PRODUCTION AND SALES PERFORMANCEshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/40695/11/11...paper by...
Transcript of PRODUCTION AND SALES PERFORMANCEshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/40695/11/11...paper by...
CHAPTER - III
3.1 ANALYSIS OF RAW MATERIAL CONSUMPTION AND
PRODUCTION AND SALES PERFORMANCE
3.1.1 INTRODUCTION
The Indian handmade paper industry produces a host of varieties of
paper by mainly recycling the waste materials such as cotton rags (in the
form of tailor cuttings) and small quantities of waste paper and agro fibres
like jute, paddy straw, banana stem, baggasse, sun hemp and other fibrous
materials'. The raw materials do not receive any harsh chemical treatment in
boiling and bleaching so that the quality of the cellulose is not degraded.
This aspect, with its co-friendly nature, earns for it an added advantage in
marketing.
Raw materials for handmade paper industry are mainly used waste
resources consisting of hosiery cuttings, waste rags, hospital wastes, waste
paper, wasted mats and fibrous agricultural wastes. The present study has
attempted to analyse the raw material pattern and whether it has used only
waste materials or any other useful fibrous materials or wood pulp.
Production and sales are the two factors that determine the economics
of any business. Given the cost and prices it is the levels of production and
sales which determine the amount of net profit of the business and thereby ,
its financial status. Moreover, performance in production and sales in
governed by many vital factors like availability of raw materials, adequacy
of management in organizing inventory, production, marketing and
competition encountered in sales.
A study of changes in production and sales will highlight problems, if
any, in the institutions under study. An analysis of trends in production and
sales will be necessary for evaluation of the economic performance.
Therefore, this chapter addresses the performance of the Tamil Nadu Kadhi
53
and Village Industries Board units under study, namely, Pidagam Handmade
Paper Unit, Ponnavarayankottai Handmade Paper Unit, Senbahapudur
Handmade Paper Unit and Veeraragavapuram Handmade Paper Unit with
respect to production and sales. Production is not the application of tools to
materials but it is the application of logic to work'.
The term production in invariably taken to mean ex-factory value of
output or value to be realized by the producer on sale of output. However,
this concept of the ex-factory value of output suffers from certain
methodological limitations. It includes value of raw materials and other
materials inputs used in production, even though the business under study
has not produced those raw materials. Therefore ex-factory value does not
represent the value addition created by the business under study, and
therefore the value of material inputs which are not part of the value addition
by the business under review.
In this regard, sushi states that the value added statement emphasizes
that the performance of the enterprise represents the collective efforts of
employees, management and productivity of capital3.
Further the Accounting Standards Steering Committee of U.K.
published a paper entitled “The Corporate Report”, recommending various
expansions to financial reporting one them being publish value added
statement.
One of the major activities of any firm is production and sales.
Production refers to the transformation of resources into the outputs of goods
and services . According to A. et. Adolph al., ‘any business is viewed as a
major system having three sub-systems of production, sales and finance’.
Decision junctures exist at critical points in this dynamic system to keep it in
balance with its environment and key activities of production and sales are
so adjusted that the enterprise will yield the best combinations of return on
its assets and risk assumption5. The profitability of any business enterprise is
54
directly related to the volume of production and sales achievement in a time
frame.
Production is influenced by several factors like raw material choice,
level of technology, productivity of labour, inventory levels, capacity
utilisation and flexibility, whereas sales is influenced by the performance
characteristics of the products, market acceptability, consumer preferences,
level of competition and the market promotional measures. Marketing
activity is influenced by several factors. In the era of information
technology, marketing practices and institutions have been s h a p e d b y
changes in technology available for collecting, storing, communicating a n d
analyzing information .
To make intelligent decisions organizations need accurate and line
information about sales, customers, competitors’ activities and other events
in the market place. Marketing may be profoundly affected by the right
choice of information systems and management6. Hence, for successful
business operations, Marketing Decision Support Systems (MDSS) should
be strengthened in organisations.
Transformation of raw material into finished goods catering to the
needs of the customer in general is categorised under the terminology
“production”. Production activities are to be carried out with the association
of factors of production, namely, land, labour, capital, organisation in the
wider sense. For maximization of profit, techniques, skill of work force,
managerial efficiency, modern devices with tolerable costs are to be
concentrated on.
To give sustainable employment opportunity at the door-step of rural
artisans, in the 1960s, handmade paper units established by the Tamil Nadu
State Government through TNKVIB in different parts of the State, under the
slogan (in Tamil) Samuthaya Membattu Thittam”, which means a plan of
social development. These small units in the rural areas of Tamil Nadu not
55
only paved way for economic gains to the rural unemployed and under
employed persons as the rural artisan was left without any job in the off
season in well irrigated and river belt cultivable areas but also unemployed
persons who were idle in the areas where cultivation activities are i n
dependence on the monsoon. To feed these people the TNKVIB, along w i t h
the KVIC, started a few medium type handmade paper units in Tamil Nadu
on the guidelines set forth by KVIC, an apex body functioning at the national
level.
3.2 ANALYSE OF RAW MATERIAL CONSUMPTION
3.2.1 Handmade Paper Unit, Pidagam
Table 3.1 indicates the raw materials used by the handmade paper
unit, Pidagam for 10 years. The unit produced mainly paper boards f i l e
covers and paper carry bags having a gsm of about 120 - I 50 gsm/. The unit
used hosiery cuttings as major raw material 5gms in the span of ten years.
The percentage of waste hosiery cuttings in the raw material mixture range
from 80 percent to 61 percent. Hosiery cuttings are obtained from Tirupur, a
town having 3000 hosiery knitting units and a leading export centre. Hosiery
cuttings are obtained in white and colour shades. White hosiery cuttings are
costlier than colour hosiery cutting. For the preparation of white paper
boards and other plain carry bags, white hosiery cuttings are used white the
colour hosiery cuttings are used for making colour boards and bags. The
hosiery waste consists of low twisted cotton yarn that yield staple fibres
upon repeated beating in the beater. These fibrous staple have anglings to
facilitate inter fibre banding to provide sufficient strength to the output.
Hence hosiery cuttings a waste by product of knitted garment making unit
has been used as major raw material by the unit.
56
The unit also used waste paper cuttings obtained as the by product
from printing press, book binding shops etc. The waste paper bits with the
addition of sodium hydroxide and soaking and repeated beating yield paper
pulp. This pulp will help to produce cleaner handmade paper. The unit used
waste paper cuttings ranging from 20 percent to 39 percent in the period of
10 years. In 1997-98 it has used low percentage of paper cuttings in the
mixing and in 1996-97 the percentage of waste paper was at highest at 39
percent.
The unit has used only two types raw materials namely waste hosiery
cuttings and waste paper cuttings and it did not use any wooden based
fibrous raw materials affecting the forest wealth.
3.2.2 Handmade Paper Unit, Ponnavarayankotii
Table 3.2 deals with the pattern of raw materials used by the
handmade paper unit, Ponnavarayankottai for a period often years. The unit
mainly produced hard boards, shoe boxes, tools boxes and sweet boxes that
are stiff and having higher grams per square meter materials.
The unit used four varieties of raw materials, namely waste paper
cuttings, sterilized hospital wastes, hosiery cuttings and worn out jute gunny
bags use of hospital waste in the raw material yield unopened long yarn in
the output generating higher strength. Boxes are to hold sufficient weights
and therefore use of hospital waste is inevitable in this unit raw material
pattern.
It also used worn out gunny jute bags that yield more fibres substance
in dull brown colour. Whenever the outer appearance of the board is not a
major concern and when the surface of the board has to be covered with
printed product display sheets, the use of jute based raw material is
preferred. This is quite cheaper than all other raw materials. The availability
of linguine in the jute waste yield sufficient strength to the board.
Handmade paper unit, Ponnavarayankottai used waste paper cuttings
as major raw material during the study period. It has used waste paper
ranging from 50 per cent to 59 per cent, in 1991-92, 1999-2000 and 2000-01,
the use of waste paper in the raw material mixing was at low (50%). During
these years, the unit manufactured mainly shoe boxes and hard boards. In
1994-95 and in 1995-96, the unit had used higher percentage (59%) of waste
paper in the raw material mixing. During these years, the unit produced
mainly file boards which are finish without any coverings on the board
surface.
The unit used hospital wastes ranging from 13 percent to 20 percent.
The proportion varied according to the final product variety and quality.
Whenever load bearing boxes are to be made the percentage mix of the
hospital waste has been increased to yield more strength.
The unit used hosiery cuttings ranging from 10 percent to 21 percent
with an average of 12 percent per annum. Among the raw materials, tlie
waste hosiery cuttings are costlier and used wherever the quality of the final
product is stressed. The unit used higher percentage of hosiery cuttings in
1991-92 and in 2000-01. During these years, the unit has produced higher
share of file boards as final products.
The unit used jute gunny bags in the proportion ranging from 10 to 18
percentage in the study period. Worn out jute bags are cheaper source of raw
material and used in producing thick boards and boxes where the outer
surface is covered with product characteristics and logos. The unit used
higher percentage of jute wastes in 1993-94 and in 1996-97 and during these
years, the manufacture of thick boards hard boards, and shoe boxes were
dominant.
Thus, the handmade paper unit, Ponnavarayankottai used waste
materials only in their raw material plan.
62
3.2.3 Handmade Paper Unit, Shenbagatpudur
Table 3.3 present the pattern of raw material varieties used by the
handmade paper unit, Shenbagapudur for the period of 10 years. The unit
mainly used two types of raw materials namely, hosiery cuttings and waste
paper cuttings. The unit manufactures high grade paper, tissue paper and file
boards. Thus it has used higher grade, envelopes, covers etc. The unit has
utilized cotton hosiery cuttings with the proportion ranging from 71 percent
to 86 percent in the study period. One reason for using higher percentage of
hosiery cuttings were attributed to the final output namely the low gsm high
quality papers and the other reason is that the unit is located very near to
Tirupur, the major source of hosiery cuttings.
The use of hosiery cuttings was at higher share during 1995-96, and
1998-2001. During these years the unit has produced white paper varieties in
bulk quantities. The unit has also used waste paper as one of the raw
materials in their production. The waste paper use ranged from 14 percent to
29 percent. Thus, the handmade paper unit, Senbagapudur used only waste
materials as its raw material during the study period.
3.2.4 Handmade Paper Unit, Thiruchengodu
Table 3.4 presents the raw material pattern utilized by the handmade
paper unit, Thiruchengodu for a period of 10 years. The unit used only two
raw material sources namely, hosiery cuttings and the waste paper cuttings
for producing the handmade paper products. The unit produced mainly
handmade paper envelopes, file boards, paper articles, craft boards and paper
carry bags. The unit has utilized hosiery cuttings with percentages ranging
from 75 percent to 88 percent. The unit has consumed higher percentage of
hosiery cuttings in 1995-96 and 1999-2000. During these years the unit has
produced mainly the white paper, craft paper than files, flap boards and carry
bags. The consumption percentage of hosiery cuttings showed fluctuation
due to fluctuation in the demand for handmade paper products.
The consumption of waste paper cuttings ranged from 13 percent to 25
percent with an average of 20 percent per annum.
Thus, the handmade paper unit, Thiruchengodu used only waste
materials as its raw materials in the manufacture of handmade paper products
during the study period.
3.2.5 Handmade Paper Unit, Veeraragavapuram
Table 3.5 presents the list of raw material used by the handmade paper
unit, Veeraragavapuram during the study period of 10 years. The unit used
mainly three types of raw materials namely waste paper cuttings, hospital
wastes and worm out jute gunny bags. The unit is located near to the capital
city, Chennai and the locational advantage offers wide scope for gelling
waste paper cuttings, hospital wastes and jute wastes. The unit has not u s e d
hosiery cuttings in their raw material plan due to the fact that Tirupur is far
away from this unit. The unit mainly produce hard boards, file boards, thick
brown colour envelopes, shoe boxes and other colour carry bags of higher
gsm. Hence the unit was good at managing the raw materials available from
Chennai and it has planned the output pattern using the three raw material
sources.
The unit has used waste paper cuttings ranging from 39 percent to 52
percentage with an average of 47 percent per annum Chennai city has
numerous printing press, paper cutting shops and book publishers that
yielded better raw material source to this unit. From 1999-2000 awards, the
share of waste paper cuttings showed. Tremendous improvement due to its
proximity to the raw material source.
The unit used hospital wastes ranging from 29 percent to 39 percent
with an average of 41 percent per annum. Hospital wastes are used when
white carry bags, file boards and shoe boxes are produced by the unit.
During 1999-2000, the share of hospital waste was at its highest waste was at
its highest of 41 percent and during this period the unit produced higher
68
volume of paper carry bags which is an alternative to plastic carry bags and
sudden increase in demand for paper based carry bags.
The unit also used worn out jute waste as one of the raw material. The
share of jute waste ranged from 8 percent to 25 percent in the study period.
In 1995-96 the jute waste was consumed at higher share due to production of
thick boards and shoe boxes undertaken by the unit.
Thus, the handmade paper unit, Veeraragavapuram raw material used
waste materials as raw material for the production of handmade paper
products.
3.3 ANALYSIS OF PRODUCTION AND SALES PERFORMANCE
3.3.1 Pidagam Handmade Paper Unit
Product ion Performance
The production values of Pidagam Handmade Paper Unit are
furnished in Table 3.6 for the years from 1091-92 to 2000-01.
The value of production ranged from Rs.2.68 lakhs in 1994-95 to
Rs.27.16 lakhs in 1999-2000 in current prices. The unit recorded fluctuating
trends in production upto 1997-98. From 1998-99 onwards has shown
increasing trends. From the primary data, it could be seen that the unit was
concentrating on white paper, ordinary board and file boards items of paper
during the initial years.
During this period, the unit was using beater machine and dipping vat
to produce papers and boards. After 1998-99, the unit introduced an
improved technology using cylinder moulds and auto vats to produce
handmade paper items. Adoption of improved technology helped the unit to
produce diversified handmade paper products - bags and bond sheets. The
ban on plastic based carry bags and packages imposed by the Government of
Tamil Nadu has helped the unit to concentrate on handmade paper based
cany bags which are considered to be diversified products. At present the
71
(a) Improving the capacity utilization. At present the unit has achieved a
capacity utilization of 65% in 1999-2000. When the capacity
utilization improves to 90 per cent it can produce hand made paper
worth more than Rs.40 lakhs. This will result in improvement in
profits, reduce the costs and enable better labour utilization;
(b) Improving the quality of the paper products;
(c) Training to the operatives in value added products and diversified
products; and,
(d) Reducing wastages from 15 per cent to 5 per cent.
Sales Performance
The value of sales recorded by the Pidagam Handmade Paper Unit is
furnished in Table 3.7.
The values of sales ranged from Rs.2.98 lakhs in 1991-92 to Rs. 12.25
lakhs in 1999-2000 in respect of current prices. The sales values showed
increasing trends upto 1995-96 and from 1997-98 to 1999-2000. Only in
1996-97 and 2000-01, the unit recorded declining sales. The unit was
making paper and related products just to employ the available workers and
not against orders or demand. Thus, when the unit produced goods work
Rs. 14.85 lakhs only and when production was at Rs.27.16 lakhs it recorded a
sale of Rs.12.25 lakhs in 1999-2000. Such unwarranted production of goods
lead to inventory build up which will affect the profitability and increase
costs. The unit should plan its production operations based on market
demands and not on the available labour force or the plant and machinery.
Hence the unit should explore new marketing avenues to improve
sales and support the production activities. Primary sources reveal that the
unit makes 75% of its total sales to Government of Tamil Nadu and the
remaining is supplied to those who come voluntarily to procure handmade
74
Iki
77
3.3.2 Handmade Paper Unit, Ponnavarayankottai
Production Performance
The values of production recorded by the handmade paper unit at
Ponnavarayankottai are furnished in Table 3.8. The production values in
current prices ranged from Rs.0.45 lakhs to lakhs with fluctuations in
between the years. The unit concentrated only on the manufacture of file
boards and flap pads for supplying to Government Offices in Tamil Nadu.
As the unit concentrated on mono products like files, it could not raise the
production beyond Rs.3.20 lakhs. The unit is equipped with a beater machine
having a production capacity of 150 kg per day. Based on the above
capacity, the unit has the capability to produce about Rs. 12.00 lakhs worth
handmade paper goods. It has achieved only a maximum of Rs.3.20 lakhs
worth of production, which is 25% of the installed capacity. Such low
capacity utilization of the production facilities will affect the growth and
sustenance of the unit.
In terms of constant prices, the values of production ranged from
Rs.0.36 lakhs to Rs.2.01 lakhs in the span of ten years. The peak
performance occurred during 1997-98 and thereafter showed a declining
trend. The unit should ensure a stable production plan based on the capacity
of the plant and Government orders for products.
The lacklustre performance in production in constant prices was also
reflected in linear and polynomial equations recorded as below:
values have shown positive trends, the rate of growth were found to be very
meager. This confirms that the unit has not shown any major growth is
Production. The unit has to expend production of value added Hand Made
Paper products to stabilize the operations and earn stuffiest profits. Low
growth rates have indicated that the unit could not enhance the value of
production sufficiently.
Sales Performance
The sales values recorded by hand made paper unit,
Ponnavarayankottai are furnished in Table 3.9. The sales values ranged from
Rs.0.14 lakhs to Rs.3.62 lakhs in the span often years. In 1993-94 the unit
recorded the lowest sale of Rs.0.14 lakhs due to sales returns as they had
supplied inferior quality of hand made paper products to the customers. It
recovered from the fall in the subsequent year and made a sale of Rs.2.10
lakhs. The park performance was recorded during the year 1997-98 which
was due to the buck order secured by TNKVIB, Chennai. In the following
years the sales made successive dips reaching a sale of Rs 1.27 lakhs in
2000-01. In terms of constant prices, the sales values ranged between
Rs. 0. 12 lakhs and Rs 2.28 lakhs with an average of Rs 1.44 lakhs per annum,
The unit has recorded a linear equation Ys=l .284-0.0016x the ‘M value for
sales equation is (-) 0.0016 increasing the declining trend in sales.
In terms of polynomial equations, the unit, has recorded the following
Mo d e l .
ys = 0.705 + 0.2675x - 0.0187x2 - 0.0006x3
After differentiation and substituting the values of x=l and x=10 in
the differenced equation, value of y]sl = 0.2286 and yl
slo=(-)0.2882. As
y1s10<y1
s1 the unit has recorded declining sales. The unit has to undertake
strategies to improve sales and identify right market seafront to affect the
sales Value added hand made paper product must be undertaken instead of
producing plain hand made paperboards. Market for such boards is very
80
competitive and unit has to compete with the large scale units sales
trend and models have confirmed that the unit has shown declining trends
Meeting the future of the unit.
3.3.3 Hand Made Paper Unit, Senbagapudur
Production Performance
The production values of the handmade paper unit Senbagapudur are
furnished in Table 3.10.
The unit was established in 1957 and has a production capacity of 150
kg of boards/files per day. The production of hand made paper requires
ample quantities of soft water, which is the major ingredient. The unit had a
well for supplying the water to the production process. After the 1980s, the
well dried up and a bore well was sunk to ensure adequate water supply,
This too got dried up during monsoon failures and summer period. Thus, the
unit’s production was dependent on the water availability in their well,
Hence, the values of production in current prices ranged from Rs. 1.33 lakhs
to Rs.8.81 lakhs and after 1996-97, the unit ha?- shown declining production.
The water problem was a major impediment in ensuring full capacity
utilization and achieving high production. Primary sources indicate that the
unit has often procured water from outside on payment basis, which also
affected their performance.
Similar trends could also be noticed in respect of production values at
constant prices. The production values at constant prices ranged between
Rs. 1.33 lakhs and Rs.6.99 lakhs with an average ofRs.3.07 lakhs per annum.
Declining trends indicate that the unit has to ensure adequate revival
measures to improve the performance.
The production values at constant prices have been fit into linear and
polynomial equations to assess the trends. The unit recorded linear equations
of yp=3.834 (-) 0.1764x with negative ‘M’ value of 0.1764. As the slope (M
value) is negative, the production trend is found to be destining. Further the
83
same was confirmed by the polynomial equation yp=(-) 4.6227 + 5.8629x (-)
1.07x2 -l- 0.0545x3 and y'p= 5.8629 (-) 2.14x + 0.163x2 substituting the x
values with x=i and x--10, it was found that ylpio<y'pi- also confirmed,
the declining nature of production performance. Hence, the unit should
stabilize production operations through adequate water supply. New water
sources have to be ‘identified by the unit within its premises or the entire
production using has to be shifted to a nearly place where copious water
supply is ensured. River Bhavani Sagar is flowing near to the unit at a
distance of 9 km. Laying pipe lines to get continuous water supply is one of
the options to sustain production operations. Detailed cost-benefit analysis
has to be undertaken by the authorities of the unit to decide on die right
choice of getting water continuously for production pui poses.
Sale s Performance
The value of sales recorded by the handmade paper unit of
Senbagapudur in current and constant prices are furnished in Table 3.11 The
sales values in current prices ranged between Rs. 1.10 lakhs in 1992-93 to
Rs.8.85 lakhs in 1994-95. The sales values showed high fluctuations and
there is a declining after 1996-97. Perusal of productions and sales values in
the respective years yield certain discrepancies in its management of
production and sales. In 1991-92 the value of production was at Rs.i.33
lakhs against a sales of Rs.7.71 lakhs and in 1995-96, when the production
was at Rs.7.88 lakhs, the sales was .at Rs.3.18 lakhs indicating its lack of
planning of operations. Hand made paper production ought to be undertaken
under batch production system. In such productions method, production of
the goods will be entirely dependent on the sales orders. As per the above
contrary values in production and sales, the unit do not undertake any
production plan and sales plan. In the absence of sound planning system the
unit has to bear the cost of excess inventories, wastages, under utilization of
the plant capacity and low manpower utilization. Hence, the immediate
Hence, the Senbagapudur unit has to ensure stable production and
sales plan, improve sales thro’ production of quality oriented paper products
in addition to more value added products instead of writing paper and bond
papers production undertaken by the unit. It is worth while to mention that
the quality of the writing paper is not performing well and it absorbs more
ink while writing. Thus, the unit has to improve quality of the paper through
use of quality inputs and chemicals and standardization of ph value of the
water. Further, the unit should establish market linkages with the paper
merchants and box manufactures. The unit is very near to Tirupur, the
leading hosiery centre in Tamil Nadu with annual exports of around
Rs.42000 millions. This proximity of market should be explored properly to
expand the marketing of this unit.
88
strategy of the unit is to introduce a sound production and sales plan and
implementation of production schedules against the available sales orders.
In terms of constant prices also, the sales values have shown declining
trends similar to trends in current prices.
The sales performance of the units in terms of constant prices was
found to be meager and exhibited stagnant trends. The linear equation
showed a declining trend as below:
3.3.4 Handmade Paper Unit, Thiruchengodu
Production Performance
This handmade paper unit was established by Khadi Village
Industries Commission and Tamil Nadu Khadi and Village Industries Boat'd
as a model handmade paper unit. Later on the entire assets were transferred
to the management of Gandhi Ashram, Thiruchengodu, for sustaining the
production, sales, research and development activities. At present the
management of this unit is carried out by Gandhi Ashram, Thiruchengodu.
The production values of hand made paper unit, Thiruchengodu is
furnished in Table 3.12. The values of production ranged between
Rs.1.99 lakhs in 1991-92 and Rs.9.82 lakhs in 1998-99. There was a gradual
increase in the value of production from 199.1-92 to 1.996-97 and from
1997-98 onwards the production values increased by about 100 per cent to
Rs.7.68 lakhs from Rs.3.8l lakhs. This sudden increase in the value of
production was attributed to the ban imposed on plastic based polyethylene
carry bags by many state Governments in India and subsequent demand for
handmade paper based carry bags as a substitute for plastic bags.
The production value reached a peak of Rs.9.82 lakhs in 1998-99 and
thereafter showed a decline reaching a production of Rs.9.23 lakhs in
2000-01. The unit is equipped with cylinder mould vat that has more
productivity than auto vats and ensure quality outputs. This resulted in
higher production in the later years.
In terms of constant prices, the production values ranged from Rs. 1.86
lakhs in 1993-94 to Rs.5.79 lakhs in 1998-99. The trends in production
values have been fit into linear and polynomial equations to assess the nature
of the growth.
89
Sales Performance
The sales values of the hand made paper units, Thiruchengodu are
furnished in Table 3.13. The sales values in current prices ranged from
Rs.1.99 lakhs in 1991-92 to Rs.8.12 lakhs in 1996-97 with an average sale of
Rs.4.65 lakhs per annum. During the initial periods, from 1991-92 to
1995-96, the sales values commensurate with the production values and alter
1995-96, the increase in production has not yielded corresponding increase
in sales. From 1996-97 to 2000-01 the total value of production for five
years was found to be Rs.40.00 lakhs and in the corresponding periods, the
total value of sales in five years was at Rs.32.00 lakhs leaving an inventory
of Rs.8.00 lakhs. This indicates that the unit has not planned its production
against sales or the sales could not be expanded due to the absence of not be
expanded due to the absence of marketing network. lienee, the unit should
ensure a production plan based on sales or market demands and not an the
available plant capacity or the skills of the labours.
In terms of constant prices the sales values ranged from Rs.l .98 lakhs
in 1997-98 to Rs.3.47 lakhs in 1999-2000. Fluctuation and declining sales
could be observed in constant prices. The unit recorded a linear equation of
ys = 2.1933 + 0.1356 x and has shown lower growth rate of 0.1356 against
the growth rate recorded in production at 0.4354.
91
In order to stabilize and improve sales, the unit has to establish
marketing linkages with private traders and ensure a-production plan based
on market demands. Though the quality of the paper products of this unit is
good, it could not generate adequate sales due to absence of marketing
efforts. Developing appropriate markets is the prime strategy of this unit as it
has potential to produce quality goods in bulk quantities.
3.3.5 Handmade Paper Unit, Veeraragavapuram
Production Performance
The values of production for the hand made paper unit,
Veeraragavapuram are furnished in Table 3.14. The production values
ranged from Rs.2.37 lakhs to Rs. 14.00 lakhs in the span often years. The
unit recorded stable operations during 1991-92 to 1995-96 and afterwards
the production values plunged to a value of Rs.2.37 lakhs and from
1999-2000 onwards, it made an upsurge reaching the record performance of
Rs. 14.00 lakhs in 2000-01. The unit is located near to the Head Office of
Tamil Nadu Khadi and Village Industries Board and TNKVIB wanted to
improve the performance of the unit during 1998-99. Accordingly sufficient
working capital fund was sanctioned to procure the inputs and to enhance the
production. This resulted in sudden increase in the value of production
during 1999-2000 and 2000-01. From the above occurrences, two major
findings could be drawn on production performance.
1. From 1991-92 to 1998-99, the unit has produced hand made paper
goods worth 2.37 lakhs to Rs.5.35 lakhs when it was capable of
producing goods worth Rs.1500 lakhs per annum. For about eight
years, the unit was kept under utilized and the capacity utilization was
around 40 per cent.
2. The unit has gone for increased production of Rs. 13.44 lakhs in
1999-2000 from Rs.2.40 lakhs in 1998-99 without ensuring adequate
orders and markets. Such quantum jumps in the production may result
in heavy inventory built up affecting the margins.
In terms of constant prices, the productions values gradually declined
from Rs.5.04 lakhs in 1992-93 to Rs.1.41 lakhs in 1998-99 and increased to
Rs.7.69 lakhs in 1999-2000. This indicates the inconsistencies in productions
plan and operations. High values of production in the last two years iiave
boosted the overall performances of the unit in the span o f t e n years. This
was confirmed by the linear and polynomial equations plotted for the
production values at constant prices.
The linear equation for the unit was as below: yp = 3.603 + 0.97x with
very low value of positive growth rate of 0.097.
95
However, it is suggested that the unit should undertake measures to
stabilize their production operations and to utilize the plant’s capacity
optimally. If these measures are undertaken care should also be given to
creating appropriate markets for their products.
Sales PerformanceThe sales values of rhe hand made paper unit, Veeraragavapuram are
furnished in Table 3.15. The sales values were quite low and all through the.
years and it ranged between Rs.!.12 lakhs in 2000-01 and Rs.4.05 lakhs in
1994-95. There was a continuous decline in the sales value from 1995-96 -
on wards reaching a bottom of Rs. 1.12 lakhs in 2000-01 in current prices.
Comparing the total value of production and sales for ten years, the .
overall production value stood at Rs.60.30 lakhs and the overall sales value
stood at Rs.22.90 lakhs leaving an inventory of unsold stocks at Rs.30.00
lakhs. Thus the unit met with inadequate sales and when the value of
production has been increased to Rs. 14.00 lakhs in 2000-01 it could make a
sale of Rs. 1.12 lakhs. Identification of right choice of products based on
market demands and establishing appropriate marketing linkages could alone
help the unit from its declining sales performance. The unit is located near to
the capital city Chennai and there is ample scope for marketing of handmade
paper products produced by the unit. Thus, the unit should earmark effective
marketing in Chennai alone to improve the sales performance by meeting
various wholesaler of handmade paper goods and other consumers of
handmade paper based cartons and sweet boxes.
In terms of constant prices, the unit recorded sales values ranging from
Rs.0.58 lakhs in 2000-01 to Rs.3.21 lakhs in 1994-95. The sales values in
constant prices declined continuously from Rs.3.21 lakhs in 1994-95 to
Rs.0.58 lakhs in 2000-01. This declining trends were also confirmed by the
linear and polynomial equations.
97
Thus, the unit has to enlarge sales through introduction of aggressive
marketing and utilize the potential of nearness to the capital city Chennai
markets to its advantage to arrest the declining sales trend both at current and
constant prices.
3.4 SUMMARY
3.4. 1 Raw Material Consumption Pattern
The f ive handmade paper units under review have used only waste
materials as their raw material for the production of handmade paper
products . Of the f ive units , three units , namely, the handmade paper unit at
Pidagam, handmade paper unit at Thiruchengoclu and the handmade paper
unit at Senbagapuram used only the hosiery cutt ings and paper cutt ing their
raw' materials during the study period. These units produce high grade
outputs namely, low gsm paper, wri t ing paper, f lap covers, paper envelopes
and craft papers.
Of the remaining units namely, the handmade paper unit
Ponnavarayankottai used four types of raw material namely, hosiery
cuttings, waste paper, hospital wastes and jute wastes. The unit produced
shoe boxes, sweet boxes, thick boards and file boards in the study period.
The handmade paper unit at Veeragavapuram, used three types of raw
materials namely paper wastes, hospital wastes and jute wastes for
production of the handmade paper products. Due to its proximity to waste
paper market and hospital waste sources, the unit managed its production
without using hosiery cuttings to be purchased from a far off source namely
Tirupur city.
100
Thus, the analysis of raw material used by the handmade paper units
under review has confirmed the first hypothesis that the handmade paper
units used only waste materials as raw material for production of handmade
paper products.
3.4.2 Production and Sales
Production and sales of the handmade paper units under review have
shown lacklustre performance in all years during the study period. The units
could not raise production due to adoption of out dated production
technologies in hand made paper production. The bottleneck process in the
flow of hand made paper making is the couching and sheet formation. For
couching work, Senbagapudur hand made paper unit Ponnavarayankottai
hand made paper unit, and Veeraragavapuram hand made paper units adopt
hand operated dipping vats and foot operated auto vats. Use of dipping and
auto vast is a slow process and require excessive manpower. This will affect
productions and quality of the outputs. The alternative upgraded technology
is the use of cylinder mould for couching. The use of cylinder mould unit
motor has been approved by KVIC, Mumbai the apex body for certifying
KVI units in the year 1990-91. The cylinder mould enhances production
rates and ensures quality output unit uniform thickness throughout the sheet
of paper/board. Hand made paper units using cylinder mould technology like
Pidagam handmade paper unit and Thiruchengodu hand made paper units
have produced paper and boards to the prove of Rs. 104.50 lakhs and
Rs.53.10 lakhs in the span of ten years. HMP units adopting dipping and
auto vats like Ponnavarayankottai and Senbagapudur showed values of
Rs. 17.70 lakhs and Rs.41.80 lakhs respectively in the span of ten years.
Veeraragavarpuram hand made paper unit used dipping/auto vats. It had
achieved a total production of Rs.60.30 lakhs in ten year as it is mainly
concentrating on paper conversions w'orks than production of hand made
paper or boards. Hence it is suggested that hand made paper units at
101
Ponnavarayankottai, Senbagapudur and Veeraragavapuram should
modernize their plants with cylinder mould technology in place of
dipping/auto vats for cinching. Such measure will help to revive their
production performance.
Most of the units do not have a sound production plan based on
market demands and had witnessed fluctuating trends in productions. Lack
of production plan will lead to excessive inventories, under utilizations of
plant and machinery and generate more wastages. The unit incharges or the
managers may be given training in production planning, inventory control
and quality control techniques related to hand made paper technology. It is
learnt that the unit incharges have qualification and training in different
disciplines which are not related to hand made paper manufacturing. Tamil
Nadu KVIB, Chennai should ensure that persons with right qualifications
and training are placed as unit incharges instead of mere shifting/transfers
among the existing cadres.
Despite the patronage extended by Tamil Nadu Khadi and Village
Industries Board, Government of Tamil Nadu, these units have never
ventured to undertake private sales. This dependency syndrome on Tamil
Nadu Khadi and Village Industries Board has affected the sales performance
of all the units and they have shown declining trend in sales. In the span of
ten years, the cumulative value of sales by all units was less than the total
value of production by Rs.77.70 lakhs. Inadequate sales coupled with
absence of marketing linkages and network have affected the sales
performance. These hand made paper units have vast scope due to the ban on
HDPE carry bags and the right alternative to the plastic carry bags is the
hand made paper carry bags. It is high time that these units should pull up
their socks to make entry into the carry bag manufacturing with their own
hand made paper. The Tamil Nadu KVIB should ensure that these units
capitalize on the vast opportunities available to them and adequate technical
102
and monetary inputs may be assured for successful operations and
marketing.
Another reason for the declining sales was the poor quality of the
handmade paper and boards produced by these units. Quality related to
handmade paper should have the following attributes or characteristics.
(1) Correct Grams per sq.metre (GSM) of all pieces in a lot;
(2) Absence of patches and specks on the surface;
(3) Even and uniform cross section or thickness at all places in a sheet;
(4) Particle size during beating should be made even;
(5) Binding and rosin sizing should be added in right proportion to get
better strength;
(6) Use of salt free water for beating and coaching;
(7) Uniform sizes for the papers/boards produced in one lot;
(8) For drying the papers/boards, shadow drying is advantageous as sun
drying may affect the colour yield of the papers.
Hence, the staff managing the handmade paper units and the workers
engaged in production operations may be given training in the production of
quality paper boards to meet the competition from mill boards and papers.
Mill made paper and craft boards lack bond strength due to the use of fibrous
material in the productions process. Better quality of handmade paper may
be ensured through the following practices.
(1) Complete removal of sand, impurities and dust from the raw material
by using adjusting box and ensuring cent percent removal of dust;
(2) Rag chopping of the hosiery cuttings into even pieces;
(3) Before feeding the raw material to the beater machine, it is advisable
to undertake a bleaching and scouring process in a boiler with caustic
soda treatment. These measures will ensure high quality paper
production;
103
(4) Care in beating and couching for quality production;
(5) Maintenance of uniform pressure in calendaring and sizing.
Adoption of the above right practices in the production process and
establishing a scheme of on process quality control techniques such as pulp
formation, ph of the water, use of chemicals and other ingredients, right
method of couching and shadow drying. For ensuring quality of the paper
products produced by these units, a centralized testing laboratory may be
established at Chennai or at Pidagam hand made paper unit. The testing wing
may have (1) precision weghing balances, to measure GSM, (2) opaqueness
testing, (3) tearing strength testing, (4) bursting strength testing, (5) flex test
and water absorbency testing etc. The results of these tests are supplied to
the respective hand made paper units to rectify the defects if any, and to
control the processing by having appropriate mixing of ingredients.
However, quality of output has to be ensured to improve the sales and
marketing.
Consolidating the above, it is necessary, that the handmade paper units
under review should ensure the following: adoption of cylinder moulds in
place of dipping vats and auto vats, enhancing the machine and labour
productivity adoption of production planning and maintenance, appropriate
inventory systems, establishing market linkages and improving the quality of
the outputs for sustaining their operations in future.
Thus, the hypothesis status that the handmade paper units have shown
meagre growth rate in production have been proved as three units using
lower level of technologies in couching and sheet formation have shown
declining trends in production. Two units namely, the handmade paper unit,
Pidagam and the handmade paper unit, Tiruchegodu using cylinder mould
technologies have shown increasing trends and their growth rates are quite
reasonable.
104
In respect of sales, use of improved technologies has produced better
quality of paper facilitates better sales and the only one unit which has better
marketing linkages has posted reasonable success in marketing. All other
units suffered in terms of growth rates in sales.
105
REFERENCE
1. PETER. F, DRUCKER “The practice of management5’, Allied
Publishers, Madras 1977, P. 13.
2. SUSHI, JAINK. “How much value are you adding” Management
account vol.29, No.8, August 1994.
3. SALVATORE AND DOMINICK “Micro Economics”, Harper Colling
Publication Inc, New York 1991, P. 172.
4. A. ADOLPH, GRANEWALD AND RE WIN ESSAR ANEMMERS
“Basie Managerial finance” Flo It Rinechest and Winston Inc., New
York 1970, P.31.
5. J. MICHAEL BAKER., “Companion Encyclopedia of marketing”,
Routledge London 1995, P.30.1.
6. SINGLI S.N. et.at, “Emerging Raw Materials for the Hand Made
Paper Industry and its end products*’, Seminar on HMP Industry,
Conducted by NIRD and KVIC, June 1998, P.3.
106