Primary & secondary data

22
PRIMARY AND SECONDARY DATA We explore the availability and use of data (primary and secondary) in the field of business research. Specifically, we examine an international sample of doctoral dissertations since 1998, categorizing research topics, data collection, and availability of data. Findings suggest that use of only primary data pervades the discipline, despite strong methodological reasons to augment with secondary data.

description

Tabulation of data

Transcript of Primary & secondary data

Page 1: Primary & secondary data
Page 2: Primary & secondary data

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 02

IMPORTANCE OF DATA AND DATA COLLECTION --------------------------------- 02

DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES ------------------------------------------------------- 02

PRIMARY DATA ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 03

IMPORTANCE OF PRIMARY DATA ------------------------------------------------------- 03

SOURCES OF PRIMARY DATA -------------------------------------------------------------- 04

ADVANTAGES OF PRIMARY RESEARCH ----------------------------------------------- 05

DISADVANTAGES OF PRIMARY RESEARCH ------------------------------------------ 07

SECONDARY DATA ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 08

IMPORTANCE OF SECONDARY DATA --------------------------------------------------- 08

SOURCES OF SECONDARY DATA --------------------------------------------------------- 08

ADVANTAGES OF SECONDARY DATA ---------------------------------------------------

10

DISADVANTAGES OF SECONDARY DATA ----------------------------------------------

11

EVALUATION OF SECONDARY DATA -------------------------------------------------- 12

CONCLUSION ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 13

REFERENCES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 14

1 of 15

Page 3: Primary & secondary data

INTRODUCTION

Data can be defined as the quantitative or qualitative values of a variable. Data is plural of

datum which literally means to give or something given. Data is thought to be the lowest unit

of information from which other measurements and analysis can be done. Data can be

numbers, images, words, figures, facts or ideas. Data in itself cannot be understood and to get

information from the data one must interpret it into meaningful information. There are

various methods of interpreting data.  Data sources are broadly classified into primary and

secondary data.

Knowing how the data was collected allows critics of a study to search for bias in how it was

conducted. A good study will welcome such scrutiny. Each type has its own weaknesses and

strengths. Primary Data is gathered by people who can focus directly on the purpose in mind.

This helps ensure that questions are meaningful to the purpose but can introduce bias in those

same questions. Secondary data doesn't have the privilege of this focus but is only susceptible

to bias introduced in the choice of what data to reuse. Stated another way, those who gather

Primary Data get to write the questions. Those who gather secondary data get to pick the

questions.

IMPORTANCE OF DATA AND DATA COLLECTION

Data is one of the most important and vital aspect of any research studies. Researchers

conducted in different fields of study can be different in methodology but every research is

based on data which is analyzed and interpreted to get information.  

Data is the basic unit in statistical studies. Statistical information like census, population

variables, health statistics, and road accidents records are all developed from data.

Data is important in computer science. Numbers, images and figures in computer are all data. 

DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES

There are two sources of data collection techniques. Primary and Secondary data collection

techniques, Primary data collection uses surveys, experiments or direct observations.

Secondary data collection may be conducted by collecting information from a diverse source

of documents or electronically stored information, census and market studies are examples of

a common sources of secondary data. This is also referred to as "data mining." 

2 of 15

Page 4: Primary & secondary data

PRIMARY DATA

Primary data means original data that has been collected specially for the purpose in mind. It

means someone collected the data from the original source first hand. Data collected this way

is called primary data.

Primary data has not been published yet and is more reliable, authentic and objective.

Primary data has not been changed or altered by human beings; therefore its validity is

greater than secondary data.

The people who gather primary data may be an authorized organization, investigator,

enumerator or they may be just someone with a clipboard. These people are acting as a

witness so primary data is only considered as reliable as the people who gathered it.

IMPORTANCE OF PRIMARY DATA

Importance of Primary data cannot be neglected. A research can be conducted without

secondary data but a research based on only secondary data is least reliable and may have

biases because secondary data has already been manipulated by human beings. In statistical

surveys it is necessary to get information from primary sources and work on primary data: for

example, the statistical records of female population in a country cannot be based on

newspaper, magazine and other printed sources. One such source is old and secondly they

contain limited information as well as they can be misleading and biased.

Validity

Validity is one of the major concerns in a research. Validity is the quality of a research that

makes it trustworthy and scientific. Validity is the use of scientific methods in research to

make it logical and acceptable.

Using primary data in research can improves the validity of research. First-hand information

obtained from a sample that is representative of the target population will yield data that will

be valid for the entire target population.

Authenticity

Authenticity is the genuineness of the research. Authenticity can be at stake if the researcher

invests personal biases or uses misleading information in the research. Primary research tools

3 of 15

Page 5: Primary & secondary data

and data can become more authentic if the methods chosen to analyze and interpret data are

valid and reasonably suitable for the data type.

Primary sources are more authentic because the facts have not been overdone. Primary source

can be less authentic if the source hides information or alters facts due to some personal

reasons. There are methods that can be employed to ensure factual yielding of data from the

source.

Reliability

Reliability is the certainty that the research is enough true to be trusted on. For example, if a

research study concludes that junk food consumption does not increase the risk of cancer and

heart diseases. This conclusion should have to be drawn from a sample whose size, sampling

technique and variability is not questionable.

Reliability improves with using primary data. In the similar research mentioned above if the

researcher uses experimental method and questionnaires the results will be highly reliable.

On the other hand, if he relies on the data available in books and on internet he will collect

information that does not represent the real facts.

SOURCES OF PRIMARY DATA

Sources for primary data are limited and at times it becomes difficult to obtain data from

primary source because of either scarcity of population or lack of cooperation. Regardless of

any difficulty one can face in collecting primary data; it is the most authentic and reliable

data source. Following are some of the sources of primary data.

Experiments

Experiments require an artificial or natural setting in which to perform logical study to collect

data. Experiments are more suitable for medicine, psychological studies, nutrition and for

other scientific studies. In experiments the experimenter has to keep control over the

influence of any extraneous variable on the results.

Survey

Survey is most commonly used method in social sciences, management, marketing and

psychology to some extent. Surveys can be conducted in different methods.

4 of 15

Page 6: Primary & secondary data

Questionnaire is the most commonly used method in survey. Questionnaires are a list of

questions either an open-ended or close -ended for which the respondent give answers.

Questionnaire can be conducted via telephone, mail, live in a public area, or in an institute,

through electronic mail or through fax and other methods.

Interview is a face-to-face conversation with the respondent. It is slow, expensive, and they

take people away from their regular jobs, but they allow in-depth questioning and follow-up

questions.

The interviewer can not only record the statements the interviewee speaks but he can observe

the body language or non-verbal communication such as face-pulling, fidgeting, shrugging,

hand gestures, sarcastic expressions that add further meaning to spoken words and other

reactions to the questions too.

A problem with interviews is that people might say what they think the interviewer wants to

hear; they might avoid being honestly critical in case their jobs or reputation might suffer.

And the respondent deliberately hides information otherwise it is an in depth source of

information. So this enables the interviewer to draw conclusions easily.

Observations can be done while letting the observing person know that he is being observed

or without letting him know. Observations can also be made in natural settings as well as in

artificially created environment.

Primary data can be relied on because you know where it came from and what was done to it.

It's like cooking something yourself. You know what went into it.

ADVANTAGES OF PRIMARY RESEARCH

Targeted Issues are addressed

The organization asking for the research has the complete control on the process and the

research is streamlines as far as its objectives and scope is concerned. Researching company

can be asked to concentrate their efforts to find data regarding specific market rather than

concentration on mass market.

Data interpretation is better

The collected data can be examined and interpreted by the marketers depending on their

needs rather than relying on the interpretation made by collectors of secondary data.

5 of 15

Page 7: Primary & secondary data

Efficient Spending for Information

Unlike secondary research where the marketer may spend for information that is not needed,

primary data collections’ focus on issues specific to the researcher improves the chances that

research funds will be spent efficiently.

Decency of Data

Usually secondary data is not so recent and it may not be specific to the place or situation

marketer is targeting. The researcher can use the irrelevant seeming information for knowing

trends or may be able to find some relation with the current scenario. Thus primary data

becomes a more accurate tool since we can use data which is useful for us.

Proprietary Issues

Information collected by using primary research is their own and is generally not shared with

others. Thus, information can be kept hidden from competitors and potentially offer an

“information advantage” to the company that undertook the primary research. This gives an

edge over competitors replying on secondary data.

Addresses Specific Research Issues

Carrying out their own research allows the marketing organization to address issues specific

to their own situation. Primary research is designed to collect the information the marketer

wants to know (Step 2) and report it in ways that benefit the marketer. For example, while

information reported with secondary research may not fit the marketer’s needs (e.g., different

age groupings) no such problem exists with primary research since the marketer controls the

research design.

Greater Control

Not only does primary research enable the marketer to focus on specific issues, it also enables

the marketer to have a higher level of control over how the information is collected. In this

way the marketer can decide on such issues as size of project (e.g., how many responses),

location of research (e.g., geographic area) and time frame for completing the project.

6 of 15

Page 8: Primary & secondary data

DISADVANTAGES OF PRIMARY RESEARCH

High Cost

Compared to secondary research, primary data may be very expensive since there is a great

deal of marketer involvement and the expense in preparing and carrying out research can be

high and has to design everything.

Time Consuming

To be done correctly primary data collection requires the development and execution of a

research plan. Going from the start-point of deciding to undertake a research project to the

end-point to having results is often much longer than the time it takes to acquire secondary

data, which can be collected in much lesser time duration.

Inaccurate Feed-backs

In case the research involves taking feedbacks from the targeted audience, there are high

chances that feedback given is not correct. Feedbacks by their basic nature are usually biased

or given just for the sake of it.

More number of resources is required

Leaving aside cost and time, other resources like human resources and materials too are

needed in larger quantity to do surveys and data collection.

7 of 15

Page 9: Primary & secondary data

SECONDARY DATA

Secondary data is the data that has been already collected by and readily available from other

sources. When we use Statistical Method with Primary Data from another purpose for our

purpose we refer to it as Secondary Data. It means that one purpose's Primary Data is another

purpose's Secondary Data. So that secondary data is data that is being reused. Such data are

cheaper and more quickly obtainable than the primary data.

These secondary data may be obtained from many sources, including literature, industry

surveys, compilations from computerized databases and information systems, and

computerized or mathematical models of environmental processes.

IMPORTANCE OF SECONDARY DATA

Secondary data can be less valid but its importance is still there. Sometimes it is difficult to

obtain primary data; in these cases getting information from secondary sources is easier and

possible. Sometimes primary data does not exist in such situation one has to confine the

research on secondary data.

Sometimes primary data is present but the respondents are not willing to reveal it in such case

too secondary data can suffice: for example, if the research is on the psychology of

transsexuals first it is difficult to find out transsexuals and second they may not be willing to

give information you want for your research, so you can collect data from books or other

published sources.

SOURCES OF SECONDARY DATA

Secondary data is often readily available. After the expense of electronic media and internet

the availability of secondary data has become much easier.

Published Printed Sources

There are varieties of published printed sources. Their credibility depends on many factors.

For example, on the writer, publishing company and time and date when published. New

sources are preferred and old sources should be avoided as new technology and researches

bring new facts into light.

8 of 15

Page 10: Primary & secondary data

Books

Books are available today on any topic that you want to research. The uses of books start

before even you have selected the topic. After selection of topics books provide insight on

how much work has already been done on the same topic and you can prepare your literature

review. Books are secondary source but most authentic one in secondary sources. 

Journals/periodicals

Journals and periodicals are becoming more important as far as data collection is concerned.

The reason is that journals provide up-to-date information which at times books cannot and

secondly, journals can give information on the very specific topic on which you are

researching rather talking about more general topics.

Magazines/Newspapers

Magazines are also effective but not very reliable. Newspaper on the other hand is more

reliable and in some cases the information can only be obtained from newspapers as in the

case of some political studies. 

Published Electronic Sources

As internet is becoming more advance, fast and reachable to the masses; it has been seen that

much information that is not available in printed form is available on internet. In the past the

credibility of internet was questionable but today it is not. The reason is that in the past

journals and books were seldom published on internet but today almost every journal and

book is available online. Some are free and for others you have to pay the price. 

E-journals: e-journals are more commonly available than printed journals.

Latest journals are difficult to retrieve without subscription but if your university has an e-

library you can view any journal, print it and those that are not available you can make an

order for them. 

General Websites; Generally websites do not contain very reliable information so their

content should be checked for the reliability before quoting from them. 

Weblogs: Weblogs are also becoming common. They are actually diaries written by different

people. These diaries are as reliable to use as personal written diaries.

9 of 15

Page 11: Primary & secondary data

Unpublished Personal Records

Some unpublished data may also be useful in some cases. 

Diaries: Diaries are personal records and are rarely available but if you are conducting a

descriptive research then they might be very useful. The Anne Franks diary is the most

famous example of this. That diary contained the most accurate records of Nazi wars. 

Letters: Letters like diaries are also a rich source but should be checked for their reliability

before using them. 

Government Records

Government records are very important for marketing, management, humanities and social

science research. 

Census Data/population statistics  

Health records

Educational institutes records

Public Sector Records

NGO's survey data

Other private companies records

ADVANTAGES OF SECONDARY DATA

Ease of Access

There are many advantages to using secondary research. This includes the relative ease of

access to many sources of secondary data. In the past secondary data accumulation required

marketers to visit libraries, or wait for reports to be shipped by mail. Now with the

availability of online access, secondary research is more openly accessed. This offers

convenience and generally standardized usage methods for all sources of secondary research.

Low Cost to Acquire

The use of secondary data has allowed researchers access to valuable information for little or

no cost to acquire. Therefore, this information is much less expensive than if the researchers

had to carry out the research themselves.

Clarification of Research Question

10 of 15

Page 12: Primary & secondary data

The use of secondary research may help the researcher to clarify the research question.

Secondary research is often used prior to primary research to help clarify the research focus.

May Answer Research Question

The use of secondary data collection is often used to help align the focus of large scale

primary research. When focusing on secondary research, the researcher may realize that the

exact information they were looking to uncover is already available through secondary

sources. This would effectively eliminate the need and expense to carry out their own

primary research.

May Show Difficulties in Conducting Primary Research

In many cases, the originators of secondary research include details of how the information

was collected. This may include information detailing the procedures used in data collection

and difficulties encountered in conducting the primary research. Therefore, the detailed

difficulties may persuade the researcher to decide that the potential information obtained is

not worth the potential difficulties in conducting the research.

DISADVANTAGES OF SECONDARY DATA

Quality of Research

There are some disadvantages to using secondary research. The originators of the primary

research are largely self-governed and controlled by the marketer. Therefore, the secondary

research used must be scrutinized closely since the origins of the information may be

questionable. Moreover, the researcher needs to take sufficient steps to critically evaluate the

validity and reliability of the information provided.

Not Specific to Researcher’s Needs

In many cases, secondary data is not presented in a form that exactly meets the researcher’s

needs. Therefore, the researcher needs to rely on secondary data that is presented and

classified in a way that is similar to their needs.

Incomplete Information

In many cases, researchers find information that appears valuable and promising. The

researcher may not get the full version of the research to gain the full value of the study. This

is because many research suppliers offer free portions of their research and then charge

expensive fees for their full reports.

11 of 15

Page 13: Primary & secondary data

Not Timely

When using secondary research, one must exercise caution when using dated information

from the past. With companies competing in fast changing industries, an out-of-date research

reports many have little or no relevance to the current market situation.

EVALUATION OF SECONDARY DATA

Because of the above mentioned disadvantages of secondary data, we will lead to evaluation

of secondary data. Evaluation means the following four requirements must be satisfied:-

1. Availability- It has to be seen that the kind of data you want is available or not. If it is

not available then you have to go for primary data.

2. Relevance- It should be meeting the requirements of the problem. For this we have

two criterion:-

a. Units of measurement should be the same.

b. Concepts used must be same and currency of data should not be outdated.

3. Accuracy- In order to find how accurate the data is, the following points must be

considered: -

a. Specification and methodology used;

b. Margin of error should be examined;

c. The dependability of the source must be seen.

4. Sufficiency- Adequate data should be available.

Robert W Joselyn has classified the above discussion into eight steps. These eight steps are

sub classified into three categories. He has given a detailed procedure for evaluating

secondary data.

1. Applicability of research objective.

2. Cost of acquisition.

3. Accuracy of data.

CONCLUSION

12 of 15

Page 14: Primary & secondary data

Primary research entails the use of immediate data in determining the survival of the market.

The popular ways to collect primary data consist of surveys, interviews and focus groups,

which shows that direct relationship between potential customers and the companies.

Whereas secondary research is a means to reprocess and reuse collected information as an

indication for betterments of the service or product.

Both primary and secondary data are useful for businesses but both may differ from each

other in various aspects.In secondary data, information relates to a past period. Hence, it lacks

aptness and therefore, it has unsatisfactory value. Primary data is more accommodating as it

shows latest information.

Secondary data is obtained from some other organization than the one instantaneously

interested with current research project. Secondary data was collected and analyzed by the

organization to convene the requirements of various research objectives. Primary data is

accumulated by the researcher particularly to meet up the research objective of the subsisting

project.

Secondary data though old may be the only possible source of the desired data on the

subjects, which cannot have primary data at all. For example, survey reports or secret records

already collected by a business group can offer information that cannot be obtained from

original sources.

Firm in which secondary data are accumulated and delivered may not accommodate the exact

needs and particular requirements of the current research study. Many a time, alteration or

modifications to the exact needs of the investigator may not be sufficient. To that amount

usefulness of secondary data will be lost. Primary data is completely tailor-made and there is

no problem of adjustments.

Secondary data is available effortlessly, rapidly and inexpensively. Primary data takes a lot of

time and the unit cost of such data is relatively high.Often secondary data have been pre-

processed to give totals or averages and the original details are lost so you can't verify it by

replicating the methods used by the original data collectors.

In short, primary data are expensive and difficult to acquire, but they are trustworthy.

Secondary data are cheap and easy to collect, but must be treated with caution.

REFERENCES

13 of 15

Page 15: Primary & secondary data

1. http://www.ianswer4u.com/2012/02/primary-research-advantages-

and.html#ixzz2B6ioqOwT

2. http://www.worldbank.org/poverty/impact/methods/datacoll.htm

3. Bryman, A. and E. Bell: 2003, Business Research Methods (Oxford University Press,

Oxford, New York).

4. Dillman, Don A. Mail and Telephone Surveys: The Total Design Method. New York,

John Wiley and Sons, 1978.

5. Galpin, T. The Use of Mail Questionnaires as a Method of Data Collection. (Sept,

1987)

14 of 15