Restoring collective memory or making moral reparations to ... · project directed by Anna Sallés...
Transcript of Restoring collective memory or making moral reparations to ... · project directed by Anna Sallés...
-
Spain’s transition to democracy in the mid 70s put the country’s Civil War (1936-39) in the limelight. The debate permeated both public and private spheres. This was because the Franco dictatorship had imposed its own version of events and forced the vanquished to remain silent.
AfterFranco’sdeaththerewasagreatdealofpublicinterestindiscoveringwhathadreallyhappened—athirstforknowledgethatwentbeyondpurelypoliticalandideologicalreasons.Manypoliticallycommittedstudentsatthetime—ofwhomIwasone—chosehistoryforitsroleinestablishingthetruthofevents.OnecansaythatHistorywasperceivedasthehandmaidenofdemocracy.Indeed,somesawthedisciplineasapoliticalweapon.Theeagernessto“restorecollectivememory”wentbeyondacademiccircles.Clio,themuseofhistory,hadneverhadsomanyardentadmirersnorhadhistoriansenjoyedsuchsocialstatus.Indeed,thescholarsseemedlikelatter-dayheroesastheywrestedcontrolofarchivesfromtheregime’scroniesinordertogivethevanquishedanewvisionoftherecentpast.AwholehostofcapstoneprojectsandtheseswerebeguninthoseyearsonthehistoryoftheRepublicandtheSpanishCivilWar.JosepM.SoléSabatéandJoanVillarroyapioneeredresearchintoFascistrepression.
In1976,twopublishinghouses,La Gaia Ciencia and Edicions 62,publishedanambitiousprojectdirectedbyAnnaSallésandalsoanimatedbyRosaRegàs.TheprojectwastitledRecuperem la nostra història[RecoveringOurHistory]andconsistedofalargeformat
nsfertra03 / / 2 0 0 8
Restoring collective memory or making moral reparations to the victims?
Andreu Mayayo
48
-
II
workintwelveissuesthatcoveredtheperiodfromtheproclamationoftheRepublic,inspiredbythepresidentoftheGeneralitatinexileJosepTarradellas,uptothemilitaryoccupation.Thisone,writtenbyJosepBenet,aleadingfigureinthestruggleagainsttheFrancodictatorship.Thesponsorsclearlystatedthepurposeofthecollectioninthefollowingterms:“Itisnotnostalgiathatdrivesustorecoverourhistorybutratherthefirmconvictionthatitisnecessaryifwearetounderstandthepresent.Recoveringourhistoryisawayofshapingthepresentandthusourfuture[...]Itinvolvesrecoveringpeople’smemoryandgoingbacktothesources.AsRaimonsays:He who forgets his origins loses his identity”.
ThefinalquotationwasfromasongbyRaimon,whoseiconiclyrics—Jo vinc d’un silenci[TheSilenceFromWhenceICome]—aretakenfromapoembySalvadorEspriu.ThesamequotationwasusedbythemagazineJovent,themouthpieceofJoventut Comunista de Catalunya,theyouthwingofthePSUC[Partit Socialista Unificat de Catalunya-UnifiedSocialistPartyofCatalonia]inanissuepublishedin1977thatrantosome10,000copies.Thepublicationhelpedfillaglaringgapinthecountry’shistory.LongbeforeBenitoBermejoinhisbook,andLlorençSolerinadocumentaryputFrancescBoixinthespotlight,EmiliPeydró(firstDirectorofJuliol,ayouthmagazinepublishedbytheJSUCmovementin1936)toldreadersofJovent justwhotheCatalanphotographeraccusingtheNazisattheNurembergTrialwas.
Arreu magazinecameoutinOctober1976undertheaegisofthePSUC,apartythatwasstillillegalatthetime.ThemagazinehadaregularsectiontitledMemòria Popular [ThePeople’sMemory].JesúsMariaRodés,whowasinchargeofthesection,adoptedthenametostressthatitservedthepeople’sinterestsanddefendedCatalanandworking-classidentity.Thefirstissueconsistedof80,000freecopies.Init,JosepBenetwrotealongarticleonthearrest,trial,andexecutionofPresidentLluísCompanys,asubjectonwhichBenetisnowanauthority.
ItisworthmentioningsomearticlesfromtheFrancoera.ThehistoriansEnricUcelayDaCalandBorjadeRiquerreferredtotheCatalansthathelpedFranco;LeandreColomertothetrialofJoanComorera;andFèlixFanéstothe1951tramstrike.Otherthemeswere:themassround-upofPSUCmembersin1946,whichendedintheexecutionbyfiringsquadoffour“ringleaders”in1949;theFreeUniversityAssemblyof1957;thesit-inattheCapuchinFriaryinBarcelonain1966;theexecutionofSalvadorPuigAntich.TheCatalanlanguagearmofRTVE[SpanishStateBroadcastingCorporation]alsobroadcastaprogrammetitledMemòria Popular,presentedbySalvadorAsliusandwiththehistorianJoanB.Cullaactinginanadvisorycapacity.
Prof.SantosJuliáremindedusthatthesewerethegoldenyearsofhistorymagazineswithnewpublicationsspringinguplikemushrooms(Historia 16, Tiempo de Historia),andwiththousandsofcopiessold.L’AvençwasfoundedinCatalonia—theflagshipofwhatsomehavetermed“popularfronthistory”.Labelsaside,L’Avençmetsocialdemandwithaproductthatwaswrittenwithintellectualrigourbutthatadoptedajournalisticstyle.Amongthefirstissuesofthemagazine,directedbyFerranMascarellamongothers,thereisanarticlebyJosepM.SoléSabatéontherepressionofthemaquis.
Otherpublishers—botholdandnew—helpedslakethepublic’sthirstforinformationonthecountry’srecenthistory.JaumeSobrequés(holderoftheChairofCatalanHistory,
-
5150/51 II Restoring collective memory Andreu Mayayo
erstwhilesenatoroftheEntesa dels Catalanscoalition,andDirectoroftheCatalanHistoryMuseum)setuptheUndàriuspublishinghouse.Thefirstbook,L’Onze de Setembre a Catalunya[11thSeptemberinCatalonia1]coincidedwiththemassivedemonstrationinSantBoíon11thSeptember1976.Thebooksoldarecord20,000copiesinthefirstfewweeks.ThebookEls catalans als camps nazis [CatalansinTheNaziConcentrationCamps]waspublishedonSaintGeorge’sDay19772.WrittenbythejournalistMontserratRoig,itspokefranklyoflifeanddeathintheThirdReich’sconcentrationcamps.JosepBenetwasinstrumentalinthebook’spublication.TheworkwasinspiredbyJoaquimAmat-Piniella’snovelK. L. Reich3 (1963),whichspokeoftheCatalans,SpanishRepublicansandothergroupswhosharedthefateofJewsinNaziGermany’sconcentrationcamps.
MonsterratRoig’sbookwasabest-sellerandhadanenormoussocialimpact.Thepresentationofthebookwasoftenprecededbydocumentariesontheconcentrationcamps,narratedbyJoanPagèsandothersurvivorsofMauthausen.Republicancombatantsandfreedomfightersbegantospeakoutinthevariouspoliticalassociationsthatsprangupatthetime.Suddenly,tradeunionsandothergroupswerefilledwiththeelderlywhonowhadtheopportunitytorelatetheirpoliticalactivitiesinthe1930safterdecadesofsilence.The4thPSUCCongress,heldinOctober1977,agreedtosetupaHistoricalArchivecoveringallkindsofdocumentsrelatingtothepartyanditssocialmovements.ThePSUCalsopaidhomagetoitsmemberswholosttheirlivesinthefightforfreedom.TheeventwasheldinBarcelona’sCongressHallon24thMay1980.TheconferencespeecheswerelaterpublishedasthebookU no és ningú [YouAreNobody],withapoembyJoanBrossaandacoverillustrationbyAntoniTàpies.ThePSUC(andnowICV)gatheredeachyeartolaywreathsattheFossar de la Pedrera—thequarrywherethelastPSUCmemberswereshotbytheregimeinFebruary1949.
AMNESTY DOES NOT MEAN AMNESIA
Theendofhostilitiesin1939markedthebeginningofalongperiodofbrutalrepressionwhichonlydeepenedthedivisionbetweenthevictorsandthevanquished.ThissplitlastedrightthewaythroughthedictatorshipandwasafundamentaltraitoftheFrancoregime.Thequestforamnestythusbecameakeydemandinanti-Francoistpoliticalculture,spurringsolidarityandsocialmobilisation.Hencetheimportanceofthemanifestodrawnupin1956,whichwasembracedbytheoffspringofthoseonbothsidesintheSpanishCivilWar.ThepolicyofNationalReconciliationwasadoptedbytheSpanishCommunistParty.AsGregorioLópezRaimundostatedinhishomagetofallenPSUCmembers:“ThepolicyofNationalReconciliationwasadoptedin1956,whentheCatholicChurchwasstillsittingonthefence.ThepolicywasdecisiveinopeningupnewavenuesinthestruggleagainsttheregimeandreorganisingtheParty[...]Here,Iwouldliketoemphasisethatthispolicymeansthatourhomagetocomradesfalleninthe
■ 1Translator’snote:11thSeptembercommemoratesthefallofBarcelonain1714duringtheWarofSpanishSuccession.TheeventmarkedtheendofCatalonia’sindependence.
2Translator’snote:SaintGeorgeisthePatronSaint
ofCatalonia.Thedayiscelebratedbythegivingofbooksandroses.
3Translator’snote:ThetitlederivesfromthelabellingofobjectsinNaziconcentrationcamps.“K.L.”standsforKonzentrationslager.
-
51 II51
fightagainstthedictatorshipshouldinnowaybeconstruedasblood-lustoradesiretowreakvengeance”.
TheAmnestyActpassedbytheSpanishCongresson14thOctober1977wasawatershed.Itgaveimmunitytothosewhohadcommittedhumanrightsviolationsduringalmostfourdecadesofdictatorship.Itwasinterpretedasexplicitconsenttosweepthepastunderthecarpet.However,theamnestywastheproductoftheresultsoftheelectionsof15thJune1977—thefirstfollowingFranco’sdeath—andwasproposedbydemocratsandtheleft.The1939AmnestyDecreesolelybenefitedtheregime’ssupportersandcoveredpardons,rehabilitation,andothermeasures.Fromthelegalpointofview,the1977AmnestyActcoverspeoplewhetherornottheyhadbeenaccused,convicted,orpunished.Moreover—andthisisimportant—itconsideredthatthedeedscommittedwerenotpunishable.Putanotherway,therewasnopardonbecausenocrimehadbeencommitted.Thus,beneficiariesoftheamnestycoulddemandrehabilitationandevendamages.Thisallowedmanyteacherstoberehabilitatedand,insomecases,readmittedtotheprofession.
However,theAmnestyActhadtwoglaringexceptions:militarypersonnelwhoweremembersoftheDemocraticMilitaryUnionandthoseaccusedofassistinginanabortion.In1977,boththeArmyandtheChurchwerepowerstobereckonedwithandwereabletoimposetheirownviewsontherestofsociety.
Theamnestyendedthe40-yeardivisionbetweenvictorsandvanquished.Unlikeothercountriesthatwageddirtywarsondissenters,inSpaintherepressionwascarriedoutinaccordancewiththeLaw.WhileinArgentinaitwastheregime’sdeathsquadswhogaveawaythechildrenofthosetheyhadslain,inSpaintheprocessof“adoption”andideologicalindoctrinationofinfantswasregulatedbylegislation.The1977amnestywasfundamentallydemocraticinnature,providingaframeworkforsocialharmony.Bycontrast,the1939legislationbenefitedonesegmentofsociety.
Today,therearethosewhocriticisethe1977AmnestyActandwhoargueSpainneedsakindofNurembergTrialtosetthingstorights.However,itisalltooeasytonoticethetimidityofthede-nazificationprogrammethatfollowedthetrial.Forexample,inItalytheverysamejudgewhoimplementedtheraciallawsin1938hadreachedthesummitoftheItalianjudicatureintheearly1950s.Onecanthereforeaskwhatarealisticalternativetothe1977legislationwouldhavebeen.Inanycase,nopoliticalpartyatthetimeconsidereddrawinguplegislationtobringhumanrightsabuserstojusticeor,forthatmatter,drawingupaGeneralIndictmentwithretroactiveeffectto1936.Indeed,fewpartymanifestosin1977evenmadereferencetotheneedtopurgethepoliceandarmedforcesofFascists.
Anotherinterpretationofthetransitionisthatthepoliticiansatthetimehadnoideaofwhattheywerevotingfororwereunawareoftheconsequencesoflettingtheregime’storturersoffthehook.Putbaldly,thisreadingconsidersthepoliticiansasnotmerelynaivebutasstupidtoboot.TheCommunistCongressman,JosepSoléBarberà,whohaddefendedpeopledetainedundertheregime’sPublicOrderAct,notedthatheoftenhadtomakelawyersandpoliticalprisonersseetheneedforanAmnestyAct(inthesamelineexpressedbyGregorioLópezRaimundo).SenatorJosepBenet,spokesmanforEntesa dels Catalans,defendedtheAmnestyBillbyarguingthatthosewhohadsufferedwould
-
5352/53 II Restoring collective memory Andreu Mayayo
-
53 II53
pardonthosewhohadwrongedthemandwoulddesireanewsocietycapableofembracingeveryone.Thiswasnotamoralissuebutratherabasicpoliticalone.OvercomingthedeepdivideinSpanishsocietywastheonlywayofburyingGeneralFranco’slegacy.
JosepBenet,inaspeechgivenon30thMay1978intheSpanishSenate,arguedtheneedtosetupasingleAssociationfortheWarWounded:“Therewillbenodemocracyinthiscountryuntilthereistruereconciliation,whichmustbebasedonasinceredesiretoliveinpeacewiththoseweoncefought.”Soon,thosewhohadformedpartoftheunder-agelevies4 ontheRepublicansidethrewopentheirassociationtotheiroppositenumberswhohadfoughtfortheFascistcause.
MORAL REPARATIONS TO vICTIMS
TheproblemdoesnotlieintheAmnestyAct,inwhatmightbetermedcollectiveamnesia,butinthefailuretomakemoralreparationstothevictims.Theissuegoesbeyondthejudicialsphereandconcernstheattitudetakenbythepowersthatbe.Neitherthe CIU or PSOE governments(from1980and1982,respectively)didanythingtorecogniseandmakereparationstotheRepublicanvictimsoftheSpanishCivilWarandthesubsequentrepression.Thegeneralattitudetakenbypoliticiansatthetimewasto“letsleepingdogslie”.Politicians’intentionmayhavebeengoodonesbutthefesteringwoundsofthedictatorshiponlykindledresentmentandadesireforrevenge.ThegovernmentsofJordiPujolandFelipeGonzáleztooktheeasyway
Axum (Ethiopia), Toni Catany (2007)
■ 4Translator’snote:Theselevieswerecalledtothecoloursin1938,eventhoughtheywerenotdueforcall-upuntil1940or’41whentherecruitswouldhavebeen21yearsofage.ThemeasurewasadesperateoneandtakentohalttherapiddeteriorationintheRepublic’smilitaryposition.
-
5554/55
out,repeatingthesamediscourseusedbytheFrancoregime,namely,thattheCivilWarhadbeenanationaltragedyinwhicheveryonehadbeenequallytoblame.Hencethestrategyofconsigningthecountry’srecenthistorytooblivionandpositivelyencouragingcollectiveamnesia.ThisiswhatthejournalistGregorioMoráncalledmanyyearsago“thepriceofthetransition”.Ithasprovedahighprice,underminingSpain’sfledglingdemocracy.
Thepresentationofmyfirstbook—thefruitofmycapstoneproject—coincidedwiththe50thanniversaryoftheoutbreakoftheSpanishCivilWar.Itwas1986andthebook
wastitled La Conca de Barberà 1890-1939: de la crisi agrària a la guerra civil [LaConcadeBarberà1890-1939:FromAgriculturalSlumptotheSpanishCivilWar].TheConcadeBarberàInstituteofStudies,whichpublishedthebook,usedthepresentationoftheworktopayhomagetothecounty’sRepublicansoldiers.TheeventincludedtheawardofcertificatestoformersoldiersaccreditingtheirserviceinthePeople’sArmy.
HundredsofpeoplepackedtheMontblanctheatre,whichwasdeckedoutfortheoccasionwithRepublicanflags.Manypeople,withtearsintheireyes,askedforacertificateforamissingfamilymember.Thewholetowntookonafestiveair.TheCIUparty5 governedmostofthecouncilsinthecountyandheldthelargestnumberofseatsbyalongchalk.Evenso,theCIUinitiallyrefusedtotakepartinthehomageonthegroundsthatthewoundsoftheCivilWarwerestilltoofresh(remember,thiswas50yearsaftertheevent!).Inanycase,theceremonydidnotpayhomagetothevictimsorjustifypoliticalviolence:itmerelyprovidedthefirstformalrecognitionofthosewhohadservedintheRepublicanArmy,whetherasvolunteersorasunwillingconscripts.Toputthisinabroadercontext,nooneintheUnitedStatesbridlesatthedisplayofConfederateflagsinshopsorevenonarmybases.The CIU finallydon’ttookpartinaneventthatshowedhowmanypeoplefeltaboutthepast.
AnothervaluablelessoncanbelearntfromSolivella—anothermunicipalityinthesamecounty.SolivellahasthedubiousdistinctionofbeingtheCatalanmunicipalitywiththehighestpercentageofpoliticalkillingsbybothsidesintheCivilWar.Duringthetransition,memoryoftheCivilWarwasarunningsore.Astheyearswentby,theCouncilthoughtitwouldbeagoodideatoreplacethestandardFascistinscriptiononthewarmemorial(“FallenforGodandSpain”)foramoreinclusiveone(“Toallthosewhofellbetween1936and1939”).Itwaswellmeantbutthevanquishedbridledattheinscriptionsincemanyoftheirnumberhadactuallybeenshotaftertheendofhostilities.
Thefirsttaskthatneedstobeperformedisthereforetoidentitythevictims.On17thSeptember2005,theRosesTownCouncilerectedamemorialtothevictimsofFranco’s
II Restoring collective memory Andreu Mayayo
The Truth Commissions established in various countries have helped grapple with the traumatic legacy left by dictatorships and the systematic violation of human rights
-
55 II55
repression.Thesameday,JosepM.Fraderawroteanarticlein El Punt newspaper.Init,hecomplainedthatthosewhowerekilledinthewakeofthefailedcoupd’etathadbeenforgotten.Thirtyyearsafterthedictator’sdeathandalmostseventyyearsafterthebeginningoftheCivilWar,itisnowthe“Franco”side’sturntocomplainaboutbeingleftoffamunicipalmemorial.FraderaarguedthattheRosesCouncilhadmissedtheopportunityofreconcilingthevictimsofbothFascistandRepublicanterror.Personalreasonsaside(themurderofagreatgrandfather,andgrandfatherinthesummerof1936),thehistorian’sproposalsaresimilartothoseputforwardbyPasqualMaragall,PresidentofCatalonia6.MaragallarguedthatthemassgraveintheMontjuïcquarryshouldbemadeintoamemorialtothedeadonbothsides.
WecanagreewithFraderaandMaragallthatthevictimsofpoliticalterrorintheRepublicanzoneshouldnotbeforgotten.Thus,allvictimsoftheviolenceshouldberespectedandsympathyshownfortheirfamiliesandfriends.However,notallvictimsoftheCivilWarhavebeentreatedthesameordiedforthesamecause.Fraderaadmitsthedictatorshipwentoutofitswaytoglorify“itsown”deadandburythestoryofthosewhodiedontheotherside.HethereforenaivelyarguesthatweshouldnotfallintothetrapofmakingthesamemistakefromaRepublicanstandpoint.
Whilemorallyirreproachable,theproposalisunacceptable.Thegriefofallthosebereavedshouldbepubliclyrespected.However,ademocracyrequiresthatthereasonsbehindeachvictim’sdeathorsufferingbeamatterofpublicrecord.Inthisrespect,onecannotaccordthesamestatustokillingscommittedbylawlessbandsandtosystematickillingandrepressionbytheorgansofState.Thegravesofthedeadmaylaysidebysidebutthatisnoreasontoerectacommonmonumenttothevictims.IdonotbelievethatFraderawouldarguethatthe ValledelosCaídos7 shouldbeconvertedintoamemorialtoalltheCivilWardead.Thiskindoftokenismwouldbenothingnew—thelateFrancoregimeitselfpracticeditwhenitopenedacemeteryforthelosingsideatthemonument.ThecorpseshadbeendiscreetlydugupandtransferredfromthemassgravesinwhichtheFascistshadthrowntheirvictimsaftershootingthemoutofhand.WithregardtoValledelosCaídos,therearetwooptions.ThefirstistobulldozethemonumentandthesecondistouseifforeducationalendsinmuchthesamewayasAuschwitzandotherconcentrationcampsareusedtoexplainthehorrorsoftheholocaust.Itisthereforeabadideatomixvictimsatsuchsites,fromwhateverperiodtheycome.Forexample,attheFossardelesMoreres8:notalloftheCatalanswhodiedintheSiegeofBarcelonaareburiedthere.
IfweweretoacceptFradera’sargument,whatshouldwemakeoftheChurch’sbeatificationofpriestsandnunskilledduringtheCivilWar?9 ShouldwetaketheChurch’sobsessionwithmartyrdomasabarriertonationalreconciliation?AsIseeit,theCatholicChurchhasasmuchrightassayBarcelonaFCtocommemorateitsmemberswhodiedintheCivilWaranddiscovertheidentityandthemotivesofthosewhokilledthem.
■ 5Translator’snote:Convergència i Unio [ConvergenceandUnion,thepartypresidedbyJordiPujol].
6Translator’snote:nowformerpresident. 7AnenormousmonumentalcomplexbuiltbytheFascists
totheirwardeadandthesiteofFranco’smausoleum.
8Thesitewheremanyofthosefallenintheheroicdefen-ceofBarcelonawereburiedduringthesiegeof1714.
9Translator’snote:TheCatholicChurcheagerlyembracedFranco’s“crusade”andwasthusatargetofRepublicanire.
-
5756/57 II Restoring collective memory Andreu Mayayo
Theimpunityenjoyedbythekillersisanaffronttothevictimsandtotheprinciplesthatshouldgovernsociety.TheTruthCommissionsestablishedinvariouscountrieshavehelpedgrapplewiththetraumaticlegacyleftbydictatorshipsandthesystematicviolationofhumanrights.Theaimofthesecommissionsistohelppeoplepardonthekillers,notbysweepingthecrimesunderthecarpetbutbygettingthoseresponsibletorecogniseandrepentfortheirsins.Manykillersandthosewhoactivelycollaboratedwiththedictatorshipstillliveamongusandhavenothadthedecencytoasktheirvictimstopardonthem.
THE vICTORS’ IMPIETY
IshareLluísQuintana’sviewthatforgettingthevictimsofhumanrightsabusesisabiggerproblemthantheimpunityofthosewhocommittedthem.QuintanausesHomer’sIlliad todemandcompassionforthevanquished.Inthiscontext,oneofthethingsthathasspurreddemandsforsettingthehistoricalrecordstraighthasbeentheopeningofmassgraves.Anykindofreconciliationmustbebasedonallowingthevanquishedtoburytheirdead.InthelastbookoftheThe Illiad, theTrojansdespairnotbecauseofHector’sdeathbutbecausehiscorpsecannotberecoveredandgiventheproperfuneralrites.ZeustakespityonPriam,KingofTroyandHector’sfather.ThroughIris,amessengeroftheGods,ZeussuggeststhatPriamgoalonetoAchilles’camptodemandthecorpseofhisson.QuintananotesthatIristellstheTrojanKingthatAchilleswillshowcompassion10andallowPriamtotakeHector’scorpse.
ReturningtoThe Illiad, QuintananotesthedilemmafacingAchillesandhowheshouldtreatPriam’sentreaty.TheKingoftheArcheansisfuriousatthedeathofhisfriend,Patroclus,atHector’shands.AchillessworetokillHector,desecratehisbody,anddenyhimadecentfuneral.PriamabaseshimselfbeforeAchilles,kissingtheArcheansovereign’shands.Achilles,seeingthatPriam’sgriefisasgreatashisown,agreestotheTrojanking’srequest.Quintanaseesthisepisodenotasdecryingwarandviolencebutratherasacriticismofthevictors’harshnesstowardsthevanquished:“compassionandhumilityshouldalwaysguidethedealingsofmen”.
OnecannotsaywhetherManuelAzañamadethesamereadingofthisbookinThe Illiad buthecertainlytookasimilarlineinhisfamousspeechatBarcelonaCouncil.HisaddressmarkedthesecondyearoftheCivilWarandwastitled:“Peace,CompassionandPardon”.ThePresidentoftheSpanishRepublicabasedhimselfbutFrancodidnotrespondinkind.Foralltheiroutwardshowofreligiousfervour,Franco’sarmy,therebelauthoritiesandtheChurchallshowedachillinglackofcompassionfortheirvictims.
AftertheimpactoftheNazideathcampsandArgentineatrocitiesoninternationalpublicopinion,whatpossibleexcuseisthereforthehurdlestoexhumingCivilWarvictimsfromSpain’smassgraves?Surely,identifyingthecorpsesandlettingtheirfamiliesgivethemadecentburialistheveryleastonecanexpect.Whilemanyofthesurvivorshavelong
■ 10Translator’snote:theauthornotesQuintana’suseofpietós (originally“pious”,andinitsmoremodernsense,“compassionate”)andgoesontocontrastthemoralofHomer’sepicwiththeregime’sunholylackofcompassiontowardsthevanquished.
-
57 II57
Aguilar, Paloma,Memoria y olvido de la Guerra Civil [MemoryandOblivionoftheCivilWar],Madrid:Alianza,1996
Barahona de Brito,AlexandraandAguilar,Paloma(eds.),Las politicas hacia el pasado: juicios, depuraciones, perdón y olvido en las nuevas democracias[PoliciesTowardsThePast:Trials,Pardon
andOblivionintheNewDemocracies], Madrid:Istmo,2002.
Morán,Gregorio,El precio de la Transición [ThePriceofSpain’sTransitiontoDemocracy],Barcelona:Planeta,1991.
Mudrovcic,MaríaInés,Historia, narración y memoria. Los debates actuales en
filosofia de la historia [History,NarrationandMemory.CurrentDebatesinthePhilosophyofHistory],Madrid:Akal,2005.
Quintana,Lluis,Més enllà de tot càstig[BeyondPunishment], Barcelona:Icària,2004.
■More reading
sincegivenuptheirlovedonesfordead,doubtsandquestionshavehauntedthemfordecades.Resolvingthismatterisnotonlyanissueofcommondecencyandjustice,itisalsoaMatterofStateifSpainistohealthewoundsoftheCivilWar.
Thatiswhyweshouldhearkentothevictims,helpthemformpartofthecommonweal,andensuretheirgrieffindspublicexpression.OnlythuscantheindividualandcollectivetraumabeovercomeandaboostbegiventoSpain’sfeebledemocracy.Sadly,thetimehaspassedforaTruthCommissiongiventhatmanyofthevictimsofthewaranditsaftermatharenolongerwithusorhavelostfaculties.History,however,candomuchtogivemanyvictimsavoiceagain.Insteadofwastingtimereviewingthesentenceshandeddownbycourtsmartialoropeningupmassgravesalloverthecountry,weneedtodiscovermoreaboutourpastsothattheghostoftheCivilWarcanfinallybeexorcised.Finally,weshouldheedJosepBenet’sproposaltoestablishaninternationaltribunalofhistorianstodocumentthemassmurdercommittedbytheFrancodictatorshipII
Andreu Mayayo is Professor of Contemporary History at the University of Barcelona.