RESETTLEMENT AND ETHNIC MINORITY …documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/789901468139764780/...The DPs...

1

VIETNAM ELECTRICITY

TRUNGSON HYDROPOWER COMPANY LIMITED

RESETTLEMENT AND ETHNIC MINORITY

DEVELOPMENT PLAN

TRANSMISSION LINE COMPONENT –

TRUNG SON HYDROPOWER PROJECT

Ha Noi, January 2013

RP857 v7 P

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

ed

1

ABBREVIATIONS

AH Affected Household

CLDF Center for Land Development Fund

CPC Commune People’s Committee

DARD Department of Agriculture and Rural Development

DCRB District Compensation and Resettlement Board

DMS Detailed Measurement Survey

DOC Department of Construction

DOF Department of Finance

DONRE Department of Natural Resources and Environment

DP/AP Displaced Persons/Affected People

DPC District People’s Committee

EMA External Monitoring Agency

GOV Government of Viet Nam

IOL Inventory of Losses

LURC Land Use Right Certificate

MOLISA Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs

MONRE Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment

MOF Ministry of Finance

PIB Public Information Brochure

PMU/ PMB Project Management Unit/ Board

RAP Resettlement Action Plan

SES Socioeconomic Survey

TA Technical Assistance

TOR Terms of Reference

TSHPP Trung Son Hydropower Project

US$ US Dollar

VND Viet Nam Dong

2

DEFINITION OF TERMS

i) Displaced Persons (DPs)

Displaced Persons (DPs) include a person or many people, households, agents or organizations,

individuals who are verified by their collected primary information during each inventory and

resettlement plans (RPs), based on surveys and documents and impacted or potentially impacted

directly on their socio-economy condition by the project implementation, due to the followings:

(a) Mandatory land acquisition which leads to:

Relocation or loss of residential place;

Loss of properties or approach ability to properties; or

Loss of income sources or facilities for earn a living, regardless whether DPs have

to be relocated to other residential place; or

(b) Were involuntarily limited to approach to preserving and legally assigning locations, causing

adverse impacts on their livelihodd.

Generally, “DPs” are all of affected people mentioned above.

ii) Compensation

Compensation is the process of payment in cash or in kind to DPs who lose partially or totally their

asset value due to the project. The compensation also includes valuation and return in cash or in kind

for financial and material loss due to the project impacts.

iii) Cut-off date

Cut-off date is the last day of the survey when all of the DPs are inventoried. After the cut-off date, no

more DP will be put into the inventory of DP. The inventory listed all possible DPs, including their

primary information. People who relocated their residential or business locations into the Right of way

after the cut-off date will be not compensated following this policy framework.

iv) Restoration

Restoration is assistance for severely DPs due to loss totally or huge part of their production materials,

income, jobs or other way to earn their livings, in order to supplement the compensation payment for

acquired properties to improve or at least restore their income and living standard as before the project

implementation.

v) Replacement Cost.

A concept is used to calculate the compensation amount for an asset and involves using current

market value plus the transaction costs, which may include taxes, fees, transportation, labor, etc. The

market value is determined by the PMU confirmed by local authorities in consultation with the PAP.

The methods of estimation of prevailing market value should evolve over time to achieve good

practice. (Footnote 11, OP 4.12)

vi) Resettlement

Resettlement mentions all methods done by the project to mitigate any and all of adverse social

impacts of the project on DPs, including the compensation for lost assets and income as well as

provision of other benefits, assistance for restoration of income and resettlement, when necessary.

3

vii) Right of way (ROW)

In this policy framework, the Right of way (ROW) is determined as ROW along the electric line, with its

width, length and height regulated by Decree 106/2005/ND-CP dated on 17 August 2005 on related

voltage. Safeguard for high voltage system is amended by Decree 81/2009/ND-CP on 12 October

2009.

viii) Vulnerable groups

They are those who might suffer disproportionally from adverse project impacts and/or be less able to

access the project benefits and compensation including livelihood restoration and assets

compensations, when compared to the rest of PAP. Vulnerable peoples include people who, by virtue

of gender, ethnicity, age, physical or mental disability, economic disadvantage or social status, may be

more heavily affected by economic or physical displacement than others and who may be more limited

than the population at large in their ability to claim or take advantage of resettlement assistance and

related development benefits. Vulnerable people can be an entire group (like an ethnic minority

community), or individual households (HHs).

ix) The DPs who have no legal status

The DPs who have no legal status are those use land and houses but have no legal use rights; and

individuals or groups who own business stores located in the project areas but have no official

registration and will be affected adversely due to the relocation.

The DPs who have no legal status but have legal rights according to Vietnamese law and verified by

commune People’s Committees (CPCs) will receive the compensation, as long as their properties

which are affected by the project are inventoried in the project population survey which is implemented

prior to the cut-off date published.

The DPs who have no legal status and no legal rights according to Vietnamese law but verified by

CPCs will be assisted instead of compensated in order to achieve the policy objectives, as long as

their properties which are affected by the project are inventoried in the project population survey which

is implemented prior to the cut-off date published.

x) Land use right certificate (LURC)

Land use as well as house and other property attached to land right certificate are issued by the state

authorities to land users so as to protect their legal rights and benefits.

4

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ABBREVIATIONS ......................................................................................................................................... 1

DEFINITION OF TERMS .............................................................................................................................. 2

CHAPTER I. PROJECT BACKGROUND ..................................................................................................... 5

1.1. Introduction to Trung Son Hydropower Project ................................................................................ 5

1.2. Mai Chau 110 kV substation and 35kV power line Subproject ........................................................ 5

1.2.1. Legal rationale for the subproject ............................................................................................. 5

1.2.2. Objectives of the Subproject ..................................................................................................... 6

1.2.3. Components of the Subproject ................................................................................................. 6

CHAPTER III. SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY ............................................................................................. 11

3.1. Socio-economic Survey .................................................................................................................... 11

3.2. Socio-economic status in the project area ....................................................................................... 13

3.3. Socio-economic survey results of the project affected households ................................................. 17

3.3.1. Household size .......................................................................................................................... 18

3.3.2. Population structure by age ....................................................................................................... 18

3.3.3. Household occupational structure ............................................................................................. 19

3.3.4. Educational level ....................................................................................................................... 20

3.3.5. Vulnerable group ....................................................................................................................... 21

3.3.6. Living standards ........................................................................................................................ 22

3.3.7. Income ....................................................................................................................................... 22

3.4. Impacts of the subproject ................................................................................................................ 24

CHAPTER IV. LEGAL FRAMEWORK (FOR LAND AND ETHNIC MINORITY) ......................................... 34

4.1. Policies of the Government of Vietnam ............................................................................................ 34

4.2. World Bank’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement and Indigenous Peoples .................................... 37

4.3. Comparison between Government of Vietnam and World Bank Approaches ................................. 37

CHAPTER V. CONSULTATION AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE ...................................................... 40

5.1. The need and Purposes ................................................................................................................... 40

5.2. Consultation during preparation of Resettlement Action Plan and Ethnic Minority Development

Plan 42

CHAPTER VI. COMPENSATION, SUPPORT AND LIVELIHOOD RESTORATION ................................. 47

6.1. Compensation .................................................................................................................................. 47

6.1.1 Compensation and Resettlement Objectives ............................................................................. 47

6.1.2. The Compensation and Resettlement Principles ...................................................................... 48

6.1.3. Project Displaced Person(s) DPs .............................................................................................. 49

6.1.4. Eligibility ..................................................................................................................................... 49

6.1.5. Cut-off date ................................................................................................................................ 49

6.1.6. Project entitlement matrix .......................................................................................................... 50

6.2. Support and income restoration ....................................................................................................... 61

CHAPTER VII. ETHNIC MINORITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND GENDER STRATEGY ....................... 67

CHAPTER VIII. IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS ........................................................................... 69

CHAPTER IX. BUDGET ESTIMATE ........................................................................................................... 75

APPENDIX .................................................................................................................................................. 76

5

CHAPTER I.

PROJECT BACKGROUND

1.1. Introduction to Trung Son Hydropower Project

Trung Son hydropower project will be constructed on the Ma River, in the territory of Trung Son

commune, Quan Hoa district, Thanh Hoa province. The proposed project aims to provide least-cost

electric power to support Vietnam’s further economic development and improvement of living

standards through the development of hydropower resources in an environmentally sustainable and

socially responsible manner. The proposed project will provide support for EVN’s development of one

of the country’s medium-sized hydropower development projects. The goal is to provide a “good

practice” case of sustainable hydropower development in this core part of Vietnam’s power sector.

Trung Son Hydropower project with its installed capacity of 260 MW and mean annual energy of 1018

GWh is a multipurpose project, providing both power generation and flood control benefits. The

proposed dam is about 40km downstream from Lao PDR, with the reservoir tail about 10km from the

border. The roller compacted concrete dam will be 84,5 m high and have a crest length of 513 meters.

Full supply level is 160 meters. The total reservoir volume will be about 348.50 million m3 including a

flood control volume of about 112 million m3. It will cover an area of about 13.13 km2, inundating

mixed forest and agricultural land.

The project will consist of the following four components:

Dam construction. This will include the construction of the main dam, including the spillway,

intake gate, penstock, power house and discharge channel, supply and installation of the

electromechanical and hydro-mechanical equipment. Auxiliary investments including the

access road and bridges, internal roads and construction camp will be included in this

component, as will consulting services for supervision of construction.

Construction of power lines, one from the switchyard to the connection point into the existing

Hoa Binh – Nho Quan 220kV system and a 110/35kV line from the area of Mai Chau to the

construction site.

Impact mitigation and compensation, which will include the implementation of resettlement,

livelihoods restoration, ethnic minorities, environment management and public health

management plans.

Technical assistance to support preparation of further hydropower projects and improvement

of capacity to meet best international practice for hydropower development.

Total costs are estimated at $412million, of which about $2.9 million is for environmental management

(in addition to remediation requirements placed on construction contractors) and $35.1 million for

resettlement and restoration of peoples’ livelihoods. Vietnam Electricity officially received a loan of

$330 million from International Bank of Reconstruction and Development (IBRD).

1.2. Mai Chau 110 kV substation and 35kV power line Subproject

1.2.1. Legal rationale for the subproject

Decision by the Prime Minister approving the National Power Development Planning in the

2006 to 2015 period with prospect to 2025 numbered 110/2007/QD-TTg dated July 18 2007

(TSDVI).

6

Decision No. 5638/QD-BCT dated October 22 2008 by the Ministry of Industry and Trade

approving adjustment of “Power Development Planning of Hoa Binh in the 2006 to 2010 period

with prospect to 2015”.

Document No. 328/DTDL-QHCP dated September 26 2008 by the Power Regulation

Department on “Adjustment of Power Development Planning of Hoa Binh”.

Decision No. 880/QD-EVN dated August 24 2010 by the Electricity of Vietnam on “approving

the adjustment of investment project for Mai Chau 110kV substation and 35kV power line

supplying electricity for construction of Trung Son Hydropower Plant”.

Document No. 552/TDTS-P4 dated November 24 2010 by Trung Son Hydropower Project

Management Board on “technical design dossier, construction draw of power supply for

construction of Trung Son hydropower plant component”.

Document No. 1538/EVN-DT dated May 9 2011 by the Electricity of Vietnam on “adjusting

information solution for Mai Chau 110kV substation”.

Document No. 180/TDTS-P4 dated May 18 2011 by Trung Son Hydropower Project

Management Board on “technical design dossier of Mai Chau 110kV substation and power line

supplying electricity for the construction of Trung Son Hydropower Plant”.

Document No. 1733/EVN NPC-KT dated May 27 2011 by the Northern Power Company on

“supplying construction power for Trung Son Hydropower Project in Hoa Binh Province”.

Document No. 392/TDTS-P4 dated September 26 2011 by Trung Son HPPCo on “adjusted

design dossier of Mai Chau 110kV substation and power line”.

Decision No. 93/QD-TDTS dated November 8 2011 by Trung Son HPPCo on “approving

technical design and cost estimates of the component Mai Chau 110kV substation and 35kV

power line supplying construction electricity for Trung Son Hydropower Plant”.

Survey documents by PECC4.

Current standards and regulations.

1.2.2. Objectives of the Subproject

The investment in construction of "Mai Chau 110kV Substation and 35 kV power line supplying

construction power for Trung Son Hydropower Plant" aims to meet the additional load demands in the

area, supply power for the construction loads at the construction site of Trung Son Hydropower Plant

during the construction period and resettlement sites.

1.2.3. Components of the Subproject

Mai Chau 110kV substation and 35kV power line subproject consists of the following 02 components:

Component 1: Mai Chau 110kV substation and branch

Component 2: 35kV power line supplying construction electricity for Trung Son Hydropower

Plant.

7

CHAPTER II

THE PROJECT’S IMPACTS

Anticipated impacts of the subproject and scope of investigation

The subproject’s affected area

Mai Chau 110kV Substation

Mai Chau 110kV substation is expected to build on one-crop rice-growing field and rain fed crop

growing land of Tong Dau Commune, Mai Chau District, Hoa Binh Province.

The North: bounded by one-crop rice field.

The South: bounded by rice field and 100m from Tong Dau Primary School

The East : bounded by National Highway No. 15.

The West: bounded by rice field and approximately 100m from Hoa Binh-Moc Chau 110kV TL

and Mai Chau- Hoa Binh 35kV power line.

Area to be acquired for the works on the total site of the substation as follows:

Table 1. Land area required for the substation

Total land area for the substation (including talus). In which: 8.336,0m2

- Land area required for operation house and access road to the

house (including talus)

1.000,0 m2

- Land area required for the substation and access road to the

substation (including talus)

7.336,0m2

35kV Power Line

The 35kV power line traverses Tong Dau Commune, Mai Chau Town, Chieng Chau, Mai Ha, Van Mai

and Mai Hich communes in Mai Chau District (Hoa Binh Province) and Phu Thanh Commune in Quan

Hoa District (Thanh Hoa Province).

Mai Chau- Trung Son HPP 35kV power line under the component “Supplying power for

construction of Trung Son HPP” is studied with one alignment option 1 and is agreed by Mai Chau

DPC of Hoa Binh Province and Quan Hoa DPC of Thanh Hoa Province. The alignment is mainly along

with the National Highway 15 and construction road of the hydropower plant with the main features as

shown in the table below:

Table 2. Main features

No. Basic parameters Main alignment Remarks

1 Starting point

35kV control cabinet at

110/35/22kV Mai Chau

substation

2 Ending point Tower numbered 141 DZ 35kV (REII) supplying

power for Ban Uon

1The alignment of the 35kV power line is agreed by Hoa Binh Provincial People’s Committee in the Official Letter

No. 285/UBND-CN dated March 9 2009 and Quan Hoa District People’s Committee.

8

substation, Phu Thanh,

Quan Hoa

3 Voltage level 35kV

4 Number of circuit 01

5 Length 19.427m 20m of connecting

underground cable

6 Lock angles 38

7 Houses in ROW 02

8 Intersections with 220kV TL 03 Being designed

9 Intersections with 110kV TL 01

10 Intersections with 35kV and 10kV TL 08

11 Length of the line going through rice area 11.461m

12 Length of the line going through fruit-tree

area 145m

13 Length of the line going through

eucalyptus 210m

14 Length of the line going through planted

forest (“luong” bamboo) 3.759m

15 Length of the line going through crops 2.403m

16 Length of the line going through bared

land, river and lake 1.429m

The alignment is divided into 2 sections which can be described in details as follows:

- Section 1: From starting point – G26 15.396m long

Starting from 110/30kV Mai Chau substation expected to build in Tong Dau Commune, Mai Chau

District, Hoa Binh Province. The alignment intersects Mai Chau-Hoa Binh 35kV TL and Hoa Binh- Moc

Chau 110kV TL. The line goes along with the National Highway 15 on its right side with the average

distance from 250 to 500m and many lock angles to avoid the residential areas to G16. The line

passes through the terrain which is relatively flat with productive land for growing rice, mixed with fruit-

trees and hills growing “luong” bamboo. The line traverses Tong Dau Commune, Mai Chau Town,

Chieng Chau Commune, Mai Ha and Van Mai and Mai Hich communes in Mai Chau District, Hoa Binh

Province.

- Section 2: From G26 – tower No. 59 DZ 35kV (REII) supplying power for Ban Uon substation, Phu

Thanh Commune, Quan Hoa District: 4.031m long

From G26, the line turns left and goes along with the inter-commune road on its right side to Trung

Son hydropower plant with the average distance from 100 to 300m. The line passes through the terrain

which is quite complex with many high mountains and hills, canyons and land for growing “luong”

bamboo mixed with thickets. From G37, the line turns lock angle and links to 35kV line of REII Project

in Quan Hoa District, Thanh Hoa Province. The line goes through Van Mai and Mai Hich communes

(Mai Chau District, Hoa Binh Province) and Phu Thanh Commune (Quan Hoa District, Thanh Hoa

Province).

10

Anticipated impacts of the subproject

Impacts on land acquisition:

Permanent land acquisition relates to land area of electric poles of line 35kV and site of Mai

Chau 110kV substation.

o Total permanent land area of line 35kV: 3,513.41 m2

o Total permanent land area of Mai Chau 110kV substation: 8,336.0m2

Temporary land acquisition will be required for erection of towers and stringing of conductors.

Temporary affected land area most likely depends on implementation plan and camping

arrangement of the implementation unit. ROW of the line is 3m; temporary occupied land area

is estimated to be approximately 58 ha during 1-2 weeks.

These generally will be relatively minor in terms of impacts on household land areas and livelihoods.

Impacts on ethnic minority communities (Ems): Except for the impacts identified, the power line will

pass through the region where (EMs) live, with the majority of the Thai people and a small part of

Muong, Hmong, Dao and Kinh groups. The impacts of the power line on the minority community are

temporary, because it only causes a small impact on some of the households, which is not adverse to

the entire community, as well as their culture. On the other hand, the 35 kV line will deliver power to

the households along the route, including the ethnic minority households in the area so there is a

positive impact in the socio-economic development of these ethnic minority communities.

Impacts on other structures: the subproject does not cause impacts on structures for the national

defense and economic purposes, historical monuments, cultural, dykes, etc.

Impacts on the environment: the line is designed in the scope to minimize the permanently acquired

land area. Some parts pass through the planted forest area; therefore, during construction period,

there will be certain impacts on the environment and socio-economic activities.

Scope of survey

Socio-economic survey, IOL and consultations were conducted with community affected by the

construction of 110kV Mai Chau Substation and the 35 kV power line. Specifically:

Survey, IOL and consultations were carried out with households whose land in the scope of

construction of 110kV substation and towers of the 35kV power line was acquired

permanently;

Survey, IOL and consultations were carried out for households temporarily affected on land in

the Right Of Way of the 35kV line, with the width of the ROW of 3m, measured from the center

to the two sides of the line.

11

CHAPTER III

SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY

3.1. Socio-economic Survey

A socioeconomic survey in order to collect socioeconomic information related to the project affected

people. The socioeconomic survey was conducted by the Development Research and Consultancy

Centre (DRCC) and the data collected through the survey will serve:

To design income restoration and livelihoods improvement program;

As the database to compare the living standards of the households losing land before and

after compensation delivery and resettlement (to be used for the monitoring and evaluation

later in the RP implementation phase).

Survey method

Use of terrain map, actual land use map of the affected communes (scale: 1/50.000) and

planimetric map of 110kV substation, 35kV power line coupled with field surveys to identify

magnitude of losses on land, crops and affected households;

Use of questionnaire to collect statistical information on socio-economic conditions of the

commune for accurate assessment of the actual socio-economic status of the communes in

terms of population and ethnics;

Use of socio-economic survey questionnaire at households level; carry out survey on 30% of

the affected households to grasp the actual socio-economic status of the PAPs;

Use of detailed questionnaire at household level; questionnaire is carried out in 100% of the

households affected by construction of the project to assess the magnitude of impacts on the

households;

Carry out consultation, combined with field works with staffs of the communes, towns and

villages to inspect the field to identify the level of impacts on infrastructures and public

structures;

Conduct in-depth interviews with village elders and leaders, and people who are main source

of information to understand the customs, traditions and spiritual sites and sources of

livelihoods for ethnic minority communities;

Conduct group discussion with EM households to understand opinions of EM communities

with regard to the subprojects;

Conduct community meetings with affected and non-affected households to disclose

information on the subproject and to find out opinions of the community with regard to the

construction of subprojects;

Carry out consultations with staffs of the commune and district-level authority to assess

livelihood restoration potential for affected households in case there is potential impacts on

severely affected households;

Processing of data: IOL data is handled using Excel; SPSS is used to analyze socio-economic

data and quanlitative data is summarized using methods of Nvivo programs;

Survey content

Socio-economic survey

Consultants collected the following information:

Socio-economic information in the locality;

12

The demographic information on the population, especially of the affected households;

Brief description of Ems: Population and information on the culture, society, economic and

relevant institutions; identification of the affected EM groups classified or not as category IP by

World Bank and whether or not it is necessary to apply IP policies of WB;

Land system and legal status;

Social development trend and matters of concern within affected households;

Identification of affected households that need special attention and support.

Survey, IOL conducted along the power line

(i) Survey of losses on residential land and assets on residential land and land of other types on

the same plot as residential land, which belong to the same owner

Based on survey for construction of the line, identification of affected households, survey conducted for

each household includes the following information:

Number of households whose residential and garden land is affected by construction of the

power line;

Area of affected land;

Type and area of affected house;

Structures on land (kitchen, storage and auxiliary works etc.);

Types and quantities of trees in the area of residential and garden land;

Types of assets on land;

Results of survey are indicated in the questionnaire for each household. For affected households that

have to relocate, pictures of household heads and their houses should be included.

(ii) Survey on losses of assets on land along the power line.

Survey is conducted along the power line with borders identified as 3 m from the center on each side

of the line.

Area around the towers will be acquired permanently; the required safety height for trees

planted along the ROW is measured as follows: the distance from the highest point of the tree

to the height of the lowest point of the lowest conductor (when it is sagged to the greatest

extent) can not be lower than 2.0 m.

Under the circumstances that trees outside the ROW of the transmision line, the distance from any

part of the tree if the tree falls down to any part of the transmission line can not be lower than 0.7 m.

Trees that can potentially grow quickly in a short time, which can risk the safety and trees that, after

being trimmed will no longer generate economic value, have to be cut down and it is strictly prohibited

to be replanted. Rice and crops can only be planted 0.5 m away from the tower foundation.

Inventory of losses for trees on acquired land: survey is carried out for the type, quantity and

age of each tree for perennial trees and type and area of each tree for annual trees.

Inventory of losses for assets on land: survey is carried out for different types of camps, other

auxiliary works serving for domestic activities and production activities of the people etc.

Inventory is conducted for other losses as well.

Consultation with relevant parties and in-depth interview

Consultations with local district authority’s offices:

o Office of Ethnicities;

13

o Office of Agriculture;

o Office of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs;

o Women’s Union, Fatherland Front;

o Compensation Board;

Consultation and in-depth interview carried out with representatives of Ems:

o Village elderly;

o Village leaders;

o Women;

o Men;

Consultation and community meeting:

o Consultation is carried out with affected households including EM people (since the

majority of PAPs are of ethnic minority);

o Consultation/community meeting is carried out with affected and non-affected

households;

3.2. Socio-economic status in the project area

3.2.1. Project area

The 110kV substation and 35kV TL are built in the area of Mai Chau District, Hoa Binh Province and a

commune of Quan Hoa District, Thanh Hoa Province. The project area includes the following:

Table 3. List of communes in the project area

No. Province District Commune Component

Temporary

land

acquisition

area

I Hoa Binh Mai Chau

1 Mai Chau Town TL 8.336,0m2

2 Tong Dau 110kV substation

3.513,41m2

3 Van Mai TL

4 Mai Hich TL

5 Mai Ha TL

6 Chieng Chau TL

II Thanh Hoa Quan Hoa

7 Phu Thanh TL

Source: Detailed design of 35kV transmission line and Mai Chau 110kV substation- PECC4

The subproject construction will affect permanent and temporary land acquisition. With the total

permanent land acquisition area is 11,849.41 m2 for both 110kV station and line 35 kV, the impacts on

land is generally considered as minor.

Temporary affected land area with ROW is 3 m wide will impact on about over 58 ha of land during

stringing of conductor. However, the affected period is short, so these impacts on livelihood are not

significant.

14

Route of the line and substation will be constructed on site of 7 communes in 2 districts of 2 provinces,

which are Thanh Hoa and Hoa Binh. This area is living place of Ems with the main affected people

group is Thai. There are 249 affected EM households. This number divides into communes and

ethnics as follows:

Table 4. Population and Ethnicity in the project area

Commune Population Including Ethnicity

Males Females Thai Muong Kinh Others

Mai Chau Town 5129 2499 2630 3077 116 1881 55

Tong Dau 2789 1355 1434 2450 49 297 5

Van Mai 3020 1529 1491 2050 124 846 -

Mai Hich 3818 1909 1909 3282 536 - -

Mai Ha 2764 1400 1364 2120 231 394 2

Chieng Chau 3455 1700 1755 3097 - 358 -

Total 20975 10392 10583 16076 1056 3776 62

Source: Statistical data provided by CPCs.

Among 7 affected communes, in 5 of them, 100% of affected households are EMs. Socio-economic

background of the affected communes and EM group will be shown in details as follows.

3.2.2. Population- Ethnic Composition

The population in 6 communes of Mai Chau District is 20,975 persons of 5,210 households. The ratio

of males to females is relatively equal. The majority in 6 communes in the project area belongs to Thai

ethnic group with the population of 16,076 persons, accounting for 76.64% of the total population of 6

communes. Kinh ethnic group is the second highest in the area with 3,776 persons, making up 18% of

the total population, followed by Muong ethnic group with 1,056 persons. The rest is 62 persons

belonging to other groups including Tay, Chinese, Dao and Mong.

Table 5. Population and ethnicity in the project area

Commune Total

people

Total household Ethnic

Men Women Thai Muong Kinh Others

Mai Chau town 5129 2499 2630 3077 116 1881 55

Tong Dau 2789 1355 1434 2450 49 297 5

Van Mai 3020 1529 1491 2050 124 846 -

Mai Hich 3818 1909 1909 3282 536 - -

Mai Ha 2764 1400 1364 2120 231 394 2

Chieng Chau 3455 1700 1755 3097 - 358 -

Total 20975 10392 10583 16076 1056 3776 62


15

3.2.3. Living standards

The communes in the project area have per capita income levels lower than the national poverty line

(VND 400,000/person/month) in the 2011-2015 period. According to the data provided by the CPCs,

the living standards of the communes are shown in the table 6 below.

Table 6. Living standards in the project communes

Commune Monthly per

capita income Rich HH (%)

Above-

average HH

(%)

Average HH

(%) Poor HH (%)

Mai Chau Town 318,000 14.9 35.1 46.0 3.7

Tong Dau 253,846 15.4 29.8 45.9 8.7

Van Mai 229,167 6.8 68.0 24.6

Mai Hich 330,000 2.9 55.3 23.5 18.0

Mai Ha 300,000 0 20.8 47.6 31.4

Chieng Chau 325,000 73.8 13.9 12.1


Apart from Mai Chau Town with the smallest poverty incidence of 3.7%, the other communes in the

project area have relatively high poor household rates, from 8.7% (Tong Dau) to 12.1% (Chieng Chau)

to the highest of 31.4% in Mai Ha Commune.

It is notable that the percentages of households with the average standard of living in the communes

are quite high, approximately 50% of total households in these communes. As the national poverty line

is built upon the principle of ensuring minimum energy, the households with average living standard,

which is approximately around the poverty line, are also those who are at high risk of falling back into

poverty if they have to suffer any adverse effects in life.

3.2.4. Production activities

The economic structures of the project communes show that they mainly depend on agriculture

(except for Mai Chau Town with the service proportion of 60%).

Table 7. Economic structure

Commune

Agro-forestry-fishery Industry Services

Percent

Number of

HHs Percent

Number of

HHs Percent

Number of

HHs

Mai Chau Town 21 276 19 252 60 791

Tong Dau 52.5 604 31.9 14 7.4 81

Van Mai 62.5 585 50 37.5 95

Mai Hich 85 831 36 15 40

Mai Ha 80 683 10 10 11

Chieng Chau 48 837 27 4 25 30


16

The table above shows that the number of households engaged in agricultural and forestry production

in the communes account for a large proportion, which does not commensurate with the economic

values in these communes. That is agricultural products do not have high value.

Main crops in agriculture are wet rice and maize and in forestry are “luong” bamboo and bead-trees.

Small and individual industry activities are mainly to serve daily life and partly due to contributions of

the handicraft products including brocade and bamboo and rattan weaving products to serve tourism.

Services activities do not develop strongly and mainly occur in Mai Chau Town where have tourism

development and a number of small businesses and services to serve people living in the mountainous

villages.

3.2.5. Healthcare services, education and energy

All communes have solid or semi-solid clinics with sufficient staff. 4 communes, namely Tong Dau,

Mai Hich, Mai Ha and Chieng Chau, have doctors at the commune clinics. Primary and secondary

schools are available in all communes and town; however, no commune has high school.

All communes are able to access to the national grid. However, clean water is still a difficulty to people

in the area.

Table 8. Status of health, education infrastructure and clean water of people in the project area

Commune Clinic

School

Electricity Clean water Primary &

Secondary High school

Mai Chau Town Solid Yes No 100%

Dug well, drilled

well, river,

spring, lake

Tong Dau Solid Yes No 100%

Van Mai Semi-solid Yes No 100%

Mai Hich Solid Yes No 100%

Mai Ha Solid Yes No 100%

Chieng Chau Solid Yes No 100% Tap water


Except for Chieng Chau Commune with 672 out of 861 households have access to tap water; people

in other communes still have to use water from drilled and dug wells or surface water including river,

spring, lake, pond and rain water for their domestic and production activities.

3.2.6. Thai community in Mai Chau

Thai people in Mai Chau in general as well as Thai community living in 5 communes and one town

mentioned above belong to White Thai (Thai Trang- Tay Khao) group who migrated from Muong Huoc

Puoc Kha (Bac Ha- Lao Cai) since the XIVth century. Due to the proximity to Muong people, Thai

people are affected in some cultural elements of Muong people, which are shown in their houses,

costume and funeral ceremony. Regarding spiritual culture, some ceremonies still keep Thai traditional

elements.

(i) Livelihoods

Most of Thai people grow wet-rice (Nà) as the main crop. The Thai people in the project area, apart

from wet-rice growing, also cultivate on mountainous fields (háy). Before, Thai people cultivated 2

17

crops (fall crop and winter crop), mainly glutinous rice. Nowadays, they have grown new varieties of

non-glutinous rice producing higher yield. Besides, they also grow rain crops such as maize, sweet

potato and cassava. Hunting barely exists anymore. Most of Thai households are engaged in livestock

husbandry such as cattle, pigs and chickens to serve their daily needs and as sacrifices for the

ceremonies like funerals or weddings, etc. Some households also keep fishes.

Handicraft is developing, particularly brocade weaving. Some products are quite sophisticated such as

blankets and headgears which are preferred by the domestic as well as foreign tourists. Since 1992,

the villages such as Lac Village, Pom Coong Village (and Van Village later) began to establish Tourism

Villages in form of community-based management, which operate quite effectively.

Currently, a number of families in the above-mentioned Thai villages also open small grocery stores at

home. Some people are engaged in brocade business (for example Ms. Mai in Van Village) quite

successfully.

Some jobs newly appear such as employees (porters, bricklayer), motorbike taxi drivers.

(ii) Physical culture

Thai people live in stilt houses (with 5 compartments, 2 lean-tos and 2 stairs with many windows).

Their stilt houses are affected and learn from the stilt house structure of Muong people. Thai women in

Mai Chau also wear costumes with many elements from Muong group.

Before, Thai people only ate sticky rice; today, in many areas, Thai people have changed to eat non-

glutinous rice. Some delicious dishes can be mentioned are grilled fish, sour fish, sour pork, boiled

pork on banana leaf. In the cuisine of Thai people in Mai Chau, there are elements from Muong

cuisine, including the type of square and wooden tray.

(iii) Social culture

Thai people in Mai Chau often gather and live in villages. Leaders of the village are head (tạo bản) and

deputy-head of the village and a person responsible for ceremonies called Chắm bản. Each village has

many families; in some villages, Ha family is the majority. The Thai families in Mai Chau include

Ha/KHa, Vi, Luong, Ngan and Quang. Aristocratic family name is Ha Cong.

(iv) Spiritual culture

Before, Thai people in Mai Chau worshiped village ghosts and district ghosts. Each village and district

had its own temple which was worshipped in August annually according to the Lunar Calendar. The

worship ceremony of district ghost was then followed by the worship of village ghost. After 1954,

village and district ghost worships are no longer maintained. Nowadays, they only worship house

ghosts (phi hườn) and the father; that means after their father died, the sons have to set up altar in

their house.

Thai people in Mai Chau have their own writing in Pili-Sanskrit system. Contents of the ancient books

are often related to migration history, family annals or customs and traditions. However, nowadays, the

number of people able to read and write Thai is very small. 3.3. Socio-economic survey results of

the project affected households Socio-economic survey results show that 288 households are

directly affected by land acquisition and construction of 35kV TL and Mai Chai 110kV substation

subproject. These impacts include impacts caused by permanent land acquisition for the construction

of tower foundations of the 35kV TL and Mai Chau 110kV substation.

18

Apart from the impacts caused by permanent land acquisition, there are impacts related to

construction activities and temporary impacts on land and crops during the construction period. These

impacts are evaluated as insignificant and short-term on the income and livelihoods of the DPs.

As the number of affected households who are ethnic minority people account for the majority (249

households out of 288 households), this section also describes the socio-economic status of the EM

affected households.

3.3.1. Household size

288 households are affected by the subproject implementation in which 249 households are ethnic

minority.

Table 9. Number of affected households and affected EM ones

No. Province/ District/

Commune

Number of

HHs

Number of

people

Number of EM

AHs

Number of EM

people

1 Hoa Binh 284 1,633 245 1,410

1.1 Mai Chau District 284 1,633 245 1,410

1.1.1 Tong Dau 59 339 59 339

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 22 127 22 127

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 44 253 44 253

1.1.4 Mai Ha 29 167 29 167

1.1.5 Van Mai 109 626 90 518

1.1.6 Mai Hich 21 121 1 6

2 Thanh Hoa 4 23 4 23

2.1 Quan Hoa 4 23 4 23

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 4 23 4 23

Total 288 1,656 249 1,433

Source: Survey Data.

A total of 1,656 people are affected from 288 affected households, in which the number of ethnic

minority people is 1,433 people from 249 households. In Mai Hich Commune, only one out of 21

households is ethnic minority. According to the survey data, the household sizes of the communes are

not different, about 5 persons/ household.

3.3.2. Population structure by age

Socio-economic survey is carried out with 30% of the PAPs, or equivalent to 108 households

participated in the survey. The total number of PAPs from these households is 621. Most of them are

from 18 to 60, accounting for 75.6% (470 people) of the total PAPs. In this age group, the number of

EM people is 419, occupying 77% of the total EM PAPs.

19

Table10. Population structure by age group


Commune 0 - 5 6 - 10 11 - 14 15-17 18-30 31-60

Above

60 Total

1 Hoa Binh 24 30 16 13 118 341 66 608

1.1 Mai Chau District 24 30 16 13 118 341 66 608

1.1.1 Tong Dau 4 9 4 3 22 80 7 129

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 1 3 1 2 11 27 6 51

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 6 2 - 1 23 50 8 90

1.1.4 Mai Ha 1 3 - 1 8 31 11 55

1.1.5 Van Mai 5 10 6 3 46 127 32 229

1.1.6 Mai Hich 7 3 5 3 8 26 2 54

2 Thanh Hoa 1 - - - 6 5 1 13

2.1 Quan Hoa 1 - - - 6 5 1 13

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 1 - - - 6 5 1 13

Total 25 30 16 13 124 346 67 621


The number of children who are in kindergarten age is 25, accounting for 4%. Particularly, regarding

EM groups, the number of EM children in kindergarten age only makes up 3.3% of the total EM

population. The number of children in school-age is 59 (making up 9.5%) while the corresponding

figure of the EM group is 8.8%. The similar percentages are shown in the number of people out of

working age, 67 people (more than 60), which are 10.7% and 10.8% for the EM group.

3.3.3. Household occupational structure

Most of the PAPs are engaged in agriculture, accounting for 74.5%. Out of the total people in the

working age, approximately 100% of the PAHs’ members are involved in agricultural production.

Table 11. Occupations of the PAPs by commune

No.

Province/

District/

Commune

Ag

ricu

ltu

re

Sh

op

ow

ner

Resta

ura

nt

Wo

rker

Go

vern

men

t cad

res

Pri

vate

secto

r

Tra

ns

po

rtat

ion

Dri

ver

Ho

us

ew

ife

To

tal

1 Hoa Binh 451 9 1 18 19 2 1 68 2 572

1.1 Mai Chau District 451 9 1 18 19 2 1 68 2 572

1.1.1 Tong Dau 102 - - 4 - 2 - 16 - 125

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 35 1 1 1 2 - - 8 2 50

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 70 1 - 4 5 - - 4 - 84

1.1.4 Mai Ha 44 - - 2 3 - - 4 - 53

1.1.5 Van Mai 170 3 - 7 9 - - 25 - 214

20

1.1.6 Mai Hich 31 4 - - - - 1 11 - 47

2 Thanh Hoa 12 - - - - - - - - 12

2.1 Quan Hoa 12 - - - - - - - - 12

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 12 - - - - - - - - 12

Total 464 9 1 18 19 2 1 68 2 584


The number of people involved in other non-agricultural activities such as running small stores,

workers, motorbike taxi drivers, etc., is small. By age group, people engaged in such activities are

mainly in 18 to 30 group. The majority of people engaged in agriculture sector (75.5%) are above 31.

3.3.4. Educational level

The table below shows the educational level of the PAPs participated in the SES.

Table 12. Educational level of the PAPs

No.

Province/

District/

Commune Illite

rate

Pri

mary

sch

oo

l

Seco

nd

ary

sch

oo

l

No

t yet

gra

du

ate

fro

m h

igh

sch

oo

l

Hig

h

sch

oo

l

Vo

cati

on

al

train

ing

Un

ivers

ity,

po

stg

rad

ua

te

Oth

ers

To

tal

1 Hoa Binh 0.2% 17.0% 41.3% 29.8% 5.9% 3.3% 2.4% 0.2% 100%

1.1

Mai Chau

District 0.2% 17.0% 41.3% 29.8% 5.9% 3.3% 2.4% 0.2% 100%

1.1.1 Tong Dau 0.8% 24.8% 42.4% 23.2% 7.2% 1.6% - - 100%

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town - 10.0% 44.0% 24.0% 6.0% 12.0% 2.0% 2.0% 100%

1.1.3 Chieng Chau - 22.6% 34.5% 33.3% 3.6% 1.2% 4.8% - 100%

1.1.4 Mai Ha - 22.2% 35.2% 33.3% 1.9% 5.6% 1.9% - 100%

1.1.5 Van Mai - 12.2% 42.5% 30.8% 7.7% 3.2% 3.6% - 100%

1.1.6 Mai Hich - 10.6% 48.9% 38.3% 2.1% - - - 100%

2 Thanh Hoa - 16.7% 41.7% 8.3% 33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100%

2.1 Quan Hoa - 16.7% 41.7% 8.3% 33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100%

2.1.1 Phu Thanh - 16.7% 41.7% 8.3% 33.3% - - - 100%

Total 0.2% 17.0% 41.3% 29.3% 6.4% 3.2% 2.4% 0.2% 100%


0.2% of the surveyed PAPs are illiterate, mainly in Tong Dau Commune. 17% of the members of the

PAHs have finished primary school while 41.3% have finished secondary school and are in high

21

school. The number of people who have not graduated from high school (but no longer pursuing

education) is 8.3%. Meanwhile, the percent of people graduated from high school is 33.3%. Only 3.2%

and 2.4% of the surveyed obtained vocational training and university level. The educational level in

these communes is not as high as the average level of the country.

3.3.5. Vulnerable group

There are total 19 vulnerable households, including 5 ones having women as leader, 3 ones having

disabled people and 11 poor ones having below 400,000VND/person/month (according to the poverty

line established by MOLISA). There are no household having only single elderly in the household

group affected by the subproject construction.

Table 13. Vulnerable households


Commune

Woman-

headed The disabled Poor HHs

Ethnic

minority

Single

elderly

1 Hoa Binh 5 3 11 243 -

1.1 Mai Chau District 5 3 11 243 -

1.1.1 Tong Dau 2 0 0 59 -

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 0 0 0 22 -

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 0 0 0 44 -

1.1.4 Mai Ha 1 1 2 29 -

1.1.5 Van Mai 2 2 9 89 -

1.1.6 Mai Hich - - - - -

2 Thanh Hoa - - - 4 -

2.1 Quan Hoa - - - 4 -

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 0 0 0 4 -

Total 5 3 11 247 -


The number of single mothers’ households is 5 including 2 households in Tong Dau commune, 2

households in Van Mai commune and 1 household in Mai Hai commune.

Disabled households: there are 3 disabled households identified in the total of 288 PAHs. In which, 2

households are in Van Mai and 1 household in Mai Ha commune.

11 poor households are in 2 communes, namely Mai Ha (2 households) and Van Mai (9 households).

All of these households are EM in Thai group. Among these households, there is one household which

not only is the poor but also having women as a household leader. Poor households who have income

lower than 2 million VND/month account for 30%; rate of households having low income from 2 to 3

million VND/month is 50% and female leader of a poor households having approximately 2-3 million

VND. They are both famers and causes of poverty is facing difficulties such as lacking labours,

employments’ sickness and other risks.

All of the 11 poor households are affected on under 10% of their agricultural land.

22

3.3.6. Living standards

The table above shows that 11 households among the PAHs are classified as poor. All 11 households

belong to Thai ethnic group in 2 communes, namely Van Mai and Mai Hich.

According to the statistical data provided by the CPCs, the average incomes of the communes

fluctuate from VND 250,000 to 330,000/person/month, which is lower than the poverty line established

by the MOLISA for the 2011 to 2015 period.

Table 14. Changes in living standards of the households (in the last 3 years)


Commune

Same Better Worse Total

% % % %

1 Hoa Binh

1.1 Mai Chau District

1.1.1 Tong Dau 59.10% 40.90% 0.00% 100.00%

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 33.30% 66.70% 0.00% 100.00%

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 40.00% 53.30% 6.70% 100.00%

1.1.4 Mai Ha 44.40% 33.30% 22.20% 100.00%

1.1.5 Van Mai 63.40% 36.60% 0.00% 100.00%

1.1.6 Mai Hich 50.00% 50.00% 0.00% 100.00%

2 Thanh Hoa

2.1 Quan Hoa

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 100.00% 0.00% 0.00% 100.00%


In the last 3 years, the living standards of people in the project communes are being enhanced,

especially most strongly in Mai Chau Town as 66.7% of the surveyed PAPs said that their living

conditions were getting better than before. However, surveyed people in two communes, Chieng Chau

and Mai Ha, believed that their living standards were worse. Nevertheless, the figures in these two

communes show differences; only 6.7% in Chieng Chau commune while up to 22.2% of the people in

Mai Ha commune share the opinion.

3.3.7. Income

Table 15. Per capita income of the PAHs by gender (million VND)

No.

Province/

District/

Commune

< 2 Mil 2 – 3 Mil > 3 – 4 Mil > 4 – 5 Mil > 5-6 Mil > 6 Mil Total

Ma

le

Fe

ma

le

Ma

le

Fe

ma

le

Ma

le

Fe

ma

le

Ma

le

Fe

ma

le

Ma

le

Fe

ma

le

Ma

le

Fe

ma

le

HH

s

%

1 Hoa Binh 13 1 33 3 41 - 8 - 5 - 2 - 106 98.1%

1.1 Mai Chau 13 1 33 3 41 - 8 - 5 - 2 - 106 98.1%

23

1.1.1 Tong Dau 1 - 8 1 9 - 3 - - - - - 22 20.4%

1.1.2

Mai Chau

Town 1 - 3 - 4 - - - 1 - - - 9 8.3%

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 3 - 3 1 5 - 1 - 1 - 1 - 15 13.9%

1.1.4 Mai Ha 1 1 2 - 3 - 1 - 1 - - - 9 8.3%

1.1.5 Van Mai 6 - 16 1 14 - 2 - 1 - 1 - 41 38.0%

1.1.6 Mai Hich 1 - 1 - 6 - 1 - 1 - - - 10 9.3%

2 Thanh Hoa 2 - - - - - - - - - - - 2 1.9%

2.1 Quan Hoa 2 - - - - - - - - - - - 2 1.9%

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 2 - - - - - - - - - - - 2 1.9%

Total 15 1 33 3 41 - 8 - 5 - 2 - 108 100%


Considering the household incomes shows that among 108 PAHs in the survey samples, 16

households have income lower than VND 2 million/household/month, which is considered as the

income of the poor households; therefore, compared to the data of the households who have “poor

cards”, the number of households whose income is below the poverty line is higher. It is remarkable

that among 16 poor households, one household is woman-headed.

With the monthly income level from 2 to 3 million dong of a household, on average, the monthly per

capita income is from VND 500,000 to 750,000. If near-poor households are those who have income

level 125% higher than the poverty line, these 36 households are considered as just above the poverty

line, which means that if such households encounter any adverse impact such as natural disasters,

flood, land loss, crop loss, etc., they will easily fall back into poverty.

The remaining households have income level from 3 to 6 million dong/month. In general, these

households are regarded as middle-income to high-income households in the mountainous

communes. As for these households, their livelihood capacity is more sustainable.

3.3.8. Other services

(i) Energy

100% of the PAHs have access to the national grid. They use electricity for the purposes of lighting,

and audio and visual entertainment activities on the communication channels such as radio, television

or listening to music and working. However, for cooking purpose, they mainly use wood/firewood,

accounting for 90.74% of the total surveyed PAHs. This figure is not different from that of the EM

group, which is 90.72%.

24

(ii) Clean water

Table 16. Water sources of the PAHs


Commune

Dug well Village well,

public well

River, spring

water Total

HH % HH % HH % HH %

1 Hoa Binh 71 66.98% 1 0.9% 34 32.1% 106 100%

1.1 Mai Chau District 71 66.98% 1 2.9% 34 32.1% 106 100%

1.1.1 Tong Dau 16 72.7% - - 6 27.3% 22 100%

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 9 100% - - - - 9 100%

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 12 80% - - 3 20% 15 100%

1.1.4 Mai Ha 8 88.9% 1 11.1% - - 9 100%

1.1.5 Van Mai 23 56.1% - - 18 43.9% 41 100%

1.1.6 Mai Hich 3 30% - - 7 70% 10 100%

2 Thanh Hoa -

-

2 100% 2 100%

2.1 Quan Hoa -

-

2 100% 2 100%

2.1.1 Phu Thanh - - - - 2 100% 2 100%

Total 71 65.74% 1 0.9% 36 33.3% 108 100%


Although some households in Chieng Chau commune have access to clean water, the remaining

households among the surveyed PAHs do not have clean water to use. Water used for domestic and

production purposes is from dug wells, rivers and lakes.

3.4. Impacts of the subproject

(i) Impacts on land

The implementation of the subproject will affect 69,286.8 m2 of land of 288 households, of which

45,211.2m2 of land belongs to 249 EM households.

25

Table 17. Scope of land acquisition and summary of impacts

No.

Province/

District/

Commune

Total PAHs and affected land area Total EM PAHs and their affected land area

No

. o

f H

Hs

No

. o

f

PA

Ps

To

tal

aff

ecte

d

lan

d a

rea

(m2)

Aff

ecte

d

resid

en

tial

lan

d a

rea

Nu

mb

er

of

EM

PA

Hs

Nu

mb

er

of

EM

PA

Ps

To

tal

aff

ecte

d

lan

d a

rea o

f

EM

s (

m²)

Aff

ecte

d

resid

en

tial

lan

d a

rea

I Hoa Binh 284 1,420 69,244.2 0 245 1,225 45,168.6 0

1 Mai Chau 284 1,420 69,244.2 0 245 1,225 45,168.6 0

1.1 Tong Dau 59 295 9,475.6 0 59 295 9,475.6 0

1.2 Mai Chau Town 22 110 159.2 0 22 110 159.2 0

1.3 Chieng Chau 44 220 271.6 0 44 220 271.6 0

1.4 Mai Ha 29 145 239.3 0 29 145 239.3 0

1.5 Van Mai 109 545 43,850.7 0 90 450 34,529.8 0

1.6 Mai Hich 21 105 15,247.8 0 1 5 493.1 0

II Thanh Hoa 4 20 42.6 0 4 20 42.6 0

2 Quan Hoa 4 20 42.6 0 4 20 42.6 0

2.1 Phu Thanh 4 20 42.6 0 4 20 42.6 0

Total 288 1,440 69,286.8 0 249 1,245 45,211.2 0


Among the impacts on land, it is notable that there is no impact on residential land. Correspondingly,

there are not any impacts regarding material relocation due to the subproject construction. The total

area of rice-growing and rain crop-growing land to be affected is 10,734.2 m2 including 10,691.6 m2 in

6 communes of Mai Chau and 42.6 m2 in Quan Hoa. All of the affected land for growing annual crops

belongs to ethnic minority people.

Table 18. Details of impacts on land

No.

Province/

District/

Commune

Reside

ntial

land

Annual

crop

growing

land

Garde

n land

Forestry

land

Aquacult

ure land

Public

land

Total

affected

land area

(m²)

1 Hoa Binh - 10,691.6 563.7 57,988.9 - - 69,244.2

1.1 Mai Chau - 10,691.6 563.7 57,988.9 - - 69,244.2

26

1.1.1 Tong Dau - 9,423.3 44.0 8.3 - - 9,475.6

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town - 159.2 - - - - 159.2

1.1.3 Chieng Chau - 271.6 - - - - 271.6

1.1.4 Mai Ha - 239.3 - - - - 239.3

1.1.5 Van Mai - 598.2 519.7 42,732.8 - - 43,850.7

1.1.6 Mai Hich - - - 15,247.8 - - 15,247.8

2 Thanh Hoa - 42.6 - - - - 42.6

2.1 Quan Hoa - 42.6 - - - - 42.6

2.1.1 Phu Thanh - 42.6 - - - - 42.6

Total - 10,734.2 563.7 57,988.9 - - 69,286.8


Among 69.286,8 m2 of permanent and temporary affected land of 288 PAHs, affected garden lands

mainly belong to PAHs in Tong Dau and Van Mai communes with the total area of 563.7m2. All of

these PAHs are ethnic minority.

Forestry land is the most affected type of land with 57,988.9 m2 and mainly distributed in 3 communes,

namely Tong Dau (8.3 m2), Van Mai (42,732 m2) and Mai Hich (15,247.8 m2). The area of affected

forestry land belong to EM PAPs with LURCs is 33,913.4 m2 including 8.3 m2 in Tong Dau commune,

33,412 m2 in Van Mai and 493.1 m2 Mai Hich commune. Details of permanent land acquisition of EM

households are presented in table 19.

Table 19. Details of permanently affected land of EM households due to the construction of 110kV substation

and tower foundations (m2)


Commune

Resid

ential

land

Annual

crop

growing

land

Garden

land

Forestry

land

Aquac

ulture

land

Public

land Total

1 Hoa Binh - 10,691.6 44.0 8.3 - - 10,743.9

1.1 Mai Chau District - 10,691.6 44.0 8.3 - - 10,743.9

1.1.1 Tong Dau - 9,423.3 44.0 8.3 - - 9,475.6

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town - 159.2 - - - - 159.2

1.1.3 Chieng Chau - 271.6 - - - - 271.6

1.1.4 Mai Ha - 239.3 - - - - 239.3

1.1.5 Van Mai - 598.2 - - - - 598.2

1.1.6 Mai Hich - - - - - - -

27

2 Thanh Hoa - 42.6 - - - - 42.6

2.1 Quan Hoa - 42.6 - - - - 42.6

2.1.1 Phu Thanh - 42.6 - - - - 42.6

Total - 10,734.2 44.0 8.3 - - 10,786.5


The table 19 above shows the details of land acquisition by type of land in each commune required for

the project components including 110kV substation, access road, houses of staff and tower

foundations. The total area of land types to be acquired from 249 EM affected household is 10,786.5

m2 (including 10,734.2 m2 of annual crop-growing land, 44m2 of garden land and 8.3m2 of forestry

land). The main impacts are on annual crop land, and mostly in Tong Dau commune due to land

acquisition to construct the 110kV substation. The least impacts are in Phu Thanh commune of Thanh

Hoa with only 42.6m2 of land to be acquired.

Table 20. Details of temporarily affected land by ROW


Commune

Resid

ential

land

Annual

crop

growing

land

Garden

land

Forestry

land

Aquacul

ture

land

Public

land Total (m2)

1 Hoa Binh - - 519.7 57,980.6 - - 58,500.3

1.1 Mai Chau District - - 519.7 57,980.6 - - 58,500.3

1.1.1 Tong Dau - - - - - - -

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town - - - - - - -

1.1.3 Chieng Chau - - - - - - -

1.1.4 Mai Ha - - - - - - -

1.1.5 Van Mai - - 519.7 42,732.8 - - 43,252.5

1.1.6 Mai Hich - - - 15,247.8 - - 15,247.8

2 Thanh Hoa - - - - - - -

2.1 Quan Hoa - - - - - - -

2.1.1 Phu Thanh - - - - - - -

Total - - 519.7 57,980.6 - - 58,500.3


28

The Table 20 shows the land acquisition of 58,500.3 m2 in the ROW including 57,980.6 m2 of forestry

land and 519.7 m2 of garden land. Land acquired for ROW is mainly forestry land in Van Mai and Mai

Hich communes, in which 42,732.8 m2 are in Van Mai and 15,247.8 m2 are in Mai Hich commune.

This area is calculated by width of ROW which is 3m and length of the line which is 19,456km.

Although the affected area is large, level of impacts is not much, because time of temporary land

occupy is only maximum 2 weeks for stringing the conductor.

Table 21. Affected productive land

No.

Province/

District/

Commune

Affected productive land area of the

PAHs

Affected productive land area of the EM

PAHs <

10

%

10

%-

30

%

Ab

ove

30

% -

50

%

Ab

ove

50

% -

70

%

Ab

ove

70

%

To

tal

< 1

0%

10

%-

30

%

Ab

ove

30

% -

50

%

Ab

ove

50

% -

70

%

Ab

ove

70

%

To

tal

1 Hoa Binh 260 20 4 - - 284 225 16 4 - - 245

1.1 Mai Chau 260 20 4 - - 284 225 16 4 - - 245

1.1.1 Tong Dau 46 9 4 - - 59 46 9 4 - - 59

1.1.2

Mai Chau

Town 22 - - - - 22 22 - - - - 22

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 44 - - - - 44 44 - - - - 44

1.1.4 Mai Ha 28 1 - - - 29 28 1 - - - 29

1.1.5 Van Mai 101 8 - - - 109 84 6 - - - 90

1.1.6 Mai Hich 19 2 - - - 21 1 - - - - 1

2 Thanh Hoa 4 - - - - 4 4 - - - - 4

2.1 Quan Hoa 4 - - - - 4 4 - - - - 4

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 4 - - - - 4 4 - - - - 4

Total 264 20 4 - - 288 229 16 4 - - 249


Impacts caused by land acquisition are evaluated as insignificant as the figures show that compared to

the total number of the affected households, only 24 households are affected more than 10% of their

landholdings including 20 EM PAHs in Tong Dau Commune (13 HHs), Mai Ha commune (1 HH) and

Van Mai (6 HHs).

Among the households losing more than 10% of land area, 20 households lose from 10% to 30% and

4 households lose more than 30% of their landholdings.

29

(ii) Land use right

Types of lands affected by the subproject are mainly annual crop growing land, garden land and

forestry land. According to PAC PC, land user right certificate was issued to the households at the end

of the 90s. Although some households currently have yet had LURC, they have sufficient claims for

(eligible to) the granting of LURCs.

The two tables below show the status of LURCs for different types of land of the PAHs by commune.

Table 22. Legal status on land of the surveyed PAHs

No.

Province/

District/

Commune

Rice growing land Forestry land Garden land W

ith

LU

RC

s

With

ou

t L

UR

Cs

bu

t e

ligib

le t

o

Not

elig

ible

Lo

ng

-term

la

nd

lea

se

gra

nte

d b

y

Go

V

With

LU

RC

s

With

ou

t L

UR

Cs

bu

t e

ligib

le t

o

Not

elig

ible

Lo

ng

-term

la

nd

lea

se

gra

nte

d b

y

Go

V

With

LU

RC

s

With

ou

t L

UR

Cs

bu

t e

ligib

le t

o

Not

elig

ible

Lo

ng

-term

la

nd

lea

se

gra

nte

d b

y

Go

V

1 Hoa Binh 185 10 - - 58 25 - - - 6 - -

1.1

Mai Chau

District 185 10 - - 58 25 - - - 6 - -

1.1.1 Tong Dau 56 1 - - 1 - - - - 1 - -

1.1.2

Mai Chau

Town 22 - - - - - - - - - - -

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 44 - - - - - - - - - - -

1.1.4 Mai Ha 27 2 - - - - - - - - - -

1.1.5 Van Mai 36 7 - - 42 19 - - - 5 - -

1.1.6 Mai Hich - - - - 15 6 - - - - - -

2 Thanh Hoa 4 - - - - - - - - - - -

2.1 Quan Hoa 4 - - - - - - - - - - -

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 4 - - - - - - - - - - -

Total 189 10 - - 58 25 - - - 6 - -


Table 22 shows that 100% of PAHs having LURCs (247 households, including 189 households having

LURCs for rice crop land and 58 households having LURCs for forest land) or not having LURCs but

can require (fully eligible to) the granting of LURC (41 households, including 10 ones who have yet had

LURC for rice crop land, 25 ones who have yet had LURC for forest land and 6 ones who have yet had

LURC for garden land). According to survey result, the households confirmed that although they have

yet had LURCs for these land types, they have sufficient claims for (eligible to) the granting of LURCs.

30

Table 23. Legal status on land of EM PAHs


Commune

Rice growing land Forestry land Garden land

With

LU

RC

s

With

ou

t L

UR

Cs

bu

t e

ligib

le t

o

Not

elig

ible

Lo

ng

-term

la

nd

lea

se

gra

nte

d b

y

Go

V

With

LU

RC

s

With

ou

t L

UR

Cs

bu

t e

ligib

le t

o

Not

elig

ible

Lo

ng

-term

la

nd

lea

se

gra

nte

d b

y

Go

V

With

LU

RC

s

With

ou

t L

UR

Cs

bu

t e

ligib

le t

o

Not

elig

ible

Lo

ng

-term

la

nd

lea

se

gra

nte

d b

y

Go

V

1 Hoa Binh 185 10 - - 34 10 - - - 6 - -

1.1 Mai Chau District 185 10 - - 34 10 - - - 6 - -

1.1.1 Tong Dau 56 1 - - 1 - - - - 1 - -

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 22 - - - - - - - - - - -

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 44 - - - - - - - - - - -

1.1.4 Mai Ha 27 2 - - - - - - - - - -

1.1.5 Van Mai 36 7 - - 33 9 - - - 5 - -

1.1.6 Mai Hich - - - - - 1 - - - - - -

2 Thanh Hoa 4 - - - - - - - - - - -

2.1 Quan Hoa 4 - - - - - - - - - - -

2.11 Phu Thanh 4 - - - - - - - - - - -

Total 189 10 - - 34 10 - - - 6 - -


Table 23 shows that status of having LURC of EM PAHs is the same as general status of the

subproject. 10 EM households have yet had LURC for rice crop land, 10 ones have yet had LURC for

forest land and 6 one have yet had LURC for garden land. However, the households have resettled

here since before 1993 and they inform that they have sufficient claims for (eligible to) the granting of

LURCs for these land types.

(iii) Impacts on standing trees and crops

Land acquisition and construction activities will affect 10,740 m2 of land for growing annual crops,

including 10,734 m2 of rice growing land and 6m2 of maize land of 1 household in Van Mai Commune.

Table 24. Impacts on land for growing rain crops


Commune Unit Rice Maize Cassava Bean Vegetable

1 Hoa Binh HH 195 1 - - -

m2 10,692 6 - - -

1.1 Mai Chau District HH 195 1 - - -

m2 10,692 6 - - -

1.1.1 Tong Dau

HH 57 - - - -

m2 9,423 - - - -

31

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town HH 22 - - - -

m2 159 - - - -

1.1.3 Chieng Chau HH 44 - - - -

m2 272 - - - -

1.1.4 Mai Ha HH 29 - - - -

m2 239 - - - -

1.1.5 Van Mai HH 43 1

- -

m2 598 6 - - -

1.1.6 Mai Hich HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

2 Thanh Hoa HH 4 - - - -

m2 43 - - - -

2.1 Quan Hoa District HH 4 - - - -

m2 43 - - - -

2.1.1 Phu Thanh HH 4 - - - -

m2 42.6 - - - -

Total HH 199 1 - - -

m2 10,734 6 - - -


In Mai Hich Commune, there is no impact on rice growing land. In the remaining 6 communes, 199

households are affected on their rice growing land with an area of 10,734 m2. Most of the affected rice

growing area is two-crop land of local people.

Types of affected trees include bead trees, “luong” bamboo, longan and mango. Among 7 communes,

only Tong Dau, Van Mai and Mai Hich are affected on these trees.

Table 25. Impacts on trees


Commune Unit Bead tree Longan Mango

“Luong”

bamboo

Chukrasia

tabularis

“lat”

1 Hoa Binh HH 10 7 3 60 10

m2 7,830 639 1,070 52,400 880

1.1 Mai Chau District HH 10 7 3 60 10

m2 7,830 639 1,070 52,400 880

1.1.1 Tong Dau HH - 1 - - -

m2 - 4 - - -

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

1.1.3 Chieng Chau HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

1.1.4 Mai Ha HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

32

1.1.5 Van Mai HH 10 5 3 41 6

m2 7,830 615 1,070 33,650 430

1.1.6 Mai Hich HH - 1 - 19 4

m2 - 20 - 18,750 450

2 Thanh Hoa HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

2.1 Quan Hoa District HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

2.1.1 Phu Thanh HH - - - - -

m2 - - - - -

Total HH 7 3 60 10

m2 639 1,070 52,400 880


90 households are affected on their trees due to the subproject implementation, including 52,400

“luong” bamboo trees, 7,830 bead trees and 880 Chukrasia tabularis trees to be cut down. These

types of trees have high economic value to people in the project area.

Such affected trees are mainly in Van Mai Commune as 100% of the affected bead-trees belong to 10

households in this commune, 33,650 “luong” bamboos are owned by 41 households and 50% of the

affected Chukrasia tabularis trees (lat) belong to 6 households in Van Mai.

Impacts on fruit trees (longan and mango) are quite significant as the number of affected trees is quite

considerable on the average of each household. Specifically, 1,070 mango trees are affected

belonging to only 3 households in Van Mai commune and out of the total of 639 affected longan trees,

up to 615 trees are owned by 5 households in Van Mai.

Summary of impacts caused by the construction of Mai Chau 100kV substation and 35kV TL is as

follows:

Table 26. Summary of impacts

No. Category Households Unit Quantity

I Land

1 Residential land - m2 -

2 Annual crop growing land 199 m2 10,734

3 Garden land 6 m2 564

4 Aquaculture land - m2 -

5 Forestry land 84 m2 57,989

II Houses and structures

1 Grade 1 - - -

2 Grade 2 - - -

3 Grade 3 - - -

33

4 Grade 4 - - -

5 Temporary houses - - -

6 Auxiliary structures - - -

6.1 Kitchen, cattle shed, etc. - - -

6.2 Electricity meter, water meter - - -

6.3 Water tank - - -

III Trees and crops

1 Rain crops 199

10,734

2 Timber 10

7,830

3 Fruit tree

3.1 Mango, longan.. 7

54,109

3.2 Bamboo, Chukrasia tabularis.. 10

880

IV Business shops - - -

V Public structures - - -

VI Number of relocating households - - -


34

CHAPTER IV.

LEGAL FRAMEWORK (FOR LAND AND ETHNIC MINORITY)

4.1. Policies of the Government of Vietnam

4.1.1. Policies of the Government of Vietnam (Gov) on land acquisition

This part presents legal framework and policies of GoV and policies of World Bank (WB) regarding

land acquisition, compensation as well as resettlement and compares between two approaches. Due

to differences between policies of WB and legal framework of Vietnam, the project needs to exempt

some certain articles of GoV’s circulars and regulations in terms of compensation, assistance and

resettlement. According to that, plan of compensation, assistance and resettlement will be

implemented by the project’s policies.

Law on land 2003 issued on 26/11/2003 by Vietnam Assembly stated that “people who are

acquired their land will be compensated by land for the same use; if there is no land for

compensation, they will be compensated by value of land use right at the time issuing

decisions on land acquisition. PC of provinces and central cities will edit and implement

resettlement projects prior to land acquisition and compensation for houses and residential

land for people who are acquired land and relocated their residential places. Resettlement

locations need to have same or better development conditions than those of old residential

places. If there are no resettlement areas, the people who are acquired land will be

compensated in cash and prioritized to buy or rent houses owned by the State, in cases of

urban areas; and will be compensated by residential land, in cases of rural areas. In cases

land acquisition from households and/or individuals which are in direct production process, but

there is no compensating land for continuing production, besides compensation in cash, the

people who are acquired land will be assisted to stabilize their lives by being trained to change

their production and/or business methods via assignment of new jobs” (Article 42)

Law on complaints and denunciations are approved on 2 December 1998 by National

Assembly

Law on amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on complaints and denunciations

are approved on 15 June 2004

Decree 181/2004/ND-CP of the Government of Vietnam issued on October 29, 2004 guiding

the implementation of the Land Law 2003.

Decree 84/2007/ND-CP of the Government of Vietnam dated May 25th 2007 on revision of

issuing LURC, land acquisition, implementation of land use right, procedure for compensation,

resettlement when land acquired by State and grievance redress.

Decree 197/2004/ND-CP issued on December 3, 2004 on compensation, support and

resettlement when land is recovered by the State and is supplemented by the Decree No.

17/2006/ND-CP.

Decree 60/CP issued on 5 July 1994 by the Government of Vietnam regulating land ownership

right and land use right in urban areas;

Decree 61/CP issued on 15 July 1994 by the Government of Vietnam regarding regulations on

purchase houses.

35

Decree 188/2004/ND-CP of the Government of Vietnam issued on November 16, 2004 on

methods to determine land prices and assorted land price brackets. This decree stated clearly

maximum and minimum prices of different land types and categories all over the country.

These land prices were established to serve the Government’s land acquisition, tax on

changing land use right, renting the state’s land and for national as well as public objectives.

Decree 123/2007/ND-CP dated July 27, 2007 on revision and supplementation of some

regulations in decree 188/2004/ND-CP.

Decree No. 69/2009/ND-CP dated August 13, 2009 by the Government additionally providing

for land use planning, land prices, land recovery, compensation, support and resettlement in

case of land acquisition, determination of land price, issuing land, renting land, and additional

requirements relating to land use right.

Decree No. 106/2005/ND-CP dated August 17, 2005 by the Government of Vietnam regulating

protection and safety of high voltage system as well as verify necessary Right of way to

ensure the safety. Certain articles of this decree, which are mainly to increase safe distance

from the high voltage lines, are amended by Decree 81/2009/ND-CP dated on 12 October

2009.

Decree No. 53/2005/ND-CP dated April 19 2005 by the Government of Vietnam detailing and

guiding the implementation of the Law on Complaints and Denunciations and the Law

amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Complaints and

Denunciations.

Decision No. 52/2012/QD-TTg dated on 16 November 2012 on policy supporting and resolving

jobs and vocational training for labours whose agriculture land is acquired.

Circular No. 114/2004//TT-BTC dated on 26 November 2004 by Ministry of Finance issuing

guideline to implement Decree 188. This circular edited details of the methods (which are

direct comparison method and collection method) regarding evaluation of price of different

land types and categories in different areas/regions to ensure the placement price.

Circular No. 14/2009/TT-BTNMT dated October 1, 2009 by the Ministry of Natural Resources

and Environment detailing the compensation, support and resettlement and order of and

procedures for land recovery, allocation and lease.

Other decisions and policy framework applied for making this policy framework include the followings:

Decision No. 2192/QD-NLDK dated on 30 June 2005 by Ministry of Industry on approval of

policy framework of compensation for resettlement, policy framework of ethnic minority

development plan and framework guiding environmental evaluation of Second transmission

and distribution project.

Policy framework of compensation, assistance for resettlement and life recovery for DPs of

Trung Son hydropower project.

4.1.2. Policies of the Government of Vietnam on Ethnic minorities

For ethnic minorities, the Vietnamese Government's policies are built based on the respect and

equality among ethnic groups, solidarity and mutual assistance among different ethnic groups. The

application of socio-economic policies for each region, each group taking into account the needs of

ethnic minorities is a requirement. Socio-economic Development Plan and Socio-economic

36

Development Strategy in Vietnam give special attention to the ethnic minorities. The major programs

for the ethnic minorities can be listed are the Program 135 (Infrastructure in poor and remote areas),

Program 134 (Eliminating temporary houses). Besides, there are also policies on education and

healthcare for ethnic minority people.

Resolution No. 30a/2008/NQ-CP of government, dated 27 Dec. 2008 on support program for rapid

and sustainable poverty reduction for 61 poorest districts

Decree No.70/2001/ND-CP: all documents registering family assets and land use rights must be in

the names of both husband and wife.

Decree No. 82/2010/ND-CP dated July 20 2010 by the Government on teaching and learning of

ethnic minority languages in schools and regular educational centers.

Decision No. 42/2012/QD-TTg dated October 8 2012 by the Prime Minister on giving support to

units, organizations using employees who are ethnic minority people in the mountainous

regions, especially difficult areas.

Decision No. 52/2012/QD-TTg dated August 18 2010 by the Prime Minister on using legal

assistance policy to raise the awareness and understanding of law of the poor and ethnic minorities

in the poor districts in the 2011 to 2020 period.

Decision No. 112/2007/QD-TTg of the Prime Minister dated July 20 2007 by the Prime Minister on

the policy supporting services to improve the people's life, and legal support to increase the legal

awareness under the program 135 phase II.

Decision No. 33/2007/QD-TTg dated March 05 2007 by the Prime Minister on Supporting ethnic

minority people in settlement and sedentary farming in the 2007 to 2010 period.

Decision No. 01/2007/QD-UBDT dated 31-May-2007 of the Ethnic Minorities Committee on the

recognition of communes, districts in the mountainous areas

Decision No. 05/2007/QD-UBDT dated 06-September-2007 of the Ethnic Minorities Committee on

its acceptance for three regions of ethnic minorities and mountainous areas based on development

status

Decision No. 18/2011/QD-TTg dated March 18 2011 by the Prime Minister on policies on the

prestigious people in the ethnic minority groups.

Decision No. 06/2007/QD-UBDT dated 12-January-2007 of the Ethnic Minorities Committee on the

strategy of media for the program 135-phase 2

Joint Circular No. 05/2011/TTLT-UBDT-BTC by the Committee for Ethnic Minority Affairs dated

December 16 2011 guiding the implementation of the Decision No. 18/2011/QD-TTg on

policies for the prestigious people in the ethnic minority groups.

Circular No. 06 dated 20-September-2007 of the Ethnic Minorities Committee guidance on the

assistance for services, improved livelihood of people, technical assistance for improving the

knowledge on the laws according the decision 112/2007/QD-TTg

37

4.2. World Bank’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement (OP 4.12) and Indigenous Peoples (OP

4.10)

4.2.1. Involuntary Resettlement (OP 4.12)

The primary objective of the World Bank policy is to explore all alternatives to avoid or at least

minimize involuntary resettlement. Where resettlement is unavoidable, the living standards of

displaced persons should be restored or improved relative to those conditions that prevailed prior to

the Project. The policy applies to the taking of land and other assets when land acquisition results in

the loss of shelter, the loss of all or part of productive assets, or access to them, and the loss of

income sources or other means of livelihood.

Policy on Indigenous Peoples (OP 4.10)

The objectives of the World Bank Policy on Indigenous Peoples aim to:

To ensure that the ethnic groups adapt to the meaningful opportunities to participate in

designing project activities that have impacts on them;

To ensure that the opportunities for those ethnic groups have taken into account culturally

appropriate benefits; and

To ensure that any adverse impact caused by the project is avoided or otherwise minimized.

For purposes of this policy, the term “Indigenous Peoples” is used in a generic sense to refer to a

distinct, vulnerable, social and cultural group possessing the following characteristics in varying

degrees:

(a) self-identification as members of a distinct indigenous cultural group and recognition of

this identity by others;

(b) collective attachment to geographically distinct habitats or ancestral territories in the

project area and to the natural resources in these habitats and territories;

(c) customary cultural, economic, social, or political institutions that are separate from those

of the dominant society and culture; and

(d) an indigenous language, often different from the official language of the country or region.

OP 4.10 requires a “free, prior, and informed” consultation with the ethnic minorities that might be

affected and establishes assistances for the project affected communities.

4.3. Comparison between Government of Vietnam and World Bank Approaches

There are a number of ways in which the approaches of the Vietnam Government – either in policy or

practice – are compatible with World Bank guidelines. The most important compatibilities are:

Vietnam has a process whereby most people without legal land rights may meet conditions of

legalization and receive compensation for losses.

Permanent residents are provided with options that include relocation to an improved site, or

cash, or a combination of the two.

Resettlement sites offer not only improved infrastructure and services but represent a higher

standard of living.

Allowances are provided to help the DPs in the transition period and there is an institutional

structure through which people are informed, can negotiate compensation, and can appeal.

38

Differences between the approaches and measures that need to be addressed within the

program also exist. However, in this context, procedures exist within national and City

governments that allow the granting of waivers of domestic law on specific projects that may

be in conflict with that of the funding agency.

On the issue of land tenure and the legal right to compensation, the Government and World

Bank approaches are compatible. The government has its own process in place whereby land

occupied without legal documentation can be legalized; this land, however, is compensated for

at a rate equal to 100% of land price minus the taxes and fee for land use right registration

from 15 October 1993 (Articles No.42, 49 and 50 of the Land Law 2003).

Required Waivers

In order to meet the requirements of the World Bank OP 4.12 on Involuntary Resettlement a number of

articles in various Vietnamese laws and regulations which do not ensure compensation at replacement

cost or set eligibility provisions which do not extend the right to rehabilitation and or assistance to

households without proper land paper, will be waived.

The articles of law and regulations that will be waived are mentioned below:

Eligibility to Compensation and or assistance – Decree 197

Article 7 of Decree 197 of 2004 (Cases where land is recovered without compensation) stipulates that

any person whose land is recovered and who has not met one of the conditions of Article 8 of this

Decree, or who has violated the plan, or who violates the protecting corridor work, or who illegally

occupies land shall not receive compensation when the state recovers the land. In case of necessity,

the Provincial People’s Committee shall consider and decide on a case-by-case basis.

Article 18, 20 of Decree 197:

Houses and structures on non-eligible-for-compensation land, which have not violated

announced land use plans or the right of way will be assisted at 80% of replacement cost

Houses and structures on non-eligible-for-compensation land, which have violated announced

land use plans or the right of way will not be assisted. If necessary, the PPC will consider on

the case by case basis.

Article 29 of Decree 197: DPs losing more than 30% of productive land will be entitled to living

stabilization and training/job creation assistance

To ensure that the objectives of this resettlement policy are met, a special decision of the Government

waiving Article 7, 18, 20, 29 of Decree 197 and article 24 of Decree 69 is needed to permit assistance

and rehabilitation measures for illegal users of land as proposed in the policy. This was represented in

Decision on approval of the project’s policy framework in Decision No. 1856/TTg-KTN dated on 15

October 2010.

Price of Land for Calculation of Compensation

Article 9 of Decree 197: The compensation rates for land shall be determined by the PPC for the type

of land which has been used for at the time of land acquisition

To ensure that the objectives of the project resettlement policy are met, unit price for land

compensation established by the Project Provincial/City People’s Committees will be adjusted to meet

the replacement costs on the 1st of January every year according to the law.

39

Assistance Policy for DPs who Rent State-owned dwelling houses – Decree 197

Article 21 of Decree 197/2004/ND-CP states that DPs who rent State-owned dwelling houses shall be

provided with monetary supports equal to 60% of the land value and 60% of the value of currently

rented houses; in cases where there are no resettlement houses are to be arranged for them.

To ensure that the objectives of the policy are met, a special decision of the Government of Vietnam

regarding waiver of Article 21 of Decree 197/2004/ND-CP is needed to permit assistance and

rehabilitation measures for DPs who share State-owned dwelling houses as proposed in this policy.

Article 2 of Decree 188/2004/ND-CP states that the land price shall be defined by the provincial

People’s Committees and/or cities directly under the central government. To ensure that the objectives

of the project resettlement policy are met, unit prices for land compensation established by the project

related provincial/city People’s Committees shall be adjusted to meet the replacement costs.

Item 5, Article 2 of Decree No.131/2006/NĐ-CP dated November 9, 2006 issuing Regulations on

management and usage of Official Development Assistance (ODA) stipulates “Conform to regulations

under Vietnamese Law and international treaties on ODA of which the Socialist Republic of Vietnam is

a member. In case an international treaty on ODA where the Socialist Republic of Vietnam is a

member has contrary regulations to those of Vietnamese Law, the international treaty shall prevail”.

40

CHAPTER V

CONSULTATION AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE

5.1. The need and Purposes

Information dissemination to, consultation with and participation of the affected people and key

stakeholders will

a. reduce the potential of conflicts;

b. minimize the risk of project delays;

c. enable the project to design the resettlement and rehabilitation program as a comprehensive

development measure to fit the needs and priorities of the affected persons, thereby

maximizing the economic and social benefits of project development and;

d. make sure that the RAP preparation and implementation are in a transparency way.

Not only required by the international financiers, but also information disclosures and dissemination

are required by GoV as in Article 39 of Land law (2003), Articles 34, 43, 52 and 53 of Decree

197/2004 and Article 49 of Decree 84/2007 and In Decree 69/2009.

The general objectives of the Public Information Campaign and the Consultation Program are to inform

and get feedback from key stakeholders about all aspects of compensation and resettlement planning.

Specific objectives and principles are as follows:

a. To fully share key information about the project with the affected persons, local authorities and

other stakeholders (project background, purposes, studied alternatives, environmental and

resettlement issues etc.).

b. To obtain information about the needs and proposed priorities of the affected persons, local

communities, local authorities, local NGOs as well as their reactions/feedback on the

compensation, assistance and resettlement policies and other relevant activities.

c. To obtain the cooperation and participation of the affected persons, relevant institutions

through all phases of resettlement planning and implementation.

d. To ensure transparency in all activities related to land acquisition, compensation, resettlement

and rehabilitation measures.

e. Participation provides for the occasion and the process by which stakeholders influence and

become co-responsible for development initiatives and decisions that affect them. Through

their full and active involvement, the needs and priorities of the local populace are ventilated

and heard. The households and other stakeholders are being consulted during the preparation

and implementation of the resettlement plan. This exercise is a two-way process – information

dissemination/disclosure and gathering of feedbacks and suggestions for preparing and

implementing RAP.

Information dissemination, consultation and participation require in the period of RAP preparation and

will be continued through entire period of RAP implementation. Consultation and participation are

carried out through different channels and instruments, such as meetings with provincial, district,

commune and village leaders and representatives of their key departments to study about the

compensation and relocation policies of the city and province; the principles of determining the

compensation cost, and potential of land for replacement, possibilities of economic restoration

programs, employment in the locality, among others.

41

The consultation and participation methods:

The consultation and improvement of the participation methods which were implemented include the

followings;

Schedule on consultation and organization of public meetings were informed to CPCs and

people a week earlier by consultancy unit and representative of Trung Son HPP (table 27);

Public meetings were hold at cultural houses of villages;

The consultation was supported by tools such as maps, pictures and colour papers on which

there are details of impacts on environment, society and of the project’s land acquisition;

One expert on EM (who is a Thai people) conducted a consultation meeting with support by

expert on resettlement, gender and society;

In-depth interviews with prestigious people in EM community were directly conducted in Thai

language by expert on EM.

Table 27. Consultation schedule

No. District/ Commune Implement

ation time Place

Number of participants

Total Male Female

1 Mai Chau District

226 137 89

1.1 Mai Chau Town 12/9 Town People’s Committee 19 10 9

1.2 Tong Dau 12/9 Commune People’s

Committee 56 36 20

1.3 Mai Ha 13/9 Commune People’s

Committee 26 16 10

1.4 Mai Hich 13/9 Mai Hoang Son Village 15 8 7

1.5 Chieng Chau 12/9 Commune People’s

Committee 40 26 14

1.6 Van Mai 14/9 Commune People’s

Committee 70 41 29

2 Quan Hoa District

2.1

Phu Thanh – consultation

by questionnaire and in-

depth interview

15/9 Households 4 3 1

Total 230 140 90

Content of the consultation focuses on:

The meetings with local organizations such as women’s unions, farmer’s association, and

fatherland front, veteran’s association etc., to draw their concerns and suggestion to

Resettlement Planning. Meetings with all affected communes and affected households,

including conduct of group meetings with women, the elderly, and other vulnerable groups;

Distribute resettlement pamphlet to leaders of communes and the displaced persons;

Conduct of socio-economic and affected property surveys, consultation with people about

42

options for compensation, i.e. “land for land or cash for land”; proposals for economic

restoration activities as well as other concerns of the different affected groups.

Results of the consultation is presented in article 5.2 (table 28) below.

5.2. Consultation during preparation of Resettlement Action Plan and Ethnic Minority

Development Plan

Table 27: Summary on consultation with stakeholders

Venue Time Participants Summary on local people’s

opinions

Solutions

Mai Chau

Town

12/9 19 participants of

the PAHs and

representatives of

the commune

leaders including:

10 males and 9

females

- Affected area is not considerable.

- The construction of 35kV line

does not affect their customs and

traditions.

- Attracting young people from the

affected villages to engage in

services in Lac Village and Pom

Coong Village does not occur.

- Some households do not know

the area of their land to be

acquired.

- Construction of the 35kV line does

not affect their customs and

traditional habits.

- The 35kV line will contribute to the

socio-economic development as

this power line directly promotes

the completion of Trung Son

Hydropower Project, and Mai

Chau is the gateway to the work.

- For the first measurement of land

area, the village leaders and some

households are not informed.

- When implementing

compensation, Mai Chau

District Compensation,

Assistance and Resettlement

Council will cooperate with

investor, the commune/ town

People’s Committee to have a

meeting publishing the project

implementation guideline,

inform people sufficiently

about DMS plan, the project,

amount of damage types,

implementation progress, value

of compensation and

assistance, etc.

Tong Dau

Commun

e


the PAHs and

representatives of

the commune

leaders including:

36 males and 20

females

- People opt to land-for-land

compensation.

- Propose for funding assistance for

processing bamboo blinds to

supply to Chieng Chau industrial

zone.

- People expect that the project will

provide appropriate vocational

training. Priority should be given

to members of the PAHs.

- Expect that the Project will employ

local labors for unskilled work

such as digging, transporting

- The CPC said that there is no

land for land-by-land

compensation method.

- PMU will be proposed to have

prioritized policy for children of

households who are acquired

land, particularly the severely

affected one.

- PMU will be proposed to work

with or have conditions with the

contractors and must prioritize

employing maximum labours,

particularly unskilled labours.

43

during construction of tower

foundation and substation period.

- The construction of substation and

tower foundations should be

started after the harvest crop to

avoid impacts on the crop

productivity.

- The project will be proposed to

try to avoid implementing

construction near to/in crop

harvest. If the project needs to

increase the progress, people’s

impacts on crops will be

compensated sufficiently and

in accordance with the project

policy.

Mai Ha

Commun

e


the PAHs and

representatives of

the commune

leaders including:

16 males and 10

females

- Impacts are mainly on rice-

growing land.

- The influx of workers will not affect

significantly people’s life.

- The construction time should be

informed in time to people so that

they can plan to cultivate in

another area to avoid more

impacts caused by construction

activities.

- People in the area depend heavily

on agriculture. Therefore, there is

not much orientation in job

conversion. They said that if they

knew the exact amount of

compensation, they would be

engaged in large-scale livestock

husbandry to increase income.

- Expect the PMB and local

authorities to identify exact

acquired land area soon and

prepare occupational orientation

plan.

- PMU will be proposed to bind

contracts with the contractor,

coordinate closely with the

locality in terms of temporary

residence registration, worker

management, and good

relation with local community.

The stakeholders need to

increase cooperation and

inspection.

- PMU and Mai Chau District

Compensation Council will

inform compensation inventory

plan, construction

implementation schedule to the

local authorities and

households soon.



inform households about

guideline and implementation

plan of the project, DMS plan,

publish acquisition area and

compensation amount for each

household at CPC and District

Compensation Council, etc.

Mai Hich

Commun

e


the PAHs and

representatives of

the commune

leaders including:

8 males and 7

females

- Impacts are mainly on productive

land.

- The acquired are is not

considerable; willing to facilitate

earliest construction.

- Consider assistances for the area

in ROW 6m (unable to continue

cultivating).

- Before construction, the PMU

should inform the commune,

village leaders, especially PAHs

so that they can have time to stop

cultivating on the area to be

- According to the country’s

regulation, land compensation

will base on type of land, area,

position and benefit capacity.

Consultancy group are aware

of people’s recommendation

and will consult with PMU.

- According to Decree No. 106

and the project policy, there is

no compensation for land. In

terms of supporting land in

ROW, consultancy will work

with PMU.

44

acquired.

Chieng

Chau

Commun

e


the PAHs and

representatives of

the commune

leaders including:

26 males and 14

females

- The construction unit should have

construction plan to avoid the crop

time.

- The specific area of land to be

acquired of each household is not

finalized, it is necessary to review

and measure to identify the exact

amount, area, households, and

locations of tower foundations to

avoid mistaking land of one

household to another household

which may lead to dispute among

DPs.

- The most important thing is that

the measurement data should be

confirmed by the commune

officials, village leaders and heads

of PAHs.

- The project will be proposed to

try to avoid implementing

construction near to/in crop

harvest. If the project needs to

increase the progress, people’s

impacts on crops will be

compensated sufficiently and

in accordance with the project

policy.



cooperate with the commune

leaders and cadastral, village

leader and households to

implement measurement, area

inventory, and types of land

acquisition, property on land

and acquisition categories.

Information regarding land

acquisition and affected

properties need to have

signatures of the household

leaders and affected amount

need to be published.

Van Mai

Commun

e


the PAHs and

representatives of

the commune

leaders including:

41 males and 29

females

- For the households whose “luong”

bamboo growing land is acquired,

according to the policy, the project

does not compensation for

acquired land but the standing

bamboo, fruit trees or crops on the

affected area.

- Consider assistances for the area

in ROW 6m (unable to continue

cultivating).

- There should be agreed document

between the contractor/

construction unit with the local

authorities and people about the

time and implementation progress

to avoid impacts on production

season.

- After construction, site should be

restored and returned to people.

- During the construction period, if

there is any emerging impact,

compensation should be provided

for DPs.

- According to Decree No. 106

and the project policy, there is

no compensation for land. In

terms of supporting land in

ROW, consultancy will work

with PMU.

- PMU will be proposed to work

with and request the

contractors to commit progress

in accordance with contract

signed with the local authorities

and people as well as

cooperate well with village

leader during the

implementation in order to limit

maximum of impacts on people

in the project area.

- During the implementation, if

the contractor affects/damage

people’s properties, they will

have to compensate

sufficiently.

- PMU will be proposed to bind

contracts with the contractor,

45

- The influx of workers does not

affect the life of people.

- Social evils as well as waste

should be managed by the

concerned agencies.

coordinate closely with the

locality in terms of temporary

residence registration, worker

management, and good

relation with local community.

The stakeholders need to

increase cooperation and

inspection.

Phu

Thanh

commune

- 15/9 - Consultation by

questionnaire at

the households;

in-depth interview

- The project should have a detailed

plan to inform to people.

- Support the project as the impacts

are not significant while the

benefits brought about by the

project are enormous.

- Project’s impacts are not

considerable, mainly on rice

growing area.



inform households about

guideline and implementation

plan of the project, DMS plan,

publish acquisition area and

compensation amount for each

household at CPC and District

Compensation Council, etc.

5.3. Consultation plan and methods of information dissemination during the project

implementation

The consultation and information dissemination need to be implemented during the whole time

preparing for the project and also planning and implementing the project in order to ensure

requirement of information dissemination, consultation and participation. So as to ensure EM people

can be aware of the project information, participate in the consultation and other activities of the

project, following actions need to be done:

(i) Disclosed materials

RP and EMDP need to be summarized and publicly disclosed to PAHs in different forms.

In terms of provincial and district level, REMDP materials need to be provided to Office of Provincial

and District PC as well as District Compensation Council and Minority Department with the full

versions and in Vietnamese.

In terms of communal level, Vietnamese summary will be placed at Office of CPC.

In terms of community, summary of REMDP will be distributed to head of villages’ houses in

Vietnamese.

Flyer of REMDP will be distributed to PAHs and archived at head of villages’ houses in Vietnamese.

(ii) Language of the materials

All of EM PAP can read, listen, write and speak Vietnamese fluently. According to people’s responses,

language of the materials can be Vietnamese with a clear printed version which is easy for them to

understand.

(iii) Steps of implementation and methods of consultation

The consultation needs to be done during the project preparation, implementation and operation. At

least, the following activities need to be done:

46

Consultation, information dissemination via flyers and publicity via loudspeakers regarding the

project information before conducting DMS;

Consultation and information disclosure via public meetings during the whole time of preparation

for the project;

Publicly posting results of DMS and applications of compensation price prior to payment;

Consultation and information disclosure via publicity and training about safe power network during

the project operation.

47

CHAPTER VI

COMPENSATION, SUPPORT AND LIVELIHOOD RESTORATION

6.1. Compensation

6.1.1 Compensation and Resettlement Objectives

Following the op 4.12 and the Government policies on land acquisition, compensation, assistance and

resettlement, the overall objectives of this resettlement policy are:

to avoid, if not, minimize resettlement impacts;

if impacts are unavoidable, the RAP is prepared in a way to ensure that affected persons are not

worse off; rather, they should be able to at least maintain or otherwise improve their pre-project

living standards and income-earning capacity. The Project should also provide an opportunity for

the local population to derive benefits from it. Likewise, the Project should serve as an occasion for

the local population to participate in its planning and implementation, thereby engendering a sense

of ownership over this development undertaking.

The main objectives and principles of WB on involuntary resettlement are:

Involuntary resettlement and loss of means of livelihood are to be avoided when feasible by

exploring all viable alternatives. When, after such an examination, avoidable is proved unfeasible,

effective measures to minimize impact and to compensate for losses must be agreed upon with

the people who will be affected;

People must be resettled involuntarily and people whose means of livelihood will be hindered or

lost must be sufficiently compensated and supported by project components etc. in a timely

manner. Host countries must make efforts to enable people affected by the project and to improve

their standard of living, income opportunities, and production levels, or at least to restore these to

per-project levels. Measures to achieve this may include: providing land and monetary

compensation for losses, supporting means for an alternative sustainable livelihood, and providing

the expenses necessary for the relocation and reestablishment for communities at resettlement

sites; and

Appropriate participation by affected people and their communities must be promoted in the

planning, implementation, and monitoring of resettlement action plans and measures to prevent

the loss of their means of livelihood.

In addition, appropriate and accessible grievance mechanisms must be established for the

affected people and their communities. For projects that will result in large –scale involuntary

resettlement, resettlement action plans must be prepared and made available to the public. In

preparing resettlement action plan, consultations must be held with the affected people and their

communities based on the sufficient information made available to them in advance. When

consultations are held, explanations must be given in a form, manner, and language that are

understandable to the affected people. It is desirable that, the resettlement action plan include

elements laid out in the World Bank Safeguard policy, OP 4.12.

48

6.1.2. The Compensation and Resettlement Principles

To achieve of the above objectives, the following principles are adopted:

a. The acquisition of land and other assets and resettlement of the project affected persons will

be minimized as much as possible.

b. All DPs residing, operating, working or cultivating land in the project area either permanently or

temporarily which identified or can prove that they have properties in the project affected areas

before the cut-off date are entitled to compensation, restoration and rehabilitation measures

sufficient to assist them to at least restore or otherwise improve their pre-project living

standards, income earning capacity and production levels. Lack of legal rights or

documentation will not bar DPs from entitlement to such measures.

c. No land recovery or site clearing will be done for the project construction in anticipation or

ahead of it being approved for inclusion in the project subject to this plan. Compensation will

be at the costs issued by local authority; no deductions of depreciation and for salvageable

materials.

d. The compensation measures will be provided include (i) in cash or in kind compensation for

houses and other structures with the unit compensation costs issued by local authorities.(ii)

productive land-for-land replacement of equal productive capacity or cash equivalent at full

Costs issued by local authorities if productive land is not available; (iii) replacement of

residential land of equal size , similar location, infrastructures and social services or cash

equivalent; (iv)cash compensation for renters; cash compensation for crops, trees and other

productive assets lost due to the project; (v) cash compensation for grave removal and

relocation; (vi) replacement or re-installation of utilities and facilities, such as water meters,

sanitation facilities, electric meters, telephone lines; and (vii) in cash or in kind compensation

for relocation of public works and other collective assets.

e. The restoration, rehabilitation measures to be provided include:

Stabilization and transport allowances for all DPs temporarily or permanently

displaced;

Resources or other income restoration/improvement programs (such as land

development, access to credit, training for farming and non-farm activities etc.,) to

assist the full restoration of income earning capacity of DPs. Livelihood restoration

programs will be developed to help DPs restore their living standards as soon as

possible.

Special assistance to vulnerable groups such as the poor, elderly; disable people;

women-headed households etc.

f. The resettlement sites will be as close as possible to the affected places and the previous

level of community infrastructures and social services will be maintained or improved.

g. The DPs will be consulted and will be given the opportunity to participate in through entire of

phased of RAP, from its preparation to implementation as well as to share with benefits of the

project.

49

h. Financial and physical resources for resettlement and rehabilitation will be made available as

and when required. Institutional arrangements will ensure effective preparation and

implementation of the DP.

i. Ongoing monitoring and evaluation of the implementation of the RAP will be carried out in

order to ensure that DP will be implemented effectively. A clear complaint and settling

mechanism will be developed to make sure that the DP will be fairly treated.

6.1.3. Project Displaced Person(s) DPs

The DPs include the following persons and organizations:

a. Persons whose houses and/or property are in part or in total affected by the Project;

b. Persons whose agricultural and/or residential land are in part or in total affected (permanently

or temporarily) by the Project;

c. Persons whose crops (annual or perennial) and trees are affected in part or in total by the

Project;

d. Persons who affected by land acquisition for the relocation sites, if required to be developed

for the project DPs.

Non-eligible DPs include those making claims based on subsequent occupation after the project cut-

off date.

The DPs are categorized into non-severely and severely affected DPs. The severely affected DPs

are the affected households who will (i) lose 10% or more of their total productive land and/or assets,

(ii) have to relocate; and/or (iii) lose 10% or more of their total income sources due to the Project. The

severely affected DPs and vulnerable affected groups will need special assistance to make sure that

the objective of RP is achieved.

6.1.4. Eligibility

The DPs eligible for compensation and rehabilitation will include:

a. Those who have formal legal rights to land or other assets;

b. Those who initially do not have formal legal rights to land or other assets but have a claim to

legal rights based upon the laws of the country; upon the possession of documents such as

land tax receipts and residence certificates; or upon permission of local authorities to occupy

or use the project affected plots; and

c. Those who have no recognizable legal right or claim to the land they are occupying.

Persons covered under (a) and (b) are provided compensation for the land they lose, and other

assistance. Persons covered under (c) are provided resettlement assistance, in lieu of compensation

for the land they occupy, and other assistance, as necessary, to achieve the objectives set out in this

policy, if they occupy the project area prior to the Cut-Off Date of the project.

6.1.5. Cut-off date

The cut-off-date means the date prior to which the occupation or use of any part of the project area

makes residents or occupiers or users of the same eligible to be recognized as DPs. For this Project,

the cut-off date is the date of IOL completion and it is 15 September 2012.

50

6.1.6. Project entitlement matrix

The project entitlements developed and presented in the entitlement matrix below correspond to the

impacts identified during the inventory of losses. Entitlements adopted are based on Government laws

and decisions of the involved PPCs on land acquisition, resettlement and assistance, and WB

guidelines on the involuntary resettlement’s impact considerations. It should be noted that these

entitlements may be enhanced, as necessary, following the conduct of DMS and consultation with DPs

to ensure that losses are restored and peoples’ livelihood are stabilized or improved.

51

Table 29. Entitlement Matrix

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of

entitled DPs Compensation Policy Implementation Issues

1 Temporary

acquisition of

productive land in

the right-of-way

(ROW)

All DPs who

have trees,

crops, other

assets in

ROW

DPs

with/without

land certificate

included in the

inventory or

able to prove

land occupancy

prior to cut-off

date

- Cash compensation for affected trees at the

replacement cost plus cost for cutting trees,

crops at market price. Number of crop

patterns to be compensated based on the

duration of temporary acquisition of land.

- No compensation for land

- Rehabilitate land after the project

construction.

- Trees that have to be cut are regulated by Article 7 of

the Government Decree 54/1999/ND-CP, July 8th,

1999 on the protection of the high voltage networks.

- TSHPCo and local authorities determine and ensure

that compensation for trees will be at the replacement

cost and for crops at the market price. If a DP is

requested to cut affected trees, PMBs will pay for this

work. The DP has the right to use salvageable trees.

- Full compensation at least 1 month before land

clearance. Payment to DPs will be delivered by

TSHPCo and District Resettlement Committees

(DRCs).

- Affected land in ROW will be rehabilitated by

contractors after the project construction and land in

ROW could be used with the restricted purposes.

- Finance available for compensation and ensuring

information disclosure/ dissemination to DPs and key

stake holders.

2 Temporary

acquisition of

residential and

garden land in ROW

without house or

structures in ROW

All DPs with

orchards or

trees in ROW

As above - Cash compensation for affected fruit trees

and trees at replacement cost.

- No compensation for land


construction.

- Article 5 of Decree 106/ND-CP of August 17, 2005 on

the protection of the high voltage networks and Article

1 of Decree 81/2009/ND-CP of October 12, 2009

amending Decree 106 regulate the cutting of trees in

the ROW.


52

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


that compensation for trees will be at replacement

cost. If a DP is requested to cut affected trees,

TSHPCo will pay for this work. The DP has the right to

use salvageable trees.

- Full compensation to DPs at least 01 month before

land clearance. Affected land in ROW will be

rehabilitated by contractors after the project

construction

- Payment to DPs will be delivered by PMUs and

DRCs

- Finance available for compensation and well

information disclose/ disseminate to DPs and key

stake holders.

3 Temporary impact

on residential and

garden land. Partial

house/building

within ROW (area in

ROW less than 10%

of total area) and

the demolished area

does not impact to

the remaining

house/building.

Residential land and

garden land outside

All DPs have

house/

building and

trees/ fruit

trees in ROW

As above House/ building:

- DP can opt for : i) Remain their houses or

building in ROW with the conditions

regulated by Article 6 of Decree 106/ND-CP

of August 17, 2005 on the protection of the

high voltage networks and Article 1 of

Decree 81/2009/ND-CP of October 12, 2009

amending Decree 106. Subsidy for fireproof

materials and lightning arrestors for the

existing house/building; or ii) Cash

compensation for the directly affected rooms

at the replacement cost and cost for




amending Decree 106 regulate which houses and

buildings must be demolished and which can remain in

the ROW.


that compensation will be paid at the replacement

cost, without deduction for salvageable materials.

- DPs will demolish the impacted part/ room and

reconstruct/or improve their houses themselves.

- Full compensation for trees and fruit trees at least 01

53

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


of ROW is sufficient

for re-organizing

(not less than 60

m2)

demolishing an affected room.

- No compensation for land.


construction by contractors.

Tree and fruit tree

- Compensation for affected trees and fruit

trees at the replacement cost.

Allowances:

- Subsistence allowance of 20 kg of rice

equivalent per person per month for 24

months

month before land clearance. If DP is requested for

cutting affected trees, PC or project provinces will pay

money for this work. DP has right for using

salvageable trees.

- Full entitlement payment to DPs impacted on

house/building at least 03 months before land

clearance.

- Payment to DPs will be delivered by TSHPCo and

DRCs

- Land in ROW could be used with restricted purposes.

- Finance available for compensation and information

to be fully disclosed/ disseminated to DPs and all key

stake holders.

4 Temporary impact

on residential and or

garden land. Impact

more than 10% or

less than 10% of

total house/building

area but the

demolished area will

impact to the

remaining of

house/structure.

Land outside of

ROW is sufficient for

All DPs who

have house/

building and

trees/ fruit

trees in ROW

As above House/ building:

- DP can opt for : i) Remain their houses or

building in ROW with the conditions

regulated by Article 6 of Decree 106/ND-CP

of August 17, 2005 on the protection of the

high voltage networks and Article 1 of

Decree 81/2009/ND-CP of October 12, 2009

amending Decree 106. Subsidy for fireproof

materials and lightning arrestors for the

existing house/building; or ii) Cash

compensation at replacement cost for full

areas of impacted house/building and

- Which house and building has to be demolished and

which can remain is regulated by Article 6 of Decree

106/ND-CP of August 17, 2005 on the protection of the

high voltage networks and Article 1 of Decree

81/2009/ND-CP of October 12, 2009 amending

Decree 106.

- Consultation for DP’s options on to remain their

house in ROW or to move out of ROW.


that compensation will be replacement cost at the time

of payment.

54

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


reorganizing (not

less than 60 m2).

demolish DP’s house in ROW.

- No compensation for land.


construction by contractors.

Tree and fruit tree

- Compensation for affected trees and fruit


Allowances:

- Subsistence allowance of 20 kg of rice

equivalent per person per month in 24

months.

- DPs will demolish the impacted areas and

reconstruct/or improve their houses themselves.

- Full compensation for trees and fruit trees to DPs at

least 01 month before land clearance. If DP is

requested for cutting affected trees, TSHPCo will pay

money for this work. DP has right for using

salvageable trees.

- Full compensation payment for impacted house and

allowances to DPs at least 03 months before land

clearance.


DRCs

- Cleared residential could be reused with other

restricted purposes.

- Finance available for compensation/ rehabilitation

and well information disclose/ disseminate

5 Temporary impact

on residential and or

garden land in

ROW. Full or partial

house/building

impacted and land

outside of is not

sufficient for

reorganizing (less

All DPs have

house, building

or trees,

including fruit

trees in ROW

As above DPs can opt for one of the following:

i) Remain in their houses or building in ROW

with the conditions regulated by Article 6 of

Decree 106/ND-CP of August 17, 2005 on the

protection of the high voltage networks and

Article 1 of Decree 81/2009/ND-CP of October

12, 2009 amending Decree 106. Subsidy

allowance for fireproof materials and lightning




amending Decree 106 on the protection of the high

voltage networks regulates which houses and

buildings must be demolished and which can remain in

the ROW. Article 6 of Decree 106 and Article 1 of

Decree 81 regulates which trees must be removed.

- Consultation on DPs’ options on remaining in their

55

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


than 60 m2) arrestors for the existing house/building; or

ii) Cash compensation for the whole

residential area which DP occupied (not only

for the impacted areas) and properties

associated with occupied land at replacement

cost. Impacted land will be obtained by local

authorities; or

iii) “Land for land” with the same area which

DP occupied and cash at replacement cost for

the affected assets associated with land. Land

occupied by DP will be obtained by local

authorities.

- Article 5 of Decree 106/ND-CP of August 17,

2005 on the protection of the high voltage

networks and Article 1 of Decree 81/2009/ND-

CP of October 12, 2009 amending Decree 106

regulates which trees may be retained in the

ROW. Compensation for affected trees and

fruit trees at the replacement cost.

Allowances:

- Transportation allowance for relocating DP of

3 million VND if moving within province and 5

million VND if moving outside province.

- Supplemental allowance for HH not moving

to a resettlement site of 1 million if remaining

houses in ROW or move out of ROW


that compensation will be at replacement cost at the

time of payment.

- Replacement land, and resettlement sites

development.

- DPs receiving compensation will demolish the

impacted house areas and reconstruct or improve their

houses themselves.

- Full compensation payment for trees and fruit trees to

DPs at least 01 month before land clearance. If a DP

is requested to cut affected trees, TSHPCo will pay for

this work. The DP has the right to use salvageable

trees.

- Full compensation for impacted house and


clearance.


DRCs

- Cleared residential areas could be used with other

restricted purposes.

- Finance/ land available for rehabilitation and

restoration and ensure information disclosure/

dissemination to DPs and key stake holders.

56

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


within province and 2 million if moving to

another.

- All relocating DPs shall, for a period of 24

months receive a cash allowance equal to 20

kg of rice per month for each family member,

calculated at the average monthly price.

- Production disruption allowance if DPs

permanently lose business or more than 10%

of their incomes of 3 million VND for one

person and 2 million VND for every additional

person of working age in HH.

- Bonus/incentive for relocating in a timely

manner: maximum 5 million VND/HH

- Other relocation allowances for health care:

200,000 VND per DP; lighting: 10,000 VND

per DP per month for six months; school

books: 100,000 VND per pupil; and 1 million

VND per person in HH if HH has poor family

book, single elderly, disabled or seriously ill

person.

- TSHPCo and local authorities will consult with DP

who are eligible to restoration programs for their

options and prepare proposal for restoration programs

in the period of RAP implementation.

6 Permanent

acquisition of land for

tower foundations,

substation and

access roads etc.

All DPs

occupying land

and properties

associated with

land

permanently

As above For DP losing productive land:

a. Land loss less than 10% of their total

landholdings and remaining land is viable

- Cash compensation for the lost area if

the remaining plot is still economically

- Consultation with DPs on their options for land

compensation.


that compensation will be at replacement cost at the

time of payment.

57

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


impacted by

towers

foundations,

substation and

access roads

etc.

viable.

- Cash compensation for the whole

impacted plot if the remaining plot is not

economically viable.

- Cash compensation for properties

associated with land

b. Land loss equal or more than 10% of

their total landholdings or remaining land is not

viable:

DP can opt for the following:

i)“Land for land” with the same area and

productive of impacted area if the

remaining plots are still economic viable

and for the whole impacted plots if the

remaining plots are not economically

viable.

ii) Cash for land at the replacement cost.

- Compensation for trees and affected fruit


- Rehabilitation assistance

c. Allowance

- DPs, who are involved in agricultural

production, will receive an allowance in cash

as follows (i) equal to 30kg of

- Replacement land, and resettlement sites

development.

- DPs receiving compensation will demolish the

impacted areas and reconstruct/or improve their

houses themselves.

- Full compensation for trees and fruit trees to DPs at

least 01 month before land clearance. If a DP is

requested to cut affected trees, TSHPCo will pay for

this work. The DP has the right to use salvageable

trees.

- Full compensation for impacted house and


clearance.

- Compensation and reorganizing houses or relocation

must be complete before starting civil works.

- Payment to DPs will be delivered by PCs and DRCs

- Finance/ land available for compensation/

rehabilitation and ensure information disclosure/

dissemination.

- TSHPCos and local authorities will consult with DPs

who are eligible for restoration on their options and

prepare proposal for restoration programs in the period

of RAP implementation.

- DPs will be granted Land Use Right Certificate

58

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


rice/person/month for a period of 6 months if

DPs lose between 10% and 70% of their

agricultural land holdings; (ii) equal to 30kg of

rice/person/month for a period of 12 months if

DPs lose greater than 70% of agricultural land

holdings.

- Support to job transfer and employment

creation: DPs, who are involved in agricultural

production and do not receive land for land

compensation for their agricultural land

acquired by the project, will be entitled to cash

allowance equal to 1.5 to 5.0 times the

agricultural land price for the acquired area of

agricultural land in addition to the cash

compensation at replacement cost. The land

area which is eligible for allowance shall not

exceed the limit of agricultural land allocation

permitted in the province. The Provincial

People’s Committee stipulates the allowance

rate suitable for local conditions.

For DP losing Residential and garden land:

- If remaining land is sufficient for reorganizing

(not less than 60 m2): Cash compensation for

lost area and assets associated with land.

- If remaining land is not sufficient for

without payment of administrative fees.

59

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


reorganizing:

DP can opt for

i) cash compensation at replacement cost for

land and assets on land, or

ii) “land for land” compensation for the whole

residential area which DP occupied (not only

for the impacted areas) and properties

associated with occupied land. For affected

house and building, the same entitlement to

DP of categories 3 or 4 or 5.

7 DP impacted on

business or other

services

All DPs

impacted on

business and

other services

-do- (a) Temporary impact on business or other

services.

Compensation for income lost in the affected

time

(b) Permanent impact on business or other

services.

Rehabilitation assistance.

- Full compensation for incomes lost to DPs at least 01

month before land clearance.

- TSHPCo and local authorities will consult with DP

who are eligible to rehabilitation for their options and

prepare proposal for rehabilitation programs in the

period of RP implementation.

8 Public structures

– Temporary

impacts

All impacted

institutional

DPs

(who directly

manage and

operate such

All impacted

institutional DPs

shall be

approached in

advance for

cooperation in

• Alternative measures to maintain the

normal functioning of the public works (i.e.

roads, water supply, drainage systems,

telephone lines etc.)

• Reinstatement after project construction.

Contract(s) with Contractor(s) should include one

article on this specific responsibility of the

contractor(s):

• approach the institutional DPs for cooperation;

60

No. Type of Losses

Scope of

application

Definition of


impacted

public works

systems)

impact mitigation

measures as

well as

measures for

maintaining the

normal

functioning of

their impacted

systems by the

Contractor(s)

• All expenses on alternative measures to

maintain the normal functioning of the

impacted systems shall be borne by

Contractor(s).

• arrange and pay for the expenses of the alternative

measures to maintain the normal functioning of the

impacted systems to the satisfaction of the institutional

DPs.

– Permanent

impacts

- do - - do - • Alternative measures to maintain the

normal functioning of the public works (i.e.

roads, water supply, drainage systems,

telephone lines etc.)

• All expenses on alternative measures to

maintain the normal functioning of the

impacted systems shall be borne by

Contractor(s).

- do –

• complete the works for ‘alter native solutions’ prior to

the commencement of the project works.

9

Permanent impacts

on rented houses

All DPs

impacted on

their leased

houses for

residential

purposes

DPs with house

lease contract

Tenants who have leased a house for

residential purposes will be provided with a

cash grant of six months rental fee at the

prevailing market rate in the area.

TSHPCo and local authorities will assist them in

identifying alternative accommodation.

61

6.2. Support and income restoration

Support Policy

Experience shows that, unless mitigated, involuntary resettlement resulting from development projects

often gives rise to severe economic, social, and environmental problems: production systems are

dismantled; people face impoverishment when their affected productive assets or income sources are not

replaced.

In addition, there are people who on account of their position in society and/or their physical and

economic situation are less capable of re-establishing themselves than the others and, therefore, face

greater risks of impoverishment. Assistances through different types of allowances and economic

restoration plan is needed to be developed in order to make sure that the project affected person will not

be worse off or otherwise improved their livelihood and living standards at new places. The Decree

69/2009/ND-CP has improved its provision of compensation and assistance to affected households,

especially those who depend heavily on agricultural production as their main source of income.

Results of the consultations with the stakeholders described in the Consultation and Participation Chapter

show that most of the severely affected households wish to receive cash to restore livelihoods by

themselves.

Table 30. Preferences of the PAHs for compensation for productive land

No. Commune

If agricultural land or other productive land is affected, which options for

compensation the household will choose?

Land for land Compensation in

cash Not yet decided Total

HH % HH % HH % HH %

1 Hoa Binh 11

262

11

284

1.1 Mai Chau 11

262

11

284

1.1.1 Tong Dau 9 15.30% 46 78.00% 4 6.80% 59 100.00%

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 1 4.50% 17 77.30% 4 18.20% 22 100.00%

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 1 2.30% 42 95.50% 1 2.30% 44 100.00%

1.1.4 Mai Ha 0 0.00% 28 96.60% 1 3.40% 29 100.00%

1.1.5 Van Mai 0 0.00% 108 99.10% 1 0.90% 109 100.00%

1.1.6 Mai Hich 0 0.00% 21 100.00% 0 0.00% 21 100.00%

2 Thanh Hoa 0

4

0

4

2.1 Quan Hoa 0

4

0

4

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 0 0.00% 4 100.00% 0 0.00% 4 100.00%

Total 11 3.80% 266 92.40% 11 3.80% 288 100.00%

Source: Survey Data

The percent of PAHs wish to receive compensation in cash for their losses are approximately 100%. Only

a small number of PAHs have not decided, mainly in Mai Chau Town with 18.2% of the PAHs said that

62

they had not selected either cash compensation or land-for-land compensation. Only 3.8% of the

surveyed opted to land-for-land compensation, mainly in Tong Dau Commune (9 households, accounting

for 3.1%).

People tend to use their compensation money on repairing or building new houses, with more than a half

of the households indicated that in the survey (55.2%). Details of households who plan to use

compensation as a make up for their affected livelihoods are as follows:

- Investing in agricultural activities or livestock husbandry: 18.7%;

- Investing in their children’s study: 12.1%;

- Depositing to the bank: 5.5%

- Buying land: 3.8%

- Investing in small business: 3.4%

Concerning the income restoration activities, the PAHs give their plans focusing on some activities to find

alternative income sources to replace their affected ones as follows:

- 54.8% plans to buy new land to re-establish production;

- 16.3% will open small shops;

- 16.3% will find new jobs;

- 5.8% will shift to business and services sector;

- 4.7% will be engaged in handicraft; and

- 2.3% will re-establish their businesses after the temporary impacts caused by the project are

over.

(See the table below for more details)

63

Table 31. Plan for using compensation cash of the surveyed PAHs

No. Commune

How is the household going to use the compensation?

Build/ repair

house Buy new land

Buy new

utensils

Invest in

small

business

Bank deposit

Spend on

children’s

study

Invest in

cultivation/

livestock

husbandry

Others Total

HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH %

1 Hoa Binh 157

11

1

10

16

35

52

2

284

1.1 Mai Chau 157

11

1

10

16

35

52

2

284

1.1.1 Tong Dau 36 61.00% 3 5.10% 0 0.00% 1 1.70% 2 3.40% 9 15.30% 8 13.60% 0 0.00% 59 100%

1.1.2 Mai Chau

Town 12 54.50% 3 13.60% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 3

13.60

% 1 4.50% 3 13.60% 0 0.00% 22 100%

1.1.3 Chieng

Chau 21 47.70% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 3 6.80% 0 0.00% 9 20.50% 9 20.50% 2 4.50% 44 100%

1.1.4 Mai Ha 16 55.20% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 1 3.40% 2 6.90% 2 6.90% 8 27.60% 0 0.00% 29 100%

1.1.5 Van Mai 61 56.00% 5 4.60% 1 0.90% 4 3.70% 8 7.30% 9 8.30% 21 19.30% 0 0.00% 109 100%

1.1.6 Mai Hich 11 52.40% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 1 4.80% 1 4.80% 5 23.80% 3 14.30% 0 0.00% 21 100%

2 Thanh

Hoa 2

0

0

0

0

0

2

0

4

2.1 Quan Hoa 2

0

0

0

0

0

2

0

4

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 2 50.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 2 50.00% 0 0.00% 4 100%

Total 159

11

1

10

16

35

54

2

288

64

Table 32. Plans of the surveyed PAHs for alternative income sources

No. Commune

What is the household’s plan to replace production activity/income source from agricultural land and/or restore affected business?

Buy new

agricultural

land for

production

activities

Re-establish

business in

the new place

Business Open small

shops Handicraft Find new jobs Others Total

HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH % HH %

1 Hoa Binh 47 2 5 14 4 14 0 86

1.1 Mai Chau 47 2 5 14 4 14 0 86

1.1.1 Tong Dau 15 65.20% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 2 8.70% 0 0.00% 6 26.10% 0 0.00% 23 100.00%

1.1.2 Mai Chau Town 5 71.40% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 2 28.60% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 7 100.00%

1.1.3 Chieng Chau 11 68.80% 0 0.00% 1 6.30% 4 25.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 16 100.00%

1.1.4 Mai Ha 5 71.40% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 1 14.30% 1 14.30% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 7 100.00%

1.1.5 Van Mai 11 35.50% 1 3.20% 3 9.70% 5 16.10% 3 9.70% 8 25.80% 0 0.00% 31 100.00%

1.1.6 Mai Hich 0 0.00% 1 50.00% 1 50.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 2 100.00%

2 Thanh Hoa 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

2.1 Quan Hoa 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

2.1.1 Phu Thanh 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00% 0 0.00%

Total 47 54.70% 2 2.30% 5 5.80% 14 16.30% 4 4.70% 14 16.30% 0 0.00% 86 100.00%

65

The following assistances will be provided for the PAPs to ensure that they can restore their income

affected partly by the project implementation:

(a) DPs losing agricultural/productive land and crops:

i. if the portion of the land to be lost represents 10% or less of the total area of the landholding,

and the remaining land is still a viable economic holding, cash compensation, at full

replacement cost for the acquired area may be provided to the DP.

ii. if the portion of the land to be lost is more than 10% of the total area of the landholding or the

remaining holding is not viable then the project will acquire the entire landholding and provide

"land for land" arrangements of equal productive capacity, satisfactory to the DP. However, if

the DP prefers to receive cash instead of land, then cash compensation at replacement cost

is applied.

iii. DPs will be compensated for the loss of standing crops at market price; productive trees will

be compensated at replacement cost.

iv. DPs whose land is temporarily taken by the works under the project will be compensated for

their loss of income, standing crops and for the cost of soil restoration and damaged

infrastructure. Land will be rehabilitated after the project construction by NPPMB or TSHPMB

as the case may be.

(b) DPs will also be provided compensation at full replacement cost, without deduction for depreciation

and salvage materials for any other fixed assets affected in part or in total by the project, such as tombs and

water wells, etc.

In cases where community infrastructure such as schools, factories, water sources, roads, sewage systems

is damaged, NPPMB or TSHPMB will ensure that these would be restored or repaired as the case may be,

at no cost to the community.

Besides the direct compensation for the losses, DPs will also be entitled to additional assistance

(subsidies/allowances) as below:

Livelihood Allowance

DPs, who are involved in agricultural production, will receive an allowance in cash as follows (i) equal to

30kg of rice/person/month for a period of 6 months if DPs lose between 10% and 70% of their agricultural

land holdings; (ii) equal to 30kg of rice/person/month for a period of 12 months if DPs lose greater than

70% of agricultural land holdings.

Production disruption allowance

DPs, who are permanently affected by losing more than 10% of productive land or incomes, or have to

relocate will be entitled to training or other economic restoration programs at 3,000,000 VND for one

person and a further 2 million VND for every additional person in the household.

Support to job transfer and employment creation

DPs, who are involved in agricultural production and do not receive land for land compensation for their

agricultural land acquired by the project, will be entitled to cash allowance equal to 1.5 to 5.0 times the

agricultural land price for the acquired area of agricultural land in addition to the cash compensation at

replacement cost. The land area which is eligible for allowance shall not exceed the limit of agricultural

land allocation permitted in the province. The Provincial People’s Committee stipulates the allowance

rate suitable for local conditions.

66

However, the consultation results show that the PAPs wish to receive assistances in cultivation and

livestock husbandry activities, job conversion and access to loans.

Based on result of consultation with local authorities, various organizations and affected households, the

subproject construction did not impact greatly on PAHs’ livelihood sources, including EM ones. However,

impacts on income sources and ability to restore income of people need to be monitored strictly.

Independent monitoring unit and internal monitoring activities need to review and observe these impacts.

In cases adverse impacts, identified as resulted from construction of subproject, affect PAHs’ living

standard, the following activities/programs are listed below are considered as the subproject’s livelihood

restoration program:

Prioritize employment for qualified persons of both genders during the construction and

operation of the Project.

Cooperate with local authorities to implement vocational training and provide non-agricultural

jobs to PAHs. These programs should be discussed between Trung Son HPP and the local

authorities in order to prioritize PAHs among currently implementing vocational training

activities according to Decision No. 1956 of Prime Minister on approval of Vocational training

project for rural labour until 2020.

Maximize the number of the affected households to the loans which available in the localities

as Decision No. 52/2012/QD-TTg on policy supporting and resolving jobs and

vocational training for labours who are acquired agricultural land.

As it is a component of Trung Son Hydropower Project, these technical assistances activities should

focus on the severely affected households of the subproject and be closely supervised by the livelihood

consulting expert as well as officials from the environmental and social group. During the implementation

period, if any potentially adverse impact that may worse the existing impacts on the PAHs is identified,

the livelihood activities should be in place for these households in accordance with the income restoration

program framework of Trung Son Hydropower Project.

67

CHAPTER VII

ETHNIC MINORITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND GENDER STRATEGY

The subproject construction impacts on 288 households, including 249 EM households of which majority

are Thai people community. The project impacts on permanent as well as temporary land acquisition and

this only affect slightly the people’s livelihood. During design process, mitigation methods to avoid

maximum impacts on production land (especially the people’s rice crop land) were implemented via

choosing one best solution for the line, including choosing conductor and route which traverses

residential areas the least; therefore, impacts on houses and residential land of people as well as

relocation of their houses were mitigated to the greatest extent.

The construction of 35kV line and Mai Chau 110kV substation does not bring direct benefits to PAP due

to not providing electricity for living or develop production directly. Positive impacts of the project are

provision of electricity for main construction which causes long-term increasing impacts in general

promotion of regional and national GDP.

In order to mitigate adverse impacts of the subproject construction on EM PAPs, a legal framework for

EM of the project was built and approved in October 2010. According to the regulation, an EMDP need to

be built for the project. As the DPs of the Project belong to the ethnic minority communities, resettlement

activities described above are also a part of the Ethnic Minority Development Plan.

Negative impacts of land acquisition, impacts on livelihood, environment as well as the project scale were

presented in consultation meeting with PAP and EM PAP, of which nearly 100% of representatives of

PAHs participating. In-depth interviews with village and family leaders as well as prestigious people in

Thai community were conducted in the communes. Responses from the consultation and in-depth

interviews focus on following main ideas:

Completely in support the project construction;

The project causes minor impacts, does not affect the community structure, livelihood as well as

worship places and sacred land area of Thai ethnic community;

Compensation and support in cash, directly payment for PAHs;

The compensation and support should be conducted once and the compensation activities should

be informed soon to people as planned;

The information dissemination activities can use Vietnamese because people mostly can read,

write, listen and communicate directly by Vietnamese.

So as to ensure mitigation of impacts on land acquisition and negative impacts of the project construction

on EM community as well as compliance with EM cultural customs, following content will be observed:

The project will not agree to land acquisition from ethnic minority peoples if they have not

provided their broad support;

Affected ethnic minorities participate in the preparation of any land acquisition;

If directly affected by a project, ethnic minorities are entitled to compensation for all lost land and

affected assets, incomes and businesses at replacement costs and provided with rehabilitation

measures sufficient to assist them to improve or at least maintain their pre-project living

standards, incomes and productive capacity;

Lack of legal rights to assets and access lost or adversely affected will not bar them from

entitlement to such compensation and rehabilitation measures;

Compensation for ethnic minorities, female headed-households, families with the disabled or

elderly will be carried out with respect for their cultural values and specific needs.

68

Besides, the EMDP and Gender Strategy added a number of specific activities to ensure the project

benefits for EMs and women in the project. The following activities will be done:

Consultation meeting on resettlement activities will be held separately with women, female

headed households and elderly women;

The district compensation committees will include representatives from district and commune

Women’s Union and women from affected households;

At the inception of the project, a capacity building training program on resettlement activities will

be designed for the women and men commune officials, and women and men from affected

households to orient them about resettlement activities. Participation of poor women, female

headed households and ethnic in the training will be ensured; The training will also include

representatives from the Project Management Board, respective line agencies and

representatives from commune Women’s Union, Youth Union involved in resettlement

committees;

The training will include information on resettlement activities, compensation, management of

compensation money, grievance procedures and impact of the project on livelihood activities

related to loss of agricultural produce, and other productive assets. The objective of the training is

to provide affected communities with understanding of resettlement issues and better access to

compensation resources and information on grievance procedures; ensure participation of

women/ EM women in training activity;

During the conduct of the DMS in the RAP implementation phase, men and women from PAHs

will participate in the said activity;

Livelihood activities will be planned with active involvement of women; need assessment for

livelihood activities and skill development of livelihood activities will be conducted separately for

women members, poor women, female-headed households, elderly women, ethnic minority

women;

Compensation payment and cash assistance will be given to both men and women from the

households; Specific attention will be provided for the poor women headed households, elderly

women in paying the compensation on time and developing suitable livelihood activities for

elderly and poor female headed households;

Joint registration of land rights in the names of husband and wife and female headed households

will be issued in instances where land is acquired;

Special measures will be taken in the relocation of elderly, disabled and female headed

households. Special support will be added.

Disaggregated monitoring indicators by gender will be developed for monitoring of Social

benefits, economic opportunities, livelihood program, and resettlement activities.

69

CHAPTER VIII

IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS

8.1 Implementation arrangement

The institutional arrangement for the preparation and implementation of RAP is clearly guided by Chapter

VI of the Decree 197/2004-ND-CP and Chapter V of the Decree 84/2007-ND-CP. The responsibilities of

key parties are described in Decree 197/2004; 184/2007 and in the decisions on land acquisition of

Thanh Hoa and Hoa Binh Provincial People’s Committees. The below description is just to summarize on

the responsibilities of the key relevant parties.

8.1.1. PC at different levels

PPC will have following responsibilities:

a. Generate awareness on the project development to all relevant institutions and various

administrative levels.

b. Direct their relevant departments such as Departments of finance, construction, agriculture

and rural development, transport and environment and natural resources to help in the

implementation of the RAP.

c. Approve the general compensation and resettlement plan and entitlement for each affected

HH and overall budget in the RAP.

d. Aware of and resolve unsolved complaints at lower levels.

District PC will have following responsibilities:

a. Guide, organize, inform and mobilize organizations and individuals regarding compensation,

support, and resettlement and site clearance in accordance with relating policies;

b. Guide District Compensation, Support and Resettlement Board to organize the implementation

of compensation, support and resettlement plan as well as EMDP. Approve the

compensation, support and resettlement plan when PPC assigns.

c. Cooperate with departments, organizations, agents and project owners to conduct the project

and implement RP and EMDP as authorized by PPC; and

d. Redress grievances of PAP in terms of compensation, support and resettlement; and

e. Cooperate with other departments relating to the implementation of site clearance,

resettlement and EMDP.

8.1.2. Trung Son Hydropower Company Limited (TSHPCo)

The TSHPCo will have the following key responsibilities related to compensation, assistance and

resettlement:

a. Preparing, updating and implementing RP, EMDP and collaboration with the People’s

Committees at various levels in implementation of the plans.

b. Develop and implement a training program on the capacity building for the Affected People’s

Committees and Mai Chau, Quan Hoa District Compensation and Resettlement Boards and

related groups regarding the RAP implementation.

70

c. Secure the budget for preparation and implementation of the RAP, ensure that funds for

compensation, assistance and resettlement are available and in a timely manner.

d. Coordinate with the Thanh Hoa and Hoa Binh PPCs to direct their relevant departments and

various levels of authorities in implementing the project and RAP.

e. Arrange for grievance officers and monitor/track/report on grievances related to the Project.

f. Conduct internal monitoring of RAP, updating, implementation and evaluation and ensure

that resettlement-related activities are carried out in accordance with the RAP approved by

WB and GOV.

g. Oversee the disclosure of resettlement related documents and consultation with DPs and

key stakeholders

h. Prepare quarterly progress reports on the, preparation, updating and implementation of RAP

to EVN and WB.

i. Coordinate with External Resettlement Monitoring Agency

8.1.3. District Compensation, Assistance and Resettlement Board

The District Compensation and Resettlement Board will be headed by the Vice-Chairman of DPC, and

will include the heads of the Finance Department, the Natural Resources and Environment Department,

and the Agriculture Department. In addition, representatives of the district Fatherland Front, Farmers’

Associations, Women’s Union and representatives of the DPs (including women DPs) will also be invited

to the District Compensation and Resettlement Board.

The main responsibilities of the District Compensation and Resettlement Board are as follows:

a. Assist the DPCs in the dissemination of information on the RAP;

b. Organize, plan and carry out land recovery, compensation, assistance and other resettlement

activities in the district on behalf of the DPC as per agreed RAP

c. Submit compensation plans to DPC for its review

d. Conduct consultation and participation activities, income restoration program, and coordination

with various stakeholders in implementing RAP and EMDP.

e. Supervise the payment of compensation and allowances, subsidies to DPs. Ensure the timely

delivery of payments of compensation, assistance and other entitlements to DPs; and

f. Assist the DPC in the resolution of grievances at the district level.

8.1.4. Commune People’s Committee

The Affected commune authorities are responsible for its compensation, assistance and resettlement

tasks. Specifically, they will be responsible for the following:

a. Handle the day-to-day preparation, updating, and implementation of the RAP

b. Form the commune working teams and direct their functions, assign officials to assist the District

Compensation and Resettlement Board in conducting DMS, preparing dossiers of land recovery

for the project, preparation and implementation of resettlement activities;

c. Identify the possibility of the replacement land for eligible DPs and propose for income restoration

programs suitable to conditions of people and locality;

71

d. Sign the DMS forms, certify legal papers or history of land use, land transfer for DPs to fulfill the

requirements for preparing compensation plans for them;

e. Settle the complaint and grievances at the first level as required by the laws;

f. Actively participate in all land recovery, compensation payment, assistance and resettlement

activities and concerns.

8.2. Grievance redress mechanism

A well-defined grievance redress and resolution mechanism will be established to address DP grievances

and complaints regarding land acquisition, compensation and resettlement in a timely and satisfactory

manner. All DPs will be made fully aware of their rights, and the detailed procedures for filing grievances

and an appeal process will be publicized through an effective public information campaign. The grievance

redress mechanism and appeal procedures will also be explained in the PIB that will be distributed to all

DPs.

DPs are entitled to file complaints regarding any aspect of the land acquisition and resettlement

requirements such as, entitlements, rates and payment and procedures for resettlement and income

restoration programs. DP complaints can be made verbally or in written form. In the case of verbal

complaints, the committee hearing the complaint will be responsible to make a written record during the

first meeting with the DP.

Complaint and settlement of the complaint are guided as in Article 138 of Land law (2003), Articles 162,

163 and 174 of Decree 181/2004/ND-CP instructing on the land law implementation, Articles 63, 64 of

Decree 84/2004 and Decree 136/2006/ND-CP on the Complaint.

Based on the above, four-stage procedure for redress of grievances is proposed as follows:

Step 1: If any individual complains about any sides of the resettlement and livelihood program, he can

complain in verbal or written with the commune authority. CPC will deal with complaints in 15 days since

receiving them.

Step 2: If the claimant does not satisfy with the decision in step 1, he can file a claim District People’s

Committee within 15 days since receiving it. District People’s Committee will make a decision in 15 days.

Step 3: If the claimant sill does not satisfy with decision at district level, he can file the claim Province

People’s Committee within 15 days since receiving the decision of District People’s Committee. Province

People’s Committee will make a decision within 15 days.

Step 4: If the claimant sill does not satisfy with decision of Province People’s Committee, the complaints

will be sent to District Court in 15 days since the decision of Province People’s Committee was delivered.

District Court will make a decision within 15 days.

The external monitoring agency will be responsible for checking the procedures for and resolutions of

grievances and complaints. The said EMA may recommend further measures to be taken to redress

unresolved grievances.

8.3. Monitoring and evaluation

TSHPMB will conduct periodical monitoring RP implementation, with close cooperation with

correspondent PC at various administrative unit levels and independent monitoring units. Findings will be

included in monthly report sent to EVN.

72

Internal monitoring will

(a) Verify that primary information of DP were implemented and valuation of lost or damaged

properties as well as provision of compensation, benefits of resettlement and life restoration will

be conducted in compliance with TOR of the policy framework and RP.

(b) Monitor whether RP is conducted in accordance with design and approval.

(c) Verify if budget for RP implementation is provided timely and sufficiently to achieve those

objectives and the budget is used in compliance with TOR in RP and the policy framework,

(d) Archive all grievances and grievance redress as well as make sure these grievances are

redressed in time,

Independent monitoring

Due to the impact of the construction of the substation and 35 kV power line does not affect many

households and the maximum execution time line is 09 months, beginning in January 2013. So, the

proposed internal monitoring group of TSHPCo will perform the functions and tasks of independent social

monitoring for this item.

Besides verification of information provided in monitoring reports and internal monitoring of respondent

PC, independent monitoring unit will visit about 10% of DP households along the electric line twice a year,

which starts before the civil construction implementation and continues until all RP’s necessary activities

are conducted sufficiently. All of the consultants or external monitoring units will:

(a) Verify whether procedure of DP’s participation and compensation as well as benefits

regarding other restoration are implemented in compliance with RP or not; and

(b) Evaluate whether objectives of the Policy Framework, which are to increase or at least

restore living standard and income of DP, are achieved or not.

(c) Collect quantitative indicators regarding socio-economic impacts of the project

implementation on DPs.

(d) Propose amendment during implementation of the subprojects, depending on each case, in

order to achieve principles and objectives of the RP.

8.4. Implementation of Resettlement Plan

8.4.1. Implementation process

The implementation process of the subprojects, depending on cases, in order to meet the objectives and

principles of the subprojects is summarized as follows:

(a) Determine boundary of the project’s site clearance: After receiving Decision of District PC and

District Compensation and Resettlement Board on land acquisition and hand over to TS HPP to conduct

the project, PMU will cooperate with District Compensation Council and CPCs to determine the

subproject’s site clearance boundary and verify it in the field site, hand over site to conduct

compensation, support and resettlement for PAP in order to do site clearance for the project. District

Compensation Council and CPC related to the project will assign professional staffs who are members of

District Compensation and Resettlement Board to participate in this activity.

(b) Training for resettlement staffs: TSHPCo will prepare and conduct a training program on RP

implementation. The training will include at least the objectives of RP, EMDP, agents’ responsibilities in

updating and implementing RP, EMDP and resolving/being aware of/reporting claims and grievances,

73

consultation/participation of PAP, gender issues and strategy, internal monitoring and report. Target

objects of the training program include representatives from PACs.

(c) Information campaign before inventory and DMS: According to Decree No. 181/2004/ND-CP,

before land acquisition, during 90 days for agricultural land and 180 days for non-agricultural land, District

Compensation and Resettlement Board need to inform via document to owner of acquired land about

reason of land acquisition, time and relocation plan, compensation, site clearance and resettlement

options.

Before conducting inventory and DMS, TS HPP cooperates with local district and communal authorities to

disclose the project information to people in the project area. The information will be broadcasted via local

loudspeaker system and other media means of communication such as radio, newspaper, TV, and

project information flyers which are distributed to the households are posted publicly at the public areas.

Oriented meetings will be held at PACs to inform the community impacts on: The project scale; Impacts;

Policies and benefits responding types of impacts; Schedule; Stakeholders’ responsibilities; Grievance

redress unit; The project handbook (pictures or books) related to the project implementation will be

prepared and distributed to all PACs during the meetings.

(d) Detailed Measurement Survey (DMS) will be conducted after detailed design is available. These

surveys will form a basis to make compensation plan and RP.

(e) Making compensation plan: District compensation and resettlement council has responsibility to

apply price and prepare compensation tables for each of PACs. These tables will be evaluated by District

PC regarding prices, amount of affected properties and benefits of PAP, etc before informing and posting

at CPC for people considering and giving opinions. All of the compensation, support and resettlement

plans need to be checked and signed by PAP.

(f) Cooperation in preparing and implementing income restoration methods: TSHPP cooperate with

District PC, Compensation and Resettlement Council as well as related departments to prepare training

courses for severely and vulnerable PAHs who have demand on vocational training. These courses will

be provided by decision 1956 and 52 of Prime Minister on provision of free training to people who are

acquired agricultural land.

(g) RP implementation: Compensation and support will be paid directly to PAP with the witness of

representative of PAC authorities and PAHs.

(h) Implementation notice: is only issued by TS HPP for civil construction and installation contracts to

conduct construction activities when authority of District Compensation and Resettlement Board officially

approves via document that (i) payment for PAP is conducted and restoration methods are prepared in

accordance with approving RP and the Policy Framework; (ii) PAP are compensated for the affected

area; and (iii) land which needs to be acquired is done the site clearance and handed over.

(i) Monitoring: Internal monitoring and external monitoring will be conducted from the preparation to

the implementation of RP. The grievances will be redressed via a mechanism established for the project.

A post-project survey will be made by Internal Monitoring Unit during 6 or 12 months after the

compensation and resettlement activities.

(k) Ethnic Minority Development Plan

The Ethnic Minority Development Plan will be implemented in parallel with the compensation process for

the DPs.

74

8.4.2. Schedule

The schedule for preparing and implementing Resettlement Action Plan and Ethnic Minority Development

Plan is presented in the Table 34 below:

Table 33: Resettlement Action Plan and Ethnic Minority Development Plan preparation and

implementation schedule

Activity Starting Time Responsibility of

1. 1. Preparation

1.1. Drafts of RP and EMDP will be submitted

to WB for consideration and feedback

End of Nov 2012 TS HPCo

1.2. Public RP, EMDP to affected district and

communes

Jan 2013 TS HPCo

2. Implementation

2.1. Information campaign Before DMS District Compensation Council and

TS HPCo

2.2. DMS Dec 2012 – Jan 2013 District Compensation Council, PAC

PC and PAP

2.3. Preparation of Compensation plan Jan 2013 District Compensation Council

2.4. Authorities review and approve

Compensation plan

Feb 2013 District PC and TS HPP

2.5. Disclosure of approving compensation

plans to PAHs

Feb 2013 District Compensation Council and

CPCs

2.6. Compensation and support payment for

PAHs

The end of Feb 2013 District Compensation Council and

TS HPCo

2.7. Handing over land and properties to PMU

and starting the construction

The beginning of Mar

2013

PAHs

2.8. Complaints/ Grievances and redressing

them

Anytime when there are

complaints/ grievances

since starting DMS

District PC and TS HPCo

2.9. Monitoring and Evaluation Dec 2012 – end of May

2013

Internal and external monitoring

75

CHAPTER IX

BUDGET ESTIMATE

The affected households will be compensated based on the replacement costs and market prices and will

be assisted to restore or to improve their living standards as a policy of the Government on land

acquisition, assistance and Resettlement.

Table 34: Cost estimate for compensation, assistance and resettlement

No. Category Compensation

for land

Compensation

for crops Assistances Total cost (VND)

A Compensation for households 713,662,050 3,701,139,330 2,572,800,200 6,987,601,580

I Hoa Binh Province 712,384,050 3,700,883,730 2,568,966,200 6,982,233,980

1 Mai Chau District 712,384,050 3,700,883,730 2,568,966,200 6,982,233,980

1.1 Tong Dau Commune 614,935,800 33,181,620 1,991,095,200 2,639,212,620

1.2 Mai Chau Town 10,350,600 557,340 28,663,200 39,571,140

1.3 Chieng Chau Commune 17,650,750 950,425 48,879,000 67,480,175

1.4 Mai Ha Commune 13,160,950 837,515 75,512,200 89,510,665

1.5 Van Mai Commune 56,285,950 2,876,856,830 396,616,600 3,329,759,380

1.6 Mai Hich Commune - 788,500,000 28,200,000 816,700,000

II Thanh Hoa Province 1,278,000 255,600 3,834,000 5,367,600

1 Quan Hoa District 1,278,000 255,600 3,834,000 5,367,600

1.1 Phu Thanh Commune 1,278,000 255,600 3,834,000 5,367,600

B Fund for operation and

implementation 348,482,228

Total (A+B) 7,132,721,212

76

APPENDIX

Appendix 1: Inventory of Losses Questionnaire

Power line Component – Trung Son Hydropower Project

------------------------------------------------------------------

Questionnaire code: ___/___/___; Survey date: ____ /__ /2012

A-BACKGROUND INFO

1. Name of head of household: ………………………………...………Age…….. Gender: [ ] (Male=1; female=2)

a) Ethnicity: [ ] (1=Kinh; 2=Thai; 3=Tay; 4=Nung; 5= Muong; 6=Tho; 7=Others)

b) Education Level: [ ] (1=Illiterate; 2=Primary school; 3=Secondary school; 4= Yet graduated from high

school; 5=High school; 6=Vocational training; 7=University and post graduate; 8=Others)

c) Main occupation: [ ] (1= Agriculture; 2=Livestock husbandry; 3=Selling goods; 4=Restaurant ; 5=Factory

worker; 6=official; 7=private company; 8=transportation; 9=driver 10= receive domestic economic support;

11=receive economic support from abroad ; 12=housewife; 13=Others

d) Secondary jobs: [ ] (1=Livestock husbandry; 2=perennial crops; 3=aquaculture; 4=handicraft; 5=forestry;

6=small business; 7=mechanic)

2. Home address: Village: ..............................Commune: ..............................District.......................Province .............

3. Vulnerable group: [ ] (Woman headed=1; Ethnic minority=2; Disabled=3; Poor household=4; Social policy

household=5)

B. SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY

4. Household component (including head of household)

No. Name

Gen

der

Relation

to the

househol

d head

Age

Ethnici

ty Main Occupation

Education level

(7 and above)

1=M

ale

2=F

emal

e

0=head

1=Husban

d/wife

2=Father/

mother

3=Son/da

ughter

4=Son-in-

law/

Daughter-

in-law

5=Grand

child

6=Niece/

nephew

7=Others

1=Kinh

2=Thai

3=Tay

4=Nung

5=Muo

ng

6=Tho

7=Othe

rs

1= Agriculture;

2=Livestock husbandry;

3=Selling goods;

4=Restaurant ;

5=Factory worker;

6=official;

7=private company;

8=transportation;

9=driver

10= receive domestic

economic support;

11=receive economic

support from abroad ;

12=housewife;

13=Others

0=Illiterate

1=Primary school

2=Secondary

school

3=Yet graduated

from high school

4=High school

5=Vocational

training

6=University

7=Others

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

77

5. Annual household income: ………………. VND

Main household income sources are from:

1) Agricultural production activities Amount________________________VND

2) Business Amount________________________VND

3) Salary Amount________________________VND

4) Other sources (for example, overseas

remittances)

Amount________________________VND

6. Water use: water sources for domestic use (tick the corresponding bracket)

1) Dug well [ ] 2) Village well [ ]

3) Tap water [ ] 4) Rain water [ ]

5) River, stream, pond, lake [ ] 6) Buy water [ ]

7) Creek [ ] 8) Others [ ]

7. Common diseases among the community (specify)

1. Catch a cold [ ] 2. Dysentery [ ]

3. Influenza [ ] 4. Hepatitis [ ]

5) Respiratory diseases [ ] 6) Intoxicated [ ]

7) Malaria [ ] 8) Others [ ]

9) Cholera [ ] 10) No answer [ ]

8. Main energy for lighting for household?

1) Grid electricity [ ] 2) Power

generator/hydropower

[ ]

3) Battery [ ] 4) Kerosene lamp [ ]

5) Wood/coal [ ] 6) Others [ ]

9. Main energy for cooking of the household? (Can select more than 1)

1) Electricity [ ] 2) Biogas [ ]

3) Power generator [ ] 4) Others [ ]

5) Gas/oil [ ] 6) No answer [ ]

7) Wood [ ]

10. Has the living condition of the household changed during the last 3 years ?

1) Remain the same [ ]; Reason _________________________________________________

2) Better [ ]; Reason: ________________________________________________________

3) Worse [ ]; Reason: _______________________________________________________

C. INVENTORY OF LOSSES

1. Land use situation of the household (affected land is in the scope of acquisition for the project)

Types of land

Land within and

beyond the

project area

(m2)

Impact degree

Land

tenure Legal title

Impacts caused

by

1= Residential land

2=Land for growing

rice

3=Garden land

4=Aquaculture land

5=Forestry land

6=Non-agricultural

land

7=Others

Total area

of affected

land

(m2)

(1)

Partial

ly

affect

ed

(2)

Fully

affect

ed

1=Owner

2=Lease

1=LURC

2=Without LURC but are

eligible for granting LURC

3= Ineligible for granting

LURC

4= Land is in the planning

area of the state

5=Long-term lease of

government land

6=Lease of private land

1= Transmission line

2= Station

78

Within Beyond

Plot 1

Plot 2

Plot 3

Plot 4

Plot 5

Plot 6

Plot 7

Plot 8

Total

2. Affected houses

Types of

houses

Total floor

area

(m2 )

Legal title Impact degree Project area

Notes

(if there is

home

business,

except for

No. 7)

1. Villa

2. Grade1

3. Grade 2

4. Grade 3

5. Grade 4

6. Temporary

7. Shop

separated from

house

1. With certificate

2. Without certificate

3. Build on agricultural land

4. Rented house

Affected floor

area

(m2)

(Partially

affected=

1; Fully

affected=

2)

1= Main

canal

2= Northern

Canal

3= Southern

Canal

4=Managem

ent house

5=Borrow pit

6=Disposal

area

7=Others

NB: A household can be impacted on several houses, thus it is necessary to fill full information of all affected

houses.

3. Information related to houses out of the project area (if any):

- No. of houses: [ ]

- Area of houses out of the project area (m2): ……………. m

2

4. Other affected structures and facilities

(List auxiliary structures separated from affected houses listed above and facilities)

Structures/ Facilities Types of structures Unit Quantity

Location

1= Transmission line 2= Station

1. Kitchen separated from the main house

1. Temporary 2. Equal to grade 4 house

m2

2. Livestock sheds 1. Temporary 2. Equal to grade 4 house

m2

3. Electricity meter Electricity meter

4. Water meter and estimate Water

79

of water pipeline length meter

5. Telephone

6. Fence 1. Brick 2. Steel, wire or wood

Fence

7. Gate 1. Brick 2. Iron, steel 2. Wood, Bamboo

m2

8. Latrine, bathroom (separated from the main house)

1. Brick, concrete 2. Bamboo, thatch

m2

9. Earth grave a) In cemetery b) Individual

Grave

10. Built grave

11. Well 1Drilled 2. Dug

m

12. Water container 1. Brick/ concrete 2. Inox 3. Plastic

m

3

13. Yard (only cement or tiled) m2

14. Fish pond (excavated amount)

m3

15. Others (Name and affected area)

5. Affected trees and crops

(Only list affected perennial crops and fruit trees)

Trees and crops Name Unit Amount

Location

1= Transmission

line

2= Station

a) Fruit tree (main) Tree

1) Pomelo

2)

3)

4)

5)

b) Timber tree (main) Tree

1)

2)

3)

4)

5)

c) Pot plant (main)

80

d) Crops (main) Tree

1) Maize

2) Potato

3) Earthnut

4) Bean

5)

e) Surface water area for

aquaculture

m2

D. CONSULTATION

6. Only for households losing productive and agricultural land

If agricultural or other productive lands are affected (acquired), which compensation option does your family

chooses?

a) Land-for-land (if land fund in the commune is available) with equal type of land and area/nature

[ ]

b) Compensation in cash [ ]

c) Not yet decided [ ]

7. Only for households losing residential land

Is the remaining residential land area out of the project area enough for the household to rebuild house?

1- Yes [ ] 2- No [ ]

8. Only for households losing residential land

If the remaining residential land area is not viable to rebuild house (the remaining area is smaller than 40m2

in the urban area or 100m2 in the rural area), which relocation option does the household choose?

a) Self relocate to another land plot of the household [ ]

b) Self relocate to another place decided by the household [ ]

c) Project’s resettlement site [ ]

d) Move to the resettlement site arranged by the local authorities [ ]

e) Not yet decided [ ]

9. What is your plan to use compensation cash?

a) Build or repair house [ ]

b) Buy new land [ ]

c) Buy other properties [ ] ; Specify________________

d) Invest in small business [ ]

e) Bank saving [ ]

f) Spend on children’s study [ ]

g) Others [ ] Describe____________________

10. At present does the family have plan to replace production/income from agricultural land and/or restore

business?

1. No [ ] 2. Yes: [ ]

81

If yes, what is the plan:

a) Buy new agricultural land for production [ ]

b) Reestablish business in the new place [ ]

c) Business [ ]

d) Open small shop [ ]

e) Handicraft [ ]

f) Look for new job [ ]

g) Others [ ]

Describe ___________________________________________

Surveyor On behalf of the household

82

Appendix 2: LIST OF PARTICIPATED PEOPLE

COMMUNITY LEVEL

Or. Full Name Position Gender

Note Male Female

I 1 Cao Văn Nguyên Mai Hich commune 1

2 Đỗ Xuân Tình Mai Hich commune 1

3 Hà Minh Quyển Mai Hich commune 1

4 Hoàng Đức Dương Mai Hich commune 1

5 Lê Văn Hồng Mai Hich commune 1

6 Nguyễn Thị Nhân Mai Hich commune

2

7 Nguyễn Thị Nhẫn Mai Hich commune

2

8 Nguyễn Thị Quy Mai Hich commune

2

9 Nguyễn Thị Tuyết Mai Hich commune

2

10 Nguyễn Văn Chiến Mai Hich commune 1

11 Phạm Văn Đô Mai Hich commune 1

12 Phan Thị Huyền Mai Hich commune

2

13 Phùng Thị Minh Mai Hich commune

2

14 Trịnh Văn Đông Mai Hich commune 1

15 Tưởng Thị Luận Mai Hich commune

2

II 1 Hà Công Hợp Mai Chau town 1

2 Hà Công Lúc Mai Chau town 1

3 hà Công Tường Mai Chau town 1

4 Hà Công Yêu Mai Chau town 1

5 Hà Thị Nhương Mai Chau town

2

6 Hà Thị Yết Mai Chau town

2

7 Hà Văn Hiền Mai Chau town 1

8 Hà Văn Sơn Mai Chau town 1

9 Ke Văn Can Mai Chau town 1

10 Khà Thị Diệp Mai Chau town

2

11 Khà Thị Ngận Mai Chau town

2

12 Khà Thị Thảo Mai Chau town

2

13 Khà Thị Úm Mai Chau town

2

14 Khà Văn Oát Mai Chau town 1

15 Khà Văn Sừng Mai Chau town 1

16 Lò Thị Duyên Mai Chau town

2

17 Lò Thị Kiên Mai Chau town

2

18 Lục Thị Sùi Mai Chau town

2

19 Vì Văn Nhai Mai Chau town 1

III 1 Bùi Thị Thức Chieng Chau commune

2

83

2 Hà Công Đang Chieng Chau commune 1

3 Hà Công Kho Chieng Chau commune 1

4 Hà Công Kỳ Chieng Chau commune 1

5 Hà Công Thương Chieng Chau commune 1

6 Hà Công Tui Chieng Chau commune 1

7 Hà Công Ưởng Chieng Chau commune 1

8 Hà Thị Khơi Chieng Chau commune

2

9 Hà Thị Phiên Chieng Chau commune

2

10 Hà Thị Suốt Chieng Chau commune

2

11 Hà Thị Tèo Chieng Chau commune

2

12 Hà Thị Thanh Chieng Chau commune

2

13 Hà Thị Tiến Chieng Chau commune

2

14 Hà Văn Dơi Chieng Chau commune 1

15 Hà Văn Phân Chieng Chau commune 1

16 Hà Văn Phiền Chieng Chau commune 1

17 Hà Văn Tuất Chieng Chau commune 1

18 Khà Văn Chúng Chieng Chau commune 1

19 Khà Văn Hậu Chieng Chau commune 1

20 Khà Văn Nhơi Chieng Chau commune 1

21 Khà Văn Nội Chieng Chau commune 1

22 Khà Văn Thắng Chieng Chau commune 1

23 Khà Văn Thiện Chieng Chau commune 1

24 Lò Thị Se Chieng Chau commune

2

25 Lò Thị Thư Chieng Chau commune

2

26 Lò Văn Đức Chieng Chau commune 1

27 Lò Văn Tuân Chieng Chau commune 1

28 Mạc Thị Cò Chieng Chau commune

2

29 Mạc Thị Dàng Chieng Chau commune

2

30 Mạc Thị Ngân Chieng Chau commune

2

31 Mạc Văn Bón Chieng Chau commune 1

32 Mạc Văn Câu Chieng Chau commune 1

33 Mặc Văn Đoan Chieng Chau commune 1

34 Mặc Văn Khào Chieng Chau commune 1

35 Mạc Văn Tản Chieng Chau commune 1

36 Ngần Thị Biên Chieng Chau commune

2

37 Ngần Văn Phúc Chieng Chau commune 1

38 Vì Thị Kêu Chieng Chau commune

2

39 Vì Văn Bay Chieng Chau commune 1

40 Vì Văn Nhiết Chieng Chau commune 1

84

IV 1 Hà Thị Thanh Mai Ha commune

2

2 Khà Thị Minh Mai Ha commune

2

3 Khà Thị Thủy Mai Ha commune

2

4 Khà Thị Xiên Mai Ha commune

2

5 Khà Văn Long Mai Ha commune 1

6 Khà Văn Thu Mai Ha commune 1

7 Lò Văn Biếng Mai Ha commune 1

8 Mạc Văn Nhâng Mai Ha commune 1

9 Ngần Thị Hoài Mai Ha commune

2

10 Ngần Thị Tân Mai Ha commune

2

11 Ngần Văn Hùng Mai Ha commune 1

12 Ngần Văn Hưng Mai Ha commune 1

13 Ngần Văn Ít Mai Ha commune 1

14 Ngần Văn Viết Mai Ha commune 1

15 Nguyễn Thị Lợi Mai Ha commune

2

16 Nguyễn Thị Lợi Mai Ha commune

2

17 Nguyễn Thị Lư Mai Ha commune

2

18 Vì Thị Dung Mai Ha commune

2

19 Vì Văn Hiên Mai Ha commune 1

20 Vì Văn Hoàng Mai Ha commune 1

21 Vì Văn Khoan Mai Ha commune 1

22 Vì Văn Kiên Mai Ha commune 1

23 Vì Văn Ngự Mai Ha commune 1

24 Vì Văn Phao Mai Ha commune 1

25 Vì Văn Xền Mai Ha commune 1

26 Vì Văn Yêu Mai Ha commune 1

V 1 Bùi Thị Hưởng Tong Dau commune

2

2 Hà Công Thìn Tong Dau commune 1

3 Hà Công Thoại Tong Dau commune 1

4 Hà Công Thuận Tong Dau commune 1

5 Hà Thị Bình Tong Dau commune

2

6 Hà Thị Đôi Tong Dau commune

2

7 Hà Thị Kho Tong Dau commune

2

8 Hà Thị Mùi Tong Dau commune

2

9 Hà Thị Nhàn Tong Dau commune

2

10 Hà Thị Quyết Tong Dau commune

2

11 Hà Thị Thương Tong Dau commune

2

12 Hà Văn Âng Tong Dau commune 1

13 Hà Văn Bếch Tong Dau commune 1

85

14 Hà Văn Cường Tong Dau commune 1

15 Hà Văn Khăm Tong Dau commune 1

16 Hà Văn Kim Tong Dau commune 1

17 Hà Văn Nhợn Tong Dau commune 1

18 Hà Văn Nui Tong Dau commune 1

19 Hà Văn Núi Tong Dau commune 1

20 Hà Văn Phong Tong Dau commune 1

21 Hà Văn Tân Tong Dau commune 1

22 Hà Văn Ưu Tong Dau commune 1

23 Hà Văn Viết Tong Dau commune 1

24 Hà Văn Yêu Tong Dau commune 1

25 Khà Thị Ngân Tong Dau commune

2

26 Khà Văn Thành Tong Dau commune 1

27 Lò Thị Ăn Tong Dau commune

2

28 Lò Thị Khuân Tong Dau commune

2

29 Lò Thị Ly Tong Dau commune

2

30 Lò Thị Tâng Tong Dau commune

2

31 Lò Thị Thanh Tong Dau commune

2

32 Lò Thị Thiển Tong Dau commune

2

33 Lò Thị Xương Tong Dau commune

2

34 Lò Thị Yển Tong Dau commune

2

35 Lò Văn An Tong Dau commune 1

36 Lò Vân Âu Tong Dau commune 1

37 Lò Văn Diện Tong Dau commune 1

38 Lò Văn Diệp Tong Dau commune 1

39 Lò Văn Dũng Tong Dau commune 1

40 Lò Văn Hảo Tong Dau commune 1

41 Lò Văn Hỏa Tong Dau commune 1

42 Lò Văn Hội Tong Dau commune 1

43 Lò Văn Hợi Tong Dau commune 1

44 Lò Văn Linh Tong Dau commune 1

45 Lò Văn Luân Tong Dau commune 1

46 Lò Văn Quang Tong Dau commune 1

47 Lò Văn Quyết Tong Dau commune 1

48 Lò Văn Tiết Tong Dau commune 1

49 Lộc Thị Lọc Tong Dau commune

2

50 Lộc Văn Kui Tong Dau commune 1

51 Ngần Văn Đoàn Tong Dau commune 1

52 Ngần Văn Hà Tong Dau commune 1

86

53 Ngần Văn Khoa Tong Dau commune 1

54 Ngần Văn Ngoãn Tong Dau commune 1

55 Vì Thị Ki Tong Dau commune

2

56 Vì Thị Un Tong Dau commune

2

VI 1 Vì Văn Oan Van Mai commune 1

2 Đặng Thị Tư Van Mai commune

2

3 Đào Huy Tích Van Mai commune 1

4 Đào Văn Hiếu Van Mai commune 1

5 Đỗ Văn Dậu Van Mai commune 1

6 Hà Công Hoàn Van Mai commune 1

7 Hà Công Ngọc Van Mai commune 1

8 Hà Thị Bền Van Mai commune

2

9 Hà Thị Bình Van Mai commune

2

10 Hà Thị Bượm Van Mai commune

2

11 Hà Thị Chiền Van Mai commune

2

12 Hà Thị Chữ Van Mai commune

2

13 Hà Thị Duyên Van Mai commune

2

14 Hà Thị Huệ Van Mai commune

2

15 Hà Thị Kéo Van Mai commune

2

16 Hà Thị Lá Van Mai commune

2

17 Hà Thị Thảo Van Mai commune

2

18 Hà Thị Yếu Van Mai commune

2

19 Hà Văn Cầm Van Mai commune 1

20 Hà Văn Chao Van Mai commune 1

21 Hà Văn Chiểu Van Mai commune 1

22 Hà Văn Huynh Van Mai commune 1

23 Hà Văn Ngăm Van Mai commune 1

24 Hà Văn Phần Van Mai commune 1

25 Hà Văn Phiết Van Mai commune 1

26 Hà Văn Phương Van Mai commune 1

27 Hà Văn Sơn Van Mai commune 1

28 Hà Văn Súm Van Mai commune 1

29 Hà Văn Thiển Van Mai commune 1

30 Hoàng Thị Cầu Van Mai commune

2

31 Khà Thị Đoan Van Mai commune

2

32 Khà Thị Kiến Van Mai commune

2

33 Khà Thị Phính Van Mai commune

2

34 Khà Thị Sang Van Mai commune

2

35 Khà Văn Hiển Van Mai commune 1

87

36 Khà Văn Khánh Van Mai commune 1

37 Khà Văn Kiên Van Mai commune 1

38 Khà Văn Quyển Van Mai commune 1

39 Khà Văn Tà Van Mai commune 1

40 Khà Văn Thuận Van Mai commune 1

41 Khà Văn Tòa Van Mai commune 1

42 Khà Văn Tùng Van Mai commune 1

43 Khà Văn Vinh Van Mai commune 1

44 Khà Văn Xuôi Van Mai commune 1

45 Lại Văn Nhu Van Mai commune 1

46 Lê Quang Thái Van Mai commune 1

47 Lò Thị Chiên Van Mai commune

2

48 Lữ Văn Chiền Van Mai commune 1

49 Lương Thị Phận Van Mai commune

2

50 Lương Thị Toán Van Mai commune

2

51 Lương Văn Lai Van Mai commune 1

52 Lương Văn Quý Van Mai commune 1

53 Lương Văn Quyết Van Mai commune 1

54 Lương Văn Sao Van Mai commune 1

55 Lương Văn Sơm Van Mai commune 1

56 Ngân Thị Thạch Van Mai commune

2

57 Ngần Thị Thạch Van Mai commune

2

58 Ngân Thị Tuyết Van Mai commune

2

59 Ngần Tiến Công Van Mai commune 1

60 Nguyễn Văn Ưu Van Mai commune 1

61 Nguyễn Văn Xai Van Mai commune 1

62 Nguyễn Xuân Hòe Van Mai commune 1

63 Trịnh Thị Dương Van Mai commune

2

64 Trương Thị Chanh Van Mai commune

2

65 Tưởng Văn Nghi Van Mai commune 1

66 Vì Thị Duyên Van Mai commune

2

67 Vì Thị Hiếu Van Mai commune

2

68 Vi Thị Lê Van Mai commune

2

69 Vì Thị Quyên Van Mai commune

2

70 Vì Văn Dương Van Mai commune 1

Total 137 89

88

COMMUNE LEVEL

LIST OF PARTICIPATED PEOPLE

Or. Full Name Position

Gender

Notes Male

Femal

e

I 1 Hà Văn Cừ Chairman of Mai Chau town PC 1

2 Hà Văn Khoan Vice -Chairman of Mai Chau town PC 1

3 Hà Văn Quang Vice-Chairman of Mai Chau town PC 1

4 Hà Anh Tuấn Land officer of Mai Chau town PC 1

5 Hà Văn Cương

Vice-Chairman of Mai Chau town Farmer

Union 1

II 1 Đinh Văn Long Chairman of Tong Dau CPC 1

2 Hà Văn Tích Vice-Chairman of Tong Dau CPC 1

3 Ngần Thị Đoàn Land officer of Tong Dau CPC

2

III 1 Khá Thái Sàu Chairman of Mai Ha CPC 1

2 Hà Văn Duân Vice-Chairman of Mai Ha CPC 1

3 Vì Thanh Túc Land officer of Mai Ha CPC 1

IV 1 Vì Văn Tít Chairman of Mai Hich CPC 1

2 Phạm Văn Định

Village leader of Mai Hoang Son village in

Mai Hich commune 1

3

Nguyễn Văn

Thuận

Vice Secretary of Party in Mai Hich

commune 1

V 1 Khá Minh Tuấn Vice-Chairman of Chieng Chau CPC 1

2 Hà Văn Tiệp

Chairman of Chieng Chau commune

fatherland fond 1

3 Hà Việt Hóa Land officer of Chieng ChauCPC 1

4 Khá Thị Thu Land officer of Chieng Chau CPC

2

5 Ngần Thị Thủy Extension officer of Chieng Chau CPC

2

VI 1 Hà Công Sang Chairman of Van Mai CPC 1

2 Ngần Văn Thoàn Vice-Chairman of Van Mai CPC 1

3 Hà Công Linh Secretary of Party in Van Mai commune 1

4 Hà Văn Huỳnh Vice-Chairman of Van Mai CPC 1

5 Vì Văn Tuyền Vice-Secretary of Party in Van Mai commune 1

6 Khà Văn Thị Land officer of Van Mai CPC 1

Total 22 3

89

Appendix 3: Some related picture of public consultation meeting and survey

The local people and authorities’ Tong Dau

commune attended to the consultation meeting

Local people registed into the list of consultation

meeting in Van Mai commune

The consultation meeting was held in Mai Hoang

Son cultural house in Mai Hich commune

Local peole contributed their opinions

Hot atmosphere of consultation meeting Local women participated in the consultation

meeting

90

Appendix 4

Appendix 4.1: Land, tree and crop compensation

Or. Contents Unit Quality Unit

price

Amount

(VND)

A Annual productive land

compensation 10,734.2

687,856,000

I Hoa Binh province 10,691.6

686,578,000

1 Mai Chau district VND/m2 10,691.6

686,578,000

1.1 Tong Dau commune VND/m2 9,423.3 65,000 612,515,800

1.2 Mai Chau town VND/m2 159.2 65,000 10,350,600

1.3 Chieng Chau commune VND/m2 271.6 65,000 17,650,750

1.4 Mai Ha commune VND/m2 239.3 55,000 13,160,950

1.5 Van Mai commune VND/m2 598.2 55,000 32,899,900

1.6 Mai Hich commune - 55,000

II Thanh Hoa province VND/m2 42.6

1,278,000

1 Quan Hoa district VND/m2 42.6

1,278,000

1.1 Phu Thanh commune VND/m2 42.6 30,000 1,278,000

B Perennial crop land compensation 563.7

25,806,050

I Hoa Binh province 563.7

25,806,050

1 Mai Chau district VND/m2 563.7

25,806,050

1.1 Tong Dau commune VND/m2 44.0 55,000 2,420,000

1.2 Mai Chau town VND/m2 - 55,000 -

1.3 Chieng Chau commune VND/m2 - 55,000 -

1.4 Mai Ha commune VND/m2 - 45,000 -

1.5 Van Mai commune VND/m2 519.7 45,000 23,386,050

1.6 Mai Hich commune - 45,000

II Thanh Hoa province VND/m2 -

-

1 Quan Hoa district VND/m2 -

-

1.1 Phu Thanh commune VND/m2 - - -

C Forest land compensation

(Not compensation for corridor

57,988.9

-

91

land)


-

1 Mai Chau district VND/m2 57,988.9

-

1.1 Tong Dau commune VND/m2 8.3

-

1.2 Mai Chau town VND/m2 -

-

1.3 Chieng Chau commune VND/m2 -

-

1.4 Mai Ha commune VND/m2 -

-

1.5 Van Mai commune VND/m2 42,732.8

-

1.6 Mai Hich commune VND/m2 15,247.8

-

II Thanh Hoa province VND/m2 -

-

1 Quan Hoa district VND/m2 -

-

1.1 Phu Thanh commune VND/m2 - - -

D Crop compensation

3,701,139,330


3,700,883,730

1 Mai Chau district 73,516.6

3,700,883,730

1.1 Tong Dau commune 9,427.3

33,181,620

Paddy VND/m2 9,423.3 3,500 32,981,620

Maize VND/m2 - 2,200 -

Longan VND/tree 4.0 50,000 200,000

Mango VND/tree - 50,000 -

Bead tree VND/tree - 200,000 -

Chukrasia tabularis “lat” VND/tree - 500,000 -

Luong bamboo VND/tree - 30,000 -

1.2 Mai Chau town 159.2

557,340

Paddy VND/m2 159.2 3,500 557,340


Longan VND/tree - 50,000 -





92

1.3 Chieng Chau commune 271.6

950,425

Paddy VND/m2 271.6 3,500 950,425







1.4 Mai Ha commune 239.3

837,515

Paddy VND/m2 239.3 3,500 837,515







1.5 Van Mai commune 44,199.2

2,876,856,830

Paddy VND/m2 598.2 3,500 2,093,630

Maize VND/m2 6.0 2,200 13,200

Longan VND/tree 615.0 50,000 30,750,000

Mango VND/tree 1,070.0 50,000 53,500,000

Bead tree VND/tree 7,830.0 200,000 1,566,000,000

Chukrasia tabularis “lat” VND/tree 430.0 500,000 215,000,000

Luong bamboo VND/tree 33,650.0 30,000 1,009,500,000

1.6 Mai Hich commune 19,220.0

788,500,000

Paddy VND/m2 - 3,500 -


Longan VND/tree 20.0 50,000 1,000,000



Chukrasia tabularis “lat” VND/tree 450.0 500,000 225,000,000

93

Luong bamboo VND/tree 18,750.0 30,000 562,500,000

II Thanh Hoa province 42.6

255,600

1 Quan Hoa district 42.6

255,600

1.1 Phu Thanh commune 42.6

255,600

Paddy VND/m2 42.6 6,000 255,600

Maize VND/m2 - - -

Longan VND/tree - - -

Mango VND/tree - - -

Bead tree VND/tree - - -

Chukrasia tabularis “lat” VND/tree - - -

Luong bamboo VND/tree - - -

Total (A+B+C+D)

4,414,801,380

94

Appendix 4.2: Assistance

Or. Contents Unit Quality Unit price Amount (VND)

A Hoa Binh province

2,568,966,200

I Mai Chau district

1,991,095,200

1 Tong Dau commune

1,991,095,200

1 Livelihood assistance

168,480,000

1.1 HHs were recovered from 25% to 70%

of agricultural productive land Person 52 3,240,000 168,480,000

1.2 HHs were recovered over 70% of

agricultural productive land Person 0 6,480,000 0

2 Assistance for job change and job

creation (3 times) m2 9,475.6 180,000 1,705,615,200

3

Assistance for disruptive permanently

of affected HHs lost over 25% of

productive land or incomes, or

resettlement

Person 52

113,000,000

4 Reward to hand over timely the

ground HH 4 1,000,000 4,000,000

5

Reward to hand over timely the

ground for beneficiary of social

welfare

HH 0 2,000,000 0

2 Mai Chau town

28,663,200


0


of agricultural productive land Person 0 3,240,000 0




creation (3 times) m2 159.2 180,000 28,663,200

3




resettlement

Person


ground HH 0 1,000,000 0

95

5



welfare

HH 0 2,000,000 0

3 Chieng Chau commune

48,879,000


0






creation (3 times) m2 271.6 180,000 48,879,000

3




resettlement

Person


ground HH 0 1,000,000 0

5



welfare

HH 0 2,000,000 0

4 Mai Ha commune

75,512,200


19,440,000






creation (3 times) m2 239.3 180,000 43,072,200

3




resettlement

Person 6

13,000,000


ground HH 0 1,000,000 0

5



welfare

HH 0 2,000,000 0

5 Van Mai commune

396,616,600

96


113,400,000






creation (3 times) m2 1,117.9 180,000 201,216,600

3




resettlement

Person 35

76,000,000


ground HH 6 1,000,000 6,000,000

5



welfare

HH 0 2,000,000 0

6 Mai Hich commune

28,200,000


16,200,000






creation (3 times) m2 - 180,000 0

3




resettlement

Person 5

11,000,000


ground HH 1 1,000,000 1,000,000

5



welfare

HH 0 2,000,000 0

B Thanh Hoa province

3,834,000

II Quan Hoa district

3,834,000

1 Phu Thanh commune

3,834,000

97


0






creation (3 times) m2 42.6 90,000 3,834,000

3




resettlement

Person


ground HH 0 0 0

5



welfare

HH 0 0 0

Total (A+B) 2,572,800,200

RESETTLEMENT AND ETHNIC MINORITY …documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/789901468139764780/...The DPs...

Documents

Transcript of RESETTLEMENT AND ETHNIC MINORITY …documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/789901468139764780/...The DPs...