Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN...

101
No. BR053255 In the Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles Appellate Division PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, Plaintiff and Respondent, vs. SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY, Defendant and Respondent, DEMETRIUS CRUMP, et al., Victims and Appellants. APPELLANTS’ OPENING BRIEF Appeal From Judgment Of Conviction And Order Denying Restitution Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 6SC00433 Honorable Alan S. Rosenfield *Margaret M. Grignon (SBN 76621) Anne M. Grignon (SBN 230355) GRIGNON LAW FIRM LLP 5150 E. Pacific Coast Highway, Suite 200 Long Beach, CA 90804 Tel.: 562.285.3171 Fax: 562.346.3201 [email protected] [email protected] Brentford Ferreira (SBN 113762) BRENTFORD FERREIRA ATTORNEY AT LAW PMB #399 5318 E. 2nd Street Long Beach, CA 90803 Tel.: 562.400.8578 [email protected] Attorneys for Victims and Appellants Demetrius Crump, et al. Additional Counsel Continued On Next Page

Transcript of Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN...

Page 1: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

No. BR053255

In the Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles

Appellate Division

PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, Plaintiff and Respondent,

vs.

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY, Defendant and Respondent,

DEMETRIUS CRUMP, et al., Victims and Appellants.

APPELLANTS’ OPENING BRIEF

Appeal From Judgment Of Conviction And Order Denying Restitution Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 6SC00433

Honorable Alan S. Rosenfield

*Margaret M. Grignon (SBN 76621) Anne M. Grignon (SBN 230355) GRIGNON LAW FIRM LLP 5150 E. Pacific Coast Highway, Suite 200 Long Beach, CA 90804 Tel.: 562.285.3171 Fax: 562.346.3201 [email protected] [email protected]

Brentford Ferreira (SBN 113762) BRENTFORD FERREIRA ATTORNEY AT LAW PMB #399 5318 E. 2nd Street Long Beach, CA 90803 Tel.: 562.400.8578 [email protected]

Attorneys for Victims and Appellants

Demetrius Crump, et al.

Additional Counsel Continued On Next Page

Page 2: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

2

R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595 Fax: 661.949.7524 [email protected] [email protected]

Brian Panish (SBN 116060) Robert Glassman (SBN 269816) PANISH SHEA & BOYLE LLP 11111 Santa Monica Blvd., Suite 700 Los Angeles, CA 90025 Tel.: 310.477.1700 Fax: 310.477.1699 [email protected] [email protected]

Page 3: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

3

CERTIFICATE OF INTERESTED ENTITIES OR PERSONS

(Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 8.208)

The following entities or persons have either (1) an ownership

interest of 10 percent or more in the party filing this certificate (Cal. Rules

of Court, rule 8.208(e)(1)), or (2) a financial or other interest in the

outcome of the proceeding that the justices should consider in determining

whether to disqualify themselves (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.208(e)(2)):

George Abagi Karen Abagi Lilia Abagi Crista Abarca Camille D. Abat Marcella D. Abat Mario D. Abat Teodosio B. Abat Giovanna Natalie Abate Ibrahim Abboud Mahmoud Abdallah Amany Abdelmalak Amany Abdelmalak George Abdelmalak Windy Abdelmalak Windy Abdelmalak Yasmine Abdullah Arthur Abeyesinhe Debra Abeyesinhe Vartoui Abgarian Lee Abigail Andrew Abkarian Jonathan Abkarian Michael Abkarian Sevak Abkarian Suezan Abkarian Jacqueline Abkian Issa Aboud Abraham Abramian Akop Abramian Anahit Abramian

Aram Abramian Carmine Abramian Katherine Abramian Linda Abramian Pierre Abramian Tina Abramian Vardui Abramian Brian Abramowitz Lisa Abramowitz Alex Abramyan Daniel Abramyan Nikolas Abramyan Valeriy Abramyan Vyacheslav Abramyan Aida Absi Ammar Abukurah Kaden Abukurah Leila Abukurah Nadine Abukurah Celina Acevedo Jaime Acevedo Melinda Acevedo Mila Acevedo Ricardo Acevedo Alejandro Aceves Brandon Aceves Brenda Aceves Candice Aceves David Aceves Victor Aceves Victor A. Aceves

Mythri Acharya Melissa Michelle Ackermann-Blair Lori Actis Austin Kash Adams Jordan Rene Adams Peter J. Adams Kevin Adekayode Claire Adelman Elaine Adelman Harold Adelman Pamela Adelman Cameron Afradi Homa Afradi Hossein Afradi Maddison Afradi Mehrdad Afradi Michelle Afradi Raihana Afridi Hasmik Agadjanian Anahit Agadzhyan Alec Agana Nand Aggarwal Sangeeta Aggarwal Sushma Aggarwal Ali Aghajani Amir Aghajani Essie Aghajani Ann Agrios Apostolos Agrios Alejandria Aguilar Arthur Aguilar

Page 4: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

4

Blanca Aguilar Jirard Aguilar Leopaldo Aguilar Irene Aguilera Matthew D. Aguilera Dulce Aguirre Bikram Ahluwalia Amir Ahmadi Mohammad Ahmadi Nahida Ahmadi Shaheer Ahmadi Abdul Ahad Ahmady Mahbuba S. Ahmady Afreen Ahmed Ammar Ahmed Sarah Ahmed Shakeel Ahmed Alice Ahn Alicia Ahn Daniel Ahn David Ahn Emery Ahn Fredrick Ahn Hailey Ahn Hey Young Ahn Hong Hyun Ahn Jin Ahn Kate Ahn Kevin Ahn Ki Duk Ahn Nara Ahn Tae Hwa Ahn Victoria Ahuna Catherine Aiello James Aiello David Airhart Natalie Aivazian Peter Aivazian Vartan Ajamian Aatif Akhtar Aida Akhtar Ali Akhtar Alvira Akhtar Ayesha Akhtar Bakhtawar Akhtar Deen Akhtar

Faiz Akhtar Farooq Akhtar Hammad Akhtar Hanaa Akhtar M. Rafae Akhtar M. Ammar Akhtar M. Sohaib Akhtar Mahmood Akhtar Minoo Akhtar Mohid Akhtar Omar Akhtar Sahibzada Akhtar Saima Akhtar Shahan Akhtar Sheza Akhtar Siedra Akhtar Katrin Akob-Mapar Marine Akopdzhikyan Arshaluys Akopyan Alexander Akselrud Marina Akselrud Arek Aksoy Baruyr Aksoy Dilbar Aksoy Maral Aksoy Noimi Aksoy Vahakin Aksoy Varujan Aksoy Darren Akuin Dennis Akuin Haidi Akuin James Akuin Arutyun Aladjadjian George Aladjadjian Jacob Aladjadjian Lily Aladjadjian Melanie Aladjadjian Susanna Aladjadjian Yana Aladjadjian Carol Alam Helene Britany Alam Mohammed Alam Richard Alanis Deanna Alba Jasmin Alba

Matthew Alba Michael Alba Arnold Alban Judith Alban Morgat Albert Frances Albert Stein Maria Aldana Alexia Alderman Aliyah Alderman Mashae Alderman Elizabeth Aldrich Garik Aleksanyan Gayk Aleksanyan Sona Aleksanyan Vardui Aleksanyan John Alex Theresa Alex Thresa Alex Emily Alexander Keith Alexander Lisa Alexander Sarah Alexander George Alexopoulos Camilo Alfarero Rosita Alfarero Brendan Frank Alferez Robert Joseph Alhanati Dhia D. Alhashim Shatha A. Alhashim Ayub Ali Hassan Ali Hussain Ali Anna Allegeier David Allegeier David J. Allegeier Natalie Allegeier Cheryl Alleman Jay R. Alleman Desjon Allen Victoria Lynn Allen James Allnutt Hasan Almagased Bernadette Almeda Chistopher Almeda

Page 5: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

5

Melchor Almeda Rachel Almeda Valerie Alnakoud Agustin Alomia Carlos Alonso Heidi Alonso Daniel Alonzo Alen Alpanian Jordan Alpanian Julian Alpanian Sophia Alpanian Noureen Al-Shawwa Rashad Al-Shawwa Samar Al-Shawwa Sultan Al-Shawwa Tatiana Al-Shawwa Reham Al-Shawwa (Abushaban) Cruz Altamirano Lupe G. Altamirano Arielle Alterman Cruz Altimirano Federico Alva Maria Alva Rosa Alva Isabel Alvarado Johaida Alvarado Nivardo Alvarado Audrey Alvarez George Alvarez Jaleen Alvarez Jasleen Alvarez Jimmy Alvarez Jopel Alvarez Juan Carlos Alvarez Karla K. Alvarez Martha Alvarez Miracle Alvarez Nicolas Alvarez Sarine Alvarez Tamar Alvarez Ahmed Aly Jasmine Aly Naima Aly Michiko Ambo Angel Ambriz

Jairo Amezcua Dilma Amezquita Morteza Amidimazaheri Azita Amighi Farshid Aminian Nika Aminian Ryan Aminian Sanaz Aminian Haazim Amirali Muhammad Amirali Rozmeen Amirali Sanayah Amirali Yazan Ammari Angela An Byung Heon An Dennis An Hae Jin An Janet An Kristie An Liam An Nancy An Nathaniel An Ryan An Samuel An Steven An Adrian Anacleto Neelam Anand Ravinder Anand Christopher D. Ancheta Christopher A. Ancheta Joshua Ancheta Kimberly Ancheta Allen Andersen Bette Andersen Aaron Anderson Akil Anderson Andres Anderson Livana Anastasia Anderson Nichole Anderson Steve Anderson Vanessa Anderson Vladimira Anderson

Dina Andkhoy Ednees Andkhoy Elyas Andkhoy Imran Andkhoy Jobir Andkhoy Khatul Andkhoy Nafira Andkhoy Rahim Andkhoy Sabour Andkhoy Salmeen Andkhoy Zohor Andkhoy Austin Andrade Carry Andrew Lukas Andrew Nancy-Bissonette Andrew Jessica Anescua Yannett Angel James Angeles Tatum Angeles Britnee Robinson Anis Fouad Anis Gizabella Anis Ihab Anis Kaylee Madison Anis Kody Jake Anis Kyle Brandon Anis Samar Anis James Annes Mason Annes Nicholas Annes Theresa Annes Alisha Ansari Aysha Ansari Iayan Ansari Mohammed Ansari Rayan Ansari Mary Anserlian Jeffrey R. Anthony David Anton Valerie Anton Ruzanna Antonyan Barbara Apfel Dolores Apodaca Joe Apodaca

Page 6: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

6

Martin Applebaum Renee Applebaum Julie Applegate Keyle Applegate Mia Applegate Michael Applegate Carie Appleton David Appleton Emily Appleton Ara Aprahamian Celestine Apusen Zenaida Apusen Emmanuel Aragon Gilbert C. Aragon Kristoff Noel Aragon Melania Aragon Miguel Aragon Akop Arakelian Garbis Arakelian Nvard "Nancy" Arakelian Ripsime Arakelian Lamont Arakilians Lavinia Arakilians Sooren Arakilians Doris Aranda Victoria Arau Claudio O. Araujo Galmel Araujo Natalie Araujo Oscar A. Araujo Agavni Ardic Sevan Oskiyan Ardic Graciela Arellano Joe Arellano Jose Arellano Lorena Arellano Girardo Ares Arianna Arevalo Maritza Arevalo Raul Antonio Arevalo Sebastian Arevalo Suki Arevalo Kaveh Arfai Parviz Arfai David Aronek

Gabriel Aronson Samuel Aronson Neelu Arora Mary Aroyan Vahe Aroyan Alonso Efren Arreola Naomi Avery Arreola Noah Alonso Arreola Rocio Arreola Charron Arrick Dulce Arroyo Narek Arshakyan Tina Arshakyan Christine Artinian Michael Artinian Robert Artinian Sylvia Artinian Angela Artounian Tade Artounian Aimee Artz Nicholas Arwanda Tiffany Arwanda Alexander Arzouman Christina Arzouman Cynthia Arzouman Michael Arzouman Noora Asadi Shamim "Shawn" Asadi Gagik Asatryan Nare Asatryan Emma Ashasian Hamo Ashasian Simon Asheroff Britney Ashford Lee Ashford Aisha Asif Alya Iwas Askar Daniel Askar Moussa Askar Samuel Askar Ziad Askar Artin Aslanian Benjamin Asor Daniel Asor George Asuncion

Ali Asvadi Faranak Asvadi Shanna Asvadi Talen Atabekian Gacia Atachian Alison Atkiels Michael Atkiels Samer Attar Alaine Atyabi Ali Atyabi Martha Atyabi Steve Atyabi Sandra Av Gilbert Avakian Gavidara Avasakdi Aaron Avedian Hayrkoohi Avedian Seroj Avedian Ovsanna Avedissian Vrej Avedissian Vrej Avedissian Antonio E. Avila Teddy Avila Venicia C. Avila Ashton Aviles Fady Awad Layal Awad Malak Awad Shady Awad Sobhy Awad Yvette Ayala Carlos Ayala Jr. Carlos Ayala Sr. Lorig Ayaltin Mehrnoosh Ayari Jaden Ayers Jordan Ayers Kamryn Ayers Kelley Ayers Ronald Ayers Mariam Ayvazyan Alan A. Aywazian Alex Aywazian Alex E. Aywazian Anthony Aywazian Ossanna Aywazian

Page 7: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

7

Panos Aywazian Petr Ayzenberg Rosselle Azar Sona Azar Adriana Azarloza Armando Azarloza Elizabeth Azarloza Isabella Azarloza Natalia Azarloza Cheyenne Azer Lilianne Azer Sharif Azer Kimia Kiana Azizi Kourosh Kia Azizi Mitra Azizi Seyed Massoud Azizi Michael Ann Azoulai Areen Babajanian Shahen Babajanian Silva Babajanian Taleen Babajanian Marine Babakhanyan Christopher K. Babapilavian Sylvia Babapilavian Brent Babayans Emil Babayans Konstanian Babeyan Susan Babinye Galina Badali Ilboroun Badaloroumieh Marilen Badelles Gabriel Badelles-Tuason Byung Youn Bae Chris Bae Christine Bae Esther Bae Jae Sung Bae Jang Bae Joanne Bae John J. Bae John K. Bae Joyce Bae Michelle Bae

Un Kyong Bae Bette Baer Roger Baer Adriana Bagdasarian Bergi Bagdasarian Dana Bagdasarian Marrall Terra Bagerdjian Alexa Baghdassarian Anahit Baghdassarian Henry Baghdassarian Natalie Baghdassarian Julous Bagoza Hannah Bahadori Illiya Bahadori Keyvan Bahadori Helen Bai Mirza Baig John Baik Brittnee Bailey Kristen Bailey Shellee Bailey Vanessa Bailey Charles Bailin Amit Bajaj Kishan Bajaj Rajan Bajaj Satya Bajaj Sneh Bajaj Desiree Baker Gabrielle Baker Jacob Baker Jim Coulson Baker Jimmie Baker Steve Balalian Vincent Balalian Ernesto Balanay Leticia Balanay Alexandra Balcazar Daniel Balcazar Daniel Balcazar Denise Balcazar Jessica Balcazar Christopher Baldwin Kaitlyn Baldwin Alen Balikcian

Claude Balikcian Claudia Balikcian Talin Balikcian Kimberly Balin Hagop Balkian Kevork Balkian Natalie Balkian Loretta Ballard Paul Ballard Georgina Balli Cynthia Ball-Ward Eileen Balme Gerald Balme Tatyana Balyka Elaine Bana Alexis Bana-Chua George Banfalvi Trung Banh Asante Banks Keith Banks Mojdeh Banks Nicholas Banks Philip Banks Jesse Bannout Lea Bannout Randa Bannout Sammy Bannout Sergio Bannout Frank Banos Gloria Barboza Jemjaziel Barican Marci Barkan Edwin Barkhordarian Oshin Barkhordarian Roubik Barkhordarian Karen Barnes Lawton Barnes Michael Barnett Aide Baron Alexandra Baron Thomas Locke Baron Lilit Baronikian Rebecca Barr Jesus Barraza Albert Barrera Danny Barrera

Page 8: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

8

Fidel Barrera Imelda Barrera Lauren Barrera Miguel Barrera Jessie Barreto Yvette Marie Barreto Makenna Barrett Melissa Barrett Lisa Barrett Mckie David Barrientos Jessica Barrientos Juanita Barrientos Cheryl Barrios Ramon Barrios Salvador Barrios Zenaida Barrios Diane Barsamian Jan Bartell Morteza Barzandeh Stephanie Basbas Anastasia Basche Josh Basche Alisa M. Basler Harold Bass Phyllis Bass Akmal Adez Aziz Bastawros Gabrial Bastawros Heidi Bastawros Stephen Bastawros Bishoy Bastawvos Margneite Bastawvos Robert Bastens Bhavna Battu Jahan Battu Karina Battu Navin Battu Alma Batugo Jacqueline Batugo Jamielynne Batugo Jayson Batugo Joel Batugo Joshua Batugo Linda Batugo Chris Baucas Ian Bautista

Reinald Bautista Farid Bavarian Phyllis Bay Chelsea Bayliss Mark Bayliss Camille Bayreuther Cindy Bayreuther Kiowa Bayreuther Koen Bayreuther Ernest Baysinger Harriet Bbosa Bruce Beach Annie Beaudoin Anastasia Beck Brooks Jonathan Beck Daniel Beck Jonathan Beck Joy Beck Laura Beck Ryder Beck Shanna Beck Valerie Beck Anita Beckenstein Neil Beckenstein Alan Becker Ana Becker Shelby Becker Sidney Becker Alan Jason Becker, Jr. Emily Beckerman Jonathan Beckerman Tidaporn Tina Beckett Dwayne Beckner Vilma Beckner Yamizel Beckner Michael Bederian Patile Bederian Nuvart Bedikoglu Jose Israel Bedoya Lia Bedoya Salpy Bedrossian-Keif Shogik Begeyan Arneh Begi Maneh Begi

Martik Begi Nairi Begi (Kureghian) Judith Begin Mitra Behnezhad Nayereh Behrooz Jayleen Bejines Abeba Bekele Ava Belinsky Chloe Belinsky David Belinsky Gita Belinsky Jason Bell Martha Bell Susan Bell Barbara Bella Joseph Bella Joe Bellucci Michael R. Bellucci Michael G. Bellucci Tracey Bellucci Paul Bogos Benarbachian Adolfo Benavides Christian Benavides Jose Adolfo Benavides Marisol Benavides Mia Benavides Vianey Benavides Ricardo A Benavides Herrera Isabel Benavidez Stephen Benavidez Yaer Ben-Efraim Lorenzo Benet Lorenzo Benet, Jr. Ramona Benjamin Sperjohn Benjamin Bernardo Benjume Juan Benjume Marisa Benjume Bernice Benjune Theodore Bennett Brian Benson Charles Benson

Page 9: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

9

Gregory Benson Kim Evey Benson Daniel Beralas Christopher Berberyan Talar Berberyan Theodore Berberyan Stella Berestetsky Hugh Bergamo Karen Bergamo David Bergesson Jill E. Bergman Sander Bergman Shandra Beri Julie Berk Danica Bernal Tristan R. Bernal II Hayden Bernardo Jennifer Bernardo Katie Bernardo Maria Bernardo Susan Bernardo Ariel Bernstein Carol Bernstein Elisa Bernstein Gregg Bernstein Joslyn Bernstein Matthew Bernstein Neil Bernstein Rocky Bernstein Matthew Berris Peyton Berris Rachel Bertelsen Julian Berzon Julie Berzon Bradly Shayne Bessey Gabriel Bessey-Sanchez Jessica Betkhoodu Nerdan Betkhoodu Nicole Betkhoodu Andrea Beugnon Eva Rose Beugnon Leo Matisse Beugnon Luke Henry Beugnon

Maxime Ryan Beugnon Michael Beugnon Akshay Bhashin Pummy Bhashin Raju Bhashin Manisha Bhasin Aroon Bhatia Vijay Bhatt Belladonna Bidgoli Gianna Bidgoli Nema Bidgoli Graciela Bilotta Steven H. Bilotta Patricia Bilovsky Robert Bilovsky Jaysen Binder Richard Binder Ronald Binder Sue Ann Binder Shelley Binderman Robert Birch Janice Bird Jon Birdt Julie Birdt Lilianna Birdt John Birk Leslie Birk Gloria Bishop Pierce Bishop Sarah Bissett Bassam Bitar Jeffrey Ronald Blair Parker Blake Patrick Blake Tyna Blake Michelle Blalock Margaret Blanchard Alison Blancia Alleyah Blancia Angel Blancia Angelina Blancia Jefferson Blancia Maria Cecilia Blancia Jose Blanco Kaias Blanco

Melissa Blevins Caitlin Blinder Jeff Blinder Shawn Blinder Steve Blinder Robert H. Blisten Sally Blitz-Weisz Andrea Block Tony Blondal Amanda Bloom Alex Blythe Jack Boatwright Jeffrey Boatwright Roberta Boatwright Carlos Bobbio Dalya Boctor Eddie Boctor Maher Boctor Andrew Bogdan Ella Bogdan Lena Bogdan Micha Bogdan Noah Bogdan Anita Boghosian Silvia Boghosian Akbar Bohra Ruzanna Bojkov Fructuosa Bolado Julianne Bolado Justin Bolado Jennifer Bolhayon Aiden Bolokofsky Brian Bolokofsky Caitlynne Bolokofsky Michael Bolokofsky Sara Bolokofsky Blake Bolona Brooke Bolona Deirdre Bolona Gus Bolona Kelly Bolona Lauren Bolona Felicia Bolton Christina Bonniwell Daniel Bonora Diego Bonora

Page 10: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

10

Jodi Borenstein Justin Borenstein Larry Borenstein Laurie Borenstein Mary Boris Bonnie Bossin Kyanna Bosworth Tyler Botana Knarik Boudaghian Annette Boulgourjian Christine Boulgourjian Harautioun Boulgourjian Robin Bourne Olivia Bousnoyan Melisse Bouziane Mateo Bowman Anna Boyadjian Houchik Boyadjian Margaret Boyadjian Meline Boyadjian Tania Boyadjian Vatche Boyadjian Tania Boyadjion Elizabeth Boyer Cristina Boykins Derrick Boykins Nadia Boykins Chandler Bradley Lashawn Bradley Gerry Braganza Jacob Braganza Lauren Braganza Patricia Braganza Patrick Braganza Therese Brager Atman Brahmachari Bonnie Braiker-Gordon Bonnie Braiker-Gordon Sharon Braiker-Seinfeld Samantha Bran Cristian Branchesi

David Brand Marlene Brand Eileen Branda Jennifer Branda Yvette Brandeis Allen Brantz Linda Bratkovich Richard Bratkovich Andrea Lee Brauer Marc Jay Brauer Diane Helene Braverman Eric Jay Braverman Fernando S Bravo Fernando P Bravo Delfina Bregaudit Lynne Brener Steve Brener Andre Brennan Duane Brenneise Mary Brenneise Rebeca Brenneise Christina Briganti Austin Briggs H. Isabella Briggs William Briggs Herman Rios Brignoni Rita Brikina Jason Brimberry Linda Brimberry Colojeno Britt Melvin Britt Nazar Brizinov Samuel Brizinov Viktoriya Brizinov Kevin Brock Sabrina Brock Laurel Brod Kristine Brogelman Susan T. Bromiley Andrew Bromley Faye Dominique Bromley Jennifer Joan Bromley

Randall Bromley Thomas Bromley Nerses Bronsozian Gail Brow Robert Brow David Brown Desiree Brown Jaimie Brown James Brown Jeanne Brown Jon Brown Margery Brown R. Keone Brown Robert Brown Sherrie Brown Tannisha Brown William Brown Willie Sharon Brown September Bruce Charles Bruen Donna Bruen Anita Brule Jerrett Brunelle Mai Brunelle Tien Q. Brunelle Van Brunelle Margarita Brunsell Ronald Brunsell Carol Sue Bryant Kinga Brynda Sarah Buchanan Satyanvathi Budde Ananisha Budhrani Rosemarie Buehler Jon'Rene Buggs Dierdra Bugli Mark Bugli Zaghum Bukhari Elicia Bullock Todd Bullock Arutyian Buniatyan Arutyun Buniatyan Natalie Buniatyan Jerome Burak Mary Burak Corazon Buras

Page 11: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

11

Karen Burbank Robert Burbank T'Ayan Burbank Eric Burch Coltrane Ronald Burdette D'Artagnan Max Burdette Ronald Burdette Theodore Wayne Burdette Yvette Burdette Susan Burgess Jean Burkett Hank Burns Jackson Burns Jesse Burns Shawna Burns Lory Burros Laurie Burroughs Ryan Burton Anthony Buschelman Christian Buschelman Brittain Bush Elinor Bush Marlee E. Bush Ward Bush Jaime Bustamante Leilani Bustamante Susana Bustamante Marv S. Busuego Nora A. Busuego Kristyn Butler Erika Byars Shannon Byrne Emma Byun Jaemo Byun Jusin Byun Moo Wan Byun Sofia Byun Su Jin Byun Vivian Byun Young Su Byun Frederick Cabahug Jeannette Cabahug Joshua Cabahug

Logan Cabahug Maverick Cabahug Nico Cabahug Angelito Caballero Evangeline Caballero Jason Caballero Jeffrey Caballero Jonathan Caballero Joseph Caballero Steven Caballero Cynthia Caballero-Bay Barbara Cabantog Chloe Cabrera Silvana Cabrera Vianca B. Cabrera Angel Cabrera-Castillo Nancy Caceres Sarah Cadena Todd Cahill Grady Cai Jeremy Cai Jing Cai Makayla Cain Genevieve Cajayon Josephine Cajayon Mark Cajayon Virgilio Cajayon Rebecca King Cajucom Hermelinda Calatraya-Deir Alejandro Calderon Ella Calderon Guillermo Calderon Julia Calderon Roberto Calderon Sophia Calderon Sherry Caldwell Tori Call Tyler Call Vosco Call Diana Calleros Jose Calleros Cheryl Calo

Julie Calo Peter Calo Lily Calo-Vaccaro Cassandra Campagna Fred Campagna Sabrina Campagna Jennifer Campana Madelyn Campana Barbara Campbell Cameron Campbell Jennifer Campbell John Campbell Kevin Campbell Douglas Sigfredo Campos Sandra Matilda Campos Adela Campos-Barnes Azniv Canasyan Herman Canasyan Karin Canasyan Ghoneim Candida Ararat Canlian Nicolette Canlian Selin Canlian Miki Cannon-Katayama Christina Cantu Reni Cantu Nghia Cao Wei Cao Yuri Cao Valeria L. Capozzi Larry Capra Maureen Capra Hector Caprarella Adriana Carbonell Alayna Carbonell Alisa Carbonell Christian Cardenas David Carey Jeanne Carey Bobby Carlos Isael Carlos Kappie Tanna Carlos

Page 12: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

12

Kristian Lou Carlos Queen Zara Carlos Raistlin Carnahan Shannon Carnahan Tyrion Carnahan Lisette Carnet Ananias D. Caro Andrea Caro Erica Caro Vanessa Ann Caro Vivian Caro Zachary Caro Cassandra T. Carraway Max Carraway Samantha A. Carraway Samuel D. Carraway Jeri Carr-Benson-Hunter Albert Carrillo Hector Carrillo Scarlett Carrillo Colin Carr-Nall Hong Carson Ian Carson Jessica Carson Myles Carson Robert Carson Sydney Carson Brian Carter Carol Carvell Mark Carvell Edward Casas Guia Cascio John Cascio Adia Casey Anne Casey Kimberly Casey Michael Casey Natalie Casey Paul Casey Ethan Caspi Laine Caspi Neve Caspi Yuval Caspi

David Caspino Pamela Caspino Sofia Caspino Agustin Castaneda Juan Castaneda Monica Castaneda Mariano Castellanos Ana Casteneda Mayra Casteneda Roberto Casteneda Xiomara Casteneda Carmen Castiel Jamie Castiel Katelyn Castiglia Alyssa Castilllo Audrie Castilllo Celina Castilllo Javier Castillo Jose Castillo Paola Castillo Espinoza John Castro Raul Castro Alexander Cecena Marco Cecena Marisela Ceja Anthony Celis Jessie M. Celis Jon Cemcem Julia Cemcem Nadya Cemcem Nicole Cemcem Sonia Cemcem Isaias Centeno Massimo Centeno Melissa Centeno Felipe Cerdan Melanie Cerdan Quintus Cerdan Felia Ceron Katherine Ceron Kenneth Ceron Rachelle Ceron Rafael Ceron William Cevallos Lauryn Cha

Madison Cha Ryan Cha Steve Cha Susan Cha Nour Chaabaan Bashamber Chabra Daya Chabra Hee Kil Chae Inki & Wonki Chae Sun Chae Vatana Chaiyaruk Amy Chalabian Sarkis Chalabian Garnik Chamichyan Nattawan Chamnankha Harper Grace Champlin Romualdo Z. Chan Sherwin Chan Daulati Chandani Shaukatali Chandani Bhuvana Chandra Muthu Chandra Alice Youngim Chang Connie Chang Connor Chang Diana Chang Eugene Chang Eunice Chang George N. Chang Gina Chang Grant Chang Hannah Chang Hee Sook Chang Isabelle Chang Jae Chang Jason Chang Jennifer Millar Chang Joanne Chang Johnny Chang Jonathan Chang Joseph Chang Jun Hyck Chang Jung Chang

Page 13: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

13

Kimberly Duk Chang Kisook Chang Leopold Chang Lucas Ryder Chang Luke Chang Melanie Chang Michael Chang Michelle Chang Nicholas Chang Sam Samkyu Chang Sean Chang Soon Nyo Chang Sung Chang Susie Chang Tae Shik Chang Taylor Chang Tyler Chang Young Sil Chang Angela Chang-Louie Chia Lin Chang-Pan Arnuifo Chanquin Katherine Chansky Leonard Chansky Abram Chapkis Sonya Chapkis David Chase Jessie Chase Mireille Chase Alek Chatekachian Christine Chatekachian Juliana Chatekachian Serena Chatekachian Vahan Chatekachian Mathew Chauvie Robert Chauvie Dashiell Chavez Erin Chavez Jessica Chavez Jorge Chavez Nicholas Chavez Rachel Chavez Tommy Chavez Inna Chechelnik Michael Chechelnik Adelaine Chen

Amy Xr Chen Andy Chen Eric Chen Gregory Chen Ian Chen Jinglu Chen John Chia-Chuan Chen Megan Chen Michelle Chen Peyton Chen Tung-Shan Chen Yolanda Chen Huei Fang Cheng Myung Sook Cheong Alex Cherny Laurie Cherny Nathan Cherny Nelli Chernyak Vijay Chhabra Alka Chhatwal Deepak Chhatwal Karan Chhatwal Kishan Chhatwal Kunal Chhatwal Savitri Chhatwal Charles Chiaramonte Carlos Chichiri Jorge Chichiri Rossina Chichiri Valeria Chichiri Jamie Chien Anand Chikyarappa Janet Chin Shih-Yen Chin Susan Chin Douglas Kwi Ching Kwangnam Ching Lesley Ching Richard Ching William Ching Nohelia Chire Ettie Chlomovitz Benjamin S. Cho Bonita Cho Brandon Cho

Chelsea Cho Connie Cho Elaine Cho Elliot Cho Evan Cho Heung Sik Cho Hyunmok Cho Jacob Cho Jayden Cho John Cho Jung H. Cho Lois Cho Mark Cho Min Jung Cho Myong Cho Myueong G. Cho Na Hyun Cho Olivia Cho Yejin Cho Yerin Cho Young Suk Cho Yun E. Cho Annie Choe Chi Choe Chong Suk Choe Chris Choe Elson Su Choe Harold Choe Harris Choe Hyong Choe Jeong Choe Pyong Su Choe Alison Choi Byung Oh Choi Caleb Choi Chan Hee Choi Chloe Choi Christine Choi Deuk Chan Choi Dukcha Choi Ee Joon Choi Emily Choi Ethan Choi Eugene Choi Eun A. Choi Gloria Choi

Page 14: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

14

Grace Choi Hae Sook Choi Hyon Choi Hyunoak Choi James Hong Hun Choi Jason Choi Jennifer Choi Jin Sook Choi John Choi Joseph Choi Joshua Choi Julie Choi Karen Choi Kristina Wonju Choi Lauren Choi Megan Choi Min Sung Choi Myung Choi Paul Choi Paul Choi Rebecca Choi Sang Bae Choi Seong Ye Lee Choi Seung Won Choi Seung Won Choi Shanna Choi Shin Heum Choi Sophia Choi Soung Ja Choi Stephen Choi Sungja Choi Sydney Choi Woojin Choi Yiwon Choi Youn Jae Choi Young Suk Choi Yun Seok Choi Yunae Choi Charles Y. Chon Jane Chon AeKyoung Chong Anabelle Chong Ashley Foong Chong Aydan Foong Chong Chi H. Chong

Chin Kyun Chong Kari Foong Chong KwanHo Chong Sean Foong Chong Sue K. Chong Christine Chong Daniel Chong Jonathan Chong Mihyo Chong Rachel Chong Timothy Chong Young Lim Chong Karina Chopra Nevaan Chopra Nitin Paul Chopra Suzette Samour Chopra Syon Chopra Sharon Chorlian Candice Chotirmal Kishli Chotirmal Umeeta Chotirmal Chih Kang Chou Connie Chou Franklin Chou Jace Chou Jeffrey Chou Jenny Chou Tenley Chou Yu Ping Chou Brandon Chow Caroline Chow Charlene Chow Charles Chow Christopher Chow Dana Chow Edward Chow Gene Chow Katherine E. Chow Lucas Chow Walter Chow Sadie Chowdhury Christiana Chrysiliou Christos Chrysiliou Marina Chrysiliou Nikki Chrysiliou

Alexander S. Chu Arthur S. Chu Chol H. Chu Eileen Chu George Chu Hayley Chu Janet Chu Robert Chubbuck Annie Chun Christine Chun Elise (Minor) Chun Erin (Minor) Chun Eun Soon Chun Ike Chun Jong Ung Chun Juwon Chun Kelly Chun Kyu Dhall Chun Saewon Chun Sungbae Chun Thomas Chun Alexandria Chung Andy Chung Austin Chung Chai Nam Chung Christina Chung Edward Chung Hee Ja Chung Hye Jin Chung Irene Chung James K Chung Jenny Chung Jiwon Jeanna Chung Jonah Chung Jong Hoon Chung Jung Hee Chung Justin (Issa) Chung Kailee Chung Madeline Chung Michael Chung Mike Chung Min Ja Chung Myung S. Chung Myung Woon Chung Namho Chung Nathon Chung

Page 15: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

15

Patrick Chung Patrick Yong Chung Samuel Chung Stephen Chung Steven Jaeyong Chung Sung Do Chung William Chung Yong Hi Chung Yun Chung Yun Jeong Chung Soo Young Chung Jabid Cicekci Mark Cicekci Heinne Natalie Cilliani Allen Cinoglu Alex Cismas James A. Clairmont Valerie Clairmont Chastity Clark Cherryl Clark Christian Clark Dubwana Clark Faith Clark Frank Clark Jadore Clark Kathy Clark Kenneth Clark Kingston Clark Larry Clark Monroe Clark Nascha Clark Nicolina Clark Renee Clark Skyy Clark Susie Clark Zachiah Clark Dubwana Clark II Heather Clark-Blanco John Clayton Kimberly Clayton Derek Clemens Erika Clemens Kirsten Clemens Stan Clemens

Yvonne Clemens Tim Clement Nicholas Clemmer Robin Clemmer Kim Clouser Reynaldo Clutario Jada Coburn Kenzo Coburn Mary B. Coburn Maya Coburn Rodrick Coburn Ju Yon Cocco Juyon Cocco William Cocco William F. Cocco Patricia Cockburn Greg Coco Jackson Coco Janet Coco Marcus Coco Christian Coerds Mari Coerds Sarah Coerds Allison Cohen Daniel Cohen Hailey Jane Cohen Roberta Cohen Jeannie Cokvar Serop Cokvar Talin Cokvar Doreen Colato Michael Colato Carol Cole Robert Cole Betty Collins Bryce Collins Kennedy Collins Larry D. Collins Rhonda Collins Richard Collins Serena Collins Bernard Collura Connie Collura Elaine Coloma Sophia Colon Christopher Conley

Robert Connolly David Connor Judith Connors Richard H. Connors Ashley Contreras Milagros Contreras Sariah Contreras Vincent Contreras Isabella Cook Norma Cook Paul Cook Randy G Cook Randy Tyler Cook David Cooper Jody Cooper Miriela Cooper Patricia Cooper Ricardo A Corbera Scott Corbridge Brenda Cordova Evangeline Cordova Josef Cordova Wendy Corell Aiden Corrado Corbin Corrado Fernando Corrado Lucas Corrado Tracey Corrado Adam Corral Anthony Corral Efren Corral Sarah Corral Jane Cortez Marlon Cortez Sarah Cortez Sigfrido Cortez Stella Cortez Stephen Cortez Nancy Costello Dina Cottrell Ethan Cottrell Nikki Cottrell Stephen Cottrell Catherine Coutermash Linda Cowan Caleb Cox

Page 16: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

16

Christie Cox Colin Cox David Cox Katelyn Cox Malcom Cox Marcia M. Cox Alan Crawford Chancellor Crawford Diesel Crawford Sandy Crawford Michael Creith Sandra Creith Stacey Crenshaw Jonathan Crohn Robert Cronin Chloe Crump Demetrius Crump Jesse Cruz Jocelyn Cruz Judith Cruz Liza Marie Cruz Lydia Cua Reginal Cua Alex Cubillos Claudia Cubillos Frank Cubillos Maria Mireya Cubillos Stewart Cubillos Wendy Cubillos Gerald Cucco Randy Cucco Aminta Cuellar Christopher Cuenca Erin Cuenca John Cuenca Lauren Cuenca Adam Cummings Charlie Cummings Jennilee Cummings Seth Cummings Joven Cumpio Alexa Cunningham Hilda Cunningham Lois Cunningham Sandra Cunningham

Verl Cunningham Emery Curry Evan Curtis Katerina Curtis Sydney Curtis Steven Czarnecki Renato Da Silva Analyn Dacanay Jaedalyn Dacanay Jannessa Dacanay Jaycee Dacanay Joemar Dacanay Kirsten Dacanay Asghar Dadashian Sudi Dadashian Tara Dadashian Naishiq Dadourion Alexia Daghlian Alick Daghlian Jimmy Daghlian Gregory Daglian Karine Daglian Mary Daglian Michael Daglian Nerses Daglian Alin Dakessian Jack Dakessian Nora Dakessian Christine Dam Malina Damach Ferrariem Dandan Pamela Dandan Elmast Danelian David Daniels Diane Daniels Asmik Danielyan Harutyun Danielyan Shake Danielyan Harout Danielyn Jakob Danino Michelle Danino Abdul Samad Danishwar Abdullah Danishwar Shafiga Danishwar Christopher Daquino

Jeffrey Daquino Stacie Daquino Narine Darbinyan Bruce Darian Charles Darin Knight Emik Darpinian Gloria Dart John Dart Rhonda Datzker Lily Daun Ami Dave Chiraag Dave Dhaval Dave Kiran Dave Douglas David Barbara Davis Catherine Davis James E. Davis Jimmy Davis Lisa Davis Pamela A. Davis Artur Davletbyev Guillermina Dawson Kason De Guzman Ray De Guzman Amber De La Torre Glenda T. De La Torre Roberto De La Torre Robert De La Vara Anthony De Long James M. De Long James A. De Long Stephanie De Long Tonya De Long Mary Jane De Los Santos Patricia De Luca Darren De Marco Danielle De Silva Kaylin De Silva Neranjika De Silva Dale De Vera Daniel De Vera Marilu De Vera Rodolfo De Vera

Page 17: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

17

Ray W Dean Dale Deardorff William Debley Wybrigje Debley Ana Maria Tenono Decilliani Kathy Decker Marshay Dede Im Jo Degerman John Degerman Robert Degidio Edilberto Deguzman Elenito Deguzman Kason Deguzman Kimberly Deguzman Kristina Deguzman Maria Ceciila Deguzman Melinda Deguzman Raef Deguzman Royce Deguzman Stephanie Deguzman Amean Dejohn Clarisse Dejohn John Dejohn Kenneth Dejohn Nicolas Dejohn Lucy Del Real Tennie Del Rosario Genevieve DeLeon Christian Delgado Joey Dellibovi Nicole Dellibovi Patrick Dellibovi Joseph Anthony Dellivobi Dana Delman Milagros Delmendo Rene A. Delmendo Olivier Demail Terry Demarinis Stephanie Colleen Deming-York Armand Demirchyan Benon Demirchyan Christina Demirchyan

Daniel Demirchyan Grigor Demirchyan Karina Demirchyan Marina Demirchyan Susan Demirchyan Valentina Demirchyan Linette Demirjian James Demoff Marcia Demoff Eileen Denburg Joshua Dennis Patrick Dennis Lucy Denny-Gardner Serge Derbedrossian Baizar Derderian Khajag Derderian Andrew Derkrikorian Carmen Derkrikorian Natalie Derkrikorian Alyssa Dermenjian Alyssa Dermenjian Ani Dermenjian Ashot Dermenjian Vahe Dermenjian Hermine Arakelvan Dermenjian ("Arakelvan") Eliza Dermirdjian Levon Dermirdjian Meghrie Dermirdjian Mike Dermirdjian Vahan Dermirdjian Marlene Dersarkissian Arsen Dervishian Tina Dervishian Nalin A. Desai Priti Desai Carlos DeSantiago Alaina Desantis Brooklinn Antoinnette Desantis Dennis Desantis David M. Desser Sophie Desser

K. Vinatha Devi Charles Deville John A. Devine Sarah Devine Daniel Devonald Hannah Danielle Deweldon Jeanne Dexheimer Ripu Daman Dhawan Sunita Dhawan Shubjeet Dhillon Gianna Diab Ida Diab Jacob Diab Maya Diab Nathan Diab Michelle Diamond Heidi Dianaty Irene Dianaty Mary Diarbekirian Missak Diarbekirian David Nicholas Diaz Guadalupe Diaz William Diaz Michael Dickinson Sandra Dickinson Sharon Dickson Michael Diehl Annette M. Diehl-Jacobs Alice Dilanian Armen Dilanian Natalie Dilanian David Dilbiyan Karapet Dilbiyan Maria Dilbiyan Sheri Dillon Josefa Dimas Anupama Dimashkie Bassam Dimashkie Kira Dimashkie Abby Dimatta Emily Dimatta Robert Dimatta Michael Dinh Valerie Dinh

Page 18: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

18

Victoria Dinh Vonny Tunru Dinh Robert Dinololker Debra Dinowitz Jerry Dinowitz Sean Dinu Carmencita Dionisio Lucia DiPietro Pearl DiPietro Tammy DiPietro-Howell Philip Ditchik Sidonia Ditchik Diana DiTommaso Joseph DiTommaso Katherine DiTommaso Maria DiTommaso Steven DiTommaso Gloria Dixon Angela A. Dizon Delia Dizon Gabriel Dizon Jean Dizon Jeffrey Dizon Joan Dizon Jocelyn Dizon Marcelino Dizon Sofiel Dizon Vincent Dizon Winston Dizon Anthony Do Due Dinh Do Nathan Do Patricia Do Samantha Do Leonard Doctor Marcia Doctor Scott Doctor Ashedik Dohabjian Babken (Bob) Dohabjian Eliahu Dolgin Anita Domingo Oliver Domingo Precious Domingo

Samantha Domingo Albert Dominguez Dominic Dominguez Patrick Dominguez Shari Dominguez Tracy Dominguez Albert Donahue Arthur Anthony Donahue Digna Donato Jerry Donato Kirstine Donato Vincent Donato Manasse Donikian Sean Donoghue Susan Donoghue Tara Donoghue Christina Donoyan Lara Donoyan Sebouh Donoyan Sevag Donoyan Jenny Rose Dorfman Jerry David Dorfman John Dorfman Sandra Dorfman Joe Dorgalli Mary Dorgalli Gary Dorian Jason Dorian Matild Dorian Michael Dorian Marilyn Dorlac Michael Dorlac Allison Dormanesh Ashley Dormanesh Flor Dormanesh Mort Dormanesh Farhad Dormani Kian Dormani Megan Dormani Sharon Dormani Eric Doroski Kathlyn Doroski Michael C Doroski Dominic Doss James Downs

Kenneth Dozier Brenda Drummond Jennifer Drummond Liam Dubon Steven Duddy Alberto Duenas Karla Duke Roger Duke Sheryl Duke Ashley Dultz Carolynn Dultz Wyatt Dultz Robert Duncan Gloria Dunkel Cameron E. Dunnet Cameron Dunnet Ian Dunnet Teri Dunnet Adrianna Maria Dunross Nicole Dunross Philip William Dunross Julie Dupont Michelle Dupont Theodore Dupont Tom Dupont Wing Dupont Katherine Duque Salvador Duque Betty Duran Diego Duran Ellen Duran Joaquin Duran Miguel Duran Raymond Duran Isabella Durand Janice Durand-Striegel David Durocher Evan Durocher Megan Durr Natalie Durr Prayong Durr Thomas Durr Gretta Durzi

Page 19: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

19

Rami Durzi Victor Durzi Robert Dutche Gabrielle Claudine Dy Pretty Lyn Dy Carla Earle Katrina Earles Kiterra Earles Caitlin Easterday Sandra Easterday Garett Eaves Erlinda Echevarria Valentino Echevarria Stacy Ecklund Jasun Edelmann Mitch Edrington Shirlie Edrington Wendy Edrington Lauren Effertz William Effertz Azadeh Eghterafi Tomas Eguiluz Alyson Ehlert Adam Paul Eichhorst Adam C. Eichhorst Avery Madeleine Eichhorst Stasha Eiland Carolin Eiliya Helen Eiliya Isabella Eiliya Andrea Eing John Eing Nathan Eing Barry Eisenman Daniel Eisenring Ethan Eisenring Alec Ekizian Aline Ekizian Aren Ekizian Noemi Ekizian Sam Ekizian Serge Ekizian Tamar Ekizian Ani Ekmekchian

Andrea Elberger Kevin Elberger Michael Elberger Steven Elberger Alendra Elbert Alexandra Elbert Ani Elbert Brent Elbert Daniel Elbert Eugene Elbert Linda Elbert Rita (Brikina) Elbert Sophia Elbert Lauren Eldib Ramsey Eldib Susanna Eldib Thomas Eldib Rita Elgrably Peter Elisseos Helaine Elkayam Jay Elkayam Aaron Ellis Christina Ellis Jason Ellis Richard Ellis James Ellison Lano Ellison Ibrahim Sami Elmazati Naida Ghazi Elmazati Mark Gavin Chan Enarsao Rosy Chan Enarsao Soren Evan Chan Enarsao Ulysses Frandel Enarsao Katherine M. Endo Beatrice Endozo Jerry England Mary Ennabi Aric Entwistle Brandon Entwistle Trevor Entwistle Evangelina Equina Gilana Equina

John Equina Ranen Equina Ellen Erdman Abolghasem Erfanzadeh Abolghasem Erfanzadeh Farah Erfanzadeh Ghazaleh Erfanzadeh Mehran Erfanzadeh Armenuhi Esayan Toros Esayan Salvador Escalante Alyssa Escartin Marcus Escartin Sandra Escartin Sophia Escartin Ulysses Escartin Mark Escobar Natalie Escobar Valerie Escobar Chester Escoto Jens Eser Sam Eskandari Cyrus Eslamieh Farid Eslamieh Griselda Eslamieh Masiolah Eslamieh Soraaya Eslamieh Rafael Esparza Andrew Espinoza Carlos Espinoza Hunter Essang Brittany Estrada Evander Estrada Luz Estrada Michael Estrada Nancy Estrada Raymond Estrada Ramiya Ettehad James Eusebio Maribel ("Soller") Eusebio Jennifer Evangelista David Evans Jill Evans

Page 20: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

20

Lana Faber Lucas Fackler Lee Ann Faeth Jilanne Fager Richard Fager Issa Fakhoury Manar Fakhoury Nasif Fakhoury William Fakhoury Ethan Fang Lauren Fang William Fang Charles Fann Josephine Briar Fann Masae Fann Reagan Fann Mahasti Farazian Mildred Farazian Sadif Fargam Joanna Farias Poopak Fariborz Maryam Farooqi Timothy Farran Alison Fass Barbara Fass Ronald Fass Ryan Fass Nicholas Fassett Lyubov Fastovskaya Mohammed Fata Shekiba Fata Sofia Fata Fouzia Fatah Mujtaba Fatah Qasim Fatah Sara Fatah Bizhan Fateri Tarek Fattal Ashley Fauria Raimunda Fauria Jennifer Favela Ray Fazendin Robert Feal Trashon Fearington Heshanthi Federer Merra Federer

Mitch Federer Esther Feldman Martin Feldman Chela Felix-Johnson Matthew Fennelly Gelila Fente Selam Fente Worku Fente Alexander Carl Ferency Kathleen Ferency Annette Fernandez Dasha Fernandez Gabriela Fernandez Kenneth Fernandez Marvin Fernandez Rosario Fernandez Salvador Fernandez Sasha Fernandez Tanya Fernandez Vanessa Fernandez Angelo Fernando Kathy Fernando Louis Fernando Noah Fernando Maria Ferreira Donald Ferrie John Ferris Kathy Ferris David Feuerhelm Jane Feuerhelm Julie Feves Adrianna Fewer Marshall Fewer Ron Fewer Valerie Fewer Brett Fichera Maureen Fichera Michael Fichera Robert Fielding Robert Fielding James Fields Ryan Fields Bruce Figoten Teri Figueras Joanna Figueroa

Peter Fillmore Renee Fillmore Cecil Fine Michael Fineberg Rimma Fineberg William Finklestein Wendy Finley Randy Finmark Charles Fiore Linda Firestone Scott Harris Firestone Jacqueline Fishel Roberts Glenn Fisher Mark Fisher Patricia Ann Fisher Benjamin Fiss Daniel D. Fiss Gayle Fitzpatrick Sean Flannery Gabriel Fleiderman Rebekah Ataliyah Fleiderman-Nelson Ian Fletcher Jaden Fletcher Jett Fletcher Mae Florentin Marilyn Florentin Rosendo Florentin David Flores Patricia Flores Patricia Flores Rudy M. Flores Joseph Florian Michael Flowers Caroline Rae Fogarty Louis Fondrick Elizabeth Fontejon Patricia Fontejon Ralph Fontejon Raphael Fontejon Asia Forbes Charlotte Ford Nahid Forghaniarani Cecilia Forrest Lynette Forrester

Page 21: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

21

Jason Foster Joan Foster Kevin Foster Sheila Foster William Foster Lisa Fournier Raymond Fournier Robert Fournier Bernard Fowler Jane Fowler Asher Fox Cheryl Fox Corey Fox Ella Fox Jennifer Fox Timothy Fox Ricky Vincent Francia Kristine Francisco Grace Franke Margaret Franke Maureen Franke Stephen Franke David Free Mindy Free Beth Freedberg Suzanne Freedberg Karen Freeman Steven Freeman Vickie Frelow Dennis Fried Joyce Fried Larine Friedman Matthew Everett Frieson Marcus Allen Frishman Roderick Fritz Irene Frizzell Stephen Frizzell Richard Charles Frontino Tim Frost Dikran Frounjian Grace Frounjian Victoria Fuentes

Isaac Fujikawa Reese Fujikawa Ryan Fujikawa Cindy Fujimoto Cruz Fujimoto Jada Fujimoto Jordan Fujimoto Lindy Fujimoto Melissa Fujimoto Stephen Fujimoto Susan Fujimoto Nazaret Fustokjian Sona Fustokjian Maria Gabriel Edgar Gabriyelyan Michael Gabriyelyan Lisa Gagliano Naomi Gagliano Nicole Gagliano Richard Gagliano Harshad Gajjar Dolores Galang Pete Galang Elita Galiamova Tony (Blondal) Galiamova Andrew Gallagher David Gallagher Rosanne Gallagher Tescile Gallagher Andrew Gallaher Amri Gallardo Bruno Gallardo Faith Gallardo Grace Gallardo Yslani Gallardo Clare Gallo George Gallo Trevan Galloway Alice Galoian Hagop Galoian Mariam Galoian Zaven Galoian Alice Galstian Robert Galstian Seda Galstian

Azatouhi Galstyan Azatouhi Galstyan Mari Galstyan Lyudvik Galustyan Bertha Galvan Emmie Galvan Hector Galvan Angelica Galvez Gladys Galvez-Grieve Connie Galvez-Sanchez Alexander Galyan Greg Galyan Stella Galyan Tagvor Galyan Termine Galyan Arutyun Gamalyan Iann Gamboa Patricia Gamboa Sergio Gamboa Zoee Gamboa Larry Gans Rochelle Gans Aida Gaona Ricardo Gaona Richardo Gaona Sarkis Garabedian Kristen Garay-Aceves Martin Garces Gurjit Garcha Maya Garcha Nashatar Garcha Sasha Garcha Surjit Garcha Tarlochan Garcha Andrew Garcia Angelo Garcia Anthony Garcia Antonio Garcia Candice Garcia Celeena Garcia Charlene Isabel Garcia Dorothy Garcia Francesca Garcia Francis Garcia

Page 22: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

22

Francisco Garcia Genesis Garcia Guillermo R. Garcia Ian Garcia Isagani Garcia Jesus Garcia Joey Garcia John Garcia Jose Garcia Juan Garcia Juliann Garcia Julie Ann Garcia Juliette Garcia Kristi Garcia Laura Garcia Lucila Garcia Marcus Garcia Maria Elena Garcia Marina Garcia Maritza Garcia Matias Garcia Matthew Garcia Maxwell Garcia Melissa Garcia Neria Garcia Nika Garcia Paola Garcia Phil Garcia Precy Garcia Shiloh Garcia Teri Garcia Va Lam Garcia Carmen Garcia Alomia Christopher Gardner Craig Gardner Arnold Garey Jordan Garey Maria Garey Ty Garey Albert Garibkhanyan Anna Garibkhanyan Edvard Garibkhanyan Emmi Garibkhanyan Maria Garibkhanyan Marten Garibkhanyan

Hrayr Garibyan Ruzanna Garibyan JoEllen Garner John Patrick Garner Kellee Garner Alicia Garrido Julian Garsdean Marcus Garsdean Marty Garton Elizabeth Garza Irma Garza Anthony Gasparyan Hratchya Gasparyan Lilianna Gasparyan Tatevik Gasparyan Frances Gateward Mark Gay William Matthew Gay Aaron Gbewonyo Alyssa Gbewonyo Enid Gbewonyo Wilmot Gbewonyo Marcia Geisser Sanford Geisser Aaron Gelejian Christina Gelejian Elizabeth Gelejian Gia Gentile Richard J. Geralds Roman Gergel Lionel Gershfeld Dmitry Gerzon Roshel Gerzon Haile Gessesse Yebralem Gessesse Matthew Getchius Rafael Gevorkov Lilit Gevorkova Mariam Gevorkova Andranik Gevorkyan Mari Gevorkyan Sarkis Gevorkyan Reda Ghacha Touraya Ghacha Wafia Ghacha

Farkhondeh Ghanikaran Narbeh Gharakhanian Noelle Gharakhanian Norik Gharassimian Sofia Gharassimian Jeanne Ghareeb Gohar Gharibian Ani Gharibyan Tehmine Gharibyan Ramy Gharzeddine Samar Gharzeddine Walid Gharzeddine Albert Ghawi George Ghawi Malvina Ghawi Peter Ghawi Lilit Ghazaryan Nazeli Ghazaryan Nizar Gheewalla Shamshad Gheewalla Shazim Gheewalla Samy Ghoneim Miganoush Ghookasian Vigen Ghookasian Cynthia Ghusayni Gus Ghusayni Sue Ghusayni Dong Su Gi Eun K. Gi James Y. Gi Michael Y. Gi Aron Gideon Christian Gideon Faith Gideon Laura Gideon Rosa Gil Sheri Gilbreath David Gilmore Marissa Gilmore Leslie Alan Gilreath Guillermo Giuliani Rocio Giulietti Brandon Glasgow Kalaya Glasgow

Page 23: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

23

Krischana Glasgow Kuan Glasgow Emanuel Glemkstein Marcos Glemkstein Kathryn Diana Glenn David Gobrial Mark Gobrial Nabil Gobrial Salwa Gobrial Mikal Godinez Maruthi Naveen Godishala Treniece Goins Estella Gold Alison Goldberg Linda Goldberg Richard Goldberg Robert Goldberg Susan Goldberg Curt Golden Doris Golden Kaden Golden Kary Golden Kayla Golden Sherron Golden Allan Goldenberg Ella Goldenberg Luca Goldenberg Tammy Goldenberg Ann Marie Golding Stan Golding Victoria Golding Karen Goldman David Goldstein Donna Goldstein Joseph Goldstein Norman Goldstein Rosetta Goldstein Sarah Goldstein Sevan Goldstein Karen Golob Maryanna Golovash Elana Gomberg Maury Gomberg Angelo Gomez Elizabeth Gomez

Ivan Gomez Jose De Jesus Gomez Julio Gomez Sasha Gomez John Goncuian Vartuhi Rose Goncuoglu Ashlyn Gonzaga Brandon Gonzaga Francis Gonzaga Gail Gonzaga Kai Gonzaga Dorothy Rae Gonzales Elizabeth Gonzales Janet Gonzales Reynaldo A. Gonzales Reynaldo T. Gonzales Rhodora Gonzales Breanna Gonzalez Gabriel Gonzalez JoAnne Gonzalez Jose Trinidad Gonzalez Nuria Annabella Gonzalez Phillip William Gonzalez Stefanie Lynn Gonzalez Ricky Goode Elaine Goodwin Tiffany Goossen Alyna Gopez Joseph Gopez Eric Gordon Mark Gordon Melinda Gordon Betty Gorelick Steven Gorelick Alexander G. Gorenc Christine Gorenc Nick Gorenc Gavin Gorham Gianna Gorham

Gilbert A. Gorham Gracie Gorham Margarita Gorham Susan I. Gorman-Chang Amanda Goshay William Goshay Lisa Goshon Brignoni John Goslin Angel Govea Shivakumar Gowder Marcie Grado Alicia Graham Camren Akira Grana Christina Grana Guillermina Dawson Granada Palms Apartm Raiden W. Grana-Mascolo Kathleen Grant Ellen Graunke Kataleya Grayer Boris Grayfer Marina Grayfer Andrew Grayr Jacob V. Grayr Victor Grayr Fatima Grayson Talaya Grayson Andrea Greanias Christopher Greanias Harry Greanias Irene Greanias Steve Greanias Gayle Grech Mark C. Grech Nadia Grech Chandler Green Irene Green Madison Green Neil Leo Green Paul Green Scott Green Lorraine Greenberg Marina Greenberg

Page 24: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

24

Peter Greenhood Bruce Greenwood Helen Greenwood Holden Gregorczyk Linda Gregorczyk Rouben Gregorian Dimitry Grekov Marina Grekov Sergey Grekov Janice Grierson Kristi Griffis Derek Griffiths Janet Griffiths Toni McZeal Griggs Verceller Griggs Jasmen Grigorian Marie Grigoryan Robert Grigoryan Anatoly Grinberg Michelle Grinberg Nelly Grinberg Nayri Guaderrama Natalya Gubanova Tony Guevara Gordon D. Guglich Irene Francis Guglich Shelly Ann Guglich James Guiboa Nancy Guiboa Alexander M. Guirguis Christina Guirguis Kristin Livanis Guirguis Ram Gulam Anil Gunaratne Anusha Gunaratne Dinushi Gunaratne Miran Gunaratne Thushani Gunaratne John Gundry Jason Gungormezer Maral Gungormezer Sevan Gungormezer Adam Guo Emily Guo

Karina Guo Kenneth Guram Marianne Guram Christine Gurenc Nick Gurenc Amethyst Gururaja Avinash Gururaja Jaiden Gururaja Andrew Guss Dylan Guss William Guss Ronald Gutcher Desiree Gutierrez Emillo Gutierrez John Gutierrez Joseline Gutierrez Leonardo Gutierrez Maria Concepcion Gutierrez Marilyn Gutierrez Martha Alicia Gutierrez Miguel Gutierrez Raphael Gutierrez Laura Marcela Gutierrez Rojas Maria Camila Gutierrez Rojas Andrey Gutin Mark Gutin Ada Gutman Willie Gutman Adrianna Guzman Camillle Guzman Dominic Guzman Francisco Guzman Wendy Guzman Davdi Gyurijian Haroutyan Gyurijian John Gyurijian Hannah Jane Haan Karen B. Haan Kenneth T. Haan Irahim Habib Alizabeth Haddad Alma Haddad

Bassam Haddad Cameron Iman Haddad Faris Haddad Fritze Iman Haddad Isam Haddad Isam Haddad Kiyan Haddad Laith Haddad Lina Haddad Manal Haddad Nadia Khalil Haddad Najah Haddad Natasha Nadia Iman Haddad Rania Haddad Samuel Haddad Samuel Haddad Shihab Samual Haddad Sultan Haddad Yazan Haddad Alireza Hadian Ashkan Hadian Firouzen Hadian Andrey Hahn Ayoung J. Hahn Chloe Hahn Christine Hahn Elizabeth Hahn Geoffrey Hahn Jaemin Timothy Hahn Jaeyi Jedidiah Hahn Kab Mi Hahn Lydia Hahn Seonghyeon Hahn Seongkook Hahn Yeongrim Hahn Farzana Haiati Jalil Haiati Lida Haiati Naweed Haiati Omid Haiati Haroot Hairabedian Vera Hairabedian Ana Hairapetian

Page 25: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

25

Artashes Hairapetian Mariam Hairapetian Seyran Hairapetian Maryam Hakimzadeh Gohar Hakobyan Marlena Hakobyan Marine Hakopian Chloe Pearl Hakverdian Lelean Hakverdian Loosema Hakverdian Mher Hakverdian Tamar Hakverdian Vartan Hakverdian Jadd Halaby Marilyn Halaby Naabeel Halaby Tarek Halaby Arvind Halani Kamini Halani Nootan Halani Chowdhury Halim Aliya Hall Amina Hall Asha Hall Ashley Hall Jason Hall John Hall Sandra Hall Scott Hall Ashley Ham Benjamin Ham Jodie Ham Sun Ja Ham Sung Jin Ham Gregory Hamamjian Sarkis Hamamjian Zara Hamamjian Aida Hambardzumyan Lorraine Hamblin Kayla Hamburg Michelle Hamburg Peyton Hamburg Steve Hamburg Melinda Hamm

Aaron Han Andrew Han Cheol Min Han Chong Hye Han Don Han Esther Chong Han Jeff Han Jihee Han Jimmy Han Kyong O. Han Sang Cher Han Sang Min Han Sharon Han Tania Han Naeem Hana MauriceE E. Haney Demetrius Hankins Andrew Hanna Cathy Hanna Daniella Hanna David Hanna Emil R. Hanna Jane Hanna John Hanna Marina Hanna Remon Hanna Rival Hanna Thamer Hannona Tate Hanson Zaghir Hapetian Brandy Harbaugh Cheyenne Harbaugh Emily Harbaugh Lisciandro Harbaugh Marie Harbaugh Isabella Jean Harder Johanna Harder Jonathan Harder Drucillia Hardy Zachary Harold Susie Harper Jacob Harrelson Anna Harris Dapree Harris Shane Michael Harris Chris Harrison

Dawn Harrison Eloise Harrison Ginger Harrison Marshall Harrison Arby Harutunyan Arsen Harutunyan Anjeatte Harville Brittany Harville Cameron Harville Victoria Harville Ryan Hashemi Samuel Hashemi Sara Hashemi Aziza Hashimi Daniel Hashimi Kaihann Hashimi Mustafa Hashimi Salmaan Hashimi Sanah Hashimi Sarah Hashimi Sayed Hashimi Dianne Haskell Ronald Hasse Valerie Hasse James Eric Hawkins Maurkeisha M. Hawkins Anas Hayat Atia Hayat Muhammad Hayat Nirma Hayat Tasweer Hayat Cynthia Ann Hayes LaLaunie Hayes-Botana George Hayrapetian Jason Hayrapetian Suzanne Hayrapetian Timothy Hayrapetian Sherry Healy Virginia Hedrick Jami Heidegger Klaus Heidegger Max Heidegger Daniel G Heil Heidi Heinl

Page 26: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

26

Ali Hekmatnia Bahram Hekmatnia Andrew Held Annette Held Kenneth Held Ariana Helmand Aydin Helmand Mariam Helmand Omar Helmand Shah Helmandi Berthe Najjar Hemaidan Jacqueline Hemaidan Toufic Hemaidan Vivette Hemaidan Ethan Hemminger Hadley Hemminger Nathan Hemminger Udi Hen Marilyn Hendrix Nancy Hendrix Brenda Hennessy Asar Henry Christina Henry Chyanne Henry James Henry James Henson Mani Heravi Mani Heravi Mona Heravi Lisa Herbert-Effertz Anibal Hermosilla Joel Hermosilla Alexa Hermosillo Alma Hermosillo Jiovana Hermosillo Richard Hermosillo Alexa Hermoso Fernan Hermoso Isabella Hermoso Yu Hermoso Ansell Davis Hernandez Daniel S. Hernandez Edwin Alvarez Hernandez

Esmeralda Hernandez Janet Hernandez Jorge Sanchez Hernandez Jose Hernandez Maria Hernandez Michael Dean Hernandez Rebecca Hernandez Silvia Hernandez Vincent Earl Hernandez Xander Hernandez Zayne Hernandez Dwight Herr Apollo Herrera Jessica Herrera Nelida Herrera Sylvia (Yamela) Herrera Yalile Herrera Bryan Herring Nysheka Herring Dianne Herriott Michael Herriott Greg Herzenach Caleb Heulitt Rita Heyn Lea Heysin Kyoko Hibino Gage Hicks Leann Hicks Eugene Hidalgo Ralph Hidalgo Chiori Higa Harold Higa Robert Hilbert Erik Hiljus Stephanie Hiljus Barbara K. Hill Hayley E. Hill Joyce Hill Kelly C. Hill Matthew C. Hill Ray Hill Richard Gantry Hill

Ryan Garrett Hill Wendy Ann Hill Williams Gregory Lane Hillman Isaiah Mathias Hillman Kimberly C. Hillman Laura Cardenas Hillman Sona Hindoyan Dick Hirsch Nina Hirsch Denise Hirsch-Shell Andy Hirun Beverly Ngoc Tram Ho Dean Ho Gene Ho Hee Sun Ho Kimberly Ngoc Phuong Ho Trieu Huu Ho Zena Ho Phu Hoang Viet Hoang Stuart Hoffenberg Brian Hoffman Elyssa Hoffman Joni Hoffman Liza Hoffman Dori Green Hoites Leo Hoites Lacey Miriam Holdstad Laurie Holeman Ronald Holeman Hector Holguin Hector Holguin Michaela Holguin Rosa Holguin Kagen Holland Russell Holley Andrew Holliday Ella Holliday Harrison Holliday

Page 27: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

27

Kristie Holliday Mitchell Holloway Debbie Holmes Joseph M. Holmes Richard Holmstrom Beverly Holt Julie Holt Gabriela Holyfield Janet Holyfield Michaela Holyfield Paul Holyfield Paul Holyfield Thalia Holyfield Bora Hong Eun Ae Hong Jong Hyun Hong Jong Joo Hong Ok Boon Hong Soo Bok Hong Soon Ja Hong Sun Uk Hong Sung H. Hong Chloe Hooper Isaiah Hooper Kenneth Hooper Gary Hoover Patricia Hoover Bryan Hopwood Gregory Hopwood Matthew Hopwood Laura Horlick Robert Horlick Shirley Horlick Alex Horosny Yaniv Horovitz Mahnaz Horriyat Jacob Horshidi Casey Horvat Jarod Horvat Michelle Horvat William Horvat Emon Hoshyarsar Payman Hoshyarsar Arpene Hovsepian Lucy Hovsepian Rafi Hovsepian

Shant Hovsepian Dawnetta Howard Joseph Dwight Howell Juliana Hsien Reynold Hu Andre Huaman Gracie Huaman Marco Huaman Gary Huang Shiufon Huang Jessica Hubbard Ruth Hubbard Steven Hubbard Renee Hudacek Julie Hudson Kasey Hudson Robert Hudson Sheri Ann Hudson Judith Huegli Sonja Huegli Ulrich Huegli Christopher Hughes Karen Hughes Krista Hughlett Ben S. Huh Eun Ho Huh Anne Hui-Bon-Hoa David Huihui Kim Huihui Candelario Huizar Gary Huizar Cheri Humphrey Christian Hunter David Hunter Gregory Hunter Benjamin K. Hur Tina O. Hur Alex Hurmetian Maria Hurmetian Aftab Husain Carol Husain Lauren Husain Zainab Hussain Cindy Hutfless Carolyn Hwang

Christopher Hwang David Hwang Eunkyung Hwang Evelyn Hwang Gaeun Hwang Hae K. Hwang Helen Hwang Janet Hwang Jimmy Hwang Jonathan Hwang Kevin Hwang Mary Hwang Shiufon Hwang Sunny Hwang Yoo K. Hwang Young R. Hwang M. Deborrah Hyde Gail Hynick George Hynick Jean Hyun Mark Hyun Alfredo Ibanez Daysi M. Ibanez Leah Ibanez Nathan Ibanez Sabina Ibanez Aida Ibrahim Kiara Ibrahim Leilani Ibrahim Nader Ibrahim Ernesto Idos Mila Idos Sylvana Iezza Hisayuki Ikeda Kimiko Ikeda Chelsea Ilejay Marie Ilejay Inok Im Yon Ok Im Joyce Imada Richard Imada Aidan Incs Eric Incs Harry Incs Irina Incs Sean Incs

Page 28: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

28

Tanita Indelicato Anthony Indzhikushyan Diana Indzhikushyan Nicholas Indzhikushyan Vardan Indzhikushyan Vianna Indzhikushyan Socrates Inonog Agathi Ioannou Ioannis Ioannou Kyprianos Ioannou Maria Ioannou Ashkaun Ali Iranfar Shayan Ali Iranfar James L Irwin Daniel Isagholian Jessica Ishak Anoush Iskenderian Zora Iskenderian Lusine Islikaplan Michael Islikaplan Onnik Islikaplan Patricia Islikaplan Raffi Islikaplan Zaven Islikaplan Christine Iso Yasser Issa Yasser Issa Nino Issakhan Irene Ito Ryan Ito Daniel Ives Ethan Iyer Ramesh Iyer Blanca Izaguirre Jerry Izenberg Maxine Izenberg Eric Izmitlian Lusi Izmitlian Shideh Jabbary Beverly F. Jacko Charles A. Jacko Chaundren A. Jacko

Ava Jackson Borrah Jackson Bradley Jackson Cynthia Jackson Emily Jackson James Jackson Joseph Mateo Jackson Kevin Jackson Marcela Jackson Mya Jackson Rachel Jackson Terrence L. Jackson Mell Charles Jackson Joseph Jackson Sr. George Jacobellis Charlie Antoinette Jacquo Stevenson Meanie Jadaon Victor Jadaon Alishan Jadhavji Anwer Jadhavji Nargis Jadhavji Carrie Jain Sheikh Jain Gopi Jaisinghani Mohit Jaisinghani Parvin Jaisinghani Preeti Jaisingmani Hagay Jalon Brenda James Mikaela James Willie James Christopher Jamgotchian Gary Jamgotchian Lily Jamgotchian Michael Jamgotchian Raffi Jamgotchian Sarkis Jamgotchian Zevart Jamgotchian Nicole Jamison-Dinowitz Lee Anne Janek Ellen Jang Esther Jang James Jang

Steve Jang George Janson Ursula Jansz Douglas Jaqua Maria Jarata Pablo Jarata Jerissa Jaravata Victoria Ilanit Jarero Nancy Jarvis Shah Jasani Carmen Jaurequi Cole Jefferson Emma Jefferson Ethan Jefferson Kyle Jefferson Brian Jekal Kyung Jekal John Jenkinson Angel Jennings Glen Jensen Sheryl D. Jensen Hea In Jeon Jeff Jeon Logan Jeon Luke Jeon Maria Jeon Young Jeon James Jeppson Barbara Jergensen Arthur Jerian Linda Jester Ross Jester Hyun Ji Liangzhong Jiang Runji Jiang Gary Jibilian Anthony Jimenez Christina Jimenez Eduardo Jimenez Erika Jimenez Geoffrey Jimenez Guadalupe Jimenez Kevin Jimenez Noah Jimenez Vanessa Jimenez Veronica Jimenez

Page 29: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

29

David Jimenez Jr. David Jimenez Sr. Neri Jimenez-Peralta Juan Jimenez-Perez Wei Jing Bo-Soo Jo Kyungil Jo Soon Ja Jo Moon Cha Joe Yong Ho Joe Amaan Jogia-Sattar Anjali Jogia-Sattar Bharti Jogia-Sattar Kamila Jogia-Sattar Anne Johns Alisha Johnson Amber Johnson Carolyn Kim Johnson Courtney Johnson Earl D. Johnson Hazel Johnson Jameelah Johnson Joseph K. Johnson Katherine Johnson Kim M. Johnson Kristel Johnson LaVette Johnson Lawrence Johnson Lori Johnson Mariah Johnson Matt Johnson Michael Felbert Johnson Noah Johnson Patrick Johnson Robert Johnson Robert Johnson Ron Johnson Soo-Chul Johnson Treva Johnson Wanda Kaye Johnson William Johnson Andrew Johnston Edwin Johnston Kaitlin Johnston Shannon Johnston

Susan Johnston Cameron Johnstone Dana Johnstone Preston Johnstone David Jones Edward Jones Jenni Jones Kimberly Jones Malaina Jones Marcell Jones Mason Jones Shawn Jones Susan Jones Andrew Sangdon Joo Ashley Joo Christine Eun Joo Joo Irene Joo Lynn H Jordan Candelaria Jose James Jose Jason Jose Mathew Jose Shaini Jose Shiby Jose Maya Joshi Priya Joshi Rajeshree Joshi Sunil Joshi Jeong Ju Soo Jeong Ju Yoon Ho Ju Young Ji Ju Mohammed Jumah Carolyn Jun David Jun Ellen Jun Yong Suk Jun Young Jun Grace Eun Jung In Cha Jung Jang Han Jung Joanne Jung Joseph Jung Shine Jung Yon Seek Jung Kathy Jura-Anthony

Iren Jureczky Ivan Jureczky Jake Justin Jillian Michele Justin Sean Justin Alice Kaczor Benjamin Kaczor Berta Kaczor Marc Kaczor Morgan Kaczor Wagdy Kades Craig Kadonaga Jennie (Kageyama) Kadonaga Lindsey Kadonaga Troy Kadonaga Hovig Kajoukian Lily Kajoukian Maral Kajoukian Mina Kajoukian Assad Kakar Nasima Kakar Rahmat Kakar Sarra Kakar Willy Kakar Anthony Kalandjian Nora Kalandjian Tanya Kalandjian Parvaneh Namiri Kalantari Soheila Kalantari Madhav Kale Vidya Kale Layla Kamae Sona Kamae Aida Kamarian Antranik Kamarian Daniel Kamarian Emylia Kamaruzzaman Mike Kaminski Alan Kaminsky Esther Kaminsky Bouthaina Kamoun Alan Kanase Natalie Kanase

Page 30: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

30

Heidi Kandel Landon Kandel Liam Kandel Payton Kandel Robyn Kandel Asher Kang Ava Kang Chi Hyun Kang Cindy Kang Clara S. Kang Danny Kang David Kang Hee Seung Kang Hee Kwang Kang Hyewon Kang In Wook Kang In Sook Kang Jacob S. Kang Jae Bok Kang Je Chul Kang Jin Ryeong Kang Jina Kang Jingu Kang Katherine Kang Luke Kang Martin Kang Michael Kang Olivia J. Kang Richard Kang Robert Kang Sang Bok Kang Sonia Kang Soo Ja Kang Suk-Bong Kang Tiffany Kang Tyler Kang Yo Sook Kang Yong Kang Young Geun Kang Young Soon Kang Young Jae Kang Young Yi Kang Ester Kangabe Atikhun Kanjanakaset Mick Kanjanakaset Tanat Kanjanakaset

Thanita Kanjanakaset Azmina Kanji Anastasia Kanonchoff Saundra Kanonchoff Sangita Kanwar Sarah Kanyago Ankur Kapadia Alan Kaplan Jason Kaplan Anil Kapur Marie Kapur Akop Kaputyan Mari Kaputyan Agavni Karaca Kristine Karaca Matyos Karaca Aram Karadolian Careen Karagoz Daron Karagoz Houshik Karagoz Sevan Karagoz Margaret Karapetian Ani Karapetyan Gayane Karapetyan Narek Karapetyan Aram Kardolian Dianna Kardolian Gayane Kardolian Suzan Kardolian Katherine Kargodorian Narayana Kashyap Ivo Kastelan Kathy Kastelan Peter Kastelan Victoria Kastelan Shinichi Katayama Gulshan Kathuria Himashu Kathuria Sadhna Kathuria Igor Kats Maya Kats Anatoly Katsev Malvina Katsev Ava Katz Brandon Katz

Brian Katz Christine Katz Deborah Katz Harper Katz Max Katz Steven Kaufman Victoria Kaufman Charanjit Kaur Gurinder Kaur Harmeet Kaur Malkiat Kaur Paramjit Kaur Parminder Kaur Rupinder Kaur Saranjit Kaur Ukarjit Kaur Vidya Kaur Devender Kaushik Aleena Kayacan Gabriela Kayacan Jack Kayacan John Kayacan Gary Kayayan Manik Kayayan Stepan Kazanchian Alexander Kazanjian Manuel Kazanjian Maximus Kazanjian Anushik Kazaryan Lena Kebresian Hovsep Kebreslian Caroline Kechabashyan Daniel Kechabashyan Hovik Kechabashyan Kayla Kechabashyan Ivan Kedikian Julian Kedikian Nela Kedikian Rony Kedikian J. Edward Keif Jake Keif Nick Keif Haig Keledjian Asawari Kelkar Rajendra Kelkar

Page 31: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

31

Rama Kelkar Rucha Kelkar Andres Keller Eric Kelly Gwendolyn Kelly Michael Kelly Timothy Kelly Wendolyn Kelly Ani Kemkemian Allison Kemp Emily Kemp Ingrid Kenneally Delious Kennedy Ryan Kennedy Stella Kennedy Donald M. Kent Janice Kent Tom Kent Vicki Kent George Keoshkarian Kevork Keoshkarian Lizette Keoshkarian Mathew Keoshkarian Armand Keosian Chris Keosian Maral Keosian Melanie Keosian Sarin Keosian Tamar Keosian Alan Keossayan Anie Keossayan Christopher Keossayan Lena Keossayan Varoajan Keossayan John Keris Kyle Keris Roseann Keris Armen Kesabyan Diana Kesabyan Natalie Kesabyan Maeis Keshish Armen Keshishian Elizabeth Keshishian Houri Keshishian Levon Keshishian

Sarmen Keshishian Alfred Keshishyan Stella Keshishyan Debbi Kessler Michael Kessler Sean Kessler Kishin/Gita Keswani Mohandas Keswani Radha M. Keswani Talin Kevorkian Tina Kevorkian Jima Kezbar Jobran Gaby Kezbar Mouna Kezbar Sharbl Kezbar Caroline Khachatoorian-Sante Marine Khachatryan Artoosh Khachikian Youssef Khair Moinuddin Khaja Naheed Khaja James Khalaf Souheila Khalaf Abderrauuf Khalil Gamalat Khalil Syed Khalil Syed Asim Khalil Mahbooba Khaliqi Azhar Khan Naveed Khan Iman Khandan Aleeza Khanlian Gabriel Khanlian Jayden Khanlian Mason Khanlian Tatiana Khanlian Geeta Khanna Irina Khilkevich Simon Khilkevich Babak Khodabaneh Fereidoon Khodabaneh Soroor Khodabaneh Chloe Khodzhumyan Eric Khodzhumyan

Harout Khodzhumyan Peter Khodzhumyan Samvel Khodzhumyan Matthew Khouri Meriana Khouri Montaser Y. Khouri Daniel Khoury Ella Khoury Emma Khoury George Khoury Hysumi Khoury Isaiah Khoury Issa Khoury Laila Khoury Maggie Khoury Maria Khoury Marissa Khoury Naser Khoury Nasif Khoury Samer Khoury William Khoury Nalini Khurana Afshin Kianpour Nikka Kianpour Nooshin Kiasat Shirin Kiassat Jirair Kidanian John Kidwell Aaron Kim Abigail Kim Aeri Kim Alex Kim Alexander Sung-Jin Kim Allen Kim Amy Hye-Young Kim An Ok Kim Andrew Kim Angela Kim Angelina Kim Anika Kim Anna Kim Annie Do Ye Kim Anthony Kim Audrey Kim

Page 32: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

32

Augustine Kim Austin Kim Benjamin Kim Bo Kim Bok Ran Kim Bok Sam Kim Bonnie Kim Brian S. Kim Bryan Kim Bryson Kim Bum Jin Kim Byeong Kyu Kim Byung Kim Caitlyn Kim Caleb Kim Casey Kim Catherine Kim Chae Kim Chang Hyun Kim Chang Y. Kim Chin Ok Kim Chloe Kim Chloe Kim Chloe H. Kim Chol Kim Choon Kim Choon Shik Kim Choongnyun Paul Kim Chris Kim Christine Kyeongja Kim Christopher Kim Christopher Kim Chul Kim Cindy Kim Claire Kim Cooper Kim Dai Kim Daniel Kim Daniela Kim David Kim David Kim David Kim David Kim David S. Kim

Dennis Kim Deog Soo Kim Deuk Po Kim Diana Kim Dol Wol Kim Donald Kim Dong Yong Kim Dong Sook Kim Doyeon Kim Dylan Kim Eddie Kim Edward Kim Edward Kim Edward Kim Edward Duk Ki Kim Elisa Kim Ella Eunhee Kim Ella Kim Emily Kim Enoch Kim Erica Kyung Soon Kim Esther Kim Esther Kim Ethan Young Kim Eujin Kim Eun Hee Kim Eun S. Kim Euna Kim Eunice S. Kim Evelyn Kim Gigi Kim Giselle Kim Glen Kim Grace Kim Grace Kim Grace Y. Kim Guyong Kim Hae young Kim Haek Sook Kim Han Joon Kim Hannah S. Kim Hayes Kim Heeyae Kim Helen Kim Henry Chankuk Kim

Holly Kim Hong Ki Kim Hoonsung Kim Hudson Kim Hui Kyong Kim Hwa Young Kim Hye Ryun Kim Hye Yeong Kim Hyun Kyung Kim Im Nai Kim In Jung Kim In Sil Kim Inhan Kim Irene Kim Isaac H. Kim Jacob Kim Jae Kim Jaiden Kim Jaiyoung Kim Jake Kim James Kim James Kim James Brian Kim James Rakwoo Kim Jane Kim Jane Kyong Hwa Kim Janet KiChung Kim Jayden Kim Jeannie Kim Jee Eun Kim Jee Eun Kim Jeeeun Kim Jehyon Kim Jeong Ho Kim Jessica Kim Ji Yeon Kim Jill Kim Joanna Kim Joelle Kim John Lee Kim Jonathan Kim Joo Mee Kim Joon Auk Kim Joseph Kim Joshua Kim Joung Hwa Kim

Page 33: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

33

Joy Kim Judy Kim Judy Yongri Kim Julie Kim Julie Ju Kyung Kim Jung Hwa Kim Jung J. Kim Jung Ja Kim Jung Min Kim Jung S. Kim Jung Y. Kim Justin Kim Justin Kim Justin Jihoon Kim Kang Kyum Kim Kathryn Haeum Kim KeeHahk Kim Keun Ho Kim Kevin Kim Ki Sung Kim Kingston Kim Kum Yei Kim Kwang Tae Kim Kyle Kim Kyong S. Kim Kyu Sik Kim Kyung Hee Kim Kyung Mi Kim Kyung Za Kim Kyusun Kim Leah Kim Linda Kim Linda Kim Loren Kim Luke Kim Maria Jung Kim Matthew Kim Mee Kim Mi Young Kim Mi Seon Kim Michael Kim Michael Dae Hyun Kim Michelle Minyoung Kim Michelle Jae Kim

Michelle Kim Mimi Kim Min A. Kim Minseo Kim Myron Kim Myung Kim Myung Sup Kim Na Young Kim Nae Deok Kim Namheon Kim Naomi Kim Natalie Kim Nicole Kim Ok Soon Kim Olyvia E. Kim Patrick Kim Paul Kim Paul S. Kim Peter Kim Phillip Kim Rachel Kim Rebekah Kim Rene Kim Renee Kim Reuben Kim Richard Kim Robert Kim Robin Kim Ruth Kim Sahra K. Kim Samuel Kim Sander Kim Sang Ok Kim Sang Soo Kim Sang Suk Kim Sarah Kim Sean Jinwoo Kim Sean S. Kim Seoung Jaw Kim Seul Gee Kim Seung Joo Kim Shane Kim Sharon Kim Shin Ja Kim Shinok Kim Simon Kim

Sky Kim Sofia Kim Song Yi Kim Soomi Kim Soon Sup Kim Soung Ja Kim Stella J. Kim Steve Kim Steve Kim Steve Kim Su Kim Suk Ja Kim Sun Hee Kim Sung Kim Sung Duk Kim Sung Kyu Kim Sunjoo Kim Sunwoo Kim Susan Kim Susan Kim Suzy Kim Tae Sook Kim Tae Y. Kim Tea Yong Kim Theresa Kim Tiffany Kim Troy Kim Ung Kim Veronica Kim William Kim William Kim William Kim Won Kim Yei S. Kim Yeon Hee Kim Yong Kim Yong Koo Kim Yoon Ja Kim Yoonil Kim You Jin Kim Young Kim Young Kim Young In Kim Young Ok Kim Young Ok Kim Young Woun Kim

Page 34: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

34

Yuliya Kim Allen Kim Brian J. Kim Jessica Kim Seonhwa Kim Seunghee Kim Yon Il Kim Jackson Kimball Savanna Kimball Fredric B. Kimmel Helene R. Kimmel Adam King Coleen King Denise D. King Meta King Meta King Patrick King Randy King Eva Kingsbury Arlene Kinslow Jayson Kinslow David Kinzler Nancy Kinzler Linda Kirakosyan Christopher Kiraz Lawrence Irwin Kirk Vicki D. Kirk Edward Kirkorian Marie Kirschner Mark Kislig Niramol Kitsawadi Alec Martin Klebba Makenzie Rae Klebba Martin D. Klebba Michelle J. Klebba Abbey Klein Howard Klein Jack Klein Kenneth Klein Lawrence Klein Melanie Klein Phyllis Gayliano Klein Rita Klein Rosalind Klein Samantha Klein

Shaun Klein Andrew Kleinbrodt David Kleinbrodt Joan Kleinbrodt Mason Kleinbrodt Maureen Kleinbrodt Michael Kleinbrodt Jasan Klepp Brian D. Kleven Larry Kleven Seta Kleven Haik Klian Harutyun Klian Haykat Klian Lily Klian Vahan Klian Leonard Kligman Shirin Klorman Jeff Knell Marlene Knox Ara Ko Elizabeth Ko Esther Ko Hwa Sook Ko John Ko Jonathan Ko Jung Un Ko Kae Hong Ko Kevin Ko Linda Ko Soon Ja Ko Suk Young Ko Andre Kocar Gulbenk Kocar Kevin Kocar Sirenus Kocar Connie Koch John Koch Armen Kocharian Caleb Koener David Koener Samantha Koener Zachary Koener Matt Koenig Caleb Koerner Dave Koerner

Samantha Koerner Zachary Koerner Rita Kogan Catherine Koh Doo Sun Koh Jay Koh Ji Yeon Koh Julie Koh Jungran Koh Young Ae Koh Hamid Kohan Eryn Koike Evelyn Koike Ranida Koike Ubolsiri Koike Watthawoot Koike Will Koike Gaurav Kokkalera Pranav Kokkalera Prathibha Kokkalera Uthaiah Kokkalera Ella Kollman Jeffrey James Kollman Lila Kollman Tricia Marie Kollman Eryan Kolta Rania Kolta Hana Kong Lifei Kong Michelle Kong Thomas Kong Audrey Koo Kaitlyn Koo Steve Koo Danielle Koretz Justin Koretz Sofi Koretz Trevor Koretz Tyler Koretz Danielle Korio Elias Korio Gabriella Korio Gina Korio Jacques Korio Justin Korio

Page 35: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

35

Katherine Korio Robert Korio Samira Korio Robert Kornswiet Madeline Kosar Scott Kosar Dan Kost Dean Kost Mia Kost Nickie Kost George Kotobuki Shushi Kotobuki Tsuyoshi Kotobuki Alek Kotoyan Apik Kotoyan Iskui Kotoyan Raffi Kotoyan Ramis Kouhnavard Reza Kouhnavard Yasmin Kouhnavard Katina Koulakis Mihail Koulakis Gulbenk Kovar Aimee Kravette Arman Krboyan Roxanne Krboyan Lillian Kremar BJ Krikorian Christopher Krikorian Ovsana Krikorian Vijay Krishnan Arthur Krokus Anatoliy Krotov Eleanor Jane Krotov Marina Krotov Nick Krotov Victor Krotov Andrew Krowne Ashley Krowne Barry Krowne Bradyon Krowne Dustin Krowne Jennifer Krowne Juliet Krowne Katelyn Krowne Aaron Krumer

Edward Krumer Elona Krumer Arkady Kuchiersky Marianna Kuchiersky Nicholas M. Kuchiersky Snezhana Kuchiersky Marilyn Kuha Terri Kuhlmann Tessia Kuhlmann Daniel Kuk Elim S. Kuk Hae Kuk Mae Sook Kuk Sanjay Kulkarni Beverly Kulow Kevin Kulow Anaya Kunkel Aneesa Kunkel Donna Kunkel John J. Kunkel Samantha Kunkel Fred Kuramura Kristina Kurbanyan Carolyn Kureghian Nairi Kureghian Nenet Kureghian Nicholas Kureghian Varooj Kureghian Patrick Kurkdjian Grant Kurney Kornel Kurney Lauren Kurney Kristina Kurtinaityte Robin Kutchai Isabella Kuykendall Joshua Kuykendall Joshua-Damian Kuykendall Netty Kwenre Shammah Kwizera Shane Kwizera Susan Kwizera Triniky Kwizera Duck Hye Kwon Eunice Kwon

Gamsa Kwon Hae Sun Kwon Inyoung Cho Kwon Jennie Kwon Jinsoo Kwon Kwi Yon Kwon Kyongyong Kwon Rosa Kwon Tae S. Kwon Young Mook Kwon Young Sook Sylvia Kwon Yumi Kwon Anita Kyaramyan Roxanne Kyaramyan Joshua Kye Kevin Kye Michelle Kye Rachel Kye Emil Kyupelyan Sona Kyupelyan Tiffani L Moses Darryl Labate Tim Lachman Michael Laga Amy Lagoy- Pearson Jeffrey Lague Jonah Lague Malia Lague May Lague Faiyaz Lalani Fatehali Lalani Khairunissa Lalani Malek Lalani Arianna Laleh Reza Laleh Stephanie Laleh Talia Laleh Alexandria Lam Genevieve Lam Giselle Lam Isabella Lam Jenny Lam Jessica Lam Liuyang Lam Manfred Lam

Page 36: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

36

Peter Lam Senh Van Lam Maquita Lamb Elizabeth Lamboy-Wilson Angela Lamont Kerry Lampkin Phyllis Lance Berthie Landa David Landa Juan Carlos Landa Marina Landa Michelle Landa Mikhail Landa Roza Landa Judith Landon Heidi Lane Roy James Lane Russell Lane Ben-zion Lang Cynthia Lang Shoshana Lang Joan Langer Joseph Langer Ambrosio Lapid Bella Lapidus Rosa Lara Toymika Lara Jodi Larman Shawn Larman-DeFrisco Mario Larrabure Santana Larrabure Susan LaRue David Lasher Dawn Lasher First Name Middle Name Last Name Alec Laterovian Ara Laterovian Garo Laterovian Eleanor Lau Stephen Lau Blake Lauer Eden Lauer Heidi Lauer

Kara Lauer Scott Lauer Suzy Lauer Adrian Lautz Cynthia Lautz Esteban Lautz Hector Lautz Diego Laverde Harry Laverde Margarita Laverde Simon Laverde Benjamin Lawrence Harvey Lawson Belus Lazar Marjorie Lazaro Dmitriy Lazdan Yekaterina Lazdan Chi Le Khanh Le Lieu Le Kimberly Ann Lebid-Jurtschyk Nickolas Lebid-Jurtschyk Guillermo Lecuona Liam Lecuona Sophia Lecuona Tera Lecuona-Hollingsworth Christine Ledesma Brent Ledford Gina Ledterman Lisa Ledterman Aaron Lee Abigail Lee Alice Lee Amy Lee Amy Heeson Lee Anastacia Lee Annie Lee Anson Lee Anthony Lee Barbara Lee Bock Duck Lee Bok Hee Lee Bongchun Lee

Brenda Lee Brian Lee Brian H. Lee Byeong Yeon Lee Byoung J. Lee Calvin H. Lee Calvin J. Lee Catelyn Lee Catheryn Y. Lee Cecilia Lee Chan Sue Lee Chang Lee Chang M. Lee Charlotte Lee Cheol J. Lee Christina Y. Lee Christine Lee Chun Suk Lee Chung C. Lee Chung K. Lee Connie Lee Conrad Lee Cynthia Lee Dae Ho Lee Dae Sup Lee Daehwan Lee Daniel Lee Daniel S. Lee David Lee David H. Lee Dong Lee Dong Yoon Lee Ee Chang Lee Elaine Lee Elliot Joowon Lee Erica Lee Eui Sun Lee Eun Ho Lee Eunice Lee Eunjeong Lee Frederick Lee George Lee Gun S. Lee Hannah Lee Harold Lee Heidi Lee

Page 37: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

37

Helen Lee Ho Jae Lee Hojung Lee Hong Joo Lee Howard Lee Howard Lee Howard Ho Lee Hwajin Lee Hyang S Lee Hyun Ju Seo Lee Hyun Woo Lee Hyung Suk Lee Irene Lee Jae K. Lee James Lee James Y. Lee Jamie Lee Jamie J. Lee Janet Lee Janice Lee Jasmine Lee Jason Lee Jason J. Lee Jee Sue Lee Jeena Lee Jeong C. Lee Jeong H. Lee Jeong Ho Lee Jesse Lee Jihye Lee Jimmy Lee JiWoo Lee Joanne Lee Joel Lee John Lee Joo Young Lee Joseph Lee Joshua Lee Joyce Lee Jung In Lee Kai Lee Karen Lee Kassandra Lee Kayden Lee Kristianne Lee Kristin Lee

Kristin Lee Kum Ok Lee Kun C. Lee Kwan Y Lee Kwan Young Lee Kye Lee Kyle Lee Kyong Ran Lee Kyu Ho Lee Kyung San Lee Kyung Soo Lee Lewis Taeeun Lee Mariann Mikyung Lee Mi Ra Lee Mi Ryung Lee Min Jae Lee Min Ji Lee Monica Ann Lee Moon Soon Lee My Wong Lee Myoung Youn Lee Nancy Lee Nate Lee Nyeng Hoon Lee Penelope Lee Ronald Lee Sandy Lee Sang Yup Lee Sarah Lee Seeun Lee Seung Ah Lee Seung Keun Lee Seung Seok Lee Soo Kyung Lee Soo Yeon Lee Sook N. Lee Soon Choong Lee Spencer Lee Stephanie Lee Stephanie H. Lee Stephen Lee Steven Lee Suk Hyun Lee Sung Lee Sung U. Lee

Sung H. Lee Sungjin Lee Susan Lee Tae Moo Lee Taylor Lee Terrence Lee Theresa Lee Tony Lee Une K. Lee Woo Hyun Lee Yi Soon Lee Yong Joo Lee Young Hee Lee Young A Lee Young Mi Lee Youngmee Lee Yungki Lee Adam Lee Jeanie Lee Jack Lees Marivie Leggett Cathy Legrand Christie Lyn Lugo Leigh Edward Arthur Leigh Sierra Lynessa Leigh Nicole Aimee Leluron Santoso Lembono Alexander De Leon Carole Leon Christopher De Leon Jay Leon Jose De Leon Laura Leon Nicholas De Leon Jose Leones Katrina Leskovar Mia Leskovar Nenad Leskovar Ruzica Leskovar Ted Lessler Franklin Lett Sagi Lev-Ari Audrey Levendosky Jennifer Levendosky Phyllis Levin

Page 38: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

38

Alex Levit Frances Levy Lawrence Levy Deanne Lewis Greg Lewis Gregory Lewis Judith Lewis Patrick Lewis Roberta Lewis Rosie Lewis Sara Lewis Wayne Lewis Alexandra Lewis-Eichhorst Ed Leyson Dan Li Ling Li Shuwen Li Crystle Libre Crystle Libre Carmela Elaine Licas Emma Licas Eric Licas Eric Anthony Licas Theodore Emil Licas Deborah Lieber Jason Lieber Mark Lieber Randi Lieber Stanley Lieber Craig Lietzke Judy Lietzke Shaun Lile Angela M. Lim Dae Hwan Lim Emeline Lim Esther Lim Hee C. Lim James Lim Soo Duk Lim Su Hee Lim Teresa Lim Won Hee Lim Alice Lim Cindy Lin Sally Lin

Linda Lin Chu Alma Lingad Lisa Lippe Dennis Liquigan Maybelle Liquigan Sonia Liquigan Danny S. Litt Karen Litt Nancy Litt Nicole Litt Chenda Hak Little Danica Little Dominic Little Iris Little-Thomas Jack Littman Charles Liu Ihsiu Liu Jun Ying Liu Prince Liu Weili Liu Alex Liva Hakmana Liyange Monica Llerena Rafael Llerena Wendy Lock Nicolette Locklear Alise Lodge Lynne Lodwick Abby Loeb Joshua Loeb Sarina Loeb Luis Loera Emma Loera-Yugay Anne Loewenthal Christopher Loewenthal Max Loewenthal Steven Loewenthal George Lohman Georgia Lohman Kevin Lohman Maria Lohman Nikol Lohman Penelope Lohman Traci Lombardo Jose Lona

Mateo Lona Maya Lona Milan Lona Munesha Lona Anjali Londhe, Pharm.D., Rph Isabella Londono Jon Londono Laurie Londono Liao Xin Lonog Raymond Look Camia Marielle Lopes Cassio Lopes Grantt Lopes Laudison Lopes Raffik Lopes April Lopes-Nalls Adolfo Lopez Adriana Lopez Aldo Lopez Alice Lopez Angela Lopez Anthony Lopez Arturo Lopez Breanna Lopez Daryl Hannah Lopez Elena Lopez Emily Lopez Estella Lopez Gilberto Lopez Gregorio Lopez Hayron Lopez Isidro Lopez Jason Lopez Juan C. Lopez Kayla Lopez Madilyn Lopez Manuel Lopez Mia Lopez Mia R. Lopez Nelson Lopez Noah C. Lopez Olivia G. Lopez Sue Lopez Violet Lopez Ana Lopez-Goode

Page 39: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

39

Nicole Lopez-Kimball Jeff Lorenz Linda Lorenz Turan Lorestani John Lorscheider Lisa Lorscheider Sophia Lorscheider Regina Theard Lott Robert Lott Helen Louie Kaylee Louie Sarah Louie Walter Louie Donna Loutsios Adrian Lovesmith Angela Lovesmith Michael Lovesmith Nicholas Lovesmith Michael Low Joel Lowell Terri (Jonisch) Lowell William Lowery Michael Lowry Mikelle Lowry Nerisa Lowry Chengzhong Lu Sherry Lu Zhenhua Lu Andrea Luboff Jordan Luboff Kevin Luboff Denise Luca Ian Luca Jesse Luca Ava Lucid Claudia Lucid Donald Lucid Antonio Luisoni Kaki Luk Sandy Luk Fabiola Lule Mary Lulejian Alex Luminato Andrew Luminato Brandon Luminato

Giulianna Luminato Lorena Luminato Malgorzata Luniak Oliver Benjamin Luniak-Silberberg Alessandra Lunsford Alyssa Lunsford Clairrissa Lunsford Robert Lunsford Sebastian Lunsford Spencer Lunsford Robert Lunsford Jr. Carolyn Lusen Beverly Lux-Kaplan Alexandre Lvov Nicole Alexandra Lvov Valerie Lvov Brandon Ly Brian Ly David Ly Hon Ly Jimmy Ly Judy Ly Lily Ly Nancy Ly Thu Hong Ly Gwendolyn Lyew Peter Lyew Alaysia E. Lyons Jackson R. Lyons Michael Lyons Chong Bin Ma Hong Il Ma Liang Ma Yong Ri Ma Christian Maadanian Daniel Maadanian Gabriella Maadanian Susan Maadanian Meghan Mabes Matthew Macgugan Amanda Machado Orlando Machado Megan Mack Omari Mack

Omari Mack Richard Macklin Marie Maday George Madenian Patrice Madrigal Oh Maeng Frank Magallanes John Magallanes Michael Magallanes Rosemary Magallanes Elen Magat Talia Magdaleno Loretta Magiar Loretta Magiar Lily Maglaris Carlos Magno Leonora Grace Magno Edward F. Magtoto Renuka Mahaindra Anmol Mahe Vikaamjit Mahe Ashok Mahtani Deepak Mahtani Pravin Mahtani Ravine Mahtani Riana Mahtani Asaad Majid Alexis Maldonado Cecilia Maldonado Dylan Maldonado Erika Maldonado Marco Maldonado Natasha Maldonado Oscar Maldonado Vichitra Angel Maldonado Renee Malek Eugene Malinov Fabian Malinovitz Orit Malkis Gilbert Mallari Chris Malloy Linda Malnassy Hani Mammo Mudafar Mammo

Page 40: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

40

Ricardina Manangon Daniel Manankichian Krikor Manankichian Kristina Manankichian Mariam Manankichian Jackelin Mancini Stephen Mancini Liana Maneyan Farzaneh Manizani Kadry Mankarious Mariam Mankarious Peter Mankarious Shokira Mankarious Ava Manley Geoff Manley Jacob Manley Leann Manley Leonard Mann Nirmal Mann Alexa Mannak Amani Mannak Anju Mannak Charles Mannak Kailee Mannak Susan Manning Anoush Manoukian Daniel Manoukian Houri Manoukian Sofia Manoukian Lefky Mansi Marian Mansi Morris Mansi Christine Mansoor Anahit Mansoorian Zabi Mansoory Amal Mansour Edward Mansour Ararat Manukyan Michael Manukyan David Manvelian Karen Manvelian Karen Manvelian Mariam Manvelian Mkrtich Manvelian

Mkrtich & Ripsik Manvelian Mripsime Manvelian Ripsik Manvelian Tigran Manvelian Kamran Mapar Kayla Mapar Sara Mapar Shalini Marathe Albert Marcarian Lili Marcarian Rachel Marcelo Samuel Marcelo Earl Marchesi Hegda Mardirosian Lala Mardirosian Rafi Mardirosian Candido Mares Diedre Mares Candido Marez Deidre Marez Simon Margolis Wendy Margolis Alfred Margousian Nadine Margousian Nella Margousian Violette Margousian Grace Marhaba Mohamed Marhaba Aida Marin Elizabeth Mariscal Maggie Mariscal Dean Markado Garrett Markado Jamie Markado Morgan Markado Teresa Markado Serjan Markari Davigh Markarian Herach Harry Markarian Nancy Markarian Areg Markosian Ivan & Goranka Markotic Raffi Maronian

Mareta Maronyan Anthony Marotta Jennifer Marotta Amanda Marquez Cesar Marquez Genessa Marquez Geneva Marquez Javier Marquez Lupe Marquez Matthew Marquez Ofelia Marquez Roberto Flores Marquez Stephanie Marquez Dana Marriott Dana Marriott Harrison Marriott Jonathan Marshall Crystal Ann Martin Fred Martin Janet Marie Martin Merlie Martin Seth Martin Tiffani Martin Cynthia Martinez Eduardo Martinez Manuel Nicholas Martinez Merline Martinez Rosaura Martinez Anait Martirosian David Martirosyan Suren Martirosyan Kenneth Maryan Osama Masada Osamu Masada Rentaro Masada Shaun Masada Sumiko Masada Michele Mascolo Dennis Mason Faramarz Massachi Mojgan Massachi Lori Masser Elaine Massion Gary Massion

Page 41: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

41

Elie Massoud Pauline Massoud Racquel Massoud Al Masters Paula Masters Kathleen Mastopietro Omar Mata Rebecca Mata Benjamin Mata Jr. Benjamin Mata Sr. Breonna Mathis Gary R Mathis Gary Q. Mathis Natalia Mathis Lata Mathrani Madan Mathrani Rasma Mathrani Aditya Mathur Sanaya Mathur Merle Matias Tommy Matias Mary Madeline Matias-Miller Martin Matin Marylin Matin Jonathan Matni Joseph Matni Shatha Matni Shigemi E. Matsumoto-Stark Karen Maturo Bueno Matusalem Maricel Matusalem Mary Jane Matusalem Armani Mauldin Regan Mauldin Crisstopher Mavian Peggy Maxwell Bryan M. May Catherine May Darren May Ignazio May Lorena May Pablo May Rosa May Vittorio May

Wanda Mayfield Andre Mayorga Nicholas Mayorga Robert Mayorga Robert Anthony Mayorga Susan Mayorga Manizheha Mazaheri Mary Mazamanyan Joan Mazie Evelyn Mazor James McCarron Therese McCarron Charlotte McClain Brendan McClure Brian McClure Heather McClure Nathan McClure Scott McClure Yolanda McCollister Laura Mcdaniel Anaya Mcdavid Camilla Mcdavid Deju Mcdavid Demi Mcdavid Dieudonne Mcdavid Jamilah Mcdavid Zac McDiarmid Robert Sekine McDonald Lin Mcdonough Sherry McDowell Terry McElroy Sandra McGill Scott McGill Ciara Mcgovern Claire Mcgovern Kathleen Mcgovern Keelia Mcgovern Phillp Mcgovern Kathleen McGowan Jennifer Mchugh Jani Mckee Marilyn McKeever Sarah McKinnie Elena McMahon

Grace McMahon Joseph McMahon Michael Mcquay Nicole McWilliams Alice Medellin Dan Medina Jacquelyn Medina Reynaldo Medina Adolfo Medrano Charles Meeler Crystal Meeler Rodney Meeler Eric Megs Joseph Meguerian Kile Meguerian Shant Meguerian Tamar Meguerian Alireza Mehrnia Gregorio Lopez Mejia Heidi Mejia Boghos Mekhdjian Harout Mekhtarian Isabel Mekhtarian John Mekhtarian Nancy Mekhtarian Ray Mekhtarian Silva Mekhtarian Siran Mekhtarian Meiling Melancon Alec Melconian Arsen Melconian Nina Melconian Shakeh Melconian Mark Meldeau Iris Melendez Isiah Melendez Johnny Melendez Michael Melendez Dona Melikian Boris Melnikov Spencer Melville Monesh Melwani Sherry Melwani Amir Memarian Hassan Memarian Rezban Memarian

Page 42: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

42

Shereen Memarian Wejdan Memarian Anthony Mena Claudia Mena David Mena Nicholas Mena Sophie Mena Irene Mena-Acevedo Daniel Mendez Sarah Elizabeth Mendez Feliza Mendoza Gary Mendoza Henry Mendoza John Mendoza Jonas Mendoza Mana Leilani Mendoza Maria G. Mendoza Rosemary Mendoza Patricia Mendoza Gladys Menendez Jun Meng Mark Menzies Leila Merchant Sam Merchant Joseph Merguerian Kile Merguerian Shant Merguerian Tamar Merguerian Tennessee Meris Angela Merrill Donovan Merrill Josh Merrill Kyra Merrill Loretta Merrill Milani Merrill John Mertell Vatche Meserlian Akop Mesropian Alexander Mesropian Ani Mesropian Arshak Mesropian Gor Mesropian Masis Mesropian Oganes Mesropian

Benjamin Messinger Daniel Messinger Darla Messinger Hannah Messinger Robert Messinger Luis Mestre Luther Metias Joseph Meugniot Ester Mgshyan Oganes Mgshyan Alfred Michaels Judith Michaels Brooks Michaels, M.D. Dianne Michaels, M.D. Donald Mick Ashley Mikell-Norman Mary Mikhail Chloe Milan David Milan Dominique Milan Lauren Milan Jennifer Milbauer Nicholas Milbauer Ron Milbauer Nancy Milkovich Monica Millan Bruce Millar Sheila Ray Millar Amanda Miller Aridis Marie Miller J'isaiah Miller Joseph Kim Miller Judith Miller Junalyn Miller Kyle Miller Lily Miller Myung Sook Miller Sora Park Miller Steven Mark Miller Thomas Owen Miller Valor Miller Vyctorius Miller Vyshonn Miller

VyShonn Miller David Mills Lisa Mills Ambrey Milmeister Cara Milmeister Jacob Milmeister Justin Milmeister Morris Milmeister David Aaron Milner Maureen Heather Milner Byung Do Min Hyun Sook Min James G. Min Ji Hyun Min Joo Young Min Joyce G. Min Sang Ki Min Seung Hyun Min Young Ja Min Mike G. Min Sandra J Minasian Aaliyah Minassian Ary Minassian Mary Minassian Barbra Elyse Miner Bruce Miner Craig Minor Jeremy Minsky Robert Minter Nina Miretsky Pamela Miretsky Kiana Mirkhani Pargol Mirkhani Shailin Mirpuri Shashi Mirpuri Shelja Mirpuri Sohan Mirpuri Sayeh Mirshojae Adam Mirza Lubna Mirza Mashal Mirza Mohammad Mirza Souzan Mirza Zainab Mirza Arlen Mirzakhanian

Page 43: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

43

Khloe Misiran Makrui Misiran Vahe Misirian Charles Mitchell Barbara Mitnick Mariko Mizuno Yoshio Mizuno David Mkhitarian Melania Mkhitarian Aleftina Mkhoyan Jose Moctezuma Erica Modlin Alina Moeen Ayesha Moeen Chetan Mohin Dalia Mohsen Elissar Mohsen Mikal Mohsen Mohamed Mohsen Zane Mohsen Bonnie Molavi Matthew Molavi Mohamad Molavi Inessa Moldaver Engelbert Molina Laila Marie Montafej Anna Montano Arianna Montealegre Juanita Montealegre Mateo Montealegre Natalia Montealegre Santiago Montealegre Valeria Montealegre Jerry Montenegro Jessica Montenegro Matthew Gehrig Montenegro Rebecca Grace Montenegro Arlishana Montgomery Elizabeth Montgomery Maryam Montgomery Bret Moody Dana Moody

Jasmine Moody Michael Moody Roger Moody Edward Moon Heather Moon Ian Moon Jin W. Moon Martin Moon Noah Moon Summer Moon Young Moon Audrey Moore Dramon Moore Kimberlee A. Moore Rashaan Moore Vincent Moore Tina Moore-Yamron Brenda Mora Elizabeth Morales George Morales Hector Morales Jennifer Morales Roberto Morales Sheryl Morales Joyce Mordoh Michael Moreno Mark Morgan Caron Moritz Rachel Mor-Josef Jennifer Morley Jennifer Morley Aisha Morris Alleyah Morris Miles Morris Kristie Morrison Robert Morrison Carmen Morse Kelly Morse Edessa Moshabad Emil Moshabad Poulin Moshabad Sharona Moshabad Bruce Moskowitz Nadine Moskowitz Sheila Moskowitz Steve Moskowitz

Mary Mostman Paul Mostman Hossein Motamedi Mahsha Motamedi Maybonou Motamedi Rani Mouchamel Arpi Mouchmouchian Hagop Mouchmouchian Karin Mouchmouchian Koko Mouchmouchian Mardig Mouchmouchian William Moussa Haleh Moustafa Florence Movsessian Varduhi Movsisyan Leila Mozaffari Paria Mozaffari Aquilah Mubdi Muqtadir Mubdi Charles Muldrow Grant Muldrow Reggie Muldrow Tracy Chow Muldrow Amarita Multani Arjun Multani Surjit Multani Cynthia Munoz Jamie Munoz Rebecca Munoz Tigranui Muradyan Charles Muranaka Evan Muranaka Karen Muranaka Ryan Muranaka Dina Murietta-Yeskel Louis J. Murillo Marlene Murphy Josephine Musisi Michelle Myers Christan Na Claire Na Hana Na

Page 44: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

44

Hong Na Hyun Sook Na Terence Na Diane Naaman Reem Naaman Robert Naaman Lauren Nabua Iva Mae Nadeau Robert Naftel Tania Naftel Siamak Nahidi Francine Nahmias Olivier Nahmias Alan Naiman Sandra Naiman Roy Nakabara Deegan Nakama Oregon Nakama Rad Nakama Rawson Nakama Tammy Nakama Morris Nakamura Susan Nakamura Marjorie Nakato Paul Nakayama Tomoe Nakayama Wendy Nakayama Mercy Hilary Nalvarte Chris Nam David Nam Hyun Jung Nam Hyung Sook Nam Jenny Nam Joseph Nam Kelly Nam Ryunhyun Nam Steve Nam Sunyoung Nam Suzy Nam Taehoon Nam Ameen Nasim Karim Nasim Mohammad Nasim Kameron Nason Anatole Nassau

Luella Nassau Diana Lee Nasser Diana Nasser Jeffrey Nasser Riad Nasser Abbas Nasseri Maryam (Hajian) Nasseri Peymon Nasseri Cattleya Natesiri Mayuree Natesiri Panya Natesiri Katrina Natura Alexandra Navarro Claudis Navarro Monique Navarro Pilar Navarro Mayra Navarro-Casillas Rosa Navasardyan Ali Navid Hamid Navid Hanna Navid Sam Navid Sima Navid Rudolf Nayshuler Anthony Nazaretian Arto Nazaretian Gregory Nazaretian Nellie Nazaretian Hike Nazarian Angelica Neece Gordon Neece Benny Neiyer Rose Pearl Neiyer Albert Nelson Albert Nelson Argule Nelson Argyle Nelson Isabella Nelson Kamrine Nelson Mamie Nelson Matthew Nelson Pamela Nelson Rhett Nelson Steven Nelson

Teagan G. Nelson Turner J. Nelson Mark Nemcoff Marnie Nemcoff Sean Nemcoff Nisha Nene Prache Nene Sanjeev Nene David Neporent Alexandra Nesbitt Christopher Nesbitt Courtney Nesbitt Guy R. Nesbitt Lynn Nesbitt Diana Neskovska Salomon Neuah Barry Neumann Bruce Newman Jill Newman Ann Neyer Neal Neyer Michael Ng Pauline Ng Van Nguyen Dimitrios Nichols Mary Nichols Gareth Nicholson Nancy Nicoloro-Tanner Benjamin Niebla Edgar Niebla Gabriella Niebla Nara Niebla Loretta Niemeyer Louis Niemeyer Dustin Niizawa Guy Niizawa Jayson Niizawa Sean Niizawa Tracy Niizawa Jim Nikolopoulos Kenyatta Niles Alexander Nimier Jerry Nishimura Patricia Nishimura Sara Nizami

Page 45: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

45

Jacob Nodd Jeffrey Nodd Kathryn Nodd Oliver Nodd Braydon C. Noone Jonathan K. Noone Maria P. Noone Tim Noone Ali Noor Lailuma Noor Somaya Noor Yahya Noor Maneeja Noory Roderick Norman Adriana Norris David Norris Diana Norris Hely Norris Jonathan Norris Noor Norris Renee Norris Mary Jane Northrup Barbara Norton Peter Norton Chloe Nouri Kamyer Nouri Leila Nouri Melody Nouri Shahrzad Nouri Raymond Novick Aileen Nowatzki James Nowatzki Jonathan Nowatzki Beatriz E. Nunez Ethan D. Nunez Karla Nunez Lani B. Nunez Rene D. Nunez Mishell Nycum Elizabeth Oakley Candice Oates Ledenilla Obnilla-Hernandez Rebecca O'Brien Girly Ocampo Carlos Ochoa

Philip Ochoa Mildred Ochou Sambaiah Odde Shriyan Odde Srinivas Odde Suguna Odde Ifeanyl Odebunmi Olumide Odebunmi Olumide Chidi Odebunmi Oluwakemi Odebunmi Liana Oganesyan Nazik Oganesyan Onik Oganesyan Sonia Oganesyan Tigran Oganesyan Alisa Oganyan Ani Oganyan Razmik Oganyan Tatev Oganyan Andrea Oh Arthur Oh Chang Hyun Oh Changbae Oh Chi Hyun Oh Chris S. Oh Cindy Oh Deborah Oh Eric Oh Hyong Hwan Oh Hyun Soo Oh Hyunjoo Oh In Young Oh Ja Oh Jayoung Oh Jeong Guk Oh Joseph Oh Keum Suk Oh Rachel Oh Sam Oh Seung Mi Oh Soon Choong Oh Sun Hwa Oh Taesung Oh Yena Oh

Yena Oh Yeong Cheol Oh Youn Suk Oh Young C. Oh Young Eun Oh Young Eun Oh Yun Jeong Sim Oh Yuna Oh Nina Ohan Alan O'Hara Benjamin Oka Lingga Oka Rose Okjian Sarkis Okjian Sarkis Okjian Gerald Okonowsky Mildred Okonowsky Oray Oktay Kairi Okuda Maria Lovewell Okuda Mark Okuda Shaun Okuda Hugo Olano Patricia Olano Cristianna Olatunji Dennis O'Leary Jan O'Leary Craig Olejnik Madonna Olila Regina Olivas Andrew Oliver Brian Onyshko Stephen Oonk Gilbert Oracion Ofelia Oracion Tiffany Ann Rose O'Reagan David Orleans Eva Orleans Paul Orleans Samuel Orleans Blanca Orozco Crystal Orozco Guadalupe Orozco Jose Luis Orozco

Page 46: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

46

Ashley Orr Donna Orr Jordan Orr Michael Orr Tyler Orr Daniel Ortega Emilio Ortega Esteban Ortega Joaquin Ortega Jose L. Ortega Leticia Ortega Jose Orterga Alexandra Maria Ortiz Amelie Ortiz Erica Ortiz Jose Manuel Ortiz Marilyn Osborn David Osnas Iosif Osnas Beverly Lorraine Ourada Gohar Ovakimyan Fleora Ovdjinejad Sharon Ownchyld Adrian Padilla Adrian Padilla Andrew Padilla Holly Padilla Liliana Padilla Emelysse Paez Jason Paez Jonathan Paez Vivino Paez Angel Pagarigan Teri Pagarigan Gracie Page Harriett Page Danica Painton Darice Painton Joey Painton Joslyn Painton Andy Pak Cindy Pak Everly Pak Laura Pak

Michael Pak Olivia Pak Farzaneh Pakfar Jason Pakfar Matthew Pakfar Mohammed Pakfar Tina Pakfar Matthew Pakucko Kharen Palacio Jorge Palacios Jerry Palermo Leslie Palermo Rohin Pallapothu Nicholas Palleschi Albert Palma Elias Palma Isabella Palma Rosa Palma Edgar Phillip Palmer Joe Pan Alan Panameno Bryan Panameno Luis Panameno Angelica Panosian Diana Panosian Michael Panosian Stephen Panosian Victor Panosian Paul Pantazis Pauline Pantazis Tiffany Paoli Arutyun Papazyan Samuel Papazyan Jonathan Batugo Paras Bhavini Parbhu Hina Parbhu Manhar Parbhu Natasha Parbhu Donald Pardi Benjamin L Paredes Eli M Paredes Emma V Paredes Josue S. Paredes Nidya P Paredes Gable Parigian

Gregory Michael Parigian Jenny Parigian Sandra Paris Scott Paris Addison Park Ae Soon Park Aerin Park Ban Park Bruce Park Caleb Park Chan Ho Park Charlie Park Chun R. Park Clara Park Daniel Park David Park Dennis Park Ellison Park Elmar Park Gavin Park Grace Park Hae Kyung (Susan) Park Hae Sung Park Hannah Park Hansin Park Hoonsung Park Hudson Park Inja Park Irene Park Jim Kouwong Park Joanna Park Jonathan Park Jonathan Park Joon H. Park Joseph Keehong Park Joshua Park Joyce Park Jung Ho Park Kaiden Park Kristine Park Kyo Young Park Kyung Ok Park Log Su Park

Page 47: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

47

Michelle Juyoung Park Michong Park Min Gyu Park Mindy Park Moonok Park Nan Sook Park Peter Park Peter Park Phillip Park Rachel Jueun Park Rebecca Park Roy (Doh Yun) Park Sang C. Park Seung Joon Park Sharon Park So Yeon Park Sook Wan Park Soon Nam Park Sung Hwa Park Towcer Park Vincent Park William Park Yoon Young Park Young Il Park Yun Hwa Park Kathy Parks William Parks Adam Parra Alyssa Parra Andre Parra Arnold Parra Daniella Parra Lisbeth Parrales Ireland Parry Isaac Parry Ryan Parry Lydia Ruth Parsons Alfred Pascual Courtney Pascual Edgardo R Pascual Elizabeth Pascual Ethan Pascual Maria Pascual Norma Pascual Salomon Passariello

Vahe Patatanyan Ashok Patel Ashwin Patel Mayuri Patel Nila Patel Rahim Patel Renisha Patel Samaya Patel Ernesto Patino Holly Patrick Joseph Patrick Patrea Patrick William Patrick Elisa Patta Tony Patta Stacey Patterson Karen Patton Megan Patton Lerma Pattugalan Avery Paul Joshua Paul Kimberly Paul Melanie Pauley Janusz Pawlikoswski Anna Pawlikowski Allen Arev Paylan Shane Sasoun Paylan Vilma Paylan Michelle Paz Ruby Paz Evelyn Paz-Durocher Marilea Peacock Christopher Pearson Sherry Pedigo Ajith Peiris Niranjala Peiris Niranjala Peiris Shehan Peiris Natallia Peksimova Daniel Pelaez David J Pelaez David Pelaez Dylan Pelaez Maryann Pelensky Stephen Pelensky Guanghui Peng

Maria Pennington Robert Pennington Robyn Pennington Carmen Peplow Erwin Perales Amarjit Perera Nalendra Perera Alejandro Perez Antonia Perez Concepcion Perez Ernel Perez Flordeliza Perez Hope Perez Manuel Perez Alvin Perkins Pilar Perkins Susan Perkins Beberlina D. Perrine Jasmin Perrine Jessica Perrine Richard Perrine Aaron Perry Danny Perry Topanga Perry Young Hi Perry Amelia Peters Teresa Petersen Kelsey Peterson Alen Petrossian Alexandra Petrossian Dina Petrossian Emily Petrosyan Kristine Petrosyan Petros Petrosyan Zoya Petrosyan Brody Pfeifer Kyle Pfeifer Lindsay Pfeifer Lucas Pfeifer Shayne Pfeifer Andrea Pham Ashley Pham Sydney Pham Win Pham Xuam Pham AshleyV. V. Phan

Page 48: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

48

Ashton Phan Bang Phan Jillian Phan Alise Phelan Duncan Phelan Fu Anh Phi Hung Phi Son Phi Aleyamma Philip Amanda Phillips Daniel Phillips Eleanor Phillips Luka Phillips Mara Phillips Victoria Phillips William Phillips Edward Pikor Susan Pikor Janice Rae Pilcher Hovsep Pilikian Mariam Pilikian Lesley Pincus Lea Pineda Joseph Pinto Mary Pinto Breanna Pinuelas Freddie Pinuelas Rosa Pinuelas Hyunsoon Pinyawat Elias Pirsay Hailey Pirsay Roya Pirsay Hermine Pirumyan Emilia Piskoulian Garo Gary Piskoulian Hovik Piskoulian Kim Pithey Michael Pithey Olivia Plouffe Trevor Plouffe Terry & Monica Poe Armine Pogossian Karmen Pogossian Agavni Pogosyan Deirdre Poillon Russell Poillon

Ryan Poillon Mike Pokras Tatiana Pokras Shant Poladian Silva Poladian Susie Poladian Vartan Poladian Leodagario Polintan Leony Polintan Andrew Polishchuk Dmitriy Polishchuk Yelena Polishchuk Phyllis Pollack Betty Pollakoff Todd Pollakoff Benjamin Pollock Helga Pollock Alexander Polonsky Alexey Polonsky Satit Pongsai Geraldine Pontillano Jalen Pontillano Janelle Pontillano Walter Pontillano Corneliu Gabriel Popa Hassan Pope Brianne Porcaro Justin Porras Lawrence Porton Courtney Portugal Evan Portugal Kimberly Portugal Olivia Portugal Todd Portugal Larisa Post Ani Postachian Karapet Postachian Levon Postachian Takhui Postachian Judith Powell Shaianne Powell Shane Powell Shawn Powell Xavier Powell Brad Pozdol Miriam Pozdol

Paul Pozdol Eduardo Prado Lola Prado Luz Prado Marley Prado Nadya Prado Natalie Prado Nicole Prado Osvaldo Prado Paul Prendez Aaron Preston Polly Preston Dennis Prevatt Joann Prevatt Dvincinai Price Latorsia Price Peggy Price Stephen Price Piero Procida Stacy Procida Nicole Procopio-Ortado Arek Proodian Berj Proodian Sona Proodian Andre Prosperi Greyson Prosperi Haven Prosperi Carol Prudian Miran Prudian Federico Pulido Tiffany Pulvino Thomas H Putnam Wanda Putnam Xiaoqing Qi Gregory Quals Gary Quesada Eric Alexander Quiarte Steven Y Quiarte Raquel Quieta-Gundry Iker Quilez April Quintal Judith Quirarte Oscar Quirarte

Page 49: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

49

Andrew Rabadi Christopher Rabadi Danielle Rabadi Masoud Rabadi Nahed Rabadi Nazil Rabadi Peter Rabadi Samer Rabadi Selvia Rabadi Sawsan Rafeh Ainsley Rafter Finlan Rafter Sanam Rahimizadeh Reshad Rahyab Alisha Rai Jay Rai Karmjit Rai Sangeeta Rai Ashley Ralph Emily Ralph Rayjasree Rambhatla Vithal Rambhatla Janice Ramilo Abigail Ramirez Candace Ramirez Carlos Ramirez Cindy Ramirez David Ramirez Jessica Ramirez Maria Elena Ramirez Miguel Ramirez Noah Ramirez Nubia Ramirez Olivia Ramirez Juanita Ramos Laura Ramos Noriel Ramos Sherry Ramos Emil Ramzy Nancy Ramzy Zachery Ranck David Randall Pandora Randall Ehsan Ranjbar Sridhara Rao Mitzi Rasca

Aricenna Rashidi Baktash Rashidi Mehrangez Danishwar Rashidi Samira Rashidi Taymor Rashidi Younus Rashidi Yousuf Rashidi David Raskin Junaid Rasul Lilia Rasulov Sousan Ravasani Camille Ravinovich Michael Ravinovich Miliana Ravinovich Svetlana Ravinovich Stephen Ray Lemma Raya Mark Raymer Jaime Raymond Lecia Rdzak Beverly Reagan Rece Reagan Terry Reagan Gordon Recht Rama Reddy Sushitha Reddy Christopher Reed Douglas Reed Kenneth Douglas Reed Nancy Gene Reed Adrianne Rehab Constance Rehab Maryann Reid Carlota Reifel Stephanie Reilly Julian Reinheimer Anastasia Resner Evelyn Revel Isabella Revel Jacob Revel Sebastian Revel Jose Antonio Reyes Leobardo Reyes Marcell Reyes

Marcelo Reyes Sylvia Reyes Victoria Alessandra Reyes James Reynolds Sara Rezaei Irina Rezian Elyse Reznik Jonah Reznik Olga Reznik Ruth Reznik Todd Reznik Mark Reznikov Chiara Rezvan Elizabeth Rezvan Gianna Rezvan Payam Rezvan Alexander Rhee Anna Rhee Gabriella Rhee Hanna Rhee John Rhee Yung S. Rhee Paula Ri Michael Ricci Robyne Richardson Tiffani Richardson Cereza Richeson Ira Zin Richman Niklaus Riedel Katherine Ries-Shedd April Rigopoulos Athena Rigopoulos Troy Rigopoulos Cody Riley Darryl Riley Juwan Riley Rebecca Riley Man Bok Rim Joseph Rincon Tanya Rios Marc Rischall Stephen Rischall Christopher Ristow Christopher Rivas Alejandro Rivera

Page 50: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

50

Rosaura Rivera Ahmad Mobeen Riyaz Haroon Mobeen Riyaz Mishael Mobeen Riyaz Zura Riyaz Soo Ro Lisa Robert-McCharen Terrell Gean Roberts Lisa Robertson-Kerr Linda Robertt Corey Robinson Daniel Robinson Sandra Robinson Pamela Robinson-Vinson Emelita Robles Joannaim Lim Robles Manolo Robles Walter Roby Alyson Ehlert Rocha Andrew Rocha Gabriela Rocha John Rocha Juan Rocha Kristina Rocha Ramon Rocha Miguel Rockamore Alissa Rockhold Chad Daniel Rockhold Christina Rodgers Lisa Rodgers Diana Rodgriguez Luis A. Rodgriguez Luis E. Rodgriguez William Rodgriguez Yolanda Rodgriguez David Rodriguez Justin Rodriguez Kourtney Rodriguez Latnan Rodriguez Laura Rodriguez

Marisel Rodriguez Miguel Rodriguez Nicholas Rodriguez Peter Rodriguez-Hope Mary Jo Roecker Richard Roecker Bernard Rogers Jaden Daniel Rogers Jaycee Deloris Rogers Pamela Rogers Rick Rogers Khashayar Roholahi Kyle Roholahi Myriam Esperanza Rojas Gordillo Shelby Rolin Chad Rolison Ui Kyong Rollins Evangeline Roman Lucille Roman Walter Roman Aaron Romano Lacie Romano Mylene Romchuk Francis Romero Paul Romero Michael Romiski Josephine Romo Juan Romo Mary Romo Vanessa Espina Romo Harold John Rood Jody Rood Jason Rosales Allen Michael Rose Diana Rose Grayson Wyatt Rose James Rose Kimberly Rose Warwick Rose Arthur Rosen Arthur Rosen Jason Rosen Susan Rosen Lila Rosenberg Joan Rosenblum

Wolf Rosenblum Elaine Rosenfield Steve Rosenfield Dorothy Rosero Felipe Rosero Kylie Rosero-Ozawa Ciriao Rosete Robert Rosner Artemia Rosqueta Daniel Rossi Ariel Rosso Beatriz Rosso Norberto Rosso Andrew Roth Ava Roth Martin Roth Sulamith Roth Susan Rothman Deana Rothman-Lopez Reza Rouhani Afzal Roushan Farid Roushan Diana Roy Andrew Willem Rozendal Redmond Rozendal Aleksand Rozinskiy Yevgeniy Rozinskiy Eric E. Rozinsky Misha E. Rozinsky Denise Ruano Mitch Rubenstein Alex Rubinchuk Albert Rubio Scott Rucker Linda Rudell Richard Rudell Moira Rudin Kristen Ruhlin Daniella Ruiz Eddie Ruiz Eddy Ruiz Elenita Ruiz Mario Ruiz Mario Esteban Ruiz

Page 51: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

51

Vanessa Ruiz Bodhi Rukavina Brady Rukavina Bryce Rukavina Doug Rukavina Marta Rukavina Martin Rukavina Monya Rukavina Rustin E Rukavina Skye Rukavina Phyllis Russell Elia Russionello Jacenda Russionello Michael Russionello Anothy Russo Jordan Russo Christina Rutherford Jennifer Ryan Bianca Ryans Johnett Ryans Malik Ryans Narvis Ryans Arthur Rybin Marsha Rybin Alan Byungjoon Ryu Christopher Ryu Emily Ryu Jin Yi Ryu Miyoung Ryu Brad Saab Brandon Saab Brian Saab Hanan Saab Zack Saab Adlil Saadozi Amir Saadozi Hamid Saadozi Vianna Saadozi Ahnn Saagar Asher Saagar Navjot Saagar Rajan Saagar Tejus Saagar Carmelita Saavedra Daniel Saavedra Janet Saavedra

Martin Saavedra Hossen Sabbagh Sanjay Sabnani Calliope Sabre Eric Sabre Leilana Sabre Mee Sabre Carole Margaret Sachs William Sachs Ahmad Sadeghi Fatemeh Sadeghi Maryam Sadeghi Beverly Sadinsky Chun K. Saeed Danish Saeed Deeba Saeed Naveed Saeed Anoosheh Safarians Fatima Safdari Melad Safdari Mohammad Safdari Joseph Safdeye Azra Yazmine Safir Mohammad Safir Mohammad Suphyulla Safir Mohammad Jawad Safir Antonio Santos Sagastizado Isaiah Sage David Sagi Ruth Sagi Ayush Saha Dristi Saha Tanmay Saha Alex Sahakian Alice Sahakian Lara Sahakian Sarkis Sahakian Araksya Sahakyan Adam Said Elba M. Saile Alec Saint Martin Mauricio Saint Martin

Susana Saint Martin Richard Salama Rosalinda Salazar Charlotte Saldier Cheryl Saldier Elias Barham Saleh Jasmine Saleh Krystal Ann Saleh Sana Mary Saleh Luis Salinas Jr Vikki Salmela Ali Salomi Nayla Salomi Gabriella Salter Jacob Salter Jordan Salter Michal Salter Roy Salter Sophia Salter Sirarpi Salukchyan Lani Salvador Matthew Salvador Nathan Salvador Wayne Salvador Gino Salvano David Salvatore Kelly Salvatore Logan Salvatore Jacob Salzman Marc Salzman Ruby Salzman Shane Salzman Sheila Salzman Colette Samaan Cyrano Samaan Justin Samaan Sean Samaan Ali Samarini Lolita Samarini Beth Sammons Lauren Sammons Neil Sammons Stephanie Sammons Amandeep Samra Roger Samuel Roger Samuel

Page 52: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

52

Lisa San Miguel Carmen Sanchez Carmen Sanchez Frank Sanchez Gabriela Sanchez Isabella Sanchez Judy Sanchez Louise Sanchez Monica Sanchez Nicholas Sanchez Rosaura Sanchez Rudy Sanchez Teodoro Sanchez Willie Sanchez Sarat Sanchi Eric Sander Sabrina Sander Paul Sangster Francesca Santogrossi Thomas Santogrossi Carmen Santos Anita Sarad Bal Sarad Swadesh Sarad Assadour Sarafian Daniel Sarafian Valentine Sarafian Smita Sardar Suvarnlata Sardar Martin Sargsyan George Sarkis Khetam Sarkis Zouheir Sarkis Victoria Sarkisian Melanie Sarkisyan Michelle Sarkisyan Natalie Sarkisyan Uryana Sarkisyan Vaagn Sarkisyan Christopher Saroj Jalaj Saroj Vikram Saroj Vilma Saroj Vishal Saroj Alicia Saucedo Marcelas Saulsbarry

Punyachat Sawatdikijj Dariush Sayah Eyden Reza Sayah Seena Sayah Nancy Sayle Gloria Scaife Gail Scalise Claudia Scalzo Cary Scaringi Matthew Schaaf Kenneth Schatz David Schickman Milad Schiekholeslami Arthur Schiffman Scott Schiffman Simee Schiffman Carol Schlicht Walter Schlicht Chase Schneider Lawrence Schneider Rita Schneider Sean Schonberger Brett Schoneman Chris Schraut Greg Schraut Matt Schraut Robert Schraut Susan Schraut Allison Schubert Marilyn Schulte Daniel Schulz Hannah Schulz Horst Schulz Nathan Schulz Orfilia Schulz Bruce Schwartz Mark Schwartz Rochelle Schwartz Shawn Schwartz Terri Schwartz Todd Schwarz Cameron Scolari Paul Scolari Remi Scolari Sofia Scolari

Bryan Scott Macarena Scott Nancy Ellen Scott Anthony E. Scott II Elizabeth Scott Krotov Mary Scott-Labate Baxter Scruggs Michael Scruggs Suzanne Marie Scruggs Chiara Scudieri Trevor Scully Lisa Scutti Mared Scutti Amelia V. Sebastian Jose Emanuel V. Sebastian Nosrat Sedaghat Mohammad Sedehi Reyhaneh Sedehi Tatyana Sedelnikova Jesse See Katherine Seegar Hee Young Seem Roger Segure Habir Sehmbey Inderbir Sehmbey Jasbir Sehmbey Steven Seinfeld Steven Seinfeld Jo-Ann Seitzinger Amrit K Sekhon Armit Sekhon Dilvir K. Sekhon Jasbir K Sekhon Karamjit Sekhon Debra Seltzer Michael Seltzer Dolores Semilang Arminda Sempertegui Guillermo Sempertegui Heather Sempertegui Jaxson Sempertegui Lenny Sempertegui

Page 53: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

53

David J. Semsarha Desirea Sena Apsara Senaratne Chandima Senaratne Thantirige Senaratne Eileen Seo Jin Woon Seo Joon Seo Jung Seo Jung Min Seo Yoon Seo Hyun Seo-Lee Michael Sepe Jocelyn Sepulveda Joel Sepulveda Betty Serafin John Paul Serafin John Serafin Mathew Roman Serafin Gabivel Serrano Jeffrey Serrano Sebastian Serrano Kendra Settle Francesco Severino Randy Severino Xinna Severino Homa Shabazi Khadijah Shabazz Jeanette Shachory Ronnie Dean Shaffer Rashin Shafiee Beverly Shafton Brendan Shafton Devyn Shafton Neil Shafton Dania Shah Hitasha Shah Joginder Shah Khurrum Shah Maheen Shah Nazia Shah Raveena Shah Saleem Shah Simrat Shah Vasanti Shah

Mihir Shah DDS Homa Shahbazi Shirin Shahbazi Andranik Shahinian Kevork Shahinian Olivia Shahinian Avik Shahnazari Enzo Shahnazari Navena Shahyar Flora Shaldjian Lora Shaldjian Nazeli Shaldjian Amber Shanny Brian Shanny Logan Shanny Rania Shanny Jamil Shanti Jana Shanti Arlene Shapiro Jacqueline Shapiro Mark Shapiro Michael Shapiro Murray Shapiro Robert Shapiro Robyn Shapiro Shirley Shapiro Arlene Shapiro-Baysinger Rochelle Shaposhnick Sheri Share Shweta Sharma Vedansh Sharma Vivek Sharma Jayden Sharobeem Makayla Sharobeem Samy Sharobeem Banafshe Sharokhi Christopher Sharp Dorothy Sharp Lillie Shearer Michael Shearer Masoud Sheikhbahaei Roxan Sheikhbahaei Mehran Sheikholeslomi David Shell

Leonard J Shenkin Cameron Shepard Devon Shepard Kadin Shepard Ranada Shepard Devon Shepard Jr. Rosemary Sheridan Brandon Sherman Steve Sherman Tamara Sherman Emily Shi Mandy Shi Pearl Shi Annie Shim David Shim Eunhee Shim Jay Yong Shim Sook Ja Shim Young Sik Shim Yumi Shim Jacob Shimel Cho Kyung Shin Claudia Shin Daniel Shin Eugene Shin Evan Shin Jaemyung Shin Megan Shin Olivia Shin Richard Shin Ryan Shin Soon Youn Shin Steve Shin Toby Shin William Shin Youngsook Shin Youngsoon Shin Euna Shin Eunice Shin Jeong Jin Shin Kaden Shin Mason Shin Nanda Shin Yong H. Shin Daniel Shindarov Marina Shoykhet

Page 54: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

54

Michael Shoykhet Carol Shpiro Heather Shpiro Irwin Shpiro Laura Shpiro Rebecca Shpiro You Ren Shui Rouzin Shukry Jester Sibanda Chloe Sibanda-Baker Brian Sibert Gretchen Sibley Alexis Sibrian Eliana Sibrian Josue Emanuel Sibrian Nicolas Sibrian Santiago Sibrian Ifrah Siddiqui Safiullah Siddiqui Michael Siecke Rachel Siecke Rebecca Siecke Robert Siecke Nancy Sieczka Danielle Siegel Darlene Siegel Mark Siegel Teri Siegel-Goldstein Teri Siegle-Goldstein Donna Siers D. Meagan Sietsema E. Claire Sietsema H. Taylor Sietsema J. Abigail Sietsema K. Leigh Sietsema O. Chandler Sietsema R. Scott Sietsema R. Parker Sietsema Emily Sigal Jonathan Sigal Matthew Sigal Jason Silberberg Murray Silberling Carlos Silva Jimmy Silva

Carol Silver Stacey Silver Victoria Silver Kay Silverman Marshall Silverman Jung Ja Sim Jung Ja Sim Christine Simbulan-Dizon Elisa Simeone Elisea Simeone Gianluca Simeone Marina Simeone Nicola Simeone Tony Simeone Will Simle Valorie Simmonds Yolanda Simmons Helen Simonaitis Natalia Simonia Makrui Simonian Nancy Simonian Petros Simonian Samuel Simonian Anna Simonova Edna Simpson Stella Simpson Steven Simpson Sylvia Simpson Dam Sin Byung Wha Sin Cameron Singer Aaron Singh Ajay P. Singh Amardeep Singh Anya Singh Arvinder Shah Singh Davinder Pal Singh Gagandeep Singh Gurdev Singh Gurinder Singh Harmanjit Singh Harneet Singh Jasdeep Singh Jasjit Singh Jasjit Jay Singh

Kaamia Singh Kamaljit Singh Karminder Singh Kawaljit Singh Khushpreet Singh Mohini Singh Moin Singh Mona Singh Ravinder Singh Renu Singh Surinder Singh Tajender Singh Vanshpreet Singh Victor Singingeagle Yacoub Siniora David Sipes Carolyn Sirof Donald Skaggs Abigail Skegin-Sipes Gabriel Skegin-Sipes Marina Skegin-Sipes Brian Skipper Linda Skipper Yelena Slavina Robyn Slepicoff Maria Doris Small Richard Small Nicholas Smathers-Palleschi Adree Smith Alison Smith Amauriah Smith Austin John Smith Callie Smith Calvin Smith Charlie Smith Daniel Smith Edwin Smith Emadia Smith Erica D. Smith Gale Smith Harry Smith Irene Smith Irma J. Smith Jack Smith Jason Smith

Page 55: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

55

Jason Grant Smith John Smith Karen Smith Langston Smith Leah Smith Lisa M. Smith Lori Smith Lulu Smith Melvin Smith Renee Smith Robert Smith Robert J. Smith Roxanne Smith Sandra Smith Sennin Smith Shalena Smith Summer Smith Sydney Gail Smith Tara Smith Triston Smith Tyler Smith Uichin Smith Valerie Tabor Smith Wayne Smith Zoltan Smith Gina Smith-Deville Fabiola Smithlin Lauren Ashley Smithlin Matthew John Smithlin Michael. J Smithlin Jasmine Sneed Jorden Sneed Nedra Sneed Suzanne Snowden-Bowman Paul Snyder Robert Snyder Anatoly Sobolevsky Roza Sobolevsky Sasha Sobolevsky Krish Sodhi Priya Sodhi Rajesh Sodhi Yash Sodhi

Christopher Soewadji Jim Soewadji Megawati Soewadji Tiffany Soewadji Recia Sokol Dylan Sokolov Gene Sokolov Marianna Sokolov Ryan Sokolov Jeffrey Sokolovsky R-J Soliven Maribel Soller Aaron Solomon David Solomon Olga ("Dianne") Solomon Sareen Solomon Sofia Solomon Cayle Solowitz Jeff Solowitz Kathleen Solowitz Denchali Soltani Gary Soltani Sareen Soltani Sofia Soltani Maria Elisa Soltes Kristi Somers-Kawas Andrew Son Jae Ho Son Sook Yi Son Apithamarak Sonalee Bunloue Sonalee Ratri Sonalee Apithamarak K. Sonbalee Bunloue Sonbalee Ratri Sonbalee Chelsea Song Daniel Song Feng Rong Song Grace Imheajin Song Homin Song Hye Yeong Song Ju Eun Song Ju Won Song Lindsey Song

Min Sang Song Nicholas Song Phillip Song Sandra Song Sun Jeong Song Wesley Song Chang Hyun Song Elli Song Eugene Song Hee Soon Song Hyun Mi Song Jae Yong Song Philip Junghyen Song Susan Sorenson Andrey Sotnikov Arseniy Sotnikov Larisa Sotnikov Saveliy Sotnikov Adan Soto Alejandro Soto Daniel Soto Jeffrey Scott Soto Jose Soto Santiago Soto Larry Spaeter Dorothy Sparks Kristi Sparks Richard Orville Sparks Aries Spear Jazz Spear Aries Spears Jazz Spears Kevin Specter Kenneth Spector Sherri Spector Beth Spencer Day Spencer Jamani Spencer Nia Spencer Nik Spracklen Linda Spruill Ann Stancarone Ann Stancarone Jesse Stancarone Jesse Stancarone

Page 56: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

56

Michael Standridge Karin L. Stanford Ashley Laverne Stanford-Jackson Nancy Stantzous Martin J. Stark Nikos Starks Paul Starr Anna Staunton Ava Stavaris Sofia Stavaris Zoee Stavaris Natalie Stavridis Gia Steele Greg Steele Cressie Steketee-Thomas Alexander Stemp Eric Stemp Sandra Stephens Louis E. Stepter Mary M. Stepter William Steurer Murelle Steven Alexandra Stevens Evan Stevens Phillip Stevens Rosemary Stevens Serita Stevens Steve Stevens Corey Ronald Stevenson Ellen Stevenson Hugo Stevenson Richard Stine Starr Stitely Kevin Stone Richard Strock Michael Strom Randall Strom Victor Strong Alice Strougo Jennifer Struchen Ira Jeffrey Strumpf Changing Su Hope Su

Ali Subhani Dawood Subhani Zainab Subhani Paul Subotic Chelsea Such Susan Such Bashar Sudah Tamie Sudah Morton Sudeck Jerrold Sugarman Elisha Suh Enoch Suh Ernest Suh Esther Yelang Suh Jung Won Suh Myoung Sook Suh Nam Suk Suh Christine Suitonu James Suitonu Usha Sukhija Koo Hae Sul Ani Sulikyan Armehuhi Sulikyan Garegin Sulikyan Hala Suliman Ani Sulukian Lily Sulukian Moses Sulukian Sophia Sulukian Moses Sulukyan Josephine Iris Sumiller Helen Summers Kenneth Summers Michael Summers Evelyn Sun Han Sun Hui L. Sun Aria Sunderlin Coral Sunderlin Gladys Sunderlin Lawrence Sunderlin Melanie Sunderlin Michael Sunderlin Lisa Sunwaye Sumana Sur

Kathryn Suranyi Peter Suranyi Susan Suranyi Garen Surenyan Kamer Suri David Suskind Christine Suzuki Joseph Suzuki Peyton Suzuki Courtney Swanigan Jacquez Swanigan Jaida Swanigan Anastasia Sweetman Christopher Swenson Daryl Charles Swenson Katherine Lynne Swenson Nancy Swern James Anthony Swist Charisse Sy Angelo Tabar Darrell Tabar Liam Tabar Lin Michelle Tabar Lani Tachera Erika Tadevosyan Katayoun Tadjali Andrew Tadros Melanie Tadros Rick Tadros Samah Tadros Rhonda Taffet Thomas Taffet Elmira Tagieva Elnara Tagieva Fariba Tahmoresi Pouya Tajali Michael Tajiri-Chase Amber Tajyar Ata Tajyar Laila Tajyar Maximus Tajyar Noorzia Tajyar Omar Tajyar Saida D. Tajyar

Page 57: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

57

Sebastian Tajyar Sophia Tajyar Suleiman Tajyar Wael Tajyar Eun Hee Tak Seong Jae Tak Shin Kwan Tak James Takeuchi Matthew Takeuchi Olga Takeuchi Jonathan Tall Sarah Tall Alexander B. Tamayo Alexis-Marie Tamayo Evangeline Tamayo Michael Tamer Amiel Tan Ean Tan Elery Tan Fayanne Tan Kaylee Tan Arlene Tanaka Brianne Tanaka Gerald Tanaka Kellen Tanaka Terence Tanbonliong Jawahar Tandon Derek Tang Evangeline Tang May Tang Jane Tanger Kaylan Tanner Ora Tanner Rick Tanner Sabrina Tanner Adella Tannous David Tannous Juliana Tannous Riana Tanwani Tina Tanwani Zaara Tanwani Angela Tapia Donaciano Tapia Suzanne Tapia Henry/Hank Tarlow John Tarpinian

Juliet Tarpinian Karin Tarpinian Nicholas Tarpinian Noelle Tarpinian Ovsanna Tarpinian Marilyn Tarroza Jon Tarverdian Moses Taslakian Patrick Tatarian Marilyn J. Taubkin Alin Tavitian Berj Tavitian Amy Tawadros Daniel Tawadros Nancy Tawadros Yousif Tawadros Alexander Tawfiq Annette Taylor Brent Taylor Cameron Taylor Carrie Taylor Kathleen Taylor Randall Taylor Sally Taylor Sean Taylor Vonetta Taylor Avetis Taymazyan Grigor Taymazyan Vartan Taymazyan Vartan Taymazyan Syeda T. Tazeen Jon Teboe Mark Teboe Arin Telimi Arlen Telimi Carolin Telimi Robert Telimi Alexis Tellez Cynthia Tellez Olivia Tellez Andrew Teplin Laila Teplin Rachel Teplin Scott Teplin Ann Teraoka Earl Teraoka

Shake Terpanhian Zaven Terpanhian Christopher Terpanjian Edward Terpanjian Matthew Terpanjian Richard Terpanjian Victoria Terpanjian Becky Terry Nathan Terry Terry Nathan Terry Christopher Terterian Janet Terterian Natalie Terterian Paul Terterian Arthur Terzian Lori Tessier-Aivazian Madan Thapar Ramni Thapar Shafina Thawer Felicia Thayer Chris Theard Jonah Theard Kristina Theard Lauren Theard Karen Theobald Robert Theobald Cassandra Thomas Cressie Thomas Gail Thomas George Thomas James Thomas Karen Thomas Michael Thomas Paul Thomas Sharon Thomas Sheila Thomas Tatum Thomas Zuanita Thomas Garey Thompson Jack Thompson Kathleen Thompson Sage Lee Thompson Calli Thomson Carolyn Thornton Earnest Thornton

Page 58: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

58

Amanda Thorpe Anthony Tikidjian Dianne Tillman Donald Tillman Joshua Tinajero Miguel Tinajero Sonia Tinajero Brian Ting Collin Ting Sarah Ting Tyler Ting Arusyak Tirakyan Hakop Tirakyan Harutiun Tirakyan Vahe Tirakyan Lon Titen Alexander Tiu Christopher To Jennifer To Long To Thuy To Cynthia Tobias William Tobias Vicky Ann Todd Michael Tom Sue Carol Tom Sue Carol Tom Armine Tonakanyan Kyla Toney David Tong Lucy Tong Nicholas Tong Marine Tonoyan Armen Toorian Sareen Toorian Karine Topchyan Christina Tormos Edgar Tormos Anthony Onik Torosian John Torosian Joseph Tigran Torosian Nicole Torosian Tigran Torosian Vartuyi Torosoglu

Mike Torossian Samuel Torossian Tania Torossian Agustin Torres Angel Torres Angelica Torres Antonio Torres Elijah Torres Hazel G. Torres Hector Rodriguez Torres Jaime Torres Josefa Torres Marlee Torres Mikaela Torres Nathan Torres Robin Torres Maria Torres-Huaman Rolan Toumanian Ola Hampton Towner Howard Toy Elizabeth Tracton Emily Tracton Kaitlyn Tracton Philip Tracton Leona Tran Loan Le Tran Ngan Le Tran Sharon Kay Trapolsi Kanika Trask Joshua Traver Reese Traver Tiffany Traver Jonathan Traynham Isaac Manuel Trejo Amber Tresvant Dakari Tresvant Josephine Trevino Vladimir Triaca Kaitlyn Trifiletti Lisa Trifiletti Matthew Trifiletti Steven Trifiletti Bellaflor Trompeta Evelyn Trono Valentin Trono

Daisy Trujillo Dung Truong Katelyn Truong Nathan Truong Tanya Tsarevsky Jeanne Tuano Jose Tuano Anthony Tucci Kim Tucci Kelly Tuccitto Matthew Tuck Doris Tucker Lucy Tufenkjian Aditya Tummala Nena Tummala Ravindranath Tummala Mani Turkzadeh Andrea Turner Andrew Turner John Turner Morgan Turner Sharmayne Turner Shelayne Turner Charlane Tyrrel Moeen Ul Haq Charlotte Ulise Dana Ulise Kailey Ulise Todd Ulise Nkemjika Ulu Scott Um Corey Shannon Upchurch Pamela Upchurch Nelia Urmanita Teodoro Urmanita Alfredo Urrutia Lydia P. Uy Dan Uzan Eric Vad Jessica Vad Lawrence Vad Stefany Vad Molly Raju Vadasseril

Page 59: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

59

Raju Vadasseril Antonio Valencia Benjamin Valencia Dylan Valencia Gia Valencia Jesdel Valencia Jocelyn Valencia Manuel Valencia Natalia Valencia Nicholas Valencia Nubia Valencia Tatiana Valencia Almi Valenzuela Alni Valenzuela Elizabeth Valenzuela Natalie Valenzuela Noemi Valenzuela Margarita Vallarta Isabella Valle Ricky Valles Nicole Vallez Chase Van Antwerp Colton Van Antwerp Gard Lance Van Antwerp Krista Van Antwerp Marley Van Antwerp Tia Van Berg John Vana Hailey Vang Jayden Vang Sheryl Vang Youa Vang Youa Vang Zoey Vang Syzanna Vanoyan Yuri Vanoyan Kathlene Vansworth Laurence Vansworth Angelina Vardanyan Arsen Vardanyan Elizabeth Vardanyan Lusin Vardanyan Nerses Vardanyan Rita Vardanyan Grigor Vardanyan Jr.

Grigor Vardanyan Sr. Vardanush Vardevaryan Destiny Varela Eric Varela Dominique Vargas Emily Vargas Evelyn Vargas Javier Vargas Juan Vargas Liduvina Vargas Mariana Vargas Nestor Vargas Christina Vargo-Sanchez Cynthia Varner Arin Vartanian Maria Vartanian Rafi Vartanian Shaunt Vartanian Vaughn Vartanian Lolita Vartapetova Elizabeth Varughese Tara Varughese Suresh Vasandani Cielo Vasquez Elisa Carolina Vasquez Elsa Vasquez Francisco Vasquez Gina Vasquez Julio Vasquez Margaret Vasquez Cynthia Vazirzadeh Lucas Vazquez Mary Vazquez Pablo Vazquez Christine Vdovich Yelena Vdovich Anita Vega Anthony Vega Jesse Vega Melissa Velazquez Vivian R. Veliz-Fiss Andrew Ventura Alana Verdi

Marina Verenitch Lynda Vernon Natasha Vetlugin Steven Vetter David Vieira Alexandre Vignolini Demail Breanna Vignolini Demail Raphael Vignolini Demail Bharat Vij Kiran Vij Prithvi Raj Vij Darian Villalta Jaeden Villalta Luis Villalta Raquel Villalta Daniel Villamayor James Villamayor Angelo Villanueva Antonio Villarruel Karlene Villars Camila Villesenda Nolan Villesenda Kenny Viloria Mathew Vinoj Chuck Vinson Spencer Vinson Ahou Vinter Craig Anthony Vinter Sophie Setareh Vinter Deborah Violante Xiomara Viscarra Daniel Vital Natalie Vital Andrew Vitelli Evangelia Vitogiannis Gimnania Vivanco Alyssa Mae Vives Isabelita Vives Zenaida Vizcarra Kirsten Vogel Rowena Vogel Alyssa Volochkov Dennis Volochkov

Page 60: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

60

Igor Volochkov Daria Volynska Kirill Volynsky Daruish Vosooghi Charles Vukovic Dean Vukovic Peter Vukovic Tim Wachsner Travis Wade Holly Wagenbach Jeremy Wagenbach Larry Wagenbach John Wagner Natalia Wagner Ramon Wagner Sherin Wahib Diane Waida Brenda Walker Bruce, Jr. Walker Bruce, Sr. Walker Melanie Wallace Taylor Wallace Trevor Wallace Abigail Walsh Elizabeth Walsh James Walsh Lillian Walsh Shannon Walsh Ryan Walter Andy Wang Andy Wang Chunsing Wang Esther Wang Fang Wang He Choil Wang He Kang Wang Jung Mi Wang Linda Wang Maolzan Wang Sang Kyun Wang Sun Mi-Katelyn Wang Yanhua Wang Al Ward Brianne Ward Danielle Ward

Lyndy R. Ward Thomas Ward James Wardle Nancy Wardle Eric Warman Luciana Warman Bailey Alice Warner Fred Warner Kelli Cole Warner Robert Mason Warner Arthur Warren Dalia Warren Daniel Warren Elizabeth Warren Sarah Warren Vikki Jean Warren Ava Marie Wartanian Berj Wartanian Katia Wartanian Silva Wartanian Larry Washington Sharon Lyn Washington Ahmad Wasifi Bashir Wasifi Jehan Wasifi Khalida Wasifi Lali Wasifi Walid Wasifi Maksym Wasylyn Nina Wasylyn Renee Wasylyn Roman Wasylyn Andrew Watanabe Greg Watanabe Lauren Watanabe Mary Watanabe Catherine Waters Marilyn Watkins Ronald Watkins Keith Webb Ginger Webber Emma Weber Isabella Weber Laura Weber Thomas Weber

Dennis Wee Joshua Wee Kayden Wee Tina Wee Barbara Weiler Norman Mordecai Weiler Adam Weiner Jess Weiqian Shi Michael Weiss Steve Weiss Naomi Weisz Jaymes Wells Erica West Florentina West Garrett West Iva West Kandace West Kathleen West Mark West Robin West Ryenn West Scott West Stephen West Taylor West Suzanne Westbrook Herbert Wetzel Martha Wetzel Alicia White Anthony White Robert Whitell Nathan Whitescarver Curlie Whiteside Samantha Whiteside Susan Whiteside Bertha Whitley Deborah Whitlock-Trotter Alexander Whitney Donald Whitney Jeffrey Whitney Nicholas Whitney Nicole Whitney Scott Whitney Charlie Wi Joshua Wi

Page 61: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

61

Kaylen Wi Jeanne Wiczek Jeremy Wiczek John Wiczek Ryan Wiczek Isabelle Wiefel Shannon James Wiefel Cindy Wigginton James Wigginton Jared Wiig Laurel Wiig Clera Wijewardene Thomas Wilcox Avrielle Willanger Genelle Willanger Huxley Willanger Maxwell Willanger Nathan William Gladdie Williams Heath L. Williams Heath Williams Jada Williams Jaden Williams Kaci Williams Kaison Williams Karen Williams Keith Williams Kendall Edward Williams Krisha Williams Leah Williams Pamela Williams Rayfield Williams Reid Williams Scott Williams David Williamson Toi Sharae' Williams-Rogers Denise Willmarth Mark Willmarth Danielle Wilson Lou Ellen Wilson Maryjean Wilson Ryan Wilson Wesley Wilson

Eloise Winfrey Gregory Winfrey Mario Winfrey Mario J. Winfrey Ruth Winkler Mary Winn Lorrie Winters Marc Winters Caleb Wise Cecille Wise Dylan Wise Steven Wise Jack Withers Jason Withers Kayla Withers Ryan Withers Tyler Withers Aimee Withers-Adams Ammar Wittwitt Baha Wittwitt Hana Wittwitt Ammar Witwit Baha Witwit Hana Witwit Shari Wohlstattar Cindy Wolfe Laurence A. Wolfe Susan J. Wolfe Harriet Wolfson Heeman Wong Jennifer Wong Anna Woo Eugene Woo Paul Woo Candace Wood Dolores Diamond Wood Gregory Wood Gregory Wood Gregory Wood Robert Wood Jacob Woodard Joshua Woodard Lisa Woodard Monty Woodard

Samantha Woodard Antonio Wooten Judy Wortsman Roger Wortsman Robert Wosnitzer Aubrey Wright Chung Min Lee Wu Daniel Jeha Wu Isabella Wu Jaden Wu Don L. Wulffson Huan Xiang Lie Wei Xu Lie Ye Xu Peng Xu Wan Xu Ira Yaffra Pedram Yaghma Mary Yaghnam Taghreed Yaghnam Zaruhi Yaldizuan Alyssa Yamane Cindy Yamane Glen Yamane Jonathan Yamane Alexandra Yamron Gary Yamron Olivia Yamron Eli Yancey Jason Yancey Madison Yancey Marie Yancey Noah Yancey Shiloh Yancey Brandon Yang Hae Ryung Yang HaeJung Yang Je Sung Yang Jenny Yang Justine Yang Kaufman Yang Lauren Yang Mee Ae Yang Susan Yang Sydney Yang Vivian Yang

Page 62: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

62

William Yang Xuejing Yao Linda Yardborough William Yardborough Linda Yarijanian Marian Yassa Nikki Yassa Noah Yassa Sherif Yassa Anna Yaylakhanyan Yegine Yaylakhanyan Ali Reza Yazdanian Minoo Yazdanian Mohsen Yazdanian Eduardo Ybern Betty Ye Donald Yeck Ellie Yeck Judy Yeck James Yee Lillian Yee Vivian Yee William Yee Mariam Yegoyan Alexandra Yenokida Anderson Yenokida Emerson Yenokida Lauren Yenokida Asatur Yepremyan Harutun Yepremyan Hovanes Yepremyan Joel Yerger Drew Yeskel Scott Yeskel Arin Yessaian Arakel Yessayan Benjamin Yi Diana Yi Fei Yi Hyon Sop Yi Jinny Yi Jung H. Yi Kanguk Yi Norah Yi Scott Yi Susan Young Yi

Tuk U. Yi Victoria Young Yi In Rea Yim Sung Yeol Yim Charles Yin Eric Yin Jennifer Yin Esmeralda Yniguez Natalie Yniguez Maya Yniguez Heinl Chase Yocum Doug Yocum Landon Yocum Laura Yocum Brandon Yong Patrick Yong Chun Lee Yong Joo Aeden Yontarabrokin Ryan Yontarabrokin Angie Y. Yoo Elley Kim Yoo Hong S. Yoo Kyung Hwan Yoo Natalie Yoo Nicole Yoo Nola Yoo Peter H. Yoo Yong Boon Yoo Young Ah Yoo Adrian Yoon Charlie Yoon Chung Yoon David Yoon Elaine Yoon Eun Kyu Yoon Hanna Yoon In Eue Yoon John Changdae Yoon Joseph Yoon Juliana Yoon Junehi Yoon Lila Yoon Michelle Yoon Pia Yoon Riley Yoon Sang Yoon

Sarah JaeEun Yoon Adella York Mariah York Martin York Betty Yoshida Nobuyoshi Yoshida Willie Leonard Youmans Andrew Youn Andrew Youn Connie A. Youn Cendy Younan Natalie Younan Raymond Younan Carolyn Young Crystal Castillo Young Mary Theresa Young Rolando Young Pouneh Yousefi Chung Xiao (Katrina) Yu Chunghi Yu Eric Yu Erin Yu Faith Yu Janelle Yu Janette Yu Jay Yu Joon Suk Yu Jordan Yu Julie Yu Kaylyn Yu Liau Jia Yu Lily Yu Max Yu Ryan Yu Serena Yu Sunhee Yu Susan Yu Suyeol Yu Timothy Yu Kai Hong Yuan Yuan Yuan Jai Yuh Lisette Yuh

Page 63: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

63

Sharron Yuh Charles Yun Justin Yun Song Wook Yun Soo Mi Yun Susan Yun Neil Yuzuk Jennifer Yzbick Joshiah Yzbick Josiah Yzbick Nathan Yzbick Nathan Yzbick Vance Yzbick Anne Zabounian James Zabounian Zohrab Zabounian Alireza Zadeh Massis Zadouri Abdallah Zakaria Carol Zamora Rudy Zamora Dana Zanieh Jack Zanieh Marwan Zanieh Rakan Zanieh Amir Zanjanipour Amir Giovanni Zanjanipour Leonardo Zanjanipour Naomi Zanjanipour

Tina Zanturyan Joseph Zapata Pedro Zara Anel Zarate Flaminio Zarate Noah Zarate Nellie Zargaryan Anjel Zarookian Dajat Zarookian Emilia Zarookian Marlene Zaslove Walter Zaslove Kiryl Zdor Victoria Zdor Vlad Zdor Daniel Zeff Zorica Zeljkovic Sheeva Zenoozy Dawei Zhang Jianying Zhang Ray R. Zhang Serena Zhang Xueji Zhang Hui Zhao Ruizhe Zhao Olga Zhevlakova Wei Zhou Yugang Zhou Nelli Zhulkovskaya Kathleen Zika

Greg Zilberbrand Samantha Zilberbrand Clartia Zinkofsky Marty Zinkofsky Brayden Zinshteyn Ethan Zinshteyn Gary Zinshteyn Marina Zinshteyn Rachel Zinshteyn Grant Zitkovich Kristina Zitkovich Robert Zitkovich Vikki Zitkovich Ellen Zohn Alec Zohrabian Eleni Zohrabian Harmik Zohrabian Aaron Zolonz Abigail Zolonz Laura Zolonz Paul Zubernick Melissa Zubi Amelia Zulueta Leena Zurayk Malek Zurayk Mira Zurayk Sana Zurayk Alexis Zwierankin

Interested Entities and Owners Belgium Waffle House, Alex and Anna Kim Best Realty Realty & Investment, Inc. Chatsworth Discount Cigarettes, Sarkis Chalabian Clairmont Cards & Gifts, Inc., James Clairmont ER Pharmacy, Nancy Simonian Exotic Transportation, Inc., Gary Piskoulian Fletcher Artist Management Enterprises, Inc, Ian Fletcher J2M Smile Corp King Taekwondo, Sarah Tall Lisa Abramowitz Virtual Assistance, Lisa Abramowitz Lucky Coin Laundry, Patricia Mendoza Marci Barkan Hair Designs, Marci Barkan Mason Cleaners, Inc, Lora Shaldjian Mindset Multimedia, Anthony Scott II

Page 64: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595
Page 65: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

65

TABLE OF CONTENTS Page

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES………………………………..………………67

I. INTRODUCTION……………………………………...……………70

II. FACTS AND PROCEDURE……………………………..…………72

A. Since The 1970s, The Gas Company Has Falsely Represented To The State That A Subsurface Safety Valve Was In Place On Well SS-25………………………….72

B. Not Surprisingly, Well SS-25 Fails And Without A Subsurface Safety Valve, Toxic Substances Spew Into Porter Ranch………………………………………………….72

C. The Gas Company Keeps The Blowout Secret………………73

D. After The Public Learns Of The Eruption, The Gas Company Misrepresents The Imminent Threat………………73

E. The Gas Company Misrepresents The Nature And Danger Of The Gas Exposure…………………………..……74

F. The Gas Company Refuses To Assist Residents To Relocate To Avoid Adverse Health Consequences……..……75

G. The Los Angeles County District Attorney Files A Misdemeanor Complaint Against The Gas Company…..……75

1. Count 1 Alleges A Failure To Report Release Of Hazardous Materials Violating Health And Safety Code Section 25510………………………...…75

2. Count 4 Alleges Discharge Of Air Contaminants Violating Health And Safety Code Section 41700……76

H. The District Attorney’s Office Promises The Victims That Any Plea Agreement Will Include Restitution…………77

I. The District Attorney’s Office Reneges On Its Promises To The Victims And Agrees The Gas Company May Plead No Contest To Failure To Immediately Report The Leak Without Any Probation Or Victim Restitution……...….78

J. The Victims Request Direct Restitution Of Their Economic Losses From The Gas Company……………….…79

Page 66: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

66

K. Both The Gas Company And The District Attorney’s Office Oppose The Victims’ Restitution Request……………79

L. The Victims’ Reply…………………………………………..80

M. The Trial Court Holds A Sentencing Hearing………..………81

N. The Trial Court Denies The Victims’ Restitution……………83

O. The Victims Petition This Court For A Writ Of Mandate And Concurrently File A Notice Of Appeal….……84

III. LEGAL ARGUMENT…………………………………………..…..84

A. Standard Of Review……………………………………….…84

B. The Victims Have A Constitutional Right To Restitution……………………………………………………85

C. The Victims Have A Right To Restitution Arising Out Of The Gas Company’s Conviction………………………….89

D. The Victims Have A Right To Restitution Because The Gas Company’s Conviction On Count 1 Is Transactionally Related to Count 4…………………………..92

E. The Trial Court Violated The Victims’ Constitutional Right To Restitution……………………………………….…93

IV. CONCLUSION…………………………………………………...…96

CERTIFICATE OF WORD COUNT………………………………………97

Page 67: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

67

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CASES PAGE(S)

People v. Beagle (2004) 125 Cal.App.4th 415………………...……………………….87

People v. Brown (2007) 147 Cal.App.4th 1213………………….…………………….95

People v. Foalima (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 1376…………………...……………….88, 91

People v. Gross (2015) 238 Cal.App.4th 1313………….…………………………….95

People v. Guevara (1979) 88 Cal.App.3d 86…………………..…………………….88, 93

People v. Harvey (1979) 25 Cal.3d 754…………………………………..…………….87

People v. Holmberg (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 1310……………………………………88, 91

People v. Klaess (1982) 129 Cal.App.3d 820………………………………………….88

People v. Lai (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 1227………….…………………………….87

People v. Martinez (2017) Cal.5th (May 25, 2017, S219970)…….…………85, 87, 90, 92

People v. Percelle (2005) 126 Cal.App.4th 164……………………...………………….87

People v. Walker (2014) 231 Cal.App.4th 1270……………………..…………86, 87, 90

People v. Walker (2016) 6 Cal.App.5th Supp. 38, __, 211 Cal.Rptr.3d 829…….…87, 90

People v. Williams (2010) 184 Cal.App.4th 142……………………...……………….…84

Page 68: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

68

People v. Woods (2008) 161 Cal.App.4th 1045…………….………………………….87

In re Vicks (2013) 56 Cal.4th 274………………………….…………………….93

STATUTES & REGULATION

Cal. Const., art. 1, § 28(b)(6)…………………….………………………….93 Cal. Const., art. 1, § 28(b)(13)……………………………...……………….85 Cal. Const., art. 1, § 28(c)(1)……………...…………………………….84, 85 Cal. Const., art. 1, § 28(f)……………………….…………………………..85 Code Civ. Proc., § 902………………………………………………………84 Health & Saf. Code, § 25500(a)…………………….………………………90 Health & Saf. Code, § 25501(c)……………….……………………………90 Health & Saf. Code, § 25501(m)……………………………………………90 Health & Saf. Code, § 25501(l)………………………..……………………90 Health & Saf. Code, § 25501(n)(1)……………………...………………….90 Health & Saf. Code, § 25510……………………………………………70, 89 Health & Saf. Code, § 25510(a)…………………………...……73, 75, 76, 89 Health & Saf. Code, § 41700……………………………….……………….71 Health & Saf. Code, § 41700(a)…………….………………………76, 77, 92 Pen. Code, § 1202.4(a)(1)………………………..………………………….86 Pen. Code, § 1202.4(a)(3)……………………………...……………………86 Pen. Code, § 1202.4(f)……………………………………..………………..86 Pen. Code, § 1202.4(f)(3)…………………………………….……………..86

Page 69: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

69

Pen. Code, § 1202.46…………………………….………………………….95 Pen. Code, § 1203(b)(2)(D)………………………...……………………….94 Pen. Code, § 1203(d)……………………………………….……………….94 Pen. Code, § 1203(g)…………………………………….….………………94 L.A. County Code, § 12.56.030…………………………..…………………77 Cal. Code. Regs., tit. 19, § 2703(a)…………...…………………………….77

Page 70: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

70

I.

INTRODUCTION

This appeal concerns the rights of the Victims of the most

serious environmental crime ever committed in California—the Aliso

Canyon/Porter Ranch gas eruption—to restitution for their staggering

economic losses arising out of Defendant Southern California Gas

Company’s criminal conduct in releasing toxic substances into the air. In

contravention of its prosecutorial responsibilities, the Los Angeles County

District Attorney’s Office structured a plea agreement with the Gas Company

to deliberately avoid an order of direct restitution to the Victims. The trial

court also refused to issue a restitution order in violation of constitutional and

statutory mandates and controlling case authority. This Court should reverse

the order denying restitution and remand to the trial court with directions to

issue a restitution order.

Victims of crimes have constitutional and statutory rights to

restitution for economic losses arising from criminal conduct for which the

defendant is convicted. Here, the Gas Company pled no contest to a

misdemeanor violation of Health and Safety Code section 255101 for failing

to immediately report its release of methane, methyl mercaptan, butyl

mercaptan, benzene and butane into the Porter Ranch community where the

Victims reside. The release of these toxic substances is an element of

violating section 25510, and failing to report the release substantially caused

1 All further references to statutes are to the Health and Safety Code unless otherwise noted.

Page 71: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

71

the Victims’ economic losses. Because of the Gas Company’s criminal

conviction, the Victims are entitled to restitution for their economic losses.

Additionally, the District Attorney’s Office charged the Gas

Company with violating section 41700 for the actual release of the same

toxic substances into the Porter Ranch community the Gas Company failed

to report. Because the release of the same toxic substances giving rise to the

dismissed count was also involved in the admitted count, the two counts are

transactionally related and the criminal conduct for which restitution must be

ordered includes the conduct charged in the dismissed count. The Victims

are entitled to restitution for their economic losses for this reason too.

Finally, in denying the Victims’ request for restitution, the trial

court abrogated the Victims’ constitutional rights. The prosecution may not

bargain away, limit, or waive victims’ restitution rights directly, nor can the

prosecution do so indirectly as here by deliberately designing a plea

agreement attempting to bar restitution. A sentence without an award of

victim restitution is invalid and may be corrected at any time. The District

Attorney’s Office’s attempted bargaining away of the Victims’ restitution

rights by plea agreement, and the trial court’s acceptance of that agreement

without ordering restitution, cannot stand.

This Court should reverse the order denying restitution and

remand to the trial court with directions to order the Gas Company to pay

restitution to the Victims.

Page 72: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

72

II.

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

A. Since The 1970s, The Gas Company Has Falsely Represented To

The State That A Subsurface Safety Valve Was In Place On Well

SS-25

The Gas Company owns a massive natural gas storage field in

Aliso Canyon adjacent to the residential community of Porter Ranch. (1 CT

82.) Natural gas is not native to Aliso Canyon—it is transported through

pipelines and injected underground into high powered wells. For over 30

years, the Gas Company reported to state officials at the Division of Oil, Gas

& Geothermal Resources that the gas storage wells at their Aliso Canyon

facility were safe, and specifically reported that well SS-25 (drilled in 1953)

had a subsurface safety valve designed to prevent the release of any gases

into the surrounding community. (See 1 CT 66, 69-79.) Yet the Gas

Company knew the mandatory subsurface safety valve on well SS-25 had

failed in the 1970s and been deliberately removed. (1 CT 82-89.) For

decades, the Gas Company willfully concealed this information from state

safety inspectors, who instead received test reports showing an operational

subsurface safety valve in place. (1 CT 69-79.)

B. Not Surprisingly, Well SS-25 Fails And Without A Subsurface Safety Valve, Toxic Substances Spew Into Porter Ranch

On October 23, 2015, the casing in well SS-25 failed, causing

the largest gas blowout in the world’s history. Because the Gas Company

had removed the subsurface safety valve, well SS-25 spewed benzene,

Page 73: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

73

hydrogen sulfide, methane, mercaptans, and numerous other toxic substances

into the atmosphere over Porter Ranch. (1 CT 1, 82-89, 110.) This spewing

of toxic substances continued for months. (1 CT 82-83.)

C. The Gas Company Keeps The Blowout Secret

For at least three days, the Gas Company kept the blowout a

secret, while over 30,000 residents in Porter Ranch, their homes, businesses

and schools were exposed to toxic gases. (1 CT 1, 82-89, 115-118.)

Specifically, the Gas Company failed to report the release of hazardous

material to the California Emergency Management Agency and to the Los

Angeles County Fire Department in violation of section 25510(a).

D. After The Public Learns Of The Eruption, The Gas Company Misrepresents The Imminent Threat

Once the public learned of the well’s eruption, the Gas

Company claimed the well was so far away, the natural gas would dissipate

before it reached Porter Ranch, and there was no public health threat: “[T]he

leak does not pose an imminent threat to public safety. The well is located

in an isolated, mountain area more than a mile away from and more than

1,200 feet higher than the closest home or public area…. In outdoor locations

such as this, natural gas quickly dissipates into the air, greatly reducing the

possibility for ignition and further diluting the gas as it reaches the public.”

(1 CT 92.)

Environmental groups and the attorneys for the Victims

obtained an infrared camera to film the blowout and capture evidence of

Page 74: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

74

natural gas, noxious odors, hazardous chemicals, and toxic pollutants rolling

in a plume down the hill and into Porter Ranch. (1 CT 99, 105.)

The Gas Company also identified an oily mist emanating from

the Aliso Canyon facility, but after initial concerns, the Gas Company

affirmatively misrepresented to the Victims that “the mist would not travel

beyond the facility.” (1 CT 99.) The Gas Company further told residents

“there was no reason to stay indoors.” (Id.) The oily mist could not be seen

with the naked eye and took several weeks before evidence started building

up on homes, cars, and in playgrounds. (1 CT 99, 105, 123-124.) Children,

vulnerable people, and pets breathed in the oily mist from the blowout for

weeks before they knew the mist had traveled outside of the facility.

E. The Gas Company Misrepresents The Nature And Danger Of The Gas Exposure

The Gas Company misrepresented to the Victims that the only

gas to which residents were being exposed was methane along with

mercaptans (a toxic substance added to natural gas so people will detect gas

leaks and leave dangerous areas). (1 CT 92-96.) The Gas Company’s blatant

misrepresentations were made knowing that the community was also being

exposed to benzene, hydrogen sulfide, and various other toxic substances. (1

CT 1, 110.) The Gas Company further misrepresented to the community

these gases were harmless. (1 CT 92, 99.) Reporters broke the news of the

misrepresentations on the levels of toxins released by the Gas Company. (1

CT 115-118.)

More than 114 Gas Company wells in Aliso Canyon did not

Page 75: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

75

meet rudimentary safety requirements. (1 CT 84.) These wells were ordered

shut down until the Gas Company complied with minimum safety standards.

(1 CT 134-145.) The Gas Company was also ordered to plug old wells to

prevent gases from rising into the community. (Id.)

F. The Gas Company Refuses To Assist Residents To Relocate To Avoid Adverse Health Consequences

Based on the Gas Company’s intentional conduct, thousands

of Porter Ranch residents suffered catastrophic health consequences,

including death. (1 RT 34-51; 1 CT 34.) The County of Los Angeles ordered

the Gas Company to relocate these families [1 CT 102], but the Gas Company

refused, necessitating a court order. (1 CT 322.) Thousands of Porter Ranch

residents had to stay in their homes while their neighbors and pets began to

die, and their children became sicker. (1 RT 34-51; 1 CT 34.) Porter Ranch

homes soon redefined the word “uninhabitable.” (Id.)

G. The Los Angeles County District Attorney Files A Misdemeanor Complaint Against The Gas Company

1. Count 1 Alleges A Failure To Report Release Of Hazardous Materials Violating Health And Safety Code Section 25510

Count 1 alleged a violation of section 25510(a), based on the

Gas Company’s failure to report the leak for three days. The complaint

stated, “On or about October 23, 2015 to October 26, 2015, in the County of

Los Angeles, the crime of FAILURE TO REPORT RELEASE OF

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL, in violation of HEALTH AND SAFETY

CODE SECTION 25510(a), a Misdemeanor, was committed by

Page 76: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

76

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY, which failed, upon

discovery, to immediately report a release or threatened release of hazardous

material, to wit: NATURAL GAS OR ITS COMPONENTS (including, but

not limited to, METHANE, METHYL MERCAPTAN, BUTYL

MERCAPTAN, BENZENE AND BUTANE) to the California Emergency

Management Agency and to the unified program agency.” (1 CT 1.)

Section 25510(a) provides in part: “[A business that handles

hazardous materials] shall, upon discovery, immediately report any release

or threatened release of a hazardous material to the unified program agency,

and to the [L.A. County Fire Department], in accordance with the regulations

adopted pursuant to this section.”

2. Count 4 Alleges Discharge Of Air Contaminants Violating Health And Safety Code Section 41700

Count 4 alleged a violation of section 41700(a), based on the

Gas Company’s release of toxic substances. “On or about October 23, 20l5

to the present, in the County of Los Angeles, the crime of DISCHARGE OF

AIR CONTAMINANTS, in violation of HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE

SECTION 41700(a), a Misdemeanor, was committed by SOUTHERN

CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY, which discharged air contaminants and

other materials, to wit: NATURAL GAS OR ITS COMPONENTS

(including, but not limited to, METHANE, METHYL MERCAPTAN,

BUTYL MERCAPTAN, BENZENE AND BUTANE) that caused injury,

detriment, nuisance or annoyance to any considerable number of persons or

to the public, or that endangered the comfort, repose, health, or safety of any

Page 77: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

77

of those persons or the public, or that caused or had a natural tendency to

cause, injury or damage to business or property.” (1 CT 3.)

Section 41700(a) provides: “[A] person shall not discharge

from any source whatsoever quantities of air contaminants or other material

that cause injury, detriment, nuisance, or annoyance to any considerable

number of persons or to the public, or that endanger the comfort, repose,

health, or safety of any of those persons or the public, or that cause, or have

a natural tendency to cause, injury or damage to business or property.”2

H. The District Attorney’s Office Promises The Victims That Any Plea Agreement Will Include Restitution

A few days after the District Attorney filed this case, attorneys

representing many of the Gas Company’s Victims, including attorneys from

the Parris Law Firm representing more than 7,000 Victims, put the District

Attorney’s Office on notice that the Victims sought restitution under the

California Constitution for their economic losses. (1 CT 45.) These losses

included cleaning costs, lost livelihood, unreimbursed relocation expenses,

and damage to, and diminution in the value of, the Victims’ property. (1 RT

35-52, 83.) The District Attorney’s Office assured the Victims’ attorneys no

plea agreement would be entered that did not include full restitution to the

Victims for the Gas Company’s criminal acts. (1 CT 45.) The Gas Company

was arraigned and pleaded not guilty on February 17, 2016. (1 CT 7-8.)

2 The Gas Company was charged in Counts 2 and 3 with failures to report under L.A. County Code section 12.56.030 and Title 19 of the California Code of Regulations section 2703(a). (1 CT 2.)

Page 78: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

78

On June 14, 2016, an attorney from the Parris Law Firm

appeared for a pre-trial hearing and advised deputies district attorney, who

were meeting with Gas Company attorneys, that he represented the Victims,

who sought restitution from the Gas Company. (1 CT 47.) He was asked to

leave and no proceedings were held in open court that day. (Id.) The parties

and their counsel met in chambers. (1 RT 28-29.) The minute order reflects

that the prosecution and defense counsel conferred in chambers and does not

reflect the presence of the Victims’ counsel. (1 CT 12.)

I. The District Attorney’s Office Reneges On Its Promises To The Victims And Agrees The Gas Company May Plead No Contest To Failure To Immediately Report The Leak Without Any Probation Or Victim Restitution

On September 13, 2016, the District Attorney’s Office

announced in open court it had entered a plea agreement with the Gas

Company. (1 CT 45.) None of the Victims of the Gas Company’s criminal

acts were notified or consulted about the plea agreement in advance. (1 CT

45, 48.) Neither the District Attorney’s Office, nor the Department of

Probation, ever contacted the Victims or their representatives regarding the

plea agreement and the Victims’ right to restitution. (1 RT 82-83.) The

settlement was presented to the trial court as a fait accompli with no notice

to, or input from, the Victims. (1 RT 26, 82-83.) The plea agreement is silent

on direct victim restitution. (1 CT 17-20.)

Under the agreement, the Gas Company pleaded no contest to

one misdemeanor count of failing to immediately notify the California Office

of Emergency Services and the L.A. County Fire Department of the leak that

began on October 23, 2015 (Count 1). (1 CT 17.) Under the plea, the Gas

Page 79: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

79

Company would receive a non-probationary sentence, including fines,

response costs, and remediation. (1 CT 17-19.) The other three counts would

be dismissed. (1 CT 19.) The agreement includes no requirement for direct

restitution of the Victims’ economic losses. (1 CT 17-20.) The agreement

also includes no requirement for a probation report, which would have

resulted in notice to the Victims and an opportunity for the Victims to submit

restitution claims.

On September 13, 2016, again with none of the Victims or their

counsel present, the Gas Company pleaded no contest to Count 1 under the

plea agreement and the trial court accepted the plea. (1 RT 1-21.) The trial

court set the matter for sentencing on November 29, 2016. (1 RT 20.)

J. The Victims Request Direct Restitution Of Their Economic Losses From The Gas Company

On October 18, 2016, the Victims moved to request their

constitutional direct restitution rights, a restitution hearing and that the trial

court retain jurisdiction over restitution. (1 CT 25-43.) The Victims’ motion

was based on the lack of notice and direct restitution. (Id.) The Victims’

motion was supported by declarations and a request for judicial notice. (1

CT 45-59.)

K. Both The Gas Company And The District Attorney’s Office Oppose The Victims’ Restitution Request

Both the Gas Company and the District Attorney’s Office filed

oppositions to the Victims’ requests. (1 CT 255-274; 2 CT 403-418.) The

Gas Company argued the Victims could not have restitution because it had

Page 80: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

80

pleaded no contest only to a failure to report and had not been placed on

probation. (1 CT 270.) The Gas Company also argued it paid relocation

expenses to some residents, including for interior cleaning, and since a civil

action was pending, direct restitution was unnecessary. (1 CT 263.) Finally,

the Gas Company argued the prosecution had agreed to dismiss the only

count for which restitution might have been ordered. (1 CT 267.)

The District Attorney’s Office argued the Victims could not

recover diminution in property value as restitution and the Victims were not

entitled to restitution for the failure to report charge to which the Gas

Company had pleaded no contest. (2 CT 412-413.)

L. The Victims’ Reply

In reply (2 CT 434-447),3 the Victims argued they were

entitled to restitution for the failure to report, because “[t]he failure to report

an emission of toxic gases cannot occur unless there are emissions.” (2 CT

438.) They also argued economic loss was a broad concept that encompasses

diminution in property values. (2 CT 442-443.)

Liaison Counsel for Plaintiffs in the coordinated civil actions,

declared that he had been contacted by a deputy district attorney on

September 11, 2016, to set up a conference call, but the deputy district

attorney told him that none of the Victims’ other attorneys (including the

Parris Law Firm) could participate. (2 CT 431.) The next day, Liaison

3 The trial court denied the Victims’ second request for judicial notice. (2 CT 450-452, 489-503.)

Page 81: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

81

Counsel spoke to two deputies district attorney, who told him only that a

preliminary settlement of the criminal charges had been reached, with no

discussion of the terms (including restitution), other than that the terms were

confidential until disclosed publicly. (2 CT 431-432.) The District

Attorney’s Office refused to give Liaison Counsel a copy of the settlement

agreement. (2 CT 432.)

The Parris Law Firm received no notice. (1 RT 82-83.)

Liaison Counsel stated in his declaration he would discuss the matter with

the Plaintiff Steering Committee Co-Leads, but did not state he ever actually

discussed the agreement with any of the Victims’ other attorneys. (2 CT

432.)

The trial court accepted the Gas Company’s no contest plea on

September 13, 2016—the very next day—with no representatives of the

Victims present or mention of the Victims. (1 RT 1-21.)4

M. The Trial Court Holds A Sentencing Hearing

The case was called for a sentencing hearing on November 29,

2016. (1 RT 22-23.) The Victims’ counsel were present. (Id.) It was unclear

whether just the Victims’ motion, or the restitution hearing and sentencing

were to be heard, so only a few Victims were present. (1 RT 34-35, 46.) The

4 Although the District Attorney’s Office argued in its opposition, without any supporting declaration, that Liaison Counsel sent a representative to the plea hearing on September 13, 2016, the record does not reflect this and Liaison Counsel’s declaration also does not state he sent a representative. (1 RT 1; 2 CT 409, 430-432.)

Page 82: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

82

trial court stated at the hearing it set aside the entire day for all aspects of the

case. (1 RT 34-35.) The few Victims present were allowed to testify. (1 RT

35-52, 83.)

The Victims’ counsel argued the Victims were improperly

excluded from plea negotiations and received inadequate notice of the plea

agreement: “[M]any victims and lawyers made requests to be heard before

any sentence or before any plea agreement was entered into. There was

written communication. There [were] verbal guarantees to Mr. Parris by the

District Attorney’s Office that the Victims would have a say. We went to

meetings. We showed up in court.” (1 RT 28-29.) The Victims’ counsel

also argued the District Attorney’s Office had improperly bargained away

the Victims’ constitutional restitution rights: “We were shut out of all these

proceedings, never had notice as required.” (1 RT 29, 31.) And, the Victims’

counsel argued the Victims were entitled to full restitution of economic

losses pursuant to the Gas Company’s plea, and those losses were calculable.

(1 RT 30.) Alternatively, restitution was due for the Victims’ economic

losses caused by the three-day delay in reporting. (1 RT 77.)

The District Attorney’s Office and the Gas Company were

aligned to oppose the Victims’ request for restitution. (1 RT 61-76.) A

deputy district attorney argued the Victims could not have restitution for

Count 1 and disputed the necessity for direct restitution to the Victims. (1

CT 64.) Despite the Victims’ entitlement to full restitution of their economic

losses, the deputy district attorney claimed the settlement with the Gas

Company and money the Gas Company spent to relocate some Porter Ranch

residents was sufficient restitution. (1 RT 66-67, 69.) The deputy made these

Page 83: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

83

representations despite testimony from Victims recounting their

uncompensated economic losses, including house cleaning, lost livelihood,

unreimbursed relocation expenses, damage to, and diminution in value of,

their property, and even the cost of an ambulance relocating one couple’s

son, who died during the blowout. (1 RT 35-52.) The deputy also argued

the Victims could not have restitution for the diminution in value of their

properties. (1 RT 65-66.) The Gas Company argued primarily that its failure

to report the emission of toxic substances was not transactionally related to

the emission of those toxic substances. (1 RT 75-76.)

The trial court noted concerns with the large number of Victims

entitled to restitution and the pendency of a civil action. (1 RT 25-26.)

N. The Trial Court Denies The Victims’ Restitution

At the conclusion of the hearing, the trial court denied the

Victims’ requests for the court to order direct restitution and to retain

jurisdiction to accomplish restitution. (See 1 RT 84-88.) The trial court

distributed a written opinion with this denial. (2 CT 489-503.)

The trial court concluded the Victims had standing to be heard,

but could not intervene. (2 CT 489.) The trial court also concluded

restitution could be ordered in a non-probationary context only for crimes of

which the defendant had been convicted. (2 CT 494-496.) The trial court

concluded restitution was not recoverable for the count to which the Gas

Company had pleaded no contest. (2 CT 501-502.) Additionally, the trial

court concluded the prosecution had reasonably notified the Victims and

Page 84: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

84

legally exercised its discretion in entering the plea agreement. (Id.) The trial

court accepted the plea, sentenced the Gas Company to a non-probationary

sentence and dismissed the remaining counts. (2 CT 502; 1 RT 88-90.)

O. The Victims Petition This Court For A Writ Of Mandate And Concurrently File A Notice Of Appeal

On December 28, 2016, the Victims timely filed a notice of

appeal from the judgment and the order denying their request for restitution.

(2 CT 555-556.) On December 29, 2016, the Victims timely petitioned this

Court for a writ of mandate. (2 CT 559-586.)

On January 5, 2017, the Court denied the Victims’ petition on

the ground they had “an adequate remedy at law via their direct appeal from

the order denying restitution.” (4 CT 975.)

III.

LEGAL ARGUMENT

A. Standard Of Review

As this Court already concluded, the Victims may appeal from

the trial court’s order denying restitution. (4 CT 975; see also Cal. Const.,

art. 1, §28(c)(1); Code Civ. Proc., §902.) “[W]hen the propriety of a

restitution order turns on the interpretation of a statute, a question of law is

raised, which is subject to de novo review on appeal.” (People v. Williams

(2010) 184 Cal.App.4th 142, 146.) The question is whether the Victims

suffered economic losses because of criminal activity forming the basis of

Page 85: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

85

the Gas Company’s conviction for failure to report the gas leak, entitling the

Victims to restitution under the California Constitution and Penal Code.

Therefore, review is de novo.

B. The Victims Have A Constitutional Right To Restitution

In California, crime victims have a constitutional right to

restitution for losses a defendant inflicts on them. (People v. Martinez (2017)

__ Cal.5th __ (May 25, 2017, S219970) slip opn. at p. 5 (Martinez).)

California Constitution, article 1, §28(b)(13) states in part: “[T]o preserve

and protect a victim’s rights to justice and due process, a victim shall be

entitled to … restitution. (A) It is the unequivocal intention of the People of

the State of California that all persons who suffer losses as a result of criminal

activity shall have the right to seek and secure restitution from the persons

convicted of the crimes causing the losses they suffer. (B) Restitution shall

be ordered from the convicted wrongdoer in every case, regardless of the

sentence or disposition imposed, in which a crime victim suffers a loss.”

Crime victims also have the constitutional right to enforce their

restitution rights. “A victim, the retained attorney of a victim, a lawful

representative of the victim, or the prosecuting attorney upon request of the

victim, may enforce the rights enumerated in subdivision (b) in any trial or

appellate court with jurisdiction over the case as a matter of right. The court

shall act promptly on such a request.” (Cal. Const., art. 1, §28(c)(1); see also

Cal. Const., art. 1, §28(f) [referring to “enumerated rights provided in

subdivision (b) that are personally enforceable by victims as provided in

subdivision (c)”].)

Page 86: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

86

To implement a victim’s constitutional right to restitution, the

Legislature enacted Penal Code §1202.4, which states in part: “(a)(1) It is the

intent of the Legislature that a victim of crime who incurs an economic loss

as a result of the commission of a crime shall receive restitution directly from

a defendant convicted of that crime.” Penal Code §1202.4(a)(3) requires the

trial court to order the defendant to pay restitution “to the victim.” This

judicial obligation is reiterated in Penal Code §1202.4(f): “[I]n every case in

which a victim has suffered economic loss as a result of the defendant’s

conduct, the court shall require that the defendant make restitution to the

victim or victims in an amount established by court order, based on the

amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims or any other showing to the

court. If the amount of loss cannot be ascertained at the time of sentencing,

the restitution order shall include a provision that the amount shall be

determined at the direction of the court. The court shall order full

restitution.” Penal Code §1202.4(f)(3) describes restitution order

requirements: “To the extent possible, the restitution order shall be prepared

by the sentencing court, shall identify each victim and each loss to which it

pertains, and shall be of a dollar amount that is sufficient to fully reimburse

the victim or victims for every determined economic loss incurred as the

result of the defendant’s criminal conduct,” including the value of damaged

property and attorneys’ fees and costs.

The trial court must order restitution for the victim’s losses

arising out of the “criminal conduct for which the defendant has been

convicted.” (People v. Walker (2014) 231 Cal.App.4th 1270, 1274 (Walker),

internal quotations omitted.) Put another way, the trial court must order

restitution for “those losses arising out of the criminal activity that formed

Page 87: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

87

the basis of the conviction.” (People v. Woods (2008) 161 Cal.App.4th 1045,

1049; see also People v. Percelle (2005) 126 Cal.App.4th 164, 179-180

(Percelle).) The victim’s loss must have been caused by the criminal conduct

for which the defendant was convicted. (People v. Lai (2006) 138

Cal.App.4th 1227, 1249.) Restitution in a non-probation context is

authorized unless the defendant’s only relationship to the victim’s loss is a

crime for which the defendant was not convicted. (Percelle, supra, 126

Cal.App.4th at p. 180.)

To determine the conduct for which a defendant stands

convicted, courts examine the elements of the crime to determine whether

the conduct is encompassed in the crime. (Walker, supra, 231 Cal.App.4th

at pp. 1274-1275; Martinez, supra, slip opn. at pp. 8-9, 16 fn. 3 [unless

defendant’s criminal conduct caused the accident, being involved in an

injury-producing accident is not part of the criminal conduct involved in

fleeing the scene in violation of Veh. Code, §20001(a).)

Conduct encompassed in the crime includes conduct

“transactionally related” to the facts that formed the basis of the count for

which the defendant was convicted. (People v. Harvey (1979) 25 Cal.3d 754,

758-759.) A dismissed count is transactionally related if “some action of the

defendant giving rise to the dismissed count was also involved in the

admitted count.” (People v. Beagle (2004) 125 Cal.App.4th 415, 421-423

[weapon charge not transactionally related to drug charge]; People v. Walker

(2016) 6 Cal.App.5th Supp. 38, __, 211 Cal.Rptr.3d 829, 833-835 [restitution

not limited to harm directly caused by criminal conduct of contractor

working without a license, but instead transactionally related to all

Page 88: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

88

compensation for unlicensed work]; see also People v. Klaess (1982) 129

Cal.App.3d 820, 823-824 [accessory after the fact transactionally related to

crime for which defendant is an accessory]; People v. Guevara (1979) 88

Cal.App.3d 86, 92-94 (Guevara) [possession of shotgun was involved in

kidnapping and thus proper aggravating factor].)

In determining whether the victim’s economic loss occurred

because of the defendant’s criminal conduct, tort principles of causation

apply. (People v. Holmberg (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 1310, 1321

(Holmberg).) Economic loss occurs from a defendant’s criminal conduct if

that conduct was a substantial factor in causing the victim’s loss. (Id. at p.

1322.) There can be more than one cause of loss. (Ibid.) For example, in

Holmberg the defendant was not convicted of the burglary during which the

victims’ property was stolen, he was convicted of receiving the victims’

stolen property. (Ibid.) The defendant’s act of concealing the stolen property

was a concurrent cause with the burglary in depriving the victims of their

property’s use. (Ibid.) The defendant was properly ordered to pay restitution

for the victims’ economic loss in replacing the stolen property. (Id. at pp.

1323-1324.) “[B]y holding on to the equipment, knowing it was stolen,

defendant’s conduct was a concurrent cause of the victims’ losses and a

substantial factor in causing their damages.” (Id. at pp. 1323-1324.)

A “cause in fact is something that is a substantial factor in

bringing about the injury.” (People v. Foalima (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th

1376, 1396 (Foalima).) The substantial factor test should not be narrowly

applied. (Id. at p. 1397.) “The test, put simply, is whether [the victim] would

have incurred damages had there been no [crime for which the defendant was

Page 89: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

89

convicted].” (Ibid.) If the defendant’s criminal conduct (including

transactionally related conduct) was a substantial factor and proximate cause

of the victim’s damages, the victim is entitled to restitution. (Ibid.) When a

defendant was convicted of murder but acquitted of arson, the trial court

properly awarded restitution for a victim’s loss of clothing and household

goods burned after the victim died, because the murder was a substantial

factor in the destruction of the victim’s property. (Ibid.)

C. The Victims Have A Right To Restitution Arising Out Of The Gas Company’s Conviction

The Gas Company pled no contest to violating §25510(a). The

elements are: (1) discovery by a storer of hazardous materials (2) of the

release of those hazardous materials into the environment and (3) failing to

immediately report the release to the L.A. County Fire Department. It is

undisputed that the Gas Company stored hazardous materials, released those

hazardous materials into Porter Ranch and failed to immediately report the

release. It is similarly undisputed that the Gas Company’s release of these

hazardous materials resulted in catastrophic health consequences, including

death, massive disruption, temporary relocation, cleaning costs, lost

livelihood, damage to property, and diminution of the Victims’ property

values.

Section 25510 is part of Chapter 6.95 of Division 20, entitled

“Hazardous Materials Releases Response Plans and Inventory.” Article 1,

of which §25510 is part, expressly declares the legislative purpose “to protect

the public health and safety and the environment” and “to prevent or mitigate

the damage to the health and safety of persons and the environment from the

Page 90: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

90

release or threatened release of hazardous materials into the workplace and

environment.” (§25500(a).) The provisions regulate “business[es]” that

“handle” hazardous materials. (§25501(c), (m).) “Handl[ing]” includes

storage of hazardous materials. (§25501(l).) “Hazardous materials” are

those that pose “a significant present or potential hazard to human health and

safety or to the environment if released into the workplace or the

environment.” (§25501(n)(1).)

Unlike the hit and run defendant who did not cause the accident

from which he fled in Martinez, supra, slip opn. at p. 9, here the Gas

Company was convicted of criminal conduct including the criminal release

into the environment of hazardous materials stored by the Gas Company in

Aliso Canyon—there can be no failure to notify of a criminal release by a

storer without the release. Thus, the Victims are entitled to restitution for the

economic losses they suffered arising out of the criminal activity that formed

the basis of the crime for which the Gas Company was convicted. (See

Walker, supra, 231 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1275-1276 [defendant convicted of

driving under the influence causing injury properly ordered to pay restitution

to all victims of eight-car collision, even those unnamed]; People v. Walker,

supra, 211 Cal.Rptr.3d at pp. 833-835 [defendant convicted of contracting

without a license properly ordered to pay restitution for all money victim

paid for unlicensed work.)

The Victims also are entitled to full restitution for the

economic losses resulting from the criminal activity for which the Gas

Company was convicted, because failing to report the release of hazardous

materials was a substantial factor in the economic losses the Victims

Page 91: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

91

suffered. (See Holmberg, supra, 195 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1321-1322.) Had

the Gas Company truthfully, accurately and immediately reported the release

and nature of these toxic substances, the economic losses suffered by the

Victims could have been lessened by immediate relocation out of the affected

area. Like the defendants in Holmberg and Foalima, the Gas Company is

not relieved of its restitution responsibility simply because there may have

been more than one cause of the Victims’ economic losses, as there is a

causal connection between those losses and the Gas Company’s failure to

immediately report the release of the toxic substances.

The Victims are entitled to restitution for their economic losses

incurred from the Gas Company’s three-day delay in reporting the gas leak

and the transactionally related ongoing leak described in Count 4. As the

Victims’ counsel argued at the hearing, the Victims’ economic losses began

with the Gas Company’s attempt to keep the blowout secret and continued

with its efforts to minimize the dangers following the eruption of toxic

substances: “I want to be absolutely clear on the record. We are not

conceding that there is no restitution for the three days. Presumably the

requirement that you report to the regulatory agencies, the release of these

substances requires a truthful, an[d] accurate report as to what’s being

released. If the Victims of Porter Ranch had known immediately that

benzene, fluorocarbons, [etc.] that were ultimately disclosed as being

released in those three days, I can tell you that there’s nobody in this

courtroom that wouldn’t have packed up their children and left immediately.

These are known carcinogens. There is no safe amount. There was hydrogen

sulfide that was put onto these homes, if nothing else.” (1 RT 77.)

Page 92: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

92

The Victims’ counsel also stated: “During those three days,

there’s a consequence. The extent of that economic consequence[] is

something the court has to decide. But a good argument can be made for the

fact that had they done their duty, had they followed the law, had they

reported exactly what they released into the environment, all of this damage

would have been prevented because I think the health department would

come in and say—they would red tag all those houses. It was that

dangerous.” (1 RT 77.)

Under any test, the Gas Company should have been ordered to

pay the Victims restitution for the economic losses arising out of the criminal

activity for which the Gas Company was convicted, because that criminal

conduct was indisputably a substantial factor in causing those losses. (See

Martinez, supra, slip. opn. at p. 16 [where defendant’s flight from accident

scene leads to delay in obtaining medical care exacerbating victim’s injuries

or requires tracking defendant down, victim entitled to restitution for those

costs].)

D. The Victims Have A Right To Restitution Because The Gas Company’s Conviction On Count 1 Is Transactionally Related to Count 4

Section 41700(a) prohibits the discharge of air contaminants

that cause injury to a considerable number of persons, endanger the health

and safety of those persons or the public, or that have a tendency to cause

injury or damage to business or property. The Gas Company was charged

with violating this statute in Count 4. In Count 1, the Gas Company was

convicted of failing to report the same release of contaminants into the air

Page 93: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

93

that constituted the violation of Count 4. That is because the Gas Company’s

conduct giving rise to the dismissed Count 4 (discharge of methane, methyl

mercaptan, butyl mercaptan, benzene and butane into the air) was also

involved in the admitted Count 1 (failure to report its release of methane,

methyl mercaptan, butyl mercaptan, benzene and butane). Thus, the two

crimes were transactionally related and the trial court should have ordered

restitution for the Victims’ economic losses for this reason as well. (See

Guevara, supra, 88 Cal.App.3d at pp. 92-94 [possession of shotgun was

involved in kidnapping and thus proper aggravating factor].)

E. The Trial Court Violated The Victims’ Constitutional Right To Restitution

Victims have a constitutional right to reasonable notice and to

reasonably confer with the prosecutor regarding any pretrial disposition.

(Cal. Const., art. 1, §28(b)(6).) Victims of crimes have a due process right

to be heard in proceedings concerning the punishment of the criminals that

victimized them. (In re Vicks (2013) 56 Cal.4th 274, 309-310.) The

California Constitution seeks “to ensure that crime victims are treated with

dignity.” (Id. at p. 310.) Here, the Victims were afforded no such dignity.

The District Attorney’s Office filed a four-count misdemeanor

complaint against the Gas Company, then without notice or conferring with

the Victims of the county’s largest natural gas disaster in history, the District

Attorney’s Office entered into a plea agreement with the Gas Company

deliberately attempting to preclude direct victim restitution to the thousands

of Victims who suffered economic loss because of the gas eruption that

began on October 23, 2015. Lest there be any doubt that the plea agreement

Page 94: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

94

was intended to attempt to preclude direct victim restitution, when the

Victims filed their motion requesting restitution, both the District Attorney’s

Office and the Gas Company opposed it, stating there was no restitution for

the count they chose in the plea agreement.

The District Attorney’s Office also deliberately agreed to make

this a no-probation case, knowing a trial court’s ability to award restitution

would be more expansive under a probationary sentence, and that a referral

to the probation department would have triggered inquiry into restitution.

(Pen. Code, §1203(b)(2)(D), (d), (g) [probation officer’s pre-sentence

investigation report must include information and recommendations

pertaining to victim restitution].)

The Victims’ attorneys had no way to foresee the Gas

Company and the District Attorney’s Office’s attempt to short circuit the

Victims’ constitutionally-guaranteed restitution rights. Shortly after the

complaint was filed, the Victims’ attorneys told the District Attorney’s

Office the Victims wanted restitution, and received assurances that no plea

agreement would be reached that did not include restitution.

Having been frozen out of any restitution discussion before the

plea was taken on September 13, 2016, the Victims turned to the trial court

for relief from this unconstitutional denial of restitution. But the trial court

concluded restitution could not be ordered for the Gas Company’s conviction

and declined to take any other measures to safeguard the Victims’

constitutional right to restitution, including rejecting the plea agreement,

requiring probation as a condition for accepting the agreement, requiring a

Page 95: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

95

Harvey waiver as a condition for accepting the agreement, or retaining

jurisdiction to award restitution at a later time.

Although a trial court ordinarily loses jurisdiction over a

defendant upon sentencing, it must nevertheless retain jurisdiction to impose

and enforce a restitution award. Penal Code §1202.46 provides:

“Notwithstanding Section 1170, when the economic losses of a victim cannot

be ascertained at the time of sentencing pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section

1202.4, the court shall retain jurisdiction over a person subject to a restitution

order for purposes of imposing or modifying restitution until such time as the

losses may be determined. Nothing in this section shall be construed as

prohibiting a victim, the district attorney, or a court on its own motion from

requesting correction, at any time, of a sentence when the sentence is invalid

due to the omission of a restitution order….”

In denying the Victims’ restitution, the trial court abrogated the

Victims’ constitutional rights. The right to restitution “cannot be bargained

away or limited, nor can the prosecution waive the victim’s right to receive

restitution.” (People v. Gross (2015) 238 Cal.App.4th 1313, 1318 (Gross);

see also People v. Brown (2007) 147 Cal.App.4th 1213, 1226 (Brown).) Not

only can the prosecution not bargain away the victim’s right directly, it

cannot do so indirectly as done here by deliberately designing a plea

agreement to foreclose restitution. A “sentence without an award of victim

restitution is invalid.” (Brown, supra, 147 Cal.App.4th at p. 1225.) “Indeed,

on the motion of a victim, a court may at any time correct a sentence that is

rendered invalid due to the omission of a restitution order.” (Gross, supra,

238 Cal.App.4th at p. 1318.) The District Attorney’s Office’s attempt to

Page 96: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595
Page 97: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595
Page 98: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595
Page 99: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

99

SERVICE LIST

Nathan J. Hochman, Esq. Morgan Lewis & Bockius, LLP The Water Garden North 1601 Cloverfield Boulevard, Suite 2050 Santa Monica, CA 90404 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Defendant and Respondent Southern California Gas Company

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Manuel A. Abascal, Esq. Latham & Watkins 355 S. Grand Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90071 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Defendant and Respondent Southern California Gas Company

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Robert J. Nelson, Esq. Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP 275 Battery Street, 30th Floor San Francisco, CA 94111 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Appellants

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Derek W. Loeser, Esq. Keller Rohrback, LLP 1201 Third Avenue, Suite 3200 Seattle, WA 98101 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Appellants

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Raymond P. Boucher, Esq. Boucher LLP 21600 Oxnard Street, Suite 600 Woodland Hills, CA 91367-4903 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Appellants

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Page 100: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

100

Paul R. Kiesel, Esq. Kiesel Law LLP 8648 Wilshire Boulevard Beverly Hills, CA 90211-2910 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Appellants

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Roland K. Tellis, Esq. Baron & Budd, PC 15910 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 1600 Encino, CA 91436 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Appellants

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Taras P. Kick, Esq. The Kick Law Firm, APC 201 Wilshire Boulevard Santa Monica, CA 90401 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Appellants

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Cassandra Hart Thorp, Esq. LA County Deputy District Attorney 210 W. Temple Street, Suite 18000 Los Angeles, CA 90012 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Plaintiff and Respondent the People of the State of California

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Yael A. Massry, Esq. LA County Deputy District Attorney 211 West Temple Street, Suite 1200 Los Angeles, CA 90012 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Plaintiff and Respondent the People of the State of California

via EMAIL and U.S. MAIL

Office of the District Attorney 320 W. Temple Street, Room 540 Los Angeles, CA 90013 Attorneys for Plaintiff and Respondent the People of the State of California

via U.S. MAIL

Page 101: Porter Ranch AOB ACTIVE 06.05 - PARRIS Law · 2 R. Rex Parris (SBN 96567) Patricia K. Oliver (SBN 193423) PARRIS LAW FIRM 43364 10th Street West Lancaster, CA 93534 Tel.: 661.949.2595

101

Office of the Attorney General 300 S. Spring Street, Suite 1700 Los Angeles, CA 90013 Attorneys for Plaintiff and Respondent the People of the State of California

via U.S. MAIL

Clerk for Hon. Alan S. Rosenfield Los Angeles County Superior Court Santa Clarita Courthouse 23747 West Valencia Boulevard, Dept. 3 Santa Clarita, CA 91355

via U.S. MAIL