PowerPoint download
Transcript of PowerPoint download
What is the Difference Between FFELP and Private
Loan Programs?
and
Why Does It Matter?
Private education loans have much in common with FFELP loans
FFELP and private loans are both consumer credit
• We are all regularly engaged in the business of making loans.
• The debtor is a person other than an organization.
• The debt is incurred primarily for a personal, family or household purpose
FFELP and Private Loans are Both
Consumer Credit• The debt is payable in
installments and a finance charge is made.
• The amount financed does not exceed $25,000.
Both FFELP and Private Loans:
• Are closed-end loans• Offer interim periods• Offer extensions of varying
length and purpose
Commercial Lenders
Commercial lenders dispense Credit Cards, automobile loans, second mortgages, lines of credit, and other types of consumer credit
on a mass scale—and do the same
with FFELP loans.
Application Process
Some private loans go through the same application process as FFELP loans such as school certification
Servicers• Servicers of FFELP & private
loans face similar operations issues– Book the loan– Process payments– Send letters– Call forgetful borrowers– Report to credit bureaus– Report paid interest to the IRS
(our favorite topic!)
Whereas FFELP and private loan programs have much in common, it is the differences that cause us heartburn; especially if FFELP is all that we know
FISL OR FIZZLE!
In the 1970’s when government-insured student loans (and electronic servicing systems) were in their relative infancy, lenders making Federally Insured Student Loans (FISL, or FIZZLE as it was affectionately known in those days…) would tweak consumer credit servicing systems to manage FISLs.
Those were the days!
• A competent mortgage loan system worked well, assuming a few minor variations.
• Those were the days before buckets, fourteen different types of extensions, and two different up-front borrower fees.
Managing Both Programs
Many servicers that manage both FFELP and private loans now use servicing systems designed for FFELP to process and book private education loans.
? Two Important Questions?
• What are the differences between FFELP and private loan programs?
• What does it take to manage a private loan program?
PRESENTERS• Stephanie Foltz
– AES/PHEAA• Dino Tsibouris
– Mallory & Tsibouris Co. LPA• Jaye O’Connell
– VSAC• Walter Witthoff
– Iowa Student Loan
What is the difference between private loans and
FFELP
Mothership• FFELP
– HEA is the mothership of FFELP rules
• Private Loans– Private loans don’t have a
mothership
Rules• For the most part, if you
know HEA, you can manage FFELP loans
• Private student loans are regulated by multiple state and federal laws
Collections• In collecting the loan, the
consumer credit debt collector asks for the money
• FFELP collectors prefer the term “loan counselor” and tend to rely on loan extensions such as forbearances and deferments
Collections
It is exceedingly difficult to train a FFELP loan counselor to collect consumer credit debt
Loan Extensions and the Re-aging of Accounts
Loan extension and the accompanying re-aging of accounts are an entitlement under FFELP
Loan Extensions and the Re-aging of Accounts
Extensions and the re-aging of accounts, unless carefully monitored, violate bank safety and soundness guidelines
Rate of Interest• FFELP rates are determined by
federal statute
• Private loans are governed by state law– The rate of interest is determined
by state law in the same fashion as automobile loans, credit cards and mortgage loans
• Nationally chartered lender can export their home state rate which includes the rate and fees/charges within the definition of interest), but only using federal law to do so, and the interplay between state and federal law on fees and charges is particularly complicated
Truth-in-Lending (TIL) Act
• FFELP is specifically exempt from the federal TIL Act
• Private loans are not exempt from the federal TIL Act
TIL (con’t)
Reg Z is arguably the single most invasive federal law confronting the private education loan creditor.
Government Insurance
• FFELP loans are insured by guarantee agencies and re-insured by the U.S. Secretary of Education.
• Private loans may be insured by a private entity, uninsured, or the holder may create its own reserve fund against loss.
State Regulated Lender Laws
• The long time assumption has been that FFELP lenders do not need to have a state regulated lender license. This is not so clear now.
• There is no definitive answer to this question. HEA does not specifically provide a broad preemption of state laws.
State Regulated Lender Laws
• Lenders that are not state agencies, commercial banks, federal savings banks, or some other federal designated financial institution are probably not exempt from state laws.
• Such lenders should explore the possibility that they may need a state regulated lender license.
State Regulated Lender Laws
• A national bank or federal savings bank can generally get around having to comply with multiple state consumer credit laws.
• Both can export rates.
State Regulated Lender Laws
• All lenders, however, must have a state choice of law; thus, all private loan creditors will always be in a position to have to deal with one or more state laws.
Funding• Some FFELP programs have
more borrower benefits, which means less revenue to support bonds.
• Issuing of debt requires projections of cash flows (interest rate assumptions, defaults, and other use of cash flow like payment of administrative expenses such as lender premiums and borrower benefits.
FundingThe biggest challenge in
funding private education loan programs is projecting default risk. Clearly, if a creditor maintains a FFELP loan guarantee, its exposure to default risk is less than that of the private education loan lender.
PrivacyThe authority and rationale for
disclosures of nonpublic personal information concerning FFELP borrowers is clearer than for private education loan lenders given the FFELP statutory and regulatory references
PrivacyThe federal Higher Education
Act of 1965 provides for the sharing of information of borrower NPI between schools, lenders and guarantee agencies that are not generally available to holders of private loans
PrivacyThere is no umbrella federal law
such as HEA that allows private education loan lenders to share borrower NPI with non-authorized third parties. Private education lenders must strictly follow the privacy provisions of Gramm-Leach-Bliley.
Contract Law
Whereas private loans must comply with state and federal laws, the creditor has more flexibility in crafting promissory note provisions
The Private Education Loan Program Policy
Function
PurposeThe purpose of the private
education loan program policy function is to provide sales, marketing, loan operations, and in certain circumstances accounting departments with the guidance they need to comply with state and federal consumer protection and credit, and privacy laws.
Program Policy vs. Compliance
• The program policy function is not a compliance function.
• The program policy folks, however, serve a critical function in educating and directing the compliance staff.
Knowledge• Private loan program policy
department staff must have knowledge of:– State consumer protection laws– The Truth in Lending Act– The Equal Credit Opportunity Act– The Fair Credit Reporting Act– The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act– The Federal Trade Commission Act– The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act
Program Policy Function
The consumer credit program policy function is so broad in scope and detailed in execution it is difficult for one person to know and understand all of the laws that go into making private education loans.
Team ApproachThe most effective program
policy departments use a team approach. Only by combining the expertise of several individuals can a lender know that it is receiving competent guidance
Who Are these Specialists?
A department head is responsible for a coordinated approach to program policy to ensure that the team’s efforts create a cohesive and comprehensive whole
Legal Counsel• Legal counsel will draft documents,
interpret the law, and perform research when appropriate
• Competent legal counsel will not attempt to interpret laws outside of his or her expertise; finding counsel with the appropriate expertise is critical
The Ideal Private Education Loan Lawyer
• Background in– Crafting consumer credit
applications– Promissory notes– Workout agreements– Regulatory documents such as
adverse action, TIL disclosure, co-signer and privacy notices
Does a single lawyer have all this expertise?
• Generally no.• What the program policy
analyst is searching for is a team of two or more attorneys’, each with his or her own area of expertise in one or more areas of law.
• Together they create a comprehensive whole of program policy expertise.
Areas of Responsibility
• Each staff member should be assigned an area of responsibility, such as state consumer protection laws, TIL, privacy, collections, and so forth.
• These individuals will gain expertise in one or more subjects. – Creates value and competency in
the position
Relationship to Operations
• Program policy must work with operations staff to understand practical aspects of implementing policy
• Some of the best program policy people come from operations
Relationship to Operations
• Understanding the basics of loan operations and the accounting associated with a loan is useful
Accounting, Statistics and Others Who Are Numerate
• While not always the life of the party, these folks have value.
• If you don’t want to develop APR algorithms or dissect tax code to perform original issue discount computations, make friend with your neighborhood accountant and fiscal analyst.
Tools of the Trade• OCC/FDIC/Fed Reserve web
sites
• Kirchman Regulatory Service
• SLSA Private Education Loan Committee
The VSAC Experience• Centralized compliance and
program policy support for FFEL and Alternative loans within a small department
• Developed a network of external resources, contacts and systems that assist with the management of a critical function in the servicing of various loan programs
VSAC Staff Structure• Assistant Director• Manager School Policy & Compliance
(FFEL)• Federal Loan Compliance Officer (FFEL &
HEAL)• Alternative Loan Compliance Officer &
Compliance Specialist (research & documentation support for all loan programs)
• For FFEL support, work closely with the Guarantor division of VSAC
Accountability• Identify new requirements,
review & interpret law/regs (with legal support as necessary)
• Provide implementation support to operations (policy, process, training development & documentation)
Accountability• Support operations staff in
research & response to policy/compliance questions.
• Serve as a liaison to internal and external legal counsel
• Promissory note development and maintenance
Accountability• Letter/marketing material
review• Web content review• And much, much more!
The Compliance Culture
• Created a collaborative model
• Staff encouraged to check their process and understanding with the Compliance Officers whenever questions arise
The Compliance Culture
• Not a “police state” – all development and revisions of processes are done in collaboration with operations staff to establish quality and compliance from the onset.
Industry Resources
• Industry Committee Participation– NCHELP Program
Regulations, Ops and Debt Management
– SLSA FFELP Committee– SLSA Private Loan
Committee
Industry Resources
• Active participation provides – access to the newest
information– the opportunity to develop
industry contacts– meet fine people like Walter!
Legal Resources
• Relative to FFEL and Alternative lending functions– Internal General Counsel– Two external attorneys
specializing in consumer credit and privacy and electronic commerce
Systems…
Databases have become a critical tool to manage our ever-expanding workload and to retain records of the work we complete
Systems…• Question Form
– Compliance intranet site – staff uses to send questions•Identifies appropriate recipient by
topic & generates e-mail•Includes utility to directly file
question and response into our archives
Systems…• Compliance Database
– Retains questions, research and response
– Internal and industry compliance and policy related discussions
– Attorney opinions•Related to loan programs,
privacy, and electronic commerce
And More Systems• Project Database
– Tool to manage many competing priorities and projects• Ability to track time and activities• Generate reports reflecting staff
contributions and how time is spent supporting compliance needs in operations, technology projects and new requirement implementation for FFEL and Alternative loans
Why Are You Here?• Review the critical elements
necessary to organize a successful private education loan servicing center
• Discuss private loan processing considerations
• Analyze the art of matching personnel with the appropriate functions and responsibilities
• Discuss legal and compliance issues
Private Loans – A Four Step Program
• Step One– The Common Manual doesn’t apply
• Step Two– Work on your creativity skills
• Step Three– Complexities exist
• Step Four– Develop a sense of humor and
remain neutral if you are a service provider
Selling Origination and Servicing
• Understand the lender’s vision of its private loan portfolio– What are the expectations and how
does this impact your systems and workload• Number of applications and volume• Number of variations of program• Boutique servicing – Web branding• School relationships – dedicated resources?
Selling Origination and Servicing
• Four C’s that lenders use to evaluate before making a loan– Credit – Has it been established yet?– Collateral – Did you own anything?– Co-Applicants – If you cannot obtain
independently, can someone assist?– Collectible – With some lenders self-
insuring – will the loan be repaid?
Determine the Lenders Needs
•Two basic needs–Originate
–Collect
Origination• What is the strategy
– Quality and Quantity• Schools will want quality & ease of
process. – Application completion
• Define what it is– Lender will have to satisfy risk
requirements
– Underwriting requirements• Fairly strict• Co-applicant if student doesn’t meet
criteria?
Origination• What is the strategy
– School communication•Is certification required
– Use of guarantor? •It helps – but not always
feasible•Usually self-insurer or limited
insurers
Collection• What is the strategy
– Relationship•Lenders using service providers
– Reactive•Due diligence schedules
– Proactive•High touch; high result
Collection• What is the strategy
– End result•Know the return on each
product and portfolio impact•Default define within each
note
– Not deal with it•Outsourcing to “experts”
Determine the Lenders Needs
• Develop guidelines for staff summarizing lender requirements– Maintain guidelines with
revision dates– Consider all potential
situations
Determine the Lenders Needs
• Promissory note terms and obligations of each loan program– How does note signed in 2003
compare with terms in 2004?– What if small differences?
• Systems and resource materials must support
Determine the Lenders Needs
• Repayment term, interest rate, borrower benefits, when do payments start
• School specific programs vs. non-school certification required
• Co-borrower, co-signer and co-maker defined
• Specific web products required
Determine the Lenders Needs
• Underwriting criteria• Guaranteed vs. non-guaranteed• Banking regulations associated
with the lender for origination and collection may help determine if there are other unique requirements to consider
Functions of an Origination & Servicing Center
• Document management– Imaging– Off-site storage– In/out bound mail
• Data management– Trading information with outside
entities requires analysis and security measures
Functions of an Origination & Servicing Center
• Policy and compliance management– Upper level management
• Charge offs• Unique situations – rehabilitation of
loans• Regulations B, Z • State collection and consumer
protection laws
Functions of an Origination & Servicing Center
• Application preparation– Inspecting for complete
information– Gathering of required documents– Data entry
• Underwriting– Credit & non-credit factors
• Age• School program requirements
Functions of an Origination & Servicing Center
• Quality Control– Sample of application to
ensure policies are in place, regulatory requirements are met and there is processing consistency
• Customer Service– Manage borrower, school and
lender relationships
Functions of an Origination & Servicing Center
• Collections– Keep the obligation in front
of the borrower– Skip trace– Collection of money
•Note choice of words rather than “Servicing”
Staffing Needs• Determine hiring strategy
– What skills can be learned– What is inherently present or not
present– How will you find your candidates– Outsourcing versus in-house
processing– How do you build in-house
expertise
Hiring Strategy – Aptitudes
• Aptitudes– Data entry – fast with few errors– Underwriting – understands basic
risk analysis & mathematics– Quality control – understanding of
compliance, consistency, and able to install preventative measures
Hiring Strategy – Aptitudes
• Aptitudes– Customer Service
• Excellent listening, verbal & written skills
• Problem solving ability
– Collections• Successful in ‘selling’ importance of
debt repayment without ruining reputation
Hiring Strategy – Attitudes
• Attitudes– Flexible
•Ability to adjust to changes in programs
– Pride•Sense of ownership in work
habits
Hiring Strategy - Attitudes
• Attitudes– Fit
• Shares similar values present in company’s culture
– Continual learner• Inquisitive and applies learned
knowledge
Hiring Strategy• Where will you find your
candidates?– Within your organization– Newspaper advertising– Referrals from employees– Networking
Hiring Strategy• Assessing Candidates
– Panel Interviews•Develop binary matrix to compare
the candidates more subjectively
– Require testing•Assess data entry, customer
service, listening, and mathematics
Hiring Strategy• Assessing Candidates
– Measure the ‘un-measurable’•Myers Briggs Analysis
Hiring Strategy• Outsourcing vs. In-house
– Four differences in FFELP & Private Loans• Lack of common regulatory entity to
provide guidance and processing rules
• Underwriting usually required for Private
• Collection mentality not due diligence• Two main programs with minor
variations vs. unlimited programs and unlimited variations
Hiring Strategy• Group discussion
– Other considerations?– Who is doing this now? Who is
not?– Success stories? Failures?– How do our borrowers view
FFELP and Private?• Do they realize differences? • Do they care?
Similarities Between FFELP/Private Loans
• Application processing requirements
• Billing cycles and loan terms
• Collection requirements• Regulatory bodies
Organizational Design
• How many people are needed?– Determine volume of
applications, in- and out-bound phone calls
– Hours of operation (east coast vs. west coast)
– Number of loan types & variations
Organizational Design
• How many people are needed?– Percentage of FFELP
borrowers with Private Loans– What is the loan program
knowledge base capacity of one person
Developing Organizational Standards
• Benchmarking – Likely not the best option due to
multiple private loan program variables
• Consider managing FTE levels based on: – Calls taken– Applications processed– Loan programs– Servicing related tasks processed
AES Example – Staff Training
• Training program length typically 6 weeks
• 130 Private Loan programs• Goal to have ‘one-stop’
shop for borrowers with both Private and FFELP loans
AES Example – Staff Training
• Trained to understand the differences between Federal Regulations and Private Loan guidelines– Some Private loan servicing
requirements are modeled after federal regulations
– Some differ such as forbearance, deferment and repayment options
AES Example – Staff Training
• Federal loan regulations are outlined first during training
• Private loan types and guidelines follow the federal training since much more detail is required
AES Example – Staff Training
• Program Directory – electronic format– Program profile outlines each
loan by type– Access each loan program
individually in an effort to respond to customer concerns regarding terms of each loan program
AES Example – Staff Training
• Program Directory – electronic format– Keep staff up to date on the terms
of private programs – Instant resource at staff fingertips
to respond to customer inquiries– Maintained on Agency intranet site
AES Example – Staff Training
• All staff is initially trained to receive customer calls and respond to telephone inquiries
AES Example – Staff Training
• Staff is later cross trained on other operational functions such as certification processing and loan consolidation options– Enables staff to gain a complete
understanding of all facets with managing alternative loans
– Increases staff knowledge base and aids them in thorough responsiveness to the customers
AES Example – Staff Training
• Staff is fully cross trained on all functions based on adaptability to managing customer calls and all other facets evaluated for performance appraisals purposes– Staff that performs at a satisfactory
level or able is eligible to receive additional cross training
AES Example – Staff Training
– Verbal & written communications are key factors that are emphasized when dealing with Private loan customers because of;• Unique terms of their loans as
outlined in the promissory note• Unique “servicing guidelines: based
on the guarantor/insurer of the loan program
• Graduate Market Professionals
AES Example – Organizational Design
• A group of staff whose primary function is to respond to customer calls– Separate groups within
Private loan department serve as a backup to the call center staff should all call reps be on a call
AES Example – Organizational Design– These separate groups are
teams that manage specific functions such as correspondence, deferment, forbearance, school certification, and quality assurance•This approach is in place to ensure
quality in processing and adhering to appropriate program guidelines
AES Example – Organizational Design
• Technical assistance is provided by a team of Business Analysts (BA) that interface with IT in an effort to develop and support new programs, run query’s, and update system tables.– Ensure the system is programmed to
automate as much of the function that is possible
– BA’s trouble shoot system issues or discrepancies in reviewing loan data
AES Example – Organizational Design
• Legal and compliance requirements for Private loans must be reviewed differently– Originating & servicing loans in
accordance with the promissory note & servicing guidelines language is critical
• OP staff work with Legal & Compliance as needed
Legal Considerations
• Lender loan licenses & national & state affiliation require different regulatory bodies
• Customers who believe that they are victims of unfair discrimination in a credit transaction should contact the appropriate regulatory agency.
Regulatory Agencies
• http://www.usdoj.gov/crt/housing/shousing.ecoa.htm
• Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS): Savings associations & federally chartered savings banks (the word “Federal” or the initials “F.S.B.” appear in the federal institution’ name
Regulatory Agencies
• Comptroller of Currency (OCC): National banks & federal branches/agencies of foreign banks (the word “National” or the initials “N.A.” appear in or after the bank’s name)
Regulatory Agencies
• Federal Reserve Board (FRB): Financial institutions that are members of the Federal Reserve system, except national banks and federal branches/agencies of foreign banks
Regulatory Agencies
• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC): State chartered banks that are not members of the Federal Reserve System
Regulatory Agencies
• National Credit Union Association (NCUA): Federal credit unions (the words “Federal Credit Union” appear in the institution’s name).
Regulatory Agencies
• Federal Trade Commission (FTC): Retailers, finance companies, creditors (including most mortgage companies) that are not assigned to another agency. This includes student loan secondary markets that originate loans in their own names.
Regulatory Agencies
• Check with your legal counsel to determine the ultimate impact to your shop. Considerations include but not limited to – ECOA references vary based on
regulatory body– GLB notices may have unique affiliates– Audit requirements for each entity
vary– Collection rules within each state may
vary
Legal Consideration
• Private education loan customers have a perception that the same rules & processes that apply to FFELP apply to their private loan
• Typically private loan customers have more questions before a loan is consummated
Legal Considerations
• Consumer and customer interactions are different
• Gramm-Leach-Bliley privacy notices– Consumer vs. Customer
• What is an application?– Phone, paper, electronic e-
signature
Legal Considerations
• Denying a consumer a loan requires interaction from the originator and servicer– Equal Credit Opportunity
Act (ECOA)•How it works•When must it be sent
Legal Considerations
• When approving a loan for a customer there are certain permissible charges that must be followed– Annual percentage rate (APR)
not to exceed usury rate
Speculation• Increase bankruptcy
– Bankruptcy law changes
• More programs with unique terms• Industry standards – ABI, default %,
average length of time for payoff• Consolidation Private loans• Line of credit• School cohort default rates linked
more tightly to terms of Private loans
What Can an Origination & Servicing
Shop Do?• Keep active in consumer
credit law changes• Actively design systems to
be flexible• Know your portfolio
characteristics
What Can an Origination & Servicing
Shop Do?• Anticipate loan program
needs– Think creatively– Know your competition
•PLUS loans•Credit cards•Home equity•Personal loans•Use of savings
What Can an Origination & Servicing
Shop Do?• Understand school
concerns– Cohort default rates for
Private loan portfolios are likely to be different than their FFELP portfolio
The End is Near
• What did you learn?– Cookie cutters belong to
bakers•The is no ‘standard’ program
– Lender involvement required•Design an effective Origination
& Servicing shop
The End is Near– The old cliché is true
•Great people equate to great results
– Hire staff wisely
– Get creative•Evolving marketplace
The End is Near
Questions?
THANK YOU!Please be sure to
complete your conference evaluation forms after the
conference!