Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in B s J/ at LHCb
description
Transcript of Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in B s J/ at LHCb
Prospects for the Prospects for the measurement of measurement of
mixing induced CP violation mixing induced CP violation in Bin BssJ/J/ at LHCb at LHCb
1. Introduction, phenomenology2. The LHCb detector at LHC3. Trigger and selection4. Flavour tagging5. Fit and systematics6. Conclusion and prospects
Olivier Leroy
VIth Meeting on B physics, Ferrara, Italy, March 19-20, 2009
CPPM, Aix-Marseille Université, CNRS/IN2P3, Marseille, France
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
2
Many thanks to my LHCb colleagues, in particular to:A. Carbone, M. Calvi, P. Clarke, T. du Pree, S. Hansmann-Menzemer, B. Khanji, G. Lanfranchi, C. Langenbruch, C. Linn, M. Musy, S. Poss, U. Uwer, S. Vecchi and Y. Xie.
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
3
Introduction (1)Introduction (1) The interference between Bs decay to J/ either directly or via
mixing gives rise to a CP violating phase
is the sensitive probe of New Physics because:1. It is well predicted in the SM: SM -2s+P = (-0.0370.002+P) rad
2. New particles can contribute to the Bs-Bs box diagrams and significantly modify the SM prediction
Bs
Bs
f =J/
is observable, D and M are not
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
4
Introduction (2)Introduction (2) In the SM, BsJ/ decay is dominated by a single weak phase:
Various penguin pollution estimates: P~10-4 [H. Boos et al., Phys.Rev. D70 (2004) 036006] P~10-3 [M. Gronau et al., arXiv:0812.4796] P up to ~0.1 [S. Faller et al., arXiv:0810.4248v1]
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
5
Notations/conventionsNotations/conventions
1. s = the smallest b-s unitarity triangle angle
2. = the observable weak phase in BsJ/ = -2s + P No penguin pollution AND no NP = -2s
3. = the possible new physics phase in Bs-Bs mixing
4. The NP phase modify other measurements:
~10 times smaller than 2s
Standard Model:
2s=(0.0370.002) rad
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
6
PPVV decays (1)VV decays (1)
B0s
B0s
J/ ψ Φ
μ+μ-K+K-
ℓ = 0
ℓ = 1
ℓ = 2
Bs is a pseudo scalar (spin=0), and J/ are vectors mesons (JPC = 1—) Total angular momentum conservation =>
in the Bs rest frame, and J/ have relative orbital momentum ℓ =0,1,2 Since CP|J/>= CP|J/> CP|> (-1)ℓ,
final state is mixture of CP even (ℓ=0,2) and CP odd (ℓ=1) Decompose decay amplitudes in term of linear polarization, when J/
and are: A0: longitudinally polarized (CP-even) A┴: transversely polarized and ┴ to each other (CP-odd) A||: transversely polarized and ║ to each other (CP-even)
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
7
PPVV decays (2)VV decays (2) 3 angles , ϕ, ψ describe directions of final decay products
J/→ and →K+K Allow to separate statistically the 3 decay amplitudes
J/ rest frame (where the meson moves in the x direction, the z axis is perpendicular to the decay plane of →K+K−, and py(K+) ≥ 0), (θ, ϕ) are the polar and azimuthal angles of the μ+.
In the rest frame, ψ is the angle between p(K+) and −p(J/)
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
8
Differential decay ratesDifferential decay rates
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
9
Differential decay ratesDifferential decay ratesTime dependent part
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
10
Differential decay ratesDifferential decay ratesAngular dependent part
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
11
Time dependent BTime dependent Bss decay amplitudes decay amplitudes
Dependends on 8 physics parameters: , s, s, ms, R┴, R, δ┴, δ
Conventions: 0=0 |A┴(0)|2+|A(0)|2+|A0(0)|2 = 1
Moduli2
Interferences
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
12
Time dependent BTime dependent Bss decay amplitudes decay amplitudes
Tagged analyses sensitive to both cos and sin Exact symmetry of the decay rates (2-fold ambiguity):
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
13
Road map to measure Road map to measure at LHCbat LHCb The decay rates give the road map:
Trigger and select BsJ/ events Measure proper time Measure 3 transversity angles Tag initial Bs flavour Likelihood fit of time and angular decay rates
6 observables: proper time, 3 angles, q (=0,-1,+1 for untagged, Bs, Bs) and mass 8 physics parameters: , s, s, ms, R┴, R, δ┴, δ
+ many detector parameters (resolutions, acceptances, tagging, …)
We will increase sensitivity and complexity step by step: Take detector param. from MC, fit only phys. param. Measure detector param. in control channels, fit only phys. param. Fit all param. from BsJ/ alone
Control channels: B+J/K+, BdJ/K*, BsDs, …
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
14
LHCb detector at LHC
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
15
LHCb detector at LHCLHCb detector at LHC
(Pythia)
Designed to maximize B-acceptance (within cost and space constraints) Forward spectrometer, 1.9<<4.9 More b-hadrons produced
at low angles Single arm is OK as b-quarks are
correlated Rely low pT triggers, efficient also for
purely hadronic decays
Choose to run at L~2x1032cm-2s-1
Clean environment: easier event reconstruction
Less radiation damage bb cross section at 14TeV
= 500b 40% (Pythia) 1012 bb produced / 2fb-1
(nominal year)
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
16
VELO:primary verteximpact parameterdisplaced vertex
Trigger Tracker: p for trigger and Ks reconstruction
Tracking Stations:p of charged particles
Calorimeters:Trigger andPID: h,e,, 0
Muon SystemTrigger and PID
RICHES:PID: K, separation
Interaction region
The LHCb detectorThe LHCb detector
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
17
Trigger and selection
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
18
BBJ/J/(()X unified trigger and selection )X unified trigger and selection (X= (X= ,, K K++, K*) , K*)
Coherent selection of the BsJ/ and two control channels: B+J/K+ and BdJ/K* in order to extract as much as possible information from data (rather than MC)
Selection criteria to obtain a reasonable statistical uncertainty on s while keeping systematics under control: Maximize signal yield while keeping background < few tens of
millions of events per nominal year (computing limit) Miminize proper time and angular acceptance distortions.
Do not cut on variables which bias the proper time b-hadrons have similar 4-momenta such that tagging properties
can be extracted from control channels and exported so signal channel without big corrections.Proper time resolution model can be cross-checked amongst channels
Other selections currently under investigation
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
19
BBssJ/J/(()) trigger selection trigger selection
Trigger uses lifetime-unbiased di-muons: L0: pT>1.5GeV, ~94% HLT1: Distance of closest approach ()<0.5mm
and m>2.5GeV, ~80% HLT2: pT(both )>0.5GeV and |m()-m (J/)|<3
and 2(Vtx)<7, ~95%
Selection: J/,
PID, 2(Vtx)<6, pT(J/)>1GeV, |m()-m(J/)|<3 KK
PID, 2(Vtx)<20, pT()>1GeV, |m()-m()|<3 2(Bs Vtx)<5, |m(KK)-m(Bs)|<3
Event yield after trigger and selection (2fb-1) ~ 117k
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
20
BBJ/J/X selection: backgroundsX selection: backgrounds
Yield (2fb-1) B(bb)/S B(prompt J/)/S
m.b. rate(300MeV mass window)
BsJ/ 117k 0.51 1.6 0.3 Hz
BJ/K* 489k 1.53 5.2 8.1 Hz
BJ/K+ 942k 0.29 1.6 1.4 Hz
Main background is prompt J/ but “easy” to isolate because ~0ps
Background studied: pp bb inclusive pp Buds J/ X Prompt pp J/ X Minimum bias (pp X)
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
21
BBssJ/J/ mass mass
<>~16MeV/c
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
22
BBssJ/J/ proper time resolution and proper time resolution and acceptanceacceptance
Average proper time resolution ~ 39 fs
Acceptance nearly flat
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
23
BBssJ/J/ angular acceptance angular acceptance
Acceptance distortions at ~10% level, come from: Kinematical cuts on the Bs decay products LHCb geometry (10-400 mrad) Single particle reconstruction efficiency = function of
momentum Above plots are zero-suppressed and made with 17fb-1
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
24
Angular resolutionsAngular resolutions
Resolution “good enough” to be ignored in likelihood fit (2fb-1) If resolutions two times worse:
|A┴,|||2 get biased s remains unbiased
Resolution (mrad) 0.020 0.027 0.027
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
25
Prompt background mass and proper Prompt background mass and proper timetime
Main background is prompt J/ but “easy” to isolate because ~0ps
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
26
Prompt background anglesPrompt background angles
Flat ? More statistics needed !
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
27
Long lived background mass and proper Long lived background mass and proper timetime
Average proper time smaller than signal (72% of events have ~0.18 ps)
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
28
Long lived background anglesLong lived background angles
Flat ? More statistics needed !
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
29
Flavour tagging
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
30
Same side
signal Bs
K-
K+
primary vertex
Opposite side opposite B
negative lepton taggers (e-, -) from b-quark
opposite
positive lepton taggers from bcl cascade
same side kaon tagger
vertex-charge taggerfrom inclusive vertexing
bb
s
u
s
u
Bs
K+
protonproton
kaon tagger (K-)
Flavour tagging at LHCb (1)Flavour tagging at LHCb (1)
+
-
BsJ/: efficiency ~ 55.7%, mistag rate ~33.3%, (1-2)2~6.2%
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
31
Main control channels B+JK+ , B0JK*0 for opposite side taggers BsDsfor same side kaon
First results will probably come with opposite side taggers (higher statistics in Bu,d channels and proper time resolution less crucial)
Unified selection true opposite-side mistag compatible amongst BJX channels:
Flavour tagging (2)Flavour tagging (2)
Combined wOS
(%)
Combined OS (1-2w)2 (%)
BsJ/ 36.510.24 3.320.11
BdJ/K* 36.150.20 3.350.09
B+J/K+ 36.000.21 3.450.10
True
performance
(MC truth)
after L0
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
32
Opposite-side mistag (wOpposite-side mistag (wOSOS) in ) in BBddJ/J/K* K*
BRvis[BsJ/()(K+K-)]= (2.710.96)x10-5
Measure wOS from mixing asymmetry in BdJ/K*
Toy MC including backgrounds Fit with 17 free parameters,
successful wOS/wOS)~0.3% with 2fb-1
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
33
Sensitivity studies
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
34
Baseline BBaseline BssJ/J/ parameters for toy MC parameters for toy MC sensitivity studies, extracted from full MCsensitivity studies, extracted from full MC
G means Gaussian: first parameter is the mean, second is the sigma.(t) is the Dirac function. “Flat Acc”, means a flat acceptance, “No Res” means a perfect resolution.The quoted yield is after L0, HLT and offline selection.
Signal Prompt background Long-lived background
Events in the 50MeV signal mass window B/S 117k B/S=1.8 B/S=0.5
Mass m (MeV)
f1G(m-MBs,1)+(1-f1)G(m-MBs,2) Exp(-1m) Exp(-2m)
MBs=5369.6
f1=0.74, 1=13.2; 2=22.5; (<=16.2)
1=0.0006 2=0.001
Proper time t (fs) (Flat Acc.)
S1(t)Res1 (t)Res2 {0.22 Exp(1=1114)+0.78 Exp(=161) }Res3
Res1 = f1G(0,1)+(1-f1)G(0,2)
f1=0.85, 1=31.5; 2=66.7 (<=39)
Res2= G(0,44) Res3 = G(0,66)
Angles (Flat Acc.)S2(angles) B1(angles) flat B2(angles) flat
No Res No Res No Res
Tagging parameters(Combined performance, assuming splitting in 5 categories !!)
wtag = 0.334±0.003tag = 0.564±0.002
tag=0.30±0.02 tag=0.62±0.06
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
35
Baseline sensitivity studies (2fbBaseline sensitivity studies (2fb-1-1) )
Perform hundreds of toy MC, maximum likelihood fit with: 6 observables m, t, cos, , cos, q 7 free parameters , s, s, R┴, R0, δ1, δ2 (ms fixed, can be floated, no changes) All “detector parameters” fixed
Pulls of fitted quantities normally distributed With 2fb-1 (one nominal year), (2s)~0.03
5 NP discovery, if 2strue>0.2 !
Standard Model:
2s=0.0370.002
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
36
Baseline sensitivity studies (2fbBaseline sensitivity studies (2fb-1-1) )
Sensitivity to other parameters is also good:
Similar results when all detector parameters are free (see backup)
Physics Parameters Input Value 2fb-1 sensitivity
s 0.049 [ps-1] 0.0095
s 0.680 [ps-1] 0.0028
2s 0.0368 0.030
R0 0.56 0.0031
R 0.233 0.0045
-2.91 0.082
-2.93 0.074
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
37
Fit BFit BssJ/J/ in full MC in full MC
Angular and proper time acceptance included Angles and proper time well described
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
38
BBssJ/J/KK S-wave (1)KK S-wave (1) The “simple” previous decay rates consider only the ->K+K- (P-wave) in
the vicinity of the KK and ignored any other resonant or non-resonant contributions in this region. Is this a problem ?
BJ/KK is a P → VPP process In principle the KK system can have any zero or positive integer angular
momentum A 5...10% S-wave contribution to Bs→J/K+K- cannot be excluded a
priori [arXiv:0812.2832]
The S wave has a time-dependent angular distribution different from that of any P-wave CP eigenvalue: -1 angular distribution
Its interferences with P waves introduce new terms Including S-wave contribution and its interference with P waves in the
signal pdf is necessary for correct extraction of s
22 cossin1
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
39
BBssJ/J/KK S-wave (2)KK S-wave (2)
Toy MC studies with 5-10% S-wave:
If ignored, leads to 2s ~10-20% biased toward zero
Including it in the fit adds 2 parameters and leads to a reduction in 2s resolution of ~20%
If KK S-wave contribution large enough, it is promising to measure the S-P phase difference as a funtion of KK mass in order to measure sign of cos(2s); like BaBar in Bd->J/K*
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
40
Preliminary systematics studiesPreliminary systematics studies
s/s (%)
Mistag =(341)% 7
Proper time resolution = (404)fs 5
Angular acceptance distorted by 5% 51
KK S wave of 10% under the 20
Doubly Cabbibo suppressed penguins ?
s measurement dominated by statistics at least up to 2fb-1 ?
Some systematics biases increases with s Work still ongoing
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
41
Sensitivity versus integrated Sensitivity versus integrated luminosityluminosity
Olivier Leroy Prospects for the measurement of mixing induced CP violation in Bs->JpsiPhi at LHCb, March 19th 2009
42
Conclusions and prospectsConclusions and prospects
BsJ/ hot topic and promising way to discover NP at LHCb But also one of the most challenging !
Critical points: Need all LHCb detectors working and calibrated Flavour tagging Angular / proper time acceptance Proper time resolution Fit stability with low statistics
Tevatron expects (2s)~0.13 by the end of 2010 LHCb with 2fb-1
117k BsJ/(), (2s)~0.03 Could expect some deteriorations with more realistic MC and real data
However, if true 2s value is the current Tevatron one ~0.8 (NP-like), we should measure it with ~0.2fb-1 !
Standard Model: 2s=0.0370.002