PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS...

45
PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT # Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject 1 13-Jul-10 Randy Mastro Jessica Schumer Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 2 13-Jul-10 Jessica Schumer Randy Mastro Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 3 16-Jul-10 Randy Mastro Jessica Schumer Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 4 16-Jul-10 Jim Walden Randy Mastro; Jessica Schumer; Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 5 17-Jul-10 Jessica Schumer Louise Hainline Email between clients reflecting attorney legal advice re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Fwd: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 6 17-Jul-10 Jessica Schumer Louise Hainline Email between clients reflecting attorney legal advice re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 7 17-Jul-10 Louise Hainline Jessica Schumer; Jim Walden Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 8 17-Jul-10 Jessica Schumer Jim Walden Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re litigation strategy. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 9 17-Jul-10 Louise Hainline Jessica Schumer Email between clients reflecting attorney legal advice re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 10 17-Jul-10 Randy Mastro Louise Hainline; Jessica Schumer; Jim Walden Iris Weinshall Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 11 17-Jul-10 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Jessica Schumer Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 12 17-Jul-10 Louise Hainline Randy Mastro; Jessica Schumer; Jim Walden Iris Weinshall Email from client to counsel discussing legal issues re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 13 17-Jul-10 Louise Hainline Jim Walden; Jessica Schumer Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 14 19-Jul-10 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Jessica Schumer Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 15 19-Jul-10 Jessica Schumer Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston Email between clients and counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 16 19-Jul-10 Louise Hainline Jim Walden; Jessica Schumer Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice 17 20-Jul-10 Georgia Winston Jim Walden; Jessica Schumer Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice Page 1 of 45

Transcript of PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS...

Page 1: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

1 13-Jul-10 Randy Mastro Jessica Schumer Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

2 13-Jul-10 Jessica Schumer

Randy Mastro Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

3 16-Jul-10 Randy Mastro Jessica Schumer Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

4 16-Jul-10 Jim Walden Randy Mastro; Jessica Schumer; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

5 17-Jul-10Jessica

Schumer Louise HainlineEmail between clients reflecting attorney legal advice

re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane.

Fwd: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

6 17-Jul-10Jessica

Schumer Louise HainlineEmail between clients reflecting attorney legal advice

re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane.

Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

7 17-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Jessica Schumer; Jim WaldenRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

8 17-Jul-10Jessica

Schumer Jim WaldenRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall; Louise HainlineEmails between clients and counsel re litigation

strategy. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

9 17-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Jessica SchumerEmail between clients reflecting attorney legal advice

re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

10 17-Jul-10 Randy MastroLouise Hainline; Jessica Schumer;

Jim Walden Iris WeinshallEmail from counsel to clients discussing potential

litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike lane.

Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

11 17-Jul-10 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

12 17-Jul-10Louise

HainlineRandy Mastro; Jessica Schumer;

Jim Walden Iris WeinshallEmail from client to counsel discussing legal issues re:

installation of Prospect Park West bike lane. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

13 17-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Jim Walden; Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

14 19-Jul-10 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

15 19-Jul-10Jessica

Schumer Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall;

Georgia Winston

Email between clients and counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park

West bike lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

16 19-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Jim Walden; Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

17 20-Jul-10Georgia Winston Jim Walden; Jessica Schumer

Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline

Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

Page 1 of 45

Page 2: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

18 20-Jul-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Jim Walden;

Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

19 20-Jul-10Jessica

SchumerGeorgia Winston; Jim Walden;

Louise HainlineRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

20 20-Jul-10 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia Winston;

Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

21 20-Jul-10Georgia Winston

Jim Walden; Louise Hainline; Jessica Schumer

Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall

Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

22 21-Jul-10Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Georgia Winston;

Randy MastroJessica Schumer; Iris

Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing legal issues re: traffic on Prospect Park West prepared at the request

of counsel.Our Conference

23 21-Jul-10Robert

Stulberg Louise HainlineEmail from counsel to client discussing legal issues re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect

Park West bike lane.Re: PPW bike lane

24 21-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Robert StulbergEmail from client to counsel discussing legal issues re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect

Park West bike lane.RE: PPW bike lane

25 21-Jul-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Jim Walden;

Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

26 21-Jul-10 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia Winston;

Jessica SchumerRandy Mastro; Iris

Weinshall

Email from counsel to clients discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

27 21-Jul-10Jessica

Schumer Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia

Winston; Randy Mastro; Iris Weinshall

Email from client to counsel discussing Prospect Park West bike lane proposal and press coverage. Re: Prospect Park West Bike Lane Article 78 Advice

28 22-Jul-10 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston; Randy Mastro

Jessica Schumer; Iris Weinshall

Email from counsel to client discussing legal issues re: traffic on Prospect Park West.

RE: Our Conference

29 26-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston; Jim WaldenEmail from client to counsel with information re:

Prospect Park West bike lane provided at the request of counsel.

First installment

30 26-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston Jim WaldenEmail from client to counsel discussing timeline of and

data summaries re: Prospect Park West bike lane prepared at the request of counsel.

RE: First installment

31 26-Jul-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline Jim Walden

Email from counsel to client discussing timeline of and data summaries re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: First installment

32 26-Jul-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Jim Walden Email from client to counsel discussing data summaries re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: First installment

33 26-Jul-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Jim Walden

Email from counsel to client discussing timeline of and data summaries re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: First installment

34 28-Jul-10 Louise Hainline

Jessica Schumer Emails between clients re: timeline of and data summaries re: Prospect Park West bike lane

FW: First installment

Page 2 of 45

Page 3: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

35 28-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Robert PaaswellJessica Schumer; Georgia

Winston; Jim Walden

Email from client to traffic expert discussing data re: Prospect Park bike lane in contemplation of expert's

potential retention.RE: Buzz Paaswell

36 28-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Robert PaaswellEmail from client to traffic expert discussing data re: Prospect Park bike lane in contemplation of expert's

potential retention.Info on the PPW brain dump

37 28-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Robert PaaswellEmail from client to traffic expert discussing data re: Prospect Park bike lane in contemplation of expert's

potential retention.RE: Info on the PPW brain dump

38 30-Jul-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica SchumerEmail between client and counsel re: history of

Prospect Park West bike lane prepared at the request of counsel.

Time line for PPW project

39 1-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica SchumerEmail from client to counsel discussing case strategy and attaching data analysis summaries prepared at

the request of counsel.Data

40 1-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer Email from client to counsel requesting legal advice re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: My story

41 1-Aug-10Jessica

Schumer Louise HainlineEmail between clients reflecting attorney legal advice

re: potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: FW: First installment

42 1-Aug-10 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Jessica Schumer Email from counsel to client discussing case strategy. RE: My story

43 1-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenGeorgia Winston; Jessica Schumer; Lois Carswell Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy. RE: My story

44 2-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy. FW: Bike Lane Story

45 3-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Robert PaaswellEmail from client to traffic expert discussing data re: Prospect Park bike lane in contemplation of expert's

potential retention.RE: Buzz Paaswell

46 3-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer; Norman Steisel

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing case strategy.

FW: Pedestrian crossings

47 3-Aug-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis. RE: My story

48 3-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis. RE: My story

49 3-Aug-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Email between clients re: fact analysis and litigation strategy discussed with attorneys.

Re: My story

50 3-Aug-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis. RE: My story

51 3-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis. RE: My story

52 3-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Email between clients re: fact analysis and litigation strategy discussed with attorneys.

FW: My story

53 3-Aug-10 Jessica Schumer

Louise Hainline Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis. Re: My story

54 10-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: Fw: New bicycle lane along Prospect Park West - I agree with your views . . .

Page 3 of 45

Page 4: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

55 10-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Jessica Schumer; Norman Steisel

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

Other responses -- some stories, some letters to politicians

56 11-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: ADA info

57 11-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: PPW Bike Lane

58 11-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: Transportation Alternatives

59 12-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email between client and counsel re: litigation strategy.

A few things from our meeting yesterday

60 12-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Jim Walden;

Matthew BenjaminNorman Steisel; Jessica

Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane and attaching list of

contacts.More info from the DOT site on

61 12-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Jim Walden;

Matthew BenjaminNorman Steisel; Jessica

Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane and attaching list of

contacts.Org chart

62 12-Aug-10 Jessica Schumer

Louise HainlineGeorgia Winston; Jim

Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Norman Steisel

Email chain among client and counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

Re: A few things from our meeting yesterday

63 12-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Email between client and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Timing

64 12-Aug-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Email between client and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Timing

65 12-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email from client to counsel re: fact analysis. Story

66 13-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminEmail chain among client and counsel discussing case

strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.FW: Safer Streets Are Out of Control! A CBS2 Special

Investigation

67 13-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminEmail chain among client and counsel discussing case

strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.RE: tip on local CBS 11 pm news on dissatisfaction with the

bike lane

68 13-Aug-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Matthew Benjamin

Email chain among client and counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: tip on local CBS 11 pm news on dissatisfaction with the bike lane

69 14-Aug-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Jessica Schumer; Norman Steisel

Matthew Benjamin; Brian Ascher

Email from counsel to client discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

70 17-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Email from client to counsel discussing study of Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: Prospect Park West

71 18-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Micha Tomkiewicz; Jessica

Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

FW: data on traffic volume and speed on selected streets in NYC

72 18-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminNorman Steisel; Jessica

SchumerEmail from client to counsel discussing community

experience re: Prospect Park West bike lane. FW: Fw: New Bike Lane on Prospect Park West

73 21-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminNorman Steisel; Jessica

Schumer

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park

West bike lane.Contact

Page 4 of 45

Page 5: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

74 21-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email between clients and attorneys re: data analysis. FW: FW: [Atlantic Yards list] Flatbush Avenue Signal Timing

75 21-Aug-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminNorman Steisel; Jessica

SchumerEmail from client to counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Contact

76 21-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonMatthew Benjamin; Jessica

SchumerEmail from client to counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Contact

77 21-Aug-10Norman Steisel Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Matthew Benjamin; Jessica Schumer

Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Contact

78 21-Aug-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Email from counsel to client discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Contact

79 25-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Georgia WinstonEmail from client to counsel discussing community

experience re: Prospect Park West bike lane. FW: Bikes!!!!!!!!

80 25-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and attorney reflecting case strategy.

FW: Mischaracterizations From Marty Seep Into Vacca Op-Ed on PPW Bike Lane

81 25-Aug-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Matthew Benjamin Norman Steisel; Jessica Schumer

Emails between clients and attorney reflecting case strategy.

RE: Mischaracterizations From Marty Seep Into Vacca Op-Ed on PPW Bike Lane

82 25-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and attorney reflecting case strategy.

RE: Mischaracterizations From Marty Seep Into Vacca Op-Ed on PPW Bike Lane

83 29-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonEmail chain among clients and counsel discussing correspondence re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: This is a letter, not an email

84 29-Aug-10Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonEmail chain among clients and counsel discussing correspondence re: Prospect Park West bike lane. This is a letter, not an email

85 30-Aug-10 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

FW: Brad lander statement about "trial"

86 30-Aug-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Brad lander statement about "trial"

87 30-Aug-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Brad lander statement about "trial"

88 1-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

"Tactics"

89 1-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: "Tactics"

90 1-Sep-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: "Tactics"

91 1-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: "Tactics"

92 1-Sep-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: "Tactics"

93 1-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: "Tactics"

94 7-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston Email from client to counsel discussing letter re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

version 3 of the letter

Page 5 of 45

Page 6: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

95 9-Sep-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline

Email between client and counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Brief phone consult?

96 10-Sep-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline

Email between client and counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Brief phone consult?

97 13-Sep-10 Brian Ascher Louise HainlineGeorgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminEmail from counsel to client discussing Community Board 6 meeting re: Prospect Park West bike lane. Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

98 13-Sep-10 Micha Tonkiewicz

Louise Hainline Email between clients reflecting data analysis prepared at the request of counsel.

FW: 2010 McClure Radar-Gun Study

99 22-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellGeorgia Winston; Michael

Toth; Norman Steisel

Email between client and counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West

bike lane.Contact between Lois and Georgia

100 22-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston Email between client and counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West

bike lane.FW: 2010 McClure Radar-Gun Study

101 22-Sep-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Email between client and counsel discussing case status.

Re: If you want to speak this afternoon, I'm at home at [redacted]

102 22-Sep-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline

Email between client and counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West

bike lane.Re: Radar-Gun Study

103 22-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston Email from client to counsel discussing

correspondence with Brooklyn Community Board 6 re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: Radar-Gun Study

104 23-Sep-10 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline Brian Ascher Email from counsel to client discussing data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

PPW Call re Affidavits and Data (Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication)

105 23-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Brian Ascher Email from counsel to client discussing data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: PPW Call re Affidavits and Data (Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication)

106 23-Sep-10 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline Brian Ascher Email from counsel to client discussing data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: PPW Call re Affidavits and Data (Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication)

107 23-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Email from counsel to client discussing data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: PPW Call re Affidavits and Data (Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication)

108 23-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

[Redacted]

109 24-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Brian Ascher; Matthew BenjaminEmail from client to counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane. [Redacted]

110 24-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin Georgia Winston Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy and data analysis re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

[Redacted]

111 24-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike lane.

RE: introduction to other affiants

112 24-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin Georgia Winston Email from counsel to client discussing data re: Brooklyn bike lanes.

[Redacted]

Page 6 of 45

Page 7: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

113 25-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin Email from client to counsel discussing NYC DOT plan re: bike lanes.

FW: Available for discussion re: PPW bike lanes +

114 25-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin Email from counsel to client discussing NYC DOT plan re: bike lanes.

RE: [Redacted]

115 25-Sep-10 Brian Ascher Louise Hainline; Matthew Benjamin Email from counsel to client discussing NYC DOT plan re: bike lanes.

Re: [Redacted]

116 25-Sep-10 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Brian Ascher Email from counsel to client discussing NYC DOT plan re: bike lanes.

Re: [Redacted]

117 25-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Email from counsel to client discussing NYC DOT plan re: bike lanes.

RE: [Redacted]

118 25-Sep-10 Brian Ascher Louise Hainline; Matthew Benjamin Georgia Winston Email from counsel to client discussing data re: bike lanes.

Re: [Redacted]

119 27-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Charlie PigottMatthew Benjamin; Brian

Ascher

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect

Park West bike lane.[Redacted]

120 27-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Linda BrookoffMatthew Benjamin; Brian

Ascher

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect

Park West bike lane.A few things

121 27-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Joan McDanielMatthew Benjamin; Brian

Ascher

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect

Park West bike lane.Bike lane

122 27-Sep-10Matthew Benjamin Louise Hainline Brian Ascher

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing potential litigation arising from installation of Prospect

Park West bike lane.

FW: Discussion with an attorney about aspects of your experience since the bike lane was installed

123 27-Sep-10 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Brian AscherEmail chain among clients and counsel discussing case strategy re: Proposed Park West bike lane. Fw: Re: Re [Redacted]

124 27-Sep-10Matthew Benjamin Louise Hainline Brian Ascher

Email chain among clients and counsel discussing case strategy re: Proposed Park West bike lane. RE: [Redacted]

125 27-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Matthew Benjamin Brian AscherEmail chain among clients and counsel discussing case strategy re: Proposed Park West bike lane. RE: [Redacted]

126 27-Sep-10Louise

Hainline Matthew BenjaminEmail chain among clients and counsel discussing case strategy re: Proposed Park West bike lane.

RE: Discussion with an attorney about aspects of your experience since the bike lane was installed

127 29-Sep-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Jim Walden Email between counsel and client re: a meeting to discuss case strategy.

Privileged & Confidential

128 29-Sep-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Email between counsel and client re: a meeting to discuss case strategy.

RE: Privileged & Confidential

129 29-Sep-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Email between counsel and client re: a meeting to discuss case strategy.

RE: Privileged & Confidential

130 13-Oct-10 Norman Steisel

Brian Ascher; Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

[Redacted]

131 20-Oct-10Louse

Hainline Matthew Benjamin; Louise HainlineGeorgia Winston; Brian

Ascher

Email chain among client and counsel discussing legal issues and case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: NBBL: Organizational and Engagement Documents

Page 7 of 45

Page 8: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

132 20-Oct-10Matthew Benjamin Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Brian Ascher

Email chain among client and counsel discussing legal issues and case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike

lane.NBBL: Organizational and Engagement Documents

133 22-Oct-10 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Brian Ascher Emails between clients and counsel re: executing papers properly.

RE: Grad Office

134 22-Oct-10Louise

Hainline Matthew Benjamin; Brian Ascher Georgia WinstonEmail chain among client and counsel discussing legal issues and case strategy re: Prospect Park West bike

lane.RE: Grad Office

135 22-Oct-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Brian Ascher; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

ppw

136 22-Oct-10Norman Steisel Brian Ascher

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston;

Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: ppw

137 23-Oct-10Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Carol Linn

Norman Steisel; Brian Ascher; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

http://transportationnation.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/prospect-park-west-bke-lane-

preliminary-data.pdf

138 26-Oct-10Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin; Jim Walden

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email from client to counsel discussing legal issues and press coverage re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Treasurer

139 26-Oct-10Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellEmails between clients re: legal issues and press

coverage re: Prospect Park West bike lane RE: Treasurer

140 26-Oct-10 Lois Carswell Louise HainlineEmails between clients re: legal issues and press

coverage re: Prospect Park West bike lane Re: Treasurer

141 26-Oct-10Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin; Jim Walden

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email from client to counsel discussing legal issues and press coverage re: Prospect Park West bike lane. Treasurer

142 27-Oct-10Louise

Hainline Georgia WinstonEmail from client to counsel discussing legal issues

and press coverage re: Prospect Park West bike lane. RE: Treasurer

143 27-Oct-10Georgia Winston Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin

Email chain among counsel and clients discussing legal issues and case strategy re: Prospect Park West

bike lane.RE: today

144 27-Oct-10Louise

Hainline Georgia WinstonBrian Ascher; Matthew

Benjamin

Email chain among counsel and clients discussing legal issues and case strategy re: Prospect Park West

bike lane.today

145 28-Oct-10Louise

Hainline Georgia Winston; Brian AscherJasmine Melzer; Norman

Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email from client to counsel discussing potential litigation re: installation of Prospect Park West bike

lane.Documents for the doorman Park Slope West Association

146 29-Oct-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Brian Ascher

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

The New York City Bicycle Master Plan, 1997 - Department of City Planning

147 1-Nov-10Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Carol Linn Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

http://ww.brooklyncb6.org/_attachments/2010-10-22%20DOT%20Response%20to%20PPW%20Bike%20Lanes.p

df

148 1-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

foia of dot data

Page 8 of 45

Page 9: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

149 1-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

notes for forthcoming cb6 meeting

150 3-Nov-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy meeting.

Forget Meeting Wizard for this one. Not many choices

151 3-Nov-10 Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: legal case strategy.

Re: Forget Meeting Wizard for this one. Not many choices

152 4-Nov-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. RE: Tuesday phone conference times

153 4-Nov-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. Tuesday phone conference times

154 5-Nov-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. CC Transportation Committee meeting issues

155 5-Nov-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel Email to counsel regarding case strategy and requesting legal advice.

FOIA

156 5-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Email chain reflecting legal advice requested from counsel.

Fwd: Streetsblog,. fundraising and political activity

157 5-Nov-10 Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. RE: Tuesday phone conference times

158 9-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jasmine Melzer

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

our foil request

159 9-Nov-10 Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

160 9-Nov-10 Brian Ascher Louise Hainline Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: NBBL: [Redacted]

161 9-Nov-10 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jasmine Melzer

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. RE: our foil request

162 9-Nov-10 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jasmine Melzer; Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. Re: our foil request

163 9-Nov-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. RE: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

164 9-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

165 17-Nov-10Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Fwd: Prospect Park West

166 17-Nov-10 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Fwd: Prospect Park West

167 18-Nov-10 Jasmine Meltzer

Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Next steps mtg

168 18-Nov-10Louise

Hainline Georgia WinstonNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Jasmine Melzer; Brian Ascher

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Sadik Kahn response

169 18-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jasmine Melzer

Emails between clients reflecting legal advice requested from counsel

next steps meeting

170 18-Nov-10 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jasmine Melzer; Iris Weinshall

Georgia Winston Email to counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: next steps meeting

171 19-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Georgia Winston Email to counsel re: litigation strategy. removal of bike lane

Page 9 of 45

Page 10: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

172 23-Nov-10 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: facts and analysis.

lane reversal on si

173 30-Nov-10Louise

HainlineBrian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin;

Georgia WinstonEmail between client and counsel regarding case

strategy and attaching document re: case strategy last two for the notebook

174 30-Nov-10Louise

Hainline Brian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin Georgia WinstonEmail between client and counsel regarding case

strategy and attaching document re: case strategy Sorry, here is the association articles

175 30-Nov-10Louise

HainlineBrian Ascher; Matthew Benjamin;

Georgia WinstonEmail between client and counsel regarding case

strategy and attaching document re: case strategy The "notebook" content, sections

176 1-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Louise Hainline Emails between clients re: legal advice requested from counsel.

Re:

177 1-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Iris Weinshall Emails between clients re: legal advice requested from counsel.

Re: RE:

178 1-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall Emails between clients re: legal advice requested from counsel.

RE:

179 7-Dec-10 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Iris Weinshall;

Georgia Winston; Norman SteiselEmails between counsel and client requesting and

reflecting legal advice.Re: response to js-k letter of 11/17 to my 10/18 letter to

goldsmith et al

180 7-Dec-10 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: suggested agenda for todays call

181 7-Dec-10Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

response to js-k letter of 11/17 to my 10/18 letter to goldsmith et al

182 7-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

suggested agenda for todays call

183 7-Dec-10 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jasmine Melzer; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

Re: Transportation chief Janette Sadik-Khan needs to back up her bike lanes with facts

184 7-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients reflecting legal advice. response to js-k letter of 11/17 to my 10/18 letter to goldsmith et al

185 7-Dec-10Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

Re: response to js-k letter of 11/17 to my 10/18 letter to goldsmith et a

186 16-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Matthew Benjamin; Brian Ascher

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

[Redacted]

187 16-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Matthew Benjamin; Brian Ascher

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

RE: [Redacted]

188 16-Dec-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Matthew Benjamin; Brian Ascher

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

RE: [Redacted]

189 16-Dec-10 Brian Ascher Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Matthew Benjamin Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

RE: [Redacted]

190 16-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Brian Ascher; Georgia Winston Matthew Benjamin Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

RE: [Redacted]

191 17-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall;

Emails between clients reflecting legal advice from attorneys in anticipation of litigation.

law suit

192 17-Dec-10 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients reflecting legal advice from attorneys in anticipation of litigation.

Re: law suit

Page 10 of 45

Page 11: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

193 17-Dec-10 Iris Weinshall Norman Steisel Emails among clients reflecting litigation strategy. Re: law suit

194 18-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

FW: bike lane and design commission

195 18-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

RE: bike lane and design commission

196 18-Dec-10 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

RE: bike lane and design commission

197 19-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between counsel and client requesting and reflecting legal advice.

Re: bike lane and design commission

198 19-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: bike lane and design commission

199 19-Dec-10 Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: bike lane and design commission

200 19-Dec-10 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Normal Steisel; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Fw: Bruce McCall's Op Art piece, dec. 19

201 22-Dec-10Louise

Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell;

Matthew Benjamin

Email from client to counsel re: community feedback and legal issues re: bike lanes. Liu on bike lane-related issues -- Google results;

202 22-Dec-10 Lois CarswellJim Walden; Georgia Winston;

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline Norman SteiselEmail from client to counsel re: data collection for

litigation. RE: Scanned section on safety

203 22-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminNorman Steisel Email from client to counsel re: data collection for

litigation.RE: Scanned section on safety

204 22-Dec-10 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Norman SteiselEmail from client to counsel re: data collection for

litigation. Re: Scanned section on safety

205 22-Dec-10 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email from client to counsel re: data collection for litigation.

Scanned section on safety

206 22-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Foil

207 22-Dec-10 Iris Weinshall Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Nyt letter

208 23-Dec-10Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Nyt letter

209 23-Dec-10 Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Foil

210 23-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Foil

211 24-Dec-10 Iris Weinshall Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

212 24-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Email from client to counsel discussing case strategy Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

Page 11 of 45

Page 12: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

213 24-Dec-10Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and attaching draft memorandum. Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

214 24-Dec-10Norman Steisel Georgia Winston

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

215 24-Dec-10Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

216 24-Dec-10Louise

Hainline Georgia WinstonNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

217 24-Dec-10 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline;

Iris WeinshallMatthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

218 24-Dec-10 Lois CarswellGeorgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Jim

WaldenMatthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

219 24-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

220 24-Dec-10 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Matt Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

221 24-Dec-10 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell

Louise Hainline; Matt Benjamin; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

222 24-Dec-10Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselLois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

223 24-Dec-10Norman Steisel Jim Walden

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

224 24-Dec-10 Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Norman SteiselLouise Hainline; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

225 24-Dec-10Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

226 24-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients re: draft attorney work product and advice

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

227 24-Dec-10 Iris Weinshall Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients re: draft attorney work product and advice

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

228 27-Dec-10 Matthew Benjamin

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

Page 12 of 45

Page 13: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

229 27-Dec-10Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline;

Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

230 27-Dec-10Matthew Benjamin Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline;

Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

231 29-Dec-10Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

232 29-Dec-10Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris

Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

233 29-Dec-10Louise

Hainline Jim Walden

Norman Steisel; Matthew Benjamin; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Georgia

Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

234 29-Dec-10 Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Matthew

Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

235 29-Dec-10 Lois Carswell Jim Walden; Louise HainlineNorman Steisel; Matthew Benjamin; Iris Weinshall;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

236 30-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

237 30-Dec-10Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselJim Walden; Matthew

Benjamin; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

238 30-Dec-10 Lois Carswell Normal Steisel; Louise Hainline Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

239 30-Dec-10 Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Louise Hainline;

Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall Georgia WinstonEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

240 30-Dec-10 Jim WaldenMatthew Benjamin; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois

Carswell

Matt Benjamin; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

241 30-Dec-10Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. FW: Request for agency action

242 30-Dec-10Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. FW: Request for agency action

243 30-Dec-10 Norman Steisel

Matt Benjamin Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Request for agency action

244 31-Dec-10 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Request for agency action

Page 13 of 45

Page 14: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

245 31-Dec-10 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Request for agency action

246 4-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Email between clients reflecting attorney litigation strategy.

call with gibson dunn on thurs

247 6-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

The cartoon we spoke about this am

248 6-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients re: litigation strategy discussed with counsel.

Fwd: PRIVILEGED & CONFIDENTIAL

249 12-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Lois Carswell; Norman SteiselJim Walden; Georgia

Winston; Matthew BenjaminEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Possible new CB6 ally

250 12-Jan-11 Jim Walden Norman SteiselIris Weinshall; Louise

Hainline; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged & Confidential

251 12-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Iris

Weinshall; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential

252 12-Jan-11 Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. FW: Request for agency action

253 13-Jan-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel discussing case strategy. Re: Transportation Committee

254 13-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselIris Weinshall; Lois

Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel discussing case strategy. RE: Transportation Committee

255 13-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Lois CarswellIris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia WinstonEmails between clients and counsel discussing case

strategy. RE: Transportation Committee

256 13-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Jim Walden; Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel discussing case strategy.

Re: Transportation Committee

257 13-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel discussing case strategy.

Re: Transportation Committee

258 13-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel discussing case strategy.

RE: Transportation Committee

259 14-Jan-11 Georgia Winston

Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

260 14-Jan-11Norman Steisel Georgia Winston

Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline;

Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

261 14-Jan-11 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonIris Weinshall; Lois

Carswell; Louise Hainline; Matt Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

262 14-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Emails among clients reflecting legal advice and litigation strategy and work product.

Fwd: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

Page 14 of 45

Page 15: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

263 15-Jan-11 Lois CarswellIris Weinshall; Norman Steisel;

Louise Hainline; Georgia WinstonJim Walden; Matthew

BenjaminEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

264 15-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Georgia WinstonIris Weinshall; Norman

Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and work product. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

265 15-Jan-11Norman Steisel Jim Walden

Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline;

Lois Carswell; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

266 15-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

267 16-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellGeorgia Winston; Iris

Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

268 16-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Norman SteiselGeorgia Winston; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Benjamin Miller

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

269 16-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: news of js-k

270 16-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselLois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: news of js-k

271 16-Jan-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: news of js-k

272 16-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Benjamin Miller Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: news of js-k

273 16-Jan-11 Lois CarswellGeorgia Winston; Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

274 16-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Louise HainlineGeorgia Winston; Iris

Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

275 17-Jan-11Georgia Winston Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline

Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

276 17-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Louise HainlineIris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

277 17-Jan-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Georgia Winston;

Louise HainlineIris Weinshall; Norman

Steisel; Matthew BenjaminEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

278 17-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential - Attorney-Client Communication

Page 15 of 45

Page 16: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

279 17-Jan-11 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: PPW: status call

280 17-Jan-11Norman Steisel Lois Carswell

Matthew Benjamin; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston;

Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: PPW: status call

281 17-Jan-11Louise

HainlineMatthew Benjamin; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: status call

282 18-Jan-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall; Jim WaldenEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: Todays NY post -- more jsk news

283 18-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Emails among clients reflecting legal strategy discussed with counsel.

Fwd: Todays NY post -- more jsk news

284 18-Jan-11 Iris Weinshall Norman Steisel Emails among clients reflecting legal strategy discussed with counsel.

Fwd: Todays NY post -- more jsk news

285 18-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Todays NY post -- more jsk news

286 18-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Todays NY post -- more jsk news

287 18-Jan-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall; Georgia WinstonEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: Todays NY post -- more jsk news

288 19-Jan-11Norman Steisel Lois Carswell

Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. dot/cb 6 meeting

289 19-Jan-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Iris

Weinshall; Jim WaldenEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Video clip that shows an ambulance diverting to the traffic

290 19-Jan-11 Iris Weinshall Norman Steisel Emails between clients re: litigation strategy discussed with counsel.

Fw: Video clip that shows an ambulance diverting to the traffic

291 19-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Iris Weinshall Emails between clients re: litigation strategy discussed with counsel.

Fw: Video clip that shows an ambulance diverting to the traffic

292 19-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel Iris WeinshallEmails between clients re: litigation strategy

discussed with counsel. Re: Video clip that shows an ambulance diverting to the traffic

293 19-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Emails between clients re: litigation strategy discussed with counsel.

privileged attorney/client communication re vacca

294 19-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Emails between clients re: litigation strategy discussed with counsel.

re: mtg tomorrow

295 20-Jan-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jim Walden;

Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact gathering and analysis.

Re: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/20110120_ppw.p

df

Page 16 of 45

Page 17: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

296 20-Jan-11Louise

Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact gathering and analysis.

RE: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/20110120_ppw.p

df

297 20-Jan-11Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Louise

Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact gathering and analysis.

Re: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/20110120_ppw.p

df

298 20-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and fact analysis.

RE: So, how'd it go?

299 20-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and fact analysis.

Re: So, how'd it go?

300 20-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and fact analysis.

So, how'd it go?

301 20-Jan-11 Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Louise Hainline;

Lois CarswellEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy and fact analysis.

RE: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/20110120_ppw.p

df

302 20-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact gathering and analysis.

RE: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/20110120_ppw.p

df

303 20-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

attorney-client privilged communication -- new development

304 20-Jan-11Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Matthew

Benjamin; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and attaching document containing attorney

work product.

RE: attorney-client privilged communication -- new development

305 20-Jan-11Norman Steisel Georgia Winston

Jim Walden; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and attaching attorney work product

RE: attorney-client privilged communication -- new development

306 20-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Matthew

Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: attorney-client privilged communication -- new development

307 20-Jan-11 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonLouise Hainline; Lois

Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: attorney-client privilged communication -- new development

308 20-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: attorney-client privilged communication -- new development

309 20-Jan-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Matthew Benjamin; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline;

Iris WeinshallEmails from client to counsel re: litigation strategy. Press Release

310 20-Jan-11 Iris Weinshall Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Press release

311 20-Jan-11Louise

Hainline

Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Matthew Benjamin; Georgia

Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. RE: Press release

Page 17 of 45

Page 18: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

312 20-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Matthew

Benjamin; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Press release

313 20-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise HainlineIris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. RE: Dan Kummer

314 20-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenIris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and fact analysis. Re: Dan Kummer

315 20-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise HainlineIris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy and fact analysis. Re: Dan Kummer

316 20-Jan-11Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients and counsel re: press and litigation strategy Fwd: Prospect Park Bike Lane--For Immediate Release

317 20-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Iris Weinshall Emails among clients reflecting legal advice and litigation strategy and work product.

Fwd: attorney-client privileged communication -- new development

318 20-Jan-11 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: attorney-client privilged communication--new development

319 20-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Where are you?

320 20-Jan-11 Jim Walden Norman Steisel Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Where are you?

321 21-Jan-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim

Walden; Georgia WinstonEmail between clients and counsel discussing case

strategy. Kramer interview and film clip

322 21-Jan-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell

Email between clients and counsel discussing case strategy. Re: Kramer interview and film clip

323 21-Jan-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim

Walden; Georgia WinstonEmail between clients and counsel discussing case

strategy. Re: Kramer interview and film clip

324 21-Jan-11Norman Steisel Lois Carswell

Jim Walden; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: So, how'd it go?

325 21-Jan-11Louise

Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall; Georgia

Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: So, how'd it go?

326 21-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: So, how'd it go?

327 21-Jan-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Emails among clients reflecting legal advice and litigation strategy and opinion work product. Re: So, how'd it go?

328 21-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Lois CarswellEmails among clients reflecting legal advice and

litigation strategy and opinion work product. Re: So, how'd it go?

Page 18 of 45

Page 19: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

329 21-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis and communications strategy re: litigation.

Re: foil request and vacca

330 21-Jan-11 Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Louise Hainline;

Jim Walden; Iris WeinshallEmails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis

and communications strategy re: litigation. Re: foil request and vacca

331 21-Jan-11 Louis Hainline

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Email among clients discussing press coverage and reflecting litigation strategy from counsel.

Re: press coverage

332 21-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Email among clients discussing press coverage and reflecting litigation strategy from counsel.

Re: press coverage

333 21-Jan-11 Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Georgia Winston;

Louise Hainline; Iris WeinshallEmail among clients discussing press coverage and

reflecting litigation strategy from counsel. Re: press coverage

334 21-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fw: So, how'd it go?

335 21-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden Iris Weinshall Email between clients and counsel discussing litigation strategy.

accident stats

336 22-Jan-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. FW: [TRN Committee] PPW Study is Online

337 22-Jan-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Iris Weinshall;

Lois Carswell; Jim WaldenEmail from client to counsel re: communications

strategy re: litigation. Re: [TRN Committee] PPW Study is Online

338 22-Jan-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel;

Iris Weinshall; Jim WaldenEmail from client to counsel re: communications

strategy re: litigation. Re: [TRN Committee] PPW Study is Online

339 22-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: [TRN Committee] PPW Study is Online

340 22-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: [TRN Committee] PPW Study is Online

341 22-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: [TRN Committee] PPW Study is Online

342 23-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fw: Occidental College :: Sadik-Khan Urges Transportation Experimentation in Dungan Lecture

343 25-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

RE: Meeting Tonight

344 25-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy. RE: Meeting Tonight

345 25-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Re: Meeting Tonight

346 25-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Re: Meeting Tonight

347 25-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: meeting ot discuss case strategy.

RE: Meeting Tonight

Page 19 of 45

Page 20: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

348 25-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: meeting ot discuss case strategy.

Meeting Tonight

349 26-Jan-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim

Walden; Iris WeinshallEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation and

communications strategy. Re: N Flatbush BID

350 26-Jan-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel;

Lois Carswell; Iris WeinshallEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: N Flatbush BID

351 26-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

352 26-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

353 26-Jan-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel;

Jim Walden; Iris WeinshallEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: N Flatbush BID

354 26-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

355 26-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

356 26-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

357 26-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Fwd: FW: PPW Study DOT "data"

358 27-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselIris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell

Email between counsel and client re: factual analysis and case strategy. [Redacted]

359 27-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenEmails between client and counsel re: litigation

strategy. New form

360 27-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: New form

361 27-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: New form

362 27-Jan-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

363 27-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

364 27-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: N Flatbush BID

365 27-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lisa Napolitano; Iris Weinshall;

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden Email between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Email about memberships

366 27-Jan-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Lisa Napolitano; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell;

Jim Walden

Emails between client and counsel re: case strategy meetings and legal advice. Re: Email about membership

367 27-Jan-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Lisa Napolitano; Iris Weinshall Jim Walden

Emails between client and counsel re: case strategy meetings and legal advice. Re: Email about membership

Page 20 of 45

Page 21: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

368 27-Jan-11Georgia Winston

Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Benjamin

Wastler

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

369 27-Jan-11Georgia Winston

Iris Weinshall; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Benjamin

Wastler; Jonathan Austin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

370 27-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

371 27-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselIris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell

Email between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. [Redacted]

372 27-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselIris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: [Redacted]

373 28-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Data

374 28-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Data

375 28-Jan-11 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Data

376 28-Jan-11 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline Benjamin Wastler Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Data

377 28-Jan-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Norman SteiselIris Weinshall; Jim Walden;

Georgia WinstonEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. Re: [Redacted]

378 28-Jan-11Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: [Redacted]

379 29-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Benjamin Wastler Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Data

380 29-Jan-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: Data

381 29-Jan-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

382 29-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Benjamin Wastler Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

Re: Data

383 29-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler; Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

384 29-Jan-11Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Matt Benjamin; Jon Austin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. RE: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

385 30-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Iris Weinshall Email between clients discussing litigation strategy and reflecting legal advice.

Joining NBBL or our sister organization, SFS

386 31-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler; Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

387 31-Jan-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

Page 21 of 45

Page 22: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

388 31-Jan-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Emails between clients re: case strategy and data analysis at request of counsel.

Re: Data

389 31-Jan-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Emails between clients re: case strategy and data analysis at request of counsel.

RE: Data

390 1-Feb-11Benjamin Wastler Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel and client re: data analysis and legal issues and attaching documents containing

attorney work product.RE: Data

391 1-Feb-11 Benjamin Wastler

Norman Steisel Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

392 1-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Benjamin Wastler Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy and data analysis for court papers.

Re: Data

393 2-Feb-11 Lois CarswellJim Walden; Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Georgia Winston; Dan Chirlin; Matthew Benjamin;

Jonathan Austin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & confidential

394 2-Feb-11Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Daniel Chirlin;

Benjamin Wastler

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. RE: Privileged & confidential

395 2-Feb-11 Jim WaldenIris Weinshall; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Daniel Chirlin; Benjamin Wastler; Matthew

Benjamin; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. [Redacted]

396 2-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Matthew BenjaminNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & confidential

397 2-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselLois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Oddo proposal re Bike Lane-SI Advance Editorial

398 2-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: data analysis for litigation strategy.

Fwd: Oddo proposal re Bike Lane-SI Advance Editorial

399 3-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Iris Weinshall Emails between clients re: data analysis in anticipation of litigation.

Re: Oddo proposal re Bike Lane-SI Advance Editorial

400 3-Feb-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim

Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & confidential

401 3-Feb-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Iris Weinshall; Jim

Walden; Georgia WinstonEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy. [Redacted]

402 3-Feb-11Matthew Benjamin

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Daniel Chirlin;

Jonathan Austin

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Task List

403 3-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Matthew BenjaminNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Task List

Page 22 of 45

Page 23: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

404 3-Feb-11Matthew Benjamin Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris

Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential

405 3-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Matthew BenjaminNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential

406 4-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between counsel and client re: case strategy and meetings.

a bit of guidance if you have time

407 4-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

FWD: Streetsblog: Transport Contractors Urge White House to

408 4-Feb-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: Streetsblog: Transport Contractors Urge White House to

409 4-Feb-11 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation and press strategy.

Re: Streetsblog: Transport Contractors Urge White House to

410 4-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation and press strategy.

Re: Streetsblog: Transport Contractors Urge White House to

411 5-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation case strategy.

Re: Streetsblog: Transport Contractors Urge White House to Revamp Enviro Review Rules

412 5-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: communications strategy re: litigation strategy.

Re: Fw: Reporter

413 5-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: communications strategy re: litigation strategy.

Re: Reporter

414 5-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall

Email among clients and counsel reflecting legal and communications strategy in anticipation of litigation. Transportation Nation published letter from walden to js-k

415 5-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

DOT safety data from the FOIL

416 6-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Email from client to counsel re: data preparation for court filing.

DVDs

417 6-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

RE: From the Parkslope Patch

418 6-Feb-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: From the Parkslope Patch

419 6-Feb-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline Georgia Winston; Benjamin Wastler

Email between client and counsel re case strategy and data

Privileged and Confidential

420 6-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Georgia Winston; Benjamin Wastler

Emails between counsel and client re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential

421 6-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline Georgia Winston; Benjamin Wastler

Emails between counsel and client re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential

422 6-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline Jim Walden; Iris Weinshall Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fwd: READ: Not in Chuck's back yard!

423 6-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia

Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fwd: NY Daily News: Transportation Commish Sadik-Khan owes New Yorkers full disclosure of her plans for bike lanes

424 6-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

From the Parkslope Patch

Page 23 of 45

Page 24: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

425 7-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

A thought before passing out for the night

426 7-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Email between clients and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

[Redacted]

427 7-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler Email between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

428 7-Feb-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline Email between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

429 7-Feb-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential

430 7-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Emails between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential

431 7-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

432 7-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Email between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fwd: READ: DOT agrees to changes near Columbus Avenue bike lane - NYPOST.com

433 7-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselLois Carswell; Iris

Weinshall; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Re: NYTimes.com: City Room: Shops Want Back Parking Lost to Columbus Ave. Bike Lane

434 7-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fwd: NYTimes.com: City Room: Shops Want Back Parking Lost to Columbus Ave. Bike Lane

435 8-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel reflecting legal advice and communications strategy.

RE: From the Parkslope Patch

436 8-Feb-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel reflecting legal advice and communications strategy.

RE: From the Parkslope Patch

437 8-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler Emails between counsel and client re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

438 8-Feb-11Louise

HainlineMatthew Benjamin; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel; Iris WeinshallEmails between client and counsel re:

communications and litigation strategy. RE: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

439 8-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Emails between clients reflecting communications and litigation strategy.

RE: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

440 8-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Emails between clients reflecting communications and litigation strategy.

RE: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

441 8-Feb-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline Emails between counsel and client re: data analysis for court papers.

RE: Data

442 8-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Lois Carswell; Jim Walden Email between clients and counsel re: data analysis for court papers.

missing spreadsheet

443 8-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel reflecting legal advice and litigation strategy

RE: From the Parkslope Patch

444 8-Feb-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Emails between clients and counsel reflecting legal advice and litigation strategy

RE: From the Parkslope Patch

445 8-Feb-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall

Emails between client and counsel re: attorney advice on communications re: litigation strategy RE: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

Page 24 of 45

Page 25: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

446 8-Feb-11Louise

HainlineMatthew Benjamin; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel; Iris WeinshallEmails between client and counsel re: attorney advice

on communications re: litigation strategy RE: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

447 8-Feb-11 Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Louise Hainline;

Iris Weinshall; Jim WaldenEmails between clients and counsel re: litigation

strategy.Re: Fwd: READ: DOT agrees to changes near Columbus

Avenue bike lane - NYPOST.com

448 8-Feb-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Iris Weinshall

Email from counsel re: organization and strategy Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

449 9-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline; Lois

Carswell

Emails between client and counsel requesting legal advice re: communications issues. [Redacted]

450 9-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall;

Lois Carswell

Emails between client and counsel re: communications strategy re: litigation. Re: [Redacted]

451 9-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler Emails between client and counsel re: data for court papers.

Re: Data

452 9-Feb-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: data for court papers.

RE: Data

453 9-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Email from client to counsel re: consultant for litigation issues.

Michael Whiteman's info

454 9-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline

Email between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy data for court papers

Re: [Redacted]

455 9-Feb-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Iris WeinshallEmails from client to counsel requesting legal advice

re: communications issues. Re: [Redacted]

456 9-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston Iris Weinshall; Louise Hainline

Email from client to counsel re: legal advice on communications issues

privileged and confidential attorney client communication re Oddo proposal

457 9-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Iris Weinshall; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

[Redacted]

458 10-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email from client to counsel re: data and litigation issues.

New development

459 10-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

[Redacted]

460 11-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselLinda Gross; Lois Carswell;

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: communications strategy and litigation.

RE: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

461 11-Feb-11Louise

HainlineNorman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim

Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: communications strategy and litigation.

RE: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

462 11-Feb-11Norman Steisel Linda Gross

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston;

Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: communications strategy and litigation.

Re: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

463 11-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Linda GrossJim Walden; Georgia

Winston; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: communications strategy and litigation.

Re: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

Page 25 of 45

Page 26: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

464 11-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy and litigation.

RE: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

465 11-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel;

Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy and litigation.

RE: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

466 11-Feb-11 Linda GrossLouise Hainline; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: communications strategy and litigation.

Re: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

467 11-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell;

Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: communications strategy and litigation.

RE: priiledge and confidential: Wiley Norville and Citizens Committee for New York City

468 11-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden

Email from client to counsel re: legal strategy related to press strategy.

latest news account

469 12-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellEmails between clients re: litigation communications

strategy prepared with counsel. RE: privileged and confidential: [Redacted]

470 12-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel Linda GrossEmails between clients and counsel re: legal and

strategic advice. Re: Read this exchange… Who's he calling bozos?

471 12-Feb-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel Linda GrossEmails between clients and counsel re: legal and

strategic advice. Re: Read this exchange… Who's he calling bozos?

472 12-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Linda Gross Email from client to counsel requesting legal advice in response to communications.

Read this exchange… Who's he calling bozos?

473 12-Feb-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Linda

Gross

Email between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy Re: Two Streetsblog postings from yesterday

474 12-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Email from client to counsel re: litigation strategy. A new twist

475 12-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

draft complaint - privileged and confidential attorney/client communication

476 13-Feb-11 Linda GrossLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Jim Walden

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategyBike Lane pr

477 13-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Linda Gross; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston;

Jim Walden

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategyRE: Bike Lane PR

478 13-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLinda Gross; Louise Hainline;

Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Jim Walden

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategyRe: Bike Lane PR

Page 26 of 45

Page 27: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

479 13-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Lois Carswell; Linda Gross; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston;

Jim WaldenLisa Napolitano

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy and litigation.RE: Bike Lane PR

480 13-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Linda GrossEmail from client to press consultant retained and

working at the direction of counsel re: communications and litigation strategy.

FW: Bike Lane PR

481 13-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

Fwd: NY Daily News: In the city's bike wars, the downside of cycling isn't counted as rigorously as the upside

482 14-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Jim Walden Email from client to counsel re: factual analysis and legal advice.

FW: data

483 14-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Jim Walden Email from client to counsel re: factual analysis and legal advice.

RE: data

484 14-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: factual analysis and legal advice.

RE: data

485 14-Feb-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: factual analysis and legal advice.

RE: data

486 14-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: data and factual analysis.

Re: data

487 14-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategy

Fwd: The Brooklyn Paper: Bike lanes -- the third rail of New York politics

488 14-Feb-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

call to discuss case strategy.Privileged & Confidential: Thursday Call

489 14-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman

Steisel; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

call to discuss case strategy.RE: Privileged & Confidential: Thursday Call

490 14-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda

Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

call to discuss case strategy.RE: Privileged & Confidential: Thursday Call

491 15-Feb-11 Linda GrossLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategyRE: Ch 11 & Bob Linn, Privileged & Confidential

492 15-Feb-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Jim

Walden; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy.RE: Ch 11 & Bob Linn, Privileged & Confidential

493 15-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel;

Jim Walden; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy.Ch 11 & Bob Linn, Privileged & Confidential

Page 27 of 45

Page 28: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

494 15-Feb-11Louise

HainlineLinda Gross; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategyRE: Ch 11 & Bob Linn, Privileged & Confidential

495 15-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Email from client to counsel regarding factual analysis in anticipation of litigation.

ny daily news

496 15-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Email between clients re: factual analysis sent to counsel.

YourNabe.com > Archives > Brooklyn > 8th Ave. fear - Moms feel unsafe crossing

497 15-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell

Norman Steisel Email from client to counsel regarding factual analysis in anticipation of litigation.

We support the Prospect Park West bike lane and traffic calming l Facebook

498 16-Feb-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Linda Gross; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden Georgia Winston

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

Re: [Redacted]

499 16-Feb-11 Jim Walden Louise HainlineEmail with attachment from counsel to client

reflecting legal advice related to communications strategy.

Here is a proposed revision

500 16-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Email from client to counsel regarding legal advice related to communications strategy.

RE: Here is a proposed revision

501 16-Feb-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman SteiselGeorgia Winston; Linda

Gross

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

[Redacted]

502 16-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Jim Walden

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

503 16-Feb-11Norman Steisel Jim Walden

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston;

Linda Gross

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

504 16-Feb-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

505 16-Feb-11 Linda Gross Norman Steisel; Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois

Carswell

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

506 16-Feb-11Louise

HainlineLinda Gross; Norman Steisel; Jim

WaldenLois Carswell; Georgia

Winston

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

507 16-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLinda Gross; Norman Steisel; Jim

WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia

Winston

Emails between client, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: attorney advice for litigation and communications

strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

Page 28 of 45

Page 29: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

508 17-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenEmail with attachment from client to counsel

reflecting legal advice related to communications strategy.

RE: Here is a proposed revision

509 17-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Linda Gross; Louise Hainline

Email between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy

Fwd: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Agenda for Status Call (2/17 at 4pm)

510 17-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Linda Gross; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy.

vacca/quinn annct re lanes

511 18-Feb-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: data analysis and related legal arguments.

Re: [Redacted]

512 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: data analysis and related legal arguments.

[Redacted]

513 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: data analysis and related legal arguments.

Re: [Redacted]

514 18-Feb-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Email between client and counsel re case strategy and legal papers

Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Revised Petition

515 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell Linda Gross; Matthew Benjamin

Email between clients and counsel discussing litigation and communications strategy.

FW: News on safety data analysis

516 18-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Jim

Walden; Matthew BenjaminEmail between clients and counsel re: arguments and

counterarguments. RE: News on safety data analysis

517 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Mark Doerr Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

[Redacted]

518 18-Feb-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

RE: [Redacted]

519 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Mark Doerr Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

Lois's form

520 18-Feb-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Matthew Benjamin; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

[Redacted]

521 18-Feb-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Matthew Benjamin; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

RE: [Redacted]

522 18-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselLois Carswell; Jim Walden;

Matthew BenjaminEmail between clients re: attorney advice on

communicating arguments to the press. RE: News on safety data analysis

523 18-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Jim Walden; Linda Gross

Emails between clients re: arguments and strategy and organization establishment and finances. latest membership info

524 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Michele Spirn Jim Walden Email between clients discussing strategy RE: further on vicious attack on streetsblogs

525 18-Feb-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline Email between client and counsel discussing strategy RE: News on safety data analysis

526 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Email between client and counsel discussing strategy RE: News on safety data analysis

527 18-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Email between client and counsel discussing strategy FW: News on safety data analysis

528 19-Feb-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

[Redacted]

529 19-Feb-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Lois Carswell Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

Re: [Redacted]

Page 29 of 45

Page 30: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

530 19-Feb-11 Lois Carswell Mark Doerr; Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: legal issues involving organization.

Re: [Redacted]

531 23-Feb-11 Ben Wastler Louise Hainline Georgia Winston Emails between counsel and client re: data files for litigation.

FW: Re: Brooklyn Radar Speeds

532 24-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLinda Gross; Louise Hainline;

Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re litigation

communications strategy.NPR - PIN

533 24-Feb-11 Ben WastlerJim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; NBBL

GDC TeamApril Lapidus

Emails between counsel, legal staff, and clients re: topics for a strategy meeting and data files for

litigation.Re: [Redacted]

534 24-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Benjamin Wastler Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsels re: data for analysis.

RE: Re: Brooklyn Radar Speeds

535 24-Feb-11 Benjamin Wastler

Louise Hainline Georgia Winston Emails between clients and counsels re: data for analysis.

RE: Re: Brooklyn Radar Speeds

536 24-Feb-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Linda Gross; Lois Carswell Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: call to discuss case strategy.Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

537 24-Feb-11Norman Steisel

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: call to discuss case strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

538 24-Feb-11Louise

Hainline

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Linda

Gross; Lois CarswellGeorgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: call to discuss case strategy.RE: Privileged and Confidential: NBBL: Thursday Call

539 25-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Email between clients regarding possible litigation strategy.

Re: further attacks from Ben Fried, and members of Streetsblog.com

540 26-Feb-11 Louise Hainline

Michele Spirn Emails between clients discussing litigation strategy and attorney representation.

RE: further attacks from Ben Fried, and members of Streetsblog.com

541 26-Feb-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline Emails between clients discussing possible litigation strategy.

RE: further attacks from Ben Fried, and members of Streetsblog.com

542 26-Feb-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel discussing litigation strategy.

Re: further attacks from Ben Fried, and members of Streetsblog.com

543 26-Feb-11 Lois CarswellLinda Gross; Louise Hainline; Jim

Walden; Brian MorgensternEmail between clients and counsel regarding fact

analysis Re: Bk Paper op ed--Privileged & Confidential

544 26-Feb-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Linda Gross; Jim

Walden; Brian MorgensternEmails between clients and counsels re: anecdotal

data for litigation arguments. Re: Bk Paper op ed--Privileged & Confidential

545 26-Feb-11Louise

Hainline Michele SpirnLois Carswell; Norman

Steisel; Linda Gross; Jim Walden

Emails between clients and counsel discussing litigation strategy.

Re: further attacks from Ben Fried, and members of Streetsblog.com

546 26-Feb-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Emails between clients discussing possible litigation strategy.

Re: further attacks from Ben Fried, and members of Streetsblog.com

547 26-Feb-11 Linda GrossLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Jim

Walden; Brian MorgensternEmail between clients and counsel regarding fact

analysis Bk Paper op ed

Page 30 of 45

Page 31: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

548 28-Feb-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Linda Gross

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Email from counsel to clients re: strategy on a legal issue.

NBBL: Streetsblog Follow-up

549 1-Mar-11 Linda Gross Louise Hainline; Matthew BenjaminLois Carswell; Norman Steisel, Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston

Email from clients to counsel re: strategy on a legal issue. Re: NBBL: Streetsblog Follow-up

550 1-Mar-11 Lois CarswellLinda Gross; Louise Hainline;

Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden;

Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: strategy on a legal issue and communications issues. Re: NBBL: Streetsblog Follow-up

551 1-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin Louise Hainline

Emails between clients and counsel re: strategy on a legal issue and communications issues. RE: Did you send an email this am?

552 1-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Matthew BenjaminEmails between clients and counsel re: strategy on a

legal issue and communications issues. RE: Did you send an email this am?

553 1-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Matthew BenjaminEmails between clients and counsel re: strategy on a

legal issue and communications issues. Did you send an email this am?

554 2-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Matthew Benjamin;

Norman SteiselLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

555 2-Mar-11 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Norman

Steisel

Louise Hainline; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

556 2-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.[SUSPECT] Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

557 2-Mar-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jim Walden;

Louise Hainline

Linda Gross; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] Re: [Redacted]

558 2-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Jim Walden

Linda Gross; Lois Carswell; Lois Carswell; Norman

Steisel; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] Re: [Redacted]

559 2-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jim Walden

Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

Page 31 of 45

Page 32: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

560 2-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline

Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] Re: [Redacted]

561 2-Mar-11 Jim Walden

Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.[SUSPECT] Re: [Redacted]

562 2-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLinda Gross; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell Jim WaldenEmails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

563 2-Mar-11Louise

Hainline

Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Lois Carswell; Norman

Steisel; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

564 2-Mar-11 Linda GrossLouis Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel

Emails between clients and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.[Redacted]

565 2-Mar-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and confidential

566 2-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and confidential

567 2-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Linda Gross

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Brian

Morgenstern; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell; Matthew

Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and confidential

568 2-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Linda Gross

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Lois Carswell;

Brian Morgenstern; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston;

Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and confidential

569 2-Mar-11 Linda Gross

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Brian Morgenstern; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and confidential

Page 32 of 45

Page 33: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

570 2-Mar-11 Linda Gross

Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Brian Morgenstern;

Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and confidential

571 3-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois

Carswell

Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Lois Carswell;

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

572 3-Mar-11 Norman Steisel

Jim Walden

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois

Carswell; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

573 3-Mar-11 Jim Walden Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston;

Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

574 3-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Norman SteiselMatthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

575 3-Mar-11Norman Steisel Lois Carswell

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

576 3-Mar-11 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

577 3-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.[SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

578 3-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Norman SteiselMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

579 3-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Emails between client and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

[SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

580 3-Mar-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

Page 33 of 45

Page 34: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

581 3-Mar-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

582 3-Mar-11 Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Linda Gross; Louise Hainline; Lois

Carswell; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

583 3-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation and communications strategy.[SUSPECT] RE: Privileged and Confidential: Weekly Call

584 4-Mar-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel; Linda Gross

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team

Email from counsel to client re: a status call, litigation, and communications strategy.

Privileged and Confidential: Agenda for Status Call

585 4-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise HainlineMatthew Benjamin; Lois

Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

586 4-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Jim Walden; Louise HainlineMatthew Benjamin; Lois

Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

587 4-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline; Matthew BenjaminLouise Hainline; Lois

Carswell; Norman Steisel; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

588 4-Mar-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy.

Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

589 4-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Georgia Winston;

Louise Hainline; Jim WaldenMatthew Benjamin; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

590 4-Mar-11 Lois CarswellGeorgia Winston; Louise Hainline;

Jim Walden

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

591 4-Mar-11Louise

HainlineGeorgia Winston; Louise Hainline;

Jim WaldenMatthew Benjamin; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

592 4-Mar-11Georgia Winston

Georgia Winston; Louise Hainline; Jim Walden

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

593 4-Mar-11Georgia Winston Louise Hainline; Jim Walden

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel and clients re: litigation strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

594 4-Mar-11 Jim WaldenMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Georgia WinstonEmails between counsel and clients re: litigation

strategy. Re: Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

Page 34 of 45

Page 35: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

595 4-Mar-11Norman Steisel Jim Walden

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; NBBL GDC Team; Linda

Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: NYT Profile of JSK

596 4-Mar-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Email from counsel to clients re: litigation strategy. Privileged and Confidential -- [Redacted]

597 4-Mar-11 Linda GrossLois Carswell; Norman Steisel;

Georgia WinstonLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

draft court papers.Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

598 4-Mar-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Emails between counsel and client re: association establishment.

RE: Grad Office

599 4-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Norman SteiselJim Walden; Linda Gross;

Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, clients and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategy.RE: My safety analysis

600 4-Mar-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Linda Gross; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, clients and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications and litigation strategy.RE: My safety analysis

601 4-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonLois Carswell; Louise

Hainline; Linda Gross; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, clients and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

legal arguments and litigation strategy.Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

602 4-Mar-11Norman Steisel

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Jim Walden; Georgia

Winston

Email from client to counsel re: communications strategy re: litigation.

Fwd: READ: DOT's 34th Street Overhaul Is Still A Danger--Editorial - NYPOST.com

603 4-Mar-11Norman Steisel Georgia Winston

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Linda Gross; Jim

Walden

Emails between counsel and clients re: draft court papers, revisions, and litigation strategy. Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

604 4-Mar-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; NBBL

GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: NYT Profile of JSK

605 4-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLinda Gross; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel; Georgia WinstonLois Carswell; Louise

Hainline

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation strategy.Re: Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

606 4-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Mark Doerr Emails between counsel and clients re: association formation.

FW: Grad Office

607 5-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Jim Walden; Lois Carswell

Email between clients and counsel re: fact analysis and legal arguments.

[Redacted]

608 5-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: fact analysis for legal arguments.

Re: [Redacted]

609 5-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: fact analysis for legal arguments.

[Redacted]

Page 35 of 45

Page 36: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

610 5-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Jim WaldenMatthew Benjamin; Georgia Winston; Norman Steisel;

Lois Carswell

Emails between client and counsel re: revisions to draft court papers. RE: [Redacted]

611 5-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Matthew Benjamin; Georgia Winston

Emails between client and counsel re: fact analysis for legal arguments.

Re: [Redacted]

612 5-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: litigation strategy and factual analysis.

Re: [Redacted]

613 5-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell Emails between clients re: draft court papers and litigation strategy.

Re: [Redacted]

614 5-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline Emails between clients re: draft court papers and litigation strategy.

Re: [Redacted]

615 5-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between client and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

616 5-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Re: [Redacted]

617 5-Mar-11 Jim Walden Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Privileged & confidential

618 5-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross; NBBL

GDC Team

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: meeting to discuss case strategy.NBBL: Weekly Status Call

619 6-Mar-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline Georgia Winston Email from counsel to client re: factual analysis and court papers.

Privileged and Confidential

620 6-Mar-11 Jim WaldenNorman Steisel; Louise Hainline;

Linda Gross; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

621 6-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Lois

Carswell; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

622 6-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Matthew Benjamin;

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Linda GrossEmails between clients, attorneys, and press

consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

623 6-Mar-11 Lois CarswellJim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman SteiselLinda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

624 6-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

625 6-Mar-11 Jim WaldenMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

626 6-Mar-11 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

Page 36 of 45

Page 37: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

627 6-Mar-11Louise

Hainline

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel

NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

628 6-Mar-11 Jim WaldenJim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel

NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

629 6-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Lois Carswell;

Norman Steisel; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

630 6-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Linda GrossEmails between client and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation

communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

631 6-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

RE: Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

632 6-Mar-11Louise

Hainline

Linda Gross; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia

Winston

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of

counsel re: litigation communications strategy.Re: [Redacted]

633 6-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Linda Gross Norman Steisel; Jim WaldenEmails between clients, attorney, and press

consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

Re: [Redacted]

634 6-Mar-11 Linda GrossLouise Hainline; Norman Steisel;

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

635 6-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of

counsel re: draft court papers.

Privileged and Confidential Attorney-Client Communication: Draft Petition

636 6-Mar-11Louise

Hainline

Linda Gross; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Georgia

Winston

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

RE: [Redacted]

637 6-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Linda GrossNorman Steisel; Jim

Walden; Lois Carswell

Emails between clients, attorneys, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation and communications strategy.

[Redacted]

638 6-Mar-11 Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Daniel Chirlin; Jonathan Austin; Brian

Ascher; Benjamin Wastler; Mark Doerr; Brian

Morgenstern

Email from counsel to clients re: litigation strategy. NBBL: Document Punchlist

639 6-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell Emails between clients re: fact analysis and legal arguments discussed with counsel.

Re: [Redacted]

640 6-Mar-11 Jim Walden Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston

Norman Steisel Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis and legal arguments.

Re: [Redacted]

Page 37 of 45

Page 38: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

641 6-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston Norman Steisel; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis and legal arguments.

Re: [Redacted]

642 6-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline Emails between clients re: fact analysis and legal arguments discussed with counsel.

Re: [Redacted]

643 6-Mar-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline; Jim Walden Emails between clients and counsel re: fact analysis and legal arguments.

privilidged confidential attorney client communication [Redacted]

644 6-Mar-11Norman Steisel Jim Walden; Linda Gross

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation strategy.

privildged , confidential attorney client communications re press stuff.

645 7-Mar-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Emails between client and counsel re: thoughts and opinions on drafting court papers.

RE: et alia -- please forward to unnamed others who were part of the [redacted]

646 7-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLinda Gross; Lois Carswell; Louise

Hainline; Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: NY1 has a copy of the lawsuit…Privileged and confidential

647 7-Mar-11Norman Steisel Linda Gross

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: NY1 has a copy of the lawsuit…

648 7-Mar-11 Linda GrossLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.NY1 has a copy of the lawsuit…

649 7-Mar-11 Linda GrossLois Carswell; Jim Walden; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Brian Morgenstern; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: Channel 2 piece

650 7-Mar-11Norman Steisel Linda Gross

Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Brian Morgenstern; Georgia

Winston

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: Channel 2 piece

651 7-Mar-11 Lois CarswellLinda Gross; Jim Walden; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Brian Morgenstern; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: Channel 2 piece

652 7-Mar-11 Linda GrossJim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Brian Morgenstern; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Channel 2 piece

653 7-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin; Mark Doerr; Benjamin Wastler; Linda

Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

thought and opinions on draft court papers.

RE: et alia -- please forward to unnamed others who were part of the [redacted]

654 7-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Mark Doerr; Benjamin Wastler; Linda Gross

Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

thought and opinions on draft court papers.

RE: et alia -- please forward to unnamed others who were part of the [redacted]

Page 38 of 45

Page 39: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

655 7-Mar-11 Linda Gross Louise Hainline; Jim WaldenEmails between counsel, client, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Re: filing your lawsuit today?

656 7-Mar-11Louise

Hainline

Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Mark Doerr;

Ben Wastler; Linda Gross

Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

thought and opinions on draft court papers.

et alia -- please forward to unnamed others who were part of the [redacted]

657 7-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Linda Gross; Jim WaldenEmails between counsel, client, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.RE: filing your lawsuit today?

658 7-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Linda Gross; Jim WaldenEmails between counsel, client, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.FW: filing your lawsuit today?

659 7-Mar-11 Linda Gross Louise Hainline; Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Norman

Steisel

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.RE: Not to beat a dead horse

660 7-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Jim Walden; Linda GrossLois Carswell; Norman

Steisel

Email between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Not to beat a dead horse

661 7-Mar-11Norman Steisel Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients and counsel re: litigation strategy. Re: privileged and confidential

662 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Lois Carswell; Linda

GrossNorman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew BenjaminEmails between clients and counsel re: legal

arguments and draft communications. Re: New release

663 8-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Linda GrossNorman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: legal arguments and draft communications.Re: New release

664 8-Mar-11 Louise Hainline

Norman Steisel Emails between clients re: legal arguments and draft communications.

Re: New release

665 8-Mar-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Emails between counsel re: legal arguments and draft communications.

Re: New release

666 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Jim Walden; Linda

GrossNorman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

667 8-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Jim Walden; Linda GrossNorman Steisel; Louise

Hainline; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

Page 39 of 45

Page 40: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

668 8-Mar-11 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Norman

Steisel; Jim WaldenLinda Gross; Louise

Hainline; Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

669 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineMatthew Benjamin; Norman

Steisel; Jim WaldenLinda Gross; Lois Carswell;

Georgia Winston

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

670 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Norman Steisel;

Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; NBBL

GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: Privileged and Confidential

671 8-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin Norman Steisel; Jim Walden

Linda Gross; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Georgia

Winston

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

672 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Lois Carswell; Linda

GrossNorman Steisel; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

673 8-Mar-11 Lois CarswellNorman Steisel; Matthew

Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; NBBL

GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.Re: Privileged and Confidential

674 8-Mar-11Norman Steisel Jim Walden

Linda Gross; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.Re: New release

675 8-Mar-11 Jim Walden Lois Carswell; Linda GrossNorman Steisel; Louise

Hainline; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

676 8-Mar-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; NBBL

GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.Re: Privileged and Confidential

677 8-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Jim Walden; Linda GrossNorman Steisel; Lois

Carswell; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: New release

678 8-Mar-11 Jim Walden Linda Gross

Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Georgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.New release

Page 40 of 45

Page 41: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

679 8-Mar-11 Lois CarswellMatthew Benjamin; Louise

Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.Re: Privileged and Confidential

680 8-Mar-11Louise

Hainline

Matthew Benjamin; Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman

Steisel

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.RE: Privileged and Confidential

681 8-Mar-11Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; NBBL GDC Team; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.Privileged and Confidential

682 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLinda Gross; Lois Carswell; Robert

Krakovski

Donald Matteson; Carol Linn; Robert Linn; Jasmine

Melzer; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.

RE: [SUSPECT] RE: 'Small Group of Anti-Bike, Well-Connected, Wealthy Park Slopers'

683 8-Mar-11 Robert Linn Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Robert Krakovski; Linda Gross; Donald Matteson; Carol

Linn; Jasmine Melzer; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.

Re: 'Small Group of Anti-Bike, Well-Connected, Wealthy Park Slopers'

684 8-Mar-11 Linda GrossLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Robert Krakovski

Donald Matteson; Carol Linn; Robert Linn; Jasmine

Melzer; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.

RE: [SUSPECT] RE: 'Small Group of Anti-Bike, Well-Connected, Wealthy Park Slopers'

685 8-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Robert Krakovski;

Linda Gross

Donald Matteson; Carol Linn; Robert Linn; Jasmine

Melzer; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel, and clients

re: communications strategy re: litigation.

RE: 'Small Group of Anti-Bike, Well-Connected, Wealthy Park Slopers'

686 8-Mar-11 Mark Doerr Louise Hainline Emails between clients and counsel re: case strategy and communications.

RE: et alia -- please forward to unnamed others who were part of the [redacted]

687 8-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Robert Linn

Lois Carswell; Robert Krakovski; Linda Gross; Donald Matteson; Carol

Linn; Jasmine Melzer; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.

RE: 'Small Group of Anti-Bike, Well-Connected, Wealthy Park Slopers'

688 9-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLinda Gross; Lois Carswell; Louise

Hainline

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.RE: Great work

689 9-Mar-11 Linda GrossJim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise

Hainline

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

communications strategy re: litigation.Great work

690 22-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Linda Gross; Lois

Carswell; Robert Krakovski Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

Page 41 of 45

Page 42: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

691 22-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Linda Gross; Lois

Carswell; Robert Krakovski Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

692 22-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLinda Gross; Jim Walden; Lois

Carswell; Robert Krakovski

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

693 22-Mar-11 Linda GrossLouise Hainline; Jim Walden; Lois

Carswell; Robert Krakovski

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

694 22-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Lois Carswell; Robert

Krakovski; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

695 22-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Robert Krakovski; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

696 22-Mar-11Louise

HainlineLois Carswell; Jim Walden; Robert

Krakovski; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

697 22-Mar-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jim Walden; Robert Krakovski; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

698 22-Mar-11Robert

KrakovskiJim Walden; Lois Carswell; Louise

Hainline; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

699 22-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Robert Krakovski; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

700 22-Mar-11 Lois CarswellJim Walden; Robert Krakovski; Louise Hainline; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

701 22-Mar-11 Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Robert Krakovski;

Louise Hainline; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

702 22-Mar-11 Jim WaldenRobert Krakovski; Lois Carswell;

Louise Hainline; Linda Gross

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

Page 42 of 45

Page 43: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

703 22-Mar-11Robert

KrakovskiLois Carswell; Louise Hainline;

Linda Gross; Jim Walden

Emails between counsel, clients, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: factual analysis for legal positions and communications.

Re: Brian Lehrer is on for tomorrow (Wed)--11:25 am

704 24-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.Re: Lehrer show

705 24-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.Re: Jim Walden re: Prospect Park

706 24-Mar-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.Re: NPR today

707 24-Mar-11Louise

Hainline Linda Gross Louise HainlineEmails between clients and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation

communications strategy.RE: Jim Walden re: Prospect Park

708 24-Mar-11 Linda Gross Louise Hainline Louise HainlineEmails between clients and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re: litigation

communications strategy.RE: Jim Walden re: Prospect Park

709 24-Mar-11Norman Steisel Jim Walden

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin; Linda

Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.Re: Jim Walden re: Prospect Park

710 24-Mar-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Lois Carswell;

Norman SteiselGeorgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.RE: Jim Walden re: Prospect Park

711 31-Mar-11Robert

KrakovskiLois Carswell; Louise Hainline;

Linda Gross; Jim Walden

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel

requesting and reflecting legal strategy regarding ongoing litigation.

NBBL Strategy

712 31-Mar-11 Jim WaldenRobert Krakovski; Lois Carswell;

Louise Hainline; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel

requesting and reflecting legal strategy regarding ongoing litigation.

RE: NBBL Strategy

713 12-Apr-11 Pamela Pollack

Louise Hainline; Micha Tomkiewicz Emails to and from clients and in-house counsel regarding FOIL request.

FOIL request-bike lane

714 12-Apr-11Louise

Hainline

Jim Walden; Linda Gross; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained by and working at the direction of counsel

re: litigation communications strategy.Privileged and confidential

715 13-Apr-11Norman Steisel Matthew Benjamin

Louise Hainline; Lois Carswell; Linda Gross; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.Re: April 11 letter

Page 43 of 45

Page 44: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

716 14-Apr-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy. RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

717 14-Apr-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell Emails between clients re: case strategy and counsel's advice.

RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

718 14-Apr-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline Emails between clients re: case strategy and counsel's advice.

RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

719 14-Apr-11 Lois Carswell Norman Steisel; Louise Hainline Emails between clients re: case strategy and counsel's advice.

RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

720 14-Apr-11Louise

Hainline Jim Walden; Norman SteiselLois Carswell; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy.RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again;

he wanted your v/m [redacted]

721 14-Apr-11Louise

Hainline Norman Steisel; Jim WaldenLois Carswell; Georgia

Winston; Matthew Benjamin Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy.RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again;

he wanted your v/m [redacted]

722 14-Apr-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Lois Carswell; Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy. RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

723 14-Apr-11 Louise Hainline

Lois Carswell; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy. RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

724 14-Apr-11 Lois Carswell Louise Hainline; Jim Walden; Norman Steisel

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy. RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

725 14-Apr-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Emails between counsel and clients re: case strategy. RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

726 14-Apr-11 Norman Steisel

Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois

Carswell; Georgia Winston; Matthew Benjamin

Email between counsel and clients re: communications strategy re: litigation.

RE: Privileged & confidential - Paul Steely White called again; he wanted your v/m [redacted]

727 25-Apr-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman SteiselGeorgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.Privileged & confidential

728 25-Apr-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Lois Carswell;

Norman SteiselGeorgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin; Linda Gross

Emails between clients, counsel, and press consultant retained and working at the direction of counsel re:

litigation communications strategy.RE: Privileged & confidential

729 25-Apr-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden Emails between counsel and client reflecting legal advice.

RE: Privileged & confidential

730 25-Apr-11 Jim WaldenLouise Hainline; Lois Carswell;

Norman SteiselGeorgia Winston; Matthew

Benjamin; Linda GrossEmail between counsel and clients re: communications strategy re: litigation. RE: Privileged & confidential

731 2-May-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Emails requesting and reflecting legal strategy regarding ongoing litigation.

Re: [Redacted]

732 2-May-11 Norman Steisel

Louise Hainline Jim Walden Emails requesting and reflecting legal strategy regarding ongoing litigation.

Fwd: [Redacted]

733 15-Jun-11Georgia Winston

Lois Carswell; Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel

Jim Walden; Matthew Benjamin; GDC NBBL

Attorneys Distribution List

Email containing attorney work product prepared in ongoing litigation Privileged & Confidential -- Attorney-Client Communication

Page 44 of 45

Page 45: PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY … · PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT Subject Iris Weinshall Emails

PRIVILEGE LOG -- DOCUMENTS PROTECTED AS ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGED AND/OR ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT

# Date Author Recipient(s) CC Privilege Description Subject

734 27-Jun-11 Louise Hainline

Jim Walden; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell; Linda Brieda

Matthew Benjamin; Georgia Winston

Emails requesting and reflecting legal strategy regarding ongoing litigation.

RE: Privileged and Confidential: Levin correspondence about the Bike Plan for PPW

735 27-Jun-11 Louise Hainline

Matthew Benjamin Georgia Winston Emails between attorneys and clients re: legal advice and factual analysis.

RE: Privileged and Confidential: Levin correspondence about the Bike Plan for PPW

736 29-Jun-11Louise

HainlineJim Walden; Georgia Winston;

Matthew BenjaminNorman Steisel; Lois

CarswellEmails requesting and reflecting legal strategy

regarding ongoing litigation.

Privileged and Confidential: IMPORTANT LEGAL NOTICE: PRESERVATION OF RECORDS Streetsblog v. The City

University of New York #10727611

737 29-Jun-11 Lois CarswellLouise Hainline; Jim Walden; Georgia Winston; Matthew

BenjaminNorman Steisel

Emails reflecting legal advice obtained from counsel regarding ongoing litigation.

Re: Privileged and Confidential: IMPORTANT LEGAL NOTICE: PRESERVATION OF RECORDS Streetsblog v. The City

University of New York #10727611

738 1-Jul-11 Georgia Winston

Louise Hainline; Norman Steisel; Lois Carswell

Email from counsel to clients re: legal documents. Privileged & Confidential

Page 45 of 45