PRESORTED U.S. POSTAGE STANDARD INSIGHT & · PDF fileInvincible plus three other armored...
Transcript of PRESORTED U.S. POSTAGE STANDARD INSIGHT & · PDF fileInvincible plus three other armored...
We plan for tomorrow so you can live today.
The Ice House
231 Riverside Drive, Suite 105
Macon, GA 31201
Toll Free: 866-606-5554
E-mail: [email protected]
PattonAlbertsonMiller.com
Insight & Outlook is published quarterly by Patton Albertson & Miller.
The statements expressed in this newsletter are the opinions of
Patton Albertson & Miller and do not represent specific investment
recommendations or results.
Financial Life Management
Interested in reading what we read? Follow us on Twitter @PAM_Wealth
PRESORTEDSTANDARD
U.S. POSTAGEPAID
MAIL SORTMACON 31201
INSIGHT & OUTLOOKA QUARTERLY MARKET COMMENTARY & NEWSLETTER
2ND QUARTER 2016
On May 31st Great Britain celebrated the
100th anniversary of the Battle of Jutland, the
great naval battle in the North Sea between
Admiral John Jellicoe’s British Grand Fleet and Vice Admiral Reinhard Scheer’s German High Seas Fleet. This World War I sea battle
engaged over 100,000 officers and sailors
aboard more than 250 ships, including 28
British battleships and 24 German ones.
The running engagement lasted into the early
hours of June 1, 1916, and when it was over
the British counted 14 ships sunk and 6607
casualties of which 6097 were fatalities.
Britain lost its three best battle cruisers,
the Indefatigable, the Queen Mary, and the
Invincible plus three other armored cruisers
and eight destroyers. The Germans lost 11
ships (1 obsolete battleship, 5 cruisers, and
5 destroyers) and suffered 3058 casualties
of which 2551 were fatalities. The Germans
claimed the tactical victory but Great Britain
won the strategic victory because 1) the
British Grand Fleet remained intact and potent
insuring that 2) the British blockade would
continue against Imperial Germany.
After the epic battle critics complained that
Admiral Jellicoe had been too cautious thereby
missing the opportunity for a modern day
Nelsonian “Battle of Trafalgar”. Winston Churchill,
however, astutely observed that Jellicoe was
“…the only man on either side who could
lose the war in an afternoon.” A major
British defeat would have broken the British
blockade which was slowly strangling
Germany’s war effort and would have allowed
German surface raiders to combine with
German submarines. Great Britain would have
found itself blockaded with dire implications
for its capacity to carry on the war.
Churchill’s judgement was correct.
Jellicoe and Scheer faced what are called
“asymmetrical payoffs”. Scheer had little to
lose if he were aggressive. If the High Seas
Fleet had been severely defeated, strategically
not much would have changed. In fact, the
German Navy had a Plan B—unrestricted
submarine warfare. So it had options although
not very good ones. For Jellicoe, as noted
earlier, a great defeat might have forced Great
Britain out of the war and handed Imperial
Germany mastery of Europe.
Investors, much like Jellicoe and Scheer, need
to carefully assess their true strategic position
when they decide how much risk to assume in
their portfolios. Are they in Admiral Jellicoe’s
position where major losses could cripple their
ability to meet their long term objectives?
Many retirees face Jellicoe’s predicament.
If they invest too aggressively in stocks and
a bear market like 2001-2003 or 2008-2009
hits, they might lack the time and fortitude
to recover. The psychological downside to
a more conservative asset allocation is not
participating as fully in bullish markets.
They’ll still make good “risk adjusted” returns,
but those might prove dissatisfying when they
see others reaping higher returns from their
higher risk asset allocations.
JELLICOE OR SCHEER?
On the other hand, many younger investors
are in Vice Admiral Scheer’s situation.
They can be fairly aggressive in their asset
allocation by holding a higher proportion of
stocks, knowing that time is on their side.
They can recover from big losses provided
they stay the course. They have options.
Behavioral finance, however, warns us that
investors, younger and older, often do NOT
stay the course in the face of large losses
aka “drawdowns”. Even a 25-year-old can
be shaken by markets like 2008 when well
diversified, high quality, stock portfolios
collapsed 35-45% in just a matter of months.
The all too human tendency is to relieve the
immediate financial and psychological pain by
selling securities, often near the bottom.
A Morningstar analysis of the 2008-2009 bear
market indicated the greatest selling of equity
mutual funds occurred in the first quarter of
2009, within weeks of the bear market low.
In other words, many investors sold out
after most of the damage had been done
and accordingly missed the huge rally which
started in March 2009.
“MANY INVESTORS SOLD OUT
AFTER MOST OF THE DAMAGE
HAD BEEN DONE”
“JELLICOE AND SCHEER
FACED WHAT ARE CALLED
‘ASYMETRICAL PAYOFFS’.”
with this great team of people who share a
common set of values. You can’t really call
this work because we love what we do and
like the people we work with!
Q: What has the transition from a lifetime
Georgian to a Chattanoogan been like?
A: Three years ago, we moved our family to
Chattanooga, TN after we opened our office
here and we have loved being part of this
beautiful city. Chattanooga has welcomed us
from both a personal and professional perspective.
The Chattanooga Women’s Leadership Institute
(CWLI) has been an awesome introduction to
so many aspects of Chattanooga.
Q: Share a little with us about your family.
A: I am married to Eddie and we have four
children, plus our golden retriever Buddy.
We have one son left at home so we are
quickly approaching the “empty nest”
milestone. Still trying to figure out if I am
looking forward to the freedom or will
miss the hectic activity. I like to read, grow
a garden (flowers and vegetables), cook,
and I also enjoy amateur photography.
The definition of a hobby is something you
love to do for pleasure or relaxation. I have
enjoyed joining The Canyons at Falling Water
Book Club as well as the Sweet and Savory
Cooking Club.
Q: Tell us more about your photography.
A: Photography has really become a passion
of mine in the last several years. There is
something about the combination of sky,
mountains and the Tennessee river that
compels me to snap photos of the
Scenic City. I have a friend who is really
good at portrait paintings and photographs,
while I lean toward landscapes. My son,
Jared, just completed a photography class
at Chattanooga Christian School where he
learned about things like aperture, white
balance, and film speed. He knows a lot
about the process and technique of taking
photographs; I am more interested in the search
for that beautiful moment I want to capture.
Q: Any particularly memorable pictures
you have taken?
A: On the morning of February 26th, after 7
inches of snow, I was fortunate to get some
pretty good shots of the sun rising on all
that ice and snow resulting in what looked
like fire and ice! (See photograph below)
We enlarged it to a poster size, left it
un-enhanced and hung it in our small
conference room. All the glory goes to the
maker not the taker!
Q: Anything else you would like to share?
A: I am always amazed by the pursuits of
others and enjoy hearing what brings joy to
each person. In my compliance role, I
regularly spend time in each of our locations
and look forward to meeting you and
hearing about your hobbies.
Bill Miller, CFAPatton Albertson & Miller
We are not advocating Wall Street’s advice
to “buy and hold” because “the stock
market always comes back.” The S&P 500
took more than six long years to recover
the losses from the 2007 high (it took
23 years, until 1952, to recover from the
granddaddy of bear markets in 1929). The
compounded return of stocks from 2007
to 2013 was about zero. Not very many
investors could have been happy with that.
Many undoubtedly wished they had cut their
equity exposure in 2007-08.
We have shown the following data before,
but it bears revisiting:
The data show the critical importance
of avoiding large drawdowns. We very
successfully used our “Portfolio Protection
Strategy” in 2007-2009 to sidestep a
significant percentage of the S&P 500’s
peak to trough decline of 57%. The cost of
such a strategy, however, is that sometimes
defensive action, in hindsight,
proves premature. For example, in 2010
during the first Greek crisis, in 2011 during
the Euro crisis, and more recently in the
fall of 2015 our rules-based model signaled
precaution so we partially hedged our clients’
equity exposure. We never know for certain
whether a 5 or 10% decline will turn into
something much more dangerous so we have
to respect the historical odds. In the last
three instances the stock market eventually
turned around and headed higher, so the
“hedge” trimmed a couple of percentage
points off clients’ equity returns. Especially in
today’s low return environment giving up any
returns is frustrating for us and our clients.
Yet we doubt bear markets are extinct and
because of their severe impact on clients’
long term, full market cycle (trough to
trough) returns, we still think it is prudent
to hedge our “Jellicoe” clients. But if you
consider yourself a “Scheer” client, please
let us know. At the end of the day it is your
individual risk tolerance that counts.
Bill Miller, CFA
Swiss 30 Year Bonds
The spread of negative interest rates
has astonished the frugal Swiss people.
On June 16th Switzerland’s 30 year bond
traded below 0% for the first time ever,
reaching -.05%. That means all Swiss
federal government debt now requires the
lenders to pay the borrowers. The 10 year
maturity has carried a negative yield since
January 2015. There was a time when
the Swiss National Bank represented a
beacon of monetary sanity, but apparently
no longer. The SNB has joined the central
bankers’ club whose motto is “We’re all
Keynesians now”.
Hedge Funds Struggle, Again
Dan Loeb, the famous hedge fund
manager, wrote his investors “We are in the
first innings of a washout in hedge funds.”
Hedge funds as a group have seen over
$15 billion withdrawn from the industry
through the first quarter of 2016. Many
large institutional investors such as the
California Public Employees’ Retirement
System (Calpers) and the pension fund
for New York City employees are cutting
their hedge fund investments due to
disappointing returns over the past
several years. Due to their enormous
investment appetite, they can only invest
in strategies capable of handling huge
fund flows—currencies, macro, long/short
equities, government bonds—and those
sort of strategies have not done well
of late. Large institutions cannot tap into
niche strategies, although smaller investors
can. As always, the top 10-20% hedge funds
account for most of the returns in the industry.
French RiotsFrance has been in political turmoil since
this spring when President Francois
Hollande proposed reforms to France’s
rigid labor laws. Unions and students
have protested against the changes in
Paris, Marseille, Toulouse and elsewhere.
The reforms would allow businesses more
flexibility in hiring and firing employees.
In recent weeks some of the protests have
turned violent, yet US news media have
largely ignored the unrest.
Facts:
• Born in Warner Robins, Georgia
• Lives in Chattanooga, Tennessee
• Married to Eddie
• Four children (Brooke, Ashley, Kyle, and Jared)
• Joined Patton Albertson & Miller in 2011
• Elected Partner of the firm in 2013
• Chief Compliance Officer and Director of
Human Resources
• Holds the IACCP (Investment Adviser
Certified Compliance Professional) and
SPHR/SHRM-SCP professional designations.
Recently, Jimmy Patton sat down with Lisa
and asked her a few questions:
Q: Lisa, what is your role at Patton Albertson
& Miller?
A: My title is Chief Compliance Officer and
Director of Human Resources. Although
that sounds like a behind the scenes staff
position, I really work for our clients by
promoting safety and soundness. My role
is to be an advocate for our clients, making
sure we have the very best in cyber-security,
best execution of trades, and, of course,
compliance with all the SEC rules and
regulations which are designed to protect
our clients. Instead of being called the Chief
Compliance Officer, a better description
would be Chief Client Advocate.
Q: Tell us a little about yourself.
A: I was blessed to have been born and
raised in Middle Georgia by two great
parents, William and Elizabeth Murphy.
Before joining Patton Albertson & Miller I
worked for two Fortune 500 companies for
20+ years. I worked with several members of
the Patton Albertson & Miller team while at
SunTrust Bank and I’m so fortunate to work
MEET LISA BRYANT
UNDER THE RADAR
10%
DRAWDOWN RECOVERY NEEDEDTO BREAK EVEN
11%
20% 25%
30% 43%
40% 67%
50% 100%
“... WE LOVE WHAT WE DO
AND LIKE THE PEOPLE
WE WORK WITH!”
“..IT IS YOUR OWN INDIVIDUAL RISK TOLERANCE THAT COUNTS.”