Pope & Videla - checking social media

52
POPE & VIDELA March 19, 2013 - Excerpt of workshop RTL Nieuws, Hilversum, The Netherlands Thursday, March 21, 13

description

You have only 30 minutes to check out if photo's and articles about the new Pope are true. How do you proceed? Fact checking in social media, case study for news station RTL Nieuws, part of workshop Henk van Ess

Transcript of Pope & Videla - checking social media

Page 1: Pope & Videla - checking social media

POPE & VIDELAMarch 19, 2013 - Excerpt of workshop RTL Nieuws, Hilversum, The Netherlands

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 2: Pope & Videla - checking social media

HENK VAN ESS@henkvaness

POPE & VIDELAMarch 19, 2013 - Excerpt of workshop RTL Nieuws, Hilversum, The Netherlands

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 3: Pope & Videla - checking social media

HENK VAN ESS@henkvaness

POPE & VIDELAMarch 19, 2013 - Excerpt of workshop RTL Nieuws, Hilversum, The Netherlands

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 4: Pope & Videla - checking social media

SERIOUS SOCIAL MEDIA

HENK VAN ESS@henkvaness

POPE & VIDELAMarch 19, 2013 - Excerpt of workshop RTL Nieuws, Hilversum, The Netherlands

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 5: Pope & Videla - checking social media

SERIOUS SOCIAL MEDIA

HENK VAN ESS@henkvaness

POPE & VIDELAMarch 19, 2013 - Excerpt of workshop RTL Nieuws, Hilversum, The Netherlands

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 6: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 7: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 8: Pope & Videla - checking social media

?

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 9: Pope & Videla - checking social media

You get 4 clues

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 10: Pope & Videla - checking social media

CLUE 1

Source: The Guardian

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 11: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 12: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Enough people tweeted it

CLUE 2

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 13: Pope & Videla - checking social media

CLUE 3

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 14: Pope & Videla - checking social media

CLUE 4

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 15: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 16: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Dutch newspaper: Pope already discredited

March 15Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 17: Pope & Videla - checking social media

One day later:

Sorry! Not true!

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 18: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 19: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Sorry, butthe sourceswere good!

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 20: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Social media research

Where the sourcesreally that good?

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 21: Pope & Videla - checking social media

CLUE 1

Source: The Guardian

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 22: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Opinionated

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 23: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Opinionated

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 24: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Opinionated

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 25: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 26: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Enough people tweeted it

CLUE 2

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 27: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Nonsense can be tweeted by thousands

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 28: Pope & Videla - checking social media

CLUE 3

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 29: Pope & Videla - checking social media

TIP

Find quotes ABOUT, not FROM

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 30: Pope & Videla - checking social media

TIP

Find quotes ABOUT, not FROM

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 31: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 32: Pope & Videla - checking social media

CLUE 4

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 33: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Check!

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 34: Pope & Videla - checking social media

TIP

images.google.com

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 35: Pope & Videla - checking social media

TIP

images.google.com

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 36: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 37: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 38: Pope & Videla - checking social media

The Source

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 39: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Was the pope in 1990 in Buenos Aires?

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 40: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Vatican.va

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 41: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Cordoba

>700 km

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 42: Pope & Videla - checking social media

TIP

Double check

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 43: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Youtube

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 44: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 45: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Tip

Find people whosupport your doubts

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 46: Pope & Videla - checking social media

false OR falsely OR fake photo "jorge videla" "jorge bergoglio"

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 47: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Translate this!

French, SpanishThursday, March 21, 13

Page 48: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 49: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Or checkon words

like “hoax”

“blunder”“not true”

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 50: Pope & Videla - checking social media

March 15 March 14 !

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 51: Pope & Videla - checking social media

Conclusion

This story could be debunked in time

Thursday, March 21, 13

Page 52: Pope & Videla - checking social media

@henkvaness@searchbistro

Thursday, March 21, 13