Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core...

35
Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall

Transcript of Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core...

Page 1: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Research into BPD

SPDN

Jeremy Hall

Page 2: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.
Page 3: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Borderline Personality Disorder

• First defined by Gunderson

• Core features– Affective instability– Interpersonal difficulties– Impulsivity

• Heritability about 40%

• Strongly associated with early life stress

Page 4: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

The Scale of the Problem

• BPD affects 1-2% of the population

• BPD accounts for 10% OPD contacts

• BPD main diagnosis in 6% admissions

• Frequent cause of attendance at A&E

• Associated with a 10% risk of suicide

Page 5: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Current Treatments

• 1. Pharmacological Treatments– Antidepressants only if concurrent depression– Antipsychotics for perceptual disturbances– Some evidence for mood stabilisers– All trials very small– NICE unable to recommend any treatment

Page 6: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Current Treatments

• 2. Psychological Treatments– Best evidence is for DBT– Some evidence also for CBT– HOWEVER

• Trials generally small• Limited availability • Not suitable for all

Page 7: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

How can Research help?

• Psychological Research– Larger studies– “Real-life” settings

• Biological Research– Develop measures of deficits in BPD– Relate these to changes in the brain– Develop new treatments

Page 8: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Our Research

• Developing measures of BPD symptoms– Affective responses– Interpersonal interactions– Impulsivity

• Determining their specificity to BPD

• Developing translational assessments

Page 9: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Emotion and Impulse Study

• 1. Background information

• 2. Symptom severity

• 3. Computer tests of:– A. Emotion processing– B. Social responses– C. Impulsivity

Page 10: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Who did we study?

• 20 people with symptoms

• 20 people without symptoms

• Age range 20-55

• 75% female

Page 11: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

What did we find out?

Page 12: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Background and Symptoms

Page 13: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Some things weren’t different…

0

10

20

30

40

CON SYMPT

Group

Ag

e

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

CON SYMPT

Group

IQ

AGE IQ

Page 14: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

… and some things were:

CHILD STRESS DEPRESSION

0

10

20

30

40

50

CON SYMPT

Group

Ch

ild S

tres

s

0

5

10

15

20

CON SYMPT

Group

Ham

ilto

n

Page 15: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Computer tests 1

Emotion Processing

Page 16: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Expression in faces

Page 17: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Facial Emotion Recognition

Anger

Happiness

Fear

Sadness

Surprise

Disgust

Page 18: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Results: Emotions

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

ANG HAP SAD SUR FEAR DIS

Task

Sco

re CON

SYMPT

**

Page 19: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Emotion Recognition and Trauma

Page 20: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Computer tests 2

Social Responses

Page 21: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Social decisions

Trustworthy?

Page 22: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Social Judgement

APPROACHABLE NOT APPROACHABLE

Page 23: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Results: Social

16

18

20

22

24

26

28

30

32

AGE ATT DIS INT TRU APP

Task

Sco

re CON

SYMPT

***

**

Page 24: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Social Judgement Bias

BPD

Page 25: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Social Judgement and Trauma

Page 26: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Computer tests 3

Impulsivity

Page 27: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Motor Impulsivity

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

CON SYMPT

Group

SS

RT

(m

s)

Page 28: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Delayed Reward

£10 Straight away

£20 In two weeks

Which would you prefer?:

Page 29: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Delayed Reward

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

2 7 30 180

Delay (days)

% w

aiti

ng

fo

r la

ter

CON

SYMPT

Page 30: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Conclusions

Page 31: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Conclusions

• We could measure difficulties in core areas:– Emotion processing– Social responses– Impulsivity

• What does this mean in the brain?

Page 32: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Basis in the brain?

PFC

AMY

Page 33: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

The future!

Page 34: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Acknowledgements

• CSO / SFC

• Merrick Pope

• Katie Nicol

• All the participants

Page 35: Research into BPD SPDN Jeremy Hall. Borderline Personality Disorder First defined by Gunderson Core features –Affective instability –Interpersonal difficulties.

Contacts

• Jeremy Hall– Email: [email protected]– Tel: 0131 537 6313

• Merrick Pope– Email: [email protected]– Tel: 0131 537 6390