PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from...
Transcript of PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from...
![Page 1: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
PS Impedance Model
Update: KFA28 & BFA09Branko Popovic
30/01/20
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 1
![Page 2: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Past PS Longitudinal Impedance Model Presentations
• PS-BD-WG #27
• https://indico.cern.ch/event/801198/contributions/3329723/
• Long. Limit. With LIU-PS RF Upgrades and Mitigation
Strategy
• https://indico.cern.ch/event/750790/contributions/3108016/
• SPS Injection Losses Review
• https://indico.cern.ch/event/672967/contributions/2753563/
• PS-BD-WG #6
• https://indico.cern.ch/event/678530/contributions/2779037/
• PS-BD-WG #1
• https://indico.cern.ch/event/662292/contributions/2704441/
2IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 3: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Updated: Further Elements to add
• 20 MHz & 200 MHz Cavities
• Septums
• See later slides for comments
• Remaining Kickers
• KFA28
• KFA13/KFA21
• Transverse Feedback Kicker*
• Beam instrumentation equipment
• CODD Elements
• Vacuum elements
• Flanges, bellows, transitions, etc.
3
*https://indico.cern.ch/event/837716/
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 4: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Elements Covered in this Presentation
• KFA13/21 Resimulation
• KFA28 Simulations
• BFA09 Simulations
• Commentary on Septum
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 4
![Page 5: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Elements Covered
• KFA13/21 Resimulation
• KFA28 Simulations
• BFA09 Simulations
• Commentary on Septum
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 5
![Page 6: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Background: Transition Piece in KFA Magnets*
• Added to new KFA45
• Piece was added to KFA13 & KFA 21 as well• Identical Units
• Need to re-simulate
• Use opportunity to use schematic solver as well
* https://indico.cern.ch/event/830722/contributions/3479602
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 6
![Page 7: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
KFA13/KFA21 Model with Transition Piece
Transition Pieces
• Piece was added to KFA13 & KFA 21 as well
• Needed to resimulate Wakefield result
• Use opportunity to use schematic solver as well
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 7
![Page 8: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Background: Schematic Solver*
* https://indico.cern.ch/event/830722/contributions/3479602
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 8
![Page 9: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Compare with Wakefield (Terminations Shorted)
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 9
![Page 10: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
KFA 13/21 Re-simulation: Conclusion
• Transition Piece:
• Mode at 50 MHz Disappears
• Higher frequency modes are heavily damped (especially 1100
MHz)
• Schematic Simulations
• Modes below 15 MHz are heavily dampened when shorted
10IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 11: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Elements Covered
• KFA13/21 Resimulation
• KFA28 Simulations
• BFA09 Simulations
• Commentary on Septum
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 11
![Page 12: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Short Commentary on Reference Files For Wire
Measurements of KFA28 and KFA09
• Both the KFA28 and BFA09 use large ferrite* sections
• Its not possible to generate a simulation model for the
ref file
• Cannot include the ferrites => They are an impedance
contribution that you are trying to measure
• No Ferrite => Extra resonance modes present that would be
damped away in the tank
• Must use numerical reference file
• Magnitude = Loss due to matching resistors
• Phase = Mechanical length
*8C11
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12
![Page 13: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 14: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance
14
Mode at 1.19 GHz
Mode at 1.51 GHz
Wire Simulation Modes
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 15: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
A Boundary Condition Error…
• 250 mm Diameter input/outputs to the device
D250 mm
fcTE11 = 900 MHz
fcTM01 = 1.176 GHz
Standard PS Beam Pipe
fcTE11 = 980 MHz
fcTM01 = 2.5 GHz
D250 mm to PS Beam Pipe
ST0377524_01
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 15
![Page 16: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Elements Covered
• KFA13/21 Resimulation
• KFA28 Simulations
• BFA09 Simulations
• Commentary on Septum
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 16
![Page 17: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
BFA09: 3D Model from Paper Drawings
17
Pedestal Staircase
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
8C11 Ferrite 8C11 Ferrite
![Page 18: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Simulations in Wire and Wakefield
18IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 19: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Why the discrepancy between solvers above for both
elements?
• Reference file?
• Swept Magnitude and Phase… No Difference
• Ferrite Material Definition Differences between Solvers?
• Fundamentally the same at these frequencies
• Meshing?
• Different meshers but seem reasonable
• Boundary Conditions?
• This issue needs to checked; the large circular beam pipes
were used as ending the device instead of attaching the
smaller PS Beam Pipes
• Resimulate Wakefield Simulations of BFA09 & KFA28
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 19
![Page 20: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Regarding Removing vs Disconnecting Staircase
Component
20
https://edms.cern.ch/ui/file/1981131/0.1/PS-LJ-EC-0007-00-10.pdf
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 21: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Elements Covered
• KFA13/21 Resimulation
• KFA28 Simulations
• BFA09 Simulations
• Commentary on Septum
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 21
![Page 22: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Comments on Septums
• BFA09• Simulated
• SMH16
• BFA21• To be removed (Removal of Continuous Transfer System)*
• Replaced with straight beam pipe
• SEH23
• SMH26
• SEH31• To be removed (Removal of Continuous Transfer System)*
• Replaced with straight beam pipe
• SMH42• To be replaced by a new septum**
• Difficulties in modeling laminated steel sections
• Measurements presented in +
• SMH57
22
*https://edms.cern.ch/ui/file/1981131/0.1/PS-LJ-EC-0007-00-10.pdf
**https://edms.cern.ch/document/1856808/0.1
+https://indico.cern.ch/event/860185/contributions/3623056/
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 23: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Comments on Remaining Septums
• SMH16
• SEH23
• SMH26
• SMH57
• Septums contain laminations
which are extremely difficult to
model
• See SMH42+
• 3D Models are not available
23
+https://indico.cern.ch/event/860185/contri
butions/3623056/
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 24: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
To Come: CODD Elements
From: https://indico.cern.ch/event/750790/
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 24
![Page 25: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Questions?
Comments?
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 25
![Page 26: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Extra Slides
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 26
![Page 27: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
All KFA13/KFA21 Plots
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 27
![Page 28: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
BFA09: Additional Transition Results
28IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 29: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
BFA09: Vary Reference File
Vary Magnitude Vary Ref Length
29
Mech Length is 1.175 m
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 30: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
BFA09: Material Definitions
30
Wire DefinitionWake Ferrite Definition
IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic
![Page 31: PS Impedance Model Update: KFA28 & BFA09...IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic 12 13 KFA28 : 3D Model from Paper Drawings IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic KFA28 Longitudinal Impedance 14 Mode at 1.19](https://reader036.fdocuments.in/reader036/viewer/2022070212/6107e87a67da6a2bc4688649/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
BFA09: Compare Meshes
31IWG#37 Branko K. Popovic