Principles of Management Project

download Principles of Management Project

of 33

Transcript of Principles of Management Project

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    1/33

    Project Work Of Principles Of Management

    On

    Apply BCG Matrix on any operating unit and project the

    actions desired from top management in the list of the same

    Submitted To:-

    Dr. Manoj Kumar Sinha

    Faculty of Business Management

    Submitted By :-

    Kumar Vikram Aditya

    Roll No. 1023

    1st Year B.B.A. LL.B. (Hons)

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    2/33

    CERTIFICATE

    This is to certify that Researcher Project Workentitled Apply BCG Matrix on any operating

    unit and project the actions desired from top management in the list of the same. Submitted

    is the record of work carried out during semester-I of First Year B.B.A. Ll.B. Course for the

    academic year 2013-2018 under my supervision and guidance in conformity with the syllabus

    prescribed by Chanakya National Law University.

    Place: PATNA.

    Date:

    GUIDE

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    3/33

    Apply BCG Matrix on any operating unit and project the actions desired

    from top management in the list of the same

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Introduction Hypothesis Research Methodology BCG MatrixMeaning, Limitations And Diagram Introduction to BCG Matrix And Nestle India Studying the construction of BCG matrix for Nestle Conclusion Suggestions Limitations Bibliography AnnexureI (List of Nestle Products worldwide) AnnexureII (List of Nestle Products offered in India) AnnexureIII (List of provisional stores surveyed for the study)

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    4/33

    Introduction

    Nestle India is the third largest food industry in India with large range of milk products such

    as infant milk, weaning cereals and from instant coffee and chocolates to confectionery and

    ready-to-cook food operating from six units and eight copackaging units.

    Nestle means little nest. Nestle began its operation from Switzerland in 1867 under henri

    nestle with commitment towards providing nutritive health and fun products like chocolates

    .The critical factors behind the corporate excellence of Nestle India is the adoption of best

    business principles for promoting their work culture and human resource initiatives for their

    growth and development .General principles of nestle is that it is more people and product

    oriented than systems oriented, committed to create value for their share holders,

    decentralized within the limits imposed by basic policy and strategy decisions as well as

    group-wide needs for coordination and management development and committed to the

    concept of continuous improvement. Nestle India does not favour short-term profit at the

    expenses of successful long-term business development. It also recognizes the legitimate

    rights of the consumers of the nestle brands to know how the company operates. As for

    relationship with business partners, Nestle India insists on honesty, integrity and fairness in

    all aspects of its business and expects the same in its relationship with all its business

    partners. Nestle India requires its management and employees to avoid such personal

    activities and financial interests as would conflict, or appear to conflict with their

    commitment to their jobs.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    5/33

    HYPOTHESIS

    The hypothesis of the present study are ,

    (i) To place the various brands of Nestle in India in the matrix as suggested by the BostonConsultancy Group, as based upon the data empirically collected.

    (ii) To analyse the brands so placed and critically compare their placement.

    (iii) To compare the outcomes so obtained and generate suggestions.

    The achievement of the above Hypothesis has been made by following the methodology as

    stated below.

    RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

    SCOPE:

    This study aims to study the products offered by Nestle in India by placing them on the BCG

    matrix. The placement of the products on the matrix shall be on the basis of the empirical

    data collected in Patna (India) from a number of sizeable provisional stores which place

    Nestle products for sale.

    METHODOLOGY:

    The present study constitutes the construction and study of BCG matrix of Nestle products on

    the basis of empirical data collected about Nestle products from six provisional stores in

    Patna.

    TECHNIQUES ADOPTED FOR DATA COLLECTION:

    (A) Interview method

    (B) Internet Survey

    (C) Opinion Generation

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    6/33

    BCG Matrix Meaning, Limitations And Diagram

    Boston Consulting Group (BCG) Matrix is a four celled matrix (a 2 * 2 matrix) developed by

    BCG, USA. It is the most renowned corporate portfolio analysis tool. It provides a graphic

    representation for an organization to examine different businesses in its portfolio on the basis

    of their related market share and industry growth rates. It is a two dimensional analysis on

    management of SBUs (Strategic Business Units). In other words, it is a comparative analysis

    of business potential and the evaluation of environment. According to this matrix, business

    could be classified as high or low according to their industry growth rate and relative market

    share.

    Relative Market Share = SBU Sales this year leading competitors sales this year.

    Market Growth Rate = Industry sales this year - Industry Sales last year.

    The analysis requires that both measures be calculated for each SBU. The dimension of

    business strength, relative market share will measure comparative advantage indicated by

    market dominance. The key theory underlying this is existence of an experience curve and

    that market share is achieved due to overall cost leadership.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    7/33

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    8/33

    - if nothing is done to change the market share, question marks will simply absorb great

    amounts of cash and later, as the growth stops, a dog.

    - either invest heavily or sell off or invest nothing and generate whatever cash it can. Increase

    market share or deliver cash.

    The BCG Matrix method can help understand a frequently made strategy mistake: having a

    one-size-fits-all-approach to strategy, such as a generic growth target (9 percent per year) or a

    generic return on capital of say 9,5% for an entire corporation.

    In such a scenario:

    A. Cash Cows Business Units will beat their profit target easily; their management have an

    easy job and are often praised anyhow. Even worse, they are often allowed to reinvest

    substantial cash amounts in their businesses which are mature and not growing anymore.

    B. Dogs Business Units fight an impossible battle and, even worse, investments are made

    now and then in hopeless attempts to 'turn the business around'.

    C. As a result (all) Question Marks and Stars Business Units get mediocre size investment

    funds. In this way they are unable to ever become cash cows. These inadequate invested sums

    of money are a waste of money. Either these SBUs should receive enough investment funds

    to enable them to achieve a real market dominance and become a cash cow (or star), or

    otherwise companies are advised to disinvest and try to get whatever possible cash out of the

    question marks that were not selected.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    9/33

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    10/33

    Introduction to BCG Matrix And Nestle India

    Need for evaluation

    In the commercial arena, the choice of an effective strategy is perhaps the most important and

    the toughest decision to take. The decision to select among the grand strategies and deciding

    upon which strategy will best meet the enterprises objectives is rendered complex by

    multifarious considerations. Nevertheless, the decision to replace the product once its

    positioning fails is a yet more complex decision. The beauty of BCG Matrix, a Matrixdeveloped by a group known as Boston Consulting Group, USA, is that it seeks to place the

    different products of an organization in different grids such as to analyze them in a

    comparative manner in terms of profitability or in terms of (a) percentage growth in sales and

    (b) market share position, to be exact. Thus, it gives an opportunity of self assessment to the

    organization to reassess its product positioning and thus come out with alternative solution if

    the original placement of the products in the market does not meet the desired level of

    growth.

    BCG Matrix explained

    Thus, when all the products of the company are put in four cells (thus it actually provides an

    opportunity to reassess the entire position of the company in terms of all the products it offers

    to the market), the market standing of the company can be analysed in four different classes

    namely, stars, cash cows, dogs and question marks. Each of these classes have a different

    meaning attached to them and can be represented on the matrix as follows.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    11/33

    It is significant to note here that this matrix denotes the areas of strategic search for an

    organization i.e. how to proceed in replacing the products if they are not found to be of

    satisfactory placement.1Nestle India and BCG Matrix

    With headquarters at Vevey, Switzerland and established in 1866 by henri nestle, Nestle has

    growthtoday to be the worlds biggest food and beverages company. Established in the

    strong foundation of growth through innovation and renovation, the company is known today

    byits several strong brands which are dominating the markets the world over. Nestle India is

    a subsidiary of Nestle S.A. of Switzerland. With six factories and a large number of co-

    packers, Nestle India is a vibrant company offering a number of productsin the Indian

    market. A number of brands are offered by the company in the country ofwhich while some

    have already established a strong hold, many others exhibitenormous prospects to dominate

    the market and are only waiting for a favourableopportunity or appropriate and sizeable

    promotional campaign by the company.The present task seeks to undertake a construction of

    a BCG matrix for the productsoffered by Nestle India Ltd. in India2 and an analysis thereon.

    The aim is to criticallyanalyse the relative positioning of the various products offered by

    Nestle India and toexamine them in the light of the prospects available and if the dogs and

    question markscan be converted to sizable opportunities and well established brands.

    1

    For Details Refer BCG Matrix2Refer to AnnexureI and Annexure II for list of all the products of Nestle International and Annexure III for

    list of products offered by Nestle in India.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    12/33

    A STUDY OF THE CONSTRUCTION OF BCG MATRIX FOR NESTLE

    INDIA

    Nestle has a wide range of products and is the market leader in food business over the world.

    However, it has a limited number of brands on India. The peculiarity of these brands is that

    those brands which are established ones are really ones which dominate the market and make

    almost no room for any competition while, the brands which are not so well established are

    not so on account of any qualitative deficiency but either because of a weak promotional

    campaign of the company or on account of a misplacement of the product in the target

    segment. Nevertheless, we go ahead with our study. The present chapter is devised in the

    manner that the overall matrix comes first and then each products placed on the matrix is

    explained as to why it finds a place in the grid it has been placed in the matrix, along with the

    relevant empirical data reproduced therein.

    Also, in the matrix itself, though the products have been placed in one of the categories, their

    projected placement i.e. where should be or can be placed with a promotional exercise, is also

    indicated by an arrow which shows the appropriate category in which the product is aimed to

    be placed. For example, Maggi Noodles has been the pioneer of the Noodle industry in the

    Indian market. But as far as Nestle is concerned, it is only a cash cow. Therefore it is aimed

    to be placed in the Stars. This is indicated by an upward arrow which signifies that the

    product is aimed for repositioning and the direction of the arrow shows the grid where it is

    heading to, in this case upward arrow is indicating to the stars.

    Also, besides the intended placement of the products, there are some products which need to

    be taken off the market. For example, Nestls world dominating brand of water, Nestle Pure

    Life, was taken off the Indian market on 29.12.2003 when strategically it was found unviable

    to continue with it. This shows the intention of Nestle not to play in the Indian water market

    though it has a well established base of the same brand abroad and it could have reaffirmed a

    market share had it decided to introduce Perrier, another famous water brand of Nestle.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    13/33

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    14/33

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    15/33

    (3) Its different variants have kept competitors at bay and its finds a place easily at almost

    every general or provisional store in the Indian market.

    (4) It is a major contributor for Nestle Indias revenues.

    Intended Placement:

    Comments:(1) With the increase in population and the growth market in the country Nestle

    India can do much better in terms of registering more shares by an aggressive promotional

    drive.

    (2) It needs to take aggressive steps to enter into those households where traditionally

    followed methods of feeding new born infants are followed. The market exists for Cereals to

    expand and though it is already a star, it can do much better in terms of expanding its shares

    by adopting market development strategies.

    Product: Maggi Noodles

    Position: Cash Cow

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) It is surprising to note that Maggi Noodles, which has found more households of

    consumption in India that any other country in the world and has become the first preference

    of Indian children in terms of instant food, is only a cash cow and not a star.

    (2) The reason essentially lies in the fact that though Maggi Noodles has a significantly high

    market share in the Noodles market in India, the market growth rate of Noodle consumption

    is not very high.

    (3) Though the number of repeat purchasers is high in case of Maggi, the rate of increase

    among the new purchasers is not too high.

    Intended Placement: Star

    Comments:

    (1) Maggi Noodles is undoubtedly the leader in the Noodles market and faces almost no

    competition which might threaten its existence in near times, yet the target placement of

    Maggi Noodles seems to be at fault.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    16/33

    (2) Instead of continuing to target the children, Maggi Noodles should now also concentrate

    on placing the products for Office Executives, Mid wives, Young adults, and the elite wing of

    the society.

    (3) The need presently is to expand the market or in fact create new markets for Maggi

    Noodles.

    (4) Therefore, the task for Maggi Noodles lies ahead for Market Development and thus

    expanding the consumer base in the presently unexplored sections of the society.

    Product: Milo

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) Though Milo has not totally been removed off the shelves of the stores and caters to the

    demand of the consumers arising on account of absence of other products in the same design

    (e.g. Bournvita, Complan, etc.), it has been unable to acquire a market in the basis of its

    brand name.

    (2) The reason why it is not placed as a dog is that it has the potential to expand and also

    because the product lies in a market with high business growth rate.

    (3) The retailers dont give much importance to Milo as an item on the shelf but they also do

    not completely disregard it off their stores.

    Intended Placement: Dog

    Comments:

    (1) Milo is a food drink with a bit subtle taste and not that sweet as its competitors offer,

    Bournvita being the primary one. Thus it needs to develop upon that.

    (3) Milo has not been promoted as a health drink as Boost or Complan and to some extent

    Bournvita has been done. Milo needs to improve in this regard.

    (4) Thus, in essence, Milo is not weak in terms of its qualitative deficiencies but on account

    of lack of an extensive promotional exercise meant to place it in the mindset of the Indian

    psyche.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    17/33

    Product: Maggi Sauce

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) India has a growing Ketchup market and Maggi has been a significant contender as a

    leader. But as far as Nestle is concerned, it is not turning up that size of revenues which every

    top brand contributes to Nestle.

    (2) Maggi Sauce has been highlighted with top television celebrities but there was a

    considerable time lag of more than five years in the two major promotion exercises Maggi

    Sauce has witnesses; once in the early 1990s and the one which is going on presently.

    (3) Maggi Sauce, acknowledge the retailers, has the capacity (both on account of the reasons

    of price and taste) to wipe out competitors (both the branded as well as the local ones) and

    thus has huge potential to be converted into a star.

    Intended Placement: Star

    Comments:

    (1) Though it has been kept as a question mark yet, Maggi Sauce has the potential of turning

    all odds in its way to become a dominating brand.

    (2) Competitors like Kissan, Tops (especially in north India) etc. do not pose any barrier in

    the growth of Maggi Sauce as the leader.

    (3) Extensive market development, followed by an extensive promotion drive in all nooks

    and corners of the country is the key to turning Maggi Sauce into a success as a brand leader

    for Nestle

    Product: Maggi Pickles

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) Maggi Pickles, on account of its limited variety (especially in this taste crazy country) and

    comparatively higher prices, has been unable to acquire a market necessary for its bare

    minimum existence.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    18/33

    (2) The sales of Maggi Pickles has never really trigged since its launch.

    (3) The placement of Maggi Pickles is doubted for the twin reasons of its high price and

    packing, which seems to target it to the upper substrata while the lack of a significant number

    of variants poses it a challenge to maintain itself in such households.

    (4) It is not a dog because it is not the market which has low growth rate. In fact the market of

    packaged pickle is growing but it is Maggi Pickles which is unable to gather a substantial

    share in this growing market.

    Intended Placement: Disinvest

    Comments:

    (1) Placing Maggi Pickles on the hearts and mind of the typical taste centric and money

    conscious Indian consumer will require an overhauling and huge investment.

    (2) Extensive price cuts are required but the matching returns are doubtful.

    (3) Pickles being a non-durable product and their success essentially related to the taste of the

    consumer, are not one of the core competencies of Nestle, which is better known to introduce

    standard taste in the country and get them approved by the consumers.

    (4) Thus it is better advised to disinvest in the business and focus on other brands.

    Product: Maggi Soup

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) With the success of Knorr and other local packed soup, it is clear that packaged soup

    market in India has a good future.

    (2) Maggi Soups have never been rejected by the consumer.

    (3) According to the retailers, the demand for soup itself is underdeveloped and thus there is

    no indicator critically against the success of Maggi Soup.

    Intended Placement: Star

    Comments:

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    19/33

    (1) Maggi Soup needs to dominate the market but before that it has to develop the market

    itself.

    (2) The demand for packages soup is underdeveloped and thus there is a need for extensive

    market development strategies.

    (3) The advantage of Maggi Soup in going in for such market development strategies is that it

    will get the advantage of early start and thus like Maggi Noodles it can make a monopoly on

    packaged soup.

    (4) The development of the market is to be based on the twin principles of the nutritive

    contents of the soup as well the convenience and taste, which make it a suitable alternative

    for other fast food.

    Product: Kit Kat

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) Owing to crispiness and superior quality, Kit Kat has an upper edge over its competitors.

    (2) Had this survey been made a couple of years ago, may be Kit Kat would have found the

    position of a Cash Cow because of the market share it acquired in a fairly decent and yet to

    develop wafer-chocolates market.

    (3) However, on account of the rise of competitors, especially Perk, Kit Kat seems to have

    loosened up its grip in the market and has lost some of the prominent recognition which it

    commanded earlier.

    (4) It is placed as a Question Mark as the brand has the potential but lack a significant market

    share as of now. Also, a mere repositioning in the market segment can lead to the success of

    the brand

    Intended Placement: Star

    Comments:

    (1) Kit Kat is one of the major successful brands of Nestle, which has proclaimed its

    dominance and success world over, ruthlessly dominating the European and the South

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    20/33

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    21/33

    (3) The Rs. 5/- which it has recently introduced is a classic example of cashing in the

    consumer psyche but it cannot be denied that it has done so following the example of Five

    Star. It needs, therefore, to take more initiatives but more so of its own accord and not as a

    follow up measure.

    (4) Bar One needs to pursue a strategy of market penetration, as already stated, but it also

    needs to emphasis on the fact that it has to sell itself in the market as a chocolate. Though it is

    in the form of a bar but it still faces competition from other forms of chocolate wherein

    Cadbury is the toughest competitor to it. Thus it has to go on an extensive promotional drive

    and also illustrate the superiority of bar over the other forms of chocolate both in terms of

    convenience while consumption as well as the price.

    Product:Nestle Butter

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) Nestle Butter, though available in the market for some time now, has not found much

    support from the consumers primarily on account of the dislike of the taste

    of Nestle Butter.

    (2) Considered as salt less, Nestle butter again is yet to grow from its pre-launch position on

    account of the huge competition it faces from Amul, the market leader in this field.

    (3) Now, as the market growth rate is quite significant, yet as Nestle Butter has not acquired a

    better share in the market, it has been placed in the category of Question Mark.

    Intended Placement: Disinvest

    Comments:

    (1) Facts do not favour Nestle to continue with its butter.

    (2) Instead of no response, a significant number of retailers are of the opinion that Nestle

    Butter seems to be rejected by the consumers for the reason that its taste does not suit the

    Indian psyche.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    22/33

    (3) Thus it is advisable for Nestle to discontinue with butter, as it did with its water brand,

    Pure Life. Also, it would be better to concentrate on other brand than to go in for a head on

    collision with Amul, the market leader, which is inevitable on account of the same market

    which both the products cater to.

    Product:Nestle Fruit N Milk

    Position: Question Mark

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) Nestle itself seems to be unclear as to which market it has been targeted to. On own side it

    is a fruit drink with pleasant flavours, on the other head, it is a health drink with nutrients of

    milk as well as fruits.

    (2) Also, the placement of the brand is dubious. While it finds a place with retailer of sizeable

    capacity, it seems absent from other health and juice shops. Thus there has to be a definite

    decision of made by Nestle as to the placement of Nestle Fruit N Milk.

    (3) The product however, on its own accord, has not been a failure totally. It seems to find a

    place consistently in some of the firms but there are no regular consumers for the products the

    consumers are either occasional users are those who have a flair to try new products.

    (4) The market for health drinks, however, is growing and the health conscious Indian

    consumer is now choosing a health drink like Real than just going in for cold drinks and other

    junk food.

    Intended Placement: Star

    Comments:

    (1) Despite the fact there has not been much promotion of Nestle Fruit N Milk by Nestle

    itself but the fact that it has not been rejected by the Indian consumer in itself is a positive

    signal.

    (2) The present step, therefore, that needs to be taken by Nestle is to promote it in a pre-

    defined market, wherein placing it as a health drink would be most favourable to Nestle

    towards establishing it as a successful brand.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    23/33

    (3) Thus, Nestle Fruit N Milk needs to be placed as a competitor to Real fruit juice and there

    is a certain prospect for this to succeed on account of the fact that it gives additional features

    than Real, which is only a fruit juice but Nestls products offers the nutrients of both fruits

    as well as milk.

    (4) Therefore the need for Nestle is to go in for Market Development Strategy and capitalize

    on the growing concern of the Indian consumer of going in for health drinks.

    (5) The aim is to place Nestle Fruit N Milk as the generic brand for health drink to a typical

    middle class Indian consumer.

    Product: Nestea

    Position: Dogs

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) With taste conscious Indian consumer, typically a middle class one, the morning has to

    essentially begin with a cup of tea which suits the tongue and also gives a fresh start. But the

    peculiarly lies in the diverse local flavours of tea, which essentially has to be perfect in order

    to favour that brand.

    (2) There lies the problem with Nestea. Though Nestle has been successful in the beverages

    section world over, the diverse and typical taste tendered to by the Indian consumers is not in

    favour of going in with one product suits all. It is for this reason that Nestea has not found

    acceptance with the Indian consumer.

    (3) But facts are not totally against Nestea. Tata Tea has been successful though it has also

    one flavour and serves on a National basis. However the taste of Nestea has simply not been

    accepted by the Indian consumer.

    Intended Placement: Disinvest

    Comments:

    (1) Though there is a possibility for Nestea to find acceptable from the consumers if some

    amount of research and development is diverted towards the taste of Nestea but there are a

    multifarious reasons for which divestment of Nestea is recommended.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    24/33

    (2) Firstly, even if the taste of Nestea is changed, it is very hard to change the mindset of the

    typical Indian consumer who are more attached to taste than to any other consideration in

    case of tea.

    (3) Secondly, Nestea, as a foreign brand of tea shall have to face the xenophobic attitude of

    the consumer who prefer to consume local flavours or say variants of tea than any other

    foreign tea as illustrated by Ruby Dust in Maharashtra Circle.

    (4) Also, going into the local taste has never been the attitude of Nestle. Instead it has always

    chosen to go in for making the foreign taste accepted to the local consumers. The same story

    has been told by the success of Maggi Noodles, Nescafe, Kit Kat etc. and wherever it has

    been unsuccessful, it has beenadvisable to disinvest the brand from the product line as has

    been done for Nestle brand of waters.

    Product: Milky Bar

    Position: Dogs

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) It become quite popular in and around the year 2000 but it never reached the stage of a

    power brand.

    (2) Primary tried by the Indian consumer as a craze which laid in trying the first nonbrown

    chocolate, Nestle Milky bar was a sweet chocolate with cream colour. Thus the primary

    acceptance of Milky bar was not based on its core qualities but on the basis of certain

    peculiarities which it contained, differentiating it from other products in the same line.

    (3) Milky Bar, as a chocolate, though has a growing market, yet it has been placed as a dog

    on account of the inherent lack of core quality which makes it generic with chocolates. This

    was the main reason why it was never considered a competitor by other chocolate

    manufactures and the consumers also treated it so.

    Intended Placement: Disinvest

    Comments:

    (1) Milky Bar has lost the primary battle which it had with mindset of the unaware Indian

    consumers who could never contemplate a non-brown chocolate.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    25/33

    (2) The market positioning of Nestle Milky Bar has been only to children (as one can

    contemplate from the advertisements which relate only to children in the age group of 10 -15)

    and thus it has lost the adolescent consumer, which is also a major part of the entire

    consuming segment of chocolates.

    (3) The promotion style of Milky Bar has never been dominating. The advertisements have

    been too soft and not too impressive. Thus success of Milky Bar requires rebuilding the

    image of Milky Bar.

    (4) The cost benefit analysis also shows that continuing with Milky Bar is expensive as the

    amount required for its promotion and development has not led to the same amount of

    returns.

    Product:Nestle Dahi

    Position: Dogs

    Reasons for present positioning:

    (1) Majority of the consumers are unaware that Nestle offers a Dahi also.

    (2) The launch of Nestle Dahi has been in select cities but there too only select outlets retail

    it. (It is not offered in Patna)

    (3) The concept of packaged Dahi is not being accepted by the consumer who prefers to play

    it safe with the local manufacturer wherefrom he can keep a check on the qualitative content

    of the product as well before consuming it.

    (4) Thus, lack of a growing market makes Nestle Dahi to be placed in as a Dog.

    Intended Placement: Disinvest

    Comments:

    (1) Dahi is a product which is best if considered fresh. This traditional mentality of the Indian

    consumer is the biggest barrier in the success of Nestle Dahi.

    (2) The concept of packaged Dahi is yet to materialize in India. Therefore its launch by

    Nestle is premature.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    26/33

    (3) It is advisable to leave the avenue then to go in for market development in this case when

    there is big risk of the failure of the entire investment to doom on account of the psychic

    barrier of the consumers.

    Product: Crunch and Munch

    (Since both these chocolates of Nestle cater to the same market and are also similar in

    composition and variety, they have been considered together in this case)

    Position: Dogs

    Reasons for present positioning: (1) Both the brands are non dominating, taste centric

    chocolates in the bar category with not much association with any particular core quality

    which they depict which differentiates them from other brands.

    (2) The market is growing almost the right pace but the share of these two chocolates is not

    considerable in the present market. Therefore they are classified as dogs.

    Intended Placement:

    Comments:

    (1) Although if we proceed with this fact situation that these two brands are not doing well

    and also they do not have a core competence upon which they can be promoted, the obvious

    answer would be to disinvest them. However that is not suggested in the instant case.

    (2) The primary reason for such is that these two brands are continuing on a no profit no loss

    basis and though they do not offer much of prospects for Nestle in terms of contributing with

    higher revenue, they in are in fact making Nestls presence felt in the chocolate market of

    which only Kit Kat is a probably power brand for Nestle.

    (3) Thus, the primary solution would be to continue with the brand such that Nestle keeps its

    prospects open in the chocolate market and thus diversifies its risk of proceeding just with

    one chocolate (Kit Kat and to some extent Bar One) especially when the disinvestment of

    Milky Bar has also been suggested.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    27/33

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    28/33

    SUGGESTIONS

    The suggestions for each of the brands have been stated along with the brands in research

    itself however there are certain general suggestion which is stated herein below.

    (1) Nestle India, no doubt is a leading company in food business yet, it has to focus on its

    distribution system and offer better incentives for retailers who have till date been clinging on

    to its products only because of the great demand they carry despite the fact that there is not

    much which Nestle offers to these retailers.

    (2) Nestle India has to stop adopting a brand focus promotion strategy and also has to go in

    for general promotional drive for the name Nestle itself. (Because majority of the consumers

    do not know that Nestle has so many brands to offer. In fact a huge number of them related

    Maggi as a different firm altogether than Nestle)

    (3) Nestle India needs to do away with this attitude of every time trying to impose a foreign

    taste on the local consumers. Instead, as regards the products which necessarily relate to the

    taste satisfaction of the consumer, proper research and Indianization of the products is

    essential.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    29/33

    LIMITATIONS

    (1) The data collected on the field considers a small sample only. Thus proper corroborative

    research is required before taking any action based on the findings of the present study.

    (2) The data for the nationwide figures of Nestle India is not widely available. Nestle India is

    maintained as a subsidy of Nestle SA and thus proper reporting of its figures is not available.

    This also poses a limitation as far as comparison of the results of the study with the national

    figures is concerned.

    (3) The factual matrix of Nestle brands, as analysed in this study, is based on a limited survey

    of one city (Patna) thus the result may be incomparable with a similar study in other areas.

    (4) Not much data was available as far the not to successful brands of Nestle were concerned.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    30/33

    BIBLIOGRAPHY

    BOOKS:

    1. L. M. Prasad, Business Policy: Strategic Management, (Sultan Chand & Co., New Delhi,2001)

    2. Meenakshi Gupta, Principles Of Management, (PHI Learning Private Limited,2009)

    3.Biswajeet Pattanayak,Human Resource Management,( PHI Learning Private Limited,2009)

    WEBSITES:

    1.

    (last visited on September 22, 2013)

    2. (last visited on

    September 22, 2013)

    3.

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    31/33

    ANNEXURE I

    (List of Nestle Products worldwide)

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    32/33

    ANNEXURE II

    (List of Nestle Products offered in India)

  • 7/27/2019 Principles of Management Project

    33/33