Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf ·...
Transcript of Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf ·...
![Page 1: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other Construction Frauds
MTA Office of The Inspector General
Cliff Brock Chief, Construction Fraud Unit MTA OIG
Construction Fraud 1
![Page 2: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
WHAT THE MTA OIG DOES
Prevent Fraud Waste & Abuse Audit Function Investigative Function Construction Fraud Unit
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 2
![Page 3: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
COMMON TYPES OF FRAUD
Bid-Rigging & Collusion Product Substitution False claims / Overcharging / Mischarging Prevailing Wage Violations Bribery & Kickbacks Embezzlement Disadvantaged-Business (DBE) Fraud Quality-Control Testing Fraud Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 3
![Page 4: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
It’s a Crime
• A colluded bid submission is a crime • A false change order is a crime • A false certified payroll is a crime • A false request for payment is a crime • A false DBE Utilization form is a crime • A false business record is a crime • Altering documents is a crime
Construction Fraud 4
![Page 5: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
What We’ll Focus on Today
Disadvantaged-Business (DBE) Fraud Prevailing Wage Violations Bribery-Kickbacks Embezzlement Quality Testing Fraud
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 5
![Page 6: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
DBE Fraud schemes •“Front” company scheme -
• Company exists only on paper. • Work is done by the prime contractor.
•“Pass-Through” scheme – Real DBE but not doing the work. DBE performs no commercially-useful function, just processes paperwork. Work is done by non-DBE subcontractor or prime.
• Use of DBE without its knowledge. • Late pay to force DBE off job.
Construction Fraud 6
![Page 7: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Construction Fraud
DBE Program, US Dep’t of Transportation, Federal Transit Admin.
• Regulations, 49 CFR Part 26 (Code of Federal Regulations)
• Applies to any contract that is even partially funded with Federal Transit Funds. 49 CFR 26.3
3/25/2013 7
![Page 8: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation is Counted Toward
Goals • Entire Amount of work performed by DBE, including
supplies purchased or equipment leased. (except if from Prime)
• Entire amount of Fees for bona fide commissions or Professional Services
• If DBE subcontracts out any of his work, only count the amount subcontracted to another DBE subcontractor. Work that a DBE subcontracts out to a non DBE does not count toward the goal.
3/25/2013 8
![Page 9: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Construction Fraud
COMMERCIALLY USEFUL FUNCTION
• COUNT EXPENDITURES TO A DBE ONLY IF IT PERFORMS A COMMERCIALLY USEFUL FUNCTION. 49 CFR 26.55(c)1
• When DBE is responsible for execution of the work and is carrying out its responsibilities by actually performing, managing and supervising the work.
• DBE must be responsible for negotiating price, ordering, determining quality and quantity, installing and paying for the material.
3/25/2013 9
![Page 10: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Construction Fraud
NOT COMMERCIALLY USEFUL
• A DBE does not perform a commercially useful function if its role is as an extra participant through which funds are passed (A pass through) in order to obtain the appearance of DBE.
• If DBE doesn’t perform or exercise responsibility for at least 30% of its contract, You must presume it is not performing a commercially useful function.
3/25/2013 10
![Page 11: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Comm. Useful, Materials & Supplies
• If from DBE manufacturer, 100%. Must operate factory.
• If from Regular Dealer, 60%. • Must own, operate or maintain a store or
warehouse where materials, supplies, articles or equipment are bought, stored and regularly sold.
• Must be an established, regular business with its principal business under its own name, in purchase and sale of products in question.
• Bulk Materials: If owns distribution equipment, ownership of store or warehouse not required.
3/25/2013 11
![Page 12: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Final Word DBE Calculations
• Other purchases from DBE: Treat as a broker and allow only the fee or commission.
3/25/2013 12
![Page 13: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Good Faith Efforts
• Efforts to achieve DBE goal or other requirement of the CFR, which, by their scope, intensity and appropriateness to the objective, can reasonably be expected to fulfill the program requirement.
3/25/2013 13
![Page 14: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Examples of Good Faith Efforts
• Soliciting interest of DBEs • Breaking down work into smaller units. • Providing plans in a timely manner. • Negotiating in good faith • Not rejecting DBEs without sound reason.
3/25/2013 14
![Page 15: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Examples of Good Faith Efforts 2
• Making efforts to assist in bonding, credit lines or insurance.
• Making efforts to assist in obtaining equipment, materials, etc.
• Attending meetings.
3/25/2013 15
![Page 16: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
DBE Fraud Sample Indicators
•Contact by unknown subcontractor •Certified payrolls from unknown contractor •DBE owner never at site •Workers switch back & forth between payrolls of DBE and prime •DBE with no facilities, equipment or workers •DBE trucker who owns two trucks, but many on site •Two Party Checks
•Orders / payment for supplies handled by non-DBE •DBE “Owner” is former employee of non-DBE company; only works on its jobs. •Companies share address / phone number •Wrong or covered company name on vehicles
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 16
![Page 17: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
DBE Investigations
• Gather Paperwork – Contracts-Subcontracts – Utilization Forms – Intents to Perform – Monthly Progress Reports – Certified Payrolls-Sign in Sheets-Daily Reports
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 17
![Page 18: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
DBE Investigations
• Investigative Techniques
Construction Fraud
• Surveillance • Interviews • Undercovers • Search Warrants
3/25/2013 18
![Page 19: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Prevailing Wages- Davis-Bacon & Section 220 NYS Labor Law
• D-B Act sets Prevailing Wage rates for various labor categories. Violation cheats workers and government and provides unfair economic advantage in bidding. 40 U.S.C. 3141
– 2 sets of books conceal the underpayments – Pay the employees the correct amount but make them
pay some back – Pay proper wage for regular but not OT hours – Day laborers – Phantom benefits Does the certified payroll match the workers actually on site?
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 19
![Page 20: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Prevailing Wage Fraud – Why?
Greed
• Contractors know how much labor is involved in a job they’re bidding on.
• Allows them to underbid honest contractors.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 20
![Page 21: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Federal Crimes • Making a False Statement, 18 USC 1001 • Mail Fraud re: Monthly Progress Reports • Wire Fraud re: Interstate FAXES, Emails, Texts • Money Laundering re: Movement of Funds
received from the fraud. • Tax Evasion – Payroll Tax • Theft from Union Benefit Plans
3/25/2013 21
![Page 22: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
New York State Crimes
• Offering a False Instrument for Filing in the First Degree. PL 175.35
• Falsifying Business Records in the First Degree. PL 175.10
• Grand Larceny. PL 155.30-42 • Spota Bill. Failure to Pay Prevailing Wage LL
220
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 22
![Page 23: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Construction Fraud
Civil Remedies
• Federal & NYS False Claims Acts • Responsibility Determination • Debarment • Contract liquidated damages • Hold Back payment • Restitution • Cost of Investigation
3/25/2013 23
![Page 24: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
EMBEZZLEMENT
• Transit authority Exec Director and Admin Asst. in Pennsylvania embezzled $419K of transit funds;
• NJ airport owner stole $375K of grant funds. •Employee stole 1500 fare cards worth $45K.
24 Construction Fraud
![Page 25: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Bribery & Conflicts-of-Interest
• Bribery - A public official takes something of value to help a contractor - steer a contract, provide confidential information, or to overlook overbilling, substandard materials, or poor performance, etc. Not only money.
• Conflict - Public official involved with a government contract that also
involves the official’s personal financial interests, or a family member, or a company that the official is seeking employment with.
• Many Agencies have Stricter Conflict Rules in Code of Ethics
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 25
![Page 26: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Bribery Examples
Official took over $150,000; allowed contractor to participate in drafting contract spec’s & steered sole-source contracts.
Contractor bribed municipal official for DBE certification, used to fraudulently obtain DBE subcontracts.
Contracted-inspector accepted $25K in bribes, allowing city to be
overbilled $1.4 million for sub-standard road milling work. Two employees agreed to take over $500,000 to influence the
settlement of a multimillion $ claim on bridge reconstruction project. Bridge inspectors accepted bribes; falsely certified quality & quantity of
bridge painting.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 26
![Page 27: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Bribery -
Sample Indicators • Business or social relationships between contractors and persons involved
in award or oversight process; too close.
• Unexplained or unusual favoritism to contractor/vendor.
• Change orders approved with insufficient justification or invoices with insufficient documentation.
• Repeated sole source or “emergency” awards by same official to same contractor.
• Insistence on use of a specific subcontractor.
• Good ratings given or continuing awards to contractors with poor performance records.
• Documents prepared by contractor that should be prepared by govt. employees.
• Official’s lifestyle exceeds salary.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 27
![Page 28: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Kickbacks
Contractor, subcontractor or employee secretly pays a fee for being awarded the contract or getting the job – amount may be passed on to the government as a cost.
Watch for: • Unexplained / unreasonable limitations on the number of potential
subcontractors. • Continuing awards to subcontractors with poor performance
records. • Non-award of subcontract to lowest bidder. • “No-value-added” technical specifications that dictate contract
awards to particular companies.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 28
![Page 29: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Testing Fraud Examples
• Inspectors randomly marked asphalt samples to be tested with paint, but didn’t take them. Company checked which samples would pass density test, took other core samples and marked them with same color paint. Substituted & turned over only good samples.
• Concrete samples secretly removed overnight by
contractor to be strengthened and then returned to project site.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 29
![Page 30: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Testing Fraud- Concrete cases charged
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 30
![Page 31: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Testing Fraud – Sample Indicators
• Contractor employees regularly taking or labeling QC samples away from inspector oversight.
• Contractor insisting on transporting QC samples from site to lab. • Contractor not maintaining QC samples for later quality assurance
testing. • Contractor challenging results or attempting to intimidate QA
inspectors who obtain conflicting results. • Photocopies of QC test results where originals are expected. • Alterations or missing signatures on QC test results. • Odd test results - too quick, too perfect, too uniform. • Test results dated too close in time to when sample taken.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 31
![Page 32: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Testing Fraud – Sample Indicators
Field testing results when no field test equipment present at site.
Density test when no scales at site. Air Entrainment test when no air pot on site.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 32
![Page 33: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Train Project Management Team- First Line of Defense
Reduce Opportunities for Fraud
• Analyze / review operations to identify risks.
• Know who is on the site; know your contractors, vendors, workers. Provide high-visibility oversight.
• Be engaged and proactive. Scrutinize. Verify. Double-check.
• Report suspicions of wrongdoing. Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 33
![Page 34: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Training: Advise Construction Team If they suspect fraud:
• Document the activity they suspect to be fraudulent
• Seek an explanation for irregular activity, if possible
• Copy all relevant documents and take photographs if possible
• Do not alert those involved or others to suspicions
• Report concerns or suspicions to management and referral to the IG
• Can report directly to the IG and remain confidential
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 34
![Page 35: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Contractor Access Forms
• Institute if Not Already in Place • Make Sure They’re Accurate • Documents who was actually on site • Security • Tool for Prevailing Wage Violations
– Davis Bacon – Section 220 NYS Labor Law
• Tool for DBE Fraud Investigations
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 35
![Page 36: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Contracting Oversight - Vigilance, Vigilance, Vigilance
Contracting officers / representatives have a direct and essential role:
• checking the documents • making physical inspections • looking at invoices • asking questions, applying scrutiny.
How Do You Know It’s So? Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 36
![Page 37: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Deterrence
• Kick Off Meetings • Site Visits • Progress Meetings • Contractor Access Forms • Review of Change Orders
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 37
![Page 38: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Kick Off Meetings
• Let contractors know we are watching. • Spell out,
– “It is a crime to file false documents.”
• Make it clear we will recommend prosecution.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 38
![Page 39: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Site Visits (Requires investigators to have proper safety training)
• Generally Unannounced • Interview workers, from printed questionnaire. • Determine employer, hours, pay, O/T, examine photo ID &
Union Card • Look for materials • Contractor Access Forms • Safety Issues
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 39
![Page 40: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Progress Meetings
• Attended well over 200 • Reinforce fact that we are watching • Get on mailing list for DBE forms • Don’t always review them but “We’re
watching.” • Found recently that a DBE under
investigation is listed as DBE supplier.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 40
![Page 41: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Teamwork • Work with other agencies. • Often with
– USDOT OIG – USDOL OIG – Port Authority OIG – Other federal and state agencies
• Extra bang for the buck
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 41
![Page 42: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Recently Completed Cases
• Schiavone • Skanska • Dragados/Judlau Joint Venture
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 42
![Page 43: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Determining the Penalty
• Normally up to the Prosecutor – Often the amount of the DBE credit falsely taken – Can theoretically be the entire contract amount. – Under the Federal False Claims Act-Treble
Damages
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 43
![Page 44: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Penalties Cont’d
• As a non-law enforcement agency we can’t share in federal asset forfeiture. – Schiavone-$20 Million all to US Gov’t.
• Can sometimes recover cost of investigation – Schiavone-$1.833 Million to MTAOIG
• Skanska-$19.6 Million Settlement – US Attorney agreed to give us half
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 44
![Page 45: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Use of Proceeds of Penalties
• Relatively small portion goes directly to MTA OIG, which is available for investigative costs and equipment.
• Majority, including $9.8 Million from Skanska went to MTA. – Used in Mentoring Program
• Training and assisting minority businesses.
– Used for Outside Monitors
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 45
![Page 46: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Vendor Evaluation The Fallacy of “The Low Bid Price.”
Is the Vendor Responsible? IS the Bid Responsive?
Even if Vendor Responsible and Bid Responsive, Other Factors?
•Technical Capability –Past Performance at all MTA Agencies. – Physical Plant – Quality Programs – Related Experience
• Moral Integrity • Business Experience & Stability • Financial Condition
• Technical – QPL – Normal Bid – Evaluation
• Commercially –Lead Time – Ability to Cancel – Requirements
• Legally
• Product Tests (to get competition) • Under $15K • RFP Criteria • A/E Firm quality (To find the best firm) • Adjustments to Bid Price
–Life Cycle Cost – Cost Equivalents – Split Awards for Extra Protection
• Emergencies
3/25/2013 46 Construction Fraud
![Page 47: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
MTA Independent Private Sector Inspector General Program
• The program establishes a pool of pre-qualified parties to serve as Independent Private Sector Inspector Generals (IPSIGs) on an “as needed” basis. IPSIGs are called upon to serve as integrity monitors for vendors needing oversight as a condition of doing business with the MTA and its constituent Agencies.
3/25/2013 47 Construction Fraud
![Page 48: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Creation of the MTA IPSIG Program
• Request for Information (RFI) Issued. • Pre-Proposal Conference – Answer questions and gauge
interests. • Assess Proposals and Interview qualified firms. • Assess interview results. • Determine strengths and assign to specific areas of
interests. • Maintain database of active IPSIG participants. • Current database has 22 active IPSIG participants.
3/25/2013 48 Construction Fraud
![Page 49: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Selected IPSIG Firms and Category Assignments
• Internal Controls BDO USA, LLP • WDBE FTI Consulting, Inc. • Safety, Financial Services KPMG LLP • A&E Navigant Consulting, Inc. • Inspection & Testing Fraud Kroll, Inc. • Information Technology The Bradlau Group LLP • Financial Review Thacher Associates, LLC • Prevailing Wage Fortress Monitoring Group • Investigation Guidepost Solutions, LLC • Indictment Armand Resource Group, Inc. • Civil/Criminal Guilt Ronald Goldstock • Organized Crime, Doar Rieck Kaley & Mack • Integrity Challenge Harmon, LLC
3/25/2013 49 Construction Fraud
![Page 50: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Case Study
• Dragados/Judlau Joint Venture – East Side Access
• Offshoot of Skanska Case • Civil Fraud Unit of US Attorney, SDNY
– False Claims Act Settlement-$7.5 Million • $1 Million to MTAOIG
Problem. Are they responsible Contractors? MTA Determined that they are.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 50
![Page 51: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Case Study Cont’d-Dragados/Judlau
• NYC Transit, Office of Vendor Relations • Could they find the companies responsible. • Responsibility Hearing • Assessor to determine whether had appropriate
compliance program. • Determined that the Dragados compliance
program was state of the art. • MTA still using the companies, at least one of
which has set the standard in compliance.
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 51
![Page 52: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Interaction with Vendor Relations and Division of Diversity and Civil Rights
• Work with NYCT Vendor Relations – Assist in Responsibility Hearings – Vetting Monitors
• Division of Diversity and Civil Rights – Conduct Training – Answer Questions – Assist in troubling areas
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 52
![Page 53: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
• MTA OIG For more information please visit websites
www.mtaig.state.ny.us
www.oig.dot.gov
www.PreventTransportationFraud.org and
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 53
![Page 54: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Questions?
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 54
![Page 55: Prevention and Enforcement of M/W/DBE and Other ... Presentation Construction Ethics.pdf · Construction Fraud Calculation of DBE Participation • 49 CFR 26.55, How DBE Participation](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040823/5e6da3b0ed932971124e0b71/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Can Also Contact US DOT OIG
NY Office:
(212) 337-1250
or HOTLINE 1(800) 424-9071
Or e-mail
Construction Fraud 3/25/2013 55