Radial Flow Turbocompressors

28
Cambridge University Press 978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow Turbocompressors Michael Casey , Chris Robinson Frontmatter More Information www.cambridge.org © in this web service Cambridge University Press Radial Flow Turbocompressors An introduction to the theory and engineering practice that underpins the component design and analysis of radial ow turbocompressors. Drawing upon an extensive theoretical background and years of practical experience, the authors provide the following: Descriptions of applications, concepts, component design, analysis tools, performance maps, ow stability and structural integrity, with numerous illustrative examples Wide coverage of all types of radial compressor over a range of applications unied by the consistent use of dimensional analysis The methods needed to analyse the performance, ow and mechanical integrity that underpin the design of efcient centrifugal compressors with good ow range and stability Explanation of the design of all radial compressor components, including inlet guide vanes, impellers, diffusers, volutes, return channels, deswirl vanes and side- streams This volume is suitable as a reference for advanced students of turbomachinery, and a perfect tool for practising mechanical and aerospace engineers already within the eld as well as those just entering it. Michael Casey is a director of PCA Engineers Limited, and was previously a Professor of Thermal Turbomachinery at the University of Stuttgart. Chris Robinson is managing director at PCA Engineers Limited and a specialist in the aeromechanical design of centrifugal compressors.

Transcript of Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Page 1: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Radial Flow Turbocompressors

An introduction to the theory and engineering practice that underpins the componentdesign and analysis of radial flow turbocompressors. Drawing upon an extensivetheoretical background and years of practical experience, the authors provide thefollowing:

� Descriptions of applications, concepts, component design, analysis tools,performance maps, flow stability and structural integrity, with numerous illustrativeexamples

� Wide coverage of all types of radial compressor over a range of applications unifiedby the consistent use of dimensional analysis

� The methods needed to analyse the performance, flow and mechanical integrity thatunderpin the design of efficient centrifugal compressors with good flow range andstability

� Explanation of the design of all radial compressor components, including inletguide vanes, impellers, diffusers, volutes, return channels, deswirl vanes and side-streams

This volume is suitable as a reference for advanced students of turbomachinery, and aperfect tool for practising mechanical and aerospace engineers already within the fieldas well as those just entering it.

Michael Casey is a director of PCA Engineers Limited, and was previously a Professorof Thermal Turbomachinery at the University of Stuttgart.

Chris Robinson is managing director at PCA Engineers Limited and a specialist in theaeromechanical design of centrifugal compressors.

Page 2: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Page 3: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Design, Analysis, and Applications

MICHAEL CASEYPCA Engineers Limited

CHRIS ROBINSONPCA Engineers Limited

Page 4: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

University Printing House, Cambridge CB2 8BS, United Kingdom

One Liberty Plaza, 20th Floor, New York, NY 10006, USA

477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia

314–321, 3rd Floor, Plot 3, Splendor Forum, Jasola District Centre, New Delhi – 110025, India

79 Anson Road, #06–04/06, Singapore 079906

Cambridge University Press is part of the University of Cambridge.

It furthers the University’s mission by disseminating knowledge in the pursuit ofeducation, learning, and research at the highest international levels of excellence.

www.cambridge.orgInformation on this title: www.cambridge.org/9781108416672DOI: 10.1017/9781108241663

© Cambridge University Press 2021

This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exceptionand to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,no reproduction of any part may take place without the writtenpermission of Cambridge University Press.

First published 2021

Printed in the United Kingdom by TJ Books Limited, Padstow Cornwall

A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Names: Casey, Michael, 1948- author. | Robinson, Chris, 1959- author.Title: Radial flow turbocompressors : design, analysis, and applications / Michael Casey, PCA EngineersLimited, Chris Robinson, PCA Engineers Limited.Description: Cambridge, United Kingdom ; New York, NY, USA : Cambridge University Press,2021. | Includes bibliographical references and index.Identifiers: LCCN 2020046835 (print) | LCCN 2020046836 (ebook) | ISBN 9781108416672 (hardback) |ISBN 9781108241663 (epub)Subjects: LCSH: Centrifugal compressors.Classification: LCC TJ990 .C366 2021 (print) | LCC TJ990 (ebook) | DDC 621.5/1–dc23LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020046835LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020046836

ISBN 978-1-108-41667-2 Hardback

Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracyof URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publicationand does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain,accurate or appropriate.

Page 5: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

The first author gratefully dedicates his part in this book to his parents, Jean and Eric

Casey, who made it all possible by their struggles and sacrifices in the hard times of

the 1950s and 1960s and for their endearing love and encouragement over the whole

of their lives.

Page 6: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Page 7: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Contents

Credits page xiiIntroduction xiiiPreface xviiAcknowledgements xixConventions and Nomenclature xxi

1 Introduction to Radial Flow Turbocompressors 11.1 Overview 11.2 Definition of Turbomachinery 21.3 Classification of Turbomachines 91.4 Short History of Thermal Turbomachines 141.5 Components of Radial Flow Turbocompressors 151.6 Applications of Centrifugal Turbocompressors 241.7 Some Other Publications 40

2 Energy Transfer 442.1 Overview 442.2 The Euler Turbine Equation 452.3 The First Law of Thermodynamics 552.4 The Steady Flow Energy Equation 612.5 The Second Law of Thermodynamics 662.6 Energy Transfer in Radial Turbocompressors 692.7 Different Ideal Compression Processes 742.8 The Aerodynamic Work 812.9 The Compressor Stage as the Sum of Its Components 85

3 Equations of State 873.1 Overview 873.2 Equations of State for Perfect Fluids 883.3 Equations of State for Real Gases 923.4 The Aungier–Redlich–Kwong Cubic Equation of State 993.5 Isentropic and Polytropic Processes with Real Gases 1013.6 The Aerodynamic Work with Real Gases 103

vii

Page 8: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

4 Efficiency Definitions for Compressors 1064.1 Overview 1064.2 Compressor Efficiency 1074.3 Isentropic Efficiency 1114.4 Polytropic Efficiency 1184.5 The Impeller Wheel Efficiency 1294.6 External Losses and Sideloads 1304.7 Efficiency in Diabatic Processes 1304.8 Efficiency Definitions for Real Gases 134

5 Fluid Mechanics 1355.1 Overview 1355.2 The Laws of Fluid Mechanics 1365.3 Pressure Gradients in Fluid Flows 1425.4 Coriolis and Centrifugal Forces in Impellers 1485.5 Boundary Layers and End-Wall Flows 1555.6 Secondary Flows 1715.7 Tip Clearance Flows 1765.8 Jet-Wake Flow in Impellers 180

6 Gas Dynamics 1916.1 Overview 1916.2 Gas Dynamics of Ideal Gases 1916.3 Shock and Expansion Waves 1996.4 Shock Structure in Transonic Compressors 2036.5 Gas Dynamics of Real Gases 206

7 Aerodynamic Loading 2107.1 Overview 2107.2 Isolated Aerofoils 2117.3 Profiles in Cascade 2197.4 Diffusers 2267.5 Blade Loading Parameters 236

8 Similarity 2478.1 Overview 2478.2 Similarity of Fluid Flows 2488.3 Geometric Similarity 2528.4 Fluid Dynamic Similarity 2538.5 Thermodynamic Similarity 2618.6 Applications of Similarity Parameters 2658.7 Performance Corrections for Deviation from Similarity 278

viii Contents

Page 9: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

9 Specific Speed 2849.1 Overview 2849.2 Specific Speed and Specific Diameter 2849.3 The Cordier Diagram 290

10 Losses and Performance 29710.1 Overview 29710.2 The Definition of Losses 29810.3 Viscous Loss Mechanisms 30310.4 Other Aerodynamic Losses 31310.5 Loss Correlations in Centrifugal Stages 31810.6 Parasitic Losses 32010.7 Global Estimate for Aerodynamic Efficiency at the Design Point 32510.8 Mean-Line Calculation of the Flow Conditions through the Stage 330

11 Impeller Design 33811.1 Overview 33811.2 Impeller Design 33911.3 Impeller Types 34011.4 Flow Conditions at the Impeller Inlet 34311.5 Flow Conditions at the Impeller Throat 35511.6 Flow Conditions at Impeller Outlet 35811.7 The Compressor Characteristic as Influenced by Losses and Work 37611.8 Guidelines to Detailed Impeller Design 37811.9 Three-Dimensional Features 38711.10 Impeller Families 39011.11 Impeller Trim 39311.12 Comparison with Rotors of Other Machine Types 397

12 Diffuser Design 40512.1 Overview 40512.2 Effect of the Flow at the Impeller Outlet 40612.3 Vaneless Diffusers 41212.4 Vaned Diffusers 41712.5 Ideal Pressure Recovery in a Vaned Diffuser 42312.6 Zones of Pressure Recovery in a Vaned Diffuser 42412.7 Vaneless Space and Semivaneless Space 42612.8 Blockage at the Throat in Diffuser Channels 42812.9 Matching the Diffuser Throat with the Impeller 43012.10 Wedge Diffuser Channels 43312.11 Cascade Diffuser Channels 43512.12 Pipe Diffusers 44012.13 Downstream Semivaneless Space and Vaneless Space 44112.14 Special Cases 441

ixContents

Page 10: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

13 Casing Component Design 44313.1 Overview 44313.2 Casing and Rotor Configurations 44413.3 Inlet or Suction Nozzle 44613.4 Intermediate Inlet Nozzles 44713.5 Inlet Guide Vanes 44813.6 Outlet Volute 44913.7 Return Channel System 45513.8 Deswirl Vanes 45913.9 Axial Thrust 461

14 Geometry Definition 46614.1 Overview 46614.2 Coordinate Systems for Turbomachinery 46614.3 Axisymmetric and Blade-to-Blade Stream Surfaces in

Radial Compressors 46814.4 Geometry Definition of Flow Channels 47014.5 Geometry Definition of Blades and Vanes 478

15 Throughflow Code for Radial Compressors 48015.1 Overview 48015.2 A Preliminary Overview of the Throughflow Method 48115.3 Notation for the Blade Angles of the Velocity Gradient Equation 48915.4 The Throughflow Equation of Motion 49215.5 Streamline Curvature Velocity Gradient Equation 49715.6 The Iterative Scheme 50415.7 Empirical Modifications 50615.8 Spanwise Mixing 50815.9 Pressure Gradient from Blade Force 51315.10 Choking 51515.11 Use of Throughflow in Design 526

16 Computational Fluid Dynamics 52816.1 Overview 52816.2 Historical Background to Turbomachinery CFD 52916.3 The Governing Equations 53616.4 The Modern Numerical Method 53716.5 Stage Calculations with Interface Planes 54616.6 Turbulence Models 55016.7 Quality and Trust 55416.8 Checklists for the Design Process with CFD 560

17 Compressor Instability and Control 56517.1 Overview 56517.2 Instabilities in Compressors 566

x Contents

Page 11: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

17.3 Off-Design Operation of Radial Compressors 58417.4 Typical Operating Range of Single-Stage Radial Turbocompressors 58717.5 Stability Control and Enhancement 590

18 Maps and Matching 60118.1 Overview 60118.2 Methods of Map Prediction 60218.3 Map Prediction for Single Stages 60518.4 Apparent Efficiency Due to Heat Transfer Effects 61918.5 Extrapolation of a Measured Map 62018.6 Map Prediction for Multiple Stages 62418.7 Matching of the Diffuser with the Impeller 62818.8 Matching in Multistage Compressors 62918.9 Matching of the Compressor to a Turbine in a Gas Turbine 63118.10 Matching Issues of a Compressor in a Turbocharger 634

19 Structural Integrity 64319.1 Overview 64319.2 Open or Closed Impellers 64419.3 Impeller Manufacturing and Materials 64519.4 Introduction to Static Blade Loading of Impellers 64919.5 Introduction to Dynamic Blade Loading of Impellers 65219.6 Computational Methods 66019.7 Design Data for Mechanical Analysis 66119.8 Assessment of Fatigue 66519.9 Vibrational Considerations 66619.10 Disc Design 67319.11 Assembly Designs 67519.12 Rotordynamics 67719.13 Rotor Modelling 684

20 Development and Testing 68820.1 Overview 68820.2 Design and Development for Centrifugal Compressors 68820.3 Compressor Testing 69820.4 Basic Research and Development Tests 70220.5 Instrumentation and Measurements 70820.6 Determination of Stall and Surge 714

References 715Index 752

xiContents

Page 12: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Credits

Unless otherwise stated, the simulations presented in the book have been obtainedwith ANSYS CFX and ANSYS mechanical software.

All photographs, simulation results, line diagrams and charts are supplied fromPCA Engineers Limited with the exception of those where credit is given to anothersource. The copyright of the figures remains with the original sources.

xii

Page 13: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Introduction

This book is about the engineering science that is most useful for the design andanalysis of radial turbocompressors over a wide range of applications. The aim is toprovide the most relevant information for designers, especially the pragmaticapproaches that the authors find are quickest and the most effective. The bookconcentrates on one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) analyses of the fluiddynamic, thermodynamic and mechanical phenomena. These analyses provide rigor-ous, common-sense ways of looking at the problems and are usually the most insight-ful way to an engineering solution that is suitable for design purposes. These methodsare also the most amenable and doable for engineers who study them. The 1D and 2Danalyses often provide a good grounding for understanding the results arising fromdetailed analysis with three-dimensional (3D) simulations.

During their careers, the authors have been faced with many difficult questions withregard to radial compressors, and this book documents some of the approaches andshortcuts in the wide literature on this subject that they have found to be the mostuseful. The book provides a coherent description of the most useful theory and thenecessary pragmatic experience associated with it in the design environment. It ishoped that the book provides a suitable introduction to engineers entering this field,enabling them to get up to speed when starting from scratch, and gives usefulguidance for advanced students of turbomachinery. It should also act as a practicaldetailed reference for practitioners, specialists and academics working in this area,helping them to see the clusters in the forest rather than individual trees. For additionalguidance, each chapter includes a brief list of the important learning objectives relatedto its content and gives extensive references for further study.

In Chapter 1, the basic definition of a turbomachine is considered together with aclassification and history of different turbomachines. Different applications of radialflow turbocompressors are then outlined to show their wide range of aerodynamicduty. They are used in many different industries due to their inherent robustness, goodefficiency and broad operating range. Meeting environmental goals with reducedcarbon and other greenhouse gas emissions is likely to lead to more applications ofradial compressors in the future. The focus of Chapters 2–9 is to take all readers to thesame level of understanding in the essential principles and concepts of aerothermo-dynamics relevant to compressors before details of the design and performance ofradial compressors are examined in the subsequent chapters. The background know-ledge in these early chapters is also relevant for most other turbomachines, but is

xiii

Page 14: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

presented in a way that draws out specific information and useful insights relevant toradial compressors. Much of the content of these first chapters derives from lecturecourses on fluid dynamics, gas dynamics and thermodynamics.

Chapter 2 considers energy transfer in radial compressors, both from the kinematicpoint of view through the velocity triangles and from the statements of the first andsecond laws of thermodynamics. Here some emphasis is placed on the definition andphysics of the aerodynamic work, also known as the polytropic head, in isentropic,polytropic and isothermal compression processes. The importance of the centrifugaleffect and the relevance of the degree of reaction are particularly emphasised. This isfollowed by Chapter 3 introducing different equations of state that can be used tomodel the gas behaviour for the many radial compressor applications where the gasdeviates from ideal gas behaviour. Chapter 4 covers some thorny and oft-neglectedconcepts related to the definition of efficiency in compressors taking into account thedissipation losses, the aerodynamic work and the change in kinetic energy across acomponent. Chapters 3 and 4 might be omitted on a first reading of the book.

Chapters 5–9 provide fundamentals of the basic fluid dynamic theory needed tounderstand the complex flow in radial turbocompressors. Chapter 5 provides aphysical description of the fluid dynamics of diffusing flow in curved blades and flowchannels and how this is affected by the duty of the compressor. Chapter 6 provides anoverview of gas dynamics for compressible flow including the important features ofthe shock system at the inlet to the blade rows in a transonic impeller. Chapter 7highlights the important fluid dynamic principles of the flows around aerofoils,cascades of blades and the aerodynamic loading limits involved in the diffusing flowin radial compressor flow channels both in impellers and vaned diffusers. Chapter 8introduces the nondimensional similarity parameters that are of most use in theanalysis of turbocompressors and provides a description of their relevance andapplication. A consistent use of these dimensionless parameters is used throughoutthe book to categorise the different aspects and link the technology in differentcompressor applications. The effect of compressibility is considered from the conceptof thermodynamic similarity leading to the definition of the tip-speed Mach number,based on the ratio of the inlet speed of sound and the mechanical blade speed at theimpeller outlet. Chapter 9 discusses two other non-dimensional parameters known asthe specific speed and specific diameter, together with their presentation in a Cordierdiagram. The awkwardness of these dimensionless parameters is described inChapter 9, where reasons for scepticism with regard to their use for radial compressorsis explained. Despite its popularity in many radial compressor publications, thespecific speed is otherwise hardly mentioned in the book.

These earlier chapters are a compendium of fundamental knowledge and conceptsthat are referred to in the subsequent chapters, which then examine details of thedesign, development, performance and testing of radial turbocompressors.Chapters 10–20 are derived from the lecture course on axial and radial compressorsgiven by the first author at the Institute of Thermal Turbomachinery and MachineryLaboratory (ITSM) in Stuttgart University and from training material used by PCAEngineers Limited. Chapter 10 begins this process with a one-dimensional

xiv Introduction

Page 15: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

description of the losses and the prediction of the performance levels of radialcompressors. The relevance of the duty required in terms of the important nondi-mensional parameters, the flow coefficient and the tip-speed Mach number indetermining the level of the efficiency that can be expected is highlighted.Elementary considerations which determine the size and rotational speed of acompressor for a given duty are also described.

The background to the design of different components is covered in in the nextthree chapters. In Chapter 11, the design of the impeller inlet to achieve the mostcompact stage is emphasised. The crucial importance of the work coefficient indetermining the steepness of the impeller characteristic is explained. The impellerand the diffuser are coupled together by the impeller outlet flow and its velocitytriangle and a little-known diagram, first used by Mehldahl (1941), is presented indifferent forms to elucidate the matching of these components at different flow ratesand for different styles of design. In Chapter 12, the pressure recovery of a vanelessdiffuser and of various forms of vaned diffuser is described. The performance of thedifferent zones of vaned diffuser is linked to the performance of planar diffusers.Chapter 13 considers other stator components, including the inlet nozzle and inletguide vanes upstream of the impeller, and the different possible downstream compon-ents, including crossover channels, return channels, deswirl vanes, volutes, sidestreaminlets and the rotor-stator cavities, and their influence on axial thrust.

The aerodynamic design tools that the authors have found to be most useful inpractical applications are described in Chapter 14 (geometry definition), Chapter 15(throughflow methods) and Chapter 16 (computational fluid dynamics). The firstauthor was involved in the development of geometry definition methods and through-flow methods for radial machines in the early 1980s. The second author has spentmost of his career using these methods. Both authors were separately involved in someof the first applications of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods in industry inthe 1980s and early 1990s. Some of the teething difficulties of CFD technology duringits development from infancy to maturity over the last 40 years left a lasting impres-sion and has certainly coloured our reflection of this important technology.

The critical difference between compressors and turbines is that compressors aresubject to rotating stall and to surge, which limit the safe operating range of themachines. The critical issue is the onset of instabilities in the flow and how to avoidthem. Despite the advances in numerical methods, the stable operating range remainsone of the least well-predicted aspects of performance. The current understanding ofthe unstable nature of the flow in compressors at low flow near the surge line isreviewed in Chapter 17 together with different control strategies to increase theoperating range. Performance maps from surge to choke in single-stage and multistagecompressors are described in Chapter 18, and their use in the matching of componentsin different compressor applications is described.

Chapter 19 offers an introduction to the key aspects of structural integrity androtor dynamics. The objective here is to introduce the important mechanical con-cepts so that an aerodynamic designer is aware of the issues and can take advantageof the many specialist works in this field. Chapter 20 closes the book by providing

xvIntroduction

Page 16: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

some details of the typical design and development processes up to and includingcompressor testing.

An extensive list of references is provided to demonstrate that our views are wellsupported by the evidence in the technical literature. This is barely the tip of theiceberg of the relevant papers that are available on the subject, and these in turn givecopious leads to other sources of useful information. The list includes most of our owntechnical publications, not that these have any special modicum of merit compared toother publications, but because these are the ones with which we are most familiar andare our personal anchor to the technology. Like all engineer scientists we are pleasedwith our contribution to design methods which were not there until we personallydeveloped them.

Communication with the authors with regard to any aspects of the book can bemade via the following website: www.pcaeng.co.uk.

xvi Introduction

Page 17: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Preface

This book is our homage to radial flow turbocompressors. These have not onlypresented us with many challenging engineering design problems but also providedus with a rewarding subject of academic study. They have also given us many friends,a network of great like-minded colleagues the world over and the major part of ourincome over many years.

The risk of writing a preface is that it can have the unwanted effect that somereaders may read the preface and leave the rest of the book untouched. While workingtogether as engineers on axial compressors, the authors experienced this effect withseveral doctoral and master theses. In many of these, the preface was invariablycompelling reading, occasionally more immediately memorable than the theses them-selves. So here we give our greetings to all those who, like us, prefer to start a bookwith the preface.

There is no single correct way to structure a book on radial turbocompressors, andour approach is outlined in the Introduction. The content is guided by our experienceand knowledge of the subject. It gives a glimpse of the theoretical concepts in theorder they are needed, much like an introductory lecture course, and provides refer-ences to more detailed coverage. As the story develops, important things get empha-sised by appearing in many different chapters, often in different guises and usuallyincreasing in complexity. The book is based on part of an introductory lecture courseon axial and radial compressors given by the first author to master students in theUniversity of Stuttgart. The content of the lecture course has been greatly expandedand tempered by practical experience both authors have gained in consultancy anddesign work for many compressor industries. It has been helped by notes made by thefirst author with regard to technical issues throughout his career, either jotted on paperor annotated on to copies of important technical papers. Without these, the bookwould have been a great deal poorer, as memories of the initial difficulty in under-standing a new concept when it is still on the learning curve fade quickly when theconcept has finally been grasped. The second author has been more than happy to letthe first author lead the way in describing the theory, feeling himself to be more suitedto describing the pragmatism in application.

The purpose of this book is to set out the basic principles and rules associated withthe design of radial flow turbocompressors across a range of applications. Primarilythe book is concerned with the aerodynamic design, but this cannot be divorced fromthe mechanical aspects, and so these are touched upon but are not gone into so deeply.

xvii

Page 18: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

The book is written from the point of view of the designer and tries to cover most ofthe points that need to be considered in order to produce a successful radial flowturbocompressor. The emphasis is on understanding the theory behind the designprocess and on minimising the reliance on empirical rules. However, because of thecomplexity of the flow patterns, a lot of empiricism and some conjecture still remains.

This is a book the authors wished they had had when they first started work oncentrifugals. We hope that it gives guidance to newcomers on their own road ofdiscovery with this technology and conveys something of our own pleasure andexcitement of working in this field. It is also intended to provide fresh insights forexperienced engineers and specialists already in this field; we hope to incite reflectionon the basic engineering science and the value and enduring contribution of 1D and2D methods, often as a means of understanding modern 3D simulations.

xviii Preface

Page 19: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Acknowledgements

Many individuals have helped in the writing of this book, and it is a pleasure toacknowledge this. Foremost among these are Hamid Hazby, Daniel Rusch, PaulGalpin and Maxine Backus. Dr Hazby provided the initial formulation of the contenton transonic impeller design and was kind enough to review some of the early draftsof other chapters, making several useful contributions. Dr Rusch of ABBTurbocharging read several chapters and was always willing to help by explaininghis own understanding of many issues. Paul Galpin provided a short description aboutmodern CFD codes, which is the basis of some of Chapter 16 . Maxine Backus readand corrected the use of English in all the chapters in draft form and made the bookbetter with her concise improvements to the style.

Closer to home within PCA Engineers Limited, we are grateful to all of ourcolleagues and partners who have supported our activity on this book. Specific thanksgo to Peter Came, who provided the solid foundation for the evolution of compressordesign at PCA. John Calvert kindly reviewed some of the content and made usefulsuggestions. Ian Woods, Mark Dempsey and Colin McFarlane helped with thetechnical content on mechanical integrity and rotor dynamics. Simon Welburn andRob O’Donoghue did excellent work on many of the figures.

The first author would like to thank many graduate and postgraduate students inStuttgart University who attended or helped with the lecture course onTurboverdichter (turbocompressors in German), which provided the initial structurefor this book, Casey (2008).

For the stimulating discussions on many issues, feedback on different chapters,supply of offprints of technical papers, provision of initial versions of illustrations andtechnical data, provision of some excellent summaries of technical issues and help invarious other ways, we are grateful to the following persons: Nicola Aldi of theUniversity of Ferrara, Claudine Bargetzi of MAN Energy Solutions, Urs Baumannof MAN Energy Solutions, Yves Bidaut of MAN Energy Solutions, John Bolger ofRolls-Royce Ltd., Colin Casey, Professor Nick Cumpsty of Imperial College, PeterDalbert, Fabian Dietmann, Ivor Day of Cambridge University, Professor GüntherDibelius of RWTH Aachen University (deceased), Markus Diehl, Professor JohnDenton formerly of Cambridge University, Professor Erik Dick of Ghent University,Fabian Dietmann of Celeroton AG, Dietrich Eckardt, Professor Phillip Epple ofFriedrich Alexander University, John Fabian, Paul Galpin of ISIMQ, Daniel Gratesof RWTH Aachen University, Professor Ed Greitzer of Massachusett Institute of

xix

Page 20: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Technology (MIT) Gas Turbine Laboratory, Professor Georg Gyarmathy of the ETHZürich (deceased), Tom Heuer of BorgWarner, Werner Jahnen of SWS Tech AG,Tony Jones of Pratt and Whitney, Professor Nicole Key and Fangyuan Lou of PurdueUniversity, Franz Marty (deceased), Professor Rob Miller of Cambridge University,Professor Beat Ribi of FNHW, Colin Rodgers, Professor Isabelle Trébinjac of theÉcole Centrale de Lyon, Professor Markus Schatz of Helmut Schmidt University,Georg Scheurerer of ISIMQ, Joachim Schmid of Delta JS AG, Christoph Schreiber,Om Sharma of United Technologies, Professor Zoltan Spakovsky of MIT Gas TurbineLaboratory, Professor Stephen Spence of Trinity College in Dublin, Bobby Sirakov ofGarret Motion Inc., Professor Xinqian Zheng of Tsinghua University in Peking,Christof Zwyssig of Celeroton AG, and others who have helped but may haveinadvertently been forgotten in this list.

For their patience and forbearance in guiding us through the production of thebook, we would also like to thank all the team at Cambridge University Press.

We would also like to acknowledge the enormous debt we both owe to manyengineers and teachers who, even when being unaware of exactly how they werehelping us, encouraged us to find our own way and own solutions throughout ourcareers. The book is written partly in thanks to the many engineers, researchers andcompanies who have a similar interest in this technology and have shared theirenthusiasm by publishing a wealth of technical literature describing the essentialengineering science that explains the performance of radial flow turbocompressors.Hopefully the book does justice to their work.

For those parts of the book which are still unclear, and for any muddles in the textand blunders in the equations, the authors are directly responsible.

xx Acknowledgements

Page 21: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Conventions and Nomenclature

Conventions

1. Unless otherwise stated, all units in all equations are SI units.2. It has not been possible to avoid the use of the same symbol for several different

quantities. This is usually made clear by the context.3. Parameter values and quantities used only very locally in the text are defined where

they are used and are not all listed here.4. Several slightly different conventions have been used for station locations. The

normal notation uses locations with numerical values increasing from 1, 2 and 3and so on through a compressor stage, as shown in Figure 10.6. In differentsituations, 1 and 2 can also indicate the inlet and exit of a stage or the inlet andoutlet of a component. Subscript 2 is most often used to denote the impeller outlet.In some situations, i is used to denote the inlet and o is used to denote the outlet.

5. The subscripts h and c are used to denote the hub and the casing contourcoordinates, and the subscript m is used for the arithmetic mean and rms for theroot mean square.

6. All angles are given in degrees. The blade angles are defined relative to themeridional flow direction. A positive value indicates flow angles that are in thedirection of rotation and negative values are against the direction of rotation, asshown in Figure 2.4. With this convention, the typical inlet and outlet angle of animpeller blade has a negative value. In such a situation, the statement that thebacksweep or the inlet angle increases usually implies a more negative value.

Nomenclature

Letters

a Speed of sounda1, a2, . . . Polynomial coefficients in equation for specific heata, b, c, d, . . . Coefficients in equationsA,B,C,D, . . . Coefficients in equationsA Areab Flow channel widthB Bernstein polynomial

xxi

Page 22: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

B (1) Blockage(2) Greitzer B parameter

BL Blade loading parameterc (1) Absolute velocity

(2) Damping coefficientcu, cr, cz, cm Absolute velocity componentscd Dissipation coefficientcf Skin friction coefficientcp Specific heat at constant pressurecv Specific heat at constant volumeC Coefficient in Mallen and Saville methodCD Drag coefficientCL Lift coefficientCM Moment coefficientCp Pressure coefficientD (1) Diameter

(2) DragDh Hydraulic diameterDs Specific diameterDF Diffusion factorDH The De Haller numbere EccentricityE (1) Energy

(2) Young’s modulusf D Darcy friction factorf s Schultz correction factorF Force componentg (1) Staggered spacing

(2) Acceleration due to gravityh (1) Specific enthalpy

(2) Heightht Specific total enthalpyH Boundary layer shape factori Incidence angleI (1) Specific rothalpy

(2) Moment of inertiaj12 Specific dissipation lossesk, l,m, n Coefficients in equationsk (1) Blockage factor

(2) Bending stiffnesskc The Casey coefficient for heat transfer to a compressorK CoefficientKE Kinetic energy

xxii Conventions and Nomenclature

Page 23: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

L (1) Length(2) Lift

m (1) Distance along the meridional direction(2) Mass(3) Exponent in gas dynamics equations

m0 Distance along the normalised meridional direction_m Mass flow rateM (1) Mach number

(2) Torsional moment on a shaftMu2 Impeller tip-speed Mach numberMw Molecular weightMR Mach number ration (1) Rotational speed in rps

(2) Polytropic exponent(3) Normal vector to a surface(4) Distance in the normal direction(5) Coefficient in Haaland equation

N (1) Rotational speed in rpm(2) Amount of a constituent expressed in moles

NPSH Net positive suction heado Throat widthp (1) Pressure

(2) s-shaped logistic functionp* Rotary stagnation pressureP (1) Power

(2) Parameter valuePIF Power input factorPh Preheat factorPE Potential energyq Distance along a quasiorthogonalq12 Specific heat inputQ Heat inputr Radiusr, z, θ Coordinates in cylindrical coordinate systemrk Kinematic degree of reactionR Specific gas constantRm Universal gas constantRa Centre-line average roughnessRe Reynolds numberRF Relaxation factors (1) Specific entropy

(2) Distance along a streamline or a blade(3) Spacing

xxiiiConventions and Nomenclature

Page 24: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

S (1) Entropy(2) Source terms in Chapter 16

St Strouhal numbert (1) Time

(2) Blade thicknessT Absolute temperatureTrim Square of the impeller casing diameter ratiou (1) Blade speed

(2) Specific internal energy(3) Fluid velocity in Chapter 16

U Internal energyv Specific volumeV (1) Volume

(2) Velocity in Chapter 16_V Volume flow ratew Relative velocityws12 Specific shaft workwv12 Specific displacement workW (1) Width of flow channel in diffusers

(2) Work inputx Mole fractionx, y, z Coordinates in Cartesian coordinate systemr, θ, z Coordinates in cylindrical coordinate systemy12 Specific aerodynamic workyþ Normalised distance from the wall in a boundary layerY Stagnation pressure loss coefficientZ (1) Altitude above a datum level

(2) Gas compressibility factor(3) Blade number

Symbols

α Absolute flow angleΔα Flow turning angle of a cascadeα0 Absolute blade angleα, β Reynolds-independent and Reynolds-dependent lossesβ (1) Relative flow angle

(2) Reduced frequency(3) Core rotation factor in swirling flow

β0 Relative blade angleγ (1) Ratio of specific heats (and isentropic exponent of an ideal gas)

(2) Blade lean angle and rake angleδ (1) Boundary layer thickness

(2) Deviation angle

xxiv Conventions and Nomenclature

Page 25: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

(3) Shock wave deflection angle(4) Logarithmic decrement

δ* Boundary layer displacement thicknessδ, ε Coefficients in real gas equationsΔ Difference or change in a parameter, such as Δhtε (1) Tip clearance gap

(2) Kinetic energy thickness of a boundary layer(3) Turbine expansion ratio(4) Shock wave angle(5) Inclination angle of meridional flow to axial direction(6) Diffusion coefficient

ζ (1) Energy or enthalpy loss coefficient(2) Damping ratio

ζ q Heat transfer in a diabatic compression as a fraction of theaerodynamic work

η Efficiencyθ (1) Boundary layer momentum thickness

(2) Circumferential coordinate(3) Planar diffuser divergence half-angle(4) Camber line slope angle

κ Isentropic exponentωs Specific speedΩs Secondary circulationλ (1) Work coefficient

(2) Fluid conductivity in Chapter 16μ Dynamic viscosityn (1) Kinematic viscosity

(2) Inlet dimeter to outlet diameter ratio(3) Poisson’s ratio

ξ (1) Kinetic energy loss coefficient(2) Ratio of local kinetic energy to the shaft work

π Pressure ratioρ Densityσ (1) Solidity

(2) Stress(3) Slip velocity ratio

τ Shear stressυ Polytropic ratioΦ Mass-flow functionϕ (1) Flow coefficient

(2) Phase angleϕt1 Global inlet flow coefficientχ Entropy loss coefficient

xxvConventions and Nomenclature

Page 26: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

χd Nondimensional slope of work characteristic at design pointψ (1) Pressure rise coefficient

(2) Slope angle of a quasiorthogonal to the meridional directionω (1) Rotational speed in radians per second

(2) Pressure loss coefficient

Subscripts

0 At zero Mach number1, 2, 3 (1) Station numbers

(2) Component numbers1 Inlet2 Outlet∞ Far upstreama Annularact Actualb Burstbtob Blade-to-bladec (1) Compressor

(2) Curvature(3) At critical conditions(4) Vortex centre(5) Relating to the camber line(6) Absolute velocity

ch Chokecorr Correctedd (1) Disturbance

(2) Discharge(3) Design

dep Departure function valuediff Diffuserds DeswirlDF Disc frictione (1) Value at the edge of a boundary layer

(2) Engineeff Effectiveeq Equivalentexit ExitEuler From the Euler equationf (1) Friction

(2) Fuelhtoc Hub to casingGT Gas turbinei, j Station location

xxvi Conventions and Nomenclature

Page 27: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

i Isothermalid Idealigv Inlet guide vanesimp Impellerirr Irreversiblej Jetl Lowerle Leading edgelam Laminarleak Leakagem (1) Meridional

(2) Mechanicalmax Maximum valuemin Minimum valuen (1) Normal to meridional direction

(2) Naturalo Outletopt Optimum valuep (1) Polytropic

(2) at peak efficiencyps Pressure surfaceq Along the quasiorthogonalr (1) Rotor

(2) Reducedrc Return channelrec Recirculationref Referencerev Reversiblerp At rated pointRS Rotating stalls (1) Stator

(2) Isentropic(3) Sand(4) Shroud

shutoff Shutoff value at zero flowss Suction surfaceSW Sweptt Total conditionste Trailing edgeth Throatturb (1) Turbulent

(2) TurbineTC Turbocharger

xxviiConventions and Nomenclature

Page 28: Radial Flow Turbocompressors

Cambridge University Press978-1-108-41667-2 — Radial Flow TurbocompressorsMichael Casey , Chris Robinson FrontmatterMore Information

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

u (1) In the circumferential direction(2) Virtual station in Figure 2.18(3) Upper(3) Ultimate

v Vapour pressurevd Vaned diffuservld Vaneless diffuservol Volumetricw (1) Wheel

(2) Wake(3) relative velocity

θ Circumferential direction

Superscripts

0 Inlet* Critical conditions at a throat0 related to blade valuec Compressorcomp Compressibled Designss Static-staticstall At stallt turbinets Total–statictt Total–total

xxviii Conventions and Nomenclature