RE: Grenfell Tower F

14
I oflO Email RE: Grenfell Tower F ••• Em all Ftam To. Cc lk:c 0 GR£NFaL Tf>INER afGENEMTION PROJECT /ltlUS/R'IG HI Ben, I have the drawings sent over and slr.etch • proposaJ to alleviate the issues raised by the BCO, als() on the pace of the- attadunerat tflave hlchli&hted the wea" Hl1\ 50 to speak in terms of &e·and I think the BCO would have also .noticed this. The proposal require$ the lnstaUatlon of RHZSg 90/60 product In two layers one at the head a( the window afi&ninB with the compartment floor tbe ot'her at the tDp ef the existiRI up stand, therefore two layers -of 60 PfObtdlon that Pf'O'!:de If tested ove.r UD minutes ·protectiGn 1 .at the window 1ocatiol!lS. Please nate that without spedfk· detafts of the construc;tlon of internallininp and or sl&tit of the Flte stratqy for the project J can on1y efflwr the abave, •nd as this is a refut'blsftinent I would lmaitne tbatw Internal wiJI re.r_nain trisitu madetood to OJ)enfnp only, which does not ald the .flnt matecv. toc:a:Honsl see any jc.lstif)cation for any1hq other than a GYity 30{15 ratin,_ so 5uitJec;t tD BCO. llfJproval you .may be able to down aracfe In 1 this helps in resolvlnc the dasfsn detail for the compartmentation on thls project, ·!Qnd re•ards Cbr'is Tethnkal Offlter Flre M: ·oni> [: SIL00000077_0001 SIL00000077/1

Transcript of RE: Grenfell Tower F

Page 1: RE: Grenfell Tower F

.I'~ I oflO

~ Email

RE: Grenfell Tower F •••

Em all Ftam

To.

Cc

lk:c

~IS

0 GR£NFaL Tf>INER afGENEMTION PROJECT /ltlUS/R'IG

HI Ben,

I have N~viewed the drawings sent over and slr.etch • proposaJ to alleviate the issues raised by the BCO, als() on the ~d pace of the- attadunerat tflave hlchli&hted the wea" Hl1\ 50 to speak in terms of &e·and I think the BCO would have also .noticed this.

The proposal require$ the lnstaUatlon of RHZSg 90/60 product In two layers one at the head a( the window afi&ninB with the compartment floor an~. tbe ot'her at the tDp ef the existiRI up stand, therefore two layers -of 60 ml~ PfObtdlon that ~rait·~ Pf'O'!:de If tested ove.r UD minutes ·protectiGn1.at the window 1ocatiol!lS.

Please nate that without spedfk·detafts of the ~rail construc;tlon of internallininp and or sl&tit of the Flte stratqy for the project J can on1y efflwr the pro~ abave, •nd as this is a refut'blsftinent I would lmaitne tbatw Internal t~nli~J.S wiJI re.r_nain trisitu ~ madetood to OJ)enfnp only, which does not ald the .flnt matecv.

A-~ ~at,wQII toc:a:Honsl ~nn.ot see any jc.lstif)cation for any1hq other than a GYity ~at 30{15 ratin,_ so 5uitJec;t tD BCO. llfJproval you .may be able to down aracfe In ~ Iota~

1 h~pe this helps in resolvlnc the dasfsn detail for the compartmentation on thls project,

·!Qnd re•ards

Cbr'is ~rt

Tethnkal Offlter Flre

M: ·oni> [:

SIL00000077_0001 SIL00000077/1

Page 2: RE: Grenfell Tower F

OsiDERJse• .5Jderise Group, Porce Industrial Estate, ~ef, .Brldpnd .CB4 DAY

T: ) F: I W:www.sidgrisf!..com

Conr:~ertto us: rJII (:, Please consider the enui.ronment:before ptlntlnc this .-mall

FI"'m: Ben &ally (matlta:Benballe.,.harleycw.oo.uk] sent: 30 Mrarth 2015 15-.16 To: Rlcky Kay Cc: Chrts c. Mort Subject Re: Grenfel Tower Fi,. Stopplna

Rlcky • ~~two d.-.wtnga att.ehed tep~ Sec:tlon A,.A twJndow head) U1d "(window

Gfll whictl can be combined tD crwfll C.C, • we clon't have a drawn deall to cowr what Chlia 18 requesting.

Rea ...,.r I Nptttar.K_I _ecp

. Si.55 7., 4:ZI lbenbaikty~h;adei(CW;to.•~K

K•rletr curt.m Well Ltd I ~c~ 1670 •4756% J o_ v8 .. /t70 "-'7563 F _At'ffF n(le• Grnri Ll bq N,JI•Apru . 11J1111e1'" C _qrQsqqe<rfl.-4 OiS

hat!eycyr1tinytul!.s;go

~llflcll_j Ut' a;J •lf''Yff' ..JIIIw.A~_j U..Jj ·J.rti,-AI,. clq:f! -91 t lfii'CII ....... ., .• UIJ.•_w· cjceJJwnallic'Kil-•81

~ ml bcb~l4a ~~· ?ar;qqlllllfJ!ctl! .-1 ' w_JWI!" ~.1111_,, IIJ!I!tCb•lhr!w..S lnrlf Cl ft:l~ ~~ r _,.; llfi.I~Jr.eiTMfi•.'OIIIRI•Vtl •-'"'-'!IJII.Ud f111a!l!rlbnn'u_r.(l • qUrcnl a"t11JP!f11F*'-ltlk_w cliiLudrj,'li 'M

tJuqnt~~qcflc lf~t c;qq__K" ....,p: tf·nqe .-r-G 1t bfP..Jq qcl·bep>:enel'lr uf cp:-t'lc qr:a~..:Jiwlf'fl'l llfc:k rm c.rh t pq

lfiiiiF ...JtcWAaJrJi :U::.i-!tfl-. Uftq..F JfCWMp;.j U_J_J141 r_lq~~qpl --le .-a_ttllf'ltllmq~-1 c;lr._j.d.ll!l rrtrptpFIII:._l I m'

•II·:O 11 ... 1RJ '!PI''Ifll--llflloP...l c•-· •r.-lfc ~~,.;iltiW_t• aiJI .ftot .. lldtl.lllc:k...t ••)1;11!1• _t-._w_at11 d I!Qf:CJ):ll_p ,41t~~lf.c .-:1111nt 'llflllr«*i '

rf.;i~lfflioqa_l tr~::cio _._, b _I w_rr_.i'h c l rq r~tf qcl rd'rlta ~~MII«iit.

·-- --. ·--- --------From: Rlcky Kay <ricky.kay§.siderise:COnt> Date: .Motu~JY~ ao~ '2015 15:~2 'To: 'Silnon :La~' <Siawrem:[email protected]>, "Chris c. ·Mort" <cbr1s :mort@sider!~.com:>, left

fJilRev<benWik;Yp)Jdtw)f;{O·~ . su~·RE: -reftftil T.,wer Flr.i.$t0pl;ina

SIL00000077_0002 SIL00000077/2

Page 3: RE: Grenfell Tower F

"" HI Ben,

To ena"ble us to assess. please see attached rnarlt up of sec;dan drawlnp th~ are required by my Technlcal Officer.

,, Please forward at your earliest 'COnVenience. Many thanks

' Kind Ngar.d$

Rlckv Kay

National F~ades M•naver

M: E:

OstDERlsE·

Slderisa Group, Forge lnctustrlal Estate, Maest.g. &rictgMd CF34 OAY

T: 1 .. : I W: www,!ilderflle.ccm

CoJU~eCt to us: r=JII mJ • e PM-- CCII'8irlM- tmiiNlllfN"' ~ Pf'IIIUIIV II'IIS CN~~JII

From: Simon L.llwrence lmaUto:slawrenCdi)rydoQ,co.ykl Sent JO Mardl Z01514:51 Tu: ~se.~ Rlckyl(ay: [email protected] Cc: S..e Sheppard . Su~ RE: Grenfell TO'Wer Fire St.Dppll"'l

. Thanks Chrls. rm happy for us as a .project team to work throuch this and q~on the ·BC ' Officer If there ls a valid point. But the emotions behl~ emaJI can easily be mkread. If you upm him now o~ a £i.Ok Issue the I" lt could affect me later when trying to ret sign off for the whole buildins a~ that'tSa £1.5m Jssue for me.

Regards

S:lmon Lawrence;, AClOB, MlnatLM (:ontrir"ts M•rwt~•r

---- ---- -· ----From: Cbrls C. MCHt (11101\tO:cllrlS :~~ Sent:. 30 Mllrdi .2o151A:46. ·. To: Slm• La~; Ric:ty ~ 1J.mba"W8~.9:J.Uk

SIL00000077_0003 SIL00000077/3

Page 4: RE: Grenfell Tower F

-- -··--· ·---- - -- - - ----·-· - ··· ·-- ·

Email: RE: On:nfeU 'rawer File Stopping

SUbJect:.RE: t;..-,.11 Tower Fire .SlDppiRJ ICcSUe~rcl

I SlmQII,

Please be assur•d that my teSponse will only be nht to Ben of Harley CW as t~ Jre our diem, ~ .and tllat H wtll .be for them to use our response as requl~ without ber,atJnt others.

I Kind reptds

ctwfs Mort

Te_dinlc:al Off'1Cer Fire

~ M: r.:- DDt:

E:

11 IJll&O& rel!lOII'ed by sen.dof. nnp: t/WvoW .sldeMO'.anJam9ilf. a&IS1dcadsk f'RQ

Slderise Group, Force tnchtstrial Estate, Maestes, Brldpnd CF34 OAY

T: l f: I W: www.sideiisg.com

Connect tc us: C!J[!J[!J~

~ ~ ., .... <nM!d<rtho .,......,.,.., befor•••lnd"" tt>lse-mall

! From: Simon Lawrent:e [mailtg:[email protected] ~ sent: JO Man:h 201s 14=41

I To: Rlcty tc.y; benbailcx@harlm:w.co.yk; R.ily BaDey Cc: .KevinLamb@tMrleycw. .CQ.uk: [email protected]; markebadeycw.w.uk; Slmon D1Connor; SUe Slleppatd; Ch,ls (. Mort 'Ma,rtln Sexton'

15ub)*ct: -RE: Gre ... l TOwer An Stoppfnl

• R.kky /Ben. }

1 appre~ that there is a discus $ion and dfffe.rent po;nts of view r'l;lrdlnJ ~ .::ladl:llng. fjrestopplng/cavitv .barrier tat1 wi!ICh we can make. However we need to do this ccmsttuctlvefy and fd rather not question the BC Qfflcer fJohn Hoban) In front ofeveryoae on emalf. ~n you

. . ple~Sf $0rt this out Jn ,..rvate a-nd r~pond tQ rnySe!f and Nelllf you have; a vaiJd argument'?

Thilnks

Simon Lawrenee, A-ClOB, JUnstLM CoRttaC& tt.rt•ger

T

SIL00000077_0004 SIL00000077/4

Page 5: RE: Grenfell Tower F

Page$ afW

\1 From: Rlcky Kay (mailtg;(!dQI.kayfil!jjdcldse.Wr.nJ Sent: 30 Nardl 2015 14:32. To: ·~bn,Hob!lnftrb!sc:gav.ut-; bel]ballgt@hilf'k¥w.cD.uk Cc: Ke-rlnlarOO@ItJadeVCw&Q.uk; [email protected]}v m;Jit®barteycw.m.uk; Simon O'~nor; Sbnon La~; [email protected]; $le She,.....S; Chrll c. Mort,; 'Martin !iDton' SubjeCt: RE: Gnnfell Tower fire Stapping

~ AI~

~ Please can N~ forward over a drawtnc of ~he bufkl-up of the ~adclincso that my f Technical Officer can evaluate and forward an oflldat response with ii'SII)ERIS£ produet spedtlc:atlon.

Many U.anks.

Klnd~rda

RiGkY Kay

M: E:

li trN~g~; remcr..ed by !!ieflder

Slcleriae Group, Forge Industrial Estat~, ~ealeg, 8ridgend CF34 OAV

T: I W: www !ljderie-mu

Connect to us:~ ~~e:J

From:Jolln.Hobanf>rokc.gav.u}s lmStilto:.John.Hobagerbkc.gov.ukl i Sent SO Mardt Z01514:U. If: To: Sue S~pparcl; lUcky Kay; [email protected]; Kevlnlarob!!bachmw.co.uk; ~ .~ell(d)s.t!J$tloe.'P.uk: [email protected]: [email protected] [email protected]: R [email protected] ~ SubJect: fW: GNnfelt Tower Fire StopPinc

I Dear All,

. ; The e.-Uding ~egulations 201 D (as amended) • Gremell Towet", Grenfell Ra.d., Refurbishment

~ Please find detailed below • copy of an emau ••nt to .vart~ P,e~n& on :the ~tll of !i ~h 2Q1.$. ~c;~mlng th.e. topic telatlng fire •topplnt of~- compartmarit floors to

I' the bulldl~. 1 would·a.dviw you that rt Is m)' ifttetptQta.on of dl.,.m·3y3 of A~ P.oc~RlfmtB 111 _.. t"- d•n ~en &»"'partment flodr.s lllid utatnal cladding il nc;>t a cavi~ blrrlerf therefore ·it r1'itls\ be fire etopped to at taut the

;

b •11< r:mtSideri~ fonrl!i' rimt •:.:.-.:: ... ·-?~·~"' ........ --£.=-~~6&o.. JMI'lllln~n7 ~- c . ····- ·· · . . p . .... ~~~ .. 1<":'~~·.· · · · """lli~-~~""· .,.... . "· ~~-·--

SIL00000077_0005 SIL00000077/5

Page 6: RE: Grenfell Tower F

fimait: 1U~: Orenftoll Tower File Stopp_ing

st,ndard of tbe exbltlng compartment flow ~ 2.0 minUtes ]. Therefore the methods d~ribed ln -clause 9.13 would not be appropriate In thle particula, case

. ln t"- meantime shouJd you wish to dlscusa any oitler aspecta·of the n please do not hesltete to can me, my direct line· contact number Is

.. • • '-1

Best regards .•

John Hoban . John Hobaa

Control Surveyor

. This e•mall may contain Information which Is confidential, legally privileged and/or copyright. This e-maills intended for the addressee· only. If you receive this In error, please contact the sender·and delete the material from your computer.

From: HOba~, John: PC·Pian · $lint: 2.0 Mlln;:h ·:Z015 13:22 To: 'Nett crawrorcr; Han.on, Paul: PC-Plan Cc: [email protected]: Kevin Lamb (KeviOU)[email protected],oo.tJk); Slmon O'Connor (SQColl!)Q[@fydon.tQ.I!Is}; luon North (ilortbooo:Jon.m,uk) Subject: RE: Gtenfell

. oelir Neif,

The BuDding Regulations 2010 (ils amended) Grenfell Tower, Grenfell Road. Refurbishment.

· Thiink you for ret:umJng In¥ call this morning.

Further to :my ·C:onv•rsation with -you today. 1 would confirm that the tire time for the new.ElementB of Strvcture( new co1umn&, ,bu.m' ~on& of comp(lrt:ment fl~f!)i' etc.) in Grenfttft TOW.r ls 120 minuteS, ·a• .Peclfled in eection 1a ofTab1e A2. · Apf,endix A of ApPioved DocUm.tnt B.

1 V~~Quld •J•o draw yotn au.nilon. to dlagram.33 of Approved Document Band highlight the ctetan between compat1mtnt ftoorJ ~nd ~teni~l.~; .. ~dtpg. fn ~e m~irtt~ ·~~ y~ ~hto dls.Gu8• ariY Otft'r asPeCt. of the pr~ please do not heattate to-eaU me~ my dlrect ·Hne contact number Is-

SIL00000077_0006 SIL00000077/6

Page 7: RE: Grenfell Tower F

· JohnHoban John Hoban Seaior Jluildfag Co•lrQI Su~eyot

~7ofJO

. !1!!!!!!.-ifOy.uk

~ This e-mall may contain lnform~tlon which Is confldeptlal, legt~Uy prlvReged and/or copyright. This e .. msills Intended for tire addressee only. If you receive this In error, please contact the sender and delete the material from your computer.

I ! F,.;~~N.i, erawfoni [matlto:~dl~d;;.~.;] --1 sent: 10 Mard1 2015 U:49 ~ To: Hoban, John: PC~Pian ~ SubjOc!: RE: Cirenfall Tower Fire 8arrlerw ~ .

I HlJohn

~

Ben Bailey from Harle'(sls who you might ask for. Hi5 phone number Is -

· ~prds Neil

.. FnMn: Nail Crawford Sent: 27. March l015 10:SS To: lobn.hoban@rbla;.qqt.uk

--- ·----

SUbjKt: ~Tower Rre BiW1'1er8

HI John

I Thent has been a lot of c:onwrsatton on site about the uvity r .. barriert"eqlllrem&nts to be p fitted be~~ the ex!St1nt co~teextemal ~~~ ~nets~nd the new e:xtern.al rain se~ 1 aalimlri~m c:assettes. g can you please see the proposal by the clad din& amtractor below and ~ftrm ihhis 1$

:t .aa:eptable~you • ..

I Ae&ards N~l

~ d_ll IT!'•fUJ·..;,JILI ~qftJ)"-..fl.l.i.Cq;., nr. rfj;.q_Q:m_l b.Ul'lld Rll'llllft!ll.cttJ• •Wif·e_1 w_rr_atil ~ rql~l!gt, •Mot·c t ~11 ~--IJ611-c p:...,.t:l rrm~ rf ccl<J:-' b.J w,_w_:ifli ill iq1·~u"' (lcj t41pk ~q:.ni · I'Cir,

SIL00000077_0007 SIL00000077/7

Page 8: RE: Grenfell Tower F

.. .. -- - --- ---- ---

EmaU: RE: Gtwnell Tower Fire -Stopping hge:KoftO

I I

i FrOm: Rkky ICilY <rtcWJcavi!sld'erl$e&Om>

I. Date: lhursday, ·Z6 Mwdl 2015 13:4-Z

To: Ben Bailey <beribaflty@har1~vcw.r:o.uk> ~= K~n Lamb <[email protected]>, Martc Stapley >,Sue Sheppard <[email protected]>

~ Spbi~ R£: Grenfttll Tower -FW .hrrlers

~ HI Ben.

ApokJ&jes for the delrf-

Please find betow extrad: from the Approved Document B of. thtt BuUdlng Aqulatlons.

! ~

~ ~ """''""con ... thaUt d .. rly ...,..th., 311 minutes_l_ and 15 .,......, imulation ~ is all dlat Is required from a avlty fwe barrier. This is reference to ralnsereen daddlng fl.j applications wile re tt.e cavity barrier ls deemed 'to be on the outsJde. of the buildinc. Our ' RHlS-90/30 wnl offer 90 minutes flre lnteJritv alld 30 mlnutes flte insulation. therefore

I exceeds mfntlllUrn requirements.

120 mi11Ute fire ratJnc IJ cenerally the ·lndustry mndarcl for ~rtat,n wnlt to concrete dab edge ! firestopplng where the firestop ls Joc:Med on the inside of • buldina al'!d is considered to be io

~ eontinllation of the floor slab.

I . ll f'lei!ISe &et in touch If you need -anythin& elaa from us to enable you to pracreu wittt your

order, rrtany thanks

National F~des Manager

M; E: iioky.Uy@!ldl!trise .gom

~ ~ li lrna_t!~ remoyet~ l>V

I ~~~7.::lMM.._-..-.... C13~0AY

SIL00000077_0008 SIL00000077/8

Page 9: RE: Grenfell Tower F

JF:

Connectto ua: ~~~~

I

This etaail ha been acannod by the SY.m.- em.ll s.~frir.cloud Hl"tice'~

~ For n\.,.lnformiltiGn *''"" visit tJtpjllyte.Qmiilntjlccfgud.cem

~~ This eDJai1 has beell sc.nned by l;be symaotee EmiPI ~rtty.cloud sen1ce. t, For moR infol'lllation please vtsit bttp:llwww.e·m.anteccloud.com

~---------------------------------------------! ~ Right Royal Ride Saturday 25 Apr.il

~ EajQ)' • leisurely eyde throup the Royai Borougll and raiR money for Jocal e-arities.

Rave fon at the post eycle cdebratio .. In Holltad Park- it's tbe perfect family ennt.

Re¥ister at hnp;! lwww .bjkemindcd.o!JVwhats:onl

Are you registered to vote? The deadline to regbter to ·vote for the IJ'K .Parliamentary elettiod is MondaylO Apn12015.

V ou nn register ·t~ \'Gte at bttp:l/w\\'W..goy. uklregistc.rtovote

••• jloojl ***·*****•······~·············•**·*···· ... ·• •••"l'••••······"· Tbe ·Royal Boroudt or Kensington and Chetse... ~ e·snail may eontain i.afonnation ~·hlc:b Is oontidential, legaDy prlvne2~ and/or ~opyrigh,t' prot«ted. 1'hi; e--maU

· a. inteaded for the J~,ddnl!• oilly. If yGII rOc:eive this t. crn.r. please ·orurtact the aeD.Mr aad· ddete the material from your CQ_•pu.ter.

llt This·e!Dail. ·~ ~-e:~n.s~•ned b~ !"eSymatttec E:iriail ~rity.el~ild service.

Fo,r m or~ ~:fQrmatiol.l please VISit ·bttp;I/W»'W.symanteccloud,oom

, ......,This,....,. .. -..,..-.eJOi-. -, . . --.• . -.. as-.. -heeD-_ . . - . --sc-.. -li-nn_ed __ -b-~--tb-t-. 8-y-m--u---Ce-f.!~Em-: -.• -ii-S-eean~· . --:-.1!-:-•~elo~: _u_d_.erv __ -.- -l~-e-. --

2!

SIL00000077_0009 SIL00000077/9

Page 10: RE: Grenfell Tower F

~n; RR: .Gr.cnfel1 1~ YU'C Stopping ~e· JOoftO

5 This ~.Dtail has been sCiiDDed bY the·.SymaJitee Email Scearit,.e1oud &a'Vke.

~ For more infunnation pleue "btt http;.l(www.11vi!Wlteccloud.com

~ ---------------------------------------------------------

i This em~il has been seaii.ned b)• tltc Sym•lited:i:thail seatrity.eloud senice. For more infomaation pleuc v~t b\tP:l/www.svmantcccloud.Com

~ . ~ .

*---------------------------------------------------------Atbldltn•nts j ~-~a--i-1 Atta---c-hm __ en_ts ___ A_cti ___ vi-t)'-·A-. tta __ chm ____ en_t_A __ ~-SOCt--~·a_t_e_d _Vi_ew ____ -----------

! v' Ek: Nbme 1' 81e Sge IB!(tC$1 'f' C

[email protected]

lrngm.;ng

jmgQQ8Jj5

Jmagt009.1Qg

U62

459

417 ' !

~ 4 Pa~l • I -------------·-··- -. -~

Due

SIL00000077_0010 SIL00000077/10

Page 11: RE: Grenfell Tower F

PERFORMANCE OF MA~fltAL$, ffirQOUCTS AND .STRUCTURES B

SIL00000077_0011

SIL

00000077/11

Page 12: RE: Grenfell Tower F

1------- ------<ttlllAFIWIE-----------1 1--------------~mME-------------~

~-----~-----~--nua--+-

/~--lf.---'11fUCM---.--------OAS------I---11157'j:ftS---II~ MOII!BillG!IIIS-------------~

L:...,..-HOT ~ OH400llAINS, E 61111!11 l4(1«llmil~

TYPICAL BAY LEVELS 1 TO 20 SOlJTH ELEVATION 160 OFF - TYPE 1

ElEVATIONS

l I D

~ i ~

J _C

( '' r

•.

'•

--c; I CJ5.9.202 C

SIL00000077_0012

SIL

00000077/12

Page 13: RE: Grenfell Tower F

------- -·---- - - ·------·--- ------

1411 ~:FM"':: :r= . --~---ml.l --T.JI--m.j--r-- ,,110.4CR$---t-5a,-f ,,rr.1--~

TYPICPJ.. BAY LEVELS 1 TO 20 EAST & WEST r:LEVA TION

(

r<rroj rz.o

SIL00000077_0013

SIL

00000077/13

Page 14: RE: Grenfell Tower F

rm~

I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I L----

r 11 11 11

h . .. AJ

...

. .

•• • • l .. . .. :. . , f' . . . / . . ·

... ~. -·· .. .. . ..._____--__:::::::~~~

SECTIONS

. , I

·----­-------

.,

GRENFB.l TOWER

<D WINDOW HEAD UPPER I...EVE.S

I•

Af'f~OVED FOR CONSTRUCTION

GRENFELl RD. LONDON. Wll lTQ ·~~All& ................ 00..... c•ow~ ....,,.,._ -­CI~-!0 1 -1:20A3 ,. . ...,., , .. -'

SIL00000077_0014

SIL

00000077/14