REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com
Transcript of REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com
![Page 1: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 1 of 17
REMAINING UNITS SCHEDULE 1
1.0 OVERVIEW 2
This exhibit provides the integrated Darlington Refurbishment Program (“DRP” or “Program”) 3
schedule and the current schedules for the refurbishment outages of Units 3, 1, and 4 (the 4
“Remaining Units”). 5
6
Section 2 begins by discussing the approach OPG employed to develop a fully integrated 7
schedule for the four-unit DRP at the time of the Release Quality Estimate (“RQE”) and the 8
Unit 2 Execution Estimate (“U2EE”). Section 3 starts by describing the development of the 9
updated integrated Program schedule for the Remaining Units. Discussion of the Remaining 10
Units’ schedule continues with a review of the Lessons Learned from the execution of Unit 2 11
and how these have been applied to the planning of the Remaining Units to produce more 12
refined schedules, with decreased uncertainties around the duration of critical path activities. 13
14
The approach used to mitigate schedule risks associated with the first-of-a-kind (“FOAK”) 15
turbine-generator controls scope to be installed in the Remaining Units is also discussed. This 16
exhibit then explains the integration of schedule logic1 for more than one unit in the period of 17
planned overlaps between the refurbishment outages of Units 3 and 1, and Units 1 and 4. It 18
concludes by comparing the planned schedule for Unit 3 to the actual schedule achieved for 19
Unit 2 and explaining the major elements that have allowed OPG to decrease the planned 20
duration of Unit 3 relative to Unit 2. 21
22
The Level 1 Working Schedule for each of the Remaining Units’ refurbishment outages are 23
provided as attachments. 24
1 Schedule logic refers to the logical interrelationships between activities and milestones in the schedule.
Specifically, that all of the predecessor activities required to facilitate completion of a successor activity are scheduled appropriately. For example, for fluid containing systems, all activities required to ensure that that system is airtight or watertight (depending on the system), including all appropriate testing, must be completed before the system is filled with fluid.
![Page 2: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 2 of 17
2.0 SCHEDULE DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT 1
OPG developed and maintains a fully integrated Program schedule that reflects the total 2
estimated duration of the individual tasks included within the Program scope. The integrated 3
Program schedule includes the individual Remaining Units’ refurbishment schedules and is a 4
critical tool used to properly strategize, plan and prepare for upcoming project work, determine 5
resource requirements, understand how work is progressing and apply corrective actions if, 6
and when, required. 7
8
2.1 Schedule Development and Management at the RQE 9
The overall planning and scheduling process involves two major stages.2 These stages are: 10
(1) formation of the baseline schedule; and (2) schedule management, including monitoring, 11
analysis, reporting, and risk mitigation. 12
13
2.1.1 Formation of the Baseline Schedule 14
OPG developed the baseline schedule in multiple phases leading up to the RQE. During the 15
development of the RQE, OPG project teams established a work breakdown structure that was 16
deliverable-oriented and addressed all of the project work, down to the individual work package 17
level. The work breakdown structure aligned with the corresponding contracting strategies so 18
that work scope, budgets and contractual rights and obligations were clearly and fairly 19
allocated between OPG and its contractors. OPG and its contractors then collaborated to 20
develop detailed schedules with inputs from appropriate project stakeholders, employing a 21
multi-level scheduling framework. 22
23
These detailed schedules included: 24
• the scope of work to be completed; 25
• identification of all key activities including their start and finish dates, duration and 26
resources required; 27
• the sequence and logical interrelationship of activities and milestones; and, 28
• identification and optimization of the critical path. 29
2 EB-2016-0152, Ex. D2-2-6.
![Page 3: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 3 of 17
After development of the initial schedules, project team members and key project stakeholders 1
reviewed them through an iterative process and approved them when they met process and 2
quality requirements. These reviews considered technical constraints, project and Program 3
constraints, milestones, resource requirements, and critical path approving the schedules. 4
5
As noted in Ex. D2-2-2, and previously in EB-2016-0152, OPG utilizes two schedules: (1) a 6
Working Schedule; and, (2) a High Confidence Schedule. The Working Schedule is based on 7
best estimates of the time required to complete the scheduled work tasks and is of shorter 8
duration than the High Confidence Schedule. The Working Schedule is used to manage day-9
to-day activities, allowing for early escalation of issues, and is used by OPG to calculate 10
performance metrics, e.g., the Schedule Performance Index. 11
12
The High Confidence Schedule includes schedule contingency amounts that are determined 13
based on a detailed evaluation of risks and uncertainties for critical path activities in the 14
schedule. OPG’s commitments to its Board of Directors and to external stakeholders, such as 15
the Independent Electricity System Operator, are based on the High Confidence Schedule. 16
The High Confidence Schedules for Units 3, 1, and 4 are the underlying basis for OPG’s 2020-17
2026 Business Plan and, therefore, of the approvals requested in this application. In EB-2016-18
0152, the Unit 2 High Confidence Schedule underpinned OPG’s requested approvals and the 19
amounts the OEB approved for Unit 2. 20
21
2.1.2 Schedule Management 22
To facilitate schedule management and control, OPG prepares project schedules with up to 23
four levels of detail, from Level “0”, which contains the Program milestones managed by OPG 24
and which identify the major deliverables and timelines for the overall DRP, to Level “3”, which 25
shows individual work components at the task level. See Attachment 1 for an explanation of 26
the multi-level scheduling approach used by OPG. 27
28
An accurate, detailed and realistic schedule facilitates risk mitigation because it allows precise 29
monitoring of progress. Progress monitoring against the Working Schedule allows for early 30
identification of potential schedule deviations, whether delays or early completion of activities, 31
![Page 4: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 4 of 17
and the development of strategies and appropriate adjustments to upcoming activities. 1
Examples of these adjustments are: 2
1. Reallocation of resources as required to address emergent issues; 3
2. Revising the timing of onboarding of resources for upcoming activities; 4
3. Reviewing and potentially revising the schedule logic for upcoming activities; and, 5
4. Re-assessments to determine if certain activities, which had been planned to be executed 6
in series, could be fully or partially executed in parallel. 7
8
During the execution of Unit 2, OPG employed all of the above listed actions at various times 9
to adjust the schedule to reflect the impact of delays or early completion of specific work 10
activities, and to help manage unforeseen challenges. The actions taken on Unit 2 informed the 11
schedules for the Remaining Units. Section 3.2 explains the important role that such information 12
played in the refinement of the schedules for the Remaining Units. 13
14
3.0 REMAINING UNITS SCHEDULE 15
This section presents the changes to the Program schedule and explains the drivers behind 16
those changes. It addresses the process used to refine the individual units’ working schedules, 17
by using phased milestones established for schedule development and introducing 18
refinements for the Remaining Units. 19
20
Figure 1 shows a simplified overview of the major critical path steps in the schedule of 21
refurbishing a unit. The critical path refers to the longest sequence of activities in a project plan 22
that must be completed on schedule for the timely delivery of the overall project. Subsequent 23
activities on the critical path cannot be started until predecessor activities are complete. For 24
example, if an activity on the critical path were completed one day earlier than planned, the 25
entire project would be completed one day ahead of plan, provided all subsequent critical path 26
activities were completed in their planned durations. As shown in Figure 1, the major critical 27
path steps are: 28
• Reactor shutdown 29
• Defuel reactor 30
• Drain systems and isolate from containment (and the other operating units) 31
![Page 5: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 5 of 17
• Fuel channel removal, inspection and cleaning and installation (includes feeder removal 1
and installation) 2
• Refuel 3
• Refill and re-establish normal containment boundary 4
• Commission and return to service 5
6
Figure 1: Major Steps in Refurbishing a Darlington Nuclear Unit 7
8 As part of the planning efforts described in Ex. D2-2-3: 9
1. The Program schedule (planned start dates and end dates and milestones for each of 10
the Remaining Units) has been updated; and 11
2. The Working and High Confidence Schedules for each of the Remaining Units have been 12
updated. 13
14
3.1 Remaining Units Program Schedule 15
Figure 2 shows the Program’s High Confidence Schedule per the final Unit 3 Execution 16
Estimate (“U3EE”).3 17
3 As discussed in Ex. D2-2-3, the final U3EE reflects the schedule impact of OPG’s response actions to COVID-19
that included deferring the start date of the Unit 3 refurbishment in 2020 and correspondingly revising the start dates for Units 1 and 4.
![Page 6: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 6 of 17
Figure 2: High Confidence Schedule at Final U3EE 1
2 The main drivers of the changes from the RQE/U2EE schedule to the final U3EE schedule 3
were the slight delay to the completion of Unit 2 and the deferrals of the start dates of each of 4
the Remaining Units in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. In response to the Unit 2 delayed 5
finish, OPG had made a strategic decision to defer the start of Unit 3 in order to manage 6
resources and to avoid introducing risks into the last segment of the Unit 2 refurbishment 7
outage. OPG also managed the risks to the overall Program by similarly moving the Unit 1 and 8
Unit 4 start dates to avoid potential schedule logic and resource conflicts risks. In response to 9
the COVID-19 pandemic, OPG decided to further shift the start date of the refurbishment 10
outage of Unit 3, by four months, to September 2020.4 This decision also necessitated a 11
corresponding shift in the start dates of the Units 1 and 4 refurbishment outages by four 12
months.5 13
14
3.2 Unit Schedules – Development and Refinement 15
As discussed in Ex. D2-2-3 (Section 3.3), a set of integrated Program, Segment and Window 16
Milestones were established to manage and monitor the progress of planning for each of the 17
4 The Unit 3 refurbishment outage is now in progress, with an actual start date of September 3, 2020. 5 As a result of the deferred DRP schedule, OPG moved a regular planned outage from 2020 to 2021 and also
added a regular planned outage in 2021 to support Unit 4 operation until its start of refurbishment. See Ex. E2-1-2 for further discussion.
Sep 2020 Unit 3 - 40 months Jan 2024
Feb 2022 Unit 1 - 38 months Apr 2025
Sep 2023 Unit 4 - 37 months Oct 2026
Total Duration = 73 months
20262022 2024 202520232020 2021
![Page 7: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 7 of 17
Remaining Units. As a part of that process, milestones were established to manage and 1
monitor the progress of schedule development. 2
3
The schedule evolves through four formal revisions with an increasing level of rigour and detail 4
in each revision. The timing and level of detail required in each of these schedules is specified 5
in OPG’s Refurbishment Unit Planning Milestones Governance (Ex. D2-2-3, Attachment 2). At 6
a high-level, the four formal revisions of the schedule for each unit’s refurbishment result in 7
progression from a Level 1 schedule overview depicting the key components of the critical path 8
and providing the overall duration and layout of the unit’s refurbishment outage, to a Level 3 9
schedule with full details of the critical path, major maintenance and modification activities, and 10
including detailed scripting of work sequences. This schedule, known as Revision 0,6 serves 11
as the baseline schedule against which performance will be measured. Each revision of the 12
schedule also supports the evolution of the cost estimates for each unit. 13
14
Refinement of the individual schedules for the Remaining Units is focused on four main areas: 15
1. Incorporating Lessons Learned from the work executed to date; 16
2. Incorporating Strategic Improvements; 17
3. Developing robust schedule logic, resources and duration for the new turbine generator 18
controls scope in the Remaining Units, and identifying and mitigating the risks introduced 19
by this new scope; and 20
4. Examining the periods where unit refurbishment outages overlap to ensure that there are 21
no unacceptable plant configurations, resource conflicts, or other logistical conflicts. 22
23
Each of these areas is elaborated upon in Sections 3.2.1 to 3.2.4 below. 24
25
3.2.1 Lessons Learned 26
The process of incorporating Lessons Learned in planning for the Program is detailed in Ex. 27
D2-2-3, Section 4. Specific to scheduling, the Lessons Learned exercises conducted after 28
6 Because of the changes to the Unit 3 start date, the baseline schedule for Unit 3 is a Revision 2 schedule. See
Attachment 2.
![Page 8: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 8 of 17
completion of each Unit 2 execution work activity were of critical importance in informing the 1
development of the Remaining Units’ schedules. 2
3
As explained in Ex. D2-2-3, Section 4, the Lessons Learned program examined each 4
completed work activity for Unit 2, with a particular focus on critical path activities, to 5
understand in detail the drivers of good performance (for those activities that took less time 6
than scheduled), and the causes of below target performance (for those activities where actual 7
durations exceeded the planned durations). This detailed understanding of the underlying 8
reasons for better than plan or worse than plan performance on Unit 2 work activities, facilitated 9
adjustments to the planned durations of similar activities in each of the Remaining Units’ 10
schedules. When compared to the original planned durations at the RQE/U2EE, the planned 11
duration of activities was reduced in some instances and increased in others. 12
13
In performing the detailed analysis of work activities on Unit 2, there was a particular focus on 14
understanding the causes of any delays in work execution as well as the causes of lower-than-15
plan or higher-than-plan productivity. Many delays were assessed to be one-time events and, 16
therefore, not expected to recur on the Remaining Units. The remaining delays were reviewed 17
to refine the assumptions about how an activity would be completed and, therefore, to adjust 18
the planned duration for that activity in the Remaining Units’ schedules. 19
20
OPG reviewed the causes of higher-than-plan and lower-than-plan productivity on Unit 2 work 21
activities, particularly critical path activities, in depth. Where higher-than-plan productivity rates 22
were assessed to be fully or partially repeatable on the Remaining Units, these rates were then 23
either partially or fully built into duration assessments for similar activities on the Remaining 24
Units. Where lower-than-plan productivity was achieved, tactical changes (e.g., changes to 25
work procedures) were implemented to facilitate increased productivity for similar activities on 26
the Remaining Units. Section 3.2.2 below discusses three specific Strategic Improvements 27
which are expected to reduce delays and to drive increased productivity on the Remaining 28
Units. 29
![Page 9: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 9 of 17
3.2.2 Strategic Improvements 1
OPG is implementing, or has implemented, a number of Strategic Improvements for the 2
Remaining Units which have more overarching impacts on the Program than the typical 3
Lessons Learned. Six Strategic Improvements are described in Ex. D2-2-3, Section 5. Three 4
of the Strategic Improvements which have positively impacted schedule are explained below: 5
• Radiation Protection Improvements: Improvements to radiation protection are a major 6
contributor to schedule improvements. Over one hundred specific actions have been 7
implemented under the Radiation Protection Strategic Improvement (Ex. D2-2-3, Section 8
5.1.4), the majority of which aim to eliminate or reduce delays. Examples of these actions 9
include: (1) ensuring that the demand for radiation protection coordinators is integrated into 10
the schedule and tied to specific tasks which require a radiation exposure permit, thereby 11
eliminating delays caused by the lack of a radiation protection coordinator; (2) 12
implementing self-issue of electronic personal dosimeters to reduce the wait times for field 13
personnel who require radiation dose measuring instruments to perform their work; (3) 14
developing a new qualification and changing procedures to allow contractors to perform 15
self-protection for low risk activities. 16
• Training: The focus of the Training Strategic Improvement (Ex. D2-2-3, Section 5.1.5) is to 17
improve productivity. Specific examples are: (1) intensively training a smaller group on 18
troubleshooting, and the ability to understand the intricacies of the work series, 19
contingencies, the tooling, and the overall process (facilitated by implementation of the 20
hybrid schedule as discussed in the next bullet); and, (2) better aligning training schedules 21
with execution schedules, thereby having the training fresh in the minds of the 22
tradespersons as they prepare to execute the tasks in the field. 23
• Hybrid Schedule: A significant focus of the implementation of the Hybrid Schedule Strategic 24
Improvement (see Ex. D2-2-3, Section 5.1.6 for a detailed discussion) is on achieving 25
improved productivity on the Remaining Units. Two examples are: (1) the Hybrid Schedule 26
will require fewer trades to be trained and allow more time for training on the reactor mock-27
up, which will result in improved task execution proficiency; and (2) the Hybrid Schedule 28
will mean that each tradesperson will spend more time in the field in experiential learning, 29
which is expected to result in a shorter learning curve, as well as higher, and more 30
sustained, peak performance. 31
![Page 10: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 10 of 17
3.2.3 Developing Robust Schedule Logic 1
OPG employs many processes to verify the quality of its schedules and improve the robustness 2
of the schedule logic. 3
4
A key process is a review of the work which is scheduled to be done in parallel, with particular 5
focus on periods when there is more than one work team scheduled to work in the same area 6
of the plant. These reviews, known as vertical slice reviews, identify potential conflicts in very 7
specific work areas of the plant (e.g., the North-East Reactor Vault, Elevation 104). In a 8
workshop setting, all of the stakeholders involved in executing the work activities review the 9
schedule in detail. Conflicts can arise in many ways when more than one work group is 10
scheduled to work in the same area. For example, conflicts may arise in the use of breathing 11
air, when radiography is scheduled (radiography interrupts the work of other work groups), in 12
electrical needs for the different work packages, and in radiation protection requirements. 13
14
During the latter stages of the Unit 2 refurbishment outage, OPG deployed for the first time a 15
technique known as “4D scheduling.” This technique utilizes computer graphics to create a 16
visual simulation of an area of the plant or a piece of major equipment. The visual simulation 17
is tied to, and driven by, the schedule logic built for that particular activity. Using this technique 18
allows the people who are planning and executing the work to view a simulation of the 19
sequence of activities in the schedule prior to executing the activities in the field, thereby 20
becoming better equipped to identify and resolve potential issues. An additional benefit of 4D 21
scheduling is that it can be used to improve the training for a sequence of activities. 22
23
Another on-going process reviews the optimal timing of efficient work package execution. This 24
process particularly applies to work that is off critical path, where greater flexibility exists to 25
review and make adjustments to the sequence of work activities. Reviews are conducted 26
frequently to identify work that could be completed earlier in the refurbishment outages of the 27
Remaining Units, which would reduce the risk of this work becoming critical path. For example, 28
opportunities are regularly assessed to maximize any work that could be done on each unit 29
before breaker open, thereby reducing risks associated with the volume of work, and facilitating 30
a more manageable work load and resource profile, during the refurbishment outage itself. 31
![Page 11: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 11 of 17
3.2.4 Reviewing the Overlapped Periods 1
The degree of overlap between the prior and subsequent unit refurbishments is subject to a 2
number of constraints that must be evaluated in detail. For example, bulkhead installation on 3
a unit that is being readied for the mechanical removal of the fuel channels and feeders 4
(Segment 1 - Lead In - Defuelling and Containment Isolation) cannot take place concurrently 5
with bulkhead removal on a unit that is being prepared to be returned to service (Segment 4 -6
Plant Restoration Start-up) because of reactor safety considerations. 7
8
Potential resource constraints also must be taken into account. For example, work activities 9
across units that are operator intensive should not overlap to a degree that would cause 10
operator resource availability to affect execution. Also, scheduling two infrequently performed 11
technical evolutions at the same time, requires carefully assessing the executing organizations’ 12
capacity to undertake those evolutions safely and with quality, and determining whether 13
changes to the schedule may be necessary to mitigate risk. 14
15
A Strategic Improvement directly related to managing overlapping refurbishment outages is 16
Workstream Specialization, which was introduced in Ex. D2-2-3, Section 5.1.1, and is 17
explained in detail in Ex. D2-2-8, Section 2.2. Workstream Specialization involves the 18
development of highly trained specialized work crews to execute the same series of work by 19
moving directly from one unit’s refurbishment outage to the next. For example, this sequencing 20
of work allows the crew which has just completed the feeder removal series of work activities 21
on one unit, to move to the next unit and complete the same series. The expectation is that 22
this team will continuously improve their high proficiency levels through specialization and 23
repetition. Implementation of Workstream Specialization requires careful attention to how 24
activities are overlapped. Figure 3 shows that similar segments of consecutive refurbishment 25
outages on the Remaining Units are never overlapped, thereby allowing the same team to 26
execute the same work on each of the Remaining Units. 27
![Page 12: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 12 of 17
Figure 3: Remaining Units Schedule Showing No Overlaps of Lead In, 1 Removal, Installation and Lead Out Work Activities on Consecutive Units2
3 4
3.3 Remaining Units Schedules 5
Chart 1 provides the High Confidence Schedule dates and durations for the Remaining Units. 6
High confidence durations have not changed since RQE. 7
8
Chart 1: High Confidence Schedule Dates 9 for Units 3, 1, and 4 Refurbishments 10
High Confidence Schedule
Start End Duration (Months)
Unit 3 3-Sep-20207 2-Jan-2024 40
Unit 1 15-Feb-2022 18-Apr-2025 38
Unit 4 15-Sep-2023 16-Oct-2026 37
11
The Level 1 Working Schedules for the Remaining Units with details of the planned start dates, 12
durations, end dates and of critical path activities are provided as Attachments 3, 4, and 5 for 13
Units 3, 1, and 4 respectively. These are the high-level Working Schedules that OPG uses to 14
manage day-to-day performance on the unit refurbishment outages. 15
7 Actual start date of the Unit 3 refurbishment outage.
Lead Out
UN
IT 1
UN
IT 4
Lead In Removal Installation
Lead In Removal Installation Lead Out
UN
IT 3
Lead In Removal Installation Lead Out
20262022 2024 202520232020 2021
![Page 13: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 13 of 17
3.4 Unit-Over-Unit Efficiencies 1
As shown in Chart 1, and consistent with the RQE and U2EE, OPG is planning to achieve 2
improvements in the High Confidence Schedule durations as the refurbishment outages of 3
Units 3, 1, and 4 are executed. The planned High Confidence durations decrease from 40 4
months on Unit 3, to 38 months on Unit 1, to 37 months on Unit 4. Given the actual achieved 5
duration of just over 43.5 months on Unit 2, these planned durations represent substantial 6
improvements of 3.5 months, 5.5 months and 6.5 months for Units 3, 1, and 4 respectively, 7
when compared to Unit 2. 8
9
Similarly, the Working Schedules for Units 3, 1, and 4, which OPG will use to manage day-to-10
day performance on the unit refurbishment outages, are 36 months, 33 months, and 32 months 11
respectively. These durations represent improvements of 7.5 months, 10.5 months and 11.5 12
months for Units 3, 1, and 4 respectively, when compared to the actual achieved duration of 13
just over 43.5 months on Unit 2. 14
15
Chart 2 shows a high-level comparison of the planned durations of major critical path work 16
activities for Unit 3 versus the durations achieved on the same activities on Unit 2. 17
18
Chart 2: Major Critical Path Series on Unit 3 19 Planned Improvements versus Unit 2 Actuals8 20
21 22
Chart 2 shows Working Schedule planned durations for Unit 3 being shorter than the Unit 2 23
actual achieved durations in 7 of the 8 major phases. On a plan-versus-plan basis however, 24
not all activities for Unit 3 are being planned with shorter execution durations than those 25
achieved on Unit 2. Chart 3 provides examples of select critical path work activities which are 26
8 The Unit 2 actuals are compared against the planned durations in the Unit 3 Working Schedule.
Shutdown and
Defuelling
Vault Prepara-
tion
Feeder Removal
Fuel Channel Removal
Calandria Tube
Installation
Fuel Channel
Installation
Feeder Installation
Vault Restora-
tion
Run-up and Syn-chronize
Total
Days Difference -1 -35 -4 -58 -32 -30 -63 -17 12 -230Improvement 2% 19% 6% 26% 18% 19% 30% 9% -49% 17%
![Page 14: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 14 of 17
planned to be shorter, and examples of activities planned to be longer for the Unit 3 plan 1
compared to the Unit 2 plan. 2
3
Chart 3: Select Examples of Critical Path Durations - 4 Unit 3 Plan vs. Unit 2 Plan 5
Unit 3 Critical Path Activities Forecast Shorter than U2 Days Unit 3 Critical Path Activities
Forecast Longer than U2 Days Defuel Reactor -23 Bulkhead Installation +8 Install Shielding -19 Remove Bridge/Install Retube
Tooling Platform +13
Pressure Tube Removal* -34 End Fitting Removal +10 Calandria Tube Insert Release -8 Lower Feeder Installation +47 Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning -7 Lower Body Tubing Install +31 Airlock Close and Pressure Test -10 Bulkhead Removal -7 *Pressure Tube Removal will be done concurrently with Calandria Tube Removal for Unit 3, saving 34 days on the schedule compared to Unit 2. This Darlington 3 Innovations Project Strategic Improvement is described in Ex. D2-2-3, Section 5.1.3.
6
Contributing to OPG’s confidence in achieving Unit-over-Unit efficiencies is OPG’s 7
implementation of the Hybrid Schedule for the Remaining Units. In the Hybrid Schedule, the 8
number of working days are fewer than the elapsed calendar days. As discussed in Ex. D2-2-9
3, for those work activities executed utilizing a 24 hours per day/5 days per week schedule, 10
weekends provide opportunities to perform near critical path work and to recover lost time on 11
critical path, as required. For example, in the case of Unit 3, the number of elapsed days in the 12
Working Schedule of 36 months, is 1,096 calendar days; however, the number of working days 13
is 930 days. Sections 3.2.1 and 3.2.2 explain that the application of Lessons Learned and the 14
implementation of Strategic Improvements are expected to address challenges experienced 15
on Unit 2 and to result in improved productivity. In addition, Ex. D2-2-3, Section 5.1.3 describes 16
the Darlington Unit 3 Innovations Project (“D3IP”) Strategic Improvement. 17
18
Chart 4 summarizes OPG’s analysis of the contributors to the improved schedule duration for 19
Unit 3. Comparing the planned High Confidence Schedule duration for Unit 3 of 1216 days to 20
the achieved duration of 1,328 days for Unit 2, the difference is 112 days. Comparing the 21
planned Working Schedule duration for Unit 3 of 1096 days to the achieved duration of 1,328 22
![Page 15: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 15 of 17
days for Unit 2, the difference is 232 days. Comparing the planned working days for Unit 3 of 1
930 days to the achieved duration of 1,328 days for Unit 2, the difference is 398 days. 2
3
4
Resolved challenges are issues that were experienced on Unit 2 that are not expected to recur 5
because, utilizing Lessons Learned, mitigation has been put in place or procedures modified 6
to avoid the occurrence of these items. Chart 4 shows a reduction of 205 days from resolved 7
challenges when comparing Unit 3 planned working days to Unit 2 actuals. Some examples of 8
these resolved challenges and the resulting reduction in the number of days are: (a) feeder 9
installation challenges because of welding issues (99 days); (b) fuel channel installation delays 10
due to various issues such as hoisting and tooling breakdowns (58 days); (c) calandria tube 11
installation delays due to various issues such as leak testing and issues with positioning the 12
tubes (15 days); and, (d) bulkhead installation delays attributed to issues related to counter 13
balance lifting beam (16 days). 14
15
OPG is forecasting performance or productivity improvements totalling 115 days through the 16
application of Lessons Learned and the implementation of Strategic Improvements when 17
comparing Unit 3 planned working days to Unit 2 actuals. Some examples of the number of 18
schedule improvement days for certain work activities, include: (a) the fuel channel install 19
Chart 4: Contributors to Unit-Over-Unit Efficiencies - Unit 2 Actual vs. Unit 3 Planned
Days Unit 2 Achieved Duration 1328
Forecast Improvements for Unit 3 Resolved Challenges (i.e. not expected to recur) 205
Performance Improvements (Productivity) 115
D3IP Tooling/Methods Improvement 78
Unit 3 Planned Working Days 930
Unit 3 Planned Working Schedule (Calendar Days) 1096 Unit 3 Planned High Confidence Schedule (Calendar Days) 1216
![Page 16: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 16 of 17
series (30 days); (b) calandria tube removal, tube sheet bore cleaning and bellows inspections 1
(10 days). 2
3
The improved tooling initiatives under the D3IP are expected to yield a total of 78 days 4
improvement. The contributors to this 78 day improvement are: (a) pressure tube and calandria 5
tube combined removal (34 days); (b) modified installation worktables (36 days); (c) use of 6
double tool sets (4 days), and; (d) bellows cut tool enhancement (4 days). 7
8
In conclusion, OPG has carefully developed the schedules for the Remaining Units, based on 9
detailed analysis of its actual performance on Unit 2, and the application of Lessons Learned 10
and Strategic Improvements. OPG has high confidence in being able to achieve the forecasted 11
unit-over-unit efficiencies and overall duration improvements reflected in these schedules. 12
13
![Page 17: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Page 17 of 17
ATTACHMENTS 1
2
Attachment 1: OPG’s Multi-Level Scheduling Approach 3
Attachment 2: Unit 3 Level 1 Working Schedule 4
Attachment 3: Unit 1 Level 1 Working Schedule 5
Attachment 4: Unit 4 Level 1 Working Schedule 6
7
![Page 18: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Attachment 1
Page 1 of 2
Attachment 1: OPG’s Multi-level Scheduling Approach 1
2
The ability to validate, integrate, oversee and ultimately to retain control over the program 3
schedule is one of the key factors that has driven OPG’s Darlington Refurbishment Program 4
(“DRP”) strategy. OPG developed a fully integrated Program schedule, which incorporates the 5
project schedules for each of the major work bundles that are detailed down to the individual 6
work packages and work tasks within each bundle. OPG effectively leverages the control it 7
retains over the Program schedule to ensure Program success since the schedule has a direct 8
impact on Program costs. This Attachment describes OPG’s multi-level scheduling approach. 9
10
Multi-level Scheduling Approach 11
Based on recommended practices, OPG established its initial schedule using a multi-level 12
scheduling approach. OPG continues to apply the same approach as the schedule is 13
redeveloped and refined. As shown in Figure 1 below, project schedules are prepared with up 14
to four levels of detail, from Level “0”, which contains the Program milestones managed by 15
OPG and which identify the major deliverables and timelines for the overall DRP, to Level “3”, 16
which shows individual work components at the task level. For example, projects where most 17
of the work will be performed by contractors utilize detailed Level 3 schedules. OPG as the 18
owner performs project management and control activities utilizing Level 0 to 2 schedules. 19
20
Figure 1 21
Multi-level Scheduling Framework 22
Level 0: Program Milestone Schedule, controlled by OPG Senior
Management.
Level 1: Program Integrated Master Schedule, controlled by OPG Senior
Management. Program Level 1 contains all Control Accounts from all
Projects as well as for Program Management work.
Level 2: Program Coordination & Control Schedules, controlled by OPG
Program/Project teams. Program Level 2 contains all Work Packages in
the Program and they are interrelated.
Level 3: Project Detailed Production Schedules, controlled at the project
level, by contractors or OPG (for OPG executed projects).
Level 0
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
![Page 19: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Filed: 2020-12-31 EB-2020-0290
Exhibit D2 Tab 2
Schedule 5 Attachment 1
Page 2 of 2 1
Level 0 consists of the Program/Project Milestone Schedule, and is used by OPG senior 2
management to provide the basis for establishing the master schedule. This includes program 3
release milestones, regulatory milestones, outage preparation milestones and outage 4
execution milestones. 5
6
The Level 1 schedule is the Program/Project Integrated Master Schedule that contains 7
particular work scopes, a time window and a responsible organization. The Level 1 schedule 8
provides a high-level management summary of the Program or project, represents all units, 9
phases and bundles, and is used by project managers, contractors and scheduling functions. 10
11
Level 2 schedules are the Program/Project Coordination & Control Schedules. This is the 12
schedule used by OPG to track the overall status of the Program. It is updated and controlled 13
by OPG and is based on the contractors’ detailed Level 3 schedules. 14
15
Level 3 schedules are Program/Project Detailed Production Schedules which further break 16
down work into detailed activities. Level 3 schedules are prepared by the group executing the 17
work (typically by contractors, and in some cases by OPG where OPG is self-performing work). 18
The lowest level of tasks to be executed are developed here. 19
20
Once approved, schedules are ‘baselined’ by the project owners as a benchmark for 21
measuring implementation performance. Baselined schedules are archived and are not 22
modified, except by means of a re-baselining process involving cost and schedule analysis 23
and only through authorized change control. 24
![Page 20: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Unit 3 Refurbishment – DNRU3 Level 1 Overview Revision 2August 31, 2020
60% CP Complete
REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2A REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2BLEAD IN SEGMENT INSTALL SEGMENT LEAD OUT SEGMENT
State 1 State 2 State 3a State 3b State 4a State 4b State 5
Outage Day 10800 96020 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 680660 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 980 10201000 1040 1060 1100
SEP 2023
JUL2023
SEP 2020
JAN 2021
OCT 2020
JUL2021
APR 2021
MAR 2021
MAY 2021
FEB 2021
JUN 2021
AUG 2021
JUL 2022
OCT2021
NOV2021
JAN2022
APR 2022
MAR 2022
SEP 2021
MAY 2022
DEC 2021
FEB 2022
JUN 2022
AUG2022
OCT 2022
NOV 2022
JAN 2023
SEP 2022
DEC 2022
FEB 2023
MAR2023
APR 2023
MAY 2023
JUN 2023
AUG 2020
AUG 2023
NOV 2020
DEC 2020
196
TG Modification and Maintenance Scope
SDC Valves East Side
125BU16 Maintenance
Transformer& Bus
Maintenance
T10/12 BU10/12
To TPDS & Even E lect rical Outage
To VVRS Commissioning & Even Electrical Outage
009 VVRS Mods and Rehab
Critical Path WindowsElectrical Windows Reactivity Device Windows
Heat Transport System Windows
Turbine/Generator & Conv Layup
Gross Air Leak Test5d
005 EPS MCC Rehab
Inst Air Mtce
057 LPSW Outage
Moderator Testing
035HTS Aux Vac Dry
Mod Drain & Flush
EP Mods & Run Vac Hose
To Mod Drain & EP
Mods
Temp Fission Chamber Guide Tube Install
Remove Vac Dry Equip
054Hold out Warm er Temp
To Gross A irLeak Test
To RCHP 1
Connect to HTS System
038
048
079
081
056 PULSW Outage
123
104 Vault Projects
Hold out for Cooler Tem ps
029 HTS Vac Dry
SDC Valves & PULSW Line Replacement & ASDC Pumps
Temp Fission Chamber Install
HTSVac Dry Pre-Req’s 105 Vault Projects
Hold out for TCB declared &
Tem p Vault ACU’s Installed
P&IC & SDC Purge HTS Rehab - Outside Vault
Tem p Power Req’d for South Side Drai nage Sum ps
To RCHP 5
Remove SG Layup
ECI NV Inspections
195 RCW Work
To RCHP 4
(Layup)
FH Bridge Upgrade Complete
029
067
208
034 Install SG Layup Primary Side
032 LZCS
Remove Mod Dry Equip & Reconnect Mod Pipework
038
Isolate Calandria & Hookup Drying Equip.
045 076 Upper & Middle Feeder Installation
073 HFD Replacements
078
089
Hold out unt il 6 months before ATC
To RCHP 5
RCHP2
To RCHP 5
RCHP4
Decl arat ion that Reactor Core is Defueled Before Entering S tate 3a
Unit 1 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU1)
Moderator Windows
To RCHP 4
SDS1 Computer Replacements
Overhaul A/I Skid
103
121
Vac Dry Lower Mod Pipework
051 CL IV Elec. Maintenance
122 Moderator Valve Rehab
108103 Purge
Hold out for Bkrs & Relays from Cl I II
055 CCW Rehab
From VF Ds Removed
Secondary Side SG Clean & Install Access Ports
PULSW P iping R-015 124 Aux. SDC Pump InstallationASDC Interference Removal
From Isolate Calandria & Hookup Drying Equi p Perm it Appl ied
040 CL II Elec. Maintenance BUS A & C040 CL I I Elec. Maintenance BUS B
041 CL I II Elec. Maintenance
147147 ECI Valve Mtce
028 Removal
From SG Access Ports, EHS O utside Vaul t & HTS Pump Insp
To Repl ace Adjuster Rods
Clean Vault (FM E) Conditi ons In-E ffect
029
037128
Clean Vault (FM E) Conditi ons In-E ffect
Cooldown A fter Vac Dry
From Mod Valve Rehab
To Complete EHS (E. Vaul t)
064 South ACU 4&3
Complete Emergency Heat Sink Pipework (E. Vault)
From South ACU 4 replacem ent
& Vaul t Projects
007
Fill Calandria 5d
080
To LPSW, PULSW, CLIV E lec. Mtce
Hold O ut for Valve/IRI Resources
From Fuel Channel Install
Purge to be applied prior to CTI release and m aintai ned unti l all CT’s have been replaced
068
Feeder Cabinet Removal
Vessel Inspection
Fuel Channel Installation Series4 13027 47 1343910 12
Dummy FB Removal
Lower Feeder Install Series
Fuel LoadGroup 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffold
4110 17
084
083119
192
111
074
51Defuel Reactor
017 Install APT & End Fitt ing Caps
90
012
Install Bulkhead
Containment Pre-test, Achieve Dew pt. & Containment Test
Bulk Interference Removals
- Final Comm issioning VVRS Phase 1- AL & TCD Logic Mods- Breat hing Air Tie-in
Remove FM Bridges & Install RTPs
11554411 268
024
137
027023
101
Full Vault Access
100
CCW
Pumpwell Cl eaning
To RCHP 5
Remove HTS Pump Motors
Vaul t Access rest rictions due to Critical Lifts
022
Pumps Lif ted into place.Hold out for motor availabili ty
Coordinate wi th Crit ical Path Work -Vaul t Access rest rictions due to Critical Lift s
060 Install PHT Pump Motors065 HTS Pump Impelle r Inspection
Miscellaneous WindowsConv Water Windows
058
Conventional Side Layup002
221RRS LM Replacements
To SDS2 Computers W007
Replace Vertical Flux Detectors
To SG SS M tce W037& EHS i nside HT P 4 Rm& HT Pum p Insp
SDS2 Computer Replacements007From HTS Bulk Drai n Complete
To RCHP 2
From W103 Purge
021 RemovalsReplace Adjuster Rods
To SG PS Clean & Install HTS Pumps
To RCHP 2
(ACU4 Complete)
Tied to FC Install F inish
To Lower Feeder Install
To RCHP 1
046 LISS Rehab
OPGSS in effect
From Instal l HTS Pump Motors & Adjuster Rods Removed and Inst Ai r Mtce
013 HTS Bulk Drain
To RCHP 7
008 MOT & UST Removal 008 MOT & UST Install
To W078 Remove Mod Dry Equip
From Inst A ir Mai nt
S/D1d
Crane Mtce
SFCR30d
D1932SFCR Jul 31/20 – Aug 30/20
U3Shutdown
HTS Operational Testing (includes ASDC)
RCHP7
RCHP6
RCHP5
190
RCHP3
RTP Removals, Bridge Replacement
19 6
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
097
7
ATC & Fission Chamber removal2d
6 23 13
092
7 20
Heat-up& Hot Condition
193
082
Replace HT Pump Seals
222 SG Wet Recirc Layup Removal Includes IUFT and N2 B lanket removal
1096 days
DNRU3StartAug 30, 2020
070 North ACU 1&2
To RCHP 4
SDC Valves West Side 050
& PULSW P iping R-016
From HTS Vac Dry Complete
From HTS Aux Vac Dry Complete
EHS Outside Vault106Hold out for P roj ect Resources
Inside HT P4 Rm
From VF D Removal
To HTS Pump Insp.
To Feeder Scanner Replacement (Removed f rom U 1 and O verhauled)
Install & Connect A ir Skid
To Remove Adjuster Rods
To RCHP 4
To W062 SG PS Cl ean
From Remove Adjuster Rods
From VF D Removal
To EHS (E.Vaul t)
316 10 6
090
087 Feeder Scanner Replacement To RCHP 4
From W058CCW Compl ete
Spares overhauled f rom D 2011
U1 Outage 2020 (D2011)
10
Skids commissioning complete
Fuel LoadGroup 4
RTP Config 1,OB Columns & Elec Removal
U2 Outage 2023 (D2321)
231
232
063 SG Nitrogen Blanket Install
To Remove Adjuster Rods
Degas & Permitry
To Waterbox ECT S tart
From Waterbox ECT Compl ete
24/7 periods
24/6 periods
24/5 periods
Establish Upper Calandria Purge Flow & E/W Valve Mtce
RHP1
RHP2
RHP3
RCHP9
See Page 2 for TG Project Level 1 Overview
To DNRU1 W002 (IUF T Availabilit y)
11
36 Months
To RCHP 2
053 ESW Rehab
To RCHP 1
124
124
From W121 MO D Vac Dry
A
B
C
D
Page 1 of 2
TG Mi ni -Perm it
TG Main Perm it
From W256, W258 Fini sh to W198 Condensate Feedwater RTS
Permits Applied for OPS
resources
RCHP1: Moderator Fill
RCHP2: Fuel Load
RCHP3: Bulkhead Removal
RCHP4: Heat Transport System Fill
RCHP5: GSS Removal
RCHP6: Exceeding 1%FP
RCHP7: Turbine Testing & First Sync
RCHP8: Exceeding 35%FP
RCHP9: Unit Available for Commercial Operation
SGECS Drained (after W012 Complete)
BWXT Resources
1.
2.
Restart Control
Hold PointRCHP
x
Reactor States
State 1: Reactor Shutdown Evolution
State 2: Guaranteed Shutdown with Irradiated Fuel Core
State 3a: Defueled State
State 3b: Defueled & Isolated from Containment State
State 4a: Non Irradiated Fuel & Isolated from Containment
State 4b: Non Irradiated Fuel State
State 5: Approach to Critical & Return to Service State
NOTES
RHP Regulatory Hold
Point
U4 Outage 2021 (D2141)
003 SG Layup
(Recirc. Skids)
5
Sever Bellows
113PT Sever
112Feeder Removal
042End Fitt ingRemoval
114CTI Release
098 CTI Removal
116
CT/PT Removal
117
28
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
149
Bellows Inspections
072
18Calandria Tube Install Series118
LBS Cabinet Frame Tie-in
233
Feeder Lower Body Tubing
235
096High Power Test ing& Turbine Test ing
Run-up & Sync & Balance
095
RCHP8
RHP4
127
270 MOT/UST Fire Protection Mod
031 SA & CA Rods
USCA ACU Line Replacements053
RCHP1
To DNRU1 Breaker Open
129 140
019
Connect Conventional Side Dryers
Condensate & Feedwater RTS
SEP 1, 2023
To 054 Inst Air Mtce
Primary Side SG Clean & Inspect062
U1S/D Feeder
Cabinet Removal Feeder Rem oval
PT Sever
Sever Bellows
End Fit ti ng Removal
CT/PT Removal
Dumm y FB Removal
Defuel Reactor InstallAPT Install Bulkhead
Containm ent Test Bulk Interference
Removals
Comm ission VVRS
Remove F M Bridges & Install RT Ps
Crane Mai ntenance
Install Shielding
CTI Release
CTI Removal
Vessel Inspection
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
Bellows Inspections
CT Install
A lignments Vac Dry
Install Lower Body Supports
230Bulkhead Removal
088
Operating Units Fuel Run
157- A/L Closed- Pressure Test- VVRS Balance
085
234
NPC Logic Restoration
1d
146
094Power Escalation
Heat-up & Low Power Test ing
093
028 Replacement
004 IPB/Switchyard Rehab To RCHP 7
To RCHP 1
To W029 HTS Vac Dry Commi ssioning
Establish GSS
216
HTS Air Hold, Fill & Pressure Test
To RCHP 4
From Upper & Mi ddle Feeder
Installati on, CWP 3197
MOT/UST Commissioning
Conventional Side Restoration
198
From fi nish W012 Defuel Reactor
from 062 P ri mary S ide SG Clean & Inspect
021 Replacements
Nozzle Inspection & Weld Prep
From HTS Vac Dry Complete
197 Nuclear Side Restoration
From W121, MO D Vac Dry
Complete
272
BUS 8 Fini shTo LPSW Outage
Hold out for Resources
Winter (need cooler temp for BU14)
Ensure S tat ion requirem ents for CCW Pumps availabilit y during D 2141
To RCHP 5
Segment 4 Exception for Rev1
Feeder Visuals
Winter (need cold tem ps - L15 work)
Install RVAS
To D2011 Outage
010 Condensate & Feedwater
155
AA Mech Removals
To W197Nucl ear Si de Restoration
From W189 Remove SG Layup
Hold out for Warmer T emps
To ESW Rehab
From CL lI II
To RCHP 5 From BUS 8 Fini sh
From W121, MO D Vac Dry
Complete
Hold out for S tart of PULSW O utage
W258
W242
W243W247
W259W256W249
W240W245 W246
AISC Project Exception for Rev1 (2)
To W250 S tator Rewi nd & Shaf t Line Maintenance
189
Filed: 2020-12-31, EB-2020-0290, Exhibit D2-2-5, Attachment 2, Page 1 of 2
![Page 21: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Unit 3 Refurbishment – DNRU3 Level 1 Overview Revision 2August 31, 2020
60% CP Complete
REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2A REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2BLEAD IN SEGMENT INSTALL SEGMENT LEAD OUT SEGMENT
State 1 State 2 State 3a State 3b State 4a State 4b State 5
Outage Day 10800 96020 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 680660 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 980 10201000 1040 1060 1100
SEP 2023
JUL2023
SEP 2020
JAN 2021
OCT 2020
JUL2021
APR 2021
MAR 2021
MAY 2021
FEB 2021
JUN 2021
AUG 2021
JUL 2022
OCT2021
NOV2021
JAN2022
APR 2022
MAR 2022
SEP 2021
MAY 2022
DEC 2021
FEB 2022
JUN 2022
AUG2022
OCT 2022
NOV 2022
JAN 2023
SEP 2022
DEC 2022
FEB 2023
MAR2023
APR 2023
MAY 2023
JUN 2023
AUG 2020
AUG 2023
NOV 2020
DEC 2020
Page 2 of 2
121
60
137
5
212
106
411
15
67
57
21
17
Degas; Apply
f irst perm it
First TG Permit
Applied
U3
B/O
Apply Addit ional
Bloc ksMain TG Permit
Applied
120
A
B
90
CD1/2/3 New Seal Install, Scaf fold Removal & Close, CCD
140
CD1/2/3 Open Waterboxes, Eddy Current, SCR Inspect ionsD
W248 Static Commissioning- TC-EC-Gen Aux Skids
From
W002
Conv S ide
Drain
IPB & Airbox Ins tall & CCD
77
W251 – Generator Reassembly
Final Inst rum entat ion Work & CCD
Cables Dis connects &
Panel s Di smantle
45
MCR, UCER & DCC Work
B
196
New Cabinets, Cable Pulling & Cable T erm inati on, Post-reqs & CCD
168
Termi nations, Verif ications , & Components Install
Cubic les & Equipment Ins tall , Cables Install & Termi nations, Post-reqs , CCD
Cables, Equipment & Cubic les R em oval
210
Skid Instal l, New M CC, Cable Pull & New Panel Install Acti vit ies, Post-reqs & CCD50
Pre-fab & Skid Removal Activ it ies
All Skids Instal l & CCD28B
196
CD 1/2/3 Open, Install Dance F loor, S trut Inspect ions & Replacements
C
MSR T B 1/4/5/6/7/8 Inspections Activ it ies, MSR 1/2 Close & Post A ir Hold
30
MSR 1/2 Open & P re Ai r Hold
W240 MOCPER Removal
W241 MOCPER-MCR-UCER Installation & Mods
W242 Turbine Control Hydraulics Removal and Install
W243 Excitation Controls Removal
W244 Excitation Controls Installation
W247 Hydrogen Cooling Skid Modif ication
W256 Condenser and MSR Maintenance
W246 Seal Oil Skid Modif ication
90
IPB & A irbox Rem oval
W249 – Generator Disassembly
168
Removal and Instal l of T SS & TC FI Components
W259 General Mods Work
180
18
GE Integration workFront Standard
Pre-fabs & P re-reqs50 24 70
Removal Act iv ities
Install, Cable T ie-ins and Connect ions, Post-reqs & CCD
W245 SCW Skid Modificat ionB
To RCHP 5 DNRU1 Breaker Open
A First TG Permit
B Second TG Permit
C CCW Outage Start
D CCW Outage Finish
Window Start Milestone
Window Finish Milestone
CCD
GE Integration w ork
Seal I ns ert ion
30
MSR Drains
30
Post-reqs & CCD
W258 – General Maintenance Activities
5
W250 – GE Execution
Generator Mtce
Center L ine Mtc e
Init ial
Airbox L inks
Remov al
Jacking Oi l PS
Pre-fabs & P re-reqs
B
B
W058 – CCW
W259 General Mods Work CON’T
W256 Condenser and MSR Maintenance
To W248 Static Commissioning
Note: W248 Static Commissioning Exception for Rev 2
Unit 1 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU1)
To Feeder Scanner Replacement (Removed f rom U 1 and O verhauled)
From W058CCW Compl ete U1 Outage 2020 (D2011) U2 Outage 2023 (D2321)U4 Outage 2021 (D2141)
DNRU1 Breaker Open
U1S/D Feeder
Cabinet Removal Feeder Rem oval
PT Sever
Sever Bellows
End Fit ti ng Removal
CT/PT Removal
Dumm y FB Removal
Defuel Reactor InstallAPT Install Bulkhead
Containm ent Test Bulk Interference
Removals
Comm ission VVRS
Remove F M Bridges & Install RT Ps
Crane Mai ntenance
Install Shielding
CTI Release
CTI Removal
Vessel Inspection
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
Bellows Inspections
CT Install
Filed: 2020-12-31, EB-2020-0290, Exhibit D2-2-5, Attachment 2, Page 2 of 2
![Page 22: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Outage Day9600 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 980 10201000 1040 1060
Revision A1July 30, 2020
1080 1100
FEB 2022
MAR 2022
APR 2022
MAY 2022
JUN 2022
AUG 2022
JUL 2022
FEB 2023
NOV 2022
OCT 2022
DEC 2022
SEP 2022
JAN 2023
MAR 2023
APR 2023
MAY 2023
JUN 2023
AUG 2023
JUL 2023
FEB 2024
NOV 2023
OCT 2023
DEC 2023
SEP 2023
JAN 2024
MAR 2024
APR 2024
MAY 2024
JUN 2024
AUG 2024
JUL 2024
FEB 2025
NOV 2024
OCT 2024
DEC 2024
SEP 2024
JAN 2025
To RCHP 7
Critical Path WindowsElectrical Windows Reactivity Device Windows
Heat Transport System Windows
Turbine/Generator & Conv Layup
Moderator WindowsMiscellaneous WindowsConv Water Windows
SDC Valves East S ide
VVRS Mods and Rehab
Gross Leak Test5d
Inst Air Mtce
Moderator Test ing
P&IC & SDC PurgeHTS Aux Vac Dry
Mod Drain & Flush
EP Mods & Run Vac Hose
To Tie-in for Mod Vac Dry
To Mod Drain
Temp Fission Chamber Guide Tube Install
Remove Vac Dry Equip
Hold out for warmer temps
To Gross Leak Test
Connect to HTS System HTS Vac Dry
048
079081
035
140
108
123
Vault Projects104
SDC Valves, PULSW Lines, & ASDC Pumps
Temp Fission Chamber Install
129HTSVac Dry Pre-Req’s
Vault Projects105
HTS Rehab - Outside Vault
Remove SG Layup
ECI NV Inspections
To RCHP 4(Layup)
FH Bridge Upgrade Complete
RCHP1
029029
208
Remove Mod Dry Equip & Reconnect Mod Pipework
Isolate Calandria & Hookup Drying Equip.
From HTS Vac Dry
Complete
Upper & Middle Feeder Installation
HFD Replacements
038
073
078
045 076
Hold out unt il 6 months before ATC
To RCHP 5
RCHP2
LZCS To RCHP 5
089
Decl arat ion that Reactor Core is Defueled Before Entering S tate 3a
REMOVAL - SEGMENT 2A REMOVAL – SEGMENT 2BLEAD IN - SEGMENT 1 INSTALL – SEGMENT 3 LEAD OUT – SEGMENT 4
SDS1 Computer Replacements
Overhaul Air Skid
Alignments
Vac Dry Lower Mod PipeworkModerator Valve Rehab
Alignments
103 Purge
Establish Upper Calandria Purge Flow & E/W Valve Mtce
PULSW P iping R-015 ASDC Interference Aux. SDC Pum p Install ation
Vac Dry
Primary Side SG Clean & Inspect062
ECI Valve Mtce
028
From SG Access Ports, EHS Outside Vaul t & HTS Pump Insp
Clean Vault Conditi ons In-E ffect
189
029
From Instal l HTS Pump Motors and Adjuster Rods Removed
Establish GSS
216
128
Clean Vault Conditi ons In-E ffect
Cooldown A fter Vac Dry
197Nuclear Side Restoration
From Mod Valve Rehab
To Complete EHS (E. Vault)
Complete EHS Pipework (E. Vault)From S outh A CU 4
replacem ent& V aul t Projects
007
State 3aState 1 State 2 State 4bState 3b State 4a State 5
Fill Calandria 5d
080
From Fuel Channel Install
Purge to be applied pri or to CTI release and m aintai ned unti l all CT’s have been replaced
Nozzle Inspection & Weld Prep
068
Feeder Cabinet Removal
Vessel Inspection
Feeder Removal
PT Sever
Sever Bellows
End Fitt ingRemoval Fuel Channel Installation Series
CT/PT Removal
Dummy FB Removal
Lower Feeder Install Series
Fuel LoadGroup 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffold
CTI Release
084
083119117098
116
112 113 114
111
042
074
Defuel Reactor
Install APT & End Fitting Caps
012
017
Install Bulkhead
Containment Pre-test, Achieve Dew pt. & Containment Test
Bulk Interference Removals
- Final Commissioning VVRS Phase 1- AL & TCD Logic Mods- Breathing Air Tie-in
Remove FM Bridges & Install RTPs
024
137
027
101Full Vault Access
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
Bellows Inspections
072
Calandria Tube Install Series118
122
To SDS2 Computers
W007
Replace Vertical Flux Detectors
To SG SS M tce W037& EHS i nside HT P 4 Rm
Removal Replacement
SDS2 Computer Replacements007From HTS Bulk Drain Complete
From W103 Purge
ReplacementsRemovals021 021Replace Adjuster Rods
To SG Prim ary Side Clean & Install HT S Pumps
To RCHP 2
SouthACU 4&3
(ACU4 Complete)
To Lower Feeder Install
Tied to FC Install F inish
To RCHP 1
From SG Primary Side Clean
LISS Rehab
OP GSS in effect
To Inst Ai rMtce
HTS Bulk Drain
013
To Remove Mod Dry Equip
From Inst Air Maint
HTS Operational Test ing (includes ASDC)
RCHP7
RCHP6
RCHP5
HTS Air Hold, Fill & Pressure Test
RCHP3
RTP Removals, Bridge Replacement
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
Bulkhead Removal
- Shielding Rem’d- A/L Closed- Pressure Test- VVRS Balance
NPC Logic Restoration
1d
146
097
088
085
094
ATC & Fission Chamber removal2d
Heat-up & Low Power Test ing
Run-up & Sync & Balance
092095
096
093
High Power Testing & Turbine Test ing
Power Escalation
Heat-up& Hot Condition
193
082
Replace HT Pump Seals
SG Wet Recirc Layup Removal
Includes IUFT and N2 B lanket removal
1010 days
222
Feeder Lower Body Tubing
235
NorthACU 1&2
To RCHP 4
SDC Valves West Side 050
Removal & PULSW P iping R-016
From HTS Vac Dry
Complete
From HTS Aux Vac Dry Complete
EHS Outside Vault106Hold out for
P roject Resources Inside HT P4 Rm
From VF D Removal E HS Inside Vault
Install & Connect A ir Skid
To EHS (E.Vault)
Install Lower Body Supports
LBS Cabinet Frame Tie-in
Feeder Visual Inspections & Stairway Install
090
Fuel LoadGroup 4
RTP Config 1,OB Columns & Elec Removal
4 11624 42 120359 11 9 164590 5 105011 247 25 16 89 197 5 127 196 9 16939 27 37
VVRS Mods and Rehab
3 12 5
001U1 S/D 1d
Crane Maintenance 3d
015Install Shielding
22
DNRU1StartFeb 15/22
33 months
DNRU160% CP
Complete
CCW W058
054
From VF D Removal
Secondary Side SG Clean & Install Access Ports037 SG Nitrogen Blanket Install
Recal l Installed for Secondary Containm ent
To Repl ace Adjuster Rods
RHP 1 RHP 4
RHP 2
RHP 3
RemoveHTS Pump Motors
Vaul t Access rest rictions due to Critical Lift s
022
Install HTS Pump MotorsHold out for motor availabili ty
Coordinate wi th Crit ical Path Work - Vaul t Access Restricti ons due to Crit ical Lif ts
060HTS Pump Impeller Inspect065
Pumps Lif ted into place
To Remove Adjuster Rods
To RCHP 4
To SG PS Cl ean P re-req W062A
From Remove Adjuster Rods
From VF D Removal
028
124 124124
124
Page 1 of 2
Unit 1 Refurbishment – DNRU1 Level 1 Overview
To Remove Adjuster Rods
190
025 149
192
234
231
232
233
023
230
121
147
009
063
046
032
064
103
070
To DNRU4 W002 (IUFT Availability)
Hold O ut BWXT Resources
SGECS Drained (after W012 Complete)
158AA Mechanism
Removal
To Containm ent Press Test W024 &Replace Veri tcal F lux Detectors W028
SA & CA Rods
Install SG Layup Primary Side034
031
CTI Removal
RCHP8
Hold out as l ate as possi ble
RCHP9
RCHP4
067
To HTS Vac Dry Draining Boilers
SG Nit rogen B lanket Installed
EPS MCC RehabCL II Elec. Maintenance
005
CL IV Elec. MaintenanceHold out for Bkrs & Relays from Cl I II
From Isolate Calandria & Hookup Drying Equip
Perm it Appl ied
BUS A & C BUS B040
IPB/Switchyard Rehab
To RCHP 7
004Hold out for Warmer T emperatures
MOT/UST Removal MOT/UST Install008 008
CL III Elec. Maintenance041
051
MOT/UST Fire Protection270
040Hold out for Winter Months (BU13) From MO D Vac Dry
To LPSW/PULSW To RCHP 1
To RCHP 7
To RCHP 1
To RCHP 2
LPSW OutageWinter (need cold water tem ps – L15 work) 057
PULSW OutageHold out for Cooler Tem ps
Tem p Power Req’d for South Side Drai nage Sum ps
To RCHP 5
056
CCW RehabP umpwell Cl eaning
055
USCA ACU Line Replacements053ESW Rehab053
RCW Work195 To RCHP 4Hold out for Valve & IRI Resources
1.
2.
3.
Critical Window
Restart Contr ol Hold Point
Reac tor St ates
State 1: Reactor Shutdown Evolution
State 2: Guarant eed Shut down with Irr adiated Fuel Cor e
State 3a: Defueled State
State 3b: Defueled & Isolated from Containment State
State 4a: Non Irr adiated Fuel & Isolated from Containment
State 4b: Non Irr adiated Fuel S tat e
State 5: Approach to Critical & Return to Service State
NOTES
11 Duration (days)
Window #
Window Name SGs
Window #
Window Name
Non-Critical Window
084
Fuel Load
RHP
Regulat ory Hold Point
062
RCHPx
RCHP1: Moderator Fill
RCHP2: Fuel Load
RCHP3: Bulkhead R emoval
RCHP4: Heat Transpor t Syst em Fill
RCHP5: GSS Removal
RCHP6: Exceeding 1%FP
RCHP7: Turbine Testing & First Sync
RCHP8: Exceeding 35%FP
RCHP9: Unit Available for Commercial Operation
4. RCHP
U2 Outage 2023 (D2321)
Feeder Cabinet Removal Feeder Rem oval
PT Sever
Dumm y FB Removal
Defuel Reactor
SD
InstallAPT Install Bulkhead
Containm ent Test
Bulk Interference Removals
Final Comm issioning VVRS Remove F M Bridges &
Install RT Ps
Crane Mai ntenance
Install Shielding
Unit 4 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU4)Sever Bellows
Unit 3 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU3)
Fuel Channel Installat ion Seri es Lower Feeder Install SeriesCalandria T ube Install SeriesBulkhead Removal
Fuel LoadGroup 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffol d
Install Lower Body Supports Feeder Lower
Body Tubing
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
NPC Logic Restoration 1d ATC &
Fission Chamber removal
Run-up & Sync & Balance
High Power Testi ng & Turbine Testi ng
Feeder V isual Inspections & Stairway Instal l
- A/L Closed- P ressure Test- VVRS Balance
Heat-up& Hot Conditi on Heat-up
& Low Power Testi ng
Power Escalati on
RTP Removals, B ri dge Replacem ent
LBS Cabinet Frame Tie -in
Operating Units Fuel Run Vessel
Inspection End Fit ti ngRemoval
CTI Removal
CT/PT Removal
CTI Release
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
Bellows Inspections Calandria T ube Install Series
DNRU360% CP
Complete
Conventional Side Restoration196
Condensate & Feedwater RTS198
To RCHP 5 & D2321 Outage
Perm its Applied for OPS Resources
003
DNRU3 W198 RTS complete
IUF T Avail abi lit y
SG Layup (Recirc. Skids)
Heat Sink – Boiler Ski ds
comm issioned, HP Demin Connected
Conventional Side Layup002
CFW Drained, RV’s Removed & B locked
Condensate & Feedwater010
CCW058
Connect Conv Side Dryers019
106
MPO Protection Upgrade159
270MOT/UST FP
Commissioning
272MOT/UST Replacment
Commissioning
To LPSW/PULSW
From CLII I & MO D Vac Dry
TG Modification and Maintenance Scope
Degas & Permitry
TG Stat ic Commissioning
To MOCPER Comm issioni ng
To Waterbox ECT S tart
From Waterbox ECT Compl ete
See Page 2 for TG Project Level 1To RCHP 5 & DNRU4A
B
C
DFirst TGPerm it
SC1
Second TGPerm it
Generator & Shaft line Mtce
From W241 Complete
From W249 Complete
From W256 Fini sh to W019 & W198 Condensate Feedwater RTS
Hold out for t raini ng post AA Rods
Filed: 2020-12-31, EB-2020-0290, Exhibit D2-2-2, Attachment 3, Page 1 of 2
![Page 23: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Outage Day9600 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 980 10201000 1040 1060
Revision A1July 30, 2020
1080 1100
FEB 2022
MAR 2022
APR 2022
MAY 2022
JUN 2022
AUG 2022
JUL 2022
FEB 2023
NOV 2022
OCT 2022
DEC 2022
SEP 2022
JAN 2023
MAR 2023
APR 2023
MAY 2023
JUN 2023
AUG 2023
JUL 2023
FEB 2024
NOV 2023
OCT 2023
DEC 2023
SEP 2023
JAN 2024
MAR 2024
APR 2024
MAY 2024
JUN 2024
AUG 2024
JUL 2024
FEB 2025
NOV 2024
OCT 2024
DEC 2024
SEP 2024
JAN 2025
Turbine/Generator & Conv Layup
DNRU160% CP
Complete
Critical Path Windows
Page 2 of 2
Unit 1 Refurbishment – DNRU1 Level 1 Overview – TG Project
60
SC1
A First TG Permit
B Second TG Permit
To MOCPER Static Comm
SC2 To Excitation Static Comm
SC3 To SCW Static Comm
SC4 To Seal Oil Static Comm
SC5 To H2 Static Comm
SC6 To TSS Static Comm
SC7 From MOCPER Static Comm
C CCW Outage Start
D CCW Outage Finish
Window Start Milestone
Window Finish Milestone
21
17
Degas; Apply
f irst perm it
First TG Permit
Applied
U1
B/O
Apply Addit ional
Bloc ks
Main TG Permit
Applied
TC MO CPER Panels SC
Jacking Oi l/SVs, PTs, N Ss SC
FRF Hy draulic s SC
Exc itat ion Controls SC
Seal O il Skid S C
TSS Modif ications SC
SCW Skid SC
H2 Skid SC
A
B
MO CPER Cables
Di sc onnects & Di smantle
MCR , UCER & DC C Work
Cabinets Ins tall
B
Cable Pulli ng & Termi nation Lights, Ins pec ti ons
& CCD
SC1
Components Removal Components Ins tall Termi nations, Veri fic ati ons,
Post-reqs
Cable
Remov alCubic les I nstall
Equipment
Remov al
Cubic les R em oval
Cables Install & Termi nations Post-reqs & CCD
SC2
Ol d Skid Removal N ew Skid I nstal l T ie-ins and Connec ti ons L ights, Post-
reqs & CCD
SC3
Cable & Panel Ins tall Act iv iti esSkid Rem ov al Act iv iti es Skid Ins tal l Act iv it ies Final Equipment Work
and CCD
SC5
All Ski ds R em ov al
All Ski ds M ec h Ins tall
All Ski ds I&C /
Elec Install
Seal O il
Skid CCD
B SC4
CD 1/2/3 Open &
Ins tall Danc e Fl oo rCD 1/2/3 Strut I nspections & Repair
CD1/2/3 Open W aterboxes, Eddy Current , SCR Inspec tions
C D
MSR TB 4/5/6
Ins pec ti ons Activ it ies
MSR 1/2 Open
& Pre Air Hold
SC4
SC5
SC7
SC2
SC6
HG 09 SC
W240 MOCPER Removal
W241 MOCPER-MCR-UCER Installation & Mods
W242 Turbine Control Hydraulics Removal and Install
W243 Excitation Controls RemovalW244 Excitation Controls Installation
W245 SCW Skid Modification
W248 Static Commissioning- TC-EC-Gen Aux Skids
W247 Hydrogen Cooling Skid Modification
W256 Condenser and MSR Maintenance
W246 Seal Oil Skid Modification
SC3
SC7
Air H old Tes t
Generator CCD
Dem ag , Seal O il Flus h &
Air H old Tes t Act iv it ies
IPB & Airbox Remov al
W249 Generator Disassembly
From W002
Conv S ide Drain
W250 Generator
MtceIPB & Airbox Ins tall
Remov al and Ins tall of TSS & TC FI Com ponents
SC6
W259 General Mods Work
W250 Shaft Line
Mtce
B
W251 Generator Reassembly
SC2
CD1/2/3 Seal Replac em ent &
Sc affol d Removal and Close
GE Mobilization &
Dedicated TH CR1
GE Dedicated
TH CR1 & CR2
GE Integration w ork
TC FI CC D
DN RU1 TG
Pre-Reqs
GE Integration w ork
Front Standard
GE Demobilization &
Dedicated TH CR1
Limited Access to U1 115 EL. TH Area
REMOVAL - SEGMENT 2A REMOVAL – SEGMENT 2BLEAD IN - SEGMENT 1 INSTALL – SEGMENT 3 LEAD OUT – SEGMENT 4
GE Generator & Shaft Line Maintenance
Valve Pos it ioni ng & CCD
GE Integration w ork
PSS Probes
B
Post G E TS S Work
TSS CCD
SC1
SC5
MSR 1/2 Clos e
& Post Air H ol d
To RCHP 5
& DNRU4
Breaker Open
SC7
SC1
Seal O il
Mtce CCD
Condens er
CCD
MSR Post-req
& CCD
CCW W058 U2 Outage 2023 (D2321)
Feeder Cabinet Removal Feeder Rem oval
PT Sever
Dumm y FB Removal
Defuel Reactor
SD
InstallAPT Install Bulkhead
Containm ent Test
Bulk Interference Removals
Final Comm issioning VVRS Remove F M Bridges &
Install RT Ps
Crane Mai ntenance
Install Shielding
Unit 4 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU4)Sever Bellows
Unit 3 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU3)
Fuel Channel Installat ion Seri es Lower Feeder Install SeriesCalandria T ube Install SeriesBulkhead Removal
Fuel LoadGroup 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffol d
Install Lower Body Supports Feeder Lower
Body Tubing
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
NPC Logic Restoration 1d ATC &
Fission Chamber removal
Run-up & Sync & Balance
High Power Testi ng & Turbine Testi ng
Feeder V isual Inspections & S tairway Instal l
- A/L Closed- P ressure Test- VVRS Balance
Heat-up& Hot Conditi on Heat-up
& Low Power Testi ng
Power Escalati on
RTP Removals, B ri dge Replacem ent
LBS Cabinet Frame Tie -in
Operating Units Fuel Run Vessel
Inspection E nd Fit ti ngRemoval
CTI Removal
CT/PT Removal
CTI Release
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
Bellows Inspections Calandria T ube Install Series
DNRU360% CP
Complete
Filed: 2020-12-31, EB-2020-0290, Exhibit D2-2-2, Attachment 3, Page 2 of 2
![Page 24: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Outage Day9600 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 980 10201000 1040 1060
Revision A DRAFTJune 5, 2020
AUG 2023
JUL 2023
FEB 2024
NOV 2023
OCT 2023
DEC 2023
SEP 2023
JAN 2024
MAR 2024
APR 2024
MAY 2025
JUN 2025
AUG 2025
JUL 2025
FEB 2026
NOV 2025
OCT 2025
DEC 2025
SEP 2025
JAN 2026
MAR 2026
APR 2026
MAY 2026
JUN 2026
AUG 2026
JUL 2026
MAY 2024
JUN 2024
AUG 2024
JUL 2024
FEB 2025
NOV 2024
OCT 2024
DEC 2024
SEP 2024
JAN 2025
MAR 2025
APR 2025
Critical Path WindowsElectrical Windows Reactivity Device Windows
Heat Transport System Windows
Turbine/Generator & Conv Layup
Moderator WindowsMiscellaneous WindowsConv Water Windows
Review Purposes Only U2 Outage 2025 (D2521)
Unit 4 Refurbishment – DNRU4 Level 1 OverviewPage 1 of 2
Unit 1 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU1)Fuel Channel Installat ion Seri es Lower Feeder Install SeriesCalandria T ube Install Series
Bulkhead Removal
Fuel Load Group 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffol dInstall Lower
Body Supports
Feeder Lower Body Tubing
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
NPC Logic Restoration 1d ATC & Fission
Chamber Rem ovalRun-up & Sync & Balance
High Power Testi ng & Turbine Testi ng
Feeder V isual Inspect ions & S tairway Instal l
- Shielding Rem’d- A/L Closed- P ressure Test- VVRS Balance
Heat-up& Hot Conditi on Heat-up
& Low Power Testi ng
P ower E scalati on
RTP Removals, B ri dge Replacem ent
LBS Cabi net Frame Tie-in
VVRS Mods and Rehab
SDC Valves East S ide
125BU16 Maintenance
Transformer& Bus Maintenance
127
T10/12 BU10/12
To TPDS & Even/Odd Elect rical Outage
To VVRS Commi ssioning & Even/Odd Electrical Outage
Gross Leak Test5d
EPS MCC Rehab
Install SG Layup Primary Side
CL I I Elec. Maintenance
Inst Air Mtce
LPSW Outage
USCA ACU Line Replacements
Moderator Test ing
P&IC & SDC PurgeHTS Aux Vac Dry
Mod Drain & Flush
EP Mods & Run Vac Hose
To Tie -in for Mod Vac Dry
To Mod Drain
Temp Fission Chamber Guide Tube Install
Remove Vac Dry Equip
Hold out for warmer temps
To Gross Leak Test
To RCHP 1
Connect to HTS System HTS Vac Dry
005
048
053
057
079081
PULSW Outage
035
108
123
Vault Projects104
Hold out for Cooler Tem ps
SDC Valves & PULSW Line Replacement & ASDC Pumps
Temp Fission Chamber Install129
HTSVac Dry Pre-Req’s
Hold out for TCB declared &
Tem p Vault ACU’s Installed
HTS Rehab - Outside Vault
Tem p Power Req’d for South Side Drai nage Sumps
To RCHP 5
Remove SG Layup
ECI NV Inspections
RCW Work195
To RCHP 4(Layup)
FH Bridge Upgrade Complete
RCHP1
029029
056
067
208
LZCS
Remove Mod Dry Equip & Reconnect Mod Pipework
Isolate Calandria & Hookup Drying Equip.From HTS Vac
Dry Complete
HFD Replacements
032
038
073
078
045
Hold out unt il 6 months before ATC
To RCHP 5
RCHP2
To RCHP 5
RCHP4
Decl arat ion that Reactor Core is Defueled Before Entering S tate 3a
To RCHP 4
REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2A REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2BLEAD IN SEGMENT INSTALL SEGMENT LEAD OUT SEGMENT
SDS1 Computer Replacements
Overhaul Air Skid
Alignments
121Vac Dry Lower Mod Pipework
CL IV Elec. Maintenance
Moderator Valve Rehab
Alignments
103 Purge
Establish Upper Calandria Purge Flow & E/W Valve Mtce
Hold out for Bkrs & Relays from Cl I II
CCW Rehab
PULSW P iping R-015 ASDC Interference Aux. SDC Pum p Install ation
Vac Dry
From Isolate Calandria & Hookup Drying Equi p Perm it Appl ied
040 BUS A & C BUS B
CL III Elec. Maintenance041
Primary Side SG Clean&Inspect062
147147 ECI Valve Mtce
028
From SG Access Ports
Clean Vault Conditi ons In-E ffect
189
029
From Instal l HTS Pump Motors & Adjuster Rods
Removed
To RCHP 2
Establish GSS
216
128
Clean Vault Conditi ons In-E ffect
Cooldown A fter Vac Dry
Nuclear Side Restoration
From Mod Valve Rehab
To Complete EHS (E. Vault)
Complete EHS Pipework (E. Vault)From South ACU 4
replacem ent& Vaul t Projects
007
State 3aState 1 State 2 State 4bState 3b State 4a State 5
Fill Calandria 5d
080
SA & CA Rods031
To LPSW/PULSW
From MO D Vac Dry
From Fuel Channel Install
Purge to be applied pri or to CTI release and m aintai ned unti l all CT’s have been replaced
Nozzle Inspection & Weld Prep
068
Feeder Cabinet Removal
Vessel Inspection
Feeder Removal
PT Sever
Sever Bellows
End Fitt ingRemoval
CTI Removal
Fuel Channel Installation SeriesCT/PT Removal
Dummy FB Removal
Lower Feeder Install Series
Fuel LoadGroup 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffold
CTI Release
084
083119117098
116
112 113 114
192
111
042
074
Defuel Reactor
Install APT & End Fitt ing Caps
012
017
Install Bulkhead
Containment Pre-test, Achieve Dew pt. & Containment Test
Bulk Interference Removals
- Final Commissioning VVRS Phase 1- AL & TCD Logic Mods- Breathing Air Tie-in
Remove FM Bridges & Install RTPs
024
137
027
023101Full
Vault Access
Tube Sheet Bore Cleaning
149
Bellows Inspections
072
Calandria Tube Install Series118
Pumpwell Cl eaning
055
051
103
122
RRS LM Replacements
To SDS2 Computers
W007
Replace Vertical Flux Detectors
To SG SS M tce W037& EHS i nside HT P 4 Rm
Removal Replacement
SDS2 Computer Replacements007
From HTS Bulk Drai n Complete
From W103 Purge
ReplacementsRemovals021 021Replace Adjuster Rods
To SG Primary S ide Clean
To RCHP 2
(ACU4 Complete)
To Lower Feeder Install
Tied to FC Install F inish
To RCHP 1
From SG Pri mary Side Clean
LISS Rehab046
OPGSS in effect
040 040
To Inst AirMtce
HTS Bulk Drain
013
IPB/Switchyard RehabTo RCHP 7
004Hold out for Warmer T emperatures
MOT/UST Removal MOT/UST Install008 008
To Remove Mod Dry Equip
From Inst Air Maint
HTS Operational Test ing (includes ASDC)
RCHP8
RCHP7
RCHP6
RCHP5
HTS Air Hold, Fill & Pressure Test
190
RCHP3
RTP Removals, Bridge Replacement
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
Bulkhead Removal
- Shielding Rem’d- A/L Closed- Pressure Test- VVRS Balance
NPC Logic Restoration
1d
146
097
088
085
094
ATC & Fission Chamber removal2d
Heat-up & Low Power Test ing
Run-up & Sync & Balance
092095
096
093
High Power Test ing & Turbine Testing
Power Escalation
Heat-up& Hot Condition
193
082
Replace HT Pump Seals
SG Wet Recirc Layup Removal
Includes IUFT and N2 B lanket removal
980 days
222
Feeder Lower Body Tubing
235
To RCHP 4
SDC Valves West Side 050
Removal & PULSW P iping R-016
From HTS Vac Dry Complete
From HTS Aux Vac Dry
Complete
Hold out for P roj ect Resources
From VF D Removal
EHS Inside Vault
Install & Connect A ir Skid
230 Install Lower Body Supports
233LBS Cabinet Frame Tie-in
234Feeder Visual Inspections & Stairway Install
090
Fuel LoadGroup 4
RTP Config 1, OB Columns & Elec Removal
3 11223 41 116349 11 9 15444 104810 237 24 15 86 186 57 185 9 15938 26 363 12 5
001U4 S/D 1d
Crane Maintenance 3d
015 Install Shielding
02521
DNRU4StartSep 15/23
009
90
32 Months
DNRU460% CP
Complete
054
126
T9/11 BU9/11Transformer
& Bus Maintenance Hold out for winter months (BU13/BU14)
RHP 4RHP 1
RHP 3
From VF Ds Removed
Secondary Side SG Clean & Install Access Ports037063 SG Nitrogen Blanket Install
To Repl ace Adjuster Rods
RemoveHTS Pump Motors
Vaul t Access rest rictions due to Critical Lift s
022
Install HTS Pump Motors
Coordinate wi th Crit ical Path Work - Vaul t Access Rest rictions due to Crit ical Li ft s
HTS Pump Impeller Inspect065
Pumps Lif ted into place
To Remove Adjuster Rods
To RCHP 4
To SG PS Cl ean
From Remove Adjuster RodsFrom VF D
Removal
124
124
124124
ESW Rehab053
197
1.2.
3.
Critical Window
Restart Control
Hold PointRCHP
x
Reactor States
State 1: Reactor Shutdown Evolution
State 2: Guaranteed Shutdown with Irradiated Fuel Core
State 3a: Defueled State
State 3b: Defueled & Isolated from Containment State
State 4a: Non Irradiated Fuel & Isolated from Containment
State 4b: Non Irradiated Fuel State
State 5: Approach to Critical & Return to Service State
NOTES
11Duration (days)
Window #
Window Name
062SGs
Window #
Window Name
Non-Critical Window084
Fuel Load
Regulatory Hold
PointRHP
060
064 SouthACU 4&3
NorthACU 1&2
070
Upper & Middle Feeder Installation076
221
034
12
RHP 2
231
232
RCHP9
To Remove Adjuster Rods EHS Outside Vault Inside HT P4 Rm106
To EHS (E.Vault)
Vault Projects105
140
Winter (need cold water temps – L15 work)
003
089
BWXT Resources
SGECS Drained (after W012 Complete)
RCHP1: Moderator Fill
RCHP2: Fuel Load
RCHP3: Bulkhead Removal
RCHP4: Heat Transport System Fill
RCHP5: GSS Removal
RCHP6: Exceeding 1%FP
RCHP7: Turbine Testing & First Sync
RCHP8: Exceeding 35%FP
RCHP9: Unit Available for Commercial
Operation
Reviewed by:
Reviewed by:
Andrew Negenman, Outage Director
David Deveau, Outage Manager
REV A APPROVALS TO ISSUE
Updated by:Chris Stewart, Outage Section Manager
DRAFT
Defuel Completed
Hold out for Valve & IRI Resources
158AA Mechanism
Removal
To Containm ent Press Test W024 &Replace Veri tcal Flux Detectors W028
MPO Protection Upgrade159
SG Layup (Recirc. Skids)
Condensate & Feedwater RTS198
To RCHP 5 & D2521 Outage Perm its Applied for OPS Resources
DNRU1 W198 RTS complete
IUF T A vail abi lit y
Conventional Side Layup002
CFW Drained, RV’s Removed & B locked
Condensate & Feedwater010
CCW058Connect Conv Side Dryers019
TG Modification and Maintenance Scope
Degas & Permitry TG Stat ic Commissioning
To MOCPER Comm issioni ng
To Waterbox ECT S tart
From Waterbox ECT Compl ete
See Page 2 for TG Project Level 1To
RCHP 5A
B
C
DFirst TGPerm it
SC1
Second TGPerm it
Stator Rewind & Shaft Line Mtce
From W241 CompleteFrom W249
Complete From W256 Fini sh to W019 & W198 Condensate Feedwater RTS
Heat Sink – Boiler Ski ds
comm issioned, HP Demin Connected
196Conventional Side Restoration
Recal l Installed for Secondary Containm ent
To HTS Vac Dry Draining Boilers
MOT/UST Fire Protection270 270MOT/UST FP
Commissioning
272MOT/UST Replacment
Commissioning
To RCHP 7
Filed: 2020-12-31, EB-2020-0290, Exhibit D2-2-2, Attachment 5, Page 1 of 2
![Page 25: REMA.3.3G :3.TS SCHED:LE - files.opg.com](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022012101/6169ef6411a7b741a34cfed6/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Outage Day9600 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 980 10201000 1040 1060
Revision A DRAFTJune 5, 2020
AUG 2023
JUL 2023
FEB 2024
NOV 2023
OCT 2023
DEC 2023
SEP 2023
JAN 2024
MAR 2024
APR 2024
MAY 2025
JUN 2025
AUG 2025
JUL 2025
FEB 2026
NOV 2025
OCT 2025
DEC 2025
SEP 2025
JAN 2026
MAR 2026
APR 2026
MAY 2026
JUN 2026
AUG 2026
JUL 2026
MAY 2024
JUN 2024
AUG 2024
JUL 2024
FEB 2025
NOV 2024
OCT 2024
DEC 2024
SEP 2024
JAN 2025
MAR 2025
APR 2025
Turbine/Generator & Conv Layup
DNRU460% CP
Complete
Critical Path Windows
Page 2 of 2Unit 4 Refurbishment – DNRU4 Level 1 Overview – TG Project
REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2A REMOVAL SEGMENT – 2BLEAD IN SEGMENT INSTALL SEGMENT LEAD OUT SEGMENT
State 3aState 1 State 2 State 4bState 3b State 4a State 5
Assumptions:
This is a copy and paste from DNRU1. Stator Rewind hasn’t been
included
Level 1 is not a roll-up of the Level 3 schedule
Level 1 is only meant for planning purposes
Refer to P6 Schedule for actual execution timelines
Revised Permitry timelines still to be discussed and reviewed
GE scope of the work does not utilize any Execution Windows
All ties have not be confirmed and are still under review
IRI Resources review at a Program level has not been yet reviewed
Post-Maintenance layup scope (W261) is still to be determined
Unit 1 Refurbishment Outage (DNRU1)Fuel Channel Installat ion Seri es Lower Feeder Install SeriesCalandria T ube Install Series
Bulkhead Removal
Fuel Load Group 1,2,3 & Hanging Scaffol dInstall Lower
Body Supports
Feeder Lower Body Tubing
Bulkhead Post-Reqs
NPC Logic Restoration 1d ATC & Fission
Chamber Rem ovalRun-up & Sync & Balance
High Power Testi ng & Turbine Testi ng
Feeder V isual Inspect ions & S tairway Instal l
- Shielding Rem’d- A/L Closed- P ressure Test- VVRS Balance
Heat-up& Hot Conditi on Heat-up
& Low Power Testi ng
P ower E scalati on
RTP Removals, B ri dge Replacem ent
LBS Cabi net Frame Tie-in
Reactor States
State 1: Reactor Shutdown Evolution
State 2: Guaranteed Shutdown with Irradiated Fuel Core
State 3a: Defueled State
State 3b: Defueled & Isolated from Containment State
State 4a: Non Irradiated Fuel & Isolated from Containment
State 4b: Non Irradiated Fuel State
State 5: Approach to Critical & Return to Service State
GE Generator & Shaft Line Maintenance
U2 Outage 2025 (D2521)
60
SC1
A First TG Permit
B Second TG Permit
To MOCPER Static Comm
SC2 To Excitation Static Comm
SC3 To SCW Static Comm
SC4 To Seal Oil Static Comm
SC5 To H2 Static Comm
SC6 To TC Hydraulics Static Comm
SC7 To FRF Static Comm
C CCW Outage Start
D CCW Outage Finish
SC8 To TSS Static Comm
SC9 From MOCPER Static Comm
Window Start Milestone
Window Finish Milestone
21
17
Degas; Apply
f irst perm it
First TG Permit
Applied
U1
B/O
Apply Addit ional
Bloc ks
Main TG Permit
Applied
TC MO CPER Panels SC
Jacking Oi l/SVs, PTs, N Ss SC
FRF Hy draulic s SC
Exc itat ion Controls SC
Seal O il Skid S C
TSS Modif ications SC
SCW Skid SC
H2 Skid SC
A
B
MO CPER Cables
Di sc onnects & Di smantle
MCR , UCER & DC C Work
Cabinets Ins tall
B
Cable Pulli ng Cable Term ination L ights, Ins pec ti ons
& CCD
SC1
Components Removal Components Ins tall Termi nations, Veri fic ati ons,
Post-reqs
Cable
Remov alCubic les I nstall
Equipment
Remov al
Cubic les R em oval
Cables Install & Termi nations Post-reqs & CCD
SC2
Ol d Skid Removal N ew Skid I nstal l T ie-ins and Connec ti ons L ights, Post-
reqs & CCD
SC3
Cable & Panel Ins tall Act iv iti esSkid Rem ov al Act iv iti es Skid Ins tal l Act iv it ies Final Equipment Work
and CCD
SC5
All Ski ds R em ov al
All Ski ds M ec h Ins tall
All Ski ds I&C /
Elec InstallCCD
B SC4
CD 1/2/3 Open, Ins tall Danc e Fl oor
CD1/2/3 Strut I nspectionsCD1/2/3 Strut R epairCD 1/2/3 Strut I nspections
CD1/2/3 Open W aterboxes, Eddy Current , SCR Inspec tions
C D
MSR TB 4/5/8
Ins pec ti ons Activ it ies
MSR 1/2 Open
& Pre Air Hold
SC4
SC5
SC6
SC7SC6
SC9
SC2
SC8
HG09 SC
W240 MOCPER Removal
W241 MOCPER-MCR-UCER Installation & Mods
W242 Turbine Control Hydraulics Removal and Install
W243 Excitation Controls RemovalW244 Excitation Controls Installation
W245 SCW Skid Modification
W248 Static Commissioning- TC-EC-Gen Aux Skids
W247 Hydrogen Cooling Skid Modification
W256 Condenser and MSR Maintenance
W246 Seal Oil Skid Modification
SC3
SC9
Air H old Tes t
Generator CCD
Dem ag , Seal O il Flus h &
Air H old Tes t Act iv it ies
IPB & Airbox Remov al
W249 Generator Disassembly
From W002
Conv S ide Drain
Generator Mtce
IPB & Airbox Ins tall
Remov al and Ins tall of TSS & TC FI Com ponents
SC8
W259 General Mods Work
Shaft Line Mtce
B
W251 Generator Reassembly
SC2
CD1/2/3 Sc affol d Removal and Close
GE Mobilization &
Dedicated TH CR2
GE Dedicated
TH CR1 & CR2
GE Integration w ork
TC FI CC D
DN RU4 TG
Pre-Reqs
GE Integration w ork
Front Standard
GE Demobilization &
Dedicated TH CR2
Limited Access to U4 115 EL. TH Area
DRAFT for Review Purposes Only
Valve Pos it ioni ng
& CCDSC6
SC7
GE Integration w ork
PSS Probes
B
Post G E TS S Work
TSS CCD
SC1
SC5
MSR 1/2 Clos e
& Post Air H ol d
To
RCHP 5
SC9
SC1
Filed: 2020-12-31, EB-2020-0290, Exhibit D2-2-2, Attachment 5, Page 2 of 2