Butler J. (2004) Precarious Life; the powers of mourning and violence.pdf
reducing gun Violence.pdf
-
Upload
winny-shiru-machira -
Category
Documents
-
view
224 -
download
0
Transcript of reducing gun Violence.pdf
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
1/311
REDUCING
GUN
VIOLENCEIN
AMERICA
Edited by
DANIEL W. WEBSTER
and JON S. VERNICK
Informing Policy withEvidence and Analysis
Foreword by
MICHAEL R. BLOOMBERG
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
2/311
Rg V A
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
3/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
4/311
T J Hpk v Baltimore
Inorming Policy with Evidence and Analysis
edited by
D W. Wb, SD, MH,
J S. Vk, JD, MH
C R
J Hpk Bbg S b H
Rg V A
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
5/311
2013 The Johns Hopkins University Press
All rights reserved. Published 2013
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
The Johns Hopkins University Press
2715 North Charles Street
Baltimore, Maryland 21218-4363
www.press.jhu.edu
Library of Congress Control Number: 2013930408
A catalog record for this book is available from the British Library.
ISBN 13: 978-1-4214-1110-1 (pbk. : alk. paper)
ISBN 10: 1-4214-1110-5 (pbk. : a lk. paper)
ISBN 13: 978-1-4214-1111-8 (electronic)
ISBN 10: 1-4214-1111-3 (electronic)
Special discounts are available for bulk purchases of this book.
For more information, please contact Special Sales at 410-516-6936 or
The Johns Hopkins University Press uses environmentally friendly book
materials, including recycled text paper that is composed of at least 30
percent post-consumer waste, whenever possible.
http://www.press.jhu.edu/http://www.press.jhu.edu/http://www.press.jhu.edu/http://www.press.jhu.edu/http://www.press.jhu.edu/http://www.press.jhu.edu/ -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
6/311
To victims o gun violence andto those who work daily
to reduce it
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
7/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
8/311
C
Fw xMichael R. Bloomberg
xx
Ronald J. Daniels and Michael J. Klag
Akwg xx
xxv
Daniel W. Webster and Jon S. Vernick
P a r t I : G u n P o l i c y L e s s o n s f r o m
t h e U n i t e d t a t e s : e e i n G u n s
f r o m i h - i s I n d i i d u a l s
1 F V D S 3
Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
2 T p B A: Ev
p 21
Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
3 vg V vvg p w S
M 33
Jerey W. Swanson, Allison Gilbert Robertson, Linda K. Frisman,
Michael A. Norko, Hsiu-Ju Lin, Marvin S. Swartz, and Philip J. Cook
4 Ev Op: B A
53
April M. Zeoli and Shannon Frattaroli
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
9/311
v Contents
5 Rg Aq C C
g F Owp 65
Katherine A. Vittes, Daniel W. Webster, and Jon S. Vernick
6 Bg D C
F: N, Fb, Ev 77
Garen J. Wintemute
7 Cpv Bkg Ck F S:
Ev Sw 95
Garen J. Wintemute
8 vg Dv C g
Ev F S w 109
Daniel W. Webster, Jon S. Vernick, Emma E. McGinty, and Ted Alcorn
9 Spg Rpb F S g g:
T p Nw Yk C w g D
Tkg 123
Daniel W. Webster and Jon S. Vernick
10 Cg Dg S b F
D: g Opp Ob 133
Jon S. Vernick and Daniel W. Webster
P a r t I I . a i n G u n L a s n f o r c e a l e
11 Eg F w g F Tk: Rg
Op Ev b wg E Ob 143Anthony A. Braga and Peter L. Gagliardi
P a r t I I I . G u n P o l i c y L e s s o n s f r o m
t h e U n i t e d t a t e s : i h - i s G u n s
12 A Exp w F A Wp B,
19942004: K Fg p 157
Christopher S. Koper
13 z : g Tg Sv v 173
Stephen P. Teret and Adam D. Mernit
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
10/311
Contents x
P a r t I . I n t e r n a t i o n a l a s e t u d i e s
o f e s o n s e s t o G u n i o l e n c e
14 C B Db Sg 185Michael J. North
15 R F Rg: Ev-b w
A 195
Rebecca Peters
16 T Bg M: Hw O D Cg Sppg
T F 205
Philip Alpers
17 Bz: C H R 213
Antonio Rangel Bandeira
P a r t . e c o n d m e n d m e n t
18 T Sp Rg A
S A 225Lawrence E. Rosenthal and Adam Winkler
P a r t I . P u l i c i n i o n o n G u n P o l i c y
19 b Op p Sg .S. w:
Fg 2013 Sv 239
Emma E. McGinty, Daniel W. Webster, Jon S. Vernick,
and Colleen L. Barry
C R R F
259
Bgp Cb 263
x 275
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
11/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
12/311
O Db 14, 2012, g g p pkg
S Hk E S Nww, C,
w bg w g-p - . T
g 6 20 bk ,
A w bk bk.
S S Hk , 100
v j bp M Ag g .
T b vv w 800. A J 14,
2013, g A v g
D pg g g v. V J B w
Bk Ob
wk. T v p kw S Hk b,
v g p v, w xp
v g, w, v g , becauseevery day o the year, an average o 33 Americans are murdered with guns.
H w k b w . O J 21, 2013,
Ob k . w k
Fw
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
13/311
x Foreword
, g 48,000 A w b k w
g w pp w k b g
V W. v v p bp
ppg v g
q xv . W p v p-
p w pp v.
F g, w p Cg g
q bkg k g , g pv g
w . T pv w 40 p
g , w 2012 , w
x g pp w bkg k. M g g, w b 90 p
. A S, 80 p g w,
90 p A, pp qg bkg k
g . T b . . W v w
bk q bkg k w g.
p Cg k w . T
p w w pp w b .
S, Cg k g kg . NwYk C, 85 p wp w v
-- , b w g b g
b b wk. C w g g p
w. Wv Nw Yk bg , p b p-
g g g w pv g . Ev
z k b g g , v
pw p . Cg g g kg, g
w wg w g w.
T gv W H pp -
g vb - wp g-p g-
z w 10 . T g qp g
p . T g k g b pp
qk. T pp v. T bg b,
bv p ,
, bb, , k C w S MC v .
M wp g w pv b
wp w xp 2004. T w w, ,
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
14/311
Foreword x
p b V B. H g p
v b pp b p p w w w
x. Rgg wp w b S-
A. S vg w gg.
T q; q p g. T
.S. Sp C, w C ,
b g w S A.
W g bb v p S A-
, g b g. A S A
Cg .
T v qg bkg k g , kg g kg , g -
wp g-p gzw q p
b p b Cg. B p
Ob k w g ppv
, w k p. V B ,
w p w x p
wv g k.
p, p g b v g bkg k -
b. Ev g p kg.
b, pp b g w
, wg g g w w g
w .
S, p J Dp k p
pg v w pv p g
g p bkg k. Y, v b , kw-
g gg b bkg k, xp w .
A , g 2010 w 76,000 b
FB J Dp. D kw w w p
76,000 2010, w w v ? F-. N
44,000, b 44 76,000. T jk. jk, jk.
T vvg g b g,
gv pg - p . , , p b j pkg
p p g J Dp: T jb, g
g b w.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
15/311
xv Foreword
A p, p k pp g -
F B A, Tb, F Expv.
T ATF, , x . C g
w g b w b w H S S-
x ? Y v g w b g
gg w jb w w, jb p
v , , g w v ,
, w v g pb , p -
w g w g w.
T p, , p ppg
w T . T T g Ww g Cg p w kp pb k b w
g k w p. T b x -
g pb vw.
A bg g bb, Cg B
A, Tb, F Expv pv -
g w pb. -
, ATF bg ggg b Cg w
g.T bp M Ag g p,
A D g w Cg, bwg g bb, -
A pp b g
g v. M gg g, Cg v
C D C v
g p g v, v p -
N H. Cg
b g w pb .
A J Hpk , T k . W
zz b , k
. T, b g , CDC
g j $100,000, bg
$6 b. T N H p
$1 j , bg $31 b-
. T p ppv, NH p $21 -g . B p $1 g
pp v . gv , .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
16/311
Foreword xv
T 31,000 g v A, g b 19,000
, w v p g. Nw Yk
C, vg, -
Nw Yk g g w. N, 51 p
b g. Nw Yk C, 16 p . T g bb
w w k w w
. , g wg. W pv
w g g, w pvg Nw
Yk C.
, A pp Cg
p . 2010, g g bb bg, Cg - gg g b pv ,
w , v g wp
w v p v b. T gg
g w . g g g w w k -
. W v -v , b bk
v pb. Cg, g p, j g
vg k w. O w v
b. Tk, g Cg pb, b Db 2012,
w k w v
w g.
Eg g. Cg W H p pb-
bv p p. A Cg p
gggg , , w
p g A pp. T w -
w p. p g w J
Hpk Bbg S b H, w g
p wk bg , gg
v b . g
, g H, Svg vM
T. Rg g v w v k p, .
A w g, D Wb, S C
R, v Nw Yk C pb -- g , b
, g v vg p
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
17/311
xv Foreword
g w g w p. Sw p
w b w p g, g
b w p bkg k. Tw-
pb w p . D. Wb
Nw Yk C k vg g
pp vg b 84 p.
N- p g b w;
p , w v g . A
. O vg v w v
pp w w pb -
. A , w p NRA, w w v v .M g w v w , k,
pp w v b .
T v vg wv j xp
w wv wk k w g v. A gg, Nw
Yk g g p g
p g: 312- p .
W v wk w p w bg NYD
kp b g , w k x. W w w g, w p-
Nw Yk bg . 2012, Nw Yk
C w (pb
b kp bk 1963). Wv v
p .
A wv wk, wv, wv v, -
, Nw Yk g 2012, w 418
C, pp w k w k. W g -
w Nw Yk C, w , v
NYD w b b w p
g. Tk, xp v. B
k v g w g
wv . T g b g w g
g g w g. T pb g g g .
S, , g k. A k p jb, p , kg p
p b, w, , , g
w v b g g.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
18/311
Foreword xv
T g A , , wv
b, gb w xp k p
v b g v. T
A 20 g v .
W v g g w, w p
W H.
v , g DA.g j pg
g , g , W
gg k . Ev you v g w,
Cg vg g w. A g
, b w v, g b . pb pb
g. p Wg gv
v. T gg k bw w v
k k.
M R. Bbg, M Nw Yk C
Excerpted rom opening remarks given at the Summit on
Reducing Gun Violence in America at the Johns HopkinsBloomberg School o Public Health, January 14, 2013
http://www.demandaplan.org/http://www.demandaplan.org/http://www.demandaplan.org/ -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
19/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
20/311
O wg b
20 6 Nww, C, ,
J Hpk v v bg g p-
g v
w. T w w v, bb, p b
g- b w bgg bz p.
x, J Hpk z pp g
v pv pp g b.
W w pp g
, b, pv g, -
b v g g ppp-
b bw v g v bg.
A J Hpk, v b vgg
pb g v w v w . F pv , C R pv
, pg gz -
g g p g v.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
21/311
xx Preace
v bkp bk p
, v b
x . T kp g g-p
b pp g g
v v Nww.
B p vw p b
v x q
g w. R, p g gv p
pp xpb q, pg pb. T vw
b b xp
S.A , pk A, S, Bz
p g w p wk g
v. T v v g pg
v g b , p v g
S, g p. B
g b g pp k -
w g v.
S, g g pb b pb v b g,
k vg, xp. F pg v g g
g b p, w v bv g v
p g gz pp gp
q b p pg.
W w g pp D Wb J Vk, J
Hpk C R, w q
, gz , bk, w
x p p. T w pp b
J Hpk w bg pp
g . T , J Hpk v ,
w pb bk p , w g.
R J. D, , J Hpk v
M J. Kg, D, J Hpk BbgS b H
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
22/311
T bkpb w b g -
b w w x pp.
W w b g J Hpk v -
R D, w, wk Nww g, g z
bg p g p
px v . H p
v pz p J Hpk bg p
kwg b , w v
z v pb g w .
W g D M Kg Bbg S b-
H, w b ggg pp C
R , v p w pb
w pp. H pp S
bk pv kg b .A w b Db , w w
w p xp g p, gb,
k p xp J
Akwg
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
23/311
xx Acknowledgments
w p p w p -
p v w b pb . T g
w v v v
g pw w , pg
g j p wk.
W pp vb g pv b Sp T, -
g J Hpk C R,
p p bk. Tk A S,
C , g
S k . W g wk
C w b vb p bk. A w w C B E M xp g
v pb p g p xp p
q g w wk J 2013.
O k Nw Yk C M M R. Bbg, w
pw pg k J Hpk S Rg
V A p g v. W kw g
M v M OM, w pk
S pg gv .O g Bbg S b g
gzg g-p v w . W xp p
g J E, J Yg, J Sg, F T, S Sp,
S Mw, w b
wk k S pp, g w g Dv C,
B Sp, H, Cp Hk, R Hw, S K, R
MKz, Rb Og, T , M Ykk, Mk S,
Jk w Fk, J Rpg, Y T, A V, N
W-Wg. A k , ,
pp wk.
W v b pp g Hw
Cp, p Cg, B, T w, E F, D
OS, J W. T, g w g B F, M
, Dv Ax, Dg B, C, DNk, A
, E Ogb, T Rv, g Rz, H Rx, T S-b, S, S, S, ,
p O Hpk b vg bw v
p g jb .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
24/311
Acknowledgments xx
T J Hpk v K K
g B w pj w pp,
w x p k K Sqzz, w b
g wkg w p b v
p bk . W k p vw v
p bk p bk. E, g, p-
g J MC, M Sw, J C, S C,
M Cg, M K, C Ek pj
w x . Mkg
Bk Bg Ck, T v, K W, K Ax, C
MCb Tb, B C, Rb R, Rb N, JkH, S V, Ax R, C Bg, V Kz
x jb w p.
O p k g , w pp
p wk.
D W. Wb, SD, MH
J S. Vk, JD, MH
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
25/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
26/311
T g v, w b , bj
b S w. B bb.
M 31,000 pp g w S
2010. B v pp g, g v
g p S. -
, 2010, w 337,960 v
w g, 73,505 p w p
g p g w., T -
g v A .
Dp g p g v, pb
g p g pb p. S
p p b v v w
pb p pv. T w vw, , w
g p g wg: (1) g, , wp p ; (2) g
w w-bg z w g g;
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
27/311
xxv Introduction
(3) v g w wk; (4) pb
pp gg g w. Y v
bk pp w .
A M . p , g vb g
k v A b g v vv
p j w g
vb. V . xp xpg qg
vg g p w
vv v w , pp v,
b b, .
Ck wg v ppg b pg g v B w gv v b gp
g w b g pv bkg
k kpg q. p b Wb . W-
pv v w gp b qg v
bkg k v g .
Ag gp bkg k p b
pbg p p b g-k gp pp
v. Sw . b pb-g v w g pp-
p w w g g b-
. Z F v pb
v vg v, W pv v
pvg v pg g
v.
S kg g w w
p pv F Ow A
w C A A. B b Vk
Wb b Bg g w
k g p g g
w w b p v g -
. C w k v p, , vk
g g , v b w g -
g b g b . S v w w g xp g
g vg b w vb w
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
28/311
Introduction xxv
g p, w g p
.
Kp vw v 1994 b wp
g-p gz. T b w g v
- wp k p b
w g. , wp b w v
xg g-p gz w g-
. T w w w xp 2004, b Kp g
w pv w .
F v b . T M b
b g g, p pz g g b pb b z . T -
g, p- b, w p p.
T S v g
g v pb. M g Db,
S, A, T, j g g w
Kg A. E b N, , Ap
b w w. Bz g g v
w. Y , , pv g g w w w v. B .
Ag b g ( K) b b-
bk p g g ( A) k
S, .S. v pk
.
F , gp v S A
.S. C b g w. R
Wk bk w g .S. Sp
C w p. T pv
bk w .
b p p w p
v-b p b w. M . p w
pb p p 33 p. M w pp b
g j pb, g j g w.
T bk w bkb. T g p v
bk. p, v p
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
29/311
xxv Introduction
b g S, g
q A.
D W. Wb, SD, MH
J S. Vk, JD, MH
otes
1. C D C v. Wb-b j S Q Rpg S (WSQARS) [O]. N C j C v, C D C v (p). Avb :R: p://www..gv/j/wq/x.. [2012, M. 15].
2. T J. C Vz, 2010. N C Vz Sv.NCJ 235508, Wg, DC: S Dp J, B JS, Sp. 2010.
3. C D C v. Wb-b j S Q Rpg S (WSQARS) [O]. N C j C v, C D C v (p). Avb :R: p://www..gv/j/wq/x.. [2012, M. 15].
4. Vk SB, A J, R W. Sv F N-Fj S, 2001.MMWR. 2004; 53(SS07):157.
http://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.html -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
30/311
/ SKpg Hg-Rk v
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
31/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
32/311
F-R D S
2010, w 31,000 S: 62
w , 36 w , 2 w (2) (CDC
2012). A A g v-
( 34,000 2010). A g 40 k
g p (CDC 2012).
Homicide
T S v g- .
O , bg, bb, x , ggv
g- (v K, Mw,
Nwb 2001); gg (k
1
F V D S
Mw M, Db Az, Dv Hw
Mw M, MD, SD, MH, p Hv j C RC p j v H Hv S b
H. Db Az, D, b b gp Hv
S b H 20 . Dv Hw, D, p
Hv S b H Hv j C R C.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
33/311
4 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
. 2013). Hwv, w A v, j
k pv . F xp, .S.
5 14 g g -
vp , v g (Tb 1.1).
.S. v v . C 30-
w, b 1991 w w g (CDC 2012).
Cg v p v g b-
b g , v b g
g g g (Hpb
Hw 2004, B W 2000, Ck 1999, Ck J
2002).
T .S. g b ,
v . N ,
75 v . A A pp p-
g b pp v.
Suicide
Cp w g- , .S. g . Ag g p, wv, -
v g: 15 g, v
Table 1.1 H, , g
g 514 : T S v
25 g- pp ( 2003)
M
H
.
N-g .
T .
S
.
N-g .
T . .
Source: R Hw 2011
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
34/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 5
S 1.6 vg g-
, g b g
vg (R Hw 2011).
Ov p v , v b b
v (M, Az, Bb 2012). Nv,
g pk 12.9/100,000 1986 10.4 2000, v g
b , v
p 12.4/100,000 2010,
b gg (M, Az, Bb 2012, CDC 2012).
Ag, x, , gp g
, , , p - (Nk . 2008). S g, x-
p, w Nv A bk, Hp, A
A (CDC 2007). A g
g v-v k vg p-
v p ; g k p
b b (S . 1996).
, g b
g .
Unintentional Firearm Deaths
Appx 675 A p w k w -
bw 2001 2010 (CDC 2007). D N V
D Rpg S w w- g
, b v w g 25
, w -. - g,
v w p b b
b (Hw, Bb, M 2010).
F Owp S
T S pv g p p (p -
g) g v g wp vp
(K 1993, SAS 2007).M w w kw b g wp v S
v p v S Sv (SS 2010),
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
35/311
6 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
v b v .S. . D SS w
pg w ppx
50 1970 33 . Cgg gp
bv xp wp g
b w (S 2000).
Nb, wv, pg v wg -
v v p v (SS 2010).
T SS pk b g v
b g w . F ,
v w -z v
p. T v gg b g v gw ppx 200 1994 300 2004
vg g w w w g pv (Hpb
. 2007, Ck wg 1997).
Cp w A, g w pp ,
, 40, k v b . T g
g (, g) w p (g g -
g). p w w g p w g p
g (Hpb . 2007, Ck 1979). 2001, 2002, 2004, b b ,
g wp S Sv w pp b -
N Bv Rk F Sv S (CDC
1997). T BRFSS z ( 200,000 p -
) g wp , , b
v 50 Mp S A.
BRFSS, g
px wp b- v. A
v b Az, p, M (2004) g
px, w (FS/S)
g w - v-b
wp , , g
v.
H wp pbb g -
b g , vvg (K . 1992, CDC 2012b) vv w
b b (K . 1992). H g w-
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
36/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 7
p v b k xp vb
k p , w w, p-
k b k. T pp
b (CDC 2012b). B , g
k b g w b -
b.
, w p bw
g pv v . A , x
g g g g k.
vg p bw
g v . N, wv, pv g g . Sg g -
wp, w v wp k p
g g.
T xv vw xg
vb v . (F pv
vw, Hpb Hw 2004, M Hw 1999,
B 2001.) R, b z () g
pg S , (b) g .S.g, , p , () v -
.
S b vw p-
g p : p k
k. F - ,
g g, g, gb; , g, x,
p k bv. F
, pg g- g- -
. p b
g g, g p (..,
g p ), v b
g- . T, -
w
b g. F g S,
kg k k p pg w - v bz (, , ), ,
.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
37/311
8 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
F HEcologic Studies
K (1993) v v 14 vp : 11 E-
p, g w S, C, A. H
1989 C Sv, p v 14
28,000 p, pv. Rp w k
w w , , w
w g g g. M w x.
, w vb, wp
w pv , w wp - w .
A b Hw M (2000) 26 g-
w pp g . T g vb,
w px, g FS/S. N vb w
. F vb w g g
w 26 .
A w-p (Hw, S-Tgw, M 2002) x-
g w g- . T v- px (FS/S, pg w )
w wp . bz
q w vb. T S -
70 v g
wp . T .S. w w v
g b; -
w v g.
U.S. Studies
Ck (1979) - 50 g
S xp p bw g vb bb, -
g bb-. g b bb 1975, Ck
x w vb ( px b Ck x) w
bb bb- , g -
v j , pp , g . g vb w w v-
bb , b w pv w pp bb-
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
38/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 9
vv g w p p bb- , g
g bb.
M . (2002) v p bw v
wp g v
1988 1997 50 9 g. A v, p-
g w px wp
g vb g v w SS. Fv p
w : pv, bz, p,
p, (-) v . v -
, pv g bw g wp -
w pp v g gp (xpg 04), p g .
A (M . 2007) v
g wp Bv Rk F Sv
S. x 2001 2003 -v
ggv , bb, p, bz, p-
, pv, q, pg pp w
bk, pg b g p. Ag,
w g wp gg vz , w, .
T w v b g- vz ; -
g- vz w g w
wp.
Individual Level Studies
Eg pv v b w g -
w . C-
pv g q w g
k vz -
b .
K . x ppx 400 v
p w w k (K . 1993). A
g w. 83 , pp w -
; g , 95 , pp w g. 14 w v . A g
g , g, , vg , w w ,
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
39/311
10 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
p g g w
k . wp w g w
k b b q.
W w , ,
, w (Tb 1.2). A g
p g k vzw
g g w g p.
T g k bgp -
vz K 1993 -
. A p, v, v
w , k vg g
w bb (B, Fwg, R-
b 1997). A - b Wb . (2003)
k w vg w g w p
g w (w w k b v p w w vg w g). H ,
g w k b b -
b .
Table 1.2 NVDRS 20052010
F N-
N
O
/p
O
v
N
O
/p
O
v
H b g gp % % , % %
% % % %
, % % , % %
, % % , % %
, % % , % %
+ % % % %
S b g gp
% % % %
, % % , % %
, % % , % %
, % % , % %
+ , % % , % %
Note: kw g (0.7), /p (1.4), (3.6) w .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
40/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 11
O - v g k
, w p g k w (C-
g . 1997, Dbg, k, Kw 2004). R pp-
b - g wp k
pp. F xp, w b
p p w gp vg b w,
g w p 65 pp v 24
pp b. A b b w
pv (Cpb . 2003).
Cohort Studies
T w g v w kw
, pg vz w g
w.
F v S
F v S g
w g pv (M, Hw, Az 2007, Kb Ww 2009). B , b
g w
wp (M, Hw, Az 2007). T p b -
p g v j v p -
, g pg , g
b, pv, , p (M, Az, Bb
2012, M, Hw, Az 2007).
H wp b b g
p k x v-v . .S.
- p g p
k (B . 1997, B .
1993, B . 1994, B . 1991, B .1988, Cw . 2002, C-
g . 1997, K . 1992, . 2003, Kg, ,
2003, Wb 2003). T v k g (w- ), pg
g gp , g p, w (M Hw 1999, B . 1991, K . 1992).
T g .S. x
g C w p g
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
41/311
12 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
w w k b w
g/x b g pp,
p b g x- p (W .
1999). H, , k w bb x-
k w (W . 1999).
Dwg b bw vb
k xg - g
b q g q
pb b w
b w (NRC 2005). A-
pb (b p w ) wp b ,
v (wb p p w
g ).
v k, wv, g bw
p .S. p b-
v. F, v-v v
ppg (B . 1997, B . 1994, B .
1993, B . 1988, Cw . 2002, Cg . 1997, K . 1992, Wb 2003).
S, wg v q, k
w p g w b all
b (Cg . 1997, K . 1992, W
. 1999); v k g g w;
g w k p p (C-
g . 1997, K . 1992, W . 1999).
T, v x w pp w v w
g v g p , b b, kw
k g g k
(O . 2004, K, O C, b 2011). F xp,
- pb p p-
g w v w (K
. 1992, g . 2008, M . 2009, S V 2008, Bz,
Bb, M 2011).F, pp b k g
g , pg w , g-
gg -p p ( . 2005).
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
42/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 13
F, g, , p -
k bv b v-v g
( bg bj b v )
: g k
b w .
F D
N pg, g - w
g g p , -
(M, Az, Hw 2001, Wb 2003, . 2005). .S. g 5 14 v v k b-
g k w g p w g
vp (Tb 1.2) (R Hw 2011).
C
T S, w g g pv g w,
pb v g-. T v g pb Tb 1.1. T
b, w p .S. g 514 w v-
p , k .S. thirteen
k eight k
pb vp . T
v .S. , . v
g- . R, w g
S vp w
p, vg b g
.
W S , v pg: w
g, v , . T
g p Tb 1.3, w p
b v bw 2001 2007 , ,
b x g gp w g- p w w g wp . T -
g pp, g g, b -
kg. N b v gg w.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
43/311
Table 1.3 V w g v w g wp v
(BRFSS 2004); M D WSQARS 19992007
Hg-ga
w-g
b R
Aggg pp , .p w % % .
g pp pg
p, p (NSDH
)
.% .% .
g pp pg
, p (NSDH )
.% .% .
Nb v
(CR )
, , .
SW
F , .
N- , , .
T , , .
M
F , , .
N- , , .T , , .
M g F , , .
N- , , .
T , , .
F .
N- .
T .
A +
F , , .
N- , , .T , , .
H
MF , , .
N- , , .
T , , .
WF , .
N- , , .
T , , .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
44/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 15
F p g . W b
b vw , wv,
b all j . S,
, w, ,
k b g g (p,
g q p) g g.
T p g pb pb w
pb . F pp , pb , ,
A g b g pp g-
. p p
v S. E q A
pb w, wv, b v b g p
p b k p, ,
z gg b . S pv
b b b , b . T b b g- v S
kpg v b b g
A v, gg, g.
Table 1.3 (C)
Hg-g
aw-g
b R
F .
N- .
T .
M
F , , .N- , , .
T , , .
A + F .
N- .
T , .
.
Note: A 19992007 b w pp bgg 2008;- .
a, , Ok, w, T, Kk, Ab, Mpp, ,N Dk, W Vg, Ak, Ak, S Dk, M, Wg
bHw, Nw J, M, R , C, Nw Yk
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
45/311
16 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
cnoledments
T x, b g p, w p p vw
w pv b , pp b J F.
otes
1. R b 1990 , g - p, pg, bz gg k (W 2000). D v b wxp.
2. H v b g w -g S. T p (CDC 2012).
3. Mg vb g x pb-, b (Wb, Vk, Hpb 2001, MA2008) v w g vv v w pv g w w w g g w.
4. S vw w pv vw - b w , p w g p- vw w v pp
vw pp w pb.5. T pv v b w g w . Hwv, g k w pp b v bv. F, k bw gwp w g bw g w-p b ; b w gk vg g . S, g wp w g - w b q (..,g w g k k b -, p, g). T, w v p-
v kpg g v bgp vv .
eferences
Az, D., J. C. p, M. M. 2004. S pv wp , , . Journal o Quantitative Crimi-nology20 (1):4362.
B, S., R. Fwg, D. Rb. 1997. C wbg wp .Journal o Adolescent Health 20 (4):261 270.
B, J. E., A. . K, . S, J. . B, F. Rv, N. B. R.1997. Rk v w .Archives o Internal
Medicine 157 (7):777782.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
46/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 17
Bz, M. E., C. Bb, M. M. 2011. S bv :R j k v. Suicide and Lie Threat-ening Behavior41 (4):384391.
B, A., J. W. 2000. The crime drop in America. Nw Yk: C-bg v .B D. A. 2001. F .Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 932:22539.B, D. A., . 1988. Rk : A p -
v w p. Archives o General Psychiatry 45(6):581588.
B, D. A., J. A. p, C. J. A, . Mz, M. E. W, J. . Zk. 1991.T p b : A- .JAMA 266 (21):29892995.
B, D. A., J. A. p, . Mz, M. Bg, J. Sw, C. R. 1994. S-
v : A - .Journal o Eective Disor-ders 31 (3):193202.
B, D. A., J. A. p, . Mz, M. Bg, J. Sw, C. R. 1993.F : A - . American
Journal o Diseases o Children 147 (10):10661071.Cpb, J. C., D. Wb, J. Kz-M, C. Bk, D. Cpb, . 2003.
Rk bv p: R .American Journal o Public Health 93 (7):10891097.
CDC. 1997. R , , - g 26z . Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. C
D C v.CDC. 2007. C D C WSQARS j p. A,
A: N C j v C, C D C- v.
CDC. 2012. C D C v, N C H S: Cp M F 19992009. E b CDC. CDCWONDER O Db, p Cp M F 19992009.
CDC. 2012b. Sv v N V D Rpg S-, 18 , 2012. C D C v.
Cw, Y., . R. Db, K. C, S. Eb, C. Cx, E. D. C. 2002.A k -g .Ameri-can Journal o Geriatric Psychiatry10 (4):407416.
Ck, . J. 1979. T g vb bb bb . Policy studies review annual, b R. H. Hv B. B. Z, 743781.Bv H, CA: Sg.
Ck, . J., H. . J. 2002. A p: R v S Crime and justice: A review o research, . M T,117153. Cg: v Cg .
Ck, . J., J. wg. 1997. A: N v pv wp (NCJ 1654476). Wg, DC: .S. Dp J.Ck, D. 1999. Exg -p -v : Ck
k g g . Journal o Quantitative Crimi-nology15 (4):379406.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
47/311
18 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
Cg, ., T. D. Kp, D. C. , J. Sv, R. S. Tp.1997. T bw p g -.American Journal o Public Health 87 (6):974978.
Dbg, . ., R. M. k, M. J. Kw. 2004. k v : Fg .American Journal oEpidemiology160 (10):974978.
, K. M., . J. W, M. A. Wg, M. . R. 2003. Abw g p j. Injury Prevention9:4852.
, D. C., B. A. M, C. R, M. D. Dw, A. V v, J. zk,J. Nkgw, J. Hw, N. T, R. H. 2005. g p- j. JAMA 293(6):707714.
SS. 2010. S Sv.Hw, D., C. Bb, M. M. 2010. : A
p - - g.Accident Analysis andPrevention 42 (2):11841188.
Hw, D., & M, M. (2000). F vb 26 g- . Journal o Trauma, Injury, Inection, and CriticalCare, 49(6), 985988.
Hw, D., T. S-Tgw, M. M. 2002. F vb vz g 25 pp g- .
Journal o the American Medical Womens Association 57:15.
Hpb, M., M. M, D. Az, D. Hw. 2007. T S g k: - 2004 v. Injury Prevention 13:1519.
Hpb, . M., D. Hw. 2004. F vb : A -vw .Aggression and Violent Behavior9:417440.
g, M. A., K. Zv, R. J. MC, M. V. 2008. M ,pv , g S. Psychiatric Services. 59 (2):198200.
K, A. ., F. . Rv. 2012. Sg S R.JAMA ():12. : 10.1001/j.2012.208207.
K, A. ., F. Rv, N. B. R, J. B, D. T. Rv, J. F, A. B., J. zk, B. B. Hk, . S. 1993. wp k . New England Journal o Medicine 329(15):10841091.
K, A. ., F. . Rv, . S, D. T. R, J. F, J. B, J. -zk, C. Fg, B. B. Hk. 1992. S g wp. New England Journal o Medicine 327 (7):467472.
K, M. 1993. bw g wp . Canadian Medical Association Journal148 (10):17211725.
K, B. ., S. S. O C, T.W. b. 2011. T b -
w p p p. General Hos-pital Psychiatry33 (2):191196.Kb, C. E., T. Ww. 2009. Expg g bk
w: Hw - g vb -p - . Social Science Quarterly(90):12031227.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
48/311
Firearms and Violent Death in the United States 19
Kg, H. C., J. . , X. . 2003. Rk - g 1564 S: R 1993 NM Fwbk Sv. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology39
(8):419426.MA (M Ag g ). 2008. T v g g g A.
M, M., D. Az, C. Bb. 2012. S S: p g g pp-v p b .Annual Review o Public Health 33:393408.
M, M., D. Az, D. Hw. 2001. F vb - .Accident Analysis and Prevention 33 (4):447484.
M, M., C. Bb, D. Az, D. Hw, B. E. M. 2009. Rppg, g p w
w : Fg N Cb S Rp.Injury Prevention 15 (3):183187.
M, M., D. Hw. 1999. T p bw :A vw .Aggression and Violent Behavior4 (1):5975.
M, M., D. Hw, D. Az. 2007. S-v vz S v wp,20012003. Social Science & Medicine 64 (3):656664.
M, M., S. J. pp, D. Az, D. Hw. 2007. H wp 50 .Journal o Trauma Injury, In-
ection and Critical Care 62 (4):10291035.
Nk, M. K., . Bg, E. J. B, C. B. C, R. C. K, S. . 2008. S- bv. Epidemiology Reviews 30 (1):133154.
NRC. 2005. N R C: F v: A vw.Wg, DC: N A .
O, D.W., C. Zbk, . Bw, M. M, A. . 2004. Mgg : A pb k.American Journal oGeriatric Psychiatry12 (1):3036.
k, W., F, J. Eg, F. Bk, M. z, K. R. 2013. T p gg 30 C. Pediat-rics 131 (1):18 26.
R, E. ., D. Hw. 2011. H, , : Cpg S w g- ,2003.Journal o Trauma Injury, Inection and Critical Care 70 (1):238243.
SAS. 2007. Cpg : Cv : Ax 1: Sv- - w pv v wp . The small arms survey: Gunsin the city, . S A Sv v. Cbg, K: Cbg v.
S, D., M. S. , . F, . T, D. M. 1996. g- .Archives o General Psychiatry53 (4):339348.
S, T. W. 2000. 1999 N g p v N Op R- C: R g. Cg, : N Op R C-, v Cg.
S, S. B., K. A. V. 2008. M -bv: p pv. Evaluation Review 32 (3):239256.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
49/311
20 Matthew Miller, Deborah Azrael, and David Hemenway
v K, J., . Mw, . Nwb. 2001. C vz v z : K g 2000 v v. Netherlands Ministry o Justice: Research and Documen-
tation Centre Netherlands.Wb, D., J. Vk, . Hpb. 2001. Rp bw g, g-, g w g. InjuryPrevention 7 (3):184189. : 10.1136/p.7.3.184.
Wb, D. J. 2003. H k w :A - .Annals o Emergency Medicine 41 (6):771782.
W, . J. 2000. g v. The crime drop in America, .A. B J. W. Cbg: Cbg v .
W, . J., C. A. , J. J. B, M. Wg, C. Dk. 1999.M g p g. New England Journal o Medi-
cine 341 (21):15831589.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
50/311
F w v pp w gp: pb
g pg
qg v . T v j
pb w q p w, p-
vg p g kp b b b
b .S. Sp C g. B g, k g, .
p w v b
b g k g pb-
k p v g g. W p pb kp
b g-k gp g- v, v
pb g v g v
b ww.
2
T p B AEv p
p J. Ck J wg
p J. Ck, D, TT / T S b p
g Dk v, - N B E R wkg gp . J wg, D, MA,
MCk F S Sv A, w b
v Cg, v Cg C b, -
N B E R wkg gp .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
51/311
22 Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
T v v-pb pp p w
. T w g q pp
bg g g p-
( p ) g . T
g wk w b C A 1968
(CA), w q b g g b -
(FF) p g b
. A pg g FF q b CA
4473 g v v
qg , g w w q
v p b ppv b.T CA q w g g b bq g,
B Hg V v A, p 1994. T B
A q FF bkg k w-b b
b g 4473 w g g. T w g w
w g p g g v, p . M
g w wp w p -
, b q g --bk . S
g p g b B A. Hwv, q v p b g FF, Brady
bkg k v bk v 2 w w p-
(Bwg . 2010).
O M 2, 2000, B C w
B B vg pp v kpg g wg
, j p b b b pp w
b g w. Dg v
B A, 312,000 pp p g (2.4
) w qg -
(Bwg . 2010). O w-b b w
v b v pg b . T g :
S g kv k b,
g Bradyw k
(Zg 1968, 1972).
T C w pb v B A Journal o the American Medical Associa-
tion (wg Ck 2000). O w pvw
v b b
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
52/311
The Limited Impact o the Brady Act 23
Brady. W pb Brady v
, b b p . pg
g, w -
(g jg, b) p,
pb Brady , b
, pv gv. F, v
Brady, p pb
g g b v vg pp.
, B A p p p g
w p Db 1998. W p,
1994 1998, w g p, p pxp bkg k q p
g. p p, p q v-
wg p pp v g, w p-
p p wg p w w , kw
N C Bkg Ck S (NCS). O v
p.
w pv v, g
g , g w q v b: (1) W p
v pb ?; (2) Hw g p-
p b g?
Bkg Fg
J B, p Rg, w g -
p g p M 1981. Tg w w,
S, B b g v, g
Hg C, . wk v v pg w
b kw B Hg V v A. T
pv w p Fb 1994, qg FF -
bkg k w v b b g
g . O 32 w b pv-
, b 18 D Cb q A. pv
xp, w 32 g -
, 18 -g vg . O v k
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
53/311
24 Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
vg xp-k g
B A .
O w V S
. W p ,
v ,
bb . (T V S
pp k pp.) W z
Bradyg . T
b w v, p
21 g . T p g
B A w g v g b 21; w 21 g p g
FF, g w bj k v bBradyb
q w . O , g -
v pv x w w w k
v, committedb g 21 v; Bradyg-
p pp v. B
p g k g v, w v
g 21 v b pp 21 g (Ck b 1998). g g
gv v, v v-
, p v p b b v
jv g p p w w
k-k v (B 1995; Ck 1999).
T p vg gp vg
Brady w
p, w ppg w 1990. p-
, pp b 34 1990 1998. M
p g 1990 (w w b -
) b b g
g. Ag v b gg xp
p 1990 p pg p,
wg k p bg -1980, ,
v, gz b 1970 (B- W 2000; v 2004; Ck b 2002). v,
v B A b
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
54/311
Brady w k b B A
w vg w v
1990.
O p 18 w b
B A pv v gp pp b kb -
p-Brady . Ev -
x p Brady . T
( p g ) -
vg bw w gp Brady, w b pb -
b vg w g b A. O
v pp pp b w qw xg v - pb
, g w w vg w w g b
v g (pp p -p g
).
A vg B A w
w v g g ,
w pg w gp g v
w (W 1997). T w b v. S pp
ATF Cg wg
g b Brady
wg p w (Ck Bg
2001). Hwv, pp Cg w
g g v p, p b g g-
kg p (Ck wg 2003). O xp -
k w b b - --
x . , gg w Brady
kg , w q
g vb k v .
H p qv v. W z
pp p p- p-Bradyg
gp. T q p g
zg p (1) bw, w Yitp - (i) p (t), Xit
p vb. T
p vb , di,
The Limited Impact o the Brady Act 25
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
55/311
26 Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
p -p x v v-
, vb,gt, p
g v v .S. bv
v, vb Tit
q 1
wg p B A q 0 w.
F V S , w vb p-Brady
(1994 1997). F pb, w p-Bradyp
p w p (1990 1993).
Yit=b
+b
X
it+b
T
it+d
i+g
t+e
it(1)
S -p x , k - (b
) bw
g v p- p-Bradyp. T
b
p - g v
v B A,
b gv Brady g v.
Eq (1) w v wg q, q
k b p-pg
p xp vb b q pp-. W Hb-W j -
p bv .
T g g z Tb 2.1.
W b bw
Brady() -Brady() g pp g 21
. W p gv, v gv
-g g ( v -
g). p w Brady.
T 95 v v g
8 13.
O B A v .
p, wg p q g p Brady
v w g q b pp xpg
p. A w Tb 2.1, v-
Brady v g g pp g 55 . Hwv, g w p b
-g (pp wp b), w wg
p v g g gp .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
56/311
Table 2.1 E B A g
p- p-Bradyp v
(S- p)
V g21
V g55
H ( p ,) . (.) . (.) . (.) . (.)
N-g . (.) . (.)
% w g . (.) . (.)
S ( p ,) . (.) . (.) . (.) .** (.)
N-g . (.) .* (.)% w g . (.) .** (.)
Source: Ck wg (2003). T g p wg Ck(2000) w b w v w w bq.
Note: T p-Bradyp 1990 1993 p-Bradyp 1994 1997. Rg b g q (2) x g pp wg j k.
**S z 5 p-v*S z 10 p-v
Hw w g b p
w v b pp g
B bkg k q? Ab 2.4 p
g b w g g p B
A bkg k (Bwg . 2010). O xp
p p w q g bg g b p
FF w b v w k g g (-
p w q v). D C w
v w w p g v
23 w v- w v b b -
v , w b p g
FF (Wg, W Rv 1999). Y w-p
b gp w, 3 v-
(Wg W 1999). jg C gg 312,000 v w w
g Brady p ( 1994 1998) w v
b 60 w .
The Limited Impact o the Brady Act 27
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
57/311
28 Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
D
Spp g p B
A p . W k
xp, w w b pb vg v
g C A b g p b g-k
gp?
T p k xp p b -
g bkg-k q b FF, B A
bkg-k q v j
pv w g. Sv p 1980 w - b g
g (Wg & R, 1994), v g
w q bkg k v b
gb. M g b pp w
FF g pv g g xg
w , g b --bk -
g k.
W pv p pg xp p B A, v
b k . F, j w p g
g q pg g. Ck, wg
Bg (2005) v
2001 v v w 10 p -
. N p -q
b g 10 p
. Expg - q ,
, v v ( q-
, w v)
p p.
S, v q p k b g FF
Brady, g , p b v
p . g pb-
Cg b N C H pv -g (NCH) pv g -
pv q b
. T v 83
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
58/311
b bkg k b 2003 (Rk 2006),
b g q p w b
g NCS p. NCH pv
g pvg w pp 2007 b w p-
g g p
NCS . A w v g g p, b
v b p bg v
v g b (M Ag g 2011).
, g b
pv g , p, pv p-
, g g q, p vg b z NCS. T -
pp g pv g , g
v p g :
k b k b g FF ( w
pv- p w b p) b k b -
q .
T b b g pv- p
b p qg g , w p k, b bj bkg k. C
, w g g FF w
g g bkg k. S , w
b b, w k q pp b
g. T q w . C
q g b g w, w -
g w b p g. Ev w
g q, v bkg k b -
v w, g w- vg g w
v b b p b p. W C-
g g v b b
(b Wb, Vk, Bz 2009).
W pp v v g g v
g pv g g , k
v g. Ev j p g w v 300 v vg j b- p-
g b kg v . T g v-
B A pb v
The Limited Impact o the Brady Act 29
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
59/311
30 Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
v v g , w
ww. N v w kw
w b p g pp .
cnoledments
T g p w pp b g
J F. T k Bb M, C Ck, H
E, Mg MN, Epz R vb -
, R A, Sv Hg, Dv Hw, A
K, Dbb , W Mg, J M, J M,W Swb, D Wb, W, M Wg
. A p .
otes
1. District o Columbia v. Heller(554 S 570 (2008)) b p g
kp g - pp.McDonald v. Chicago (561 S3025 (2010)) x g b j p gv.
2. B Cpg v V, Svg v b Tkg O C: T Dp -R C D S E Bw, Exv S, w p://www.b.g/x/F/b-w-p--.p
3. p p, w -v g -wg v: p - p p ( g ), pg pp vg
p , pg pp vg bw pv v p wk ( 1998 ) pg w A- A, pg pp g 7 ggp.
4. v w g p vb g. T g p .
5. F p g b FF, b Wb, Vk, M, A ( v).
6. p J 14, 2013, M OB, D- Mwk H Rvw C, p v ,
k v , q k b g FF.F J 1, 2010 Db 31, 2012, w v 59
v C Mwk. ATF T w : p-, v p. ATF w b
http://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdfhttp://www.bradycenter.org/xshare/Facts/brady-law-drop-in-crime.pdf -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
60/311
52 v. 31 (60) v p . T v w p FF wp w v.
eferences
B, A. 1995. Y V, , -Dg ,Journal o Criminal Law and Criminology86: 1036.
B, A J W, . 2000. The Crime Drop in America. NwYk: Cbg v .
Bwg, M, R J. F, A. v, A D. B, Dv B.
A. 2010. Background Checks or Firearms: Statistical Tables. B JS B NCJ 231679.B Cpg v V. 2002. Svg v b Tkg O
C: T Dp -R C D S E Bw, Exv S, w www.bpg.g///vgv.p, Ap 17.
Ck, p J. A A. Bg. 2001. A Cpv F Tg:Sg vgv Nw D F Mk,Arizona LawReview 43(2): 277310.
Ck, p J. J H. b. 1998. T p Ep Y V-
Crime and Justice: An Annual Review o Research . M H. M M T, E (Cg: v Cg ), 2664.
Ck, p J. J H. b. 2002. A Ep: R T YV S Crime and Justice: A Review o Research , b M T. Cg: v Cg , 117153.
Ck, p J. J wg. 2003. T E B A V- B E. H (.) Guns, Crime, and Punishment in America.Nw Yk: NY : 283298.
Ck, p J., Sp M, T B. C. 1995. Rgg Mk. The Journal o Criminal Law and Criminology86(1): 5992.
Ck, D. 1999. Exg T-Sp C-v HD: Ck Mk D Ag Y.Journal o Quan-titative Criminology15 (4): 379406.
v, Sv D. 2004. g W C F 1990: F F Exp D Sx D N. Journal o Economic Perspectives,18(1): 163190.
wg, J p J. Ck. 2000. H w p B Hg V v A.Journal othe American Medical Association 284(5): 585591.
M Ag g . 2011. Fatal Gaps: How missing records in the ederal
background check system put guns in the hands o killers.p://ggg.g/w/p/g__vb.p
Rk, F. 2006. Improving Criminal History Records or Background Checks,2005. B J S g Rp NCJ 211485.
The Limited Impact o the Brady Act 31
http://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asphttp://www.bradycampaign.org/facts/research/savinglives.asp -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
61/311
32 Philip J. Cook and Jens Ludwig
Wb D W, J S Vk, MT Bz. 2009. E -v b p kg. Journal o UrbanHealth; 86:525537.
W, Dg S. 1997. Trac Stop: How the Brady Act Disrupts Interstate GunTracking. Wg, DC: C v Hg V.Wg, J D. H. R. 1986.Armed and Considered Dangerous: A Sur-
vey o Felons and Their Firearms, Nw Yk: A .Wg, M A., J. W, Fk . Rv. 1999. Ev
D Hg Bv B Hg Rk F- V.American Journal o Public Health 89(1): 8890.
Wg, M A. J. W. 1999. pb . Dv,CA: V v R g, v C DvM C.
Zg, Fk E. 1968. C k R V Kg? TheUniversity o Chicago Law Review 35: 721737.
Zg, Fk E. 1972. T M Mg: F Cb D- D A,Journal o Legal Studies. 1: 97124.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
62/311
T Db 2012 g Nww v
pg b b g . B
, q w g v b pv 28
gvz pk p
p. S w w b g
3
vg V vvgp w S M
J W. Sw, A b Rb, K. F, M A. Nk, H-J ,Mv S. Swz, p J. Ck
J W. Sw, D, p Dp Bv S
Dk v S M. A b Rb, D, MH,
p Dp Bv S Dk v S
M. K. F, D, p w v C S
S Wk w C Dp M H
A Sv. M A. Nk, MD, MAR, p p
w Dv Y v S M F
Sv C Dp M H A Sv. H-J ,
D, p S S Wk v C
pp R Dv C Dp M
H A Sv. Mv S. Swz, MD, p Dv S C Bv H Dk v H
S. p J. Ck, D, TT/T S b p
g Dk v, N B
E R wkg gp .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
63/311
34 J. W. Swanson et al.
, , pp w v? S w
, p- -
bkg-k, g kp g -
g pp? D pb w w v, w
b v k pp w wp-
g p g ?
Cg w q g
g p kwg p- g
b b v v pb
v (N . 2009; Sw 2011). A , g
p p b bg v gv g p w b . O
, g p p g w pb -
pvv pb - j .
O , k v b
w vwg pb p v g
b g
p g p p p p
ppg w gg g, px, b g (Appb Sw 2010).
, w k g p bw
pb v g g g
p w. T gppg w
g b g w w
b w g pp g w g
-g g, , bv. Wv
v gg b pp w v
kg p g
pv b g pb ( . 1999).
F k v j, w bg -
. A g , , pv,
w pv b b j. ,
pp w b b
b k p w w b w g .A pb p g x b p g-
gp v pb b w vg
w .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
64/311
Preventing Gun Violence Involving People with Serious Mental Illness 35
W kwg xg pkg
p v w wk. B -v w
w b k g w
b . , , k vb p-
b pb pkg p, v
xg , p, w gzb.
p, w p w g p v-
g pb g k v
C p 23,000 pp w .
g g v pb
j 2002 g 2009, q-xp p p b C bg
pg N C Bkg
Ck S (NCS) 2007. W p
pb ( pp w b) p g
v.
1968, Cg p C A, w g p-
b pp bg v b v -
p j v (Sp2007). (T g b .
g , k -
gg gzg v.) A p g-
, x v pp w v b b -
v g p b g p g w
. v v p
q b .
T g 1968 C A pb w ,
g v z v
, g pg k v -
(Appb 1994; F 2010). T g x
w g 1994 B V
v A, w bkg kw g -
g NCS pb p w p
b g g . T pb, p, b p v -
b 45 g, b v g v
v v g .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
65/311
36 J. W. Swanson et al.
T p p :
pp p g ww g
w k v bv; pp w
g w vb
p, w b k v
ppp p p; , g, v-
p p w w w k
p g , , b -
g pb bg ; , , w
v pb v pg -
g b w b g b w g-qg -
p , , b pp. g w
wk v, all p ; w k
pv. A , p w w.
Sbq pg w b-
pp v v (Fz 2006; Sw
1994; V D, Vvk, J 2012). T v pp
pp w w b g k b g ; -
q g-qg j (
, ) w w p bkg k. , -
g jg, w p w b v-
(z, Mv, 1993) p
v k. S v w
g (F 2010). T
bkg k p w b g g -
g , w b pp -
pv (Ck wg 1997). A pp v
g , v w g b b p
g (N C S C H S 2001).
S v bv w pvg g pg b -
b v xg pg NCS
(M Ag g 2011). , v gg g NCS w pp w g-
qg w v b p
g v pp , , pvg
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
66/311
Preventing Gun Violence Involving People with Serious Mental Illness 37
g. , w b p v-
. S, w b g p v-
w p g , g g v-v
w b p pp w
p w v b bj w
xp NCS-pg p w w v . W w
p g C.
Ev F b Rg Vg p w S M C,
20022009: Fg Nw R S
C bg pg NCS 2007.
T Dp b S pb wg NCS
gg g-pb p. T w b
g-qg g bk bx
, p
. T p 3,062
NCS pg, b 2013 14,000 b. b, p w
w w vb g bkg k
bq w g; g w
v q g v , k -
g v v . W b p,
, v b g-q p w
? O q.
Data
Av w pg 8
w b g C pb
j g. A v vvg p-
v w vw ppv b
v j Rvw B (RB). Mg
J 2002 g Db 2009 w b 23,292 g wg : (1) g zp, bp -
, j pv (2) pz p
p v vg p. Tw
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
67/311
38 J. W. Swanson et al.
w p: p w
p j p NCS (v -
, p , q, vp);
p w v p pz b -
j. D w p- .
T p pv pp p g w
w v pb
w v j v b p-
z v -p -g
b b . A , p w gz w
pp p w - w v v qg p
w v pv . T p k v
v bg p , g b b -
b, g pp w vv w j
. T b v p g -
p p w . R
vb b v p
, p v g v p.
Measures
T p vb w v (-
w) w gv . V ,
g, , kppg, x , , bb,
bg. , w w v p g p
, b v w vb .
p O gv R C
w b 92 v (.g., g p, -
, , .) v,
p bgg g (R 2007). F
v p v g- . ,
w v v px g . V
p pb gb g
g g g w vb .Cg vb w w g-
qg w p gv , w
q w ( v,
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
68/311
Preventing Gun Violence Involving People with Serious Mental Illness 39
g , v ), w
bv b NCS pg bg C-
. Ag, x, , p p g, -g b
g w v.
Analysis
W vb g g w p -
v v. T p vb w gg
pp p g v g
g-qg v w v. W g k
v g b NCS pg bg. W , p g w, v k pp
w w q v q, p- p-NCS
p. W vg v -
q gp b
bv. W j k b vg bv
w v w pz . W j -
p p bv v .
Results
T g pp w 36 , j w (62.5).
T - p p w 62.7 -Hp w,
18.4 A A, 16.6 Hp, 2.3 - gp.
Rgg p p g, 28.1 zp, 30.6
bp , 41.2 p. A g gp, 85.9
-g g b pb g
p. T pv b b b g
p w b -pv p,
p pz , w
w v w v px v p-
pb.
Tb 1 w b v pp p
w q pg g p-
b p q. Ab 40 p w q j . Dq
w g g g
(34.9 v. 7.0). O 1,634 v w
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
69/311
40 J. W. Swanson et al.
q, 512 (31.3) w q b
. T g j (93.7) pp w w
v g-qg g p w v -
v w q .A b pp p (39.0) w v v
g 8- p. T pp
vv g kw, b 4 p v
v p g g, g p .
Tb 2 w j q v v pp-
p- bv vb , b -
q , bv b NCS pg
bg. p, w z
v w NCS pg w
q 7.8 6.5, pp 17.
bgp bv w q, -
pg w g 6.7 b NCS 3.2 NCS, p-
p 53. T j w NCS
pg , g pv p. A ppp-
q-xp g q b -vb .
Tb 3 p vb g p.
Hvg g-qg k
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
70/311
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
71/311
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
72/311
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
73/311
44 J. W. Swanson et al.
v b k v -
b 1.6. T v w g
w pp w j, p w
w q p-NCS p. Ag w w -
q, v g NCS
pg bg. T w v w w
vg b , bg g, , A A
Hp bkg, vg bp v p. T
b w pp w
, g - g
px vg, w w - . Bp w pv w v
p w p. Szp w gv w v-
p w p ( g p MA
V Rk S; M . 2001.)
Tb 4 w p w q pb
-- w pg
NCS pg p C, w p g -
v v. , bv w v p- w v
q . T w g
v g g w qg -
NCS pg bg. T k v w w b
0.69 g q p-NCS-pg p
p w p-NCS p. , k v
q v w w p NCS w -
b v pp w v b q-
. Hwv, gp w w v q, v-
w ppx b NCS p w
p0.65 v 0.62ggg, w b xp, NCS
pg pp w p NCS.
D p
Cg pp w, w v
B A pb v k v . , vg
g-qg v k g in-
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
74/311
Preventing Gun Violence Involving People with Serious Mental Illness 45
creasedk g v . T x g w
vv b pp w g
b g, pp pz
g g bkg k; w, ,
pp b wg xp .
Hwv, g p bgp pp w -
w v , gg
B w bkg k v pv , .
w g-qg , k v
g g C bg pg g-
qg NCS.T g pv p bw bkg
k v . T b xp,
xp, p-2007 pv
j p pp w g-qg
j, g pv -
w k g. T .
W v px g . T
w g , g gz w .
W xg pb-
p b b vv
vb w k v
. A v, ,
vg j v NCS g-
k v . Avg pv -
pg NCS p v
b g , , pv pb .
Hwv, p w pv g v b g
v w k bkg k b
. g pv q p g
g v. A v w pp wk, p
pp pp p w
, b b j C- ( ) v w. O b 7 p q-
g j, v pp5w
q q b w bg
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
75/311
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
76/311
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
77/311
48 J. W. Swanson et al.
q b . --q
bp, w q 3.0
p 3.4 v . p-NCS p,
6.2 p 5.0 v . , 96 p
w b v w v
q , . T pp-
gg bkg k
pbv p vw v v
p v v p w ;
k b w.
Rv pb g . M b b ecient pbg
g pp g g air pvg g
w g. , bg g
p g g
p w w g, bg
p g p w
w g g. M p, , g
pb g v g-, g p bw v k
bp g p w j
, pv b g-
g v q .
vv g q x v
pv g, pp,
. g p w (k 2010), xp,
v v vg g-
b g. -
, w vg g
g p w g. T w w -
p k p v v w w
v w p g v
(k 2010). A pg pp w C-
w w z g v w w g 72- , pg j
g 14 (Sp 2007). T p w, b ,
k pb pp pp
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
78/311
Preventing Gun Violence Involving People with Serious Mental Illness 49
w p ppb k g v pp
b g x b v p
p x g v k.
O gg , g pp w w v
g vv w j , x-
g w p g pv g
g k b v. E pv
g v kw w
g g k ; pvg
-b ; g -
v g g pg , j v, g v p w
w v b (M S 2012;
Sw 2010). A , w v g
pp-b, g- pb w -
.
F, w b w g b p
: -
b . W w bg p g v, - g b g v ; b
p p v p pv v. S
61 S19,393 31,672
g 2010 (C D C v 2013).
S g A g 15 24, pp
g gp w g pp g g, j
, xp p j . T j
v pb
. Hw g g? p q w.
W w , w ? b v p.
Dp p p g
w . S vg p b g pv
p . Dp , wv,
g v g-qg v -
. w, pp g - q k k
w p g bkg k. Ev v w p
j NCS, gp w
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
79/311
50 J. W. Swanson et al.
. B pg v w k
pbb g , ; v pp w
. Agb, g, b v-b -
pp w- pp, ,
p ( g g v)g
pv w g pv NCS
pg kp g g pp.
acnoledment
Fg p w pv b g
N S F, w pp Rb
W J F g b H w R.
eferences
Appb, . 1994. A Rv: M H w
Cg. Nw Yk: Ox v .Appb, S., J W. Sw. 2010. w :
Hw b ? Sv 61: 652654.B, R J., J S. R, p H, Ezb . Mv.
2009. M H S T A T Vg T Tg.H A 28: 793804.
C D C v. 2013. j v & C: D& S Wb-b j S Q Rpg S (WSQA-RSTM). F j D N j D. p://www..gv/j/wq/x.
Ck, p J., J wg. 1997. A: N Sv -v Owp F. N J, R B, Wg, DC: Dp J. p://www.j.gv/p/165476.p
Fz, S, M . 2006. T p p Sv M V C. T A J 163: 13971403.
FB. 2013. p://www..gv/b-/j/F, W, T . 2010. C: Cv C S
40 Y Cv. T J A A w 38(3): 365368.
z, C W., Ew . Mv, W . 1993. T A V O. T J A M A269: 10071011.
http://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/nicshttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/165476.pdfhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.htmlhttp://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/index.html -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
80/311
Preventing Gun Violence Involving People with Serious Mental Illness 51
M Ag g . 2011. F p: Hw Mg R FBkg Ck S H K. p://www.ggg.g/w/p/g__vb.p
M, J, H J. S. 2012. Exg V R -p J-vv w M . Appg S S R V Og, b J A. Dvk, J . Sk, R- W. Nv, Kv S. Dg, 245261. Nw Yk: Ox v.
M, J, H J. S, E Sv, . 2001. Rkg Rk A-: T MA S M D V. Nw Yk: Oxv .
N, Ov, Dq Bg, T j, . 2009. H Sg- b p w . Szp B 35: 10121021.
Nk, M A., V M. Db. 2008. E. J A A w 36: 269.
N C S C H S Bv Rk F Sv- S. 2001. p://www....//b/2001//3.
k, g. 2010. App F Sz w A Dg: O F Tw Y. Sv 61: 478482.
, B A., J M, B . k, . 1999. T bVw Cp, Dg, N g C w M H b. A J b H 89: 13391345.
, M., D. M. N. 2008. N C Bkg Ck
pv A: p w M . J A A w 36: 123130.
R, Cp. 2007. C S F V. OR RRp, 2007-R-0442, C O F A Db. p://w.g/vw/1/CZ/2007/08/02/0000070154/vw/1.26782.75
Sp, Jp R. 2007. B Rk? A Ovvw w bg F b v w H T M . J A A w 35: 330338.
Sk, J, J M. 2011. C D V RkA. C D g S 20: 3842.
Sw, J W. 1994. M D, Sb Ab, CV: A Epg App. V M D, b J. M H. S, 101136. Cg: v Cg .
Sw, J W. 2010. Expg R A V: T pR Ev. Sv 62: 13691371.
Sw, J W. 2011. vg p: Mgg V Rk M H C. Sv 59: 191193.
V D, R A., J Vvk, N J. 2012. M D V: T Rp b Sb ? S
Epg 47(3): 487503.
http://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://worldcat.org/arcviewer/1/CZL/2007/08/02/0000070154/viewer/file1.html26782.75http://www.schs.state.nc.us/schs/brfss/2001/us/firearm3.htmlhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdfhttp://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/maig_mimeo_revb.pdf -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
81/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
82/311
2010, 1,082 w 267 w k b p-
. F- p v w k w g ( S
Dp J 2012). F p w-v , -
p (H) v b w g w
wp b (Fx Zwz 2009). F, w
k b k b p b
gp (Fx Zwz 2009; M, R, B 1998). T v
: w w k, k b -
p w g.
, w p b g, v-
pp p, v pv
p xp. W bg w vvw v
b g g v w b b kw
4
Ev Op B A
Ap M. Z S F
Ap M. Z, D, MH, p S C J Mg
S v. S F, D, MH, p J Hpk
Bbg S b H.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
83/311
54 April M. Zeoli and Shannon Frattaroli
j . S, w xg g v g
b. W p pg v b p
b g p H, w p-
w. W w g p
pv H.
D V : A B Ovvw
wp H pp. D v vv-
g g k v
vv k, wp, b (Sz . 1992). , k w v g (B
. 1997; K . 1993), w g v
k (Cpb . 2003). p k g
k v - p w k w
(Abk . 1996; M . 1998). Mv, gwg v
g g v pp b
g w (M . 2006; R . 2005; S
Wb 2004; Tj T 2000). T g w v: b wp b -
w k (Cpb . 2003).
T -- v p
w k b p (B . 1997;
Cpb . 2003; MF . 1999; S, M, B 1998),
kg v g p g k
H (Cpb . 2007). Skg b p k
H (Cpb . 2003), w pg 76
v 85 p v w k b b
p (MF . 1999). O b kw
. Rg w k b p -
w j p v kg w
pg . T w p v/kg
p, , g, b-
v g (DVRO) g b(MF . 1999; M, R, B 1998).
W w k j , pp-
v pv v .
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
84/311
Policies to Limit Batterers Access to Guns 55
qpp w pv v w, w -
b b p g v v v. w
b g p -
pv pp v.
C F w: Rpg Rk
Tw pv w g b b-
g. 1994, Cg C A pb
v w qg DVRO pg pg
g (18 .S.C. 922(g)(8)). T q, DVRO b g b w p w w p-
p pp. T p DVRO perma-
nent. Egb DVRO p p
p, p w,
b (18 .S.C. 921()(32)).
1996, Cg C A pb -
v v pg pg
g (18 .S.C. 922(g)(9)). T xp b , , p p
, wp w b
p (18 .S.C. 921()(33)). T
p w xpv DVRO g
pb p g w -
p, p g (18 .S.C. 921()(33)). p,
w pp w qg -
p- w.
S-v D V g
M v w g DVRO p g. S w
v w , xp, xp
qg DVRO p DVRO. C -
g p DVRO b p v b - p q p b. T
b p .S. j , b
p g DVRO p . Rp
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
85/311
56 April M. Zeoli and Shannon Frattaroli
DVRO v g j vv (K 1996;
M . 2010; V S 2006) v
v v (H . 2003; g, S, Wk 2005;
S S 2005). F, w w k DVRO
x p b (g . 2008),
g k (Cpb . 2007; W D 1993). T-
p DVRO w v g p DVRO pv w-
qg w g.
S v g. T
w b xpv g. O w
w b DVRO v g vg b xpg g p v
b w, xp b g g p. C-
g p w pb 35 p H b-
w 1976 2005, b H b
g p b g (Fx Zwz 2009). A,
DVRO pp w g
g p pp g gp
w k g pp g - p b (V S 2006).
T g v DVRO v -
g w, g w p g pb p-
pb. N pv vg
g, v p g pb. B
v w b -
b g , w .
Ev
F gv g k w b-
xg g pg v -
g j DVRO p
. T pp w v:
p b p b p b g k w H. w -
pp gg g. b p
p g b qg bv, w
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
86/311
v v g g g p-
b p g bkg k (F B
vg 2011).
Evaluating Impacts
T v x w w g g
DVRO p v H (Vg-
M 2003, 2006; Z Wb 2010). Vg M x-
DVRO v g
-v H 1982 1998 (2003), g 1982
2002 (2006). b , DVRO w w g w H k, b H w g H.
F vg v p
pp bkg k w-b g p (Vg
M 2003, 2006). T g gg p g
pg w p pp: p-
b g pg g b v bkg k
, pv, qg .
T w b w pbgg p p w pbg p (Vg
M 2006). pbg p, g H -
10 12; w b p p-
w. b v pb b
p p v
g w g w pb p
(Vg M 2006).
A v g w H 46 .S. -
1979 2003 pv v DVRO w -
p (Z Wb 2010). T 46 w 27 , 15 w v
DVRO g pb 9 w v v -
g pb. C w DVRO g 19
w H 25 w H w g p
w w (Z Wb 2010).
Tk g, pv pg v DVROg H. p, w
H w g, ggg
b b . W-b k p
Policies to Limit Batterers Access to Guns 57
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
87/311
58 April M. Zeoli and Shannon Frattaroli
g w wp b kg. O, p
w, v gg DVRO g pb v v.
k b w DVRO w,
b p H w g v-
g. T b b .
M v v b w -
(Vg M 2006).
, w b g
w g bkg k pb ,
v p v
g (Vg M 2006). F, k p w p v.
Implementation and Enorcement
W v g w k w
g v p -
w. DVRO p v b ,
w p g w DVRO w pbg p
b p pb p pv g gg p pb. W w x-
g w v pb p
. Hwv, w p p vv
b b w q b pbg b
bkg k p vg
g w q v b p.
O v N C DVRO g w b
p g v g p p-w b
g DVRO qg p
g w g w v p (M .
2006). T w w b
p w w .
T p k q N C. ,
v p v g p (A-
Tk F C J Rp DV 2005; F T 2006; w 2006; Wb . 2010).
B p g p pb p-
p b pb z (F T
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
88/311
2006; W . 2012). kw w p p-
g , , w . S b b
g g b (w x), DVRO p, p-
. O v v p C DVRO
w w pv q b -
p g, p (W . 2012).
Fg b g b p g
DVRO pp g p (F T 2006;
Wb . 2010; W . 2012), v p g
-- b p g (g g
g; pv ) b v DVRO p pb (W . 2012). Kw-
g w p v w w b
pp g w p ,
k g v (W . 2012).
Ev w b p g,
w DVRO w g
(F T 2006; S S 2005; Wb . 2010). S,
v vg DVRO g w.Fwg x DVRO b, C D-
p J v g
w z g pb DVRO b (Sv
2006). A vw wg xg v
pg w g pb (Sv 2006).
Sv DVRO j b zg DVRO g
pb. F v b w ,
v v g -
p w DVRO. T v w --
b pv b p v
g b , p k
w g xg (W . 2012).
v g bv , w pz -
w DVRO g k
p pb p pb. W p w px vv pp
g, b b, C v
(W . 2012). A, p gg
Policies to Limit Batterers Access to Guns 59
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
89/311
60 April M. Zeoli and Shannon Frattaroli
b ggg vv g -
DVRO w bg pv pb (K 2006).
Bw gg v v
vpg p, g gz
g k w
v v g.
p
T w g w v -
. Fwg v- bg xv.
Goal: Prevent DVRO respondents and DV misdemeanants rom purchasing or
possessing guns.
Policy: Require all gun purchasers to submit to a background check.
R: w, bkg k q
pv , pvg pb b w
g. Rqg bkg k g w p- g pb b.
Policy: Incentivize states to automate DVRO and domestic violence misdemeanor
records or reporting to background check systems.
R: Bkg k b p
g qg -
vb g .
Policy: Incentivize states to create gun registries or gun purchase databases.
R: A w w qk w
DVRO p p v v
w g w xg pb g p-
g gp pp kw b v.
Goal: Expand ederal law to prohibit other categories o violent intimates rom
purchasing and possessing guns.
Policy: Extend the DVRO prohibition to include those covered by temporary
DVROs.
R: T p g DVRO, g w
p DVRO p, g p. F w
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
90/311
gz g b xg pb -
p DVRO.
Policy: Expand the denition o intimate partners.
R: C g p b -
w v v p v q p.
Policy: Extend ederal gun prohibitions to cover those convicted o misdemeanor
stalking.
R: Skg p k p -
. Hwv, b kg w
p p , wp,
v g pb pp.Policy: Extend ederal gun prohibitions to cover persons who have violated a DVRO
(permanent and temporary) because o threatened or actual violence.
R: T w v - DVRO b v
b p g b bj b g p-
p w v bj.
Goal: Provide the resources and support needed or state and local systems to
implement and enorce domestic violence gun prohibitions.Policy: Establish and und a center that will provide the training and technical
assistance needed to realize ull implementation o laws that prohibit DVRO
respondents and misdemeanants rom possessing guns.
R: F w , w p
pg C A b S,
w-p w vpg
w z b pb
.
eferences
Abk, J., . O, M. Hw, J. B, C. A , D. Sk. 1996. S ? D v g w Nw Mx.
Ann Emerg Med27: 21015.A Tk F C J Rp D V-
. 2005. Kpg p: V b b.S, CA: C Dp J.
B, J., A. K, . S, J. B, F. Rv, N. R. 1997. Rk v w .Arch Intern Med157: 77782.
Policies to Limit Batterers Access to Guns 61
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
91/311
62 April M. Zeoli and Shannon Frattaroli
Cpb, J.C., N. , .W. Sp, K. g, T. B. 2007. p : Rvw p p. Trauma, Vio-lence & Abuse 8: 24660.
Cpb, J.C., D.W. Wb, J. Kz-M, C. Bk, D. Cpb, M.A. C,F. , N. , J. M, C. S, . Sp, Y. , S.A. W, J. M-g, X. X, J. Sbg, V. F, K. g. 2003. Rk bv p: R .
American Journal o Public Health 93: 106997.F B vg. 2011. N C Bkg Ck
S (NCS) p. Wg, D.C.: .S. Dp J.F, R.E., C. Sv, D. Bb. 2000. W g p
v: W xp v b p. ViolenceAgainst Women 6: 136383.
Fx, J.A., M.W. Zwz. 2009. H S: B J S. p://bj.jp.j.gv///..
F, S., S.. T. 2006. g g p p-: A v pv M VA. Evaluation Review 30: 34760.
w, C. 2006. D v : R p. Evalu-ation Review 30: 23744.
H, V.., M.A. K, M.E. W, F. Rv. 2003. D p k p v j?American Journal o Preven-tive Medicine 24: 1621.
K, A., F. Rv, N. R, J. B, D. R, J. F, A. ,J. zk, B. Hk, . S. 1993. wp k . New England Journal o Medicine 329: 108491.
K, A.R. 1996. R-b pp - b: Wg wk. Do arrests and restraining orders work?, 192213.T Ok, CA: Sg.
. 2006. Eg v pb: A p p-g p. Wg, D.C.: O V Ag W. p://www.bwjp.g//bwjp//Eg_F_b.p.
Kz, D. 1996. Sp, v, w b. Violence Against Women 2:6381.
g, T.K., . S, R. Wk. 2005. v b: A p ppv . Violence Against Women 11: 876911.
g, T.K., R. Wk, . S, J. C. 2008. F w p- gg v g w w v pv .Journal oFamily Violence 23: 37785.
MF, J., J.C. Cpb, S.A. W, C. S, Y. , X. X. 1999. Skg p . Homicide Studies 3: 30016.
M, K.E., K. A, R.M. B, C. Ep, J.M. Bwg,
C. D. 2010. W v p ? Violence Against Women 16: 120123.M, K.E., K.A. Ck, C. Ep, J.M. Bwg. 2006. vg
v g v p v: A v wN C w: .S. Dp J.
http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfmhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://www.bwjp.org/files/bwjp/articles/Enforcing_Firearms_Prohibitions.pdfhttp://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/homicide/homtrnd.cfm -
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
92/311
M, K.E., C.W. R, J.D. B. 1998. F N C, 19911993: A w p p. Homicide Studies 2: 42246.
R, E.F., D. Hw, M. M, D. Az. 2005. B g
p.Journal o the American Medical Womens Associa-tion 60: 6268.Sz, .E., J.A. M, . O, M. Rbg, . R. 1992. Wp
vv j .Journal o theAmerican Medical Association 267: 304347.
Sv, .. 2006. Dg b g g : T p C. Evaluation Review 30: 24565.
S, .H., K.E. M, J.D. B. 1998. x: App-b ppv. Homicide Studies 2: 400421.
S, S.B., H. S. 2005. Rg C: A k -
w . Violence Against Women 11: 91233.S, S.B., D.J. Wb. 2004. Wp v b w.Amer-
ican Journal o Public Health 94: 141217.Tj, ., N. T. 2000. Ex, , q
p v. Wg, DC: .S. Dp J. S Dp J. 2012. pg pg :
Spp p, 2010. p33527-v1. A Ab, M: -v C S R [b].
Vg, E.R., J.A. M. 2003. Dg b: T p v w. Evaluating gun policy, 157214. Wg, DC: T
Bkg .. 2006. D w g b v
pv p ? Evaluation Review 30: 31346.V, K.A., S.B. S. 2006. A p g k
b w pp ? Evaluation Review 30: 26682.Wb, D.W., S. F, J.S. Vk, C. OSv, J. R, J.C. Cpb.
2010. W w pv p v bv p: R xp . Journal o Womens Health19: 9398.
W, M.., M. D. 1993. Sp k g. Violenceand Victims 8: 316.
W, ., S. F, K.A. V, B. C, M. Wg, D.W. Wb.2012. F v v pj: Fp p v. S, CA: V vR g, v C, Dv.
Z, A.M., D.W. Wb. 2010. E v p, x p g v p g .Injury Prevention 16: 9095.
Policies to Limit Batterers Access to Guns 63
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
93/311
This page intentionally le blank
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
94/311
A p bjv g v pv p
kp g g-k v w gg g w-
bg z p . v p-
w g kp g g v v v,
g v b pb pg
. T g p (1) b vw
pb p
pb, (2) k bg
g g v, (3) p
p p b vb v-
. T p pb
5
Rg Aq C C gF Owp
K A. V, D W. Wb,
J S. Vk
K A. V, D, MH, J Hpk C R. D W. Wb, SD, MH, p Dp H
Mg J Hpk Bbg S b H. J S. Vk,
JD, MH, p Dp H
Mg J Hpk Bbg S b H.
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
95/311
66 Katherine A. Vittes, Daniel W. Webster, and Jon S. Vernick
pb v ,
b v w v.
R C C b F
Rgzg g v g k -
g v, w pb p b wg
gp: ; gv; p v -
v; w bj g
v; w b; w v b b jg b p, g -
v , v b v -
; w v b b g
; g ; p w v .S.
zp. , w 21 g w
p w p g
b 18 g g g p
g w g (18 U.S.C.922 (d) (2012)). N p g pp g g (
g) w.
R pv j g p
gp. Cv k bq
v g (Ck, wg,
Bg 2005). S, p w g p
v k kg p (Cpb .
2003) g v g b (E
Bz 2007; Fg, Sw, H 1983; 1975; Hg, S,
1989).
R pp g p g b.
g b g w v
bv (A . 2012; F 1998; K . 1994; k
A 1998; Rv . 1997; W-M . 2005) (Bg,
W, K 2000; Bwk, , Rk 2001; Rv .1997). F xp, v k
b g , g
w v g k (Rv . 1997).
-
7/27/2019 reducing gun Violence.pdf
96/311
Reconsidering the Adequacy o Current Conditions on Legal Firearm Ownership 67
T g v g b g
pp. vv v , pp v,