Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed...

23
Fifth Public Workshop Fifth Public Workshop Fifth Public Workshop Fifth Public Workshop August 23, 2005 August 23, 2005 August 23, 2005 August 23, 2005 Diamond Bar Diamond Bar Diamond Bar Diamond Bar Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM Coatings SCM Coatings SCM Coatings SCM Coatings SCM Coatings SCM Coatings SCM Coatings SCM

Transcript of Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed...

Page 1: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Fifth Public WorkshopFifth Public WorkshopFifth Public WorkshopFifth Public WorkshopAugust 23, 2005August 23, 2005August 23, 2005August 23, 2005Diamond BarDiamond BarDiamond BarDiamond Bar

Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish Proposed Automotive Refinish

Coatings SCMCoatings SCMCoatings SCMCoatings SCMCoatings SCMCoatings SCMCoatings SCMCoatings SCM

Page 2: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

California Air Resources Board (ARB)

Public Workshop on the Proposed Suggested ControlMeasure for Automotive Refinish Coatings

August 23, 200511:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. (PST)

South Coast Air Quality Management DistrictDiamond Bar, California

AGENDA

1. Introductions

2. ARB Staff Presentation (Proposed SCM)

3. Questions/Open Discussion

4. Next Steps

Page 3: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 3

���� Background

���� Proposed SCM for Automotive Refinish Coatings

���� Schedule

���� Questions/Open Discussion

Page 4: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Background Background Background Background

� Local districts regulate VOC emissions from automotive coatings

� Twenty districts have local rules

� Fifteen districts have National Rule VOC limits

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 4

Page 5: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Background Background Background Background

� ARB has oversight authority

� Provides technical assistance -

Development of the SCM

� SCM serves as a model rule for districts

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 5

Page 6: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

SCM Objectives:SCM Objectives:SCM Objectives:SCM Objectives:

� Increase consistency among district rules

� Improve rule enforceability

� Protect public health by reducing VOC emissions

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 6

Page 7: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Overview of SCM ProposalOverview of SCM ProposalOverview of SCM ProposalOverview of SCM Proposal

� Combines Group I and Group II VOC limits

� Eliminates the composite VOC limit for multistage systems

� Combines coating categories

� Replaces specialty coatings categories with specific categories

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop – August 2005 7

Page 8: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 8

Overview of SCM Proposal Overview of SCM Proposal Overview of SCM Proposal Overview of SCM Proposal (continued)(continued)(continued)(continued)

� Establishes VOC limits based on available technology

� Establishes prohibition of possession� Lowers the VOC limit for solvents used in

cleaning operations to 25 grams per liter� Simplifies recordkeeping � Improves labeling

Page 9: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005

Key Changes to SCM ProposalKey Changes to SCM ProposalKey Changes to SCM ProposalKey Changes to SCM Proposal

� TBAC is added to the VOC exemption list

� Two additional coating categories

� Extended implementation to 2009 9

Page 10: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Proposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesExisting Coating Category Proposed Coating Category

Pretreatment Wash Primer Pretreatment Coating

Adhesion Promoter Adhesion PromoterPlastic Primer

PrecoatPrimerPrimer Surfacer PrimerPrimer SealerFlexible Primers

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 10

Page 11: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Proposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating Categories (continued)

Existing Coating Category Proposed Coating Category

Multi-stage Topcoat System Color Coat(color portion)Camouflage

Multi-colored Multi-Color Coating

Uniform Finish Coating Uniform Finish Coating

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop -August 2005 11

Page 12: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Proposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating Categories (continued)

Existing Coating Category Proposed Coating Category

Multi-stage Topcoat System(clear portion)Multi-colored Multi-Stage Clear Coat(clear portion)Elastomeric ClearsTopcoatSingle-Stage Coating Single-Stage CoatingMetallic/Irridescent TopcoatTruck Bed Liner Coating Truck Bed Liner Coating

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop -August 2005 12

Page 13: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop -August 2005

Proposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating CategoriesProposed Coating Categories (continued)

Existing Coating Category Proposed Coating Category

Temporary Protective Temporary Protective Coating

Rubberized AsphalticUnderbody Underbody Coating

Anti-Glare Safety CoatingsImpact Resistant CoatingsWater Holdout Coatings Any Other Coating TypeWeld Thru CoatingsBright Metal Trim Repair

13

Page 14: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

14

Coating Categoryproposed VOC limit

current SC VOC limit

Adhesion Promoter 540 * 840 Clear Coat 250 250 Color Coat 420 760 Multi-color Coating 680 685 Pretreatment Coating 660 * 780 Primer 250 250/340 Single-Stage Coating 340 340 Temporary Protective Coating 60 NA Truck Bed Liner Coating 310 420 Underbody Coating 430 840 Uniform Finish Coating 540 840 Any Other Coating Type 250 NA

Proposed VOC limits effective 1/1/09

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop -August 2005

Page 15: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Benefits of the Proposed SCM

� Total estimated emissions from this category are 20.7 tons per day

� Preliminary estimates indicate the proposed SCM would reduce emissions by 13 tons per day

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop -August 2005 15

Page 16: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Potential Impacts on Body Shops

� Use lower VOC Coatings (possibly water-borne color)

� Train Paint Technicians

� Air Movement and Heating Equipment

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop – August 2005 16

Page 17: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Potential Cost ImpactsShop Size Annual Gross Revenue

Small Less than one million dollarsMedium Between one and three million dollarsLarge More than three million dollars

Assumptions:� Shops have to convert mixing bank to water-borne

coatings� Painter(s) must be retrained

Cost range: $7,000 to $50,000 per booth

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop – August 2005 17

Page 18: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Air Movement Systems

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM

18Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop – August 2005

Page 19: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

� Comments on draft SCM regulatory language by August 30, 2005

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop – August 2005 19

Page 20: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

ScheduleScheduleScheduleSchedule

� September 20, 2005:Proposed SCM and Staff Report

� October 20, 2005:Tentative Board Hearing Date

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 20

Page 21: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

Public Involvement Public Involvement Public Involvement Public Involvement •Website:

http://www.arb.ca.gov/coatings/autorefin/scm/scm.htm

•Sign up for List Server to get updates

•Provide Comments

•Meet with ARB

•Attend Board Hearing(can participate via internet)

Automotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCMAutomotive Refinish Coatings SCM

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 21

Page 22: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

David [email protected](916) 324-8177

Jose Gomez, [email protected](916) 324-8033

ARBStationary Source DivisionMeasures Assessment Branch1001 I Street, P.O. Box 2815Sacramento, CA 95812

ARB Points of ContactARB Points of ContactARB Points of ContactARB Points of Contact

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 22

Page 23: Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings SCM · 2006-06-01 · Presentation: 2005-08-23 Proposed Automotive Refinish Coatings Suggested Control Measure (SCM) Author: mjorgens Subject:

QUESTIONS?

Automotive Refinish Coatings Fifth Public Workshop - August 2005 23