This is a n Op e n Acces s doc u m e n t dow nloa d e d fro m ORCA, Ca r diff U nive r si ty 's

ins ti t u tion al r e posi to ry: h t t p s://o rc a.c a r diff.ac.uk/115 0 1 1/

This is t h e a u t ho r’s ve r sion of a wo rk t h a t w as s u b mi t t e d to / a c c e p t e d for

p u blica tion.

Cit a tion for final p u blish e d ve r sion:

Collins, Pe t e r W., Bell, S a r a h , De Lloyd, Lucy a n d Collis, R ac h el 2 0 1 9.

M a n a g e m e n t of pos t p a r t u m h a e m o r r h a g e: fro m r e s e a rc h in to p r a c tice, a

n a r r a tive r eview of t h e lit e r a t u r e a n d t h e Ca r diff exp e ri e nc e. In t e r n a tion al

Jou r n al of Obs t e t ric Anes t h e si a 3 7 , p p. 1 0 6-1 1 7. 1 0 .10 1 6/j.ijoa.20 1 8.08.00 8

file

P u blish e r s p a g e: h t t p://dx.doi.or g/10.10 1 6/j.ijoa.201 8.08.00 8

< h t t p://dx.doi.o rg/10.10 1 6/j.ijoa.201 8.08.00 8 >

Ple a s e no t e:

Ch a n g e s m a d e a s a r e s ul t of p u blishing p roc e s s e s s uc h a s copy-e di ting,

for m a t ting a n d p a g e n u m b e r s m ay no t b e r eflec t e d in t his ve r sion. For t h e

d efini tive ve r sion of t his p u blica tion, ple a s e r ef e r to t h e p u blish e d sou rc e. You

a r e a dvise d to cons ul t t h e p u blish e r’s ve r sion if you wish to ci t e t his p a p er.

This ve r sion is b ein g m a d e av ailable in a cco r d a n c e wit h p u blish e r policie s.

S e e

h t t p://o rc a .cf.ac.uk/policies.h t ml for u s a g e policies. Copyrigh t a n d m o r al r i gh t s

for p u blica tions m a d e available in ORCA a r e r e t ain e d by t h e copyrig h t

hold e r s .

1

Title

Managementofpostpartumhaemorrhage:fromresearchintopractice,anarrativereviewofthe

literatureandtheCardiffexperience

PWCollinsa,SFBell

b,LdeLloyd

bandRECollis

b

a. InstituteofInfectionandImmunity,SchoolofMedicine,CardiffUniveristy,Cardiff,UK

b. DepartmentofAnaesthetics,IntensiveCareandPainMedicine,CardiffandValeUniversity

HealthBoard,Cardiff,UK

Correspondingauthor

RachelCollis:DepartmentofAnaesthetics,IntensiveCareandPainMedicine,CardiffandVale

UniversityHealthBoard,Cardiff,UK

Email:Rachel.collis@wales.nhs.uk

rachel.collis@wales.nhs.uk

Keywords

Postpartumhaemorrhage;viscoelastometry;fibrinogen;coagulopathy;qualityimprovement

Highlights

• Fibrinogenfallsbeforeothercoagulationfactorsduringpostpartumhaemorrhage(PPH)

• LaboratoryClaussfibrinogenandpointofcareFibtemA5®predictprogressionofPPH

• HaemostaticimpairmentisuncommonduringPPHandcanbeassessedbyFibtem

• Afibrinogenof2g/LorFibtemA512mmandaboveisadequateforhaemostasisduringPPH

• Anationalqualityimprovementprogrammehasbeeninitiatedintegratingtheseresults

Summary

Postpartumhaemorrhage(PPH)iscausedbyobstetriccomplicationsbutmaybeexacerbatedby

haemostaticimpairment.Inatenyearprogrammeofresearchwehaveestablishedthathaemostatic

impairmentisuncommoninmoderatePPHandthatfibrinogenfallsearlierthanothercoagulation

factors.LaboratoryClaussfibrinogenandthepointofcaresurrogatemeasureoffibrinogen(Fibtem®

A5measuredontheRotem®machine)arepredictivebiomarkersforprogressionfromearlytosevere

PPH,theneedforbloodtransfusionandinvasiveprocedurestocontrolhaemorrhage.Fibrinogen

replacementisnotrequiredinPPHunlesstheplasmalevelfallsbelow2g/LortheFibtemA5is

2

below12mm.Deficienciesofcoagulationfactorsotherthanfibrinogenareuncommonevenduring

severePPH,andRotemmonitoringcaninformwithholdingFFPsafelyinmostwomen.Inthe

absenceofplacentalabruption,clinicallysignificantthrombocytopeniaisuncommonunlessthe

plateletcountislowbeforethebleedstarted,orverylargebleeds(>5000mL)occur.Measuring

bloodlossisfeasibleinroutinepracticeduringPPHandismoreaccuratethanestimation.These

researchfindingshavebeencollatedtodesignanongoingqualityimprovementprogrammeforall

maternityunitsinWalescalledOBSCymru(Wales)(TheObstetricBleedingStrategyforWales).

Aims

Theaimsofthisreviewareto:Summarisetheliteraturerelatingtothecoagulationprofileofwomen

withPPH,describehowpointofcare(POC)basedalgorithmscanprovidetimelyinformationfor

clinicianswiththepotentialtoreducebloodproductuseanddescribehowprotocolsusedduring

researchcanhaveapositiveimpactonallpatientswithfewermajorcomplicationsandmassive

bloodtransfusions.

Background

Theincidenceofpostpartumhaemorrhage(PPH)isincreasinginmanycountriesandisthemost

commoncauseofdeathforwomenofchildbearingageworldwide.1-6Blee

dingiscausedbyobstetriccomplicationsbutmaybeexacerbatedbyhaemostaticimpairment.7Itis

widelyassumedthathaemostaticimpairmentoftencomplicatesPPHandconsequently,when

coagulationtestresultsareunavailable,guidelinesendorsetheuseofformulaicinfusionoffresh

frozenplasma(FFP)orcryoprecipitateinfixedratioswithredbloodcells(RBC),8-10

basedon

evidenceextrapolatedfromnon-pregnantadultmajortrauma.Itisquestionablewhetherthese

datashouldbeappliedtothemanagementofPPHgiventheverydifferentbaselinecoagulation

statusofthegroups.

HighqualitystudiesdescribingcoagulopathiesassociatedwithPPHarelimited,howeveritis

probablythattheyresultfromcomplexinteractionsbetweendilution,localconsumption,

disseminatedconsumptionandincreasedfibrinolysis.7Thenatureofhaemostaticimpairmentvaries

accordingtothecauseofthebleedandisaffectedbycomplicationsofpregnancysuchaspre-

eclampsia,sepsisandimpairedliverfunction.Thephysiologicaladaptionsofpregnancyresultina

pro-thromboticstateattermwithincreasedlevelsofpro-coagulantsanddecreasedanti-coagulants.

3

Inparticular,attermthefibrinogenlevelis4-6g/Lattermgestation,comparedto2-4g/Linhealthy

non-pregnantwomen.11;12

Untilrecentlyitwasnotknownwhetherfibrinogenreplacementduring

severePPHshouldtarget‘normalforterm’(>4g/L),‘normalforthenon-pregnancy’(>2g/L),or

somewhereinbetween.ThisisimportantwhenconsideringtheroleofFFPintreatingcoagulopathy

inPPH.13

FFPcontainsabout2g/Loffibrinogen,whereastheaveragefibrinogenlevelinawomanwith1000-

2000mlbloodlossduetoatonyortraumaisabout4g/L.14Thismeansthatinmostcases,infusion

ofFFPduringPPHwouldreducefibrinogenbydilution.15Thisimpliesthatunmonitoredfixed-ratio

infusionsofFFPwouldexposemanywomentoFFPwithoutanyprospectofimprovinghaemostasis.

Studiesexploringtheuseoffixed-ratioinfusionsofFFP:RBCduringPPHreportfewerwomen

developinglaboratoryevidenceofcoagulopathy,however,someofthesestudiesdescribemultiple

interventionsincludingearlyinvolvementofseniorstaff.16-20

Whenguidedbyviscoelastometricpoint

ofcaretesting(VE-POCT),wehaveshownthatFFPcanbewithheldsafelyinwomenexperiencing

moderatetoseverePPH,withoutdevelopmentofclinicalsignificanthaemostaticimpairment.21A

recentreviewsuggestedthatFFPwasnottheoptimalwaytoreplacefibrinogenduringPPH.13

PPHObservationsandResearchAdvancementsinCardiff,Wales

UsingFibrinogenConcentratetoTreatPPHwithHypofibrinogenemia

WeobservedthatsomewomenexperiencingseverePPHhadlaboratoryfibrinogenlevels<1g/L

associatedwithclinicalhaemostaticimpairment.AtthistimetheRoyalCollegeofObstetricsand

Gynaecology(RCOG)guidancewastomaintainfibrinogen>1g/Lusingcryoprecipitate.22Thawing

andinfusingcryoprecipitatetakestime,delayingcorrectionofthecoagulopathy.Atourcentreand

others,weaddressedthisissuebyinfusingfibrinogenconcentratewhichrapidlyincreasedthe

fibrinogenlevelandwasassociatedwiththeclinicalimpressionofimprovementinhaemostasis.23-26

Weinfusedfibrinogenconcentratebetween2and4Gtosixwomenovera2-yearperiod

(approximately12,000deliveries)withclinicalimprovement,althoughthedataonallwomenwith

lowfibrinogenwasnotcollectedatthistime24Theseearlyreportsreflectedareactiveratherthan

preventativestrategytohaemostaticimpairment.Morerecentstudiesfromothergroupshave

reportedimprovementsinhaemostasiswiththeuseoffibrinogenconcentratetotreat

hypofibrinogenaemia.27;28

Thesecasereportsareselectiveandpronetoreportingbias,butwere

sufficientlyencouragingtopromotefurtherinvestigation.

4

TheroleofStandardCoagulationTestsandClaussFibrinogenforDetectionofCoagulopathyinPPH

Toinvestigatetheeffectofseverityofbleedingonstandardcoagulationtests,weevaluateda

consecutivecohortof18,501womenwhodeliveredatourunitover3years.WomenwithPPH

>1500mL(n=456,2.5%)hadtheirbloodtestresultsreviewed.PTandaPTTusuallyremainedwithin

thenormalrangeuntilbloodlossreached4000-5000mL.29Thisreflectedsufficientcoagulation

factorsforhaemostasisuntilthebleedvolumereached4000-5000ml,andinfusionofFFPuptothat

timewasunlikelytohaveimprovedhaemostasis.Incontrast,fibrinogenfellrapidlyasbloodvolume

lossincreased,suchthatby2000mLthemajorityofcaseshadafibrinogenbelowthenormalrange

forterm(4g/L),andat4000mLmostwomenhadafibrinogen<2g/L.29AUKObstetricSurveillance

System(UKOSS)surveyofwomentransfused≥8unitsofRBC(averagebloodloss6000mL)also

foundthatmanymorewomenhadafibrinogen<2g/LthananabnormalPToraPTTbothatfirst

presentationandwhencoagulationwasatitsworst.30Thelikelihoodofhypofibrinogenaemia

dependedonthecauseofbleedingandwasmostoftenassociatedwithplacentalabruption.14;30

Takentogether,thesestudiesindicatethatthestandardcoagulationtestsPTandaPTTshowthat

earlydepletionofcoagulationfactorsisuncommoninobstetrichaemorrhage,andthatplasma

fibrinogenlevelmaybeamoreimportanttherapeutictarget.

FibrinogenandFibtemasbiomarkerstopredictseverityofprogressionofpostpartumhaemorrhage

Inaninfluentialpaper,Charbitetalmeasuredmultiplecoagulationfactorsinwomenexperiencing

PPH.FibrinogenlevelwastheonlyindependentpredictorofprogressiontoseverePPHanda

fibrinogen<2g/Lhadhada100%positivepredictivevalueforprogressionfrommoderatetosevere

PPH.31Thisfindinghasbeenconfirmedbyusinretrospectiveandprospectivestudiesandbyother

groupsinvestigatingPPHinmultiplecohortsusingdiversemethodologies(Table1).14;31-35

These

studiesnowshowconvincinglythatplasmaClaussfibrinogen,measuredearlyduringPPH,isa

biomarkerforpredictingprogressiontoseverePPH.

AlthoughplasmaClaussfibrinogenlevelsyieldsusefulinformation,ittakesatleastanhourfora

resulttobeavailable,limitingitsutilitytodirectpracticeduringPPH.VE-POCTsgenerateasurrogate

measureoffibrinogenwithresultsavailablewithin10minutesofvenipuncture.36-38

Weinitiatedthe

ObstetricBleedingStudy1(OBS-1)toinvestigatewhetheraFibtem®assay,performedontheRotem®

machine(Werfen,Barcelona,Spain),couldpredictprogressionfromearlytoseverePPH.A

consecutivecohortof346womenwithPPH>1000mLwasenrolled.AtrecruitmentbaselineFibtem

wasperformedconcurrentlywithaplasmaClaussfibrinogen,whilstallotherroutinePPH

5

managementwasprovided.ClinicianswereblindedtotheFibtemresultbutdidknowthe

laboratoryfibrinogenwhenitbecameavailable(Fig.1).14

DespiteonlyamoderatecorrelationbetweenClaussfibrinogenandFibtem(r=0.59)thetwo

parametershadanalmostidenticalvalueforpredictingprogression.AstheClaussfibrinogenor

FibtemfelltheneedforanyRBCtransfusion,≥4unitsRBC,≥8unitsofbloodproducts

(RBC+FFP+platelets),useofaninvasiveprocedureorableed>2500mLincreased.Thelowerthe

fibrinogenorFibtemA5thehighertheproportionofwomenwithpooroutcomes(Fig.2).For

example,themedian(IQR)fibrinogenandFibtemA5ofwomenwhoreceived≥8unitsofblood

productswas2.1(1.8-3.4)g/Land12(7-17)mm,respectively,comparedwith3.9(3.2-4.5)and19

(17-23)inthosewhodidnot.FibtemA5<10mmwasassociatedwithmoreprolongedbleeding

(median127versus65minutes,p=0.02),longerinlevel2care(patientsneedingextendedpost-

operativecarewithenhancedinterventionsandmonitoring)(median24versus11hours,p<0.001)

andshortertimetofirstRBCtransfusion(p<0.001).Inaddition,thecombinationofalow

fibrinogen/Fibtem,withtheclinicalobservationthattherewason-goingPPHatrecruitment,wasa

strongerpredictorofthesepooroutcomesthaneitheralone.14

OBS-1confirmedthatalowfibrinogenorFibtemA5,measuredearlyduringaPPHwasassociated

withprogressionofPPH,howeveritremainedunknownwhethercorrectionoftheseparameters

wouldimproveoutcome.Furthermore,theappropriateclinicaltargetforfibrinogenorFibtemA5to

maintainhaemostasis,andthereforewhenfibrinogencontainingproductsshouldbeinfused,was

unknown.

AppropriateTriggersforFibrinogenreplacementduringPPH

InanauditreportcomparingaRotem-basedalgorithm(thatinfused3goffibrinogenconcentrateif

theFibtemwas<7mm,or<12mmwithseverebleeding,andFFPiftheExtemCTwas>100s)with

theUnit’spreviouspracticeoftreatingmajorPPHwithshockpacks(consistingof4RBC,4FFPand1

poolofplatelets):TheRotem-basedalgorithmwasassociatedwithalargereductioninFFP,

cryoprecipitateandplateletusage,fewerwomenneeded>5unitsRBC,orhadtransfusion

associatedcirculatoryoverloadoradmissiontoITU.39;40

Whilethesedatawereretrospectiveandun-

randomized,theiroutcomesindicatethatROTEM-guidedtransfusionmanagementmaybesuperior

toanempiricmassivetransfusionapproachforPPH.Thereisnoinformationinthepaperabout

responsetimestoadministrationofbloodproductsafteradoptionoffibrinogenconcentrate

6

infusions,althoughimmediateavailabilityoffibrinogenconcentratestoredontheirdeliverysuite

mayhavereducedresponsetimeandthereforeimprovedclinicaloutcomes.

Aprospective,double-blind,randomisedcontrolledtrial(RCT)ledbyWikkelsoeinvestigated

whetherinfusing2goffibrinogenconcentrateafter500-1000mLbloodloss,irrespectiveofplasma

fibrinogenlevel,reducedtheneedforRBCtransfusionandbloodloss.Nodifferenceinoutcomes

wasachievedwiththeempiricadministrationof2GfibrinogenconcentrateforPPHshowingthat

earlypre-emptive,formulaicfibrinogenreplacementwasnotindicated.Analysisfoundthatthe

averagefibrinogenlevelwhenfibrinogenconcentratehadbeeninfusionwasabout4.5g/Linboth

armsofthestudy,demonstratingthatthislevelisadequateforhaemostasisduringPPH.41The

resultsprovidegoodevidenceagainsttheuseofempiricfibrinogenreplacementduringPPHinthe

absenceofamonitoredlowplasmafibrinogenlevel,whileexposingmanywomentoplasma-derived

bloodproductsunnecessarily.

IntheObstetricBleedingStudy2(OBS-2)weusedFibtemA5andobservationofongoingbleedingto

guidefibrinogenandFFPreplacement.InOBS-1,aFibtemA5<16mm(fibrinogenabout3g/L),ina

womanwithongoingbleeding,hadbeenassociatedwithprogressiontomultiplepooroutomes14

andthiswassupportedbyotherobservationalstudies(Table1).OBS-2wasadouble-blind,placebo

controlledRCTwhichenrolledwomenwithPPH>1000-1500mL.Thestudyinvestigatedwhether

infusingfibrinogenconcentrate42ifFibtemA5was<16mmandbleedingwasongoingreducedblood

productusage.OBS-2alsoinvestigatedwhetheritwassafetowithholdFFPifFibtemA543was≥15

mmontheassumptionthatanormalfibrinogenwasasurrogateforadequatelevelsofother

coagulationfactors(Fig.3a).14;29;31

Therewasnostatisticallysignificantdifferenceinanyoutcomebetweenthefibrinogenandplacebo

(Normalsaline)groups,demonstratingthatafibrinogenofaround3g/Lisadequateforhaemostasis

duringPPH.44Pre-specifiedsubgroupanalyses

43showedthatfibrinogen>2g/LorFibtemA5>12mm

wereadequateforhaemostasisdespiteseverePPH.However,ifFibtemA5orfibrinogenwas<12

mmor<2g/Latthetimeofrandomisation,womeninthefibrinogengroupreceivedfewerblood

productsandhadlowerbloodlossafterstudymedicationcomparedtoplacebo.44Theseexploratory

subgroupanalysesdidnotreachstatisticalsignificancepossiblyduetothesmallnumberofwomen

randomisedwithafibrinogen<2g/L.Howevertheseresults,inconjunctionwiththedatafrom

Mallaiah39,suggestthatanappropriateinterventionpointforinfusionoffibrinogenisaFibtemA5

<12mmorfibrinogen<2g/L,andastudyinvestigatingthisiswarranted.

Inourexperienceafibrinogenlevelbelow2g/Lisuncommonduringobstetrichaemorrhage.

Combiningdatafromconsecutivestudiesandobservationfromourinstitutionoverthelast8years

7

showsarateof1-2/1000deliveriesandasimilarincidencehasbeenobservedacrossallunitsin

Wales.InOBS-2,irrespectiveofbloodloss,womenwithaFibtemA5>15mmorwhohadstopped

bleeding,hadFFPwithheld(n=605).Median(IQR)bloodlosswas1500ml(1300-2000ml)andnone

ofthewomendevelopedhaemostaticimpairment21suggestingthathaemostaticimpairmentduring

PPHcanbeassessedaccuratelyusingVE-POCTs.

Thrombocytopeniaandplatelettransfusionduringpostpartumhaemorrhage

IthasbeensuggestedthatamassivetransfusionprotocolusedforPPHshouldinclude

platelets.18;20;45;46

Guidelinesrecommendmaintainingtheplateletcountabove75x109/Lduring

PPH.8;9TherearelimiteddataontheincidenceandcausesofthrombocytopeniaduringPPH,

thereforeweanalysedthewomenrecruitedtotheOBS-1study.InmoderatetoseverePPH,

thrombocytopeniawasuncommon,with8/347(2.3%)womenhavingaplateletcount<75x109/L.

Twelvewomen(3.4%)receivedaplatelettransfusionandthesefellintotwogroups.Firstly,women

whowerethrombocytopenicbeforedeliveryduetopre-eclampsiaorpre-existingdiseasessuchas

immuneorinheritedthrombocytopeniaandsecondly,womenwithinitiallynormalplateletcounts

whoeitherhadaplacentalabruptionorbleeds>5000mL.47Thesefindingsweresupportedbythe

UKOSSsurveyofwomenwhoreceived≥8unitofRBC(medianbloodloss6000mL)wherethe

medianfirstplateletcounttakenduringthebleedwas131x109/Landlowestwas68x10

9/L,77%of

thesewomenreceivedaplatelettransfusion.Placentalabruptionwasassociatedwiththelargestfall

inplateletcount(137to54x109/L).

30Thesereportssuggestthattheplateletcountisadequate

duringPPHinthevastmajorityofcases,andinclusionofplateletsinshockpackswouldresultin

manywomenreceivingunnecessaryplateletinfusions.

MeasurementofbloodlossafterdeliveryandduringPPH

EarlyrecognitionofPPHwithmeasuredratherthanestimatedbloodlossiscriticalbecauseclinicians

oftenunderestimatethevolumeofbleeding.48Measurementofbloodlossismoreaccurateandis

feasibleinroutinepractice,shouldbestartedaftereverydeliveryeveniftheinitiallossseems

normal49andisakeyrecommendationinRCOGguidance.

8Weadoptedthepracticeofgravimetric

measurementofbloodlossonswabsandpadswiththeadditionofmeasuredbloodlossinconical

underbuttockdrapesandsuctionbottlesduringourstudiestostandardisepatientrecruitmentand

ensuretimelyescalationofcare.Measurementofbloodlossalonedoesnotleadtoimproved

outcomesduringPPH,50butwhenintegratedintoapathwaycanaidescalationofcare.

20Inaddition,

escalationofcarealsoneedstotakeintoaccountotherfactorssuchasmaternalvitalsignsas

bleedingcanbeconcealedandtheapparentrateofbloodloss,althoughspecificguidanceisnot

available.

8

ImpactofObstetricBleedingStudiesonpracticeandevolvingqualityimprovement

Between2013and2015womenrecruitedtoOBS-2followedthestudybloodproductalgorithm(Fig

2a)andthosenotrecruitedweretreatedusingthelocalmajorobstetrichaemorrhageROTEM

algorithm(Fig3b).Since2010PPHoutcomedatahasbeencollectedatourinstitutionaspartofa

qualityimprovementinitiative.DuringOBS-2,RBCusagedecreasedby32%,FFPusageby86%and

thenumberofwomenreceiving5ormoreunitsRBCfellby86%(Fig4).Inaddition,bleeds≥2500ml

fellby83%andlevel3ITUadmissions(womenrequiringadvancedrespiratorysupport)duetoPPH

decreasedfromabout4/yeartononein3years(Fig4).Althoughtemporallyrelated,itisunlikely

thattheinterventionoffibrinogenadministrationwassolelyresponsiblefortheseimproved

outcomesasonly7womentreatedintheinterventionalarmhadafibrinogen<2g/L.Thisimplies

thatotherfactorsassociatedwithrunningthestudyandcomplyingwithprotocolswereinfluencing

maternaloutcomes.Inordertostandardiserecruitmenttothestudy,womenwereriskassessed,

bloodlosswasmeasuredratherthanestimatedandobstetriciansandanaesthetistsattendedthe

mother’sbedsidetoobtainconsentandtakestudybloodsasspecifiedinthestudyprotocol.

WhenOBS-2endedinNovember2015,itwasexpectedthatimprovedoutcomeswouldcontinue.

However,itrapidlybecameapparentthatthiswasnotthecaseandtheendofthestudycoincided

withanincreaseinlargehaemorrhagestoratessimilartobeforethestudy(Fig4).Asystematic

reviewof16largebleedsovera6monthperiodidentifiedcommonthemesincludingareturnto

estimatingbloodloss,themultidisciplinaryteamnotattendingthemother’sbedsideinatimely

fashionandPOCTsnotbeingperformedearlyinthecourseofthehaemorrhage.Thisresultedin

delayedrecognitionofadeterioratingpatientanddelayedescalationofobstetricintervention.

Qualityimprovementinitiativesinpostpartumhaemorrhage

In2011ShieldsdescribedaqualityimprovementprogrammethatstandardisedcareduringPPH.This

includedriskassessmentfollowedbyanescalating3-stageapproachbasedon500,1000and1500

mLbloodlossand/orclinicalsigns.Thisstepwise,prescriptiveapproachrequiredaccurate

contemporaneousmeasurementratherthanestimationofbloodlossandwasinitiatedafterevery

delivery.Theprotocolstipulatedthataseniormidwife,obstetricianandanaesthetistshouldattend

themother’sbedsidewhenbloodlossreached1000mL.At1500mLbloodloss,empiricalfixed-ratio

bloodproducttransfusionwasstartedbasedondataderivedfromtraumastudies.Thegroupnoted

thatPPHprogressedinfewerwomen,thenumberofbloodproductsusedfellandfewerwomen

9

developedcoagulopathy.19TheprotocolwasrolledoutacrossaregionbytheCaliforniaMaternal

QualityCareCollaborative(CMQCC)withsimilarresults.20Asimilarqualityimprovementprogramme

wasinitiatedbyTheAssociationofWomen’sHealth,ObstetricandNeonatalNurses(AWHONN).

BothCMQCCandAWHONNhaveextensiveinformationavailableontheirwebsites

(http://www.awhonn.org/?page=PPHandhttps://www.cmqcc.org/resources-tool-kits/toolkits/ob-

hemorrhage-toolkit).

Theseinitiativesoverlappedwithourexperiencesintermsofriskassessment,measuredbloodloss

andearlyescalationofobstetriccarebyseniorclinicians.Themaindifferencewastheapproachto

bloodproductreplacement,liberalfixed-ratioinfusionofbloodproductsbasedondataderivedfrom

trauma19;20

versusVE-POCTstotargethaemostatictherapybasedonourprogrammeofresearch.It

isnotknownwhichoftheseapproachesresultsinbetteroutcomesandclinicaltrialsspecifically

addressingthevalueofVE-POCTsarerequiredtoaddressthis.

Understandingtheimpactofpointofcaretestsofcoagulationinpostpartumhaemorrhage

DuringOBS-2Rotem-guidedbloodproductreplacementwasintroducedintoroutinepracticeatour

centreforallpatients..Asexperienceincreasedandcliniciansacceptedtheresultsasclinically

reliable,managementofPPHchanged.IfearlyinthebleedtheRotemresultswerenormal,the

bleedingmustbeduetoaphysicalcause(atony,traumaorretainedplacentaltissue)andnot

coagulopathy.Thisknowledgefacilitatedearlytargetedescalationofobstetriccareand,ifnecessary,

involvementofamoreexperiencedcolleague.Ifcoagulationwasabnormalearlyinthebleedthe

motherwasimmediatelyidentifiedashighrisk.Earlycoagulopathyinsuchcasesraisessuspicionof

delayedresuscitation,placentalabruptionoramnioticfluidembolus.Themotherrequiredurgent

treatmentforcoagulopathy,almostalwayswithfibrinogenreplacement,andescalationofobstetric

managementtoaddresstheunderlyingcauseofbleeding.Thisbinaryclassificationhelpedtheteam

focusonthemostimportantclinicalproblemandourimpressionwasthatVE-POCTsfacilitated

behaviouralchangeofthemultidisciplinaryteam.

ANationalInstituteforHealthandCareExcellencereviewofVE-POCTduringPPHfocusedonlyon

bloodandbloodproductusage(https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/dg13).Ourexperienceisthat

VE-POCTscanactasatriggeraroundwhichcarecanbestructuredbyencouragingcliniciansto

attendthebedsideearly.TheVE-POCTresultsinfluencedecisionmakingand,ifnormal,allowthe

obstetriciantofocusonmanagingtheobstetriccauseofbleedingwhiletheanaesthetist

10

concentratesonappropriateresuscitationandbloodproductreplacement.Ourobservation,

supportedbythefindingsfromOBS-2andotherretrospectiveobservationalstudies,27;28;39;40;44

isthat

inthesmallnumberofwomenwhoareidentifiedashavingafibrinogen<2g/LorFibtemA5<12mm,

rapidcorrectionofhypofibrinogenaemiawithfibrinogenconcentrateimproveshaemostasisandis

advantageous,althoughlargeprospectivetrialsareneededtoverifythesefindings.

Localqualityimprovementinitiatives

Improvedlocalclinicaloutcomesmaybeaconsequenceofmultipleinter-relatedfactors.These

includedriskassessmentofallwomen,cumulativemeasurementofbloodlossandensuringthatan

experiencedmidwife,obstetricianandanaesthetistattendthemotherat1000mLbloodlosswith

ROTEMassessmentofcoagulationforallwomenweathertheywereenrolledintotheOBS-2study

ornot.Wedonotknowwhichoneoftheseinterventionsimprovesoutcomesanditislikelytobea

combinationofallofthesefactors.Overaoneyearperiod(2017,18monthsafterfinishingtheOBS

2trial)inourtertiaryreferralcentre,2.8/1000womenhadaPPH>2500mL,abloodtransfusionof≥5

unitsRBCorreceivedFFP.WhencomparedwiththepublisheddatafromHealthcareImprovement

Scotland,whereanoverallrateof6/1000wasreported,ourresultsfallbelow3standarddeviations

fromthemean.2WearecurrentlyseekingtoreplicatetheseimprovementsacrossWales.

AllWalesqualityimprovementprogramme:OBSCymru(ObstetricBleedingStrategyforWales

(Cymru))

OBSCymru(http://www.1000livesplus.wales.nhs.uk/obs-cymru)isaregisteredqualityimprovement

initiativethataimstoreducematernalmorbidityduetoPPHacrossWales.Waleshasapopulation

of3.1millionanddelivers30,000womenayearin12consultantledunits(CLU),withbetween500-

6000deliveriesperannumineachCLU.TheprojectaimstoreduceratesofmajorPPHandblood

transfusion,level3ICUcareandhysterectomyduetoPPH.

TheOBSCymruintervention

ThekeytoOBSCymruistolimitthenumberofmoderatebleedsthatprogresstosevere

haemorrhageandsoreducematernalmorbidity.Theprojectfocusedon4keyelementswhichdraw

onthequalityimprovementworkfromothergroups19;20

andthelessonslearntfromourresearch

programme.

11

1. Riskassessmentofallwomen:potentialriskfactorsforPPHareflaggedonadmissionto

deliverysuiteandwithon-goingriskassessmentduringlabour.

2. Cumulativegravimetricmeasurementofbloodlossaftereverydelivery:tofacilitate

escalationofcarewithspecificactionsrequiredat500,1000and1500mLbloodloss.

3. Multidisciplinarycarewithaseniormidwife,obstetricianandanaesthetistattendingthe

bedsideat1000mLbloodloss.

4. Rotem-guidedbloodproductreplacementusinganalgorithmderivedfromtheresultsof

OBS-2.

Thesethemesareembeddedintoclinicalpracticeusinganumberofinterventionsandtools

(availableathttp://www.1000livesplus.wales.nhs.uk/obs-cymru).APPHproformadescribingan

escalating4-stageapproachwasdevelopedandisplacedinallmothers’notesonadmissionto

deliverysuite.(Specificpaperworkwhichdescribesallactionsandinterventionswhichshouldoccur

asPPHprogressesandalsoactsasatemplateforscribingtheevents).

• Stage0:riskassessmentforallwomeninlabour(onadmissionandaslabourprogresses).

• Stage1:at>500mLafteravaginalbirthaseniormidwifeisinformed,thecauseofbleeding

assessedandinitialtreatmentinstituted.

• Stage2:at>1000mLaseniormidwife,obstetricianandanaesthetistattendthebedsideto

assessandescalatemanagementasappropriate.SamplesforRotem,bedsidelactateand

haemoglobin,FBCandcoagulationscreenaretakenandtranexamicacidisgiven.

• Stage3:at>1500mLwithon-goingbleedingtheconsultantobstetricianandanaesthetistare

informed.ThemajorobstetrichaemorrhageprotocolisactivatedandRotem-guidedblood

productreplacementinstitutedwhilstmedicalandsurgicaltreatmentsarecontinued.

ThisisacomplexinterventionandsoitsimpactisbeingassessedaccordingtoMedicalResearch

Councilguidance.51Thestep-wiseinterventionshavebeenincorporatedintoanallWalesPPH

guideline

(http://www.wisdom.wales.nhs.uk/sitesplus/documents/1183/Post%20Partum%20Haemorrhage_M

aternity%20Network%20Wales%20All%20Wales%20Guidelines_2017.pdf)andisbasedontheRoyal

CollegeofObstetricsandGynaecology(RCOG)green-topguidance8andincorporatingtheOBSCymru

approach.

DataarecollectedprospectivelyonallPPHs>1000mlinWalestobecomparedwithretrospective

datacollectedfromtheunits.ItistooearlytoassesswhetherkeymarkersofseverePPHare

changing;thisinformationwillbereportedatthecompletionoftheprojectin2019.

12

OBSCymruRotemguidedalgorithm

TheOBSCymruRotem-guidedbloodproductalgorithmisshowninfigure5http://www.oaa-

anaes.ac.uk/assets/_managed/cms/files/Guidelines/ROTEM%20Protocol.pdf.At1000mLbloodloss

withongoingbleedingFibtemA5andExtemCT,bedsidevenouslactateandhaemoglobinare

performedandFBCandcoagulationsenttothelaboratory.Intravenoustranexamicacidisgiven.The

WOMANtrialshowedthattranexamicacid,givenwithin3hoursofdelivery,reduceddeathdueto

bleedingwithoutanincreaseinthromboticorotheradverseevents,52ouralgorithmtherefore

infusestranexamicacidassoonasPPHisrecognisedoratthelatest1000mL.Therationaleforearly

Rotemtestingisnotonlytorapidlyidentifythesmallnumberofwomenwhoneedhaemostatic

support,buttoreassuretheobstetricianthatcoagulationisnormalandfocustreatmentonobstetric

causesofbleeding.Haemostaticbloodproductreplacementinitiallyfocusesonfibrinogen.IfFibtem

A5is≤12mmorClaussfibrinogen<2g/L,fibrinogenconcentrateisgiven.Fibrinogenconcentrateis

notlicensedforthisindicationintheUKandanalternative,asrecommendedbyRCOG,istoinfuse

cryoprecipitate.8TherecommendationsonfibrinogenreplacementarebasedondatafromOBS-2

andtheLiverpoolPPHalgorithm.39;40;44

Thetargetistomaintainthefibrinogen>2g/Lwhichis

supportedinthe2016RCOGguideline.8;9IftheExtemCTisprolongedabovethenormalrange(75

secbasedonlocalvalidation)orthePT/aPTTisabovethenormalrange,afterfibrinogen

replacement,15ml/kgFFPisinfusedbasedonRCOGguidanceandOBS-2data.8;44

Plateletsare

transfusedif<75x109/LbasedonRCOGguidance.

8Becausecoagulopathycanevolverapidlyduring

PPHwerepeatRotemandlaboratorytestingevery500mLorevery30minutesduringongoing

bleeding,oratanytimeforclinicalconcern.Testsarerepeatedafterbloodproductsaregivento

assessresponse.

TheFuture–questionstobeaddressed.

TheroleofVE-POCTsinthemanagementofPPHremainsdebated53;54

anddefinitiveevidenceis

lacking.Wehypothesisethatitisthecombinedeffectoftheearlyrecognitionofbleedingtriggering

timelyinterventionsincorporatingVE-POCTsandamanagementstrategyinvolvingthewhole

multidisciplinaryteamthatiskeytopreventingprogressionofPPHandminimisingmorbidity.A

studycomparingsuchanapproachutilisingearlyVE-POCT,withacceptedstandardcarebasedon

laboratorytestsofcoagulationisnownecessaryalthoughthiswouldnecessitatelargemulti-centre

studies.Itmayalsobepossibletopartiallyaddresssomeofthesequestionsbyspecificallystudying

highrisksurgicalproceduressuchaswomenhavingaCaesareansectionforplacentapreviaor

womenwhopresentwithabruption.

13

Dataonthecosteffectivenessofsuchanapproachisimportantifthisistobeusedmoregenerally

withinavarietyofhealthcaresettings.Wesuggestthatqualitativeassessmentoftheimpactofthe

interventiononteamdynamicsandbehaviourshouldalsobestudied.Amultinationalgroupof

interestedresearchersmayberequiredtoaddresstheseissues.

Funding

Thisreviewwaspreparedwithoutexternalfundingsupport.

Acknowledgements

Theauthorsthankthewomenwhohaveagreedtotakepartinthestudiesdescribedandthe

midwives,anaesthetistsandobstetricianswhohavehelptoenrolthesubjects.Theroleofeveryone

involvedinOBSCymruisgratefullyacknowledged.

Declarationsofinterest

PWChasreceivedresearchsupportfromCSLBehring,Werfen/TemInternationalandHaemonetics.

HehasactedasapaidconsultanttoCSLBehringandWerfen/TemInternational.

SFBhasreceivedsupportforqualityimprovementinitiativesfromWerfen/TemInternationaland

WelshGovernment.

LdeLhasreceivedresearchsupportfromWerfen/TemInternationalandHaemonetics.

REChasreceivedresearchsupportfromCSLBehring,Werfen/TemInternationalandHaemonetics.

ShehasreceivedsupportforqualityimprovementinitiativesfromWerfen/TemInternationaland

WelshGovernment.ShehasactedasapaidconsultanttoCSLBehringandWerfen/Tem

International.

14

Reference List

1. Kramer MS, Berg C, Abenhaim H et al. Incidence, risk factors, and temporal trends in severe

postpartum hemorrhage. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 2013;209:449.

2. Lennox C, Marr L. Scottishconfidentialauditofseverematernalmorbidity.9thannualreport

(datafrom2011). http://healthcareimprovementscotland.org/his/idoc.ashx?docid=5fb640e2-

d079-48cc-ad49-a58f6929b685&version=-1 2013

3. Lutomski JE, Byrne BM, Devane D, Greene RA. Increasing trends in atonic postpartum

haemorrhage in Ireland: An 11-year population-based cohort study. British Journal of

Obstetrics and Gynaecology: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology

2012;119:1150-1151.

4. Mehrabadi A, Hutcheon JA, Lee L et al. Epidemiological investigation of a temporal increase in

atonic postpartum haemorrhage: A population-based retrospective cohort study. British Journal

of Obstetrics and Gynaecology: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology

2013;120:853-862.

5. Say L, Chou D, Gemmill A et al. Global causes of maternal death: A WHO systematic analysis.

The Lancet Global Health 2014;2:e323-e333.

6. Wilkinson H. Saving Mothers' lives. Reviewing maternal deaths to make motherhood safer:

2006-2008. BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 2011;118:1402-1403.

7. Collis RE, Collins PW. Haemostatic management of obstetric haemorrhage. Anaesthesia

2015;70:78-86.

8. Mavrides E, Allard S, Chandraharan E et al. Prevention and management of postpartum

haemorrhage. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology: An International Journal of

Obstetrics and Gynaecology 2016

15

9. Collins PW, Kadir R, Thachil J. Management of coagulopathy associated with postpartum

haemorrhage: guidance from the SSC of ISTH. Journal of Thrombosis and Haemostasis

2016;14:205-210.

10. Klein AA, Arnold P, Bingham RM et al. AAGBI guidelines: the use of blood components and

their alternatives 2016. Anaesthesia 2016;71:829-842.

11. Allard S, Green L, Hunt BJ. How we manage the haematological aspects of major obstetric

haemorrhage. British Journal of Haematology 2014;164:177-188.

12. Solomon C, Collis RE, Collins PW. Haemostatic monitoring during postpartum haemorrhage

and implications for management. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2012;109:851-863.

13. McDonnell NJ, Browning R. How to replace fibrinogen in postpartum haemorrhage situations?

(Hint: Don't use FFP!). International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2018;33:4-7.

14. Collins PW, Lilley G, Bruynseels D et al. Fibrin-based clot formation as an early and rapid

biomarker for progression of postpartum hemorrhage: a prospective study. Blood

2014;124:1727-1736.

15. Collins PW, Solomon C, Sutor K et al. Theoretical modelling of fibrinogen supplementation with

therapeutic plasma, cryoprecipitate, or fibrinogen concentrate. British Journal of Anaesthesia

2014;113:585-595.

16. James AH, Paglia MJ, Gernsheimer T, Grotegut C, Thames B. Blood component therapy in

postpartum hemorrhage. Transfusion 2009;49:2430-2433.

17. Pasquier P, Gayat E, Rackelboom T et al. An observational study of the fresh frozen plasma: Red

blood cell ratio in postpartum hemorrhage. Anesthesia and Analgesia 2013;116:155-161.

18. Saule I, Hawkins N. Transfusion practice in major obstetric haemorrhage: Lessons from trauma.

International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2012;21:79-83.

16

19. Shields LE, Smalarz K, Reffigee L et al. Comprehensive maternal hemorrhage protocols improve

patient safety and reduce utilization of blood products. American Journal of Obstetrics and

Gynecology 2011;205:368.

20. Shields LE, Wiesner S, Fulton J, Pelletreau B. Comprehensive maternal hemorrhage protocols

reduce the use of blood products and improve patient safety. American Journal of Obstetrics and

Gynecology 2015;212:272-280.

21. Collins PW, Cannings-John R, Bruynseels D et al. Viscoelastometry guided fresh frozen plasma

infusion for postpartum haemorrhage: OBS2, an observational study. British Journal of

Anaesthesia 2017;119:422-434.

22. Royal college of obstetricians and gynaecologists. Preventionandmanagementofpostpartum

haemorrhage.Green-topguidelineNo.52,2009. http://www.rcog.org.uk/files/rcog-

corp/GT52PostpartumHaemorrhage0411.pdf 2013

23. Ahmed S, Harrity C, Johnson S et al. The efficacy of fibrinogen concentrate compared with

cryoprecipitate in major obstetric haemorrhage - an observational study. Transfusion Medicine

2012;22:344-349.

24. Bell SF, Rayment R, Collins PW, Collis RE. The use of fibrinogen concentrate to correct

hypofibrinogenaemia rapidly during obstetric haemorrhage. International Journal of Obstetric

Anesthesia 2010;19:218-223.

25. Gollop ND, Chilcott J, Benton A et al. National audit of the use of fibrinogen concentrate to

correct hypofibrinogenaemia. Transfusion Medicine 2012;22:350-355.

26. Weinkove R, Rangarajan S. Fibrinogen concentrate for acquired hypofibrinogenaemic states.

Transfusion Medicine 2008;18:151-157.

27. Matsunaga S, Takai Y, Nakamura E et al. The clinical efficacy of fibrinogen concentrate in

massive obstetric haemorrhage with hypofibrinogenaemia. Scientific Reports 2017;7:

17

28. Seto S, Itakura A, Okagaki R, Suzuki M, Ishihara O. An algorithm for the management of

coagulopathy from postpartum hemorrhage, using fibrinogen concentrate as first-line therapy.

International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2017;32:11-16.

29. De Lloyd L, Bovington R, Kaye A et al. Standard haemostatic tests following major obstetric

haemorrhage. International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2011;20:135-141.

30. Green L, Knight M, Seeney F et al. The haematological management and transfusion

requirements of women who required massive transfusion for major obstetric haemorrhage in

the UK: a population based descriptive study. British Journal of Haematology 2016;172:616-624.

31. Charbit B, Mandelbrot L, Samain E et al. The decrease of fibrinogen is an early predictor of the

severity of postpartum hemorrhage. Journal of Thrombosis and Haemostasis 2007;5:266-273.

32. Cortet M, Deneux-Tharaux C, Dupont C et al. Association between fibrinogen level and severity

of postpartum haemorrhage: Secondary analysis of a prospective trial. British Journal of

Anaesthesia 2012;108:984-989.

33. De Lloyd L, Collins PW, Kaye A, Collis RE. Early fibrinogen as a predictor of red cell

requirements during postpartum haemorrhage. International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia

2012;21:S13.

34. Gayat E, Resche-Rigon M, Morel O et al. Predictive factors of advanced interventional

procedures in a multicentre severe postpartum haemorrhage study. Intensive Care Medicine

2011;37:1816-1825.

35. Simon L, Santi TM, Sacquin P, Hamza J. Pre-anaesthetic assessment of coagulation

abnormalities in obstetric patients: Usefulness, timing and clinical implications. British Journal

of Anaesthesia 1997;78:678-683.

36. Hill JS, Devenie G, Powell M. Point-of-care testing of coagulation and fibrinolytic status during

postpartum haemorrhage: Developing a thrombelastography-«-guided transfusion algorithm.

Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 2012;40:1007-1015.

18

37. Huissoud C, Carrabin N, Audibert F et al. Bedside assessment of fibrinogen level in postpartum

haemorrhage by thrombelastometry. BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and

Gynaecology 2009;116:1097-1102.

38. Pavord S, Maybury H. How I treat postpartum hemorrhage. Blood 2015;125:2759-2770.

39. Mallaiah S, Barclay P, Harrod I, Chevannes C, Bhalla A. Introduction of an algorithm for

ROTEM-guided fibrinogen concentrate administration in major obstetric haemorrhage.

Anaesthesia 2015;70:166-175.

40. Mallaiah S, Chevannes C, McNamara H, Barclay P. A reply. Anaesthesia 2015;70:760-761.

41. Wikkelsoe AJ, Edwards HM, Afshari A et al. Pre-emptive treatment with fibrinogen concentrate

for postpartum haemorrhage: randomized controlled trial. British Journal of Anaesthesia

2015;114:623-633.

42. Bruynseels D, Solomon C, Hallam A et al. Commentary on Reconstituting Fibrinogen

Concentrate to Maintain Blinding in a Double-blind, Randomized Trial in an Emergency Setting.

2016;50:104-107.

43. Aawar N, Alikhan R, Bruynseels D et al. Fibrinogen concentrate versus placebo for treatment of

postpartum haemorrhage: Study protocol for a randomised controlled trial. Trials 2015;16:

44. Collins PW, Cannings-John R, Bruynseels D et al. Viscoelastometric-guided early fibrinogen

concentrate replacement during postpartum haemorrhage: OBS2, a double-blind randomized

controlled trial. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2017;119:411-421.

45. Onwuemene O, Green D, Keith L. Postpartum hemorrhage management in 2012: Predicting the

future. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 2012;119:3-5.

46. Pacheco LD, Saade GR, Costantine MM, Clark SL, Hankins GDV. The role of massive

transfusion protocols in obstetrics. American Journal of Perinatology 2013;30:1-4.

19

47. Jones RM, De Lloyd L, Kealaher EJ et al. Platelet count and transfusion requirements during

moderate or severe postpartum haemorrhage. Anaesthesia 2016;71:648-656.

48. Bose P, Regan F, Paterson-Brown S. Improving the accuracy of estimated blood loss at obstetric

haemorrhage using clinical reconstructions. BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and

Gynaecology 2006;113:919-924.

49. Lilley G, Collis RE. Gravimetric measurement of blood loss versus visual estimation in simulated

postpartum haemorrhage. International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2013;22:S10.

50. Hancock A, Weeks AD, Lavender DT. Is accurate and reliable blood loss estimation the 'crucial

step' in early detection of postpartum haemorrhage: An integrative review of the literature.

BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth 2015;15:

51. Moore GF, Audrey S, Barker M et al. Process evaluation of complex interventions: Medical

Research Council guidance. 2015;350:

52. Shakur H, Roberts I, Fawole B et al. Effect of early tranexamic acid administration on mortality,

hysterectomy, and other morbidities in women with post-partum haemorrhage (WOMAN): an

international, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. The Lancet 2017;389:2105-

2116.

53. Bamber JH. Point-of-care testing on the labour ward should be mandatory. International

Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2016;27:69-74.

54. Collis R. Coagulation point-of-care testing on the labour ward should be mandatory.

International Journal of Obstetric Anesthesia 2016;27:66-69.

Table1:

Studiesinvestigatingtheassociationbetweenfibrinogenandprogressionofpostpartum

haemorrhage

Study N Studydesign Fibrinogeng/L

Timeof

fibrinogenassay

Outcomedefining

progressionof

PPH

Descriptive

statistic

reported

No

progression

ofPPH

Progression

ofPPH

ROC

AUC

(95%CI)

Charbit31 129 Infusionof

uterotonicafter

manualexploration

ofuterus

Invasiveprocedure

tocontrolbleeding,

fallinHb≥4g/Lor

≥4unitsRBC

Median(IQR)

4.4(3.7-5.1 3.3(2.5–4.2)

0.75(CInot

reported)

P<0.0001

Cortet32 738 DiagnosisofPPH Invasiveprocedure

tocontrolbleeding,

fallinHb≥4g/L,≥4

unitsRBCor

admissiontooITU

Mean(SD) 4.2(1.2) 3.4(0.9) 0.66

(0.64-0.68)

Poujade55 98 Variabletimebefore

embolisation

Successof

radiological

embolisation

Mean(SD) 2.9(1.3) 1.8(0.9) NR

Gayat34 257 Variabletimebefore

procedure

Invasiveprocedure

tocontrolbleeding

Median(IQR) 2.7(2.1-3.5) 1.8(1.1-2.5) 0.83

(±0.03)*

deLloyd33 240 Firstclinicalconcern

duringPPH

≥2500mLbloodloss Mean(SD) 4.4(1.1)

3.1(1.0) 0.85

(0.78-0.93)

Collins14 346 1000-1500mLblood

loss

Transfusionof≥8

unitsallogeneic

bloodproducts

Median(IQR) 3.9(3.2-4.5) 2.1(1.8-3.4) 0.82

(0.72-0.92)

Simon35 797 Beforebleeding

started

PPHrequiring

manualuterine

exploration,RBC

transfusionorfallin

Hb≥2g/L

Mean(SD) 4.9(1.0) 4.3(1.3) NR

StudiesareshownwhichinvestigatedtheassociationofClaussfibrinogen,takenearlyduringa

postpartumhaemorrhageorbeforebleedingstarted,withprogressionofbleeding.Variablestudy

designswereemployedbutinallcasesalowClaussfibrinogenwasassociatedwithastatistically

significantlyincreasedriskofprogression.Thisdemonstratesthatfibrinogenlevelisauseful

biomarkerforpredictingprogressionofpostpartumhaemorrhage,however,dothetimerequiredto

obtainaresultit’sclinicalutilityislimited.NRnotreported,CIconfidenceinterval,ROCreceiver

operatingcharacteristicscurve,IQRinter-quartilerangeandSDstandarddeviation.*,inthisstudy

theROCreferstoacompositepredictivetoolcombiningfibrinogen<2g/l,abnormalplacental

implantation,PTratio<50%,heartrate>115beatsperminute,troponinraised.

20

Legendsforfigures

Figure1:StudydesignforOBS-1

Figure2:

Theproportionofwomenprogressingto>2500mLbloodloss(red),redbloodcelltransfusion(dark

blue),atleast4unitsredbloodcelltransfusion(lightblue)oraninvasiveproceduretocontrolthe

bleed(green)dependentonClaussfibrinogen(Fig2a)orFibtemA5(Fig2b)takenat1000-1500

bloodlossisshown.DataarederivedfromtheOBS1study.

Figure3:Rotemguidedbloodproductalgorithms

Figure2ashowthestudydesignandbloodproductalgorithmusedforwomenrecruitedintoOBS-2.

Figure2bshowsthebloodproductalgorithmusedforwomenwhowerenotenrolled.

Figure4:ChangesintransfusionpracticeacrosstimeinCardiff

Figure4ashowsthenumberofunitsofredbloodcells(RBC)(grey)andfreshfrozenplasma(FFP)

(black)transfusedforeachyearbetween2010and2017.TheOBS2studywasassociatedwitha

reductioninRBCandFFPtransfusionwhichincreasedafterthestudyfinishedandfellagainonce

OBSCymruwasinitiated.Figure4bshowsdataforthenumberofwomenwhoreceivedatleast5

unitsofRBC,representingasubgroupofveryseverepostpartumhaemorrhage.Asimilartemporal

trendwasobserved.

Figure5:OBSCyrmubloodproductalgorithm.

Studyentry

1000mLPPH

measuredor

suspected

Perform

Fibtem,

APPT,PT,

Clauss

fibrinogen,

Hb

Fibtemperformedoutside

clinicalareasoclinicianswere

blindedtoresults

AllusualObstetric

interventions

Orderbloodand

bloodproductsif

PPH>1500mL

Reactto

laboratory

resultsasthey

became

available

Figure1

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

<2g/L 2-3g/L 3-4g/L >4g/L

%ofwomen

Concentrationoffibrinogen

>2500mLbloodloss

TransfusedanyRBC

Transfused≥4unitsRBC

Invasiveprocedure

Figure2b Figure2a

Figure3a

Figure3b

Figure4b Figure4a