Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and...

42
©2016 MFMER | slide-1 Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target-Specific Oral Anticoagulants David Roy, PharmD PGY2 Emergency Medicine Pharmacy Resident Pharmacy Grand Rounds September 13, 2016

Transcript of Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and...

Page 1: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-1

Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target-Specific Oral Anticoagulants David Roy, PharmDPGY2 Emergency Medicine Pharmacy ResidentPharmacy Grand RoundsSeptember 13, 2016

Page 2: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-2

Objectives• Review the evidence behind current guideline

recommendations for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants

• Identify novel agents in clinical development for reversal of Factor Xa inhibitors

• Describe the risks and benefits of reversing anticoagulation

Page 3: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-3

Anticoagulation on the Rise• 6 to 8 million Americans are prescribed OAC

• Increased global prescribing of anticoagulation; NOACs quickly replacing warfarin

McBane R, et al. Thromb Res 2016;139:160-5Barnes G, et al. Am J Med 2015. 128(12):1300-5

Kuramatsu J, et al. JAMA 2015;313(8):824-36Ruff CT, et al. Lancet 2014;383(9921):955-62Van Es N, et al. Blood 2014;124(12):1968-75

OAC: Oral anticoagulationNOAC: Novel oral anticoagulantsICH: Intracerebral hemorrhageNVAF: Nonvalvular atrial fibrillation

NOACs vs. WarfarinNVAF Treatment of DVT/PE

Efficacy Stroke risk ↓ 19% Similar VTE recurrence

Safety Major bleed ↓ 14%ICH ↓ 52% Major bleed ↓ 38%

Page 4: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-4

ICH Mortality

Selim M, et al. Stroke 2012;43:2539-2540Frontera J, et al. Neurocrit Care 2016; 24:6-46

WarfarinMeasure and reverse

Goal INR ≤ 1.4

NOACCan’t measure or reverse

• ICH mortality 40-50% with OAC• Increased age/comorbidities• Increased hematoma volume• Greater hematoma expansion

Modifiable Risk Factors

OAC: Oral anticoagulationNOAC: Novel oral anticoagulants

Page 5: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-5

Warfarin Reversal

Page 6: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-6

General Approach: Warfarin

INR Algorithm Antidote

AntidoteVitamin K

FFPPCC

Page 7: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-7

Vitamin K

• IV normalizes INR quicker than PO (6-8 hours); no difference at 24 hours

• 10mg IV recommend with all reversal agents in WAICH

Watson H, et al. Br J Haematol. 2001;115:145-9Frontera J, et al. Neurocrit Care 2016; 24:6-46

WAICH: Warfarin-associated Intracranial Hemorrhage

Factor Half-life (hr)VII (7) 8IX (9) 24X (10) 48II (2) 72

Vitamin K ???

Page 8: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-8

Fresh Frozen Plasma (FFP)

• 10-20 ml/kg increases factors by ~20%• 1 unit of FFP is 250ml• FFP = INR 1.6

• INR normalization depends on initial INR, volume of FFP

• Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema, TRALI or TACO

• Requires ABO typing, thawingTRALI: Transfusion-related acute lung injuryTACO: Transfusion-associated circulatory overload

Chapman S, et al. Ann Pharmacother. 2011;45:869-75Makris M, et al. Thromb Haemost. 1997;77:477-80

Factor VII, IX, X, II

Page 9: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-9

Prothrombin Complex Concentrates (PCC)

Factor VII (+/-), IX, X, II(25x concentrated)

3-factor PCC

4-factor PCC

Sarode R, et al. Circulation. 2013;128:1234-43Goldstein, et al. Lancet. 2015;128:360-4

Voils SA, et al. Thromb Res. 2012;130(6):833-40

3F-PCC 4F-PCCFactor IIFactor IXFactor XFactor VIIProtein C/SAntithrombin IIIHeparinPrice ↑ 30%

Page 10: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-10

Vitamin K FFP

Vitamin K 3-factor PCC

Vitamin K 4-factor PCC

Page 11: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-11

FFP vs. 4-factor PCC• Randomized, open-label, non-inferiority: 4-factor PCC or

FFP for major bleed with INR>2• Hemostatic efficacy at 24 hours• INR reduction ≤ 1.3 at 30 minutes

Sarode R, et al. Circulation 2013. Aug 9 [Epub ahead of print]

Notable ExclusionPrior to ICH, GCS < 7 or mRS >3

History of thrombotic event (MI, DIC, stroke, TIA) within 3 months

History of antiphospholipid or lupus anticoagulant antibodiesSepsis

Expected survival < 3 daysExpected surgery < 1 day

Page 12: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-12

FFP vs. 4-factor PCC• 4-factor PCC (107 pts), FFP (109 pts)

• 12% of patients had ICH• 55% anticoagulated for atrial fibrillation

4-factor PCC FFP

Hemostasis @ 24hr 72.4% 65.4% 95% CI (-5.8-19.9)

INR ≤ 1.3 @ 30 min 62.2% 9.6%Noninferior

Visible Bleed 4-factor PCC FFP

Hemostasis @ 24hr 82.6% 50%

Nonvisible Bleed 4-factor PCC FFP

Hemostasis @ 24hr 69.3% 71.1%

ICH 4-factor PCC FFP

Hemostasis @ 24hr 41.7% 58.3%

Sarode R, et al. Circulation 2013. Sep 10; 128(11):1234-43

Page 13: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-13

Trial weaknesses• No clinical outcomes

• INR poor surrogate marker

• Hemostasis efficacy scale not validated

• Difficult for FFP to meet INR primary outcome; INR 1.6

• 4-factor PCC thromboembolic events: 8.7% vs. 5.5%

4-factor PCC FFP45-day mortality 9.7% 4.6%

Sarode R, et al. Circulation 2013. Sep 10; 128(11):1234-43

Assumption:↓INR = ↓ Hematoma Expansion = ↑ Outcomes ???

Page 14: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-14

3F-PCC vs. 4F-PCC• Only retrospective studies comparing 3-factor vs.

4-factor PCC• 4-factor PCC more rapidly corrects INR• Risk of thrombosis possibly decreased with 4-

factor PCC (proteins C/S, ATIII)• 4-factor PCC FDA-approved for warfarin reversal

Sarode R, et al. Circulation. 2013;128:1234-43Goldstein, et al. Lancet. 2015;128:360-4

Voils SA, et al. Thromb Res. 2012;130(6):833-40

Page 15: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-15

Question #1From 2010-2012, how many Mayo Clinic (Rochester) patients had a thromboembolic event after receiving Bebulin for major bleed reversal?A. 2.5%B. 5%C. 10%D. 20%

Page 16: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-16

Risk of Reversal• Retrospective review of 3-PCC for reversal of

major bleeding or periprocedural at MCR

McBane R, et al. Thromb Res 2016;139:160-5MCR: Mayo Clinic Rochester

Major bleeding (n = 113)

Periprocedural(n = 52)

Thromboembolic events 24 (21%) 7 (13%)

Time to 1st complication 7.3 days (0-32) 13.4 days (1-30)

Arterial embolism 2 2

Stroke/TIA 5 0

Intracardiac thrombus 3 0

DVT 13 5

PE 1 0

Major Bleeding NA 7

Death 20 (18%) 8 (15%)

Page 17: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-17

WAICH Reversal Summary• Risk/Benefit prior to reversal• Educate on limitations of PCC studies using INR

reduction as primary outcome• Administer 10mg IV Vitamin K with 4-factor PCC

INR 2-4

4-factor PCC 25 units/kg

(max 2500 units)

INR 4-6

4-factor PCC 35 units/kg

(max 3500 units)

INR > 6

4-factor PCC 50 units/kg

(max 5000 units)

Frontera J, et al. Neurocrit Care 2016; 24:6-46Kcentra [package insert]. CSL Behring

Page 18: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-18

General Approach: NOAC

Identify medication

Assess magnitude of anticoagulation• Time of last dose• Renal function

Antidote

Renal function quantifies therapeutic anticoagulation levels

Activated charcoal if last dose within 2 hours

Page 19: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-19

Dabigatran Reversal

Page 20: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-20

Idarucizumab• FDA-approved humanized monoclonal antibody

for patients treated with dabigatran that require anticoagulation reversal

• Dabigatran 350x higher affinity for Idarucizumab than thrombin

Eikelboom JW, et al. Circulation. 2015;132:2412-2422

Dosing 5 gm IV (Two 2.5 g boluses within 15 minutes)T1/2 10.3 hours

Dabigatran-Idarucizumab Dissociation 40-50 hours

Onset of Action 1-2 minutesRoute of Elimination Renal

Page 21: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-21

Idarucizumab for Dabigatran Reversal (RE-VERSE AD)

Pollack C, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 511-520

Page 22: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-22

RE-VERSE AD

• Multicenter, prospective cohort study• 90 patient interim analysis• Two 2.5 gm infusions (5gm total)

A(Life-threatening bleed)

B(Urgent procedure)

Primary outcome: maximum % reversal

Secondary outcome: Normalization of dTT, ECT,

reduction in unbound dabigatran

Pollack C, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 511-520

Page 23: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-23

RE-VERSE AD Results• Primary: Maximum % reversal: 100%

• Secondary:

• No clinical outcomes

• Biochemical reversal ≠ clinical reversal?• 4 case reports suggest no

Normalization of clotting time

dTT ECT

Group A 98% 89%

Group B 93% 88%

Safety OutcomesDeath 18/90 (20%)

Serious Adverse Event 21/90 (23.3%)

MI 1/90 (1%)Stroke 1/90 (1%)

DVT/PE 3/90 (3.3%)

Pollack C, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 511-520Thorborg C, et al. Br J Anaesth 2016; 117(3):407-9

Henderson R, et al. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 2016 [Epub ahead of print]Alhashem H, et al. Am J Emerg Med 2016 [Epub ahead of print]

Marino K, et al. Pharmacotherapy 2016 [Epub ahead of print]

Page 24: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-24

Question #2What is recommended as second-line therapy for Dabigatran reversal if bleeding persists after giving Idarucizumab?

A. Redose 2.5 gm IdarucizumabB. Activated charcoalC. Andexanet alfaD. 4-factor PCC

Page 25: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-25

Refractory to Idarucizumab• Repeat 5gm Idarucizumab may be considered• Small clinical trials, animal studies support

activated 4-factor PCC (FEIBA) over other products

• Dialysis

Dickneite G, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 511-520

Page 26: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-26

Dabigatran Summary• Time of last dose; activated charcoal if < 2 hours• Renal function; anticipate level of anticoagulation• Idarucizumab 5 gm over 15 minutes• Consider FEIBA (activated 4-factor PCC) or

dialysis

Frontera J, et al. Neurocrit Care 2016; 24:6-46

Page 27: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-27

Apixaban/Rivaroxaban/Edoxaban Reversal

Page 28: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-28

Current Recommendations• Retrospective, observational data• Obtain time since last dose to estimate

anticoagulation exposure• Activated charcoal if < 2 hours

• Reversal guided by life-threatening severity of bleed, not laboratory testing

Frontera J, et al. Neurocrit Care 2016; 24:6-46

4-factor PCC 50 units/kg if within 3-5 half-lives

Page 29: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-29

Andexanet Alfa• Recombinant factor Xa decoy protein designed

to neutralize direct/indirect factor Xa inhibitors

Procoagulant Activity

Anticoagulant Activity

Lu G, et al. Nat Med. 2013; 19(4):446-51

Gla

S S

Factor Xa

S S

Andexanet alfa

Page 30: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-30

Andexanet Alfa for the Reversal of Factor Xa Inhibitor Activity

Siegal D, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 2413-2424

Page 31: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-31

• Phase 3 double-blind, placebo-controlled RCT in healthy volunteers (50-75 years old)

ANNEXA-A, ANNEXA-R

Siegal D, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 2413-2424

ANNEXA-A (Apixaban 5mg BID)

Bolus: 400mg IV Bolus: 400mg IVInfusion: 4 mg/min

x 120min

ANNEXA-R(Rivaroxaban 20mg daily)

Bolus: 800mg IV Bolus: 800mg IVInfusion: 8 mg/min

x 120min

Page 32: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-32

Endpoints (ANNEXA-A)94%

21%

0

20

40

60

80

100

Apixaban

Red

uctio

n in

Ant

i-Xa

Act

ivity

(%)

AnXa

Placebo

Siegal D, et al. N Engl J Med 2015; 373: 2413-2424

9.3

1.9

0

5

10

Apixaban

Red

uctio

n of

unb

ound

ap

ixab

an c

onc.

(n

g/m

L)

96%

7%0

20

40

60

80

100

Apixaban

Full

rest

orat

ion

of

thro

mbi

n (%

)

Page 33: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-33

ANNEXA-4: Andexanet Alfa for Acute Major Bleeding Associated with

Factor Xa Inhibitors

Connolly S, et al. N Engl J Med 2016

Page 34: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-34

ANNEXA-4 Design

Connolly S, et al. N Engl J Med 2016

30 min Bolus

2-hr infusion After infusionAcute Major

Bleed

Last fXa inhibitor < 18hrs

Patient Screening Andexanet Tx

Bleeding/Laboratory Assessment

1 hr 4 hr 8 hr 12 hr

Day 1 Day 3 Day 30

Safety

Primary Efficacy Endpoints

• Change in anti-FXa activity• Clinical hemostasis (12hr)

Safety Endpoints

• Thrombotic events• Antibody development• 30-day all-cause mortality

Page 35: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-35

Baseline characteristicsSafety population, n = 67 Efficacy population, n = 47

Age, mean ± SD 77.1 (10) 77.1 (10.1)

Male, n (%) 35 (52.2) 24 (51.1)

Caucasian, n (%) 54 (80.6) 36 (76.6)

Time @ presentation until andexanet bolus (hrs) ± SD 4.8 ± 1.93 4.8 ± 1.82

Est CrCl < 30 mL/min, n (%) 6 (9.0) 4 (8.5)

Indication for AnticoagulationAtrial fibrillation, n (%) 47 (70.1) 32 (68.1)

VTE, n (%) 15 (22.4) 12 (25.5)

Medical HistoryMI, n (%) 13 (19.4) 7 (14.9)

Stroke, n (%) 17 (25.4) 15 (31.9)

DVT, n (%) 20 (29.9) 16 (34.0)

PE, n (%) 6 (9.0) 4 (8.5)

Atrial fibrillation, n (%) 49 (73.1) 34 (72.3)

Connolly S, et al. N Engl J Med 2016

Page 36: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-36

Anti-factor Xa Activity

0

200

400

600

Baseline End ofBolus

End ofInfusion

4 hr 8 hr 12 hr

Ant

i-fac

tor X

a A

ctiv

ity

(ng/

ml)

Rivaroxaban(n = 26)

Connolly S, et al. N Engl J Med 2016

Median 277.0 16.8 30.6 177.7 127.1 97.9

% change (95% CI)

-89%(-58 to -94)

-86%(-55 to -93)

-39%(-27 to -45)

-49%(-43 to -57)

-64%(-51 to -70)

Page 37: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-37

Clinical Hemostatic Efficacy

Subgroup # of patients Excellent/Good Hemostasis, %(95% CI)

All patients with efficacy analysis 47 79 (64-89)

Drug

Rivaroxaban 26 81 (61-93)

Apixaban 20 75 (51-91)

Enoxaparin 1 100

Site of bleeding

Gastrointestinal 25 84 (64-96)

Intracranial 20 80 (56-94)

Other 2 0

Connolly S, et al. N Engl J Med 2016

Page 38: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-38

Safety• Thrombotic events

• 3 days: 4 patients (6%)• 30 days: 12 patients (18%)

• Only 18 patients (27%) restarted anticoagulation within 30 days

• 30-day all-cause mortality• 10 patients (15%)

Connolly S, et al. N Engl J Med 2016

FDA did not approve Andexanet alfa in August 2016

“…additional data needed for manufacturing and enoxaparin/edoxaban reversal”

Page 39: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-39

Does reversal even help?

Although ICH-mortality is 40-50%, two-thirds of survivors can live an independent life

Togha M, et al. BMC Neurology 2004. 4(9)1-5

• Studies say no difference in ICH reversal• Others say reversal normalizes INR and

reduces hematoma expansion

Page 40: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-40

Question #3What additional information was requested when the FDA did not approve Andexanet alfa?

A. Clarification of thrombotic events in ANNEXA-4

B. Data related to enoxaparin reversalC. Data related to argatroban reversalD. Pharmacokinetic studies in liver failure

Page 41: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-41

Summary• Assess risk/benefit of reversing anticoagulation

for intracranial hemorrhage• Warfarin reversal with 4F-PCC and Vitamin K

preferred• Dabigatran reversal with Idarucizumab• Xa Inhibitor reversal with 4-PCC until new

antidotes are approved

Page 42: Review of Reversal Strategies for Warfarin and Target ... for reversal of warfarin and target-specific oral anticoagulants ... • Large volume required may lead to pulmonary edema,

©2016 MFMER | slide-42

Questions & Discussion