Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by...

25
Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Dr. Eric Cardiff, Brian Pomeroy NASA GSFC Lt. John Matchett USAF / GWU October 25th, 2005 L Lunar OX OXygen Project

Transcript of Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by...

Page 1: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Dr. Eric Cardiff, Brian PomeroyNASA GSFC

Lt. John MatchettUSAF / GWU

October 25th, 2005

LLunar OXOXygen Project

Page 2: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Goals• Demonstrate the production of oxygen from a

lunar simulant by the vacuum pyrolysis technique, including all the subcomponents.– Model the system to indicate potential yields.

• Demonstrate the feasibility of a large solar concentration system (two approaches).

• Examine the potential for the system to be used to extract other volatiles from the lunar regolith.

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 3: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Vacuum Pyrolysis Overview

• Vacuum pyrolysis is based on the vaporization reaction of metal oxides that simultaneously reduces the oxide and produces O2 at temperatures between 2000ºC and 2600ºC.

• The reduced oxide can be condensed out of the low-pressure gas at temperatures below ~500ºC

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

)g(221

)g()s(2 OSiOSiO +→

October 25th, 2005

Page 4: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

• Has a much higher potential efficiency (6.3% - 21%).• Requires no imported chemicals.• Can potentially produce metallic byproducts from the

condensation.• First proposed by Steurer and Nerad in 1983.• The most significant experimental work, Senior, 1991, was

a proof-of-principle experiment that showed pressure increase due to gas production (order of µg) from heated minerals. O2 was not recovered or sampled.

• Sauerborn, DLR, has done some proof of principle work with a high flux solar furnace at relatively low temperature (1700K).

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 5: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Vacuum Pyrolysis FlowchartProduction of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Mining

Reactor Condensation Slag Discharge

O2 Storage

Solar EnergySolar EnergyMinimal

Benefication

Benefication:• Pit Scalping (remove large rocks)• Crushing

Structural Materials

Non-vaporized Slag Discharge

Condensate Removal

Gas Sensor Instrumentation

Page 6: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Experimental Approach

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Two different solar concentrator designs

October 25th, 2005

Page 7: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Fresnel System

O2Storage

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Fresnel Concentrator

WindowScroll PumpCrucible

Radiation Shield

Thermal Condensation

System

Coolant Circulator

Ceramic Support

Page 8: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Fresnel System

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 9: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Prototype System in Testing

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 10: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Concentrator System

O2Storage

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Mirror Concentrator

Scroll Pump

Thermal Condensation

System

Coolant Circulator

Crucible

Window

Mass Spectrometer

Page 11: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

3.8m Diameter Reflector System

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 12: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Experiment StatusThe Fresnel system is complete and operational

– We have demonstrated run times of over an hour.– Limiting factor is the vacuum window. We are currently

investigating the failure mechanisms of the window.– Condensation occurs within inches of the surface – the

condensation system is integrated into the vaporization chamber.

– All of the instrumentation is operational.The reflector system is built.

– Three techniques were evaluated for mirroring.– The combustion chamber for this has been designed and

built.

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 13: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Instrumentation

• Residual Gas Analyzer: gas analysis.• Pyrometer: surface temperature (>1600 C).• Thermocouple: surface temperature in-situ• IR thermometer: chamber and window temps.• Scanning Electron Microscope with X-ray

analysis: chemical and morphological characterization of the pyrolyzed and condensed surfaces.

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 14: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Current Results

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 15: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Current Experimental Results

• Mass loss was measured from ilmentite vaporization.– Images, SEMs, and temperature data.– Mass loss was measured to be several orders of

magnitude more than out-gassing of volatiles (tested in vacuum and oven): several grams.

• A mass loss has also been measured from enstatite– It is also significantly more than outgassing.– Condensation of enstatite was also studied. It is all

within 1.6 inches (4 cm) of the sample.• A substantial mass loss was also obtained with

MLS-1A.October 25th, 2005

Page 16: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Current Experimental Results• The SEM was used to probe the chemistry of the

slag.• Ilmenite slag shows a relative increase in the

amount of titanium present at the vaporized surface, and a relative decrease in the amount of oxygen present at the surface. This indicates the oxygen is in fact leaving the system.

• The condensate also appears to be reduced by SEM analysis.

October 25th, 2005

Page 17: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Current Experimental Results

Particles of Ti remain at the surface while the iron has melted and vaporized.

October 25th, 2005

Page 18: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Ilmenite Test Picture

October 25th, 2005

Page 19: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

MLS-1A Test Picture

MLS-1A is a lunar simulant. October 25th, 2005

Page 20: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Condensate from Ilmenite Test

Picture taken from the chamber wall above the surface of the non-vaporized slag.The material on the walls is reduced oxide material that condensed from the vapors, and splatter from boiling .

October 25th, 2005

Page 21: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Current Modeling Results

Yield should be ~10% for ilmenite!

If we heat the equilibrium to 2500 C and then condense out the remaining oxidized gasses, only the oxygen system is left.

October 25th, 2005The vaporization will shift left for lower pressure.

Page 22: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Future Work

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Page 23: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Pumping ModificationsRGA measurements have not been successful because a leak valve had to be used to reduce the chamber pressure.The setup was modified to lower the chamber pressure and integrate the RGA directly into the flow.

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

October 25th, 2005

Flex Hose

RGA

Turbopump

Leak Valve

ScrollPump

Old Design

Flex Hose

RGA

Turbopump

ScrollPump

New Design

Page 24: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Although it is not possible to examine with regolith simulantshere on Earth, the same system can be preheated to ~700K to extract many of the volatiles that are present in the lunar regolith. This includes the H2 and He3 that is embedded in the lunar regolith by the solar wind, as well as indigenous, or meteoritic, volatile species of scientific interest (Ar, etc.).

Analysis has been performed to predict potential yields of these volatile species in the lunar regolith.

The in-situ production of volatile materials on the moon will be difficult, but the vacuum pyrolysis technique CAN be used to support scientific studies.

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Volatile Species

October 25th, 2005

Page 25: Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis · 2005-11-10 · Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis Current Experimental Results • Mass loss was measured from ilmentite

Production of Lunar Oxygen by Vacuum Pyrolysis

Implementation Plan

The second flight, the demonstration mission, requires further development of those components which were not direct heritage from the instrument flight. The demonstration mission is fully capable of producing oxygen from lunar regolith.

The instrument/volatiles mission will demonstrate some of the key technologies, such as the window and collector. This mission advances the technology to TRL 5.

The pilot plant can be modular in design and scaled to meet the desired production rate.The pilot plant serves as a prototype for a future production plant.