pnrp.gw.govt.nzpnrp.gw.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/Table-of-Decisions-Topic... · Web...

Topic – Beneficial Use and Development

Submission point

Further submission point

Submitter Provision Support Oppose

Decision requested Panel decision

S1/001 Barry Joseph Doyle Objective O9: Recreational values

Not stated Agree to place suitable sand on several of the small stony beaches between Oriental Bay and Ohariu Bay (towards Red Rocks) to create recreation areas for family sized groups.

Reject

/S12/001 Neville Fisher Regionally

significant infrastructure

Amend Include water races in definition of 'regionally significantinfrastructure'.

Reject

FS85/054 Carterton District Council Neither support or oppose

Not stated

S12/013 Neville Fisher Regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Include the Lower Valley Drainage Scheme (LVDS) and the Barrage Gates in definition of 'regionally significant infrastructure'.

Reject

/S12/032 Neville Fisher Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Add 'diffuse discharges' to P7 (b) [relating to the benefits of

treatment, dilution and disposal of wastewater and stormwater].Reject

/S12/039 Neville Fisher Policy P15: Flood

protection activities

Support [Decision requested unclear. Refer to original submission for detail.]

Accept

/S13/003 CT and EM Brown Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Identify and recognise stormwater channels in the NRP. Provide

for their maintenance by Councils and land owners by making this a permitted activity in the NRP.

Reject

FS30/049 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS26/070 South Wairarapa District Council Support Allow

Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Beneficial Use and Development of 124

Submission point




FS85/132 Carterton District Council Support AllowS13/004 CT and EM Brown Policy P8:

Beneficial activities

Oppose Water bodies that are storm water channels MUST be maintained so that water can move freely.

Reject

FS68/007 Tim Mansell and family Support AllowS13/005 CT and EM Brown Policy P9: Public

access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Amend The protection of property owners rights to restrict the publics acess to their properties.

Reject

/S13/006 CT and EM Brown Policy P15: Flood


Support Supported Accept

/S14/014 Egon Guttke Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Add forestry to the list of land and water uses recognised in Policy

P7.Reject

FS67/001 The Carter Family Support AllowS28/014 Jeffrey Arthur Policy P8:


Amend Be classified as a sensitive areas where beneficial enviroments are located. e.g. Bees be given at least a 5km safety margin.

Reject

/S29/001 Powerco Objective O12:

Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Support Retain O12 without further modification Accept

FS73/006 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS29/002 Powerco Objective O13:

Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Support Retain Objective O13 without further modification Accept

FS73/007 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support in part

Allow in part


Submission point




S29/016 Powerco Policy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support Retain Policy 13 without further modification Accept

FS61/022 Minister of Conservation Support AllowS29/017 Powerco Policy P14:

Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Support in part

Modify Policy 14 as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected ... by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any adverse effects, including reverse sensitivity effects.

Accept

FS25/019 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS73/010 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS51/014 GBC Winstone Support Allow

S29/018 Powerco Policy P15: Flood protection activities

Support Retain Policy 15 without further modification. Accept

/S29/019 Powerco Policy P16: New

flood protection and erosion control


/S29/060 Powerco Regionally


Oppose Modify Definition of Regionally Significant Infrastructure as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure includes...· facilities for the generation and transmission

of electricity where it is supplied to the electricity distribution network, including the

Reject


Submission point




national grid· Facilities for the generation and/or

transmission of electricity where it is supplied to the national electricity grid and/or the local distribution network. This includes supply within the local electricity distribution network...

FS73/018 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS71/006 Horticulture NZ Oppose DisallowFS22/005 Transpower NZ Ltd Neither

support or oppose

Not stated

FS32/006 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowS31/002 Hamish Trolove Objective O7:

Water for livestock

Amend Add a comment about only being enough to provide water for appropriate stocking rates and livestock type.

Reject

/S31/003 Hamish Trolove Objective O13:


Support Support Accept

/S31/029 Hamish Trolove Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Bneficial use for irrigation should be properly measured Reject

/S31/030 Hamish Trolove Policy P12:

Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities



Submission point




/S33/008 Porirua Harbour and Catchment

Community TrustPolicy P8: Beneficial activities

Support in part

Delete (l) [artworks] from Policy P8 and insert into Policy P9. Reject

/S33/009 Porirua Harbour and Catchment

Community TrustPolicy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Support in part

Insert (l) artworks from Policy P8 into Policy P9. Reject

/S35/008 Allan A Smith Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend P7 to specify the need to find a balance between

competing uses or claims on the limited resources and which enables conflicts to be resolved and cultural, social and economic aspirations to be met.

Reject

FS1/067 Waa Rata Estate Support in part

Allow in part

FS67/017 The Carter Family Support AllowS35/009 Allan A Smith Policy P8:


Amend Amend P8 as follows.

"The following activities....

(f) theretirement, fencing and planting of riparian margins, in appropriatesituations, and ...."

Reject

FS1/068 Waa Rata Estate Support AllowS46/003 Kintyre Meats/Kintyre Trust 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend [Include] provision within the Plans allocation framework

identifying industry.Reject

/S46/004 Kintyre Meats/Kintyre Trust 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend Amend to clarify industrial and commercial reliant on supply

independent from "potable water supply networks".Reject


Submission point




/S55/001 The Oil Companies Objective O12:


Support Retain Objective O12 without modification. Accept

/S55/002 The Oil Companies Objective O13:


Support Retain Objective O13 without modification. Accept

/S55/014 The Oil Companies Policy P13:

Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities


/S55/015 The Oil Companies Policy P14:


Support in part

Modify Policy 14 as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure ... to avoid, remedy or mitigate any adverse effects, including reverse sensitivity effects.

Accept

/S55/016 The Oil Companies Policy P15: Flood



/S55/017 The Oil Companies Policy P16: New Support Retain Policy 16 without further modification. Accept


Submission point





/S55/069 The Oil Companies Regionally


Support Retain definition of regionally significant infrastructure. Accept

FS57/011 The Oil Companies Support in part

Allow in part

FS61/072 Minister of Conservation Support AllowS62/003 Wellington Civic Trust Objective O10:

Public accessSupport Retain the specified objectives with their current wording. Accept

/S66/004 GBC Winstone Regionally


Amend Add either a generic bullet-point which refers to quarries which serve regional or sub-regional areas, or specifically list the hard rock quarries which serve the region's main urban areas.Add either a generic bullet-point which refers to landfills and cleanfills which serve regional or sub-regional areas, or specifically list these facilities.

Reject

FS59/011 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council

Support Allow


Support Allow

S66/005 GBC Winstone 3.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Either add a new objective which relates to Objective O31 or add "major quarry and cleanfill sites' to the definition of regionally significant infrastructure, or develop an alternative means of recognising and providing for such facilities under this heading in a similar way to the provision made in Objectives O12 and O13.

Accept

/S66/007 GBC Winstone Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Retain item (g) but add a reference to sand and other materials.

Provide new items to address the matters referred to above. Alternatively such provision could be made within the suite of policy provisions in Policy P12 to P14.

Reject


Submission point




/S68/005 Sophie Mormede Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend [to balance the economic value of aquaculture against the

environmental impacts].Reject

FS85/131 Carterton District Council Oppose DisallowS68/006 Sophie Mormede Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend [Amend Policy P7 so that] a water body is not seen as a cleaning,

dilution or disposal means of wastewater.Reject

/S69/002 Friends of Taputeranga Marine

Reserve TrustPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Not stated [Do not provide blanket support for aquaculture practices]. Reject

/S69/004 Friends of Taputeranga Marine


Amend Remove or soften the part of P7 [relating to] the use of fresh water body as cleaning, dilution and diposal of waste water.

Reject

FS85/133 Carterton District Council Oppose DisallowS69/005 Friends of Taputeranga Marine


Amend Include a catchment-based approach to stormwater management in Policy P73

Reject

/S75/053 Minister of Conservation Policy P8:


Amend Retain as notified except for amendment as follows:(d) Removal of aquatic weeds, and pest plants, and animal pests.

Accept

FS67/021 The Carter Family Support in part

Allow in part

S75/054 Minister of Conservation Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Amend Include policy direction to enable the enhancement of public access when development is proposed.

Reject

FS74/188 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowS77/001 Juken New Zealand Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Recognise forestry as a beneficial use of land and water. Reject


Submission point




FS67/019 The Carter Family Support AllowS81/004 New Zealand Defence Force Regionally


Amend Amend the definition of Regionally Significant Infrastructure to include defence facilitiesOREnsure that Objectives and Policies that give recognition to the importance of "regionally significant infrastructure" are supplemented by the words "and defence facilities".

Reject

/S82/004 Meridian Energy Limited Regionally


Support Retain the definition of 'regionally significant infrastructure'. Accept

FS73/023 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowS82/005 Meridian Energy Limited Renewable

energy generation activities

Amend Amend the definition of 'renewable energy generation activities' to include necessary ancillary activities and facilities as follows (or similar wording):The construction, operation and maintenance of structures and ancillary facilities (including access tracks and roads) associated with renewable energy generation ...

Accept

FS73/024 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support in part

Allow in part

S82/006 Meridian Energy Limited Reverse sensitivity

Support Retain the definition of 'reverse sensitivity'. Accept

/S82/007 Meridian Energy Limited Upgrade Amend Amend the definition of 'upgrade' as follows (or similar wording):

Use and development to bring existing structures or facilities up to current standards or to improve the functional characteristics of structures or facilities, provided the upgrading itself does not give rise to any significant adverse effects on the environment and provided that the effects of the activity are

Reject


Submission point




the same or similar in character, intensity and scale as the existing structure and activity and

(a) in relation to renewable electricity generation activities, includes increasing the generation or transmission capacity, efficiency or security of regionally significant infrastructure and replacing support structures within the footprint of authorised activities.


Allow in part

FS73/025 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS71/017 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS56/013 Powerco Support Allow in part

S82/008 Meridian Energy Limited Objective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Support Retain Objective O12. Accept

/S82/009 Meridian Energy Limited Objective O13:


Amend Amend Objective O13 in the following manner (or similar wording): The use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Accept

FS22/012 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS73/026 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support Allow

S82/013 Meridian Energy Limited Policy P12: Support Retain Policy P12. Accept


Submission point






Allow in part


Allow in part

FS56/041 Powerco Support AllowS82/014 Meridian Energy Limited Policy P13:


Support Retain Policy P13. Accept

/S82/015 Meridian Energy Limited Policy P14:


Amend Amend Policy P14 as follows (or similar wording):Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development...

Reject

FS73/027 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS84/002 Hutt City Council 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend Provide a policy framework that provides a pathway for new

infrastructure reasonably needed to support existing or planned future development to gain resource consent. This would allow for resource consent for these activities to be granted in appropriate circumstances.

Reject


Submission point




/S84/003 Hutt City Council Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend P7 to include 'urban use and development' to the list of

uses in Policy 7.Reject

FS27/007 Porirua City Council Support AllowS84/004 Hutt City Council 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend Include a schedule and/or map of the Strategic Transport

Network, to provide clarity as to what infrastructure is identified as regionally significant.Extend provisions for regionally significantly infrastructure to other types of infrastructure.

Reject


Not stated

S84/008 Hutt City Council Upgrade Amend Review the definition of 'upgrade'. Reject

/S85/007 Roading, Parks and Gardens and

Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council

Regionally significant infrastructure

Oppose Amend the definition of Regionally Significant Infrastructure to include solid waste disposal; OR Ensure that Objectives and Policies that give recognition to the importance of "regionally significant infrastructure" are supplemented by the words "and municipal solid waste disposal facilities".

Reject

FS85/045 Carterton District Council Support AllowS85/010 Roading, Parks and Gardens and



Oppose Amend the definition of Regionally Significant Infrastructure to include all roads administered by HCC and UHCC;OR Ensure that Objectives and Policies that give recognition to the importance of "regionally significant infrastructure" are supplemented by the words "and roads" (or similar to reflect the district level hierarchy of roads).

Reject


Solid Waste departments of Hutt Policy P16: New flood protection

Not stated The wording should bewidened to exempt hard engineering measures that contribute to protection ofthe environment or public

Reject


Submission point




City Council and Upper Hutt City Council

and erosion control

assets, and mitigation of adverse effects.Reconsider the use ofthe word 'development'(throughout the plan), and if retained, insert a definition that includesroads.Clarifyin what circumstances a risk assessment is required with a consent application,and what that should comprise, ensuring the assessment is only required inappropriate situations and is commensurate to the scale of the activity.



Offset Not stated [Revise Policy P97 and associated definitions as per submission point S85/025].

Reject




Amend Amend the definitionof 'regionally significant infrastructure' to provide for key coastal roads [also see submission point s85/053]

Reject




Amend Amend the definition of `regionally significant infrastructure' to include roads.

Reject



5. Rules Amend Amend the wording in the policies [P45, P138, P143, P148] and rules [R67, R114, R152, R162, R167, R195, R205, R198, R209, R215] to ensure necessary works [within scheduled sites], such as structures in rivers or in the CMA, can be carried out by HCC and UHCC.

Reject

/S87/004 Christine Marjorie Stanley Objective O10:

Public accessAmend Recreation and public access should only be maintained where

the effects of such use are well regulated within the local bylaws.Reject

/S88/019 Trelissick Park Group Objective O9: Amend The northern beach of the reclamation needs improved public Reject


Submission point




Recreational values

access.

FS40/002 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Oppose DisallowS88/020 Trelissick Park Group Objective O10:

Public accessAmend The northern beach of the reclamation needs improved public

access.Reject

FS40/003 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Oppose DisallowS88/022 Trelissick Park Group Policy P9: Public


Amend The northern beach of the reclamation needs improved public access.

Reject

/S93/048 Coastal Ratepayers United

IncorporatedPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Oppose in part

Delete Policy P7 or:

· reconsider the appropriateness of including each of the items and remove those that should not be there;

· delete (a) aquaculture;· include reference to the benefits of river and stream mouth

cutting and protecting against natural hazards by structures. An option is to revise (g) along the following lines "natural hazard mitigation measures including gravel extraction from rivers, river and stream mouth cutting, and structures [particularly in areas of significant existing development]". If that is not done, delete (g); and

· revise (k) to remove the word "transport" and reword the policy so it refers to something like "appropriate access to and along water bodies and the coastal marine area".

Accept


IncorporatedPolicy P8: Beneficial activities

Amend Include reference to "upgrade" in Policy 8(h). Accept

FS49/099 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS93/050 Coastal Ratepayers United

IncorporatedPolicy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes

Oppose in part

Revise the policy completely to address the concerns that it:

· is too uncertain in its reference to "extent or quality" of public access;

Reject


Submission point




and rivers · too extreme in referring to "shall be avoided" and "necessary";

· too limited in (a) to (c) in that the purposes do not include reference to other beneficial activities, including in particular natural hazard mitigation measures; and

· fails to distinguish between walking and vehicular access and could interfere with attempts to limit inappropriate pedestrian or vehicular access.


IncorporatedPolicy P15: Flood protection activities

Amend Either widen Policies P15 and P16 to include coastal hazard mitigation activities (using appropriate terminology) or create new policies to deal with those activities.In addition, given the limited definition of "upgrade" and the importance of the existing activities, upgrade should be included

Reject

/S98/004 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Regionally


Oppose Amend bullet points two and three:

strategictelecommunication facilities, as defined in section 5 of the Telecommunications Act 2001 strategic radiocommunication as defined in section 2(1) the RadioCcommunications Act 1989.

Reject

/S98/005 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Objective O12:


Oppose in part

Amend Obj 12:The social, economic, cultural, and environmental and health and safety benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities.Obj 12ARecognise that some existing and future regionally significant infrastructure has a

Reject


Submission point




functional need and/or operational requirement to be located and/or operated in a particular environment.

FS57/016 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS22/010 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS56/021 Powerco Support AllowFS32/013 Meridian Energy Limited Support in

partAllow

S98/006 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Objective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Support Amend Objective 13The existing use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure of activity.

Reject

/S98/009 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterSupport in part

Amend P7:The cultural, social and economic benefits of using land and water for:(1) Regionally Significant Infrastructure

Reject

FS56/037 Powerco Support AllowS98/010 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Policy P9: Public


Support in part

Amend P9:Reduction in the extent or quality of public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers shall be avoided except where it is necessary to: (d) protect Regionally Significant Infrastructure

Reject


Submission point




FS57/032 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS32/033 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS56/039 Powerco Support AllowFS73/029 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support Allow

S98/011 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support in part

Amend P12:(e) the functional need for the operational requirements associated with developing, operating, maintaining and upgrading regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities, including where those activities are proposed within areas of outstanding natural character and landscapes, high hazards, sites of significant value, ecosystems and habitats with significant indigenous biodiversity value, natural features, sites significant historic heritage value, and sites within significant Mana Whenua.

Reject

FS56/043 Powerco Support AllowFS73/030 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS57/040 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS57/036 The Oil Companies Support Allow

S98/012 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Policy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support in part

Amend P13:The use, operation, maintenance, and upgrade, and removal of existing regionally significant infrastructure as beneficial and generally appropriate. The removal of infrastructure should also be acknowledged in the policy framework.

Reject


Submission point




/S98/013 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Policy P14:


Support Amend P14 as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigateany adverse effects, including any reverse sensitivity effects.

Accept

FS73/031 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS99/006 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings

LimitedObjective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Amend Objective O12 in Section 3.2 as follows:'The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised enabled.'

Reject

/S99/007 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings

LimitedObjective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Support Retain Objective O13 in Section 3.2 of the Proposed Plan as notified without modification.

Accept


LimitedPolicy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P12:The benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised enabled by having regard to consideration of:..

Reject

FS61/018 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS99/009 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings Policy P13: Amend Amend Policy P13: The use, operation, maintenance, and Reject


Submission point




Limited Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

upgrade of existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are beneficial and generally appropriate.'

FS61/021 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS99/010 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings

LimitedPolicy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Support Retain Policy P14 in Section 4.2 of the Proposed Plan as notified without modification.

Accept


LimitedRegionally significant infrastructure

Support in part

'Regionally significant infrastructure includes:

· Paraparaumu Airport Kapiti Coast Airport...'And such other additional or consequential relief as is necessary to achieve consistency with the above and to satisfy the concerns of the KCAHL.

Accept

/S100/002 Southern North Island Wood

CouncilPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Amend In Policy P7 forestry should be included as a beneficial use of land and water resources

Reject

/S107/001 Upper Hutt City Council 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend Include a new policy into section 4.2 that recognises the

contribution of urban areas. Reject

/


Submission point




S112/039 Friends of the Paekakariki Streams Policy P8: Beneficial activities

Support [not stated] Accept

/S113/056 Michael John Slater Regionally


Amend Add after treatment plants: water race networks and facilities for the irrigation of pasture and crops.

Reject

/S113/058 Michael John Slater Objective O8:

Allocation regimeAmend Amend Objective O8: "the social, agricultural, industrial,

cultural and environmental benefits of taking and using water for current uses and also for future needs are recognised and provided for within the Plan's allocation framework"

Reject

/S113/061 Michael John Slater Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Add "diffuse contaminants" to (b). Retain (h). Reject

/S113/062 Michael John Slater Policy P11: In-

stream water storage

Support Retain. Reject

/S117/005 Kāpiti Coast District Council Objective O2:

Importance of land and water

Support Retain the objective Accept


Recreational values



Public accessSupport Retain the objective Accept


Benefits of Support Retain the objective Accept


Submission point




regionally significant infrastructure




/S117/024 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterSupport Retain the provision Reject

/S117/025 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P8:


Support Retain the provision Accept








Incompatible Support Retain the provision Accept


Submission point




activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

/S119/008 Kaiwaiwai Dairies Limited Regionally


Amend Include LVDS and Barrage Dates in "Regionally Significant Infrastructure"

Reject

/S119/011 Kaiwaiwai Dairies Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend by adding: ...and diffuse discharges. Reject

/S119/012 Kaiwaiwai Dairies Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterSupport Supported Reject

/S119/019 Kaiwaiwai Dairies Limited Policy P15: Flood


Support Supported. Accept

/S119/046 Kaiwaiwai Dairies Limited Regionally


Amend Include water races in defintion Reject


Not stated

S120/011 Java Trust Limited Policy P8: Beneficial activities

Amend Amend P8(h) so it is not limited to structures but applies to all existing pipes, artificial farm canals, drains, weirs, fences, gardens and other works. Provide for all such activities as permitted not subject to conditions. Amend all related provisions accordingly; allincidental and consequential amendments.

Reject


Submission point




/S121/015 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Regionally


Support Retain this definition in its current form. Accept

/S121/016 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Reverse

sensitivitySupport Retain this definition in its current form. Accept

/S121/021 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O9:

Recreational values

Support in part

Amend Objective O9 as follows:The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and their margins and natural wetlands are maintained and enhanced where appropriate.

Reject

FS69/013 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS121/022 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O10:

Public accessSupport in part

Amend Objective O10 as follows:Public access to and along the coastal marine area and rivers and lakes is maintained and enhanced where appropriate.

Reject

FS69/014 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS60/006 NZ Transport Agency Support Allow

S121/024 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Support Retain this objective in its current form. Accept

/S121/025 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O13:


Support Retain this objective in its current form. Accept

/S121/042 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterSupport Retain Policy P7 in its current form. Reject

FS61/012 Minister of Conservation Support AllowS121/043 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P8: Support in Amend Policy P8 as follows: ... h) maintenance, use and Accept


Submission point





part upgrading of existing structures in the coastal marine area, natural wetlands and the beds of rivers and lakes, and

FS25/018 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS69/038 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS35/005 First Gas Ltd Support AllowFS60/010 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowFS49/097 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow

S121/044 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Support in part

Amend Policy 9 as follows:Reduction in the extent or quality of public access to and along the coastal marine area ...(b) protect public health, and safety, security and biosecurity, or...with respect to (a), (b) and (c), where it is necessary to permanently restrict or remove existing public access, and where practicable and achievable and considering the nature of the activity, the loss of public access shall be mitigated or offset by providing enhanced public access at a similar or nearby location or offset.

Reject

FS69/039 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS60/011 NZ Transport Agency Support Allow

S121/046 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support in part

Amend Policy P12 as follows:... (d) the functional need for port activities and infrastructure to be located within the coastal marine area, and ...

Reject

/


Submission point




S121/047 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support Retain Policy P13 in its current form. Accept

/S121/048 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P14:


Support Retain Policy P14 in its current form. Accept

/S124/002 Wairarapa Water Users Society

IncorporatedRegionally significant infrastructure


Reject

FS71/005 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS85/055 Carterton District Council Neither

support or oppose

Not stated

S124/004 Wairarapa Water Users Society Incorporated

Objective O8: Allocation regime

Amend Amend Objective O8: "the social, agricultural, industrial, cultural and environmental benefits of taking and using water for current uses and also for future needs are recognised and provided for within the Plan's allocation framework"

Reject

/S124/007 Wairarapa Water Users Society

IncorporatedPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Amend Add "diffuse contaminants" to (b). Retain (h). Reject


Submission point




FS74/268 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowS124/008 Wairarapa Water Users Society

IncorporatedPolicy P11: In-stream water storage


/S125/004 Rural Residents Environmental

Society IncorporatedObjective O2: Importance of land and water

Amend Include air in objective O2. Poor air quality reduces the well being of the community.

Accept

/S126/001 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Entire Plan Amend While WELL is generally supportive of the Proposed NRP,

submission points have been made to enhance relevant provisions in the Proposed NRP, and to enable the importance of critical distribution infrastructure across the region to be recognised. [see submission S126]

Reject

/S126/005 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Offset Support Supports the term 'Offset' being defined and seeks that is

retained, unaltered.Accept

/S126/006 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Regionally


Amend Amend the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure to read:...· the national electricity grid· facilities for the generation, transmission and distribution of electricity.· a network (as defined in the Electricity Industry Act 2010) ...

Reject

FS22/004 Transpower NZ Ltd Neither support or oppose

Not stated

FS32/005 Meridian Energy Limited Support Allow


Submission point




S126/008 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Upgrade Support Support the term 'Upgrade' being defined in the Proposed NRP and seek it is retained, unaltered.

Accept

FS57/008 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS35/002 First Gas Ltd Support AllowFS56/012 Powerco Support AllowFS60/003 NZ Transport Agency Support Allow

S126/012 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Objective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Support in part

Support Objective O12 as currently worded.WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for O12 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Reject

/S126/013 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Objective O13:


Amend Amend O13 include the word 'development' as follows:

"The development, use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure andrenewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area areprotected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over,or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity."

WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for O13 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework

Reject


Submission point




should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

FS56/026 Powerco Support in part

Allow in part


Allow in part

FS69/016 Wellington International Airport Limited Support in part

Allow in part

S126/014 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P8: Beneficial activities

Support in part

Support P8 to the extent that it covers existing electricity structures and facilities that were legally established at the time of the PNRP notification.

WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P8 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Reject


Allow

FS56/038 Powerco Support in part

Allow in part

S126/015 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support in part

Support Policy P12.WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P12 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Reject


Submission point




FS71/076 Horticulture NZ Oppose in part

Disallow in part

S126/016 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Supports P13 and requests that P13 is amended to to remove the word "generally".WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P13 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Accept in part


Disallow in part

S126/017 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Support in part

Policy P14 is supported.WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P14 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Reject


Disallow in part

S127/005 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Objective O6: Health needs of people


/S127/006 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Objective O8:

Allocation regimeAmend Amend to add the words "in the management of water quality and"

before "within"Reject

/S127/018 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterSupport Support Reject

/S127/019 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Policy P11: In- Amend Amend policy as follows: In-stream w Water storage Reject


Submission point





The benefits associated with the damming and storing of water within the bed of a river are recognised when: ...

/S129/003 Alana Bowman 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentSupport in part

Allocate resources for these proposals Reject

/S131/002 PF Olsen Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Include Forestry as a beneficial use of land and water resources Reject

/S132/001 Hammond Limited Objective O8:

Allocation regimeSupport Retain O8. Accept

/S132/010 Hammond Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend P7 to add a new condition recognising farming as

beneficial as follows:...(l) farming.

Reject

/S132/011 Hammond Limited Policy P8:


Support Retain P8. Accept

/S135/026 Wellington Water Limited Regionally


Amend Replace the sixth bullet point with "the local authority water supply network, water treatment plants and intake works" or similar.

Accept

FS30/019 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS26/019 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS85/052 Carterton District Council Support Allow

S135/031 Wellington Water Limited Upgrade Amend Change "current standards" to "community decided levels of service" or to like effect. Change the definition so that infrastructure can accommodate growth.

Reject


Submission point




FS26/021 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowS135/037 Wellington Water Limited Objective O6:

Health needs of people

Support Add new Objective: Sufficient water is available to meet the communities' need to fight fires (or similar).

Reject

/S135/038 Wellington Water Limited Objective O8:

Allocation regimeSupport Support Accept



Amend Add to the end "...are recognised and protected." Reject



Amend Amend to protect significant three waters infrastructure against reverse sensitivity in all environments, not just the coastal marine area.

Accept

/S135/054 Wellington Water Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Include reference to the social and economic benefits of providing

stormwater systems to protect against flooding. Reject

/S135/055 Wellington Water Limited Policy P8:


Amend Add public water supply, protection of the community and property from flooding by stormwater networks and protection of public health by maintaining and operating a wastewater network and disposal system to the list of beneficial activities. Remove "generally appropriate" from (c). Include "operation of" existing structures in (h). Include "or infrastructure" between "monitoring resource use" and "or the state of the environment" in (j).

Reject

FS85/137 Carterton District Council Support in part

Allow


Submission point




FS49/098 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS135/057 Wellington Water Limited Policy P12:


Amend Replace "by having regard to" with "and protected" to the end of the sentence (or to like effect). Add new benefits of the provision of the health needs of people with a potable water supply, the protection of people and property from flooding and the protection of public health by the provision of a wastewater service.

Reject



Amend Replace "are generally appropriate" with "are protected" or similar. See consequential amendments to rules R114 and R116 [submission points s135/163 and s135/164].

Accept




/S135/060 Wellington Water Limited Policy P15: Flood


Amend Replace "are generally appropriate" with "are protected" or similar. Clarify that stormwater management and river flood protection infrastructure are included, for the avoidance of doubt.

Accept in part

/S135/061 Wellington Water Limited Policy P16: New Amend Add "and provided for" or similar. Reject


Submission point





/S135/212 Wellington Water Limited Entire Plan Amend The objectives, policies, rules and methods are re-drafted to more

adequately recognise the benefits of three waters regionally significant infrastructure and protect its establishment, operation, maintenance and upgrade.

Reject

/S135/213 Wellington Water Limited Regionally


Amend Clarity is provided on whether regionally significant infrastructure also includes the discharges inherent in the three waters systems. It would be beneficial if the discharge itself was considered part of the three waters regionally significant infrastructure.

Accept



Amend Provision for and protection of the stormwater network and associated watercourses and wastewater networks is afforded throughout the plan in a similar manner that has been provided for the potable water supply

Reject



Amend The proposed plan distinguishes and recognises the benefits of the urban environment and infrastructure, and in particular reflects the urban context and its benefits in the determination of activity status.

Reject



Amend The proposed plan contain provisions that recognise and provide for the long lives of regionally significant infrastructure and consider the use of review conditions and other mechanisms, such as adaptive management and review provisions, to encourage continuous improvement.

Reject

FS54/080 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Support Not statedS135/231 Wellington Water Limited Objective O12: Amend The proposed plan recognises and provides for the benefits of Reject


Submission point





regionally significant infrastructure when considering the scale of their adverse effects.

/S140/008 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Offset Support Retain Accept

FS73/034 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS140/011 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Regionally


Support Retain Accept

/S140/012 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Reverse

sensitivitySupport Retain Accept

/S140/013 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Strategic

Transport Network

Support in part

add or any subsequent versions, to the end of a, b, c and d; and add:

The Strategic Transport Network is mapped in the Regional Land Transport Plan 2015 and if subsequently altered the latest map shall take precedence.

Reject

FS60/002 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowS140/014 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O9:

Recreational values

Support in part

Amend Objective 9 as follows;The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and their margins and natural wetlands are maintained and enhanced where appropriate.

Reject

FS60/005 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowS140/015 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O10:

Public accessSupport in part

Amend Objective 10 as follows;Public access to and along the coastal marine area and rivers and lakes is maintained and enhanced where appropriate.

Reject


Submission point




/S140/016 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O12:



/S140/017 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O13:



/S140/030 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P7: Uses


Amend Policy P7 to add:(l) regionally significant infrastructure.

Reject

FS30/050 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS22/020 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS26/071 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS61/013 Minister of Conservation Oppose Disallow

S140/031 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Support in part

Amend Policy 9 as follows:(b) protect public health, safety and security, or(c) ...with respect to (a), (b) and (c), where it is necessary to permanently restrict or remove existing public access, and where practicable and achievable and considering the nature of the activity, the loss of public access shall be mitigated or offset by providing enhanced public access at a similar or nearby location or offset.

Accept in part

/S140/032 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P12:

Benefits of Support in part

Amend Policy by adding:(f) the functional need for regionally significant infrastructure to be located

Accept


Submission point




regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

over, under, within and adjacent to the beds of rivers and lakes.

FS96/008 Queen Elizabeth II National Trust Oppose in part

Disallow in part


Not stated

S140/033 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities


/S141/010 CentrePort Properties Limited Regionally


Support Retain this definition. Accept

/S141/011 CentrePort Properties Limited Reverse

sensitivitySupport Retain this definition. Accept

/S141/013 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O9:

Recreational values

Amend Amend to refer to "where appropriate". Reject

/S141/014 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O12:

Benefits of regionally

Amend Recognise the benefits of other commercial infrastructure and developments in the coastal marine area that are not regionally significant infrastructure or renewable energy generation

Reject


Submission point





activities.Amend Objective O12 as follows: The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure, and renewable energy generation activities and new commercial development activities are recognised.

/S141/021 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P8:


Support Retain in its current form. Accept

/S141/022 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P12:


Amend The benefits of regionally significant infrastructure, and renewable energy generation activities, and new commercial developments are recognised by having regard to:...

Reject

/S142/003 New Zealand Fire Commission and

Wellington Rural Fire AuthorityPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Support in part

Amend i) firefighting and firefighter training, and Reject

/S143/022 Maypole Environmental Limited Policy P9: Public


Amend Amend Policy 9 to promote sustainable public access to wetlands. Reject

/S144/004 Chorus New Zealand Limited Regionally


Amend Amend bullet point two and three of the definition as follows:

· strategic telecommunication facilities, as defined in section 5 of the Telecommunications Act 2001

Reject


Submission point




· strategic radiocommunications as defined in section 2(1) of the RadioCcommunications Act 1989.

/S144/005 Chorus New Zealand Limited Objective O12:


Oppose in part

Amend Objective O12 as follows:Objective O12(Coastal)The social, economic, cultural, and environmental and health and safety benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities.Objective O12ARecognise that some regionally significant infrastructure has a functional need and/or operational requirement to be located and/or operated in a particular environment.

Reject

FS26/052 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS56/020 Powerco Support AllowFS61/008 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowFS26/033 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS30/032 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS57/015 The Oil Companies Support Allow

S144/006 Chorus New Zealand Limited Objective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Support in part

Amend Objective O13 as follows:The existing use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewableenergy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Reject


Submission point




/S144/009 Chorus New Zealand Limited Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend Policy P7 as follows:The cultural, social and economic

benefits of using land and water for:(l) Regionally Significant Infrastructure

Reject

FS69/037 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS57/030 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/036 Powerco Support Allow

S144/010 Chorus New Zealand Limited Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Amend Amend Policy P9 as Follows:Reduction in the extent or quality of public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers shall be avoided except where it is necessary to:(d) protect Regionally Significant Infrastructure

Reject

FS57/033 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS57/037 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS32/032 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS56/040 Powerco Support AllowFS73/035 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS59/027 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid

Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council

Support Allow

S144/011 Chorus New Zealand Limited Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P12 as follows:(e) the functional need for and the operational requirements associated with developing, operating, maintaining and upgrading regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energygeneration activities, including where thoseactivities are proposed within areas of outstanding natural character and landscapes, high hazards, sites of significant value, ecosystems and habitats with significant

Reject


Submission point




indigenous biodiversity value, natural features, sites significant historic heritage value, and sites with significant Mana Whenua.

FS73/036 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS61/017 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowFS57/035 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/042 Powerco Support AllowFS57/039 The Oil Companies Support Allow

S144/012 Chorus New Zealand Limited Policy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P13 as follows:The use, operation, maintenance, and upgrade, and removal of existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are beneficial and generally appropriate.

Reject

FS73/037 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS144/013 Chorus New Zealand Limited Policy P14:


Amend Amend Policy P14 as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any adverse effects, including any reverse sensitivity effects.

Accept

FS73/038 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS145/012 First Gas Ltd Regionally


Amend Regionally significant infrastructure includes: . . . . Pipelines and incidental equipment and facilities for the distribution or transmission of natural or manufactured gas or petroleum.

Reject


Submission point




FS56/008 Powerco Support AllowS145/014 First Gas Ltd Objective O12:


Amend The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised within the region and beyond.

Reject

/S145/015 First Gas Ltd Objective O13:


Amend The use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Reject

FS30/033 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS26/034 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS26/053 South Wairarapa District Council Support Allow

S145/016 First Gas Ltd 3. Objectives Amend Add new objective: The safe, effective and efficient use, operation, maintenance, upgrade and development of regionally significant infrastructure is provided for

Add new Objective:To recognise that regionally significant infrastructure represents appropriate use and development in all environments where there are functional needs and / or operational requirements

Reject


Submission point




FS32/009 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS32/011 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS83/004 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Oppose DisallowFS57/013 The Oil Companies Support in

partAllow

FS56/018 Powerco Support AllowS145/027 First Gas Ltd 4. Policies Not stated Add a new policy: Resource consent durations for

regionally significant infrastructure applications required under ss13, 14 and 15 of the RMA will generally be granted for the maximum period of time unless reasons are identified during the consent process that make this inappropriate.

Reject

FS32/028 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS73/042 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support Allow

S145/028 First Gas Ltd Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy 12: The benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised and provided for by having regard to taking into account: (a) . . . (b) the investment in, and the location of existing infrastructure and structures, and (c) . . . . (d) the functional need for port activities and other regionally significant infrastructure to be located within the coastal marine area and the coastal area, and (e) the functional need for regionally significant infrastructure to be located over, under, within and adjacent the beds of rivers and lakes , and

Reject


Submission point




(f) .....

FS22/021 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS56/045 Powerco Support AllowFS73/043 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS85/122 Carterton District Council Neither

support or oppose

Not stated

S145/029 First Gas Ltd Policy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy 13: The use, operation, maintenance, and upgrade replacement, and development of existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are beneficial and generally appropriate.

Reject

FS73/044 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS85/127 Carterton District Council Support AllowFS56/046 Powerco Support AllowFS32/037 Meridian Energy Limited Support in

partAllow

FS69/041 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS145/030 First Gas Ltd Policy P14:


Amend Amend Policy 14: Regionally significant infrastructure .... reverse sensitivity effects which may compromise the efficient and effective use, maintenance, upgrading replacement or development of that infrastructure.

Reject

FS56/047 Powerco Support AllowS146/026 NZ Transport Agency Offset Support in

partAmend the definition of offset: A measurable positive outcome resulting from an action designed to compensate for the significant residual adverse effects on the

Reject


Submission point




environment arising from an activity after avoidance, remediation and at source mitigation measures have been taken.

FS51/002 GBC Winstone Support AllowS146/029 NZ Transport Agency Regionally


Support Subject to amending the term 'Strategic Transport Network', retain the definition of 'regionally significant infrastructure':

Accept

/S146/031 NZ Transport Agency Reverse

sensitivitySupport in part

Amend the definition of reverse sensitivity: The vulnerability of an existing lawfully-established activity to other activities in the vicinity which are sensitive to adverse environmental effects that may be generated by such existing activities, thereby creating the potential for the operation, maintenance, upgrade and development of such existing activity to be constrained.

Reject

FS25/007 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS69/002 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS57/001 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS71/008 Horticulture NZ Oppose in

partDisallow

FS49/011 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowFS56/010 Powerco Support AllowFS22/006 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS51/003 GBC Winstone Support in

partAllow

S146/036 NZ Transport Agency Strategic Transport Network

Support in part

Amend the definition of 'strategic transport network, as it applies to the Transport Agency's infrastructure, as follows: The Strategic Transport Network comprises the following parts ...(c) Any other road classified as a high productivity motor vehicle (HPMV) route identified in the Regional Land Transport Plan 2015, and (d) All sections of the regional cycling network

Reject


Submission point




classified as having a combined utility and recreational focus identified in the Regional Land Transport Plan 2015; and (e) All other road, cycling and walking transportation corridors and routes, including ancillary infrastructure such as stormwater infrastructure, which are owned and managed by the NZ Transport Agency The current Strategic Transport Network is mapped in the Regional Land Transport Plan 2015.

FS83/002 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Support in part

Allow in part

S146/039 NZ Transport Agency Objective O10: Public access


/S146/040 NZ Transport Agency Objective O12:


Support in part

Amend Objective O12: The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised within the region and beyond.

Reject

/S146/041 NZ Transport Agency Objective O13:


Support in part

Amend Objective O13: The use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Reject


Submission point





Support Allow

S146/042 NZ Transport Agency 3. Objectives Not stated Add new objective: The safe, effective and efficient use, operation, maintenance, upgrade and development of regionally significant infrastructure is provided for

Reject

FS69/010 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS22/009 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS83/006 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Oppose DisallowFS32/010 Meridian Energy Limited Support Allow

S146/043 NZ Transport Agency 3. Objectives Not stated Add new Objective: To recognise that regionally significant infrastructure represents appropriate use and development in all environments where there are functional needs or operational requirements

Reject

FS69/011 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS22/008 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS83/005 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Oppose DisallowFS32/008 Meridian Energy Limited Support in

partAllow

S146/064 NZ Transport Agency 3. Objectives Not stated Add new objective: Discharges associated with regionally significant infrastructure are managed through the adoption of the best practicable option.

Reject

FS32/007 Meridian Energy Limited Support in part

Allow


Submission point




FS56/017 Powerco Support AllowFS69/009 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS57/012 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS15/002 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings Limited Support AllowFS96/028 Queen Elizabeth II National Trust Oppose Disallow

S146/078 NZ Transport Agency 4. Policies Not stated Add a new policy to provide direction on the duration of operational consents for infrastructure of regional significance. Resource consent durations for regionally significant infrastructure applications required under ss13, 14 and 15 of the RMA will generally be granted for the maximum period of time unless reasons are identified during the consent process that make this inappropriate

Reject

FS25/011 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS30/043 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS69/036 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS32/027 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS26/064 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS51/009 GBC Winstone Support Allow

S146/080 NZ Transport Agency Policy P7: Uses of land and water

Support in part

Amend Policy 7: The cultural, social and economic benefits of using land and water for: (a) Treatment, dilution, conveyance and disposal or wastewater and stormwater, and . . . (k) Transport over, under, adjacent, along, and access to, water bodies (l) Construction and operational water supply for regionally significant infrastructure. shall be recognised.

Reject

FS25/017 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowS146/081 NZ Transport Agency Policy P9: Public Support Retain Accept


Submission point





/S146/082 NZ Transport Agency Policy P12:


Support in part

Amend Policy 12: The benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised and provided for by having regard to taking into account: (a) . . . (b) the investment in, and the location of existing infrastructure and structures, and (c) . . . . (d) the functional need for port activities and other regionally significant infrastructure to be located within the coastal marine area and the coastal area, and (e) the functional need for regionally significant infrastructure to be located over, under, within and adjacent the beds of rivers and lakes , and (f) operational requirements associated with developing, operating, maintaining and upgrading regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities. (g) The safe, efficient and effective use of the Strategic Transport Network

Accept

FS61/016 Minister of Conservation Oppose in part

Disallow in part


Not stated

FS69/040 Wellington International Airport Limited Support in part

Allow in part

FS96/033 Queen Elizabeth II National Trust Oppose in Disallow in part


Submission point




partS146/083 NZ Transport Agency Policy P13:


Support in part

Amend Policy 13: The use, operation, maintenance, and upgrade and development of existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are beneficial and generally appropriate. Or Retain Policy 13 (i.e. excluding 'development') and add a new policy to enable new development: The development of new regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities to meet the needs of the community are beneficial and are generally appropriate.

Accept in part

FS30/052 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS22/022 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS32/038 Meridian Energy Limited Support in

partAllow

FS26/073 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS61/020 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowFS32/036 Meridian Energy Limited Support in

partAllow

FS85/126 Carterton District Council Support AllowFS85/128 Carterton District Council Support AllowFS51/012 GBC Winstone Support Allow

S146/084 NZ Transport Agency Policy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Support in part

Retain Policy 14: Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects which may compromise the efficient and effective use, maintenance, upgrading or development of that infrastructure.

Reject


Submission point




FS25/020 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowS162/011 Mt Victoria Residents Association

IncObjective O10: Public access

Not stated We recommend deletion of Objective O57 and Policy 142(b) as they are contrary to Objective O56, and therefore comparison with the Wellington city CBD should not be relevant - the reference point should be the maritime surrounds.

Reject

/S163/006 Porirua City Council 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentNot stated [Take into account the costs of implementation with many routine

maintenance/upgrade works now requiring resource consent and make the approach practical and realistic]

Reject

/S163/013 Porirua City Council Objective O10:

Public accessNot stated [Give more recognition and protection to the need for public open

space and public access to and along the coastal marine area, lakes and rivers]

Reject

/S163/015 Porirua City Council 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentNot stated [Provide more recognition of the maintenance requirements of

infrastructure and balance the need to protect natural resources with the need for urban resources to be maintained and enhanced as well]

Reject

FS51/004 GBC Winstone Support AllowS163/030 Porirua City Council Regionally


Amend Amend definition to include municipal landfills. Amend definition to clarify what strategic telecommunications and radio communications facilities are.

Reject

FS30/018 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS26/018 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS85/044 Carterton District Council Support AllowFS85/046 Carterton District Council Support Allow

S163/034 Porirua City Council Upgrade Amend Amend to read: "The replacement or alteration of an existing structure or facility that results in the effects of the activity being the same or simlar in character, intensity and scale as the existing structure and activity."

Reject


Submission point





Recreational values

Support [Retain] Accept


Public accessSupport [Retain] Accept



Amend Amend the objective to protect significant infrastructure against reverse sensitivity in wetlands and the beds of lakes and rivers as well as the coastal marine area.

Accept

FS73/046 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS163/049 Porirua City Council Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Amend subclause (b) to read: "treatment, management, dilution

and disposal of wastewater and stormwater..."Reject

FS25/016 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowS163/050 Porirua City Council 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentSupport in part

[Support Policies P12-16] Accept

FS96/073 Queen Elizabeth II National Trust Oppose in part

Disallow in part

S165/004 Transpower NZ Ltd 3.2 Beneficial use and development

Support Retain section 3.2 (in particular Objectives O12 and O13) and the Heading Beneficial Use and Development, except for the specific relief sought in submission points S165/005 and S165/006.

Reject

/S165/005 Transpower NZ Ltd Objective O12:


Amend Amend Objective O12 as follows:The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits at the national, regional and local scale of regionally significant infrastructure, and renewable energy generation activities are recognised and provided for.

Reject


Submission point




FS64/006 New Zealand Defence Force Support AllowFS56/023 Powerco Support Allow

S165/006 Transpower NZ Ltd Objective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Amend Objective O13 as follows:The ongoing use, and ongoing operation, maintenance and upgrade of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible orinappropriate use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Reject

FS25/008 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS57/021 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/027 Powerco Support Allow

S165/008 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P12, as follows:The national, regional and local benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities are recognised and provided forby having regard to:.....(e) the technical and operational requirements associated with developing, operating, maintaining and upgrading regionally significant infrastructure, particularly the National Grid.

Reject


Allow

FS56/044 Powerco Support AllowFS73/048 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose Disallow

S165/009 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P13: Existing regionally significant



Submission point




infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

/S165/010 Transpower NZ Ltd 4. Policies Not stated Add an additional policy as follows (or similar):

Policy P13A: Managing environmental effects of new National Grid infrastructure.When considering the environmental effects of new infrastructure associated with the National Grid, or major upgrades of the existing National Grid, decision makers shall have regard to:(a) the benefits of the infrastructure to meet the needs of present and future generations,(b) the extent to which any adverse environmental effects have been avoided, remedied or mitigated by the route, site and method selection; and(c) the constraints imposed by the technical and operational requirements of the National Grid.

Reject

FS32/039 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowFS73/049 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose Disallow

S165/011 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Support in part

Amend Policy P14, as follows:Incompatible activities adjacent to Protection of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities. The ongoing use, maintenance, and upgrade of regionally significantinfrastructure and renewable energy generation

Reject


Submission point




activities shall be protected from new incompatible or inappropriate use and or development occurring under, over or adjacent to it the infrastructure or activity, by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects.

FS73/050 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS165/020 Transpower NZ Ltd Regionally


Amend Amend clause (d) as follows: the National electricity Grid Accept

/S165/021 Transpower NZ Ltd National

electricity gridAmend Amend the definition to National Electricity Grid: National

electricity Grid means the assets used or owned by Transpower New Zealand Limited, including:(a) transmission lines, and(b) electricity substations.

Accept

/S165/050 Transpower NZ Ltd Upgrade Support Retain Accept

/S170/002 Chris Engel Regionally



Reject

/S170/004 Chris Engel Objective O8:


cultural and environmental benefits of taking and using water for current uses and also for

Reject


Submission point




future needs are recognised and provided for within the Plan's allocation framework"

/S170/007 Chris Engel Policy P7: Uses


/S170/008 Chris Engel Policy P11: In-



/S174/001 Rob Kennedy Objective O8:

Allocation regimeNot stated We need to protect our water resources in situ and find

management synergies rather than compromises, and we are in-danger of developing irrigation systems that become hazardous and unaffordable [see full submission].

Reject

/S175/031 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterOppose in part

Delete Policy P7 or revise it as per detail in original submission S175 p23.

Accept

/S175/032 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P8:


Support in part

Include reference to "upgrade" in Policy 8(h). Accept

FS73/052 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support Allow in partFS49/101 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in

partAllow

S175/033 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

Amend Revise the policy to address the concerns expressed. Reject

/S175/034 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P15: Flood

protection Amend Either widen Policies P15 and P16 to include coastal hazard

mitigation activities (using appropriate terminology) or create new Reject


Submission point




activities policies to deal with those activities. In addition, "upgrade" should be included.

/S175/035 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P16: New


Amend [See submission point S175/034]. Reject

/S176/001 Ian Jensen Objective O9:

Recreational values


/S176/019 Ian Jensen Policy P9: Public


Not stated New Rule sought:Provide reasonable access to parts of a site that may bedenied by the presence of a Natural, Significant, Outstanding Wetland, or anEcological Site, using the principals of Policy P4 and in particular (a, b& e). -'Discretionary Activity'Consider how other points of access may beimplemented.Minimise the parts of the site that may beaffected.Position the access if possible to the marginsof the site.Allow for areas of 'Off-setting' that firstlycan be undertaken on the site and secondly off site but as close as practicableto the site.That the Off-Set' areas are equal to a minimum150% of the affected part of the site.

Reject

FS74/302 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow


Submission point




FS45/011 KRL Developments Limited Support AllowFS47/002 Maypole Environmental Limited Oppose in

partAllow in part

S274/002 Alexander Haddon Webster Regionally significant infrastructure


Reject

/S274/004 Alexander Haddon Webster Objective O8:



Reject

/S274/007 Alexander Haddon Webster Policy P7: Uses


/S274/008 Alexander Haddon Webster Policy P11: In-



/S275/002 Forest Enterprises Growth Ltd Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend The value of Forestry as a major contributor to the regional

economy needs to be recognised. Forestry should be included as a beneficial use of land and water resources

Reject

/S276/002 Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd Regionally


Amend Add bullet-point which refers to quarries which serve regional or sub-regional areas, or specifically list the hard rock quarries which serve the region's main urban areas. Add bullet-point which refers to landfills and cleanfills which serve regional or sub-regional areas, or specifically list these facilities.

Reject

/S276/003 Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd Objective O6: Support Retain Objective O6 Accept


Submission point




Health needs of people

/S276/004 Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd Objective O8:

Allocation regimeSupport Retain Objective 08. Accept

/S276/011 Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Retain (g) but add a reference to other mineral /aggregate

materials, cleanfills and landfills or provide for this within policies P12 to P14.

Reject


Support Allow

S276/012 Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd 4.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Add two New Policies - 1) To achieve social, economic and environmental benefits from the region's mineral resources, enable regionally significant mineral extraction activities, and associated water takes, use and discharges, along with the remediation of quarries using cleanfill, provided that the significant adverse effects of these activities can be avoided, remedied or mitigated. 2 ) Regionally significant mineral resources and mineral extraction activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring within or adjacent to them.

Reject

FS51/010 GBC Winstone Support AllowFS74/301 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow

S276/026 Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd 13 Maps Amend Amend the Maps to identify the regionally significant quarries and mineral resources.

Reject


Submission point




/S277/002 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Objective O12:


Not stated Recommend strengthened wording to support this [O12] objective. Reject

/S277/003 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Objective O13:


Amend [Clarify whether this limits new use and development by the current managers of regionally significant infrastructure]

Reject

/S277/004 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P12:





Support in part

[Clarify what discretion is attached to the term "generally appropriate"]

Reject


Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally

Support in part

[Clarify whether this policy limits new use and development by the current managers of regionally significant infrastructure]

Reject


Submission point




significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

/S279/012 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O2:


Amend Amend as follows; The importance and contribution of land and water, and ecological systems and processes, to the social, economic and cultural well-being, and the health of people and the community are recognised.

Accept

FS30/025 Masterton District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/045 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/026 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose Disallow

S279/017 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc 3.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Amend objective so that it links to and is consistent with RMA and NPS-FM wording

Accept


Water for livestock

Support Retain as notified Accept


Allocation regimeOppose Delete the objective Accept

FS85/072 Carterton District Council Oppose DisallowFS52/002 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Oppose DisallowFS36/018 Wairarapa Water Users Society

IncorporatedOppose Disallow

S279/020 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O9: Recreational values

Support Support as notified Accept

/S279/021 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O10: Amend Amend the objective so that access to and along the coastal Reject


Submission point




Public access marine area is maintained and enhanced except in circumstances and locations where it is inconsistent with safeguarding or protecting significant values or sites, including sites of significance to Maori.






Amend Amend the objective to be clear that it applies to existing infrastructure only.

Reject

FS73/053 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowS279/074 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterOppose Delete the policy Accept

FS36/020 Wairarapa Water Users Society Incorporated

Oppose Disallow

FS85/134 Carterton District Council Oppose DisallowFS85/119 Carterton District Council Oppose Disallow

S279/075 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P8: Beneficial activities

Amend Amend the policy so that the listed activities (subject to the further amendments below) are recognised and provided for.Remove clauses (h) and (k) or refined to describe a specific set of activities and uses.

Reject

FS54/020 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Support in part

Not stated

FS73/054 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowFS49/102 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow

S279/076 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal

Amend Retain Policy P9(a) as notified.Amend the exception to apply only to (a) and (b).

Accept


Submission point




marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers

FS54/021 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Support Not statedS279/078 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P11: In-


Oppose Delete or amend to reflect that there are adverse effects from damming, and in particular that these adverse effects can impact irreversibly on indigenous biodiversity, and mana whenua values.

Accept

/S279/079 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P12:


Amend Amend to state where the benefit is accrued and to be clear that adverse effects of the operation, use, maintenance and upgrade can still have adverse effects on the environment and need to be managed.Add in a new policy to ensure that new, or increases in scale or extent of existing, regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation facilities shall avoid causing adverse effects on sites in Schedules A to F, H and J.

Reject

FS85/124 Carterton District Council Support in part

Allow in part

FS49/105 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowFS32/057 Meridian Energy Limited Neither

support or oppose

Allow in part


Oppose Disallow


Oppose Disallow

FS73/055 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowS279/080 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P13:

Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity


Reject


Submission point




generation facilities

FS30/053 Masterton District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/074 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS73/056 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowFS32/035 Meridian Energy Limited Not stated Not statedFS85/125 Carterton District Council Support in

partAllow in part

S279/081 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities


Reject

FS32/040 Meridian Energy Limited Not stated AllowFS85/138 Carterton District Council Support in

partAllow in part

FS73/057 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowFS26/075 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS30/054 Masterton District Council Oppose Disallow

S282/004 Wellington International Airport Limited



/S282/005 Wellington International Airport

Limited3. Objectives Amend New Objective O# (amend numbering as necessary) -

Development of regionally significant infrastructureProvide for and enable the development and growth of regionally significant infrastructure.

Reject

FS15/001 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings Limited Support AllowFS73/062 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support Allow


Submission point




FS83/007 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Oppose DisallowFS32/012 Meridian Energy Limited Support Allow


Objective O9: Recreational values

Support in part

Amend Objective O9 as follows:The recreational values opportunities of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and their margin and, natural wetlands are maintained and where appropriate enhanced.

Reject

FS49/040 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS282/007 Wellington International Airport

LimitedObjective O10: Public access

Support in part

Amend Objective O10 as follows:Public access to and along the coastal marine area and rivers and lakes is maintained and enhanced, except where it is appropriate and necessary to impose a restriction

Reject


LimitedObjective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Support in part

Amend Objective O12 as follows:The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised and provided for.

Reject

FS57/017 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS73/063 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS56/022 Powerco Support Allow


Objective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Support in part

Amend Objective O13 as follows:The use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent in close proximity to the infrastructure or activity.

Reject

FS56/028 Powerco Support AllowFS57/022 The Oil Companies Support Allow


Submission point





Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers



LimitedPolicy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P13 as follows:The use, development, operation, maintenance, and upgrade of existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are beneficial and generally appropriate.

Accept

FS73/065 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS282/031 Wellington International Airport

LimitedPolicy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Amend Amend Policy P14 as follows:

Policy P14: Incompatible activities adjacent in close proximity to regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities

Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent in close proximity to it, by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects.

Reject

FS51/015 GBC Winstone Support AllowS282/082 Wellington International Airport

LimitedPolicy P12: Benefits of regionally

Amend Amend: The benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised and

Reject


Submission point




significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

provided for by having regard to:...

FS73/064 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS51/011 GBC Winstone Support Allow

S285/036 Land Matters Ltd Objective O9: Recreational values

Amend Amend O9:The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and theirmargins and natural wetlands are maintained and where possible/identified enhanced over time.

Reject

FS49/032 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose in part

Disallow in part

S285/080 Land Matters Ltd Objective O9: Recreational values

Amend Amend O9:The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers, lakes and their margins and natural wetlands are maintained and where possible, enhanced, over time.

Reject


Disallow in part

S286/001 Wellington City Council 4.2 Beneficial use and development

Not stated Include a new policy (or similar) in Section 4.2 Beneficial use and development:Recognise the contribution existing urban areas, identified urban growth areas and infrastructure make to the social, economic and cultural wellbeing of people and communities and provide for their ongoing use and development.

Reject

FS25/015 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS22/018 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS27/006 Porirua City Council Support AllowFS85/130 Carterton District Council Support Allow


Submission point




FS49/095 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS286/005 Wellington City Council 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentNot stated Review the use of the non-complying activity status where

activities, structures and infrastructure are an expected part of the environment and in areas that have been identified by territorial authorities as urban development areas.

Reject

FS49/096 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS286/012 Wellington City Council Policy P8:


Amend Retain policy 8 and method 15 Accept

/S286/014 Wellington City Council Regionally


Amend Amend the definition of Regionally Significant Infrastructure to include all roads; orEnsure that the objectives and policies recognise and provide for the local roading network, in a similar way as they provide for Regionally Significant Infrastructure.

Reject

FS30/020 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS26/020 South Wairarapa District Council Support AllowFS85/049 Carterton District Council Support Allow

S292/002 Andrew Patrick Regionally significant infrastructure


Reject

/S292/004 Andrew Patrick Objective O8:



Reject

/S292/007 Andrew Patrick Policy P7: Uses


/S292/008 Andrew Patrick Policy P11: In- Support Retain. Reject


Submission point





/S294/036 Bell Camp Trust Objective O9:

Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S294/080 Bell Camp Trust Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S295/036 The Carter Family Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject

FS49/031 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow in partFS1/077 Waa Rata Estate Support in

partAllow

S295/080 The Carter Family Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject

FS1/107 Waa Rata Estate Support in part

Allow in part

FS49/021 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow in partS297/036 Kennott Family Trust Objective O9:

Recreational values

Amend Amend O9:The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and theirmargins and natural wetlands are maintained and

Reject


Submission point




where possible/identified enhanced over time.


Disallow in part

S297/080 Kennott Family Trust Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S299/036 Julian and Ruth Blackett Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S299/080 Julian and Ruth Blackett Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject

FS49/022 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow in partS301/037 Carterton District Council Policy P12:



/S301/038 Carterton District Council Policy P13:

Existing regionally



Submission point




significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

/S301/039 Carterton District Council Policy P14:


Amend Amend Policy P14 to read as follows (or words with similar effect):'Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by locating and designing any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects.'

Reject

/S302/009 Fertiliser Association of New

Zealand IncObjective O2: Importance of land and water



Zealand IncObjective O7: Water for livestock



Zealand IncObjective O8: Allocation regime



Zealand Inc3.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Include two new Objectives under 3.2 Beneficial use and development as follows, or similar:Objective OXThe use of land for cultural, social and economic activities that benefit the community and the Region is enabled and provided for within the Plan.Objective OX

Reject


Submission point




Efficient and productive use of land for primary production that contributes to the economic wellbeing of the Region and New Zealand.

FS51/005 GBC Winstone Support in part

Allow

FS49/013 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowFS71/033 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS46/038 Ravensdown Limited Support Allow

S302/030 Fertiliser Association of New Zealand Inc

Policy P7: Uses of land and water

Support in part

Amend Policy P7 as follows:The cultural, social and economic benefits of using land and water for:......(f) food production primary production and harvesting, andshall berecognised enabled and provided for.

Reject

/S306/001 Irrigation New Zealand Incorporated Objective O8:

Allocation regimeNot stated Amend objective O8 as follows:

The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of taking, storing and using water are...

Reject

FS71/036 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS52/004 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Support Allow

S306/003 Irrigation New Zealand Incorporated 3.2 Beneficial use and development

Not stated Add the following objective:The benefits of food, beverage and fibre production systems to the regions socio-economic well-being are recognised and provided for

Reject

FS74/271 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS43/005 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyOppose Disallow

S306/004 Irrigation New Zealand Incorporated Policy P7: Uses of land and water

Not stated Amend Policy P7 as follows:The cultural, environmental, social and...

Reject


Submission point




...(h) water storage and distribution infrastructure, and(i) irrigation, and(j) stock water, and...

FS52/009 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Support AllowS306/005 Irrigation New Zealand Incorporated Policy P11: In-


Support Support Reject

/S307/008 Horticulture NZ National

electricity gridAmend Amend 'National electricity grid' to 'National Grid' Accept

/S307/014 Horticulture NZ 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend Add a new objective in 3.2 Beneficial use and development.

Take an integrated management approach to biosecurity risks to ensure that rural production is not adversely affected by incursions of pests and unwanted organisms.

Reject

FS54/101 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Support Not statedFS74/246 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow

S307/015 Horticulture NZ 3.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Add a new objective in 3.2 Beneficial use and development: The social, economic and cultural wellbeing benefits of rural production activities are recognised and provided for.

Reject

FS74/247 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowS307/032 Horticulture NZ Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterAmend Add l) primary production.

Amend Policy P7 by adding: '...shall be recognised and provided for....'

Reject

FS46/018 Ravensdown Limited Support AllowFS54/103 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Support Not statedFS74/252 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow

S307/033 Horticulture NZ Policy P8: Amend Include an additional policy in Policy P8 Beneficial activities: Accept in part


Submission point





m) removal of pest species identified in the Regional Pest Management Strategies and material declared as unwanted organisms under the Biosecurity Act 1993. Amend point f) to include management of riparian margins.

FS74/253 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support in part

Disallow

S308/013 Fish and Game Objective O2: Importance of land and water

Amend Include recognition of ecosystem health, ecological processes, natural character, and ecosystem services to the economic, social, and cultural aspects within Objective O2. Also include human health as an aspect within objective O2

Accept

FS71/030 Horticulture NZ Oppose DisallowS308/016 Fish and Game Objective O7:

Water for livestock

Amend Amend objective O7 to ensure that provision of water for livestock is not contrary to s14(3)(b) and that it does not cause significant adverse effects on aquatic life and occurs within water quantity limits

Reject

FS30/028 Masterton District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/029 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/048 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS61/005 Minister of Conservation Support Allow

S308/017 Fish and Game Objective O8: Allocation regime

Amend Amend objective O8 to ensure that the take and use of water including its assimilative capacity occurs within environmental limits which achieve the freshwater objectives in relation to non-consumptive values including safeguarding life supporting capacity and ecosystem health and processes, cultural values, natural character, mahinga kai, indigenous species, and the habitat of trout, and recreational values including primary contact recreation and angling

Reject

FS71/037 Horticulture NZ Oppose DisallowFS52/005 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Oppose in

partDisallow


Submission point




FS85/071 Carterton District Council Oppose DisallowS308/046 Fish and Game Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterOppose Delete in its entirety Accept


Oppose Disallow

S308/047 Fish and Game Policy P8: Beneficial activities

Amend Amend to include activities which result in enhancement of sportfish and gamebird habitats (wetlands, lakes, and rivers), including restoration of spawning and juvenile rearing habitats.Include removal of structures which impede fish migration and flow.Amend clause (h) to ensure that it is only structures which have a beneficial role in enhancing or protecting the habitat and its ecological values which are recognised as beneficial and generally appropriate.

Reject

FS84/009 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited

Oppose in part

Disallow

FS49/100 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS308/048 Fish and Game Policy P9: Public


Amend Amend the policy such that the access to and along rivers, lakes, wetlands, and the coastal marine area are provided for and enhanced

Reject

/S308/050 Fish and Game Policy P11: In-


Oppose Delete in its entirety. Accept


Oppose Disallow

S308/051 Fish and Game Policy P15: Flood protection activities

Amend Amend policy P15 and P16 to ensure that river management and flood protection activities are undertaken in a manner which is consistent with safeguarding the life supporting capacity and ecological health and processes of freshwater and which protect the natural character of rivers, lakes, wetlands, and their margins. [See original submission p41-42 for detailed amendments].

Reject

FS74/119 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support Allow


Submission point




S308/052 Fish and Game Policy P16: New flood protection and erosion control

Amend Amend policy P15 and P16 to ensure that river management and flood protection activities are undertaken in a manner which is consistent with safeguarding the life supporting capacity and ecological health and processes of freshwater and which protect the natural character of rivers, lakes, wetlands, and their margins. [See original submission p41-42 for detailed amendments].

Reject

FS74/120 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowS309/016 Ngā Hapū o Ōtaki Policy P8:



/S309/017 Ngā Hapū o Ōtaki Policy P9: Public


Support Not stated Accept

/S309/019 Ngā Hapū o Ōtaki Policy P11: In-


Oppose Delete policy Accept

/S309/020 Ngā Hapū o Ōtaki Policy P15: Flood


Oppose Delete policy Reject

/S310/005 Ravensdown Limited Reverse

sensitivitySupport Retain the definition of reverse sensitivity as written, and add

additional provisions as requestedAccept

/S310/006 Ravensdown Limited Objective O2:


Support Retain as written Accept


Water for livestock



Submission point





Allocation regimeSupport Retain Accept


Recreational values

Support in part

Reword to: The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and their margins and natural wetlands are maintained and enhanced where degraded.

Reject

/S310/012 Ravensdown Limited 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend Add new Objective O13B that addresses reverse sensitivity issues Reject

FS57/014 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS71/034 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS56/019 Powerco Support in

partAllow in part

S310/024 Ravensdown Limited 4.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Add new Policy P4B to address reverse sensitivity issues Reject

/S310/025 Ravensdown Limited Policy P7: Uses


Reword to: (f) primary food production and harvesting, and...shall be recognised enabled and provided for.

Reject

FS61/014 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS316/024 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative

Group LimitedObjective O2: Importance of land and water


/S316/025 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative

Group LimitedObjective O7: Water for livestock



Group LimitedObjective O8: Allocation regime



Submission point





Group LimitedObjective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Amend Objective O12 as follows: "The wider social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure, regionally significant industry and renewable electricity generation activities are recognised." Add a new definition for "regionally significant industry" as follows: "An economic activity based on the use of natural and physical resources in the region and is identified in regional or district plans, which has been shown to have benefits that are significant at a regional or national scale e.g. primary production activities, irrigation infrastructure. These may include social, economic or cultural benefits."

Reject

FS74/216 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS61/007 Minister of Conservation Oppose Disallow

S316/028 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited

Objective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Amend Objective O13 as follows: "The use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure, regionally significant industry and renewable electricity generation activities are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity."

Reject

FS27/002 Porirua City Council Oppose DisallowS316/045 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative

Group LimitedPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Support Retain Policy P7. Reject


Group LimitedPolicy P8: Beneficial activities

Amend Amend Policy P8 to clarify that this list of beneficial activities is not exhaustive. For example, amend the heading to read: "Recognition of beneficial activities" and amend the preamble to read: "The following list includes examples of activities that are recognised as beneficial and appropriate."

Reject


Submission point





Group LimitedPolicy P11: In-stream water storage

Amend Change the title of Policy P11 to "Water Storage" and amend as follows: "The benefits associated with the damming and storing of water within the bed of a river are recognised when:(a) there are significant social and economic benefits for the region, and(b) water remains available for multiple in-stream and out of stream uses concurrently, and (c) the reliability of water supply improves as a result, and(d) the damming and storage of water contributes to the efficient allocation and use of water.

Reject

FS71/075 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS61/015 Minister of Conservation Support Allow

S316/048 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited

Policy P12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P12 as follows: The benefits of existing and proposed regionally significant infrastructure, regionally significant industry and renewable electricity generation facilities are recognised by having regard to...". Amend the policy title to include reference to regionally significant industry.

Reject

FS61/019 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS316/049 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative

Group LimitedPolicy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Amend Amend Policy P13 as follows: "The use, operation, maintenance, and upgrade of existing regionally significant infrastructure, regionally significant industry and renewable electricity generation activities are beneficial and generally appropriate." Reword policy title accordingly.

Reject


Group LimitedPolicy P14: Incompatible

Amend Amend Policy P14 as follows: "Regionally significant infrastructure, regionally significant industry, primary

Reject


Submission point





production activities and renewable electricity generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by the location and design of any new use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects." Amend policy title accordingly.

FS71/079 Horticulture NZ Support in part

Allow in part

FS74/219 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowS317/002 Susannah and Mark Guscott Regionally



Reject

/S317/004 Susannah and Mark Guscott Objective O8:



Reject

/S317/007 Susannah and Mark Guscott Policy P7: Uses


/S317/008 Susannah and Mark Guscott Policy P11: In-



/S317/076 Susannah and Mark Guscott Objective O2:


Support [Not stated]. Accept

/


Submission point




S317/077 Susannah and Mark Guscott Objective O8: Allocation regime

Support [Not stated]. Accept

/S317/083 Susannah and Mark Guscott Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterSupport [Not stated]. Reject

/S317/085 Susannah and Mark Guscott Policy P8:


Oppose Rewrite the objectives and policies section of the Plan so that it gives clear and concise guidance to decision makers.

Accept

/S321/002 Edward Handyside Regionally



Reject

/S321/004 Edward Handyside Objective O8:



Reject

/S321/007 Edward Handyside Policy P7: Uses


/S321/008 Edward Handyside Policy P11: In-



/S327/005 A.J Barton and Ongaha Farms

LimitedObjective O8: Allocation regime

Not stated That a robust economic analysis be undertaken of the potential effect of the minimum flow restrictions on the abstraction of water from Category A & B aquifers where such a restriction has not previously existed

Any economic analysis must recognise that the value of water for irrigation varies throughout the season, and is a function of the

Reject


Submission point




particular land use activity. The analysis presented in Harris (2015) should be revised to take account of the critical nature of water during certain periods


Support Allow

S335/003 NDR and BA Davies Regionally significant infrastructure


Reject

/S335/005 NDR and BA Davies Objective O8:



Reject

/S335/008 NDR and BA Davies Policy P7: Uses


/S335/009 NDR and BA Davies Policy P11: In-



/S337/019 Bob Tosswill Regionally



Reject

/S337/021 Bob Tosswill Objective O8:



Reject


Submission point




/S337/024 Bob Tosswill Policy P7: Uses


/S337/025 Bob Tosswill Policy P11: In-



/S340/012 Jim Hedley Regionally



Reject

/S340/014 Jim Hedley Objective O8:



Reject

/S340/017 Jim Hedley Policy P7: Uses


/S340/018 Jim Hedley Policy P11: In-



/S342/002 Gary James and Anne Marie Daysh Regionally



Reject

/S342/004 Gary James and Anne Marie Daysh Objective O8:


cultural and environmental benefits of taking and using water for current uses and also for

Reject


Submission point




future needs are recognised and provided for within the Plan's allocation framework"

/S342/007 Gary James and Anne Marie Daysh Policy P7: Uses


/S342/008 Gary James and Anne Marie Daysh Policy P11: In-



/S346/036 Waikanae Christian Holiday Park (El

Rancho)Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S346/080 Waikanae Christian Holiday Park (El Rancho)

Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S347/002 Brian Bosch Regionally significant infrastructure


Reject

/S347/004 Brian Bosch Objective O8:



Reject


Submission point




/S347/007 Brian Bosch Policy P7: Uses


/S347/008 Brian Bosch Policy P11: In-



/S348/078 Max Lutz Objective O9:

Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part


Disallow in part

S348/122 Max Lutz Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject

/S349/036 USNZ Objective O9:

Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S349/080 USNZ Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Submission point





Disallow in part

S351/036 Tim Mansell and family Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S351/080 Tim Mansell and family Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject


Disallow in part

S352/042 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Regionally significant infrastructure includes:...

· Commercial Port Area ... and associated wharflines· River and catchment flood protection

schemes, rural drainage infrastructure, rural water infrastructure including water races

· Rural transport infrastructure

Reject


Not stated

FS74/018 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowS352/055 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O2:



/S352/057 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O6:

Health needs of Amend Amend as follows or to similar effect: Sufficient water of a suitable

quality is available for the health needs of people.Reject


Submission point




people The quality of drinking water sourced from rivers or groundwater is maintained or improved by:...[see original submission p29 for full suggested wording]

FS89/016 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowS352/058 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O7:

Water for livestock

Amend Amend to the following or similar effect: Freshwater is available in quantities and is of a suitable quality (e. coli not > 1000/100ml) for the reasonable needs of livestockThe importance of reliable access to drinking water for livestock is recognised and provided for.

Reject

FS1/026 Waa Rata Estate Support AllowFS74/029 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow

S352/059 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O8: Allocation regime

Amend Amend to the following or similar effect: "The take, storage and use of water for social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits is recognised and provided for within the allocation regime set out in this Plan.

Reject

FS52/001 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Support AllowFS89/018 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS1/027 Waa Rata Estate Support AllowFS61/084 Minister of Conservation Oppose in

partDisallow

S352/060 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O9: Recreational values

Amend Amend to the following or similar effect: The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and lakes and their margins and natural wetlands are maintained and or

Reject


Submission point




enhanced in (named) priority areas in partnership with landowners and community

FS49/039 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part

Allow in part

FS89/019 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS1/028 Waa Rata Estate Support Allow

S352/061 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O10: Public access

Amend Amend to the following or similar effect: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and rivers and lakes is maintained and or enhanced in (named) priority areas in partnership with landowners and community

Reject

FS89/020 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS1/029 Waa Rata Estate Support Allow

S352/063 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure

Amend The social, economic, cultural and environmental benefits of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities are recognised and provided for

Reject

FS69/015 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS61/006 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowFS89/021 Fish and Game Oppose Disallow

S352/064 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Objective O13: Protecting regionally significant infrastructure

Amend Amend to the following or similar effect: The use and ongoing operation of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Reject

/S352/065 Federated Farmers of New Zealand 3.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend [New Objective] The social, economic, cultural and

environmental benefits of primary production, manufacturing and processing activities are

Reject


Submission point




recognised and provided for.


Disallow

FS46/004 Ravensdown Limited Support AllowFS89/022 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS74/031 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow

S352/066 Federated Farmers of New Zealand 3.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend [New Objective] The use and ongoing operation of primary production, manufacturing and processing activities is protected from new or inappropriate development located alongside

Reject

FS71/035 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS74/032 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose Disallow

S352/116 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P7: Uses of land and water

Amend The cultural, social environmental and economic benefits of using land and water for: a)

aquaculture, andb) treatment, dilution attenuation and disposal of wastewater and stormwater and animal effluent, and diffuse contaminants and c)...f) food primary production, and harvesting, and processingg)...

Reject

FS89/059 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowS352/117 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P8:


Amend The following activities are recognised as beneficial and generally appropriate and shall generally be enabled:A)...D) removal of aquatic weeds or pest plants, and invasive faunaE) the establishment of river crossings (culverts,fords and bridges)...G) the retirement or planting of erosion

Reject


Submission point




prone land from stock access, and...M) construction of stock watering damsN) cleaning drains to maintain the water table and reduce flooding risksO) ground spreading and aerial topdressing of lime and fertiliserP) returning nutrients to the land including effluent, manure, bedding and compostQ) making and storing hay, baleage and silageR) maintenance and development of farm tracks for the safe and efficient movement of people and stockS) farm infrastructure and buildings for holding stock off paddocks T) clearance of annual or perennial weed species and clearance of regenerating scrub U) clearance of manuka/kanuka for the establishment of hive sites and access to themV) enhancement of natural wetlands or construction of new wetlands to support nutrient and sediment attenuation, including regular cleaning and harvest of plant material to support ongoing function

FS74/048 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS89/061 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS1/037 Waa Rata Estate Support AllowFS49/104 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in

partAllow in part


Submission point




S352/119 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P11: In-stream water storage

Amend Policy P11 In-stream water storage - The benefits associated with the damming and storing of water within the bed of a river are recognised including when:a) there are significant social and economic benefits for the enterprise, catchment or region, andb) water remains available for multiple in-stream and out of stream uses concurrently, and c) the reliability of water supply improves as a result, andd) the damming and storage of water contributes to the efficient allocation and use of water.

Reject

FS89/063 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowS352/120 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P12:



/S352/121 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P13:



/S352/122 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P14: Support Retain Accept


Submission point





/S352/123 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P15: Flood



/S352/124 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P16: New



/S352/125 Federated Farmers of New Zealand 4.2 Beneficial use

and developmentAmend [NEW Policy] Primary Production - The benefits of

primary production, manufacturing, distribution and processing are recognised and provided for by:(a) Recognising existing land uses and investments, including capital and operational investments in sustainable farming practices and environmental stewardship (b) Supporting the ongoing use and development of land, recognising the need for flexibility to respond to seasonal fluctuations and changing markets(c) Providing for any requirements for significant new capital investments to be made only in the context of robust cost-benefit analysis(d) Providing transition times to meet new requirements or catchment limits(e) Working alongside industry and

Reject


Submission point




landowner/catchment groups to support the ongoing development of sustainable farming systems, and to enable collective or cross-catchment solutions to meet objectives

FS50/022 Fertiliser Association of New Zealand Inc

Support in part

Allow in part

FS74/049 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS71/073 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS89/064 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS43/026 Royal Forest and Bird Protection



Amend [NEW policy] The benefits of irrigation are recognised and provided for by:(a) Recognising existing uses, and existing capital investments in water takes, pumping, storage, reticulation and application systems(b) Providing for investment certainty with consent durations of at least 25 years(c) Providing for reliability of supply in determining minimum flow and allocation regimes(d) Providing for any changes to minimum flow or allocation regimes impacting reliability of water takes to be made only in the context of robust cost-benefit analysis(e) Providing transition times to meet new minimum flow or allocation limits, or to transition to more efficient systems(f) Providing for rootstock protection to be exempt from minimum flow restrictions(g) Working alongside industry and water user groups to promote water efficiency

Reject


Submission point




technologies, and to enable water sharing and temporary transfers between catchment users

FS71/071 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS89/065 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS43/027 Royal Forest and Bird Protection


FS74/050 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowS352/127 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Policy P11: In-


Amend [submission referred to Policy P7] The benefits associated with the damming and storing of water outside or within the bed of a river are recognised...

Reject

FS74/051 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS89/060 Fish and Game Oppose Disallow


Amend [NEW Policy] - drainage infrastructure - The use and maintenance of drainage systems to provide the required outfall and water table levels for agricultural productivity and to protect from flooding are beneficial and shall generally be enabled

Reject

FS74/052 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS52/008 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Support AllowFS89/066 Fish and Game Oppose DisallowFS43/028 Royal Forest and Bird Protection



Amend [NEW Policy] Reverse sensitivity - Primary production activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by the location and design of any new use and development to

Reject


Submission point




avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects.

FS74/053 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS22/019 Transpower NZ Ltd Oppose DisallowFS71/072 Horticulture NZ Support AllowFS89/067 Fish and Game Oppose Disallow

S353/013 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society

Objective O6: Health needs of people


/S353/014 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyObjective O7: Water for livestock



SocietyObjective O10: Public access



SocietyObjective O12: Benefits of regionally significant infrastructure



SocietyObjective O8: Allocation regime

Oppose Delete Reject


Oppose in part

Disallow

FS26/030 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/049 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS52/003 Wairarapa Regional Irrigation Trust Oppose DisallowFS84/026 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative

Group LimitedOppose in part

Disallow

FS30/029 Masterton District Council Oppose DisallowS353/056 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Policy P7: Uses Oppose Delete Accept


Submission point




Society of land and waterFS84/032 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative

Group LimitedOppose in part

Disallow


Oppose in part

Disallow

FS85/118 Carterton District Council Oppose DisallowS353/057 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyPolicy P8: Beneficial activities

Oppose in part

Delete (h) Reject

FS85/120 Carterton District Council Oppose in part

Disallow

FS49/103 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowFS26/072 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS30/051 Masterton District Council Oppose Disallow

S353/058 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society

Policy P9: Public access to and along the coastal marine area and the beds of lakes and rivers



SocietyPolicy P11: In-stream water storage

Oppose Delete Accept


SocietyPolicy P13: Existing regionally significant infrastructure and renewable electricity generation facilities

Support in part

Add the words, "provided the adverse effects are avoided remedied".

Reject

FS73/067 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowFS35/006 First Gas Ltd Oppose DisallowFS60/012 NZ Transport Agency Oppose Disallow


Submission point




FS51/013 GBC Winstone Oppose DisallowS353/061 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyPolicy P15: Flood protection activities

Oppose Add the words, "provided the adverse effects are avoided remedied".

Reject


SocietyPolicy P16: New flood protection and erosion control

Oppose Add the words, "provided the adverse effects are avoided remedied".

Reject

/S361/002 Sandra Shivas Regionally



Reject

/S361/004 Sandra Shivas Objective O8:



Reject

/S361/007 Sandra Shivas Policy P7: Uses


/S361/008 Sandra Shivas Policy P11: In-



/S365/019 A J Barton Regionally



Reject

/S365/021 A J Barton Objective O8:


cultural and environmental benefits of taking Reject


Submission point




and using water for current uses and also for future needs are recognised and provided for within the Plan's allocation framework"

/S365/024 A J Barton Policy P7: Uses


/S365/025 A J Barton Policy P11: In-



/S366/019 South Wairarapa District Council Regionally


Oppose That the following sub-definition be added to the definition of regionally significant infrastructure:

"Local Authority Roads, including culverts, bridges, and any other support structures or ancillary infrastructure"

Reject

FS85/051 Carterton District Council Support AllowS366/027 South Wairarapa District Council Upgrade Oppose Amend the definition by replacing the word 'modern' with

'current accepted standard or accepted industry practice standard (where defined in an adopted industry standard or similar)" or similar with the same effect.

Reject

/S366/034 South Wairarapa District Council Objective O2:


Oppose in part

Retain Objective O2 with the addition of the words "and provided for" following the existing text.

Reject

/


Submission point




S366/036 South Wairarapa District Council Objective O6: Health needs of people



Water for livestock



Allocation regimeSupport Retain Objective O8 Accept



Amend Retain Objective O12 with the addition of the words "and provided for" following the existing text.

Reject



Amend Reword Objective O13 to read:The use, and ongoing operation, and upgrade of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occuring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Accept


Allow in part

FS56/024 Powerco Support AllowS366/068 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P7: Uses


Amend P7(k) to read:Transportation, including along, and access to,

Reject


Submission point




water bodiesAmend the last phrase of Policy P7 to read "...shall be recognisedand provided for"

FS85/136 Carterton District Council Support AllowS366/069 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P9: Public


Support in part

Retain Policy P9(b), and amend the last paragraph of Policy P9 to read as follows:"...with respect to (a), (b) and (c), where it is necessary to permanently restrict or remove existing public access, the loss of public access shall be mitigated or offset by providing enhanced public access at a similar or nearby location where a practicable alternative does not already exist"

Accept in part

/S366/070 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P12:


Support in part

Retain Policy P12, with the addition of the words "the functional need and..." before "operational requirements..." in P12(e)

Accept



Support Retain Policy 13 Accept


Incompatible Support in part

Retain the intent of Policy P14, but amend to read as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy

Reject


Submission point





generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by locating and designing any new or changing use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects.

/S366/074 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P15: Flood



/S366/075 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P16: New


Support in part

Retain Policy P16, with the addition of the following at the end of the existing policy "... and provided for".

Reject

/S367/019 Masterton District Council Regionally


Oppose That the following sub-definition be added to the definition of regionally significant infrastructure:

"Local Authority Roads, including culverts, bridges, and any other support structures or ancillary infrastructure"

Reject

FS85/050 Carterton District Council Support AllowS367/027 Masterton District Council Upgrade Oppose Amend the definition by replacing the word "modern" with

"current accepted standard or accepted industry practice standard (where defined in an adopted industry standard or similar)" or similar with the same effect.

Reject

/


Submission point




S367/034 Masterton District Council Objective O2: Importance of land and water

Oppose in part

Retain Objective O2 with the addition of the words "and provided for" following the existing text.

Reject


Disallow

S367/036 Masterton District Council Objective O6: Health needs of people


/S367/037 Masterton District Council Objective O7:

Water for livestock



Allocation regimeSupport Retain Objective O8 Accept



Amend Retain Objective O12 with the addition of the words "and provided for" following the existing text.

Reject

FS22/011 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowS367/041 Masterton District Council Objective O13:


Amend Reword Objective O13 to read:The use, and ongoing operation, and upgrade of regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities in the coastal marine area are protected from new incompatible use and development occuring under, over, or adjacent to the infrastructure or activity.

Accept


Submission point





Allow in part

FS56/025 Powerco Support AllowS367/068 Masterton District Council Policy P7: Uses


Amend P7(k) to read:Transportation, including along, and access to, water bodiesAmend the last phrase of Policy P7 to read "shall be recognisedand provided for"

Reject

FS85/135 Carterton District Council Support AllowS367/069 Masterton District Council Policy P9: Public


Support in part

Retain Policy P9(b), and amend the last paragraph of Policy P9 to read as follows:"with respect to (a), (b) and (c), where it is necessary to permanently restrict or remove existing public access, the loss of public access shall be mitigated or offset by providing enhanced public access at a similar or nearby location where a practicable alternative does not already exist"

Accept in part

/S367/070 Masterton District Council Policy P12:


Support in part

Retain Policy P12, with the addition of the words "the functional need and..." before "operational requirements..." in P12(e)

Accept


Incompatible activities adjacent to regionally significant



Submission point




infrastructure and renewable electricity generation activities



Support Retain Policy P13 Accept



Support in part

Retain intent, amend as follows:Regionally significant infrastructure and renewable energy generation activities shall be protected from new incompatible use and development occurring under, over or adjacent to it, by locating and designing any new or changing use and development to avoid, remedy or mitigate any reverse sensitivity effects.

Reject

/S367/074 Masterton District Council Policy P15: Flood



/S367/075 Masterton District Council Policy P16: New


Support in part

Retain Policy P16, with the addition of the following at the end of the existing policy "... and provided for".

Reject

/S370/036 Mahaki Holdings Ltd Objective O9:

Recreational Amend Amend O9:

The recreational values of the coastal marine area, rivers and Reject


Submission point




values lakes and theirmargins and natural wetlands are maintained and where possible/identified enhanced over time.


Disallow in part

S370/080 Mahaki Holdings Ltd Objective O9: Recreational values


Reject

FS49/020 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow in partS371/002 George Ritchie Regionally



Reject

/S371/004 George Ritchie Objective O8:



Reject

/S371/007 George Ritchie Policy P7: Uses


/S371/008 George Ritchie Policy P11: In-



/S372/002 Leo Vollebregt Regionally



Reject

/S372/004 Leo Vollebregt Objective O8: Amend Amend Objective O8: "the social, agricultural, industrial, Reject


Submission point




Allocation regime cultural and environmental benefits of taking and using water for current uses and also for future needs are recognised and provided for within the Plan's allocation framework"

/S372/007 Leo Vollebregt Policy P7: Uses


/S372/008 Leo Vollebregt Policy P11: In-



/S375/002 Graeme Hugh Tulloch Regionally



Reject

/S375/004 Graeme Hugh Tulloch Objective O8:



Reject

/S375/007 Graeme Hugh Tulloch Policy P7: Uses


/S375/008 Graeme Hugh Tulloch Policy P11: In-



/S377/002 Donald McCreary Regionally



Reject


Submission point




/S377/004 Donald McCreary Objective O8:



Reject

/S377/007 Donald McCreary Policy P7: Uses


/S377/008 Donald McCreary Policy P11: In-



/S378/002 Lewis Herrick Regionally



Reject

/S378/004 Lewis Herrick Objective O8:



Reject

/S378/007 Lewis Herrick Policy P7: Uses


/S378/008 Lewis Herrick Policy P11: In-




Submission point




/S380/002 Willy and Sally Bosch Regionally



Reject

/S380/004 Willy and Sally Bosch Objective O8:



Reject

/S380/007 Willy and Sally Bosch Policy P7: Uses


/S380/008 Willy and Sally Bosch Policy P11: In-



/S382/008 Noel and Ann Gray Regionally



Reject

/S382/010 Noel and Ann Gray Objective O8:



Reject

/S382/013 Noel and Ann Gray Policy P7: Uses


/


Submission point




S382/014 Noel and Ann Gray Policy P11: In-stream water storage


/S383/008 Brad Gooding Regionally



Reject

/S383/010 Brad Gooding Objective O8:



Reject

/S383/013 Brad Gooding Policy P7: Uses


/S383/014 Brad Gooding Policy P11: In-



/S384/008 Richard Osborne Regionally



Reject

/S384/010 Richard Osborne Objective O8:



Reject

/


Submission point




S384/013 Richard Osborne Policy P7: Uses of land and water


/S384/014 Richard Osborne Policy P11: In-



/S388/002 Gerard Vollebregt Regionally



Reject

/S388/004 Gerard Vollebregt Objective O8:



Reject

/S388/007 Gerard Vollebregt Policy P7: Uses


/S388/008 Gerard Vollebregt Policy P11: In-



/S390/002 Hayden Thurston Regionally



Reject

/S390/004 Hayden Thurston Objective O8:


cultural and environmental benefits of taking and using water for current uses and also for future needs are recognised and provided for

Reject


Submission point




within the Plan's allocation framework"

/S390/007 Hayden Thurston Policy P7: Uses


/S390/008 Hayden Thurston Policy P11: In-



/S392/002 Stewart Weatherstone Regionally



Reject

/S392/004 Stewart Weatherstone Objective O8:



Reject

/S392/007 Stewart Weatherstone Policy P7: Uses


/S392/008 Stewart Weatherstone Policy P11: In-



/S393/002 Blair Roberts Regionally



Reject

/S393/004 Blair Roberts Objective O8:

Allocation regimeAmend Amend Objective O8: "the social, agricultural, industrial, Reject


Submission point





/S393/007 Blair Roberts Policy P7: Uses


/S393/008 Blair Roberts Policy P11: In-



/S394/002 Owen Butcher Regionally



Reject

/S394/004 Owen Butcher Objective O8:



Reject

/S394/007 Owen Butcher Policy P7: Uses


/S394/008 Owen Butcher Policy P11: In-



/S395/002 Daniel George Regionally



Reject


Submission point




/S395/004 Daniel George Objective O8:



Reject

/S395/007 Daniel George Policy P7: Uses


/S395/008 Daniel George Policy P11: In-



/S396/002 Bernie George Regionally



Reject

/S396/004 Bernie George Objective O8:



Reject

/S396/007 Bernie George Policy P7: Uses


/S396/008 Bernie George Policy P11: In-




Submission point




/S398/016 Atiawa ki Whakarongotai Policy P7: Uses

of land and waterOppose Remove P7 (g) Reject

/S399/002 Sandy Bidwell Regionally



Reject

/S399/004 Sandy Bidwell Objective O8:



Reject

/S399/007 Sandy Bidwell Policy P7: Uses


/S399/008 Sandy Bidwell Policy P11: In-



/S400/002 Mike Moran Regionally



Reject

/S400/004 Mike Moran Objective O8:



Reject

/


Submission point




S400/007 Mike Moran Policy P7: Uses of land and water


/S400/008 Mike Moran Policy P11: In-



/S407/002 Kurt Simmonds Regionally



Reject

/S407/004 Kurt Simmonds Objective O8:



Reject

/S407/007 Kurt Simmonds Policy P7: Uses


/S407/008 Kurt Simmonds Policy P11: In-



/S408/002 John Petrie Regionally



Reject

/S408/004 John Petrie Objective O8:



Reject


Submission point





/S408/007 John Petrie Policy P7: Uses


/S408/008 John Petrie Policy P11: In-



/S409/002 Peter Vollebregt Regionally



Reject

/S409/004 Peter Vollebregt Objective O8:



Reject

/S409/007 Peter Vollebregt Policy P7: Uses


/S409/008 Peter Vollebregt Policy P11: In-



/S410/002 Richard John and Carolyn Ann

StevensonRegionally significant infrastructure


Reject


StevensonObjective O8: Allocation regime

Amend Amend Objective O8: "the social, agricultural, industrial, Reject


Submission point






StevensonPolicy P7: Uses of land and water



StevensonPolicy P11: In-stream water storage


/S411/002 Andrew Douglas Harvey Regionally



Reject

/S411/004 Andrew Douglas Harvey Objective O8:



Reject

/S411/007 Andrew Douglas Harvey Policy P7: Uses


/S411/008 Andrew Douglas Harvey Policy P11: In-



/S412/002 Shane Matthew Gray Regionally



Reject


Submission point




/S412/004 Shane Matthew Gray Objective O8:



Reject

/S412/007 Shane Matthew Gray Policy P7: Uses


/S412/008 Shane Matthew Gray Policy P11: In-



/S413/002 Mike Warren Regionally



Reject

/S413/004 Mike Warren Objective O8:



Reject

/S413/007 Mike Warren Policy P7: Uses


/S413/008 Mike Warren Policy P11: In-




Submission point




/S414/002 Stephen Hammond Regionally



Reject

/S414/004 Stephen Hammond Objective O8:



Reject

/S414/007 Stephen Hammond Policy P7: Uses


/S414/008 Stephen Hammond Policy P11: In-



/S415/002 Simon Vaughan Campbell Regionally



Reject

/S415/004 Simon Vaughan Campbell Objective O8:



Reject

/S415/007 Simon Vaughan Campbell Policy P7: Uses


/


Submission point




S415/008 Simon Vaughan Campbell Policy P11: In-stream water storage


/S416/002 Bryan Thompson Tucker Regionally



Reject

/S416/004 Bryan Thompson Tucker Objective O8:



Reject

/S416/007 Bryan Thompson Tucker Policy P7: Uses


/S416/008 Bryan Thompson Tucker Policy P11: In-



/S417/002 Matthew Honeysett Regionally



Reject

/S417/004 Matthew Honeysett Objective O8:



Reject

/


Submission point




S417/007 Matthew Honeysett Policy P7: Uses of land and water


/S417/008 Matthew Honeysett Policy P11: In-



/S418/002 Rod Sutherland Regionally



Reject

/S418/004 Rod Sutherland Objective O8:



Reject

/S418/007 Rod Sutherland Policy P7: Uses


/S418/008 Rod Sutherland Policy P11: In-



/S419/002 David G Holmes Regionally



Reject

/S419/004 David G Holmes Objective O8:



Reject


Submission point





/S419/007 David G Holmes Policy P7: Uses


/S419/008 David G Holmes Policy P11: In-



/S420/002 Richard Kershaw Regionally



Reject

/S420/004 Richard Kershaw Objective O8:



Reject

/S420/007 Richard Kershaw Policy P7: Uses


/S420/008 Richard Kershaw Policy P11: In-



/S421/002 Ray Craig Regionally



Reject

/S421/004 Ray Craig Objective O8:

Allocation regimeAmend Amend Objective O8: "the social, agricultural, industrial, Reject


Submission point





/S421/007 Ray Craig Policy P7: Uses


/S421/008 Ray Craig Policy P11: In-



/S422/002 Shaun Rose Regionally



Reject

/S422/004 Shaun Rose Objective O8:



Reject

/S422/007 Shaun Rose Policy P7: Uses


/S422/008 Shaun Rose Policy P11: In-



/S423/002 Willem Stolte Regionally



Reject


Submission point




/S423/004 Willem Stolte Objective O8:



Reject

/S423/007 Willem Stolte Policy P7: Uses


/S423/008 Willem Stolte Policy P11: In-



/S424/002 Gary Svenson Regionally



Reject

/S424/004 Gary Svenson Objective O8:



Reject

/S424/007 Gary Svenson Policy P7: Uses


/S424/008 Gary Svenson Policy P11: In-




Submission point




/S434/001 New Zealand Deer Farmers

Association - Wairarapa Branch3.2 Beneficial use and development

Amend Recognise food production in the values and commission a Section 32 report for primary production values prior to the hearings

Reject

/S435/003 Forest Owner Marketing Services

LtdPolicy P7: Uses of land and water

Amend Include Forestry as beneficial use of land and water resources. Reject

FS68/006 Tim Mansell and family Support Allow


pnrp.gw.govt.nzpnrp.gw.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/Table-of-Decisions-Topic... · Web...

Documents

Transcript of pnrp.gw.govt.nzpnrp.gw.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/Table-of-Decisions-Topic... · Web...