8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

1/21

  ?

1

 

...

...

2

( . . 7)

7  

1 1 17 8 13.30 – 1 .3 .

2

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

2/21

1    

15

 

1. 3

“      

”4

 

state capture regulatory capture 5

1  

3 ,“ ” , ,

8 . . 2549. 4 ,‘ ’, , 1, , 6. 5   state capture

  state capture , regulatory capture  

state capture, regulatory capture The World Bank, Anticorruption in Transition A Contribution to the Policy Debate, Washington D.C. 2000 ,

xv-xvi; Oleksiy Omelyanchuk, Explaining State Capture and State Capture Modes: The Cases of Russia and Ukraine , Budapest, 2001.

Http://www.ualberla.ca/CIUS/stasiuk/st-pdf/Explaining State Capture.pdf , 31 2015; Boehm, Frederic , Regulatory Capture Revisited – Lessons from

Economics of Corruption, Ph.D Economics, Anti-Corruption Training & Consulting (ACTC), and Research Center for Political Economy (CIEP, Universidad Externado

de Colombia), Working Paper,July 2007. State

http://www.ualberla.ca/CIUS/stasiuk/st-pdf/Explaining%20State%20Capture.pdfhttp://www.ualberla.ca/CIUS/stasiuk/st-pdf/Explaining%20State%20Capture.pdf

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

3/21

  Petty Grand Petty Corruption ( )

Grand Corruption

state capture

  6

“ …

  … ”

7  

8

2. 15

9 2   Petty Corruption

Grand Corruption

2542 557 6 , . , . .2537, 1. 7 ,   , Freidrich Ebert Stiftung, 2557 . . 8 Prakash Chander, Address, The XI Annual Conference of the Asian Law & Economics Association,

, 10, , 2558, 105, , . 9

  ( )  

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

4/21

    10 ? 111

912

3 7 3 ( 1)

1

1

EDI 10 “ “

”, ( .)   7,www.trf.or.th 11 …. 6. 12 1 7 9 9 71 6 8

. . 2542 2557

(10%)

10 4.8

( )

9,722 5,016

( ) (2557 )

15,400 1,648*

( )

, , ,

, , ,

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

5/21

13  

( Corruption Perception Index CPI )

(Transparency International TI 1)

1 (CPI) (TI)

CPI

CPI

14

CPI 1 1

1 CPI  

1 . . 1 . . 6 CPI 1

13 2557, , 48-49. 14 3

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

6/21

  61 2542 1 55615

2556 ( , 3 9 )

2541 430  

63 36

500,000

16

. .2535

3 - “   ”17

. . 254318

600 43.6 50.3 6.2

 

   

15 1998 13 8 17 16 “ : “

,   2541, 179, 209

17 “ ” , 20 2533. 18 , “ “, 2543

:

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

7/21

?  

   

6 63 ,

(3   )  

. . .

10 19 2558 . . . 180

  .3 20

“ ”21  

  . ( .1) ( .)

( .) DirectorsCertification Program (DCP)

19 3 6. “ .3 ”; 22 2558 20 “ . . . 179 . “ 25 2558. 19 2558.

21 ’ ”

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

8/21

? ?

.3   ?

.

22

( 7) . . . 6,1 1, 38 23

“   ...

191”24

.1   .

  “ .... ...

22 ‘ ’   ‘ ’, 7 8; “ ‘ ‘ 200 “, THAIPUBLICA, 25 . 2554. Thaipublica.org/2011/supoj-robbery-game/ 27 . .2558. 23 “ ‘ “46 ”, Thai Publica 1 2557. . . .  

. .2542

24

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

9/21

... ”25 ?

CTX 9000

. . 6 . CTX 9000

6 . .

. . 7 ( . . .)

  CTX

  26

“ ”   .

. . 9 . . . CTX

( .)

. . 1 . . .   . .

25 “ ” ”   “ ”, , 6 . 26 ”

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

10/21

“ …

“ ”

”. . . . . . . .

27 . . . 9 28

8 . . . . . . . CTX

29

31 .   . . . “

...[ ] ”30 “

?” 31

    CTX 9000  

?

?

. . .

  . . .

27 , . . . ,10 7 73.28 , . . . , . 29 Thaipublica 27   2012. CTX 9000

30 , . . . , 75. 31

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

11/21

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

12/21

state capture

 

15 Petty Corruption

Grand Corruption  

3.

4 (1) (2) (3)

34

35

. . . 36

34 “   ”, 3 8 35 “ ”PPT. (TDRI), . . 9 36 “ ‘ . ’ – . . .” 1   . . 7.www.isranews.org/isranews-scooplitem/32873-matee-777-

8

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

13/21

  37 “ (moral man)”

38

     

 

(economic rent)

 

 

2500 2510  

(2523- 2531) (2532 – 2534, 2535 –2548)  

37 “   ”, 3 8 38 . “ ” ”,

8 2549; ,   .. ”

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

14/21

2502 2516   2524 2534

 

“   39 “   .

“ …. ...

... ”40

  . .

 

. . 1  

“

2540”41

39 . . 184.40 . “ ” 3 – 1. 41 3

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

15/21

   

   

2     42

   

   

 

    “ ”   “ ”

? 43

  ?44  

42 Marc Saxer. In the Vertigo of Change : How to resolve Thailand’s transformation crisis. , Openworlds,

7. 43 ,” : ,

, . .2558, 4 4.2 .   75 77 j ( 53.3)

  4 1.3 21.3. 44

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

16/21

45

 

   

46

  “ ”

( patrimonialism)   47

  19

3 ( . . .

)

2550  

1 1 48

45 World Bank, Anticorruption in transition. A Contribution to the Policy Debate , Washington D.C. 2000.46 Michael T. Rock , “Corruption and Democracy “, DESA Working Paper N o.55 ST/ESA/2007/ DWP/55, August 2007. 47 Marc Saxer, In The Vertigo of Change . 3. 48 Saxer. The Vertigo of Change 18 - 3

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

17/21

4.

  ? ? (moral man)

“ ”  

John Dalberg-Action 1 st Baron Acton (1834-1902) “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely“

 

  “ ” “ ”

 

. . .

?

? 49

49

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

18/21

?  

17 44

50

 

 

   

   

 

2550  

51

50 , , 3. 51 , “   / ? “, , 21

2 8 l d bi l

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

19/21

3  

 

52

30    

 

  ( . . .)  

( . . .) ( . . .)  

 

 

 

Davide Ticchi, and Andrea Vindigni, “A Theory of Military Dictatorship”, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics , 2 (1): 1- 42; Acemoglu, Daron, “Oligrachic vs

Democratic Societies.” Journal of the European Economic Association 6: 1-44.

52 ,  

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

20/21

.

  state capture regulatory capture

25    

 

  “

”

8/20/2019 Puey Speech Pasuk

21/21

21