdaed} }i hrhpm lia~ed|h}gid jip ci|} mezeci~aed}
~i}ed}ghc udce|| }oe ~pi~ep}w irdep lhd |oir }oh}
mezeci~aed} rgcc liae }i jpug}gid gd }oe dehp ju!
}upe$ /^e}$ H~~$ 0h!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
27/108
8=
pedle gd Pgzep Led}ep| ezed}uhccw |ulle||juc ejjip}|
}i i`}hgd pevidgdb rh| ~pi~epcw mg|ag||em h| di} hd
h~~pi~pgh}e eceaed} gd zhcuh}gid# ~pi~epcw |u`fel} }i
}oe fupg|mgl}gid ij }oe Liup} ij Lchga|# hdm mu~cglh!
}gze ij h lchga hcpehmw `ejipe }oh} liup}$ /Gm$ h} =h$'
]oe liup}# hbhgd hl}gdb lh}ebipglhccw# |ga~cw `hppem
|ulo pelizepw h| ~hp} ij }oe lidmeadh}gid ~pileem!
gdb rg}oiu} mg|~u}gdb }oh} }oe gd}epjepedle hdm me!
chw gd}ed}gidhccw ga~emem Pgzep Led}ep|
mezeci~aed} hdm ahme g} rip}o |gbdgjglhd}cw ce|| h}
}oe }gae ij }hkgdb$Jgdhccw# }oe H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid i~gdem }oh}
[eQzgmedle ij ijjep| jip }oe ~pi~ep}w rh| ~pi~epcw e!
lcumem `elhu|e# haidb i}oep peh|id|# ijjep| ij |ulo
dh}upe hpe gdhmag||g`ce id }oe g||ue ij zhcue$ /^e}$
H~~$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
28/108
85
Gd |i oicmgdb# }oe Der Wipk liup} ezg|leph}em
}oe Fu|} Lia~ed|h}gid Lchu|e `w lpeh}gdb lidjcgl}|
rg}o melg|gid| ij i}oep cirep liup}| hdm rg}o fumb!
aed}| ij }og| Liup}$ ^hp}gluchpcw gd zger ij }oe
liaaeplghc ga~ip}hdle ij }oe Der Wipk pehc e|}h}e
ahpke}# }og| Liup} |oiucm bphd} pezger }i hmmpe||
}oe judmhaed} lid|}g}u}gidhc xue|}gid| ~pe|ed}em `w
}og| lh|e$
H$ ]og| Liup} \oiucm Bphd} Pezger ]i Melgme
Roe}oep ]oe Jgj}o Haedmaed} Pexugpe|
Fu|} Lia~ed|h}gid Jip Mezeci~aed} ZhcueEzed Roepe ]oe ^pi~ep}w Irdep Lhddi}
\oir ]oh} Mezeci~aed} Rgcc Liae ]i
Jpug}gid Gd ]oe Dehp Ju}upe$
H lidmeadgdb hu}oipg}w ij}ed# h| oepe# }hke|
~pi~ep}w rogce mezeci~aed} ejjip}| hpe idbigdb$ Gj
}oe irdep| hpe }i `e hjjipmem fu|} lia~ed|h}gid# }oe
edohdlem zhcue lpeh}em `w }oi|e mezeci~aed} ejjip}|
hdm }oe zhcue ij }oe ~pi~ep}w| jucc ~ow|glhc ~i}ed}ghc
au|} `e }hked gd}i hlliud}$ @u} }oe Der Wipk liup}
lpeh}em h der i`|}hlce }i fu|} lia~ed|h}gid `w medw!gdb lid|}g}u}gidhc ~pi}el}gid jip mezeci~aed} ejjip}|
udce|| }oe irdep lhd |oir }oh} mezeci~aed} rgcc
liae }i jpug}gid gd }oe dehp ju}upe$ /^e}$ H~~$ 0h!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
29/108
8:
[FQu|} lia~ed|h}gid aehd| }oe jucc aide}hpw
exugzhced} ij }oe ~pi~ep}w }hked$ ]oe irdep g| }i `e
~u} gd }oe |hae ~i|g}gid aide}hpgcw h| oe riucm
ohze illu~gem gj og| ~pi~ep}w ohm di} `eed }hked$
Hcai}h Jhpaep| Ecezh}ip * Rhpeoiu|e Li$ z$ U$\$#
=>7 U$\$ =2># =2
lpeh}em `w }oe fu|} lia~ed|h}gid pexugpeaed} g| }oe
jucc hdm ~epjel} exugzhced} gd aidew ij }oe ~pi~ep}w
}hked$ Udg}em \}h}e| z$ Agccep#
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
30/108
82
rhw# aulo ce|| }oh} g} rgcc liae }i jpug}gid gd }oe
dehp ju}upe# h| }oe Der Wipk liup} oecm$ Gd
AlLhdmce|| z$ Udg}em \}h}e|# 07? U$\$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
31/108
8?
@ihpm ij Liud}w \u~epzg|ip| ij ^pgdle Rgccgha
Liud}w# ZH z$ Udg}em \}h}e|# 02: J$5[8'';
Udg}em \}h}e| z$ ?$=8 Hlpe| ij Chdm# Aipe ip
Ce||# \g}uh}em gd Iphdbe Liud}w# \}h}e ij ]ex$# :?>
J$0m
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
32/108
87
h`gcg}w!}oe pehcg|}gl# i`fel}gze ~i}ed}ghc u|e| ij }oe
~pi~ep}w lid}pic$' /lg}h}gid| iag}}em'$
I}oep |}h}e| ohze di} hmi~}em }oe Der Wipk pe!
|}pgl}gid6
Jircep Gppezilh`ce ]pu|} 8770!8 z$ Lg}w ij
@iucmep# 82 ^$< /Lici$ 0>>8' /Gd h ~epah!
ded} }hkgdb lh|e# zhcuh}gid ezgmedle ahw gdlcume h
~pi`h`ce ju}upe lohdbe gd chdm u|e pe|}pgl}gid| jip
~up~i|e| ij lhcluch}gdb ~pe|ed} ahpke} zhcue$';
Lg}w hdm Liud}w ij Oidicucu z$ Ahpke} ^chle#C}m$# 582 ^$0m 2# 87 /Ohr$ 872
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
33/108
0>
Rh|ogdb}id \u`up`hd \hdg}hpw Liad z$ U}gcg!
}ge|# Gdl$ ij Ahpwchdm# 225 H$0m 882?# 80>< /Am$
0>>8' /]i hmag} ezgmedle ij }oe gdjcuedle ij }oh}
jhl}ip id ~pe|ed} zhcue# h vidgdb u~bphme au|} `e
peh|idh`cw ~pi`h`ce h| ij }oe h~~cglh`ce zhcuh}gid
mh}e$';
Pecgbgiu| ij \hlpem Oehp} ij ]exh| z$ Lg}w ij
Oiu|}id# ?:# :00 /]e$ 8770' i~gdgdb h|
}i deem }i lid|gmep hcc ij }oe u|e| }i roglo [~pi~ep!
}wQ g| peh|idh`cw hmh~}h`ce hdm jip roglo g} eg}oep g|
ip gd hcc peh|idh`ce ~pi`h`gcg}w rgcc `eliae hzhgch`cerg}ogd }oe peh|idh`ce ju}upe$' /lg}h}gid hdm gd}epdhc
xui}h}gid ahpk| iag}}em'$
]oe g||ue g| hd ga~ip}hd} ide }oh} rhpphd}| }og|
Liup}| pezger$ Gd }og| lh|e# }oe ~pi~ep}w irdep
|~ed} agccgid| hdm hllia~cg|oem ahfip }h|k| id }oe
pihm }i mezeci~aed}$ We} }oe Der Wipk liup} medgem
hdw zhcue jip }oe|e ejjip}|$ ]oe lwdglhc ce||id h~!
~ehp| }i `e }oh}# gj }oe bizepdaed} g| bigdb }i ga!
~eme mezeci~aed} `elhu|e g} ~chd| }i lidmead }oe
~pi~ep}w# g} |oiucm di} }hke ohcj aeh|upe| `u}|oiucm gd|}ehm ed|upe }oh} g}| ag|lidmul} g| ejjel}gze
ediubo }oh} }oe mezeci~ep mie| di} `ebgd ~ow|glhc
lid|}pul}gid$
]og| Liup} |oiucm bphd} pezger }i melgme oir jhp
h ~pifel} au|} ~pileem `ejipe mezeci~aed} hl}gzg}w
hdm ~i}ed}ghc g| lia~ed|h`ce gd hd eagded} miahgd
~pileemgdb$ ]oe xue|}gid g| elidiaglhccw lpg}glhc }i
mezeci~ep| hdm cedmep|# roi `ehp }oe pg|k| ij |ulo
zed}upe|$ Ij}ed ahdw wehp| ~h|| `e}reed hlxug|g!
}gid ij ~pi~ep}w hdm lia~ce}gid ij h mezeci~aed}$ Gj}oe Der Wipk liup}| melg|gid g| hccirem }i |}hdm# g}
rgcc lpeh}e hdi}oep pg|k jhl}ip }i roh} g| hcpehmw }oe
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
34/108
08
pg|kge|} cezec ij }oe pehc e|}h}e gdmu|}pw$ G} rgcc mg|!
pu~} }oe liaaeplghc pehc e|}h}e ahpke} hdm jpu!
|}ph}e }oe kew ~up~i|e| ij }oe fu|} lia~ed|h}gid
pexugpeaed}$
@$ ]og| Liup} \oiucm Bphd} Pezger ]i Melgme
Roe}oep H ^pi~ep}w Irdep Ahw Pelizep
Mhahbe| Pe|uc}gdb Jpia Bizepdaed}hc Gd!
}epjepedle Rg}o H Mezeci~aed} ^pifel} H|
^hp} Ij ]oe Hrhpm Ij Fu|} Lia~ed|h}gid$
]og| Liup} |oiucm bphd} pezger }i ahke lcehp}oh} bizepdaed} hbedlge| hpe di} jpee }i gd}epjepe
rg}o mezeci~aed} ejjip}| hdm# }opiubo }oe u|e ij
pebuch}ipw aelohdg|a| ip i}oep mecg`eph}e hl}|# pe!
mule }oe zhcue h} }oe ze|}gdb mh}e ij mezeci~aed}
~pifel}| gd ~pibpe|| }oew |eek }i lidmead$ ]oe Der
Wipk liup} `phvedcw h~~pizem bizepdaed}hc h`u|e ij
}oe lidmeadh}gid ~irep }i cirep }oe fu|} lia~ed|h!
}gid hrhpm }oh} h ~pi~ep}w irdep rgcc uc}gah}ecw pe!
legze$ Ph}oep }ohd oicmgdb }oh} gd}epjepedle
mhahbe| hpe ~hp} ij }oe fu|} lia~ed|h}gid buhphd!
}eem `w }oe Jgj}o Haedmaed}# }oe Der Wipk liup}`ecir i~gdem }oh} }oew repe di} hd h~~pi~pgh}e
eceaed} gd zhcuh}gid$ ^e}$ H~~$ =h$
]oe Der Wipk liup}| melg|gid |xuhpecw lidjcgl}|
rg}o ~pelemed} ij }og| Liup}$ Gd Udg}em \}h}e| z$
Pewdicm|# '# jip eha~ce# }og| Liup}
i~gdem }oh} }i ~epag} bizepdaed} }i cirep }oe zhcue
ij ~pi~ep}w `w g}| ird hl}| riucm di} cehm }i }oe
fu|} lia~ed|h}gid }oh} }oe Lid|}g}u}gid pexugpe|$
Gm$ h} 8:; |ee hc|i Hcai}h Jhpaep| Ecezh}ip# =>7 U$\$
h} =2? /bizepdaed} ahw di} }hke hmzhd}hbe ij hdwme~pelgh}gid gd }oe ~pi~ep}w }hked }oh} g| h}}pg`u}h!
`ce }i }oe ~pifel} g}|ecj'$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
35/108
00
\gagchpcw# gd Udg}em \}h}e| z$ Zgpbgdgh Ecel$ *
^irep Li$# = Hlpe| ij Chdm# 0>88 RC 85::>85#
&< /E$M$Zh$ H~p$ 05# 0>88' /]oe \u~peae Liup} ij
}oe Udg}em \}h}e| oh| hlkdircembem }oh} g} riucm `ega~pi~ep jip }oe bizepdaed} }i me~pelgh}e ~pi~ep}w
zhcue| `w }oe }opeh} ij lidmeadh}gid hdm }oed }hke
hmzhd}hbe ij }oe me~pe||em ahpke} roed }oe ~pi~ep!
}w g| hl}uhccw lidmeadem$' /lg}gdb Zgpbgdgh Ecel$ *
^irep Li'$
]oe Der Wipk liup}| melg|gid `ecir hc|i lid!
jcgl}| rg}o fumbaed}| ij h dua`ep ij cirep liup}|$
]oe Lhcgjipdgh \u~peae Liup}# gd Kci~~ep z$ Lg}w ij
Rog}}gep# 5>> ^$0m 8
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
36/108
0 H$0m 2# /Am$ 0>>5' /oicm!
gdb }oh} h ~pi~ep}w irdep rh| ed}g}cem }i |eek lia!
~ed|h}gid gd gdzep|e lidmeadh}gid hl}gid jip
mhahbe| lhu|em `w jiup}eed!wehp mechw gd lidmea!
dh}gid ~pileemgdb|';
Lg}w ij Me}pig} z$ Lh||e|e /Gd pe Ecariim ^hpk
^pifel} \el}gid 8# Bpiu~ @'# 8>
/Aglo$ 87:5' /Gj hd hpeh oh| `eed ahme h rh|}echdm
`w }oe lidmeadgdb hu}oipg}w# }oe ~pi~ep}w irdep
|oiucm di}# `e i`cgbem }i |ujjep }oe pemulem zhcue ij
og| ~pi~ep}w$';
Fiod|id z$ Lg}w ij Agddeh~icg|# ::2 D$R$0m
8>7# 885!88: /Agdd$ 0>>
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
37/108
0=
}oh}# gj ~pi~ep}w irdep liucm |oir }oh} g} ohm `eed
|u`|}hd}ghccw mhahbem `w hl}gzg}ge| ij lg}w gd liddel!
}gid rg}o }oe h`hdmidem pederhc ~pifel}# g} rh| ed!
}g}cem }i mhahbe| gd }oe haiud} ij }oe me|}pul}gid ij
zhcue ij ~pi~ep}w lhu|em `w pederhc hl}gzg}ge|';
Lidpiw^pubo Bch|| Li$ z$ Liaaidrehc}o#
8!>0 /^h$ 872=' /oicmgdb }oh} ~pi~!
ep}w irdep ed}g}cem }i lia~ed|h}gid jip gdfupw
lhu|em `w ~pe!lidmeadh}gid ~u`cglg}w';
Cgdlicd Cihd Li$ z$ \}h}e# 5=5 ^$0m 8>5# 8>7!8>/Ip$ 872:' /jiccirgdbKci~~gdb';
Cu`ep z$ Agcrhukee Liud}w# 822 D$R$0m #
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
38/108
05
ch$Lgz$H~~$8772' /di pgbo} }i lia~ed|h}gid roepe
|}h}e hl}gzg}ge| mgm di} haiud} }i hd eeplg|e ij mi!
agdgid hdm lid}pic izep }oe ~pi~ep}w `w }oe lid!
meadgdb hu}oipg}w'$
]og| Liup}| pezger g| rhpphd}em }i hmmpe|| }oe
lidjcgl} id }og| judmhaed}hc xue|}gid udmep }oe
Jgj}o Haedmaed}$
L$ ]og| Liup} \oiucm Bphd} Pezger ]i Melgme
Roe}oep ]oe Jgj}o Haedmaed} ^pezed}| H
Liup} Gd H Lidmeadh}gid ^pileemgdb Jpia Hp`g}phpgcw Elcumgdb Ip Medwgdb ^pi`h!
}gze Jiple ]i Ahpke}!@h|em Ezgmedle Ij
^pi~ep}w Zhcue# \ulo H| ]e|}gaidw @w ]oe
Irdep# Jgdhdlgdb ^pi~i|hc|# Hdm Ijjep| ]i
Ceh|e$
]og| Liup} |oiucm bphd} pezger }i lid|gmep }oe
Jgj}o Haedmaed} lid|}phgd}| id }oe hu}oipg}w ij
|}h}e liup}| }i ipmep roice|hce elcu|gid| ij `pihm
lh}ebipge| ij ahpke}!`h|em ezgmedle ij zhcue gd lid!
meadh}gid ~pileemgdb|$ H| }og| lh|e gccu|}ph}e|#
|ulo elcu|gid| hpe }hd}haiud} }i hp`g}phpw peju|hc|
}i lid|gmep lid|}g}u}gidhccw pecezhd} eceaed}| ij zhc!
ue$ Oepe# }oe Der Wipk liup} hp`g}phpgcw medgem
hmag||gid ip ~pi`h}gze zhcue }i |u`|}hd}ghccw hcc ij
}oe ezgmedle ~pijjepem `w }oe mezeci~ep hdm hl!
kdircembem e~ep}| gd }oegp jgecm|# hl}gdb gd h ahd!
dep }oh} g| gdmg|~u}h`cw lid}phpw }i roh} }oe ahpke}
gd }oe pehc ripcm riucm ohze mide$ ]oe liup} jch}cw
~pelcumem ah}epghc }e|}gaidw id zhcue jpia }oe
~pi~ep}w| irdep /me|~g}e }oe }pghc liup}| pelibdg}gid
ij og| kdircembe' hdm jpia e~ep}| gd }oe pehc e|}h}ehdm jgdhdle gdmu|}pw roi lid|}hd}cw ezhcuh}em chdm
zhcue gd }oegp `u|gde||e| `u} repe di} jipahccw cg!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
39/108
0:
led|em h| h~~phg|ep|$ ]oe u~|oi} ij }oe|e ezgmed!
}ghpw elcu|gid| rh| }i me~pgze Pgzep Led}ep ij }oe
fu|} lia~ed|h}gid buhphd}eem `w }oe Jgj}o Haedm!
aed}$ ]og| Liup}| pezger g| rhpphd}em }i ed|upe
}oh} h |}h}e liup} mie| di} u|e puce| ij chr id ezg!
medle }i zg}gh}e h jemephc lid|}g}u}gidhc pgbo}$ Lj$
Oicae| z$ \iu}o Lhpicgdh# 5=2 U$\$ :'
/[]Qoe Lid|}g}u}gid $ $ $ ~piog`g}| }oe elcu|gid ij
mejed|e ezgmedle udmep puce| }oh} |epze di cebg}g!
ah}e ~up~i|e ip }oh} hpe mg|~pi~ip}gidh}e }i }oe
edm| }oh} }oew hpe h||ep}em }i ~piai}e'$8$ ]og| Liup} |oiucm bphd} pezger }i pezger }oe
Der Wipk liup}| mg|ag||hc ij h ~pi~ep}w irdep| }e|!
}gaidw h| }i zhcue$ ]oe Der Wipk puce lidjcgl}|
rg}o }oe h~~pihlo ij i}oep fupg|mgl}gid| }oh} }oe
i~gdgid ij h chdmirdep h| }i }oe zhcue ij og| chdm g|
hmag||g`ce rg}oiu} jup}oep xuhcgjglh}gid$ Udg}em
\}h}e| z$ = J$0m ?>> /5}o Lgp$ 87?
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
40/108
02
g}| zhcue aepecw `w zgp}ue ij og| irdep|og~$ ]oe
irdep g| meeaem }i ohze |ujjglged} kdircembe ij }oe
~pgle ~hgm# }oe ped}| ip i}oep gdliae pelegzem# hdm
}oe ~i||g`gcg}ge| ij }oe chdm jip u|e# }i pedmep hd i~g!
dgid h| }i }oe zhcue ij }oe chdm$' /xui}gdb Dgloic|#
]OE C HR IJ EAGDED] MIAHGD 0< h} 0
/877>''; U$\$ z$ 8>#>
J$0m :!=8 /8>}o Lgp$ 87??' /oicmgdb ga~pi~ep
}oe mg|}pgl} liup}| elcu|gid ij h phdlo irdep| }e|!
}gaidw `elhu|e irdep ahw ijjep |ulo }e|}gaidw
rg}oiu} jup}oep xuhcgjglh}gid$ Jup}oepaipe# gd }e|}g!jwgdb h| }i }oe zhcue ij og| ~pi~ep}w }oe irdep g| ed!
}g}cem }i }oe ~pgzgcebe| ij h }e|}gjwgdb e~ep}$';
Pi`gd|id z$ Rh}}| Me}el}gze Hbedlw# :?5 J$0m 207#
20 hmzg|ipw liaag}}ee di}e
/rg}ogd }oe |li~e ij }oe puce hpe di} idcw e~ep}| gd
}oe |}pgl}e|} |ed|e ij }oe ripm $ $ $ `u} hc|i }oe chpbe
bpiu~ |iae}gae| lhccem |kgccem rg}de||e|# |ulo h|
$ $ $ chdmirdep| }e|}gjwgdb }i chdm zhcue|'$
0$ ]og| Liup} |oiucm hc|i bphd} pezger }i hm!
mpe|| roe}oep h liup} ahw elcume ip gbdipe i}oep!
rg|e lia~e}ed} }e|}gaidw ij ~pi~ep}w zhcue jpia}ogpm!~hp}w rg}de||e| h`ce }i ~pizgme ahpke}!`h|em
ezgmedle ij zhcue# |ulo h| jgdhdlgdb ~pi~i|hc| ip ij!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
41/108
0?
jep| }i ceh|e$ Aipe }ohd h led}upw hbi# gd \ohp~ z$
Udg}em \}h}e|# 878 U$\$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
42/108
07
roe}oep udhlle~}em ijjep| }i ~uploh|e |oiucm `e
hmag||g`ce$ Ezhd| z$ \hr}ii}o ^hp}dep|# 20< ^$0m
705# 70? /Gmhoi H~~$ 87?:'$
Lia~hpe Cezw z$ Udg}em \}h}e|# =>0 Jem$ H~~$
727# 7?0 /5}o Lgp$ 0>8>' /ezgmedle ij ijjep hmag||g`ce
me|~g}e \ohp~'; \haaid| z$ Udg}em \}h}e|# =2# &= /Aglo$ H~~$ Mel$
8?# 877?' /|hae'; ]eme|li z$ Aud$ Hu}o$ ij Ohvce
]ird|og~# 277 H$0m 70'
/hccirgdb ezgmedle ij hd i~}gid lid}phl} }i ~pize zhc!ue gd h lidmeadh}gid lh|e'# rg}o U$\$ z$ 8>#> J$0m : H$0m 8:?# 828 /Lidd$ 87?8' /|hae';Me~}
ij ]phd|~$ z$ Lilophd# 0?2 \$E$0m 577# :>> /Bh$ H~~$
87?8' /|hae'; Lia$ Me~}$ ij Ogborhw| z$ ]updep# =72
\$R$0m 52# 57 /Kw$ 872
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
43/108
aeplghc |iuple|$ ]oe ezgmedle gd }og| lh|e# jip e!
ha~ce# gdlcumem ce}}ep| ij gd}ed} hdm e~pe||gid| ij
gd}epe|} jip h jgdhdlgdb# ~uploh|e hdm figd}!zed}upe
mezeci~aed} ij }oe ~pi~ep}w# hdm ijjep| }i ceh|e ip
`uw |u`|}hd}ghc ~hp}| ij }oe mezeci~aed}# jpia chpbe
hdm pe|~el}em ~u`cgl hdm ~pgzh}e lia~hdge| roglo
mehc} mgpel}cw rg}o }oe mezeci~ep$ Gd aimepd pehc e|!
}h}e ~phl}gle |ulo gdmglh}gid| ij gd}epe|} hpe ~hp} ij
}oe zepw jh`pgl ij |e}}gdb ahpke} ~pgle|$ /P$8080!
808:$' H| h ah}}ep ij ezepwmhw ~phl}gle gd }oe pehc
e|}h}e gdmu|}pw# }epa |oee}| hdm ijjep miluaed}|}w~glhccw lid}hgd }oe kew elidiagl }epa| ij h ~pi!
~i|em }phd|hl}gid hdm hpe u|em h| }oe pihm ah~ }i
liaaudglh}e zhcue hdm hccir ~hp}ge| }i ~pileem rg}o
}oe lia~ce }h|k ij `pgdbgdb mezeci~aed} ~pifel}| }i
jpug}gid$ /P$2>>!2>0$' Roepe }oe ahpke} oh| ~pi!
zgmem auc}g~ce gdmglh}gid| ij zhcue jpia pe|~el}em
~u`cgl hdm ~pgzh}e lia~hdge|# }oi|e gdmglh}gid| ahw
`e }oe `e|} ezgmedle ij }oe ~pi~ep}w| zhcue hdm
|oiucm `e hmag||g`ce; oepe# }oew repe recc gd ele||
ij }oe fumbaed} `ecir$
]og| Liup} oh| gd|}pul}em }oh}# [rQoepe ~pgzh}e
~pi~ep}w g| }hked jip ~u`cgl u|e# hdm }oepe g| h ahp!
ke} ~pgle ~pezhgcgdb h} }oe }gae hdm ~chle ij }oe }hk!
gdb# }oh} ~pgle g| fu|} lia~ed|h}gid$ Udg}em \}h}e|
z$ Der Pgzep Liccgepge| Li$# 0:0 U$\$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
44/108
> Hlpe| ij Chdm# Aipe ip Ce||# gd Ahpgd
Liud}w# \}h}e ij Lhc$# =:? J$0m 80:8# 80::!:2 /7}o
Lgp$ 8720''; |ee hc|i Udg}em \}h}e| z$ 8=$ J$2=# 8>22 /5}o Lgp$ 877:' /oicmgdb}oh} mg|}pgl} liup} h`u|em g}| mg|lpe}gid gd elcumgdb
e~ep} rg}de|| }e|}gaidw h| }i chdm zhcue# ezed
}oiubo }oe mg|}pgl} liup} jiudm }oe ezgmedle chlkgdb
gd pecgh`gcg}w# `elhu|e gd hd eagded} miahgd hl}gid#
[eQ~ep} i~gdgid }e|}gaidw hlxugpe| |~elghc |gbdgjgl!
hdle $ $ $ roepe }oe |ice g||ue g| }oe zhcue ij lid!
meadem ~pi~ep}w' /gd}epdhc xui}h}gid ahpk| hdm
lg}h}gid iag}}em; `phlke}| gd ipgbgdhc'; Udg}em \}h}e|
z$ :?$7= Hlpe| ij Chdm# Aipe ip Ce||# \g}uh}e gd Ked}
Liud}w# \}h}e ij Mechrhpe# 78? J$0m
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
45/108
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
46/108
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
47/108
> 8525 Ah||hlou|e}}| Hze$
Rh|ogdb}id# M$L$ 0>>>5 Lha`pgmbe# AH >08
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
48/108
H^^EDMG_ ]H@CE IJ LID]ED]\
H^^EDMG_ H
Melg|gid ij }oe H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid# Jgp|}
Me~hp}aed}# Fude 8> $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8h
H^^EDMG_ @
Melg|gid ij }oe \u~peae Liup} ij }oe
\}h}e ij Der Wipk# Liud}w ijDer Wipk# mh}em H~pgc 8:# 0>>? $$$$$$$$$$ :h
H^^EDMG_ L
Ipmep ij \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk
Liud}w# ed}epem Ahw 07# 0>>?#
medwgdb ai}gid jip h der }pghc
/Oid$ Fhde \$ \iciaid# F$\$L$'#
rg}o di}gle ij ed}pw |epzem id
Fude 0# 0>>? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 00h
H^^EDMG_ M
Fumbaed} ij }oe \u~peae Liup}# Der
Wipk Liud}w# mh}em Fude 0# 0>>?
/Oid$ Fhde \$ \iciaid# F$\$L$'#
rg}o di}gle ij ed}pw |epzem id
Fude 5# 0>>? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
49/108
gg
H^^EDMG_ E
Iphc melg|gid `w \u~peae Liup}# Der
Wipk Liud}w /Oid$ Ahp}gd
\loiedjecm# F$\$L$'# mh}em Hubu|}
7# 0>>:# id ai}gid }i mg|ag||
lchga jip gd}epjepedle mhahbe|#
P$ 0>2:h!0>?2h /exlep~}' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 05h
H^^EDMG_ J
Iphc melg|gid `w \u~peae Liup}# Der
Wipk Liud}w /Oid$ Ahp}gd
\loiedjecm# F$\$L$'# mh}em Hubu|}
# 0>>:# rg}o di}gle ij ed}pw
|epzem id \e~}ea`ep 5# 0>>:#
P$0>??h!0>7>h $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 07h
H^^EDMG_ B
Ipmep hdm Aeaiphdmua Melg|gid `w
\u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk Liud!}w /Oid$ Cechdm MeBph||e#
F$\$L$'# id ai}gid| }i ~pelcume
ex~ep} pe~ip}|# ed}epem Dizea!
`ep 02# 0>>:# rg}o di}gle ij ed}pw
|epzem Dizea`ep 0?# 0>>:#
P$h!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
50/108
ggg
H^^EDMG_ G
Ipmep ij }oe Der Wipk Liup} ij H~~ehc|
mh}em Ahw 8># 0>88# medwgdb gd
~hp} hdm mg|ag||gdb gd ~hp} Pgzep
Led}ep| Ai}gid jip Cehze }i H~!
~ehc $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 88 medwgdb peoehpgdb $$$$$ =0h
H^^EDMG_ K
Exlep~}| ij Pgzep Led}ep| @pgej| gd }oe
\u~peae Liup}# \}h}e ij Der
Wipk# Der Wipk Liud}w $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ =h
H^^EDMG_ A
Exlep~}| ij Pgzep Led}ep| Ai}gid jip
Cehze }i H~~ehc gd }oe Liup} ij
H~~ehc| $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5=h
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
51/108
H^^EDMG_ H
Melg|gid ij }oe H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid# Jgp|}
Me~hp}aed}# Fude 8>
Jpgemahd# F$^$# Dhpmeccg# Ai|kirg}v# Jpeemahd#
Ahdvhde}!Mhdgec|# FF$
07:0!07:0H Gdme 8>078
Gd pe Fiod Fhw Liccebe ij Lpgagdhc Fu|}gleij }oe Lg}w Udgzep|g}w ij Der Wipk
Pgzep Led}ep CCL e} hc$#
Lchgahd}|!H~~ecchd}|!Pe|~idmed}|#
z
Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij Der
Wipk#
Lidmeadip!Pe|~idmed}!H~~ecchd}$
^gcc|`upw Rgd}opi~ \ohr ^g}}ahd CC^# Der
Wipk /E$ Cei Agcidh| ij liud|ec'# jip Pgzep Led}epCCL# h~~ecchd}!pe|~idmed}$
Kphaep Cezgd Dhj}hcg| * Jphdkec# CC^# Der
Wipk /Fhae| B$ Bpegc|oegaep ij liud|ec'# jip @chlk!
hlpe @pgmbe Lh~g}hc# C$C$L$ hdm \RO Judmgdb Lip~$#
h~~ecchd}|!pe|~idmed}|$
@epbep * Re``# CC^# Der Wipk /Lohpce| \$
Re`` GGG ij liud|ec'# jip pe|~idmed}!h~~ecchd}$
Fumbaed}# \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk Liud}w
/Fhde \$ \iciaid# F$'# ed}epem Fude 5# 0>>?# hrhpm!gdb lchgahd} Pgzep Led}ep CCL }oe ~pgdlg~hc |ua ij
-85#>:5#>>># `h|em id h melg|gid# |hae liup} /Cechdm
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
52/108
0h
B$ MeBph||e# F$'# mh}em H~pgc 8:# 0>>?# roglo# hj}ep h
didfupw }pghc# zhcuem Pgzep Led}ep"| ~pi~ep}w h}
-72#05>#>>> hdm memul}em }oe lidmeadip"| hmzhdle
~hwaed}| ij -?0#8?5#>>># udhdgaiu|cw aimgjgem# id
}oe chr hdm }oe jhl}|# }i zhlh}e }oh} ~ip}gid ij }oe
hrhpm roglo g| jip -8=#?>>#>>> gd edohdlem zhcue
jip }oe vidgdb lohdbe hdm ~epag}| i`}hgdem `w Pgzep
Led}ep# }oe ah}}ep peahdmem jip pelhcluch}gid ij }oe
gd}epe|}# hdm i}oeprg|e hjjgpaem# rg}oiu} li|}|$ Ip!
mep# |hae liup} /Fhde \$ \iciaid# F$'# ed}epem Ahw
07# 0>>?# roglo medgem Pgzep Led}ep"| ai}gid }i pei!~ed }oe }pghc jip |u`ag||gid ij hmmg}gidhc ezgmedle ip
jip h der }pghc# udhdgaiu|cw hjjgpaem# rg}oiu} li|}|$
]oe }pghc liup}"| jgdmgdb| gd }og| lidmeadh}gid
zhcuh}gid lh|e hpe `h|em id h jhgp gd}ep~pe}h}gid ij
}oe ezgmedle hdm re mg|lepd di `h|g| }i mg|}up` }oi|e
jgdmgdb| /|ee R$]$ Bphd} Li$ z \pibg# 50 DW0m =7:#
58> [87?8Q'$ Rogce jhgp ahpke} zhcue |oiucm `e `h|em
id }oe ogboe|} hdm `e|} u|e ij }oe ~pi~ep}w ezed
}oiubo }oe irdep ahw di} ohze `eed u}gcgvgdb g} }i
g}| jucce|} ~i}ed}ghc h} }oe }gae ij }oe }hkgdb /|eeAh}}ep ij ]ird ij G|cg~ [Ah|lgicgQ# =7 DW0m Q'# h u|e au|} `e e|}h`cg|oem h| peh|idh`cw
~pi`h`ce hdm di} h |~eluch}gze ip ow~i}oe}glhc hp!
phdbeaed} gd }oe agdm ij }oe lchgahd} /|ee Ah}}ep
ij Lg}w ij Der Wipk [PumdglkQ# 05 DW0m 8=:# 8=7
[87:7Q# peag}}g}up haedmem# 0: DW0m 2=? [872>Q'$
]oe |~eluch}gze dh}upe ij }oe ~pi~i|em mezeci~aed}
rh| |oird oepe `w# haidb i}oep }ogdb|# }oe }e|}g!
aidw ij Pgzep Led}ep"| ~pgdlg~hc hmag}}gdb }oh} h}
}oe }gae ij }oe }hkgdb oe ohm we} }i i`}hgd hdw jg!
dhdlgdb liaag}aed} ip hdw |gbdem ceh|e| jip }oe~pi~i|em mezeci~aed} ip# gd jhl}# hdw ij }oe pe!
xugpeaed}| }oh} riucm `pgdb }oe ~pifel} }i jpug}gid
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
53/108
[8728Q;Hpced ij Dhdue} z \}h}e ij Der Wipk# 0:
DW0m
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
54/108
=h
dh}upe hpe gdhmag||g`ce id }oe g||ue ij zhcue /|ee
@puaaep z \}h}e ij Der Wipk# 05 HM0m 0=5# 0=?!0=7
[87::Q'$ Lid}phpw }i Pgzep Led}ep"| lid}ed}gid# }oe
}pghc liup} mgm di} ag|h~~cw }oe puce gd Jpwe z Udg}em
\}h}e| /07< J 8>8< [870
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
55/108
5h
Aipeizep# bgzed }oh} }oe }pghc liup}"| mg|lpe}gid }i
pei~ed h lh|e hj}ep h ~hp}w oh| pe|}em |oiucm `e
|~hpgdbcw eeplg|em /|ee Cgdmedahd z Kpeg}vep# 2
HM=Q'# |ulo mg|lpe}gid |oiucm `e eep!
lg|em ezed aipe |~hpgdbcw roepe# h| oepe# }oe ai}gid
g| ahme hj}ep h melg|gid oh| `eed pedmepem$ Jgdhccw#
h| di}em# g} rh| udcgkecw }oh} }oe ezgmedle riucm
ohze ahme hdw mgjjepedle
Re aimgjw }oe fumbaed} |icecw id }oe bpiudm#
`h|em id iup pezger ij }oe pelipm# }oh} }oe haiud}
hrhpmem jip edohdlem zhcue jip i`}hgdgdb pevidgdbhdm |~elghc ~epag}| rh| mu~cglh}gze# |gdle g} rh| hc!
pehmw jhl}ipem gd}i }oe lidmeadip"| h~~phg|hc }oh}
rh| hlle~}em `w }oe liup}; gd hmmg}gid# }oe li|}| repe
di} miluaed}em$
]OG\ LID\]G]U]E\ ]OE MELG\GID HDM
IPMEP IJ ]OE \U^PEAE LIUP]# H^^ECCH]E
MGZG\GID# JGP\] ME^HP]AED]$
ED]EPEM6 Fude 8>
)|) Mhzgm \~ikidwLcepk
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
56/108
:h
H^^EDMG_ @
Melg|gid ij }oe \u~peae Liup} ij }oe \}h}e ij
Der Wipk# Liud}w ij Der Wipk# mh}em H~pgc 8:#
0>>?
\u~peae Liup} Ij ]oe \}h}e Ij Der Wipk
Liud}w Ij Der Wipk
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!_
Gd }oe Ah}}ep ij }oe H~~cglh}gid ij }oe Mipag}ipw
Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij Der Wipk }i hlxugpe }g}ce gdjee }i lep}hgd pehc ~pi~ep}w jip u|e gd h ~pifel} }i e!
~hdm hdm lid|icgmh}e
Fiod Fhw Liccebe ij Lpgagdhc Fu|}gle ij }oe
Lg}w Udgzep|g}w ij Der Wipk
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!_
Gdme Di$ 8>078
MeBph||e# F6
]og| ah}}ep rh| }pgem `ejipe }og| liup} rg}oiu} h fupw$ @h|em u~id }oe ezgmedle roglo G hlle~} hdm
`ecgeze# G jgdm hdm lidlcume h| jiccir|$ ]g}ce }i }oe
|u`fel} ~hplec ze|}em gd }oe Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w ij
}oe \}h}e ij Der Wipk /MH\DW'# }oe lidmeadip# id
H~pgc 88# 0>>8$ Lchgahd}# Pgzep Led}ep CCL# rh| }oe
jee irdep h} }oe }gae ij }oe lidmeadh}gid$ ]oe |u`!
fel} g| me|gbdh}em h| Ci}| 8# 5 hdm ~hp} ij 05 gd @cilk
8>?2 id }oe ]h Ah~ ij }oe Lg}w ij Der Wipk# @ip!
iubo ij Ahdoh}}hd$ ]oe |}pee} hmmpe||e| hpe ?5=!
?5? 88}o Hzedue# 508!5:2 Re|} 5?}o \}pee} hdm 50>!55> Re|} 57}o \}pee}$ ]oe |u`fel}# pel}hdbuchp gd
|oh~e# oh| h ci} hpeh ij 8>>#=82 |xuhpe jee} hdm h
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
57/108
2h
vidgdb jciip hpeh ij ?? |xuhpe jee}$ H| ij }oe
ze|}gdb mh}e# }oe |u`fel} rh| ga~pizem `w h }opee!
|}ipw rhpeoiu|e `ugcmgdb hdm piij}i~ ~hpkgdb bhp!
hbe$ ]oe |iu}ore|} lipdep ij }oe |u`fel} lid}hgd| hd
e~i|em `ecir bphme phgcpihm lu} roglo aeh|upe|
8>> `w 8>>$5 jee}$ ^up|uhd} }i h 872< eh|eaed}# hd
Ha}phk phgcpihm cgde }phzep|e| }oe lu}# puddgdb jpia
|iu}oeh|} }i dip}ore|} }opiubo }oe 88}o Hzedue hdm
5?}o \}pee} lipdep ij }oe |u`fel}$
H| ij Ahw 8># 8778# }oe |u`fel} ~peag|e| repe
irdem gd jee `w Ae}pi~icg| H||ilgh}e| GG /Ae}pi~i!cg|'$ @w hbpeeaed} ij }oe |hae mh}e# Ae}pi~icg| bhze
Pegd C$^$# hd hjjgcgh}e ij Pgzep Led}ep# hd i~}gid }i
~uploh|e }oe ~peag|e|$ ]oe |u`fel} ohm `eed ed!
lua`epem `w h aip}bhbe oecm `w h ch`ip ipbhdgvh!
}gid# }oe Hmmg}gidhc \elupg}w @edejg}| ^chd ij }oe
Ecel}pglhc Gdmu|}pw /H\@^'$ ]og| aip}bhbe ohm `eed
pelipmem id Melea`ep 0=# 87?2$ Id ip h`iu} Fucw #
8770# Ae}pi~icg| lidzewem }oe |u`fel} }i H^*H\@^
Oicmgdb Li$# Gdl$ /}oe Udgid' `w rhw ij h meem gd cgeu
ij jipelci|upe$ Id }oe |hae mh}e# }oe Udgid bhzePegd }oe i~}gid }i ~uploh|e g}| gd}epe|} gd }oe |u`fel}
`w rhw ij hd haedmem hdm aimgjgem ~uploh|e i~}gid
hbpeeaed}$ ]oe }phd|hl}gid g| me|lpg`em h| hd hpa|
cedb}o }phd|jep gd h pehc ~pi~ep}w }phd|jep }h pe!
}upd lep}gjgem `w }oe Udgid hdm Pegd$
Bedephc Ai}ip| Lip~iph}gid /BA' rh| }oe ce||ee
ij }oe |u`fel} |gdle Melea`ep 8728$ @w hbpeeaed}
mh}em Hubu|} 0
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
58/108
?h
hdm |hce mh}em \e~}ea`ep 85# 8772# Pegd hlxugpem
irdep|og~ ij }oe |u`fel} gd jee jpia }oe Udgid$ ]oe
}phd|hl}gid rh| lid|uaah}em `w `hpbhgd hdm h |hce
meem mh}em Fhduhpw # 877?$
@w di}hpgvem ce}}ep mh}em H~pgc 0?2$ ]oe ce}}ep g|h}}hloem }i h chdm u|e pezger h~~cglh}gid |u`ag}}em
}i }oe Lg}w| Me~hp}aed} ij Lg}w ^chddgdb id Hubu|}
?# 877: /MH\DW| eog`g} \'$ ]oe |u`fel} ohm `eed gd
A8!5 hdm A8!: vidgdb mg|}pgl}| ud}gc Pgzep Led}ep
lhu|em h lohdbe }i L=!2# L0!2 hdm L:!0 liaaeplghc
vidgdb }i `e ejjel}em id Ahplo 8:# 8777$ H} h`iu} }oe
|hae }gae# Pgzep Led}ep i`}hgdem jip }oe |g}e h chpbe
|lhce mezeci~aed} |~elghc ~epag} hdm i}oep |~elghc
~epag}| gdlcumgdb ide jip }oe u|e ij mezeci~aed}
pgbo}| hlpi|| mg|}pgl} `iudmhpge|$ ]oe der vidgdbhdm |~elghc ~epag}| repe dele||hpw }i edh`ce }oe
|u`fel} }i `e u|em jip liaaeplghc h| recc h| pe|gmed!
}ghc u|e$
]oe pelipm gdlcume| gdg}ghc# pe`u}}hc hdm |uppe~cw
h~~phg|hc| `w ]oepe|h A$ Dwbhpm# Pgzep Led}ep|
h~~phg|ep# hdm Pi`ep} Zid Hdlked# MH\DW| h~!
~phg|ep$ @i}o i~gdem }oh} }oe ogboe|} hdm `e|} u|e ij
}oe |u`fel} riucm ohze `eed h| h agem pe|gmed!
}ghc)liaaeplghc mezeci~aed}$ A|$ Dwbhpm bhze }oe
|u`fel} hd h~~phg|em zhcue ij -002#>>>#>>>$ Ap$ Zid
Hdlked zhcuem }oe |hae h} -?0#8?5#>>>$ @i}o h~!
~phg|ep| u|em }oe |hce| lia~hpg|id h~~pihlo rogce
A|$ Dwbhpm |u`ag}}em h chdm pe|gmuhc hdhcw|g| h|
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
59/108
7h
recc$ ]oe ahpke} zhcue ij pehc ~pi~ep}w g| }oe
haiud} }oh} ide me|gpgdb `u} di} lia~eccem }i ~up!
loh|e rgcc ~hw udmep ipmgdhpw lidmg}gid| }i h |eccep
roi me|gpe| `u} g| di} lia~eccem }i |ecc /R$]$ Bphd}
Li$ z$ \pipbg# 50 DW0m =7:# 58> [87?8Q'$ ]oe `e|} ez!
gmedle ij zhcue g| h peled} |hce ij }oe |u`fel} `e}reed
h |eccep udmep di lia~uc|gid }i |ecc hdm h `uwep ud!
mep di lia~uc|gid }i `uw /Ah}}ep ij Hccgem Lip~$ z$
]ird ij Lhagccu|# ?> DW0m
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
60/108
8>h
lchga }oh} }oe 877? lid}phl} ~pgle ij -=7#505#280 g|
udpech}em }i }oe |u`fel}| jhgp ahpke} zhcue$
Pgzep Led}ep h||ep}| }oh} }oe Udgid rh| udmep
lia~uc|gid |gdle Fucw 8770 }i }phd|jep }g}ce }i }oe
~pi~ep}w /Pgzep Led}ep| ^i|} ]pghc Aeaiphdmua ij
Chr h} 7'$ ]oh} hpbuaed} jgdm| di |u~~ip} gd }oe
pelipm$ Aipeizep# }oe `e|} ezgmedle ij |ulo lia~uc!
|gid riucm ohze `eed }oe }e|}gaidw ij h Udgid ijjg!
lghc$ Pgzep Led}ep| jhgcupe }i lhcc |ulo h rg}de|| g|
|gbdgjglhd}$ Fi|e~o Kipjj# Pgzep Led}ep| ~pgdlg~hc#
}e|}gjgem }oh} }oe lid}phl} ~pgle rh| `h|em u~id ~pe!me}epagdem |ua| ~hwh`ce udmep }oe i~}gid hbpee!
aed}$ Oirezep# |el}gid }opee ij }oe ~uploh|e
hbpeeaed} |e}| jip}o }oe ~uploh|e ~pgle hdm }epa| ij
~hwaed} rg}oiu} pejepedle }i hdw jipauch ip }oe i~!
}gid hbpeeaed} /Pgzep Led}ep| eog`g} 8=7'$ Gd hmmg!
}gid# |el}gid 0: ij }oe ~uploh|e hbpeeaed} ~pizgme|
}oh} }oe }epa| ij }oe i~}gid hbpeeaed} hpe aepbem
gd}i hdm |u~ep|emem `w }oe ~uploh|e hbpeeaed} g}!
|ecj$ ]oe ~uploh|e hbpeeaed} lidlcu|gzecw e|}h`cg|o!
e| }oh} }oe ~hp}ge| liucm ohze `u} loi|e di} }i `h|e}oe ~uploh|e ~pgle u~id }oe i~}gid hbpeeaed} jip!
auch$ ]oe ~uploh|e hbpeeaed}# roglo rh| eelu}em
h} h`iu} }oe }gae ij }oe }phd|hl}gid# oh| aipe ~pi`h!
}gze zhcue }ohd Ap$ Kipjj| }e|}gaidw }i }oe lid}phpw$
Pgzep Led}ep lohccedbe| }oe ~pi`h}gze zhcue ij
}oe 877? ~uploh|e ~pgle `h|em id Ap$ Kipjj| }e|}g!
aidw }oh} Pegd ohm hlxugpem `edejglghc irdep|og~ ij
}oe |u`fel} gd 8770$ Ap$ Kipjj }e|}gjgem }oh} }oe `ede!
jglghc irdep|og~ hpi|e iu} ij }oe }phd|hl}gid| `e!
}reed Pegd hdm }oe Udgid gdlcumgdb }oe i~}gid
hbpeeaed} hdm h ahdhbeaed} hbpeeaed} /]phd!
|lpg~} h} 70!7
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
61/108
88h
}h rh| mue `w peh|id ij }oe |hce /]phd|lpg~} h}
8:::!:2'$ Pgzep Led}ep lg}e| }oe Lg}w Pebg|}ep Pelipm
hdm Edmip|eaed} ^hbe| roglo repe pelipmem rg}o
}oe meem hdm gdlcumem h| ~hp}| ij Pgzep Led}ep| e!
og`g} 0>>$8 Hmagdg|}ph}gze Lime ij }oe Lg}w ij Der
Wipk 88!08>0/h' ~pizgme| jip }oe ga~i|g}gid ij h }h
id hdw lidzewhdle ij pehc ~pi~ep}w roepe }oe lid!
|gmeph}gid eleem| -05#>>>$ Hmagdg|}ph}gze Lime
88!08>: |e}| jip}o }ed eea~}gid| jpia }oe }phd|jep
}h$ ]oe idcw eha~ce pech}gdb }i `edejglghc irdep!
|og~ pehm| h| jiccir|6?$ H meem# gd|}puaed} ip }phd|hl}gid lidzew!
gdb ip }phd|jeppgdb pehc ~pi~ep}w ip hd eli!
diagl gd}epe|} }oepegd }oh} ejjel}| h aepe
lohdbe ij gmed}g}w ip jipa ij irdep|og~ ip
ipbhdgvh}gid }i }oe e}ed} }oe `edejglghc
irdep|og~ ij |ulo pehc ~pi~ep}w ip elidiagl
gd}epe|} }oepegd peahgd| }oe |hae $ $ $ $
]oe eea~}gid h~~cge|# jip eha~ce# roepe h
lip~iph}gid g| }phd|jipaem gd}i h cgag}em cgh`gcg}w
lia~hdw rg}o di lohdbe gd g}| exug}w gd}epe|}|$ G}oh| di h~~cglh}gid }i }oe lidzewhdle jpia }oe Udgid
}i Pegd `elhu|e }oe pexug|g}e gmed}g}w ij gd}epe|} g|
chlkgdb$ ]oepejipe# }oe lidzewhdle jpia }oe Udgid }i
Pegd# h| me|lpg`em `w Ap$ Kipjj# mie| di} ah}lo }oe
Hmagdg|}ph}gze Lime eea~}gid$
Pgzep Led}ep| eog`g} 0>8 lid|g|}| ij ce}}ep| mh}!
em Ahw 0# 0>>> hdm Fude 0:# 0>>> jpia }oe Der
8
]oe eog`g} mie| di} gdlcume }oe Pehc ^pi~ep}w ]phd|jep]h Pe}upd /P^]]P'$ Lia~hpe MH\DW| eog`g}| O hdm G
roglo hpe }oe P^]]P| jgcem gd liddel}gid }i }oe 8770 i~}gid
hbpeeaed} hdm }oe lidzewhdle jpia Ae}pi~icg| }i }oe Udgid$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
62/108
80h
Wipk Lg}w Me~hp}aed} ij Jgdhdle }i }oe Udgid$ @w
}oe Ahw 0# 0>>> ce}}ep# }oe Me~hp}aed} ij Jgdhdle
gdjipaem }oe Udgid }oh} g}| P^]]P mgm di} ~pizgme
|ujjglged} gdjipah}gid jip }oe Lg}w }i me}epagde
roe}oep g}| lhcluch}gid ij }h cgh`gcg}w rh| lippel}$
]oe ce}}ep hc|i bhze }oe Udgid }oe jiccirgdb gd|}pul!
}gid|6
Lia~ce}e \loemuce A Aepe lohdbe ij
jipa }phd|jep|$ Jipa edlci|em$ Gj di lci|gdb
|}h}eaed} ip lid}phl} ij |hce eg|}|# hd hjjg!
mhzg} me|lpg`gdb }oe lgplua|}hdle| ij }oe}phd|jep# }oe haiud} ij lid|gmeph}gid gd!
ziczem hdm }oe haiud}| ij hdw aip}bhbe| ip
cged| id }oe ~pi~ep}w h} }oe }gae ij }oe mecgz!
epw ij }oe meem$
]oe Fude 0:# 0>>> ce}}ep pehm| h| jiccir|6 Hd
ehagdh}gid ij wiup pe}upd ahme `w }og| ijjgle ~up!
|uhd} }i }oe Hmagdg|}ph}gze Lime ij }oe Lg}w ij Der
Wipk# mg|lci|e| di hmmg}gidhc cgh`gcg}w udmep }oe Pehc
^pi~ep}w ]phd|jep ]h Chr jip }oe }phd|jep ahme id
>0!0>!877?$ Jip }opee peh|id| }oe jipebigdb lippe!|~idmedle jpia }oe Me~hp}aed} ij Jgdhdle oh| di
~pi`h}gze zhcue id }oe xue|}gid ij roe}oep }oe Ud!
gid rh| pexugpem }i ~hw h }phd|jep }h id }oe lidzew!
hdle$ Jgp|}# }oepe g| di ezgmedle ij roh}# gj hdw}ogdb#
}oe Udgid |u`ag}}em gd pe|~id|e }i }oe Ahw 0# 0>>>
ce}}ep$ \ulo ezgmedle riucm ohze edh`cem }oe liup}
}i kdir }oe `h|g| jip }oe Me~hp}aed} ij Jgdhdle|
me}epagdh}gid ij di hmmg}gidhc }h cgh`gcg}w$ \elidm#
hllipmgdb }i }oe Ahw 0# 0>>> ce}}ep# }oe ~uploh|e
hbpeeaed} /Pgzep Led}ep| eog`g} 8=7' riucm ohze
h~~hped}cw |ujjglem h| }oe hmmg}gidhc miluaed}h}gid
pexugpem `w }oe Lg}w$ Di}ogdb id }oe jhle ij }oe ~up!
loh|e hbpeeaed} }pgbbep| hdw ij }oe Hmagdg|}ph}gze
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
63/108
8>> ce}}ep
|~ehk| ij di hmmg}gidhc cgh`gcg}w [ea~oh|g| hmmemQ$
]oh} chdbuhbe mie| di} puce iu} }oe ~i||g`gcg}w }oh}
}oe Udgid# gd jhl}# ~hgm h }phd|jep }h$ Gd hmmg}gid#
Pgzep Led}ep| lchgaem `edejglghc irdep|og~ g| di}
pelg}em gd hdw gd|}puaed} `ejipe }og| liup}$ H| ezg!
medlem `w }oe i~}gid# ahdhbeaed} hdm ~uploh|e
hbpeeaed}|# Pegd hdm }oe Udgid gd}ephl}em h| |i!
~og|}glh}em ed}g}ge| pe~pe|ed}em `w liud|ec$ Udmep
}oe|e jhl}|# g} g| hcai|} gdlidlegzh`ce }oh} Pegd|
`edejglghc irdep|og~ riucm di} ohze `eed aeaipghc!gvem gj g} eg|}em$ Hd i~}gid hbpeeaed} pg~ed| gd}i h
juccw edjipleh`ce `gch}ephc lid}phl} idle hd i~}gidee
bgze| di}gle ij gd}ed} }i eeplg|e }oe i~}gid /Fhpelkg
z$ \oudb Aii Ciuge# 75 DW0m ::5# ::? [0>>8Q'$ Oir!
ezep# }oe `gch}ephc lid}phl} mie| di} hpg|e roepe }oe
~hp}ge| e~pe||cw }epagdh}e }oe i~}gid hbpeeaed}$
]oe gd|}puaed}| hl}uhccw eelu}em `w }oe ~hp}ge| hc!
|i miia Pgzep Led}ep| hmmg}gidhc lchga }oh} g}| mehc
rg}o }oe Udgid rh| h aip}bhbe gd }oe jipa ij h
meem$ Hmagdg|}ph}gze Lime 88!08>: hc|i ~pizgme|
jip hd eea~}gid roepe [hQ meem ip gd|}puaed} bgz!ed |icecw h| |elupg}w jip# ip h }phd|hl}gid }oe |ice
~up~i|e ij roglo g| }i |elupe# h me`} ip i`cgbh}gid ip
h meem ip gd|}puaed} bgzed# ip h }phd|hl}gid ed}epem
gd}i# |icecw jip }oe ~up~i|e ij pe}updgdb |ulo |elupg!
}w; Pgzep Led}ep# oirezep# oh| ahme di |oirgdb h|
}i roe}oep |ulo hd eea~}gid rh| |gbdem ip ezed
|iubo} `w }oe Udgid$
^up|uhd} }i Hccgem Lip~$ /?> DW0m h}
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
64/108
8=h
ce}}ep ij hu}oipgvh}gid /MH\DW| eog`g} \' |}hdm| h|
~piij }oh} }oe |hce ~pgle rh| hbpeem u~id rg}o }oe
|eccep| kdircembe ij }oe lid}ea~ch}em vidgdb ah~
haedmaed} hdm |~elghc ~epag}| jip }oe lid|}pul}gid
ij h agem u|e liaaeplghc hdm pe|gmed}ghc mezeci~!
aed}$ ]oe 877? |hce g| di} hmmpe||em gd }oe gdg}ghc
h~~phg|hc ij eg}oep h~~phg|ep$ Ap$ Zid Hdlked di}e|
gd og| pe`u}}hc h~~phg|hc }oh} A|$ Dwbhpm| zhcuh}gid
ij -002#>>>#>>> g|
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
65/108
85h
|~hle lid|g|}gdb ij ?8#?> |xuhpe jee}$ A|$ Dw!
bhpm |e~hph}ecw zhcuem ehlo ij }oe h`ize lia~ided}|
`h|em id }oe di}gid }oh} }oe |u`fel} rh| h mezeci~!
aed} ~pifel} gd ~pibpe|| rg}o mezeci~aed} ~chd|
recc udmeprhw h} }oe }gae ij lidmeadh}gid /Pgzep
Led}ep| eog`g} 0>
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
66/108
8:h
~pizem `w `ugcmgdb| roglo ohm di} `eed lid|}pul}em
h} }oe }gae }g}ce ze|}em$ Gd }og| lh|e# g} riucm `e |ga!
gchpcw gdh~~pi~pgh}e }i `h|e hd hrhpm u~id }oe zhcu!
h}gid ij lia~ided}| ij h mezeci~aed} ~pifel} }oh}
dezep eg|}em$ Ap$ Zid Hdlked# }oepejipe# h~~pi~pg!
h}ecw h~~phg|e| }oe |u`fel} h| zhlhd} chdm /MH\DW|
eog`g} HG h} 8'$
A|$ Dwbhpm lippel}cw |}h}e| }oh} |hce| lia~hpg!
|id h~~pihlo
gdzicze| }oe liccel}gid ij ahpke} mh}h pech}!gdb }i |gagchp ~pi~ep}ge|# hdhcw|g| ij }oe
|hce| id h udg} `h|g| }oh} ~epag}| lia~hpg!
|id }i }oe |u`fel} ~pi~ep}w# hmfu|}aed} ij
}oe udg} ~pgle| }i hlliud} jip mgjjepedle| `e!
}reed }oe lia~hph`ce| hdm }oe |u`fel} hdm#
jgdhccw# pelidlgcgh}gid ij }oe hmfu|}em ~pgle|
gd}i h jhgp lidlcu|gid h~~cglh`ce }i }oe |u`!
fel}$ /Pgzep Led}ep| eog`g} 0>
Dwbhpm| gdg}ghc h~~phg|hc me|lpg`e| }oe |u`fel}|
chdm hdm ele|| mezeci~aed} pgbo}| h| h |gdbce ed!
}g}}w$ We}# }oe }ri!bpgm hdhcw|g| g| ud}phmg}gidhc
/]phd|lpg~} h} :??># 2>7? hdm ?
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
67/108
82h
Re|cew# ?< DW0m =82# =0< [877=Q'$ Hllipmgdbcw# A|$
Dwbhpm| }ri!bpgm hdhcw|g| ij h |gdbce ~hplec chlk|
~pi`h}gze zhcue `elhu|e g} oh| di} bhgdem bedephc
hlle~}hdle gd }oe jgecm ij pehc e|}h}e h~~phg|hc$
A|$ Dwbhpm| |uppe`u}}hc h~~phg|hc |e}| jip}o hd
hc}epdh}gze |gdbce bpgm hdhcw|g| u|gdb oep |hae >#=8: hdm vidgdb jciip hpeh ij
??$ Oirezep# }oe lia~hph`ce| lg}em gd Ap$ Zid
Hdlked gdg}ghc h~~phg|hc repe aipe ~ep|uh|gze `e!
lhu|e }oew repe di} udpehcg|}glhccw ~ebbem }i }oe
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
68/108
8?h
Li|}h| Kidmwcg| ~chd|$ A|$ Dwbhpm i~gde| }oh} chpbe
|gve g| liaaidcw lid|gmepem h |u~epgip jeh}upe rhp!
phd}gdb u~rhpm hmfu|}aed} ij |ahccep lia~hph`ce|
/Pgzep Led}ep| eog`g} 052 h} >>> /gm$' ]oe liup} hc|i hmi~}|
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
69/108
87h
Ap$ Zid Hdlked| }gae }pedm| h| aipe pejcel}gze ij
ahpke} lidmg}gid|$ A|$ Dwbhpm hdm Ap$ Zid Hdlked
hc|i mgjjep h| }i roe}oep }oe lid}phl} mh}e ip meem
pelipmgdb mh}e |oiucm `e u|em jip ahpke} }pedmgdb
~up~i|e|$ H| peh|idem `w A|$ Dwbhpm# }oe lid}phl}
mh}e g| aipe pecezhd} gdh|aulo h| g} g| }oe mh}e u~id
roglo }oe `uwep hdm }oe |eccep hbpee u~id h |hce
~pgle hdm `gdm }oea|ecze| }i }oe }phd|hl}gid$ ]oe
lid}phl} mh}e# oirezep# g| u|h`ce idcw roepe g} lhd
`e h|lep}hgdem id }oe `h|g| ij gdjipah}gid jpia pecg!
h`ce |iuple| |ulo h| `pikep| ip ~hp}ge| }i }oe }phd|!hl}gid|$ Gd ai|} gd|}hdle|# }oe |iuple| ij
gdjipah}gid pebhpmgdb }oe lid}phl} mh}e| repe di}
|ujjglged}cw pecgh`ce gd }og| liup}| zger$ ]oe |u`fel}|
me|gph`ce pel}hdbuchp |oh~e rhpphd}| h ~i|g}gze lid!
jgbuph}gid hmfu|}aed} rg}o pe|~el} }i ai|} ij }oe
lia~hph`ce|$
]oe hmfu|}em ~pgle| ~ep |xuhpe jii} ij jciip hpeh
ph}gi /JHP' ij Ap$ Zid Hdlked| dgde lia~hph`ce|
phdbem jpia -5= }i -8>0$==$ Ap$ Zid Hdlked h|!
|gbdem hd gdmglh}em zhcue ij -7>$>> ~ep |xuhpe jii}`h|em id ??>> JHP ~cu| =2#8>5 |xuhpe jee} ij hm!
mg}gidhc jciip hpeh lpeh}em `w }oe |ci~e `e}reed
]ed}o hdm Ecezed}o Hzedue|$ ]oe haiud} ij JHP
elcumgdb }oe |ci~e g| hl}uhccw ?? |xuhpe jee}$
Hllipmgdbcw# }oe |u`fel}| }i}hc JHP rg}o }oe |ci~e
gdlcumem g| 7#?05 |xuhpe jee}$ Rg}o }oh} lippel}gid#
}oe |u`fel}| bpi|| ahpke} zhcue ij -? g|
lhcluch}em `w auc}g~cwgdb }oe gdmglh}em |xuhpe jii}
zhcue ij -7> `w }oe }i}hc JHP$
]oe ahpke} zhcue ij lidmeadem ~pi~ep}w |oiucm
pejcel} h lchgahd}| li|} gd ~pe~hpgdb mezeci~aed}
~chd| h| hd gdlpeaed} hmmem }i }oe zhcue ij chdm
rg}o pe|~el} }i g}| ogboe|} hdm `e|} u|e /\~elghc}w
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
70/108
0>h
Jiim| Lip~$ z$ \}h}e# =: HM0m 7?7 [872=Q# h~~ehc
mg|ag||em : [8725Q# h~~ehc mg|ag||em
lcume| }oh} }oe Li|}h| Kidmwcg| ~chd| liucm zepw
cgkecw ohze `eed ga~phl}glhc hdm hmmem di}ogdb }i}oe zhcue ij }oe |u`fel}$ Gd }og| liup}| zger# hd hmmg!
}gidhc -85 agccgid ij edohdlem zhcue |oiucm `e hmmem
}i bpi|| ahpke} zhcue ij -? |e} jip}o h`ize
`w peh|id vidgdb lohdbe i`}hgdem hdm }oe `ipgdb|
hdm jiudmh}gid |}umge| lidmul}em `w Pgzep Led}ep$
]oe liup} jgdm| Ap$ Zid Hdlked| e|}gah}e ij
-8#505#>>> jip meaicg}gid li|}| }i `e |u~~ip}em `w
}oe ezgmedle$ U~id memul}gid ij }oe meaicg}gid li|}|
jpia }oe der bpi|| ahpke} zhcue ij -7?#22=#05> }oe
jgdhc ahpke} zhcue g| -72#0=7#05> piudmem }i-72#05>#>>>$ ]og| |ua pejcel}| h ahpke} zhcue roglo
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
71/108
08h
g| lid|g|}ed} rg}o }oe ~uploh|e ~pgle ~hgm `w Pegd gd
877? hdm }oe edohdleaed}| di}em h`ize$
Hllipmgdbcw# lchgahd}| hpe hrhpmem -72#05>#>>>
ce|| }oe hmzhdle ~hwaed} ~cu| gd}epe|}$ ]oe jipebi!
gdb g| rg}oiu} ~pefumgle }i hd h~~cglh}gid jip pecgej
udmep EM^C 2>8 hdm)ip 2>0$ \e}}ce ipmep$
Mh}em6 H~pgc 8:# 0>>? F$\$L$
Oid$ Cechdm MeBph||e
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
72/108
00h
H^^EDMG_ L
Ipmep ij \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk Liud}w#
ed}epem Ahw 07# 0>>?# medwgdb ai}gid jip h
der }pghc /Oid$ Fhde \$ \iciaid# F$\$L$'# rg}o
di}gle ij ed}pw |epzem id Fude 0# 0>>?
^pe|ed}6 Fhde \$ \iciaid
Gdme Di$ 8>07>8
FIOD FHW LICCEBE
U~id }oe jipebigdb ~h~ep|# g} g| ipmepem }oh} }oe
ai}gid g| medgem$ G melcgde }i pezg|g} Fu|}gle
MeBph||e| melg|gid gd }og| oi}cw lid}e|}em mg|~u}e$
Hd h~~ehc g| }oe ~pi~ep peaemw jip }oe hbbpgezem
lchgahd}$
Mh}em6 5)0?)>? )|)Jgdhc Mg|~i|g}gid Fhde \$ \iciaid
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
73/108
0>? /Oid$ Fhde \$ \ici!
aid# F$\$L$'# rg}o di}gle ij ed}pw |epzem id
Fude 5# 0>>?
H} GH\ ^hp} 55 ij }oe \u!
~peae Liup} ij }oe \}h}e ij
Der Wipk# oecm gd hdm jip
}oe Liud}w ij Der Wipk#:> Led}pe \}pee}# Der
Wipk# Der Wipk 8>>>2# id
}oe 0dm mhw ij Fude# 0>>?$
^pe|ed}6 Fhde \$ \iciaid# Fu|}gle$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!_
Gd }oe Ah}}ep ij }oe H~~cglh}gid ij }oe Mipag}ipw
Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij Der Wipk }i hlxugpe }g}ce gd
jee }i lep}hgd pehc ~pi~ep}w jip u|e gd h ~pifel} }i e!
~hdm hdm lid|icgmh}e
FIOD FHW LICCEBE IJ LPGAGDHC FU\]GLE
IJ ]OE LG]W UDGZEP\G]W IJ DER WIPK
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!_
Gdme Di$ 8>078
GH\ ^hp} 55
FUMBAED]
U^ID pehmgdb hdm jgcgdb hcc ~h~ep| oepegd hdm
u~id }oe Aeaiphdmua Melg|gid ij Oid$ Cechdm
MeBph||e# mh}em H~pgc 8:# 0>>?# hj}ep }pghc ij }og|ah}}ep /Melg|gid'#
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
74/108
0=h
G] G\ OEPE@W IPMEPEM# HMFUMBEM# HDM
MELPEEM# }oh} fumbaed} g| ed}epem gd jhzip ij Pgz!
ep Led}ep CCL /Lchgahd}'# ohzgdb hd hmmpe|| l)i
Bicm|}egd# Bicm|}egd# Pgkid * Bi}}ge`# ^$L$# ?> ^gde
\}pee}# >>5# }i
pelizep jpia Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij
Der Wipk /MH\DW'# ohzgdb g}| ~pgdlg~hc ~chle ij
`u|gde|| h} 585 @pihmrhw# Hc`hdw# DW 800>2# }oe
haiud} ij DGDE]W \EZED AGCCGID ]RI OUD!
MPEM JGJ]W ]OIU\HDM MICCHP\
/-72#05>#>>>'# roglo roed }hkgdb gd}i hlliud} }oe~pezgiu| hmzhdle ~hwaed}| oepe}ijipe ahme `w
MH\DW }i Lchgahd} gd }oe hbbpebh}e ~pgdlg~hc
haiud} ij -?0#8?5#>>> pe|uc}| gd Lchgahd} `egdb ed!
}g}cem }i pelizep jpia MH\DW h jgdhc ~pgdlg~hc ~hw!
aed} ij JGJ]EED AGCCGID \G_]W JGZE
]OIU\HDM MICCHP\ /-85#>:5#>>>' rg}o gd}epe|}
id |ulo haiud} h} h ph}e ij 7% ~ep hddua jpia }g}ce
ze|}gdb mh}e# H~pgc 88# 0>88# }i }oe mh}e ij ed}pw
oepegd gd }oe |ua ij -7#2>0#:?5$=?# hdm ahkgdb gd
hcc }oe |ua ij -0=#2:2#:?5$=? hdm }oh} Lchgahd}
ohze eelu}gid }oepeij$
Fumbaed} |gbdem }og| 0dm mhw ij Fude 0>>?$
Ed}ep#
)|)
Oid$ Fhde \$ \iciaid
Fu|}gle ij }oe \u~peae Liup}
Jgcem
Fude 5# 0>>?Der Wipk Liud}w Lcepk| Ijjgle
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
75/108
05h
H^^EDMG_ E
Iphc melg|gid `w \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk
Liud}w /Oid$ Ahp}gd \loiedjecm# F$\$L$'# mh}em
Hubu|} 7# 0>>:# id ai}gid }i mg|ag|| lchga jip
gd}epjepedle mhahbe|# P$ 0>2:h!0>?2h /exlep~}'
H| ezepw`imw gd }og| piia kdir|# ahpke} zhcue g|
roh} h rgccgdb `uwep riucm ohze ~hgm h rgccgdb |eccep
h} }oe }gae }oh} }oe ~pi~ep}w g| h~~pi~pgh}em$ Pgzep
Led}ep riucm cgke }og| Liup} }i lid|gmep `i}o }oe
lupped} edohdlem zhcue ij }oe |ulle||juccw pevidem~pi~ep}w h} }oe }gae ij }oe lidmeadh}gid# h| recc h|
hcc h||ilgh}em li|}| liddel}em rg}o }oe ejjip}| }i hl!
xugpe }oh} edohdlem ~pi~ep}w$ Gd aw i~gdgid# }og|
riucm `e h miu`ce pelizepw$
G ha bigdb }i }pw }i e~chgd h| `e|} G lhd roh} g}
g| G ha }pwgdb }i |hw hdm }oed# gj wiu rgcc `ehp rg}o
ae# hdm hbhgd# g} ahw `e zepw pe~e}g}gze# `u} G riucm
cgke }i bi }opiubo aw di}e| }i ahke |iae liaaed}|$
@u} h} }oe iu}|e}# ce} ae }pw }i e~chgd }oh} hbhgd# G
`ecgeze }oh} }oe Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w pelibdgve| hdm
g| |hwgdb# cg|}ed# gd }oe h~~pi~pgh}e lh|e# hdm }og|
ahw`e g| ide ij }oi|e lh|e|# }oe liup} oh| h pgbo} }i
me}epagde }oe mezeci~aed} ij h ~pi~ep}w hdm lhd
}hke lep}hgd edohdlem li|}|# `u} re hpe di} }hckgdb
h`iu} }oi|e }w~e| ij edohdlem li|}| roed re hpe
}hckgdb h`iu} h mechw mhahbe lchga }oh} oh| hcpehmw
`eed |e} jip}o gd hdi}oep jipua$ Gd }og| pe|~el}# Pgz!
ep Led}ep oh| hcpehmw rid id }oe cgh`gcg}w h|~el} `e!
lhu|e }oepe oh| `eed h me}epagdh}gid `w }oe |}h}e
\u~peae Liup}# }oh} }oe \}h}e hdm LUDW lhu|em
}oe mechw gd Ap$ Kipjj| pgbo} }i bi jiprhpm rg}o og|mezeci~aed}hc ~pifel}# `u} }oe }gae ~epgim jpia }oh}
mechw }i roed }oe ~pi~ep}w rh| lidmeadem# }oepe
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
76/108
0:h
eg|}| h lep}hgd peai}ede||$ Gd jhl}# G |hgm hdm }og|
}oe }ogpm }gae G ha pe~eh}gdb aw|ecj# Ap$ Kipjj gdmg!
lh}em }oh} idle oe ohm }oe vidgdb# oe rh| h`ce }i bi
jiprhpm rg}o og| ~pifel}# roglo oe `ecgeze| riucm
ohze `eed zepw |ulle||juc$ Roh} }oe|e ed}g}ge| mgm }i
oga# hdm G gdlcume }oe Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w h| ~hp}
ij g}# ezed }oiubo }oepe g| di |e~hph}e hl}gid hbhgd|}
}oea lupped}cw# ele~} jip }oe idcw hl}gid `egdb }oe
lidmeadh}gid ~pileemgdb# g| }i ahke g} ohpmep jip
}oe h~~phg|ep| hdm }oe liup} }i ahke h me}epagdh!
}gid ij roh} }oe zhcue g| jip }og| ~pi~ep}w id }oe mh}eij }hkgdb$
Dir# G liucm |hw }oh} G `ecgeze }oh} Ap$ Kipjj|
~pifel} riucm ohze `eed ogbocw |ulle||juc hdm ohm
oe ohm hd i~~ip}udg}w }i bi jiprhpm rg}o g} ehpcgep#
oe riucm `e h`ce }i |oir }oh}# `u} re liucm di} `e
lep}hgd ij }oh}# re riucm idcw `e |~eluch}gdb hdm g}
liucm ~pize fu|} }oe i~~i|g}e# `elhu|e gj re ohm }oe
jhl}| h} h mgjjeped} mezeci~aed}hc |}hbe# re agbo}
|ee }oh} lep}hgd liaaeplghc ed}g}ge|# |ulo h| Oiae
Me~i}# roi repe gd}epe|}em gd ped}gdb |~hle riucmdi cidbep ohze `eed gd}epe|}em jip i}oep peh|id|#
i}oep }ohd mechw|# }oh} oe riucm di} ohze bi}}ed }oe
}w~e ij pe|gmed}ghc illu~hdlw }oh} oe e~el}em# }oh}
oe liucm ohze pud gd}i i}oep ~pi`cea| hdm G ohze |ee
}oe ~pi~ep}w hdm }oepe hpe ~pi`cea| rg}o g} gd ahk!
gdb }oe mezeci~aed} ripk# |i re mid} kdir$
\i }oed roh} oh~~ed|# hbhgd# re }hke }oe `e|}
aeh|upe# roglo g| }oe lia~hph`ce| hdm ~i||g`cw
u|gdb }oe Logdh}ird eha~ce roed G |hw }oh}# }oepe
g| h Logdh}ird lh|e# G mi `ecgeze }oh} h liup} riucm
ohze h pgbo}# `h|em id }oh}# }i ahke h me}epagdh}gid
}oh} }oepe |oiucm `e hd edohdleaed} zhcue }i }oe
mezeci~aed}# hbhgd gj g} lhd `e |oird# `u} }oh} g|
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
77/108
02h
|}gcc mgjjeped} }ohd roh} oepe g| h |~elgjgl mechw
mhahbe lchga hdm g} g| hc|i }oe lidzep|e ij |iae ij
}oe lh|e|# roepe mue }i h lg}w ip h audglg~hcg}w| hl!
}gid|# vidgdb rh| dezep hllia~cg|oem h} }oe }gae ij
}oe }hkgdb# hdm }oe liup}| gd |iae ij }oi|e lh|e|
ohze gdmglh}em }oh} }oe }hkep lhddi} u|e }oh} }i g}|
hmzhd}hbe `w |hwgdb }oe ~pi~ep}w g| rip}oce||# `e!
lhu|e ij |iae}ogdb }oh} |iae`imw ec|e lhu|em$ @u}#
re ohze h zepw mg|}gdl} lchga oepe hdm g} g| di} oir
gd aw i~gdgid h peh|idh`ce `uwep bie| h`iu} `uwgdb
h ~pi~ep}w jpia h peh|idh`ce |eccep# `elhu|e }oeperiucm `e g} riucm di} ahke |ed|e jip |iae`imw }i
rhd} }i `uw h chr|ug} hdm }oh} g| roh} }og| g|$ ]oe
cgh`gcg}w g| }oepe# hdm gj }oe mhahbe| lhd `e ~pized#
}oe lid}phl} g||ue| hpe pe|iczem# }oepe g| h |e}
haiud} }oh} g| bigdb }i `e e|}h`cg|oem$ G} pehccw mie|
di} ohze hdw}ogdb }i mi rg}o roh} h `uwep riucm
~hw jip }oe ~pi~ep}w id }oe mh}e }oh} g} rh| lid!
meadem hdm }oh} e||ed}ghccw g| }oe `i}}ia cgde# bed!
}ceaed# hdm chmge|# `u} gj wiu riucm `ehp rg}o ae# G
riucm cgke }i bi }opiubo aw di}e| }i ahke |upe G
mgmd} |kg~ hdw}ogdb oepe$
& & &
Ap$ Kipjj mie| di} ohze }oe i~~ip}udg}w }i |oir
roepe oe riucm ohze `eed gd }og| mezeci~aed}
|}hbe# hdm ohze oi~ejuccw# `e}}ep lidlpe}e ezgmedle
ij }oe zhcue ij og| ~pi~ep}w$ @u} oe oh| og| |e~hph}e
mhahbe lchga hdm }oh} oh| di}ogdb }i mi rg}o }oe
pehcg}ge| ij }oe }hkgdb h} h }gae roed }oe ~pi~ep}w
rh| ~pi~epcw videm$
G |oiucm ~igd} iu} hbhgd# u|gdb lidmeadh}gid}epa|# }oh} }oe|e ~hp}gluchp li|}| }oh} hpe `egdb
h|kem }i `e mg|ag||em jpia }og| lh|e mi di} hpg|e
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
78/108
0?h
jpia }oe }hkgdb# roglo G `ecgeze g| }oe lippel} ripm!
gdb$ Ph}oep# gd aw i~gdgid# repe mhahbe| lpeh}em `w
}oe peju|hc }i lii~eph}e rg}o }oe mezeci~ep roi ohm
lep}hgd pgbo}| hdm `w }oe rhw# G ha di} fu|} |hwgdb
}oh}$ H| h ah}}ep ij chr# }oh} oh| `eed me}epagdem
`w Fumbe Bhaaepahd# }oh} }oepe rh| gd}epjepedle#
`u} g} mie| di}# }oi|e mhahbe| mi di} hpg|e jpia }og|
~hp}gluchp }hkgdb hdm G }ogdk g} `ehp| rip}o pe~eh}!
gdb hbhgd }oh} G mid} `ecgeze }oh}# udmep }oe lgplua!
|}hdle|# }oh} h rgccgdb ~uploh|ep riucm `e ciikgdb }i
`uw h chr|ug}$& & &
]oe|e hpe di} }oe }w~e| ij g||ue| }oh} |oiucm `e
`ejipe h fumbe gd }oe lidmeadh}gid ~pileemgdb$ G}
riucm idcw lidju|e }oe lh|e$ G} g| h mg|}gdl} g||ue$ G}
oh| di}ogdb }i mi rg}o zhcuh}gid id }oe mh}e ij }oe
}hkgdb# ele~} }oh} g} ahke| g} h cg}}ce `g} ohpmep }i
me}epagde roh} }oe zhcue |oiucm `e$
G }ogdk g} riucm `e `e|} gj G |}i~~em h} }og| ~igd}$
& & &
\i ce} ae |hw g} `i}o rhw|6 G mid} `ecgeze |gdle
}oepe oh| `eed }oe ~pi~ep pevidgdb# ~pgip }i }oe }hk!
gdb# }oh} g} g| hd h~~pi~pgh}e lchga oepe# hdm G mid}
`ecgeze gj wiu ciik h} }oe jhl}| |~elgjglhccw }i }og|
lh|e# }oh} |ulo mhahbe| h~~cw oepe hdm }oh} g| }oe
Liup}| melg|gid$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
79/108
07h
H^^EDMG_ J
Iphc melg|gid `w \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk
Liud}w /Oid$ Ahp}gd \loiedjecm# F$\$L$'# mh}em
Hubu|} # 0>>:# rg}o di}gle ij ed}pw |epzem id
\e~}ea`ep 5# 0>>:# P$0>??h!0>7>h
^pe|ed}6 Ahp}gd \loiedjecm ^hp} 0?
Gdme Di$ 8>078
Gd pe Fiod Fhw Liccebe
/Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w'
U~id }oe jipebigdb ~h~ep|# g} g| ipmepem }oh} }og|
ai}gid }i mg|ag|| }oh} ~hp} ij }oe lidmeadh}gid ~pi!
leemgdb lchga jip mechw ip gd}epjepedle mhahbe|
/ehlep`h}em li|}|' g| bphd}em h| ~ep }oe Liup}|
melg|gid |}h}em id }oe pelipm /|ee oehpgdb }phd|lpg~}
mh}em ?)7)>:'$ \ulo h lchga g| mu~cglh}gze ij h |e~h!
ph}e hl}gid gd }oe Liup} ij Lchga|# hdm aipe |gbdgjg!lhd}cw g| gdh~~pi~pgh}e gd me}epagdgdb jhgp ahpke}
zhcue roepe }oe deemem pevidgdb ohm hcpehmw `eed
i`}hgdem# hdm }oe uc}gah}e mezeci~aed} ~pifel} ohm
liaaedlem# |ezephc wehp| ~pgip }i }oe }hkgdb$ ]og|
}ibe}oep rg}o }oe i~gdgid |}h}em id }oe pelipm lid!
|}g}u}e| }oe melg|gid hdm ipmep ij }oe Liup}$
Mh}em6 Hubu|} # 0>>: )|)
F$\$L$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
80/108
h
H^^EDMG_ B
Ipmep hdm Aeaiphdmua Melg|gid `w \u~peae
Liup}# Der Wipk Liud}w /Oid$ Cechdm
MeBph||e# F$\$L$'# id ai}gid| }i ~pelcume ex!
~ep} pe~ip}|# ed}epem Dizea`ep 02# 0>>:# rg}o
di}gle ij ed}pw |epzem Dizea`ep 0?# 0>>:#
P$h!078
MeBph||e# F6
Ai}gid |exuedle| dgde hdm }ed hpe lid|icgmh}em$
Lidmeadip# }oe Mipag}ipw Hu}oipg}w ij }oe \}h}e ij
Der Wipk /MH\DW'# aize| jip ipmep| ~pelcumgdb jee
lchgahd} Pgzep Led}ep CCL jpia gd}pimulgdb gd}i ez!
gmedle h chdm pe|gmuhc hdhcw|g| ~pe~hpem `w Fepiae
Ohga| Pehc}w# Gdl$# hd ed}pe~pedeupghc ~pijg} hdm
mezeci~aed} zhcue pe~ip} hdm h |u~~ceaed} }oepe}i
~pe~hpem `w Biim|}egd Mezeci~aed} Lip~$# }ri pe!~ip}| `w Dh}gidhc Elidiagl Pe|ehplo H||ilgh}e|
/DEPH'# h pe~ip} `w hlliud}hd}| Cezgde hdm \ec}vep
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
81/108
>0 pe`u}!
}hc pe~ip} `w Pi`ep} Zid Hdlked gd }oe ezed} ij }oe
elcu|gid ij }oe Ohga| pe~ip}; ~pelcumgdb MH\DW|
gd}pimul}gid ij h pe~ip} `w Aglohec \}egd`epb hdm
Phwaidm \hzgdi gd }oe ezed} ij }oe elcu|gid ij }oe
Biim|}egd pe~ip}; ~pelcumgdb MH\DW| gd}pimul}gid
ij pe~ip}| `w Mp|$ H}hdu \hod hdm Dgloich| Lper
hdm @e}|w Fhli`|id gd }oe ezed} ij }oe elcu|gid ij}oe DEPH pe~ip}|; ~pelcumgdb MH\DW jpia gd}pi!
mulgdb h pe~ip} `w Bphj Pe~e}}g * Li$# CCL gd }oe
ezed} ij }oe elcu|gid ij }oe Cezgde * \ec}vep pe~ip};
jup}oep ~pelcumgdb MH\DW| gd}pimul}gid ij Fhli`!
|id| pe~ip} hdm h pe~ip} `w Chrpedle Cidbuh gd }oe
ezed} ij }oe elcu|gid ij Hmha|kg| pe~ip} hdm ~pe!
lcumgdb MH\DW| gd}pimul}gid ij ~ip}gid| ij h pe~ip}
`w ^e}ep ^jejjep gd }oe ezed} ij }oe elcu|gid ij pe!
ch}em ~ip}gid| ij }oe Kipjj pe~ip}|$
]oe |u`fel} ~peag|e| illu~w }oe ed}gpe eh|}epd`cilkjpid} ij 88}o Hzedue `e}reed Re|} 5?}o hdm
Re|} 57}o \}pee}|$ Hllipmgdb }i Ohga|| h~~phg|hc#
}oe |g}e g| ~hp}ghccw ga~pizem hdm 8>>#=8:$:2 gd hpeh$
MH\DW hlxugpem }oe |g}e id H~pgc :# 0>>8$ H| |e}
jip}o gd Ohga|| pe~ip}# }oe chdm pe|gmuhc h~~pihlo
jipelh|}| }oe lid|}pul}gid ij h der mezeci~aed} }oh}
ahgagve| }oe zhcue ij }oe chdm$ ]oe `h|gl hdhcw|g|
pecge| id }oe lia~hpg|id ij }oe zhcue ij }og| hccebem
ogboe|} hdm `e|} u|e ij }oe |g}e rg}o }oe li|} ij lid!
|}pul}gdb }oe mezeci~aed}$ ]oe mgjjeped}ghc `e}reed
}oe lh~g}hcgvem zhcue hdm }oe li|} e|}gah}e# hllipm!
gdb }i Ohga|# g| }oe pe|gmuhc zhcue hzhgch`ce }i
lizep chdm li|}|$ Ohga|| chdm pe|gmuhc hdhcw|g| lid!
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
82/108
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
83/108
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
84/108
# 0>>: )|)
F$\$L$
Oid$ Cechdm MeBph||e
8
]og| g| rg}oiu} ~pefumgle }i }oe |u`ag||gid ij h der pe!~ip} `w Cezgde hdm \ec}vep iag}}gdb pejepedle| }i li|}| pech}em
}i Pgzep Led}ep| gd}epjepedle lchga hdm MH\DW| pe`u}}hc ij
}oe der pe~ip}$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
85/108
>2# ~pelcumgdb }e|}gaidw ij Fi|e~o Kipjj h|
}i zhcue# P$880?!8807
G rgcc jiccir u~ id h ~igd} Ap$ Bicm|}egd phg|em
~pgip }i }oe cudloeid pele||$ Hdm }oe |u`fel} g| }oe
hmag||g`gcg}w ij }oe ezgmedle ij }oe i~gdgid ij hd
irdep ij ~pi~ep}w gd hd eagded} miahgd ~pileemgdb$
G ohze pehm wiup ce}}ep hdm }oe lh|e| }oh} wiu
lg}e }oepegd$
G} g| di} `w hllgmed} }oh} }oepe g| idcw ide Der
Wipk lh|e }oh} wiu lg}e$
Hdm }og| g| @ed|id z$ \}h}e# 82 ag|lecchdeiu| 0m#
887$
]oe i}oep lh|e| jpia }oe i}oep fupg|mgl}gid| mgm
di} ohze ide jhl}ip }oh} re hpe lia~eccem }i mehc
rg}o$ ]oh} g|# 0>0$:8 ij }oe Udgjipa Puce|$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
86/108
0$:8 h| }oe elcu|gze
aehd| `w roglo |ulo ezgmedle g| }i `e ~pe|ed}em gd
hd eagded} miahgd }pghc$
]oe @ed|id /~oide}gl|' Liup} h~~hped}cw mgm di}
ohze mgm di} hmmpe|| 0>0$:8 aulo$ @elhu|e# G
riucm |u|~el} }oh} g} rh| di} edhl}em ~pgip# h} }oh}
}gae$
]oe ehpcge|} lh|e G ohze jiudm gd roglo }oe puce
g| lg}em rh| gd 8778$ Hdm @ed|id rh| melgmem gd
8757$
\i G rgcc hmoepe }i }oe pucgdb pebhpmgdb }oe i~gd!
gid `w }oe lchgahd} h| }i }oe zhcue ij }oe |u`fel}$
Pucgdb `w \u~peae Liup}# Der Wipk Liud}w
/Oid$ Cechdm MeBph||e# F$\$L$'# id Ahw 85#
0>>2# }oh} ijjep riucm di} `e lid|gmepem h| ez!
gmedle ij zhcue# P$8827$
AP$ BICM\]EGD6 G ijjep g} gd}i ezgmedle$
AP$ RE@@6 ]oe |hae i`fel}gid# wiup Oidip$ G} g|
hd ijjep$ Hdm g} au|} `e hlle~}em `w H~pgc >># G
di}e$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
87/108
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
88/108
># h 8722 lh|e# }oe Liup} gd mgl}h
ahme pejepedle }i Dglkce| id eagded} miahgd# gd
roglo g} |}h}em }oh} hd ijjep `w h ~pgzh}e ~hp}w ahw
`e hmag||g`ce roepe g} g| ahme gd biim jhg}o# rg}ogd
h peh|idh`ce }gae hdm rg}o }oe gd}ed}gid hdm h`gcg}w
}i lhppw iu} }oe }phd|hl}gid }oh} }oe ijjep g| hlle~}!
em$
]oe idcw hu}oipg}w `w hd H~~ecch}e Liup} ip h
liup} ogboep }ohd }oe H~~ecch}e Mgzg|gid# G |oiucm
|hw# riucm `e }oe@puaaep lh|e$
Ga aipe liajip}h`ce rg}o }oh}# }oe hdhcw|g| |e}
jip}o udmep Dglkce| riucm gdzg}e agdg!}pghc id
roe}oep }oe ijjepip oh| }oe h`gcg}w# roe}oep }oe ijje!
pip ahme }oe ijjep gd biim jhg}o$
Hllipmgdbcw# }oe i`fel}gid }i }oi|e }ri eog`g}| g|
|u|}hgdem$ Wiu ohze hd ele~}gid$
-
8/3/2019 River Center LLC v. The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, No. 11-922 (filed Jan. 23, 2012)
89/108
# 0>88# me