Sheet1Package No.:Name of Firm/JV :Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only )(max 10 marks)Type of jobNo of ProjectsRemarksFeasibility study of Road5Service cost not less than 5 lakhsDetailed Engineering Survey and Design of RoadPre-Feasibility/Alignment Study of RoadMarks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training ( max 50 marks)DescriptionMax. marksObtained marksUnderstanding the objective of ToRComments or suggestions on ToR and services6Description and review any relevant documents6MethodologyDetailed step by step description of the methods to be adopted for road alignment survey, hydrology, soil investigation, socio-economic survey, environmental survey and other relevant data collection from the macro structural point of view.12Explanation on use of software intended to be used for the job.2Work Plan/ScheduleDescription of analysis steps or flowchart of the analysis process.5Clear work schedule with description4Manning schedule4If any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site or if any of key personnel has worked in the nearby location during the last five years and has attached a photograph, described the site.5Technology transfer/TrainingThe idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the consultant.6TOTAL50MARKS FOR QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE OF THE KEY PERSONAL (max 40 marks)PersonnelMarks for qualification (Y/N)No of experience in similar jobs **Max marksHighway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )Basic qualification*Post graduation degreeGeotechnical Engineer / Engineering geologist / GeologistBasic qualification*Post graduation degreeHydrologistBasic qualification*Post graduation degreeTransport Economist/sociologistBasic qualification*Post graduation degreeEnvironmentalistBasic qualification*Post graduation degreeNote :* Basic qualification means Bachelor degree in relevant field.** Feasibility study of Roads, Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Roads and Pre- feasibility/Alignment Study of Roads are considered as similar jobs.

SummarySummary of EvaluationContract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Name of Work: -Detailed Engineering Survey, Design and Report Preparation of Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar Road,BankeSNName of Firm/JVTechnical Mark ObtainedRemarks1CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.17.80Fail2SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.17.40Fail3RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.14.40Fail4CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.36.60Fail

1Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only ) : Max 10Road Length=10 KMName of FirmWork Experience As ConsultantMarks per ProjectMax MarkCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road11011DPR Preparation11000Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road11000TOTAL1Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training : Max 40DescriptionCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.Evaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3Comments or suggestions on ToR and servicesNot Significant41.6General1.6SignificantDescription and review any relevant documents like Design StandardsNot Significant50.0General Review0Critical ReviewIf any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site and has attached a photograph, described the site.No Description80.0General DescriptionGeneral Description with site photograph0Technical Description with site photographMethodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic StudyNot Significant30.0General0Clear Methodology with flow chartsMethodology to perform Detailed Engineering SurveyNot Significant127.2General Methodology Only7.2General Methodology with flow chartsClear Methodology with flow chartsWork Scheduled with descriptionNot Significant44.0Fairly justify the proposed methodologyRelevant to proposed methodology4Manning scheduled as per Work ScheduledNot Significant44.0Fairly justify the proposed Work scheduledRelevant to proposed Work Scheduled4TOTAL4016.8Average TOTAL4016.8Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5DescriptionEvaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3The idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the consultant.Not Significant50.0General (only standard method description)Significant0TOTAL0Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45PersonnelNo of experience in similar jobsMinimunm Experience after Bachelor DegreeCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.Education(Y/N)ExperienceMarksHighway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks10y150Dr.Padam Bahadur ShahiGeotechnical Engineer1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7y200Hari Krishna MainaliHydrologist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y150Binod Chandra DevkotaSociologyist /Economist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y150Embika Prasad MahatoTotal0.00Grand Total17.80RemarksFail

2Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only ) : Max 10Road Length=10 KMName of FirmWork Experience As ConsultantMarks per ProjectMax MarkSLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road11033DPR Preparation11000Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road11000TOTAL3Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training : Max 40DescriptionSLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.Evaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3Comments or suggestions on ToR and servicesNot Significant41.6General1.6SignificantDescription and review any relevant documents like Design StandardsNot Significant50.0General Review0Critical ReviewIf any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site and has attached a photograph, described the site.General Description80.0General Description with site photograph0Technical Description with site photographMethodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic StudyNot Significant30.0General0Clear Methodology with flow chartsMethodology to perform Detailed Engineering SurveyNot Significant127.2General Methodology Only7.2General Methodology with flow chartsClear Methodology with flow chartsWork Scheduled with descriptionNot Significant41.6Fairly justify the proposed methodology1.6Relevant to proposed methodologyManning scheduled as per Work ScheduledNot Significant44.0Fairly justify the proposed Work scheduledRelevant to proposed Work Scheduled4TOTAL4014.4Average TOTAL4014.4Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5DescriptionEvaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3The idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the consultant.Not Significant50.0General (only standard method description)Significant0TOTAL0Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45PersonnelNo of experience in similar jobsMinimunm Experience after Bachelor DegreeSLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.Education(Y/N)ExperienceMarksHighway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks10y340Sita Ram ShahGeotechnical Engineer1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7y60Arun Kumar PanditHydrologist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y140Hemant Kumar JhaSociologyist /Economist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y100Ambar Bahadur ThapaTotal0.00Grand Total17.40RemarksFail

3Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only ) : Max 10Road Length=10 KMName of FirmWork Experience As ConsultantMarks per ProjectMax MarkRURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road11000DPR Preparation11000Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road11000TOTAL0Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training : Max 40DescriptionRURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.Evaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3Comments or suggestions on ToR and servicesNot Significant41.6General1.6SignificantDescription and review any relevant documents like Design StandardsNot Significant50.0General Review0Critical ReviewIf any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site and has attached a photograph, described the site.General Description80.0General Description with site photograph0Technical Description with site photographMethodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic StudyNot Significant30.0General0Clear Methodology with flow chartsMethodology to perform Detailed Engineering SurveyNot Significant127.2General Methodology Only7.2General Methodology with flow chartsClear Methodology with flow chartsWork Scheduled with descriptionNot Significant41.6Fairly justify the proposed methodology1.6Relevant to proposed methodologyManning scheduled as per Work ScheduledNot Significant44.0Fairly justify the proposed Work scheduledRelevant to proposed Work Scheduled4TOTAL4014.4Average TOTAL4014.4Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5DescriptionEvaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3The idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the consultant.Not Significant50.0General (only standard method description)Significant0TOTAL0Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45PersonnelNo of experience in similar jobsMinimunm Experience after Bachelor DegreeRURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.Education(Y/N)ExperienceMarksHighway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks10y210Arvind Kumar YadavGeotechnical Engineer1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7y50Anand GuptaHydrologist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y110Deepak PaudelSociologyist /Economist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y200Sohan MaharjanTotal0.00Grand Total14.40RemarksFail

4Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only ) : Max 10Road Length=10 KMName of FirmWork Experience As ConsultantMarks per ProjectMax MarkCARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road1101010DPR Preparation11000Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road11000TOTAL10Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training : Max 40DescriptionCARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Evaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3Comments or suggestions on ToR and servicesNot Significant44.0GeneralSignificant4Description and review any relevant documents like Design StandardsNot Significant55.0General ReviewCritical Review5If any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site and has attached a photograph, described the site.General Description80.00General Description with site photographTechnical Description with site photographMethodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic StudyNot Significant30.0General0Clear Methodology with flow chartsMethodology to perform Detailed Engineering SurveyNot Significant1212.0General Methodology OnlyGeneral Methodology with flow chartsClear Methodology with flow charts12Work Scheduled with descriptionNot Significant41.6Fairly justify the proposed methodology1.6Relevant to proposed methodologyManning scheduled as per Work ScheduledNot Significant44.0Fairly justify the proposed Work scheduledRelevant to proposed Work Scheduled4TOTAL4026.6Average TOTAL4026.6Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5DescriptionEvaluation RemarksTotal MarksAvg marks from 3 evaluatorsEval 1Eval 2Eval 3The idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the consultant.Not Significant50.0General (only standard method description)Significant0TOTAL0Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45PersonnelNo of experience in similar jobsMinimunm Experience after Bachelor DegreeCARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Education(Y/N)ExperienceMarksHighway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks10y200GBS TAMRAKARGeotechnical Engineer1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7y300Dr.Ram Krishna PoudelHydrologist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y50Sanjay AdhikariSociologyist /Economist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks7Y230Hari Darshan ShresthaTotal0.00Grand Total36.60RemarksFail

Manpower Repetition sheetManpower Repetition SheetContract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Key PersonnelsFirmsCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Highway/ Transport EngineerDr.Padam Bahadur ShahiSita Ram ShahArvind Kumar YadavGBS TAMRAKARGeotechnical EngineerHari Krishna MainaliArun Kumar PanditAnand GuptaDr.Ram Krishna PoudelHydrologistBinod Chandra DevkotaHemant Kumar JhaDeepak PaudelSanjay AdhikariSenior SurveyorEmbika Prasad MahatoAmbar Bahadur ThapaSohan MaharjanHari Darshan Shrestha

all in 1Name of Work: -Detailed Engineering Survey, Design and Report Preparation of Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar Road,BankeContract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only ) : Max 10Road Length =10KMWork Experience As ConsultantMarks per ProjectMax MarksCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road11013010DPR Preparation10000Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road10000TOTAL1013010Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training : Max 40DescriptionMax MarksCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Comments or suggestions on ToR and services41.61.61.64Description and review any relevant documents like Design Standards5000000If any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site and has attached a photograph, described the site.800.00000Methodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic Study3000000Methodology to perform Detailed Engineering Survey1207.20000Work Scheduled with description4040000Manning scheduled as per Work Scheduled4040000TOTAL4016.81.61.64Average TOTAL4016.81.61.64Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5DescriptionMax MarksCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.The idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the consultant.50000TOTAL50000Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45PersonnelNo of experience in similar jobs **Max MarksCIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.Highway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks150000Geotechnical Engineer1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks100000Hydrologist1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks100000Senior Surveyor1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks100000Total450000Grand Total10017.8000Remarks

CE Combined Evaluation Sheet (Technical and Financial)Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10Total estimated amount excluding VAT & contingencies =1,504,983.84SN.Name and Address of Financial ProposalTechnical Score out of 100Rate/Km Without VATRead out Financial Proposal PriceDiff w.r.t. estimateTechnical Score(80%)Financial Score(20%)Total Score (100%)Rank1CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.17.800(100.00)14.240.000.0002SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.17.400(100.00)13.920.000.0003RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.14.400(100.00)11.520.000.0004CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.37

&CGovernment of NepalMinistry of Physical Infrastructure and TransportDepartment of RoadsDesign and Planning BranchPlanning Monitoring and Evaluation UnitBabarmahal, Kathmandu