Policies and Procedures for the United States
Transcript of Policies and Procedures for the United States
July 2014
CBRE Valuation and Advisory Services
Practice Area Guidelines
Policies and Procedures for the United States
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | TABLE OF CONTENTS
2
July 2014
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Foreword/Preface ..............................................................................3
2. Best Practices ....................................................................................4
3. Organizational Charts .......................................................................8
4. Contracting For Services ....................................................................9
5. Litigation ........................................................................................ 18
6. Managers ....................................................................................... 22
7. Appraisers ...................................................................................... 26
8. Appraisal Process And Procedures .................................................. 34
9. Human Resources Policies And Procedures ..................................... 35
10. Training: Administration, Appraisers and Management................... 48
11. Other Valuation Services ................................................................ 51
12. Appendix ....................................................................................... 52
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | FOREWORD/PREFACE
3
July 2014
1. FOREWORD/PREFACE
The policies and procedures contained herein apply to all valuation and consulting work
undertaken by CBRE Valuation and Advisory Services (VAS) employees in the United States.
This document replaces all prior VAS policies and procedures, whether provided verbally, in
writing, or previously undocumented.
This manual provides guidelines for the VAS practice area. It addresses the professional
practices of Appraisers, Administration and Management within the VAS business line, the day-
to-day administrative operations of the business, contracting for services, human resources
policies, and legal guidelines – including managing conflict and risk, employee training, and
best practices.
All policies and procedures addressed in this manual must be adhered to by all administrative
staff, professionals and managers in the ongoing operations of the VAS business line across
the country.
1.1 Practice Area Guidelines Committee
The Practice Area Guidelines (PAG) Committee, Elizabeth Champagne and Michael Rowland,
will seek input from VAS management, professionals and administrative staff relative to the
contents of this manual. The Committee will consider all input, making revisions as necessary,
and will continue to amend the manual as policies change due to evolving regulatory
requirements, federal or state legislations and/or CBRE policies and procedures, etc.
1.2 Living Document
This is a “living document” and must always be considered a work in progress where company
policies, legislation and regulatory changes (i.e., USPAP updates) will impact our day-to-day
operations and practices. The Practice Area Guidelines Committee is scheduled to update this
on an annual basis at a minimum.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | BEST PRACTICES
4
July 2014
2. BEST PRACTICES
2.1 Client Communication and Templates
Communication with the client is of the utmost importance throughout every stage of the
appraisal process. Appraisers must contact the client to introduce themselves within 24-48
hours of the job being assigned. They also need to contact the property contact (if different
from the client) within 24-48 hours to introduce themselves, request property data and
schedule the inspection. This should always be done via email and can be supplemented with
phone calls.
Weekly status reports are to be made to the client in writing. Any delays in receiving
property data or setting up inspections, or client changes in scope of the assignment,
MUST be documented in writing with the client. Establishment of a new due date or fee
MUST be documented in writing with the client, where client acknowledges the
changed scope, fee, timing, etc.
In addition, all client communication should be retained in the work file and copied to
Administration, who tracks the status of all pending jobs in the pipeline. Any changes
to fee, timing and scope must be tracked by the status report and communicated to
Management.
Utilize Client communication templates to quickly generate email correspondence to
client.
2.2 Quality Control
All appraisal reports and consulting deliverables must be reviewed by Management and
include at least one MAI-designated signatory. The review function must be fully performed in
order to provide excellent client service and superior products. All reports and consulting
deliverables must be spell- and grammar-checked by the Appraiser prior to submitting it to
Management for review. The Appraiser and then the Reviewer must also review the
engagement letter and the data sheets for accuracy and to insure that all client-specific
guidelines and requirements have been met.
2.3 Risk Management
Refer to the Risk Management Flowchart for guidelines when contracting an engagement. All
engagements must be carefully considered and processed with the least amount of risk for the
company.
2.4 Conflict Management
All aspects of conflict – internal and external – must be carefully managed. Internal conflict
checks must be performed on every assignment by checking all possible resources and
databases. In order to take on a new assignment, both the client and the property need to be
researched. Have any other CBRE service lines serviced this client or property in the past three
years? Is this client on the “Full Fee Retainer Client” list? Would there be any perceived conflict
from both an internal or external point of view? Can this conflict be managed and how? The
Full Fee Retainer Client List is located on iChannel >> .Library \ Client Documents \ ADMIN
folder.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | BEST PRACTICES
5
July 2014
2.5 Technical Skills
It is imperative that the appraisal professionals with the right skill set, both by property type
and by geographic competency, perform the assignment. Additionally, the Appraiser needs to
have access to the databases and materials which would provide the best analysis and service
to the client. All Appraisers need to be proficient in the CBRE report templates and utilize the
full array of data available to provide the best valuation analysis.
Appraisers who specialize in and benefit from certain properties or geographies must maintain
an ongoing dialogue with market participants, including CBRE brokerage and competing
brokerage houses that are active with this market. Appraisers must keep apprised of the
current lease and sale transactions as well as pending lease and sale transactions and listings
which may materially impact their value conclusions.
Professionals must keep current in their technical skills and expertise, including taking classes
and attending professional group seminars and presentations, in addition to reading articles
and news stories that impact real estate and the economy. Additionally, all licenses and
designations need to be actively maintained. Advanced knowledge of Word, Excel and Argus
software must be obtained and maintained.
2.6 Specialty Practice Groups
Those Appraisers specializing in specific property types, such as office, retail, industrial and
multifamily, need to be the “go to” professionals in their markets for assisting clients. These
professionals must communicate regularly with the brokers specializing in their property type(s)
and market(s). It is mandatory for these professionals to be included on the monthly national
conference calls hosted by the various CBRE specialty groups to increase their exposure and
gain market knowledge.
Additional specialty groups include hotel, land, healthcare, seniors housing, student housing,
gas stations, etc. Additional VAS Specialty Practice Groups include value-add services such as
litigation support, partial interest valuation, tax appeal work, eminent domain and myriad
consultative services including market studies, rent analysis, highest and best use studies and
feasibility studies, to name a few.
The more specialized a professional becomes, the greater the potential demand for this
Appraiser’s expertise and knowledge. Clients demand the best person for the job and it
behooves the company to utilize those professionals with the greatest skill set. Those
professionals who are known as industry specialists will garner a greater level of respect, be
asked to perform the greatest amount of assignments by clients and typically are recognized by
the market as industry leaders.
2.7 Maintaining Updated Profiles and Qualifications
It is the responsibility of each appraisal professional to maintain updated profiles with a current
headshot, qualifications and appraisal license(s). These are maintained in the iChannel Library
as well as on the shared network in your respective regional offices.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | BEST PRACTICES
6
July 2014
2.8 Competency
State licensing requires all professionals to conform to USPAP. The competency provision within
USPAP insists that only a competent Appraiser can perform an appraisal. If a professional is
not competent within a particular geography or product type, he or she must decline the
assignment or otherwise take the necessary steps towards becoming competent in doing the
appraisal. If you are assigned a job for which you do not believe you are professionally
competent, you must immediately inform the assigning Manager of this so that the job can be
performed correctly. Managers can choose to reassign the job or bring in the necessary
expertise to ensure the assignment is performed competently.
2.9 RISE Values
The company and all employees are expected to promote and exemplify the ideals of Respect,
Integrity, Service and Excellence. We expect these values to guide your actions at all times.
Failure to adhere to CBRE's RISE values will result in disciplinary action up to and including the
termination of your employment.
2.10 Mentoring Internally and Externally
The appraisal profession has always been one of “learning on the job” and being mentored by
a senior Appraiser. Although Appraisers take courses at colleges and professional
organizations, such as the Appraisal Institute, it is widely acknowledged that there is no
substitution for experience in the field under the guidance of a senior Appraiser.
We encourage all senior professionals to mentor junior staff, both on a structured and
compensated basis, as in taking on a one-third junior Appraiser “under your wing”, or on an
ongoing informal basis with your office mates. Appraisals are best done in collaboration with
others based upon an open exchange of ideas. It is important to foster this attitude within each
CBRE office as it helps all Appraisers become more proficient. Additionally, there are
numerous opportunities to mentor other appraisers professionally by participating in
professional organizations’ mentoring programs, typically on a voluntary basis. All of these
mentoring opportunities enable you to help others, increase your exposure in the industry and
enhance your skills.
See Appraisal Process and Procedure.
2.11 Representing CBRE Internally and Externally
When meeting with internal (CBRE) and external clients, you are at all times representing the
company. Whether you are meeting a property contact on a site inspection or attending the
CBRE monthly brokers’ meeting in your office, you must present yourself professionally in
accordance with our corporate culture and RISE values.
Get involved with as many people in the industry as possible. Develop relationships, work on
professional committees and boards, participate on panels and accept speaking engagements.
All of these activities will provide additional exposure for you and for CBRE. Please refer to
Corporate Media Policy.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | BEST PRACTICES
7
July 2014
2.12 Generating Revenues
As you establish yourself in the appraisal profession and implement the Best Practices and RISE
values, you will typically find that clients – both old and new – will seek you out to order work.
It is a natural progression in this industry. With increased exposure and reputation, clients will
trust you more and often times prefer to deal directly with an Appraiser on the ground than
with Management.
2.13 New Client Accounts and Maintaining Existing Accounts
Generating new and maintaining existing client accounts is an essential Best Practice. All senior
professionals and Management need to continually look for adding new clients to our client
base. New clients are found in various ways, but are best found by networking and attending
as many industry events, seminars, conventions and conferences as possible. Maintaining
existing accounts will naturally occur by providing excellent client service and quality reports.
Make the extra effort to follow up with your client for feedback after services have been
completed. This will not only increase your client relationship but help hone your skills for the
next time.
2.14 Client Service
The primary goal of the VAS business is to provide best-in-class service to our clients at all
times. This objective needs to be emphasized for all CBRE employees as well. Excellent client
service sets us apart from our competitors and will continue to differentiate us from the rest of
the appraisal firms in the country.
Strive to understand what your competitors are delivering in terms of service quality, fees and
timing – and commit to doing it better. Maintain market share and increase dominance in your
respective markets. Strive to be at the top of your clients’ lists as well as the “go to” people in
your offices. Demonstrate that you are always ready and able to assist others, available and
present in the office, and committed to being the best in your area of expertise. If you hold
yourselves to these expectations, your business will grow organically and you will enjoy long,
successful careers in appraisal.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | ORGANIZATIONAL CHARTS AND VAS OFFICES
8
July 2014
3. ORGANIZATIONAL CHARTS
3.1 CBRE Global Operational Structure
http://library.cbre.com/xpedio/groups/public/documents/cbresource_mrk_008/cbre022737.pdf
3.2 CBRE Americas Operational Structure
http://library.cbre.com/xpedio/groups/public/documents/cbresource_mrk_008/cbre025656.pdf
3.3 VAS Management Chart
http://www.cbre.us/services/valuationadvisory/AssetLibrary/VAS_ManagementChart.pdf
3.4 VAS Locations
http://www.cbre.us/services/valuationadvisory/AssetLibrary/VAS_Locations.pdf
3.5 VAS Regional Contacts
http://www.cbre.us/services/valuationadvisory/AssetLibrary/VAS_RegionContacts.pdf
3.6 VAS Office Contacts
http://www.cbre.us/services/valuationadvisory/AssetLibrary/VAS_OfficeContacts.pdf
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
9
July 2014
4. CONTRACTING FOR SERVICES
4.1 Risk Management in Contracting
The initial question which should be addressed by all persons doing contracting is whether or
not an assignment is appropriate for CBRE Valuation and Advisory Services to complete. The
Engagement Flow Chart below gives guidance on determining whether or not to accept an
assignment:
VAS Engagement Flow Chart
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
10
July 2014
4.2 Minimum Requirements
It is mandatory to utilize the most recent CBRE contract on iChannel for CBRE generated
engagements. All contracts should contain the following information:
Date
Identification of subject property
Intended use
Intended user
Reliance Language
Scope of work
Type of product or report
Fee to be charged
Date of delivery
Number of copies of report, but electronic delivery is preferred
Indemnification clause
Arbitration clause
List of information to be provided by client
Signature and state license certification number of CBRE contracting officer
Signature of client and date contract is accepted
Charges for additional work
Additional charges for travel costs
Effective dates of proposal
4.3 Authorization
All contracts to provide appraisal services will be in writing and will be signed by the
President, an SMD, MD, or an Appraiser with an MAI designation or a state license
with a Vice President or higher title and the client prior to commencement of the
assignment. Only the President, SMD or MD may sign contracts with a value greater
than $25,000. It is the responsibility of the CBRE signatory to confirm that the person
signing on behalf of the client has authority to do so. In cases where several entities
are involved (i.e., law firm and its client) it is critical that the party who will be
responsible for payment either sign the contract or sign a separate document
acknowledging financial responsibility.
If master contracts are used, the initial appraisal contract should include all of the
above minimum requirements. Additional inclusions must include accurate names for
client-approved correspondents with a required approved client correspondent
signature on the master contract.
If master contract signatures for all client correspondents are impractical, separate
contracts must be executed by all client correspondents and must reference the master
contract.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
11
July 2014
No assignment will be logged into the VIEW, assigned to an Appraiser, or begun
without a written, enforceable contract. Electronic delivery of contract is acceptable.
4.4 Client Engagement Letters/Contracts
Many engagement letters or contracts are prepared by the client. The following procedure
should be used for all new client contracts and reliance language:
Step one:
Search VIEW to confirm if the client has already been approved. Retainers are not required for approved clients. Use the “Client/Search Client” tool. Client types where this is not required are:
Any federally regulated lender.
Governmental entities (unless there is an unusual requirement in the contract).
If we have not been engaged by an approved client in the prior 5 years, they are considered a
new client and Step Two must be completed.
Step two:
Review any new client engagement letters with the following items in mind.
Property – Review Engagement Flow Chart
Property Type:
Value Premises:
Property Risk Profile: (High/Med/Low)
Client – Review Client Types
Client Type:
Client Risk Profile: (High/Med/Low)
Additionally, Reliance Language, Client/Report Context and Appraiser Competency should all
be considered.
Client master agreements should be reviewed when revised by the client and sent to CBRE VAS
for signature. Client engagement letters should be reviewed by management at least once
every two years to ensure the terms and conditions and risk profile is acceptable to CBRE VAS.
Step three:
If high risk is indicated in any of the above categories, the information should be forwarded to management and possibly to the following legal staff for review:
Mardi K. Milia Senior Counsel - Central Division T 630 573 1296 [email protected]
John L. Mauk
Senior Counsel - Tri State
T 516 714 2703
Griswold Ware Senior Counsel - Eastern Division T 630.573.7109 [email protected]
Alan Wang Senior Counsel - Western Division T 213.613.3002 [email protected]
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
12
July 2014
All Client provided contracts must be signed using the following convention: “YOUR NAME,
TITLE, AS AGENT FOR CBRE GROUP, INC.”
No assignment will be logged into the VIEW, assigned to an Appraiser, or begun without a
written, enforceable contract. Electronic delivery of contract is acceptable. The minimum
information in the billing file for a client generated contract is:
Date of request/contract
Identification of subject property
Intended use
Intended user
Type of product or report
Fee to be charged
Date of delivery
In the event the client responds with an email acceptance of the fee and timing for a contract
or RFP for an assignment, we should sign the contract or RFP, return it to the client as a PDF
and save it in the billings file. If the client responds with an email to an email bid, save the
email and a PDF copy in the billings file. It must contain the minimum requirements.
4.5 Bidding
It is the responsibility of the receiving office (office that will perform the appraisal) to disclose if
CBRE previously appraised the property in question at the time the bid is made. If the manager
bidding on the assignment bypasses the receiving office for a bid, then it is the responsibility of
the manager submitting the bid to disclose if CBRE previously appraised a property at the time
the bid is made. This can be determined by checking with the VIEW.
For many clients (i.e., Bank of America, Wells Fargo, etc.), it is their policy to disclose at the
time the bid is being made if any other CBRE service line is providing real estate services for
the property in question. This can also be determined by checking third party resources such as
CoStar, REIS, LoopNet, Google, etc.
4.6 Reliance Language
When using and/or adding client’s reliance language to our contracts and reports, the
borrower and/or equity participant should not be allowed to rely on the report, unless proper
indemnity and limitation of liability is provided by this class of users. See sample Approved
Reliance Language on iChannel >> .Library \ Client Documents.
The following steps should be used for all new clients and reliance language:
Step one
Search VAS to confirm the client has not been approved by another office. Use the “Client/Search Client” tool. Client types where this process is not required include:
Any federally regulated lender.
Governmental entities (this type of client may have specific requirements that
should be reviewed and approved).
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
13
July 2014
Step two:
If the client exists, search the Client Documents topic folder on the Library site to
determine if the reliance language has already been approved.
If the reliance language is not found or if it has changed, submit the following items to
the Senior Managing Director or Managing Director for approval.
Reliance
Reliance Language:
Intended Use:
Intended Users:
Equity/Borrower: (Yes/No)
Indemnification from Equity/Borrower: (Yes/No)
Client/Report Context
Please provide a general outline relative to the origination of the client and
the property, if available.
As an example, if the “new” client is a prior client who now works at a new
institution, provide a sample of prior approved reliance language at the prior
firm and the proposed language at the new firm (i.e. in many instance the
language is effectively identical to existing approved language).
If high risk is indicated in any of the above categories, the information should
be forwarded by management to the legal staff for review.
4.7 Retainer
A retainer should be obtained prior to commencement of any work from all clients
except those clients that the SMD or MD has determined to have shown a pattern of
timely payment of invoices. The percentage of the retainer may vary based on the
contracting party’s creditworthiness as determined by the SMD/MD. When contracting
with firms that are accustomed to obtaining 100% retainers themselves (i.e., law firms),
a 100% retainer should be obtained.
Receipt of retainer (including date received) should be noted in writing on the contract
and/or in the VIEW. If the contract requests a retainer and the SMD/MD has since
waived the retainer, SMD/MD should initial a note approving the waiver on the
contract. If a requested retainer is not submitted, the job will not be entered into the
VIEW, the job will not be assigned to an Appraiser, and the job will not commence
until this occurs.
4.8 CBRE Standard Contract
A copy of the most current standard contract is maintained on iChannel and should be used.
Any significant changes from this contract must be authorized by the SMD or President and
may need to be reviewed by the Legal Department.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
14
July 2014
4.9 Terms and Conditions
Clause #15
LIMITATION OF LIABILITY. EXCEPT TO THE EXTENT ARISING FROM SECTION 16 BELOW,
OR SECTION 17 IF USED, IN NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER
FOR ANY SPECIAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE, INCIDENTAL OR INDIRECT DAMAGES.
EXCEPT TO THE EXTENT ARISING FROM SECTION 16 BELOW, OR 17 IF APPLICABLE, IN
NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY’S TOTAL LIABILITY TO THE OTHER FOR DAMAGES
UNDER THE AGREEMENT EXCEED, IN THE AGGREGATE, THE GREATER OF EITHER THE
AMOUNT OF THE TOTAL FEES PAID TO APPRAISER UNDER THIS AGREEMENT, OR TEN
THOUSAND DOLLARS ($10,000). BY SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, CLIENT INDICATES
ITS UNDERSTANDING OF THE LIABILITY LIMITATION HEREIN AND AGREES TO ABIDE BY
SUCH LIMITATION. THIS LIABILITY LIMITATION SHALL NOT APPLY IN THE EVENT OF A
FINAL FINDING BY AN ARBITRATOR OR A COURT OF COMPETENT JURISDICTION THAT
SUCH LIABILITY IS THE RESULT OF A PARTY’S GROSS NEGLIGENCE, FRAUD OR WILLFUL
MISCONDUCT.
Existing Aggregate Limitation of Liability is $10,000 and has been approved to move up to
$1,000,000 (One Million). Amount exceeding $1,000,000 needs approval from VAS
President. To waive Limitation of Liability, you must have SMD approval along with
understanding of intended use and user of report, and risk profile of client and property
type. If risk profile of client and/or property type is high (per VAS Engagement Flow
Chart), then approval from VAS President is necessary.
Clause #17
In the event Client incorporates or references the Appraisal Report, in whole or in part, in
any offering or other material intended for review by other parties, Client shall indemnify,
defend and hold each of the Indemnified Parties harmless from and against any Damages
in connection with (i) any transaction contemplated by this Agreement or in connection
with the appraisal or the engagement of or performance of services by any Indemnified
Party hereunder, (ii) any actual or alleged untrue statement of a material fact, or the actual
or alleged failure to state a material fact necessary to make a statement not misleading in
light of the circumstances under which it was made with respect to all information
furnished to any Indemnified Party or made available to a prospective party to a
transaction, or (iii) an actual or alleged violation of applicable law by Client (including,
without limitation, securities laws) or the negligent or intentional acts or omissions of Client
(including the failure to perform any duty imposed by law); and will reimburse each
Indemnified Party for all reasonable fees and expenses (including fees and expenses of
counsel) (collectively, “Expenses”) as incurred in connection with investigating, preparing,
pursuing or defending any threatened or pending claim, action, proceeding or
investigation (collectively, “Proceedings”) arising therefrom, and regardless of whether
such Indemnified Party is a formal party to such Proceeding. Client agrees not to enter
into any waiver, release or settlement of any Proceeding (whether or not any Indemnified
Party is a formal party to such Proceeding) without the prior written consent of Appraiser
(which consent will not be unreasonably withheld or delayed) unless such waiver, release
or settlement includes an unconditional release of each Indemnified Party from all liability
arising out of such Proceeding.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
15
July 2014
4.10 Cancellation
Cancellation of contracts should be in writing and maintained in the billings file.
4.11 Additional Services to Clients
Extra Copies – When clients request additional copies of reports, it is recommended the client
be charged $250 for each color copy or $100 for each black and white copy. This is at the
SMD/MD discretion. When invoicing a client for extra copies, the entire allocation should go to
the profit center as an expense reimbursement.
4.12 Indemnification Letter
Ask for Indemnification in the following circumstances:
Single asset securitization (144a).
Single asset or group of assets appraised by us is the sole collateral of a public offering such as public bond financing.
Our report will be filed as part of security offering on a public exchange, domestic or international.
Any time our report is to be used to raise equity against the appraised asset.
When the purpose of an appraisal is for one of the above situations where third
parties may rely on our opinion of value, an indemnity letter must be signed by
the client. A copy of the standard indemnity letter is maintained on iChannel.
Any significant changes from this contract must be authorized by the SMD or
President and may need to be reviewed by the Legal Department.
VAS Indemnification Letters
Indemnification Form
Indemnification - Securitization Form
This differs from loan securitization because our appraisals only cover some of the properties in the pool and loan default risk is spread across the pool.
Any modification to the language in the indemnity agreement is not preferred and VAS is not in a position to modify, without consulting the legal department.
4.13 Re-Certification/Reliance Letter
Per USPAP, reliance letters are no longer prepared and have been replaced by a new
engagement which USPAP requires if there is a new intended use or user. A new contract for a
new assignment must be issued and signed by both parties (CBRE and the New Client). The
“old” or existing report, prepared for Client A, may be issued to the new client B who wants to
rely on the “old” report utilizing the old date of value. This “new” report prepared for Client B
must be issued with a current date on the letter of transmittal, along with the new client name
(user) and intended use. All confidential property data must be requested from and provided
by the new client.
4.14 Confidentiality Agreements
Confidentiality Agreement
VAS Appraisers are bound by USPAP, State Licensing, FIRREA regulations and
interagency guidelines in most assignments. Our professional designation and
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
16
July 2014
applicable regulations all carry confidentiality requirements which only allow disclosure
to the client and intended users. We are prohibited from sharing information internally
or externally. Frequent institutional users of appraisals know this and accept it, and
standard agreements with financial institutions may have clauses addressing
confidentiality. Our professional standards for all intents and purposes require the
same level of confidentiality that specific agreements seek but without any prescribed
liability or recourse.
From time to time we are asked to sign a specific confidentiality agreement, usually in
the following situations:
Owner of the property is concerned about the disclosure of property information to other CBRE Business Units.
There is a pending sale of the property.
Property is in some type of litigation.
Standard practice for some asset managers.
In these situations we are usually provided with a document that is designed for the
dissemination of property information for prospective buyers or investors in the
transaction, and we need to rewrite it to reflect our appraisal assignment and remove
language concerning investor or buyer responsibilities. In litigation or bankruptcy
assignments, it will vary by attorney.
Critical points we need in a Confidentiality Agreement are:
Absolute right to retain copies of documents to comply with state licensing laws and professional regulations.
Protect our other business unit’s right to conduct normal business concerning the property, acknowledging our restriction from sharing information but also acknowledging that other business units have other sources and may already be in possession of related material.
Should be binding on VAS only and not other CBRE business units
Language that we don’t want in the document:
Statements that assume CBRE actions immediately harm the client.
Assumption that we are immediately liable for monetary damages.
If in doubt, forward the Confidentiality Agreement to legal for review.
When we are asked to provide our own document, which is the preferable option, we
should use the one prepared and approved by CBRE legal department.
4.15 Intended User – Limitation of Liability
In order to add an intended user, before the assignment is completed, who wishes to
rely on the report, an Intended User Limitation of Liability must be signed by the new
intended user. This form is used when a new engagement letter is not realistic. This
allows the new intended user to rely on the report and limits the risk liability and
exposure incurred by CBRE. When this form is used, ensure that the limitation amount
does not exceed the limitation amount in the client’s agreement.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | PORTFOLIO PROCEDURES AND POLICY
17
July 2014
4.16 Non-Reliance and Release
When a client asks us to provide a copy of the report to a party who will not be an
intended user (informational purposes only), a Non-Reliance and Release must be
signed by the recipient. By signing, the party acknowledges that it is not relying on the
report and agrees to release all liability.
4.17 Securities Offering Indemnification Agreement
When a client wants to include information from the Appraisal for use in a securities
offering, CBRE will consent to the use of the Appraisals or any information therein with
the offering, if the Offering Indemnification Agreement is executed by the client.
4.18 Privacy Policy
http://www.cbre.com/EN/Pages/legal/privacypolicy.aspx
SOBC – confidentiality with our clients is mentioned specifically on page 14 of the
document, and addressed sporadically throughout. The link for the outwardly facing
version is here: http://www.cbre.com/sobc
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
18
July 2014
5. LITIGATION
The following section contains the additional policies and procedures for litigation support
related work.
5.1 Conflict Check
For assignments related to expert litigation, a conflict check needs to be completed. Send an
email using the following format to !CBRE-Notice of Litigation.
CBRE Valuation and Advisory Services has been contacted to perform expert related services in
connection with a lawsuit involving the following property and parties. Please let VAS know
within 2 days of any conflicts concerning this potential assignment.
Property Address
Party Retaining CBRE
Attorney for Party Retaining CBRE
Opposing Party
Attorney for Opposing Party
Court where matter is pending
Short Description of Dispute/Assignment
5.2 Additional Contract Provisions
While our usual contract contains the following, you need to pay particular attention to:
A clear description of the services you will be providing
Fees – hourly/flat fee/combination of the two. What does the flat fee cover and what do the hourly fees cover. This is necessary to identify what can be billed and when.
If hourly fees, indicate we will bill monthly (this is a GAAP requirement so that we recognize revenue in the proper period)
Is there a cap on the fee? (only include if there is a cap)
What constitutes allowable expenses (especially if they are added to the fee)
Signature of party financially responsible (if a lawyer on behalf of the client, the lawyer needs to understand that his/her signing of the contract puts him/her under obligation to pay if the client does not – otherwise, the lawyer needs to get the client to sign)
It is highly recommended that a retainer or prepayment is required. If a retainer is paid at the beginning of the assignment, the full fee must be paid before delivery of the report.
Additionally an additional retainer is required for additional work (additional research, deposition, testimony, etc) based on an estimate of time.
5.3 Additional Litigation Specific Documentation
The following needs to be contained within the file for all litigation assignments.
Contract properly and clearly outlining services and fees with all proper approvals
Copy of conflict check email
Proof of delivery of any product (if applicable)
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
19
July 2014
Time Log (if hourly fee) which clearly indicates dates and amount of hours when services were rendered (this serves as your POD on hourly assignments and must be turned in monthly with billings)
Copy of invoice (date of invoice must be in the same month that the hourly services are provided)
If there is a cap on fees, you must have additional approval from client to bill above the cap (i.e., addendum to contract or email from client approving)
Copy of any payments
5.4 Subpoenas
A subpoena is a writ by a government agency, most often a court, that has authority to
compel testimony by a witness or production of evidence under a penalty for failure.
There are two common types of subpoena:
1. Subpoena that orders a person to testify before the ordering authority or face
punishment. The subpoena can also request the testimony to be given by phone or
in person.
2. Subpoena that orders a person or organization to bring physical evidence before
the ordering authority or face punishment. This is often used for requests to mail
copies of documents to requesting party or directly to court.
What to do when you receive a subpoena:
1. Internal Notifications - You need to immediately notify, i.e., send a copy of the
subpoena to:
The legal department
Your MD/SMD
2. Read the subpoena! - Once you get a subpoena:
Identify the property and appraisal(s) at issue
Determine:
WHO is asking you to appear
The PARTIES to the case
Whether we did the appraisal for a party to the litigation
Identify what type of subpoena was served
Trial or Deposition
Documents or Testimony or Both
If testimony is requested, determine:
o Expert or Fact Witness
o If they intend to pay you and how much
o Determine who is paying
Identify and calendar initial date noticed for testimony and/or document
production
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
20
July 2014
3. Notify Your Client - With the assistance of the legal department, you’ll need to
contact your client to determine whether your client wants CBRE to comply with the
request or if the client (not CBRE) wants to move to quash the subpoena. If the
client wants to move to quash the subpoena, notify legal IMMEDIATELY.
4. Work with the Legal Department - Coordinate the following with the assistance
of the legal department:
DOCUMENT COLLECTION
Hard copies
o For hard copy documents, assemble all hard copies in your possession or control
o Send via FTP or PDF to legal
Electronic documents
o Identify the custodian(s) of record
o Coordinate with the senior paralegal to collect any documents in electronic form
TESTIMONY
Coordinate with the legal department
TRIAL Subpoena
o Confirm your availability
o Block out on your calendar all possible dates on which you might be required to appear
DEPOSITION Subpoena
o Identify dates on which you are available to appear
5.5 Legal Compliance and Support
The corporate legal department has designated counsel for the VAS division. They include:
Central Division
Mardi Milia
630.573.1296
Eastern Division
Griswold Ware
630.573.7109
Western Division
Alan Wang
213.613.3002
Beverley Lu
213.613.3004
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
21
July 2014
Tri-States
John Mauk
516.714.2703
5.6 Litigation Specialist
For additional information regarding litigation related matters, please contact the Litigation
Practice Leader:
Steve D. DuPlantis, MAI | Senior Managing Director CBRE | Valuation & Advisory Services 2700 Post Oak Boulevard, Suite 250 | Houston, TX 77056 T 713 840 6625 | F 713 840 6649 | C 713 703 8038 [email protected] | www.cbre.com
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
22
July 2014
6. MANAGERS
Managers include all employees with titles of Managing Director (MD), Senior Managing
Director (SMD) and sometimes Director. Some of the following guidelines may also apply to
Senior Appraisers who generate business and provide training to Appraisers, including those
with teams.
6.1 Initial Client Communication
Clients are either contacted by CBRE or contact CBRE directly or through third parties (i.e., law
firms acting on behalf of their clients or mortgage brokers obtaining financing for their clients).
It is the responsibility of the receiving office (office that will perform the appraisal) to disclose if
CBRE previously appraised the property in question at the time the bid is made. If the manager
bidding on the assignment bypasses the receiving office for a bid, then it is the responsibility of
the manager submitting the bid to disclose if CBRE previously appraised a property at the time
the bid is made. This can be determined by checking with the VIEW.
For many clients (i.e., Bank of America, Wells Fargo, etc.), it is their policy to disclose at the
time the bid is being made if any other CBRE service line is providing real estate services for
the property in question. This can also be determined by checking third party resources such as
CoStar, REIS, LoopNet, Google, etc.
Also see “Contracting for Services”.
In all cases, Management must identify and fully understand the client’s needs first, including
the intended use and user, any other reliant parties, and the required scope of services. These
are further described below.
Intended Use - What is the purpose of the report or requested service? Will they be
used in conjunction with additional reports or filings (i.e., estate tax filing, financing,
partnership buy out, etc.)?
Intended User - Who will be relying on this report or service? Who is paying for it? Are
the purchaser and the intended user the same party? With whom are we contracting to
provide this report or service – the purchaser or the intended user?
Scope of Services - Type of report, dates of value, interest appraised, property details,
detail level of analysis required, inspection required, expected cooperation of the
contact or borrower, property data that is/is not available for the assignment, etc.
Required Report Signature - Approved Appraiser or Manager; MAI/Manager will
subsequently review and cosign.
Staff Expertise - Which staff Appraiser or Manager has the geographic and property
type expertise and competency to perform the required scope of services?
Management is responsible for maintaining the national “Full Fee Retainer Client List.” This list
is to include all Clients that are known to have a poor payment history, outstanding receivables
or other issues, such as pending lawsuits against CBRE. The latter necessitates national
notification to all offices that these are not clients with whom CBRE will continue to do business.
The Full Fee Retainer Client List is located on iChannel >> .Library \ Client Documents \
ADMIN folder.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
23
July 2014
6.2 Assigning Work
Work is assigned by Management based on geographic and property type
expertise/competency in addition to availability, timing and client requirements. Typically, if
Appraisers generate assignments, they may have first option to perform the assignment
themselves if the property is within their region. However, circumstances may arise requiring
Management to reassign the work to better suit the client’s needs.
6.3 Communication During the Workflow Process
Administration, Appraisers and Management must have a uniform process in place ensuring
all parties are in continual communication, internally and externally with the clients, regarding
the status of each assignment. The suggested process follows below.
Contract comes in, either directly from external client or as a referral from another VAS
office, and assignment is set up in the VIEW.
Administration provides unassigned contract to Management, who then assigns the job
to an Appraiser, based on expertise, geographic or property competency, timing, client
requirements, etc.
Administration sets up electronic job folder and provides contract and any data to
assigned Appraiser.
(Optional) Administration provides full Appraiser contact information to the client.
Appraiser contacts client for initial introduction, property data request and inspection
within 24-48 hours of receiving the job. Appraiser should copy procuring manager
and Administration on initial email.
Appraiser should re-verify if any other CBRE line of business is providing real estate
services for the subject property before work begins.
Appraiser provides assignment weekly status report updates to the client,
Administration and Management in writing.
Appraiser to notify Management and Administration if there are any changes to the
due date. Appraiser must copy procuring manager on any changes in due date or
scope. (Optional) Two weeks and one week before job is due, Administration sends
follow up email to Appraiser to make sure all property info is received and job is still
on time.
Appraisers must contact client to request delay of contracted deliverables immediately
upon determining that the contractual due dates are unachievable based on
documented delays. Appraiser immediately notifies the client, Administration and
Management (both local office and procuring manager) of any delays in receipt of
information or inspection in writing.
Management must be informed of all timelines with a “living” job log/status report,
updated at regular intervals by Administration, in order to track all assignments in the
pipeline and to track and distribute appraiser workload.
In addition to timelines, Management must stay informed of any valuation issues that
may create the need for additional client service in order to take preventative measures
and manage client expectations. Appraisers must notify Management of any such
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
24
July 2014
issues immediately so that they may help to diffuse potentially contentious situations
before they become a problem.
6.4 Review
6.4.1 Quality Control
The review process is an essential part of the appraisal process. It is at this point of the
assignment that critical thinking and analytical skills are utilized by an objective party
to confirm or critique all aspects of the appraisal report, including the non-textual
parts such as photos, maps, exhibits, addenda, etc.
The Reviewer must review the contract to ensure that all client requirements are met.
The data sheets must also be reviewed for accuracy. Argus inputs must be reviewed as
well. All reports provided to a Reviewer must first be spell- and grammar-checked,
including the Excel charts, photo captions, exhibits, etc.
The review function provides tremendous, objective insight into the quality and
capabilities of the Appraiser. During this process, strengths and weaknesses of the
Appraiser become evident, immediate feedback is provided to the Appraiser and they
typically learn to enhance their skills. If deficiencies are addressed repeatedly with a
particular Appraiser and efforts are not made to improve, reviewers must
communicate this with Management, particularly the relevant MD (SMD).
At Management’ discretion, Management may implement specific performance
measures for an employee to help them perform at a higher level and to provide
additional training or mentorship. Continued or substantial performance issues may
lead to other corrective action up to and including termination of employment.
6.4.2 Procedure
Upon assignment of a new project to an Appraiser, the project Reviewer should also
be assigned, if possible. The Reviewer and Appraiser are noted on the project Status
Report at the outset, so that all parties to the assignment can be introduced to each
other and made aware of their responsibilities. Appraisers and Reviewers should
discuss the assignment up front and periodically throughout to ensure all client
expectations are being met.
6.4.3 The Review Process Link by Appraisal Institute
The link above shows the detailed steps to perform a thorough review as endorsed by
the Appraisal Institute.
6.4.4 Internal Review Checklist
For every assignment, the Reviewer is required to complete the Internal Review
Checklist, which must be maintained in the job folder. This document is critical and
attention to the checklist details is mandatory.
6.4.5 Argus Audit
All Argus runs must be reviewed for consistency between the report and the Argus
model.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | MANAGERS
25
July 2014
6.4.6 Signature Protocol
CBRE VAS requires all appraisal reports to be reviewed by Management and signed by
MAI-designated Appraisers, which may be one and the same. If a non-management
MAI Appraiser signs a report, the report must also be reviewed by Management,
although it does not need to be signed by Management.
If a report is signed by a non-MAI Appraiser, the report must also be reviewed and
signed by an MAI-designated Manager. This ensures that all appraisal reports are
reviewed by a second set of eyes.
Make sure you understand each State’s requirements before accepting the assignment.
Unless contrary to law, USPAP allows another person to sign for an appraiser
(including digital signatures), as long as it is with the appraiser’s specific authorization
(i.e. on an assignment by assignment basis). An appraiser must not affix the signature
of another appraiser without their consent. Blanket permission is not allowed.
Many States require the signatories or preparers of the report to be licensed in the
state the property is located. Restrictions as to what may or may not be done by
licensed/unlicensed appraisers vary widely by jurisdiction. “Mandatory” states do not
permit any exception to licensing laws; “Voluntary” states generally have provisions
permitting unlicensed practice under certain circumstances. These statues require us
to educate the client when they are requesting reviews/signatures of client approved
appraisers who are not licensed in the state the appraised property is located. Either
the approved appraiser needs to get licensed in the state the property is located or
work with the client to have the appropriate state licensed appraiser added to the
client’s approved appraiser list. It is the individual appraiser’s responsibility to ensure
that all work performed on the appraisal meets state regulatory requirements.
6.4.7 Signature Protocol For Freddie Mac Reports
Freddie Mac requires every appraiser who signs the report to inspect the property and
they do not require that all reports are signed by an MAI; that is a CBRE requirement.
This effectively requires cosigning MAI’s to inspect.
There are times this is impractical, therefore, we have amended our signature policy
for Freddie Mac reports. The field professional (assuming not an MAI) will inspect and
sign the report and the non-inspecting MAI will review and be added to certification
page as reviewer/contributor under clause number 13.
6.5 Portfolio Procedures and Policy
See Portfolio Procedures and Policy.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
26
July 2014
7. APPRAISERS
7.1 Job Flow
7.1.1 Starting an Assignment
The appraiser will receive an engagement memo via email that provides the job
number and instructions specific to the assignment. An optional voting button may be
included in the notification email in order for the appraiser to confirm receipt of the new
assignment. The following electronic file attachments to this email notification will be
included in the form of a .zip archive:
A job summary sheet (to be produced in the new VIEW system);
A job folder .Zip file with a new job folder structure (see folder extraction instructions below);
An engagement letter; and
Any other pertinent job related information/spreadsheets provided by client.
Upon receipt of a new assignment email notification, use the following 2-step process
to quickly save the electronic job folder and subfolders from the WinZip archive file to
Work in Progress:
Right-click the zip file and select Open With then select Windows Explorer from the sub-menu;
Drag and drop to add the new job folder to your Work in Progress folder.
Drag and drop into Work in Progress
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
27
July 2014
As part of the new procedures, the network library archive will be restricted to read-only
access and the appraiser will no longer move or copy the electronic job files to the
library archive. Instead, a new folder location has been created on the network library
named “Archive Inbox”.
Each office will designate an admin staff-person to be the “Archive Administrator” for
the electronic archives.
Upon completion of draft and/or final report, the appraiser will move or copy the entire
work file into the “Archive Inbox” folder (not into the job archive as was the prior
procedure) and notify the Archive Administrator that it is ready for one of the following
steps:
to be moved to the Archives; or
to be scrubbed.
This procedure will overwrite any previous versions of the assignment that may exist.
Designated staff members who move the files to archives are instructed only to keep the
latest versions and only 1 copy of any file.
7.1.2 Review Initial Information Provided
Engagement Letter. Understand scope of work, client requirements, intended use/user
and client before starting assignment.
Current Client Requirements. Check iChannel >> .Library >> Client Documents.
Current Template. Retrieve current template format from iChannel >> .Formats or
use a customized template as long as it is based on the most current version of the
format.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
28
July 2014
7.1.3 Initial Client Communication
First Contact with Client. We are a professional service business, and excellent
communication with our clients distinguishes us from our competition. Appraisers must
contact a client representative within two business days of engagement; however,
contact within 24 hours is preferable. Check iChannel for client communication
templates.
Introduction letter with initial data request. Retrieve current template format from
iChannel >> .Formats >> Miscellaneous \ Client Correspondence.
Copy originating CBRE employee on the introduction letter.
7.1.4 Data Request
Must be done in writing within two business days of engagement; however, one
business day is preferable.
CBRE Affiliation. In addition to our standard data request, the Appraiser must ask for
the names and affiliations of all selling/listing brokers, financing brokers, leasing
agents, and property managers. If CBRE is managing, leasing, listing the property to
SELL or BUY, and/or the mortgage broker for the property, the Appraiser must inform
the client in writing. The client will let us know if they believe there is a conflict or not.
Perceived Conflict. If the client believes CBRE’s affiliation causes a conflict of interest,
they can cancel the assignment.
No Perceived Conflict. If the client does not perceive CBRE’s affiliation with the property
to be a conflict, then we will proceed with the assignment. The following language must
be added to the report (in the letter of transmittal, certification and reconciliation). Use
only the words in red that apply.
“The client is aware that CBRE was/is the sales agent/leasing agent/management
agent/mortgage broker for this transaction. Although employees of other CBRE
divisions were involved in the sale/leasing/management/financing, Valuation and
Advisory Services (VAS) operates as an independent economic entity within CBRE.
VAS has not and will not receive any compensation as a result of the transaction. Our
fee is a standard and customary flat fee and not contingent upon a sale or mortgage
placement. Our work and the conclusions herein were reached independently and the
results of this assignment were not influenced in any way by the involvement of other
CBRE divisions.”
7.1.5 Inspection
Dress Professionally and Arrive Promptly. You are the face of CBRE. Please dress in a
manner befitting our global brand. On-time arrival at the subject property is expected.
See CBRE’s dress code policies.
Be Prepared and Ask Questions. Review property information (if provided) prior to
inspection and come prepared with any questions. Check rent roll against actual
occupancy. Complete a full inspection. See Sample questions.
Take Pictures. A photographic record is an essential part of the inspection process. This
serves as a memory aid and an important record of the property and its surroundings
at the time of inspection in case of a future dispute. Please be courteous – ask for a
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
29
July 2014
tenant’s permission to take photographs inside their building, and respect any
restrictions they may require.
Measurement Techniques and Accuracy
Typically we rely upon a confirmed source of information that has been provided to us or is publicly available to determine the size of the improvements. Occasionally, at the request of the client or if no source is available, the appraiser will have to measure the improvements. Extreme care should be taken and working with a partner who can hold the end of the tape is helpful, but most buildings can be measured solo.
Create a basic building sketch or field drawing. It does not need to be exact; it simply needs to illustrate what the building looks like. Have this with you when you measure so you can indicate measurements on your sketch. Label your sketch with the name of the building, the address, and the date.
If possible, measure from one corner of the building to the other. This gives you the entire length of the building. Measure in sections if one part of the building sticks out from the rest. Indicate where windows, doors, and other features are located. Again, use running dimensions to decrease the chance of making a mistake. Keep the tape level for more accurate measurements. Be sure to start at a level that allows you to get measurements for the key features.
Make additional measurements and notes on the drawing as you see fit. These might include the ceiling height, loading door dimensions, flooring or wall materials, etc. As you photograph the building, indicate on the sketch the location and direction of the photo.
To estimate the floor area. Multiply the length and width of each section, then add those together. Round off to the nearest square foot. Any material error in any of the data could have a substantial impact on the conclusions reported. Thus, make sure we clearly reserve the right to amend the conclusions reported if made aware of any such error. Make sure to properly state the source of the building size and add the appropriate disclaimer.
Use a sketch software programs such as Apex Sketch or RapidSketch to improve accuracy. The appraiser must be familiar with the BOMA measurement standards as well as the Marshall Valuation Service information regarding building measurement.
7.1.6 Ongoing Client Communication
Weekly Status Updates. Draft letters with templates on iChannel >> .Formats >>
Miscellaneous \ Client Correspondence.
Review Process. Please respond within 24 hours of receiving comments from the client
regarding the draft appraisal. If additional research is required which would put the
response time beyond 24 hours, the client’s Reviewer should be notified and an
estimated date of completion given and met.
Work File. Appraiser must keep copies of all communications with client, Management,
etc., in the electronic work file. Of particular importance will be documentation
demonstrating the Appraiser’s attempt to complete the job in a timely fashion should
the client later assess late penalties. Failure to do so may result in financial penalties to
the Appraiser if a client challenges the delivery deadline. A signed certification is
included in the “true copy” of the report, however a signed certification must be
included in the work file if an oral report is given or if no “final” report is provided.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
30
July 2014
7.1.7 Administrative Procedures
Uploading Invoices. Follow the instructions from the initial client email regarding
uploading invoices, if required.
Proof of Delivery. This must be submitted to Administration promptly. The project will
not be billed until proof of delivery is received; and it is not Administration’s
responsibility to track it down.
Billing Sheets and Internal Review Sheets. These must be submitted electronically when
the report is completed – NOT at the end of the month. Late submission is
unacceptable and causes problems with accounting.
Work File. Save Argus and all correspondence. They must be submitted to
Administration when the project is completed.
Responsiveness. Respond to client emails immediately, even if you are just letting them
know when you will respond fully. If others are cc’d on the email, make sure to “Reply
to All”. Remember to respond to Job Reminders by hitting “Reply to All” with an
updated project status. If the due date has changed, indicate this in your email.
Client Communication. Client communication must be ongoing throughout the
appraisal process. As discussed earlier, you must make initial client contact within 24-
48 hours to introduce yourself and request property information. Once received, review
property information thoroughly to ensure it is complete. Make sure you are
communicating with the person who ordered the appraisal report.
Report Delays. If you do not receive full property information promptly, you must alert
the client via email. If these delays will cause a delay in delivery of the final report, you
must inform the client via email and cc Administration so they can note the billing file.
This is critical for auditing purposes.
If you are delayed with delivery of your report because you are behind, you must still
contact the client and let them know, in writing, as soon as possible before the due date.
Do not “lay low” hoping the client will forget the due date. This will only upset them further.
If you no longer plan to bill your job in the current month due to delays, you must send an
email to Management and Administration to let them know.
7.2 Assignment Execution
With the exception of specific contractual obligations with the client, hard-copy working files
will no longer be archived. Appraiser must adhere to a consistent electronic job filing
structure. Refer to the Job Archiving System section for procedures regarding conversion
from the hard-copy work papers to scanned electronic file archives.
Paper job folders will no longer be created. The appraiser will have access to a supply of
pocket folders, manila files, plastic sleeves, etc. in which to keep the work papers during the
course of the assignment.
During the assignment, the appraiser may continue to use their own preferred filing system
for hard-copy working files.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
31
July 2014
7.2.1 Electronic File Storage
Naming Primary Job Folder
12-271PH-XXXX-YY {Description} – This is the root-level job folder that contains all files related to the specific assignment. “XXXX” represents the file number. The suffix “YY” will be added to distinguish properties within a portfolio. The {Description} is a brief description such as property name or address. Examples include:
12-361HO-0012 Zipline and Canopy Tours, Walnut Shade MO
12-251LA-0122 Atria West
12-231SF-0536-04 Bayside Business Center, Fremont CA
Documents at Root Level
Files to be maintained at the root level are:
Argus
Excel
Word
PDF complete with Addenda. Initial draft will be replaced with the Final PDF
Any other Excel files directly linked to the primary XLModel or Word document (DCF link spreadsheets, for example)
Sub-Folders within each Primary Job Folder
Billing – contains all relevant files for billing and payment/collection info, such as:
Signed Engagement Letter and any amendments
Client and accounting invoices
Copy of retainer check
Copy of cash transmittals (copies of checks are optional, as they are archived as part of the lockbox system)
Documentation of collection efforts
Proof of delivery
Internal Review Checklist (completed and signed)
Job worksheet (completed)
Expense report
Comps – contains comparable property research used in preparation of the appraisal report such as:
Comparable data sheets
VAS import files
Maps
Correspondence – contains any job related correspondence and relevant e-mails.
All correspondence with the client, property contact, broker, etc. Save e-mails as Outlook item or print to PDF.
Market – contains all backup information for regional, neighborhood, and market study sections.
Investor surveys
Industry specific publications cited in the report
Area analysis – Land sales, building sales, building rents, zoning ordinance
Photos – contains all .jpg files taken during the assignment (to be deleted during archival process).
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
32
July 2014
Keep only one set of the photos to be used in the report.
Reduce resolution to "Documents" or 1024 x 768 pixels prior to using in report or archiving.
Property – contains all property information received from client and/or property contact.
Financials, operating statements, cap ex itemization, etc. (scan documents if provided hard copies)
Environmental reports
Leases
Zoning documents
Architectural plans, ALTA surveys, etc.
Use subfolder structure such as “Provided by Client”, “Provided by Borrower”, etc. to identify the source of the property data, if desired.
Work-papers – contains relevant work-papers to be scanned and archived with the assignment at delivery of the draft report.
All field inspection notes
Notes on any communication with brokers, developers, etc.
Comparable verification notes
Any market data unique to this assignment.
Temp – contains any miscellaneous data files used during the execution of the assignment that are to be deleted upon archival.
Demographics
Addenda items
Any other document which is needed for report production
Copies of old reports used during the preparation of the appraisal
7.3 Job Archiving
All jobs must be archived on the network after the final report has been delivered to the client.
The assignment is deemed effectively complete once the report is delivered to the client,
whether in draft or final.
Work-file archival is to commence immediately upon this event.
Once the assignment is complete, the following steps should be followed for file archival:
The appraiser will optimize the hard-copy (paper) work-file by removing duplicate information and information that would normally not be archived i.e. Argus report print-outs, comp data sheets, and any market data or surveys that have been incorporated within the report.
The appraiser will scan the paper file to .PDF and move the scanned file into the “Work-papers” sub-folder within the electronic job folder.
The electronic job folder is moved or copied to the network “Archive Inbox” folder.
The VAS billing sheet is sent to the Billing Admin/mailbox.
The Archive Administrator will audit the optimized complete electronic job folder and move it from the “Archive Inbox” folder into the appropriate “Archive” folder on the network library drive.
The electronic job folder will be removed from the network Archive Inbox folder.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISERS
33
July 2014
If additional revisions need to be made after the job has been finalized and archived, it is the appraiser’s responsibility to ensure that the latest version of the file is used by always copying the job file from the Library Archive in order to minimize any duplicate scrub efforts.
When revisions are completed and a revised report delivered to the client, the electronic file is to be immediately returned to the Archive Inbox folder on the N: drive. Any additional hard copy items should be delivered to the Archive Administrator with the Job Summary Sheet attached.
The revised PDF report overwrites the original PDF report. Only one final report should be maintained in the archived directory at any time.
If a separate archive of assignments is maintained by the appraiser away from the N: drive archive folders, the separate archive must be identical to the archive folder on the N: drive. It may not contain additional files such as review comments from the managers. It may not contain prior drafts of the reports. It may not contain notes that were kept but were not put in the N: drive archives. All relevant information must be maintained in the "official" archive folders and there must not be additional data located elsewhere.
7.4 Requesting Assistance within the CBRE Platform
When utilizing the VAS platform for assistance with an assignment, whether it be updated market
studies, formats, comparables or insight, please be cognoscente of the perception of your request.
The recommended subject line for help is below.
Subject: Request for Assistance – “Property Type”
Within the body of the email describe what type of assistance you are requesting. You are seeking
information, assistance, or help, not competency. The more specific your request, the better
assistance you can expect. If you do not have the necessary competency to complete the
assignment, notify management immediately.
7.5 VAS Technology User Manual
The VAS Technology User Manuel is an important piece of reference material and it is available on iChannel >> .Format \ Miscellaneous \ Appraiser Tools.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPRAISAL PROCESS AND PROCEDURES
34
July 2014
8. APPRAISAL PROCESS AND PROCEDURES
8.1 Keys to a Well-Written Appraisal
A well-written appraisal anticipates and addresses a Reviewer’s questions. Many narrative reports
lack a summary thread that relates how the findings of the report impact the value of the subject
property. Some of the differences between a well-written appraisal and a below-average appraisal
are the addition of a detailed descriptive analysis in each section of the report and a concise
summary at the conclusion of each section.
See Appraisal Process and Procedures
All of the expectations of what makes a quality appraisal are also contained in the formats’ hidden
text.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
35
July 2014
9. HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
9.1 Hiring
All hiring will be done in conformance with the CBRE Human Resources policy and procedures.
SMDs/MDs will conduct annual performance reviews of all administrative and professional staff in
accordance with the Human Resources Policies and Procedures. Employment with CBRE is at-will,
which means that either the employee or CBRE may terminate an employee’s employment at any
time, with or without notice or cause. All titles are honorary.
9.1.1 Titles and Job Description
Valuation Associate
Hourly
New to business
Works on collecting data
Assists senior staff
Database management
Valuation Associate
1/3 commission
New to business
Works on collecting data
Assists senior staff
Database management
Appraiser
1/3 commission
Capable of writing whole report
Assigned to senior staff
Working knowledge of Argus, formats and database
Must be, at a minimum, state licensed as a “trainee”
Senior Appraiser
Standard incentive plan (3/4 multiples)
Proficient in all phases of valuation and report writing
State-certified
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
36
July 2014
Vice President
Standard incentive plan (3/4 multiples; 2.75/3.75 multiples if MAI)
Develop new clients
Serve or assist as account manager for existing clients
Good mentor
Hold either MAI or $400,000 production average for three (3) out of 4 years
First Vice President
Standard incentive plan (2.75/3.75 multiples)
Develop new clients
Serve as account manager for existing clients
Good mentor
Responsible for 2 or more associates or Appraisers
MAI designation required
Production average of $600,000 for three (3) out of 4 years
Senior Vice President
Standard incentive plan (2.75/3.75 multiples)
MAI designation required
Production average of $750,000 for three (3) out of 4 years
Sells significant percentage of own work
Account management responsibility
Highest standards of work quality
Majority approval of other SMDs
Executive Vice President
Standard incentive plan (2.75/3.75 multiples)
MAI designation required
Production achievement of $900,000 or above for three (3) out of four (4) years
Sells significant percentage of own work
Account management responsibility
Highest standards of work quality
If designated by SMD, the EVP could have review responsibilities
Majority approval of other SMDs
Director
Compensation varies depending upon responsibility. Provides oversight and
management assistance in regional offices as well as managers of satellite offices. Bids
on appraisal assignments, analyzes and negotiates business terms of appraisal
contracts, communicates client requirements to local Appraisers and follows up to
ensure that the client’s requirements and deadlines are met, reviews completed draft
appraisal reports for quality and consistency, assists in keeping appraisal professionals
in region current relative to use of technology
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
37
July 2014
Managing Director
This position is responsible for the day-to-day management of the appraisal
transactions required for clients and provides ongoing support and assistance to the
SMD. Bids on appraisal assignments, analyzes and negotiates business terms of
appraisal contracts, communicates client requirements to local Appraisers and follows
up to ensure that the client’s requirements and deadlines are met, reviews completed
draft appraisal reports for quality and consistency, assists in keeping appraisal
professionals in region current relative to use of technology.
Senior Managing Director
This position provides overall corporate strategic direction for an appraisal region.
Creates and implements strategic initiatives for a specific region. Responsible for Profit
& Loss, and budgeting for the region. Manages financial reporting for a region
including revenue projections and reconciling monthly variances. Coaches and directs
staff to ensure all strategic initiatives are achieved. Manages client relationships, which
includes business development and client follow-up. Develops and implements
departmental policies and procedures to increase operational efficiencies. Formally
supervises individual employees and/or subordinate supervisors within the region.
Responsible for identifying training needs, tracking performance, coaching, and
motivating direct reports. Directly responsible for hiring, terminating, compensation,
and performance evaluation for entire region.
9.1.2 Assistants (Valuation Associate)
CBRE may hire research assistants (Valuation Associate) to be assigned to specific
Appraisers upon recommendation of the SMD and approval of the President. SMDs at their
own discretion may disallow the use of assistants.
Major factors considered are:
% of business generation done by the Appraiser (needs to be more than 50% of
his/her own work);
top work quality;
responsiveness to clients; and
ability to work with and mentor junior employees.
Appraisers outside of California are required to reimburse their profit center monthly for the
cost of the assistant at a percentage based upon the Appraiser’s billings rate. (Annualized
billing levels shown below are per Appraiser.) Appraisers may not combine billings with
other Appraisers for eligibility, nor will Appraisers be allowed to share assistants without the
approval of the SMD and the President.
Appraisers outside of California reimburse their profit centers through a revenue
allocation to their profit center from one or more of their invoices per month. Assistant
costs include salary (including PTO and holiday time) and/or hourly rate, corporate
support, payroll related and miscellaneous costs.
Corporate support - A company overhead charge for each employee based on a
monthly average (currently $1,000) determined by the Accounting Department. The
yearly rate will be established by Accounting.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
38
July 2014
Insurance and Benefits - A percentage rate (currently 15%) against all salaries,
established yearly by Accounting.
Miscellaneous costs - Include desk cost, phones, mileage, supplies, management, etc.
This cost will be determined annually by President (currently $500 per month).
An Appraiser who elects to discontinue use of a assistant must give 30 days’ notice to
the SMD and continue to reimburse the Company according to the above policy for that
30-day period and will be responsible for all termination costs including severance and
pay-out of PTO.
Due to differences in labor laws, California Appraisers with researchers are handled
differently. Please see your SMD if there are questions regarding California Appraisers.
9.2 Reimbursement for Licensing Dues and Education
Professional Memberships And Licenses
Appraisal license
All Appraisers are required to be certified general in the states in which they perform
appraisal assignments and must follow state licensing requirements for the state in
which a property which they appraise is located. Appraisers are responsible for
maintaining all licenses current, and SMDs and MDs are responsible for verification.
Appraisers whose licenses lapse may have work withheld until the license is brought
up to date.
Permanent license
CBRE will reimburse appraisal professionals for the fees directly related to
maintaining their General Certificate (within the region the appraiser practices)
including renewal fees and continuing education fees subject to limitations noted
below.
Temporary license
When an Appraiser must obtain a temporary license, the cost of the temporary
license will be reimbursed to the employee through an OOP expense report, and
deducted from the total fee as a job expense (see Expense Deductions).
SMDs, MDs, and professional staff’s Appraisal Institute dues are fully paid for as part of the
corporate program. Other expenses incurred in the Appraisal Institute will be reimbursed, subject to
the following:
Reimbursable expenses
Continuing education courses and/or MAI courses for designation upon receipt of passing grade (where applicable). This may include Argus or other software training, with approval of SMD. Subject to the $1,000 annual cap per appraiser.
Challenged examination (reimbursement upon receipt of successful completion). Subject to the $1,000 annual cap per appraiser.
Comprehensive examination (reimbursement upon receipt of successful completion). Subject to the $1,000 annual cap per appraiser.
Expenses Not Reimbursed
Travel and/or lodging related to optional courses, including courses outside an Appraiser’s region when a comparable course is offered in the Appraiser’s region.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
39
July 2014
Outside services used in conjunction with demonstration reports.
Optional review courses (unless the hours would apply to state certification).
Late fees.
Continuing Education
Paid educational time shall not exceed five working days annually. Due to the expense involved and in light of the maximum reimbursement, Appraisers are encouraged to attend continuing education courses which apply to both their State Certification and Appraisal Institute requirements.
Continuing education reimbursements are capped at $1,000 per year. This benefit may not be carried over from year to year. It is the responsibility of the regional office to monitor the reimbursement usage of each of its Appraisers.
Professional organizations
SMDs and Appraisers may be reimbursed for membership dues in other professional
organizations and attendance at their seminars and conferences with prior approval of the
President.
9.3 Automobile Allowance
To reward and retain quality professionals, Valuation and Advisory Services maintains an
automobile allowance policy based on billings levels. The minimum billings level required to qualify
for an automobile allowance is revised from time to time by the President of Valuation and Advisory
Services and is communicated to the Appraisers through their SMD. For Appraisers hired after
March 1, 1996, and subject to the 5% department surcharge, billings will be adjusted upward to the
100% billings level to allow the billings level minimum to be equal to that of Appraisers not subject
to the surcharge. The formula for this is: Billings/.95 = Adjusted billings.
The auto allowance program is only for Appraisers who are on the standard incentive plan
as of the date of review. Appraisers who switch from the standard incentive plan will have
the auto allowance discontinued as of the effective date of the plan change
Allowance program is subject to semi-annual review. Appraisers are reviewed for 12-month
billings levels at June 30 and December 31.
Qualification
Previous 12-month billings at or above the minimum requirement. The minimum
requirement for 2014 is $450,000 in net billings (adjusted for those on the 5% tax as noted
above). Employees who receive the automobile allowance may not submit reimbursable
mileage reports.
Levels
For those professionals who qualify for an automobile allowance based on minimum
billings, the current automobile policy allows for two levels of allowance based on title:
$800/mo. Senior Appraiser, Vice President
$900/mo. First Vice President, Senior Vice President
Effective dates
Changes in automobile allowance status are effective August (for June 30 review) and
February (for December 31 review). Automobile allowances, which are paid out on the
second bi-weekly paycheck of each month, are considered income and subject to
withholding.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
40
July 2014
Changes
The automobile policy is subject to change or revocation at any time, without notice.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
41
July 2014
9.4 Incentive Compensation
Valuation and Advisory Services has various incentive compensation plans designed to reward the
Appraisers based on quality and quantity of work. Admittance to any of the incentive plans must be
approved by the President in writing prior to issuance of any offer. All Appraisers enrolled in an
incentive plan should be issued an Offer Letter outlining their specific approved plan, and should
also sign an Indemnity Agreement and an Employment Agreement (except in the State of California
where a Release Agreement is signed in lieu of the Indemnity Agreement). The originals of these
documents should be kept in the local personnel file and an electronic copy emailed to HR in
Dallas. Compensation is calculated on net fee (gross fee, less expenses incurred, if any, for each
assignment) to professionals. One percent of all fees are placed in a reserve account for bad debt.
Other deductions may occur for marketing, administration, portfolio management, job related
expenses, such as travel, etc. Base salary is paid bi-weekly and commissions are paid on the second
bi-weekly paycheck in the month following the booking of fees.
All Appraisers (except those on the 33.3% plan) hired after 3/1/96 are subject to a 5% department
surcharge or a 10% portfolio (of 12 or more properties) management fee on billings. For any
assignments which the Appraiser sells, the 5% department surcharge is waived.
Standard incentive plan
Must be state licensed as General Certified. Base salary established at the discretion of the President and reviewed periodically. Annual standard base salary is typically $30,000 (except in California).
To be eligible for incentive payments, net fees booked must exceed three (or 2.75) times the sum of the Appraiser’s base salary for the previous 12 months (Base Fee Requirement). The standard incentive formula includes:
35% payment of net fees booked in excess of the Base Fee Requirement
An additional 10% of net fees booked in excess of $120,000 or 4 (or 3.75) times salary, whichever is greater, (except in California where it is a set $120,000 and not a multiple of the salary) and
An additional 5% of fees booked in excess of $180,000.
The following multiples apply based on title:
3 / 4 Senior Appraiser, Vice President (not MAI)
2.75 / 3.75 Vice President (MAI), First Vice President, Senior Vice
President
This is the only incentive plan in which Appraisers are eligible for the Automobile Allowance program.
50% plan
To reward and retain the most seasoned professionals. These are professionals who are
recognized for maintaining good client relationships, have large client following, are well
regarded by others in the industry, and make significant contributions to the division and
the Company.
Base pay of $30,000 ($37,440 in California).
50% of monthly net billings which exceed the minimum billings requirement of 2x salary (based on a rolling 12 months).
Not eligible for automobile allowance.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
42
July 2014
45% plan
Base pay of $30,000 ($37,440 in California).
45% of monthly net billings which exceed the minimum billings requirement of 2.222222x salary (based on a rolling 12 months).
Not eligible for automobile allowance.
40% plan
Base pay of $30,000 ($37,440 in California).
40% of monthly net billings which exceed the minimum billing requirement of 2.5x salary (based on a rolling 12 months).
Not eligible for automobile allowance.
33.3% plan
Base pay of $30,000 ($37,440 in California). 100% of allocations from invoices which exceed minimum billings of 1 x salary (based on a rolling 12 months).
33.3% / 30.0% / 36.7% split (Appraiser, Reviewer billing pool, Office).
Not eligible for automobile allowance.
Not subject to 5% profit center allocation
9.5 Appraiser Vacations
Per CBRE policy, Appraisers who earn incentive compensation are not eligible for PTO. Appraisers
who choose to take vacation time must give prior notice to their SMD or MD and may be subject to
a base pay reduction. Vacation time must be approved by management. This policy may be subject
to revision in locations where state or local law conflict with CBRE policy.
9.6 Referrals
CBRE encourages its professionals to refer its clients to other business units and other appraisal
offices.
Appraisal assignments
Except for 1/3 Appraisers, an Appraiser who refers an appraisal assignment to another appraisal office or professional within the same office is entitled to a 5% allocation of the gross fee. One-third Appraisers will receive a 2.5% referral allocation for any assignments which they sell. Appraisers who work with a 1/3 Appraiser will not receive 5% referrals for assignments they sell and in which they participate as Reviewer.
If there is a 5% referral to another CBRE Line of Business, the Appraisal office that executes the contract and carries it on their receivables will receive a 5% management fee on the job.
Inter-company referrals
Appraisers who refer business to other CBRE lines of business will split the referral fee
50/50 with their department. Referral fees will not be added to an Appraiser’s annual
billings for purposes of meeting auto allowance or recognition conference thresholds. See
the CBRE Policies and Procedures Manual for further information regarding referrals to
other business units.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
43
July 2014
9.7 Travel Expenses
Authorization
All Appraisers’ expense reports must be approved by the appropriate SMD/MD or BSA as proxy. When traveling on appraisal assignments, Appraisers must follow company travel policy and travel expenses must be considered reasonable. Any travel expenses deemed excessive by the SMD or the President will not be reimbursed.
Parking
Managers
In offices where parking is not provided by the building, SMDs and MDs are entitled to
be reimbursed for monthly parking expenses.
Staff
Payment of staff parking is based on local custom and is at the discretion of the SMD,
given the vast differences from region to region.
Link to how to complete an expense report:
https://navigator.cbre.com/NR/rdonlyres/90D421E2-6FD5-428C-984D-
E61ABC6DA7A6/116957/PeopleSoft91CreatingExpenseReportsQuickReferenceGu.pdf
9.8 Travel Policy Purpose and Enforcement
9.8.1 General
The Travel and Entertainment Expense Management Policy (“Policy”) provides guidelines
and procedures for all CBRE employees who incur business travel and entertainment
expenses for the benefit of and are reimbursed or otherwise paid for by the Company. Any
policy not mentioned will automatically fall under the CBRE Travel and Expense Policy. Any
changes or alteration from this policy must be approved in writing by Supervisor and SMD.
Airline tickets will be issued in Coach/Economy Class unless:
No other reasonable option exists (must be documented).
Approved in writing by your direct supervisor for situations such as traveling with a client.
International flights (under certain circumstances).
Should book non-refundable fares for cost savings.
Frequent Travelers are required to use CBRE’s corporate credit card to book and pay
for travel. Using the corporate card eliminates an expensive layer in CBRE’s payment
and reimbursement process, and is required to realize savings on rental car insurance.
Consistent with long-standing practices, employees on client accounts who are required
to use the client’s credit card, sales professionals, TCC employees, and employees who
travel twice a year or less will typically not be issued a CBRE corporate credit card. If
you travel more than twice a year and do not fall into one of the exception categories
noted above, you should apply for a corporate card by completing the application.
Expense reports should be submitted monthly. With Expense Manager’s approval,
reports may be submitted biweekly.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
44
July 2014
Receipts must be submitted with each expense report. Only receipts for said report
should be submitted. If additional receipts are submitted, which are not included on the
report, it will be pushed back with instructions to remove additional receipts.
Dates on expense report must match dates on receipts.
Client information, job number, place of business, and purpose for expense must be
noted in description on expense report. Client name or job number should be noted on
receipt.
9.9 Computers
All Appraisers will be issued a standard Valuation computer for use in accordance with
the company’s Information Asset Protection Agreement.
Appraisers who desire dual monitor setup will buy the additional monitors unless you
are working in an upgraded Workplace 360 office which includes dual monitors.
Managing Office will pay for the connection.
Other Equipment – Equipment that may be needed for an appraisal job such as
cameras, measuring tapes and devices, portfolio pad, iPad, iPods, etc. which are
supplied by the employee and may be used for employee’s own personal use are the
employee’s own property and not CBRE’s.
9.10 Performance Reviews
These are performed on all employees by Management annually in compliance with the CBRE
company policies. See Performance Management and a sample performance review template.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
45
July 2014
9.11 Reduction in Incentive Compensation
In order to comply with CBRE’s customer service requirements, it is essential that all Appraisers
routinely prepare quality appraisals and communicate with clients for each assignment. The SMDs
will have the option of instituting a reduction in incentive compensation if any appraiser repeatedly
performs an assignment without the proper due diligence and/or fails to communicate with their
clients continuously throughout the process. The following guidelines should be adhered to:
Client Maintenance Letters
A. Introduction Letter - Within 24-48 hours of new assignment email notification, contact client to introduce yourself, request property data and schedule site inspection. Copy all admin staff on your message.
B. Copy client on all communication with property contact – Always!
C. Provide client with weekly progress/job status – every Monday or Friday, or every 7 calendar days/5 business days from date of introduction. Copy all admin staff on your messages.
D. Any and all delays must be communicated to client with a written letter. Copy managers and all admin staff on your messages.
A B C D
Reduction in Incentive Compensation Splits
At Management’s discretion, if an SMD or MD believes an appraiser has violated these
guidelines, the Appraiser may be counseled for an initial violation. After such counseling, if
a second violation occurs, the Appraiser may receive a written warning. If an Appraiser has
three violations within a 12-month period and the Appraiser’s direct report/supervisor
agrees the Appraiser’s future compensation may be reduced by taking between 20% and
50% off the gross fee for the following three months on all assignments performed by the
Appraiser. Other corrective action may be imposed for violation(s) of these guidelines, up
to and including termination of employment.
9.12 Termination
All involuntary terminations should be reviewed by HR in advance. Contact Patti St. Clair
(602.735.5445 for assistance and direction. Be prepared to provide written documentation of all
actions.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
46
July 2014
9.13 Legal Compliance and Support
The corporate legal department has designated counsel for the VAS division. They include:
Central Division
Mardi Milia
630.573.1296
Eastern Division
Griswold Ware
630.573.7109
Western Division
Alan Wang
213.613.3002
Beverley Lu
213.613.3004
Tri-States
John Mauk
516.714.2703
9.14 Legal Services
All Appraisers, administrative staff, and managers should familiarize themselves with CBRE Policies
and Procedures regarding Legal Services. CBRE legal staff must be immediately contacted to assist
with all of the following matters as they arise:
Subpoenas
Declarations
Confidentiality agreements
VAS Indemnification Letters – Indemnification Form
Indemnification - Securitization Form
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | HUMAN RESOURCES POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
47
July 2014
Depositions
Lawsuits
Any assignment that may be used in conjunction with potential litigation must have a
completed internal conflict check performed prior to accepting and executing the contract.
9.15 Office Standards
As a professional service company, we should convey professionalism in operations, appearance
and attitude. These office standards will ensure a good first impression and continued respect from
both the client and the marketplace. The office standards described below apply to all CBRE
employees.
9.15.1 Attire
Personal appearance of all employees must be professional at all times and in adherence with
CBRE’s dress code policies, especially when client facing. Assumptions are made about your ability
to perform at a high level based on the way we dress. When we dress professionally, we convey a
strong message that we are a capable professional.
9.15.2 Attendance
All employees should notify Administration and Management of material changes in their
anticipated daily schedules so that during company hours, employees can be located, if necessary.
Managers should be notified in advance of any vacations or extended periods of absence so that
workflow is not unnecessarily disrupted.
9.15.3 Out-of-Office Communication
All employees are responsible for notifying their clients of absences that may impact communication
during the course of an assignment. This could include the use of the “out-of-office” reply function
for company email as well as an “out-of-office” voicemail greeting. (Please refer to the Out-of-office
Assistant under Tools within Microsoft Outlook.)
All employees must make a diligent effort or arrange for someone to check both voicemail (office
and cell phone) and email during their absences from the office for any urgent matters that may
arise during that time. Exceptions may be made for unexpected emergencies or lack of access to
email and voicemail while in remote locations.
9.15.4 In-Office Communication
While in the office, employees should keep email open so they can be responsive to all urgent
matters and cognizant of issues as they arise. While email is important, we should remember the
value of face-to-face or even voice-to-voice communication. Also a signature that includes contact
information ensures that people know who you are.
9.16 Additional Policy
Any CBRE policies not relating specifically to Appraisal Line of Business are included in the CBRE
Policies and Procedures Manual posted on Navigator. All employees are responsible for knowing
and adhering to CBRE’s Policies and Procedures. In the event of a conflict between CBRE’s Policies
and Procedures and the Practice Area Guidelines, CBRE’s Policies and Procedures will control unless
such policy is specifically addressed herein.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | TRAINING: ADMINISTRATION, APPRAISERS AND MANAGEMENT
48
July 2014
10. TRAINING: ADMINISTRATION, APPRAISERS AND MANAGEMENT
10.1 Administration Training
For Business Services Administrators (BSAs), typically an experienced BSA from another region will
go to the new BSA’s office for training. There are ad-hoc conference calls when there are issues to
discuss – no set schedule for calls.
A procedural manual for Administrative Training is forthcoming.
10.2 Appraiser Training
There are several areas of Appraiser training. It is the responsibility of the Appraisers’ direct
supervisor to either provide such training or make that training available to the Appraiser. It is also
recognized in the appraisal profession in general, and CBRE in particular, that a significant amount
of training occurs in the everyday setting as professionals interact and collaborate on various topics
and issues.
The following is a list of areas where training is expected, and how to access the appropriate
resources.
10.2.1 Internal Resources
Several resources are available and provide a benefit for the Appraiser in their day to day
work. A listing of these resources is provided, along with where to access training on these
tools. For all of the listed items, it is the responsibility of the Appraisers’ direct supervisor to
either provide the training, or to ensure that the Appraiser has access to the correct
resources.
Practice Area Guidelines (PAG) – This is available on iChannel. It is a requirement
that a copy is provided to Appraiser. Document is to come from direct supervisor, or
from their designee. The employee is expected to review and be familiar with this
document.
VIEW
Training at CBREU (Houston, TX)
Use Houston IT team for interactive training
Refer to the VIEW User Guide
Navigator
The Navigator is an intranet site which is accessible only by CBRE´s employees or authorized outside users.
The Navigator is home to both corporate and local news, business line information and department information such as HR, IT, Corporate Communications, Research, and Web Marketing. This is your central location for tools, training and information.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | TRAINING: ADMINISTRATION, APPRAISERS AND MANAGEMENT
49
July 2014
iChannel
iChannel is the VAS group’s web-based document archival and delivery system. Client-accessible sites are created for portfolio assignment management and report delivery.
Use Houston IT team for interactive training.
See iChannel instructions.
CBRE Word Excel linked templates
Training at (Houston, TX)
Use Houston IT team for questions and interactive training
CBREU materials available on iChannel or from IT team
One-on-one training with direct supervisor
Transaction, Flood, Site, Economic and Demographic Information
CBRE has a wide variety of this information including, but not limited to Costar,
Loopnet, Nielsen SiteReports, Economy.com, among others. In most cases, many of
these services are also market specific. Most of the instructions for these services are on
iChannel or the providing service tutorial. Further, all of these outside services have a
help phone number or virtual help service.
10.2.2 Appraisal Process and Procedures
Several important areas are presented in the PAG. It is the supervisor’s responsibility to be
familiar with these items and ensure that the Appraiser is trained in these procedures.
Further, it is up to the Appraiser to be familiar with these sections. For the comprehensive
list of areas covered, refer to the Appraisal Process and Procedure section.
Process and Procedures
The list in the PAG section on Process and Procedures is not repeated here. However,
the training note is that it is the responsibility of the supervisor to understand these
policies and procedures, review these with the Appraiser, and be prepared to provide
day-to-day training. Some of the items that deal with the templates and technology will
need to be provided from the CBREU training, the CBREU training materials, access to
the IT support team, or face-to-face training with the supervisor. As a summary, it is the
responsibility of the supervisor to ensure that these resources are provided and utilized
by the Appraiser.
ARGUS
This is an especially important area for training. The supervisor providing any and all
training MUST be proficient in Argus or provide access to a professional that is
proficient. It is not acceptable for Appraisers with little or no training in Argus to
prepare this analysis. There are Argus training courses. Review of Argus should be
done anytime an Argus is used. At a minimum, the supervisor should be provided with
access to the electronic version, or review the detailed Argus Assumptions reports,
along with the cash flow and DCF schedules.
Expense Reports
See section on expense reports in Administrative Procedures of the PAG.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | TRAINING: ADMINISTRATION, APPRAISERS AND MANAGEMENT
50
July 2014
10.3 Management Training
Many of the areas covered in the Appraiser training section are relevant to manager training as
well. Specifically, the sections that relate to job set-up, work flow, client communication, and
appraisal process and procedures are listed in the Appraiser section. Added training for managers
includes references to portfolio management, and administrative procedures.
10.3.1 Portfolio Procedures and Polices
There is a detailed section highlighting what is needed from bidding, coordinating and then
executing a portfolio assignment. Managers are referred to the Portfolio Procedures and
Policies section for added detail. Further, added resources for portfolio management
include the IT team, along with other MD/SMD professionals who are experienced in
managing portfolio assignments.
10.3.2 Administrative
The manager is responsible for items noted in this section. Resources for training include
Tina Peterson, regional BSA, the President of VAS and other SMD/MD professionals. The
items noted in the Administrative section are to be followed, and questions referred to the
various individuals named above, as needed and per the needs of the particular work area
in question.
Appraisal Review
There are several references to review policies throughout the PAG. In short, the PAG
provides comprehensive information, and is detailed in expectations and requirements
pertaining to review. The reviewing manager/lead signature on the report is
responsible for ALL contents in the report, and this individual is expected to be entirely
familiar with the analysis and report. A full and complete review is required for all
assignments before communicating any written or verbal work product to the client.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | VALUATIONS FOR FINANCIAL REPORTING (“VFR”)
51
July 2014
11. OTHER VALUATION SERVICES
11.1 Valuations for Financial Reporting (“VFR”)
The ever-increasing corporate scrutiny around transparent financial and tax reporting requires
valuation experts who are well versed in the current trends and techniques related to valuations for
regulatory reporting purposes. If you are working on an assignment with Financial Reporting, a
brief overview of the policy and process is available here.
11.2 Property Assessment and Consulting Services
The Policy and Procedures for the Assessment and Consulting Services (ACS) Group is to ensure that
all Environmental Site Assessments (ESAs), Property Condition Assessments (PCAs), and other
technical work produced by CBRE, Inc. (CBRE) meet a high level of professional standards while
protecting the company from unnecessary liability risks. It is the intent of this PAG to set out a
consistent procedure and work product standard such that CBRE will provide its clients with
consistent level of quality and report content regardless of the Field Professional (FP) conducting the
work, the Project Manager (PM) setting up the project and reviewing the work product, or the MD
overseeing the region the work is conducted. These policies and procedures are currently under
development.
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPENDIX
52
July 2014
12. APPENDIX
12.1 Appraiser
12.1.1 Internal Review Checklist
12.1.2 Client Communication Templates
Introduction and Property Request Letter
Weekly Status Letter – On Time
Weekly Status Letter – Late
Document Delay Letter
12.1.3 VAS Quality Management Checklist
12.1.4 iChannel Instructions
12.1.5 Standard Incentive Plan Excel Calculation Worksheet
12.1.6 1/3 Incentive Plan Excel Calculation Worksheet
12.1.7 Apartment Property Questions
12.1.8 Industrial Building Property Questions
12.1.9 Office Building Property Questions
12.1.10 Office Data Request
12.1.11 Shopping Center Retail Property Questions
12.1.12 Single Tenant Retail Property Questions
12.1.13 VAS Technology User Manual
Located on iChannel >> .Format \ Miscellaneous \ Appraiser Tools
12.2 Administrative
12.2.1 Contract
Located on iChannel >> .Format \ Miscellaneous \ Contract with Letterhead
12.2.2 Full Fee Retainer Client List
Located on iChannel >> .Library \ Client Documents \ ADMIN
12.2.3 Expense Report and Procedure
http://library.cbre.com/xpedio/groups/public/documents/cbresource_hr_054/cbre043
809.pdf
12.2.4 Status Report-Pipeline by Appraiser
12.2.5 Master Status Log-Report Delivery Schedule
12.2.6 VAS Risk Analysis Sheet
CBRE | VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES | POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES | APPENDIX
53
July 2014
12.3 Human Resources
12.3.1 New Hire Induction Check List
12.3.2 Performance Review Template
12.3.3 Job Architecture Matrix
12.4 Legal
12.4.1 Indemnification Agreements
a. Indemnification Form
b. Indemnification - Securitization Form
12.4.2 Confidentiality Agreement
12.4.3 VAS Engagement Flow Chart