7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

1/20

6:33

X@VE ZCZ@V

@BLOB@@VOBL XM@VEK H_BCEOAQ

Ev" Xpd`qm Qkbo

IQ@%F

Ev"Z V Vcecb

Vkii bk7%VF8?36F1

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

2/20

CADBK\I@HL@E@BX

O xcd` xmoq kzzkvxpboxy xk zv`q`bx ey ~kx`q kn xmcbdq xk cii xmkq` lpoh`zkqx |mk

v`ciiy cax`h cq iolmx`bobl zoiicvq xk `biolmx`b kpv |cy xmvkplmkpx xmoq zvkg`ax

xmcx mcq i`h xk qpaa`qqnpi cbh qcxoqncaxkvy akezi`xokb kn xmoq qxphy" \` cv`

v`ciiy lvcx`npi xk kpv MKH Ev" Lpvzv``x qoblm zmpii nkv zvk~ohobl pq |oxm cb

kzzkvxpboxy xk pbh`vxcd` xmoq zvkg`ax ob xmoq pbo~`vqoxy cbh zvk~ohobl pq |oxm cii

xm` ncaoioxo`q" \` cv` molmiy xmcbdnpi xk Ev"Xpd`qm qkbo nkv m`v caxo~` qpzzkvx)

~cipcfi` xoe` cbh ch~oa`) |mki`%m`cvx`h lpohcba`) qoba`v` akkz`vcxokb cbh

zcobq%xcdobl ob~ki~`e`bx hpvobl xm` qxphy cbh ob akezi`xobl xm` cqqolbe`bx kn

zv`zcvobl xm` qcoh zvkg`ax |oxmob xm` xoe` qxozpicx`h" Icqxiy) \` cv` xmcbdnpi xk

cii xmkq`) zcvxoapicviy xm` ~cvokpq nvo`bhq ) |mk mc~` f``b obqxvpe`bxci ob

av`cxobl zvkz`v) m`cixmy cbh akbhpaxo~` `b~ovkbe`bx cbh obaiphobl b`| cbh

nv`qm obbk~cxo~` oh`cq nkv pq hpvobl xm` zvkg`ax) xm`ov m`iz) ox |kpih mc~` f``b

`}xv`e`iy honnoapix nkv pq xk zv`zcv` xm` zvkg`ax ob c xoe` fkpbh nvce`|kvd"

ECBOQM DPECV

:6+:8+6:33

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

3/20

Xcfi` kn akbx`bx

3" Cfqxvcax6" Moqxkvy kn zkiye`v np`ii a`ii1" Zkiye`v `}amcbl` e`efvcb`8" Zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i a`ii h`qolb oqqp`q0" Qao`ba` kn Z@E np`i a`ii>" Acxciyqx v`q`cvam

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

4/20

Cfqxvcax

Zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb` -Z@E/ np`i a`iiqciqk acii`h zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i

a`iiqh`io~`v molmzk|`v h`bqoxy cbh knn`v xm` ch~cbxcl`q kn ik| |`olmx cbh ~kipe`)

akezcv`h |oxm kxm`v np`i a`iiq" Z@E np`i a`iiq pq` c qkioh zkiye`v cq cb `i`axvkiyx` cbh

zkvkpq acvfkb `i`axvkh`q akbxcobobl c zicxobpe acxciyqx" Xm`y b``h kbiy myhvkl`b) k}yl`b

nvke xm` cov) cbh |cx`v xk kz`vcx` cbh hk bkx v`spov` akvvkqo~` nipohq iod` qke` np`i a`iiq"

Xm`y cv` xyzoaciiy np`i`h |oxm zpv` myhvkl`b qpzzio`h nvke qxkvcl` xcbdq kv kbfkcvh

v`nkve`vq"Zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb` np`i a`iiq kz`vcx` cx v`icxo~`iy ik| x`ez`vcxpv`q)

cvkpbh =:A -3N/" Ik|x`ez`vcxpv` kz`vcxokb ciik|q xm`e xk qxcvx spoadiy -i`qq |cvepz

xoe`/ cbh v`qpixq ob i`qq |`cv kb qyqx`e akezkb`bxq) v`qpixobl ob f`xx`v hpvcfoioxy" Mk|`~`v)

ox v`spov`q xmcx c bkfi`e`xci acxciyqx -xyzoaciiy zicxobpe/ f` pq`h xk q`zcvcx` xm` myhvkl`b,q

`i`axvkbq cbh zvkxkbq) chhobl xk qyqx`e akqx" Xm` zicxobpe acxciyqx oq ciqk `}xv`e`iy

q`bqoxo~` xk AK zkoqkbobl) ecdobl ox b`a`qqcvy xk `eziky cb chhoxokbci v`caxkv xk v`hpa` AK

ob xm` np`i lcq on xm` myhvkl`b oq h`vo~`h nvke cb ciakmki kv myhvkacvfkb np`i" Xmoq ciqk chhqakqx" H`~`ikz`vq cv` apvv`bxiy `}zikvobl zicxobpe+vpxm`bope acxciyqxq xmcx cv` ekv` v`qoqxcbx

xk AK"Z@E np`i a`iiq cv` pq`h zvoecvoiy nkv xvcbqzkvxcxokb czzioacxokbq cbh qke` qxcxokbcvy

czzioacxokbq" Hp` xk xm`ov ncqx qxcvxpz xoe`) ik| q`bqoxo~oxy xk kvo`bxcxokb) cbh nc~kvcfi`

zk|`vxk|`olmx vcxok) Z@E np`i a`iiq cv` zcvxoapicviy qpoxcfi` nkv pq` ob zcqq`bl`v ~`moai`q)

qpam cq acvq cbh fpq`q"

C qolbonoacbx fcvvo`v xk pqobl xm`q` np`i a`iiq ob ~`moai`q oq myhvkl`b qxkvcl`" Ekqx np`i a`ii

~`moai`q -NA^q/ zk|`v`h fy zpv` myhvkl`b epqx qxkv` xm` myhvkl`b kbfkcvh cq c

akezv`qq`h lcq ob zv`qqpvow`h xcbdq" Hp` xk xm` ik|`b`vly h`bqoxy kn myhvkl`b) ox oq

honnoapix xk qxkv` `bkplm myhvkl`b kbfkcvh xk ciik| ~`moai`q xk xvc~`i xm` qce` hoqxcba` cq

lcqkiob`zk|`v`h ~`moai`q f`nkv` v`np`iobl) xyzoaciiy 1::8:: eoi`q" Molm`vh`bqoxy iospoh

np`iq) qpam cq e`xmcbki) `xmcbki) bcxpvci lcq) iosp`no`h z`xvki`pe lcq) cbh lcqkiob`) acb f`

pq`h nkv np`i) fpx xm` ~`moai`q epqx mc~` cb kbfkcvh np`i zvka`qqkv xk v`nkve xm` e`xmcbki xk

myhvkl`b" Xmoq v`spov`e`bx obav`cq`q akqxq cbh ecobx`bcba`" Xm` v`nkve`v ciqk v`i`cq`q

acvfkb hok}oh` -c lv``bmkpq` lcq/) xmkplm i`qq xmcb xmcx `eoxx`h nvke apvv`bx lcqkiob`

zk|`v`h `blob`q"

Moqxkvy

F`nkv` xm` ob~`bxokb kn Z@E np`i a`iiq) `}oqxobl np`i a`ii xyz`q qpam cq qkiohk}oh` np`i

a`iiq |`v` kbiy czzio`h ob `}xv`e` akbhoxokbq" Qpam np`i a`iiq ciqk v`spov`h ~`vy `}z`bqo~`

ecx`vociq cbh akpih kbiy f` pq`h nkv qxcxokbcvy czzioacxokbq hp` xk xm`ov qow`" Xm`q` oqqp`q

|`v` chhv`qq`h fy xm` Z@E np`i a`ii" Xm` Z@E np`i a`ii |cq ob~`bx`h ob xm` `cviy 3?>:q fy

\oiicvh Xmkecq Lvpff cbh I`kbcvh Bo`hvcam kn L`b`vci @i`axvoa" Oboxociiy) qpinkbcx`h

zkiyqxyv`b` e`efvcb`q |`v` pq`h nkv `i`axvkiyx`q) fpx xm`y |`v` v`zica`h ob 3?>>

fy Bcnokb okbke`v) |moam zvk~`h xk f` qpz`vokv ob z`vnkvecba` cbh hpvcfoioxy xk qpinkbcx`h

zkiyqxyv`b`"

Z@E np`i a`iiq |`v` pq`h ob xm` BCQC L`eobo q`vo`q kn qzca`avcnx) fpx xm`y |`v` v`zica`hfy Cidciob` np`i a`iiq ob xm` Czkiik zvklvce cbh ob xm` Qzca` qmpxxi"

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

5/20

Zcvcii`i |oxm Zvcxx cbh \moxb`y Covavcnx) L`b`vci @i`axvoa h`~`ikz`h xm` novqx zvkxkb

`}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i a`iiq -Z@ENAq/ nkv xm` L`eobo qzca` eoqqokbq ob xm` `cviy 3?>:q"

Xm` novqx eoqqokb xk pxoiow` Z@ENAq |cq L`eobo ^" Mk|`~`v) xm` Czkiik qzca` eoqqokbq cbh

qpfq`sp`bx CzkiikQkypw) Qdyicf cbh Qzca` Qmpxxi` eoqqokbq pxoiow`h np`i a`iiq fcq`h kb

Fcakb,q h`qolb) h`~`ikz`h fy Zvcxx cbh \moxb`y Covavcnx"

@}xv`e`iy `}z`bqo~` ecx`vociq |`v` pq`h cbh xm` np`i a`iiq v`spov`h ~`vy zpv` myhvkl`b cbh

k}yl`b" @cviy np`i a`iiq x`bh`h xk v`spov` obakb~`bo`bxiy molm kz`vcxobl x`ez`vcxpv`q xmcx

|`v` c zvkfi`e ob ecby czzioacxokbq" Mk|`~`v) np`i a`iiq |`v` q``b xk f` h`qovcfi` hp` xk xm`

icvl` cekpbxq kn np`i c~coicfi` -myhvkl`b cbh k}yl`b/"

H`qzox` xm`ov qpaa`qq ob qzca` zvklvceq) np`i a`ii qyqx`eq |`v` ioeox`h xk qzca` eoqqokbq cbh

kxm`v qz`aoci czzioacxokbq) |m`v` molm akqx akpih f` xki`vcx`h" Ox |cq bkx pbxoi xm` icx` 3?=:q

cbh `cviy 3??:q xmcx np`i a`iiq f`ace` c v`ci kzxokb nkv |oh`v czzioacxokb fcq`" Q`~`vcizo~kxci obbk~cxokbq) qpam cq ik| zicxobpe acxciyqx ikchobl cbh xmob noie `i`axvkh`q) hvk~` xm`

akqx kn np`i a`iiq hk|b) ecdobl h`~`ikze`bx kn Z@ENA qyqx`eq ekv` v`cioqxoa" Mk|`~`v)

xm`v` oq qolbonoacbx h`fcx` cq xk |m`xm`v myhvkl`b np`i a`iiq |oii f` c v`cioqxoa x`ambkikly nkv

pq` ob cpxkekfoi`q kv kxm`v ~`moai`q""

\mcx oq Zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` ;

C zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` kv zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb` -Z@E/ oqc q`eoz`ve`cfi` e`efvcb` l`b`vciiy ech` nvke okbke`vq cbh h`qolb`h xk akbhpax

zvkxkbq |moi` f`obl oez`ve`cfi` xk lcq`q qpam cq k}yl`b kv myhvkl`b" Xmoq oq xm`ov `qq`bxoci

npbaxokb |m`b obakvzkvcx`h obxk c e`efvcb` `i`axvkh` cqq`efiy -E@C/ kn c zvkxkb

`}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i a`ii kv kn c zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` `i`axvkiyq`v 7 q`zcvcxokb kn

v`caxcbxq cbh xvcbqzkvx kn zvkxkbq"

Z@Eq acb f` ech` nvke `oxm`v zpv` zkiye`v e`efvcb`q kv nvke akezkqox` e`efvcb`q

|m`v` kxm`v ecx`vociq cv` `ef`hh`h ob c zkiye`v ecxvo}" Kb` kn xm` ekqx akeekb cbh

akee`vaociiy c~coicfi` Z@E ecx`vociq oq Bcnokb) c HpZkbx zvkhpax" \moi` Bcnokb oq cbokbke`v |oxm c z`vnipkvobcx`h fcadfkb` iod` X`nikb) xm`v` cv` ecby kxm`v qxvpaxpvci ekxonq

pq`h xk ecd` okbke`vq nkv zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb`q" Ecby pq` zkiycvkecxoa zkiye`vq

|moi` kxm`vq pq` zcvxociiy nipkvobcx`h zkiye`vq"

Zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb`q cv` zvoecvoiy amcvcax`vow`h fy

zvkxkb akbhpaxo~oxy -/) e`xmcbki z`ve`cfoioxy -Z/) cbh xm`veci qxcfoioxy"

Zvkxkb @}amcbl` E`efvcb` Np`i A`iiq -Z@ENA/ cv` f`io`~`h xk f` xm` f`qx xyz` kn np`i a`ii

cq xm` ~`moapicv zk|`v qkpva` xk `~`bxpciiy v`zica` xm` lcqkiob` cbh ho`q`i obx`vbci

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

6/20

akefpqxokb `blob`q" Novqx pq`h ob xm` 3?>:q nkv xm` BCQC L`eobo zvklvce) Z@ENAq cv`

apvv`bxiy f`obl h`~`ikz`h cbh h`ekbqxvcx`h nkv qyqx`eq vcblobl nvke 3\ xk 6d\"

Z@E np`i a`iiq pq` c qkioh zkiye`v e`efvcb` -c xmob zicqxoa noie/ cq xm` `i`axvkiyx`" Xmoq

zkiye`v oq z`ve`cfi` xk zvkxkbq |m`b ox oq qcxpvcx`h |oxm |cx`v) fpx ox hk`q bkx akbhpax`i`axvkbq"

Xm` np`i nkv xm` Z@ENA oq myhvkl`b cbh xm` amcvl` acvvo`v oq xm` myhvkl`b okb -zvkxkb/" Cx

xm` cbkh`) xm` myhvkl`b eki`api` oq qziox obxk myhvkl`b okbq -zvkxkbq/ cbh `i`axvkbq" Xm`

myhvkl`b okbq z`ve`cx` cavkqq xm` `i`axvkiyx` xk xm` acxmkh` |moi` xm` `i`axvkbq nik| xmvkplm

cb `}x`vbci aovapox cbh zvkhpa` `i`axvoa zk|`v" K}yl`b) pqpciiy ob xm` nkve kn cov) oq qpzzio`h

xk xm` acxmkh` cbh akefob`q |oxm xm` `i`axvkbq cbh xm` myhvkl`b okbq xk zvkhpa` |cx`v" Xm`

v`caxokbq cx xm` `i`axvkh`q cv` cq nkiik|q7

Cbkh` V`caxokbq7 6M6 52 8M$ $ 8` Acxmkh` V`caxokbq7 K6 $ 8M$ $ 8` 52 6 M6K K~`vcii

A`ii V`caxokbq7 6M6 $ K6 52 6 M6K

Zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i a`iiq

Ob xm` cvam`xyzoaci myhvkl`bk}yl`b zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i a`ii -Z@ENA/ h`qolb)

c zvkxkbakbhpaxobl zkiye`v e`efvcb`) -xm` `i`axvkiyx`/) q`zcvcx`q

xm` cbkh` cbh acxmkh` qoh`q" Xmoq |cq acii`h c &qkioh zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` np`i a`ii& -QZ@NA/

ob xm` `cviy 3?

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

7/20

xm` Z@ENA cbh pqpciiy ech` kn c zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` qcbh|oam`h f`x|``b

x|k acxciyqx akcx`h acvfkb zcz`vq" Zicxobpe cbh+kv qoeoicv xyz` kn bkfi` e`xciq cv` pqpciiy

pq`h cq xm` acxciyqx nkv Z@ENA" Xm` `i`axvkiyx` akpih f` c zkiye`v e`efvcb`"

Zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb` np`i a`ii h`qolb oqqp`q

Akqxq" Ob 6::6) xyzoaci np`i a`ii qyqx`eq akqx PQ(3::: z`v doik|cxx kn `i`axvoa zk|`v

kpxzpx" Ob 6::?) xm` H`zcvxe`bx kn @b`vly v`zkvx`h xmcx =:d\ cpxkekxo~` np`i a`ii

qyqx`e akqxq ob ~kipe` zvkhpaxokb -zvkg`ax`h xk 0::)::: pboxq z`v y`cv/ cv` (>3 z`v

doik|cxx" Xm` lkci oq (10 z`v doik|cxx" Ob 6::= PXA Zk|`v mcq 8:: d\ qxcxokbcvy np`i

a`iiq nkv (3):::)::: z`v 8:: d\ obqxcii`h akqxq" Xm` lkci oq xk v`hpa` xm` akqx ob kvh`v xkakez`x` |oxm apvv`bx ecvd`x x`ambkiklo`q obaiphobl lcqkiob` obx`vbci akefpqxokb

`blob`q" Ecby akezcbo`q cv` |kvdobl kb x`ambosp`q xk v`hpa` akqx ob c ~cvo`xy kn |cyq

obaiphobl v`hpaobl xm` cekpbx kn zicxobpe b``h`h ob `cam obho~ohpci a`ii" Fciicvh Zk|`v

Qyqx`eq mc~` `}z`voe`bxq |oxm c acxciyqx `bmcba`h |oxm acvfkb qoid |moam ciik|q c 1:%

v`hpaxokb -3 el+ae xk :"< el+ae/ ob zicxobpe pqcl` |oxmkpx v`hpaxokb ob

z`vnkvecba`" Ekbcqm Pbo~`vqoxy) E`ifkpvb` pq`q Z@HKX cq c acxmkh`" C 6:33

zpfioqm`h qxphy"hkape`bx`h xm` novqx `~`v e`xci nv`` `i`axvkacxciyqx pqobl v`icxo~`iy

ob`}z`bqo~` hkz`h acvfkb bcbkxpf`q xmcx cv` i`qq xmcb 3% xm` akqx kn zicxobpe cbh cv` kn

`spci kv qpz`vokv z`vnkvecba`"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalysthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_paperhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinumhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinumhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_paperhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalyst

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

8/20

Xm` zvkhpaxokb akqxq kn xm` Z@E -zvkxkb `}amcbl` e`efvcb`/" Xm` Bcnokb e`efvcb`

apvv`bxiy akqxq (0>>+e" Ob 6::0 Fciicvh Zk|`v Qyqx`eq cbbkpba`h xmcx oxq np`i a`iiq |oii

pq` Qkipzkv) c zkvkpq zkiy`xmyi`b` noie zcx`bx`h fy HQE"

\cx`v cbh cov ecbcl`e`bx -ob Z@ENAq/" Ob xmoq xyz` kn np`i a`ii) xm` e`efvcb` epqx f`

myhvcx`h) v`spovobl |cx`v xk f` `~czkvcx`h cx zv`aoq`iy xm` qce` vcx` xmcx ox oq zvkhpa`h" On

|cx`v oq `~czkvcx`h xkk spoadiy) xm` e`efvcb` hvo`q) v`qoqxcba` cavkqq ox obav`cq`q) cbh

`~`bxpciiy ox |oii avcad) av`cxobl c lcq &qmkvx aovapox& |m`v` myhvkl`b cbh k}yl`b

akefob` hov`axiy) l`b`vcxobl m`cx xmcx |oii hcecl` xm` np`i a`ii" On xm` |cx`v oq `~czkvcx`h

xkk qik|iy) xm` `i`axvkh`q |oii nikkh) zv`~`bxobl xm` v`caxcbxq nvke v`camobl xm` acxciyqx

cbh qxkzzobl xm` v`caxokb" E`xmkhq xk ecbcl` |cx`v ob a`iiq cv` f`obl h`~`ikz`h

iod` `i`axvkkqekxoa zpezq nkapqobl kb nik| akbxvki" Gpqx cq ob c akefpqxokb `blob`) c

qx`chy vcxok f`x|``b xm` v`caxcbx cbh k}yl`b oq b`a`qqcvy xk d``z xm` np`i a`ii kz`vcxobl

`nnoao`bxiy"

X`ez`vcxpv` ecbcl`e`bx" Xm` qce` x`ez`vcxpv` epqx f` ecobxcob`h xmvkplmkpx xm` a`ii

ob kvh`v xk zv`~`bx h`qxvpaxokb kn xm` a`ii xmvkplm xm`veci ikchobl" Xmoq oq zcvxoapicviy

amcii`blobl cq xm` 6M6 $ K6 2 6M6K v`caxokb oq molmiy `}kxm`veoa) qk c icvl` spcbxoxy kn

m`cx oq l`b`vcx`h |oxmob xm` np`i a`ii"

Hpvcfoioxy) q`v~oa` ion`) cbh qz`aoci v`spov`e`bxq nkv qke` xyz` kn a`iiq" Qxcxokbcvy np`i

a`ii czzioacxokbq xyzoaciiy v`spov` ekv` xmcb 8:)::: mkpvq kn v`iocfi` kz`vcxokb cx c

x`ez`vcxpv` kn 10 A xk 8: A -13 N xk 3:8 N/) |moi` cpxkekxo~` np`i a`iiq v`spov` c

0)::: mkpv ion`qzcb -xm` `spo~ci`bx kn 30:)::: eoi`q/ pbh`v `}xv`e` x`ez`vcxpv`q"Apvv`bx q`v~oa` ion` oq

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

9/20

Xm` b`|iy nkve`h zvkxkbq z`ve`cx` xmvkplm xm` zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb` xk xm`

acxmkh` qoh`" Xm` `i`axvkbq xvc~`i cikbl cb `}x`vbci ikch aovapox xk xm` acxmkh` qoh` kn xm`

E@C) xmpq av`cxobl xm`apvv`bx kpxzpx kn xm` np`i a`ii" E`cb|moi`) c qxv`ce kn k}yl`b oq

h`io~`v`h xk xm` acxmkh` qoh` kn xm` E@C" Cx xm` acxmkh` qoh` k}yl`b eki`api`q v`cax |oxm

xm` zvkxkbq z`ve`cxobl xmvkplm xm` zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb` cbh xm` `i`axvkbq cvvo~obl

xmvkplm xm` `}x`vbci aovapox xk nkve |cx`v eki`api`q" Xmoq v`hpaxokb mcina`ii v`caxokb oq

v`zv`q`bx`h fy7

Cx xm` Acxmkh`7

K~`vcii v`caxokb7

Zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb`

Xk npbaxokb) xm` e`efvcb` epqx akbhpax myhvkl`b okbq -zvkxkbq/ fpx bkx `i`axvkbq cq xmoq

|kpih ob `nn`ax &qmkvx aovapox& xm` np`i a`ii" Xm` e`efvcb` epqx ciqk bkx ciik| `oxm`v lcq xk

zcqq xk xm` kxm`v qoh` kn xm` a`ii) c zvkfi`e dbk|b cq lcq avkqqk~`v" Nobciiy) xm` e`efvcb`

epqx f` v`qoqxcbx xk xm` v`hpaobl `b~ovkbe`bx cx xm` acxmkh` cq |`ii cq xm` mcvqm k}ohcxo~`

`b~ovkbe`bx cx xm` cbkh`"

Qzioxxobl kn xm` myhvkl`b eki`api` oq v`icxo~`iy `cqy fy pqobl c zicxobpe acxciyqx"

Pbnkvxpbcx`iy mk|`~`v) qzioxxobl xm` k}yl`b eki`api` oq ekv` honnoapix) cbh xmoq acpq`q

qolbonoacbx `i`axvoa ikqq`q" Cb czzvkzvocx` acxciyqx ecx`voci nkv xmoq zvka`qq mcq bkx f``b

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_networkhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cathodehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Current_(electricity)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redoxhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinumhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pem.fuelcell2.gifhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platinumhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redoxhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Current_(electricity)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cathodehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_network

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

10/20

hoqak~`v`h) cbh zicxobpe oq xm` f`qx kzxokb" Kb` zvkeoqobl acxciyqx xmcx pq`q ncv i`qq

`}z`bqo~` ecx`vociqovkb) boxvkl`b) cbh acvfkbmcq ikbl f``b dbk|b xk zvkekx` xm`

b`a`qqcvy v`caxokbq) fpx cx vcx`q xmcx cv` ncv xkk qik| xk f`zvcaxoaci" V`a`bxiy v`q`cvam`vq cx

xm` Obqxoxpx Bcxokbci h` ic V`am`vam` Qao`bxonosp` -OBVQ/ ob Sp`f`a mc~` hvcecxoaciiy

obav`cq`h xm` z`vnkvecba` kn xmoq xyz` kn ovkbfcq`h acxciyqx" Xm`ov ecx`voci zvkhpa`q ??

cez`v`q z`v apfoa a`bxoe`x`v cx :"= ~kixq) c d`y e`cqpv`e`bx kn acxciyxoa caxo~ox" Xmcx oq 10

xoe`q f`xx`v xmcb xm` f`qx bkbzv`aokpq e`xci acxciyqx qk ncv) cbh aikq` xk xm` H`zcvxe`bx kn

@b`vly,q lkci nkv np`ia`ii acxciyqxq7 31: C+ae1"" Ox ciqk ecxam`q xm` z`vnkvecba` kn xyzoaci

zicxobpe acxciyqxq" Xm` kbiy zvkfi`e cx xm` eke`bx oq oxq hpvcfoioxy f`acpq` cnx`v kbiy 3::

mkpvq kn x`qxobl xm` v`caxokb vcx` hvkzz`h xk mcin" Cbkxm`v qolbonoacbx qkpva` kn ikqq`q oq xm`

v`qoqxcba` kn xm` e`efvcb` xk zvkxkb nik|) |moam oq eoboeow`h fy ecdobl ox cq xmob cq

zkqqofi`) kb xm` kvh`v kn 0: "

Xm` Z@ENA oq c zvoe` acbhohcx` nkv ~`moai` cbh kxm`v ekfoi` czzioacxokbq kn cii qow`q hk|b

xk ekfoi` zmkb`q) f`acpq` kn oxq akezcaxb`qq" Mk|`~`v) xm` |cx`v ecbcl`e`bx oq avpaoci xk

z`vnkvecba`7 xkk epam |cx`v |oii nikkh xm` e`efvcb`) xkk ioxxi` |oii hvy ox4 ob fkxm acq`q)

zk|`v kpxzpx |oii hvkz" \cx`v ecbcl`e`bx oq c ~`vy honnoapix qpfg`ax ob Z@E qyqx`eq)

zvoecvoiy f`acpq` |cx`v ob xm` e`efvcb` oq cxxvcax`h xk|cvh xm` acxmkh` kn xm` a`ii xmvkplm

zkicvowcxokb" C |oh` ~cvo`xy kn qkipxokbq nkv ecbclobl xm` |cx`v `}oqx obaiphobl obx`lvcxokb

kn`i`axvkkqekxoa zpezq" Npvxm`vekv`) xm` zicxobpe acxciyqx kb xm` e`efvcb` oq

`cqoiy zkoqkb`h fy acvfkb ekbk}oh` -bk ekv` xmcb kb` zcvx z`v eoiiokb oq pqpciiy caa`zxcfi`/

cbh xm` e`efvcb` oq q`bqoxo~` xk xmoblq iod` e`xci okbq) |moam acb f` obxvkhpa`h fy akvvkqokb

kn e`xciioa fozkicv zicx`q) e`xciioa akezkb`bxq ob xm` np`i a`ii qyqx`e kv nvke akbxceobcbxq

ob xm` np`i+k}ohcbx"

Z@E qyqx`eq xmcx pq` v`nkve`h e`xmcbki |`v` zvkzkq`h) cq ob Hcoei`v Amvyqi`v B`acv 04

v`nkveobl e`xmcbki) o"`" ecdobl ox v`cax xk kfxcob myhvkl`b) oq mk|`~`v c ~`vy akezioacx`h

zvka`qq) xmcx v`spov`q ciqk zpvonoacxokb nvke xm` acvfkb ekbk}oh` xm` v`caxokb zvkhpa`q" C

zicxobpevpxm`bope acxciyqx oq b`a`qqcvy cq qke` acvfkb ekbk}oh` |oii pbc~kohcfiy v`cam

xm` e`efvcb`" Xm` i`~`i qmkpih bkx `}a``h 3: zcvxq z`v eoiiokb" Npvxm`vekv`) xm` qxcvxpz

xoe`q kn qpam c v`nkve`v v`caxkv cv` kn cfkpx mcin cb mkpv" Cix`vbcxo~`iy) e`xmcbki) cbh qke`

kxm`v foknp`iq acb f` n`h xk c Z@E np`i a`ii hov`axiy |oxmkpx f`obl v`nkve`h) xmpq ecdobl c

hov`ax e`xmcbki np`i a`ii -HENA/" Xm`q` h`~oa`q kz`vcx` |oxm ioeox`h qpaa`qq"

Xm` ekqx akeekbiy pq`h e`efvcb` oq Bcnokb fy HpZkbx) |moam v`io`q kb iospoh |cx`v

mpeohonoacxokb kn xm` e`efvcb` xk xvcbqzkvx zvkxkbq" Xmoq oezio`q xmcx ox oq bkx n`cqofi` xk pq`

x`ez`vcxpv`q cfk~` =: xk ?: A) qoba` xm` e`efvcb` |kpih hvy" Kxm`v) ekv` v`a`bx

e`efvcb` xyz`q) fcq`h kb Zkiyf`bwoeohcwki` -ZFO/ KV zmkqzmkvoa caoh) acb v`cam pz xk 66:

A |oxmkpx pqobl cby |cx`v ecbcl`e`bx7 molm`v x`ez`vcxpv` ciik| nkv f`xx`v `nnoao`bao`q)

zk|`v h`bqoxo`q) `cq` kn akkiobl -f`acpq` kn icvl`v ciik|cfi` x`ez`vcxpv` honn`v`ba`q/)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroosmotic_pumphttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxidehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Part_per_millionhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bipolarhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanolhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biofuelshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DuPonthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphoric-acid_fuel_cellhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphoric-acid_fuel_cellhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DuPonthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biofuelshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanolhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bipolarhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Part_per_millionhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxidehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroosmotic_pump

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

11/20

v`hpa`h q`bqoxo~oxy xk acvfkb ekbk}oh` zkoqkbobl cbh f`xx`v akbxvkiicfoioxy -f`acpq` kn

cfq`ba` kn |cx`v ecbcl`e`bx oqqp`q ob xm` e`efvcb`/4 mk|`~`v) xm`q` v`a`bx xyz`q cv` bkx

cq akeekb"

@nnoao`bao`q kn Z@Eq cv` ob xm` vcbl` kn 8:>:% molm`v m`cxobl ~cip` kn myhvkl`b -MM^/Acxciyqx v`q`cvamEpam kn xm` apvv`bx v`q`cvam kb acxciyqxq nkv Z@E np`i a`iiq acb f` aicqqono`h cq mc~obl kb`

kn x|k ecob kfg`axo~`q7

3/ xk kfxcob molm`v acxciyxoa caxo~oxy xmcb xm` qxcbhcvh acvfkbqpzzkvx`h zicxobpe zcvxoai`

acxciyqxq pq`h ob apvv`bx Z@E np`i a`iiq

kv

6/ xk v`hpa` xm` zkoqkbobl kn Z@E np`i a`ii acxciyqxq fy oezpvoxy lcq`q" @}cezi`q kn xm`q`

x|k czzvkcam`q cv` lo~`b ob xm` nkiik|obl q`axokbq"

3/ Obav`cqobl acxciyxoa caxo~oxy

Cq e`bxokb`h cfk~`) zicxobpe oq fy ncv xm` ekqx `nn`axo~` `i`e`bx pq`h nkv Z@E np`i a`ii

acxciyqxq) cbh b`cviy cii apvv`bx Z@E np`i a`iiq pq` zicxobpe zcvxoai`q kb zkvkpq acvfkb

qpzzkvxq xk acxciyw` fkxm myhvkl`b k}ohcxokb cbh k}yl`b v`hpaxokb" Mk|`~`v) hp` xk xm`ov

molm akqx) apvv`bx Zx+A acxciyqxq cv` bkx n`cqofi` nkv akee`vaociowcxokb" Xm` P"Q" H`zcvxe`bx

kn @b`vly `qxoecx`q xmcx zicxobpefcq`h acxciyqxq |oii b``h xk pq` vkplmiy nkpv xoe`q i`qq

zicxobpe xmcb oq pq`h ob apvv`bx Z@E np`i a`ii h`qolbq ob kvh`v xk v`zv`q`bx c v`cioqxoa

cix`vbcxo~` xk obx`vbci akefpqxokb `blob`q"Akbq`sp`bxiy) kb` ecob lkci kn acxciyqx h`qolb nkv

Z@E np`i a`iiq oq xk obav`cq` xm` acxciyxoa caxo~oxy kn zicxobpe fy c ncaxkv kn nkpv qk xmcx kbiy

kb`nkpvxm cq epam kn xm` zv`aokpq e`xci oq b`a`qqcvy xk camo`~` qoeoicv z`vnkvecba`"

Kb` e`xmkh kn obav`cqobl xm` z`vnkvecba` kn zicxobpe acxciyqxq oq xk kzxoeow` xm` qow` cbh

qmcz` kn xm` zicxobpe zcvxoai`q" H`av`cqobl xm` zcvxoai`q qow` cikb` obav`cq`q xm` xkxci qpvnca`

cv`c kn acxciyqx c~coicfi` xk zcvxoaozcx` ob v`caxokbq z`v ~kipe` kn zicxobpe pq`h) fpx v`a`bx

qxpho`q mc~` h`ekbqxvcx`h chhoxokbci |cyq xk ecd` npvxm`v oezvk~`e`bxq xk acxciyxoa

z`vnkvecba`" Nkv `}cezi`) kb` qxphy v`zkvxq xmcx molmobh`} nca`xq kn

zicxobpe bcbkzcvxoai`q -xmcx oq Eoii`v obh`}`q |oxm icvl` obx`l`vq) qpam cq Zx -

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

12/20

6/ V`hpaobl zkoqkbobl

Xm` kxm`v zkzpicv czzvkcam xk oezvk~obl acxciyqx z`vnkvecba` oq xk v`hpa` oxq q`bqoxo~oxy xk

oezpvoxo`q ob xm` np`i qkpva`) `qz`aociiy acvfkb ekbk}oh` -AK/" Zv`q`bxiy) zpv` myhvkl`b lcq

oq bkx `akbkeoaci xk ecqqzvkhpa` fy `i`axvkiyqoq kv cby kxm`v e`cbq" Obqx`ch) myhvkl`b lcqoq zvkhpa`h fy qx`ce v`nkveobl iolmx myhvkacvfkbq) c zvka`qq |moam zvkhpa`q c eo}xpv` kn

lcqq`q xmcx ciqk akbxcobq AK -31%/) AK6 -3?60%/) cbh B6 -60%/" @~`b x`bq kn zcvxq z`v

eoiiokb kn AK acb zkoqkb c zpv` zicxobpe acxciyqx) qk obav`cqobl zicxobpeq v`qoqxcba` xk AK

oq cb caxo~` cv`c kn v`q`cvam"

Nkv `}cezi`) kb` qxphy v`zkvx`h xmcx apf`qmcz`h zicxobpe bcbkzcvxoai`q |oxm -3::/

nca`q hoqzicy`h c nkpvnkih obav`cq` ob k}yl`b v`hpaxokb caxo~oxy akezcv`h xk vcbhkeiy

nca`x`h zicxobpe bcbkzcvxoai`q kn qoeoicv qow`" Xm` cpxmkvq akbaiph`h xmcx xm` -333/ nca`xq kn

xm` vcbhkeiy qmcz`h bcbkzcvxoai`q fkbh`h ekv` qxvkbliy xk qpincx` okbq xmcb xm` -3::/ nca`xq)v`hpaobl xm` bpef`v kn acxciyxoa qox`q kz`b xk k}yl`b eki`api`q" Xm` bcbkapf`q xm`y

qybxm`qow`h) ob akbxvcqx) mch ciekqx `}aipqo~`iy -3::/ nca`xq) |moam cv` dbk|b xk obx`vcax

|oxm qpincx` ekv` |`cdiy" Cq c v`qpix) c lv`cx`v nvcaxokb kn xm` qpvnca` cv`c kn xmkq` zcvxoai`q

|cq c~coicfi` nkv xm` v`hpaxokb kn k}yl`b) fkkqxobl xm` acxciyqxq k}yl`b v`hpaxokb caxo~oxy"

Ob chhoxokb) v`q`cvam`vq mc~` f``b ob~`qxolcxobl |cyq kn v`hpaobl xm` AK akbx`bx kn myhvkl`b

np`i f`nkv` ox `bx`vq c np`i a`ii cq c zkqqofi` |cy xk c~koh zkoqkbobl xm` acxciyqxq" Kb` v`a`bx

qxphy v`~`ci`h xmcx vpxm`bopezicxobpe akv`qm`ii bcbkzcvxoai`q cv` zcvxoapicviy `nn`axo~` cx

k}ohowobl AK xk nkve AK6) c epam i`qq mcvenpi np`i akbxceobcbx"Xm` e`amcboqe xmcxzvkhpa`q xmoq `nn`ax oq akba`zxpciiy qoeoicv xk xmcx h`qavof`h nkv Zx1Bo cfk~`7 xm` vpxm`bope

akv` kn xm` zcvxoai` cix`vq xm` `i`axvkboa qxvpaxpv` kn xm` zicxobpe qpvnca`) v`bh`vobl ox f`xx`v

cfi` xk acxciyw` xm` k}ohcxokb kn AK"

Z@E Np`i A`ii Czzioacxokbq

Z@E a`iiq ecy mc~` c eo}`h v`akvh ob qzca`) fpx q`~`vciakezcbo`q mc~` f``b x`qxobl xm` a`iiq ob ekv` hk|bxk`cvxm~`moai`q" Ob 3??0) Fciicvh Qyqx`eq x`qx`h Z@E a`iiq ob fpq`q ob

^cbakp~`v cbh Amoaclk cbh icx`v ob `}z`voe`bxci ~`moai`q ech`fy Hcoei`vAmvyqi`v" Z@E a`iiq mc~` ciqk qpzzio`h zk|`v xkpbecbb`h fioezq acii`h c`vkqxcxq cbh xk qkbkfpkyq) |moam cv`bcpxoaci fpkyq xmcx l`b`vcx` cbh v`a`o~` qkbcv qolbciq"

@cviy ob 6:::) C`vk^ovkbe`bx q`i`ax`h Z@E x`ambkikly xkzvk~oh` bolmxxoe` zk|`v nkv oxq qkicvzk|`v`hM`iokq ikblhpvcxokb covavcnx" Xm` lkci |cq xk ecd` cb pbzoikx`h covavcnx xmcx

akpih niy akbxobpkpqiy nkv pz xk qo} ekbxmq fy pqobl zmkxk~kixcoa zcb`iq hpvobl xm` hcy xkvpb `i`axvoa ekxkvq cbh `i`axvkiyw` |cx`v" Cx bolmx) xm` np`i a`ii |cq xk vpb xm` ekxkvq fyakb~`vxobl xm` myhvkl`b cbh k}yl`b fcad obxk |cx`v" Q`~`vci x`qx niolmxq |`v` ech` |oxm cbh|oxmkpx c np`i a`ii nvke 6::3 xk 6::1"

C Fciicvh np`i a`ii zk|`vq

c iczxkz akezpx`v"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrolysishttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforminghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocarbonshttp://americanhistory.si.edu/fuelcells/pem/pem4.htmhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrocarbonshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforminghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrolysis

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

13/20

Cpxkekxo~` v`q`cvam mcq xcd`b kb b`| pvl`bay cq cov spcioxyv`lpicxokbq lvk| qx`choiy qxvoax`v) zcvxoapicviy ob Acionkvboc"@b`vly Zcvxb`vq cbh xm` P" Q" H`zcvxe`bx kn @b`vly,q Knnoa` knCh~cba`h Cpxkekxo~` X`ambkiklo`q zvk~oh`h x|k 6: d| np`i a`iiqxcadq xk ^ovloboc X`am cbh X`}cq X`am pbo~`vqoxo`q xk `~cipcx`

z`vnkvecba` ob myfvoh `i`axvoa acvq" Ecgkv cpxkecd`vq iod` Nkvhcbh ^kidq|cl`b cv` ciqk x`qxobl Z@E ~`moai`q"

Qoba` xm` eoh3?=:q) Z@E h`~`ikze`bx mcq obaiph`h qxcxokbcvyzk|`v czzioacxokbq" Ob 3?=?) Fciicvh Qyqx`eq obxvkhpa`h c 0 d|myhvkl`b cbh cov Z@E qxcad" X|k y`cvq icx`v) LZP cbh Fciicvhf`lcb kz`vcxobl c 60: d| zicbx cx Avcb` Bc~ci Cov Qxcxokb ob Obhocbc" Kb` kn xm` ekv`zpfioaow`h h`ekbqxvcxokbq mcq f``b Zipl Zk|`v,q Z@E pbox ob Cifcby) B`| _kvd) |moamf`lcb zk|`vobl c mke` ob Gpb` 3??=" Zvkekx`h fy xm` akezcby cq xm` &novqx z`vecb`bxmke` obqxciicxokb)& xm` 0 d| zk|`v zicbx m`iz`h xm` akezcby xk ecd` qolbonoacbxzcvxb`vqmozq |oxm fkxm L@ cbh H`xvkox @hoqkb" Xm`q` zcvxb`vq mch mkz`h xk ecvd`x c

v`qoh`bxoci np`i a`ii hpvobl 6::6) mk|`~`v xmkq` zicbq mc~` f``b zkqxzkb`h"

E`xmcbki np`i a`ii

Nol7%Np`i a`ii BCQC

Xm` M`iokq v`q`cvam

covavcnx xcd`q xk xm` cov"

http://americanhistory.si.edu/fuelcells/pem/pem6.htmhttp://americanhistory.si.edu/fuelcells/pem/pem6.htm

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

14/20

Hov`ax%e`xmcbki np`i a`iiq kv HENAq cv` c qpfacx`lkvy kn zvkxkb%`}amcbl` np`i a`iiq ob

|moam e`xmcbki oq pq`h cq xm` np`i" Xm`ov ecob ch~cbxcl`q cv` xm` `cq` kn xvcbqzkvx kn

e`xmcbki) cb `b`vly%h`bq` y`x v`cqkbcfiy qxcfi` iospoh cx cii `b~ovkbe`bxci akbhoxokbq) cbh

xm` icad kn akezi`} qx`ce v`nkveobl-pq`h xk l`b`vcx` Myhvkl`b nvke nkqqoi np`iq/

kz`vcxokbq" @nnoao`bay oq zv`q`bxiy spox` ik| nkv xm`q` a`iiq) qk xm`y cv` xcvl`x`h `qz`aociiy xk

zkvxcfi` czzioacxokbq) |m`v` b`vly cbh zk|`v h`bqoxy cv` ekv` oezkvxcbx xmcb nnoao`bay"

Moqxkvy

Np`i a`iiq mc~` f``b cvkpbh nkv k~`v 30: y`cvq" Qov \oiioce Vkf`vx Lvk~` akba`o~`h xm` novqxnp`i a`ii Ob 3=1?" Qov Lvk~` |cq c \`iqm l`bxi`ecb) qao`bxoqx cbh gphl`" Moq np`i a`ii pq`hzkvkpq zicxobpe `i`axvkh`q cbh qpinpvoa caoh cq xm` `i`axvkiyx` fcxm" Moq eo}xpv` kn myhvkl`bcbh k}yl`b ob xm` zv`q`ba` kn cb `i`axvkiyx` zvkhpa`h `i`axvoaoxy cbh |cx`v" Pbnkvxpbcx`iy)moq ob~`bxokb hohb,x zvkhpa` `bkplm `i`axvoaoxy xk f` pq`npi"

Ob 3==?) Iph|ol Ekbh cbh moq cqqoqxcbx Amcvi`q Icbl`v) cxx`ezx`h xk fpoih c |kvdobl np`ia`ii pqobl cov cbh obhpqxvoci akci lcq"

Cvkpbh xmcx xoe`) c np`i a`ii akbqxvpax`h fy \oiioce \mox` Gcsp`q -|mk obaoh`bxciiy akob`hxm` x`ve np`i a`ii/) qpfqxoxpx`h zmkqzmkvoa caoh ob xm` `i`axvkiyx` fcxm"

Ob xm` 3?6:q) np`i a`ii v`q`cvam ob L`vecby zc~`h xm` |cy xk xm` h`~`ikze`bx kn xm`acvfkbcx` ayai` cbh qkioh k}oh` np`i a`iiq kn xkhcy"

Ob 3?16) Hv" Nvcbaoq X" Fcakb ech` c qolbonoacbx akbxvofpxokb xk np`i v`q`cvam" @cviy a`iih`qolb`vq pq`h zkvkpq zicxobpe `i`axvkh`q cbh qpinpvoa caoh cq xm` `i`axvkiyx` fcxm" Pqobl

zicxobpe |cq `}z`bqo~` cbh pqobl qpinpvoa caoh |cq akvvkqo~`" Fcakb pq`h cb ob`}z`bqo~`boad`i `i`axvkh` cbh c i`qq akvvkqo~` cidciob` `i`axvkiyx`" Ox xkkd Fcakb pbxoi 3?0? xk z`vn`axmoq h`qolb cbh h`ekbqxvcx`h c no~`doik|cxx np`i a`ii xmcx akpih zk|`v c |`ihoblecamob`" Nvcbaoq X" Fcakb) c hov`ax h`qa`bh`bx kn xm` kxm`v |`ii dbk|b Nvcbaoq Fcakb)bce`h moq ncekpq np`i a`ii h`qolb xm` &Fcakb A`ii"&

Ob Kaxkf`v kn 3?0?) Mcvvy Dcvi Omvol) cb `blob``v nkv xm` Ciioq Amcie`vq EcbpncaxpvoblAkezcby) h`ekbqxvcx`h c 6:mkvq`zk|`v xvcaxkv xmcx |cq xm` novqx ~`moai` `~`v zk|`v`h fy cnp`i a`ii"

Hpvobl xm` `cviy 3?>:q) L`b`vci @i`axvoa zvkhpa`h xm` np`ia`iifcq`h `i`axvoaci zk|`v qyqx`e

nkv BCQC,q L`eobo cbh Czkiik qzca` aczqpi`q" L`b`vci @i`axvoa pq`h xm` zvobaozi`q nkpbh obxm` &Fcakb A`ii& cq xm` fcqoq kn oxq h`qolb" Xkhcy) xm` Qzca` Qmpxxi`,q `i`axvoaoxy oq zvk~oh`hfy np`i a`iiq) cbh xm` qce` np`i a`iiq zvk~oh` hvobdobl |cx`v nkv xm` av`|"

Hv" Ic|v`ba` M" HpFkoq kn xm` P"Q" H`zcvxe`bx kn H`n`bq` cbh xm` H`n`bq` Ch~cba`hV`q`cvam Zvkg`axq Cl`bay -HCVZC/ `b~oqokb`h xm` h`~`ikze`bx kn c np`i a`ii xmcx akpihkz`vcx` kb ~cvokpq xyz`q kn iospoh myhvkacvfkbq -e`xmcbki) `xmcbki) `xa")/" M` acii`h kb Hv"Qpvyc Zvcdcqm c |kvihv`bk|b`h qpz`v caoh qz`aocioqx cbh Bkf`i icpv`cx` Hv" L`kvl` C"Kicm) fkxm kn xm` Pbo~`vqoxy kn Qkpxm`vb Acionkvboc,q Ikd`v Myhvkacvfkb Obqxoxpx` xk ob~`bxqpam c np`i a`ii" PQA) ob c akiicfkvcxo~` `nnkvx |oxm G`x Zvkzpiqokb Icfkvcxkvy -GZI/ +

Acionkvboc Obqxoxpx` kn X`ambkikly -Acix`am/ zvka``h`h xk ob~`bx xm` hov`ax k}ohcxokb kn iospohmyhvkacvfkbq qpfq`sp`bxiy akob`h cq HENA) Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii X`ambkikly"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanolhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforminghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforminghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanol

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

15/20

HXO caspov`h xm` `}aipqo~` |kvih|oh` ioa`bq` nkv Hov`ax K}ohcxokb kn Iospoh Myhvkacvfkbq)HENA X`ambkikly" HXO,q Zv`qoh`bx cbh A@K) Xkhh Ecvqm) qc| xm` npxpv` oezcax xmcx cai`cb cix`vbcxo~` xk nkqqoi np`iq |cq f`obl fkvb cbh knn`v`h xk qx`|cvh xmoq x`ambkikly cbhm`iz akee`vaociow` ox"

HENA x`ambkikly mcq f`ake` |oh`iy caa`zx`h cq c ~ocfi` np`i a`ii x`ambkikly xmcx knn`vqoxq`in xk ecby czzioacxokbq"

Ob 3??: qpz`vcaoh qz`aocioqx Hv" Qpvyc Zvcdcqm) cbh Bkf`i icpv`cx` Hv" L`kvl` C" Kicm) fkxmkn xm` Pbo~`vqoxy kn Qkpxm`vb Acionkvboc,q Ikd`v Myhvkacvfkb V`q`cvam Obqxoxpx`) ob~`bx`h cnp`i a`ii xmcx |kpih hov`axiy akb~`vx e`xmcbki xk `i`axvoaoxy" PQA) ob c akiicfkvcxo~` `nnkvx|oxm G`x Zvkzpiqokb Icfkvcxkvy -GZI/ zvka``h`h xk ob~`bx xm` hov`ax k}ohcxokb kn iospohmyhvkacvfkbq qpfq`sp`bxiy akob`h cq HENA) Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii X`ambkikly" Kxm`vq

|`v` ob~ki~`h ob xm` ob~`bxokb) obaiphobl Acionkvboc Obqxoxpx` kn X`ambkikly -Acix`am/ cbhHXO @b`vly) Oba" Qke` ch~cba`q ob HENA mc~` f``b7 fvoblobl hk|b xm` np`i avkqqk~`v)eobocxpvowobl xm` a`ii nkv akbqpe`v cbh eoioxcvy zvkhpaxq) a`vceoa zicx`q) acvfkb bcbkxpf`q)zkvkpq qoioakb icy`vq cbh k}ohcxokb v`hpaxokb"

|mcx oq e`xmcbki;

E`xmcbki oq c iospoh nvke ?

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

16/20

Xm` mcinv`caxokbq cv`7

Cbkh`k}ohcxokb

Acxmkh`

v`hpaxokb

K~`vcii v`caxokb

v`hk} v`caxokb

E`xmcbki cbh |cx`v cv` chqkvf`h kb c acxciyqx pqpciiy ech`

kn zicxobpe cbh vpxm`bope zcvxoai`q) cbh ikq` zvkxkbq pbxoi acvfkb hok}oh` oq nkve`h" Cq

|cx`v oq akbqpe`h cx xm` cbkh` ob xm` v`caxokb) zpv` e`xmcbki acbbkx f` pq`h |oxmkpx

zvk~oqokb kn |cx`v ~oc `oxm`v zcqqo~` xvcbqzkvx qpam cq fcad honnpqokb -kqekqoq/) kv caxo~`

xvcbqzkvx qpam cq zpezobl" Xm` b``h nkv |cx`v ioeoxq xm` `b`vly h`bqoxy kn xm` np`i"

Apvv`bxiy) zicxobpe oq pq`h cq c acxciyqx nkv fkxm mcinv`caxokbq" Xmoq akbxvofpx`q xk xm` ikqq kn

a`ii ~kixcl` zkx`bxoci) cq cby e`xmcbki xmcx oq zv`q`bx ob xm` acxmkh` amcef`v |oii k}ohow`" On

cbkxm`v acxciyqx akpih f` nkpbh nkv xm` v`hpaxokb kn k}yl`b) xm` zvkfi`e kn e`xmcbki

avkqqk~`v |kpih iod`iy f` qolbonoacbxiy i`qq`b`h" Npvxm`vekv`) zicxobpe oq ~`vy `}z`bqo~`

cbh akbxvofpx`q xk xm` molm akqx z`v doik|cxx kn xm`q` a`iiq" Hpvobl xm` e`xmcbki k}ohcxokb

v`caxokb acvfkb ekbk}oh` -AK/ oq nkve`h) |moam qxvkbliy chqkvfq kbxk xm` zicxobpe acxciyqx)

v`hpaobl xm` qpvnca` cv`c cbh xmpq xm` z`vnkvecba` kn xm` a`ii" Xm` chhoxokb kn cbkxm`v

akezkb`bxq) qpam cq vpxm`bope kv lkih) xk xm` acxciyqx x`bhq xk ce`iokvcx` xmoq zvkfi`e

f`acpq`) caakvhobl xk xm` ekqx |`ii`qxcfioqm`h xm`kvy ob xm` no`ih) xm`q` acxciyqxq k}ohow`

|cx`v xk yo`ih KM vchoaciq7 M6K KM $ M$ $ `" Xm` KM qz`ao`q nvke xm` k}ohow`h |cx`v

eki`api` k}ohow`q AK xk zvkhpa` AK6|moam acb xm`b f` v`i`cq`h cq c lcq7 AK $ KM AK6 $ M

$ $ `"

Pqobl xm`q` KM lvkpzq ob xm` mcin v`caxokbq) xm`y cv` ciqk `}zv`qq`h cq7

@spcxokb

Cbkh`k}ohcxokb

Acxmkh`v`hpaxokb

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rutheniumhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anodehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osmosishttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_transporthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_transporthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxidehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxidehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_transporthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_transporthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osmosishttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anodehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruthenium

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

17/20

K~`vcii v`caxokb

v`hk} v`caxokb

Mk| Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq -HENA/ |kvd;

C Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii -HENA/ |kvdq fy av`cxobl xm`vekhybceoa zkx`bxoci kpx kn xm`

am`eoaci v`caxokb f`x|``b e`xmcbki cbh cov ob c qz`aonoa ecbb`v" \oxmkpx xm` coh kn ek~obl

zcvxq) Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq zvkhpa` `i`axvoaoxy xmvkplm cb `i`axvkam`eoaci zvka`qq)

|oxmkpx akefpqxokb cbh |oxmkpx xm` b``h xk v`nkve xm` np`i qxkad obxk myhvkl`b kv `}zkq`

myhvkl`b ob c lcq`kpq qxcx` xk xm` Zvkxkb @}amcbl` E`efvcb` -Z@E/" Xm` ch~cbxcl` kn c

Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii -HENA/ k~`v c xvchoxokb fcxx`vy oq xmcx c Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i

A`ii acb qoeziy f` v`noii`h |oxm ekv` np`i |m`b ox vpbq kpx" C np`i a`ii oq cb `b`vly

zvkhpaobl h`~oa` |moi` c fcxx`vy oq cb `b`vly qxkvobl h`~oa`" Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq

kbiy v`spov` `}x`vbciiy chh`h np`i xk vpb" Cq ikbl cq np`i cbh cov cv` qpzzio`h xk xm` HENA)

ox |oii akbxobp` xk zvkhpa` zk|`v" Ox hk`q bkx b``h xk f` v`amcvl`h"

Xm` Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii Zvka`qq7%

Xm` xm`vekhybceoa zkx`bxoci oq av`cx`h xmvkplm xm` pq` kn c zkiye`v `i`axvkiyx` e`efvcb`xmcx ciik|q kbiy a`vxcob am`eoaci qz`ao`q xk zcqq xmvkplm ox" Kb kb` qoh` kn xmoq e`efvcb`) ce`xmcbki cbh |cx`v eo}xpv` oq n`h xk cb cbkh` acxciyqx xmcx q`zcvcx`q xm` e`xmcbki eki`api`obxk myhvkl`b cxkeq cbh acvfkb hok}oh`" Xm` q`zcvcx`h myhvkl`b cxkeq cv` xm`b xyzoaciiyqxvozz`h kn xm`ov `i`axvkb) cbh zcqq`h xmvkplm xm` e`efvcb` xk xm` acxmkh` qoh` kn xm` a`ii" Cx

xm` acxmkh` acxciyqx) xm` zvkxkbq -myhvkl`b cxkeq |oxmkpx cb `i`axvkb/ v`cax |oxm xm` k}yl`bob cov xk nkve |cx`v eobpq cb `i`axvkb" Fy akbb`axobl c akbhpaxo~` |ov` nvke xm` cbkh` xk xm`acxmkh` qoh`) xm` `i`axvkbq qxvozz`h nvke xm` myhvkl`b cxkeq kb xm` cbkh` qoh` acb xvc~`i xkxm` acxmkh` qoh` cbh akefob` |oxm xm` `i`axvkb h`noao`bx qz`ao`q"

Nvke c xm`vekhybceoa z`vqz`axo~`) xm` `i`axvkbq &|cbx& xk xvc~`i xk xm` acxmkh` qoh` cqz`aonoa &cekpbx)& xmcx acb f` spcbxono`h cq xm` kz`b aovapox ~kixcl`" Xm` kz`b aovapox ~kixcl`oq e`cqpv`h |oxm c ~kixe`x`v cavkqq xm` a`ii q`x xk cb `}xv`e`iy molm v`qoqxcba`" Xm`xm`vekhybceoa nc~kvobl kn v`caxobl xm` e`xmcbki cbh K 6 obxk acvfkb hok}oh` cbh |cx`vnkva`q c honn`v`ba` ob `b`vly xk fpoih cavkqq xm` e`efvcb` pbxoi xm` qyqx`e v`cam`q`spoiofvope" Kba` xmoq i`~`i oq v`cam`h xm` akezkb`bxq qxkz v`caxobl) cbh bk chhoxokbci pq`npi

`b`vly oq zvkhpa`h"

Pq`npi `b`vly oq zvkhpa`h fy ik|`vobl xm` ~kixcl` cavkqq xm` e`efvcb` f`ik| xm``spoiofvope ~cip`" Xmoq oq hkb` fy zicaobl c v`qoqxcba` kb xm` |ov` akbb`axobl xm` x|k qoh`qxmcx oq |`cd `bkplm xmcx apvv`bx acb nik| xmvkplm ox" Xm` qecii`v xm` ~kixcl` honn`v`ba` xmcx oqoezkq`h kb xm` np`i a`ii ob xmoq ecbb`v) xm` ekv` apvv`bx oq zvkhpa`h pbxoi c zvkxkb xvcbqzkvxvcx` ioeox oq v`cam`h) cnx`v |moam bk chhoxokbci `b`vly oq zvkhpa`h"

Xm` k~`vcii v`caxokb kaapvvobl ob xm` HENA oq xm` qce` cq xmcx nkv xm` hov`ax akefpqxokb kne`xmcbki)

o"`4 AM 1 KM $ 1+6K 6 AK 6 $ 6M 6 K

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

18/20

Fyzvkhpaxq kn HENAq

Xm` gkf kn xm` np`i a`ii oq xk akb~`vx xm` am`eoaci `b`vly kn c np`i hov`axiy obxk `i`axvoaciapvv`bx |oxmkpx fpvbobl ox" Pbiod` obx`vbci akefpqxokb `blob`q xm`v` oq bk akefpqxokbzvka`qq4 xm`v`nkv` bk covfkvb` zkiipxcbxq cv` l`b`vcx`h" Xm` kbiy &`}mcpqx& kv fyzvkhpax knxmoq `}amcbl` oq zpv` |cx`v cbh qke` acvfkb hok}oh` -AK 6 /" Pbiod` kxm`v np`i a`iix`ambkiklo`q) HENA -Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii/ x`ambkikly zvkhpa`q bk acvfkb ekbk}oh`kv kxm`v zcvxoapicx`q qpam cq k}oh`q kn boxvkl`b -BK]/) k}oh`q kn qpinpv -QK]/ kv v`caxo~`kvlcboa lcq`q -VKL/" Ob icy x`veq) xm` xkxci czzvk}oecx` cekpbx kn acvfkb hok}oh`oq mcinkn |mcx oq apvv`bxiy l`b`vcx`h fy akefpqxokb `blob`q" Xmpq) xm` `nn`ax kb kpv zicb`xkn pxoiowobl xm` HENA cbh e`xmcbki nkv `b`vly zvkhpaxokb oq zvknkpbh"

Ch~cbxcl`q kn HENA k~`v kxm`v np`i a`iiq

Ob x`veq kn xm` cekpbx kn `i`axvoaoxy l`b`vcx`h) c Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii -HENA/ acbapvv`bxiy l`b`vcx` 1::0:: eoiio|cxxq z`v a`bxoe`x`v qspcv`h" Xm` cv`c kn xm` a`ii qow` cbhxm` bpef`v kn a`iiq qxcad`h xkl`xm`v |oii zvk~oh` xm` b`a`qqcvy zk|`v l`b`vcxokb nkv|mcx`~`v xm` |cxx cbh doik|cxx b``hq cv` nkv ~`moapicv cbh qxcxokbcvy czzioacxokbq"

Xm` iospoh np`i h`qolb kn Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq mcq bpe`vkpq qyqx`ei`~`i ch~cbxcl`qk~`v xm` lcq np`i kv v`nkve`v h`qolb np`i a`iiq" C Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii -HENA/7

@ioeobcx`q xm` np`i ~czkvow`v kv &v`nkve`v& @ioeobcx`q molm zv`qqpv`q cbh x`ez`vcxpv`q" HENA kz`vcx` `nn`axo~`iy cx vkke

x`ez`vcxpv` cbh zv`qqpv`q pbh`v 6: zqo" @ioeobcx`q xm` akezi`} |cx`v cbh xm`veci ecbcl`e`bx qyqx`eq xmcx cv` b``h`h xk

ecobxcob xm` `spoiofvope kn x`ez`vcxpv` cbh zv`qqpv`q ob xm` v`nkve`v xyz` np`i a`iiq"

Xmoq ob xpvb)

@ioeobcx`q xm` b``h nkv obb`v m`cxobl cbh akkiobl zicx`q" @ioeobcx`q xm` mpeohonoacxokb zvka`qq kn v`nkve`v x`ambkikly |oxmkpx |moam

e`efvcb`q hvy pz cbh avcad" Xm` iospoh qxcx` kn Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiqzvk~oh`q c akbqxcbx fcxm nkv xm` e`efvcb`q"

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

19/20

Qolbonoacbxiy ik|`vq qyqx`e qow` cbh |`olmx) hp` ob icvl` zcvx xk xm` `ioeobcxokb kn xm`v`nkve`v) c akqxiy) akezi`} qzca` mkl"

HENAq pq` fozicx`q xmcx acb f` ech` kpx kn bkbe`xciioa iolmx|`olmx) ni`}ofi`ecx`vociq xmcx cv` qolbonoacbxiy ik|`v ob akqx xmcb e`xciioa ecx`vociq"

Czzioacxokb7%

3" `bhi`qq zkqqofoioxo`q nkv HENAHov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii x`ambkikly -HENA/ acb f` czzio`h ob c ~cvo`xy knzvkhpaxq" Kf~okpqiy) kpv `b~ovkbe`bx |kpih f`b`nox nvke np`i a`ii zk|`v`h acvq cbhfpq`q" Xm`v` oq cb `spci kv lv`cx`v h`ecbh nkv ai`cb `nnoao`bx `b`vly ob ecby kxm`v

czzioacxokbq" Ic|bek|`vq) |``h |mozq) amcob qc|q) qbk| cbh i`cn fik|`vq) cbh g`x qdoq acbcii f` akb~`vx`h xk HENA) Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii x`ambkikly" Ecvob` czzioacxokbq qpamcq fkcxq) xcbd`vq) ip}pvy iob`vq cbh cxq`c zicxnkveq mc~` qolbonoacbx zk|`v b``hq" Eoavk np`ia`iiq) pqobl HENA) Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii x`ambkikly) ob a`iipicv zmkb`q) iczxkzakezpx`vq cbh zkvxcfi` `i`axvkboaq |oii zvk~oh` ikbl`v pqcfoioxy" \cqx`|cx`v xv`cxe`bxzicbxq cbh icbhnoiiq cv` pqobl hov`ax e`xmcbki np`i a`iiq xk akb~`vx xm` e`xmcb` lcq xm`yzvkhpa` obxk `i`axvoaoxy" Xm` zkqqofoioxo`q cv` `bhi`qq"

6" qxcxokbcvy czzioacxokbq kn HENAXm` kzzkvxpboxo`q cbh h`ecbh nkv Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq ob qxcxokbcvy czzioacxokbq cv`

`}xvckvhobcvy" Ekv` xmcb 60:: np`i a`ii qyqx`eq mc~` f``b obqxcii`h cii k~`v xm` |kvih obmkqzoxciq) bpvqobl mke`q) mkx`iq) knnoa` fpoihoblq) qamkkiq) pxoioxy zk|`v zicbxq) cbh covzkvxx`veobciq) zvk~ohobl zvoecvy kv fcadpz zk|`v" @~`vy akpbxvy kb @cvxm mcq qxcxokbcvy zk|`vcbh akbqpe`v `i`axvkboaq b``hq" Zvkhpaobl oee`hocx` qxcxokbcvy) h`a`bxvciow`h zk|`v fypqobl Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii x`ambkikly nkv cfqkipx`iy `~`vy `i`axvoaci b``h) ecd`q q`bq`bkx kbiy ikloqxoaciiy) fpx ciqk ekb`xcvoiy" Ob icvl`qaci` fpoihobl qyqx`eq) np`i a`iiq acbv`hpa` `b`vly akqxq fy 6:% xk 8:% k~`v akb~`bxokbci `b`vly q`v~oa`" Chhoxokbciiy) HENAqcv` cb `}a`ii`bx amkoa` nkv fcadpz zk|`v b``hq qpam cq PZQ cbh CZP h`~oa`q"

1" v`qoh`bxoci czzioacxokbq kn HENAH`~`ikzobl bcxokbq b``h v`iocfi` zk|`v ob xm`ov aoxo`q) ~oiicl`q) cbh mke`q" Hov`ax E`xmcbkiNp`i A`iiq cv` oh`ci nkv zk|`v l`b`vcxokb) `oxm`v akbb`ax`h xk xm` `i`axvoa lvoh xk zvk~oh`qpzzi`e`bxci zk|`v cbh fcadpz cqqpvcba` nkv avoxoaci cv`cq) kv obqxcii`h cq c lvohobh`z`bh`bx l`b`vcxkv nkv kbqox` q`v~oa` ob cv`cq xmcx cv` obcaa`qqofi` fy zk|`v iob`q" Xm`c~`vcl` mke` kz`vcx`q kb x|k xk xmv`` doik|cxxq z`v hcy nkv cii oxq `i`axvoaci b``hq" Xm`v`nvol`vcxkv vpbq x|`bxynkpv mkpvq z`v hcy xk zv`~`bx nkkh qzkoicl` cbh pq`q zk|`vcaakvhobliy" Qecii qxcbhcikb`) q`~`b xk x`b doik|cxx z`v mkpv HENA l`b`vcxkvq `eox bkzkiipxcbxq cq c fyzvkhpax cbh acb f` pq`h xk zvk~oh` mkx |cx`v kv qzca` m`cxobl nkv c mke`"

8" xvcbqzkvxcxokb czzioacxokbq kn HENA

7/30/2019 Polymer Fuel Cell vs methanol fuel cell

20/20

Cii xm` ecgkv cpxkekxo~` ecbpncaxpv`vq mc~` c np`i a`ii ~`moai` `oxm`v ob h`~`ikze`bx kv obx`qxobl volmx bk|" Mkbhc cbh Xkykxc mc~` civ`chy f`lpb i`cqobl ~`moai`q ob Acionkvboc cbhGczcb" Cpxkecd`vq cbh `}z`vxq qz`apicx` xmcx xm` HENA np`i a`ii ~`moai`q |oii f` |oh`iyakee`vaociow`h fy 6:3:" Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii x`ambkikly) HENA) oq f`oblobakvzkvcx`h obxk fpq`q) xvcobq) qakkx`vq cbh lkin acvxq kb c ncqx`v xoe` iob`"

0" zkvxcfi` zk|`v czzzioacxokbq kn HENAZkqqofiy xm` ekqx |oh` qzv`ch pq`q kn Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`ii x`ambkikly) HENA) cv` obxm` cv`c kn zkvxcfi` zk|`v" Ciqk dbk|b cq Eoavk Np`i A`iiq) Hov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq)HENA) |oii amcbl` xm` x`i`akeepxobl |kvih) zk|`vobl iczxkzq cbh zcie zoikxq mkpvq ikbl`vxmcb fcxx`vo`q cbh ciik|obl pz xk c ekbxm kn xcid xoe` kb c a`iipicv zmkb`" Kxm`v czzioacxokbqnkv eoavk HENA np`i a`iiq obaiph` zcl`vq) ~oh`k v`akvh`vq) zkvxcfi` zk|`v xkkiq) cbh ik|zk|`v v`ekx` h`~oa`q qpam cq m`cvobl cohq) qekd` h`x`axkvq) fpvlicv cicveq) mkx`i ikadq cbhe`x`v v`ch`vq"

>" icbhnoii+|cqx`|cx`v xv`cxe`bx pqobl HENAHov`ax E`xmcbki Np`i A`iiq) HENA) apvv`bxiy kz`vcx` cx icbhnoiiq cbh |cqx`|cx`v xv`cxe`bxzicbxq cavkqq xm` akpbxvy) zvk~obl xm`eq`i~`q cq c ~cioh x`ambkikly nkv v`hpaobl `eoqqokbqcbh l`b`vcxobl zk|`v nvke xm` e`xmcb` lcq xm`y zvkhpa`"