Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management...

33
Posterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009

Transcript of Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management...

Page 1: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Posterior Shoulder InstabilityOpen Management

Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009

Page 2: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Ambiguity of Terminology

• Dislocation vssubluxation

• Traumatic vsatraumatic

• Habitual vsvoluntary vsinvoluntary

FUCHS B. et.al. J Bone Joint Surg2000:82:16-25

Page 3: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Basic Questions• Is the shoulder unstable? Directions?

• Is the labrum torn?• Is the capsule stretched? Gone?• Is the bony fulcrum adequate

– Glenoid– Humerus: “Locked” dislocation?

• Does the patient have mental reasons to fail?

• Previous surgery?FUCHS B. et.al. J Bone Joint Surg 2000:82:16-25

Page 4: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Determination of Instability

• History• Clinical examination

– Supine load and shift with comparison to opposite side

– ABER apprehension/Relocation tests

– Posterior jerk test

• Arthroscopic Evaluation

Page 5: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Labrum/Capsule

• History & exam: – Thermal Capsulorrhaphy

– Hyperlaxity

• MRI/Arthrogram– Labrum

– Posterioinferior pouch

• Arthroscopy

Millett et al, JAAOS 2006

Page 6: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Osseous Evaluation

• MRI suboptimal

• CT scan best. 2D and 3D recons of glenoid face– Bone loss: Glenoid or humerus

– Posterior rim sloping/Fx

– Excess retroversion/dysplasia

Page 7: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Psychological Factors• Workman’s Compensation claim

• Psychiatric/emotional disorder– Habitual (psychiatric, willful)

– Voluntary (intentional but not willful)

– Involuntary/unintentional• Hawkins et al, JBJS 1984

• We are not psychiatrists

Page 8: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Etiology and Treatment

• Detached labrum– Arthroscopic repair

• Capsular tissue stretched– Arthroscopic or open repair/casulorrhaphy

• Inadequate bony fulcrum– McGlaughlin Procedure– Open Glenoid Augmentation

• Inadequate capsular tissue– Open capsular reconstruction, Graft Reinforcement

Page 9: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Open Capsullorhaphy: Exposure

Matsen: www.orthop.washington.edu

Page 10: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Exposure

Matsen: www.orthop.washington.edu

Page 11: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

FUCHS B. et.al. J Bone Joint Surg2000:82:16-25

With InfraspinatusRelease

Page 12: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Neer Humeral Sided Capsular Shift

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 13: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Posterior Glenoid Deficiency

• Dysplasia– Osteotomy

• Posterior GlenoidRim Loss– Augmentation (“Bone Block”)

Page 14: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Glenoid Dysplasia:Osteotomy

Matsen: www.orthop.washington.edu

Page 15: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Glenoid Osteotomy

Matsen: www.orthop.washington.edu

Case Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 16: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Patient Selection/Complications

• Severe hypoplasia

• Perforation of Glenoid– Johnston et al CORR 1984

• Osteoarthritis

Page 17: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Complication: Osteoarthritis

19951995

1993199319911991

Case Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 18: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Posterior Glenoid Rim Loss

• Open Posterior Glenoid Augmentation with Bone Graft

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 19: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Vertical Glenoid Sided Capsuloplasty

. Post glenoid abraded

. Drill inferior hole (3.2 mm)

T-Shift of Capsule •

•

•Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 20: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Iliac crest (InnerTable Graft

2-3 cm Deep3-4 cm Long

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 21: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Extra‐Articular Fixation of Graft

• 2 MalleolarScrews (Large Frag)

• Slight Overhang

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 22: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Graft Position

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 23: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Post operative course

Neutral rotation4 to 6 weeks

Passive ROM

No IR for 6 weeks

Return to sports after 4 months

Page 24: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Results (Gilles Walch)

21 shoulders

FU 6 y (2-19)20 VS or S (95%)

Failures : 3 (14%)- I recurrence- 2 apprehension +++ Walch et al, Knee Surg Sports 

Traumatol Arthrosc 2007

Page 25: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

RESULTSMean Constant score : 93.3 (80-100)

Constant Score

Pain 13 (8-15)

ADL 19.3 (17-20)

Mobility 39.5 (37-40)

StrengthKg x 2

22 (14-28)

(55% no pain)

(80% symmetric ER)

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 26: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

XR Results

4 Arthritis2 preop2 postop

Courtesy of Gilles Walch

Page 27: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Post. Capsulorraphyn FU Rec

sub/disFailure

rate

Provencher (Ascop)(2005-Am J Sports Med)

33 3 y 7 21%

Wolf BR (Open)(2005-JSES)

37 8 y 8 19%

Kim (Ascop)(2003 - JBJS Am)

27 3 y 1 4%

Williams (Ascop)(2003-AJSM)

27 5 y 3 11%

Page 28: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Additional Open Procedures

• Posterior Stabilization via an anterior approach

• Posterior “Addition Acromioplasty”

• Cadaver Graft/Capsular Reinforcement

Page 29: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Post Stabilization via Anterior Approach• Introduced by Neer (“cruciate closure”) for MDI patients with significant posterior instab

WIRTH M. A. et.al. J Bone Joint Surg 1998:80:1570-8

Page 30: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Posterior Addition Acromioplasty

Scapinelli JSES 2006

Page 31: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Graft Reinforcement

• Possible improvement of results in cases of thinned/insufficient capsular tissues

Page 32: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Open Posterior Capsular Reconstruction

• Acceptable treatment option. Higher morbidity but effective alternative to arthroscopic stabilization if performed properly

• Can be performed from the front in cases of MDI

• Treatment of choice in cases of bony and capsular deficiency

Page 33: Posterior Shoulder Instability Open ManagementPosterior Shoulder Instability Open Management Armodios Hatzidakis MD OLC 2009. Ambiguity of Terminology • Dislocation vs subluxation

Thanks


Understanding shoulder instability

Understanding shoulder instability

shoulder instability - dislocation and subluxation the injury

shoulder instability - dislocation and subluxation the injury

MR Imaging of the Shoulder: Instability Glenohumeral joint Shoulder ...

MR Imaging of the Shoulder: Instability Glenohumeral joint Shoulder ...

Evaluation of Shoulder Instability Braces - Human · PDF fileEvaluation of Shoulder Instability Braces ... Figure 3 - Posterior view of Shoulder Subluxation ... and ligaments is shifted

Evaluation of Shoulder Instability Braces - Human · PDF fileEvaluation of Shoulder Instability Braces ... Figure 3 - Posterior view of Shoulder Subluxation ... and ligaments is shifted

Bristow-Latarjet Instability Shoulder System - Implants · Bristow-Latarjet Instability Shoulder System ... • Campo magnético de gradiente espacial máximo de 720 Gauss/cm o ...

Bristow-Latarjet Instability Shoulder System - Implants · Bristow-Latarjet Instability Shoulder System ... • Campo magnético de gradiente espacial máximo de 720 Gauss/cm o ...

Atraumatic Shoulder Instability Principles and Assessment

Atraumatic Shoulder Instability Principles and Assessment

Posterior instability of the shoulder lennard funk

Posterior instability of the shoulder lennard funk

Multidirectional instability of the shoulder 2014

Multidirectional instability of the shoulder 2014

Excessive range of movement: instability of the shoulder · Stability:: The Stability. shoulder. :. 1: ...

Excessive range of movement: instability of the shoulder · Stability:: The Stability. shoulder. :. 1: ...

Bristow-Latarjet Instability Shoulder System - Instruments

Bristow-Latarjet Instability Shoulder System - Instruments

Shoulder instability current concepts mike walton

Shoulder instability current concepts mike walton

Shoulder instability (anatomy,types, management )

Shoulder instability (anatomy,types, management )

Clinical Assessment of Instability of the Shoulder

Clinical Assessment of Instability of the Shoulder

Shoulder Instability, by Dr. Warren King - PAMF · shoulder joint) or shoulder pain. Dislocations can cause fractures and rotator cuff tears. Osteoarthritis or ... Shoulder Instability,

Shoulder Instability, by Dr. Warren King - PAMF · shoulder joint) or shoulder pain. Dislocations can cause fractures and rotator cuff tears. Osteoarthritis or ... Shoulder Instability,

CPG Shoulder Instability 2019 Handouts...shoulder pain related to shoulder instability and movement coordination deficits 4. Recognize the strengths and limitations in CPGs to define

CPG Shoulder Instability 2019 Handouts...shoulder pain related to shoulder instability and movement coordination deficits 4. Recognize the strengths and limitations in CPGs to define

PRINCIPLES OF SHOULDER INSTABILITY REHABILITATION

PRINCIPLES OF SHOULDER INSTABILITY REHABILITATION

Recurrent Posterior Shoulder Instability

Recurrent Posterior Shoulder Instability

Recurrent Posterior Shoulder Instability | Orthopaedic Surgeon | Vail Colorado

Recurrent Posterior Shoulder Instability | Orthopaedic Surgeon | Vail Colorado

Dislocated Shoulder and Chronic Shoulder Instability--Dr ... · A Patient’s Guide to Shoulder Dislocation and Chronic Shoulder Instability The shoulder functions to place the hand

Dislocated Shoulder and Chronic Shoulder Instability--Dr ... · A Patient’s Guide to Shoulder Dislocation and Chronic Shoulder Instability The shoulder functions to place the hand

Management of Shoulder Instability · PDF fileManagement of Shoulder Instability ... Posterior (SLAP) •Posterior inferior (Bennett’s ... – 6 with a true dislocation and 8 with

Management of Shoulder Instability · PDF fileManagement of Shoulder Instability ... Posterior (SLAP) •Posterior inferior (Bennett’s ... – 6 with a true dislocation and 8 with