Religion and the Public/Private Divide in the European ...SILVIO FERRARI. Religion and the Public...
Transcript of Religion and the Public/Private Divide in the European ...SILVIO FERRARI. Religion and the Public...
SILVIO FERRARI
Religion and the Public Sphere in the European Legal Systems
Religion in the European legal systems: a visible, State supported presence (teaching religion at school, public financing of religions, etc.)Elements of change: increasing number of European members of no religion: advocating a neutral public sphere increasing number of European members of new religions: advocating a plural public sphereSome mainstream religions opposing both neutral and plural public sphere
CHANGES
PATTERNS
Three patterns of ownership of the public sphere The traditional religion: Italy and the crucifix at
school Secularism: France and the ban of burqa Human rights: UK and the State definition of who
is a Jew… and their weak points
STRATEGIES
The transformation of the European public sphere Ethical, cultural, religious, ethnic pluralization De - privatization of religion (against Gentili’s
“silete theologi in munere alieno”)The context: fear of the decline of Europe. The
future is no more here.Remedies: confining more firmly religion in the
private sphere, giving the traditional religion the monopoly of public sphere (or both at the same time: Sarkozy’s France). Examples
What to do? 1A better distinction between common space (streets, squares, etc.): physical
and inescapable. Accessibility and ban of burqa public space (media, Hyde Park Corner, etc.):
metaphorical and voluntary. The space of discussion; freedom and ban of students’ religious symbols
institutional space (courts, public administration, etc.). The space of decisions binding on all: fairness and impartiality (the crucifix in the court rooms)
What to do? 2
Fairness and impartiality only through exclusion of religion? Exploring the possibilities of an inclusive neutrality (oaths, marriages, etc.)
Different European paths toward a common goal?