refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written...

36

description

engineer muhammad ali mirza sahab of jehlum 0323-8556237 [email protected] had written article number 2 research paper on his website ahlesunnatpak.comNow faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir 0321-5501977 [email protected] written radd refutation of that article.Original article of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab was titled andha dhund peravi ka anjaam.These links and articles are uploaded for those researchers who want to do comparatvive study themselves.

Transcript of refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written...

Page 1: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!"#$%&'()*!+,-

./01!,23456789:;</=>?@A!BC!DEFGH!IJKLMNOP/QRSP;T9,UVWX!(/YZ

[\%]_?GH!IJK;a*b!cdeCfghijUhi!kl!(/mn\o%jpqXrM%(st!ucqv*w@

Uxq!yzL!{|}~�!("1(!g?!#$%;]!,!&{fGH!IJK['1()W?!a*w*+Uoq,!a

*!-}.i/)q%01)!(/2345!6U\xX[8967189):!;<g=>KALGH!IJK;?,NOf@i$

~[AB/<g?GH!IJKC89D(EWb2345!6CWX!(/!yzL(E%F:GHb?2345!6G

1)WX!I(�UGH!IJKL!JNOA*23mn;89/jAK!LLCMN!6oCX!BCIJKL3%a

6O!BCP?GH!IJK*Qx?fg!a;NO*b!cR1STXAL!aIJKUUV?faUaWi(XYt

Wihi!ZxXAL>K!{af@i$ UH[9%XZ1)W\~!yzLGH!IJKUU]1S[9?!!J/QRS_

~ra!b{<!?GH!IJKL%c(defg!(/BC|h%F:*i/!j!(/!#$%(klm;%F:*n<1o_X

!{aAoGH!IJK;!BC!BC!p!q*b!creaq!s%tgu(v>w1xyXz{|!w+!#$%(

klm}vf~�.i/)![9"W#Uxq!A$}!J+WiHy!p!%6;b!896%&*'91<zX!{a

+!#$%(klm;89/jA(X!!a!p!%6;b!896./01!,; ) !p!%6GHqvA *+ A!yzL

G,-./s0Wq12!/3x?4U89F5i<1>wde67!(/89XGH!IJK:;<C=>iG1)W!(/O!{;

?}@g[9AtgG1)WXH>iBa*!"#!H30z<C?:GH!IJK*D!p!qE_FTCqO!{WiP!G!cHa

!~IcP;J!aU%[9FTCX

GH!IJK;!p!%6WiK,U6ML(%6]!,!&{C,-./s0Wq!(/MNO/Wi!a~Pz;Qb["W?rea

1R*$}!/%(5iS@iT1UVWX$}!UYZ[x,%4!(/\];!,Wi_s1LA*ac<Z[xX

X!6,b()c/d!e!f)de6)Wgh;reaiCjka1T9!(/!{;AK,1T9qUV!{WWil!,xb!p!#X *

#*mn }!ao%!c!paN <q!{89/jAq6!s%tg(!/%W!(/!{Wi!kr.sxX

X56t<uv/w!exyzLde6[9 {

-|m** }~!�%!!%q/"!#tg X

5iS$/j%&<'q!a(zA6"C)6<*!(/rea+FFTC,?!U7-!(/k.qG%!(/]/6q/09!(/hi!q1,

!(/H!%2@ia3X45fg6(!F7C?~Pzf_<89?(X|)'()o1)sF{Area@i:<zX

!{Atgf@iT1;!<-1T9./0;QYa<CX!(/3[Es"=cGH!IJK*x~Pzfrea;T9,>1?/xWX

!u!@�!ABCW!(/DE~�FhG%fmnH2%!IJW}K?GH!IJK#!(/L(XM,xNzO1!P2mnW

-m)Nm }m/!FQ<)d R9(STUVX;</=!WX}Y#f~PzWiZ1R9xX

Page 2: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

Ls"3GH!IJKx?([!\rea@iT1q!WY;][96re;;_!(/`a1)W!(/!ob>i!(/=>i;

</=c/xWqd;eA!BCf&!(/g%Chi%/j/xWX

XGH!IJK*%])~[x?!aC=BC4!(/dek(!/@gU'9lxq=!a*|HmnRG!/d!(/do;234 p

qr$}!e*q*sXt1q Kxqb%u?%&;vwUV~~Pzfrea1RC%]6%xWqyG!/dC|z!

!%]6{"1L(!~z;|!89}~Pzf~lq�!X[9rea;!"*Xc%xWXGH!IJKL!#$%;/%A(X[96

\E#qb$/!(/~%C&./AT9H"<'q!ex(z;\U)*de6Tq!+~Pz;89/jA,�/|"-56

.!eu//w!ex0z*1">wde6'

-{n+Nn }2!F3!4/)5

q56.!eu//w!ex0zG!/df?,67AYtU8#5i"(z{(X!a[96fb$/;9AT9H"<'q 5iS

}!(/0z!aWi*de(~l*:)t)-X 7;Wi<1)(

Wi3=xX 5 !{/(!@gC>fs?!u@/d!ecL!WA9c2!N

XBLGH!IJK;!p!%6;b!cAC%DE(F4q!G}H./;Q!>GHWqz{GH!IJKde6)W I

P}!kr!./#fJ6K%/Lrea(Atg*r6IAE%!MxPX

72!c!DGH!FIJK;!a!p!%6C|}NWb!yzL!#$%WiH!(/O!W%!PA(XT9.QR/%"WX

GH!IJKCW!eLS%0z!(/TUzC�!E(.i89%)CYtUhi)(�*<10zde6[9x

!VW

!a}S%)!(/Tg#~PzL!ef/91!J%/(X~Pz!(/;<f!Y/cZjxX}([/91!J\i/PzC6] 5iS@g/?

J!aS%(_/C�!EChi)(�# }!"#$%&'()*!+,N WX-

=cGH!FIJKL!{M,WiT9D@gE1;qG%S%0z(!F|!ab/_xXD@g30zx

5iSD@g!a}S%)!(/Tg#~PzL!ef/91!J%/(X~Pz!(/;<!(/c!uGRf!Y/cZjxqsF{!afrL<!

d?!BC,-!C1*1xq!{;|!fge%6;Ffoq(X'9lx!{Uqb(X\BCg!)WX

=cGH!IJKL!(h~%i896kaC!(/%ijyqO[?!{Wi!W|}Ub896.ikAR1%u?%&CflC?

}([/91!J\i/PzC6]W-q(X!a;%]);vT9*oxqz{!{@gUGH!IJK[m9ng1T9opW?%/(X~Pz

Page 3: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!(/;<;!1!"f89qQR([;6KrxXyGH!IJK2</![\ST_56sc!t,C8966Kr(\lx!(/_56

sc!t,r(\l*r1uvW\22!w<89eXxyz#!I(�UGH!IJKL$!{S%<!ab/1)<T%i@gf|%[9X

m9}!{@g/?UGH!IJK*~�*!/6U/!o<Z[z{!{@g;89"#q$GH!IJKL|jdqAS%

(_/)C�!EC[(�kaC%x?!yzL!ex0;YZ\BCg!v(!(/%/(&zq;<!(/56!uGRc!t,f,-!

ZjdXL!aC'/!E*(%d(/X/|",-!56sc!t,C8966K~)!G,dX*/de672?GH!IJKC/QRCH%

U/|",-!\)*oq!(/GH!IJKC!{89+R9(,C(�U-,-!56sc!t,C8966K\�!Eg.xX!ex0

!//QR!(/R9(S6UVXU)*de6TX

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCW

;<*B[>K0<!$/*~1Wi?!G,*231%xq[45(X!6N!c*(!7xq/c8(cL~%de6;oE!J9Cq:y<!f

r<!F!(/*de(zf;(T9<%1%jX!{L=4=>z/!6f89UVo?~!exyL!{f89@1%[9q!I(�U:y<!UD'9;

.i/)7FT9!A/%MaIJKBC6 o.iDqOEUde6[9~!{L4q_BLF!(/!GlmCq(X*!(/$/f.i89%1T9\(r_X}

HC*/Ii@- pJJ #K/,N

X|/LMN ([*B[

5iS!{!e*r~!PT9Ox?>KD*P*!/!%!X1R9x~!U!Qde6%R*ox?<Fq~(X!I(ST<F.xX

`/" }!"#$%&'()*!+,N

GH!IJK*[!p!qU!#$%A!J234!*.i4CV*W6xX&f/X(!7fX/DY44IJKZ[\i!/\\]

T#L!WP[PAEde6[9xqK?_Eu.!}H/.;6B/d!ecde6)W {+{ !<a!A!u/(u.!bc}!do

4

efgq!H_E.!}H/.;c!hd# *{{q*{* }H/.;\z7!ijk_

!{;(X!{(!7f44IJKlL\\!(/44IJK~!/d!L\\L\Ede6[9x

T#*m|| qefn(6!H_Fu.iIa!o4pqo {q5mn| }!L!k_

Page 4: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!uG%([!WjA56!ue{U!BCrska1)Wq(Xde6)W?!6N!c(!y/!6A89%E<L89t:"U

=u!B%(bz/|",-!C~%1xq89t:"Lb!cA89tEU=!a!vLF89wqlXq!x(uH!%]/6/!6foy1.X89%

E<L=9x0zWi{1jX!(/!U|q89@Z%[9X~d<!L!{/!6/|"!eC~%C(X89tE}X!IQ~/L

de6[9|)~%89tEUC�!(/1,m%%</q89%:"U!lC�X

ef1!"!H].!#DY%$)c!hd# pm*k_ { }~!/d!L5

L(!7%!&*;YZ'()lA\7b%xX

4

efF</q'9*a- |Jmk_ pT5JJ| j!pua!+!Hs?,%!o4!<!!<!-.u/!p0!o1qo

<X-*++n efn(6q23a *npk_ **T5p*m }F4!53aoj!pua!H!�6EuMN>i7)!do

efn(6X- *|8N*|p_ mm) !94F,!pua!HEu!A!F_/)!p:!do

L(!7%!&*;YZ'(!s%tgA!Y;u;YZ\7b%x

#A<Hz#u=-.A<>�qK?}H[9%u(=-.#@Au!q@%!(%u>�Bq@ **|m AH[9%u#q(}!C} Da!FE/}

#J*mm FGG}!FH<=yH(!I#!F>6y(!F8N!<

-*m*n*) }0!J(!I#(K!L!I# G

-*)** }M!FD/@H(!I#!!/ !G

-**|m }!C(b!UV!N

!H2&f/X(!7E1LCZWiUO.i/)c!hd}P<89e#�!X(Q%4Wq~R/�<,;TS(TUzL!{(!7

Page 5: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

f/(!@g!(/E_xq=c!a;V_rI%/de6'3X

T#X m) 56.!eue{/w!ez}, W

T#X *mm 56!<.!eF_/d!ec}, W

T#X |*m 56!<au7XuG%([/d!ec}, W

T#X {+{ 56!<a!Au/(u.!bcIJKZ[\i!/}, W

T#X *m|| 56_Fu.iIa!o4IJKZlL}, W

T#X **{| 56_Eu.!}H/.;/d!ec}, W

T#X *mn{ 56].!#DY%$)/d!ec}, W

T#X JJ| 56_!u/re0%1/d!ec}, W

T#X p*m 56_!uMN>i7)/d!ec}, W

T#X mm) 56_Eu!Are:/d!ec}, W

!ubH)d!ec W

_/d!ec W

!6,\i!//d!ec W

!6,!oZ/)/d!ec W

5iS44~BL!aWiu"#i!(/[\b]BXuT\\X #+ }|/L!F6N!cu@g_ _

!ex0de6R9x?BL*de(zWi<!q!(/AtgAx?Wi(!gL:"U=a/|",-!C~%1xX!a%(bzAbCL

!/6x?r/89;q:yf\<!=c#/d89%Eq!ex0L89%Efr%[9?e!(/:y%(bzF!!(/|j9C~%1(X:yLfR9�

Cq7/%{<1g![9c<gX!H2[deq_FT?89%:yfr/89;o<!~!U7/%{g!L!(/g!%&C(�_}\2

~hijz#k0z'lqmzn!oF6W

\\de6T9p<!X r/89;%(bzA*fodq89tE!WG0U�}q~44 !q"

r/89;$}Wi(!gfdq!{L!W|}U:yU=q~:yWi{!(/!{fg!Qr/<g!(/[s<!X %(,

r%(bzfd!BCf.i!t/!stq%(fjfc#/dEq89tELurC!(/fvN(<gX:yLT9de6;Cg![9c<gXL?/!~m |,

ef!w#[9!H7FT9xE\yz!#!{)# *p)q*pJ }|6qk_ X!I(!7fUO.i/)c!hdLBC6#K/,Akade6[9xX

qq!ex0L89%:yf89@1%[9X89@1L*` 56!ue{/w!e}C/(!@gAx4

#{q5mn| lLk_ Lx?!{U'9;o.iDX}

Tde6)W mm) _E!A!F_/)!p:!do

4

efn(6# *|8N*|p }!94F,!puak_

Page 6: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

56F_Lde6[9}~�#!6N!cC/!6A89%!cL89%:"U=?~/C~%kaX89t:"Lb!c%[9?"!/)]/6

/!6fo#Xb<!}~/c!$L(!t,C~%k#�(X89tE}X

s%j!94F,!puaA&44'L\\;()"xX

#* s%_ *|5*|p X}!94F,!puak_

}'L#89%:y;!-<AU!BCT9,xX 5iS

}(�*#z{(X89%~zfH!:1.x!(/!o>F.xqq!{U89/3o<.X

[(!7~1+/X4c\yz*xX4<zUU]~(Iz89%:yU'9;Do.iDXB(DaWi4cf,{1T9f!f89+xX

&f/X(!7U,-!("#n({C44Q!ab/)m9ng1T9\\-(.*r/!(/N/0(1ST;|!3oX

urX1L!(/rX2AHO(u-a*de7xXrX3qs4;5C%6x!(/*f7*urX1T9!(/8%(T9de6;Cg!'9T9q

5C%6o,s4;.%/<LC%6xqmz%(f)!/6x9!/6oX

./01!,2*/1x

!ex0L!:;fr%[9?56u%,c!t,f<X1q!{L<Xo_q[=aCf>(T9de6;xq!{C?[x? W

=aLT9de6;CX[?px?=aWi!ex0*rXyX

!ex0Lv(!@fr%[9?!HaF!!)LT9de6;CX!{C3?Lx?!)LT9de6;Cq[?px?!ex0*r W

oyX

!ex0LAbzfr%[9?!(!G\BC'91)1(qb!EUCX!)LT9de6;Cq!{C3?Lx?!)L W

T9de6;CX[?px?!ex0*royX

!I|z89t:"f!ex0*r<!?*de(zf;(T9<%1q!{LT9de6;CX!{C\3?Lx?!{Lur W

oCqT9de6;Cq!{f8#"10zD?!{UFH,u[9?!ex0*r89t:"WiXy!(/P<89e44,-!Q!ab/x\\q%ET,FT*8#5i4

#*|m MN,xX}|6k_

m9E!G56/d!ecL[(!7H!T96qIR96!(/k%!6A6%JK'9TFL!(/!{C(�Ug![9c<L;V<1

_xq!H2!LMbz!(/!z;(X!(/fgP*896CNo}~!e/c!O6LreuaiA[zz!/xy%de6[9P

-p+ }!Q,

HOARFb/!(/%(89H!(zU!9L(!>Wi"#jWYt$/)|z67W}v;!b!r*Sc\!LMaCGSTU89UV

}5iS<<!e!GT)-X x=#?/)bUtUfg89UVoOYtf!JWi(/%C/C|}~V1FT9x

!{u@gCjA23(I�E%!!%/!HWXx?

44SAU!BCklm;Yi%BC%/[9g(Z;?,[N"#Wi"#!\!\!./WqUV!BC;(!]-!_(<1xqu[96(!s%tgA

(z(2XC_\m9ngxua6b}--L%(a0zfc)%d1!<</eUde6[9d!j!<</2eF]<[zzc/EW\

Page 7: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!<</eL4q_?oquoLde6[9y!eGcFfx!(/,./A%(bz;%/aa!_}1jC!(/56gaeUG()x?

,./;/(Hhz(!>UQhz(!>*\iN%[9FjX/(!X!u!Ao[!kX!(/G()x?!e'9l!a*81;de6%j

#p qs% *n) <g5iS(!Freuai C?eYtMl<F!!{s"f%d1*del1x3?*3udB\Ml<F)q/(!X.!hH!7X}

LF&ij%!!%/!HXx?44q67AUUVP!{C'9m*!(/nyzka1.xqy!j~P2e!aC_fo"<!{Q

?(X$/)H89aAoqH!T96IR96k%!6Yt!{;_G!zWXXXXXX!eL*67f_!(/oH;!re!/U89}o

#*s% p|pqN*n }<g5iS(!Freuaiq'9/X /9!X

!BC!(/F&ijpz!o40q!WjAXx?

44!au[96(3!s%tgU(!rx?k%!6(IR96;!"#/\!BCsNt*u/7b%xqdfBXYvq=(X!{u/CZWi!e

#pJ|qN*n }!w!53aq'9/X C_1)WX

&f/X89FF&xz;5iS!(/jUy,<!?UV67;Q-!-!oH!(/<1(_z/x!(/UV67G!X!{*wk%!6Ux[9

IR96Uq!{A!BCMNt*u/\7b%xqdCZWi(X!e/c!{|C_(oH!%!1.xX

<!\6.6Axy}xq4UV67U!{f~1%Xu/;]/(H,./|!"<CqK?56�T9!<UV>iX/w!exyzU

G()x

q(."6!!/)!u!u.i.aqn!"#q(u3F\$(n%FX# p{)|z|p{p }>vN�!&4o!/lqA9c!'d

CjAde6[9?/(H,./?,6.6f(_FTCq)'9Tq 56!<UV>iX/w!exyzL!exy;de6aP

Fb/qWi"#j!(/%(f)?,6.6q4!exy**"!aeC+Cq4!PFb/d;,oq!{;Q(X,(!>f-jCO

de6TC?.<Fq4!{(ST*den344*3A\.<FR9\\X

456�T9!<UV>iX/w!exyzC/(!@g!(/&f/X89F234Ce/!6U(!r<89??,6.6f/YXuL(!Fu/~

_89xqdCZWi!aA!Glm(K*6%X7b%xq4!I!Glm(KC(�U/(H,./!af!eC89/CXA(_FT

C!(/!I;]!a;%/aa8<Cq!H2(X!{WiNo~!aU0!<-Xzz\X

!H2UV&*Uv(!@;(X%(f)6.61T!ab/)UFwx~!aU1<T!,"Wi0!<-Xsxq_!e/c!{|g*

T9de6;;!afg!%jC\X

A3de7(!2<R9x!(/XE!e/c!O6;<!6Afg3CUV<R9x,!exyC|} !a(bI6CZWiX~

U!af~_89q!a;!Q!";]u/E!aC!Glm(T9de6;*(%xqdWi!o!e/c!{|!Wxya;]8N!(g!

%4xq!(/%jCX

m95�)!F56c!hdC!{e/6Wi234;f6HngL\!p!qHWq7I8z!a*b!c\G,-./

xX=cJK89/89/!W=>iA&44!8/\\!9"1)WqD!W?44R9:;!1!"Chi%Wi[%])1/xW?:y

Page 8: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!(/D!W?44!A/%Ma.i/)*[%])x?:y<!L!exy* #p{N)m }!#tgq:/X <!L!exy;rU!8/1%[9d\\X

(2?X #pmN)m }!#tg:/X ro6T9\\X

sF{!G56/d!ecCU/)e/6A&44!8/\\7b%oq,89%Z:y*b!c&f/x?!{Lb!c%[9?44=>z/!6f89UV

o?\\q;!a;!G}(<!!zL!exy;rWiu-bzqHO!(/=9(z*!8/1T9>xq>w<

!exy*de6ax?

-J{ }!6N!c

44BL!W!6?gfu-bzWiHOWi!(/=9(zWiG_yYtL!{;!LLU!8/1%[9!(/!{U@/y=!LMaL!U!L

}5iSpz!o40q- j(Xhi!ECnF#xX

!{u@gCjALF&ijXx?44G1L*_x\!(/u-a(HO!(/=9(zLA|z!{*b!c%[9\!(/!LMbz

L!UA(ST{"_\!{CU/)BXBFauvWX!Uka1uvWq/[C/DEo?!eL!WUV67A!BC

MNt*!S{(u//jxqPB!{CAUuCXoy!exy~!aC896FWi.%/xq!{L0(/!{!6?gf!aWiG_<

Cq${"1LU!yzL!8/1%[9!(/[!8/!yzLf>(G(6CZWio_q,!{A[G}*/de6d?!H2B!{!6?g;

q%!/!t,# nmm }j!w!53aq HIU/jX1J~!{CKg!/L<*\\X

!(/!Iu@gCjA%!!%/!H23Xx?UM*(y!5iSLx?!yzL!8/1%[9q]/!TNOP(Q45iR!I

qU/(}(MXSa# n*{ }<g5iS(!Freuaiq 5iSfs`xX

gT2_u-a(HO!(/=9(z*U!1L(!F!eo\_!{L!afVo_<!\!H2!a;!8/1LCR9(,G}UCFWX

x~89t:yCR9(,\9YZm%6C(�44=>z/!6f89UVo?\\DUCFWXxX==cW?3/(!@gC7b%*A\

4([%*\Ma]!G56/d!ecWi!p!q1/xWX

!8/Z$_!(/b!cZ2$_Ade7xq[!#hU_oxqdC!BC"reuaide.aaA!LMaCb;Q!cU7b%

x?!e/c!{|LdedzUde6[9

-pm }!eL

>Kfj/cLdedzU=?AHOWi}!Y#!BCT9ggZLf<z}bYt%ECu89%)Wih!;1j#(X<>_uo!+W

fT9ggZ)Wb!{}HO#Ag%1j!(/GaiT!(/!H2jEZT9k/<~B!{;.QRW!{Q?#Bf)Gkzka

}5iS<g- 1)W!(/l'9CU[9%1)W,-!L=mAFf<zbeoF]\\X

ijz#(%nKC0(/6oq=c;\i/�;5iSA7b%!&*44!H2jEZT9k/<~B!{;.QRW\\Ua3(!r</I

-nm }!o p xX;dedz;89/jA(!rO/Wireuaide.aaA7b%x?P

44!(/d896*!afr<R9x(E1)W\\X!{qUy,<!?GH!IJK!(/!r<!klm234*[!p!qs!(/89+xX

Page 9: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCW

<(!ta560@c!t,*uxqz{o3/(Hv;wA/xXXX;<de6)W?!{v*w!ex0 ` ;<*B[

;43!xU!yx?!BC-*3%azCX/IX>Kv*w43!xU!y<89~56{M~a*|'9ldA�T9

}.i/)x!A[9/}IJK\z~L5|,N !F�i<-b6XeC!X!de(H/x(X~43!xU\!yxX

|/L!F4!}q@g_ = ([*B[

}K?!{Cxya;Ffx# 5iSQ"$//c!ex0xdLU!de6[9-bz!(/HOf]%aAqO43!xWi!X!de(H<!

GH!IJKL!{@gAP!#!<F!@3PU_G!%jx\[!yzLwUVI}!&*Akao_qy$7K,U(!r<R9x?

(X[ST9opW?t<!eq!e1Rq43%Wi&<!x!(/){43!{U'Xxq!{v(1R)!ec(*U+'X!,<

C-T43!xfYtU!y6Ko.Xijz#GH!IJK;!{%])Uy,<?(X!exyC'9l!(//X@!c<!6fP0P

6]WX!w<89eX

("~4q[x?GH!IJKLrea'9lU!1F"_x!{CUV2~[y,</Ij?GH!IJK[DopW?X>K(

1R-;3*(X#bHOU+1/Ix~(X43!(/de3U!y<89~!{;.i4!H2!ex0L43f+_~!{43f?,

*56U!y<T9o7X?(1R-;3U+1L(!FHO*#X=/GH!IJK;!{6w#j!1F"U!-}

xz{!#$%(klm!Gx0;3;.:oz{6%)PE*U+1WXxX!(/!ex0UVPU.i)q'9l!(/7!

xX!G%!ex0;3*.:<T9!BCp8XxX!H2GH!IJKj!uMN>i*]91:;~!y,<R9?Q41!,!(/!#

$%(klm!ex0f3U'9l'9]WX,;<1!,;Q!cF67b%WdA!<zL!ex0*!,<f+1Lfp=

xX[M,=*o?!a?,Q!cF6fka_FTX

!H2GH!IJKrea'9l*E]91:;~!af!I8966CMN6X<.X!ex0rea'9lA_de6R9x>w1xX

89%xyX>@g'9C(!FUV3UG./X #{p?n+ }!pa!@R X (."x

Q"!eY/jNaUQEHxX #+J?p }!pa!@R (."x

Q"!eEQWi(!xYtGAzf!IX #{m?p* }!pa!@R (."x

!{;BfgPoX #**?|{ }!pa!@R (."x

_~Ffx!{;T9,*fgX #mn?*+ }!pa!@R X (."x

!{;b9*fgoX #|?**{ }!pa!@R (."x

[@gq[96Ci6AUxq!!{@gAK,1T9DrxqEFF!/[96*fg_G1;!U!JUV8X;9

A%6;O/Wika_FTX;rea1R~!(z;89/jAde6R9x?!a~Pz;%~zAGqxqb[96Ci6;

Page 10: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

</=g%Cfl1)W!(/!W-;]H31LCfl1)WX

GH!IJKLb[96Ci6Wi!WQWiCH9!gx!{;89/jA\]!(/rea*8\>w1IX

!exLde6[9

(ExdL!R9/)zWiA9c!{AEJKW|LNWA9cCq!(/%(f)WM|}Nq|v;

%"WOj<T(XJW!a;@OP(!QzUqH31)W�!E!(/H31)WHaCo&;q!(/!aCofgoFf

|!T!e;q!(/bR{h(!>W|!WB!{Wi!HaFTYt3?/j/cC|}Uxq!(/ST(ETWvf-

#m{ R9dUF</N *{* q7r!pa5iS(jxyX.!V%/ J?p }!pa!@R xX

GH!IJK*W"x?reaC@gX!(/!WGwUbY,8&o<!afH!%)x!(/]!,!&{["W?GH!UVZrea(

AtgU%j)WXA./01!,f!{[U!\iX1T9o]<z?reaU!1F"1T9UV*CC896o!(/[_?rea@iT

1UV1jf!@g}FT*[G%rea;?}xX

exLreai!R9/!x!@gde6L!(/1(zfH6L;vX

!IreaUazf�!Xde6T!(/b(zf/!X%jTX #{m?{ }!pa!@R X

!c./01!,2[|R/x<'?reaUc!BCW�!X<Z[xX4q[x?reaU!@g!(/d6C(�%(tC[96*

<T9xX

!("e6v;_I}Q%STWf!exC'9C(QEH)(QgCJv*<1!(Wi12/!X%(,Ci6v;hA

!B"x[9~CUV&U3YEoR9fl(ij6!n(2X[9bYAR9x(X!e8(cWik"xqX

(Xhi!l(!F!{L43Wi!#!<de6[9X #n?{m }!pa!@R X f

O!{L43Wi!#!<de6[9X (2X# p?*m(n|?J }!pa!@R [9

./01!,2reaA[9x!e43Wi&xq43WimN$<!xq43Wig89xX[[96Ci6AUWX

!(/[9Te6breaCLNnHafo%[9XsF{rea%A~!#!<[9x!(/!{;_mNpqqqgT9q<T9q;M~�!W-

!(/.Uka1)WX=_[0(/)x?!a;rbeLkaH(X3<zX!(/!H2!a*_fg!W-(.U1/Ix~.!(/

5iSWirea!(/([*rFP1T9_soX

!exL!{Wifg%6T9H"Xde6gX #|m?*{ }!pa!@R !ex0de6R9x

./01!,2!{s*t[x?b%(f(zf�!X1T9opW~(XreaC[96Ci6~Pz;YuG1)WK?!ex0

*43Wi!#!<1T9X!(/bhAv!(/!eC|}U!@gWiW(X[96e6f!e*CBU[T?!exyr3U'9l!(/

/!xX!wqqqmNpq!5iT9qfxgT9!y,;*,W!(/(XUVza{U'9lx~|}!a~z;CUV)_b?/)Y

A)WUV12G!%oqOvN__IX!{A[!@g(!>%(H2(<zA�<yX

!("!)Lde6[9>K[CUV)_|!%o!(/R9("`G(D(%o~B!W|}U_nqL#?!{*h!eWi/9x

Page 11: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

/?/j/cL[9TCi6;$@iLU%de6[9!(/!aC&G!%AGq1Lf�!ES[9~BAU89UVzzn,%'xq

#b3?/j7CG!%xB!{Wi!HaFT( J?p !Irea;ST)Wi*lm1x=k"o-+/ZX}!pa!@R

C"Yt?/j/c;'9{UxX

[&ij,/!-S*x!(/L!*(!(x!U+./(0!Wq!a!-Lde6[9!#!<y,x?0(/!exC!BC

1x!(/23"x?!{;_?/)YU(/!<Wq!(/!Ha!{Wi(!>Kx?45reaUm9ngxX

#de6[9?(XA9cCLN J?p }!pa!@R %(,ELW"_?>K!e8(cL(C"%(6de61e6f

WX!(/CUVx?UVder!W!C|}7x~[18LR9(,Ci6C/!XG%S%)!(/!aC9://;%)?!aA(X

%/st('9mX!oF6U!1(vU[!W!`qe6;]F'!(/[(d"(89+(k"/!XX'9'X[0(/x?!J8>

<T_WiCo1uv?!e8(cCLG!%x=>K_I}('9mXW!(/!<e6U.i)(/XW!(/k(/!64c;

&*Uu\uvW~!oyO/Wika1LA_ldX

jtn!,A!{@g*_Q4bka_x(X\>w1IX

Xtn!,Ax *

q/x!=q(X[de6)W?43Wi!#!< #*pJ?{ %!/!>!n(6 n|?J }tn!,(!"N X

!e8(cC!BC1Q);(?@xqAaWideqx?H{Wi!HaFT!(/!{;_*h,-!f|AX

X!6,BA9c!F-<(!C6Ade6)W {

#*nm?{ }A9c!F-<(!C689c6F<o1"!ex!hDF!@3!)q!!FEi[YF#GU/X

?/j!,cHO/w!exI!#!<;3_X!(X!{A!JH89a+Kd|z?,L6Ci6AHa*L

&ijxX

XuU/(!@gC p

#*n(!*nm?{ }A9c!F-<(!C689c6F<o1"!ex!hDF!@3!M!!FEi[YF#GU/X

B!6,6N/w!exzC,-./As0(!BCWLs0<14qC!j!<.!e2/DL43Wi!#!<de6[9[!#!<A|z

x\!{;OPE!6,Lf/lQjmzeC?8#aR{SS<89qOde6[9!#!<3"o!(/BT"o!(/!{Wi

!Hadeq!(/!{U!U/8#lm!(/|jW"A~0(/8#&ijxqOr%[9?!U8"%(X

X.!euIVu#U/(!@gC |

}A9c!F-<(!C689c6F<o1"!e

#*n*?{ 8(c!hDF!@3!)q!!FEi[YF#GU/X

Page 12: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

q!6,/Wu!�.!hD!D<!6,6NUO<�16-()6,{/!h!T>FR9L|!"<!qde6[9B2T"x!(/

!ex*!#!<3"o!(/XWi!(/zWi!aYt89~zWi!HaFT9(!>KxX

X!6,!Au!�!Y!/)!6,uZU/(!@gC?de6) n

q!{tC[\L6!e #*n*?{ (89c6<1o](! *n*?{ }A9c!F-<(!C689c6F<o1"!e8(c!hDF!@3

8(cLrea%A!Jvkade6gW!aCjLx?H(69!(/M73/.X

}A9c!F-<(!C689c6F<o!6!;! X!_u7!_/)L=? m

*fFaio?4�AG!XU/I*H89aA!{;_7X #|{?{ !FEi[YF#GU/X

Xs4U/(!@gC!yzL!6,!<a!Au!_u!0c*bI#T9_%j[9dA&ij!=R/�d!{A>x J

/D* #*n{?{ }A9c!F-<(!C689c6F<o1"!e8(c!hDF!@3!)!!FEi[YF#GU/X

!#!<ca(axX

X!6,xydeq!6,!Aufge;89/jA>x )

}A9c!F-<

#*n{?{ (!C689c6F<o1"!e8(c!hDF!@3q!!FEi[YF#GU/X

q!{89cASIVU/(![96q6W!(/!{|h6Wi!Haxyd*&ij%F/01R9x!(/L+!6,!Aufg(!6,

iuyj!(/kvN4U!6,!<lX�*xX

X!6,Be!WA9cA!6,X�UE1)WX +

}A9c!F-<

#)m?{ (!C689c6<1o!m,!hc!!FEi[YF#GU/X

q>KHa!-1!,LbBAUhAH!I#!(/H6LAR,!(//Ahij(Ci6Ah6de6[9~/Yno/p!(/!a;

_3XD!(/H[9%XFfd=?/jH6LA%(H2(XU!<T!BC~!{tCAqzffjUr%1R9!(/sVSR9xq!{A;T

/(!L!s%tgCtfgFH,.xqsF{(X%4;!6,W!(/uz;T9v!(/(1R)!exc(*eC?/j(Yw(/Y:X!(/

%(f!H2(X!a/(!xzf6a1!a;CUV)_C|}!PFR9x?!{*K,!e8(cf{Uz"1%&eCyo]x!(//[

%(bz89DT9zWB!aAU*f&ijZLWi/!woq~/0(/<!?!{896Ab3A{'HaC(XR9(,1%xd

U!a;_!!"bI#([96e6;]<F'!(/3/(!J?;<|6C>U'89+X<L'9'X

!{ZWia/(![96!(/DE1!,;!1!"7b%W=!}/C(�U$}MQ!cF6E1WX!H2GH!IJKL3\!/6

Page 13: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

1LC|"~!\M<!e%F:;!I/7b%WX

B!{ZCijz#(%nK!(/GH!IJK;%c(defg;/%;v!G}AU;<(DE;!1!"E1)WR9?

./0f!"#!HX<J?b896�)!6,!A/%Ma!(/~!F./x!A[9/Ma}/d!e�Lde6g!(/!aC!W!!!rUV12oq,

SU[8X!./Aq!/YxqyGH!IJK*$}!a%(5!6f7/%!J!,gT9q[9~GH!IJKCN/0*{<"W6xq[9

#j%'Z;|!3oX7>wde67

!j$c2B !6,Z!o4/!H)c/d!e!%%)qj&A%/d<,@g/?;(de6)W

#*mJ?{* }!pa!@R LlXP=/'Y/jNa;vX

j

>K~/?,mn;v/'W(!>K<!??,6|!T!eU!y<zXA

(<z)*%)1T9CUVUF%6vN(dx!(/(X*mv;Yi%BCFaioEFF*UO;Yi%BCX!(/!exyE!@g

#*mn?m %!/!>!n(6 {np?{ }*+,!-}!'!.-(!"N %&(!FxX

5iS!{896Wi!krx DY!u/1/d!ecde6)W

-p*nN{ }0!)(!hxy%d ?b#3;YZ><!xq(XUVPU!yx1?23U\!yxX

DY4T/d!ecde6)WQRi!y-!!6(!@3(!5X,[}HO*#b(1R-;3;YZ+_<!x#

-np*Np }6!h[9q\z!7<d -bzq43!(/2U\!yxX

6I(!~z;v~!QE*oxy_1xGH!IJKf~�!{(STeCo6]>KeC!a;!J**Q!cX%dIq(+

6]~O\o!8(9O/WiM73<F)WqGH!IJK2;!:a;;v!a;!J<*Q!c>w9qxyz#[6aE

F'q!u=q!u>;Q!>UE1)W

5iS!H2$/)G!%?@X@)-Ux~2!yxq!(/!H2$/)G!%A"B!Cxq~,-!Ct2XE43qXsD43!(/XE

H2%31L(!>!Elqfg\P!{U!yoxFz{/(G/?A!BC!PB!Cx?!H2%(bzNbz;YZ\!U~F

#*mmnNp }8#!H!L!I#d FT}(Ha_FT#~(XI/)/xX

=c(!F2!cB%JW?o23mn X#p|m }>w1x|!K%!(%5b)N !{896f23mn=c%!(%5b)L\kaxq

=c%!(%5b);T9,\LGzAxy}1)W[9OoC%M$}!#$%;YZxX

Page 14: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCWX

;<*B[!BCGN56�!OPQR!)/d!ec%SWiyzFT!(/[9!e!<T!{WiHOCB27q%f!BCW

u[9q!U'9/FLC0(/6}qfgT!{(ST7b%X}X>K!{L56fF)%UX4qCAA|zu!zde6[9[9Q[9Q

(yuX!{LL=!(/%/[9WiHOC|z2tX>KV,%/[9AWX=a;L%"A(|X@!Fq?56G%~[9!en!(/X

U[9QY!)WXA\[9!ezzXZzX!{L[9!e=!(/YZE*$j[9X[/!56Ayqde6[9(E'[9Q[9Q>K=

%/[9U'9/<!X4qC56[_896}Xuo!en~'9/<z!(/AZz~*$j!zXde6[9!/jT9%!a!\~QeC~Wo!eeC

HC*/Ii@- +J }.i/)7FT9!A/%MaIJKBC6#!("N /YgC<{xX

([*8�T9.!eue{ka1)W?A/|"!e-;$|!/)Wi&<!d~o-L!/xy%de6[9!j\]~!e;

!,C_1!ef)_de6TCX!e;7*W"/j~!U!JYu'9TCX!<!Y/0UY"!e(!<!!U

89eX}5iS>K~|!"1j~$}!eU1T9!(/>K~~%a1j~!eEU~%a1T9#!(/Fa>?!H2U/)!./\(<1

lfgUI#XWT9ox~oWJ*=b!eoxX!(/!H2U/)!./\(<1lbaWT9ox~oWU*=b!eox

}bV!6,5i&)L!{C>fw3=x-}F45i&)A9c!cAtg }d>ie;%#K!f3�!(/gh<3/X

- _

4q[x?GH!IJKLbBC6Wi!p!q_x(Xq;?}xXz{i)/j[;MQRABC6;e/6.QR{"

oxXG%x!xB7FT9k/%MaLBC6A!1{!(/*lg;mzWi!n/.io!(/T9zp*!n/_xXz{T9\4

BC6Vo/xW=!{Cq*fg!r,o_89X!:/j[b?~(ax!{;MsABC6f(XM,s`ob?

!BCt;!JIZCX<gA9c<.xX

_ua!vw[qFx!{[9y{!w#[9CW

P~/x!xCGN!*Cv~PzLzI!(/O!a{zU%(!~zLA9ng1!(g!{AA9ngC|z%/'qvA[9

~!}b{U*,oj89[9OmzC!pzWi~�o%)<gX}!{;%_ua!vIJKLM!1{*<1_-!{U

!"#!HX<!?!6,!A/%;BC6;YZ(X!~<o_89b<T9o7dX!{U[896�<F.x?b|z%/'!{U

-pJn }Nzx!xN IJKBC6*ffgwoX

!!.if/!"!v(}.i"\yzs0<!qF"x!xBR9d!#d56 {n !{;%_ua!vw[IJKCW

7FT9!HUV)IJK$~%!{yU>.6<gq4q_?faY&x$x!xBLG%xyH1(![9d!{Wi567!}L

F'CUVde6g!(/de6[9?%(!>(zWix!xBT9/!)CUVde6)(!(/de6)(?XFLc*!%[9X~/DY&_+<

!vL\!{CR9,de6gXXXXXC%(zUMs;%/!"f!S{<!?%(!~zL!*Ann-}\_

Page 15: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!H2!{-_;%\fgF&ijBC6!G56C9>1!G56!(/;<!=f.a1R9x~ -pJn }Nax!xBN xX

O!U!eU@/T9o7X

!(/[[9%/x?BC6!G56!aC!W/o,!aU0<T1:f;<L(232>dA4!(/5";!6T96

7/pWX!!H2fgZi(/j[;?}BC6AFT~(XGbr<CX!BC6Wi!p!q1T9fg8*,oX;

!Ie/6;.i4!G56!JBC6A!{|!"*b!c30z%xWX

T-*pp+ /Na J }!H9MXdez#U/@!:XMN!;<U/=c%!e>w#/ {|nZ

_de6)W;T%4?Q!BC\i/�*}(!yzL?_q/!@A!BC%/[9@i!!{f'9/1)(ST!BC%ZL=?Xf\

%/[9;'9/1%Aqlg!a\i/�*}L=e|j$[9Q[9Q!a!(/A!e!e(azCq%/aaA(X%Z\!e!e6t

lg(X@(]tq!{(ST!a\i/�L=?~!e!e./'[9Q[9Q'qlg!{%ZL[9Q[9Q=>K(Xo@(89X[%/stx

[9o\!(/\i/�*};Q_rx!(/%Z;Q_rx\!~MN(!X

!G!c[px??A%/[9>,%SE;'9/FT9dq!(/[\H[9%Xx?A!e!e(azCq!(/[?!B!x?!yzLde6[9~!e

!e./'X[9QDCDE6%E()ACD;GB7b%W!Ufa%1Z[x?%Z*rUVFT!(/56�!OP

-|pmX|pnk{m }i()/j[5 QR!%)/w!exyz;QrUFG"Q!%�(LH(%/z#X%IxX(!ex!hX

>K!G56*!{896C5i%z#A:7b%x~O!aWi!J!,N/0;|!<!(/3\oX

ijz#[?!H289Jq[(!7BC6A6a\jF<j~_!{(!7fE1LU!G56rea($%C!<1)W~Ov\i/�

K}56QR!%)/d!ec-*[1"x!a;89/jAo*_:<CX</!<3L"1b!c%R=cX<Z[x?GH!

IJK!WM8N;v!{8R!(/89.inoKWifg!p!qX1%jX!{vDEU!a;89/jM!1!"G,-./WX

XDY!�/d!ecCWX *

-JmN* }O6!PQd

XDYRS!Pd/d!ecCW {

-{mmN{ }O6!T!PQd

XDY!u/de6)W p

-*m)N* O6!Pd }

XDY!u!U%)/d!ecde6)WX |

-pJp+ }R9/VR!%

XDYWR!%)de6)W n

-{|+NJ }R9/VR!%d

-*{+N* }R9/V!X4d X_!o((%)!ABde6)W m

}R9/V!FG, XDY_<Y/d!ecCWX J

Page 16: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

-+{|Nmd

X_Z)/d!ecde6)W )

-+{mNm }R9/V!FG,d

XDY;/d!ecCWX +

-nnmN| }!FLMcd

T#CWX )m+ X_!u} *m

-*+mN* }!~[6Fud

XDY;/d!ecCWX **

-nnmN| !FLMcd }

-Q;B!(/5689\iz#C 23mn.!e5b) X!BC23mn1,/|"])IJKCW?|j8j;/(U(X} *{

-|n{X|n* }#1X7FT91,/|"])N 6_WX

!aQ!cF6;%!H2*A!p!qCMN!6x~1;%d>X!axy<!e!{*\b!c%[9FTCX!H2!{;%\!G56

/d!ecWifg!p!q1j~!{f\,(EUfg(!oXz{DEL~56QR!%)/d!ecCH.i%st~a[9nyz

Cx!H2!p!q1T9x~O!aDE1!,Wi9X

ijz#4q[x?GH!IJKf$}!*.i!#$%EbW!p!q1L;v!(/!{;.i4(X[!<Tocd?(X?,6lg

eU!-}/fgWX=!<zL!JU/jUhA!BCi\234;?}o>!{U[y,<R9x?GH!IJK2

345!6;jkWX!H2GH!IJKA%,lx~O�!E*:</!234;mmn=c7FT91,/|"nazoWi

\FP1;S'X

./01!,2!c</!7FT91,/|"nazoIJK23C!BC1!./>w1xX

!BC%pq/!o4(fde!H6raVXsXts?1,EIJKoC,-./As0<T!(/4q_??/jHA*aY#%/[9L

>jx!(/refgx??/)?,HO%/[9.i%<FTX%mde6'!ex0/!{uU+6%jXvzIJK%(/(Hnaz

oA/xX(ST/w7~)IJKLde6[9?%/[9;x/jWixj<189(!HyDX[9>!e!t,z-1,/|"n(!F!(/

|/Xn/(H@ipqvzW*kax?>KBL%/[9;x/jWixj<1{|de6a7FT9IJK*G,W[9?/j%J

E%J%/[9}i\(r<89!(/~;89�F./EXB:!;U%J/x%/[9*BC!}i\(r<T9hi!"#!GdX|/X@i$

-**n }|!KE61,/|"N U%/[989�#j89!(/!W!)s/0Wi89X

|jW"A!{(!%fe;%r*tC&X1LC0(/6oz{!a;sF6e(!>G%23=c!'7(

IJKWX

Page 17: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCWX

;<*B[,�)Eu.!}H/.;de6)W44?!�i<)!$L(!t,C{/*XA!H(!d*!6GCF.WX(X!a;

- }!"#$%&'()*!+,N YZ+t890de6)W\\X

-m X}|/L!F6N!c@g ([*8

IJKZ-(u/!{896f!,|zF]W?!H2fgWfg1"E1j[9*;1"fka1j~!{C<_%!/)$}!- !(F

<.x?(XdUE1/Ix[9ka1/Ix!{Um9ng1%jX!H2(Xm9ng1%j~!{1"C(�Ufg\%[9.!/!U>./o

1jCz{!{**,$}E%jT9[9dU(Xka1/Ix!{*W6de!B1T9x

}t$ K?234;b!cq/w6'9~)IJK;I0!%jFwq1L>?44T9v**,x?E%j%j\\X

#*J)?|q1

!8EM66Wih6*ZU!<R9xyYZ!2/U3A!{*&*o/jFR9qMN1>K*7jrWi3CF/E<

!(/;Z%F:Um9ng<~!{;V**1"ka1%R!(/D?EzL[\=x[4;Q.QRZH2FT!GoX

=_=FT!a!(/(!fb!G56/d!ec;44BC6\\C!{e/6fG%@iT1[971]!,!&{AN/0q4

q[%q#j%'Zq5[9!J%"C6C(�U!G56/d!ecEC|}!U7c1;]!,!(/Y%X~z~PzfuoU81L

CFs1LA7/pWq[W"\o1)?Bdefgq%u?q!J!,[98#%[99*!/:c1/xWX

m9E!a!(/(!fo~[d?_H/.;/d!ecC;6C|}/<1)!(/!{896f!aC=>AH31)q

!H2}F.~!{;89/jAreua(AtgC|}/<1)<T!{Cq1)?u[9[896%/stx[9?6Z!G@;!"

qO!J.(de!st;&*U!-}1)[9!)71)q=!a/A/09T!&*;sDL!{896f<B"<T!a*<1E8"

%[9!(/N/0Cu9A[9sV*i/!>1%u?(defgf!Y)<TX$}[?!WmCfvN!c1L;%/D<y,]!,;

<EzA\!FG/(!B!7CH/[9zI%xX

!G56/d!ec*[<!.1"oq,!yzL(!rde6[9?44�)Eu.!}H/.;de6)W\\!{AJfg"

q%!/pn)k) o?[1"_H/.;/d!ecC/K44\z!J/.;F!L!OP!89M!NN!;5

<O\\A7b%x!(/_H/.;/d!ec[1"G%!W|}Ukao1/x, *++mTX*|*J !>!n(623aq!!(y

!u>P/d!ec;Q!>UE1/xWq!&*>wde6'

_H/.;/d!ecCQ;89/jA234;Rs0;DY(S!/xy%!#!Ei)Tu89%)L%010z;DY(

Sfde!HMaU/*/%1)<T>x?

Page 18: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

T\y'9[DYWq!aC7GC\zo/5(zAH0VWU **{{ 44!I|z_Eu.!}/d!ec!J/.;!do

u/!X<Yx_!Z;L!o44DY!o[9/![\\;!&*U[9%_x!(/>x?!a;H&X(2X!oM![*!(/M

\);{%4A:/_xX_A9;de6)WF](X!Jum9/CZ<Wi ** !_E!(q,!c!aF;L!o6b;

#c7!H2[\So~!(/fax$dA:/_FT\XG%7FT9U/ *d|nJq|nm !Ie;FfW}f{!/{N

IJK_H/.;/d!ecWigM#;!J!,;b!cAb?\z!L!ijE;Q!c;89/jAqCW44F]!6,hi/d

!ecj#(y_b/!o4/d!ec!(/_H/.;/d!ec*gM#m9ngo!(/FQ!c!(/8#(a%6!a5!6*gM#

q!%!/L!k,!FEi[Tu89%# JmqJn q7FT9fde!HU/!W=>;ulAqN {|{ }m!n(/N 2#x\\

_Eu.!}!J/.;/d!ecCQ>K234;Rs0;DY(S;Yi%BCX$}!#ZhAUW,!BCy

'9[DY(SW!(/%010z;6wrefg;!6,(DY;Yi%BC(Xj#\oqMN1>K(XQ!c<11x~#WX

4!H2!W!IA9cqd*&f/X89Fe/6A<1<!xqAF5i%z#Xx~!aWifg!J!,o!(/XE(X!{896feC(�

U7/%Z!J!,re!/'9)Wq~!H2!oU!G56/d!ecLpE1%)~!{C(�Uuof.QRZH2%aH%;zzre!/%[9F/I

x2_[*"(!_}qq!ST(!6?gx\X

?/)$ka1%X3;GB!H2*<qA[|!"U!<?!H2(X!(/(!_H/.;/d!ec*<1X1LC(�U

7/%Z!J!,W~!G56/d!ecL\~_H/.;/d!ecC|}!U7c_x;[1"!u>P/d!ec*x~!{

*b!c[x?_H/.;/d!ec[1"rxy/zE1/xW!(/[1"_;/d!ecCE1%X!BCe/6C\zA

<11/xW!(/>Kfgxy/z*896C\zAfg896G!X*UE1/I<(X!{*!Y0s<R9x!H2(X!{C5i%z#X1j~q!(/

mz!PEx?!6,RS/d!ecC44O6\\;Q!cU!u3/l/d!ecC896C\z1)<T_H/.;/d!ec!{1"

fFTW!(/!{C!yzLfg5i%z#ode6gq![!a*0sg!P?[!U*!(/UE1/xWq!!G56/d!ec*

!u>P/d!ec*T9,<1X1T97/%Z!J!,oz{_H/.;/d!ecrxy/z!{1"fF5i%z#E1/xW~!a*!YB[

\Lxq!!aC|}7c1T9\%/stdq!{v!G56/d!ecL!u>P/d!ec*T9,<11gde6[9?�)

Eu.!}H/.;de6)WX

O!G56/d!ecL[1"_H/.;/d!ecWi/%1L;B[U7co_,r@g!{fkade6[9xq!(/!#

Zh(%!t!{U\u�uCXW?*Wi/%1L;Q*896f<11T9!(/@g;O/Wi*C|}7c1LA\ade7x

/!vwq!(/(!!G56/d!ecCe/6Wim,O/Wi%(|zU!p!q1)Wq!BC~[?%xT2[c<Z[x

?yA!H(!dZ*!6G<zq!(/%(f![?%xyA+t890[LHxX

!a%(bz89~z;89/jA!W'zb!e8(cL~de6gxq;]M89D<11R9xqr!LMa|).(

de!stAY!(/fR9E*\!6a7b%xq!H2fgIJKZh!{C|}/{g1jC~!axy<!e!O\ig*|(}/Z+9f

0_FTCX

!(F%E()H"#*~1L;%b!{%EUfR1FR9x!{;YZ*s/0A6!H,,Z,./!{;!#ZMXq!WA0z(2XC

Page 19: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

>.6<WXx[9?o\

#* Atg_}

qnm?* q(>Ao�:!!W +m?n #&cq(!"go!#!T) *m{*}{p+ #q(!u6�qA9c!$aiq m{m|}**{+ }>vN�#o!%qA9c!&:N

q(2BX-|/de!{@mG@'(7@m/w!(xy)X- {mJ?| (!oZ/)o!C(b!'!N

!,!;56m*eU/(!@gx?ua6-C]/DYt!+<'qfg!aAU89}o/E}qua6-;'9{

@jAGq!L6A#!,A56U-/w!e)u'q!aCo".ua6-Co"}quo/Lde6[9qGu|)01q

O!af2[9!W89'|}%!{;3U!BC896!aUde6gq~(X/(L4qO3U!BC896!aUde6gq~(X56qA

L!aU=qezz/('q!yzL=Aua6-*7+N(!yoXAL=ud*Y%aALo%UdAG0x

y/8U9<g}G0~[?ua6-Lfg:M/656U-f%)>K~(X;!(//8[?uoC</)*q_%(fj[/!H

y,X<!#AL56U-U=>K(X/('qua6-LfgMN896eUde6gb!W�AzUo=O\e/(.<q

!(/ALUVuvNuo/L_de6[9q!yzLLb!c%[9?Aua6-*7U31L(!yoq>>Kua6-C(U6

<�~AL56U-UUV?uoL!{/(H_de6[9d}%(f)/(!@gAx?AL!af!J9Ct%)#!yzL=:

uo/LXUde6[9?56?,c!t,UVY"!BC89/XUreua\yz*(/%1)(!c;Y"%(89/%(/_q~A@<z?

|)76*(STu89x!(/eYt|j8\i(zUXf:A*q!(/AaBXGC<z$/jQ[71A/(gOuo/L

uDUXfde6[9?_e!{896UG3o<?7+zC]/~zC[9!{!./C]/~z}C-ef%!/<*[71AEX

}s%%(f)/(!@gA0zx?>Kuo/Lde6[9|)(U6<L(!yx~A/(gXO[de6[9?eYtU:rA*q~AE#

}5iS(s%(F!J6a23-

!{89/jAM!(//(![967b%WvfDE1T9O!/0*89Gm]Cq!!aAU!J0z#!&*t|/<11)Wq>w

de6'

#{ Atg_}

#X*{+q(*{J?*| }>vN�!u>�o!

Page 20: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

#p Atg_}

#X{*mp})?n }>vN�!u/!u[o[X

#| Atg_}

#X*)|m+}pJn?+ }>vN�!!;o!.

#n Atg_}

q(2BX- |m?{ q(><Ho! Jm|?{ #q(>Ao�:!!W *)|mm}pJ{qpJ*?+ >vN�!!;o!.

#m Atg_}

#X+}{* }>vN�!uxyIo8N<�:UJ

&f/X89F!s%tgZ/?A(!1,-L!W/0Cs/0A�XU-/w!ex0)fde6[9?|j!#MXAUYtU:

$/)>.6|jYZ<*X!H2*C>.6k"}~(!1,-L�Xfzz!/xy%de6[9?eYtU:XUA*\X

4y,<!?%!H(I"!#ZMX[9%(fj~PzU>.66!H,K,./T9L(k"o,<.WqM~(!1,-L

!WI0!%)56U-/w!exy)f[de6[9!(/!yzL\!n/G01;!{896f01jqb!a;!{B[Wi%F/01R9x?

!{%EUWi%X1FL(!~zC\!BC%(fjU>.D<.Wq(!e!h89N!cX

#J Atg_}

q(!uuao!% *{*?m q(>Ao[X )* q(1;de!{! {J #q(!"/V!(O *|{m}**mNP{ }3Q/)qA9c!J*Lq8N

q(!Ro pJ*?m #q(!o%F:!L {ppp}pJ+?* #q(o!#!T) {n|p}pJ| #q(!"go!#qA9c!J*Lq pp*n}*m+q*m)?)

X-+m q(!u/1o!/:okST>6!; {m+?) q(!uToOU *)+?| R9/

56m*/w!ex0)U/(!@gx?EA0zL56-U=?BAUuo;YZ55iV(!yA)fax\

56-Lde6[9d*IZH[9%X5iWx|uoCA0zL*L*!BCX!j!{s"A?!JIZT9Yn|56|%X/w!e)

*IZYtUH[9%XWg!>K56-;!Z";%H[\/w!e)*!Z"<!~BLy,_?]IZU(6G!%x

!(/BAU56-;YZ55iV(!yH[\/w!e)}?(X>!61Lfa%(st/_}X}5iS!<!a$bc-

#) Atg_}

Page 21: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

#q(2?X p{) q(!�!doO6!_E89a} *nm?{ }>vN�!�HoR9/V!a

#Xm{J{}*n*q*nm?J >vN�!!;o!(O } #+ Atg_}

XpJ|m /(!X!o!oF: #*m Atg_}

}bVeB!{;?YtU:(!1,-;YZ!H(!f*!6AU56|%Xe[956H[\eAUfagq!{=;Q>w

de6'&f/X89F!(/R/�<,/(![96(h!/)qBL!V/)(2?\(sT3Q/)-

!{89/jA\M/(![967b%WvfDE1T9O!/0*89Gm]Cq!!aAU!J0z#!&*t|/<11)Wq>w

de6'

#** Atg_}

q(!u.!io!Fjc pJ|?m q(!o!oF: nm?*n#q(pp*|}*m)?) #q(!uuao!% m{mm}**pm }>vN�#o!%qA9c�:!!Wq

q(2BX |m+?| q(.!#o!,!#k!T) *)nmq*)|+?|

#*{ Atg_}

q(!; {m{q({|n?*) q(."!Atg3F\{#(n%FXX((!l!mo!X(!!/o[X {n?| >vN�!&4o!/l

q(2BX- n|?{ #q(><Ho! *+m{J}*J{?*m q(!!;o!. {np?n o!Fs%(!n;

X{m*?* #q(!()o\zo!pm9/ {|*}pmm?* /(!X!!/o[X #*p Atg_}

X*m)?) /(!X!uToOU #*| Atg_}

&f/X89F?,/(![96U[896!q-!r<F.x?!{%ECCUV)E6;%!(//(s,./U:!{%EUWi%X1L(!~z

;%/aa>.6<T9m9ngxdWi?6Z!G@AtN7b%Wq!H2CUV)E6;%,K,./U:*C*;YZ

>.6k"}~(!1,-D\!WI0!%)56�XU-/w!exy)!(/!W!H(!d*!6f!{896*Xde6)?eAU

EzYtU:XUb*quo-*de6T9!{896C%6x?uo-C!H(!f*!6uo-;CUV)%EUWi%X

de6L;%\uo-U(!(F9<WXWX

%(f)M/(![96vA%(fj~PzC\!{CUV)%EUWi%X1L;%>.6*W6xq(!s%tg(lAI

7b%WvA!BC�XU-/w!exy)C(!1,-;YZ>.6<L;Q!>U12/Yq4BO!/0;GZB!oWi

!u1)WqL(X896xdf!G56/d!ecL!J~zA!6,H/.;/d!ec;Q!cU0zka_?

44?!�i<)!L(!t,C{/*XA!H(!dZ*!6GCF.W(X!a;YZ+t890de6)W\\X

!G56/d!ecCka1%Xe/6A!vwdf!xgp!"#!HAka1;Y,pG!%>1~Pzf[89(/1(![9FR9

x?[(!1,-!(/!H(!dZ*!6/w!ex0CLHx!(/!{wAU&44+t890\\Wihi!H(/%[9FR9x!(/hi)ya

;YZ!{Wip!"#!HA&X_FR9xXBYtU:[%JW?[&AH89a;W!(/!#H89a!{;__G!%:;WX

Page 22: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

+t890*_/!612!/L;(X3oxX W

#Jmm }z(H!{6k_ /!6*,,q/!6/pX +t890

efG|2)!/%(</@F</q!HGH!}"!A8#~;# {|{ }!/%(�qk_ }0!g#/!612!/T9X +t890

#pp{ }/!:!/%(@")k_ /!612!/L(!FX +t893

qerz(H#$F</\\Ax?44+t890}}X!X#/!6*,,X/!6/p Jpm !/%(�CX/L(}A9c44z(H!{6qN

q[U/Ixq!%q7!gxd*_/!6~1T9q/!6/pq/!612!/T9WX

!c!G56/d!ecCka1%Xe/6f%&qd*_['ix?!H(!f*!6uo-WiGCF.Wqq>.6<.x

!(/uo-!a;YZ/!6~1)WX

!c!{A89GmZ!p!q896faIxq>K!s%tgZ/?A>.6<LWi%67b%x~O!{Wi!p!q[9~4'x[9

$}5qU!(/[%xX!c!H2fg7?9x!H(!f*!6;YZ>.6f~B01)W=/!6~1T9!{WifaU%6

x\~!{*b!c[x?>K>.6*W67b%x!(/!{A*(STC(!(/)\7b%o~/!6~1LWi\!p!q%/st

oq[!p!qlgU!_FZ[x>K)f*1L[9Y,A)U!1LWifg%67b%<q>K!{89/jAfg%67b%

o~[!p!q1T9G%!WN/0fm9ng1T9xX

(X~�b!{+t890fp/+C%j1~PzA!B!7(!FG/U!1LC&7,,A7/pW!af:!J<(zC-.o/

?!a;!J;<LL&=z=z!9"1WXYtU:23.w!*0z(HU/)C!BC=>idA!{L44'9*a

A4c1<Cyzu(/)\\f!Y7jr2Z)<T!aC%M66Wi%234U>.~z*#1X_xq!{A(X

Xx?

44oH3<;%4c1<*[(47FT9<<!e!(/7FT9s?.!hD~;C,%6A5/XAaz6Eq!|klm!GZ'9*a

;'9{W!(/azIJKU!a;%BA!BC78AGc9%:WF6<!q%1:Wi\z(;UazIJKU3

<g5ik;;de!<=c=!hDIJKf!+,%j/x(b>Y9?89/X@(IzUU/A<1(46@"09!aWX4c

T#*|m| /B!F(" {p }C/(HX!FG,F</q XSa/(@Wi_89dX *** 1<C+t890*!D,X

!H2+t890*!BCE_xb(X((!G!%>1(!(S1)W~!o:!J\i/PzU|!"1T9o/d?B~

!G56Wi!{C(�U!p!q1/xWquoS'?uoL!aE)4c1<C+t890;Q_3!D,_d\X

!(/[\|!"1x?!a;B[;]b+t890*_(XG!%>/xW!{*!D,1L(!>?/j.gF;]_G]

W\

!I|z23=mnq1L!WA9c44qH*56\\A%(M66Wi[&!9"1)<T>x?44uo}56m*

q/w!exy)#!{W"U.IC+t890;M,WiJF.W?rfgH31Lk0(/uTC\\X}q*56

Page 23: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

#**JqN

%(fjM,Wi>x?

44YtU:.QRZ~�896[x?!H(!f*!6;@!6YZYZ(!(/OK@)UU/A<1(c!t,*!)[L"d?

MM6kUVH(�*X;Izyz>F)X!(/Nzuo-C+t890C89/)<.(Iz3(STkYt(<FDX

#*nm }q*56qN

!-.WLG%!J44i()\\A[&!9"1)<T>x?

44NO/!6;%&PA!VuH/!/XyzFT!yzL!Y{Q<!d56/Lde6[9e/!6fuT<sF{!JR[S

TZ$/jU6*oT9GV!/WX!TLde6[9562=cCu~C-'91!/6s"3\<r,-./H2!ZAyd

#+| }i()WN XNO56!TuH/!/X(W+t893<T!(/X(!4YyX

!c!H2fg!aU|!"1j?!H2+t890*t$}(Exb[((!:;W~_Z4!G,*U/![~�U(![Wi

\zAL*,1R9/I\X

_/|"!e-UV/!6!Is/0A~de6)(\

_56!TuH/!/X/w!ex0z(!1,-C89/CXAd/!6s0<T!yzL[/!6!Is/0A~C>K?X(X!a*

!Ykd!(/XE!a;YZfg!#MXAU7b%d\X

;<%01!(/234Ce/!6(=>i!6U!/Me/!6(=>i!6GCFWXWyB!}/;GZB!oWi!u1)WX

!H2fg_H/.;/d!ecCE1%Xe/6*5iS1)<T!I896fm9ng1LWi]<~\!{A*tCLH[9!p!qU!

o<R9q234;(!1,-CETHvN();89/jAuoL$!a;B[96@i?vA!BCB[[\x?uo

-!{(ST_AH"#XWqK?234;Rs0;S(DYgL>x?

44?!`!{Y/)q*?5[x?(1R-36<yWq(U6;%uo_AH"#XWuoC[H"#*HvN()xq

#{mk* }8q!p[!(/'MF65 $.iHHH"#*\=FR9xq[H"#*%E()H"#*ox\\X

234;!{S(DY;Yi%BCuo-_AH"#XWq4>K_AH"#*uo-fs`x~_CazU

b<T96!H,K,./\m9ngxK?(!1,-CM!s%tgZ/?!{Wi%6WqB$}mzWi!BCfE1)W!(/

MC|}!xy/X1)WR9?(!r<FT?_Cc,./;%%G"Z_U:\s<.W!(/<WXWq>wde6'

#!6,Q/)/d!ec!W3A!W>;YZ*)um9ngU/(!@g1)W? *}

!yzL.i!<umHc/w!ezUF?>K!.i!dc!t,ua6-;I0!%jGy~uo/Lde6[9eA!a;

q5iS(F!J6a23# *{++ qAtg m*|k* }3Q/)\yzO\5 Q!BC%(%TfL(!yxX

L(F!J6aIJK!u6�C56!ue{/w!ex0}Cka1%X/(!@g*0z5iS1)W?

44_A!af%(%Tf[9FR9xz{![9,Z/%lmU/jo<T(?!aC(U6<g\\X

Page 24: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

*)um9ng;|/U!{/(!@gf!6,Q/)/d!ec;(XR/�<,DEL\/(!@g_x

q(pm{q(pmm?| #q(>Ao[X Jmm #q(!go[X} m*+n}||N) #q(8N< p{nn}**+N| #q(8N< *p){}*mmN{ }>vN�!4/)o!%8N<

q(><HoL!!W |*?| #q(!&4o!/l {|p #q(><a!o8N<!F"%R/} m+|+}|mm?*n #q(!uuao!% *{|| !o�:!!W}

q(fg **n?*| q(!)o\z!h **|?*) q(o! n)?* #q(!u.!io!Fjc m* #(!6i!c!} *++ q(!o!j(!/} {mm?*

#(2BX |*}**m q(!uo!/Ha! p+{?** !k"

#q(2?X p*pn}{++?n q(!u!�mlo!Fs%(!n; *|m?* W(-|/mG!m@!i!</w!(zq/(!X!uTo!6

#q(2?X |m+}|){?* q(!h([9;o[X +J?* W(-|/#un@!i!</w!(zq/(!X!u]oR9/V!op

X(2XX *|*?* W(-|/#u/!a@!i!</w!(xyzq/(!X!uTo!6

#q(2XX p*pm}pmm?n W(-|/\iz#u!i!<@>k/w!(zq/(!X!u>�mlo!Fs%(!n;

[9%/x?!{89/jA56!@u6Nq56.!eue{q56iuF(2B/w!ex0IU\/(![96G()WX

4>K[8963!s%tgUm9ngx?!#!HaAUEf!ex0,./U:\_CazUfde!Hde6R9x~_C

azAU!BCq[\x?!#_f!aCr\A[9zg*qdWireuaiCMu[96Z/?%6WqvAUM>w

de6'

#* u@g_}

P

-{n }!e!L p

!(/!Ha(!~z!(/sm1L(!~zf!atzCGu[9z%(v;vwxx/EW>KD(Xyz*/H7%zF'3!(/B

{FTF'3~n3[(ExbB!{U:%7y(!(/!a;QA[9zWI}|)!(/(X!atzA7/}

}5iSEbT9~2i23- (!>WX

#{ u@g_}

P

-*n }u"/!a

uo'%A_A]!{UaE#PS!z\�)(!~z;Q!a;/cxy;'9{!"Wv;vwxx/EW

vA(X7/W3!(/'9mXA[9z!(/!ex0C/%R)xYt1j!exyrC#XAWX}5iSEbT9~2i23-

#p u@g_}

P

-nJ !"<

!(/b~�!HaFT!(/xy$!,"1B5fg!o!atzA>F'3v;vwxx/EWvA(X77/W

}5iSEbT9~2i23- 3!a;Q(IzI}|)A[9z<z*!(/B%V!z!(/U/)/!nKA>F'3X

4y,<!?!#Z_f'9l(I}]/D%)F'*bQ/(zC{!(/!{%EAb7b%n!aAUsr\A[9z!J

Page 25: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

s(r\&UV(z;YZ<z*!(/(X!a;YZ!WG!';]!H%(!Tw\.s1x3d;Q!o!{%ECGST

U|(9XH[9%XGST~de6gFT*XK?!s%tg/?A7b%xq>w<

#* Atg_}

56�T9!@u6N/w!ex0z(!1,-U/(!@gka1)Wuo-L!/xy%de6[9x?

q(!!;o!F(O ))?p #q(!)Io!*/L {m*{ #q(!go[X} J|mm}|*p?*m #q(!uuao!% {n|* }5i&)q!<!c!+}

#q(2BX-|//!a!a@,%L@>@/w!(xyzX- {J{}*+p #q(!u>�!oEo!+ {np)}{n*?p

q7-f_Akr;Q!-!-GST~CFT*q4q_89q_!{C\GST%)FT*\de6[9!{Q|u%-zCGST

~de6gFT*X

!(/.u!�4("@,%X@!@/w!exyz;|/A/%!H(!d*\<1_89xEA0!(/EA1A[9z<1C�Wq

q(2Bqy!aAK,xX *mm?p #q2<! {mm) q[!!/} )|+?{ >wde6'j34uG,

#{ Atg_}

q(!!;o!(O |n|?m q(!"go!#!T) |p*?{ q(!o!/Zo!# pJ*XpmJ?| q(>Ao[X |||q||p?*m }>vNX!uuao!%

#q(><Ho **{}**n #q(!u>�!oE pmm}*)) #q(!o!j(!/ |)J*q(|)Jmq(|)m+q(|)m)}{+mX{+n?p #q(o!. *J|p}|p*?{

#X-|/ ))q(Jp?* q(!u!5)o!J6 n*{ #q(!u!W/lo!J6 n*|}*m)X*mJ #q!u!)o! pnm q(o!+} pmm?J !

7u@Hz#u!/"/w!(zX-

56Hz#u!/"/w!exyzU/(!@gxde6[9?(!1,-;'9{!#S%U!BCu%Zu[9q4!{L=!j!<!V%-_

uo*[8ao?[\_Aj'93\~uo-Lde6[9r!{<!6Ctd;:n/6A|)FaxqQ"!a

AUUV!BCfjLq;]qG!<6!(/\6;Q|u%-zC16~CFT*XXX!MX

!{89cA!(/M,"1!,/w!ex0IU\/(![96G()WyB!oWi!u1)Wq!c>wde6'?_A!#Z_

/(!H!X|"!/)]/~zU7H(=_!%!1x3q!6,7!;/d!ec!W>?q!(O!(/&A56!<UV>iX/w!exyzU

/(!@g1)WquoLde6[9?

#*pmn}p{m#q(p*p}*p{#q(*Jn}*mn?** #q(o!. n{mp}*{)?m#q(J{{}|mJX|mm?* #q(o!(O J+n}m)?{ }>vN�!!;o!@

#qpn{n}*+)?| #q(!!/o[XqGoM!FD/ Jm)n}pJ|?| q(!oAo!J%({ pm?*m #q(!o!/Bo! p+J (><Ho!+}

X#pJ*?* (!RoR9/

de6[9BL4qC[9/|"!e-_B!W]/~zU_A7H(=_U/j1x3quo-Lde6[9!BCW!BC%aA|

Page 26: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

"!/)]/~zU7H(=_!%!1jCX

#q(!+ pnn}{mnX{m| 44!j(!/q !{89cA56.!eue{/w!exyzU\/(!@gG()xq>wde6'

#q(2B\\X ))})J?* #q(!J6%u!5) p+) #q(!+�H} {m+}*+{ Fu>�!oE

&f/X89F/(![96U[896m9ng<�?!#_fkrC16(GST|u%Z;.i!.i~CFT*!(/!#_!WA0zUkr\

1x3q

&f/X89F3U[(!r<89?!#_6!H,,,./!W{/A\_CazUfde!HHF)W!(/(!1,-C!H(!d

;YZ>.6<T9\m9ngx!(/uo-Cy!b/_;89*zAU!BC89Axq>K[89Dm9ngW!(/C"g/|"!e

-_AH"#XW~_CazU\b</xWq4!{Wi!p!q1;T9H>t;!&*!9"1T9X$}?T

!G@UQ-)x,N/0*{<"W6\xX

4!a~Pz!W4'*6e1T9o/dq=!yzL*"(!_}*Ga1)<T7/t!J!,!G56/d!ecfg!%[9qP

pX

Page 27: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCWX

*mm }.i/)7FT9!A/%MaIJKBC6k ;<*B[4q*YUVH6XA<R9xX!/xy%g*Y;HO(u-a.so/XuvX

HC*/Ii@#

([*8

5iS@g/?Q"!eEL-bz!(/HOfd,/jx?(X!WiUDRXF'X!(/!H2(XDRF'~O!e;|!<fg\!P

- }|/L!&|q@g_ o?!afd,JXQ(X.i%!Ut1L(!Ft}1L(!FxX

4q[x?B!{@gf%"(FaU{"1)!(/6]WX!(/!{;aA*fq/.E"oX=!-}[x?_!ex0

L!{%E!(/-a*F(G*(%;(_x[9g(%;\!(/_[@gm,x[9!{A*<!6!(/QC)\x?o\

-n }|/L!Hm6q@g qt!adedzC??,*/(89/%E!aCI#nUxX !ex0reaA!/xy%de6R9x

!{@g;(QIJKA9ctn!,CW?56.!eue{eLde6[9?[~!.i!6!FG><?W?!a*7zWiz/

-||{N| }tn!,d WvC*/(!g!o!ex0LSgxX

ijz#[?!H2!{%E!(/mnAUV*,g(%</Ix~rea!(/$%!+?,bI#*/%1R9xX

G%.-Cn/6*J*!"#!HXtT9oxX56�T9F.iu.!e!F_/)ede6)WX

N| }>!F(Od q�mn-L|/dfr%[9?3%>iXY~|/dK,L89X

[[9//x?[(!756Fe;v|/d;~M;(X!(/ Wi!{AtgC>fw=xX- {+JN) q_/d!ecL0!J(!I# |m{

-!xX

!F56!6,!A/%Ma/d!e!/xy%*(!rx?,./eC*Y}!(j<*D*!BCe#/W3X!o;

(b%N%C.inoUHO(u-a.sWX<ST,./!a*(I"<FTCX!F56/d!ec*de6a~)AtgUm9ng

xX!H2!p!q1T9x~ODEWi1xOzL!//(![96E#X:6C896x?!s%tgDEE1x!(/!p!q!G56

Wi_FT\%/!GH!IJKf~�DEWi!p!q1LCP~o/fg=!JsA+fm9ng1L;v!6,!A/%Ma

.i/)/d!ecC<!6H2!ZWi!p!q;|!<!a;Q3\oXGH!IJK!H2Px~%/d<,!s%tg>w1x!(/O

DEWi\!p!q1;!J%]fm9ng1xX

#|)|/"**mN{ q!<!*/Xd m{N*m q0!J(!I#d )+m/"**{N* }[!6,!Ad

Page 28: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

(1R)!exc(*de6)W!8#!"xy,AW!(/(XoRW>K!BCGR9x!ex!{;8#>%(f!.s1R9xX!o;

(%S%[9FR9xq!oU%TzWi~%Nxq!o;89Gmxy,(!~zUi!cU!FR9xX

Wi\7b%xX |)m !p!BC1)kVG%!<!*/X/"

de6)W)!exc(*

!8#!"|)!./A0W!oUHO.sx!o;(%eWiS!5iR9xX!o;89Gm]~%NxX

W!6,*){?* %!/!>!n(6 pmpp q!94!@X!c!!;@e%Lu!Y./Atg mp?*m }0!J(!I#q89c6F<o!F8#!"!M%!/!>n(6

Wi!{Atgf3=xX- k()L=!m>iP

/"*)*N*m !!.d *Jp }LZ!!"F�H!F;q/"!#tg

-|m*p?q| %!/!Zc!@�n(6 {mp !u[!VUVLq\!F(j<5iSHz#u(ij *mp+m !#tg

5iS56.!euN%/w!ex}de6)W?(1R)!exc(*Lde6[9oRG%,./eC<!1x3vU

!exyHOC_>C>K!aA*!BC!Z"1jC!ex!J8#>%(f!.sde6jq!(/(XY/)HOAWX

!{/(!@gf\DE1!,Lwre!/%[9xX!a/(![96;(XaY/)!Y;u(v7b%WdU!8#!"[9!e;(y

;(b%N%C(�U!ex0HA(!~zWi89/3!(//H7Cde!(!;1)WX!H2GH!IJKA%,lx~!{Wi!p!%61x!axy<

!e!af(Xb!c%[9FTC?!af]X!/lnoU~"1;@ij*Xz{!a*!-<!hF";Wi?,5i!_/y23HnFHgWi

xX!(//!a;?,!p!%6y,WXz{!{=>iCabox(H2X!8#!"C!s%tgWic!BCA9cd@ij*X!GH!

IJK/!(0zWi!p!q1LU:?,!1!"f%(89/XU@iTIXijz#[?!8#!"!(/!e;s~Pz;</=/H7!(/89/3C

/(![96*Y,~q!5i!s%tgU)"xX

xyz#GH!IJKhAtgUT9eWz{!8#!";(X(/!//(![96CWvA[$!nK7b%x?f~PzC(�UE

!ex0C~%!(//H7SxX

q_g~%!(/ `56Tu!�(.NLde6[9?(1R-L!/xy%de6[9

A9c!h%# |mnN{ }3Q/)d /H7!Jiz;(X*!(/USx\

=cGH!IJK2>K!eCf67C8#(/0!(/(jU!eC67f/H7!(/~%Nx~O~!e;!(j<;~k!(/(!`U_3

Page 29: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

oS<CXGH!IJKvlz;~kUj)W!m*!8/\1)WX!ex0!/T9n)UoTX

T#;sF6ACW ppm 56xyX.!O\iDY%$)/d!ecDYk9R!%)}, W

44Eu!pLb!{q;\i/�WWX[ka_?ALG!cA%U?fg6(!F(x9x0!#R!%WiUr(

ef1!"# *{{ }sta!_E}!/%(#k_ unok9/d!ecF%v1R9x\\X

56!@NCG3rAtgx W

#*|) q3# *{m|p q[!6,!Aufg {+| qwd!�]!X m)|+ }x!uua X

5iS/|"!1,!Lde6[9?X.s<*,./1?HOA!e!eX=F(jCX

56>F./)y/d!ec!{Atg;(CW W

#*m5{pJ }G.6\zzLk_ X

!{Uy,<!?m};<(IV1(z!(/m,7+zC.inoUNz89}xX

4q[x?[[9%/x?AtgAHO;.s/}C\{f!e!e6U~({_x!(/!e!e*(/%!BCsW[9(y!eE1R9x

X!(/>Ks1j;!e!e6C(�UHA.sx~O!8#!"!(/!(j<;(b%C(�UHO!(/-a;.s/}*1"cp<

Z[xX!{x?GH!IJK!W!{N/0U/br1;!ex0;%/89/AfvN(<uvWX

ijz#[x?*Y!x$c|;/d!ecUb1"I%/x!H2Px~DE1!,!(/;<1!,U!{Wi:m9ng1xXb896

DE1!,f2\�BXgdo;!BC~w#jf[!p!qBR9xX=c(!F2!u}!(/!u=f(IAz;!*.i4A[P

X<~?*Y!x/d!ecCxyaA3Q!%�1vXG%!u}*Y!xCA9cC\z1)<TZ�{1R9xX!u}

K(Qz*!"\*Y!x/d!ec;!U"xX

#nm }!Ff!/<1#!-i@!M%!/!>!n(6N

qST[9�)(!eUo!?g@CF"$(F(%[!o(7(G(!&e/c!{|X

5iSXq!6,!c56!<!V%/uN%(\i!/!(/56!<'/./(!exde6)W?/j]~/�T9.!V%//w!e

xz!W)A.i>HOUy1X<!Wi*de6)!(/!/xy%1)ic+ro1R9mzeC?XWiG,1>EY">KR9x

Page 30: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

XWiG,1R9!(/r-%4xb3!{A<L(!FxE,>KR9xXWiG,1R9!(/r-%4xb3!{A<L(!FxqE%a

bR9xXWiG,1R9x!(/r-%4xb3!{A<L(!Fxqr!J/cC86Ct2??,.(-XWiG1F)W

|).~z)*Wi4xq~z)*|jGBxqA!e8(c;h(zX;%/[9!zA*$Ha<zqAeYtWiJ!

<zqA/|"!e)!exc(**T9gg!(/HOA~/})!exc(*#*(!/Y<zX/de6[9xoL!j|j.q

0!oCWi12K,de6)WdAfg"!(/(B/!Xo'9R9XQ"oUfg896=F.x~o!W!(/of~

<R9x~o�de6)WXof!G_FR9x~om1)WX!(/Ytn3!e/c!{|;vX

*Y!xe;!{R/�89FQ!cUxyz#GH!IJKf3<3FTz{!4!uc!)!M!R!M;</=*Y!xe;%5!1!"

!#$%;?}G1)WX

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCWX

!j$cde6%(?AeKA<zXXXX!{@gA$/UXcx **m ;<*B[|/L!@g_

){UVP!W26U761.x!de6[989?!j$/eXU89!(oqA$/)6U<zqA<z}K?#B/)

-*|n }.i/)7FT9x!A}IJKF<!#k Fb/(zCI(!H8"1B/1R9x!{U$/f!W|}6:1T9!%xX

-+ q|/L!J.aq@g_ |) }|/L:!f!;q@g_ ([*B[

5iS}!j$c-#</!%x~[}L<#~�o-;V<<Ika1)Wq|(X�!X<3)4</!X!@g

o'9uvX

4q[x?GH!IJKLx!A[9/Ma}IJKCe/6Wi3!p!qEo_!(/

b!cAreaC!BC@gE1%)X!{@gfE1LUy,<R9x?GH!IJKf.-;V"ka1LWi!p!q

xX!afxyz#xIJKCe/6U[y,</Ix?xIJKL(1R-fB/)U=%)X!{89ngML(%64q

WX

XGH!IJKL%c(defgU*,:;<TxIJKCe/6A}-.ikAb!&*}K?-G%!%VWXsF{F<!# *

A}K?-!&*7b%oWX./01!,G%F<!#C&f/Xe/6%d1>1uvWX

XGH!TLO%c(defgU./0Wi[CUV1LCflCx?xIJKL(1R-fB/)U=%)xX=xIJK {

Ce/6A!+=C~fg$!nKeCoxXz{xIJKCbe/6GH!TLECx(X!BCwo,!{AC%?

WX

Page 31: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!("{@gA$/UXcx){UVP!W26U761.x!de6[989?!j$/eXU89!(oqA$/)6U

<zqA<zG

%(,B/)Fb/(zCI(!H8"1B/1R9xX

|,!{U$/f!W|}6:1T9!%xX

!cGH!TL!an@z;E1)<T!BCwZ%[9X!(/Y,e/63*31%[9X!a@zA*M,Wi\(1R-f

B/)U=o%)X

89Jq!H2[6ajFT?xIJKL!{e/6AB/)U=%)\x~O\LH*!o"oxXz{!#hWi[896

UAXo?"A$}(�B*&*<R9x?,P(zA!C!l<T9FH,oX";O/WifB?,6lge;~�!{896Wi

DW?56F1,!e(E!@R;uF,-!xX!(/!H2!cfgwq[?%j%x56Fef!BCFU=%)!(/F~hi!Ga

G!/<R9xX!(/G(/Fb/(zWis1R9xX~_P<89e!P!p!q%/st<Z[xqUV12oXsF{56F1,!e(E!@RfFU

=$}!BC(�U%)F.x!(/(Xxi%/)X!I|zxIJKCe/6A\}89Jq!H2!{!p!qf0_FT-B/)C

"$}!(/$}6b{<LCHfka1L;vxX

!(/=cmy2</!o!{e/6U3MI(z;%[\xIJKC[e/6@iT:;?(X_de6)WX

%/�*de7xXXXXX {J xIJKCWH!a!(/!LMaA$}!BC%/�*de7x=A@g!(/xyaJ)-A

XXXX?/)A@g!(/$c-CA@gAfgKoq7FT9}/(,-L)Ade6)WXXXX~/-CA@gMV!/I?"

-p+n }F<!#N zU!GxX

=cmy2xIJK~(1R-;.i!.i*fo"EFF?!af!BCB/);.i!.ig!xX!GH!T*%c(defgX!a;

*,pX!ex0!+de!@U)*de6TX

Page 32: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCWX

;<*B[56%!(%NC!BCB>K(Iz@i)NzX@i;o7}q!(/[9CA)Wiq~o-f9x0C|}UO*Yk

1T9@i!XXXX?/j--C!BC!{|zC#X56Hz#eCA)Wi@i)~56Hz#eWi!aCA)l!,<*}!m;%A(

1R-L8zde6[9qH,!L;�XH[\e#!P?56%!!%NCBs/0s/0Q}qs/0<3#A}!(/?/j--C

.i/)5iS7Fa {+* R!(/Q*ka%01)5iS7FT9.!h(}U/(}k *| }M!c89c Bs/0R}q~<0Cs/0#A}X

-{mJ y!o4P'k

([*8

5iS@g/?txD/jC>K(X!5ijX$/jIJK}E-#X~DSW!(/XEDT)/!XWiYW!(/XE(X!W

-|R9* }|/L!UX@g_ G!';Ufg896!W,(X~o=([b}!ex0C|}U#!CF.xX

4q[x?!DEFGH!IJKLsV<N;/V/@~9%WWXz{!aC!J

<!.fgqo&X234;?,!p!%6E1;!JofSF7WX

!("!{89/jA4q[x?GH!TLb!{e/jAs/0Q;_<3!(/R;~<0;HW(X$7(Y7U#j1

!(/%c(defgU_xXz{>K~/%!R9IJK/d!ecL!{e/6A*\is/0Q!(/s/0R;_oH;

.iZ}#A!{;%W<T_89�pW!(/GH!TC=yz!(/!%hF6WX

%(,56%!!%NCe/6E1LU6G%~/%!R9IJK/d!ecs/0Q!(/s/0RCnyz5689\iz#[Z/d!ec

U30z1)WX

!(/v~PzLRfQU!ySx!aAU5689\iz#[Z/d!ec!(/!a;\WX(X}5689\iz#[Z/d!e

c#!W?Qq%]Wi(!_!"C!/6U!1R9x!(/[!ex0Uc!xx!(/RqFT;H!:<LqL6

A@gAaLq1j;!ab/(I#n;YFLqb)c;YZ9x0A1j;-U6;d<<L!(/!{;16;

d<LUb1jA!{C6;?}xqUs<.x!(/[s/0QUH[9%XeqH[9%XR9,!(/H[9%X*}<.xXNE

56%!!(%-s/0QA(~!aU!BCfI%/<!d9x0L!aU7c1%[9!(/de6[9X(g%!!%F~6}|/L!eL@g

#!(/%!!%LF~6fg_X!(/k-s/0RA(XNE!BCfo-UI%/<!~9x0L(Xf!W|}7c {n*

#!(/o-Lh[9zoi>Ko-L *J }|/X!Fj"q@g de6jX

iy(X~!ex0LkX4%l?1j}(1R-#*1j}56%!!%N#;%/aade7xX!BC1X}56

%!!%N#b!J(b%A.sd!(/!WL6Um9ng!{;V!/xy%<!?eLg_[!{C1!./*!n/dX!(/!BC(X1X}(

1R-#xb9x0;YZ.s/]d!(/!WL6UU;<mdX!{ff}!ex0L#!Yfde6[9!(/=?b3}o-

L#_BL_X41j;fCK,-!x0;YZ<T9qH{KU#xb9x0;fCK<q!(/1jUC

Page 33: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

FTX>K9;fCK1j;YZ<~1X!J(b%;YZ.s<R9x!(/>K1j;fCK9x0U<~(X9

x0U.s<R9xX>K1X!J(b%;YZ.s<R9x~!{Cs/0(E<.xb%!!%c!t,C}X!aCB!{i

q16b!cHCxyo# {p*X{pm }M!ck @i)XXXXXXX

./01!,2!{e/6A*iQCnyzAs/0<3!(/RCnyzA~<0o>X==cGH!TL!{e/6A!Y5iS

nL;bPCx!eU(X!{=yzCto6o!(/!{e/6Wi!p!q1LU/br1xX

|,~/%!R9IJK/d!ecLM!cAR(Q;89c;89�\(rAb>x!H2GH!IJK!{e/6fE@iT:;~

!P!p!q1LCy/6X1)X~/%!R9IJK/d!ecde6)W

Fa>!ex0lp%6%j?R(qf!/89ct;L!ex0;qrUe/6_x!(/Qs"G!%Ue/6xX!#

16b!cHCxyo# {pm }M!cN t;L!a;89/jAMt2H;CxX

!{89c;!ub,Wi%!R9IJK/d!ecLOQ!(/RC!v,\ka#WX!H2GH!IJK!a!v,CwE%d:;~~/%!R9

IJKCe/6AQ*t;s/0<3!(/R*t;s/0~<01LCPX1)X!ex0/@i?VN~zU)*

de6TX

ijz#[?B(Da;/F"Wi234!(/%010zCYi%BC'5i4A9cYi!x!|Ab>x(X>wde6'!(/GH!IJK;

%c(defgWi./01!,G%8de6'X

#m+N* Yi!x!|d

q!<!aFuga}%!R9ye#]q!6,qmnqz!(/H!XXX(Xh!(/LFT}{}#;X/(L(}~PzAU(XXX!r

=>A'!(/X/A9c!#h!(/LFT;Yi%BCM!cxX

234!(/%010z5!6CYi%BC'A9cYi!x!|AA~/%!R9IJKeC=>AUM!cf'>xX!{

Q!c;%*\F&ij;!p!qCz!BC|UH[9%XoXF&ijGH!IJKf!p!q1LU6;<B(DaC=>

*]91}3odX

!ex0/![<1!,*!%c1LC~~!(/!aWiH89a%/!H)1LU)*de6TX}O#

Page 34: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

!DEFGH!IJK!p!q1)<TCWX

;<*B[G!��!o4!/*CIJK}bj(G!�a!o4"IJK;#!BC%p!4'9{!BCW[9!(/4q_?A

Gz#<L[9<zXG!�IJKLde6[9b3Bn31jC!H2[\{k/x~Gz#1(zCXH{L=b3on3(E1(z

CXG!��!o4!/*CLde6[9~#!Iz@i:xX}F!c!F!eE/|"!e-~!c!BC89/!{|z@iT}F!c!F!e"/|"

!e-){/!$!%Xd!{L3/2@iT%[9XG!�IJKL!{U"y!(/a3(q~de6[9!(/=AL&f!!'aj

}\i/�}.i/)(%01)#G!�dez#!o4)n d?zfXUAn/86x(/X|!!%Xd?zU!{|z#@iu!zX

*+.i!%/H- *+ IJKq,e}3!I#!-.#k

P!E * P(zWi//�x n ([*85iS3Atg�T9.!eu/e/(!@g1)W?/|"!e-L!/xy%de6[9!G,Chi%

}3Q/)A9c /Na;/(Hj/DEX n 01T9!(/ | H1L!%!1T9q!(/ p XoH.s1T9q!(/ { %R}F!c!F!e#!(/[?}E/|"!e-#!(/

-**p q3#A9c!FHaAtg_ ) !FHaAtg_

4q[x?GH!IJKLG!�a!o4"ef$}%01)!(/.i/0z*\i/�>

xX!{896U2x?2345!6;|}!aC=>i*/<UV12o<R9!(/!JaA%][_x?(XUV+U-!!(/

!a;?}WX=cGH!IJKL~$}!#$%(klmfE!W=>i*\MXZ[9xX!H2GH!IJK!#$%(klmC4

U#j?]9de6:;~![y,<FR9?G!�a!o4"eCnyzA2345!6L_>xX=o!&"!BCA9cb

B(Da;/F"WiX�x!{*Q!cG,-./xX

Wi>xX +*N* Yi!x!|d

q(X]q!6,q!(/hij3!(/m8#!(/X/(y(XXX!(/!ry/l!4\yzAaX/!(/!ryCH[9/6CF.!(/!{U5l

s_FR9xX

!H2GH!IJK*6y/6U6[\@iTI?Yi!x!|CnyzA77234L_>x~xyz#!af[\R*X!L;

@i8X!e/U!(/*!(!6U)*/9XGH!IJKCN/0f:z1L;QM234!*.i4Ce/!656G!�a

!o4"eCnyzAE1)WR9?]!,!&{Wi[896(!r<FT?G!�IJK?,6lge;Yi%BC'!(/(y*}WX

X7~)<<!e!GT)23Xx *

![<1!,C(�U!G,fa5i}<gq;/!<R9XA!G,C!xylm56G!�a!o4";</d<gq=A56F

>!;;</d!G,cq%?;H2%(b!zA56@,!o4*MN!Eidq56{%IJKfB)C,-./!G,\CI.QR<1

Page 35: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

W!w#[9# }i()<A5!("N # WX}

Xb!cq/wMz6'9y23Xx {

}B!CN

X.wEDa5/U/)23Xx p

T#(X\i/�WUzL0Eq/!<R9Xq%7qi/AF;YZ!Gf\(r_ �a!o4wH)!4)/d!ec},

T#%?AG!�IJK!4A!{FCI!;1)(X q!a;Gz#(jG!��!o4!/*C/d!ec},

T#c!hdL'9lJf!YG|2Z[9!(/!JnX/K<fnM66Wi �IJK;j8989dez#!o4n)U/(}},

LI"!o4!"H2X ,-(,FI.i/(9CA} 56@,!o4!(j<%?A} L!1G!�\i/�;|/f(!(/R{_X}

AX!@@A�EM%/!H(X\i/�WUzL%7AL!UT9f!G,U/(N{1![9!(/�OPQL!(%Tf!G,*RX(/Z[9q

!H.wEDa5/U/)WF</ }/Y:SX!T(}UXNOqN V(,NEzNzW;*/T9XdeCYCHOf[9%WX

#

ijz#[?=cGH!IJKL3!I#!-.*Q!c%j1faY!B*,1%[9xX!{Q!cC89ngML(%6G,-./WX

[?*\!p!q;b!cM|z;<)WX!BC8q%(f!!J!Z!(/Z!*\!p!qfde[6a1b!c

"/|"!e*#@iu!T9*\>u;YZ56G!�a!o4"/d!ecUm9ngoX!H2!p!q1T9x~[896

89>3m9ng1xXz{[3!I#!-.T9ZA9c~56G!�a!o4"/d!ecC!WoxX

!H2fg[b!c%j?3!I#!-.~56G!��!o4*C/d!ec;BC6Wb!4Gz#!(/j~/dez#!o4)

nc!h\L(HWX~!{89/jAb!]4q[x?3!I#!-.T9ZA9c*56�!o4*C/d!ec;|}

!Gc!(/56)nc!h\*!aBC6f(1T9\~lx2'xXz{!{A9c;R\_!\eC%/[9FT<T[9

TCWX!(/*&; n)| v~PzL3!I#!-.*!Gc!a~PzC|}_x(X>2m9ngoX3!I#!-%A%/d?,`

>X~ax!(/XE!{%(/*>[9~(a<T9m9ng<pX!bA9c>2\m9ngX<~!BCmmn%4!(/mn89L!oC|}!{

e/6*!Gc!xgMN!6R)<X

!H2E3!I#!-.*!GcrBCT56G!"�!o4!/*C/d!ecC|}Mb6L_xX=!{

89/jA4q[?!H2[!o"%/st6a\jFT~7b%X3!I#!-.A7b%#"/|"!e*!{A9cA<T9=yz!(/~2T

hiT;!X3\oXz{7b%%cdc3!I#!-.AaY/)89DXR9/eO/Wim9ngW!(/XfX!(/aY/j(!g6~

hj<TJWX3!I#!-.T9Z7b%XA9cA!+(!g6VWb!{A9c;~(a;a4i%/(o<T~[c

Y"%;(!%!{A9cAka1%WF'XdU7b%X3!I#!-.T9ZA9c2'!(/T9.QR!2/g. *mm[9nm <89?

xX

!8O/Wi[896m9ng<.x?!{A9c*!Gc!a\i/�lz;|}!Gcj!(/7jrxX3!I#!-.X~G!��

!o4!/*C/d!ec;BC6W!(/X!4F4568989)n/d!ec<uvWX,[EA9co,![<1!,;

Page 36: refutation of engr muhammad ali mirza sahab's article andha dhund peravi ka anjaam article written by faisal khan sahab barelvi munazir

%5BC6k3!I#!L!I#q!f!/!F(j<(2X\*o~l!(/>22m9ngWX

./01!,2[896fg!lmC896o,H6XnRU!#$%(klm!(/![<1!,CA9<zA=yz!(/I#n<./ExX!u

4�/d!ecCA9<z;YZ\[<!X;_o!;/d!ecL!{896*.i>!n/_?!aCE6A!aCA9<zA=yz

<gXxyX(y!e%$)/d!ec!(/xyX.!O\i/d!ecCA9<z;YZ!aCE6Ab<!(Xfg@pq896oX!>KeC

fg896>!rm9ngX<!{Wi*t*K,!(/!p!q!!"!(/!_};ko!(/N/0xX

!ab!896 }?[(!76;sAUx!{Wi!p!qo1T9o/- t!#$%(klmL"/|"!e;#*bb!c%[9x

U[!<-1T9?[mn!{896f3m9ng"WX~!/8961T9\N/0xz{!a;<1!,L!/e/~zfUV123o6T9,!af

89Jqk"36a1!{;b!896%WWb!WiWi%/stWX=[896!Wi.sx?!a\i/PzU!+!1!"m9ng1L;

Q5W6C0(/6xX;%(f)|}!/A9<z*!Gc1T9\pxX%(f)|}T9\45!6!/~lW1(!)W

!a*!J!,;<1!,Wi@!&p!(/sxX;<!(/zu!/A9<z;R/F6U.i)!m_Wv*!Gc3m9ngX<JX!(/!a

A9<zU.i)!m_<L*!re!/G%!G56LC%M66Wii(/j[A_xX!(/DYv/)/d!ecL\!IA9<z*

!Gc!a\i/Ca%4C|}1LWihi)'%U/%_xX!!#$%(klm;;<Wi!+!p!q1T9N/0xX

!J!Zb!c!H2Px~O23mn.wDaU/)Wi!p!q1;%j'OzLG!��!o4*C/d!ec;89/j

A!BCo>xX

!(/568989)n/d!ec;89/jA>xX

!(/56G!�a!o4"/d!ec;89/jA>xX

rH{x?./01!,2!{qfw/]91;9!(/xg*YZ%xy!(/+y;|}!W~�0(/!("1xyX!e

x0/!a:zUP)*de6TX}O#

M%,!#$%(klm

TMa

/!(z)