QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian,...

46
QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?

Transcript of QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian,...

Page 1: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTION:

HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?

Page 2: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex-director of the Human Genome Project, appointed by President Barack Obama as Director of the National Institutes of Health, July 2009.

Page 3: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTION:“OK, maybe you’re right. Science hasn’t ‘buried’ God, but as we discover more and more through science, the Bible’s version of events does look increasingly unlikely. Yes?”

Page 4: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTION: SCIENCE?1. The origin of the universe2. The “fine tuning” of the universe3. The origin of organic life

Page 5: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 6: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 7: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

Past History of the Universe Present

Page 8: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

A CASE FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD:STEP 1: Everything that begins to exist has a causeSTEP 2: The universe began to exist

CONCLUSION: The universe has a cause

Page 9: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTION: SCIENCE?1. The origin of the universe2. The “fine tuning” of the universe3. The origin of organic life

Page 10: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 11: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 12: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 13: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

THE ORIGIN OF ORGANIC LIFE:a) A cause for biological information (e.g. DNA code and means of translating it, needed

simultaneously)a) No “reducing” atmosphereb) No pre-biotic soup of chemicalsc) Oxygen-ultraviolet paradox

Page 14: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

THE ORIGIN OF ORGANIC LIFE:a) A cause for biological information (e.g. DNA code and means of translating it, needed

simultaneously)a) No “reducing” atmosphereb) No pre-biotic soup of chemicalsc) Oxygen-ultraviolet paradox

Page 15: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTION: SCIENCE?1. The origin of the universe2. The “fine tuning” of the universe3. The origin of organic life

Page 16: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

Q. WHAT ABOUT THE ‘MUTLI-VERSE’?Q. WHO MADE GOD?Q. WHAT ABOUT STEPHEN HAWKING?

Page 17: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

Q. WHAT ABOUT A BOUNCED OR OSCILLATING UNIVERSE?Q. ISN’T THIS JUST THE ‘GOD OF THE GAPS’?

Page 18: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

Q: WHY DON’T MORE SCIENTISTS BELIEVE IN GOD?

Page 19: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 20: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

HASN’T EVOLUTIONDISPROVED GOD?

Page 21: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

HASN’T EVOLUTIONDISPROVED GOD?THREE DIFFERENT CHRISTIAN POSITIONS:

1. Young Earth Creationism

Page 22: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

• The earth is 20,000 to 30,000 years old.• Dinosaurs and all fossils are thousands

not millions of years old. • The Earth created in 6 x 24 hour days.• Macro-evolution has NOT taken place.• Micro-evolution HAS taken place.

Page 23: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

HASN’T EVOLUTIONDISPROVED GOD?THREE DIFFERENT CHRISTIAN POSITIONS:

2. Old Earth Creationism

Page 24: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

• The universe is 13.7 billion years old. The earth is 4.5 billion years old.

• Long creation days of more than 24 hours.• Macro-evolution has NOT taken place.• Hominids (e.g. Homo Ergaster 1.8m - 0.5m

years BC) did exist before Adam & Eve, but NOT ancestors of Adam & Eve.

Page 25: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

HASN’T EVOLUTIONDISPROVED GOD?THREE DIFFERENT CHRISTIAN POSITIONS:

3. Theistic Evolution

Page 26: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

• Macro-evolution HAS taken place & Common Descent HAS taken place.

• God may have intervened to get evolution over barriers.

• Humans & chimpanzees share ancestor.• Adam & Eve were part of a population and

God put his spirit into them, so that they received the “image of God.”

Page 27: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

THREE DIFFERENT CHRISTIAN POSITIONS:

1. Young Earth Creationism2. Old Earth Creationism3. Theistic Evolution

Page 28: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

HASN’T EVOLUTIONDISPROVED GOD?

Page 29: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 30: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 31: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

HASN’T EVOLUTIONDISPROVED GOD?• Is the assumption behind this

question a “category mistake?” • Surely there is a difference between

“how?” questions and “why?” questions

Page 32: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

THREE KEY QUESTIONS THAT LIE OUTSIDE THE SCOPE OF EVOLUTION:• Why did the universe begin to exist?• Why is the universe so finely-tuned?• Why & how did life start on earth?

Page 33: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

JESUS IS ASKED A QUESTION ABOUT DIVORCE:“Some Pharisees came to him to test him. They asked: “Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any and every reason?”(Matthew 19:3)

Page 34: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

JESUS’ REPLY:“Haven’t you read,” he [Jesus] replied, “that at the beginning the Creator ‘made them male and female.’” (Matthew 19:4, quoting Genesis 1:27)

Page 35: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

JESUS’ REPLY:“and said, ‘for this reason a man will leave his father and mother and the two will become one flesh.’” (Matthew 19:5, quoting Genesis 2:24)

Page 36: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTIONS EVOLUTION FACES:

1. How can gradual step by step evolution explain the missing links in the fossil record and “the Cambrian Explosion”?

Page 37: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

“The Cambrian strata of rocks, vintage about 600 million years are the oldest ones in which we find most of the major invertebrate groups. And we find many of them already in an advanced state of evolution, the very first time they appear. It is as though they were just planted there without any evolutionary history.” Richard Dawkins The Blind Watchmaker p229

Page 38: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

“The fossil record in defiance of Darwin’s idea of gradual change often makes giant leaps from one form to the next. Far from the display of intermediates to be expected from slow advance through natural selection, many species appear without warning, persist in fixed form, and disappear, leaving no descendants. Geology assuredly does not…

Page 39: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

“reveal any finely graduated organic chain, and this is the most obvious and gravest objection that can be urged against the theory of evolution . . . As more bones turn up the story becomes less clear . . . In spite of a century’s claims of ‘missing links,’ it is quite possible that no bone yet found is on the direct genetic line to ourselves. With so many kinds to choose…

Page 40: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

“from and so few remains of each, and such havoc among the relics, none of the fossils may have direct descendants today.” Steve Jones, Almost Like a Whale, p252 & p457

Page 41: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTIONS EVOLUTION FACES:

2. How do you get the new genetic information needed to drive evolution over all the barriers it faces? What’s the mechanism?

Page 42: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

QUESTIONS EVOLUTION FACES:

3. Surely much of the evidence for common descent could just as easily be interpreted as common design?

Page 43: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.
Page 44: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

A CAUTIONARY TALE OF HUMAN ORIGINS?

1. The “Multi-Regional Hypothesis” replaced by the “Out of Africa” model.

Page 45: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

A CAUTIONARY TALE OF HUMAN ORIGINS?

2. The demise of “Junk” DNA

Page 46: QUESTION: HASN’T SCIENCE BURIED GOD?. Francis Collins, former atheist, now evangelical Christian, ex- director of the Human Genome Project, appointed.

RESPONSE:• If the case for God is NOT defeated by

evolution, then the way may be clear for you to look at the claims of Christ.

• Today we’ve heard Jesus calling us back to basics. Is there an area of your life where you are seeking God’s will or God’s word to guide you?