Populist anger and midterm elections
-
Upload
ourfuture -
Category
News & Politics
-
view
1.548 -
download
0
Transcript of Populist anger and midterm elections
Celinda Lake, Lake Research PartnersWashington, DC | Berkeley, CA | New York, NY| Richmond, VAwww.lakeresearch.com202.776.9066
Populist Anger and the Midterm Elections
A presentation for Campaign for America’s Future
October 13, 2010
2
Key Findings: Political Climate• Voters are highly pessimistic about the direction of the country, dissatisfied with both Parties
in Congress, and angry about the lack of palpable results, especially when it comes to jobs and the economy.
• Republicans hold a significant advantage in voter enthusiasm—especially among young voters, although both Republicans and Democrats in Congress receive low approval ratings.
• Democrats and Republicans are ranked equally on the economy. Voters blame Bush and Wall Street more than Obama, but the election is still being framed as a referendum on the President rather than a choice between the two Parties.
• The economy dominates the issue agenda. This is a jobs recession for men and a pocketbook recession for women, making voters both debt- and tax-sensitive.
• Voters, primarily Republican men, are worried about the deficit and spending. Broader concern stems from people believing a lot of money has been spent with few results.
• Given the economy’s dominance of the issue landscape, progressives can use successful economic frames to set the contrast. We need to offer a credible strategy for re-building the economy, but the emphasis of our message at this point in the cycle must be a clear contrast on the GOP’s record and agenda when it comes to the future direction for the economic well-being of the country and individual American families.
– Key issue contrasts revolve around Social Security, trickle-down economics, and outsourcing of American jobs.
3
More than half of Americans are pessimistic about the direction of the country.
Direction of the Country
Right direction, 36%
Wrong direction, 57%
Don't know, 9%
Source: NBC-Wall Street Journal. September 22-26, 2010. 1000 adults nationwide.
Nationally, voters are mixed on the job President Obama is doing, but they are starting to tilt negative. They are far more unified, however, in their contempt for Congress—two thirds of Americans disapprove of the job Congress is doing with very high intense disapproval.
-3866
46
28
51
59
45
16
35Barack Obama
United StatesCongress
Disapprove Approve
-5
*Politico/GWU Battleground: 1,000 likely voters nationwide – September 22, 2010 (Lake Research/Tarrance Group).
Darker colors = intensity4
Americans have equally unfavorable attitudes toward the two major parties – intensity is key as about four in ten strongly disapprove of the job done by both parties. This dissatisfaction with Washington is the undercurrent of the anti-incumbent mood of the electorate.
57
59
34
2638
43
8
15Democrats inCongress
Republicans inCongress
Disapprove ApproveNot Sure
9
16
*Politico/GWU Battleground: 1,000 likely voters nationwide – September 10, 2010 (Lake Research/Tarrance Group).
Darker colors = intensity5
Contributing to Congress’s low favorability is the fact that over three-fourths of voters believe there is more bickering in Congress than attempts to work together to address important issues facing our nation.
Pew Research/National Journal Poll, 9/30/10-10/3/10
Partisan Bickering in Congress
77%
8%15%
Working together more Same Bickering more
This year, have Republicans and Democrats in Washington been working together more to solve problems OR have
they been bickering and opposing one another more than usual? 6
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
8/5-
8/10
2/1-
3/10
8/6-
9/09
2/9-
12/0
9
8/7-
10/0
8
2/11
-14/
08
9/14
-16/
07
3/11
-14/
07
10/2
0-22
/06
6/1-
4/06
12/5
-8/0
5
6/6-
8/05
12/5
-8/0
4
6/3-
6/04
12/1
1-14
/03
6/12
-15/
03
12/5
-8/0
2
7/9-
11/0
2
1/7-
9/02
8/3-
5/01
2/1-
4/01
1/7-
10/0
0
1/15
-17/
99
9/11
-12/
98
12/1
8-21
/97
2/24
-26/
97
11/2
-4/9
3
Disapprove %
Voters’ ratings of the job Congress is doing are at historic lows.
Source: Gallup Poll. Aug. 5-8, 2010. N=1,013 adults nationwide. MoE ± 4.
7
In a generic ballot, the Republican candidate has a slight lead over the Democratic candidate.
45
52
Democratic candidate Republican candidate
Source: CNN/Opinion Research Corporation. October 5-7, 2010. N=1,008 adults nationwide
8
-7 Democratic candidateAmong blue-collar voters
-20% support the Democratic candidate
-71% who support the Republican candidate
Among white-collar voters
-47% support the Democratic candidate
-50% who support the Republican candidate
The contempt toward Congress is leading to a strong anti-incumbent climate. A solid majority of voters feel it is time to give someone new a chance, and half would vote to replace every single member of Congress.
Defeat and replace every member of Congress, including your own representative?
48 49
Yes No
Congress Re-Elect
11
56
31
Not sure
Give newperson achance
Deserves tobe reelected
NBC News/Wall St. Journal – August 30, 2010
9
Building off the anti-incumbent sentiment, four-in-ten registered voters believe a switch in control of Congress would be a good thing. However, fewer voters believe a change would be a good thing than when Republicans controlled Congress before the 2006 midterm elections.
Would a Switch in Control of Congress Be Good or Bad?
40%
47%
28%23%
October 2010 October 2006
Good Bad
Washington Post/ABC News Poll, 10/3/2010, registered voters.
If control of the Congress switched from the Democrats to the Republicans [Republicans to the Democrats in 2006] after November’s election, do you think that would be a good thing, a bad thing, or wouldn’t it make any difference? 10
-12 -24
11
Another major issue facing progressives this cycle is the shift toward a more conservative electorate as a majority of voters (54%) identify themselves as conservatives. Since 2006, the percentage of voters identifying as conservative has increased while the percentage of voters identifying as moderate or liberal has decreased (by 10 and 3 points, respectively).
Ideology of Likely Voters - 2010
Liberal, 18%Moderate, 27%
Conservative 54%
Source: Gallup. September 23-October 3, 2010. 1,882 likely voters nationwide.
Ideology of Likely Voters - 2006
Liberal, 21%
Moderate, 37%
Conservative 42%
Moreover, Democrats face an enthusiasm gap going into the 2010 midterm elections. Half the battle this cycle will be getting progressives to the polls.
Percent saying they are extremely likely vote in the 2010 midterm elections
69%
56%
70%
Republicans Democrats Independents12
-13
Source: GWU/Politico Battleground Poll. September 19-22, 2010. N=1,000 likely voters nationwide. (Lake Research/Tarrance Group).
13
Contributing to the enthusiasm gap, young voters who turned out in record numbers in 2008 show much less interest in the coming midterm elections.
Pew Research Center Aug 25-Sept 6, 2010, N=2,816 registered voters
Percent giving a lot of thought to the elections53%
50%
42%45%46%
31%
39%
30%29%33%
1994 1998 2002 2006 2010
Over 30 30 and Under
In 2008
Overall: 81% giving a lot of thought to the elections
-Over 30: 83%
-Under 30: 72%
14
This decrease in youth engagement is even more pronounced among young Democrats.
Pew Research Center Aug 25-Sept 6, 2010, N=2,816 registered voters
Democrat/Lean Democratic
43%
53%
43%43%40%
27%
47%
35%31%
25%
1994 1998 2002 2006 2010
Over 30 30 and Under
Percent giving a lot of thought to the elections
Democrat/Lean Democratic
43%
53%
43%43%40%
27%
47%
35%31%
25%
1994 1998 2002 2006 2010
Over 30 30 and Under
Republican/Lean Republican 67%
49%43%
53%53%
39%
31%28%29%31%
1994 1998 2002 2006 2010
Over 30 30 and Under
15
There is a clear enthusiasm gap among most groups that compose the Rising American Electorate—all of which propelled Obama to a decisive win in 2008.
Source: GWU/Politico Battleground Poll. September 19-22, 2010. N=1,000 likely voters nationwide. (Lake Research/Tarrance Group).
58
36
65
63
50
65
64Total
Black
Latino
Women
Men
Under 34
Seniors
Enthusiasm--% Extremely Likely to Vote
Voters who are engaged in this election cycle are thinking with their wallets—meaning a further Republican advantage lies in voters perceiving them as being better to handle controlling wasteful spending, keeping taxes down, and controlling the deficit. Voters do split, however, on who is best to turn the economy around and on creating jobs.
Better to handle . . .
39%
42%
37% 10%
20%
8%
8%
8%53%
28%
26% 10%
Turning theeconomy around
Controllingwasteful spending
Holding down taxes
39%
39%
39% 10%
11%
8%
8%
8%45%
39%
28% 16%
Sharing your values
Creating jobs
Controlling thedeficit
GOP DEM Both Neither Unsure
Source: Politico/GWU Battleground. September 7-9, 2010. N= 1,000 likely voters nationwide. (Lake Research/Tarrance Group).
Margin (Dem minus Rep)
-2
-14
-27
0
0
-1716
17
Additionally, a majority of Americans see the economy as either staying the same or getting worse.
State of the National Economy
72%72%66%66%65%
69%
58%56%
69%66%71%73%
77%
91%
27%27%32%32%32%29%
36%41%
33%
23%26%20%
68%60%
67%65% 68%65%
4%
26%30%
39%
29%31%26%
31%
SeptemberAugustJulyJuneMayApri lMarchFebJanDecNovOctSeptAugJulyJuneMayApri lMarchFebruary
The Same or Worse
Better
Source: http://americanresearchgroup.com/economy/
18
It’s the economy, stupid! In this issue climate, it is hard for other issues to break through.
11
10
9
9
6
3
1
1
1
49The economy
The federal budget deficit
Education
Health Care
The wars in Iraq/Afghanistan
Illegal immigration
Terrorism
Energy and environmental policies
Other
Unsure
Source: CNN/ Opinion Research Poll. September 21-23, 2010. N= 1,010 adults nationwide.
19
Unemployment tops the list of economic issues, followed by the budget deficit and taxes.
18
8
7
6
2
1
1
57Unemployment
The federal budget deficit
Taxes
Mortgages and housing costs
Inflation
Stock Market
(Other)
No Opinion
Source: CNN/ Opinion Research Poll. September 21-23, 2010. N= 1,010 adults nationwide.
A quarter of voters blame Bush for the current economy, while one in five blame Wall Street.
Most Responsible for Current National Economy
8
10
11
15
20
25
Normal economic cycle
Global economic forces
Barack Obama
U.S. Congress
Large financial firms
George W. Bush
Source: Politico/GWU Battleground. September 7-9, 2010. N= 1,000 likely voters nationwide. (Lake Research/Tarrance Group).
20
Among Independents
-27% Large financial firms
-13% George W. Bush
-13% Global economic forces
-11% Congress
-6% Normal economic cycle
-6% Barack Obama
The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are seen as most responsible for the growth of the federal deficit over the past few years.
Most responsible for growth of federal deficit
6
8
28
29
31
36
49
The cost of the Medicare Prescription Drugbenefit
The economic recession that cut tax revenue andrequired support for the unemployed
President Obama's economic recovery orstimulus plan
Bush tax cuts for corporations and top earners
Lobbyists and special interests puttingunneeded spending in the budget
Bailouts of big banks and auto industry
Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan
Source: Democracy Corps, Campaign for America's Future. July 26-29, 2010. N=1,100 likely voters nationwide . (Greenburg Quinlan Rosner)
21
A plurality of Americans are dissatisfied with the way the federal government works, and another one in four are angry.
2
20
52
25
Enthusiastic Satisfied Dissatisfied Angry
22
77
Source: Washington Post/ABC. Aug 30-Sep 2, 2010. N=1,002 adults nationwide.
22
The public expresses discontent with many major institutions. Within the context of elevated economic anxiety, banks, Congress, HMOs, organized labor and big business receive the highest criticism.
Views of Institutions
19% 19%11%
20%22%23%25%27%34%36%36%
40%48%
59%66%
76%
The
mili
tary
Smal
lbu
sines
s
The
polic
e
The
chur
ch o
ror
gani
zed
relig
ion
The
med
ical
syst
emTh
e U.
S.Su
prem
eCo
urt
The
pres
iden
cy
The
publ
icsc
hool
s
The
crim
inal
just
ice
syst
em
New
spap
ers
Bank
s
Tele
visio
nne
ws
Org
anize
dla
bor
Big
busin
ess
Heal
thM
anag
emen
tO
rgan
izatio
ns
Cong
ress
Source: Gallup, July 8-11, 2010, N=1,020.
23
While three-in-five voters feel the government should still play an active role in the economy, half of those voters are not sure they can trust the government to be effective.
Allstate/National Journal Heartland Monitor Poll, Apr, 2010
Government's Role in the Economic Situation
32%33%
28%
Government is not the solution Government should play an activerole, but can't trust
Government should play an activerole
Which of the following comes closest to your view regarding the proper role of government in the economy?...In the current economic environment, government is not the solution to our economic problems, government is the problem. I would like to see government play an active role in the economy to ensure it benefits people like me, but I am not sure that I can trust government to do this effectively. In the current economic environment, the government must play an active role in regulating the marketplace and ensuring that the economy benefits people like me.
60%
24
This perception of a bleak economy comes from voters’ personal lives: a majority says its personal economic situation is only fair or poor.
Personal Economic Situation
6%
38%
58%
20%
Excellent/Good Only Fair/Poor
Source: Pew Research Center/National Journal Congressional Connection Poll, June 3 - 6, 2010, N=1,002.
*Darker colors indicate intensity
How would you rate your own personal economic financial situation? Would you say you are in excellent shape, good shape, only fair shape, or poor shape financially?
25
Strong majorities believe those at either end of the age spectrum and unmarried women are most likely to have trouble making ends meet. Majorities also believe that working and middle class families have trouble making ends meet, but these views are less intense.
Trouble Making Ends Meet
43%
53%
53%
56%
41%
36%
37%
44%
82%
85%
85%
71%
84%
82%
79%
76%
Women
Latinos or Hispanics
Middle-class families
Working families
Blacks or African Ams
Unmarried women
Senior citizens
Young adults
A lot Some
From your perspective, how much trouble making ends meet do you think each of the following groups faces: a lot of trouble, some, a little, or no trouble at all?*
Source: Wider Opportunities for Women. 1,000 adults nationwide, with oversamples of 100 African-American adults, 100 Latino adults, and 100 adults with incomes $10,000-15,000 annually. May 20-27, 2010. (Lake Research Partners)
26
Ten years ago, about three-in-ten Americans reported that they were living paycheck-to-paycheck all or most of the time. Last year, that number increased to four-in-ten, and now it’s up to 44%. The current data shows that it is also more common for women (47%) to be living paycheck-to-paycheck than it is for men (40%).
Frequency of Living Paycheck to Paycheck*
-22%
-21%
-20%
-24%
-17%
-15%
15%
23%
24%
-58%
-71%
-54%
39%
28%
44%
2000
2009
2010
Never Hardly ever/once in a while Sometimes/Some of the time Always/All of the time Most of the time
Consumer Federation of America/Bank of America: September 11-November 11, 2000 (1,637 adults nationwide); Newsweek: January 14-January 15, 2009 (1,200 adults nationwide); LRP survey for Community Voices: January-February 2010 (1,000 adults nationwide,100 Latinas, 100 African American women, 100 single mothers, 200 low-income women)
* Note wording change in answer categories.
27
Nearly two-thirds of Americans say either they, a family member, or someone they know well has lost a job in the past year. Nearly as many Americans say they have been impacted by a reduction in wages or hours, with a strong majority saying they, a family member, or someone they know well has experienced this hardship in the past year.
Impact of the Recession
63%58%
33%38%
Loss of a job Reduced wages or hours
Impacted you, a family member or someone you know well Has not impacted
Democracy Corps Poll, September 2010. N=1000 voters ntationwide.
I'm going to read you a list of economic experiences some people have recently had. For each one, please tell me if you have directly experienced this in the last year, if your family has directly experienced this in the last year, or if someoneyou know well, like a friend, neighbor or co-worker, has experienced this or if no one you know well has experienced it.
Impacted you personally: 12%
Impacted a family member: 23%
Impacted you personally: 15%
Impacted a family member: 23%
28
29
Job loss, reduced wages, or lost health insurance have impacted a significant portion of voters—especially younger, blue-collar voters.
Have you or your family...
41%
59%
39%44%
51%
38%
28%
34%
27%
Total Blue-collar White voters,younger than 50
Blue-collar White voters, 50or older
Lost job
Reduced wagesLost health ins.
Democracy Corps, August 2010
30
Six-in-ten Americans are concerned about job loss in the next twelve months, and three in ten are very concerned about it.
CBS News Poll, July 2010, N=966.
Job Loss Concern
39%
31% 29%
Very concerned Somewhat concerned Not concerned at all
60% concerned
How concerned are you that in the next 12 months you or someone else in your household might be out of work and looking for a job--very concerned, somewhat concerned, or not concerned at all?
A third of Americans think the stimulus was too large, and nearly half think it has had no impact on the economy so far.
Government's Stimulus Package
27% 28%
11%
34%
Toolarge
Notlarge
enough
Aboutright
Don'tknow
Stimulus Impact on Economy
4%
46%
20%
30%
Don'tknow
No impact
Made itWorse
Made itBetter
CBS News/New York Times: 990 adults nationwide – September 10-14, 2010 31
Message and Positioning
Message Themes for Progressives
Approaches to Use Approaches to AvoidGentle and realistic optimism; we have a difficult road ahead, but we’re starting to
take the steps we need.
Over-selling the accomplishments of Democrats in office.
Populist language. Government should work for regular families, not multi-millionaires
and CEOs.
Talking about the “less fortunate,” government programs to help those in need.
Righteous indignation based on the American values of fairness and opportunity. Make the wealthy pay their fair share, shift
the burden off of the middle class, allow that everyone has the opportunity to
succeed.
Accepting frames of debate based on smaller questions. Instead of talking about
whether business should have emissions regulated, talk about the right to clean air and water, and the principle that polluters
should pay to clean up their mess.
A willingness to fight for what’s right and take a stand, even if it’s politically unpopular.
Talking about policy minutia or using acronyms.
33
Words Matter
Working Families
Guaranteed, Quality,
Affordable Health Care
Manufacturing Jobs in Clean
EnergyGreen Jobs
Universal Coverage
The Middle Class
34
Words to Use Words to AvoidEveryone paying their fair share Taxes
Making the economy work for working families Welfare and subsidies
Getting and keeping good-paying jobs Incentivizing development
Making sure our workers are trained for 21st-century jobs Funding technical education
Accountability Regulations
Rooting out waste Cutting programs
Government that serves everyone, not CEOs and multimillionaires Government programs
Get rid of tricky loopholes and hidden fees Banking regulations
Words That Work: The Economy
People vs. Banks and CEOsA useful frame:
35
Americans respond to messages that evoke achieving the American Dream and strengthening the middle class.
36
52%
52%
53% 76%
79%
82%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%
Recapturing American Dream-w/Seniors*
Strengthen Middle Class*
Recapturing the American Dream -w/o Seniors*
Very convincing Somewhat convincing
Top messages on the economy emphasize broad themes, such as recapturing the American Dream and strengthening and building the middle class.
TEXT OF MESSAGES
• [Recapturing the American Dream – Family Economic Security without seniors] The American Dream is about having family economic security and the opportunity to succeed with hard work. In this country we work hard as individuals to get ahead for ourselves and our families and to provide a better chance for the next generation. Family economic security is about a good-paying, secure job, affordable healthcare, and a secure retirement. It’s about more than living paycheck to paycheck. We need to build the middle class and recapture the American Dream by creating good-paying, secure jobs, providing affordable, quality healthcare, and investing in education and training.
• [Strengthen and Build to the Middle Class] The current economic downturn has hit working families the hardest and the longest. Even as they continue to work hard and act responsibly, more and more families are living paycheck to paycheck and are increasingly on the edge of economic crisis. Our economy will only be strong again when our working and middle class families are strong. This means not only helping middle class families reclaim their sense of economic security and strengthening the middle class, but also helping low-income and working families move into the middle class through jobs that come with good wages, benefits, and secure retirement.
• [Recapturing the American Dream – Economic Security w/ Seniors] The American Dream is about having family economic security and the opportunity to succeed with hard work. In this country, we work hard as individuals to get ahead for ourselves and our families and to provide a better chance for the next generation. Family economic security is about a good-paying, secure job, affordable healthcare, and a secure retirement. It’s about more than living paycheck to paycheck. We need to build the middle class, protect our senior citizens who have worked hard all their lives, and recapture the American Dream by creating good, secure jobs, providing affordable, quality healthcare, and investing in education and training.
37
Voters respond to messages that reflect voters’ core beliefs about Social Security: it belongs to the people and represents a promise made to all generations that must be protected and paid back.
38
64%
66%
69%
80%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%
*Other priorities/WallStreet
*Broken promise
*Prioritize paying SS backfirst/bailout
*Belongs to the people
Five: Represents your values extremely well
*Split-sampled questions: On a scale that goes from 0 to 5, where 0 means it doesn’t represent your values and positions at all and 5 means it represents your values and positions extremely well, how well does this statement represent your values and positions.
The messages that resonate most with voters reflect their core attitudes about Social Security: it belongs to the people and represents a promise made to all generations that must be protected and paid back.TEXT OF MESSAGES
• [Belongs to the people] Social Security moneys belong to the people who have worked hard all their lives and contributed to the program, not to the government. We must protect Social Security from cuts that will hurt beneficiaries, we cannot let Congress try to use Social Security as a piggy bank. (80% saying “5: represents values extremely well”)
• [Prioritize paying back SS first/bailout] Social Security has a funding gap in the future and that gap needs to be closed. The disagreement in Washington is what to do about it. The answer is pretty clear: The federal government has to pay back the $2.6 trillion it took from the Social Security trust fund. Before Congress even thinks about cutting Social Security benefits, the government must pay back the money it owes the trust fund. We cannot accept that the government has the money to bail out Wall Street banks, but not to pay back Social Security. (69% saying “5: represents values extremely well”)
• [Broken promise] Social Security is a promise made to all generations to provide a basic and reliable income for when they retire, become widowed or disabled, or leave loved ones behind. Americans need to know the promise of Social Security will continue to be met for them. This is one promise we cannot allow Congress to break. We need to make sure we continue to support Social Security without making cuts that will harm current and future generations (Broken Promise: 66% saying “5: represents values extremely well”)
• [Other priorities/Wall Street] Washington should be thinking about getting Americans back to work, protecting Americans from predatory lenders and changing unscrupulous business practices on Wall Street. We shouldn’t expect middle and low income Americans, in the middle of the largest recession since the 1930’s, to have their Social Security cut. We should ask Wall Street bankers to give back their bonuses and we should put a tax on Wall Street, not cut Social Security benefits. (64% saying “5: represents values extremely well”) 39
Celinda Lake, Lake Research PartnersWashington, DC | Berkeley, CA | New York, NY| Richmond, VAwww.lakeresearch.com202.776.9066
Populist Anger and the Midterm Elections
A presentation for the Campaign for America’s Future
October 13, 2010