Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

26
Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia. Asov and Black Seas study (Krasnodar region). Inna Krylenko Natalya Yumina Stepan Zemtsov Lomonosov Moscow State University Faculty of Geography Natural Risk Asessment Laboratory (NRAL)

description

Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia. Asov and Black Seas study (Krasnodar region). Lomonosov Moscow State University Faculty of Geography Natural Risk Asessment Laboratory (NRAL). Inna Krylenko Natalya Yumina Stepan Zemtsov. Object and purpose. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Page 1: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Asov and Black Seas study (Krasnodar region).

Inna Krylenko Natalya Yumina

Stepan Zemtsov

Lomonosov Moscow State University

Faculty of Geography

Natural Risk Asessment Laboratory (NRAL)

Page 2: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Object – aqua-territorial systems as a type of social-ecological systems

Subject – influence of natural processes (river flooding) on aqua-territorial systems

Purpose – an estimation of influence (risk and damage assessment) of natural processes on aqua-territorial systems

Object and purpose

Page 3: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Municipal districts and main cities of

Krasnodar region

(Krasnodarsky kray)

Page 4: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Potential flooding zones and observed flooding areas

Page 5: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Ecological sphere

Technosphere1.Infrastructure 2.Fixed funds

Sociosphere1. Socio-demographic

2. Ecomomy3. Political-administrative

4. Cultural

Psychological sphere

Social-economic geosystemor

social-ecological system

Natural hazards

AtmosphereHydrosphereLitosphereBiosphere

Antroposphere

The basic concepts of Russian approach

Page 6: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Risk Asessment Methodology in Russia

R = p*D R — risk p — hazard probability (%) D — expected damage

D = d*S + C

d — real damage per exposure area (rub*km2) — depends on flood depth, velocity, duration and land development

S — exposure area (km2) C — costs of preventive measures (rub)

Page 7: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

The scheme for selection of indicators to assess risk of flooding on regional level

(N.Frolova and others, 2011, Russia)

Flood risk assessment

Vulnerability assessmentAssessment of natural hazards

Natural factors Socio-economic factors

1. Probability of flooding of coastal areas

2. Scales of the phenomenon - maximum excess of the flooding level - flood duration - exposure area

3. Riverbed factor

1. Average population desity

2. Proportion of the population in the flood zone

3. Anthropogenic conditionality of emergencies

4. Main funds in the economy

5. Human development index

Map of the index of the natural hazards of flooding

Map of the socio-economicvulnerability index

Map of flood risk

Page 8: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Map of the index of the natural hazards of flooding (N.Frolova and others, 2011, Russia)

Index of the natural hazards of flooding

Page 9: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Map of the sociol-economic vulnerability of the territory during floods (N.Frolova and others, 2011, Russia)

Socio-economic vulnerability index

Page 10: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Map of typological zoning of Russia on the degree of flood risk (N.Frolova and others, 2011, Russia)

Classes of flood riskLow risk

Insignificant risk

Average riskHigh risk

Very high risk

Extremely high risk

Page 11: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

D=Dφ×θ ∑ Si Кi Pi

I – hazard level (1≤ i ≤3),Dφ×θ – damage coefficient for different types of damageSi – exposure area for each level of hazardКi – level of destruction coefficientPi – concentration coefficient:

 

ρi - density of population in each hazardous zoneρфон – density of population in the region, М – population of the region, mi – population in the zones of low (i=1), medium (i=2) and high (i=3) hazard

  

Сreg - net assets value of fixed production assets for year of census, n – years from census data, Ki – level of destruction coefficient.

Damage Asessment Methodology of Russian Emergency ministry

Page 12: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Destruction coefficients

Type of building

High level of destruction Medium level of

destruction Low level of destruction

Depth, m

Velocity, m / s

Duration, hours

Depth, m

Velocity, m / s

Duration, hours

Depth, m Velocity,

m / sDuration,

hours

Brick buildings(1-3 stages)

4 2,5 170 3 2 100 2 1 50

Industry buildings with light metal

construction 5 2,5 170 3,5 2 100 2 1,5 50

Brick buildings (more than 4

stages)6 3 240 4 2,5 170 2,5 1,5 100

Industry massive construction

7,5 4 240 6 3 170 3 1,5 100

Page 13: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Integral aproach.Scheme for indicators collection

    Exposure Vulnerability DamageSphere Dimension Spatial

objectsCost

parameters for damage

Susceptibility

Coping capacity

Adaptive capacity

 

I. Environment

 

Description:  Name Indicator Level Source      

II. Technosphere

 

Infrastructure

Fixed funds; industry and

serviceIII.

Sociosphere   

Social-demographi

c EconomyPolitical-

administrative

Cultural

Page 14: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Database

• Data from the Russian Statistical Service (Rosstat) for municipal districts (local level), federal ministries, departments of Krasnodarsky region administration, and etc.

• More than 300 indicators for 14 municipal districts from 2007 to 2011 years

• Seasonal data

Page 15: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

SphereDimension

Spatial objects

 Cost

parameters for damage

 Susceptibil

ity 

Coping capacity

 Adaptive capacity

 

Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator

I. Environment

Rare landscapes

Share of all area

   Ecological capacity

Landscape recovery

time

Ecological enthusiast

s

Number of members

of ecological organizati

ons

Biodiversity

Concentration Index

for landscape

Wild animals

areas

Share of all area

   Ecological capacity

Share of endangered species

       

Polluted area

Share of all area

PollutionEcological fines

Pollution

Quantity of

chemical fertilizers

   Ecological investmen

        Pollution

Number of waste

processing factories

       

Page 16: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

DimensionSpatial objects  

Cost parameters for damage   Susceptibility  

Coping capacity  

Adaptive capacity  

    Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator

II. Technosphe

re

Infrastructure

RoadsLength of improved

roadsRoads

Cost of kilometer

Susceptibility of different

roads

Share of improved

roads

Recovery crews

Share of population

DamsLength and

location

Water supply system

LengthWater supply

systemCost of

kilometer   

Alarm systems

 Number Bulk rollsLength and

location

Sewerage system

LengthSewerage

systemCost of

kilometer   

 Evacuation plans

 Irrigation system

Area and location

Heating system

LengthHeating system

Cost of kilometer

   Siren

networks  

Hydro and meteorologic

al stations 

Industry

Agricultural lands

 

Share of all area

Agricultural enterprises

Cost of fixed funds

       Agricultural management

?

Share of different

crops   

Susceptibility of different

crops

Share of susceptible

plants        

Forest lands  

Share of all area

Forest enterprises

Cost of fixed funds

       Forest

management?

Share of different

trees   

Susceptibility of different

trees

Share of susceptible

trees        

Fixed funds

Fixed funds of industries

 Industrial area

 Funds  Cost

Susceptibility of different

types of buildings

Share of susceptible buildings 

       

Fixed funds of service

 Service objects

  Funds Cost 

Susceptibility of different

types of buildings

Share of susceptible buildings 

       

Fixed funds of dwellings

Dwellings area 

  Funds

 Cost

Susceptibility of different

types of buildings

Share of fragile

dwellings

 

     

Page 17: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Sphere DimensionSpatial objects  

Cost parameters for damage   Susceptibility  

Coping capacity  

Adaptive capacity  

    Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator Name Indicator

III. Sociosphere

Sociol-demographic

Population exposed to

hazardsPeople 

Value of peoples life

?  Susceptible

people

Share of old and young

people

Emergency crews

Share of population

EducationLevel of primary

education

        Poor people

Percentage of population

with incomes below the

subsistence minimum

Emergency public crews

Number of participants in

voluntary groups for the protection of public order

Diversification of labour

market

Herfindahl–Hirschman

Index 

           Unemployme

nt rate     

           Income per

capita

Average monthly wages

   

           Social

networks?    

Economy

Industry enterprises

Volume of production

Cost of production

Sales of own-produced goods and services

    Insurance  Diversification of economy

 

    IncomeIncome of

enterprises            

   Profits of budget

Share of different

sources of budget  profits

       

The share of own revenues

of local budgets

 Herfindahl–Hirschman

Index 

                Investment  

Political-administrative

           

Medical service

 

Number of hospital bed per

10000 inhabitants

Administration efficiency

Time for building license

            Number of physicians per

10000 inhabitants

Private health expenditure

?

           Administratio

nSuspicious

transactions   

Cultural       

Susceptibility of different

nations

Share of migrants        

Page 18: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

VulnerabilitySusceptibility

Public infrastructureHousing

conditionsPoverty and dependencies Economic capacity Index

Length of improved water source / people

Length of improved

sanitation / people

The share of the inhabitants in

fragile dwellings

The share of the population with incomes below the subsistence

minimum

The share of the population

benefiting from social assistance

to pay for housing services

The share of the population served by the departments of social services at home for senior

citizens and disabled

Sales of own-produced goods,

works and services / people

 

0,075 0,075 0,15 0,15 0,15 0,15 0,25 0,33Lack of coping capacity  

Government and authoritiees Medical services Social networks Material coverage Index  

Unemployment rate

The share of own revenues of

local budgets

Number of hospital beds

per 10000 inhabitants

Number of physicians per

10000 inhabitants

Share of participants in

voluntary groups for the protection

of public order

Average monthly wages per capita

   

0,1 0,10 0,22 0,22 0,26 0,1 0,33  Lack of adaptive capacity      

EducationEnvironmental management

Adaptation strategies

Investment Index      

Share of employed

people with good education

Observed /Maximum flood

area

Diversification of the labour

market (Herfindahl–Hirschman

Index)

Private investment /

people       

0,25 0,25 0,25 0,25 0,33     

WorldRiskIndex approach. Selected indicators from database

Page 19: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

I = (X - Xo)/(X*-Xo) (1) – monotonic increasing dependence

between variable X and index I

I =1-(Xo - X)/(X*-Xo) (2) – monotonic decreasing dependence

Xo – minimum of variable X among N municipal districts,

X* – maximum

Index I belongs to [0,1]

Unification of variable indicator X

Page 20: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

  MunicipalRiskIndex

Exposure Vulnerability Susceptibility Lack of coping capacity

Lack of adaptive capacity

Novorossiysk 0,02 0,05 0,40 0,26 0,37 0,58

Gelendzhik 0,03 0,07 0,42 0,47 0,25 0,55Sochi 0,03 0,06 0,51 0,66 0,39 0,47

Tuapsinsky 0,04 0,09 0,50 0,45 0,56 0,49

Sherbinovsky 0,08 0,11 0,70 0,65 0,68 0,79

Kanevsky 0,09 0,14 0,62 0,40 0,70 0,77Eysky 0,10 0,16 0,65 0,67 0,66 0,63Anapa 0,13 0,28 0,47 0,49 0,36 0,56Krymsky 0,14 0,24 0,58 0,67 0,59 0,49

Krasnoarmeysky 0,23 0,32 0,70 0,56 0,83 0,72

Temryuksky 0,26 0,53 0,49 0,45 0,74 0,27Kalininsky 0,35 0,47 0,74 0,63 0,86 0,75Primorsko-Akhtarsky  0,39 0,7 0,56 0,63 0,65 0,40

Slavyansky 0,45 0,75 0,59 0,43 0,71 0,65

Page 21: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Lack of capacity and susceptibility indeces

Page 22: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Exposure and vulnerability indeces

Page 23: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Municipal Risk Index

Page 24: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Future directions

1.Seasonal or day / night vulnerability

2. Damage estimation (Russian methodology) for case area

3. Workshop (elaboration of indicators)

4. Survey (verification of methodology, search for some indicators) on the case area

5. Experts‘ interviews (Emergency ministry, Hydrological service, Economic department of local government, etc.)

6. Resilience estimation (methodology, indicators, etc.)

Page 25: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Map from the GIS cadastral register. Temryuk city

Page 26: Risk assessment of coastal zones in the European part of Russia.

Thank you for your attention!